AMENDMENTS 1 - 45

AM\1218442EN.docx PE660.354v01-00

EN United in diversity EN

European Parliament2019-2024

Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs

2020/2174(DEC)

8.1.2021

AMENDMENTS1 - 45Draft opinionDerk Jan Eppink(PE660.353v01-00)

2019 discharge: European Banking Authority (EBA)(2020/2174(DEC))

PE660.354v01-00 2/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

AM_Com_NonLegOpinion

AM\1218442EN.docx 3/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

Amendment 1Csaba Molnár, Jonás Fernández, Paul Tang

Draft opinionParagraph 1

Draft opinion Amendment

1. Acknowledges that, in the opinion of the Court, the European Banking Authority’s transactions underlying the annual accounts for the year 2019 are legal and regular in all material aspects;

1. Highlights that, in the opinion of the Court, the European Banking Authority’s transactions underlying the annual accounts for the year 2019 are legal and regular in all material aspects;

Or. en


Draft opinionParagraph 1 a (new)


1 a. Welcomes the Authority’s efforts towards a more coordinated supervisory regime across the European financial system; underlines its role to ensure a stable, well-integrated, efficient and safe financial market; highlights the importance of consumer protection in the Union by promoting fairness and transparency on the product and financial services market, and looks forward to receiving an update on future measures taken in this direction, including also responses to the challenges of the digitalisation of the economy and sustainability measures;

Or. en


PE660.354v01-00 4/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

Draft opinionParagraph 1 b (new)


1 b. Stresses that the supervision of the public financial sector positively contributes to combating tax fraud and money laundering;

Or. en


Draft opinionParagraph 1 c (new)


1 c. Recalls the importance of the Authority in the prevention of money laundering and terrorism financing; looks forward to seeing the 10-point action plan for 2020/21 to enhance the future framework of prudential and anti-money laundering requirements over dividend arbitrage schemes;

Or. en

Amendment 5Csaba Molnár, Jonás Fernández, Marc Angel, Paul Tang

Draft opinionParagraph 1 d (new)


1 d. Underlines the duty of the financial system in responding appropriately to the financial sustainability challenges, the European Green Deal and the Paris Agreement; welcomes, therefore, the Authority’s efforts of incorporating Environmental,

AM\1218442EN.docx 5/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

Social, and Governance factors fully into its work; is curious, in particular, about the intention to gather evidence over time on exposures related to assets of activities associated substantially with environmental and/or social objectives, and looks forward to an update on this work;

Or. en


Draft opinionParagraph 1 e (new)


1 e. Welcomes the establishment of an Advisory Proportionality Committee to oversee the principle of proportionality and looks forward to receiving the proposed methodology on how the Committee will provide input to EBA’s annual work programme;

Or. en


Draft opinionParagraph 1 f (new)


1 f. Recalls the Recommendation of the European Ombudsman in case 2168/2019/KR1a, which found that the EBA’s decision not to forbid its Executive Director from becoming the CEO of a financial industry lobby and not to immediately withdraw its Executive Director’s access to confidential information were maladministrations;

PE660.354v01-00 6/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

underlines, therefore, the importance of an open, efficient and independent European administration for all European agencies and the whole Union; stresses the need for a unified legal framework to address these issues;_________________1a https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/recommendation/en/127638

Or. en

Amendment 8Derk Jan Eppink



2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues;

2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues because of blurred responsibilities;

Or. en

Amendment 9Ivars Ijabs, Gilles Boyer, Engin Eroglu, Stéphanie Yon-Courtin, Dragoș Pîslaru



2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause

2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts particularly in the IT sector the Authority relies on interim staff,

AM\1218442EN.docx 7/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues;

which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues;

Or. en

Amendment 10Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Danuta Maria Hübner



2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues;

2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues; is aware that, up to the time of its relocation, the Authority had been governed by UK labour law, which implies differences with regard to temporary subcontracting; calls on the Authority to enhance clarity from now on in its recruitment of staff in line with EU labour standards;

Or. es

Amendment 11Gunnar Beck, Marco Zanni, Antonio Maria Rinaldi, Valentino Grant, Francesca Donato



