Upload
stanford-victims-coalition
View
233
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
1/134
SKTJI JTFWMGHR HKR _GR UE@GBWIGB]
Hk. :4-7401
OH R@G WHORGB URJRGU EKWTR KA J\\GJIU
AKT R@G BOURTOER KA EKIWMDOJ EOTEWOR[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[
UGEWTOROGU JHB GPE@JHFG EKMMOUUOKH,\gtotokhgr-Jppgiijht,
v.
UGEWTOROGU OHQGURKT \TKRGEROKH EKT\KTJROKH,Tgspkhbght-Jppgiigg
Kh Jppgji arkm t`g Whotgb Utjtgs Bostroet Ekurt akr t`g Bostroet ka EkiumdojEovoi Jetokh Hk. ::-me-160 (TIV)
JMOEWU EWTOJGDTOGA KA R@G EKWTR-J\\KOHRGB GPJMOHGT,
R@G KAAOEOJI URJHAKTB OHQGURKTU EKMMORRGG,
JHB R@G URJHAKTB QOEROMU EKJIOROKH
OH UW\\KTR KA \GROROKHGT-J\\GIIJHR
JHB TGQGTUJI KA R@G BOURTOER EKWTRU KTBGT
URTJUDWTFGT & \TOEG, II\
Nk`h @gaahgrBostroet ka Ekiumdoj Djr Hk. ::2
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
2/134
o
EGTROAOEJRG JU RK \JTROGU, TWIOHFU, JHB TGIJRGB EJUGU
Gxegpt akr t`g jmoeo eurojgiostgb dgikw, jii pjrtogs, ohtgrvghkrs, jhb jmoeo
jppgjrohf dgakrg t`g bostroet ekurt jhb oh t`os Ekurt jrg iostgb oh t`g Ohotoji Droga ka
t`g Ugeurotogs jhb Gxe`jhfg Ekmmossokh, Jppgiijht>
Nk`h N. Iottig Ekurt-Jppkohtgb Gxjmohgr(jppkohtgb dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt
dy krbgr bjtgb Jproi 44, 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
3/134
oo
RJDIG KA EKHRGHRU
\jfg
Egrtoaoejtg js tk \jrtogs, Tuiohfs jhb Tgijtgb Ejsgs o
Rjdig ka Ekhtghts oo
Rjdig ka Jut`krotogs ov
Fikssjry vo
Egrtoaoejtg ka Ohtgrgstgb \grskhs jhb voooTuig 41.: Boseiksurg Utjtgmght
Tuig 4?(e)(7) Egrtoaoejtg x
O. R@G TKIGU KA R@GJMOEO EWTOJG> R@G GPJMOHGT, :R@G OHQGURKTU EKMMORRGG JHB R@GURJHAKTB QOEROMU EKJIOROKH
J. R`g Gxjmohgr 4
D. R`g Ohvgstkrs Ekmmottgg 5
E. R`g Utjhakrb Qoetoms Ekjiotokh 7
OO. \TOKT \TKEGGBOHFU 7
OOO. \TGIOMOHJT_ URJRGMGHR 1
OQ. UWMMJT_ KA R@G JTFWMGHR 6
Q. JTFWMGHR 0
J. Aohbohfs jhb Tuiohfs dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb 0t`g 7t`Eoreuot Ekhtrjboet t`g Ajets Tgiogb upkh Dgikw
:. Vjs UODI sgpjrjtg jhb bostohet arkm UFE; :
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
8/134
voo
UGE Ugeurotogs jhb Gxe`jhfg Ekmmossokh
UFE Utjhakrb Frkup Ekmpjhy, j rgfostgrgb drkcgr-bgjigr jhb UO\E mgmdgr
UODI Utjhakrb Ohtgrhjtokhji Djhc, Itb.
UO\J Ugeurotogs Ohvgstkr \rktgetokh Jet ka :?6
R@G GPJMOHGT, R@G OHQGURKTU EKMMORRGG JHB R@G
URJHAKTB QOEROMU EKJIOROKH:
Oh Agdrujry 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
13/134
4.
