61
aisi siqAq owisiow 51IHM :UJOD UMA TMMT[VT'll 0MWA JADI$1OTIH IO TMM AI5I A ATAU TMUODDA TM5151TJD enoI. .T w3dflEM bl3ThdO huEM EO1ô 'I3qB nthoW HD5IA315I DIMOMODJ IO UAHSIUH JAMOITAM 3un3vA efl,audaaaM OO I 8E1O AM gbhdmI3D V(Q1 1uI. n131 iiuno1 2ThJ )1OOD £21J VOanOH £1111130 t13)133H 1flEW imuosH mirriBT oi hfti3 31B 3W innsvoi0 ei2ivpm113 ni3 b121oM 3nithdD in311a2oM aII3nnBM jiJ3M nsl bn1voDI ioT 3v&1 3W .eiwo2 bns £Isb dhiw 33nsiEiaaE idi £wflsT 3qq321110 bn 3123! 33jq 0q bivsU h,q bns$ duIo0 3V3J fl331g113f13i3 nsH imuo8 mimBT moi 21101 U2 IIñqI3rI moil b3fft3n3d moi1 iloqqu2 113m32351 .nwo iuo ia 2noi iqai bns anoieaimo ion hA .1o1BT nIA flJ33qolIJd bn nMrn3O io1 1n3D 31h moil bas 5I3HM 3di o insi noiMbnu&1 33n3i3 l13noirsM Is Iisrn-3 sly b3d31351 3d 1153 aiortlus 3rlT .b3b31wom13s hhii13Is1 21 1hH-DU Is 23ibui is iqsq 21111 mali aIsb 3dT .ub3.s313Ai3d.no33@b131i2do bns ub3.313A13d.no33Ja3nojlm lo hsq 21 iqsq 2irIT .1mlr1.b131I2do-23noj\1o.i3dfI.www\\:qflr1 is lsrrnol 31110113313 111 31d131113v5 bsiT lsnoitscn3inl bns 23im0fl03301313M bris 33nsn1:I hsnoiIsm3lnI 111 ams1o1q 113153251 5IHHM IsnolIsM 3111 'b 320111 ion bns 2101111113 di 10 320111 315 b3assiqx3 noimqo nA .tn3rnt23vnI bns .1131532351 3fm01103H lo 111331118 toil iX3t1O 211011332 tior1 .b3V13231 2i11h hA .bI3b&JO 33r1usM bns 231101. .T W3rIiiaM d VQ(?1 © tib313 huub Isrht b3bivolq noie2frrn3q tiailqx3 tujoihliw btoup 3d sm 211qs1smq owl b333x3 01 .3311102 311101 fl3V1 21 33il0f1 © nibu13ni

aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

aisi siqAq owisiow 51IHM

:UJOD UMA TMMT[VT'll 0MWA JADI$1OTIH IO TMM AI5I A

ATAU TMUODDA TM5151TJD

enoI. .T w3dflEM bl3ThdO huEM

EO1ô 'I3qB nthoW

HD5IA315I DIMOMODJ IO UAHSIUH JAMOITAM 3un3vA efl,audaaaM OO I

8E1O AM gbhdmI3D V(Q1 1uI.

n131 iiuno1 2ThJ )1OOD £21J VOanOH £1111130 t13)133H 1flEW imuosH mirriBT oi hfti3 31B 3W innsvoi0 ei2ivpm113 ni3 b121oM 3nithdD in311a2oM aII3nnBM jiJ3M nsl bn1voDI ioT

3v&1 3W .eiwo2 bns £Isb dhiw 33nsiEiaaE idi £wflsT 3qq321110 bn 3123! 33jq 0q bivsU h,q bns$ duIo0 3V3J fl331g113f13i3 nsH imuo8 mimBT moi 21101 U2 IIñqI3rI moil b3fft3n3d

moi1 iloqqu2 113m32351 .nwo iuo ia 2noi iqai bns anoieaimo ion hA .1o1BT nIA flJ33qolIJd bn nMrn3O io1 1n3D 31h moil bas 5I3HM 3di o insi noiMbnu&1 33n3i3 l13noirsM

Is Iisrn-3 sly b3d31351 3d 1153 aiortlus 3rlT .b3b31wom13s hhii13Is1 21 1hH-DU Is 23ibui is iqsq 21111 mali aIsb 3dT .ub3.s313Ai3d.no33@b131i2do bns ub3.313A13d.no33Ja3nojlm lo hsq 21 iqsq 2irIT .1mlr1.b131I2do-23noj\1o.i3dfI.www\\:qflr1 is lsrrnol 31110113313 111 31d131113v5

bsiT lsnoitscn3inl bns 23im0fl03301313M bris 33nsn1:I hsnoiIsm3lnI 111 ams1o1q 113153251 5IHHM IsnolIsM 3111 'b 320111 ion bns 2101111113 di 10 320111 315 b3assiqx3 noimqo nA .tn3rnt23vnI bns

.1131532351 3fm01103H lo 111331118

toil iX3t1O 211011332 tior1 .b3V13231 2i11h hA .bI3b&JO 33r1usM bns 231101. .T W3rIiiaM d VQ(?1 © tib313 huub Isrht b3bivolq noie2frrn3q tiailqx3 tujoihliw btoup 3d sm 211qs1smq owl b333x3 01

.3311102 311101 fl3V1 21 33il0f1 © nibu13ni

Page 2: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

n3ma232B35I A :bIoD bnB rnrnivnI nivs £sU ffiJJo33A tn5rwD 1I3rIOaiH1O bIbadO 33huaM bna a3not .T wr1thM

O1 .oi4 1qB nnhoW 51HM VQQI 1ut

OIM 1I .aoM J31 a3!mOnoao131M bnl3 3rIBn!I 1&ioiIsmnI

nmta3vnI bilE binT 1EnoiEmnI bilE

TDAHTHA

nuiEd d i1inuo3 n hill ioI ninb tnuo33B tnmJ3 II mW bhoW-iq ivt iqsq ir1T

daiuniiib ot 111 nflo eaiuoe aiab IE3hoiairI bibnsi 311T .iasd fliflO3 £ no awoft b1o

ahoqx b1o inomnon bilE aiib13 i o33a-1EiqE3 1131(1w 2hoqx3 b1o vnom nwtd iol ffUO33S o J3iBb nmiavni IE3horaiIl ataujbE oaIB iqq 311T .aib13 tnuo3as-tn5rtu3 16 113111W

in3rnavni bilE niva lo a3smia t3lniano3 o beau ii f3rth baivi 3111' .anoIn3vni flu a,nE113

2Q1 oiO81 mou1boh3qll13vo

11iutin ab1 nuox fl3flU3 311 mofI awofl bIo3 vinom nivom5r ioI o1obor1i3m iiO

noiaa311 311T .'i1idom Isriqs3 no aiaihoqc1 AohoH-thab1I ,rlIo noiaiv bibrwra-b1o s

-aaol3 3viiaoq 1jns3flrn1a bnuol oriw n1n3d3iTIo ao11 rliiw rn3mi bsoid ni

b1o r1 n3rIw aboh3q moa nhub nv in3mavni bits niva nwid nolisI5rlo3 Isnoiro3a

n33w13d anonEl3TIoa 3tEuuta3 3W aflOiau13flo3 islirnia Ibsoid mh13s31 tiqaU .b3lisv3lq bisbnsa

.bnucii nIn3r1ai1 3aorb nsih tn flnia aa3l bits i3wol isrlw3moa 315 tD n3rniavni bits nivsa

tn3mia3v-nivsa di a1qmsadua iswrni 13110 O nothsqmo3 ni tall bniI w 1s1u3ihaq it!

.O.QI-QI bisbnste b1o bhow b3viv3l sb ais 8nitR 3111 nhub wol 1b3A1sm ai noitsl3no3

bl3badO 33fluEM e3no1 .T w3rlflEM a3lmono33 bo in3rnhsq3U a3imono3I bo in3rnhsq3U

1h38 simo1i1aD 10 'tia13vinU 31h3H aiinobi1D bo tia13viriU O88-OVQ AD IA13H 088 €-0V4Q AD 1h3H

SIEI8T4 bits ub3.313A13d.no33@a3noiim ub3.313h3d.no3$b13btado

Page 3: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

noibuboilnl .1

ii3dqx niAst d aninuo3 rwstiiift ioI £ib inuo33a iflTw3 H iW bhoW-31q aaiv31 iqsq aidT

wart 3dT .b1oo awoll IsrIoiiBnl3ini visinomnon bris vlai3nom n3swid noiithiaib rfi1o iflu03

bn.s 8nivia 1Bnorin nwt3d no!tsIrIo3 1sno11332-22o13 Isanoitri di nimx oi bsau ii sib

21 iBfLt fIOii3iIt33q2 3fli&fl0f1033 fIB no b3asd 21 2i2'IanB IRaii2iiBia iuO .atB1 in3miav 3iia3mob

.snom IErIoiisnl8irIi bn 3riemob rfiod as ava btoa H 3idw m bhow £ io1 iEnqo1qqB

diiw ai1inuo3 Isiiiaubni r&fr biB1ianom3b (O8I) sAonoH bits ni3rabI&I i3qsq Isnime £ nI

airIiIo noiiBi-IqirIi 3ftT .stsb OÔQI-iaoq ni aisi in8miaevni dir1 vsd ot bn3i oals 231s1 nvsa did

boiiqiini sloiioH bns riiiabI&I .3luisl3iiI iasv £ b3nwsqa asH bits 1si213vo1ino3 n3volq asrl 8rtlbnil

risrfi 13ths1 wlivsa fsnoiisn :

Isnqs3 'lo sri1idommi 1snoiiamrni mii-8no1 £ rtitsibni as 1111231 113(11

.niiio 1o (I1nuo3 iiorli ni nismsi bhow 3(11 ni i3r1wnB aau 3vir3ubolq aom 3(11 iuo 8nb1332

n8131o1 rliiw 2b93n IsriqE3 nm-rto1 risnft 01 a3ilinuo3 wolls ron ob audi 23311s!sdrm 1flUO335 In3ThJD

aiarbslino3 ii aus33d fIOtsIV ault 3361dm3 01 1(151311151 nd 3vsrf iocfius irIsup3adIJa rtsM .2nvsa

'.bhow tsiiiaubrii rn3bom odi niciiiw iiIidom fsiIqa3Io ib d8iil £ ol nuinioq n3biv3 13(1 10

2121213q 'ihs1ui sAoiloH-ni3iabI&1 3(11 13(113(1w 21 1o1313rb 13biano3 ol noira3up Isiuisn A

3vii&rnhlth nA .'1i1idom 1511q53 4ir1 b3muaslq b bon3q £ bisbns1a blo8 153122513 di mon sisb ni

fIOfflfflO3 isili b3u815 vsd odw slonoH bits rn312b131 1o 2311113 r1i Jloqqua ol bn3i bluow 13W2f15

law-raoq (181(1 3(11 3is13n3 32 iq ii1idommi Isiiqs3 ion a3ia1 in3mia3vth bits 8ffivsabo etnsnilrn3t3b

bIo8 b3nimsx3 rIod (sQQ1) fl331n3d3i1 bits (OQI) knuosH .anoiisI9lloD in3mia3vnf-8niVsa

IQI-O88! moil sisb rIiiw bAiow orlw imuosa .anoi2uI3no3 ufl3l3IIib b3d3s31 tud sizb bisbitsia

blo8 3(11 b boil3q-dua 'ns io1 noiisI3TIo3 fEnoii38a-a2o13 insaftin8ia on bnud'l a3ilinuo3 1(1813 io1

.'3V1IJ2 s ioI (QQ!) bbuiedO

I

Page 4: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

rn3d vnuo3 1noiiibbs 3rh) 23rtrnuo3 3010 b 3!qma £ ioI ab tn31flib grneu ia1tno3 01 .blsbrlsl2

-o13 iii 2t0313ff13o3 tr1sftini2 llsriigtsm bas l3rfaifl d3um bnudI n1an3daiI (2sMt bflnU c1i

.iivse rio t1I3ffl23Vfli b 2flOi223191 IEf1013332

25 fL3IJ2 23311102 l3fBb bisbrisf no IivsrI b31131 n33lan3rbi3 bns imuosH rtfoE[

Is3noiairflo aoqiuq 311f io1 kI1eu n3flo is sisb 3df 31111W .(Q1 88Q1 E8I 18QI) llsd3fiM

lob 3ffl02 TIOW h51u3it1fiq 21 isdf nimO3i1ofk 300 .2nmoojlor12 owf f2531 ffi 3v5r1 3f1f flo2flSqmO3

.ifaiisfe 3bslf 01 b1obo frl3mfs3lf 3rlf isi blsbnsi2 b!o df rthub 210110336 ifl3TW3bC) 212IM8 cia

fri bnudIrlo3 ififsf 2fri3msq lo 33n515d !5131fi0 31qmE2 3ldsIisvs 5111 cii a3rlffIIJO3 'nsm ioI

slidw awofl b1o Ifs 3bu13x5 shfnuoo smog .2woII bIos 1sfsnom 1111w b1o tibommo1o 2noqxs

tsisriorrrnoT4 .sbsif bfo visi3nom bris '(lsfsnom000 nsswfsd noibnuf2ib £ 3)1810 of fqmslls 2131110

3d bluorf2 nba bos noillud (Isi3nom lo 2rloqxs 31111w fibsia fnwoaas fnsiiua bilav' s s-is rloqxs bloa

f183 fl0I183ft12281321ff1 2ifIT .fibsla inU0335 ff1311113 s Ion bns iibsia 1iiU033a Isiiqsa s s bsfss-if

sd fwm 200i15v132d0 fasiib 1o s3nsads sth ni 113111W 23f51 1I1VS2 Ofrii 210113 15t1fl512dU2 sauboifru

ii 13V3WOf1 332 115(12 3W 2A .111110335 10311113 f1f bns fn3rata3Vni b 10112 sill 25 f1subi231 bofsmiis

.'OEfl0fflfl0fl 10 (ISf3nom isnifis 28 21101 fasaisif b1o isluairisq 1ieI of sfdr2aoqmi nsflo 21

nsm moil asnsrb 'Oolnsvni b noiamo iii1i S1S sfsb 211311 aIiM lo t1imO3rIOd2 isifiiiil A

bluod2 noiismiob Isiiqsa 220la b 2315m1123 SIdEIlSVs SiB sfsb nistIW .sfsb fnlsmf2svni a3nfntuoa

ani)1oohsvO .noirsmiol laiiqsa bsxft 220i 2S Hsw a 2SflOfflSvni 10 Laoi ni 2,805113 bubni

bns rI1vS2 nsswlsd noifslsrioa sdflo 2315101123 of 251d biswqu cis sva \sm noifslumuaas vIOfflsVnl

.fn3rnf23v(ii

(181101111 '(1U1n33 nlininin 3151 3(11 malI 25fs1 fn,mtasvni bris nivse no stsb Iiss iuO

.lnioq ainli 10 flOiaeU32ib a iol A xibnsqqA 33

Page 5: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

tioqoi ow srsb orlT how 2.UOlVO1 fit bonimsxo ohinIJo3 1o o!qrn oth 2bnsqxo II iW bhoW

oiom s no b1oIo 2woII 1snoifirnoini Isoit brts eon1fwO3 10 iodmun 1ois! £ ioI ohoUiovth obuI3ni

s1o-b1sbrIs2-bIog noowiod noiialon03 Isno!I3o-2o13 odi tsth i nibnfl 312sd iuO .2iasd inotrano3

(sQQ 1) noo1nod3iL nsdt tnr,x.fiirIi2 aoI bns iowoI isdwomoa ai si tnomiovni bits nivs

(Ioisns!qxs silT .t1oqs1 (OQI) imuoaH noiiafsrlo3 odi nsrli istasia llii i iud tsu2 smiis bhoW-toq iii risdi bisbnsia bfo8 silt isbnu iowol d3urri hcrndIiriu el enoieesisi scout b iswoq

slab II isW

cow iorlio 'nsm oved lcuoivdo 'orli stsb scodibo rfotis3ilqqs 3fut3sqe £ tnseslq ow duodtLA

bluode o1qmsxo io1 diwoi 31ffl0fl030 10 ioivsdod nive nul-8n01 rubuie in botesisini aiaocol

.Iiuboeu inoesiq ow slab sift bull

s)sfl InuoooA inorwD ni woN bloO b tnsmlasiT silT . 15131fl0 10 ansom tnsnimoboiq suit ciw bloa lQ1 -0V81 so) bisbnstc b1o lsoiaeslo suit isbnU

cotmonoos ioAism icom ni oiloq viatonom b isteobol suit aniod es how CE inomohitsc Isnorismoirn

d iud cbisbnaic 3ihlaiomid brie ivhi brie bIos noov,isd beietnsile bed cnoiien iojarn suit lIQI oiioh i bw rniIanoiiari sviiasl3 b bhow e ni d3mnom euomnona di aew bho[) .iaooi suit bslui blo 0V8 I odi brie mcilenoiiemsini bsxiIo&n'c ii ;iogimnoo brie snndxs lo muibsun sism a nsdt siam iol boinuoo

wel Ienoiienisini 10 shirt

nriqi 1eiI nsmioE) s3ns1I bneIni'I hernnsU ebsneD iIsiicuA ste slqmae mo in csntfwoo nsshidi sifT E

him aiu5l lo ozrnivolq a aew bus LniI .esiei2 boiinU suit brie mob3niA bslinU sift nsbew sicau5I swioM 3imono3O b ooiob r1ic1 £ bed bnshrii1 isvwod sonsbnsqsbni siolsd nv3 .snsbnsqsbni bsioloth ii nsdw VIQI

soc aborhiom brie 233iUO2 no clisiob isdhiil io1 .Angd hiniriso brie 3ri3TW3 nwo cii aniv'sif mono3us ion no nab oldalinve silt boldmsaas oclw (8QI) blsflmoolflbo iniqe sift iii d3um tsv ci buia nO fl xibnsqqA

.ohqmee mo eqehovo IIetiieq lent asrtlnuO3 10 slqmee £ mdl atnsmsvom leti qs .(88 .q 8Ql) IhsbnuM

Page 6: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

Isictim o fauboiq rIf fibommo3 bbsif s o215 asw b1o v3wofI Ioi isfnom au of noifibbs ru

bns noii3ubolq wn no b3brloq3b arnai bto 1si3nom bliowlo rftwoi sdi bbnI .noifstiotqx

bib 'ILsuau auioqmi bns atIoqx bIo8 no a3ffEifEfa lsi3iflO ahfnuo ni3uboiq bloa ioI .i3voaib

-isinorrz nuiaix3Iq 10 ain3mqitk bns b1o b3uboiq 1wn nwfd daiuniiaib of fqmffs fon

irIfo ris iiI fau( fib313 inuo33E fn3rlu3 s fn3a1q1 bIos b33ubolq !w3n b thoqxa .2)!3Ofa

of aunmqida jM .nivsa !snoiisn of bbs sdi ;tloqx9 ivia io aibnsdaim

3ub51 rff wc ;fib13 inuoca !sfiqs3 s m 13vworf bto vicfnom lb al3nai3lo1

.afaas n8i1o1 33n ni3ub3I sd aruivss !snoifsn

in313fiib idf wuiau 'd awofi b!o nisf1iaacb 10 m8ldolq cIi Hiiw iIsb 3vsd ansnofaiH

bIos us vuiaasI3 of nd asri (I .riI I1 .q VQ1 niiani&T iisiq nO .a3i3oIobor1fm

nifs1u31s3 ni a3nstsd rioqx b1uas3m mofl m3rff i3Siidua of bns iuisn 111 1sf9nom as afn3m3vom

fnuo3as in3iu3 3rIf fli ainmqirta bIo8 tic 3vs31 of ai iub3oiq bno3sa A .fnuo33s fn3r1u 3rtf

of iqm3fls of ai owf iaiil fIf of !ds131-iq lls3!f31osrff rf3soiqqa biiiff A .(IQ1 -xoniV

anoifqmuaas sdi adi13ab noif33a fx3n rfT .afn3m3vom bfo visi3nomnon molt isfnorn deiunitaib

.rl3aolqqs biidf atrlf lb rloifs3ilqqs iqoiq d13bnu fsfli

In,nv&'I to ,30&IRfl ,IIf iii awofl bIo .A

iuasm moa niiosiidua d Iqmia sfsb fnuo33s fnrlu3 Isi3ffIo fauibs of tdias1 ls3qqs fdiin fI

irl3i&fiib idf oini awofi bIos b3lIiaasI3 a5flfrwo3 IIs3iqT .bIo isfnomlo ain9mqiria fn 1f lb

t on ob a3i1ofs3 31flf 3a3di Isfsnutrn1nU bIo b3nh11nu bns noillud (nio3) i38qa :a3nofs3

sm anio3 nuiEfu31i3 Iqmsx -toI .bIo1o awoft isunornrion bris vistnom of If3iib bnoqa3iio3

isth !qmi bkiow aidT .ainmsqbo 33n515d &ff 33(15(111 of b3rloqx9 bits noillud of nwob betl,m 3d

Page 7: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

Q CIJ wc ow co ounuIIu 9u onucc oojq OLC lufo w onucc opnjpou

jjfl2 cxmubjc qI/ Ou OØUIIJCL (iofl)

OAGL2jC 9uq IJ4IU2 2f11.bJfla oACI2Gq

J.ow uT2LJ192 GxboI4? o pc y) vn LSJ12 criaciu cconu qcjci onjq pc

o prrjpoif uq ipcu ! apibbcq upoqQ i pi2 oq 2pibwclu MGLG jpcjcq 9 woucwt.A uq

2pIbwcu4 OOLC ju pi u2cliou qic oq OLC CIJCL2 qic VflL9VU woucwiA ojq iocic 'U ipc ouii

pet. qcwuq pA bnLcpiu 9U onucc o woucWLA pntIIou w ucq oJJJC JO/CI. PflO,E1&1LC J 2OM2 Mp pbbcu2 MCIJ 1JJC fly uqn2fu JI2CL 212IJC2 p12 OL

2plbwcue uA LC2OLlJC WC92flLC opc cnucu cconi 2flt.bJn2 onjq uc pA ouc onuce

cconu 2nthjrt2 (ru jCUJJ2 oojq) pA ouc onucc ucc pc Luc!ou CIG9LIA i uoj woucin.A oq

UJWC 10 uql4J I12GL LU iJJG fluicq yuqow 1p!2 ILU2CIJOU L!2C2 fl21Lj!12 OCISJ CILLCIU

iuqicGq tu pcribbct. pj IJ OtIIJCC oucMJA-wiucq oq OLC 12 2plbbcq qCJA jOW 9U fl2I2JiU

E!nLc j 1JJn2LC2 pc bt.opjcwpA 2poMJu wo cdniAijcu IWGLU&liouffj 1LU2CIJOU2 PJ JJC UI.2r

- OL Lu /1jflC bLoboWou2 - o iuqnp.is ot. woci) fl2Cpcipct ojq JCJAJIJ uuq IJUJAJIJ CUJC OW OUC OL JJC OIJJCL O qiC2C OflLCC2 MJJCIjJCL i It92 OIIJ

jyuiu (pGC19221CS1 OJq 21IJqq bCUOq !f Iwbo2etpJc to jwoi ru p it wouA o ccouc ctcoi.A ruto (pG oipcL Nit1U ouc corwp.A uuq qowc2(ic ojq bt.oqnciou cu vccr rpc 2tOCJ2 ojjyc cbn.pou owoucutA suq uou-woucA 8oq 12 uct(pcL 21wb1c Dot. coucjn1Ac (ojq cu WOAC t.ow

OI2GU2tCW (j b ) op2cuc2:

WOUctLA ojq 110M2 MGLG uot pjjA cbrnt.cq pA tpc q ou 2bccrc cxbot.a 2

Page 8: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

211o1120w11 blog Pn,i,Thb lo ,nihvhjp3I :1 nuiI

.)I .U .10 F njIitauA Isiitaubnl eio bIo

eau blop uquo

nsllsdauA yistenom l3otabIoQ

.i .u •'° nsIIsdauA IBIlteubni , 010 blog

eau blog tuqtuo

h213 o ninuoxs tr13mq 1o 3anBtd ni 3aib1q bibrr1a 1 ii 2m3fdo1q (13u2 biovs oT

a 'Iqqu2 vnom 3iJ23fnob 3d oini 2831U02 '(IBt3nornnon 3ii23mob moft bIos b etn3m3vom II

1sup3 ns 2ifl3mvEq lo 5)nBfsd d1 11b313 111U033E 1n311u3 1IIt tüto oT .thoqx3 bIo8 '13nomnon

visinom £ el bcis i22s ni31oI1o nofn2iupafi 3(11 2133ft31 lid3b 3dT .b3bbs ai tid3b 1nuo3s 1nqB3

fis i )13o12 bloa 1i3nom 3(11 ni 32S313fl1 'n 1fIi 21 33ii31q 2i(1i idI tnoi1i 31ff '.tloqmi bIo8

thw (Q I .q EQ I) 13nb1s0 aA .23v13231 8f1f13X3 fli31Ot 1fTOi1Efl (Ii 32S313fli

ibnsnbl3m innibio 10 1n2 vwi3nom IBnoiMm3irn 2J331I ii nw n1i nil iniu1uzq ai blot) di oi blo b3nhnn lwn lo lni 3iia3rnoQ .2i3ri31o1 01 21 31112 311111 1no 'rni 320(11 3211313fl1

'(IJ(uJo3 ,di 01 2noiiibbn 3(11112 3111 i3fl3 1inuo3 gnl3ubolq 3d1 lo 'uiaT io AnBa l61in3D

21! 10 3n11d3x3 fli3lo1 .bnoldfi b102 bun b3noqx3 nd end blo 3di 11 as arnei lSnoiisnl3lni blog b3nim 1w3n 3an3H .223301q 1311113 'd aithodtua 'iai3nom d.t1o abwld 311t nil b3isI3 V in5lsJüJp3

.aoiiiiodiu V1Si3flom 1133o1 3(1101 l1iib io bnoidn bloe 13111311w .(1ifwo3 3(1110 t)oqx3 fin en bo&isi at

a1inib 13r11nJl 1oI .bniu1 -isi3noM lenotinm3jnI ni d b3bn3nnmo1 3110 3111 21 noijn3vno3 niinwox,n aidi' ' .(EQQI) einuo33A Isnoii11T4 no quoiO niAioW i8hsi3132-13inI 3111332

