AMFA’S STATISTICAL AMFA’S STATISTICAL ANALYSISANALYSIS

TITLE II & III CABIN TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEESEMPLOYEES

TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES STATION MANNING PER TWU STATION MANNING PER TWU

ATTACHMENT 1 & AA ELIGIBILITY LISTATTACHMENT 1 & AA ELIGIBILITY LIST

ORD- 70ORD- 70 DFW- 75DFW- 75 MIA- 252MIA- 252 LAX- 146LAX- 146 JFK- 130JFK- 130 SJU- 37SJU- 37 LGA- 23LGA- 23 SFO- 21SFO- 21

SJC- 13SJC- 13 HNL- 12HNL- 12 BOS- 29BOS- 29 EWR- 15EWR- 15 FLL- 17FLL- 17 AUS- 3AUS- 3 MCO- 7MCO- 7

These numbers also include Title II Cabin Cleaners included in AA’s Eligibility List.

1

Title II & III Cabin Employees Station Title II & III Cabin Employees Station Manning Per TWU Attachment 1 & AA Manning Per TWU Attachment 1 & AA

Eligibility ListEligibility List The following chart The following chart

reflects the total reflects the total number of American number of American Airlines Title II and III Airlines Title II and III cabin employees at cabin employees at the stations objected the stations objected to by the TWU. This to by the TWU. This chart also reflects the chart also reflects the Title II cabin cleaners Title II cabin cleaners who were submitted who were submitted as part of American as part of American Airlines March Airlines March 15,2004 Eligibility 15,2004 Eligibility List.List.

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

STATION MANNING

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

2

CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT

MARCH 1-31, 2004MARCH 1-31, 2004

ORD- 7918ORD- 7918 DFW- 9495DFW- 9495 MIA- 4927MIA- 4927 LAX- 2032LAX- 2032 JFK- 981JFK- 981 SJU- 1126SJU- 1126 LGA- 977LGA- 977 SFO- 602SFO- 602

SJC- 502SJC- 502 HNL- 277HNL- 277 BOS- 871BOS- 871 EWR- 336EWR- 336 FLL- 372FLL- 372 AUS- 483AUS- 483 MCO- 455MCO- 455

Source: AA March 1 – 31, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.

3

CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT

MARCH 1-31, 2004MARCH 1-31, 2004

The following chart The following chart reflects the total reflects the total cleaning performed cleaning performed by American Airlines by American Airlines Cabin Employees at Cabin Employees at the locations the locations objected to by the objected to by the TWU. All levels of TWU. All levels of cleaning are reflected cleaning are reflected in these numbers, as in these numbers, as this is a total this is a total numbers of airplanes numbers of airplanes cleaned by AA cabin cleaned by AA cabin employees, both Title employees, both Title II and Title IIIII and Title III..

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

10000

Airplanes Cleaned Per Station

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

Source: AA March 1 – 31, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.4

AIRPLANES CLEANED BY AA TITLE AIRPLANES CLEANED BY AA TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH

TWU OBJECTED TO STATIONTWU OBJECTED TO STATION ORD- 113ORD- 113 DFW- 127DFW- 127 MIA- 20MIA- 20 LAX- 14LAX- 14 JFK- 8JFK- 8 SJU- 30SJU- 30 LGA- 44LGA- 44 SFO- 29SFO- 29

SJC- 39SJC- 39 HNL- 23HNL- 23 BOS- 30BOS- 30 EWR- 22EWR- 22 FLL- 22FLL- 22 AUS- 161AUS- 161 MCO- 65MCO- 65

Source: AA March 1 – 31, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.5

AIRPLANES CLEANED BY AA TITLE AIRPLANES CLEANED BY AA TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH

TWU OBJECTED TO STATIONTWU OBJECTED TO STATION

020406080

100120140160180

AIRPLANES CLEANED PER ATITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE

FOR MARCH

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

Source: AA March 1 – 31, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.

6

A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED

TO CLEANING STATIONSTO CLEANING STATIONS

ORD/DFW Total: 17,413 aircrafts cleaned ORD/DFW Total: 17,413 aircrafts cleaned with 145 Title II & III Cabin Employees, with 145 Title II & III Cabin Employees, equates to 120 airplanes cleaned per equates to 120 airplanes cleaned per employee.employee.