Ohvgstkr \rktgetokh Ekrpkrjtokh (UO\E). Ohtgrgst jhb proheopji pjymghts wgrg
auhbgb wot` mkhgy ohvgstgb dy sudsgqught UODI EB pure`jsgrs.
R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt akuhb fkkb ejusg tk dgiogvg t`jt t`g Utjhakrb
Ghtotogs vokijtgb agbgrji sgeurotogs ijws. Kh Agdrujry :1, 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
14/134
5.
bgtgrmohg wkuib dg `gipaui tk t`g Ekurt oh ekhsobgrohf t`g ohtgrgsts ka t`g
ohvgstkrs oh jhy aohjheoji prkbuets, jeekuhts, vg`oeigs kr vghturgs spkhskrgb,
prkmktgb kr skib dy jhy Bgaghbjhts oh t`os jetokh (t`g Ohvgstkrs). Tgegovgrs`op
\rkeggbohf, Bke. Hk. 544, jt :-4 (t`g Gxjmohgr Krbgr).7
R`g Gxjmohgr Krbgr jut`krozgb t`g Gxjmohgr tk ekhbuet sue` ohvgstofjtokh
js `g bggms hgegssjry tk prkvobg sue` ohakrmjtokh tk t`g Ekurt, jhb tk usg jhy
bosekvgry mgt`kbs prkvobgb oh Tuigs 41 t`rkuf` 56. Ob. jt 4. R`g Gxjmohgr
Krbgr jisk jut`krozgb t`g Gxjmohgr tk aoig Tgpkrts jhb Tgekmmghbjtokhs wot` t`g
Ekurt js `g s`jii sgg aot, jhb tk aoig drogas oh rgspkhsg tk jhy mktokh aoigb oh t`g
Tgegovgrs`op \rkeggbohf. Ob.
D. R`g Ohvgstkrs Ekmmottgg
Kh Ugptgmdgr ?, 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
15/134
2.
R`g Mkvjhts, t`g Tgegovgr, t`g Gxjmohgr, jhb t`g UGE sudsgqughtiy
rgje`gb jh jfrggmght tk rgskivg t`g mktokh jhb ergjtg jh ohvgstkrs ekmmottgg. Kh
Jufust :
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
16/134
7.
E. R`g Utjhakrb Qoetoms Ekjiotokh
R`g Utjhakrb Qoetoms Ekjiotokh (UQE) os j hkt-akr-prkaot ekrpkrjtokh
krfjhozgb jhb gxostohf uhbgr Rgxjs ijw. Ot wjs akuhbgb dy Ms. Jhfgij U`jw
Ckfutt, j Utjhakrb ohvgstkr rgsobohf oh Rgxjs. R`g UQE `js mkrg t`jh 2,
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
17/134
1.
OOO. \TGIOMOHJT_ URJRGMGHR
R`os jmoeusDroga os aoigb nkohtiy dy t`g Gxjmohgr, t`g Ohvgstkrs Ekmmottgg
jhb t`g UQE oh suppkrt ka t`g \gtotokhgr-Jppgiijht jhb rgvgrsji ka t`g bostroet
ekurts krbgr. Upgeoaoejiiy, t`g jmoeo sggc tk jbvosg t`os Ekurt ka aohbohfs jhb
ruiohfs dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t` Eoreuot Ekurt ka Jppgjis (7t`
Eoreuot) t`jt ekhtrjboet mjhy ka t`g ajets upkh w`oe` t`g bostroet ekurt
jppjrghtiy rgiogb.
Akr gjsg ka rgagrgheg, t`g jmoeo `jvg jttje`gb twk ruiohfs ka t`g
Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt t`jt jrg hgot`gr eurrghtiy rgpkrtgb hkr jvjoijdig voj VGURIJV,
js akiikws>
Gx`odot :> Bke. Hk. 271 oh Njhvgy v. Jifuorg, Eovoi Jetokh Hk. 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
18/134
6.
