41

act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

� ������������ ��� ����� ����� ����������� ���!�"�#$�%��&'( $�*)'�+��,�������&.-/&

021+354�6.1874�9%:;4 <+=?>�@A0�B%CD@�9%E�FHGH=?@CI4�J?4�GLKIMON+N(PQSRUTWVXQWYOV[Z]\^VH\`_�a

bdcfe!g�g^h�gji�k�g^lnm!o!prqLstbdcvuwqLxycvqk{zjsrx!qL|^uwq~}IqLhwh�g`x���x!uw��qLs���u�p��� uwprp[����o!s�|^e�� �+���L�`���L�

���]�v���j���`�

�������[���X 5¡£¢d�$¤5¥(¦��[§©¨d�X 5¡£ª��X«j¤��¬ ­�[®°¯�¤��[�±¤�¦²®³�X¯H �«`¡£«`´±«`�[¥'¥(¦^ 5���(¡£«±�[¦^«j¤��[§`¤Xµ�������¤r¶`��·¤5¥�¦S¤;·�¨��[��¦L¸�«`�[¥¹¥(¦^ 5���vº�ª��[¤r¯H¨�»`¦^ ­�$¼½¸¾¦^ �¥�»`¦^ª�¯W 5�[®£¯L¤��[��ª��X¯j«`¡°«`´¿¯�®° ­�X¯L��·¿�[§`¡³��¤��rÀ¯H«`��¯j 5¤�¡ÂÁ��[¡£¯L®�¥(¦^ 5���Xµ�Ã�»`�$«`�[¥¹¥(¦^ 5���%¥��X ­�$¶`���[��¯H«�¯H¨�»`¦` 5¡³�X¯L®³®Ä·n¤�¦± 5��¸¾�X �¤�¦¨�¯L��¤{¦^¢jÅÆ;�[�[¤��~¡£«Ç¤r»`�¿¤��[§^¤XµÇÈ�¦` ~¯H«�¯j¨�»`¦^ 5¡³��ª��[¤�¯H¨�»`¦^ 5�XÉ(��¶�¢`Æ;�[�[¤��²�r»`¦L¥(�[�ʯH«Ë¡°«`¡³¤�¡£¯L®�¢`¡£¯L�W¤�¦¯L��¦^¨`¤�¯±®³¡³¤��X �¯L®(¡£«H¤��X �¨� 5�[¤r¯L¤�¡Ä¦`«!É+¥�»`¡Ä�[»2�r»`¡Â¸Ì¤��[�ͯL�t¤r»`�²�[§�¨��X 5¡£ª��X«j¤~¨� 5¦H´` 5�[�����[�Oµ±Î�¶�¢jÅÆ;�[�[¤��²®³�X¯H �«`�[�Ϥr»`�¿ª��X¯H«`¡£«`´I¦L¸�¤r»`�¿ª��[¤�¯H¨�»`¦^ 5�~ªÐ¦^ 5�¿ �¯H¨`¡³��®³·Ê¯j«`�ʪ�¦^ ­�¿¯L�[�X¶� �¯L¤��[®³·HµÑ ¸¾¤��X ² ­�X¨��X¯L¤��[�Ç�[§©¨d¦H�r¶� 5�Ò¤�¦�¤r»`�±¥(¦^ ­���²¡£«�¯H¨�¨� 5¦`¨� 5¡£¯L¤��¿�[¦`«H¤��[§`¤��XÉ(ª��[¤r¯j¨�»`¦^ 5¡³�±���X«jŤ��X«`�[�[�Ó¥(�X 5��¨� 5¦^�[�[�����[�~�[¦`ª²¨�¯H �¯H¢`®³·²¥%¡Ä¤�»�¤r»`�����X«j¤��X«`�[�[��ª²¯L���%¦^«`®³·²¦L¸!¸Ô¯jª�¡³®Ä¡£¯H ]¥(¦^ 5���vÉ¥{»`�X 5�X¯L��¯H 5¤�¡ÂÁ��[¡£¯L®ÂÅÕ¥(¦^ 5�I���X«j¤��X«`�[�[�²ª²¯L¡£«H¤�¯L¡£«`�[�Ö¯×��®³¡Ä´`»H¤t��¡Ä��¯L��ØÙ¯H«j¤r¯L´j�Hµ¿Ú(�[�r¶`®³¤����r¶`´LÅ´H�[��¤(¤r»�¯L¤�¨�¯H ­¤�¡³�[¡°¨�¯j«H¤���¶`���[�¿�[¦^«j¤��[§`¤�ª²¯L¤��[»`¡£«`´$¤�¦~¶�«`���X 5��¤r¯j«`�¿¯H«`�±®³�X¯H �«±«`�[¥'¥(¦^ 5���vµ���$¨� ­�[���X«H¤�¯S�[¦^ª²¨�¶`¤r¯L¤�¡Ä¦`«�¯L®+ª�¦`���[®+¤�»�¯L¤��X¯H¨`¤r¶� ­�[�{¤r»`�t�[�����X«j¤�¡£¯L®?¤r 5�X«`����¡°«Ò¤r»`�t��¯L¤r¯¦^¢`¤r¯L¡£«`�[�׸Ԡ5¦`ªÛ¤�»`��¤;¥(¦��[§�¨��X 5¡£ª��X«j¤��Xµ

Ü�ÝHÞ³ßOàÕá�ßÕárâfàÕã5ݲä�â[ß?ßÕåHæHæ`çXàéèÕá�ê�ëLì�íXà;âfîLèðïLñ�ò?óÕô[õfóÔöj÷røvøXö�ù�àÕçvúÏèÕÝHá]û�â[èéÞ³çXî^âfü^ïLã�Þ³á�îHã�áþýjçXåjîLóê^â[èéÞ³çXî�ÿ

Page 2: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

���������O�]��� lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sðcvg`lnm�s�qLe!qÙxO��u�g`x��XhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�X�LhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|�x!q� � {g`s����v�cvg^lnm!o!p�zjpruwg`xyzjh?l�g��.qLh

Page 3: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

� g ��.g±mOqLg^m!hwq$z`c���o!u�s�q�x!q� � �g`s��!������u��+qLs�qÙx.p�qH��p�uwl zjp�q��]m!h¾z^cvq�pre!q�x�o!lÒ�OqLsgHi� �g^s��!�ÒpreOzjp zÏcfe�uwh��Ïh�qHzjsrxO�×mOqLs¿��qHzHsÒu�x8p�e�qIs[zHx!|`qDgji �� ! � �" �� � ! �#%$ zH|`���� x&�.qLs[��g`x��(' � qLs�l zjx�� ��)�*�+!,�-/. e!qLs�qÖzjsrq0�.u1�?qÙs�uwx�|Íg`m!u�x!uwg^xO�nzj�Og^o!p2 �e!qLpre!qLspre!u¾��cÙzjx�g`s²cLzHx!x!g^pS�Oq�z`cLcXg`o!x�p�q�2iÕg^s²�.�Öcfe!u�h��.srqLxD��u�lnm!hw��qLxycvg`o!x�p�qÙs�uwx�|3 {g`s����u�x¿cvg`x�p�q�4�p�zjx5�±uwx.iÕqÙs�s�u�x!|�pre!qLuws�lnqHzjx�uwx!|�iÕs�g^l p�e�q�cvg`x�p�q�4�p -76 e!uwh�q�zH|`s�qÙqLuwx!|$p�eOzHpz±c[e!uwh8�×eyz`��zj�Og^o!p�z �� mOqLs[cvqÙx.p¬cfeOzHxOcvq�gji�hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|±z9 {g`s�� q�z`c[enp�u�lnq�uwp{g�cLcvo!s��u�x8cXg`x�p�q�4�pL�;:+zHx5�!zjo�qLs�zjx&�<��o!l�zjuÌ� #���)�)�+!, cvg^xOcvhwo&�.qnp�eyzjp¿p�e!qLsrq�u¾�Wx!g0 ¬z�� z��uwlnm!h�qWu�xOcvs�qÙlnqLx�p[zjh= �g^s���>;�.�?>@ �g`s��Çhwq�zjs�x�uwx!|nl�g��.qLh�cvg^o!h���z`c��do!u�s�q±pre!qH��q±l zjx�� {g`s����v�A �e!qLs�q�z`� $ zj|`�©� � qÙs�l�zHx��Ózjx5� � x5��qLs[��g`x #���)�*`�?, cXg`xOcvh�o5�.qnpreOzjp±pre!u¾�²u¾�B oO��p�p�e!q²s�zjp�q~gji�hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|±p�eyzjpC �g`o�h��n�OqSx�qHcvqH�r��zjsr� -

. e!uÌ��s�qH��qHzjs�cfeD �uwh�h?x!g^p�zjxO�E �qLs�p�e�q9��o!qH��p�u�g`x�gjiF �e!qLpre!qLs�uwxycvs�qLl�qLx.p�zjh!h�qHzjsrxG>u�x!|ÇgHi� �g^s��!�WiÕs�g^l cvg`x�p�q�4�p¿z���q�doyzjp�qÙhw�'z^cLcvg`o�x.p��iÕg^sÒpre!q�s[zjprqIgHi²��g�cLzj��o!h¾zHs��z^c��do�u¾��u�p�u�g`x -�� g �qL��qÙsL�� �q2 {g`o!h8�ÇhwuIH�q±p�g�z!�.�^zjxOcvq�p�e!q���p[zHp�q�gji�pre!q�cvg^lnm!o!p�zJ>pruwg`xyzjh�pre!qLg`sr�8gHiWe�gK z� �g^s��¹lnuw|^e.p±�OqÍh�qHzjsrx!q� iÕs�g^l cvg^x.prq�4�p -L6 q�zjuwl prgu�x.��qH��p�u�|�zjprqtpre!u¾��uÌ����o!q²uwx2 �eOzHp�cXg`lnqH��cvh�g���qSprg±p�e!qÐz`cvproOzjhÓ��uwp�oyzjp�u�g`x�mOqLg`m�hwq�i;z`cvqu�xÇh�qHzjsrx!uwx!|D {g`s���lnqHzjx�uwx!|©�$iÕsrg`l cvg^x.prq�4�p -n� � $ zH|`�ÍqLp~zjh -A#���)!*`�?, m�g^uwx�pWg^o!pL�pre!qLs�qzjsrq±z±x.o!l¿�OqLs�gjiþo!x!s�q�zjhwuÌ��pru¾c²z`��m�q�cvp[�tprgnl�zHx.����p�o5��uwqH��gji�h�qHzjsrx!uwx�|3 {g`s����iÕsrg`l cvg^x.prq�4�p -NM uws���pL��mOz^��p���p�o&�.uwqH�Weyz���q�gHiÕp�qLx q�4.m�hwu¾cXuwp�h��Iu�xO��prs�oOcvprq�'��o!� B q�cvp[�preOzjp�pre!qLu�s�p[z^�OHP ¬z`��p�g�hwqHzHs�x0 �g^s��ÍlnqHzHx!uwx!|©�v�5 �e!uwh�qWu�xÍxOzjpro!s[zHh���u�p�oOzHp�uwg^xO��p�e!q��o!� B qHcvp��RQ�|`g©zjh�uÌ�Sm!srqH��o�l�zj�!h��IprgIo!x5��qLs[��p[zjx&� prq�4�pL�Ózjx5�S {g`s���hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|�g�cLcvo!s��lng^s�q{uwx���qLsr�.uÌcvq�gHiÓp�e!uÌ�]|`g©zjh - b�qHcXg`x5�?��pre!q�l�zjprqLs�uÌzjh���o!� B q�cvp[�(hwq�zjs�xWiÕsrg`l�uÌ�þgHiÕp�qLxo!x�xOzjpro!s[zHhwhw���.q���uw|^x!q�np�g±i;z`cXuwhwu�p[zHp�q�pre!qWh�qHzjsrx!uwx!|±gHi�p�e�qSl zjp�qÙs�u¾zHh -A. e!u�s��?�!l zjx��q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p[��eOzL��qD��o!� B q�cvp[�±hwqHzHs�x zÍlnqHzjx�uwx!|IiÕg^snz0H.x�gK �xUcvg`xycvqLm!pÙ�; �e!qLsrqHz`�lng©��p²s�q�zjh; {g`s��!�T {qnqLxOcvg^o!x�p�qLs~zjsrqnuwx�p�srg��.oOcvqJ�Ç�OqHcLzjoy��qnpre!qLs�q¿u¾�²x!g`pzjx!g^p�e!qÙs {g`s��ÒiÕg^stpreOzjp�lnqHzHx!uwx!| -

