Against the Church: From Vaticinium ex Eventu to Applied Logic

7/21/2019 Against the Church: From Vaticinium ex Eventu to Applied Logic

1/8

Bkbdest tol Mourmo> Grih Wbtdmdeduh lx Lvletu ti

Bppcdl` Cikdm

Hirtuus lst @ld gcdus1 mrl`dfcl lst qudb delptuh lst>lt slpuctus rlsurrlxdt1 mlrtuh lst qudb dhpissdfdcl lst.

-PLVP\CCDBE

Hy mcbdh ds tol gicciwdek> tol Fdfcl ds eit letdrlcy trul !ir su""isl tolmietrbry# tobt ds$ su""isl tol Fdfcl ds letdrlcy trul %iwl&lr$ flgirl D flkde hy'dsmiursl dt ds elmlssbry ti l("cirl wobt tol Fdfcl bmtubccy mcbdhs de rlkbr's ti dtsiwe butoletdmdty De )ri&lrfs *+$ Bkur tol sie ig ,blo ds s"lbdek ti Dtodlc be'\mbc )bssdek i&lr tol "odcicikdmbc l(lklsds ig tol mobrbmtlrs$ tol tl(t mclbrcy'l"dmts Bkur.s cbm ig beswlrs gir "odcisi"odmbc /ulstdies be' ods krb'ubcbmml"tbeml ig tol Fdfcl bs delrrbet truto> :L&lry wir' ig 2i' ds tlstl'6 =)ri&lrfs

*+> 0 *+ De b''dtdie$ )sbch ;4> stbtls :Pol cbw ig tol Cir' ds "lrglmt$rlstirdek tol siuc# tol tlstdhiey ig tol Cir' ds surl$ hbdek wdsl tol sdh"cl61clbrcy$ tol Fdfcl "isdts tobt dt ds letdrlcy butoletdm be' tolrlgirl tolrl ds ei slcg-mietrb'dmtdie de hy dedtdbc oy"itolsds

2d&le tol Fdfcl ds trul$ wl mbe rlb'dcy bmml"t 3lutlrieihy ;?>88 wodmostbtls tobt dg b "ri"olt s"lbs de tol ebhl ig tol Cir' be' tol todek ol sbys 'ils

eit mihl bfiut ir mihl trul$ tole tol "lrsie obs s"ile dt "rlsuh"tuiuscy be':yiu sobcc eit fl bgrbd' ig odh6

Hi&dek slrdbtdh$ tol Elw Plstbhlet i5lrs b &lry detlrlstdek hlssbkls"ile fy ,lsus de Hbr ;* be' "brbcclcl' de Hbttolw 89 be' Cul 8;> 0-*J Polstiry flkdes bs ,lsus be' sihl ig %ds 'dsmd"cls brl clb&dek tol tlh"cl de ,lrusbclh-tods ds bgtlr ,lsus.s trbes7kurbtdie =Hbr 4>8 *-98;-88< - tole "ri"olsdMls tobt :wole yiu olbr ig wbrs be' ruhirsig wbrs6 yiu wdcc eiw tobt tolsl brl :hlrlcy tol flkdeedek ig fdrto "beks6 tobt:tods ds eit ylt tol le'6 =Hbr ;*> -? 4-;;


2/8

wole yiu sll tol bfihdebtdie ig 'lsicbtdie stbe'dek wolrl dt soiuc' eit fl6 tolefl ie tol ciiiut :gir toisl 'bys wdcc fl b tdhl ig trdfucbtdie$ b tdhl tobt obs eitimmurrl' uetdc eiw6 =Hbr ;*> ;9-;4 8+< be' b'hdts$ :Fut tbloll'# floic'$ D ob&l tic' yiu l&lrytodek de b'&beml6 =Hbr ;*>8* Dsbdbo ;*> ;+ "brbcclcl' de LMldlc *8> $ ,ilc 8> ;+$ *;$ *>;0# Dsbdbo *9> 9# 3bedlc > ;*# be' Glmobrdbo 8> J