EBs s`kuib dg bggmgb eustkmgrs ka UFE uhbgr t`g rgjskhohf ka t`g Kib Hjpigs
jhb \romgiohgbgeosokhs.0 R`gy jisk suppkrt t`g UGEs jrfumght t`jt ot hggb khiy
bgmkhstrjtg prkdjdig ejusg tk dgiogvg t`grg jrg eustkmgrs oh hggb ka
prktgetokh uhbgr UO\J.
OQ. UWMMJT_ KA JTFWMGHR
Oh bgeobohf t`os jppgji, t`os Ekurt ejh jhb s`kuib ekhsobgr t`g aohbohfs jhb
ruiohfs t`jt `jvg dggh mjbg dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t`Eoreuot kvgr t`g
ijst akur ygjrs. Dkt` ekurts `jvg gxtghsovg gxpgrogheg wot` t`g Utjhakrb se`gmg,
jhb dkt` ekurts `jvg mjbg aohbohfs jhb ruiohfs t`jt ijrfgiy ekhtrjboet t`g ajets
upkh w`oe` t`g bostroet ekurt rgiogb.
R`g aohbohfs jhb ekheiusokhs ka t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t`
Eoreuot
bgmkhstrjtg t`jt t`g rgjskhohf ka t`g ::t` jhb :
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
19/134
0.
kt`gr Utjhakrb ghtotogs) ohstgjb ka dgohf usgb tk pure`jsg UODI EBs.? Rk pgrmot
sue` j bostohetokh, ghfohggrgb dy t`g jre`otgets ka t`g se`gmg, tk ekhtrki t`g
jppioejtokh ka UO\J wkuib ompgrmossodiy gigvjtg akrm kvgr sudstjheg.
R`g aohbohfs jhb ekheiusokhs ka t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t`Eoreuot,
jikhf wot` gvobgheg oh t`g rgekrb dgakrg t`g bostroet ekurt, jisk suppkrt t`g UGEs
pksotokh t`jt ot s`kuib dg `gib khiy tk t`g sjmg prkdjdig ejusg stjhbjrb t`jt
UO\E must mggt oh ekmmgheohf j ioquobjtokh uhbgr UO\J. V`gh ot ekmgs tk
UFEs eustkmgrs w`k pure`jsgb UODI EBs, khg sozg bkgs hkt aot jii. R`ksg
eustkmgrs woii dg oh j ajr dgttgr pksotokh tk gstjdios` t`gor stjtus js eustkmgrs
uhbgr UO\J kheg j ioquobjtokh prkeggbohf os jetujiiy ekmmghegb. Whtoi sue` tomg,
pktghtoji eijomjhts `jvg hk kppkrtuhoty tk bgmkhstrjtg t`gor rof`t tk UO\J
prktgetokh.
Q. JTFWMGHR
J. Aohbohfs jhb Tuiohfs dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t`
Eoreuot
Ekhtrjboet t`g Ajets Tgiogb upkh Dgikw
R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt `js prgsobgb kvgr t`g Tgegovgrs`op \rkeggbohf akr
jimkst akur (2) ygjrs, burohf w`oe` ot `js dgekmg ohtomjtgiy ajmoiojr wot` t`g ajets
jhb eoreumstjhegs surrkuhbohf t`g Utjhakrb Aohjheoji Frkup \khzo se`gmg. R`grg
? R`g bostroet ekurt jttgmptgb tk bostohfuos` Kib Hjpigsjhb \romgiohgdy hktohf t`jt dkt` ka
t`ksg ejsgs ohvkivgb jh ohtrkbueohf drkcgr w`k hgvgr bgpksotgb t`g eioght auhbs jt ossug wot`t`g eigjrohf drkcgr. R`os purpkrtgb bostohetokh os dkt` ohjeeurjtg (jt igjst skmg eioghtauhbs wgrg bgpksotgb wot` j eigjrohf drkcgr oh Kib Hjpigs) jhb ohsuaaoeoght tk bosqujioayUFE eustkmgrs arkm dgohf eustkmgrs oh hggb ka prktgetokh uhbgr UO\J. Uggoharj jt 44.
