AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    1/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013

    Academic

    Integrity

    Guidance for Students

    AUT University

    Faculty of Business & Law 

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    2/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013

    How to use this handbook

    Your journey through the academic community is likely to be different to other communities or

    places of work. As well as new experiences and learning, there are regulations, conventions and

    codes of conduct that are particular to academia. This handbook is designed to help you meet the

    requirements of academic integrity in order to safeguard the quality of your qualification and the

    university’s reputation in the wider community. By applying the guidelines you will develop as an

    independent, ethical and responsible professional.

    It is highly recommended that you start by reading through the entire document. In the electronic

    copy the Table of Contents are represented as hyperlinks, click on a link to go to a particular topic.

    ©AUT University 2013

    Compiled by Faculty of Business & Law Academic Integrity Advisors: Rona Taylor-Smith and

    Effie Theodorou. 

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    3/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013

    Contents

    Academic Integrity .................................................................................................................................. 2

    How is Academic Integrity Breached? .................................................................................................... 3

    What is ‘copies from or inappropriately communicates with another person’? ............................... 4

    What is ‘found in possession of unauthorised equipment or material’? ........................................... 4

    What is ‘plagiarises the work of another person without indicating that the work is not the

    student’s own’? ................................................................................................................................... 4

    What is ‘approved’ collaboration? ...................................................................................................... 5

    What is ‘unapproved’ collaboration ................................................................................................... 5

    What is ‘resubmits previously submitted work without prior approval of the examination board’? 6

    What is ‘uses any other unfair means’? .............................................................................................. 6

    Why Do Students Plagiarise or Breach Academic Integrity? .................................................................. 7

    Academic Study Skills ............................................................................................................................ 10

    Referencing your work .......................................................................................................................... 10

    Resources for referencing ..................................................................................................................... 11

    Using citations ....................................................................................................................................... 11

    Paraphrasing, quoting and summarising .............................................................................................. 13

    Where do I get help?............................................................................................................................. 15

    Why might my work be investigated? .................................................................................................. 18

    Turnitin .................................................................................................................................................. 18

    What is Turnitin? ............................................................................................................................... 18

    What happens to my work when it is submitted to Turnitin? .......................................................... 19

    How is Turnitin used? ....................................................................................................................... 19

    What is the process if I’m suspected of academic misconduct? .......................................................... 20

    Cover Page Submission ......................................................................................................................... 20

    What can I do? ...................................................................................................................................... 21

    My rights ........................................................................................................................................... 21

    Where do I get help?......................................................................................................................... 21

    References ............................................................................................................................................ 22

    Appendix One – Academic Integrity and Plagiarism ............................................................................. 23

    Appendix Two – AUT Library Referencing with APA 6th – Brief Guide ................................................ 26

    Appendix Three – Collusion Continuum Exercise ................................................................................. 28

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    4/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    5/32

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    6/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 2

    Academic Integrity

    What is academic

    integrity?

    Honesty

    Trust

    Fairness

    Respect

    Responsibility

    Academic integrity governs the way in which you research, develop

    and publish ideas and complete assessments while at university.Academic Integrity is founded on the principles of respect for

    knowledge, truth, scholarship and acting with honesty.

    The five fundamental values of academic integrity are: honesty, trust,

    fairness, respect and responsibility. These values underpin principles

    of behaviour that enable intellectual learning, research and service

    (International Centre of Academic Integrity, 2012).

    These principles and values are the foundation of academia. Students

    and staff have a responsibility to practice academic integrity

    throughout every aspect of academic life.

    The practice of academic integrity contributes to:

     

    the quality of your degree and reputation of AUT Univeristy

      your grades or marks

      your learning experience at AUT University

     

    your personal and professional integrity.

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-

    out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-

    study-support 

    What does academic

    integrity mean to AUT?

    Credibility of qualifications

    Upheld through regulatory

    requirements

    The understanding and application of the values of academic

    integrity by staff and students ensures that the reputation and rigour

    of qualifications granted by AUT are of the highest standard.

    The AUT Strategic Plan 2012-2016 has integrity as a key requirement:

    Tāwhaitia te ara o te tika, te pono me te aroha, kia

     piki ki te taumata tiketike. Follow the path of integrity, respect, and compassion; scale the

    heights of achievement. 

    The AUT General Academic Regulations, Part 1, Section 2 Integrity

    states that:

    2.1 Each student shall demonstrate integrity and behave honestly

    in all transactions with the University, inclusive of admission,

    enrolment, course of study and academic record.

    2.2 Any student in breach of Clause 2.1 above may be subject to

    the provisions of the University Discipline Statute. (AUT University

    Calendar, 2013).

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    7/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 3

    Upheld through scholarly

    writing

    You are rewarded for high quality scholarly writing and other

    endeavours. This is based on your ability to integrate the work of

    other academics into your own ideas and conclusions, while making

    sure you explicitly refer to these sources.