6 e!u�hwq²p�e!q���qWi;z`cXp�g`s�� u�lnm!h��ÒpreOzjpU {g`s��IhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|ÒuÌ� gHiÕp�qLxÍq�z`��u�qLs�uwxIpre!qWhÌzj�OgK>s�zjp�g^s���p�eyzjxIu�xIpre!q²s�qHzHh� �g`srh��?�Ouwx�g^p�e!qLsC �zL����p�e!q~h¾zH��g^s[zHp�g`sr�Í��uwp�oyzjp�u�g`xÖcLzjxD��qlng^s�qV�.u1W�cXo!hwp -3. e�q3 {g`s����Suwx�p�srg��.oOcvqJ�Ëu�xÇlng©��p²h¾zH�Og`s[zHp�g^s��Ïq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p[��g�?qÙsx!gDe!uwx�p[��prgIp�e�qLuws�l�qHzjx!u�x!|�� -YX x�p�e!q¿g`pre!qLsWeyzjx5�?��z`� $ zj|^�ÏzHx5� b�cvg^p�p #���)�)! �,eOzL��q���e!g �x��!��o!� B qHcvp��]gjiÕprqLxÒeyz���q�q�4.mOqHcvp�zjpruwg`xy�%zH�Og`o!pZ �g`s��×l�qHzjx!u�x!|��Ó�Oz`��q�×g^xpre!q� �g`s��!��p�e�qLl���qÙhw��qH� -[X x!q$mOzjsrp�u¾cXo!h¾zHs���qLs[��uwg`x�gHi(pre!u¾��uÌ�; �e!qLxDzjx�g`h8�2q�4�u¾��p�u�x!| {g`s��IuÌ� |^uw��qLxÖzÒx!q� lnq�zjx!u�x!|¿z`��z¿lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c�q�4�p�qÙxO��u�g`xIgHi{uwp[��g`h���lnqHzHx!uwx!|����oOcfeDz^� pre!q� �g`s��P\�]G^`_Íuwx�pre!q²m!e!s[z^��qa\�]�^8bZc!dYe�f5g�higkj -

6 qS�OqL|©zjxDg`o!s�s�qH��qHzjs�cfe�u�x.prqLs�qH��p�q�±uwx�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾ctq�4�p�qÙxO��u�g`xO��gHi(g^h��Y {g`s��!� -. e!q9lys[��p$q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p{uwxIpre!u¾��mOzjmOqLs²u¾��q�4�cvhwoy��uw��qÙhw��cvg`xOcXqLs�x!qJ�Y �uwpreÍhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|ngHipre!u¾�²�`zHs�u�qLp�� -m� g �qL��qLsÙ�� �q��OqHcLzjl�qncvg^x.��uwxycvq�Íp�eOzHp±p�e!q�m!srg�cvqH����qH�±z`�r��g�cvuÌzjprq� �u�p�e8pre!u¾�aH�uwx5�Ïgji� {g`s��'hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|m �z`�¿x!g`p±iÕo!x5�!zHlnqLx�p[zHhwhw�n�.u1�?qÙs�qLx�p±p�eOzHx¹p�e!qh�qHzjsrx!uwx!|±gHi{cvg^lnm!hwqÙp�qLh��Wx!q� � �g^s��!�X��x�qLg`h�g`|`uÌ��l�� -A. e!q²g`x!h��D�.u1�?qÙs�qLxOcXq�u¾��p�eOzHp�uwp

Page 4: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

uÌ�þq�z`��u�qLs�p�g~uwx5�.oycvqtpre!q�iÕqHzjpro!s�qH�(gHiÓx!q� 8l�qHzjx!u�x!|²uwx¿p�e!q$cvg^x.prq�4.p�gji�zSl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s -. e!qÙs�qviÕg^s�q��Op�e!q¿��qHcvg^x5�Iq�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p{uwxÍpre!u¾��mOzjmOqLs~cvg^lnmOzHs�qH��hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|¿gji{x!qLg^hwgK>|^u¾��l � # x�q� o {g`s��!� , zjx5��lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� -

X x!qÍl�z B g^sn|`g©zjh~gji±pre!u¾�¿s�qH��qHzjs�cfe¹uÌ� prgN�.qL��qLh�g`m¹z'cvg^lnm!o!p�zjpruwg`xyzjh�lng���qLhgHi�e!g /��oycfe�hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|�p[zH�qH��m!h¾z^cvq -36 qV �uwhwh[�.qH��cXs�uw�Oq�zIcvg^lnm!o!p�zjpruwg`xyzjh(lng���qLh �e!uÌcfe�eOz^�t�OqLqLx��.qL��qÙhwg`mOq�nu�xIp�e�q � k . >qp zHs[c[e!uwprqHcvpro!s�q #;� x5�.qÙs[��g^x0'r:OqL��uwqLsrq����)�)�*?,�-Z. e!u¾�Óu¾�Ózjx�zjs[c[e!u�p�qHcvpro!s�qA �e!uÌcfe±eyz`�]�OqLqLx±oy��q�WprgSl�g��.qLh�zs �u��.q��^zHs�uwqÙp��²gHicvg^|`x!u�p�u���qSm�e!qLx!g^lnqLxOzWu�xOcvhwo&�.uwx!|¿l�zHp�e!qLl zjp�uÌcLzjhOm!srg`�!h�qLl ��g^hw��uwx!|���h�u¾��p�l�qLlng`sr�����p�s[zHp�qL|^��c[e!g`uÌcvq���zjxOzHhwg^|`u¾cÙzjh�s�q�z`��g^x!uwx�|!�Ozjx&�2�rcvuwqÙx.pru�l+c�s�qHz^��g^x!uwx!| -tX o!s�m�s�uwxycvuwmOzHhm!o�s�mOg���q%iÕg`sF�.qL��qÙhwg`m�uwx!|{g`o!sÓlng��.qLh�u�x²p�e!uÌ��zjs[c[e!u�p�qHcvpro!s�q�u¾�?p�g�qH��p[zj��hwu¾��eWpreOzjp�pre!qLs�quÌ�Wx!g`pre!uwx!|n�.u1�?qÙs�qLx�p±zH��g^o!p2 {g`s��'hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|Íp�eyzjx8pre!qH��q2g^p�e!qÙs±�`zHs�u�q�'cvg`|^x!uwpruw��qiÕo!xycvp�u�g`xO� -b�u�xOcvq±g`o�sulys[��p²q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p�uÌ�Ðq�4!cvh�oO��u���qLhw��cvg^xOcvqLsrx!q�P �uwpreÍlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[��z^�²z

��g`o!s�cvq�gji�x!q� v �g^s��!�±zHx5�Ïq�4�p�qLx5���So!x5��qLs[��p[zjx&�.uwx!|�gji$lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌc×m�s�g�cvqH�r��u�x!|!� {qT �u�hwh+��qÙ|`uwxD �u�p�eDz×��s�uwqXiÓs�qL��uwq� ¹gHi�m!srqL�.u�g`oO��srqH��q�zjs[c[eng^xIlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌc pre!qLg^s�� -

wyxAzU{P|�}3~0����zT�7zU��x(�Z� }3� � zs�F�9����}ax;�

�v� g�e@�R��f��?^Wu¾��zÒs�e!qÙp�g`sru¾cslO|^o!s�q~p�eOzHptq�4�m!hÌzjuwxy�tzV�.g`l zjuwx�����l�zKH�uwx!|V��uws�q�cvp�g^su�x5�.uwsrqHcvp�srqviÕqLs�qÙxOcvq�prgnzHx!g`pre!qLs��.g^l�zju�x -�� lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�eOz`��pE �g¿p�qLsrl��R��p�e!qVe@�R�=���# e%�?^�dGg�e , zjx5�Íp�e�q0�Kg�f����R�`g # \��?]�^��Rg ,�-�. e!q±p�g^m!u¾c±gji{p�e�qÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�u¾��p�eyzjp� �e!u¾c[euÌ� q�4�m!hÌzjuwx�q�np�e!srg`o!|^eÍp�e!q~lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s -�. e!q~��qLe!uÌcvhwq�u¾��p�e!q��.g`l zjuwx�prg2 �e!u¾c[e�p�e!qprg`m!uÌctu¾��cvg^lnmOzHs�q� -F� xIzWl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sÙ�.pre!qLs�q$u¾�%g^x!q # zHpth�qHz`��p , cXg`lnlng^x×iÕq�zjp�o�s�q�prg�Og`preÍp�e!q~��qLe!uÌcvhwq²zHx5�Ip�e�qWp�g^m!u¾c^�� �e!u¾c[eIuÌ�tcLzHhwh�q�np�e!q�d?^��?]�c��Igji�pre!qWl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s -� x�p�e!q~zHm!e!g`sru¾��l �7� � g���\ � �?c�g��j�!p�e�qS��qÙe!u¾cvh�qtuÌ� � �?c5gk�nzjx5��p�e!q²prg`m!uÌcSu¾�Ue@� � g -. e!q$|`s�g^o!x5�ÒgHi(pre!u¾�(lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�u¾��p�e!q���oOzjh�uwp��±gji7�=^�g������?] \�c5g�\�\²cvg^lnlng^xWp�g~�Og`p�eð��!o�p�m�g©����uw�!h��2l�g`s�qÐ��zjh�uwqLx�p�prgÒpre!q²��qLe!uÌcvhwq -

X o!snsrqH��qHzHs[c[e��; �e!uÌcfe¹uÌ�ÒcXg`xOcvqÙs�x!q�¡ �u�p�e e!g �zÇx!q� l�qHzjx!u�x!|�u¾�¿cvs�qHzHp�q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHhwhw�©�foy��qH�¢ �eOzHp£ {q�cLzHhwh5�?c��R��f��?^R��� � g�e%�R��f��?^�\ -Ó� x¤�?c��R��f��?^k��� � g�e@�R��f��?^# g`s�z � g�e%�R��f��?^k���9^�g`_gk^�gkcGe@�������Gg�\���^k�¥�5e@���?c , uÌ��zWlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�u�x2 �e!uÌcfenpre!q���qLe�u¾cvh�qsrqLm!h¾z^cvqH�?pre!q�prg`m!uÌc%uwx~p�e!q(�.u¾�rcvg`o�s[��q©�jh�u`H�q�uwx¤e¦f5gZ�`g�d��O_C�Ue%�?jk�`g -Z� x~p�e!uÌ��q�4.m!srqH����uwg^x��pre!q±p�g^m!u¾c # �e!u¾c[eÍu¾��z^cvp�oyzjhwh��ÍzncXg`xOcvqÙm!p�p�eyzjp²eOz`��x!g�g^p�e!qLs²xOzHlnq±zHx5�m�.qLx!g^p�qH�g^x!q²gji�pre!q²m�qÙ|���p�eOzHp���oO��p�zjuwxDz±p[zH�!hwq , uÌ��s�qviÕqÙs�s�qJ�Òp�g¿�.��p�e!q²��qLe!uÌcvhwq��Ig�d -

Page 5: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

§©¨«ª�¬A­T®C¯i°/±S¯�²y­s°&¨[®C¨´³Cµ�¶E¯�³� qÙs�eOzHmO�(p�e!q�lng©��p�i;zjlng^oO�(zHx5�iÕsrq��o!qLx�p�hw�²srqviÕo!p�qJ�Wp�e!qLg^s��~gji+lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�cvg^lnm!s�qk>e!qÙxO��u�g`x�u¾�tb�q�zjs�h�q?Q³��qLs�srg`sE>5srqHcvgH��qLs��¿p�e�qLg`sr� # b�q�zjs�h�q�� ��)�+J)�,�- b�qHzjsrhwq²cXh¾zju�lnq�±p�eOzHpL� �e!qÙx±cvg^x.iÕs�g^x.prq�T �u�p�e±z�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^sL�Hm�qÙg`m!h�qilOs���pÓp�s��²prgto!x&�.qLs[��p[zHx5�Wp�e!q¬��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqh�uwp�qÙs[zjh�hw����zjx5�+��u�xÍcLz^��qWgHi�i;zjuwh�o!s�q©�!p�e!qL��hwg�g�H�iÕg`s$zÒlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh+uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qÙp[zjpruwg^x -. e!q¿zHm!m!srg`m!sru¾zjprqLx!qH�r��gji�pre!q±hwu�p�qLs�zjhÓlnqHzHx!uwx!|¿u¾���.u¾cvp�zjprq�I�.��pre!q¿cvg`x�p�q�4.p -9. e!qsrqHcvg`|^x!uwpruwg^xÍgji�znlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s²cXg`xO��u¾��p���gji�pre!s�qÙq±��prqLmO�k�slOs[��pL�ÓznhwuwprqLs[zHh(uwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp[z�>pruwg`x�gji¬p�e!q���qÙx.prqLxOcvq±uÌ�t�!o!u�hwp�·���qHcXg`x5�?��pre!u¾��uwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp[zHp�uwg^xÍu¾��l�zHp[c[e!q�IzH|�zHuwxO��ppre!qncXg`x�p�q�4�p�·Óp�e!u�s��?��u½i¬x!gÍcXg`xO��u¾��prqLx�pSl zjp[c[e!u�x!|ncÙzjxÏ�Oq±iÕg`o!x5�+��z l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cLzHhu�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`x�u¾�²cvg`xy��u���qLs�q� -I� cvg`srg`h�h¾zjsr�Ígji$p�e!uÌ��p�e!qLg^s���u¾�²p�eOzHpWmOqLg`m�hwq¿p[zKH�qh�g`x!|^qLs�p�g±o!x&�.qLs[��p[zHx5�2lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHh�o�p�p�qÙs[zjxycvqH��p�eyzjxIprg±o!x5�.qÙs[��p�zjx5��hwu�p�qLs�zjhOo!pO>prqLs[zHxOcvqH� -�¸ o!p¿p�e!qDmO����cfe�g`hwg^|`uÌcLzjh�qL��u���qLxOcvq #OX srp�g`x�����b�c[eOzjh�hwqLsrpL�Zp qL��x!g^h��!�X��'� x�p�g©�v� ��)?+* · � x!e!g���t:Ou�l�z.�A'�k{zjs�srg`h�h5� ��)�*¹ ·²b�e!uwx B gm' }I��qLs��v� ��)�*?+�, ��e!g ��preOzjp±u�x l zjx�����uwproOzjpruwg^xO�WuwpV�.g�q��Wx!g`p±p�zKH�q�hwg^x!|`qLs±prgÍo!x5�.qÙs[��p�zjx5�ÏlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c��qLx.prqLxOcvq�� -