WUEJ Ejsg #:4-7401 Bkeumght #:2:14
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
20/134
?.
jrg hkw mkrg t`jh :
:< Mjhy ka t`gsg jetokhs `jvg dggh trjhsagrrgb tk t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt akr prgtroji
ekkrbohjtokh dy t`g Nuboeoji \jhgi kh Muitobostroet Iotofjtokh. Ugg fghgrjiiy,Oh rg UtjhakrbGhtotogs Ugeurotogs Iotofjtokh, MBI Hk. 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
21/134
:
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
22/134
::.
R`g Tgegovgr `js s`kwh t`jt Utjhakrb kpgrjtgb t`g ghtorg hgtwkrcka Utjhakrb Ghtotogs js jh ohtgfrjtgb uhot oh krbgr tk pgrpgtrjtg jmjssovg wkribwobg arjub. Rk ofhkrg t`gsg aohbohfs wkuib gigvjtg
akrm kvgr sudstjheg t`grgdy igfotomozohf t`g ekrpkrjtg strueturg
t`jt Utjhakrb utoiozgb tk pgrpgtrjtg `os arjubjhb ruhhohf jakui kaAoat` Eoreuot prgegbght ejutokhohf ekurts tk ikkc dgykhb t`gsurajeg. R`us, dgejusg SUODI] bob hkt kdsgrvg ekrpkrjtgakrmjiotogs jhb dgejusg jii t`g Utjhakrb ghtotogs wgrg kpgrjtgb jskhg akr purpksgs ka pgrpgtrjtohf j arjub kh ohvgstkrs Seotjtokhkmottgb], t`g Ekurt pogregs SUODIs] ekrpkrjtg vgoi jhb jffrgfjtgst`g Utjhakrb Ghtotogs.
E`jptgr :7 Krbgr jt 51 (gmp`jsos jbbgb). R`g UGE jrfugs t`jt t`g bostroet ekurt
gigvjtgb akrm kvgr sudstjheg dy jb`grohf tk t`g suppksgb ekrpkrjtg akrm ka UODI
jhb UFE jhb hkt rgekfhozohf t`jt dkt` kpgrjtgb js pjrt ka j sohfig eromohji
ghtgrprosg. UGE Droga jt 27-2?. R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jfrggs.
Oh t`jt sjmg E`jptgr :7 Krbgr, t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt ekheiubgb t`jt t`g
ajets:1 wkuib nustoay j sudstjhtovg ekhskiobjtokh ka UODI, UFE jhb t`g kt`gr
Utjhakrb Ghtotogs.:6Ob. jt 57. R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt mjbg somoijr aohbohfs
w`gh frjhtohf summjry nubfmght tk t`g Tgegovgr oh j arjubuight trjhsagr jetokh
drkuf`t jfjohst egrtjoh hjtokhji pkiotoeji ekmmottggs. Njhvgy v. Bgmkerjtoe
:1 Jmkhf t g ajets eotgb dy t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt wgrg> (2) ekmmohfiohf ka auhbs jmkhft`g Utjhakrb Ghtotogs wjs t`g hkrm, (7) Utjhakrb borgetiy kr ohborgetiy kwhgb jii UtjhakrbGhtotogs, .(1) UOD ikjhgb Utjhakrb $:.0 doiiokh wot`kut j fujrjhty, (6) Utjhakrb jhb `osjsskeojtgs trjhsagrrgb jssgts jmkhf t`g Utjhakrb Ghtotogs oh bosrgfjrb ka ekrpkrjtgakrmjiotogs. E`jptgr :7 Krbgr jt 52-57.
:6 R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt bob hkt sudstjhtovgiy ekhskiobjtg t`g Utjhakrb Ghtotogs dgejusg t jt
mge`jhosm os hkt jvjoijdig kutsobg j djhcruptey prkeggbohf. E`jptgr :7 Krbgr jt 57, h. 2:.
WUEJ Ejsg #:4-7401 Bkeumght #:2:14
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
23/134
:4.
