8/2/2019 All India Seniority-Guntur Comments
1/2
ALL INDIA CENTRAL EXCISE INSPECTORS ASSOCIATION
GUNTUR BRANCH: KANNAVARITHOTA: GUNTUR
522 004(RECOGNISED BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, VIDE CBEC F.NO.B.12017/1/2004-Ad.IV A dated 31.12.07
&
14.01.08)
A.REVANTH P.V.SATYANARAYANA
PRESIDENT GENERAL SECRETARY9848234664 7893961234
Ref. No.09/2012-Gen. Date:31.03.2012.
ToThe Secretary General,AICEIA, Kolkota.
Dear Koushikji,
Sub: Proposal of unified Seniority in the cadre ofInspectors to
remove regional disparity Reg.
***
Kind reference is invited to the Boards
letterF.No.8/B/44/HRD(HRM)2011(Pb.I) dt.28.03.2012 on the subject
matterand further to the request of the SG for the views and
comments. Letme thank you, profusely for undertaking this exercise
on such a issuewhere there is no unanimity.
2. The Guntur Branch has the following
comments/views/suggestions to offer.
a) The subject of all India seniority and all India
transferabilitywere discussed and dealt at length few years ago and
wasshelved as impracticable by the Board itself.
b) The all India seniority subject is brought fore again just to
solvethe regional disparities in-promotions would invariably
invitelitigations and would lead to mess-up the issue further than
tosolve.
c) Differences in the member units of AICEIA would surface on
thecontroversial subject and would lead to a situation where
theexistence of AICEIA would be at stake.
d) The AICEIA represents only a third of the cadre, therefore
takingup a controversial subject where there are differences,
wouldgive opportunity to the Board to pit AICEIA against its
members.
e) For a problem limited to certain regions an all India
solution isnot possible. Therefore a specific solution is to be
foundpertaining to the identified regions.
f) The cadre cannot be compared to other cadres who have the
allIndia seniority. The post of an inspector is a small one and
hislimits have to be drawn confining to the boundaries of a
state,at the most.
8/2/2019 All India Seniority-Guntur Comments
2/2
g) As decided by the Board this is practicable only from
2004onwards. Nothing should be done to disturb the
existingstructure as it would bring out tsunami of litigating
issues whichwill take away our energies and immerse us in a sea
oflitigations which is very much avoidable.
h) We have enough no. of issues pertaining to the cadre
where
there is unanimity of opinion, we better concentrate on
thoseissues than on the issues which divide us.
i) If this issue is allowed to take centre stage the Board will
havean excuse to further delay Cadre Restructuring which is
alreadya delayed and truncated one.
j) Let us not allow ourselves to play into the hands of the
peoplewho are bent upon striking at our beleaguered unity. Lets us
bevigilant and remain awake against such attempts.
k) Therefore, the AICEIA is requested to think twice before
takingany decision on this issue where there is no unanimity.
Comradely yours(P.V.Satyanarayana)
***