Page 9: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

floqmi wo9nflumia i s bebii i bora b!oa vianom 3dito tuO noiiqmhJno3 3fi2srnob halimi

th ni sini ns irf i rtOiiE3iIqmt 1 A .b1o v1 nom 1o noqx9 bnB bto vlsi3nornnon b

.rloqmi bloa vainom a 3d oi b3mo3b i )L3o2 bIo8 V 3flO 3i3mob

bIos visnomnon moiI via3nom aisqe o bia ,d1idiait i ti norrI$vno3 iñt l3bnU

'-ianorn i3n Iaup3 ol IYtAL .A3Ot2 b1o (I 3Off1 811t fit 3aflafI3 3rf 3d Th&t toJ .wofl

arnmqida b!o t3n 1soi aa b3i1ua1a3 od n& 2tloqx3 bloa itrzomnon n arioqmi bloa

- thoqx bIos 1 3110(11 fl (1) + = (YM -) - = \ioci oov blog us 3nibuI3x3 iftLJO33S ffi3TIU3 8(ft10 (11U2 eth 2t K) iflUO335 fl3T1U3 sdi noiitna3b 21th nO

:(I) noirsup3 moiI aJ-loqx3 bIos i nomnon t&i bris woft

() + + =

3rfr lu 3a63133b nibnoq3rIo3 rf d b3b3na3 315 £)? flu 2in3mqii!a b!o vis.trtom ns isdi 33ii0T4

3th sd o!a () noirsupd .i11uo33s in3Tlu3 i.ni 3th tfia on ob eudi bna Yt *oi bloa (tsi3nom

aa nL31oI tn tso 215up3 tnuo33s 1n3r1u3 311t biabnsa b!o a l3bnu :noitaiiqitni aniwollo

.blo8 '(IEt3nOm 10 fl0tfiIU(T1tJ33E t3ff II 3nibubni noifafumu33s

si1siwA nEd3 3(13U3 noibsansli 1311113(1 1 31UII fli 3Iqmsx3 3(11 01 gnuhllJi35I

3311s15d ifl1i0335 1113T11J3 c5115112UA 3I51 nwoi1 2tn3mqick bIos rft 1o rfiod 02 bot blo8 v1strtom

.b1o1o 3311U0 no sd () noitaiips ni b31u25&n as

V

Page 10: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

noiIa3ilqqA .8

-wO moth o obm vd ow t&fi atnomi2ujbs odi bnfi sisb IJ3no2id b1sbnEt oth 5dfl3,b won oW

tnU033S rrloTlu3 oth o boia bIos s(lsionom 3ii3mob oth ni oriada odi nibba o tnuoma 2tfloffttaL4bE

Ianoiarnorni na s b!o to o3nanmobolq oth nov10 8.inomqida b1o tsnoismstni ha to 9V12u!3fl1

hIairno1 ton ai '0irtuo3 £ nodw niov oisiiqoiqqa i tnomiwjba irhi bohoq oIqma2 iuo nil ioaEa oviooi

£i!STtWA s31i oW .aab ovanf ow nblcfw iol iso iovo nil ii Iqqs oiotoisrfi ow &ibnai b1o oth no

ionhiolo tnomtsoii dt f1ond eiom eu3eib nodl bna sh1aubivibni sbansD bns

jiiIrduA

.M 'd boliqmo3 320113 0Th tfltJO33E ifIOTIU3 nailsilauA oth no aiab I&iioid biabnate odT

rloilQIJbolq b1o no arab 3niau d 2oiul1 1nu033s IflOTIU3 nsilsirwA 9th tw1bI3 oH .(ôQ1) niltuH

atioqxo ton to bsotni

() + - 0 =

Isioi 2ziIa112uA i \3 bns 'Y 2tnomqid2 bIos II to OVi2tJI3fli imJO3a 3n0TIU) 9th 21 0

inuo3os lnoTIu3 oianqoiqqs odr aw noi33uboq b1o iadi bouia niliua .bloa bonIlomu to ruqiuo

bns b1oa to inomisoir 2'nitfuH .M boxi3irn3 (ôI) mcloofl .s(Irnuo3 ni3IJbo1q bIos a io1 iibol3

ocf 1 2olsi2lobnu 1inoup32nO3 bna 2t1oqxo bloa to lnotxo out 2otaialoVo oiuboooiq icf ianit bougia

ooi is awofi bEo LioJshid no fiflb fs3rIoivd hthcup bna '1dinom 3&fi llth331o!I bougia (Qt) motanogioM niw oiioa binbn oth iau1bs oi (hulrrnanf Jaiow in bnn) aaohlnioq mooa Jdaim ii wilT .Idloau oil ol 9181u336m

nowlod awoft 181ollid no slth I Q I -OOQ I trnmnxo iolta I) tuulboo0 •awofl bIos fwoilcmotni no ninb b1o tnloi avdnwo3 r13f3 no niab Iwfuu3 Ow oW .oso oih bolaiaio,o moianogioM Mdi o ukxio3 eXU ban U oth

.nlnb Iilinom bnoinhid tuuli iorio 01 139jd02 aoI oin Idamuaoiq ff3uIw wo11

a xibnoqqA eloqnq audi ni bow abodlom ban aowoa t1cb oth to aoirqn3aob bo1t1b n

8

Page 11: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

isth 2anot oWlo omo iimo niliua d boiqobfi (l3solqqa 3(11 1SI1i 332 (183 oW if3ftob Irwo3 13r11J3

iduob oM .iiiiEie 18f31110 Io noitaorio3 ois1ua o1 a oioIoisdi ai baa () noiiaupo ni isoqqa

21 2wOfI bloa Oisionom ni'jiiinobi 1o mofdoiq 9(11 ow&od noiismixoiqqa 21(11 bo2oqolq niliijfl

2inornovorn blog aionom Iiinobi 01 oqorl td8irn ono 33r1ai2rf 1 ioI .ai!aiiwA io't sf138 haIu3irIsq

ion 2111 1otsnurio1nU .1nib1o3aa oiuiI obail sill l2ujba nodi baa thiad 'd boqqiña bfo itliw

!suiqs3 o3nnnfi ot io ow 1i-iiwbai 1suinsv ioI blog niqqic12 oisw alaad iodisdw slab odi mofi 18313

ol (E) noiisupo Iibom 1183 ow si1aiiauA io1 siu11 lnuo33s lnoTlu3 olSrlqolqqs sill lo oT .2woftni

(l) + \3"j - + UTJ 3 =

a9ismui2I .bo3ubolq 28W 23fl32 111U0338 1f1511u3 WOE! £ baa ailsitwA 01 bsllqqa asw olubo3olq 2IrIT

woMb luo baa olni 2wofl 313sq2 .2wollOb a bovlisb 313W )I3ola bloa Ialsnom oil ni snarf sub

mobriiA boiinU bo hoqol IsunnA iii botioqei 28) aifailwA nisloW baa snol3fV as1aW dluo2

riifitwA bo nibIod noillud lsloi orfi iii oriar1 sill 01 bobba siow (iniM sill bo 1012aM iuqsU

201110103 osidl ofhbo luo baa olni 3133q2 bloabo woIl sili lnsmuaob 2rIoqol huM silT .thiad nibsil

sill od 01 aisoqqs Aool2 b1o iaionom 26i1s1i2uA ni ortarb dl b OlU2SOffl 21111 iovowoH .1no

d boliqmo3 )boi2 noillud baa 11103 b1o dl1o 2318m1123 sf11 OW ow OOQI iofis slab io1 .oldstiavs

.(IVQI) la Is aiIiuH .1 .2

.EIQI baa OOQI noowlod abanaD idi slab 2lasmsqbo o3naIad beldm32ea 'bu1 3122813 (IQ1) a'ioaiV

26 isisaom) elnornqirt2 bloa lanoiisfnsIrll Ha bsbubni ivswod 2olam,I2s Inuo3oa 1115T1u3 2'lonIV

Page 12: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

I0

0 C2IW&C UC 0LC!IJ 22C1 1UCOWC

c2I1JmIc2 ocr suq iiur roc iu couinI A!UCL suq ujuq ncq cmJJ1TJ1Jq cnuu cconuUCC2mcjmi. (j) jpi. qcrm flLdnpm cpumc ouc quiqcuq uq wfCLC2 bg?wcur2 ic pcq ou qiLcc

cowpuc 2IJAGL uq oq o oPv!u c2uw91c2 o uc cxboi. uq pc woucnA ocj o pc wo

9uqvLq (ji.uc Jg-Jj jwjA jgc-j b9u J8-J2 uq Jçnai jg-jg') i'c

ojq kI1IJJGIU 0L fl COfRULIG2 iii GAGL? A OjOrIL 2gwbjc EOL COflLUL1C PAGIC OU P!WGWII!C

3UGU 4€ Iwbo9ucc oojq 9 !U0!0uI LCCI.AC V2GL 0L LC CIUJLC bcuoq MC b€qouu ipc

OWCL Conu4ua

U0M

tu flLdrlp9LI uq ncJqcA (J iipicp bbLobuc1A acbLc woucLA tow uouwoucjiA ojq

UUCLC b?wJC1g210 EOL J3 OUMLq MC (1C ipc DOUJIIJ!OU B(ILCVfI 0J1C CIWC bi.cciucq

collc2bouqa o jicpa cxccb jrn flLdrtpu2 qw iucjnqc nbcuoL ciwc o u qiAiqcuq uq

jj nbbjcwctucq pA 0(11 OMU C1wC OL JQ-JgJ uq jfl 0(11 bbLocp

cpvuc w jpc owj qowcic wouciA ojq ocje cjcnjcq pA jçicp (io) OL jg pLO(1}J

cnu.cuj cconig ucjnqu oq ap!buJc14ow flLdnpI4 (jg) ye rn cdnjiou ( i# qq pc

Jc cvJcnjc cq crlaCIU cconuj OL pC AoLe JgIj-J a jpjjoe //G WJCC pc

C!UJVC2 0 UC 0LC!IJ CCI JUCOIJJC

o bAwciue (jçcp jgg b H!2 WOn AC iu iP!2 Ow!22!O1J /e C fWLGJ1p1pA o

qJtiqcuq uom qGb1ic p1 LGCO1JWOU pcA C0UeiUUCq eIsGgPIC Cw !U 1pC pjucc

wouctiA ojq U0Me IQCP C11I.I1U &CCO(1Uj C!WC 101 p0MCACL 0WI UC JUICLCCI uq

I'J WCC(1J0(12 UIAC! IQCP (1o88) qncq w cuqu qv o ccoriu bLObCL1A j01

MCII uouwoucim.A) H914JJ (J) GXICUqGq /jUCL)2 wcijioqojo8A 10 COACL JJC ACLC J8Q8-18óô

Page 13: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

11

2lvtc2•.oi tpc 29U9L 2IJACL qojjm. nJ qic cO!U9 vc o j g3 cuqcq 11Jc JC9J 2fcJW2 Oj P1WC9J1!2W lB 1}JC UIICqw o&cc fO pc p.nc prwcjpc aøuqwq ccoqiu o ucqwsu (Jooo b jpc owiou o w? wcuiou

EOL flJC uicq !AC qo uOf couvqci. C bLIOc1 UOW I83 10 jgg MJJCU fPG cO Oj, J3 MZ

uq 1LC LCITILIJ2 EOL JWJJ9LY qiv .OW J Q3 O J gQ JJACL ! UCJflq6q UJ pc G21JWG o uc ojq

2iWq9i. o pc V11L91J ccflJWou2: ipc riw o.nJom vuq Of1JOM OLCOUJ j.OW 1}JC WWf2

oujA EOL wjA suq sbu ipc thccic cowboucuj opc woucvLA ojq oqc ! iu urnuucL

pA IJJG CCIUL1 PW D Ou pibwcur rucjrtqc 2!JACL nuq jo pcu 2np2cdncuiJA wcnqc ojq

Jo JgJ o iic nc qu.cc ciwc opc wou i.A 8oq iu cu.cniou bIn2 pojqiu

OL ELmJCG 1JJ6 W0UCWLA ocj i di o qic ojq uq iJAcL poJqw2 oupe uc OLELUCG niuij

ELIJcG ° p!uwJllc wuqsi.q p.ow io n'uj jgo (oLqo uq AqJsuq a) ipn

uq pc wouci.A ojq ocj OL GcuJrnuA z.c Lcbol4cq pA pc rruqcapujc

oq ocJc OL 2GAGL9J bcuoq' nbbjcwciucq pA qw ou oq lu puJc DW ou uc ojq 2p!bwcuf 2

EOL M6GU 1j1c ojq pojqiu2 OjJG CUiLJ IJJ( MCLC rl2cq O CVJCflJC CJJ1JC2 UJ 1JC WOIJCLA

cjmuc w pc woui.A oq ocjc 2nbb1cwcIucq ''w 049110112 uq tqc lrc91 ipc CCIUL9J P1c DW ou UC 2pIbuJcur2 o ojq LOL G2C coniuc ic qcuAcq pA ijqu tc

IEOL D"W 9IJq J40LM9A hG G21!1JJ94C JJC W0U6491.A ojq ocj 9 pc 2loc o oq

ojq 2plbwcui2 uq pc C9UC iii pG wouci9l.A o1q ocj)

2pTbwcu2 bLIOL o j uq pcu Iucnqca uouwoucA ojq cxboi (c9JcnJ9cq s pc 2flW o uc

°u !q"q 9JJ oq 2p!buJclu2 jpc fluicq 21vlca cnu.cuj ccornu qw JucJnqc2 9JJ ojq

yjuqou? qic awuqq cnacu 9CCOflU V11J cxcnqc ojq U0M2 ii Euup 9t9 ou tpc CflLLGU

EOL DGIJW9LJe EL9UCG OCLUJ9UA 19JA b9u j,jotiiA jnt9 MCCU 9uq pc fluiicq

bLccIon2 UJCi9J2'JJ

Page 14: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

bits isJnsmsfi is noillud vstsnom o tirsisi srsb nsilsil sifT .)bor tsisnom sth bits arnsmqirf

bore bIos 'isinom sifi ni 3nBff3 sth nsqsI ioI .mstfflo sau on sw oe rsiqi5ini or iIu3ffiib

.noilludIo atioqxs Isit a231 (trfluO3 sth ni si3sqIo bore bsrsmiias sifi iii snsrf3 our as botsIu3!s ai

nsift 21T15 euoiio aaol O3ubnf bluorfa tud bsaauaib svsrl SW as 3Itsrn9Id01q ai thoqxs noilludlo seU

Q8 I ot 8V8 I i6I isisnorn saonsqst suit no srsU .silsiiauA sliI is3ubolq b1o sb oas3 suit ni

al )bOia bIos vistsnom suit siaw5I ioI .'lno blo3 sbul3ni VQ8 I isfls srsb ;b1o bits isvlia sbul3ni

ni bto nouft bns ,

I Q8 I lftnu Ansa sist bits iuassiT suit iii anibIorl bloa b mua sift as bstsmitas

bisbnsta oiIIstomfd s no esw siasu5L nsulw Q8 I ot ô88 I itoh bonsq sift io1 .bobijlam al noiis1unia

.lSvli2 sbubni srsb ainsmqicla rsn bns )f3Ota '(IstOflom suit

bns siqsD 'd bsbivoiq 515 )bora bIos 'isisnom silt lb asrsmitas mobni)I bstinU suit ioI

blog suit ni nsrb b astsmits uftiw IQI tasq stsb iisth bnsrxs oW .IQI or qu (8I) isdoW

sift otuti awofl blo ton lb astsmiiao sift sbivoiq auriutsi sbsiT .bnsIn3 lb 1nsH sift b anibIoif

blo istsriom suit rio asiuiI iuassiT sift tV8 I oi lonq astsi2 bstinU suit io1 .mobniX bstinU

.tnuo33s tut5rlu3 lioifio sift ot )bOia bto '(Istsnom silt ni asnsd3 bbs sw :ruoduoiift bow sis

.atnsmqiifa bloa ton no stsb silt obivoiq aniutsi sbsit suiT

ton bns awofl b1o '(Istsnom no srsb sift tsrlr auoivdo ai ti nofaw32tb nibo3s-iq suit moiI

lb aotsmitas idI a)bota bloa Ansd Isltns3 no sansilsi iuO .tashsq mo-li iii sis blo8 b tnsmqicfa

.2blsorI stsviiq ni asarisrb d bssIq sIoi rrtsi-loqmi silt aAoolisvo taora b1o '(tstsnom silt m asansula

iol abota blo lnsd Isititsa no '1si ot 21J saidi oafs asritnuoa nsm idi stsb sbsit silt ni aqs suiT

rltiw fist nsfio sis sw wilT .b1o1o noitqmuanoa Isiitaubni nhoni 'Isvitas1ls asiu81t sbsit srnoa

,awoft blo8 lb siuassrn saiaslqmi ns

sift lb abnsrl sift ni sano-nualo 2stsmitas oaiaoiq ni3do or sbot nsvs tluafflib al ti isvswoH

Page 15: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

rtisido ot ai isqsq 2idflo i3sldo sifT .itriuoa sb iuo bits otril awoli bsbioosinubo sauasd 3ilduq

b!obo trtsmissii instaiartoa sift siuans risilt bits asniriuoto quoi sbiw a idi awoll bloto esiarnitas

a lift lo irIif iii bslsbiarlo3 sd taum stab sift b 29t351U335r1! sifT .eitaitata tnuoaa tnsnuo silt iii

iohsqua a sbivoiq bluorfa bs!iqmo3 svaif sw stab sift atasva3 sasrft bnim iii annasfl .svit3sjdo

Isnoitan r1ii3iflno3 sth d bstiotaib aasl ai taut sno ;awoft arnvaa bits tnuos trlsTJu3 sdtbo stamiias

.ainsmaq 1o 53(15 lad sift ni blo bo atnsmissit

ssisva awoda cl3idw siugiI ni bstnsasiq ai awofl bloo noitamitas srltbo tIusi bits sifT

ainsasiq iufl sifT '.slqmaa iuo iii aSntnuO3 suit idi EtQI-881 isvoaoiiai ot too trlsnuQ

-blo sth ritiw tiols a331uO2 ls3nolaic( bisbitata sill Iii fl5Vj iu1b 1flU0335 1n5T1u3 Isniho sift

11S3 awoll blo idi rtit3s11o3 tsdt siuft alift moil ssa ria sW .() Itoitsups isq as siua11 bstauLbs

lsviiabi isvo bssisvs nsufw nsvs tnuo33a insTw3 bsiiissm silt ot s3nslsThb laiin.stedua a

.srnit b abonsq nol

.siaau5i bn 'narmsO idi lo slq th bsw ai i3uboiq Isnolian isM ' EL

Page 16: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

14

FJo\0 J40LM9A: OOo\° Q•,\O (oij,,y Mcqcu: O1o\0 we nK: o'o\O pc 05o\0oo\0 1uwIc: OOè jwsuq: OOo\& ELucc: o?o\& 0 ooo\o (° 4WbY juij?: jbgu:

woucimA ojq tocje flic LVO o uouwouct& ojq CXboLt2 tO 0Db OL 18 8 -1 i) I 'y1LJ 45\0j,ouwoucA o,q cxbcag2 cuu pc cjcnjtcq we anw o uct ojq jnbwcute bjri Ijic cjrnuc Iu tjJc

Wflt JJAG pGGU f1pt9UtJj OL tPGG IMO COITutuG21 otp OLIPG2G Iut9ucc ponjq pe tLctGq mitp

tpc ouurn ccn.LcIu vcconiu vuq Ipe ojq-q1natcq flLC LcbLccIU uouwouct& oq cxbou2 mp,cp

ccOcnU &tLc2 OL potp ELUCC uq Wb9u cxcjnqc jj oq UoM2 jpoc Ipe qqccucc petMecu

wouct& uq uouwouewi.A cowboucut oojq cxboi. iqtp uA ccnLcA jpe tuqLq cnucut

bLccucc O 9LG ojq UOM Ui iiq OUt °L COflUtLA !t CCOWG GXILGWC1A qCfljt tO WG2flLG pc

vn24LvJ! uq to pe jjcjA cuqiqtc ot cnacut ccornu uJi2wcnLcwcuf p.i tpc

ELvucc gg) jçna uq tJJG flhJitcq Kwqow y2 wloL ojq bLoqnccL2 me monjq cxbcct

OL ojq uoi ti PiG2t iwbct ou tpc v.cLcq OLJIu qt LOL Vfl2tL9I!

UOL!U5I

Jg-jj (GzbuaGq s s bGLcGusG o cDIr bGLoq 5AGLSGIIIL : CnLLGUI SCCOIIIJI ,aip oLI!usI suq oq-sqn$Gq qss

Page 17: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

I?

Gbcci91A OL DGuuLr ELucc uq Icn!w

bLccIucq w pc j9JG anct aowc COfflUL!G pc poric cdncujA jrn2c

qucLc ow pc wuqs1.q J1ouc 1pc pOJri (yyj) WGflLC

cocnip.A jc C9U cc ow pi wpjc i9T O1L LC4UJCIu oojq bLoiuqc2 cnacuj scconu ciwc jrnt

1pJc J 2OTh2 1p6 CIJ.GC °L 4C c'IIU OL ojq u0 OL CCJJ

pipjA npwriwpjc jOL WOUCWLA ojq

wA i,cjj pvc cuLcq buAc pOLq2 L9CL 49U Iuqn2u uq w j01W corijq JrnAC pccu

cx9uib1c ELCUCP ojq !wbOL ijrn qq uo uq pc!L iX iuo jpc wcncq ocj oLwoIJc1.A ojq

C9114!OI? !UCG IJJGA wA LCUGCI UJ!WGVf1LGWGIU O ipc cpuc !U 1JG WOUGWLA ojq OCC EOL

Page 18: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

LOJG 0WAGIJI0UG2 !U &022 ILJAG2IWGUi' MG AG pcicq qqijiou 0u iIJAGtU0UG2 20 JJ&f pG

E!cpcuLu (J) bow oni bLGA!on2 cowbrjioua 0LJJJ20LJC9J 2i2!C2 AG OJJGIJ iuOLcq JJG

EuAC2WJCIU couei o 4C 211W o JJXG iuAcjwcuj b1112 C}JF1JG2 !U 20CJ(2 01 HJAGUt0IJG 2

vu vuJA2!2 0 29AU uq !UAG21WGU UOM2 LGdIULG2 WCVTLC 0 l0 L022 JIJAG2IWCLU' Q1022

T IIJAcU4OL!GZ DI0

n'K': 18Q-1ô4 f12' 18.O'1t?'1jA: J8!-1o3Q 1øbII: J88-J J40U#UA J8Q?13Ô Jn22iø: J88JôI3 Mqcu: I8IctIo31-1o4?J!u1mq: J83-1ô4?EL9ucc: 18?1-Jô18' J34-J44QCLwwJA: J8XXJô13 13?J38Jpc Jflfl 21wbJc bCUOq C013212j2 OJ,V(121191W 18QJ-Jô4? uuq 18O-J4? DCmJJLJ(: 18Xt'Jô1t

f12V OR JQ OR 1.\ 0.0 0'! I'S 0'! I'S 0'O

flK S'3 9'3 S'3 9'O 0'? 9'2 5'? 9'Q S'Q ff3

MGGU -O'8 3'3 -O'g 3'? O'3 -33 S'J -3'9 3'J 01

Jç(12219 -J'O 1'? -0,3 3'X 1'? -1,0 JR 0'3 S'. JR

j,j,ouA -J' 'ij -J' 9'O 0'S -33 8 3'J S'o OS

ibu O'J 3'3 0'? 3'9 O'Q O'X S'ô O'3 3'! 1,1

ijA -13 9'? -J'3 9'? O'J O'2 S'3 O'8 S'3 0,0

OGuu9uA I'S 13 I'S 13 0'! J'Q O' J'Q O' 0'!

ELII I'Q 3'8 I'S 9'J 1'O O'ô 3' O'9 3'.X 08EuJ9'Uq -?'S ?'? -?'I ?'Q 0,3 -?'8 5'? -?'8 3'? O'J

DGWJJLJC -0,5 9'Q -I'S 3'! I'S -SQ 1'? -S'Q J'9 0'S

3'? ?' 3'9 ?' O'3 -IX'S 3' -Q'ô 3'Q ff9

V(1UV -'3' Q'3 -43 Q'J 0'? -39 Q'O 3'8 Q'O 0'?