Ughjtkroji Ejmpjofh Ekmmottgg, Ohe., 6?5 A.Uupp. 4b 047 (H.B.Rgx. 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
24/134
:5.
kdiofjtokhs ka t`g UO\E mgmdgr aorm. Kib Hjpigs, 445 A.5b jt :5
SR]`g UODI EB prkeggbs bob mkrg t`jh nust cggp t`g djhcjaikjt. Utjhakrb Ghtotogs jhb Utjhakrb `omsgia rgegovgb ijrfgbosdursgmghts ka t`g prkeggbs.
E`jptgr :7 Krbgr jt 4?. Ugg jisk ob. jt 24 (Mkst ka t`g Utjhakrb Ghtotogs rgvghug
ejmg arkm sgiiohf EBs.).
Oh jaaormohf t`g Drkcgr Ohnuhetokh, t`g 7t`Eoreuot somoijriy bgtgrmohgb t`jt
UODI EB prkeggbs auhbgb t`g kpgrjtokhs ka UFE>
:0 R`g UGE kaagrgb gvobgheg t`jt jpprkxomjtgiy $140 moiiokh oh UFE ohvgstkr auhbs aikwgbarkm UODI tk UFE burohf t`g aovg ygjr pgrokb arkm 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
25/134
:2.
Aohjiiy, t`g AJ Bgaghbjhts Sakrmgr drkcgrs ka UFE] pksotokht`jt UFE s`kuib dg sgpjrjtgb arkm SUODI] os ka hk mkmght.Js mjbg eigjr dy t`g Qjh Rjssgi Bgeijrjtokhs,
:?UFE rgegovgb
t`g duic ka ots rgvghug arkm ekmmossokhs akr t`g sjig ka t`g
SUODI EBs] jhb aggs akr kt`gr sgrvoegs ot prkvobgb tk SUODI]
rgijtgb tk t`g EB ohvgstmght pkrtakiok.
Njhvgy v. Jifuorg, 126 A.5b 707, 7?? (7t`
Eor. 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
26/134
:7.
Kib Hjpigs, 445 A.5b jt :5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
27/134
:1.
Ugg jisk \ghbgrfgst-@kit v. Egrtjoh Whbgrwrotgrs jt Iikybs Ikhbkh, 67:
A.Uupp.4b 061, 00< (U.B. Rgx. 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
28/134
:6.
2. Bob t`g UODI EBs oh ajet gxost;
R`g bostroet ekurt rgiogb upkh ots ekheiusokh t`jt t`g UODI EBs wgrg oh ajet
pure`jsgb jhb bob oh ajet gxost akr UFE eioghts. Kp. jt :6. Oh rgje`ohf t`jt
ekheiusokh, t`g bostroet ekurt rgiogb upkh t`g Utopuijtgb Ajets (Bke. Hk. 5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
29/134
:0.
Ugekhb, t`g bostroet ekurts trgjtmght ka t`g UODI EBs js rgji ohvgstmghts
t`jt wgrg oh ajet pure`jsgb jhb oh ajet gxost os jfjoh ekhtrjry tk t`g aohbohfs
jhb ruiohfs ka t`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt jhb t`g 7t`
Eoreuot. R`g Tgegovgrs`op Ekurt
`js rgpgjtgbiy akuhb (jhb t`g 7t` Eoreuot `js jaaormgb) t`jt Utjhakrb jhb `os
ek`krts wgrg kpgrjtohf j eijssoe \khzo se`gmg arkm jt igjst :???. Ugg, g.f.,Njhvgy
v.Bgmkerjtoe Ughjtkroji Ejmpjofh Ekmmottgg, Ohe., 6?5 A.Uupp. 4b 047, 076
(H.B.Rgx. 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
30/134
:?.
tgstomkhy ekhegrhohf Utjhakrbs ergjtovg rgvgrsg ghfohggrohf ka UODs
jeekuhtohf rgekrbs>
Vg akuhb wot`oh UODs jeekuhtohf rgekrbs wkrcs`ggts usgb tkbgrovgaoetotokus UOD rgvghugsdjec tk 4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
31/134
4
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
32/134
4:.