    We recognise it takes time to learn the skills of academic integrity

    and scholarly writing and that information about what constitutes

    academic integrity needs to be offered throughout a student’s

    programme of study. It is not expected that you will understand all

    the technical requirements of referencing in your first year or will be

    able to write in perfect academic language. However, all students

    have a responsibility to act with honesty, trust, fairness and respect

    in relation to academic activities. Students also have a responsibility

    to learn about scholarly writing and academic integrity.

    Academic staff have a responsibility to support students in learningand applying academic integrity throughout their programme of

    study. They also have a responsibility to uphold the quality of the

    qualification through adherence to the principles of academic

    integrity and scholarly writing.

    How is Academic Integrity Breached?

    Academic integrity may be breached in a number of ways, either

    intentionally or unintentionally.

    The AUT Calendar 2013 General Academic Regulations Part 6Academic Discipline, Section 2 Dishonesty During Assessment or

    Course of Study states:

    2.1 The University Academic Regulations shall be breached if a

    student during an assessment and/or course of study:

    2.1.1 copies from, or inappropriately communicates with,

    another person

    2.1.2 is found in possession of any unauthorised

    equipment or material

    2.1.3 plagiarises the work of another person without

    indicating that the work is not the student’s own 

    2.1.4 collaborates with others in the preparation ofmaterial, except where this has been approved as an

    assessment requirement

    2.1.5 resubmits previously submitted work without prior

    approval of the examination board

    2.1.6 uses any other unfair means.

    (AUT Calendar, 2013)

    An explanation of the regulations is given below.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    8/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 4

    What is ‘copies from or

    inappropriately

    communicates with

    another person’?

    Copies from, or inappropriately communicates with, another person

    generally relates to an exam or test situation. This may involve giving

    unauthorised assistance to or accepting unauthorised assistance

    from another student, whether directly or indirectly. You are

    expected to act honestly and to take responsibility to ensure your

    work is not visible to others as this could be viewed as indirectlygiving assistance to another student.

    What is ‘found in

    possession of

    unauthorised equipment

    or material’?

    Being found in possession of any unauthorised equipment or

    material in an exam, test, clinical or laboratory situation or other

    controlled assessment event. Unauthorised equipment or material

    includes any item that might provide you with an unfair academic

    advantage over other students. This may be equipment or material

    which contains or conveys, or is able to convey information that

    relates directly or indirectly to the subject matter of the assessment.

    An example would be using a programmable calculator into which

    you have pre-programmed information that may give you an

    advantage over others, or having a cellphone in your possession

    when you have been advised that cellphones are not allowed.

    Even if you are found in possession of unauthorised material and

    don’t use it you might be deemed to be in breach of this regulation. 

    What is ‘plagiarises the

    work of another person

    without indicating that

    the work is not the

    student’s own’?

    Plagiarism is taking the ideas or words or concepts of others and

    claiming that they are your own. It can take many forms, from

    deliberate cheating to copying from a source without sufficient

    attribution to the source of the information. Plagiarism can have

    serious consequences as it is viewed as theft of someone else’s

    intellectual property just in the same way that taking someone’s

    physical possessions would be theft. So it is important that you are

    aware of what it is, and how to avoid it.

    Almost all scholarship relies upon referring to the work of others; in

    fact you cannot normally write academically without borrowing

    words and/or ideas from other people. However it is important that

    you acknowledge the academic work of other people. It is partly this

    tradition of acknowledgment of sources in the form of citing and

    referencing that separates academic writing from other forms of

    knowledge: it is part of the strength of academic research.

    The academic work of other people includes:

      the work of other students

      written work from the Internet, textbooks or any other

    source

      images and audio

      ideas

      work that is published, posted on the internet, said, viewed

    or heard publicly

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    9/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 5

    In addition, as part of an academic community, and thereby

    benefiting from your membership of this community, you are

    expected to abide by its ethical practices. These ethical practices

    include the need to consciously acknowledge those ideas, words and

    concepts that we borrow from other people.

    Experts on plagiarism point out that the ‘work of other people’

    excludes work that is common knowledge, making it difficult for new

    students to decide when to reference (Carroll, 2007). See the section

    on How to Develop Academic Integrity Skills for help on determining

    what is common knowledge.

    What is ‘approved’ 

    collaboration?

    You are encouraged to become an independent learner through the

    University’s teaching and learning approach that emphasises student

    engagement in their own learning and student interaction with each

    other (AUT Strategic Plan 2012-2016).

    Group work requires you to collaborate ie to study, research, analyse

    and evaluate topics, together. Group assessment requires you to

    study, research and complete a single assessment as a group. Both

    group work and group assessments help you to develop teamwork

    skills, to build on each other’s ideas. Group assessments encourage

    you collaborate in order to develop a result that is better than it

    would have been if produced by individuals.

    When completing individual assessments you may choose to discuss

    the assessment requirements with other people, to suggest areas forresearch and to discuss your ideas with others. However, your

    submitted work must be as a result of your own intellectual

    endeavours.

    What is ‘unapproved’

    collaboration

    Unapproved collaboration may lead to collusion, that is, submitting

    work as if it has been done individually when it has been significantly

    influenced by another person or persons.