X s�prg`x��ÒqLp¬zjh -�#r��)?+*�, ��e�gK {q�n��o!� B qHcvp��%pE �gcvg`x�p�q�4�p[�]iÕg^s�p�e!q$��zHlnq²��qÙx.prqLxOcvq?�z�hwu�p�qLs�zjh�uwx5��oOcvuwx�|²cvg`x�p�q�4.p�zjx5�¿z�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcLzjh�uwx5��oOcvuwx�|²cvg`x�p�q�4.p -£M g^s%u�xO��p�zjxOcXq��pre!q���qLx.prqLxOcvq¤�¢f5gif5g�c�\��R�1]���º?g��Vc��?��\��`�1�U �z^�þm�s�qHcvqJ�.q��qLuwpre!qLsÓ�.�~ztmyz`���rzj|^q²zj�Og`o�p��g`lnq�c[e!uÌc�H�qLxy�tg`xUz2i;zjs�lÖ�]g`s±���'zImOz^���rzj|`qÖzj�Og`o�pnz0 �g^lnqLx�QÄ�ScXhwo!�Ïl�qLqLp�u�x!| -. e!q zjo!pre!g`s��×lnq�z`��o�s�q�ÇsrqHz���uwx!|Dp�uwl�qH�tiÕg`s±p[zHs�|^qLp¿��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�²zjx&� g^�!p[zHuwx!qJ� x�g�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvqI�OqLpE �qÙqLx8lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHh�zHx5� h�uwprqLs[zHhtp�zjs�|^qLp[� -»� gK {qL��qLsÙ�; �e!qLx¹pre!qL�l�z!�.q�pre!q²m!s�u�g`s�cvg^x.prq�4.p���e!g`srp # g^x!q±��qLx.prqLxOcvq$g`s�hwq���� , �!p�e!qÙ�ÒiÕg`o!x&�2z¿��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvq²uwxÍs�q�z��.u�x!|np�u�lnqH�%iÕg^s�p�e!q~pE �g2H�uwx5��� gHi�p�zjsr|`qLp�� -�� x!e!g�'qLp$zjh -7#���)�*¹G,srqLm!hwuÌcLzjprq�Ip�e�u¾�W��p�o5���ÏzHx5�Çg`��p[zju�x!q�'��u�lnuwhÌzjs�s�qH��o!hwp�� -�. e!qL�ÊzjhÌ��gÍcXg`hwh�qHcvprq�IqL��qlngH��qLl¿qLx�p=�!zjp�z iÕg`s(pre!q�cXs�uwpru¾cLzHh� {g`s���� # q - | - f5gkc�\�iÕg^s]pre!q�q�4�zjl�m!hwq�zH�Ogj��q , ·`pre!qLs�q ¬z`�(x!g��.u1�+qLs�qLxycvq��OqLpE �qÙqLxWpre!q��.u�q� �uwx�|�p�u�lnqH��iÕg`s�p�e!qH��q� �g^s��!�(uwx±pre!q�h�uwprqLs[zHh!zHx5�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c±cvg^x.prq�4.p�� -¤. e!qH��q�s�qH��o!hwp��u {qLs�q¿uwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp�q�Iu�xËi;zL��g^sSgHi�hwu�p�qLs�zjh�zHx5�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c(m!s�g�cXqH����qH�(��qÙuwx!|²��uwlnu�h¾zHsL�Hzjx&�±zj|�zHuwxO��p{z���p�zj|`q�lng��.qÙh? �e!u¾c[e±m!s�qJ�.u¾cvp��preOzjp�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcLzjh+��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��p[zH�qSh�g`x!|^qLs�p�g�cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLx5� -

$ g^pÒg^x!hw�N�.g'��o!� B qHcvp��Ò��g`lnqÙp�uwl�qH�Wz^cLcvqH�r�×pre!qIlnq�zjx!u�x!|ÍgjizÇlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s¿z^�i;z^��p~z`�²p�e!q¿hwu�p�qLs�zjh(lnq�zjx!u�x!|!�?��o!p²p�e!q¿lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcWlnqHzjx�uwx!|�cÙzjx�uwx�p�qLs�iÕqLs�q� �uwp�epre!q�hwuwprqLs[zHh�lnqHzHx!uwx!| -¡¼ hwoOc�H!���OqLs�|�� ¼ hwu8�.qHz���zjx5� ¸ g�g�H�uwx #���)!*`�?, eOz�� ��o!� B q�cvp[�B o5��|`qWpre!q²hwu�p�qLs�zjh?prs�o!preIgHi���qLx.prqLxOcvq���gji�pre!q�iÕg`s�l�½¾��\�¿ - b�o�� B qHcvp[��prg�g�HDhwg`x�|`qLsprgWs�q B qHcvp���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�(p�eOzHp�l�z��.q$��qÙxO��q�l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cLzHhwh��Wp�eyzjx�x!g`xy��qLxO��q²��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�X�zHhw�OqLuwp±�Og^p�e8�OqLu�x!|Íhwu�p�qLs�zjh�hw�Ii;zjhÌ��q # q - | -ÁÀ � � gUÂ��?j�\��?^�g�Â��?�`�¥\ ,�-Áà qÙ�!�rzjs #���)�*!)�,q�4�p�qÙx5�.q� ¼ hwoOc�H����OqLs�|¿qLp$zjh - Q³��srqH��o�hwp[��uwxÖzjxDuwx!|^qLx!uwg^oO��q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p -A� qWl�zHx!uwm�>o!hÌzjprq�Ò�Og`pre2pre!q²hwu�p�qLs�zjh+zjx5�nlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c�p�sro!p�e�gHi���qLx.prqLxOcvq��(½¾��\U¿¬�.���Ò�^zHs���uwx!|

Page 6: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

pre!qDcvg`x�p�q�4�p±p�eyzjp¿m!s�qHcXq�.q�Çpre!qLl -Á. e�oO�±p�e!q�p�zjs�|^qLp���qLx�p�qLxycvq�cvg^o!h��Ï�OqI�Og`preh�uwp�qÙs[zjh�hw�Özjx5�Çl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cLzHhwh��Ip�sro!qng^sW�Og`pre h�uwprqLs[zHhwhw�Özjx5��lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cÙzjhwh��2i;zHh¾��q# cvg`x!|^s�o!qÙx.p�cXg`x5�.u�p�u�g`xO� , �tg^s�hwuwprqLs[zHhwh��Ïp�sro!q�zjx5�¹lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh�hw�Çi;zHh¾��qÍg`s�hwu�p�qLsE>zHhwhw�Ïi;zHh¾��q�zHx5�¹lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cÙzjhwh��Ïp�sro!q # u�xOcvg^x!|`sro!qLx�p�cvg`x&�.uwpruwg`xy� ,�-Ä� qÍg^�!p[zHuwx!q���e!g`srp�qLs B o&�.|`qLl�qLx.p±pruwlnq��ÐiÕg`s�p�e!q�cvg^x!|`sro!qLx�pncXg`x5�.u�p�u�g`xO�ÒpreOzjx8iÕg^snp�e�qÍuwxOcvg^xG>|^s�o!qLx�p¿g`x!qH�X�; �e!uÌcfeUzjs�|^o!qH�×iÕg^sÒpre!qIu�xO��qÙmOzjs�zj�!u�hwuwp��ÏgHi²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcnzjx&�8hwuwprqLs[zHhm!srg�cvqH�r��uwx�| -Dà qL����zjs #r��)�*!)�, srqLmOqHzjprq�Ëpre!q¿q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p�zHx5�ÇlnqHz^��o!srq�Ícvg^lnm!s�qk>e!qÙxO��u�g`x�p�u�lnqH�R·�e!q~g`�!p�zju�x!q�Òi;z`��p�qH��ptsrqHz��.u�x!|±gji%��qLx�p�qLxycvqH�%preOzjpC �qÙs�q²�Og`p�eDhwu�p�qLsE>zHhwhw�Özjx5�ÍlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh�hw��p�sro!q -V. e!q±x!q�4.p�i;z`��p�qH��p²h¾zjprqLxOcvu�qH�s {qLs�qWiÕg^sW��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�preOzjp� �qÙs�q±qLu�p�e!qLs$hwuwprqLs[zHhwh��2g^s²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cÙzjhwh��np�sro!q��Ózjx&�Ç��hwg �qH��p²s�qHz!�.uwx!|�pruwlnqH�iÕg^s���qLx�p�qLxycvqH��p�eyzjp� �qÙs�q²�Og`p�eDlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcLzjh�hw�¿zjx&�2hwu�p�qLs�zjh�hw�Wi;zjhÌ��q -

¼ uw�!�y� #���)�)� ?, m�qÙs�iÕg`srlnq�²zjx±q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p¢ �e�qLs�q¬��o!� B qHcXp[��eOz��Wlng^s�q�s[zHm!u��~z`c�>cvq����%prgWh�uwp�qÙs[zjhOlnq�zjx!u�x!|�� -´� p{��e!g �qJ�Òp�eOzHpL��uwxnpre!q²cLz^��q�gHi�zjxOzHm!e!g`sru¾c�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�X� �e!qÙx pre!qnprg`m!uÌc gHi�pre!qnlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s~u¾�Sx�g`p¿q�4.m�hwu¾cXuwp�h���lnqLx�p�uwg^x!q�Íuwx'z���qÙx.prqLxOcvq���!o�p�uwp�uÌ�þsrqviÕqLsrs�q�±q�4�cvhwoO��uw��qLh��²�.�±pre!qt��qÙe!u¾cvh�q��Hp�e!q�srqHz���uwx!|~p�uwl�qH�ðiÕg^s�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾co!prp�qLs�zjxOcXqH�tzHs�q±h�g`x!|^qLs�p�eyzjxIiÕg`s$q�do�uw�^zjh�qLx.p�h�uwprqLs[zHh�o!p�prqLs[zHxOcvqH�X��qL��qÙxIu½iþp�e!qcvg`xG>prq�4.p$u¾�tlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sE>���o!m!mOg`srp�uw��q -9. e!q±prg`m!uÌcL�tgHi�p�e�q±lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�tu�x ¼ u��!�O�kQ?q�4�m�qÙsO>u�lnqLx�pWeOz!�8��qÙqLxÛzjhI �zL�!�±uwx�p�srg��.oOcvqJ� uwx p�e!q�cXg`x�p�q�4�p±m!s�q�cvq�.u�x!|Çpre!q���qÙx.prqLxOcvq -M g`s~uwxO��p[zHxOcvq��(u�xÏp�e!q ��qLx�p�qLxycvq��¢f5g¤��^�g�� � �=]�Å��?���?c�Æ eU\�f��?hÇ]J�O�(pre!q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s��^�g�� � �=]�Å srqviÕqLs�srq�8p�g zÏ�Og4.qLs�uwx�p�s�g���oOcvq�¹uwxÛzHxAzHx.prqLs�u�g`snmOz^���rzj|`q -r6 g`s�prelnqÙx.pruwg`x�uwx!|²u¾��pre!q�i;z`cvp�preOzjp ¼ uw�!�y�RQ!lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌct��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH��eOz��nx!g¿mOg��r��uw��hwq²hwu�pO>qLs�zjh�u�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`x -ÁX x�u¾��e�u�zjx&�8}Io!srm!e.� #���)�)^��, srqLm!hwuÌcLzjprq� ¼ uw���O�RQ£lOx&�.uwx!|©�R·pre!qL�DzjhÌ��gnm!srgH��q�2preOzjp�pre!g���q±s�qH��o!hwp��s �qÙs�qWx�g`p²zHx�zjs�pru½i;z^cvp�gji{u�xO��oGW cvu�qLx.p���p�g^s��H�x!g �hwq��|`qng^s±h¾z`c�HÍgji$s�qXiÕqLs�qLx�p~��zHhwuwqÙxOcvq -�� x'zjx!g^p�e!qÙs±q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ� X x!u¾��e!u�zHx5�}Io!srm!e��Ïlng��.u1lOq�Çpre!q�p[zjsr|`qLp���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�²p�g�eOzL��qnp�e�q iÕg^s�l ½È��\2¿ # u - q - �¢f5gj��KÉ?g�^a��\a�D��^�g�� � �=]�Å ,�-UM g`s�p�e�qH��q~lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�v�Op�e�qL��g`�!p�zjuwx�q�Ix!g¿s�qHz!�.uwx!|�p�uwl�q�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvq��OqLpE �qLqÙxnlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc�zjx5��q��o!uw�^zjh�qLx�p�hwu�p�qLs�zjh+��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH� -