Bctoiuko tol kis"lcs kd&l b scdkotcy &brydek bmmiuet ig wobt ,lsus sbd' bgtlrods "ri"olmy$ lbmo kis"lc bmmiuets tobt ,lsus tic' be' l("cbdel' tol "brbfcl ig tol7k =Hbttolw 89> *8-*0$ Hbr ;*> 8?-84$ Cul 8;> 84-*;


3/8

1clbrcy dg slts N be' O brl fito lh"ty$ tole l/ubtdie =*< hust oic' wodmowiuc' "ri&d'l b mietrb'dmtdie Polrlgirl$ clt.s l("cirl lbmo ig tolsl slts de 'ltbdc

u""isl N ds b eielh"ty slt# tobt ds$ su""isl tol "ri"olmy obs ylt tiob""le Pods ds hist mihhiecy eiwe bs b guturdst b""ribmo be' ds wd'lcybmml"tl' fy hi'lre 1ordstdbes8 Dts brkuhlet ds rbtolr uefdfcdmbc$ gir toly "isdt tol

l(dstleml ig toldr mcbdh de tol wir'dek ig tol irdkdebc 2rll tl(t ig Hbr ;*> *+$ be'ture b fcde' lyl ti "lrsiebc wir's grih ,lsus ti fl :rlb'y6 ir :ie tol ciiiut6

Pol s"lmd7m 2rll tl(t de /ulstdie ds tol trbescbtdie ig tol wir' =klelrbtdie *+ tobt clb's hl ti tolgiiteitl de Hbttolw 89> *9- dts "brbcclc &lrsl- wodmo sbys :Ei iel cd&dek wole ,lsuss"il tolsl wir's cd&l' ti sll Abcc tolsl todeks. mihl ti "bss %iwl&lr$ tol 2rllwir' mbe hlbe Arbml. ir Agbhdcy$. wodmo hbls kii' slesl olrl# dl$ tol ,lwdso rbmlwdcc fl "rlslr&l'$ de s"dtl ig tlrrdfcl "lrslmutdie$ uetdc tol Cir' mihls6 D bh b fdtmiegusl' olrl gir D flcdl&l tol Fdfcl ti fl trul fut tods beeitbtir mcbdhs tobt wlsoiuc' mobekl tol "rifclhbtdm wir' de "rdet ti rlbmo b frib'lr mcbdh de ir'lr ti

ustdgy tol guturdst eitdiePi bhle' tods dccikdmbc cii"oicl$ D wdcc i5lr b cdtbey tol mclrky mbe rlcbtl ti>

immurs 9* tdhls de tol Elw Plstbhlet> 98 tdhls wlrl trbescbtl' bsklelrbtdie ir klelrbtdies be' iecy ieml wbs dt trbescbtl' bs de' =Cul ;J>? ? EBF> Be' ods hbstlr "rbdsl' tol uerdkotlius hbebklr flmbusl

ol ob' bmtl' sorlw'cy# gir tol sies ig tods bkl brl hirl sorlw' de rlcbtdie titoldr iwe de' tobe tol sies ig cdkot

Cul ;J> ? 2rll> !"#$ % &'()* +, )-)/) +:* 26(=* 0+(;-; 2rll> =LG)* K$7* O;$) D'($+) 4) N6 4)AL'C/ EI$( )Z 4 2", AL'/ R7* N6 6+K$$'*M 2", N6 R7* +:* /+)($=* LG3)* 6+K$$'*M 2", +:* /+)($=* LG3)* R7* +) D'($+) 6+K$$'*.

ds usl' giur tdhls ti 'leitl b cdelbkl

8 ur"rdsdekcy$ 8*Z ig Bhlrdmbes flcdl&l tobt ,lsus.s )briusdb wdcc immur fy 8+0+


4/8

%lsymodus ig Bcl(be'rdb.s mih"rlolesd&l cl(dmie- hi'lccl' bgtlr

3dikledbeus. "iltdm cl(dmie des"drl' fy %ihlr- i5lrs tol gicciwdek 'l7edtdiegir R]>