All remaining TWU objected to stations: All remaining TWU objected to stations: 13,941 with 705 Title II & III Cabin 13,941 with 705 Title II & III Cabin

Employees, equates to 20 airplanes Employees, equates to 20 airplanes cleaned per employee.cleaned per employee.

SOURCE: MARCH 1-31, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT USING BOTH AA’S AND TWU’S TITLE II AND III CABIN EMPLOYEE LISTS

7

A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED

TO STATIONSTO STATIONS

02,0004,0006,0008,000

10,00012,00014,00016,00018,000

TOTAL CLEANINGSDURING MARCH 2004

ORD/DFW

ALLREMAINING

SOURCE: MARCH 1-31, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT

8

THE NUMBER OF TITLE II & III CABIN THE NUMBER OF TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW & ORD vs. THE EMPLOYEES AT DFW & ORD vs. THE

REMAINING TWU OBJECTED TO REMAINING TWU OBJECTED TO CLEANING STATIONSCLEANING STATIONS

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

NUMBER OF TITLE II & IIICABIN EMPLOYEES

ORD/DFW

ALLREMAINING

SOURCE: AA’S MARCH 15,2004 ELIGIBILITY LIST AND TWU’S APRIL 22, 2004 ATTACHMENT 1

9

AIRPLANES CLEANED BY TITLE II & AIRPLANES CLEANED BY TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU

OBJECTED TO CLEANING OBJECTED TO CLEANING STATIONSSTATIONS

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

AIRPLANES CLEANED BYTITLE II & III CABIN

EMPLOYEE

ORD/DFW

ALL REMAINING

SOURCE: MARCH 1-31, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT USING BOTH AA’S AND TWU’S TITLE II AND III CABIN CLEANERS LISTS

10

LEVEL 1 BILL OF WORKS LEVEL 1 BILL OF WORKS ACCOMPLISHED BY AA TITLE II & III ACCOMPLISHED BY AA TITLE II & III

CABIN EMPLOYEESCABIN EMPLOYEES ORD- 384ORD- 384 DFW- 204DFW- 204 MIA- 117MIA- 117 LAX- 86LAX- 86 JFK- 15JFK- 15 SJU- 8SJU- 8 LGA- 14LGA- 14 SFO- 40SFO- 40

SJC- 4SJC- 4 HNL- 0HNL- 0 BOS- 32BOS- 32 EWR- 2EWR- 2 FLL- 2FLL- 2 AUS- 1AUS- 1 MCO- 1MCO- 1

NOTE: Level 1 Bill of Work is an extensive cleaning.

Source: AA March 1 – 31, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.

11

LEVEL 1 BILL OF WORKS LEVEL 1 BILL OF WORKS ACCOMPLISHED BY AA TITLE II & III ACCOMPLISHED BY AA TITLE II & III

CABIN EMPLOYEESCABIN EMPLOYEES

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Level 1 Bill of Works Accomplished

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

SOURCE: MARCH 1-31, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT12

A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING OBJECTED TO THE REMAINING OBJECTED TO

CLEANING STATIONS, LEVEL1 BILL CLEANING STATIONS, LEVEL1 BILL OF WORKS ACCOMPLISHEDOF WORKS ACCOMPLISHED

0100200300

400500600

700800

LEVEL 1BILL OFWORKS

TITLE II & IIIEMPLOYEES

ORD/DFW

ALLREMAINING

SOURCE: MARCH 1-31, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT USING BOTH AA’S AND TWU’S TITLE II AND III CABIN EMPLOYEE LISTS.

13

CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT

APRIL 1-30, 2004APRIL 1-30, 2004 ORD- 7815ORD- 7815 DFW- 9509DFW- 9509 MIA- 4803MIA- 4803 LAX- 2080LAX- 2080 JFK- 1124JFK- 1124 SJU- 1119SJU- 1119 LGA- 960LGA- 960 SFO- 574SFO- 574

SJC- 414SJC- 414 HNL- 244HNL- 244 BOS- 902BOS- 902 EWR- 367EWR- 367 FLL- 398FLL- 398 AUS- 489AUS- 489 MCO- 186MCO- 186

Source: AA April 1-30, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.