� x~cvg`xOcXhwoO��uwg`xð�Luwp���qLqLl��Op�eOzHp(b�qHzHs�hwqF �z`�� �s�g^x!|�uwx�e!uÌ��z`�r��o!lnm�p�uwg^x²p�eOzHp�hwuwprqLs[zHhu�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`x�lÒoO��p~zjh` ¬zL�!��m!srqHcvq�.q¿lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌc`���!o!p±preOzjp��g`l�qLp�u�lnqH��hwuwprqLs[zHhm!srg�cvqH�r��uwx�|±l�zL�±m!s�qHcXq�.q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c�m!srg�cvqH����uwx!| -;X x!q²cLzHx2u�l�zj|^uwx!q�qÙuwp�e�qLs�p�eOzHph�uwp�qÙs[zjh�g^stl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾ctu�x.prqLs�m�s�qLp�zjp�u�g`xO��zjsrqWm!o�s[��o�q�2u�xImOzHs[zjh�hwqLh� �u�p�eÖ��g`l�qLp�u�lnqH�g^x!q�cvg`l�uwx!|�u�xW�OqviÕg`srq�p�e!q{g`pre!qLsL�^g`s(preOzjp���o!� B qHcvp����^zHs�u¾zH�!hw�~c[e!g�g���q�p�g�m�o!s[��o!q�p�e!qh�uwp�qÙs[zjhþzjx5�'��g^lnqLpruwlnqH��p�e�qÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cWuwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp[zHp�uwg^xÊlys[��p -P� p~u¾��x!g`prg`sruwg`oy��hw�eOzHs��'p�gÊ��qLmOzHs[zHp�q���qÙs�u¾zHh�iÕs�g^l mOzjs�zjh�hwqLh�lng���qLh¾�WgHi~cvg`|^x!uwpruwg^x # q - | -Ë. g �xO��qLx5�?���)�+�¹�,�-�Ì u�p�e!qLs�pre!qWmyzjs[zHhwh�qLh?g^s���qLs�uÌzjh�uwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp[zHp�uwg^x�zjh�hwg ���oO� prgÒl zKH�q$��qLxO��qWgHipre!u¾�(mOzHp�p�qÙs�xngHiÓs�qH��o!hwp�� -´� x���g^lnqtq�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p[�?pre!q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c�uwx�p�qÙs�m!srqLp[zHp�uwg^x±u¾�zL�^zju�h¾zj��hwq~z`��i;z`��ptg^xÍzL��qLs[zH|`q~z`��p�e�qSh�uwprqLs[zHh #OX srp�g`x��nqLp�zHh - � ��)�+J*�, ��zjx5��uwx�g`pre!qLsq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p[��uwp~u¾�²zL�`zHuwhÌzj�!h�qnh¾zHp�qLs #O¼ u��!�O�v� ��)�)! �,�- b�g^lnqLpruwlnqÙ�tp�e�qÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c

¹

Page 7: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

u�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`xm �uwhwh���q�zjp±g`o�pWp�e�qÒh�uwp�qÙs[zjh�m!srg��.oOcvu�x!|Iu�x.prqLs�iÕqÙs�qLxOcXq±p�gIpre!q¿hwuwprqLs[zHhu�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`x #O¼ hwoyc�H����OqLsr|ÒqLpÐzjh - � ��)!*`��,�-9� i�pre!q±��o!� B qHcvp$cLzHxIm!srg�cvqH����p�e!q¿��qLxG>prqLxOcvq� �u�p�e±qLu�p�e!qLs�p�e!q�hwu�p�qLs�zjh�g`s�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc�uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qLp�zjpruwg`xð�`p�e!qÙ�9 �uwh�h.�Oq�i;z`��p�qH��p#@à qÙ�!�rzjsL� ��)�*!)�,�-

X x!qÍcÙzjx¹z^����o!lnq�p�eOzHpL��z`�¿zÇlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s±|©zjuwxy�i;zHlnuwh�u¾zjsruwp����Óuwp�cvg`lnq��Sp�gÊ��qm!srg�cvqH�r��q��z`��s[zHm!u���hw��zHx5�nm�qÙs�eOzHmO� l�g`s�q$s[zjm�u��.h��np�eOzHx�p�e!q²hwu�p�qLs�zjh+lnqHzjx�uwx!| -(� �z±lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�z^c��do�uws�q���uwxOcvsrqHz`��q�Òi;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p����`p�e�qT {g`s��2s�q�z`c[e!qH�%pre!qWmOg^uwx�p� �e!qLs�qu�p B oO��pneOz^�nzjx!g^p�e!qÙsnlnqHzHx!uwx!| -�� x&�.qLq�?�{p�e!qLsrqÍzHs�qÍz�hwg`p¿gji� {g`s����Òuwx xOzjpro!s[zHhhÌzjx!|^oOzj|^qH��p�eOzHpWzHs�q¿��oOcfeÍl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cLzHh]q�4.prqLxO��u�g`xO��gji{g`h8�IlnqHzjx�uwx!|©�v�?�Oz^��q�Ig^xlng^s�q~g`s²hwqH�r�tg`����uwg`oy����u�lnuwhÌzjs�u�p�u�qH���OqLpE �qLqLxDpE �gDcvg`xycvqLm!p�� -�� p$u¾�tgHiÕp�qLx�p�e!q¿cÙz`��qpreOzjp²zHx�zjxOzHhwg^|`�Í|`u���qH��s�uÌ��q~p�gnpre!q¿��zHlnq²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^stu�xÍ��qÙ��qLs[zHh]hÌzjx!|^oOzj|^qH� " hwuIH�qu�x8p�e�q�cvg`lnl�g`x!h��ÇlnqÙp0Í��`g�d8gHi¿zÇp�zj�!h�qÎÇg`snÍÏ_����e±gjizÏe!uwh�h�Î.�{g`snqL��qÙx8uwx p�e!qh�qH���±g`���.u�g`oO��cLz`��qH�×gHi~oO��u�x!|Ï��qLsr�O�×h�u`H�qnpre!q Ì x!|`h�u¾��eÇ����e@��f¹g`s¤d?^��K\E�¹p�gÏlnq�zjx]�c��Ggk^�\ke%�?c�� # �th�hwl�zHx!x�� ��)�Ð�Ð?,�- �thwh�l�zjx!x #���)�Ð�Ð?, lnqÙx.pruwg`xy�×g^p�e!qLs�u�x.prqLs�qH��p�u�x!|q�4�zjl�m!hwqH�±gji� �g^s��!��gji±l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾c�g`s�u�|`u�x�� pre!qm �g`s��UiÕg^sme%�?c�d ]&g[�²p�e�qÇg^s�|�zHxgHi±��mOqLqHc[e�����p[zHx5�!�ÒiÕg`sÑ�1�?c�d?]���dGg�uwx8l zjx�� � x5��gK> Ì o�s�g`mOqHzHxAzHx5� M uwx!x�gK>­�t|`sru¾zjxhÌzjx!|^oOzj|^qH�R·±p�e�q� {g`s��¹iÕg`sIpre!qm�=]J�=�`�WgHi±pre!qÇqÙ��qÇu�xÒ:+zHp�uwx # �=]��=�`�`�Ó� , �±b�mOzHx!u¾��e# c��KÔc�� , � � g`srp�o!|^o!qH��q #�� gkc���c�� , zjx5�±g`pre!qLs(hÌzjx!|^oOzj|^qH�%uÌ�]p�e!q��rzjlnqZ �uwpre±p�e!q� {g`s����iÕg^s��1�`e�eÏ�`gZd?��^��+zjx5�¿cvg`l�qH�ðiÕsrg`l�p�e!q�Í��^zj|^o!q�s�q���qLl¿�!h¾zHxOcvq(�OqLpE {qLqLx±z²c[e!uwh8�²zjx5�±p�e!qlnu�x.o�p�q�lO|`o!srq²s�qRÕOq�cvp�q�¿uwx�p�e!q²qL��qJÎG·.l zjx��3 {g`s���� eOzL��q²zHx.prs�g^m�g^lng`srm!e!uÌcÐg^s�u�|`uwx# q - | - Íc5g���º�gji�z��Og`p�prhwqÎ��sÍ!gk��g¿gji z2s�u���qLs�Î��;Í � �?]?e�fÏgji z2sruw��qLs�ÎÒqLp[c -�, �+g`sL�Óp�e!qg^p�e!qLsC �zL�Dzjsrg`o!x&� " �g^s��!�U��qLx!g`pruwx!|¿mOzHs�p[��gji{e.o�l�zjx��Og��.�Iu�x!uwpru¾zHhwhw�¿eOz!�Ix!g`xG>zHx.prs�g`mOg^lng`srm!e!u¾c²lnqHzHx!uwx!|©� # q - | -a� ]�\��R�`g²iÕg`s�lÖ:+zjpruwx � ]�\���]��Ó] \X��lnqHzHx!uwx�|D�1�`eÏe��`g^���eR· � �!zjlÑQ³�a�R�?�5�`g¿qLp�c -�,�- b�g`lnq¿gji�pre!q¿x!q� �lnqHzHx!uwx�|���gji$��oOcfen �g`s��!�WcXg�q�4.uÌ��p �u�p�e�p�e!q²g^h��.qLs�l�qHzjx!u�x!|��X�.g^p�e!qLs���s�qLm�h¾z`cXqSpre!qLl -� ��zjxÍg^h��Y {g`s��Iz`c��do!u�s�qH��z±x!q� Alnq�zjx!u�x!|!�!u�ptuÌ� srqHz`��g`xOzH�!hwq~p�g�z^����o�lnq²p�eOzHp

��o!� B qHcvp��Ò��e!g`o!h8�8x!gÏh�g`x!|^qLs���o��?qÙs�zÏcvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLxO��uwg`xN�.qkl+cvuwp -Û� �Òp�e�qIp�u�lnqnprgcvg^lnm!srqLe!qLx5�¿z¿��qLx�p�qLxycvqU �uwpreDzjxDzjxOzHm!e!g^s�u¾c²lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�zHm!m!s�g©z`c[e!qH��p�e!q²pruwlnq�prgcvg^lnm!srqLe!qLx5�¿��qÙx.prqLxOcvqU �u�p�e�z±cXg`x���qLx.pruwg^xOzjh= �g`s��?�.pre!q~��o!� B q�cvp�l¿oO��p��Oq~z`c���o!u�sO>u�x!|²ztx!q� ÏlnqHzHx!uwx!|�iÕg`s�p�e!q{lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s -7. e.oy�v�? �q¬cLzjx±prs[z`cXq�lnqHzHx!uwx�|�z^c��do�u¾��u�p�u�g`x �u�p�e!g^o!p(q�4�m!hwuÌcvuwprhw�$z`�EH.u�x!|²��o�� B qHcvp[�Óp�g²��p[zjprq�p�e!q�l�qHzjx!u�x!|�gji+p�e!q� {g`s�� -´. e!uÌ�£ �uwh�hzHhwhwg 'oO�(p�g$|`qLp�zHs�g^o!x5�Òpre!q�cvs�u�p�uÌcvu¾��lAgjiðmOz`��p%q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p[�X�R �e!uÌcfea ¬z`�(p�eyzjp(pre!qL� {qLs�q²cXg`hwh�qHcvpruwx!|~q�4.m�hwu¾cXuwp�lnqHz^��o!srqH�%gHi´ {g`s��nlnq�zjx!u�x!|±zHx5�I��g±l�z��.q$p�e!q²hwq�zjs�x�uwx!|gHi� �g^s�� l�qHzjx!u�x!|��Wpre!qD��o!� B q�cvp�QÄ�Wp[z`�EH -N. e�oO�v��g^o!salOs[��pÒq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p²uwx���g`hw��qJ�srqLmOqHzjprq�Ëm�s�qH��qLx.p�zjpruwg`x�gji$zD �g^s��ÍoO��q�Êz`�WzHx'zjxyzjm!e!g^s�uÌcÒlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uwx��^zjsruwg`oy���qLx.prqLxOcvq���zjx5�Ícvg^lnmOzHs�q��cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLxO��uwg`x�gHi�p�e!q���q±��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�; �uwpreÍ��u�lnuwhÌzjs���qLxG>prqLxOcvqH�C �e!u¾c[e0�.u8�Ix!g`p²u�x.��g^hw��q� �g^s��!��lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh�hw�nq�4.prqLx5�.q��p�g�eOzL��q±znx!q� lnq�zjx!u�x!| -