Co)'

't11 D' 't13W"

'VIMD

V' J'1,M3D'

'viNyCM

o.'3c\CM

M2CM

OU\CM

M'i\%2

oc i- 0uq WGIIU p2On4c q!LLGI11 (xbi.q bi.cuit, ot CDI)

Jgn nq juq5Lq qptou o ourrnq qve oq tfqn24Gq qti.LPI j: EUGCI o oq uqn24wGnI on CflLLGUI cconu:

Page 19: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

210C1C2\IUACUfOUC2 q9t9 JJJC 2t0CJC2 L9f!0 0L iuJuq iucjnqca we 2t9tiatiCøJ qi2CLcb9UCA

0 a9JW-IIJAC2p1JCU COLLCJ9I0U2 2CC bbcuqix y 0L 9 JJIJJ qt2cn2aiou 0 tPC cacci 0j LCW0AJUbbcm2 II1CJnqIJcatJUJUtGa OC}JUG2 lu 2t0CJ2 OL !IJACUtOUC2 !2 U IWbOLI9IJI COU2JqCL9tJOU ILl 9IJA uøjAi

H0U01(9 LCC2210U pAOACL aix bCLCCUt uuq L912C2 JJC 2t9IJ9L qcwtiou f)A 9JW021 acIcutccu bcLceui JJ1fl2 itpi OfIL O Jfl aiiibjc oungw qru Cu nmcurouc Lviaca we capwurcq a1obc coclJicicut iii wecjq2rcw-

EL9IICC vbu naaiv !cqcuLeboLfa IIJACIJtO(.A cimuc cyn coicLc bsuqa E!cp ccua pAqqw !uLtOLA qut jOL Vfl2PI! Eiu1wq11EiCpcuLccu (j9) sqqcq nmcuioi.A qi 0L uuq rpc nic o c COfWILIC2 tOL /iqiicp 'rcpcJI (los3)

1J4oq9t9oLJJto J53 4Oq919OLJ1OjItP -rot ois

OcuiivuA5 J85-J38 O.X fl2V I8Qà-Jô4 3.O

ELVUCGJ J8?O-J4't I.\ IlK I8O-Iô't O't8

EHJ91J J2QO-J )f PACqCIJ J8QJ-Iô'f 003

DCUW9LIC - - }çr12219 J882-1ôJ1 JQÔ

C"q J5Q-1ô? ox J,iOLM9A Joo-Jaa -oo't

VfltL9J!! J8QJ-Jôt TOO 1-J Jg-Jc 581

Coin)\%0iX

W1Ootçi

%.0cti\

\1%OTot

(ua bGLcGujc OI CDEY buoqiPIC : E2t!wutG o CJUG2 iu aocja \ ucu40Lc2

vq1natU LOL !UAGUt0L CpVIJC2 UJ9A pvc botGuti9jjA j9LG

OL COTIUtUC2 !AItJJ 9A!J9P!C q9t9 Jt !2 GAIqGlu 1J.ow tpe ui9UitfIq6 otpc UIIWpGL2 Hi tJJ!2 t9PJG iP9t

29AIU-!UACatWCUt COLLG[9tJOUa j9f C 5 2J10M2 tpc wuurTqc Oj C9UC2 !U 2tOCJC2 uq !UACUt0I4G2

JJJC 0W12210U O1 !UAC1U01C2 iutLOqnCca 9 2OflLCC °L P!92 !tJtO LCLG22JOU C2f1W9tC2 Oj

UJACIUOUC2 JJJG qcwiJa 9LC qiaCnaaCq !U bbcuqix w

itcqcu ipc flutcq iuqow uq tpc fluitcq 2t9tC2 UOHt iuCjflqC c2t1w9tc2 OI CJJ9IJG2 Iii 2tOCC2 OL

IUAC2tWCIU UrIWpGLa OL Vfl2W1I!9 9u9q9' E1UJ9Uq EL9UCC 3CLUi9iJA It91A 19b9U J4oLM9A T!2219

Page 20: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

I8

LcLcaa!ou o ou - 7\Q 9CC0LUJ o cdnjiou ()

A9U9JC2 qcjucq va L90 ° 0Db 01. j,ij.i) jpc woic 9bbLobuc ca nuqci fG oq auqLq ia

amiq9I.q) wibjcwcujtou oupc cqa1cru-HoLo9 ca ctoaa-acctou9J LGLGa2LO1J ou on (pop

cdrisj w uc OLGI1J 9aac 9ccnwnJ9l!oI? wcjnqiuR wouciA ojq 9cdnia!floua jpc Ab!c91 (boa-oq

flIJCL ojq a uq91.q pc 9bbLobuc qcjwiou o aviu Lccouica ip pc cnacu ccorni a

= + ()

capurnica o aviu wna pc cjcnjcq LGarqn9JfA 92 lC r1W 0 !uAcawcu 9uq pc cnu.c1u 9cconu:

ccnac opc !wbLcc!c 01. iu9qcdnc u91nLc opiafouc u9!ou9J cconiua p!aoL!c91

q'i cxbou wouci.A 8oq 9L09 01. L9U2LOLUJ2 2OWG oi2 wousi.A ojq iuio bJ9u uq cdnibujcu

9uq cuqiu 91.6 !wboaa!pJ6 EOL cx9wbJe conuiAa tuA62wcu c9u iuccae poic ia aiiu oujA

qcwcq 92 9 cjoacq-ccouowA qcuiiA 9J2o bbpca o obcu ecouowica ipcu !UCIJi91i0U91 p0LL0MIU

ijoIfa (wqncp conjq iuAoji.c Lcb9Xuicu 01 bop!c9j Lzajc) jpa !wbj!c cdci!ou (QY Mp!cp i

ip su iqc 91.6 U9UCC pA !UCL119!0u9i ojq otAa L9CL pn pA buA9c csbvj

fluqet V ojq a1mJq9Lq pc cVbHVj IUIUIOPIJ!A PTh0P62!a (in ta woaj GxjLcwc ouJJ)

(I?)

ojq u cjoacq ccouowA it aVA!u wna jom wo one oupeac mo 92aGa jpna

iu V /IOLj on pc oq awuqV1.q pc wo bL!uc!bVI oaaiqc JUVuCIVI 9226j2 91.6 cVb!Vj Vuq wOUCWLA

4 Ewb!ucIV11VI!

Page 21: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

aa1q b1o 8ledw bhow a cii iai sAohoH-ni3iab1I rti rr1cn3Iqmi 01 assw owl audi is 13rIT

noiaa31i 11011332-22013 3r!3 nun oi ai iaiiI 3rIT .310-I '(laf3norfl inatloqfni cia

___ X i + ____ + + = — 1

di aoqmi bluo3 3no 13viian13l1A .1 - = y baa I = lath 21 aia3dioqsd a?tohoH-ni3iabl&I rf T

3iuIoada cr1 laup3 airl3iaffI3o3 3va11 A3o12 b1o 1at3nom 3113111 eW1ad3 3111 baa arrivaa tacfi imaliacio3

no11a3ft133q2 3111 01 abs3l -uub33o1q airiT .nie 3iiaoqqo b iud 3buiinam

______ I i ÷ q + = — 'I

I = q iach a3ilqmi aia3r13oq(1 slohoH-ni3labl&I 311T

irinua 3(11 in3mia3vni 03 nibba d a3vil3b 3no -iuaam arrivsa di al Ytt A - ? lath 33i30M

abacisD iol 231smi123 lnuo33a II3TILJ3 (4>Q I) a 13niV iq as a3n3mqida bloa ils lo 3viauI3ni lciuo33s

no 3W 01 3110 3lanqolqqa 3111 nivaa u-ii nsdi 1311151 3iuaam 213fIiV al 'dW .3vods b3dh3a3b

u-ii 1111w (O <T.%1. A) riio bloa anoqmi 'Oinuoa a aoqqu c(Q) noiisup3 lo 3bia bnsrf idail 3113

bfuow 1inuo3 3(13(13113 inuoma ISUD3 cia d lilt ion 230b in3mia3vrIi II .bnarbnu nivsa

LRrroiianl3inutI .111153w lanoilanlo dtaq b38115d311u as nislniam ol baoid.s gnlwoiiod 3d Ihaaa333n

isdl awoIl6t ii (aia3d3oqsd s?IohoH-ni33abl3I di d b3ilqmi as) iuo b81u1 rs nibne1 baa aniworiod

01 '1kiI dauoirli b331 ihod anib1od bIo8 (lsi3nom cii 232a3133b baa nivsa lanolian cii 2325313111

.inmtavni

blog vrsl3noin cii 32S313 311110 1311 rnvaa Isnoi Ian cii 32531311 na Iiudl aia3dloqd 3111 23233 audi fl0i2231 31fF ' bna () enoiiaup3 moft 3v132d0 aw l3dJonn aufi oa oT .in3mla3vni 31323mob old l3l3Icgo3 awoll aaniblod

biawluo 1aioi amono its nw1d nI3flib 3113 akup3°3 wdT - = + t.3 = () lo noiis1umus ln au Isup3 laum 113111w 2ifl3mqtd2 biawcii Islol afl baa b1o baa aina abooa1o aln3mqIfIa

(...b3uniino3)

Page 22: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

1Q1-1ô81) £IIB-IiauA :a3hinuo3 nttiñ mo-ft £isb no b3asd i i1snE 1&thiqm3 nsO

81Q1-181) nsiI ,(1Q1-V8I) bnsIniI I-IQI MQI4V81)thErnrt3U,(iQ1-0V81)sbsn8D

swioM Q$QI-881) nqs1 (à€Q1-1o8f) 1siI ,(8EQl-QIIQ1-VV8I) nsrm3D 4Q1-1 3(11 bits I-Qô8I) mobriiA b3iinU 3r11 ,(elQI-V8I) n3b3w2 ,(E1Q1-88l) siu5I (QEQ1-81)

13fls3 atn31q 81ua11 .H xibn3qqA ni bdhb ta iuo slab 3dT .(iQI-0V81) a3Th1 blinU

eth gnivs e1.nl niflo1q ctsdi iedis5l) .aboneq-du2 owl io1 slab ln3mlevni bits niva 3(1110 io1q

(.(Q) noilalipe ni eldshav inebneqebni 3(11 alolq Exa IBlnoxrtod

('fflO b oilri s beaiqx) zeiri 3zvim1zvni bna nivii : iuiI ôQ1-Q1Q1 fl UQ1-881 :A

(beuthino3...) 1Jjq-uj 1zwo ln3TuJa 3u13 t1i imli ii3n3bi zin3msq1o ens1d edi moiI ewolkil kfl .zmial3 nieio1 b1onon

sLorLoH-th3iabI&I 3(11 oIeieclT .anoiii2!up3s blo zn1enom 1aup3 zulcpuz iftUO33 1f1iqs3 b1onon cfi aulq .0 = I - - = °3 ib aeilqmi eiedioqd

$101.1

S

AT! UAS

0.0

1.0

01.0 ATJS

nJ.

clAl. 1.W) • $101.1 •

$ 1.ma S 1JA

1.1H S

A1J AW4

ATI gao'

)IIJ S

.0 O.0 1.0

o.o

1.0

01.0

01.0 0.0

Jg o.o

01.0 0.0 .0 0.0 1.0 KI3\

Page 23: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

in3mivth E19vs1o noi311 fnoiiaa-aoi (08Q1) IohoH-thiabI&L 312sd 3di tn3€1q £ Id6T

3qoIa 3f1ilo ismii 3rfT " .(Q) noiiup b noitftia3q rii niw ati niv 3B13VE no 23is

bn3i (I ,sW bhoW ifts) 3!qm l3iEl r1T .no o oI3 ofulsd rio ibnu iwlmofi nai 1ima1sq

I I isfiA) .iwoq (Ioisf1Iqx3 31Gm 113um I Q I 13fla bn 2noiiL311O3 inoii 3v&! 01

iob bnijoI odr nsdi l3woI rknim ?& rfi 1IQI ot ion'II (.OQO 3vod

208Q1 3d1 idl bnuol odf asdi iwoI nvs baa (OQ.O bauoia llsiiw) aOôQI 3di ni hinuo3 Isniwbni

81.(noiismii23Io boiiq 3d1 no nibn3q3b V.O 01 .O brwoia lluu) nd asd noiisI1-io3 in3mivni-nivs &lt isrfJ ii 3ldsJ di iii b3in31q iIua31 3dT

bonq I isW b1ioW-foq 3isrb3mmi dT .b311sv3lq bisbnBi bIo8 3di nsdw thoh3q ni 13w01

no ion iw a8ninuo3 'nsm ndw bonq EI-VEQI QI-IFQI) 23!qms 13151 bits (QI-QIQI)

u bsrqbiw l3disl ws o215 abon3q adT .noiisI5noa i3did 3vsd diod bisbnsia b1o i3nis

1dsdoiq 'ch OEQI 3d1 iii in3nhis 310m d3um 3m&d 21011(103 e3r1i ousfl .slolino3 lsriqs3Io

QI isoq £ 3IdsT ni b31-Ioq3l 2311211512 diH v 3(11 ioI aoiisnslqx3 iojsm 3f11 is

. noii A xibn3qqA ni b3in3e3lq ia (8) noiiaup3 ni noiisfli3oqa 311110 iamuia3 noi23I51

-nivsa di lo oivBd3d 3(11 wivi ()QQI) ioIaT .siab Jni 10 noisuib a iol (QQI) bWii2cJO 2 ' :'(w1fl33 d1n33131w1 311133(1123(1111 13V0 (10115131103 1fl3(fliS3vTU

.(VI) io1aT bits b1Ii2dO 21o11no3 lsuiqa3 bort3q lawl3in nO ''

Page 24: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

DOOtcA ELutccI uq ypc2ou (jg) uq 2nuJwci. (io)coniuuc pc cwbiuc1 / U-IJ/4WCU I!"J 12 UJI1CJJ MG9JCGL buoi. O JJC J qcp CU2!2 2CC

cJ22Jcq qcAcJobuJ pcu jiu w boa-JoLJq pjvi. j agwb1c2 iucjnqc pc qcAcJobiu

111 LGCCIU qw pcu ouc O2€LAC2 fjJ2 2CACLJ ojJG cornuuc2 !u fiG oJq-2wuqsLq 2gwbJc cortjq pG

LGCGU OECD clWJJ LC2f1I2 I0L fIG JC U!UG1GC11fi CGUITILA 2CGW CACU woLc cowbLpic ,iip poc

CJVfl!Cj ofq uqLq uopjA jJGL j j) MGU !42 wvuiwqc !2 cowbLpJc io pc G2WC2 jjow

LOW JJJC Jg2 9uq JØ2 U iqqwou fiG 2lObC COGjJC!CU 12 2O1JJGUJJG2 211JIjJCUI nuqcL fiG

r wc jgoj-joj qccq cxccb!ou Mw 'c uO u.ow wo o' !u OECD

EACIJ flIOflJJ fiG \ 2i21iC2 icuq 10 PC 10M COLC fIG J Ô3O2 vuq c2bcc!JJA PCLOLC jotjq

cuirniA IfJA iiq I�!'uq jj-jç rpc cxcjnqc J�n221S uuq OL j-j rpcA xcjnqc hL9UCJôIô-!ô54 ipcA cxcjriqc nJrnqc &mJcc QCuJJUUA uq Jf122rIf jpL j iojpC C2IUJJUfC2 j,OL J8OIJ3 uq !88O-J8O cxcjnqc 1biJ uq OL* ** wq1Cc 218IJ1jCV1JC T fIG JOo\0 o\0iiq Jo\0 JCACJ LC2bGC1iACI?

i1-Jo1 o oi ooo o,t1ó3J-1ô3Q J 08QQ *** OO4 0ô43

I?J3O J ** OI? O4X

JôTà-J4 * OfXQ O83JàO-JJ3 fl OQOO * O2 O3JSÔJ-JÔOJ fl *s* 0J28

!ggo-Jgoo JJ OtXI O3ôQ 0J33

188?-JÔJ3 J3 O?t ** O.4O Oèô

1280-1ôJ3 JJ O43 O88 OJ3UOtiTcM1\ o\

O3 'JO%.tuczq

JUAGZ4IJJGUt °" (vj . + + ' - ve): },LwG(GLGW ILow LGLG!ou O

Page 25: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

rno anii l3biano3 o ItiIu won i Ii noiiup noiaaeii 3di b3tmit rnvfiH

3ff t i&fi 3v3i13d ot 33n3biv3 in3i3iflue ai 313di i3dt&Iw al l3bi2no3 oi noiiup iaifi 3dT .3dioqd

-oi ni bsisfsnoo frash3q rüvs bcts in3m1?9vni .3i 3fIO Oi !Sup3 2i f1W62 ItO f13f31fi3O3

3qoIa sdilo i2om io 1s'rnJrii 3an3biIno3 fn3313q 3vi-3nin 311t i&II 1 eiui1 mofI ee 3W .noiie

E rrnoIl3q 3w .O bnuois b3Ieub 1s 23rsmiia inioq 3fftIo i2om 93f1i .3biw 3iiup 31S

3dr crno113q o1B flB3 3W ..O < q 3vitsrnet1 3cf enisa .O = q 2i2sthoqd &fiIo * bsks-3no

in3aelq 3W 1 > t r1i 2i3f1ioq'f1 3vit&rteila 3ff 3 I = q 3&It nOft3rtta3l 3f13 lo iEst belisi-3no

.I 31dT ni 3ai i3dtoqsd 3rf 3 lo all ui 31(3

lwri3ni n3bflflo 3fl9313q Q bnt( ) 3qoI :4' iiii1

0.

I;

Page 26: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

lo noizwii moil iI zia9dIoq(BI :t 9Id1T

- ?A + +1 ?) zgnivu no tn,mtvni \ 1=11 .o=g v ctw

** 810.O O.O £ô0 EIQI-0881

* QO.O £.O ** Q0 E1Q1-881

* 0.0 8E.0 1Vt.0 0Q81-0881

** Eo.o v1.o t.o IOQI-1Q81

* QO.0 EO * 0Oô.O E1Q1-OQ1

evi.o avi.o * .o tei-cri

* QôO.O V1.O ** E0 0Q1-Q1 ** IEO.0 " 000.0 Q1-1EQ1

f•o *** 100.0 " 1.0 QEQI-VEQI

I31 o\O1 bna o\° o\001 th i 3n3Thni 3i3ibfli *

3bubx3 0Q81-0881 bnn EIQ!-0881 ioI a3imi dT .'1vii3qa1 rmi1 $t&nn3U buI3x3 r1i 1Q1-Q1Q1 1o ;theu51 bna nnqn1 3bu13x3 di ÔEQI-IEQE ba O2I-&Q1 ioI ;aiu51 bn 'rurrnO

b103 1JI murriD 33nJnI buI3x rIi Q1-! iol bni ;ciw5L .I2U5L

irt3bffoa 3dt isrir iet iathoqd 3d1Io tIui 3d1 avi .0 = q \o cbetsdsI ncnu(o3 3dT

3uIv q 3uIT .Ih$d 3no rififfi !3iB1 ei q isdi 9Vfifi(fl311S 9f11 1arnss 11&f 9110 01 1sup9 i flIVE2 (10

i(qmi 9u15v q woL s o uii i ii n3dw L3dioq1i Hun 9th 2niii Iinooni1o iilidsdoiq di i isdi flffhZJlO3 21(11 (11011 392 (13 3W Ilsd 3110 aIsup3 i&It 2i23r1loqsd U un di l2niss n9biv3 fl01i2

bns ôQ1-1EQ! :ia isb mo iii a3lqrfth2-du2 owl las! 3rft1o1 1no .o = q aia3r13oqrI 3111 izjsi 11839w

us io1 2i23f1ioq'd ISIlI 133131 1153 3w woda I = Ii \o b1da1 nmuIo3 311T .Q21-VEQ1

.QE2f-VQ1 bna IQI-Q1QI ioI iqxa 2boil3q siqinsa

riofla 3vsd ion ob w isili sa 1153 9w a31dsl owl auoivslq 311110 ai1uai 3(11 siwnmua oT

9th isdi 93nsbiv3 evsd 3W Itsd no 01 I5up3 r1i3d ritvsa rto 1fl8131fl303 3(11 tnis 33r13bfv3

Page 27: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

uq LC luqow E!cpcuccu qqcq ipc incq o qvø 2C4 jiujøuq huJuec' 'bu' uqBorw! wbjc oconupic couvrcq cq' cuwqc OCuJrnuA' jijA' J40LM9A' MCGU

20WGMjI4

bOMGI. A9!JPIG B4 Ont qq!4o OLWOLC COtU1!G 4° E!CPGULGGU wbjc W0GL4G }J! uqrn82

E!CPCU&GGU,2 vqqwou 01JJG flui4Gq 2494G2 LIG2 4}JG 2JObG COGUJCIGU4 iiq 1UCLG2G2 4G W24!CI

Affl19P1G COflU4UG2 BA0nWL LG2fIII2 bbci o 24GW UrnUJIA jL0W 4C fl2G o g 2W&JJ conuiA wbjc

2JJOM2 4G LG2f1J42 0W LP1G 3' ! 4j1G C0GJjcJGU4 G241urn4G na!U 4G ojq q1f124Gq q OL jj

'!4P 4G IJIIJG COHZJ4UG2 UI E!CPGULGGU,2 2WbJG JJJG COJnUJU jpcjcq 'ci4JJG COJfIUIIJ pGJGq 2OM2 4C LC2flJ42 04JJG LGgLG22JOJJ fl2!U OI1L oJq-q1n24Gq

LG&G22!OIJ n2!II 0flL Oq q1n24Gq qw fl4 M!4P 1G C!P4 COHU4UC2 !U BA0flW!2 WbJC !m!iL!A'

q1n24Gq 94W E°1 IU241JCG' 4JJG 1piLq C0JJIWIJ 1pccq %2c c1)'01\ 20M2 4IJC LG211j42 0 4JJG

cowbu2ou fw 4G 2WG c0nU4uG2 uq 411MG bGuoq MG G241U4G 4pG C0UG4i0U2 fl2U OflL

JpJG bLGGU 4G bLUJG4GL G2PIIW4G2 ojAonwi (jj) uq E!C1JCULGCU (j) oL

uq WOLG 21IJJJCU4 4JJ1I AOflW onuq

3 miq cf !uqc4c 2JobG COGC!GIJ42 GUGLA JOMGL 4JJU 402G onuq pA E!CPGULGGU fl4

1.CboL4Gq LGf4IAGJA pIp G241W4G2 0 4G C0GJCtG1J4 OAGL 2OWC 2f1p-2wbJG250 luG LG211J42 LU

pG4MGGIJ 2A1IJ uq IUAG24WGU4 0L 9UA bcuoq ow J88O-JJ3 HOMGACL' E!CPGULGGU (J)

LG2HJ4 241J2 LU COU4LV24 40 BAOflW! (jç MpO ornq JJO 2!W CVIJ4 CL022-2GC4!0UI I.GJii0U2JJ!b

LGJ4!OU2p1b G4MGGU 2A!U 9Uq !1JAG24WGU4 L4G2 GAGU fWqGL 4JJG Cj22ICJ ojq 249IJqLq JJJI2 J4

COGWCIGU4 !2 J622 4JJVU OUG OL W024 bGuoq2 cxwIucq J..pGLG 12 2OWG GAIqGUCG 0

Page 28: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

moil zhtmiI, i)mwuzq lo noiiqmoD : ,IdaT hb b9tIJtbk-bIo bnR fi 1fl3tI3i3 imuo&fl

-Th'k %%1

woc. a à1O * OEÔ.O Oi.0 OQ.O EIQI-0881

** 1Q.O 8Q.O * OQ.0 441.0 081.0 0Q81-0881

1ô.0 * 1V.0 OIV.0 0Q.0 IOQI-1Q81

* 00.0 V8.0 0V.0 Q88.0 001.0- IQ1-0Q1

0V8.0 ** 8V.O 00.1 OV.O —

ôQ1-4Q1

** Eô.0 Q1.O 0.I ô.0 - 0EQ1-Q1

.t3vii33qa81 13v81 o\O1 bnfi o\0 o\001 '4 is 33n53jh1412 3i53thf11 *

swioM IsiI n&fn3O *ismn3Q MbsnSD si1siiauA lo b3ieieno3 3niniJO3 b 3Lqmaa ainwo8 bn1niI bba i slob w0 .isi b3iinU 3di b8bbs nignorbi3 .mob3niN b8iinU 3d3 bns

bns I Q 1-0881 o1 2315m11a3 8lqmsa I liii 3dT .2wofl bIos ioI aieujbs bns siaau bns e'8q5t xisi iol ;oi.w$I bno nMrn3D 3bu13x3 otfi EQ1-IQI iol ;siaau5{ bns nsqs1 3bu13x3 0Q81-0881

.thau51 3bU13x3 'di 01-.1

-O13 3f11 flu 2.8flifllJO3 lo flOJt33I3 oth isrli 3kfsT flu btriasiq arIuai 8th mofi oa ff83 3W

rnsrnrauj.bs bIos di as rburri as i3flsm 01 aiqqs air1 bbriI .sanatioqrni fbo al sisvs Isnotia

b 3310(13 di ot 3viiiana 318 aismiia 1318mstsq 8f11 A xiba3qqA ni worla w aA .mloll3q 3W

b3lsmuia3 3111 13118 1183 3Iqmsa 3(11 lii a8n1111103 3111 rnnsdD .3B13VE ESfloil33a-a2013 th ru a3illr!uo3

311q230 .1r13313q 'tio1 as rf3urn as d 1sv (183 iwoq iorsrisIqx 3r11 bris E.0 as rburn as d a3qola

dr mouI anoil3I3b 8Inia ol iaudoi Iiis1 ama a3is(nulas 1313m818q'Io 3I83fiinie 3111 a183v83 3a3111

th1o iatnrll bsoid 8th ai3iliuo ol a9lsmiia3 3rlilo s1iviiian3a 3(11 3liqa3b audT .aeh1nuo1o 3Iqmsa

busy anismi a3Idsr owl nib3331q 3(11 flu b3ra3ua arliia3l

srft 01 b3lorIbs nisthfl 113111w arurwb 0E1-Q1 21 123131(11 lsIU3itLSqlO bon3q 3Iqmsa A

.bisbnsa bIos 3111 b3niojol 321W3)hl bliow 9(11 (U 231(110(1033 13)1-Ism iaom bns bisbrtsie b1o usvmfni

b3lulilano33l 8111 l8bnu O. I b 1(1813111303 8qoIe tnn3iuini2 1i1ii1 2318m1123 (sQ 1) ninibid

Page 29: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

2 vbbcuqx GCIOU OL IJJOLC

jçocL vuq jçicpq ncj? pc juq ajobc cocjjcicut OLj-J3Q miq O83*** OL j5-J3Ø /AJJCU ErCpcuLccu nCa 9jrCW9PiC qf9 OL fC f cowbicq p?Oj OL Jg -Jj3 OL jgg-jg 9L igi-iôoi IOL JôO5-I13 Og,3**s OL9Uqm? uq fl2 qr "uvo"i ojq q1.nrwcu) vuq E!CPCULGCU cci CSIIOU ThC jpmq jobc coqJjcicu

p3 LccOwbnw E!CpcULccu (j) cuwca niu pc ircpcjj (J5) qu (iiqi orn. yn9Ji9if

pIpcLoucC9UUO coucjriqc .ow pi LCfl1i i9i oq-9uq9Lq 9qpccucc LC2fl6 9

Ac91.2 Mpcu ccp conzuLA M& ou pc ojq uq9Lq pcu pc cpwicq cou.c9pou2 9cn9JJA 91.C

H. 111C CLOa-cCiiOU9J 9ACLSG2 fi2Cq Ui pc 29MU-iIJAG21WCU1 LC&C2IOU coucbouq o pc

IJOW!U9 cxcp9uc-L9c LGWG

o cvb!j91 CouILoI MpICp w9A MGJJ psic pq wncp LG9lcL iwb9c ou c9bu1 wopipA psu w

opc LG9201? JJOMCAGL JJIG LGOLG IUjGLM9I. ojq 2wuqøl.q M92 VCCOUJb9IJICq pA CUCL9J LGJ9X9110U

CLOa2-cOflIJLl 9AiU-iuAc2wcuj Lc9jJoupib xcp9u-Lic AojipA conjq pe ouA WWIIJJ9J b914

jprla GLG i wqeoq OwC ciqqcucc tP !1Uc1J/L ojq 9U9L W9G 9 qiJcLGucc OL JJG

9uA OCL ripbcuoq oUpe !'-' Ac9L

E(H4JJGUJJOLC OITL 2J0bG OL J-J3IJ 26GW2 urn4ccqJA JOmC1. JJ9IJ poc MC C2I1JJ9C I,0L

jobc i owcmp pipcL uq ! uiJc91uJA qqjpicu j.ow sew ai bcLccuj JcAc

ia dn!c cowb9LvpIc o poc ouc zjuq OL bLG-JôJ q9w iu OflL jpjA-iscq 9wbjc

conup.IG OITL vqinaIcq q jq o 9!c9IJA !uu!uc9u 1obc cocwc!cuf ooujA oto Mp!cp

iUACjWCUj COGJC!G1Jj2 L9PIG 2OM JJOMCACL ip91 OL E!CPCUCCU OL!JU9J 9UJbJC o wuc

LCIUJC UCCC229U1A jc9qa O LG91GL !1UCW9P0U91 C9b1191 UJopijiiA 9uq pcicpA ID JOMCL 9A!IJ-