]W =R][_T^Q] R]SXUYU< jTS> ` ^UYSXUYQ n]Q Ya] XUY UYp qq^nY]# Y] R]] jYU]YU^ Ya] Q X] $ Q

[$ Q T]W =ebtd&dty ig iel.s rbml ir gbhdcy< b fi'y ig hle uedtl' fy fcii'tdls ir cimbc obfdtbtdie> e b tdhl detlr&bc$ eit tobt wodmo 'lsmrdflsoiw cdgl ob' "bssl'# fut mlrtbdecy sufhdttdek tol trdfl ti b tlh"irbcmiestrbdet fltwlle 8+ be' *+ ylbrs

Bs mbe "cbdecy fl slle$ tolrl ds ei rlbc sufstbeml ti tods "brtdmucbr brkuhletFlmbusl ,lsus ds s"lbdek iecy ti ods 'dsmd"cls ie Ht cd&l$ dt mbeeit fl deglrrl'tobt %l ds rlglrrdek ti tol ,lwdso rbml$ fut ti tol 'dsmd"cls. s"lmd7m cdgltdhlHirli&lr$ tol Fdfcl obs hbey &lrsls rlgutdek b guturdstdm mcbdh De Hbttolw ;+$

,lsus kd&ls ods twlc&l 'dsmd"cls :butoirdty i&lr uemclbe s"drdts$ ti mbst tolh iut$

be' ti olbc l&lry de' ig 'dslbsl be' l&lry de' ig sdmelss6 be' toleml destrumtstolh bcc ie ods hbstlr "cbe flgirl usolrdek tolh iut bs wdtelssls ti itolr ebtdies=Hbttolw ;+> 0 *-*? 04< fut 'ils eit 7e' bey uetdc 1bdb"obs de/udrls$ :D b'url Niu fy tol cd&dek 2i'$tobt Niu tlcc us woltolr Niu brl tol 1ordst$ tol ie ig 2i'6 =Hbttolw 8J> J* ; be' 3bedlc >;*- el&lrtolclss$ tol dhhdeleml ig %ds rlture dsb""brlet


5/8

!urtolr l&d'leml cdls de tol )bucdel =Hbrmdiedtl< clttlrs be' tol tlstdhiedls ig t)ltlr x ,bhls tol ,ust>

;st1irdetodbes > 84> Fut tods D sby$ frltorle$ tol tdhl obs flle

soirtlel'$ si tobt grih eiw ie toisl woi ob&l wd&ls soiuc' fl bstoiuko toly ob' eiel

;stPolssbciedbes 9> ;J-;> !ir tol Cir' %dhslcg wdcc 'lsmle' grih olb&lewdto b soiut$ wdto tol &idml ig tol brmobeklc be' wdto tol truh"lt ig 2i'$be' tol 'lb' de 1ordst wdcc rdsl 7rst Pole wl woi brl bcd&l be' rlhbdewdcc fl mbukot u" tikltolr wdto tolh de tol mciu's ti hllt tol Cir' de tolbdr$ be' si wl sobcc bcwbys fl wdto tol Cir'

DD )ltlr *> 4> Pol Cir' ds eit sciw bfiut %ds "rihdsl$ bs sihl miuet

sciwelss$ fut ds "btdlet tiwbr' yiu$ eit wdsodek gir bey ti "lrdso fut girbcc ti mihl ti rl"letbeml

D )ltlr 9> > Pol le' ig bcc todeks ds elbr# tolrlgirl$ fl ig siue' u'khlet

be' siflr s"drdt gir tol "ur"isl ig "rbylr ,bhls 0> ?-4> Niu tii fl "btdlet# strlektole yiur olbrts$ gir tol mihdek ig

tol Cir' ds elbr 3i eit mih"cbde$ frltorle$ bkbdest iel beitolr$ si tobtyiu yiurslc&ls hby eit fl u'kl'# floic'$ tol ,u'kl ds stbe'dek rdkot bttol 'iir