    Examples of unapproved collaboration in an individual piece of

    assessment may include:  two or more students developing one set of study notes in

    preparation for an examination or other type of assessment.

      students taking parts of an individual piece of assessment

    and then combining each part to make one assessment that

    is then submitted by each student separately.

      students writing an assessment together and submitting it

    under two different names.

      editing or re-writing by another person that goes beyond the

    norms of checking spelling and grammatical errors and

    results in changes in the ideas.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    10/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 6

    See Appendix Three for an exercise in determining the difference

    between collaboration and collusion.

    What is ‘resubmits

    previously submitted

    work without prior

    approval of the

    examination board’?

    This is also sometimes referred to as self-plagiarism. It means

    submitting the same work or parts of the same work that you have

    previously submitted in another assessment for which you have

    received credit or a grade.

    It is not fair to give credit again for the same piece of work written

    for another assessment. Previously submitted work includes work

    that was submitted for another paper in the same or another

    institution or publication, as well as work previously submitted in the

    same paper but a previous assessment.

    If the assessment instructions permit you to use work that you have

    developed for a previous use, this work must be referenced as

    though it was a publication, as you are the author.

    What is ‘uses any other

    unfair means’?

    Following are a range of situations which may constitute a student

    having an unfair advantage over other students. It is not a mutually

    exclusive list.

      Tampering with examinations

      Obtaining the exam or test script prior to sitting

      Sitting an exam for another student or having another student sit

    an exam for you

      Changing a marked assessment and submitting for

    reconsideration  Allowing someone else to do the work eg writing, of an

    assessment

      Overuse of third party assistance such as editors, proofreaders

      Altering group assessment work of participating students without

    the collaborating students’ consent 

      Fabrication or falsification of data or results of field or other work

      Making a false declaration, eg falsifying the word count for an

    assignment

      Misrepresenting exceptional circumstances beyond your control

    and then claiming special conditions  Any situation where a student gains an unfair advantage through

    using work that is not their own and is not acknowledged by

    them as not their own.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    11/32

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    12/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 8

    Poor planning Poor time management skills are often a cause of if you leave writing

    assignments or studying until the last minute or due to your busy life

    you have difficulty in prioritising time. Sometimes you may have

    difficulty coping with multiple assessment deadlines.

    As a result you may panic and try to find the quickest method of

    completing an assessment.

    Citation misunderstanding Citing and referencing indicates to the reader the sources of ideas

    and material that you have used as a foundation for your own work.

    Citation misunderstanding can result from insufficient understanding

    of the academic conventions of citing and referencing, particular to a

    student’s area of study. For example, the Faculty of Business & Law

    requires students to use the APA (American Psychological

    Association) 6th

     edition method of referencing.

    ‘It’s my own work, I’ve usedit before’ 

    You rightly see work that you have already produced as your ownintellectual property and feel you have the right to use it again where

    appropriate. However, you cannot resubmit work that has previously

    been used to gain credit (a grade) unless prior permission is given

    and then the work must be referenced.

    ‘I thought they were my

    own notes’ Poor research practice results in students copying and pasting chunks

    of work or recording information without reference to the original

    author. At the time of borrowing the information, you may forget to

    record the attribution information such as the source, author,

    original date and date of retrieval when using the material of others.

    Then when you come to use the information it is no longer clear who

    the information belongs to. This results in the text losing ownership

    (Carroll, 2007).

    ‘It’s common knowledge’  Information may be viewed as ‘common knowledge’ and therefore it

    is implied that as ‘everyone knows this’ there is no need to reference

    that information to its source.

    Some of the rules around referencing may seem contradictory and

    vary in their interpretation of what is common knowledge. See the

    section on How to Develop AI Skills for help.

    Ambiguity of terms Students who are new to academic study may have difficulty

    understanding terms such as ‘define’ or ‘explain’ or ‘analyse’. Some

    students do not think a definition needs to be referenced.

    Different cultural

    perspectives

    Students may unintentionally plagiarise due to differing cultural

    assumptions. In some cultures, paraphrasing is viewed as being

    disrespectful to the original author and to include material from an

    expert in a particular field without citation is acceptable (Chester,

    2001).

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    13/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 9

    How todevelop

    AcademicIntegrity

    skills

    This section offersguidelines on how to

    develop skills leading

    to academic integrity  

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    14/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 10

    Academic Study Skills

    Good academic practice

    Recognise gaps and seek

    help

    Be a responsible student

    Good academic study skills are gained through:

      developing good note taking skills

     

    developing skills in researching Internet and library material  reading and researching widely

      planning your writing, drafting and redrafting

      learning to paraphrase and summarise appropriately

      limiting direct quotes

      learning to develop a clear argument and thinking critically

      managing your time effectively

      understanding the requirements of the assessment

    Recognise where you have gaps in your skills and knowledge in the

    above areas and seek help. This might be through self-directed study

    such as finding resources that will help you develop good academicstudy skills. You are also encouraged to attend courses and seek help

    from academic staff. See the later section on Where do I get help?

    You also have a responsibility to familiarise yourself with the

    Business Assessment and Study Handbook and follow the Student

    Expectations (AUT Business Assessment and Study Handbook).