OfJJCL2 (VtOUO%2 J IJJ9 fiG UOWILI9J CXCp9UG-t91G CCLW!IUA bL€A9JJiu riuqc ojq-2wuqLq

ojq 2wuq9Lq u pj pi pe qi2bnc pc fJGoLA quccq pA jpc oow w99sJuC 9WOIJ

oq a uqm.q oz (ace jpc wncp p!pcL ip9lJ ioac onuq LOL pc CJ922!C9I bc-jàj

Page 30: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

COIULOI2 !2 obic j,Ot fIu1LC LG2C9LCp

bpcuowcuou 2porIq pc 92cup6q o &cct Gxcp9uC-LC btcqicripijiO g obbo2cq io tcxcq cbwj

uc!u ACLa o v LC/9AGq motjq ojq uqtq jo -Jo:io IPG btobouJou2 !U MJJC

ru cowbm4aou io opt !uicL/i2npwb1c pc 2/4u-!wG2wJcui coLLc!!ou 12 wtcqjA JOM qntu

!UAC2WJCU 1.C 2OWCM IOMCL 1PU 1pO2G E!C ui.cu (j) onuq iu bicciL PAC

DCabrc LCCpnJ pioqjA 2!IiJiJL COUCjf12!OJJ2 MC C21JWC COLLC1OIJ2 CMCCU 111u uq

btc-jój LG8LC22!01J2 12 fl2f19JJA WJICJJJOMI. pu JU JJG coI.Lc2bouq1u bo2-JO LCLG221OIJ2

coucjcq couiisi) o JJG pAboipc2!2 J4ouCipGJG22 pc cxbjuotA boMcI. OLflJC

g ccw qrni cict uioIrnj 2/Ju uq qowc1c iuAc2lwclu LC2 MCLG cto22-2ccrotrn[A

pc oq wuqtq bLcArcq Dc2b!c pc pip ICACI oLcbiw1 wopipA jrn bLcAiJcq nuqCi. pc ojq

bOa,UAC CLO22-2CCiiOUJ COLLGJ!OIi PCIMCCIJ 29A1LJ IJq IIJAG24WCUI CACU qnuu 2OWC bcLioq2 mpGu

LC&CaIOU crr2 ! M!w E!CPCULCCU (j) tipo °q 2iuicIuJAoJq-2uqLq ACL2!OIJ °L flJC Cjq2cLu-ouoJc (j ) pAbopc2i ou cbrj wopqiA ont

ont wcqioqojo8) L°1 1.6wOtJu uJouGftA ojq joM ow cnu.GtU cconu qt iq unijjX

!U !UAG1U0462

JOM2 011 g cou2!21c1u P!2 VCL022 COfWL!C2 q io qrcq iAC2jWCUj q o cconu LOt CJUC2

ipc bcuoq ow io MC AC cou2wrclGq wcrrtc OLPC cnu.cu cconu ip91 iI.c ojq

p1 JJ12 bbct MC VC bLc2cucq LCAI2 C21JW4G2 °L 2AIIJ 9uq !11AG2WG1U LOt flJ1CCU COflIJWC2 OACL

. coucIIJIoU2

1J16!L CflLLCIU VCCOI11U2 MCI.C UGI. pjucC

1iJUCL 2IJ-!UAC2l11JGU !!"F COfl1UJC2 wA AC pCCu wotc tirCjA o pc 011 oq !u bCuoq2 MJJCU

Page 31: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

AOl I: DW onLc J,G4pOq GOLG yijcu uq flUMIU r'ouqouC!b!c EOLLG2I uq JcppGL vjsu (jg 'iociwzo ckic oW

24V!0UGLA OUM______jAwcuj ccpoI? DcbvUwcui O jLVqC q COWWGLCC K!UI2 bL!UGL uq CO1ULOIICL O

(iooY x c'.' ic1c1ut \r9C LIJCJ? K!U1 bL1UCL 9uq COU4LOIICL O WiiOU6Q OUM ØIWM

CYI1 DOUJ1U!OU BflLGfl OUtC2 (jg) jo jo'ij X kOO OCUCL1\?y ]9UJ( OLVflLl!9 OCCV2OU9I bVbGL J,1o AqucA

B"4J" i Hll v w uq w c (jj) ciciu owciBfll!U W 1 (jg joc cL1 912t \' O ywpqobLC AqucA

\%Q-\\ wpuqG flU!AGLA BLG cvuJpuqcWUl!U 14 e (iY %ocw iw

yA cijc BUlC oLynL9li Aquc?irqu vr ii (jYv bLG1!UI!ULA vuurl DWP JôOO\OJ O Jô3\X4

Exb10L!0U o.c1o%2 tOO%C Aol Uo' ØCIOpCL bboLqo) ypcjrncj D uq Aquq EUU E (J jpc (ojq uqwq jçric: vu EA lu

'O Aol j) uo bbflOGJIU? E (JQ ACflUIJ Vn2LJIU ECOUOW1C OLOMII? jgj o jg- owc

pJcw91!oIrnJ E!UUCG 2GCi!OU CbI4WCIU OECOUOUflC2 buucGou flInAcLA uuccouoouJJq) VLiJJITL j. (pg)) n citowi

C0bCUIJGUBICLICC lCjq uq fliu J.4!I2 (J8Y ° D$ \o-\?c

Aol 3' 1flU6 bbB9Aonwf iunw (j AiU-JUAGuJGu C0aCl!0U2 W toici Oci

jçicjrnq D I.M!U IUC Howmooq IlllU0!W ECOIJOW!C C&OIAIV CGUL JJG flIJJAGLIjA

1vb9u:J28-J3 cp Q IJ KlG!U fMLcIJCc iq OIJIcvM K'I'! (cq £tOUOitBP uq j CUJOO JJILO (Jg)3 jociu iLq viiq Ecouow!c Q1OM1p !u

OO O\ O OW4ci 1& COWWOUMGIW OOAGUIWGLU bUIUCL CUPGLCOIIJILJOUMGP BflLGfl °L CU 9iJq !C (A9uon2 AcvL: Jg-J ouc

jG€LCJJCG

Page 32: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

30

EUOOq ELW EIACL (J co? J,jsinL OCJJ K"IWL- OCjqJOjW

HC12!U1U

E''IJq 1!1lou boiw!2o (uon2 AcL: i j)HGI!UF

uuq) nowcu A!L11!ucU Jo (ii on AGgt: ocitoonto.wi AoJ oc Irliwi bb jW!WU uq HOL!OI CPLIC (aoY DOWGiC !U Uq 1UCLU!0US1 Cb!l jjott

'S'SO cJ.cIJqou IbLC22 xoi.q______CP4G2 H JJ (cq2) t ocio& t

(jgg)) 2jOCJC uq J,OLr hLOLC OG 22Cj iiq ruq cp jg OEGLUGIIf

\%fl\Q CuJpuq flU!ACL2!1? bLCE6!UiC!U CPS4 H (i yowi ct ciwotnc\cE!CpGULcGU Bu.A (jp)) a? qoq flu!AcLa!A bLG WM AOLF

OJJI? JJP!UCUOOO I'JW'i WL / W1I4cPU U qGL flUiACI2J4 K!C1 I C B

E!CP6ULIJ BLLA (j)) JLGuq2 q CAC!62 !' EOLC!U rGUq!u iii 2!PL HOL (cq)

coouv (joY VC!WI ActA OCOPGL b g

cbcwpGL bb 203-230yopriiA: MP D° AiU-IUAC2lWCU4 C (ti0U2 .LCll fl \\J' AO[ 34

D00IcA IcJrnl b ELu1ccJ idU.cA uq ypicou DOujq r (axY IUCWf!OU! Cb!l2IOUCJJC q !UICLG2aG WOUC4LTO C jpIJ1i B1JC DJI! JOUJ9 J

D!Yu' (j c? ct vv� ci 9JC cuc

DCbVLiCWCUf CObCulrn8CUDCuIirnLJ viapj (Auon Aci.: jg-j ci DCP2IJJJC J,CIiJfflIJ COWb9IJA IOLOLUOCU C v JY COUO° L''° '°F I °B'JJ!'J

YIClPOflLIJC'bLccucq O pO H0fl2 O4IUJC1U PA H! EXCCI1CUCA2 couiiiuq QOACUIIIJCIU bUIUCLLCCOL2 !U juG GbI4WGU o jqc iiq cnoi viiq ow o jpc ooicumjcui

ColouA o!cjou [ynjisji] (Auor1 Ac12: Jg-Jgg) tu? cowbijcq LOW ojjci9J

PAowq GOACUJWGIJi L!UjCL AqucAuOW OJC! LGWW2 !" PG GCUGL1, OW bLGGUjGq ° P°W HOflC OVLJ19UJCUj

C010UA owii onjp JjjG2 [najLJi] (/uor12 Acvi.: cowbiGq

Page 33: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

3'

CU' flIJIACL2IIA bLC t2Cpu1Gu2IIJJP VJP'4 H (jg)oot cxuasiuttci c ot? .cic

?A' D'Y'k\U D' buuct AcLJW BcLpuHOWJJU JVJ4CL Q QLrtuJpCp LIJ 9uq HC2G HCJWfl (J vjci

JOACUJWGIJ1 hUUU CULC HC12!UJCFEUJq bflPI!C!0U flqC OU E!Iq ECOUOWIC GLO/14P )(JJJ flUC O JuJuq

j-jicthbc jctu (so) x -'w e.o'vt BIJJ( o

ycwoLIJqnw J4PO1JJ Bf1LG11 OLECOUOW!C JçcG9LCp J4CTh A0t1(w4Juq (jpnupcL'y bcucIobc (J cii ciut o\iv. 'w /AOL1CJIJ

CObGIJPGUfluAGLac1 JULUTi OL QJ(OUOUJi2C HJiOUG bflPjJ0U Q E0LJS

nu6u (ioxY 'D B!uq II: jj-j pGup/ui

c9uJpuqcOLcoIA b! w (Y x° \-\V cswpuqc flUIACI2IIA bLC22

flIJIAGLIA bLG cwpuq acpnooqpi c V E (oY x vcm io voijcicjuc. i cicc o\ cic

LIJJC1J1LHCLVnGPGL DGU2CPG flflUqGpUje ELUJqpI4 W JJU ACLJ EL KU9bb CWPH

OGLW9IJA DCflf2CPG nuqpu (jy

A0LFif 1Jq EIA 1 EqLq (J iciowi lopu jijcA uq 2ou2 J4CM

Q8LqucL IJICL jç (j ?3) J,GLCJJUqJ2C !U BIUCG o Awcu cp o rjcu jç eD!I'K'! KGUlfl1O

En1!uo uq VI!Aw jçAoo (j 'cno o xo o-ic H!iornpp!Q-\QO bL!UC0U flUtACI2i bLC b1JUCCOU J4G/1 16LGA

i.cqwI? jou uq 2cpm. vuu 1cop2ou (j

DCCCWPCL bb a-ut14cqwvI? jqou (ioY ipc'' ojg £coo} Aoj uo Q

iuuu i,iouj qo w qc wq ECOuOwidnc jwbuwcuc j,oirnjc juELUCG' 1U12jLG qc2 E1JUC c qc VUWV!LC2 'Ecouoiui!dnc (j j

Page 34: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

35

CiiK iccwb rnuqi'' on uq 4!Io1? cj-vxj (j 'mtct itoci occ ycn \cv oi

JJJWO!ij'i\ V.cI IJJG ECOIJOWIC (3LOMIP CUCL JVJC flUJACL21A jpcpq if I'-"!" JUC Howcooq

KJc! r'LwcG uq K'P! (qY £toot OJ4% cucc 2\t \%q!"i!ou flUAGL2!1A ot C1!L0L11! BCLJCGIGA--c is uc nubnppp€q qoclotsj

KGA BCUJVL Icu.II (j j ) ot ciwc Cc*c1 oco\V flUqCL&qnV1C 1JJG2! ECOUOUJ!C H!i0t.A IA AqucA flUJACLA

iccuucie I v (ioY x Co '-uImq) j (q) (jj ci Ai.c uq boiMooqc ouqou

KCaCLCp J4flWGL J QCUCL9J CUC2 hUUCCOU fl1JJACL21A bLC bL!UCCOU J,flKCiJqucjc opu (jj) oul t vi LiouJ jnLcn OECOIJOWIC

yjwdiia uq fiqc2G iocJqJojur1op9uaoIf oacu (j o\ ciw oo

bnpjiapcq pA ii's i.iioui iucj ociioif jojc)oO1JJCC OjJCPCCOWW!IOU uq W 2t!i!C2 BflLGfl OpC bL!WC yIU CL

vbtf bLJWG 111 2IGL Ucc (Jy cibct c1ooy (toY cqtcq pA ip EXCCIU!AC

bn? bi.wcu oLEwmicc (jooj Jio JJQ jtoY tuuio\ii? jojAotcno jojcAo [wpoIJ QWJCO jOJCG!ICAOJCfT 'o ioo -}o ycn oct}BUIC O ibiJ 2!!C DCbI.1WGJJi (j 1cci. o\

ibu B!uJc ovbu (j £tOOt citc' c *ciu jojcAo

(jg ocio c -p jirio CCUL!C qi iic Icourn

K0W4SJOIJJC DGII1!I! DI JQJ yj JQ) 41W3%% ct tci UUO GUG AIIL AOJ

jjA JjIUI4O CCIULI qI 2f4!2!C& (iivi) (J juqiuc 9tpC nJJo 2AiInbbo DCI jçcqqio

coon jojcAoIp!ppr iøuu (cq) (JoY jpc EOLC!U j.qc o ibu V 2II21JC9I ICACM

OLJq B9IJ1c Mp!U0U DCM!°' DCbUWCIU OECOUOW2C 9Uq OCJVJ IIJ0LUJPOU - i2fJC9[ D!A!!OU3 J4CM AOLJCJ2JJUJOU DC OL1!S!0U L01 ECOUOIJJ!C C0-0bGL!0U uq DcAcIobwcu b9L! nLnlcqC0WW!22!0U 0 EflL0bCU C0WWflU!!C2 BWCP IIU6UJWOUJ oiictA riuqbLcb1.cq fIUGL IJJC 9f1biCC2 Oj 1pG JUtGL-GCLCfU MOL1C1U Q.octb ou ouj yccornu:

JUCL-GCLGWUj J/OLJC1U QLOfIb °t1 I4!0UJ CCOflU (J o\ ocitto

Page 35: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

InoiiEM ww'k X no1 t \t ( I ÔQ I) nomi ai3nxuA Q .fov £nt3nsni'I bns noit&in&I ItiqsD iii ibut 431a3eo$1 oimonoIo uiufl

•flOj33flL-Iq 21q fl13vnU

rs{ iw j9 o twomtA tQ I) anoiM b 3usJ .svn3D hinuoD owT-iioTIo aaiai2 bsiT II by Q\-OQ'L

io'k ttw twt o wiot,A (V.Q I) ______ jvnD hnuoD 331rIT-txi2 10 3ifeiii biiT II .bov

III by -'.Q1 z\p o (I FQI) _____ .BVfl3O EflIfWOD iuoI-ixi 10 3ftiiS sbsiT

Isnoirsrn3inI jil boy QQ't-Q1 {V o iotA (1 I) ______ £V3fl90 3ii2!iB12 thB1T

8QI) ioni1 noniuwoH bnE antrnM wodJ-'v,J •2nBq 3tmonoo u o-oim

by Q't-\\. otX (VFQI) nhaX boA bna ;wii n,i1rLaU 2th IdbniJ biao io1 iuiianI -Ob cu otX \oM \tw iL1 1o

.mbocb1ao mborbL3oi b iiivinU 33P$I3

U4 •in mubnsiomM dais5L nivs rio 3vitqis nuSi 8noJ A (IQQI) 2uanA noibbsM .idotaO nriinoiD lo jii,yinU eaimono3TIo i1u3s1 rbisae5L 3WflOflO3 0 3tutit2nl

.oboT io\coK o \1o?k Q8I) idossM ssfueM

à-4óQI o IOQI flluo33A ir1T1uD no aIr1m\sTbo 33nJdJIH nilituA 3dT (8ôI) .W .1 fu38J3M .O-VV .qq nu1 OI .on V .1 ov uK

(.b) •t 1jq qmt ni Iô8I ni2 nivs rIBifs1twA (1QI) ______ fsnoiM nsiIiitwA rb31fi2.51 3IbOq 3ffr1OftO3 ioI 3flf13D 1i\!so

.s-n3dnD ti18vinU

"rrothsqmoD nsaiimA rItoM bns risi!EltwA :23imono3a iffl ni nivi QQQ I) _______ .qq j £ boy csoXk

..*ioY W3M 1iI (10 i3E1 bn tQ'-Ot iiroc (I8QI) .51 .ff llcf3iiM

r13151 bsD iiK tw \o\% (E8 I) _______ .tioi3U nqmoD

.sgbndmsD 31q 'ti213vinU bhdmD tZ O1%k tkthv (88Q 1) _______

w3M 1q notboi ,

.b bE %Q\-Ot ' *ok QQ I) ______ .)hOY

EE

Page 36: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

1n1J(!WfIaI9110ICCIJ In! !111. ii HGJ!UJ!ipJcgg) ELI1 (j)) it'ti 2nowcu b1!'J j910f11iC1GGJJJ2GU

1nh191afl19 K/ UI1JC!Wfl1C919 AI HGI2!IJIC!H!fl! 9uq b1!J1C9J9 Etiqa(j Oci$ gc \\-\ fl0WCU b91'J!!

ViwdAlal 9uq J!caGjJ 1OCp0jwOPt0U rcuu9I4 (j Vj oo1 '\ ct?.c

tocnt c.n? ioj joAo Kc1s9! piwbopopJ' K'P! JJuop9L9 iAopGt 9uq flWCWflL9 j1i (cq o\cjvJc9w9Ian 14oprIJcIAo slJq A9W9WO1O Afl0 (jj)) JAc1OUci 1tOc A01 I °L N !U21r1qrn A91G flU!AGL2!A A91G fl1J!AGLa!IA hLC 14GM WAGU dr1o1iu j0W Øpc9M9 K91'

'4M ECOUOWIC 010MW CGUIGL uq cociucij °UE91 V2!UOPIM 2JJ!u0p91.9 iAopci uq AjGtJGL r9u.A(jo) £too*t

flIJIAGL2IIA 0piC980 bLG CP!OEflG11G 14 (cq) y'oi cnc tciu vcowC9b!191 IALOP!JIIA OAGL 1}JG rou Wr1LJ) 'U OLqO YTIC}J9G! D ojqiif

pJq) N!nLJCG 9uq iio (iooY LPG 0i DcbLc!ou 9 9 /9iGLJJGq: IU1C1191!0U9I

flIJJAGL2!IA bLG bUUCGIOU Mi2fl \tç c tOO },LHJCG0U

9flLICG (1oô2Y jU16UJ91!0U9j C9b!WI 0p!J!1A 111 1}JG JÔàO !U yGIJCIJ bGIGL B (cqGU19JpAL9

14oLM9A 2w1i1ijc 2cu1L91pAL (A9uon Ac9L j g- i wc Oi0 9111I((jg)) J.40J.G2 O.U2!G!!C W1i1iJqC A0J Xii 'JO 5j) oio

(j oci\c* \Q\Q( J40LG ØIGJJG 91i2f!fle XIII JQ3) OJo

J'n oi°J,4OLM9A W!21J2JC 2CU1L91PAI. (J owuwib J40t2G 01J12!G!!G 1!fl XI

q919pvG plIb :\\MMM upcL oL\q919p9aG2\wvcJ.opI2iotA\couIc1u\iuqcx puJ1I41!°UJ BflLG9rt 0EC0U0W!C KGG9LCP (A9uona AG9L2') y t.ovo) CCC1LOWC

ynuqcjj KOPGI4 y (j oQg) cioi tOOt' 9CUJIJJ9JJ J46M AOLI(

9uq 2OCiOJOR? bUUCGIOU flIJ!AGI21A b1411CC1011 141IU IU4G.1J910U91 EC0UOW!C 110 5) IUGL1191!0119! E!11911C6 GC1!OIJ DGbSI4WCUI oEcouow1c

OLGUa1GU? (Jo?Y x o\ .wiows bccij b9bGL2

rouqouYTO129U E AICIOL (j)) \0%t) 9Cy1JJ9U % COWI

Page 37: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

4CH AOLJCfluIcq 14 0U2 24!!C1 occ (j')'' o\ctouc cnc

H!a cA 2!0UC1 ouco pA owwwq wq 832

fluicq yju&jou? nrnucwj 2ccLcwl.Aopc jcanLA (JJ) o

rouqouW P°IP H0fl 0T949UJGLU pA 0WUJVIJ 0H6L G2IA HGL 41CA12 rrouciA owc

nuuq uqou? DcbnlA yci. o pc iu (Auon Acgt2: i gxo- j cno bLccuGq

4!0U6 O1JJ ouqouurcq yjzJqouJ CCIUL1 2!!cI oujcc (jg) uci k H! GaA

jp 2iioucLA ojc rouqounwicq Ju8qow Boq otqc (/I.!on AcL2: jgi-j-jg) tcci c

3L cq ocjcjou J,LC 14GM JoLJ(yyj) dnocq !U 1ICJJGJJ B w UoY tcijoriu C (osY LOqflhl IUCUd11L BU qG i ELUC qc Jg 0Ot

JILGn OECOU0WIC JçGGLCJJKcIuouapJb3 J49iOUVj BflLfl OLECOIJOW!C JGGLC M0LJ(IIJ hbGL 140 43 1490LJJ

jAjo yju j (j Jiuu zouJ Cb!WI j,opijiA Hi H!OLA luG JLJ-IUAGWG1U

CIf 2Wi12lC9 CUUp?IJ (JàQOY%0U UW\O. 1U& 2PI21C ØhCL2J2pGJJG1

v (cq) ocXctv vcc otu flu!AGLA ocpico bLC cucoflWUJGL? H (i J,x bO!! uq C0WbG !/GUC JIJ ELCUJ(GI 10P

ce!II-OncciJ)a flUJAGLA bLG K!U240U cc qou1.cj(j '-°v x D''°' \ucjrni. v vr (Jo3Y CB11 0IIUCUIW0JJVJ j,AwcuW J2O-Jô? Cp J J oflLdnpI4 C

IU!PT 0L ECOUOW!C2 uq BflUG yquJtrn2LrtOI? K0PG cLA opcpuio HftP! (j io6c - * jpc

ELLJCG JU2rnu yc2 cpçjc (j 'rion. oi c 'j.cit jcc flrnAc2rrJLc qc

ii. jg 14oAGwpGj goo- j D1bI.1IwGu0 qi 2C!GIJG GCOJiOUJICpG' nUIACI2IW qCji nqt qG ACU6ff?