Pol guturdsts tole usubccy de&il Hbr ;*> *8 bs wlcc bs DD )ltlr *> ? ti 'lgle'toldr "isdtdie de s"dtl ig tol mietrb'dmtdie ig toldr uemobekl' mcbdh !ir b /udmrlmb"$ Hbr ;*> *8 stbtls :Fut ig tobt 'by ir oiur ei iel eiws$ eit l&le tolbeklcs de olb&le$ eir tol ie$ fut tol !btolr bciel6 DD )ltlr *> ? stbtls :Fut 'i eitclt tods iel gbmt lsmb"l yiur eitdml$ flci&l'$ tobt wdto tol Cir' iel 'by ds cdl btoiusbe' ylbrs$ be' b toiusbe' ylbrs cdl iel 'by6 Pol cbttlr &lrsl wbs eits"ile fy ,lsus de ods cd&lt 'dsmiursl eir beywolrl lcsl de tol Elw Plstbhlet$ fut

fbrls rlslhfcbeml ti Hbr ;*> *8 de tobt tol !btolr bciel eiws tol tdhl Hirl"rlmdslcy$ DD )ltlr *> ? ds b rlglrleml ti )sbch 4+> 9

B""cydek DD )ltlr *> ?$ tol guturdsts mcbdh tobt =8< oic's %iwl&lr$ tods

b""cdmbtdie ds b mbsl ig mcbdhdek R ds trul be' R ds bcsi trul gir D )ltlr 9>

"ri&d'ls b mietrb'dmtdie fy tol sbhl butoir$ :Pol le' ig bcc todeks ds elbr6Polrlgirl$ ldtolr DD )ltlr *> ? mbe fl detlr"rltl' de b guturdstdm gbsodie ir D )ltlr 9> ds trul 2d&le bcc ig tol Fdfcl ds trul$ dt hust fl tol mbsl tobt tol de'd&d'ubc &lrsl D)ltlr 9> ds trul$ dh"cydek DD )ltlr *> ? mbeeit fl detlr"rltl' de sumo b gbsodie


6/8

Pods clb&ls iecy Hbr ;*> *8 ti l("cirl Pol brkuhlet dh"cirl' fy tolguturdst ds bs gicciws> flmbusl tol l(bmt tdhl ig 1ordst.s rlture ds ueeiwe$ tole1ordst obs eit ylt rlturel' fut wdcc rlture*

Clt 1ordst wdcc rlture 'urdek tol b"isticdm l"imo$

, tol l(bmt tdhl ig 1ordst.s rlture ds ueeiweVl"rlsletl' cikdmbccy$ toldr mcbdh stbtls>

=9< N A

u""isl =9< oic's$ tolrlgirl tol mietrb"isdtd&l =0< bcsi oic's>

=0< A N

L/ubtdie 0 stbtls tobt dg 1ordst wdcc rlture de tol b"isticdm lrb$ tole tol l(bmttdhl ig 1ordst.s rlture wbs hb'l eiwe ti tol 'dsmd"cls Fy oy"itolsds wl eiw

fito =Hbr ;*> *+< be' , =Hbr ;*> *8< brl trul$ tolrlgirl wl mbe miestrumt tolgicciwdek truto tbfcl>

A N A N

P P P

P ! !

! P P

! ! P

Pous$ kd&le tol Fdfcl ds letdrlcy trul$ wl ob&l rlbmol' b mietrb'dmtdie> =0< hustfl gbcsl be' tol mietrb"isdtd&l ig =0


7/8

eielh"ty =lh"ty Pol sue wdcc fl 'brlel' be' tol hiie wdcc eit kd&ldts cdkot$ tol stbrs wdcc fl gbccdek grih olb&le be' tol ie ig Hbe wdcc fl mihdek demciu's wdto krlbt "iwlr be' kciry$ be' 7ebccy 1ordst.s kbtolrdek ig tol lclmt- tolmoisle iels rlglrrl' ti de Dsbdbo 90>9< bcc hust ob&l immurrl' de tol cdgltdhl ig tol'dsmd"cls =*+ ?+ 1L

Documents

Against the Church: From Vaticinium ex Eventu to Applied Logic