    Referencing your work

    Assessments Assessments such as tests, essays, reports, presentations and exams,

    provide you with the opportunity to show your understanding in aparticular subject area and to demonstrate the achievement of the

    learning goals for the papers you are enrolled in.

    As part of your learning you are expected to refer to and incorporate

    the work of experts in the subject area. However, it is unacceptable

    to use another person’s ideas without attributing the work to them.

    Attribution is undertaken by citing the source in the body of the work

    and giving a full reference at the end of the work.

    What is referencing? Referencing is the formal acknowledgement of the source of any

    material (other than your own ideas) used in your work. The sourcematerial used could include: other people’s ideas, research,

    diagrams, images, audio files, statistics, facts and theories from both

    published and unpublished works.

    Systems of referencing There are a number of accepted referencing systems used by

    different disciplines. Please refer to your subject study guide for

    details.

    NZ Law Style Law students and academics use The New Zealand Law Style Guide

    available at: http://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-

    guide/index.html 

    http://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.html

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    15/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 11

    APA 6th

     Edition The Business School in the Faculty of Business & Law uses the APA

    (American Psychological Association) system of referencing (6th

     Ed.).

    A Guide is available through the AUT Library online resources

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/library/study/referencing 

    This system requires sources to be acknowledged by:

     

    citations within the body of your work

    and

      full written details of those citations in the reference list at

    the end of your work.

    Reference list The purpose of the reference list is to allow your sources to be found

    by your reader. It also gives credit to authors you have consulted for

    their ideas. A reference list must be included as a new page after the

    body of the report and be titled References. It is an alphabetical

    listing of all the sources cited in your work except for personal

    communications (such as conversations), which cannot be retrieved.

    Bibliography A reference list is different from a bibliography which is more a

    comprehensive list of all background reading. A bibliography lists all

    the sources used during your research and background reading, not

     just the ones you refer to in your assignment.

    Resources for referencing

    AUT Business Assessment

    and Study Handbook 2013

    Endnote

    MS Word

    Student Learning Centre

    Courses

    This booklet has been developed specifically for business students

    and is a useful resource for information on academic integrity,referencing and assessments (AUT, 2013).

    EndNote is personal reference management software that allows you

    to import, store and manage your references to create citations and

    references lists, using a range of referencing conventions. You may

    download it for free from the AUT University website for off-campus

    use.

    http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=84548&sid=628305 

    Increasingly, students are using MS Word to manage their sources.

    The Student Learning Centre offers courses early in the semester on

    a range of skills related to academic study. Moreover, they are free

    to AUT students http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-

    out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-

    support/student-learning 

    Using citations

    What is a citation? A citation indicates that particular information in your work is

    borrowed from or based on another source. The citation gives briefdetails regarding the author that help the reader to identify the

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/library/study/referencinghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/library/study/referencinghttp://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=72586&sid=1383668#4383010http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=72586&sid=1383668#4383010http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=84548&sid=628305http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=84548&sid=628305http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=84548&sid=628305http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=72586&sid=1383668#4383010http://aut.ac.nz.libguides.com/content.php?pid=72586&sid=1383668#4383010http://www.aut.ac.nz/library/study/referencing

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    16/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 12

    source of the material in the alphabetical reference list at the end of

    your work.

    These are often referred to as in-text references and require the

    name of the author/s and date of publication. If a quote is used then

    the page number must also be included.

    Citations within the body of

    your work

    A citation is required every time you use or refer, in the body of your

    text, to another person’s: 

      opinions

      ideas

      statistics

      diagrams

      images

      audio files

      charts

      illustrations

     

    suggestions  facts

      observations.

    This means every time you:

      quote

      paraphrase

      summarise

      make specific reference to another person’s work 

      use another person’s work as the basis of the development of

    your own thoughts.

    You do not need to cite your own original thoughts or common

    knowledge, unless you are referring to something you have written

    elsewhere.

    How to use a citation Citations are used in the same way whether you are paraphrasing,

    quoting or summarising.

    The citation may go before or after the paraphrase, quote or

    summary depending on how you have presented the material. The

    following example uses a quote:

    “In performance cultures, employees are more likely to see their own

    goal achievement as synonymous with their own organisation’s

    success”(Macky, 2008, p.261). 

    OR

    Macky (2008) comments that “In performance cultures,

    employees are more likely to see their own goal achievement as

    synonymous with their own organisation’s success” (p. 261).

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    17/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 13

    Paraphrasing, quoting and summarising

    What is a paraphrase? A paraphrase is when you put the words, sentences and paragraphs

    of another person into your own words without copying the words or

    structure of the original material. Good paraphrasing indicates thatyou have clearly understood the original material as you have

    integrated it into your own thinking and personal writing style.

    Paraphrasing is a skill that takes time to do well and will develop with

    practise.

    Paraphrasing requires more than minor changes to the original work.

    Simply changing the order of the words or changing the occasional

    word with another word that has a similar meaning is not the correct

    way to paraphrase. Even someone with very good writing skills may

    have difficulty at times. See Appendix One for an example of poor

    and appropriate paraphrasing.