2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a

2. Shares with concern the Court’s observation that to compensate for a

PE660.354v01-00 8/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues;

shortage of posts the Authority relies on interim staff, which may cause dependencies on the interim work agencies and pose risks of inadequate supervision of complex work by external contractors and contractual litigation issues; urges the Authority to make sure that contracts avoid any confusion between the procurement of services and of interim workers;

Or. en

Amendment 12Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Inese Vaidere, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Danuta Maria Hübner



2 a. Considers that the responsibilities of the Authorities have progressively increased since their creation; notes that budget increases should be gradual and continuous over time in line with the increase in competencies. Considers that the future responsibilities arising, inter alia, from the Digital Finance Strategy as well as the responsibilities inherent in the fight against money laundering require an adaptation of the Authorities' financing;

Or. es




2 a. Stresses the urgency to allocate

AM\1218442EN.docx 9/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

sufficient resources to the Authority to allow it to carry out its allocated tasks in an adequate and efficient manner;

Or. en




2 b. Recalls the Report on the annual accounts of the European Banking Authority (EBA) for the financial year 2019 of the European Court of Auditors, according to which the EBA might have used IT service contracts for the provision of labour, which is not in compliance with EU social and employment rules; calls the Authority, therefore, to ensure that contracts avoid any confusion between the procurement of IT services and of interim workers;

Or. en




2 b. Underlines that in certain cases the mandates adopted at level 1 of the legislation do not take into account the minimum timeframes required for the Authorities to carry out the necessary work to develop and adopt level 2 measures, thereby making reallocations of resources necessary and causing delays in

PE660.354v01-00 10/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

the implementation of certain measures;

Or. es

Amendment 16Stéphanie Yon-Courtin, Gilles Boyer, Ivars Ijabs



3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest;

3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest; calls on the Authority to draw inspiration from the publication by the ECB's Ethics Committee of its opinions on cases of conflict of interest and post-mandate gainful employment, in order to increase transparency on potential conflicts of interest and on post-mandate gainful employment;

Or. fr





3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest; emphasises in particular that the Board of supervisors should not have given its approval for the Authority’s former Executive Director to take on the role of a Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Financial Markets in Europe;

Or. en

AM\1218442EN.docx 11/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN





3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest; welcomes the first steps taken towards prevention and proper management of conflicts of interest and transparency measures, by following up on the Ombudsman’s recommendations; looks forward to a full update on the state of play of preventive and management measures taken and/or foreseen;

Or. en





3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest; notes with satisfaction that the EBA acted upon the EU ombudsman’s recommendations and introduced measures on how to deal with future revolving door situations and, for instance, stands ready to forbid senior staff from taking up certain positions when they leave the EBA; warns, however, that only time will tell whether those rules will be properly enforced; 3a

_________________3a See the Ombudsman reaction to the

PE660.354v01-00 12/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

introduction of new measures by the EBA : https://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/press-release/en/131984

Or. en

Amendment 20Stasys Jakeliūnason behalf of the Verts/ALE Group




3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment conflicts of interest; calls upon the Authority to ensure that its internal procedures for dealing with conflicts of interest are in line with the Ombudsman’s recommendations following her inquiry into the EBA Executive Director’s move to a finance lobby group, if they are not yet fully aligned; calls further upon the Authority to enforce it Ethics Guide so as to protect the integrity of the institution and establish fair and responsible practices;

Or. en




3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment

3. Recalls its resolution of 13 January 2020 on institutions and bodies of the EMU: preventing post-public employment

AM\1218442EN.docx 13/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

conflicts of interest; conflicts of interest and the decision of the European Ombudsman in case 2168/2019/KR of 7 May 2020; strongly agrees with the Ombudsman that the Authority should have forbidden the job move and that the measures put in place to prevent conflicts of interest are not sufficient to address the risks involved;

Or. en




3 a. Welcomes the adoption by the Authority`s Board of Supervisors of its Policy on Independence and Decision Making Processes for avoiding Conflicts of Interests; calls on the European Court of Auditors to specifically scrutinize in its future audits of the Authority (i) if senior staff members have taken up certain positions in the financial industry after their term in office, (ii) the timely manner in which access to confidential information for staff members is withdrawn, once it became known that they are moving to another job;