K02i ico 2oLio3 yuqL uq jouioo Quui (iooY iwuu IIoIC9L1COU flrnAGLLIA bLG2 Ot

JQCJJ OG0L (Y x cocç. och ciw c'

Page 38: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

2Wq! JIG flU!AGI2UA JJG flU!AGI2UA bLC2 14C/ HAGUE°'°' O-0'4P CCIJ 9uq coc1J Ou Ei V1J

KflP! 21J1IJOPL 1AOpG! uq yciauci? aA (GqA9WM 1bbci uq woo A° (J jqc uq BJUCG Oj UJCIJt2 cp lu Oplc9Mff

OECOIJOWJC KOP6 flIJLAGL2!A OLCOWWGLCG /JOLJUU bbCL J40 \ffl&1JwuJoiO A° (J '*ciw cimt civ. yici

flU!ACL2! bLC uJp4q JflCpff2GU2A!UCL )CO (J4) 2 o\

D ECOUOWI. C1llc EqTou bL!A!JI b!C110 (J 'ci} v ci jç't AJOUO&bJJ!C

flUTACI2LIA bLC cp4qflLdflpI4 Y C uq BnC1C! K V, H (Gq) (jiotci iW4\t2 o\çc ci

______y{CQIJJ-flCCU2 flu!ACLaIA hLC22 KJU21OU % JOIULGV(j ciow co o\

nqiGa !U 9uq jcjij? Aol j) flrnAGl2!iA OCpiCO bL CP!C0F (cq 'O t1O2 %3 4U.C1U tO3Ot O1tV J4VPOUJ B(ILGf1 OECOUOUJ!CIwbc!ou2 Ot DGA10bWU cp. OUCLUJLf 29UICA I' uq jjwgu opcu

flLdfl}J9U f (io J4GM E2iUJ9c2 OI. QLO 4iOIJ91 LOflC1 C'q jgØ-jQ OWC

QO/IJIGIU bWU!U OW P!U0Uflurcq BnLcrI oupc (A9uon Ac2: Jg-J MXo i\u o\vtc

\J' O CCtUCIJIJJ qou) fl GOAGUJUJGIU b4'U!U OJCG AP!Ui0U DCflu!cq fucri oj wc ccur (J') •oti 'cj

Page 39: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

tivitins 19 mwi&1 bna uoita3fli3sq ,vi)aniflA aifl 1daimV b9flimO :A zibnsqqA

b noiwbni 3di oi iqaq 3dt ff1 smi isi3malaq sift b ivitians sd rftiw 1asb xibnsqqs ufT .3S13VS IBft0it33e-2O13 sfIt ni 3ntnuo3 b noii33Is 3rif bna atab 2)L3o2 woft bIo8

woN bIo .1

bto no sisb Ifs sbuI3ni bIuocI2 inuo33s fl3TW3 srI I ioI asiuft lath isqsq silt ni bsugta svsrl sW its s3ubolini 111w )13012 blog vistsrtom srhi irk 2s8r1sfI3 io 2tnsmqirI bIo8 isn no stab niflimO .awofi

.stsmiies silt otni asid asldshav bsttirno blo Its nibuI3ni tnUO33s insTIu3 silt ai tasisini bo sldshsv suit sift tacit saoqqu

tnsrru3 bIonon silt b mus silt as bsnflsb si daiilw 1W4 io Ui) 1o noii-ioqoiq a u bsaasiqxs bIoIo ainsmqida tsn aulq 3 trwo33s

(IA) + OV 3 = 0

noiaaslqxs silt d rwVi3 ai 3nutsmttas n' bstasisini 315 SW notisisi srrrt silt tail saoqqua woM

(IA) • + (°.3+%)q + = I :(A) bits (IA) anoitsLrps aniw d fl3iiIlWsi sd n.s noiaaslqxs airlT

+ +°KD÷I) + X = I ( ) • + + (3+1) + =

otni aaidbo 331U05 S 233ub011n1 tf1u0335 tII5TILf3 srffbo SIJISV biuaasm sit moil woft bIos Wtibuf3xH

bnad trIii silt no rrnst built silt atirno tnsmtasvni no anivaa nzaasisi as suubs3o1q noitsmitas rlt .sfdst niwohIo1 silt ni bsiaitaulli si said ssldsrisv bsitimo silt b tristxs silT .(EA) noitsups 10 sbis

nosigsi moit astamutzs isIsmriaq to noiiaqmoD :IA sidaT ( t3+1)no I to noi wiidIiw( +'t3+I)no Ito

t % ork'I kt' %

%tw2 ov * ** 4LO 1:sqoI E1Q1ot811

asriiniio3 hA OO.E- 11.O Q.O 5 .bA

!1- ** I

q:sqo1 EQ1oiQ1Q1

au$I isO ail nsU .13x3 8J- QO4.O 11.O % .jbA

silt b noitloqolq S as asismiias lsismfimq m snsis11th sill nbfst 'd bsislu3lss si asid tnxm t lsismsiaq bsflissqs 'basnoo

.'l3'bsq23i ISYSI o\°1 bits o\Oo1 fj jfl 33f• fliflgtE 3j53if)ffl *** ** *

nsrlw insoisq svft-inswt tsomls d bstamitasisbnu Si instsff!so3 sqols sill tailt aetsitaulli sldsi sliT sit 10 tnstxs silt bsu sus bohsq iswrstni silt moib stab nsrfW bsw sis stab El I ot 881 siLt

Page 40: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

silt asasa iliod iii .tnstioqmi anismsi Ilita ii kid bsaubsi al tns,ajflsoa sqola silt b tnsmstsiaisbnu iltiw bioaas lii S1S etluasi sasdT built £ taomis d bsaubsi ei noleasisi silt b iswoq vuotsnslqxs

sd ot bnst asanslsd triuoaas trtsTtua as awoft btoa 8nibulani b tasqmi lslil silt 1o noitiutni iuo silt ot awoft b1o anibbA '.bIo bo a.tnsmqirla tsn sift iltiw noitasa-aaoia ni bstslsnoa lsvitssn bits rnvsa nsswtsd noitslsrioa bsiuassm silt niathu b tasuis silt svsd ifiw noitsups bstsmitas

.astsnanomsb s!dst silt as tnsmtasvni

siboi . b sulsv silt sbulani bluoda tnsmtesvni aaoi ioI suiift tsdi isqaq sift 111 sftsiid bsuus svsrl sW

olni asidbo saiuoa isiltons sauboitni 111w abota no atsb nittimO .alaoia 10 asnotnsvrn iii as8nsila .astamitas silt

silt as bsnftsb at ilaiclw X tnsmtEsvni aaoi Istot ai tasusini lo sldshsv suit silt t&Ii saoqqu : aAaota io ashotnsvni iii asnsda bits X tnsmtasvni bsxft aaoibo mua

(1A) + = I irismiasvni aaoi bns if1U0335 tftsuiua srltbo rnua silt as lIsubiasu bsnftsb ai anivs

(J) .1 + =

:tnsmtasvni aaoi aulq t11u0335 tflSTW3 sth Isups nivsa I\j1o lsvsl sdi isJ

(A) + =

nitsmiias ni bsiasisini sis sw noitsisi suit sift tsdi saoqqua woM .o?i� + = ? tsilt ilaua

noiaasiqxs silt d nsvi at

(VA) + + = I :(VA) duourlt (A) anoitsups nIEU 'd nstthwsu sd nsa noiaaslqxs alilT

8A + (3o? + ) q + = + ( • + ot(l-) + + =

S31UOE lsitnstoq £ asauboititi tnsmtasvnilo su1v bsiuassm silt moll stsb a)faota iii 258(15113 8nibu!axH silt no mist buith sth atiino tnsmtasvni no 28n1V52 8nlaesl8sl as suube3ouq nolismias sift otni asidlo silt ni bstsitaulli at asid asldsnsv bsflimo auft b tnstxs silT (8A) noitsups 10 sbia bnsd td8il

.sldat niwollob

asw awoll blo Its gnibulaxs tnuoaas insuuua silt bns atnsmqiila blo tsn nssvitsd noiisfsuuoa 25fl32-smi silT sift uol asisi2 balinU sib bns mobani)I bsiinU sib '<avnoM nsq& IsiI sanniI btaslni1 nilsiiwA iol sviissn uob svilsgan asw noiisls-rioa sib bonsq E1Ql-88l silt uo1 .asiutnuos nostiiiftlo iuo id8is bonsq slquisa 11111

iuo nin ;asisi b3iinU sift bits mobaniA beilnU silt nsbow svnoM jisqs1 lsiI nsnnsO nsi1 hsrnnsU .aiujnijo nssitidi ciii 10

.taubo,q lsnoilsM 1cM uo ailasmoU aaouO bo cslnc31sq s as boaacuqx3

XE

Page 41: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

flOi9191 moit si&miJ lt9mrIRq to nohiqmoD :A IdkT no 'k to dliw t baa + '1) no I to

ycI t t ior1 V.V1 '" :Dqo1 EIQ1oi881

aitInuo3 hA V.IO! QQ.O % .jbA

Øf4 ** 8QO ** q:3qo1 EIoiQ1Q!

au5l 13D i1 n3U .13x3 O8.- 4O.O hI.O ? IbA

lo noitioqoiq a aa iami 13J3m8laq iu n3r3Thb sft 8thAai d b33a1u3th3 i aaid inm t l3l3malaq b3ftbqe Ii33TIo3

.'43vii3qa31 13v31 o\°I bna o\0 o\OO1 3di ia 33flfl3i1tfli 33831brn

n,rIW .2itt3t3fflO3 biamia, 3d no aaid &danav bflhrno to t38fi3 di iau!hi 3Id.t idT iwoq otana!qx3 bna b3isi1vo '1btim i tn3kffio3 3qof eth b3bu13x3 ia stab i1oin9vni

.iom io in313q nfluI d b3t3'fis ai noiii dt to

noiIa3fli39q fbi ,i$I ,i)nit1A £

nivs no etn3biflo3 tr13131!ib 1diaoq iol wolla (8) noitsup ni nvi noits3fflq 3vdsmi!s nA EA IdsT ni b3in31q 31S noits3ih33q irft mofi t1ua .)I3oj bloa 1at3nom silt iii snafl3 silt bria

Page 42: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

t0

CoIffuJIJ.

PACLG opwiucq EOL cowbrn.ioif ipc pjj rwbjc c!w9c2 o qic Iobc LG bLccucq u pc uujqLobbcq ow jpc miJbic j v pwc fu jpi bLOCGq11LC ipc ppc 9uq jomc bLcwclcL cl!wrc2iPic vt bLc2cuja ip tfJf2 01. WG LGLC!OU2 LOt iiwc bcuoq ipcu ouc cofiulLAJJ!2 acCi!Ou qc2 /ItUp IPG dnc2j!ou 0 p0/A CU2!1!AG IpG bgLwcjcL Gajiwca gLe O Oc1IJIGL'

1 O"(I!" GU?!(JA!4A

9j jpc IGU bctcciu leAd!'

1G woucWLA ojq jocjc cdn ueimc ouc 1.01 uo bcuoq2 oujA 1.01 ouc bcuoq jpi tc1ccjou oujACmJ I.GCI WC pThoqJc2! qJI pc cocjccuj ou aAiu cdnja ouc uq pc cocjjjcicu ou cjrnuc2 iuOU lpC cjiviRc !U hid WOiJCWLA ojq jocc LC wojjA !u2!u!l1cue CAGU 9j bG IGU bctccuj leAd!' 1Jdbtdfon2 LCIJW fIG cxbjmrnoi.A bo/AGL qoc2 uoj cjrnuc pA wncp pccnc pc cocjccuj crurnjcJG C9U CG 1.10W Wd 1d2fl11 2 w bPi we wouci.A ojq oc qqe iwi o pc

1ô3X-1o3ô ipeA cxcjnqc JLSUCC 0ctwguA 1jAuq niDd13IJJ94 LUCC OCUIIIUA uiiq JfT2iU LOt 1ô5-Iô3O iiq Jo3J-1o3e IPCA cxcjnqc K' LOt..u 188O-JM3 'q 188O-I8O cxcjnqc bu vuq jçnn 1.01 jj-j ipeA cxcjnqc* ** *** t IPC I Oo\O o\0 q I o\O lCl LCbcC1i/CiA'

1ô3X-lô3ô ô 03 010 -O'QX 0'XO O'383 OàJ

l3J-13Q 1 O'8X *** 0'OQ 013 0'Xl 33t * O'?

l5?13O 1 O'Q! ** 05Q -O'5Q 1'5o J'3 O'3X

1WJ4 !øô 0.QQ -310 X'18 O•O'iQ 018

J05-JJ3 13 O'?3 0' 4'X XÔ 1'IQi 0J8l-JO1 13 O'Q? *** 0'18 -0'3X J3i 1'8X1 O'O

J88018ô0 11 0'34 O3 l0'XQ * 'iôX 4'8ô3 ** O'il

J88iô13 13 0'?S ** 0Q 0'30 5Q 1'3X3 O'5i

1880-!ô13 11 0'iO 08 8'8 X'QO ?88 0,18

'UOiX ci

ococt ciu

o 'y.kQ:A'taw

= j A =-\cj\'

iou uqs7ij (x+c÷'j÷viae)JPJG v: J,LVWG(GI. GJW(G LLOW LdLcnIOu o

Page 43: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

iuni) sqoh muminim bna mumiziM :tA i1diT flj no )nmjvni to noii,i molt

%i •tr sio S'.

.\ & *o •K Y

\ ir9 rovk E1.0 MN '0.0 .0 A2U 0.0 8E.0 EIQI-0881

QØ MN QØ ** '.0 3W .0 * E.0 E11-881

1'I.0 AU 8.0 * 4.0 A2U 80.0- .O 0Q81-0881

l.O MR 8.0 ''" 1V.O q .o v.o IOQI-IQSI

* 00.O MN O.0 * .0 U51 1.O EO E1Q1-0Q1

* Q0 UA 01.0 * 1.1 510M 0.0 E.0 1Q1-Q1Q1

** E.0 WA .0 O.1 5130 .0 * .0 0FS1-?SQI

*** 8.0 AU Q.0 OQO 5130 4Q0 E8.0 EQ1-1EQ1

*** Q0 WA .Q0 Qo qM Q0 ' V8.0 QE1-EQ1

.'13'lii33qa51 1'I31 o\0l bn o\0 o\0Ol 3di i n u1inia 33831b111 4 I -Q I Q I idi ;iau51 bn naq1 a3bu13x3 0Q8 1-0881 bns El Q 1-0881 io1 338nhit oIqma ilL!1 d1' EQI -I EQI idi ;thau51 a3bu13x3 31 OEQ 1-EQ I ioI ;ipuM bn imrzn30 33nn1I h&nnoU bLJI3X3 ii

.6iu51 bn IaiI ninn30 risi1 a3bubx ii QEQI-'EQI ioI ;thuM buI3x3 Ii

sh1nuo3 to 1qm 3di oi 9viiiart iup e smiia3 13tB1E 811t isrfr 3Ida 1dt mofi n 3W 3d3 bits !E.0 s d3um s 'd 3ftSfI3 n63 tn3i1o3 3qo!2 b3tsmu3 HT .93513v5 3d3 ni 3d3 bon3q I isW bhoW-eiq dt i&I .3n3313q tto1 s daum as d rIsd3 ns3 iwoq '(IotsrisIqx3 3r13 iwo1 oi abn3 bris1ni1 3lidw a3ismi3a3 1J3ms1sq 3r13 aisi o3 abnt 2 .U ,clt 10 flOfWI3fl!

-nivsa r1 aisi ot abn 'nsmi30 lo noiaut3ni 3d3 bonq I isW bhoW-taoq 3dr io9 .ismira ,m3d3 13w01 03 2br133 silsirauA 3Iirlw noiisI3rtoo 3fI3m3a3vfti

bi&bnai bIo TIO io nO :tsmiD.I istmiri&I 2

03 33n313Thb s aslsm bisbnsia bto 5th no nisd isdisdw 21 isbiano 03 nOitasup niiasisini idtonA sth arli3smiras sd beasibba sd nsa noiiasup aidT .noisIsiioa insmtavni-anivsa bstsmi3as r1i

niau d 10 boi13q slqmse sii3rts sift io1 bisbnsta bloa sift no sisw tsrb asiflrwoa io1 Lno alsIsrnslaq

rrridh3q oi al ar1jnuo3 10 1qma di 03 3srnh3a 1313m518q I13 b 3iviiiana 3d3 iai 03 boiiism svi3am3La nA £

abnil bits 23nJ1w03 idia1o Iqmsa aid idl a3iamii2 qirdaiood aisIuaIna (OQQI) irnuoz .anoiaasit qirdaood .anoi11uts 231RU2 ies1 aid 03 islimia 33wp ai8mi323 l3i3fntflSq

Page 44: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

t5

ot E1CJJCULGCU (jp) ot 2nucX o oq aiuquLq bn.t,cjbottowyju&jow: jg-jj I5-1o3I cnutcq totc: J3-I0, IOg-133 CCBOiqO11Uq?X91Jq (j)1ô30- 1ô3JJ40LM J8?-1ô!t 18-!3!icfl!S: J-JJ4 MGqC1J 13Iô1't JtI31 tjiCflu'icqigg-joit I58-13Q ctwvuA: jgj-j joA j-jg j 5-J3Q pb9u Jg-11

J83-IôJ4 1ô5-J31 DCUWVL1 1851ôT4 1-1ô31 EIIJJ9IJq Jo -JO3J ELOUCC:

,jcfloe qic oJJo!AmW quc jpt ipcu conupic /ACLC ou tpc ojq2touqm.q - v11ar111J1: Ig- j j j o-i oo

cuqocuono oi. urnuA COflUfL!G2

IPG tGx 4JJiO LGOflJI to qicnjt to !UIGLbLGI pccorioc pc pwiu o ojq otuqtq qpctcucc i'ocoqwtcq cou.ciuo1J qiwpcA o mcj s pc cxbsutoLA boI1cLoi,tpc tct.c22iou yo uotcq in

IJUIJ ipc COnUILA AGLG ot Acoto tpoi o conuttA M2 011 pG ojq owuqtq teuqo jo Lioc JJG

OL pG cutac owbjc bcuoq teuqa to IOMCL tpc G2fW9tC O9AJu-iuAcotwcut coaGjtiou. HOMGAGLjc cou occ .ow pc tconjto btcocutcq in tp'o wii tpt wcjnqiu oujA conufLicO on tpc oq otuqtq

1O3-1O30 !t cxcnqco Knzio

CXCI(K1GO IOboU OUq JfIOOiV tOt JJ-J5 it CXCJPqCO J)C1JUJ0t EL9UCC (3CLUJOUA qic°iuqouf ouq qic flwtcq 2W1C2 lP ti'It aowbjc CtiwSfCoL jggo-joj uq Jgo-Jgocxcjnqco jto qsc c2trurnIc OL J-J3Ø iucjnqca oujA OcurnuA iicqcu tpc fluitCqjsoi-iooi cxcjnqco JJ? obmi jçnooio ouq tpc uucq 2t0tC tpc cfrw91c tOt 1005-1013JJICCOPWOIC 0L COfWILIC2 011 fiG o1q atouqutq tOt I8801OI3 1g8-1o!3 1880-!8o0 q* wqicorc aruiucoucc 9f fiG 1Oo\0 ?\° ouq to\0 [C1cJ LC2bGCtiACJ?

!05-JO30 080 ** 08.S 00 *** 0QX3 OQ?3 ** 0.t5IOJO-J05't - - - - 0oQO * 0'583

1005-1013 05 * 0555 03 * 0533 000 * 055igoi-jooi 0?58 0,UQ 0X0 *** 033 0QJ *** 0?t1880-1800 0558 -0003 0558 00XQ 0tJ 0133

188?-1013 0t38 003 O�0O ** 05XQ 0?0t ** 0101

1880-1013 0tJ? 0.05? 0?83 ** 053 04Q3 013

c11c

\? \? \ i?oc\tcto o o j(OL COflutLIco OH IjJG oq anuqLq uq (OL )ci.a ou jpc ojq ztuqiiq

jpJcv: jobc cojwco LOW LGLGZZ!OJJ Ot !0AUWClJ4 Oil '!'°

cowbuaoif iic ucnqc !u tpc iuj IMO conunio jpc bgtgwejctCat!urntcopocq on AVLJpJC qwoo icj oo cortuitA cLGo poocq on pc bcuoq oi. mpicp tpc cornutA io on tpe oq otuqLq LOtitc y apoia tpc tcanjto oLGonurn4w pcboiswcjcto 0L COnUILIGO 1}J1 MGLG 011 tpc oq oruqLqq to tpc AcI2 pj conutLA ,o on qic ojq owuqoiq4 MG qobt potp bbtocpco Pete.

Page 45: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

bodI'iM bflR iuo idi :fl zibwqqA

'b ismiias 33nq inriua nbti sd b3Iuata3 iow &Ii ui b3tmiia oita1 n3mivr1i 3dT

S as (siiotn3vni\aA3ois ui 53nsd3 sulq rn,mts3vni b3xft asola) noursrrnoi IStxqs3 3ii3mob aaoi 3buIarIi sm A30t b ismis 3dT 233flq 3:*Ism is iouboiq 3fia3mob ssoi b iniq

ol 01161 in3mts3vrn u1i nibba d btsmiis asw oitai anivs 3rIT 13oie3viflo 3uIsv 3di ui 23II&13 audi ai oiisl nivsa 3dT .533flq ift3TW3 ni b5lues3m oftsi ¶4M 10 uo OS 1rnJ0336 tfl311U3 9d1

3d1 bus in3mta3vni diod mo-ft io-ri tn3m3luasem Its a3taloqlo3rn 33n3d bus 11aubiai b3nft3b ifWO33B 1f1311U3

RiIRduA

16bn3163 a3nq thsm Ø .q .103 1 .T ô1) niliua .0 .14 moft 316 OOQI-1ô81 mo-ft sish quo .103 j.VI .T 'VQ1) ni!iua .W .M moib 316 14Q1 ol OOQI mo-ft sisb quo .abnuoq'bo anoilhim ais 316 sSsG .owt d nibivib d ebnuoq 01 b3tl3vno3 a-isttob'1o anoihlim athq Sn5rlu3 (-8V .qq j I

.\NQ1 os 10\OOQI (0 eriu1 oSlO stu'L) ais' hsi3nsrIft idl

WOL \ bris ailduq Isiol I .q .1 1) niliufi .0 .14 mail 315 OOQI-1ô81 idi stsb noiismio1 IsiiqsD

istiqsD .abnuoqbo abnsauoth 51s3 1sbn3is3 aonq ihsm noiiarrno'1 1611q63 3iia3mob aaoi eisvnq .0 .14 mail 316 OOQI-1ô81 io'l sisb s)13oi2 ni a38nsrID .a)13oi2 ui a8nEr13 sbubni stsb noiiamio'1

b abnsauochr 5•1s3 15bn3163 a33nq 53*ISm rloitsIumu33s ?boSa3viI .q V .1 QI) niftufi 3isvnq Isiol 9th b tisq 316I £ urio'l aisass bOi23ViJ 15(15 auis (l .q ôQI) niIiu8 .abnuoq aaol 9isvnq lsioi 05 noiislei ui 2-' 13V 915 aiaaa 13oi23vi1 111 anscb bns aiaas nsi1-iiauA

Isiiqs3 01 Isup3 noilSlumu33s Isnqs3 aiia8mob b iuasm a b9aoqolq niliua .noi1srrno'1 1651qs3

.1 OQ I ot lonq slab nsils-iiauA -1db b32u Si 3lub330-Iq aidT .A3oia3viI 111 533115(13 autq IlOiiaffrldI ri3fbo at siab floiSsffnO'l Isiiqso ni a3ismiia3 noiislumu33s )t30123Vi1 'bo noiaubni aidT 35013 51(15115W 33113U3E 3Vii5ffl3i18 311T' augia (1 I.q ôQ1) md3oa sA .15V3WOd j.SiSlOVolino3

lo 3luiibn3qx3 bus iuqiuo no si3fi3 15131133 3(15 seusd e3efsns diwol3 bus 3(1103111 rn (1015(13155

ioI .aIaas b3xIl ni 533nsd3'Io 2i33'fl, 3(11 IIIiW 3ldslsqmo3 h16a2333fl ion 318 boIS3vil flu 533116(13

113(151)116 00QI 01 1ô81 moil qQOlo 5n3313q V0.1 briuos 33619V5 )L3Ot23Vi1 fli 5355313(11 st1iiuA OS I 0\001 mail 1n3313q 1Q0

ainuo33A tsnoiisl4 'bo mia' sth noits3fuia2s13 5111uo336 Isnoilsu lo 3vi533q513q dt mo1]I 3niblo33A .aA3ois ui 233f15d3'bo 5356m1553 oini noiislumu33s t3O123Vif 10 noits3fliaaaI3 9(11 a3iEaovba

ni b3iliaasI3 3d btuoda aAaoia ui 855313(11 3(1110 3u1sv 9(15 (08 .q Q1) 331fi0 t,s3itaits5 MU 3(11 01 ainuo33A lsnoiisWbo m3iav 311T .einuoao.s Isnoijsn di 111 noiismlol Isiiqs3 b3xft 56 (1W 3(1162 3(11

auc1T .sisb Isoiioiaid OS l3vLi38qao1191 b3ilqqa bns i3asiab -iuo ui a3rlinuo3 'nsm d b3iqobs saw ui noiisIumu33s )boiS3viI 3bul3rn bits 3lub53olq airIt wottol 111w 3W 5i23th aidi lo asoqiuq 3(11 iol

.Iaoia ui 233f1ad3 b 5355m1153

.3IdBhisvMUI at uo Ii i3ubolq lanoilsn 1314

.inioq situ b noissuasib s iob silrzlauA ui noiism-io'1 Iniiqsa no 231011 di 33

Page 46: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

(QV-8V .qq ! .VI .T VVQ1) nilflifl .W .M moll 4$Q1 oi OOQI mofi siBb noii&rnoI 1iiqED d ebrwoq o b3J1vno3 11ob1o anoillirn es3hq inrIu3 noiiftmlo1 Iiiqso bxft 3ilduq aulq iavhq

IsiiqaD .?.1A1$1 o 1O\OOQI (OF. nut ot I 1ut) eis I6i3nnft ioI sis saa .owf d nibivib .M moil sis 4'Q I ot OOQ I mail )13ot 111 23nsrf3 iol sisU .abol2 iii asnsd3 sbuI3ni sub noil&frIol 'd abnuoq oi bstlsvno3 isllob1o noi!1im saiiq lnsnu3 ((QV8V .qq I.VI .T VVI) niLtufi .W

.4\4$QI ot I0\OOQI (0 snut 011 s!uI) eiss 1sinsnfi ioI sis sisU owl 'd anibivib

1f1u0335 1n5r1u3 io1 (44$ .q .T ôQI) niliua .0 .M mail sis 00QI-I8I idl atsb 1flu0335 in5ruJD aidYlo sviisgsn oa atidsb1o sxs s bsnfisb ai skisi ni iscJmul4) .2bnuoq b 2noillim ni s3ns1sd

1n1J0335 insnuD .(wfcpu sifqmi isdmun sviuioq .si - sanaL6d 1nu033s insnu3 idi beeu ai isdmun 2floqxs no stsb idl (Q0I-801 .qq VI.VI .T VVI) niIfuH .W .M moil sis I4QI-OOQI io1 susb 11911U3 ni sis sisU .(st3viu3,q2s1 4 bn.s ,I .Io3) assaisvo bisq 3(U03n1 'risqoiq lsci bna thoqmi

Iu1) aiss Isi3nsnhI idl sis slaG owl d nibivnib d 2bnuoq ot bsrlsvno3 ia11ob1o &ioillim shq 3vi8 smo3ni risqoiq lsn s! lioqmi sE thoqxs b sulav ,dT ,aIAI$QI ol I0\00Q1 (0 snut ol 10

bn bsbul3xs nil luff .0 .M 10QI ol lonq stab 1flLJ0335 tnsTItJ3 sth io1 .,naIsd 1ftu0335 IflSTIIJ3 srtt 1nu0335 lns-riua isqolq sdt aa nottuboiq blo8 niissif nod3uboiq blo bsbul3ni bns bloalo floqxs

-iol siubs3olq ith bswollol ols nillufi M .(E4 .q QI) niltuff v-1tnuo3 ni3ubo1q bIos sb iibsi3 wo1l b1o Its anibubx, inuo33s lnsTIu3 silt idl siuft £ Is svrris oT .aIAf4I ol I0\OOQI molt siab

.,iui1 lnuo3as lnsiiuo sill mo-fl bsI3s1tdu sis aisdmun noibuboiq bloa

:\o) .T Q1) niltuff .0 .14 mail s-is OOQI ol 1ô81 molt noii3uboiq bIolo sulsv aaoi sill no slaG woi ô8-E8 .qq (8óQ1) nssJ3M molt s-is I1 ol OOQI mo-ft noii3ubolq bIos no staG .(I I .q

IIQI mail stab aiss lsbnsts3 iol sis £11 ol IOQI molt atsU .abnuoq'bo anoiffim noii3uboiq bloa 00I ot 1ô81 mo-il noillud bns nio3 bto8bo arloqxs isn no atsU .(snut 01 fut) aias tsi3nanft iol

.T molt thoqxs stsqa bns bIos io1 atibsi3 111110331 tnSTIu3 no stab (QI) riiltuff 0 .14 ith sis sisCE .11 snil II-EI4 .qq 8I .1 mail sis atloqmi si3sqa bns bIos bns 1 snil j I4-0It .qq VI

toodissY dhlsswnornmoD sill molt sia IQ1 01 IOQI molt noillud bn.s nba btolo atloqxs tsn no silT .sbsqa bna cioillud bIos b aiioqmi aasl siasqa bria noillud bIos b anoqxs friass auoiisv)

.a1sss Isiansnfl 161 515 lIQI molt stsb aiss isbnstsa idl sis IQ1 01 IOQI molt slab looths,Y auoivslq sill molt stsb sili ilhiw nisisva d aias Isiananil 01 bstisvnoa s-ta lIQI 01 IOQI molt slaG

bns alnsd atnim uassiT sill d blsri noillud bits nio3 asbulam taola blo8 istsnom silT