    What sort of common

    knowledge doesn’t need to

    be cited?

    Following are some thoughts on what determines common

    knowledge.

      Information that is common to your discipline is common

    knowledge when it is referred to in at least five credible sources

    without being referenced (Owl Writing Lab, Purdue University). 

      Whether something is common knowledge depends on the

    audience. If you were referring to general information or ideas

    from your discipline and your intended audience was from the

    same discipline then you may expect it to be common knowledge

    and therefore there would be no need to find the source of this

    common knowledge.

    For example as a marketing student you might use the term

    ‘market segmentation’. This is a common term in the marketing

    discipline and therefore when using this term in a general sense

    there may be no need to attribute it to its source. However, if

    the same term was referred to in say the psychology discipline, it

    would be wise to cite it as it is not a term common to thatdiscipline and you would want to explain it in more detail for that

    audience and make reference to the source of information

    (Referen©ite, University of Auckland).

    It is suggested that even where citing does not seem necessary as

    with common words, your credibility as an academic writer is

    enhanced by attributing to the source of your research (Carroll,

    2007).

    What is a quote? A quotation is when you copy the exact words from the source

    material.

    http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/http://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    18/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 14

    When to use quotes

    Why have you chosen to

    include the quote in your

    assignment?

    Quotes are used where the wording of the original material is

    powerful and you cannot reasonably paraphrase without losing the

    meaning of that work. You would use a quote to emphasise an

    important idea from a leading expert.

    All quotes must be followed by an explanation. It is not sufficient toquote and leave it up to the reader to interpret it in the context of

    your writing.

    Limit the amount of quotes you use. Remember the majority of the

    assignment needs to be your own thinking in your own words. It is

    suggested that quotes should not exceed 10% of the total word

    count (McCulloch & Reid, 2012).

    How to use a quote

    Short quotes

    Long quotes

    If a quote is less than 40 words, the quote must be in double

    quotations marks, together with the author, year of publication and

    page number of the original source of the quote. Examples:

    “So once you start preparing assignments, you will need to ensure

    that you properly acknowledge any information that you have used

    to support your writing. This applies in the professional world as

    well” (McCulloch & Reid, 2012, p. 62) .

    McCulloch and Reid (2012) stated that “once you start preparing

    assignments, you will need to ensure that you properly acknowledge

    any information that you have used to support your writing. This

    applies in the professional world as well” (p. 58).

    If a quote is 40 words or more, the quote should start on a new line

    and each line is indented fives spaces from the left hand margin. No

    quotation marks are required but the author, year of publication and

    page number format is the same as for short quotes. Examples:

    If you understand that you need to acknowledge all your

    sources, then this is the first step in ensuring you practise

    academic honesty and avoid plagiarism. This also applies in

    the professional setting where you are demonstrating

    professional integrity by acknowledging your sources of

    information. (McCulloch & Reid, 2012, p. 63)

    McCulloch and Reid (2012) explain that:

    If you understand that you need to acknowledge all your

    sources, then this is the first step in ensuring you practise

    academic honesty and avoid plagiarism. This also applies in

    the professional setting where you are demonstrating

    professional integrity by acknowledging your sources of

    information. (p.63)

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    19/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 15

    Summarising A summary gathers together and identifies the key points from the

    original source. A summary is written in your own words.

    Where do I get help?

    Your lecturer Your first point of contact is your lecturer. If you are unsure of the

    assessment requirements or whether you can use previously

    submitted work then you should speak to them.

    Paper Co-ordinator/Leader Your Study Guide will also refer you to the Paper Leader for the

    paper you are enrolled in.

    Student Learning Centre The Student Learning Centre provides free academic support to

    help you excel and achieve better grades. If you are struggling with

    an assignment, essay or paper they offer a range of resources onessay writing, referencing, time management, exam preparation

    and how to study effectively. They also hold free workshops

    throughout the year to help you achieve the best possible grades.

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-

    undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-

    support/student-learning 

    Services for Māori and

    Pasifika studentsMāori and Pasifika students at AUT can access a wide range of

    student learning services and resources, including tertiary readiness

    programmes for new AUT students, tutorial groups, one-on-one

    academic support, and fono and whānau spaces on campus.

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-

    undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-

    support/maori-academic-support 

    AUT Library The Library provides a range of tools and resources to assist you

    with your learning and research.

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/library/study 

    AuSM (Auckland Student

    Movement at AUT)The AuSM Advocacy team can provide support, advice and

    advocacy services that are independent, confidential and free.

    http://www.ausm.org.nz/ 

    The AUT Chinese Centre AUT Chinese Centre is under the umbrella of the Office of

    International Relations and Development and Student Services. The

    primary aim of the Chinese Centre is to provide pastoral and

    academic assistance for students from the Chinese region.