Page 8: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

×LØ��SzUx;|Ù zT�V�ÛÚ

. e!q±q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p� �z^�²cvg`xOcXqLs�x!qJ�P �uwp�e�cXg`lnmOzHs�u�x!|nhwu�p�qLs�zjh�zjx5�ÍlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcW��qLxG>prqLxOcvq{o!x5�.qLs���p�zjx5�.u�x!|²o!x5�.qÙs%srqLmOqHzjprq�Wq�4�mOg���o�s�q�p�g�pre!q��rzjlnqZ �g^s��!� -;X o�s(q�4�m�qÙsO>u�lnqLx�p´ �z^��lng���p�cvh�g���qÙhw�¿lng��.qLh�q�ÒzLiÕp�qLs ¼ uw�!�O� #r��)!)� �, ��p�o&�.� -�� zHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[�%srqHz����e!g`srpWmOz^����zH|`qH�k·%pre!qLx�s�qHz!�ÇzHx!g`pre!qLs��qLx�p�qLxycvq¿zjx5��eOz��Çprg B o5��|`qV �e!qLp�e�qLs²p�eOzHp��qLx.prqLxOcvq� ¬z`��p�sro!qWgHi�pre!qWmyz`���rzj|^q -9. e�u¾�tprgK>;��qk> B o5��|`q����qLx�p�qÙxOcvq±cXg`o!h8�Icvg^x.p�zjuwxzHx¹zjxyzjm!e!g^s�uÌc l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s±g^s±x!g`p -<6 q�q�4�m�q�cvpL�(�Oz^��q�Ïg^x ¼ uw�!�y� #r��)�)! �, ��pro5�.���preOzjp���o!� B qHcvp��[ �u�hwh+��e�gK zjx�u�x!uwpru¾zjh=�.u1W�cXo!hwp��9 �u�p�enl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾c���qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH� -´� g ;>qL��qÙsL� �q�e��.mOg`pre!qH��u`ÜLq{p�eOzHpL�? �uwpre±m!s[z^cvp�uÌcvq��Hp�e!q�pruwlnq�p�g~cvg^lnm!srqLe!qLx5��lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c��qLx.prqLxOcvq��i �uwh�h�zHm!m!s�g©z`c[eIpre!q²p�uwl�qtprgncvg^lnm!srqLe!qLx5�¿p�e!q²hwu�p�qLs�zjhð��qLx�p�qLxycvqH� -� ptpre!q±qLx5�IgHi�pre!q±q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�G {q±p�qH��p�q��mOzjsrp�uÌcvuwmOzHx.p��RQOm!s�qXiÕqLs�qLxycvqSiÕg^s�p�e!q

lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� pre!qL�¹h�qHzjsrx!q�¹�.�¹eOzL��uwx!| p�e!qÙl c[e!g�g���qÏ�OqLpE �qLqLx z8��qLx�p�qLxOcXq�cvg`xG>p�zjuwx�uwx!|ÛzHxÝÍrg`h8��Î.�Wh�qHzjsrx!q� l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sÖzjx5�Apre!q'��zHlnq'��qLx.prqLxOcvqÊcvg^x.p�zjuwx�uwx!|Uzx!q� lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s -<6 q�q�4.mOqHcXp�q�Ïp�eyzjp���o!� B qHcXp[�9 �g^o!h��'�Oq2u�xOcvh�uwx!q��p�g �zHs��!�±oO�q>u�x!|²x!q� ¹lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -iX o!s�e��.mOg`pre!qH��u¾�i ¬z`���Oz`��q�Òg`x�p�e!q$z`�r��o!lnm�p�uwg^xÒpreOzjpÙ�!zLiÕp�qLsztl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cA �g`s��±z`c���o!u�s�qH�Óz�x!q� Ïlnq�zjx!u�x!|!�Huwp(h�g���qH�]uwp��«lO|^o!s[zHp�uw��q©�jlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾ciÕg^s[cvq -76 q�iÕo!srp�e!qLsþz`����o!lnq�WpreOzjp{g`o!s{��o!� B qHcvp��[ {g`o!h8�Wm!s�qXiÕqLsA �g`s��!�´ �uwpreÒ|^s�qHzHp�qLslnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c iÕg^s[cvq -

§©¨«ª5®C¯CÞß��!�L�àÕ�?àÏáÓ��â�����ã . e!qImyzjs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�a �qÙs�q ¹? k{zHs�x!qÙ|`uwqÖ}IqLhwh�g`x �tx!u���qLs[��uwp��Ío!xG>�.qÙs�|`s�z��.oyzjp�q��ä �e!gm �qÙs�q�xOzjpruw��q Ì x!|^hwuÌ��e ��mOqHzH�qLs[� -Á. e!qL�ÏmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjprq�Ïuwx'p�e!qq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p]iÕg`s$cvg^o!s[��qWcXs�q�.u�p -

å �.����àé��æé��ã�6 q�cvg^xO��prs�oOcvprq� * lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� # ��qLq . zH�!hwq �K, zHx5� й ��e!g^s�pWmyz`�q>�rzj|`q�� #%* iÕg^s�qHz^cfe�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s , zj�Og^o!p²p�e!q~p�g`m�u¾cL��gji{p�e�qH��q~lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[� -C. e�oO�v�5 �qeOz!� * �.uÌ��p�u�xOcvp�mOz^����zH|`qH��zj�Og^o!p�l�z`�r��u���q�zHp�e!h�qLp�qH�X� * zj�Og^o!p�cXg`h��¿s�g�g`l �%qLp�c -´. e!qzL��qLs�zj|`q~hwqLx�|`p�eÍgHi{p�e!q��p�g^s�u�qH�s �z^� �L�!) �g`s��!� -�M g^s�qHz`c[eÍ��p�g^s��P {q¿cvs�q�zjp�qJ�2pE �gprs�o!q~zjx&� pE {gWi;zjh¾��q²m�g©����uw�!h�qSp�zjsr|`qLp���qLx.prqLxOcvq��%p�g B o&�.|`q -ZÌ z`c[e�gji�p�e!qH��q�pE �g±p�zjsO>|^qLp[�(cXg`o!h8�W��q�|^uw��qLx~uwx¿zth�uwprqLs[zHhdiÕg^s�l g^s(uwx¿z�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c]iÕg^s�l -7. e!q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cp�zjs�|^qLp[�$cvg`x�p[zHuwx!q��zHx�zjxOzHm!e!g`sru¾c²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s -�M g`s�uwxy��p[zHxOcvq��!iÕg`s$zn��p�g`sr�Dzj�Og`o!pÐz�!o�h`H��Ízjpre!hwqÙp�q���z�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcSp[zHs�|^qLp� �g`o�h��Í��qN�¢f5gVjRg��?^9f5g�� �5g��Ye�f5gaf��?] \g�h´� _ge@�2��^��?��ºae�f5g�c�]?e�\±zHx5�np�e!q²cXg`s�srqH��mOg^x5�.uwx�|Òh�uwp�qÙs[zjhOp�zjs�|^qLp� �g^o!h��n�Oq0�¢f5guh´^�g�\ke��`gk^f5g�� ��g��me¦f5g2f��?]�\gkh´� _gDe@�Á��^��?��ºÑe¦f5g�c�]�e�\ -¡. zj��hwq � cvg^x.p�zjuwxy�±zjx8q�4!zHlnm!hwq�gjiÐz��p�g`sr��zjx&�2p�e�qWz^����g�cvu¾zHp�q�Í��qLx.prqLxOcvq�� -

Ð

Page 9: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q � �(}IqLp�zjm!e�g`s[��oO��qJ�×u�x Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p �!-(� ��qÙs[zj|^q�i;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p��²zjx5�¿|`g�g��.x!q����gHi�q�z`c[eIlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s� �qÙs�qWs�zjprq�Ig`x��rcLzjh�qSiÕs�g^l � p�g ¹Ñ#��aç cvg^lnm!h�qLp�qLh��±o!x.i;zHlnuwh1>uÌzjsRèÙ��qLs����Oz��?� ¹Pç ��qLs��Òi;zHlnuwh�u¾zHsRèL��qÙs��±|`g�g�� ,�-�� cLcvo!s�z`cv����hwg^m�q���zjx5��uwx�p�qLs�cvqLm!p��iÕg^s�qHz`c[e�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�uwx Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p �!-. g`m!uÌc é�qLe!u¾cXhwq M zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p5� ¼ g�g��.x!qH�r� b�h�g`mOq � x�p�qLs�cvqLm!pl�z^����uw��q$zjp�e�hwqLprq �OqHzjs ��-³�� �G-êÐ� �� G-Ä�`� ¹�¹�-ë)`�cvg^h��ns�g�g^l iÕs�qLq�ÜLqLs ��-³�� �G-Ä�� ��-ì¹G+ + �-¥¹��eOzHs��G {g`s�H.u�x!|×i;zHs�lnqÙs zjx�p ��-ëÐ� �G-ê*� ��-ê*�* Ð�*�-³�`�prg`o!|^e2iÕg�g�� s�o!����qÙs ��-�+ �G-ê � G-Ä��+ +��!-ë)`��.qÙm�qÙx5�.qLx�p�e.oy���OzHx5� m!o!m!m�� ��-³�� �G-Ä�� *G-1+�+ �`��-ë*.�o!x�iÕqLqLhwu�x!|WgW�cXu¾zjh u¾cvqÙ��qÙs�| ��-³�� �G-ê � �G-êÐ.� Ð`��-ë*`��.uÌ��e!g^x!qH��p�m�g^hwu�p�u¾cXu¾zjx iÕg4 ��-³�� �G-Ä�� ¹�-Ä��* Ð� �-³�`���hwg o ¬zju�p�qLs ��xOzHuwh ��-w�� �G-ê � �G-1+) Ð`��-³��+

M g`s�p�e�qthÌz`��p�m!eyz`��q�gjiÓpre!q�q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�Lp�e�qtlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s(m�s�qviÕqLsrqLxOcvq{p�qH��p�u�x!|!�? �qcvsrqHzjprq� * x�q� 8mOz^���rzj|`q��v�.q�z`c[eÒmOz^���rzj|`q$��qÙuwx!|~zj�Og^o!p�pre!qtprg`m!uÌc gHi�g^x!qtl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s -. e!qÙs�qa �qÙs�qWpE {g2mOg©����u��!hwq±qÙx5�.uwx�|���qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH� iÕg^s�qHz^cfeÍmOz^���rzj|`q ·(p�e!qL�D {qLs�q±�Og`prelnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c(zHx5��u��.qLx�p�uÌcLzjh^o!m²p�g�g`x!qA {g`s�� -´. e!q¬��o!� B qHcXp[�?eOz!�Ðprg�c[e!g�g©��q��OqLpE {qLqLxpre!q�pO {gÍqLx5�.u�x!|�� -¡X x!q�qLx5�.u�x!|�cvg`x�p[zHuwx!qJ� g^x!qIgHi�pre!q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�Wu�x . zj��hwq � �zHx5�Ip�e!q±g^p�e!qÙs�cvg^x.p�zju�x!q�Ízjx�zHhwprqLs�xOzHp�u���qSl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sC �uwpreÍp�e!q��zHlnqWprg`m!uÌc -U. e!qzHhwp�qÙs�xOzHp�uw��q$lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[��zHs�q��.qH��cXs�uw�Oq�¿uwx . zH�!hwq �G-