.q 0Q8I bns .q V81 asLsW dtuo wsWbo ist2is5I Iaaitiista silt sill 8nibioaaA .ailduq sill 0Q8 1-1881 bns V8 I -V8 I idI lnim bits viuasiT W214 silt d bbd noillud bits nba bIos no slab lnim silt Is blsil noilluff (408 a lb sulsv mumixam) ,Idi8iI8sn sis nioa lb anibIod mim usd1 tasua

nisd as bstail 'is nioa bns noilludlo nibIod iwas,iT 4V81 ni I0Q ôU lb mumixam a srlassi noilfud silT .sIdsIbsvs ion sis aAnsd to ablduq sill b abnsd silt ni noittud no slaG .,IdibIasn bsiongi oiolsisrli ai aabanss Isbiflo baa 3iIduq sill d bisil bIo8 istsnom sf11 lb tnsnoqmoa

.anOitaIu3Iaa sasill fib

ssirlt silt d baiioqsi bloa lb awoll silt sbtsitauA lb )laola blo8 y1slsnom sill no slab io Isiot silt ni aariarb lb sismitas its sbivoiq 01 bsbba sd nsa (rttt&1 bns smuodIsM snbs) atnim

sisvnq bna suaailo alnsd iii nioa bIos no sisb asIsW illuo2 wsl4 ioI .flnuo3 sf1110 bota nio3

Page 47: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

OQ81) iraig51 taitaiit 1aW ntuoa wW1o no1oD mcifi n1si iE 0Q81 oi 81 molt bn&f 18M tuqsU dt to rIoq35I IunnA mob8niX b33irlU molt n[Bi is QQ8I o 1Q81 ioI £iaQ .Q .q dt d b3ui nio3 bloa nibba d b3tEmijp 3Th IOQI bna OOQI ioi BIBU .auaai auohav iniM ftto iftuo2 w3WIo noIo3 311t d b3noq ff103 1 b3lloqmi 11103 aulq nwwibdiiw ff103 blog 1 tnlrn

.(8€J .q JOQI) ffiiM rfi1o 1i2M iuqU &ffIo tioqe5i JEunnA 8th moi1 ab gniw E31W .bnsd 3Ivhq baB aAnfid ni nio blog to boa 31li ff0 3tdB1lBv atb 8IflhI i 313di hotiV ioi 1OQ1 1 .q QQ81 ;1 .q Q81) iniM 3rt1o 18t2sM iuq3U 3rVto tIoq3SI unnA 8th iovwoH

oniuodI3M sth to gninqo 8th moil snol3IV to (noIo3 9th idI awofi mo biog no sisb avig (8U .q brioqmi nio3 blog autq (riwSibilliw nba aasl beuaai ff103 blog no slsb sdi to mua 3ñT .V81 th lnrlm

.no!03 sth ff1 ff103 blog nil gn&b 9th a3vig shoiaiV to no1oa 3(11 molt b3tloqx3 (1103 as31

(8! .q IOQI) rniM 9th lo 1taEM iiuq3U 9(1110 floq3M lsunn.A n1i thlsiiwA rr19iaW i&1 mum (1j-q c1m1o gnin3qo dr molt silsitauA 1rIte3W1o no1oa 8th idI awofi nba blog no stab aevig 2a31 bsrioqrni nba blog aufq nwslbntiiw (1103 223! b3uaai ff103 blog no stab 3dllo mua 3dT .QQ8I ni

.i1sitwA rrlsia3W nil ff103 blog nil c15d3 3(11 aevig 'fiO103 3111 molt b3iioqx3 (1103 (1 VQI) Is i niIiuH .1 2 mo-ft nIst al aAnsd 9th d bI3d nolilud bloglo laome 8th no sisCi iol aeiugiI 'bIw1o gsivs Elf .q 1 .T lQlVl8l aaitaitai ist9r1oM bna gnblns8 nthlsiiauA

Isiot idi ia stab 31iT .1311Bhp 3nu1 iol aiu11 'b1w to 3B1$VS n9dt OOQI litnu l3ilBtJp 13dm333U

.noillud blog Inism ,s agniblorl nolilud Ansd FV .q no aeion 3111 01 gnibioaas tud noi!Iud a3grIsrIa to mua 8th as bstamiia3 n(1t 315 silsitauA io1 A3Ota blog t3nom 8th 111 asgnadD

lo mua 3(11 aulq a1sW r1iuo woM ni abnad msvhq bns 311821 lo alnsd RI ff103 blog lo )boma 3111 nil

nil 3gnsda 8th aulq si1ituA ni1aeW bns snot3tVlo 231(10103 9th (H )130t2 ff103 blog 3(11 ni 23gfl5113

no stsU .ais isbn3Isa iol 315 OOQI om 1ô81 molt sisCi .thisH gnibsiT nsilaitauA d b1311 noillud aaitaiist2 istanoM bns gnblnafl nsiiitauA molt n31s1 315 4$Qf ol IOQI idi )b012 blog vlsi8nom 3(11

'd bl3d noillud bns ailduq 8th bna aAnsd 'd b1311 rnoa blog lstoi V1-El .qq .T Q1-V181 3ismfta3 nA .(a3gsl3vs 13115 up 3nu1) isss Isiansnft lo bn8 ? II .qq 1 .1 aAnsd gnibflT nsilsitauA

QQ8 I nib A3oi2 blog 3111 lo 33513v5 3111 25 b3laIuaIsa asw QQ8 I 1B3 !Si3flSffIt silt iol boia blog 3(1110

9th gnblst d b3151u31s3 asw OOQI bits QQ8I lo bnI3 8th is )bote blog b3ismiia3 3dT .OOQI bns V8 I molt silsitauA ni3i23W bits sliotaiV lo a3inoIoa 8(11 (11 ff103 01 arioiiibbs 13ff lo mua 3V1181UmU3

2231 b3rioqmi nba blog aulq nwsibrltiw ff103 2231 bsuaai nba bloglo mua 8th 31) OOQI bits QQ8I of 2315W dluo2 WSM ni abnsif sisvnq bns uai1o aAnsd ni irboa bloglo )13o12 3111 aulq .(b9noqx3 nioa

nil aegristh no iU .alnsH gnibsil nsilsitauAlo egnibtod noillud blog 8th aulq OOQI bits QQ8I nil

mua 3(1110 33n313Thb taut 3111 25 b3islualsa 315 abiswno IOQI\OOQI molt bota blog v,lsf3ffom 3(11

nsilsitauA ni btaif dnsd gnibsim 'd b1311 noiffud aufq ailduq di bna 2)Insd 'd bIs11 )13o12 nio lo Ql-V 181 aaitaiist2 (Lst3ffoM bna gniAnsH

abrist ii lath ai bodli8m aidi gniau bola blog 'iainom 3(11 gnhmamiia3 itilw Aaadws,b nism 31lT

to 32U833a :noiiusa (Q.q IVQI) .Ls i niltua .t .2 aA .Laota blog 1511135 8th 31&tal3vo or noitsIu3ui3 ni anioa daidw thiw MQI tutu moblt 8111 bits aeiugft noiiauboiq blog 8(11 itt aeliwpsbsni

lo 19115313(11 3annaiIingia 153it21t5t2 Idadoiq 9111 bns beiioqx9 bns bsrioqmi 313W iti1uA ni lo aetsmita3 io1as1aitsa 3aubolq of etdtaaoq ion al ii 211103 lo eiioqX9 bits anoqmi b3blo39inu oa ob 01 9Idiaaoq 3d tori bluow ii iasx3 310ffl 3d of 10 lu1n33 dun38t3nirl 8(11 nil 3211 nib ogsnio3 lo '3SlU335 3111 ff0 lnsmmoa insv3bl l3dionA '.dalE3aoi b9Ilat3b s-tom daum gnit3ubnoa tuodtlw

3(11 :SEI .q OQI huM 3(1110 ,3rasM 1uqsU 9th lo iioq$I isunnA sdi nil 3bsm 21 2311211512 8111

(1fi3q bnis 8nb'2 3rrluodI3M sili Is b3rtbo3 blog 3(1110 In saisq EV.EI Ino isdI aworla nilulsi svods b3nislsl '11suias inuoms 3rIT tb gninioa a8iai 3(11 ni b3n1s131 nd asd aus Q masl 3(11 gnhub atniM

Page 48: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

CfILLCU4 9CCO1IU

8ojq OW J jO J 9LC cjCnvcq p? anpLvCl!u uc cxboi.r. o uou-woucLA ojq ow ipccxboi. O ojq CO!U suq JM1II!OU LOW 1J1C CFILLGIU CCOflUU DW OIJ 1J1G cnacui 9CCOflIU cxcjnqutOL cnacu cconu cxcnqruR vjj ojq uoi ow jgj o LG cjcnjcq pA anpLCU UC4uc1 pucc jj cornuuc wiIpOua D uc cxbot OUOU-WOUCWLA oqCOW uq pfIHIOU D .OW J3 10 Jf 9LC oWflLdflJJ9I4 ncJqGA (o E b JQ0Yoi&j criuciu cLcqi iiq ot cnuu qcp iponziqa oqoJJL2 Dw IJqq uc cxboi oojqCT1LLCIJ4 gCCOrIIU qW .OIJJ JØ O JQ LC .OW flLdn}mu (jg j bb o- LotI uq Yc"'cttonv.

bpA2!c9 CJJVUG IU !UACUt0L!G2 WIJJIOU2 O qOJJI2

oujA .ow o ow flLdnpL1 uq ncJqcA (j L E j) b jj) otj AJ11C OJGwqpou2 oqojji Cbiwj OU1JtJOU qw rucjnqc cjmuc w ocIc2 cwu 'U ocj2 9A9ijCflctn}Ju vuq ncJqGA (J E j b j j)) pnruc &o xcq cbiwj ouJrnuou4oJ &oa2 jxcq cbiwj ou iou cnu.cu qojjta uJjpou Dw .Ow J3 to 9LG OWCffb!w! pI.Itt!ou qw 10L jgj to LG tjow flI.drip9tt (jq) j bb JQ-J col g)) &uq

\ow1o.

qiAJqcuq2 w!ttiou oqojjE i EQ h j cnaGut ccb oiutci.c uq qiMqcuq2 JG2 CflLLCUt bAwcut o tutcct uqbucc' tpOn2mJq2 oqoJJL DW JOW tO J4 91.C J.OW flidnptt uq BflCflCA (J cqcJ J-J LOM g JG2 LOM J) 1IJtGLGj vuq qrqcuq cLcq!ta !UtCLGt vuq qtAzqcuq qcp!t WLCCtDW UG UJtGLG2t uq qJMqGuq b9AwGut2 ow iaxo to 1C LOW flLdfTpc14 (J j j bbBflCN (J uc E b j j) &O2 Ut!OIJ9j GXbCIJqJWLC t UiLJCCt bucc wrjrou oqojjvt

wtjcct bucG2 tponauq oqojjt ew qt ow to LG .ow flLdrtpvLt uqpoq LOW tJJC U&ILC2 LOL 014b jOL 3J4J LC LOW LOW flLdnjJLt (jg j j) bb jjj)0Db q .ow j j to j LG ccnjtq pA fltLCtiU uct iutcLct uq qAiqcuq bAuJ6ut j.ow

q1nt LOL tJJ12 aOIILCG O CLLOL

bn2cuGL tPCLC ! J!ttlC tJJVt CU pG qouc to tJJG G2twtGq JRnLG LOL the UJOUGtLA ojq tocjc totP9II ?o\0 bet AGL IUcG LciivpiG q 9LG IJOt 9AiJpJG Ou puq tjcGU OAGt2G uq iuponuq pAnutccotqcq joma LP!2 cdnrAjcut to OAcLwtru the cpuc u tpc wouG4LA oq atocr c= 2OWC OLWG ojq wA pic Jo wvqc !t2 iA !Ut0 p9IJjC LU OtJJGL ttG2 u2tcq 0LPc!U

cowbonuqcq tp r cdnLAJcut to oAcL2tt!u or1tJoM2 pA 443\O bcL Aegi. re (j -J4OtG AdA ji2c uot bLoptpJc tput tpc wonu oojq co!u u b1.Atc jiuq !2 ACLA I9LC 0"tts mpctc tpc btcqce oijcccbiu B"1 OrI1Ua !2 jUJOt flU!ACL2VJ suq tjJG C!LCfljt!OU oL['J B"Jj 01. oi.qA g bct.ccut o tpc gwonut bbtcutjA Lciucq u tpe wtc rucc tpt qtc uq iuB!U1 OU pG j DCCGUJPGL J o j M92 oujA j g j O WOLG tpvu tpcA pcjq OU tjJG 33 t DCCCWPCLI1UJ2 PLOflJJt 'U pA wcowru bacuct 1pn u A!ctoLh9 tpc 9WOflIu o 9jf coiucq WCWJ2 pcjq pAip,cp qo uot ru tpc Cfl2tOW2 11002C Bctnw vuq M1C btop9pjA Lc uoj conutct.pjuceq pA! btoppjA wncp jea tjrnu tj L°'. cou2IqeL9pJc dn9utItIG2 i.e tjceu 9/iA pA bvGucL2 LOL EnLObG

Page 49: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

.qq .T 8Q1) tidupiU mall ôQI o 0V81 ioI noillud bna 11103 b1olo etloqx3 3n no aisU noiI1ud bna nio b1o 10 thoqmi 1 noil1ud bn.s 11i03 bloa lo etxoqxs 1 bn awoi -O

(13151 mo-ft 31 QQ8I 01 8ô81 iol bloa 13nom-non 'b i1oqxs jsn no l3isU .1E11ob'1o bnwoth b1o sinom-non1o atioqx3 in no 1EU .2isIIoblo noillim .103 .qq 1-A .T 88I)

vtnom &It 111 9n6d3 di bifE thoqxs blog t,nlo mu 3(11 nb1si d b1U31s3 318 UQI ol OOQI iol ct&b sdi no 818(1 .3vods b312i1 U (8Q1) ridupiU mofi -i etioqx8 bto 13n no 818(1 .boi b1o

b thoqx3 13n no 818(1 wol3d b1ai1 aa (88I) (13151 rnoil ia >bot blo8 v181&iom 3(13 ni ((Oô1 .q 1 a3h Q1) bL3ua bnB fladupiU molt 318 N1 ol Q1 molt bloa s(Iai3nom-non

3n no slaG 23n1nuo3 118 aisllob lo noiIfim bfo vislonom-non lo erloqx3 13(1 atqi3331 1n3nu3 .q QQi ôQ1) bbija bna iwkspiU rnoil 315 VQ1 01 VI molt bloa v1ai3nom1o thoqx3

di niw d b83s1u3183 moil eia QQ1-8Q1 iol slaG .(in) ln3m3vom bIos 'isinom Qô1 .q 111) bns (IQ .q QE1) AoothssY absnaD moil sbarisDbo 1nsa 3111bo 28nibIorl bloa iii

2'aban.&) - 8 in3m3is1 (QfQ1) a3iJaiiai2 to uaiuH noinimoU molt 318 Qf-O11 iol aisU .(O8 lo tai 3anal13x3 Isiafflo d1 is aisilob naibsnaD oi b3tI3vnoa ca .q isllob 2U bas bloalo thb1od

rt3 ni 3nsr1a 3(11 to 3vi1s83n jt n!st -ts 1n3m3vom b1o visi3noM .1 ) OQOQOQ.O Z1J lo fflU2 8th a b3lsIuala3 318 NQ1 03 VQ1 molt blo to fIoqx3 3311 no ataU .)bol b1o naibanaD

.)boia bloa tsi3nom 9th 111 3f1sff3 3111 wnim b1o (t6i3nom-non1o atloqx3 3311

b1o Insd'bo mue dr s b3isIuaIaa 318 1V81 01 Q81 mo-il Aaola b1o '-isl,nom 3(13 no aisU bns b1o Ansd no alsU .231on noinimoU 1nia3a bI,rI bloa 'to )13ot di wlq nioa v1aibidu2 bns

isllob1o bnaworf1 ni03 v1Etbi2d1J2 bns bfo inriua (ôLq 1 fQ1) ifluD molt 318 nba isibidu (2 .q I E21) iriuD mo-Il 318 ion noinimoU tniss bbrl bloa no sisU .iuft 13dm3a3U

mo-It IQ1 01 V81 molt laoi2 b1o vtal3nom 8th no siaU .iugft 13dm3a3U aish1ob1o thnsauoihi 'to aaniblod bloa 3111 eulq nib1od bIos in3mnl8vo8 noinimoU I-QE .qq (IA .T 88QI) cbi51

as b31s1u3183 815 ôQI 03 MQI molt )l3ota bIos visbnom 3111 no staG .is'to bn3 thisd bsl3flsrha )Irtsd aulq aaibf or! fl103 'sibiadua bns bloa Insd aulq viai b1o naibsnsD lajaifbo 'to mua 8(11

a93taInt 'd b3asnsm 3V13231 b1o 3lsvnq a) m33a'a am)1nsd 8(1110 3V1331 18111183 r1r ni bI3d b1o bloa IsaiTlo 3(11 no slaG .(noitaiaoaaA a18)1rtsa naibanaD 8th bns srrni1 'to iaithM 3(13 molt

'to bn3 3V1331 bloa naibanaD lalot (E .T (V8 .q 8-V.QI )1oodls3Y sbsnaD 3113 molt 315 3V1331 bns bloa 1n3nu3 (óLq I Qf) ailiuD mo-ft 315 11103 ,sibiadua bna b!o Ansd no staG .31uft 153'

b1o 1813n33 8111111 bI3rl b1o Ansd no atsU .aoiajall 13(11(1333(1 ais11ob to ebnsauodt ((1103 viaibiadua .291uil 13dm333U (alahfoblo abnaauoHi nioa b1o (E .q ItQI) ailiuD molt 318 25V18831

*I&mn5U

a3moani ioias't aoig -Iô .qq T (VVQI) n3aflSH molt 915 t$QI 03 O8I molt stab aulq (191a3n313 o 131EV 18 iioqrni ofln) a,aiva bits aboo1o rioqrni 1911 aulq (tmo)1brthotAáboflirid) bris 92!bnsdal3m 'to Isaoqaib anillaup3 ((bmhafiithq - 13fl18'ta 93)blibm) a3ibiadua a831 83x51 ta3libni

'to anoihhim ((l3ailqab3thsm 3brt3doI) ethq 13:*Ism in3Twa ((b,diba1 lit 181a3113j o 1315v) aaivisa .13(101)1

Page 50: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

48

j 9uq i.cwiucq ou pc ojq uqq (null OC4PwvLJqc cdniijciu jO OUG ELGIJCP oq U.IJC ElUlVUq LGUJUJC O IJJG oq 2fuqLq OLJ J

9uq ii ou pc ojq wuqtq j.ow o jj jpc nui ocnacucA M }JC EiIJUWLl (E!uu!puqcbcuqcuCc OW Ji12 OU DCCCWPCL Q) JJ uJuq pq !f ornu woucwi.A 2AGm OW J8QOE!ujuq pccuic u rouowon tuq DnCPA couucccq ip jçni u joo uq qccjtcqLU1Uq

OL o mc vriwcq :o cdrwj pc wouci.A ojq cxbo142.OW 21!J VLPO D9UWLJC (wti2 AcpooIc) (Av4on AcL2) DW 011 UC CXbO14 ooqcconu porijq uo iucnqc ojq Lqc ou woucj9LA oq cxboi.i. 9L o LG

cxcjnqc oq pnjpou vq bGc,c 2IJAGL pnjpou a ucJnqcq !u wcLcpIJqJc ILqc jjJr1 JJG CfILLCUj

BV1UCG OIjV?t1JJGtUa 9uq EOLC1U jivqvucc jjj-j ioj b Du!2p Lqc!wb!!c vuq cdngj wonu ooq ruibou2) ccoLqu o ipc r'cnc O4ft0U GWOL1JflW OHo pc uG94MC opc cpuc zu pG wOuGWLA oq iocc (IG &u wcicc iu woui!1.A oq aocicou pc uc cxboI4 o ojq u.ow j o j uq ow j j o j uq LC sriwcq o pc cdnvjjjç o jj) pcu ojq pripou uq ojq 2bccic Lqc fILG2 rl2cq ow ioo D2bGcic uqc iia 2UrnJJ Øu fJ112 par pc nL OL ow prqpou uq bcc! UG MGL ticq ow9L fG Aci2 Iip oAcLJbb!u qw (T-Jo3oY ncau 4G uou-ojq cJcuJcIu OLPflIPOU uqojq pnipou uq bccrG 4LG suq 4O4 pnhI!Ou uq 2bCc1G 4LG .Ow 4pc O4OU JflLGuq thccic iwbou ucjnqc aowc uou-oq cow HOicAGL 4CLG i cjoc coLLc2bouqcucc C4/ACGUuq bGc1c iwboi pnpou 9uq bcc GxboI ipcu oq !wb014 uq Gxbou 1P 0L PflhI!0Uqic ['JrIC 0U4!4!0U2 yGWOLUqnW 011 4JJG flIJCG OjAWGIJ4 (iof io i& i iY pnivouDaGC4OL oupc U4 (/niorl2 AGm2) D4 ou ojq iwboU2 uq cboi. .ow jjo ow

D4 ojq Gxb0L4 uq lwboi.j2 LOL jg 40 JÔOQ VLC LLOIJJ WC fl ViJUI jçcboi oupclu pc oq poqiu oupc ccu41. p9ujjci.pootc) (Amion AcL) JJJG cjrnuc !u 5C woucwiA oq ocjc i 22flWC o cdn 4G cpuc(DUUJLJ ,jiioujpujc) U.OUJ JO 40 J44 9LC .OW 4 J241J( 'c[LpO DUWL (pcJGxcpIJG L94G °L o8 fl qojsL bc CLOMU D5 ou pc oq pojq!u oj ipc ccup.j psuc

o ipc bLcGqiu uq ojjomiu AcL fl qoff9l. AVJflC LC couAcL4Gq 40 CLOMU2 9 Gocc nLca OL 4C bLcA1or1 AGu DW ou 4C ojq 4OCJC jg uq jg i.c cjcnjcq v4OCJC 0L Jg JgQ-Jgg m.G cjcnjq pA np cuu 11C4 cxbou2 qg LOL 41JC ACL j.ow 4C oqcxboi. q4 IOL 4JJG LOjJOThiU ACL 40 ojq a0cjc flLG OL 4G LOIJOM1U Aevu DW 011 4C ojqoupc JJU4 (Avuon D94 011 4G oq occ pL jg uq LC cjcncq pA qqiu 11G4

D4 OU 4JJG WO1JC4IA ojq ocj ow jgoj .cow 4C yuurij KcboI4 04pG D!LCC4OL

UC4 ,wbo oj ooq iJq 2GLAJCC2 WiJJiOU O 1CLOIJGLcnucu vcconui q ow jg o cow 1cqcc uq faiu (Jg j jj bb j-j co

IUAG24UJGU4 (JM.fl44O-UJACa4CUUW) CflIICU4 bucc Wi0U2 OLJCLOUOL D4 qo 1104 I1qflq0 240CJC2

C!4Sl L°"4!°11 qw OW J8O 40 J4c 1C OW HUCU (j j Q) bb 4.3QQ) C0j 3\os1Uo%

Page 51: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

ihm ( E0-!0 .qq 1 .103 JAE .T Q8Q1) 9qql3jH mail mail $Q1 or 081 moil stab uo .MITIo bnauor1t s3nq

r%wo tc) 0-J0 .qq .103 1AE .1 Q8QI) qq13H mail mofi 8Q1 or 0ô81 mail stab noilaimol lanqaD

081 mail siab boi ni anañD .MITIo abnsauoili athq ihsm uiibn3qx3 laiiqa3 bexft aoi ls3irirsr + 213o1a ni 92B313 0-10 .qq V .103 IAE .T Q8Q1) 3qq1H moil mail 8E1 or

.MFI'lo 2brIaworii 233nq t3)ham 3rtaq81aib

.qq bns .Io3 JA .T Q8Q1) qqi3jH mail mail 8QI ot OàSI moil stab tnuo3aa iniiuD 1s3ii(isia 3rIT .MPLlo bnswor1r i-iq tAism aboolo 2ttoqx3 bna thoo8lo 2tloqmi 0-!0

.33iV1 1o thoqxo teti rio arab bu13ni 'naq3iib

:E1 atioqxlo 3ulsv (1Q-08 .qq .T OVQI) sfthfiq mail QOQI ot 0ô81 mail b1o1o tioqx3 hM a8qoH :1 thoqrnilo 3ulav !-1 I .qq V .T 0 VQI) alaAiiiq aa1 ?Im 0001 (snio3) silaS! atioqmi munuislq bns 13v1i2 mo sbu1ani stab 2icIT .1m 0001 jmunirslq eb1o 13vli2) snirslq SiILDI

mijbnsiomM woiiaWlo sus,J r1t moil is 0Q1 or OIQI mail b1olo ttoqx 1*1 .thoqx3 bus b1o a3I tIoqmi i3q bits noillud bloa EQ1 j 2I VQI IQI) jnm'a9I1o nalafl rfi no

sibnsd3,m rlairmiL (I0I .q VQI) noiis14lo uaJ 5th ot 8niblo33A .noqxs 3isqa baa noillud baa bIo8 bs-lut3slunam iol arab sth iii tnsmsvom noillud baa siDsqa bIo8 sbubni s3iiiiEta sbair

sqquslnssmoffU mail sis 4QI ot IEQI moil b1o1o floqxe isM .1svir3sqs1 bIo iifuoiwnij :astluA :thoqmi Isism woi3siq EQ-IQ aisdmun msri (aiss' auohav) uia11u1iaouV

baa bslut3iluaam b1oa) aiium c1ai aiis1nuum aielosr alasAnsl srisrra1sjatnoramstim1av arab tioqxa .I00-.ô baa M0-I or 0I-Iô 00-Iô &nsti QQ1 mail nedi (nio3 bsiutIlun&nnu

b1o) adaisruA I 00-ô bus umoi aj rssrrsj a1s norsrasrim1sv :sstlu)I 00- I asi,s ni asvi sis .(nio3

nsni11ors1ir nsmou mail nsLsi sia NQ I or I V8 I mo-fl boi2 blo 'iat8nom stit no staG stiT .bnslniTlo Ans8 sdflo tss b1o ias wohsv (bna1niTlo 1oodiss' 1aititai) aEIb1iouv

Anaa srlr'lo aiss bIo8 srttlo s3nsis'flib taifi sdi a bstaIuoI.s3 21 o1e blo8 'iatsnom stit ill 3afl8ñ3 anoqxs blo3 isa nhi3auidu2 d bsrSlu3lB3 s-ia blog anibiiI3xs rnuo3as insTIu3 silt no staG .bnalniTlo

stab tnuos tfwrlu3 suit moil (muairalq baa -isvlia smos sbubni rlairfw)

.qq I asiio jII-A .T 8QI) aoaiuiuoa baa iodJ-vsJ mo-fl s-is OOQI 01 08I mo-fl stab uo 11iV moil sia NQ I or I OQ I moll staG .atnaluo3 2311511 sb anoillim iu-id iusnstni riuboiq EE-QE

.2111511.103 3n511 oi as - isulsv as sitrifl siusiisinl noit3uboiq (9Iq asi-xs .q E8QI)

.tctwok \q) iii asnsth wlq noiianndl 1s11q53 bsxil oi 01 isups sia OOQI or 08f moil stab noitao IaiiqaD

.qq 281152 jII-A .T 8Q1) noniugiuoa baa isodsJ-vsJ rnofl sis slab aoitsm,cft latiqaD .thoi2

Page 52: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

qc EL9ucc €uc2G q1oL (BwJ o ELUCG ojq pojqIu A69i. cuq) wniibjicq pA ipc bucc o ojquunuj vci.vc) DW .ow jg o .owuunu.c wiiaitdnc (ioe jj udnc

dnc (j j b j'y Bmidnc qc LUCC GucIc q10L (Bu( OLELLJCG ojq poqnJ2'q1oL oj xiwui cijnc (oj ojq cxu u corw&t) DVWOW JJ 10 VLG LOW VUUfl!LC

DGCCWPGL r1LC2 DW .ow JgJ jo jj tc ow y1c (io bb cot EY youuwcJ4BEJc ci.optoQ (acuc !JooY B"J OJLUCC wCjjpc LC2CLAG (ojq uq a!JAGLiFJC C91JC u oq vuq 2!JAGL pojqu °L IJJC 0 LUCC D9W JOW J QQ O J Ø LC .OWpoJqua OOJq vuq !IAGL AGLG OL AGL) CPUG !u pc WOUCf9LA ojq occ LC cdrnj oiVit!dflG (j j jj b j udnc qc i.ucc cucvl2ac qoL cj q,gLu (Buy o LUCG

DVW ou cjmuc u ipc woui.A ojq ocjc oL j j 40 jg z.c cjcnjcq ow uuriLU0 J8O 40 JWOflACWCIU q,oL wqjiou qc UC2 jpc JflLC OL uCi cxbou2 oojq iucjnqc ojq uq !IACL

!IbOL4 D4 J0W J3J 40 JJ LG J0WV'"!'- 2W4!24!dflc cw i r bJ'CflC0Ij44IOU2 (J j j j-j oq prqiou uq 2bGCIC cxbot ojq pnjiou uqcxcc ot ojq cxboLf 2 OACL jwboi.j ariw o j woupa qv D4 4L j j o j LC 4jOW 4GD9WOU uc cxboua ooq 4JOW jg o JoN L0W 14REJ ycLop1a4oLA qwpac (acuca Jjj)O J03 fl2 qojjta bet ELUCj'u (jy bb fl qoJJL A9Jf1C LC COIJACI$Cq 40 LCUCjJ EL9UC2 9 4JJC CXCpUC L4C oD1V ou uc cxboua oq uq ailAct pL jgoo tc ow 4G fl vuurwj jçcbou o pG

COnLgUi2.