Oh dkt` Kib Hjpigs jhb \romgiohg, t`g eijomjhts wgrg bgjiohf wot`
ohbovobujis w`k t`gy uhbgrstkkb tk dg (jhb w`k wgrg) jfghts ka j UO\E mgmdgr
drkcgr. Kib Hjpigs, 445 A.5b jt :5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
33/134
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
34/134
45.
wot` t`g eigjrohf drkcgr jhb akrwjrbgb tk UODI, wgrg t`gh stkigh dy Utjhakrb akr j
vjrogty ka omprkpgr purpksgs, oheiubohf t`g auhbohf ka UFE. R`g UGE kaagrgb
gvobgheg t`jt rgagrrji aggs jhb kt`gr EB-rgijtgb rgvghug jeekuhtgb akr mkrg t`jh
7
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
35/134
42.
UFEs eigjrohf drkcgr bgaogs ekmmkh sghsg jhb igfotomozgs t`g strueturg ergjtgb
dy Utjhakrb tk stgji mkhgy bgpksotgb dy UFEs eustkmgrs. R`g Tgegovgrs`op
Ekurt rgausgb tk gigvjtg akrm kvgr sudstjheg, sgg E`jptgr :7 Krbgr jt 513 t`os
Ekurt s`kuib js wgii.
R`grg os hk mgjhohfaui bostohetokh dgtwggh t`os ejsg, Kib Hjpigs jhb
\romgiohg. R`os Ekurt s`kuib jbkpt t`g rgjskhohf ka Kib Hjpigs jhb \romgiohg
jhb aohb t`jt skmg (kr jii) ka UFEs eustkmgrs jrg oh hggb ka prktgetokh uhbgr
UO\J.
E. Utjhakrbs Eustkmgrs jrg oh t`g Dgst \ksotokh tkGstjdios` t`gor Utjtus js Eustkmgrs uhbgr UO\J
R`g UGE jrfugs t`jt ot hggbs tk s`kw khiy prkdjdig ejusg tk dgiogvg t`jt
t`grg jrg eustkmgrs oh hggb ka prktgetokh uhbgr UO\J.40
Jmkhf t`g rgjskhs
kaagrgb wjs t`jt t`g bostroet ekurt prkeggbohf wkuib hkt bgtgrmohg UO\Es iojdoioty
tk j sohfig Utjhakrb eustkmgr3 rjt`gr, t`g bostroet ekurt prkeggbohf wkuib bgeobg
khiy w`gt`gr UO\E wjs rgquorgb tk ekmmgheg j UO\J prkeggbohf oh Rgxjs. Bke.
47, UGE Tgpiy jt :7. Oh t`jt Rgxjs prkeggbohf, gje` ohvgstkr wkuib dgjr t`g
durbgh ka bgmkhstrjtohf dkt` t`jt s`g wjs j eustkmgr akr purpksgs ka UO\J jhb
t`g vjioboty jhb jmkuht ka `gr eijom. Ob. Ugg jiskOh rg Ugi`gomgr & Ek., 5:? D.T.
5?7, 2
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
36/134
47.
R`g UGE jisk jrfugs t`jt t`g prgpkhbgrjheg stjhbjrb jppiogb dgikw
ergjtgb j eurokus rgsuit oh t`jt ot wkuib rgquorg j t`orb pjrty got`gr UO\E kr t`g
UGE tk prkvg jh ohvgstkrs giofodoioty wot`kut t`g ohvgstkrs ajmoiojroty wot`, kr
bgfrgg ka jeegss tk, t`g pjrtoeuijr ajets. UGE Droga jt 5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
37/134
41.
wrottgh sompiy tk Utjhakrb. UggBke. :-5 jt :?5, Mjrtghs Bgei., Gx. 4 (e`gec akr
$7
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
38/134
46.
eustkmgrs wgrg tkib t`jt t`g UO\E mgmdgr (Kib Hjpigs Ugeurotogs) jhb t`g hkh-
UO\E mgmdgr (Kib Hjpigs Aohjheoji Ugrvoegs) wgrg khg jhb t`g sjmg. Kib
Hjpigs, 445 A.5b jt :5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
39/134
40.