Or. en

Amendment 23Stéphanie Yon-Courtin, Gilles Boyer, Ivars Ijabs



3 a. Calls on the Authority to draw

PE660.354v01-00 14/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

inspiration from the ECB's initiatives to propose internal programmes for the promotion of women and for greater diversity among its staff; Notes in this regard the public and written commitments made by the Authority's new Executive Director, and calls on the Authority to report regularly to Parliament on the progress of its commitments on parity and diversity;

Or. fr




3 a. Reiterates its call for a gender balanced staff policy, as well as an implemented employment policy fully compliant with EU social and employment rules;

Or. en




4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles;

4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles, which was illustrated by the non-adoption of a recommendation in the Danish-Estonian money laundering case; is concerned about the reluctance of supervisors to

AM\1218442EN.docx 15/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

sanction their peers, which may hamper efficient decision making;

Or. en

Amendment 26Markus Ferber




4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles as illustrated by the Danske Bank case;

Or. en

Amendment 27Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Sirpa Pietikäinen




4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles; considers that its ability to obtain accurate information from financial institutions is not sufficient to exercise its various responsibilities;

Or. es


PE660.354v01-00 16/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN




4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles; notes that the Authority is understaffed and not in a position to conduct EU-wide mission such as stress test exercises under the best conditions; recommends greater means for a greater autonomy from Member State’s national authorities4a

_________________4a See the Court of auditors’ special report : With very limited staff resources and a lot of effort the EBA coordinated the exercise involving many stakeholders and within tight deadlines. (..). Owing to the lack of resources and the current governance arrangements, the EBA was not in a position to ensure “comparability and reliability of methods, practices and results”, as envisaged in the regulation. https://op.europa.eu/webpub/eca/special-reports/eba-stress-test-10-2019/en/

Or. en





4. Acknowledges that the composition of the Board of Supervisors seems appropriate to deal with the EBAs’ rulemaking responsibilities, but less so for their supervisory roles; recalls, in this

AM\1218442EN.docx 17/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

context, the Authority’s new mandate in the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing; stresses further that the Authority should make full use of the powers granted to it under Chapter II of Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010 to ensure that all assignments and tasks are carried out properly and on time, and to ensure attainment of the tasks and objectives set out in that same Chapter, particularly with regard to consumer protection in the fast-growing area of digital finance, including neobanks;

Or. en




4 a. Notes that, as the Authority’s workload is increasingly shifting from regulatory tasks to enforcing and applying Union law, budgetary and personnel resources have to be reallocated internally; points out that a strict focus on the mandate assigned by the European legislator will ensure a more effective and more efficient use of resources;

Or. en




4 a. Acknowledges that the Authority

PE660.354v01-00 18/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

has conducted an inquiry into dividend arbitrage trading schemes such as cum-ex or cum-cum as requested by the European Parliament1a; notes, however, the report's shortcomings in shedding light on those illegal practices and regrets that no date for a formal inquiry has been set;_________________1a https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/TA-8-2018-0475_EN.html

Or. en




4 b. Points out that the principle of proportionality should be a guiding principle for the Authority's work;

Or. en

Amendment 33Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Sirpa Pietikäinen



5. Is concerned that in contrast to the established budget, the contributions of EFTA Members’ National Competent Authorities (NCA) were not calculated according to the formula set out in that very same budget and thus reduced the payments of EU and EFTA NCAs by EUR 0.7m; notes that the calculation of pension

5. Notes that in contrast to the established budget, the contributions of EFTA Members’ National Competent Authorities (NCA) were not calculated according to the formula set out in that very same budget and thus reduced the payments of EU and EFTA NCAs by EUR 0.7m; notes that the calculation of pension

AM\1218442EN.docx 19/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

contributions needs further clarification; contributions needs further clarification; is aware that the calculation is an estimate and that it is subject to the composition of the staff during the year and to the possibility of making adjustments annually;

Or. es




5. Is concerned that in contrast to the established budget, the contributions of EFTA Members’ National Competent Authorities (NCA) were not calculated according to the formula set out in that very same budget and thus reduced the payments of EU and EFTA NCAs by EUR 0.7m; notes that the calculation of pension contributions needs further clarification;