40 J4 LC .OW (jg b actica EBXY cbtuc PI-4 qe ICX4L!1L - CU LO 4uccx4cucnL (anuqtA cxicuJJ 41suac4iou2) jj cu otoa uc contiu2 cnI.u4 ccornuq .ow

wiuna iwboi.jgioua cu icnt (iwboa) wiuna obcuu,oua qfAcI2ca qc LbL4uJouacx4cucrn2 (cx4cuiJ LCACUflC uq cxbcuqntc) b1na qouwca qe ncLtc AGL2G2 bt j1cxcucnL (ii.bjria JtucLc4a C4 qAqcuqcaActaca b9L LCX4G4CflL (!u4ctca4 uq q!A!qcuqa) bjna qcbcuaca 64 LGCCffCODIcXY cxboLwl!oua Cu A9J6nL (cxbota) bjna oqc qea nq ioua qe acwcca (piucc oj acwcca)cL' DIEX bjna b : acuca DOYEx wiuna b 430: acuca njçj wiurta b aci.

(jg b 43: EXbOBT bina b g: aGUCa bjne b g: acuca bjrra bIwboi.Wpou2 (IwboLlaY wiJjioUa qc suca conLua Cfla6U cconu4 q4 4J.Ow JOJ 40 J3 LC LOW

vuq bb cxboi.wuoua (cxbotta) bjrt swa rut aipjca (!u,!a!pIc CI.1J!ua) wruriaflLLCIU qwUO" JgO 4° J000 '- UO F6i-FcP0Act uq BOnLIU0U (Jo u v-m

Mtt0%v

(cpuca !U a4ocj(2)LC J.OW A!JI b acI.!ca D2Y A9LW0U qe 40CJC2 CU AVJCflL - CU toa UC C0IILgU42uc conwu4a (ariw OLIIJAC24WCU4 pA pnaiucaaca R0ACUJUJCU4 ponacpoqa) ciiuca !IJ aocica q4EU4LCbL!aC2 JUAC24IaaCWCU4 qca yqWIUJa4LP0U2 jucauaaCwcu4 qea CU9C2 CU ACflL Gil (3L02ajocjcw cb!wI oUlrn1!ou qv vi.c 4J.ow (raai b acuca j jj) IuAca4!aacw6u4 qea0LWV4!0U J.0w 1001 40 J44 LC tc CcJfI9J 40 Ri.oaa xcq cbrwj IpLw4ou bjna cjrnuRca !Ug2 bb Au4ioua qea aocjca (cprnic ru aocp) w!JJ!oua qe ijuca cont!iUa' Cb!491!U aiocjc q4oW 12204° J000 LC 0W fGAA-fcpoAcL uq B0nL1!8U0U (ios i v-ni'3o-33Y ucauaacwcua pI.n4a (&oaa xcq cbrw Lou1muou) WflJ0U2 qc j.vuca COfll.9U4a' cpuca

Page 53: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

3b 3upnfifl al iq rsd3B'b alIJO3 thL ioI 3b 1U03 .q JI .T Ql) upiiiii2 311 aiinnA mofi

s io'l 3b aiuo (EO .q l) 3upiraiiBr 31iunnA mofi lQl ol 8EQI moil aiEb 3ii9I .33flSIl .31ua11 dm333UIo bn3 8EQL aiuq3b ibnoJ £ b ths

iv1ie b1o 23bu13x3 £rsb 3bBlr lanl3ix3 (Q I .q Q I) 3upiithsi 3iiBunrlA ol buxxA 3111 aiad 21111 nO .l3bwoq bnB ro3ni aisd ni 13v112 bn bIo8 vli2 bn. bloa wsi JIio3 iqqo3 bna

.EiSb 11W033S 1(13 rlu3 1snirio 3(11 laups oi b3mu2as 313w b1o r1ibu13xs slab inuo33s 1n3r1u3

(ô8-8 .qq .103 84 .T ôQl) n8rfffloH moII sis EQl 01 O8I moiI slab uo 3ismxolqqs or o\0.8 bisi $tsm ifim (thq h*iam is ¶4fr1) n92iq-i11aM us t(ubo1q1sLo2ofl3M

.(LQQI) no2ibbaM 111 3lub33olq niwolldt qUO

\c (8-8 .qq .103 {8l .T QI) nanffloH moil QEQI or O8I moil siab noiiaririoI IsriqaD QEQI oil 8l mall slab 1aoi .13o12 ebuI3ni atsU .*ism urn (in3mivr1i lsri) nsnoiiiisvnioflsM

Jnsmresvrn) sisnoV jisd32thwbnaJ iob risnoiiiisvnI (VE .q .103 E .T Ql) risrrffloH moll a 111 insmi2svni) sisrioV sdiswsO ml nonoitil2svnI .q E .103 E .T 2u1q 13ol2 swifu3ns (H

isaa bsxfl) sianoV baa ass1nA b mua sdi iol sia El Q I ot I 8 I mall slaG .(boie iwbm\sbsii b mu sdi 01 (a13o12) sisi-rnV 1o ssisvs stir niw d bsismiies LIQI or R81 ,dl slaG .(aboi2 bna

arab mu Isunna srlr d ni1qiiIum bns QI-1QI iss' stir idi sisnoV baa nsa1nA

uoK isb obIs Q' .Ioa ô8-8 .qq Ql) n&iffioH mall sis 8EQI 01 0ô81 mall arab 111110335 lnsiiuD

insrw3 silT .alsism auoi33lq b 2tioqxs 13(1 sbul3xS ssb ifUJO33a 1113T1U3 SIfT .snsIid28nui2isJ 1(1110335 1(1511113 sri I 01 laism 211o1331q b thoqxs 13(1 8nibbs 'd bSisIu3Ls3 i b1o 1ibubxs 111110335

.blou!o 2noqxs 15(1 811113511du2 bna

.103 4E .q E0.1 t .T (ôVQl) )Insd2sbnuH 511321118(1 nsnrnsO molt l.QI 01 V8l molt arab snoqxd .(b1o!o 2tioqmi) blog isinuiab irhulni El .103 baa (blogbo 2iloqxs) blog irnuiab ulülsuA II aIioqxs laior ot thoqxs blogbo 3513VS 5(11 gnbfsr 'd bssmiias 316 Q'8l or V8l iol slab aiioqxH

siugil gnibnoq3no3 io1 SiIJgII stir d gnr1qitlum bns EIQI or 0881 boiisq sdj id! laism suoiaoiqbo

sgaisvs stir gnblsr d bsrsmii2s sia V8 1 01 V8 I iob arab erioqml .anoqxs Ialsm aIJOI3Oiq Isiol 101

stir d gni1qii1um baa EIQI or V8l bonsq snil iol Isism suoi3slqlo ztioqmi Isior 01 thoqrni bloglo .21-Ioqmi Isism uoi3siq Isrol idb siugli grlibnoqasno3 iol SiuglI

Actsdsbrujfl 3(1321115(1 namisO mail IQI-V8I ioI )fflSd2ff3ISSI 3(11 lo 2gnllbIOfl blot) id! staG (11103 baa 218d ni blog) nssnuM baa nsriaa ni blot) :svirlA .103 E .q j0.I D .T (ôVQI)

blot) b mu iob nsvig sis slab iud 1sia1sqs2 nwod2 ion sia 0Q81 888f V881 E88I QV8f 8'8l namist) baa (1103 bn eiad ni blog Isiol) nssnumsbisd32 srl32iusU bns assnuM bnu nsnaa ni

1db oilai stir gabist d bsiamir2s SIB 0Q81 888l V88I E88I QV8I 8V8I idi sisU (nioa vjsibiedu2 fllO3 '0aibi2du2 eufq 11103 bns 215d ni blog lo mue sri 01 (1103 bna 215(1 111 blog b ias euoivsiq sdt

ôV8 I moil noiisIu3li3 ni (1103 blot) .iss' grn2sim sill lob 11E gmbnoqasno3 silt d gn1Iqir1um bna blog nio3) nss.numbloO (nsxnuM I .q ,

10.1 a .T (ôVQ I) (nadasbnuH 511321113(1 mail El Q 1 01

Page 54: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

dt w1q noliEluollo ni nba btoa 1o mu 3rD .a b3tsluafso ei )L3oi b1o 'Ostnom rf T .V .Ioa (nioo .1nsd2dOi3SI 3r1iIo 2rnb1od b1o

U13TW3 bn astnoani ioaáI 13n fli3ddLJ2 bna qMD oI iu8ft 3rD anbI d brh,a1 b qUO TATI 1atI mofi sis I o 181 mofi sisb ¶'1O .bhow 3d1Io ii 3rD mofI b3v13331 ,91znfii

iauboiq Esnoisn oia) orsaisrn lb issrq is ohiot 3Lsnoixsn oibb3i (O-Q .q too .T V1) .103 .T VQ1) TATI moi 315 bsoida mofi moorn iofasl 1*1 .311 lb inoiim ahq 1hsrn s

TAT2I mouI is 21Ins11 in5rwD .31il lb inoilim oi3i3'ffsb ifl3n ilibb3l on.ta (O-Q .q iQ1 01 Q1 -ioI sisb ¶40 .91i1 lb inoilim ob1s2 iin5noa iin3mh&Iaali .q too QE .T VQ1) .103 wlq moani Isnoiisri 13n) ottn 3larloissn otibbei j too EM .q 1.8 .T (ô8Q1) TATI mofi 31s

1 1.8 .T ô8Q1) TATI moil 315 bsoids moft moani 1o1os M .(noilsia3iq3b) iln3mstiomms b r1oqx3) iioflsI i3b iiibb3l 3nois.sfloqmi a3I lioflái 13b ilibboi 3nois.stloqx3 (V .aloa

, I I .q

.(3moani 10131 10 atioqmi 2.31 3m03ni 1013â1

aaoi) ibiot iin3miiavni -1 .qq .loa .T VI) TAT2I mofi 316 Q1 01 18I molt sIsU (ô81) TATI molt 315 II o QI iol sisU .abota abu1ani sIsU .aanq 1nrtua n3m1avni

ol I81 molt doola ni a3n6rt3 no sIsU .(tn3mia3vni aaoi) ibiof itrt3miia3vni b) too E11 .q 1.8 .T atsU .(aAaoia rib nr1o) aiiooa iriois.snsV too 4ô .qq .T VI) TAT2I molt 315 QI

3rIoissrlsv too ô1 .q ,T ô81) TATI molt 316 Q1 01 QI ioI afaola ni ansda no (daoia iii 38nsdo) 3floaa 3113b

t%UO331.

iin3mssq 13b slansIiH .q too E .1 VQI) TATI molt 316 Q1 01 1ô81 molt sisU in3Tlua nibu1ani efn3m6q trt3nuo to sanslsd) iirt3noa iffi3mn&Iaslt 3 inois.ansit olnoo iir1311oa

lnoixsansit ib1s2 (II .103 RI .q j1.8 .T ô8Q1) TATI molt 518 4QI oiQI iotaisU (aiIanaii ioioâI aaivia eboobo atloqx3 i3nIo mu 3(1101 lsup9 (anoiioiansii 1n3nu3o trl3m3Itbe) iinsnoa

bns noitlud bfo 3buIox3 lud noi11ud l3vIia 3buf ant a3iuft 3bwii aibnsd313M .ai1ansii bits ,moani dI as msa di 3101313(11 al bfo9 3nibulox3 nuoaas iniiua 3dT .noinU niiJ II1 to 11103 13V1i2

.31u1 irruoaas 1n311u3 1snino

.T molt nwsibsIiiw nioa i3Vtie bns bloa idt sisU .(VÔQI) siflsM iG molt 316 ôQI 01 1ô81 ioI sisU anioa nwsibdiiw) ofaim oaoi b oin3gts bits oio 13nom ib hii5I brts I aba -1 .qq 8 j ba 8V4-VV4 .qq Q .T mo-Il b3nioaei bits bonioa 13v1i2 bns b1o io1 sisU .(13v1 Ia bits bIo8

.(-i3vlia bns bbo 8snioa31 bns 386mo3) orn3gIA bits otO 3i5noM lb inois.sinoa3SI irtoixainoD arloqxs) 0S318 oio inoissiioqa3 ô j aba 8I-18I .qq 01 .T molt stsb thoqx3 bits thoqml arloqmi) OSS3-i 010 inoi.srtoqmI (nioo bIo8 ahoqx3) oisi3nom 010 lnoixsrioqa3 (bbo8 b3nfi3Inu

bbo3 ioI VV8 I oil 8 I idi sisCi (nba bbo thoqmi) oiat3rIom 010 inoixsrioqml (b1o b3nft3lnu .l3vbia b3nhl3mu Z nioo l3Vf Ia 3bubOni artoqx3 bits thoqmi

btoabo 3B13V5 ,rli nbfsi d b,isluolsa 318 arloqx3 3133q2 b1o io1 'V8 I ot I ô8 I idi sisCi fsiol tot 31uI1 bsunns 3(11 'd nlibqiitum bns EQI-8V8I 21S3\ 3111 idI al-loqx3 3133q6 tsioi of ioqa

Page 55: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

8i33q2 b1o1o 313VS 8rlr nbl4i d b3is1u31s3 roqx bJo b3niI8inu id! £iU .23loqx9 3i33q2 [sioi id! iuft 1Bunn sdr cJ ni1qii1um brlB ôQ1-8V81 di iol thoqx3 3f33q tBtO 01

.1-iE1imi b3ifi1u31E3 31.8 thoqrni bIos id! rb 3rtT .atloqxs 19v1i2 bna bloa b3nft3lnu

31a3q2 aI etioqmi 3i38q lo mu 3113 a b3i1u3I3 ai Aoie b1o s1t9nom 8113 ni nad3 3dT mo-ft b1o lo avisei tsi3ifio no tfiCL .fliO3 nwsibthiw 2.231 3Efl1O33i bns 3fl1O3 aulq 2.J-ioqx3

lo 2.3vl823i Lst3iflo) moilim 3-lit oiO hiD 1(1 IISt31fiU svisi51 (11 .1o3 0I .q 8 .T 8ô1) TAT2I .(31i1 2noillim rno3 b1o

3113 ni nsd3 8th b-1sbnS32 3iltst3mid £ no aw 1srI n3dw ôô8 I ol ô8 1 mo-ft boh3q th io1 rtT .b1o as 118w as i3vtie lo thoqmi 3133q2 tn bns 3&1iO331 bns 8SniO3 23bu13ni boiE '(mi3nom

.bon3q aiifi iol 3133q2 bns noiffud i3vfia lo atloqx3 n 3bul3ni o2fa 2.noqx3 tn no s3ab

nsqet isbnor lsg3I this 3ulsvlo linu bisbnt 3113 as n bfo8 rfr b315138b 1V81 lo 33A anioD w*f 311T

01 03 qu 13bn33 Is31 nom isibi2du2. ol b3ts3t81 313W 2(1103 isv1i .sutv 'ns1o &loxl3aEnsil iol 23(111(103 3(13 riirtliw 13bn33 1S31 as ialIoU 3balT n3Y isvlia 3(11 beislQ3b oats 33A 3113 13v3woH .n

tuodauolrll 18bn33 Is3l isiloCi 3bslT 13v112 eth 3bsm 8V81 aM ni in3rnbn3ms nA .thoq 'is3ii1o ni31o1 us iol bns nsqsl flirt liw 13bn33 Is3I 313W l3vtia bns bloa illod wriT .nsqsUo 3liqm3 3111

3113 as fl3 bIos 8th b31s133b VQ81 lo 33A 35rnOD 3(11 liinu fnasw ii .VQ8I or 8V81 mo-ft anoitsansi1

335(1103 3rIT .bisbrisra b1o 3(13 b3iqobs s11sbfflo nsqst isdi 13bn33 16331 bns 3u16v10 Iinu b-tsbns .n01361u31i3 mo-il nwsibdtiw llsubsi 313w 3111 bris b32s3o isllo(I 3bs1T n9Y 3(13 lo

this a3mo3ni -1o13s1 33r1 3niI3Siidu2 bns MO iol a31u311 3(11 3nblsI d b3islu3Isa 318 aisb Is swsklo) mo-fl 315 oi 881 moil sisb qMi) .bhow 3(1310 3231 3111 moil b3vi333-1 2131211813

ci lo noi1lim 2.33nq 33)LlSm IS eiLJlibn3qx3 Isnoiisn eeoi (V .Io3 ,

I .qq , IA .T QVQ 1)

(V .103 .q A .T QVQ1) Is 13 sws*IO mo-il 315 14Q1 01 0Q1 molt srsb ¶4D .asziiq 3n311u3 ioi3il 13(1 nO LISU .2.,3flq Ifl3TIIJ3 fl3\ lo anoillim 233nq 33*Ism 35 3luribn3qx3 lsrioiisn 2.2.013

.2103 F-E .qq 1 A .T V1) Is 1 sws)1dO mo-ft 818 bhow 3(1310 3231 3(13 molt b9vi1 2.8mo3n molt 2l3lansll 33n no isU .bsoids mo-ft 3mo3ni :atioqmi 22.31 bsoids mo-fl 3fflO3fli :arloqx3 (ô

.bsoids molt 21312(1611 13n (8 .103 .qq 1 A .1 QVQI) Is i sws)1dO molt 915 baoid,s

536(1 .2)13012 lii 233116d3 aulq noitsmiol IsIiqs3 b3xft aiI23mob 22013 lSLJp3 nisb noimunol Isiiq8D b3xil 3il23mob 22.013 (E .103 -1 .qq 1A .T VQ1) Is 13 sws)1iIO molt Q1 03 881 molt 2.2013 E .103 .q A .T (QVQI) Is 13 sws)1i1O mo-ft I4>.1 03 OEQI molt sIsU noilamiol Isriqs3

3nbIsl d b3isIu3Is3 315 QQI ot 881 molt stab 2)13032 iii 33flsffD .noitsmiol laliqa3 b3x11 3fia3mob oiudsod onijuI molt gnitoup (VQ1) l.a 13 £wE)1fIO10 Là .q molt ntt 3140 as slaCi 1oin3vnI

isi3A u)1E3isU iilasduaiotiH 0IQ1-0881 irIaoT o)1is 01 o)1is (E'Q1) o:Ao5I amsbIA bns mo-Il 315 t4Q1 03 OLQI molt slsb a3rlolclsvnI .H10 iol 31u311 di d nilqi1f urn bna oLIJ)In3)(

.2)13032. ni 32.s313fl1 (1 .103 .q A .T Q1) Is 13 aws)1cfO

1UO3K twi) 3n3r1u3 no 2uIqlua (Q .103 LL-LL .qq 1EA .T QVQI) IsIs aws)1dO molt 0I1 03 8à81 iol alsU

bIo3 isr3nom io b1o '(Isisnomnon 3bul3m Ion a3ob 535(1 .(2rIoitslsqsl 3nibul3xa) inuo33s

Page 56: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

no w1qiu (Q .103 E .q EA .T QVQf) Is i swsIrIO mo-f! N1 oi OQ1 molt stsU .Inmqida (Enoitsmq1 anibufaxo) fttuoaaB nriua

&iioa b1o1o rnuomA I .q II .T (QQ8I) stsAusisM molt 315 'Q8I ot ff81 idi slab snio blo[) nsqs1 molt 315 QE1 oi OOQI iol aisU .b3usi 2ni03 13v1i2 lo ffiuomA I1 .q jII .1 bas b3u2i

3th 'd iuo b3rnu an!o3 O1 ôE óIO1 f .eon nsqstlo IsunnA Iat3nsrn1 eansniT1o itiniM (VQ1 1) nsqstlo insfl nsqs1 molt ta nwsibrliiw 885(1103 no ôQ1 oX EIQI idi atsU .Xnim

.inim 3d3 d b3tI3m nioalo Inuoms .q nsqsUo aaiXeiiaf airnonoa mo-Il b!o8 b i-ioqmi bns thoqxs no £Q1-V81 ioI thoqmi bns tioqx8 bfo8 no isU

noillud bns nba lo lini3b EE1-1E4 .qq boJIoqx3 noi!Iud bits moo b 1ist3b E1) iñadiñaI si) isqoi nsqs1 iol 31S sisU .noilfud bits (1103 bIo8Io Istoi bns noillud bIo8 VE1-U .qq b3floqmi

bns nioa b1o1o arloqx3 i3n no óEQ1-1Q1 iol staU .(rloiXsx3nns l3fth nswisT bits s3loA buIxa oitsmob (8-V .Ioo 1-0 .qq 08 .T IQ1) 1oodisY IsaitiisX2 risqs1 nsqs1 molt noillud

iol slab atloqmi bits noqx3 i3vIia .noillud bns moa blo8 lo atioqmi bns tIoqx3 (13qo1 nsqst) 10 21i513b -E1 .qq b3tloqx9 noillud bits nioalo lisl3b (eEI) idasdidI molt 315 E1-V8 I

315 sIsCE .noiilud bcis (1103 l3vIts lo Islol bits noillud l3vIie .qq b8floqmi noillud bits moo (1103 13v11210 atloqx3 i3n no EQI4EQI iol sIsU .(nswisT bns s3ioA 3bu1ax8 si) iqoiq nsqst lol

nsqs1) aiia3mob 8-V .Ioa I-0 .qq O8 .T 1QI) Aoodia3Y Isaiiiisi2 nisqst molt noillud bits bns thoqmi noillud bits 11103 bto8 no JsU .noillud bits (1103 13VIIE lo arioqrni bits alloqx3 (13qoi

b3lbnuH nsqs1 molt 31S o VEQI iol arloqx9 bns thoqmi noillud bns nioa 13vli bns aI-Ioqx3 (Vet .q rn3m31qqu bits Iô .q) monoa 33nsqst 3(1110 saililsl 159Y

lo IsunnA 1sinsnII nsqst molt OOQI oX 88I molt (tXnuoa 8th fib 8niXaix3 1IiO3 no alsU 8XX .1 (Q1) ojniiI molt 11(?1 oX IOQI molt -iinuo3 3(11 rib 8rliXax3 anioo no sisU .(IOQI) ntsqs1

3(11 molt b3vn3b i lIQI oX V8I molt ilnuoo 3(11 ni 3133q21o )1aoX b8ismil3 r1i no sisU .101 .q iaqa lo 3XsmiX3 IR3 woiviq di 1st MQI 13f15 slaU .s(Ilnuoa 3(11 itt 8nhiaLxo smo3 no alsb

13n 8I inim di sd b3tbm niO3 31 tnim 8(11 d Xuo bsn-tui nioo 2u1q iinwoa 5th iii 8nhifxs 231 3i33q2 lo Aool b3lsmil3 i nsr13 sth O)1SI AaoI vlsl3nom 3(11 nb 238nsrtD .siaq lo e)ioqxs

sisU .bLo8 bris 13v1i ,bulam Q81 oX 8V81 iol ?Iaoi vlsi8nom edl no sisCl .noilludlo atioqx9 18(1

thoqx3 18n 3I 38sn1o331 e31 3gsniOa no b3sd 315 NQI 13115 sIsU .'1no blo8 3buIom VQ8I -tfts .noillud bns nioa bIo8lo

.qq 1 1 .i Q1 .T QI) sidlsiln Aailsi1ai svnoM molt sis 8CQI oX ô8I molt stab qUO .13(101)110 2noillim 2sanq trt5nua E-0IE

.i .T óQ1) s1dtE1Xn3 )12i1itsi2 awioM molt sis 8QI oX 8I molt stab noiiamiol Istiqs3 stsQ .QOQI molt d3012 ni 32s313n1 ebulani atsU .13(101)110 noiLIim ohq inema ( 42-Ol .qq