íZ�.�v�JàÏâ�îÁ�Gï�ðÁ�d����á£ñ7�O�H��ãÖ� p�uÌ� srqHz`��g`xOzH�!hwq~p�gnq�4.mOqHcvp�preOzjp�p�e�qW|`g�g���x!qH���²zHx5�pre!qni;zjlnu�hwu¾zHs�u�p��ÍgHi~zÍlnqLp[zHm!e!g^s±l�zL�Çu�xGÕOo!qLxycvq�p�e!qD��mOqLqJ�8zjpV �e!uÌcfe'uwp¿u¾�Wm�s�gK>cvq�����qJ� -�$ g^x!qLp�e�qLhwqH�r�v�!m!srqL��uwg`oy�t��p�o5�.u�qH� #O¼ qLs�sruw|¤' � qHzHhw��� ��)�*`� · . g`o!s�zjx!|^qHzjon'b�prqLs�x��OqLs�|�� ��)!*.�K, ��e!g �q��p�eOzHptpre!qW|^g�g��.x!qH�r�ÐgHi{zÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�uÌ� x!g^ptx�qHcvqH�r��zjsruwh��cvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�q�� �uwp�e~p�e!q�q�z`��q�gHiðcvg`lnm�s�qLe!qÙxO��u�g`x # �!o�p���qLq . g^o!s[zHx!|`q�zjo¤'op�uwmO�X� ��)!).� �iÕg^s�zÒcvg^o!x�p�qLsrq�4!zHlnm!h�q ,�-

. e!qLsrqviÕg`srq��5 �q²eOzL��q~cvg`x5��oOcvp�qJ�IzÒs�zjp�u�x!|���p�o&�.�Iu�xY �e�u¾c[e �� xOzjpruw��q Ì x!|`h�u¾��e��m�q�zKH�qLs��v�!��p�o5��qLx.p���g`s���p[zJ�Ögji{k{zjsrx!qL|`u�q~}IqLhwh�g`x��tx�uw��qLs���uwp��~s[zjprq�Òpre!q²|`g�g��.x!q����zHx5�Ïp�e!qni;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp��IgHi�pre!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�Sg^x¹zÍ�rcLzjh�q iÕsrg`l � prg ¹Á#��2ò hwg i;zJ>lnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p���èL|`g�g���x!qH���k· ¹P" e!u�|`eÏi;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p���èÙ|`g�g��.x!q���� ,�-Ï� zHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�²s[zjprq�Ïp�e!q��Ð lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� # �yz`��uÌc²zjx5�DzjhwprqLs�xyzjp�u���q , ��qH��cvsruw�Oq�Òu�x�p�e!q²l�zHp�qLsru¾zjhÌ����qHcvpruwg^x2m�hwoO�g^p�e!qLs �+H� l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��¢ �q�oO��q�tiÕg`s�zs�.u1�+qLs�qLx�p���p�o5��� -´M s�g^lAp�e�qH��q �K+�� lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�X�¹©� {qLs�qWi;zHuwsrhw�P {qLhwhFH.x!g �x # zHx5�Ëm�s�qH��o!l�zj��hw��|`g�g�� , l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��toO��q�Ëu�xÍqL��qLsr��!zL�'h¾zHx!|`oyzj|`q�zHx5� ¹�� �qLsrq2x�g`xO��qLxO��uÌcLzjh�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -Û� hwg^pÒgHi²p�e�qIx!g^xO��qLxy��u�>

+

Page 10: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q � � � ��p�g^s��¿cvg^s�s�q���mOg`x5��uwx!|±prgSpre!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^sU�����Ó�3^��K� �Äó _�^�g�g�ôg�^�zjx5�Òu�p[�z^����g�cXu¾zjprq�I��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -õH¡£ª�¥(�X«j¤�¤�¦¿¯±�[¦^«j¸¾�X 5�X«`�[�~»`�S¥þ¯���ØH�X 5·n�[§^�[¡³¤��[�I¯H¢�¦^¶`¤vµ²Ã�»`�²�[¦^«j¸¾�X 5�X«`�[�W¤�¦^¦�ö¿¨`®£¯L�[�¡£«¿¯tØH�X 5·W®£¯H 5´H��¯H«`�±�[¦j®Ä�¿ ­¦^¦^ª×É©¯j«`�±¦^«`®³·±¤r»`��Á� 5��¤� 5¦L¥��(¥(�X 5�%¸Ô¶`®³®³·¿¦`�[�X¶�¨`¡³�[�OµF÷%���r¯L¤��¦^ª��[¥�»`�X 5�²¡£«�¤�»`�ª�¡³����®³�¿ 5¦L¥��XµTõH¡£ª ¥þ¯���¸¾�[�[®Ä¡£«`´�¢�¯L�Yø »`¡³�²»�¯H«`����¯H«`��¸¾�[�[¤�¥(�X 5�¸Ô ­¦ù[�X«!É�¯j«`� »`����¦^¶�¢`¤��[� »`���[¦^¶`®³����¨��X«`�n¤5¥�¦W»`¦^¶� 5��¡£«Ò¤r»�¯L¤�¯X¥þ¸Ô¶`®� 5¦`¦^ª±µZú(¶`¤�¥{»`�X«¤r»`���r¨d�X¯öL�X %��¤r¯H 5¤��[�»`¡³��¨� 5�[���X«j¤r¯L¤�¡³¦^«!É�¡³¤�¥�¯L�(��¦²¡£«H¤��X 5�[��¤�¡£«`´W¤r»�¯L¤´õH¡£ª ¥�¯L��«�û ¤�¯H¢`®³��¤�¦¸Ì�[�[®?¯H«H·`¤r»`¡£«`´²�[®³����¢�¶`¤{�X«j¤r»`¶`��¡£¯L�rª ¸¾¦^ (¥{»�¯�¤þ»`�t¥�¯L�(®Ä¡³��¤��X«`¡°«`´±¤�¦�µ

ü¤ýRþ�ÿ�����������ÿ�� ��ý���þ�ý����ý����õH¡£ªA¸¾¦^ 5´j¦H¤(ØH�X 5·²��¦`¦^«Ò¯H¢�¦^¶`¤�¢��[¡£«`´~¡£«Ò¯t¸Ô ­�[��ù[�X [µ��Ïþ�����ý��� «`®³·±¤r»`��®£¯L��¤� 5¦L¥��(¦L¸ð¤�»`��¸Ô 5�[��ù[�X þ¥��X ­��¦^�[�X¶�¨`¡³�[�Oµ�����ÿ�����ý��

� �`þ�ý��%ÿ�����ý��Gþ�ý����ý!���õH¡£ªA¸¾¦^ 5´j¦H¤(ØH�X 5·²��¦`¦^«Ò¯H¢�¦^¶`¤�¢��[¡£«`´~¡£«Ò¯��[¦H®³�� 5¦`¦^ª±µ"�Ïþ�����ý��� «`®³·±¤r»`��®£¯L��¤� 5¦L¥��(¦L¸ð¤�»`�� 5¦^¦`ªÛ¥(�X 5��¦`�[�X¶�¨`¡³�[�Oµ��#��ÿ�����ý��

cLzHh]l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��; �qLsrq±z!�!zjm!prq�2iÕs�g^l q�4.uÌ��prqLx.p�h�uwprqLs[zHp�o!srq #E¼ qLs�sruw|¤' � qHzjh���� ��)!*`� ·X s�prg`x����Gé�g^x5�.s�oy�OH^z.� M g©���X�5'%$`g^x!qH�X� ��)�*^��,�- b�g^lnq�gji�p�e!q�|^g�g��2lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��i �qÙs�qp�zKH�qLx±iÕs�g^l X srp�g^x.�±qLp{zHh -5#���)�*`�?, zjx5�±iÕs�g`l � x!e�gK�DqLp{zjh -�#r��)!*K¹G,�-;. e�qH��q�qLxO��o!s�q�preOzjp$��o!� B q�cvp[�A �uwhwh�oy��q~zjh�h�p�e!q²mOg`u�x.p���g`xIpre!q~��cLzHhwq -

Ì z`c[e�mOzjsrp�u¾cXuwmOzHx.p��rzJ p�e!q²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[��uwxDz±s[zjx&�.g`l g`s��.qLs -A� zjh£i(gHi(pre!q~��o!�G>B qHcXp[�Ó��z� 'p�e!q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s���u�x±p�e!q�iÕg`s�l�gjið��u�lnuwh�qH� # ½/��\C�1��º?g;¿ , zjx&�×pre!q�g^p�e!qLs�eOzjh£i�rzJ ¹pre!qLl/uwxnpre!q�½y��\C¿AiÕg`srl -7. e!q²s[zHp�uwx�|��þiÕg^s�p�e!q$��u�lnuwh�qH�(zHx5�np�e!q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� {qLs�qZ �qLh�h!cvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�q� #'&Tç)(�+�� iÕg`s(i;zHlnuwh�u¾zjsruwp��$zjx5� &9ç*(�+�¹ iÕg^s(|`g�g��.x�qH��� , ·!e!qLxycvqR>iÕg^s�p�eD {qT �u�hwh+m!s�qH��qLx�p�zj|`|^s�qL|©zjprq�0�!zjp�z×gH��qLs{p�e!q²pE �g¿cXg`x5�.u�p�u�g`xO� -

. e!q²zL��qLs�zj|^qH�%gHi(pre!qt|^g�g��.x!qH�r��zjx&�×i;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p��Ss�zjpruwx!|©��zjs�q$|`uw��qÙxnuwx . zH�!hwq �iÕg^s(p�e!q{�Oz`��u¾c�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��]zHx5�Wuwx . zH�!hwq � iÕg`s(pre!q�zHhwprqLs�xOzHp�u���q�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -7. zH�!hwq ¹cvg^x.p�zju�xO�?p�e!q{zL��qLs�zj|`q��?gjiOpre!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�?oO��q��uwx Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � zHx5�Spre!q{zL��qLs[zH|`qH�gHiWpre!qIg^p�e!qÙsÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��×preOzjp���o!� B qHcvp��×s�zjprq� -Û� �±g`x!q�cLzHx¹��qLq���pre!qÍzL��qLs�zj|`qi;zHlnuwh�u¾zjsruwp���zjx5�I|^g�g��.x!qH�r�SiÕg`s�pre!q±lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�� �q±oO��q�P �qÙs�q±cXhwg���q±p�gnpre!q¿��zHlnq��oOzjx�p�u�p�u�qH�þiÕg^stpre!q²|`g�g��IlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[��oy��q�nuwx�g^p�e!qLs�srqH��q�zjs[c[e -

ß²����?�G�+Ó�K�5ãÖ. e!q²mOzjsrp�uÌcvuwmOzHx.p�����z� Ûp�e!q²l�zHp�qLsru¾zjhÌ�(g`xIpre!q²�rcvs�qLqÙx2gHi�z±}Íz^c � xG>prg���ecvg`l�m!o!p�qÙs -7. e!q{cvg`l�m!o!p�qÙs� �z`��q��o!uwm�m�qJ�u �u�p�ez lnuÌcvs�g^m!e!g^x!q -�� zHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�oO��q�±g`x!q�gHiÓpE �g�H�qL��� #-, iÕg^sse@^k]&g[�/. iÕg^s�_����¥\g , zjx5�¿p�e!q�lnu¾cXs�g`m�e!g`x!q�prgWq�4�m!srqH���pre!qLuws$zjxy�O �qÙs[� -�Ì z^cfeÍmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�ptprg�g�HÖzj�Og`o!p ¹©� l�uwx�o!p�qH��p�g�cXg`lnm!h�qLp�q²pre!qWq�4?>