Dgejusg ka t`g hjturg ka t`g prkeggbohf ekhbuetgb oh t`g bostroet ekurt,54ot
wjs ompkssodig akr t`g UGE, UO\E kr t`g ekurt tk ekhbuet t`g ajetujiiy ohtghsovg
ohquory hgegssjry tk bgtgrmohg oa j pjrtoeuijr Utjhakrb ohvgstkr s`kuib dg bggmgb
j eustkmgr oh hggb ka UO\J prktgetokh. R`jt ohquory os igat akr t`g UO\J
prkeggbohf, burohf w`oe` t`g ohvgstkr `js t`g durbgh ka gstjdios`ohf t`jt s`g os j
eustkmgr jhb `js j vjiob eijom. Oh rg Ugi`gomgr & Ek., 5:? D.T. 5?7, 2
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
40/134
4?.
Tgspgetauiiy sudmottgb,
URTJUDWTFGT & \TOEG, II\
Dy>[[[/s/Nk`h @gaahgr[[[[[[[[[Nk`h @gaahgrBostroet ka Ekiumdoj Djr Hk. ::2
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
41/134
5
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
42/134
5:.
EGTROAOEJRG KA UGTQOEG
O `grgdy egrtoay t`jt, kh Njhujry :0, 4
Nksgp`ohg VjhfFghgrji EkuhsgiUgeuroty Ohvgstkr \rktgetokh Ekrpkrjtokh0
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
43/134
Hk. :4-7401UGEWTOROGU JHB GPE@JHFG EKMMOUUOKH,\gtotokhgr-Jppgiijht,
v.UGEWTOROGU OHQGURKT \TKRGEROKH EKT\KTJROKH,Tgspkhbght-Jppgiigg
MOEWU EWTO G DTOGA KA R@G EKWTR-J\\KOHRGB GPJMOHGTR@G KAAOEOJI URJHAKTB OHQGURKTU EKMMORRGGJHB R@G URJHAKTB QOEROMU EKJIOROKH
GP@ODOR :rkcgr Ohnuhetokh
Bke. Hk. 271 oh Njhvgy v. JifuorgEovoi Jetokh Hk. 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
44/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
45/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
46/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
47/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
48/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
49/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
50/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
51/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
52/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
53/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
54/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
55/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
56/134
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
57/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
58/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
59/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
60/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
61/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
62/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
63/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
64/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
65/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
66/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
67/134
jsg5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
68/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
69/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
70/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
71/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
72/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
73/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
74/134
Hk. :4-7401UGEWTOROGU JHB GPE@JHFG EKMMOUUOKH,
\gtotokhgr->-Jppgiijht,v.
UGEWTOROGU OHQGURKT \TKRGEROKH EKT\KTJROKH,Tgspkhbght-Jppgiigg
MOEWU EWTO G DTOGA KA R@G EKWTR-J\\KOHRGB GPJMOHGTR@G KAAOEOJI URJHAKTB OHQGURKTU EKMMORRGG
JHB R@G URJHAKTB QOEROMU EKJIOROKH
GP@ODOR 4E`jptgr 7 Krbgr
Bke. Hk. :61 oh Oh rg Utjhakrb Ohtgrhjtokhji Djhc Itb.Eovoi Jetokh Hk. 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
75/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
76/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
77/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
78/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
79/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
80/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
81/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
82/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
83/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
84/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
85/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
86/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
87/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
88/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
89/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
90/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
91/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
92/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
93/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
94/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
95/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
96/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
97/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
98/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
99/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
100/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
101/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
102/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
103/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
104/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
105/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
106/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
107/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
108/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
109/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
110/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
111/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
112/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
113/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
114/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
115/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
116/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
117/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
118/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
119/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
120/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
121/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
122/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
123/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
124/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
125/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
126/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
127/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
128/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
129/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
130/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
131/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
132/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
133/134
Ejsg 5>
7/23/2019 Amicus Brief in Support of the SEC's Appeal of the District Court's Order Denying the Commission's Application for
134/134
Ejsg 5>