5. Is concerned that in contrast to the established budget, the contributions of EFTA Members’ National Competent Authorities (NCA) were not calculated according to the formula set out in that very same budget and thus reduced the payments of EU and EFTA NCAs by EUR 0.7m; notes that the calculation of pension contributions needs further clarification; calls on the Commission to ensure the receipt of missing payments

Or. en

Amendment 35Gunnar Beck



5 a. Regrets that the amended 2019 budget does not contain adequate information on France´s contributions to the Authority’s running costs; calls on the Authority to publish these figures as soon as possible;

PE660.354v01-00 20/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

Or. en

Amendment 36Gunnar Beck



5 b. Calls on the Authority to verify the declarations of compliance with French social and labour law made by contractors in accordance with the Financial Regulation applicable to the general budget of the Union, and to publish these declarations on its website;

Or. en




6. Notes that the Authority has intensified its administrative cooperation with the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) in terms of public procurement procedures;

6. Notes that the Authority has intensified its administrative cooperation with the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) in terms of public procurement procedures, in particular when both authorities make use of framework contracts established by respective other authority but also when joining public procurement procedures run by the European Central Bank (ECB) and the Eurosystem Procurement Coordination Office (EPCO);

Or. en

Amendment 38

AM\1218442EN.docx 21/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Inese Vaidere, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Danuta Maria Hübner



6. Notes that the Authority has intensified its administrative cooperation with the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) in terms of public procurement procedures;

6. Welcomes the fact that the Authority has intensified its administrative cooperation with the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) in terms of public procurement procedures; calls for the spirit of synergy to continue in the interests of the efficiency of both authorities.

Or. es




7. Notes that after the completed relocation from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is made for the lease of the EBA’s London office.

7. Notes that after the completed relocation of its premises from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is accounted for in relation to the lease of the EBA’s London office.

Or. en




7. Notes that after the completed 7. Notes that after the completed

PE660.354v01-00 22/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

relocation from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is made for the lease of the EBA’s London office.

relocation from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is made for the lease of the EBA’s London office; notes that the new host Member State, France, contributed 2,5 million euros in January 2019 to the EBA’s running costs but the amended 2019 budget does not contain adequate information on France’s contribution.

Or. en




7. Notes that after the completed relocation from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is made for the lease of the EBA’s London office.

7. Notes that after the completed relocation from London to Paris following the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, a provision of 10,1 million euros is made for the lease of the EBA’s London office; suggests that an audit be conducted once all the costs and consequences of the move are clear in order to identify best practices and areas for improvement .

Or. en




7 a. Is of the opinion that the

AM\1218442EN.docx 23/24 PE660.354v01-00

EN

combination of public-private experience that its staff brings is beneficial to the Authority; considers that systems should be explored to attract talent from the private sector to the public sector and vice versa, with minimum safeguards in place to promote the independence of both sectors; believes that the implementation of the rules in this area should be monitored by common bodies of the Union and should take into account the specific circumstances of each case;

Or. es




7 a. Recalls that France, as the new host member of the Agency, contributed 2500 000 euros in January 2019 and 500 000 euros in January 2020 to the budget of the EBA, which was adopted in December 2019, but do not contain adequate information on these contributions.

Or. en

Amendment 44Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Markus Ferber, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Danuta Maria Hübner



7 b. Points out that the Authority, when carrying out its activities, needs to pay attention to ensuring compliance with

PE660.354v01-00 24/24 AM\1218442EN.docx

EN

Union law, to respecting the principle of proportionality and to complying with the fundamental principles which govern the internal market;

Or. es

Amendment 45Isabel Benjumea Benjumea, José Manuel García-Margallo y Marfil, Andreas Schwab, Eva Maydell, Markus Ferber, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Danuta Maria Hübner

Draft opinionParagraph 7 c (new)


7 c. Believes that the Authority should take account of new digital challenges and those related to sustainability; considers that the fulfilment of these established objectives and their integration into the regulatory and supervisory framework must always be in line with the strengthening of the market, without undermining its competitiveness and without placing an excessive burden on market actors, especially small and medium-sized ones; considers that the monitoring of the implementation of these objectives must be met with adequate resources;

Or. es

Documents

AMENDMENTS 1 - 45