*

Page 11: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q � � � hwprqLs�xOzHp�u���q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[��oO��q�nuwxDp�e!q²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�m!srqviÕqLs�qÙxOcvq�p[z`�EH�gji�q�4?>mOqLsruwlnqLx�p �!-W� ��qLs[zH|`q�i;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p��nzHx5�I|`g�g��.x�qH���²gji{qHz`c[eÍlnqLp�zjm!e�g`sC �qLsrqWs[zHp�q�g^xÏ�rcLzjh�q×iÕsrg`l � prg ¹m#��2ç cvg^lnm!h�qLp�qLh��Òo�x.i;zjlnu�hwuÌzjsRèÙ��qLs����Oz��?� ¹0ç ��qLs���i;zjlnu�h�>uÌzjsRèÙ��qLs��¿|`g�g�� ,�-. g^m!u¾c é�qLe�u¾cvh�q M zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp�� ¼ g�g���x!qH���l�z`�r��u���q�zHp�e!h�qLp�q l�g`o!x�p[zHuwx"0cvg`h8�ns�g�g`l u�|`h�g�g ��-ëÐ! �G-ê)� eOzjs��G �g^s�H�uwx!|Wi;zHs�lnqÙs �OqHz^��p�gji��!o!s��.qLx ��-³�! �G-Ä�� p�g^o!|`e�iÕg�g�� cÙzjs�����g©zjs�� ��-�+J �G-ê)� �.qLmOqLx5��qLx.p{e.oy���OzHx5� iÕg�g^p�l�zHx �!-³�! �G-ê*� o!x.iÕqLqÙhwuwx�|WgKW cvuÌzjh ��p�g^x!q ��-³�! �G-ê*� �.u¾��e!g`x�qH��p�mOg`h�uwpru¾cvuÌzjx c[eOzHlnqLhwqÙg`x ��-ë ! �G-Ä�� ��h�gK � �zHuwprqLs ��hwg^p�e ��-¥¹  �G-êÐ� 132Óî�á�àéàÕçXà]æHàÕá-4Xá�îLèÕá�ê~åHß?ùwàÕçXú ã�çXü³ü³á�ã�èéÞÄîjí�à;â[èéÞ³îHíXß�ù�çXà�èéÝHÞ³ß�ú�á�è5â[æHÝjçXàrÿ

mOqLsruwlnqLx�p -� p�sru¾zjhÓcXg`xO��u¾��prq�ngji�p�e!srqLq²m!eOz^��qH�k��!-t� zjs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[��s�qHz!�Iz±��e!g`srptmOz^���rzj|`q -��-t6 e�qLxYlOx�u¾��e�q�?�Op�e!qL��m!s�qH�r��q�ÍzaH�qL���OzHx5�Ip�e�qWmOz^����zH|`q±g^xÍp�e!q��cvsrqLqLxD �z^�srqLm!hÌz`cvq�¿�.�npre!q²p[zHs�|`qÙp���qLx.prqLxOcvq # lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh+g`s�h�uwp�qÙs[zjh;�.prs�o!q²g`s�i;zjhÌ��q ,�-b©o!� B qHcvp��]eOz��Wprg��.qHcvu8�.q; �e!qÙp�e!qLs�p�e!q���qLx.prqLxOcvqZ �z^�þprs�o!q�g^s(i;zjh¾��q�zjx5�±m!srqH���g^x!qWgHi{p�e!q~pO {g3H�qÙ�!��p�g¿uwx5��u¾cLzHp�qWpre!qLu�s�zjxO�E �qLs -U. e!qL�D {qLs�q~uwxO��p�s�oycvp�q�nprg�Oq�z`��i;z`��pz`�²m�g©����uw�!h�q -n� iÕprqLs²p�e!qÙ�I|�zL��q¿p�e!qÙuws~zjxO�E �qLsÙ��p�e!qL�0 {qLs�q¿|`u���qLxiÕqÙq�.�Oz^c�H # g^xÍzWx!q� ��cvsrqLqLx , zjx5��m!s�qH�r��q��zaH�qL�¿p�g�cvg`x�p�u�x.o!q -

��-t� ��p�qLl zHm!mOqHzjsrq�2g^xÍz¿��qLmyzjs[zHp�q��cvsrqLqLx -�� zHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[��eOz!�2prg±m!s�g^x!g`o!xycvqpre!q²cvg^s�srqHcvpA �g^s��np�g� �e!u¾c[enp�e�q²��prqLl��OqLhwg^x!|`q� -´6 q�eyz��ne!g`mOq�2 {q�lnuw|^e.p��qLq±��g`lnq²m!sruwlnu�x!|±qR�+qHcvp��v�O�!o!p�pre!qa��zjp[z±iÕs�g`l pre!u¾�tm�eOz`��qa �qLsrqSprg�g�x!g`uÌ���zHx5�Y {qU �uwh�h�x!g`p�srqLmOg`srptpre!qLl -

. zj�!h�q � u�hwh�oO��prs[zjprqH�(p�e!q��.q���uw|^xngji�p�e�qSq�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p - M g^s�qHz^cfeD��o!� B qHcvp�iÕg`o!s�gHipre!q * p�g^m!u¾cL��iÕs�g`l . zj�!h�q � �qLsrqWs�zjx5�.g^lnhw� ��qLh�qHcvp�qJ� prgÒ�Oq±srqviÕqLs�srq�nlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�u1>cLzHhwh�� -´. e!q$s�qLl�zHuwx!u�x!|SiÕg^o!s�iÕg`s{p�eOzHp���o!� B qHcvpZ �qLsrq�s�qXiÕqLs�srq�×prg±hwu�p�qLs�zjhwh�� -7. eOzjp�uÌ�v�g^x!qn��o!� B qHcvp$lnuw|^e.p$��qLq¿lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcSp�zjs�|^qLp[��iÕg`s~zjh�h(p�e�qn��p�g`sruwqH�²cvg^xOcvqLsrx!uwx�|!�?iÕg`su�xO��p�zjxOcvq©�?l�z`�r��u���q±zjpre!hwqÙp�qH�X��zjx5�Íhwu�p�qLs�zjhÓp[zHs�|`qÙp[�tiÕg`s²zHhwh(pre!q¿��prg`sruwqH�²cvg^xOcvqLsrx!uwx!|��

)

Page 12: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q ¹ � � ��qLs�zj|^qI|`g�g���x!qH����zHx5�Ui;zHlnuwh�u¾zHs�uwp��Ís�zjp�u�x!|��±iÕg`snlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��×oO��q�8uwxÌ 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p�� � zHx5� � �?cvg^lnmOzHs�q�3 �u�p�eDcvg^s�s�q���mOg`x5��uwx!|�zL��qLs�zj|^qSs�zjpruwx!|©� gHi�|`g�g��zHx5�2x!g^xO��qÙxO��uÌcLzjh�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� # ��cÙzjhwq � �Uò hwg �qH��p�· ¹äò e!u�|`e!q���p ,�-

M zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p�� ¼ g�g��.x�qH���Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p � ��-�+H� �G-ë*^�Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p � ��-³��* �G-�+Jм g�g��IlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� ��-�+H� �G-�+��$ g^xO��qLxy��q²lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� �!-¥¹? ��-�+��

iÕg^sÒu�xO��p�zjxOcvq©��cvg`h8� srg�g`l�� -LÌ z`c[e8p�zjs�|^qLpV �z`����qLh�qHcvp�qJ� prgÏ�OqIprs�o!qDg`s±i;zjh¾��qÍzHps�zjx5�.g^l -

. zH�!hwq � �A��qH��u�|`xIgHi Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p �!-

. g`m�u¾cL� � > ¹ . g`m�u¾cL� � > *¸ h�g�c�H �V#5� z^��� �65 ��, ¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc . sro!qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh . sro!qH�

¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc M zjh¾��qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh M zjh¾��qH�¸ h�g�c�H �D#5� z^��� �75C¹G, ¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc . sro!qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh . sro!qH�

¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc M zjh¾��qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh M zjh¾��qH�¸ h�g�c�H �D#5� z^��� �75�Ð�, ¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc . sro!qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh . sro!qH�

¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc M zjh¾��qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh M zjh¾��qH�¸ h�g�c�H ¹�#5� z^��� +85�*�, ¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc . sro!qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh . sro!qH�

¹ }IqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc M zjh¾��qH� ¹ :OuwprqLs[zHh M zjh¾��qH�

. e!qLsrq� �qLsrq * mOz`�r��qH�(p�e�s�g`o�|`enpre!q�l�zjprqLs�uÌzjh -�� x±qHz`c[e±mOz`�r�%pre!q���o!� B q�cvp´ �g^o!h����qLq(g`x�q���p�g^s��²uwx���g`h��.u�x!|�qHz`c[e�p�g^m!u¾c]iÕg^sÓz�p�g`p�zjh�gHi * ��prg`s�u�qH�?uwxÐzjhwh -7. e!q�g`s���qLs�gji�p�e!q��p�g`sruwqH��u�x�qHz`c[enmOz^���� �z`��s[zHx5�.g^lnu`ÜLqJ�iÕg^s�qHz`c[eD��o!� B qHcXpL�!z^�t ¬z`��pre!q~z`����uw|^x!lnqLx�pgHi$��p�g^s�u�qH�SprgImOz^����q�� -�$ g`prqÒpreOzjp~qHz`c[eÏ��p�g^s��m �z`�²oO��qJ� B oO��p~g`xOcXq " pre!qLs�qV �qÙs�qй ��p�g^s�uwq��tuwx�zHhwh -�. e�qH��q±mOz^����qH�U �qLsrq±g`s�|©zjx!uIÜLq�Iu�x.prgn�!hwg�c�H��tgji{pE �gnmyz`����qH� -�� xqHz^cfe��!h�g�c�H+�.g^xÍzL��qLs�zj|`q©�.g`x�qW��p�g^s��niÕg`s�qHz^cfe�prg`m!uÌcu {g`o!h8�n��q�iÕg^hwhwg {q�n�.��z×prs�o!q��qLx.prqLxOcvq�zjx&� g^x!qD��prg`s��n �g`o�h��Ç�OqniÕg`h�hwg �q���.�Êz2i;zjhÌ��q���qLx.prqLxOcvq -0. e!q�c[e!g`uÌcvqgHi� �e!u¾c[e'p�gÍiÕg`h�hwg �uwpre zËprs�o!qÖ��qLx�p�qLxycvq2 �z^�nzjhÌ��g�s[zHx5�.g`l -¡$ g^p�qDp�eOzHpÒpre!u¾�lnqÙp�e!g��.g^hwg^|`�WiÕg`s�l�zHp�qLsru¾zHh!|`qLx�qLs[zHp�uwg^xÒl�qHzjx�p(p�eyzjp�qHz`c[e���o!� B qHcXp(eOz���z9�.u1�?qÙs�qLx�p

��

Page 13: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

s�zjx5�.g^l���qLp(gji+l�zHp�qLsru¾zHh¾��zjx&�WlnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�Ózjx5�WpreOzjp(u�x±|`qLx�qLs[zHhwu`ÜÙuwx!|�gH��qLs���o!� B q�cvp[� {qWzHs�q~zjhÌ��g¿|`qLx�qLs[zHhwu`ÜÙuwx!|~gj��qÙs�l�zHp�qLsru¾zjhÌ� # k�h¾zjs�H?� ��)�+���,�-

. e!q±u�x5�.qLmOqLx5��qLx.p��^zjsru¾zj��hwqH�U �q~oO��qJ�2iÕg`s²p�e!uÌ�tq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p; �qÙs�q #r�K, p�e�q ��Ð >prs�u¾zHh��!h�g�c�H # pO {g'mOz`�r��qH�Dzj|`|^s�qL|©zjprq� , � #5�?, p�e!q�p��.mOq�gji±prs�uÌzjh%�'lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌc2g^sh�uwp�qÙs[zjh;�?�.qLmOqLx&�.uwx!|²g^xÒpre!qtp���mOqtgHi�p�e�qtp�zjs�|^qLpL��zHx5� #5�?, p�e!q�p�sro!p�e¿gjiðp�e!q$��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqprg B o5��|`q # p�zjs�|^qLp , �(p�sro!q²g`s�i;zjh¾��q -� ��zTlOxyzjh�p�q���p�gHi´ �e�qLp�e!qÙs�p�e!q�l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��%eOz!�Icvg^lnm!h�qLp�q�Wpre!qLu�s�p�s�zjxO��uwpruwg`xy�

prg3 {g`s����t �u�p�e�x!q� Al�qHzjx!u�x!|��X�!zHptpre!q²qLx5�ngji�pre!q²q�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p�mOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[��eOz!�prg8mOqLs�iÕg^s�l pre!qÇl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s ��qLh�qHcvp�u�g`xÛp[z^�OH - . e!uÌ�2p[z^�OHÛcvg^xO��uÌ��prq� gji×��o!� B q�cvp[�srqHz��.u�x!|�zÍmOz`�r��zj|^q���zjx5�'p�e!qÙx8cXg`lnm!h�qLp�u�x!|Íz���qÙx.prqLxOcvqnsrqLh¾zHp�q��p�g�p�e!q�mOz^����zH|`q �u�p�e'g`x!qDg`o!p¿gjiÐpO {g�zjxOzHm!e!g^s�u¾c�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� - X x!q�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s¿cLzHlnqÒiÕs�g^l g`o�su�x!uwpru¾zjhy��qLh�qHcvp�u�g`x���pre!q�g`pre!qLsZ �z`�{zjxDzjh�p�qLsrxOzjpruw��q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sA �uwprenp�e�q²��zHlnq�p[zHs�|`qÙp# z`�a�.qH�rcvs�u��Oq�ÏuwxÏpre!q�l�zjprqLs�uÌzjh¾�²��qHcvp�u�g`x ,�-m� x'pre!u¾�Wp�z`�OH+�(p�e�qLs�qD �qÙs�q * prs�u¾zHh¾� "qHz^cfe¿g`x�q²cvg`srs�qH��mOg`x5�.u�x!|WprgWg^x!q�gjiðg`o!s * prg`m!uÌcL� -AM g`s�eOzHh½iÓgHi�p�e�qH��q�prs�uÌzjh¾�(x!qÙuwp�e�qLsgHi�pre!qnpE �gDlnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�T {qLs�q�qLxOcvg^o!x.prqLs�qJ�Ç�OqviÕg`srq # u�xÏg`o!s±q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p , �.��p�e!qmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p -;6 qWl�qHz`��o!s�q�npre!qWm!srg`mOg`srp�u�g`x�gji�pruwlnqH��p�e!q��o!� B q�cvp[�� �g^o!h���oO��qzlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sÙ�� �e�qLxÒpre!qL�±eOz!�n��qÙqLxÒpreOzjp{lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s���qXiÕg`s�qÐzjx5�3 �e�qLxÒpre!qL�±eOz!�Òx!g^p��qLqLx�uwp -