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-

    chinese-centre 

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/library/studyhttp://www.aut.ac.nz/library/studyhttp://www.ausm.org.nz/http://www.ausm.org.nz/http://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-chinese-centrehttp://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-chinese-centrehttp://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-chinese-centrehttp://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-chinese-centrehttp://www.aut.ac.nz/study-at-aut/international-students/aut-chinese-centrehttp://www.ausm.org.nz/http://www.aut.ac.nz/library/studyhttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/maori-academic-supporthttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learninghttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/current-undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    20/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 16

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    21/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 17

    AUT

    Processes

    This section outlines

    the University

     processes for alleged

    breaches of academic

    integrity  

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    22/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 18

    Why might my work be investigated?

    Why might my work be

    investigated?

    Academic misconduct or cases of suspected plagiarism or cheating

    are generally found by the lecturer, marker or examination

    supervisor.

    In an unsupervised (uncontrolled) assessment such as a written

    piece of work or submission of visual or audio or other material, the

    marker may suspect there is academic misconduct when:

      there are significant similarities between the work of one

    student and another student

      the language used or work presented is more sophisticated

    than would be expected at that academic level and/or is

    inconsistent with the student’s previous work 

      submission to Turnitin.com results in an unacceptable

    overall similarity score.  in the lecturer’s professional judgement a body of

    knowledge has been used that has not been given

    attribution rights

      there are other irregularities.

    In a supervised (controlled) assessment such as an examination or

    test the marker or examination supervisor may suspect there is

    academic misconduct when:

      a student is in possession of material that is not permitted

    in the examination room

     

    a student tampers with the examination or the examination

    setting

      a student shares their work intentionally or unintentionally

    allows their work to be shared

      there are other inconsistencies.

    Turnitin

    What is Turnitin? Turnitin.com is an electronic text matching tool used to check the

    similarity of student submitted work with other sources held in its

    databases. Submitted work is checked against:

     

    the Current and Archived Web - 20 billion web pages from the

    current web as well as archived web pages.

      student papers - a database of over 220 million items of

    student submitted work.

      content partnerships - over 100 million books, publications and

    articles (Turnitin, 2012).

    When work is submitted to a ‘class’ and ‘assignment’ that has been

    set up in Turnitin, an Originality Report is automatically generated.This report shows an overall similarity index (OSI), the overall

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    23/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 19

    percentage of the document that is matched to sources on the

    Turnitin databases. The OSI is also broken down into the

    percentage of matches to other student work, the internet and to

    publications. Furthermore, each match to the same source is

    highlighted in the student report and a percentage of that match is

    given.

    What happens to my work

    when it is submitted to

    Turnitin?

    When you submit your work to Turnitin your work is permanently

    stored in a database. In order to help maintain your privacy you

    should remove your name and use only your student ID on the

    coversheet, headers and footers of the work you submit.

    If your work matches the work of a student in another educational

    organisation, the lecturer of that organisation may be able to view

    your work. If your work is not available, they may request, via

    Turnitin, to view your work. If permission is given by your AUT

    lecturer then your work is then made available to another

    institution.

    How is Turnitin used? Turnitin is one of several methods used when investigating any case

    of alleged copying, plagiarism or cheating. Turnitin scores are also

    only one of a number of factors that are taken into consideration in

    determining the outcome of an investigation.

    In considering the Overall Similarity Index and the percentage of

    matches as determined by Turnitin the marker will:

     

    Consider the matches to other students or your own previouslysubmitted work.

      Take into consideration text that has been included in the

    matches but may be part of a template or other material made

    available to all students and part of the structure of the

    assessment.

      Take into consideration text that is appropriately cited and

    referenced.

      Look at text that has been cited but is a direct match and

    therefore should have been included in quotation marks.

     

    Look at text that appears to have been altered by replacingsome of the words but still follows the same sequence, flow

    and themes of discussion as another source.

      Look at text that has not been matched to Turnitin but may

    follow the same sequence, flow and themes of the discussion in

    another source.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    24/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 20

    What is the process if I’m suspected of academic misconduct? 

    What is the process? The type and severity of the misconduct will determine how the

    student’s case is dealt with. The Faculty of Business & Law has

    robust procedures in place to ensure allegations of academicmisconduct are dealt with in a transparent, fair and consistent

    manner. In the case of examination or test misconduct the

    student’s case may be sent to the Faculty of Business & Law

    Discipline Committee. In the case of written or other academic

    misconduct, the case may be referred to the Faculty of Business &

    Law Academic Integrity Advisors for further investigation.

    A student will receive written and email confirmation of an alleged

    case of academic misconduct. This advice will be sent to their AUT

    email address and the residential address on ARION, the student

    records management system.

    There are a range of possible outcomes as a result of an

    investigation into alleged academic misconduct:

      An interview with academic staff or request for further

    information

      No penalty

      A requirement to complete a course on academic writing or

    study

      A warning penalty

     

    A warning penalty that is formally recorded on the

    University academic dishonesty database

      A change to the grade awarded for a piece of assessment

      A requirement to resubmit work or re-sit an examination or

    test

      a change to the overall grade awarded for a paper

      In rare cases a student may be removed from the

    university.