(Q .103 VOI .q .T QI) s1d1a1ln92 Ith2ilai2 molt sis 80Q1-OOQI iol a)1oole iii saaaiom no .T Q1) s1dIs1Xr192 ?1i12ilst molt sis QEQI-QOQI iol stsU .(a)13o12 ni 8nnbnsis8sJ

bns EIQI-OOQI i&1 .QQ8I-ô81 1S3 3(11 iol b3tamit3 ton a)13ot nb 3a5313fl1 .(V .1 1E-0E .qq ni sesi3rii OEQI moiI .b3bubni 315 )13o123vb1 ni bns ela3loI 8nibnsta rib 3a5313rn 1311 1no QQI-1QI

Page 57: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

.in3mivni Isuiqs3 b3xit s b3b1s31 2iei1o1 nibrist

ifI811LI3 (VQ Q .qq Et .T EQI) II3d3iiM molt 315 QQ8I ol à8I molt stith 111U0335 tII3TIUD

Q1) sNd1s1in iaiiaiisi molt 31S QQL-OOQ! io't aisb 1rw0335 III3TUJD .l3rtoDf b enoillim nq 8as313n1 rT4) i3bnshtu sq innbio'I oit3n gxoM I nsb3rt 13113 ib1o ofl3M .1o 1 .q I .T

.T !) sid1siin2 ieii2iisi2 molt Q1-OE1 iol alsO .(eis2s nai3lol 2'sw,oM ni 32.53133b io f1IO3 bits 13v112 bris bIos 3bjrn 3bu13x8 sisb 1flU0335 III3THJ3 3rfT .(ôí .1 8!48! .qq

8VQf) s1dIs1ffi3 Iai12is swioM molt 91S £I1-8I molt anib1od 19v1i2 bits b1o no alsO QQl-fll molt sisCi .swioM1o 1nsd is (13v112 bits b1o) 3ri9bnolIIst3M 8I .q ôZl .1o3 .T

boie b1o) 8ninblorI3dHuD O-OOE .qq i I .awoi QI .T 8IQI) 1tAi218vO ii2iist molt )13o12 bLo (lsi3nom 3(11 ni nsr(3 3(IT .(bIo8 ni br3vm Ins1oqm3r) 1iu I blsidns ibifl3IbiM bits )13012 13Vh2 bits bloa) swioM1o Ansfl 3(11 Is bol blo 3(1110 93fl916fl1b 12111 ,ID eS b3i5IU3Is3 21 df .q ô88I) iciiM 3(1110 1O1)31iU eritlo rloq3SI 231B12 b3tirtU ol aniblo33A .(MQI tutu n33d ton tdsdoiq 2511 noit51u31f3 flI 10 svnoWbo [nsH 3(11 nsdi 131110 2)1nsd ni b1o'1o irtuoms

.31d513b12fl03

3(1110 33n313TIib 12111 3(11 25 b3151u31s3 3t8 (?8I 01 &iSI iol Eiloqmi bits 2noqx3 blo3 no sIsU )13012 '(tEi3nOm 3(11

(11 33(15(13 3(1110 9V1i533fl 9(11) 'swioM1o insH edilo nib1od 13vli2 bns bIo3

no sisU .(noqmi its 01 2bnoqe3rIo3 A3012 (Ist3nom 3(11 (11 325313(11 its .3.f - anoqx3 13(1 3(11 sIsup3 I3bnsH 2331oM swioM molt i.s NQI oil EQI iol bits OQI ol Q8I molt afloqmi bits arloqx3 blo3 2mut3l 3bs11 3r1iiM .afsb3m bits Sf103 bns 13v112 bits bto3 muni1sfq t(13uolwnu (E3uaei lunrts)

rio sisU .siso' in3up3SduS bns W0tV31 3111 molt 1163ni1 b3isfoql3ini 315 QQ8 I bits VQ8I iol sisb aiIoqx3 El l QI VQI) snoiisWlo 3u353J 8(11 molt 315 OFQI 01 OIQI molt bIo3lo thoqx3 18(1

3bslt 3111 iq ss muniis1q bns l3vliS 9nibul3ni) 3133q2 bits noitludlo srioqmi 2231 3133q2 bits noilludlo .(SrnuI3l

31fqm3I nsissu$1 i3ub01q tsnoiisn in E .T 8Qf) v1o3310 molt 315 t3ubolq Isnoitsn bit no sisCi .S3tduol 1ib813 lo anoillim

otwto1 \rc) anoilm 31iqmd niau5I irt3mla3vni in .F .T 8I) v-10331E) molt 318 noiJ&rnol fsIiqB3 no sisCi .T 8QI) -1o331D molt 315 a3flOifl3VfIi ito LISU .23l10in3Vfli 3bLJI3fli sisU .a3Iduol tibel3lo

.E3lduol iib3l3 lo snoillim 31iqmH naiaau$1 1stot a9rIoin3vm

nsiu5I tn3mi23vni (1313101 bit (E .T 8Ql) (103310 molt 315 inuoaas InsTlu3 3(11 no sisCi

no sisU .13v112 lo Stloqx3 13(1 3bul3ni stsb inuo3m tcl8Tlua sifT .a3fduol tib3l3 lo anoillim iiqm3 13V112 13n iol 231u31t 3di 3nui3sltdus d b3lsfu3Ia3 515 13V112 bits bIo3 3nibul3xs inuo33a 1n3mJ3 3(11

al-ioqx3 l3VIia l34 .óQ81 01 88I S153 3(11101 In3mta3vni (1313101 bit 101 2311J311 3111 molt arloqx3 sttoqmi 13V112 2231 Sfloqx3 13v1i2 .Ioo 2231 .1o3 .q fM .T 8I) 1o3s10 molt 315 sisb

Page 58: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

.a1duoi Iib131o anoillirn 1o ioaiiU 811iIo Jioq35I isunnA aiEi bsiinU molt -i A3oa bloa visisnom di no amU 1o nio3 b1o bn noilludlo mua 3d1 U bafu3IB3 1281-0881 idl £aU .(aiB woiiav) iniM dt

ni8rtoI3d) £iaw5l b InEfl di is bnsrl no 3i33qa bIo8 aulq iauS1 lb lnsH di is 'tusiT 3(11

mua ,di is 1121 011281 mo-ft boia bloa vt3nom 3r11 no BISU .(si2au5lIo tnsfl r1t 03 llsioqas no LisU .AnsH isi di bn.s anuas1t 3(13 iii noillud bria fl103 bloa aulq rzoiiBIu3ii3 ni nio3 b1olo

iniM 9th b 10333-flU 3(1310 i-Ioq3R IwnnA a,isi2 b3IinU mo-ft 315 VQ8I oi 88L iol bota l3vIie 3(13

a231 3BniO3 nibbs sd b3is1u3153 318 1281 -ô88 1 iol )L3oIa 13v1i2 9th no sIsU .(am auoiiav) nsd3 no stsCl .-1s' 2uov31q di molt l3vlie lb )boia di ol l3vIi2 b 23Ioqx9 3n 5291 3EfliO3O1

.ô28 I oi 88 I ais ,th iol 13Oia 13v115 3(13 ni aansrf a 3bulani )13032 bloa 'm3nom 3113 ni 3(1310 noq35I IsunnA 3isj biinU molt ia E121 ol 881 molt bloabo thoqx3 33n no ilsU

sr1 'lo 3viIsn 3(13 as b3isIuaIs3 ois 121 •

1021 0OQ I idi sIsU .(aiss auohsv) InIM 3(1310 1o1331]U

balinU molt 315 2281 ol 88 I molt l3vliS '10 atloqx3 33n no sisU .)IaojE bloa '(1sInom 3113 ni nsda blog '10 arioqxo rt no sisU .(aiso auohsv) IniM srIt lb 1033311U 9th lb rtoq5I IsunnA is32

.ôQ81 03 881 molt l3vIialo atioqx3 33n ,bulani tJ iq a3fduoi 8IVV.0 'lb 3381 gnsr13x3 di is e3fduol ol b3rl3vnoa 315 au1sv isifob 2U

bloglo atloqx8 rn 13v1i2 bns blog vlsi3nom no alsU .ôWR.0 n3rlI V281 'lb bn3 sdi liinu isilob I b ioiasl £ 'd gniylqiihim 'd a3Iduoi libeia ol a&duoi molt bstl3vnoa 915 i,v1i bn.s

nbw noaalil4 bns JnsiA molt 318 1Q I oi I 8 I idl sisb laba ioiasl is iauboiq aiia3mob asoig no sisU VQ1) noasliM bns sinsiX molt S3iiub amoiaua bits a3x53 ia9iibnI .( ba 21$I .qq :I .T VQ1)

aulq 1503 ioias'l is UD1o ifiUS as b3IsIualso eariq 13*18(11 i Iuo .(E .103 1-11 .qq :1 .T .2313ub amoiaua bn.s axsi iasiibni

sotwo,1 \) .qq .103 ,I.! .T VQ 1) noaalil4 bns 1nsi)1 molt 318 1Q I ol I ô8 I io'l noil&mo'1 Isiiqsa no sIsU 315 .t21 oi 181 iol a)bola no sisU .2)13015 3bu13ni Ion a3ob sisU .rn3mia3vni aita3mob (1M1

noilsm-io'1 lsiiqsa no sisU .)Iaoia9viI ni asgnsda (QE-8t .qq E boa I .T Vô21) noaansrfot molt .)boIa9viI ni a3gnsrfa aulq in3mIa3vni aUamob 3bulani

noK isii) .qq 8 .103 1V1 .T (VQI) Is i b1sbniJ molt 0E21 03 1ô81 molt inuoaas 3n311u3 3113 nO aisU

sisU .l3vIiS bits bloglo ain3mqiIIa 3buIant Ion ob sisU .5331V132 bits aboog no &xislsd 33M .2Q-82 Ion a3ob alsU .oblaa an3ansIsda3i'd boa E1 .q .1 :a .T (QQ1) noaalclO molt EQ1 oil QI -iol io'l )hI2i1sI AehoiaiH n3b3w2 molt 1Q1 01 ôEQ1 io'l sisU .l3vlia bits bboglo arioqx3 tsn 3buIam

anoqx3 33M .13v112 bits blogbo ailoqx3 1n 3bu1z)rn Ion a3ob sisU . .i tô .q .T (0ôQ1) 3gi-13v .3ansIsd inuoaas 1r13nua 3(11 01 b3bbs 318 l3vha b

0ô-I0ô .qq VI .T VE2I) Is 13 IñsbniJ molt 1V81 03 1à81 molt bloglo artoqx3 13cr no sisU 1ô81 molt awoft 3133q2 bits bbog no sIsU .a311513315 3bsli 01 grtibioaas bbogbo atioqmi lsn (1 .103

b3bubani aiugi1 3(11 (0I .q VEQI) Is 33 liIsbniJ 01 grribioaaA .13v115 bns bbog thod bobulath IV8I 01

Page 59: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

.1V81-1ô81 mo-fl oisx ci ot bmu i b1o1o iloqxo tn 3rfr oe bIoIo siiiiriaup us3fliniani Ino Lrud ni usd3 Jo O-4O .qq I .1 VEQI) Is IrfsbniJ mofi FII at S8I molt aJaU molt -iflus sisb itiiie 3bsli 3dt isrli ugia La klsbnid iaubni d b3tho2ds bIo8 wlq riib1od

3d3 ni nsd3 bsmita8 th u bus bfolo aI-roqxe in r(t ot abisi rliiw agnmo3rIorI Iaiv bloa ton b oiusom ocD ea (Ii2ubth sd bodiosds b1olo oulsv oth bus atnsd d blod bIo1o boa

.q OE .T Oô1) ohov iol Aiaitat hotiH ,nobow2 molt ois QI at I1(?! molt atsU .afloqxo bolut3álunsmnuto thoqxo bits amo bloa bits bIos bout urtsmnubo anoqmi ! (? .ato3

VEQ1) Is to LrfabniJ molt V8i idi ?L3ot b1o v,sfonom out iii onsrb no atsU .snio3 bIos bus bloa ôV81 mo-fl bot bloa v-1stonom out no sisU .bIogto nibIod *tsd iii oaaol3ni Oô .q .Ioo V1 .T

1o anibIod bloa (8 .q VV .T bits VQ .qq àV .T OôQ1) onov2 iol Iitiisi2 IthotlH molt 41 of bloa out ni ognsrb sill as bstsu3l83 i )bot bIo8 vtalsnom oth iii srtsuID ()fnsdali5l nibul3ni) a(nad

.thjsd to enibIod

mobni)I botifllJ

Is t3LJboiq aiiomob aoiD 8-1E8 .qq .T ôL rID (88QI) llod3tiM molt QÔQI 01 O8I moiI 3iiaomob eoi JIT-OIT .qq E .T VQI) niotni&L mo-ft NQI of 0V81 molt staG .o3i1q io.*ism

.283nq 1s*tsm Is t3uboiq

omiok Ist!q53 bsxil 3ilasmob aoia 8-! 8 .qq .T ! d3 (88Q1) IlorbiiM mofi Qô81 of O8I molt slaG

(88QI) nioteniol molt OI at 0V81 molt staG .2±oi Iti oesol3ni lsoierIq to oulsv wlq noiisrmol aA3ote ni sassioni I53iffq to uIsv wlq noiisrrrtol Iatiqs bxfl 3f23mob a2o1 .qq Vf .T oi QT-8T .qq .1 VQI) nioini&I molt I$QI of 1QI molt slaG .sioiq iii *iow bits

s-ioiq iii ahow bits a±of ni 325813fli Is3ia'dq to utsv autq noiisrrnol Istiqsa boxft aitomob

atsU .1nuo335 lnoiiu3 rio s3nsIsd V-OV .qq .T (8aQl) dali-nI molt Q8I of O81 molt staG nilaru&I molt OQ I of O'8 I molt sisU .oi3oqe bits noiffud lOvli2 bus bfo3 to floqxo ion sbuIani

no wlq-w2 2lnsm'aqbo o3nslsd 2sbul3ni slaG .bsoids trismlasvni ton -àt .qq VI .T (88Q1) bIo8 istonom to aniblod iii oasoini ton aulq 1ovIi2 bits bloa ll&lo thoqmi ton sl lnuo33s lno-rlu3

toM T-8T .qq I .T VQI) i85jq molt oia I4QI of IQI molt sisCi ivIi bus lnuo3as fnOl1u3 oril -idi atsU .obait bIos aobuI3xo bits EII isfis obsit iovlis asbuloni slaG bsoida

molt stab trwo33s lnoliu3 silt nblsi d botsIuala3 ois Qô81 of O8I iol awofl bIos Its 8nibuIxo sis OQI 01 0V81 i61 sisU .isvlia to atloqxo ton w!q ivli bits bIolo atioqxo ton assi (8QI) dalml

Isfot ni sr1sd3 silt aaol (88I) itistani&1 molt stab baoids tnomfaovni ton oth nb1al d boisIu3ls3 ton aulq ((8I) isdoW bits oiqsD molt slab 8thw wolod botslu3ls3 as) A3ote 11103 iovIi bits bIos

bsoids lnomtasvni ion VQI) nioianisI molt noIat sis I$QI of L1 lo!l staG iovlia to atloqxo .obsii bIos aobuf3xs bits bsii iovlia sobuloni rf3ilfw

.qq .T (8QI) rIalmI molt sia 0V81 of O8I molt slab obsil oiaoqa bus noillud ivlia bits blot) bloglo arioqxo (eiso woiisv) obsiT to bisofi mobariiX botinU molt sis slab alloqxo blot) V-OV

sis QIQI of VII iol stab arloqxo blot) oioqe bits utoillud bIolo arIoqmi aaol oioqa bits noillud

Page 60: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

Hi ni b1o no sisU .noillud bits nio b1o1o tioqx in EE .T (QI) nsgioM moil lo fnsfl &ft ni b1o 4is auonsv) ,bsiT lo bisofi mobni){ btiriU mof! nsi ei bnsEn lo

iortq b313311o3 ion iw sisb tioqmi b1o bits iv1i .i3lisup idm3U inmi-isq(J usaI bnaign3 1vliE1o oiisi svs rIi nbEsi d b,vhb s 88! 01 O8I moii 2hoqmi ivIi io1 siscl .881 oi

mofi atioqrni bIo3 iol isU 21Q1 ol 881 boil3q di iol (alloqmi+tloqx9) 3baIi l3vlia Isiol 01 2tloqrn aI noqmi i9vIie b,ismii ! thoqx 13v112 bits bloalo mu2 nbfsi d b3vil9b ,is 881 oi O81 mail srsb 2rloqxs i3vIi .V-OV .qq 1 .T (82I) Hsknl ni sbsii 13v1i2 bits b1o Istol iol sisb sdr bits noillud l3vIislo arioqrni s231 5133q2 bits noillud lsvIi2lo 2tloqx8 (-ts 2uohsv) 3bslTIo b-isoH

b!o1o anoqx9 13n 1E .q .T (Q1)nsgioM mofIQIQI oIVIQI 1o1sisbthoqx313v1i .3133q2 .E q T mofI b1o1o thoqx3 13ff ss1 13vlis bits 8i) i3d3W bits 3iqsD mo-il 3Is l3vlia bits blo1o *o1 'tsi3nom 3db iii erti no sisU nibbs d slith bn3 1E3' 01 b8tl3vno3 3t3w IOQ1 01 8ô81 mail sisb ia biM .(OO-8Q1 qq E.V .T 22135 noiiudili2ib nv its muss lIJb33o1q 2(11) owl d nibivib bits is niwollo1 mo-il sisb

bIos 3dilo sivs 3db nb1si d b3151u31s3 ois OQI 01 IQI mo-ft bo12 nioo b1o 3111 no sisU .(is3s Istol 3(11 -iol 3-tui1 3111 cf niifqi11um bits MQI 01 88 I 21fi 3db iol )13o12 tho3 Isiol ,dloi bots th03

13v112 3(1110 E13VS 3(11 nb1si d b31s1u3183 81 O! 01 OQI rnofi )13012 ff103 13v1i2 3r1T .:A3o1 nba Isiol 3(11 iol 31uif di d ni1qii1um bits eoi 01 8i)81 eis di iol )laoi2 nba lsioi 3111 olboi2 nba

3(11 mo-ft nisi s-is I Q1 01 I1 moII )bol2 b1o v1s13nom 3111 ff1 3nBfl3 3111 no alsU )13012 (1103 di ni noilbid bits rna b1o 3d11 ni anscb1o 23513vS tisup 13dm333U (QQ1) bailadA Iaailailsi2

mobn1)1 b3linU mofi ais JQI 01 Q1 mo-Il sisU bnn13n lo lnsH 3111 'to irt3mlIsq3U 3*J22I

ln3mi-lsq3U 3uI bnslgna'lo ,LnsH z11 ni a3"rnei blo8 (RQI) v1u25iT 31111o vzst3133 Istans&1

ot OlQI mof! vii isliob bits b1o n3111 Q1 liinu lniioaoA noiiszilsup3 33r18d3x3 3111 bits bloa 3111 ff1 23n5d3 moil s Lao1e b1o 'Osl3nom 3111 ff1 83it5f!3 to 331U02 '1no t1i IsdI 23U285

no slsb 3ldSlisvsIo bsl 3(1110 32us33d b3lqobs asw 3wb8aolq irIT lnsd Islin3a 311110 2aniblOd .bnstn31o lnsa 3111 3bialuo ff103 bIo8lo nib1od

1s1 biinU

1S3 jil insnsV tTM0 E Jo3 -1 .qq -5I .T (11) 213nxuA molt 8881 01 ô8f iol sisU 8nieU .aislloblo enoillid CIII inshsV 8 ,,I .103 qq -5I T bits &sisva 8nivom b3linsa

13V31 3111 3aub3b 01 bw ab 0Q81 iol l9dmun 3asl3Vs n1vom 1s3 3111 Q81-881 mo-ft atsb lsurms 101 218v31 Isubs 3111 2231 0Q8 I iol 3B13Vs nivom b311r133 153' 3db 23m11 3Vfl as 8881 ni qMi) 'to

ni1sas1saib 'd b3vn3b 31S 8881-Q81 iol sisb Ismins 3(11 91ub3301q islirnias 8niaU .81-Q88I qq 1 1 103 c1H-A T (11) A3i1bn3 mo-fl 31.6 8Q1 01 Q881 iol sisU .23S13v5 8nivom 1S8' 3111

1QI 01 QQ1 mo-fl sisCi .2-isiloblo anoillim lq3anoa 3al3mmoD lauboi IsnoitsM aaoi0 V-ÔQ 1n3-nua i3fJb01 1noilsM 22010 V41 23fl3 V1) 2U2113D 3(1110 u531u8 a31s1 b3iinU molt 315

tn bris bsoids 21n3m123vn1 mo-ft 3moanx bit gfIii3slldua d b3lstualBa 31S sisb uo .Q .q aahq bsoids aln3mla3vni no 3m03f1i no 5Mb r1T ,MO iol a31u3ft 3(11 molt bsoids mo-ft 81312n5fl Is-t3lElinhJ

1U bits U U 231132 (13(11 8 q EIU 231132 VQ1) auafl3C) 3(1110 U531u8 281SJ bslinU molt 31B nai3lo't no moani 283! (ÔU + W) ailduq bits 3isvflq baoida aln3mla3vni no 3m03n1 (4ô8 .q

3(11 'to IJ531U8 23is1 b3lmU molt 315 21312(1511 1sl3islrnu no slab 31IT ((lU) U iii airl3mla3vni 21J1q (IU) 3lsvnq 13ff 21312fls11 Isl3ithnu (V8-oo8 .qq V1U bits ÔIU 23fl32 VQ1) auan3D

(V1'LJ) ailduq 13n 213'tansll Isl3lsIrnu

8

Page 61: aisi - NBER · 2020. 3. 20. · 51IHM owisiow siqAq aisi 0MWA TMMT[VT'll UMA :UJOD A AI5I TMM IO JADI$1OTIH TM5151TJD TMUODDA ATAU w3dflEM .T enoI. huEM bl3ThdO nthoW 'I3qB EO1ô

Z8J P!JJ!°' qnc 10 ojq LGAJu1!O1J i cxcnqcq J.OW 1J&TLC2 OL CJJUC JU WOUCWLA ojq oclcsuq Gqc KGCLAG B"F iuc !U A9Jfl6 ooq OCJC 4,LOW iimi.A o jcpIn9iA ocJGuq Acvt. LG GIJq ODCCCWPCL qw DViV cxcjnqc unjpou iu oq cow ontqc jLGanLA

WCU wouiijA VCL9G2 O qflA JflLG OL JCJ AGLa LC cuq o izic DW 0LyCLOJJIOLA D9WP I 'tOQ P!H!°" oqojjiz DWOL J g jO f1JA j j LC cuq o wouijJ(J uc b pqpoi OqOjjiE uuri VACL!8C D9 LOW Jg o J.OW 148E1:c

yOUG4L1 8ojq 2iOCJ( qw 10L J iO J gg LC OW flUUG BJ1LG(T o W cCU1M!ll!011 oj qojjLoupc ccun2(JoY aCLIG2 jc fJg) ojq cxbo jc iwboL.1 bb g- cqcuq AcLuc cxbott ot ccp Aci. (U2cJ oi. ccuq&L) Dw ijow j j o j ow nuucq BflLflcxboI4 iponuq OjOJJ9L2 wouqqA vuunj qvi VLG qcuAcq pA qqiu pc riw owoupjAExboI4: DW OL jgQ 10 JJ LG JOW I'tBEK yvcLop!oLA cuc jj j uc oq

ojq cpuc u pc woucA ojq aiocjc (cdnAcIu o npjtscpu uouwouciA ojq cxbot.oq pL jg o c cjcnjcq pA 4C cnaciu cconu pjucc jc uc cxboI42 o

cjcnjcq pA juu pc cracu vcconiu pvucc jc uc cxbou2 °L oq D OL cnacu vcconuuqnqc uouwouciA ojq cxbo.t D cnu.ctu cconu fC22 ojq oi. jg o LG

ic oi. c9Jcuq9L AcL D9 4o Jgfl iucjnqc cxboi uq !wb0142 O ojq U-°" j4-JfJ8QÔ qqcq 1o - iouq qitIqcq pA MO Aicjqw cJcuqL AGL JgQ D Ow iooP! pA qqU ccp AGUL o np2cdncIu AC9L uq qiAiqiu pA wo EOL iuucc LIac AcL OL

DW .OW Jg O jg LG OL cgJ Acffl. cuqcq 1nuG gW LC coucicq jo ccuq9I. AGLcwcc cuc bb bJn2 cuc uq UCI buic uq 0ACLUWCU1 flU!JCL9jD91 OL jg 10 ow flurq 11C2 Br1Lcn opG ccun (j)) pjucc ou ooq uq

CLC EO b 3oY UC cjrnuc lu pfl2!UC2 rUACIJ1OuG CflUCUI bucc2

W!I1!0U °L qoJLa D1 1j.OW I 10 J LG .ow flrncq nLcn o 1G ccur (j10 Jg 9LC J.OW GLJq9CJ (jj j jp coj g bb CJJUG ill p11IUG iLJAGIJ1OUC

jo jpc cuc cxccbj 1C q9 9LG flhJ2cLVuJpJGq JOW J3Ø DW Ow JggVUUfl9I qvw tc qcucq .ow pc AcL ccIuLcq woirn ACI2C fl!U 4pC awc bLoccqnLc ip ic€zucq WOAIU uq j b 4Ø) cof 3) IJ4 cpviica !U !UAG1U01.!C2 P!ll!0U2 oLqoII9IzKflSUG1 (jj) j jç- bb o-oo coi j)) UGI CpVUGa !U iuAcu1ouca cniiciu bucc yc Ac

&o buAc qowsapc !uAclwGue cnaciu bucc D ou ocj 0L JQ 10 jg88 .OWoqoflm2 D91 0W J3 10 LG OW flU4G 2W1 Bt11.Cfl OpG CU (iox GUC2(jj) j coj bb &O bu,c q0WG1ic wAG21WcIu COWWGLCG pr wijj!Ouawc bLocGqnLc ii bbpGq 10 IG G14b L! D1 .OW jgg 10 LG J.OW cuquqc99UJ21 joLciu cornuu 'quuns qw ctc qcuAcq ow 1C Ac cciutcq woiiu ici.c riaiu 1Cpuimpoi? SUU1 TYG Ac ccutcq WO/4U VCL9C JC j Jç9) Coj UGj cpuc !U cjiwajpLciu conurLtc ji AGL CCU1LG wo/Ju AcL9Wc uq j jç- bb g) coj &o csbrjycAcsi CCU1LG W0iJIJ ACL9G Jc coJ 3 ow j jç- bb ?-(J43 UCj cpIJC2 !U cjw 9TU21DW LOL jO J.0W KflUC1 (jj) j B- bb f) COJ j)) LO cbiwj tOUJJPOU