Upload
maricel-nicolas-olbes
View
252
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
1/26
AGRARIAN REFORMISSUES
Symposium
March 12, 2012
Aelimianum College, Inc.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
2/26
In an agrarian country such as the
Philippines where majority of thepeople are peasants, land reform isa must if the government seeks to
respond to the needs of the people,and achieve peace and developmentfor the nation.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
3/26
The most recent of these programs
is the Aquino regimesComprehensive Agrarian ReformProgram (CARP). Enacted on June10, 1988, Republic Act 6657 or the
Comprehensive Agrarian ReformLaw was supposed to beimplemented for 10 years.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
4/26
Falling short of its targets, the
Agrarian Reform Law wasextended by the Ramosadministration for another 10years. It expired for the second
time in June 2008.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
5/26
In June 2099, the House ofRepresentatives adopted HouseResolution 4077, or theComprehensive Agrarian ReformProgram Extension with Reforms
(CARPER). Only 13 voted no andtwo abstained.
Shorty thereafter, the bicameral
conference committee voted forthe extension of the CARP foranother five years.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
6/26
In August, Arroyo signed theCARPER, a consolidation of HouseBill No. 4077 and Senate Bill No.2666, effectively extending theCARP from July 1, 2009 to June
30, 2014.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
7/26
Will the CARPER finally resolve thecenturies-old problem oflandlessness afflicting thepeasantry?
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
8/26
A genuine agrarian-reformprogram should result in the freedistribution of land to the tillers.After all, land, which should beuniversally available to all, was
merely grabbed and titled bylandlords who were close to theSpanish and then the American
colonial authorities.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
9/26
Second, these landlords havealready profited immensely
through the labor of generations ofpeasants. Herein lies the basic flawof CARP and CARPER, which
provided compensation to thelandlords, thereby negating theaforementioned historical truths.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
10/26
Compensation limited the capacityof the government to distribute
land and gave the landlords thepower to dictate the price ofcompensation and eventually take
back the land from peasants whoare unable to pay the amortizationbecause of the backwardness of
agricultural production in thecountry.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
11/26
The task is to cover one millionhectares in the next five years. By
2010, the department should be ableto distribute 200,000 hectares ofland.
The CARPER also mandates that privateagricultural lands the type that theArroyos and the Cojuangcos own canonly be distributed if the original CARPmanaged to distribute 90 percent of itstarget. But CARP, despite the two decadesof its implementation, only distributed lessthan half of its target.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
12/26
Lands covered by CARPER will beacquired and distributed in three
phases. Phase One will cover rice and corn lands,
all idle lands or abandoned lands, allprivate lands voluntarily offered by theowners for agrarian reform, all landsforeclosed by government financialinstitutions, all lands acquired by thePresidential Commission on GoodGovernment, and all other lands owned bygovernment devoted to or suitable foragriculture.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
13/26
Phase Two will cover all alienable anddisposable public agricultural lands; all
arable public agricultural lands underagro-forest, pasture and agriculturalleases already cultivated and planted
to crops in accordance with Section 6Article XIII of the Constitution; allpublic agricultural lands that are to beopened for new development and
resettlement; all private agriculturallands in excess of 50 hectares.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
14/26
Phase Three will cover all other
private agricultural lands startingwith large landholdings and thenmedium and small landholdings.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
15/26
Based on its past performance,however, the government seems
not only unable to do what itpreaches but more alarmingly hasshown itself incapable of freeing
the peasant masses fromcenturies-old feudal bondage oreven improve the tenant-
beneficiaries productivity.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
16/26
Amid what critics said are theflaws and the emasculation of
CARP, government may claim thatland may have been given to manyfarmers. But the vast majority of
land toilers remain poor forcingeven many of what governmenthad identified as tenant-beneficiaries to sell, mortgage or
abandon their lands.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
17/26
In an ironic twist of fate, studiesshow that CARP lands have beengradually turned over back to thelandlords.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
18/26
The departments latest CARP impactassessment study compared poverty
incidence in rural areas between1990 and 2000 and, in the sameperiod, between agrarian reformbeneficiaries (ARBs) and non-ARBs.
Poverty incidence among ARBs wentdown from 47.6 percent in 1990 to45.2 percent in 2000, showing
positive impact of CARP on farmer-beneficiaries.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
19/26
It looks like however thatwhatever improvements had been
made on the living standards ofARBs compared to non-ARBs, havenot influenced the general
economic condition in thecountryside as the incidence ofpoverty nationwide seemed to
have even risen.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
20/26
In Tarlac province, about 100 kms northof Manila, Hacienda Luisita was oncetouted as a showcase of the land reformprogram. Here, however, CARP hasfailed to win the hearts and minds of
farmers: In recent random interviews,they told Bulatlat.com that their liveshave been ruined further because ofCARP. Luisita is owned by the family of
former President Corazon CojuangcoAquino.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
21/26
One of the workers, FranciscoNakpil, is an agricultural worker inthe sugarcane plantation ofHacienda Luisita, Inc. (HLI) for 45years. When the stock distribution
options (SDO) scheme under CARPwas introduced in the hacienda in1989, Nakpil became one of the
7,000 workers who became instantstockholders of the agro-corporation.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
22/26
Within 30 years under thisscheme, hacienda owners were to
transfer 32 percent of the totalstocks of the company to the farmworkers.
Yet, has Nakpil become richerthrough the land reform program?
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
23/26
Today at 62, Nakpil says he has only ahome lot souvenir from the HLI, a
P20,000 separation pay, and someP2,600 monthly pension from the SocialSecurity System. His retirement ended
his profit share from the HLI. He doesnot have land to pass on to his children.His monthly pension gave him just P86 aday that can hardly meet his familys
needs. And so his answer in Filipino: I am
poor, past and present.
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
24/26
Danilo Ramos, secretary general of the militantKilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP PeasantMovement in the Philippines), offered his own
assessment of CARP. He said: Pagkatapos ng CARPextension period, naibenta na ulit ng mgabenepisyaryo ang lupa sa mayayaman dahil walanamang pag-asang umunlad ang kabuhayan ng
magsasaka sa taas naman ng gastos saproduksyon. Wala namang suportang pautang at ibapang serbisyo ang gobyerno kaya magigipit uli angbenepisyaryo, mababaon sa utang, mapipilitang
ibenta ang lupa
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
25/26
Ramos argues that the root of thisflawed land reform program is in
the very concept of compensatingthe landlords and making thefarmers pay for the lands. Nasaan
naman doon ang katarungan? Angnaging papel lang ng gobyerno saprogramang ito ay ang pagiging
middleman sa bentahan ng lupa sapagitan ng may-ari at ngmagsasaka. Reporma ba yun?
7/28/2019 Agrarian Reform Issues
26/26
If I were to ask you, do you thinkCARP will already attain itsobjective/purpose of distributingland to landless farmers and farm
workers now that it has beenextended up to 2014?