    Cover Page Submission

    Electronic or hard copy

    submissionStudents submitting assessments are normally required to submit a

    standard AUT coversheet declaration with their assessment. This is

    a declaration that you understand and agree to comply with the

    AUT General Academic Regulations. When the coversheet is

    submitted in hard copy you are required to sign and date it. When

    it is submitted electronically you are not required to sign or date it

    but by submitting it electronically you are agreeing to the terms of

    the declaration.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    25/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 21

    What can I do?

    My rights Students’ rights are strongly respected and therefore as well as

    recommending students seek support the University also requires

    students to have the right to appeal a decision made. There areseveral steps to the appeal process. Students have the right to:

      seek a reconsideration of an assessment grade

      appeal the decision to the Discipline Committee

      appeal the decision of the Discipline Committee to the Vice

    Chancellor’s office. 

    (AUT Calendar 2013, The General Academic Regulations, Part 6

    Academic Discipline, Sections 1-4)

    Where do I get help? It is recommended that students seek help and support from AUT

    AUSM (Auckland Student Movement). This is a free studentadvocacy service. Alternatively, students may wish to discuss their

    case with family or other support people.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    26/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 22

    References

    AUT (2012). AUT Strategic Plan 2012-2016. Retrieved on 5 April 2013 from

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publications 

    AUT Student Learning Centre (2013). Academic integrity and plagiarism. Retrieved 8 April 2013 from

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-

    information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-

    resources-for-students 

    AUT (2013). AUT University Calendar 2013. Retrieved from http://www.aut.ac.nz/about-

    aut/university-publications 

    AUT (2013). Business assessment and study handbook .

    Carroll, J. (2007). A handbook for deterring plagiarism in higher education (2nd ed.) Oxford, Great

    Britain: Oxford Centre for Staff and Learning Development.

    Chester, G. (2001 ). Plagiarism detection and prevention: final report of the JISC electronic plagiarism

    detection project . Retrieved 8 April 2013 from

    http://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/plagiarism.aspx 

    Student Materials (n.d.). Retrieved 8 April 2013 from http://plagiarism.org/resources/student-

    materials 

    International Centre for Academic Integrity (2012). The fundamental values of academic integrity .

    Retrieved 5 April 2013 from http://www.academicintegrity.org/icai/resources-2.php

    McCulloch, R. & Reid, A. (2012). Your business degree. Australia:Pearson.

    Purdue University (2010). Purdue online writing lab. Retrieved 11 July 2012 from

    http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/ 

    The New Zealand Law Foundation (n.d.). The New Zealand law style guide. New Zealand: Thomson

    Reuters. Retrieved 25 March 2013 from http://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-

    guide/index.html 

    Turnitin (2012). Turnitin products. Retrieved 19 July, 2012 fromhttp://www.turnitin.com/en_us/products/content#page 

    University of Auckland (2012). When do you need to reference?   (Referen©ite, University of

    Auckland). Retrieved on 11 July 2012 from

    http://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_reference 

    http://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/plagiarism.aspxhttp://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/plagiarism.aspxhttp://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/http://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.turnitin.com/en_us/products/content#pagehttp://www.turnitin.com/en_us/products/content#pagehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.cite.auckland.ac.nz/index.php?p=when_to_referencehttp://www.turnitin.com/en_us/products/content#pagehttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://www.lawfoundation.org.nz/style-guide/index.htmlhttp://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/589/2/http://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://plagiarism.org/resources/student-materialshttp://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/plagiarism.aspxhttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publicationshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/being-a-student/starting-out/undergraduates/academic-information/academic-and-study-support/student-learning/student-learning-centre-print-resources-for-studentshttp://www.aut.ac.nz/about-aut/university-publications

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    27/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 23

    Appendix One – Academic Integrity and Plagiarism

    ACADEMIC INTEGRITY & PLAGIARISM

    Academic integrity refers to the practice of honesty around using and reporting academic research,

    texts and ideas and the research process in general.

    When a person uses another person’s words (direct quotations) or ideas and does not give them

    credit f or those ideas in their assignment it is known as “Plagiarism” and this goes against the

    principles of academic integrity – whether intentional (on purpose) or unintentional, it is still

    considered a breach or breaking of academic integrity.

    What is wrong with plagiarism?

    There are many reasons why plagiarism should be avoided:Plagiarism is really stealing someone else’s words or ideas and pretending that they are your own.

    e credit.

    procedures as described in the AUT Calendar under “Policy Statements” (AUT, 2013).

    is disrespectful to other students studying with you. Plagiarism is like when you cheat on anexam. You give yourself an unfair advantage over others who have worked hard to avoid plagiarism.

    iarising, or even worse, you could be asked

    to leave the programme you are studying.

    ideas and wants to follow up your sources, they do not have any idea of where to find your sources if

    you do not reference them.

    community made up of many years of thinkers and writers.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    28/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 24

    How to avoid plagiarism Manage your time carefully. You need to allow yourself enough time to read your material, write

    useful notes and complete your assignment.

    need to choose what you want to read. Allow yourself enough time to read the material at leasttwice so you have a good understanding of what the author is saying before you start making notes.

    ng the information in the body

    of your assignment and in the reference list at the end i.e.: author, date of publication, name of

    book/journal (Vol. &No.), page range of journal articles or chapter, publisher, place of publication,

    page number, website url, webpage title, date of retrieval, all references to where information is

    taken from.

    information in YOUR OWN WORDS.

    u are reading you may find that several authors have a similar

    idea. In your notes write down the idea (in your own words) and the authors who think this.

    o

    include the page that this quote came from.