14

CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF CABIN CLEANING PER AA BILL OF WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT WORK ACCOMPLISHED REPORT

APRIL 1-30, 2004APRIL 1-30, 2004

0100020003000400050006000700080009000

10000

Airplanes Cleaned Per Station

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

The following chart The following chart reflects the total reflects the total cleaning performed by cleaning performed by American Airlines Cabin American Airlines Cabin Employees at the Employees at the locations objected to by locations objected to by the TWU. All levels of the TWU. All levels of cleaning are reflected in cleaning are reflected in these numbers, as this is these numbers, as this is a total numbers of a total numbers of airplanes cleaned by AA airplanes cleaned by AA cabin employees, both cabin employees, both Title II and Title III.Title II and Title III.

Source: AA April 1-30, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.15

AIRPLANES CLEANED PER AA AIRPLANES CLEANED PER AA TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT

EACH TWU OBJECTED TO STATIONEACH TWU OBJECTED TO STATION ORD- 112ORD- 112 DFW- 127DFW- 127 MIA- 19MIA- 19 LAX- 14LAX- 14 JFK- 9JFK- 9 SJU- 30SJU- 30 LGA- 42LGA- 42 SFO- 27SFO- 27

SJC- 32SJC- 32 HNL- 20HNL- 20 BOS- 31BOS- 31 EWR- 24EWR- 24 FLL- 23FLL- 23 AUS- 163AUS- 163 MCO- 27MCO- 27

Source: AA April 1-30, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.16

AIRPLANES CLEANED PER AA TITLE II & AIRPLANES CLEANED PER AA TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH TWU III CABIN EMPLOYEE AT EACH TWU

OBJECTED TO STATIONOBJECTED TO STATION

020406080

100120140160180

AIRPLANES CLEANED PERTITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEE

FOR APRIL

ORD

DFW

MIA

LAX

JFK

SJU

LGA

SFO

SJC

HNL

BOS

EWR

FLL

AUS

MCO

Source: AA April 1-30, 2004 Aircraft Cleaning Report.

17

A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED

TO CLEANING STATIONSTO CLEANING STATIONS

ORD/DFW Total: 17,324 aircrafts cleaned ORD/DFW Total: 17,324 aircrafts cleaned with 145 Title II & III Cabin Employees, with 145 Title II & III Cabin Employees, equates to 119 airplanes cleaned per equates to 119 airplanes cleaned per employee.employee.

All other remaining objected to stations: All other remaining objected to stations: 13,660 with 705 Title II & III Cabin 13,660 with 705 Title II & III Cabin

Employees, equates to 19 airplanes Employees, equates to 19 airplanes cleaned per employee.cleaned per employee.

SOURCE: APRIL 1-30, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT USING BOTH AA’S AND TWU’S TITLE II AND III CABIN CLEANERS LISTS

18

A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. A COMPARISON OF DFW & ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED

TO CLEANING STATIONSTO CLEANING STATIONS

02,0004,0006,0008,000

10,00012,00014,00016,00018,000

TOTAL CLEANINGSDURING APRIL 2004

ORD/DFW

ALLREMAINING

SOURCE: APRIL 1-30,2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT

19

THE NUMBER OF TITLE II & III CABIN THE NUMBER OF TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW & ORD vs. THE EMPLOYEES AT DFW & ORD vs. THE

REMAINING TWU OBJECTED TO REMAINING TWU OBJECTED TO CLEANING STATIONSCLEANING STATIONS

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

NUMBER OF TITLE II & IIICABIN EMPLOYEES

ORD/DFW

ALLREMAINING

SOURCE: APRIL 1-30,2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT

20

AIRPLANES CLEANED PER TITLE II & AIRPLANES CLEANED PER TITLE II & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW & III CABIN EMPLOYEES AT DFW &

ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU ORD vs. THE REMAINING TWU OBJECTED TO CLEANING STATIONSOBJECTED TO CLEANING STATIONS

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

AIRPLANES CLEANED PER A TITLE II& III CABIN EMPLOYEE

ORD/DFW

ALL REMAINING

SOURCE: APRIL 1-30, 2004 AA AIRCRAFT CLEANING REPORT USING BOTH AA’S AND TWU’S TITLE II AND III CABIN CLEANERS LISTS

21