    Print out or photocopy all your source information. Start the bibliography or reference list as you

    find information.

    Hints to identify plagiarism in your writing

    Pretend that you have seen the following opening in Brooksbank’s book Battle for the market .You think this is what your lecturer wants to see in your essay.

    Brooksbank, R. (1996). Battle For the Market .

    Smart marketers know that to be successful, their company’s products and services must be

    well “positioned” in the marketplace ... positioning strategy provides the key to market success.

    However, research has also shown that not all managers fully understand either the concept of

    the process of positioning strategy development. Recent research I conducted suggests that up

    to 50% of marketing executives in medium-sized companies in the UK fall into this category. 

    You have read the information and taken notes. Look at what you have written below anddecide if you think your lecturer would be pleased. 

    How a company positions itself in the marketplace can determine the success or failure of the

    company. However research has shown that not all managers understand the concept or the

    process of positioning strategy development. 

    The first sentence in the above text is fine. It is a summary of what the paragraph will be about.

    The second sentence, however, is clearly plagiarism. The sentence has been written word for

    word, except for the word ‘also’. There is no acknowledgment that these words/this idea came

    from someone else.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    29/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 25

    Positioning strategy provides the key to market success. Smart marketers know that to be

    successful, their company's products and services must be well “positioned” in the marketplace.

    The above text is also plagiarism. The writer has reversed the two sentences in the opening

    paragraph, but this is still considered plagiarism. 

    How a company positions itself in the marketplace can determine the success or failure of the

    company. Surprisingly, research shows that up to 50% of managers in some UK companies do

    not understand the importance of effective marketing.

    In the text above the writer has paraphrased the ‘idea’ from Brooksbank’s article. However, this is

    still considered plagiarism as the ideas have not come from the writer and Brooksbank has not been

    referenced.

    Changing the occasional word for another with a similar meaning is not “writing in your own

    words.”

    So what does good referencing look like? Have a look at the two texts below. Both have been

    referenced properly. The first text is an example of paraphrasing and the second is an example of a

    direct quote.

    Paraphrasing and citing

    How a company positions itself in the marketplace can determine the success or failure of the

    company. Surprisingly, research by Brooksbank (1996) shows that up to 50% of managers in

    some UK companies do not understand the importance of effective marketing.

    Quoting

    How a company positions itself in the marketplace can determine the success or failure of the

    company. Surprisingly, as Brooksbank (1996, p.48) states, ‘recent research … suggests that up to

    50% of marketing executive in medium sized companies in the UK fall into this category’.

    Taken from AUT Student Learning Centre, Academic Integrity & Plagiarism.

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    30/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 26

    Appendix Two – AUT Library Referencing with APA 6th – Brief Guide

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    31/32

    Academic Integrity Guidance for Students 2013 27

  • 8/9/2019 AI Guidance for Students Final 2013.pdf

    32/32

    Appendix Three – Collusion Continuum Exercise

    Read the exercise below and think about at which point the students move from acceptable

    collaboration to unacceptable collusion that would result in academic misconduct.

    Discuss it with your friends and see if their viewpoint differs from yours.

    A teacher sets this task: ‘Choose one of the three companies I suggest and write an individual report 

    on their advertising campaigns in the last three years’. Three students do the steps listed below in

    this order.

    When (if ever) do they move from co-operation and collaboration to creating a report that gives a

    false impression to the assessor as to whose work is being marked?

    The three students:

    1. 

    Discuss the coursework brief with the teacher and with other students.

    2. 

    Look at examples of similar coursework from the past and discuss their good and bad points with

    each other.

    3.  Discuss the best way to tackle the task of writing the report and decide to choose the same

    company (Let’s all do Microsoft ).

    4.  Decide to all do a bit of research on advertising campaigns (You find out about design, I’ll do

    impact, Joe, you do cost, etc.).

    5.  Tell each other what they have found and brief each other on useful sources of information.

    6. 

    Photocopy each others’ scribbles, library notes and printed Web pages. 

    7. 

    Delegate the best researcher of the group to find out about the company’s campaign, tell the

    others and give them copies of notes, Web pages, summaries of articles, etc. ( Joe, you find out

    and tell us…).

    8. 

    Jointly agree a structure for the final report; agree which are the strongest points, which should

    go first, etc.

    9.  Share out the writing task with each person writing one or two sections.

    10. Pool the sections and everyone takes the collected test to write their own final draft. Nobody

    changes more than 5%.

    11. 

    Submit the report for a mark.(Carroll, 2007, p. 19)

    It is our opinion that anything below Point 3 above, is collusion. Students may select the same topic

    area when a predetermined range is given, however as part of your academic study and assessment

    requirements you must undertake your own research.