9�¨7µ;:=<%ª�µ¸ qHcÙzjoO��qs {qs ¬zjx�p�q�Òprg±��p�o5�.�¿p�e�q�hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|WgHi7 �g^s��!��gj��qÙs%q�4.prqLx5�.q�±q�4�mOqLs�u�qLxOcvq�� {qU �qLsrq²cvg^xO��prs[zju�x!q��p�g±hwg�g!H�zjp�srqLh¾zHp�u���qLhw�WiÕq� Ûp�g^m!u¾cÙ�%uwx�g^s��.qLs�prg9lOp�p�e�qSh�qHzjsrxG>u�x!|±q�4�m�qÙs�uwqÙxOcvq�u�x.prg¿z×srqHz`��g`xOzH�!hwq~m�qÙs�uwg���gji�p�u�lnq -´. e�u¾��s[zjuÌ��qH����o!qH��p�u�g`xO��zj�Og`o�p �e!qÙp�e!qLs²pre!qLs�q�u¾�²��g^lnqLp�e�uwx!|�mOqHcvo!h�u¾zHsWzH�Og`o!p±g^o!s * prg`m!uÌcL��p�eOzHp¿cvg`o!h8�Ë�Oqnm�s�gK>�.oycvuwx!|�p�e!q~s�qH��o!hwp�� -�. e!qLsrqviÕg`srq��5 �q9 �u�hwhÓ�Oq±s�qLmOg`srp�u�x!|np�q���p[��gj��qÙst�Og`pre���o!� B q�cvp[�#?>A@ ��p�zjpru¾��pru¾cL� , zHx5�Íuwp�qÙl�� #->�B ��p[zHp�uÌ��p�uÌcL� ,�- b�u�xOcvq~p�e!q±l�zHp�qLsru¾zHh¾�; �qÙs�qWs�zjx5��g`lnh��|^qLx!qLs�zjp�qJ�ÐiÕg`s�qHz`c[e±��o!� B qHcvpÙ�dk�hÌzjs�H #r��)�+���, mOg`u�x.p���g^o!p(p�eyzjp(pre!qH��q{p�qH��p[�Ózjsrq�s[zjpre!qLssrq�.o!x5��zjx�p���uwxycvq²uwxn|^qLx!qLs�zjhwuIÜLuwx�|±gj��qÙs���o�� B qHcvp[�; {q²zjsrq²|`qLx!qÙs[zjh�u`ÜLu�x!|±gH��qLs�l zjp�qk>sru¾zjhÌ��zjx&�I�.uÌcvqW��qLs���z -�� g �qL��qLsÙ�� {qWpre!g`o!|^e.p²u�pU �z^�tuwlnmOg^s�p[zHx.p$p�gnmOqLs�iÕg`s�l p�e!qu�p�qLl p�q���p[�Óp�g²m!s�gH��u��.q¬z`�r��o!s�zjxOcvq�p�eyzjp�g`o!s�qR�+qHcvp[�7 �qLsrq�x!g^p���mOqHcvu�l�c�p�g�mOzHs�pru¾cvo!hÌzjsu�p�qLl�� -

6 qnqLhwu�lnuwxyzjp�qJ�2iÕs�g`l g`o�s¿zjxOzHhw����u¾�±��g`lnq���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��iÕg`s� �e!g`l pre!q�zL��qLs�zj|`qz^cLcvo!s�z`cv� # zj|^|`srqL|�zHp�q�ÇgH��qLs$��g^p�eÏl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾c~zjx5�Íhwu�p�qLs�zjh�cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`xO� , �z`��h�qH���preOzjx �� mOqLs[cXqLx.p @ -V. e!qH��q¿��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�teyz���zjh¾��gDz h�g �zL��qLs[zH|`q¿z^cLcvo!s�z`cv��iÕg`s²p�e!qCED á�âfã�èÕå^âfü³üÄì�á�üÄÞ³útÞÄî`â[èÕá�ê{èéÝHçXßéá�èÕàéÞ°âfü³ßOù�çvà+ä�ÝjÞÄã5Ý�èÕÝjáþâfã�ã�åHà5â[ã�ì�Þ³î�ë`çXèéÝGFIHLæ^á�àéÞ³ú�á�îLè�÷(â[îHê

FIHLæ^á�àÕÞ³ú�á�îLè�ö�äðâfß�ü³á�ßÕß�èéÝ^â[îGJ�K�æ`á�àéã�á�îLèrÿ

�^�

Page 14: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

h�uwp�qÙs[zjhÐcvg`x5��uwp�u�g`x z`�D �qLh�h²z`�niÕg`s�p�e!q�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcÍcvg`x&�.uwpruwg`xð��zjx&� p�eOzHpIl�z!�.qoO�²��oO��mOqHcvp²preOzjp²��o!� B qHcvp��U �qLsrq±cvg^x.iÕoO��qJ�Ëg^sSl�u¾��o�x5�.qLs���p�g�g��Ipre!g���qÒmyz`���rzj|^qH�Sg^sp�zjs�|^qLp[� -DM g`sWprs�o!q¿p[zHs�|^qLp±zHxOzjh��!��u¾�v�7 �q¿qLhwu�lnuwxyzjp�qJ� � myz`���rzj|^qH�Wg`o!p~gji йS#Ϲ�-ëÐ!*mOqLs�cvqLx�p , ·¬zjx5�ÏiÕg`s±i;zjh¾��qIp�zjs�|^qLp�zjxOzHhw����u¾�a �q�qLh�uwlnu�xOzjprq� Ð mOz^���rzj|`q�� g^o!p¿gji й#@)G-³�?+ mOqLs�cvqLx�p ,�-

ßC�.�H�?��â��H��î¢�ML��O�H��.�`�?ã M uw|^o!s�q � m�s�qH��qLx.p��%pre!qt�^zHs�u¾zHp�u�g`xngHi(pre!qtmOqLs�cvqLx�p[zH|`q�gHicvg^s�srqHcvp±zHxO�O {qLs[�±p�gÍprs�o!q�g^s×i;zHh¾��q ��qLx�p�qLxycvqH�WgH��qLsWpre!q��.o!s�zjp�u�g`x'gjiÐp�e!qnq�4.mOqLsru�>lnqÙx.p -´. e!q²mOg`u�x.p�� u�x2pre!qWpE {g±|`s[zHm!eO��zHs�q~zL��qLs[zH|`qH��gH��qLs�g^x!qW��hwg�c�H ò u - q - gH��qLs��Ð cXg`xO��qHcvo!pruw��q�prs�uÌzjh¾� -£6 q�mOqLs�iÕg^s�lnq�~zjx�zjxOzHhw����uÌ�þgHi+�`zHs�uÌzjxOcvq #;�U$TX é �T, g`x¿p�e!qmOqLs�cvqLx�p[zj|^q±gji cvg`srs�qHcvpÐ��qLx�p�qLxycvq B o5��|`qLlnqÙx.p�� -�. e!qLs�qV �qÙs�q±��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�pSl zjuwxDqvi�>iÕqHcXp[�]gHi?p���mOq�gji+p�sru¾zjh ò lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcþ��qÙs[��oy�]hwu�p�qLs�zjh #->A@�#��8N���)�,ZçÛ��+O(ë !Ð �IPRQ�S @ZçÐ^�`��(Ä�.� �UT @WV �(ë � ! .� � >�Bk#���NR+�,mç )�(ê*`� �XP*QYS B<ç �.��Ð�N[��)!)�(Ä��+ �ZT B[V �(ë `�?, ��!h�g�c�H #->\@�#5��NL�`�+�,2ç ��(³�^� �]PRQ�S @2ç ��)! �(³��� �AT @^V �(ë ! `� � >�BR#;��N[���K,2ç�¹�¹I(Ä�.� �PRQ�S BYç �K¹©��N�Ð!)�+O(ë*`� ��T BMV �(ë � ! .�,�-N. e!qLs�qD ¬z`�¿zjx'qR�+qHcvp±gHi�prs�o!pre ò prs�o!q��qLs���oO�Si;zHh¾��qI��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� ò iÕg`s¿p�e!qDuwprqLl zHxOzjh��!��u¾� #->�Bk#���NR+�,Dç *�(ë*?+ �UP*QYS BPç�� � �N��.��*�(¥¹ Ð �_T B[V �(ê `��, ���!o!p�uwp �.u��¹x!g`p�srqHz`c[eÛ��u�|`x!u1l+cLzjxycvqËiÕg^s�p�e!q���o!� B qHcvpzHxOzjh��!��u¾� #->A@�#���N[��)?,9ç ��(³�^� ��PRQ�S @�ç/��N� .�^�8(w�k¹G,�-D. e!qLs�qa ¬z`�~z2��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�pSu�xG>prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xI�OqLpE {qLqLxIprs�uÌzjhÓp���mOq±zHx5�Ë��hwg�c�H #?>A@�#;��NL�^�K+!,UçÇ*�(ë)K¹ �`PRQ�S @UçL¹  K¹I(Ä�`� �T @aV� �(ë ! � �� � >�Bk#5��N[�.�,3ç ��(�+J) �]PRQ�S B2ç �^�`��N�*`�^��(¥¹ * ��T B^V �(ë ! `��,�-S. e!uÌ�Wu¾�pre!qtl�g���p�uwlnmOg`srp[zHx.p(u�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xWiÕg^s�m!o!srmOg���q��%gjiðg`o!s{uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qÙp[zjpruwg^x -´. e!q�g`pre!qLsu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xO�£ {qLs�q$��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p�g`x�hw�WiÕg`s�pre!q���o!� B qHcvp �U$�X é � �L�OqLpE �qÙqLxÒprs�uÌzjh!p���m�qzHx5� prs�o!pre #->\@�#���N[��)?,Dç �.��(ë)� �UPRQ�S @Pç �8N� ^��)�(Ä��* �YT @bV� �(ê � � ��8N�>cB�#��8Nk+�,Dç �(ë � ¹ ��PRQ�S B9ç/�^�K¹IN���Ð�+O(ë)^��, �(�OqLpE {qLqLxÍp�sro!p�eÊzjx&�Ç�!hwg�c�H #?>A@�#;��NL�^�K+!,9ç �L��(Ä�`� �PRQ�S @Sç ¹?)! �(Ä��) �=T @dV �(ë � ! .� � >�Bk#5��N[�.�,Sç �8(ì¹?) �XP*QYS B¡ç �.�Ù��N�Ð!)�*�(êÐ`�?, ��OqLpE �qÙqLxÇprs�o!pre���p�s�uÌzjh{p���mOq�zjx&� ��hwg�c�H #?>A@�#;��NL�^�K+�,Vç��k¹I(ì¹?* �=PRQ�S @Vç �?+�¹I(1+ �T @]V� �(ë � ! .� � >�Bk#5��N[�.�,;ç)(ê)`� �eP*QYS Btç ��*�Ð�N�)`�!)�(Ä��*�,�-

. e!qÖ��uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p±uwx�p�qLs�z`cvpruwg^x �OqLpE {qLqLxÏprs�u¾zHh�p��.mOqDzjx5�'�!hwg�c�H'uwx5��u¾cLzHp�qH�²p�eOzHp��o!� B qHcvp��9 �qLsrqnhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|Íp�e�q2l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s�� -¡X ��qLs~p�e!qDcvg^o!s[��q2gHi²p�e�q2q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p��o!� B qHcvp��%��p[zHs�p�qJ�Òg`o!p{mOqLs�iÕg^s�lnu�x!|²m�g�g^s�h��Òg^xnlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌc�q�4.m�s�qH�r��uwg^xO�(�!o!p{qLx5�.q�o!ma �u�p�e¿zHx¿z`cLcvo�s[z`cX�±cvh�g���q{p�g�preOzjp�gHi?h�uwprqLs[zHh¾� -7. e!uÌ�(��o�m!mOg`s�p��(p�e!q�u�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`xpreOzjp���o!� B qHcvp���zjsrq�hwq�zjs�x�uwx!|~p�e!q�l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s���z^��x!q� ¹lnqHzHx!uwx�|ÐiÕg^s�p�e!q� �g`s��!� -A. zJ>�!h�q � |^uw��qH��pre!q~��hwg^mOqWgjiþp�e!q²hwu�x!qHzHs�uwlnm!srgH��qLlÒqXx�pþiÕg^stq�z`c[e2gHi�p�e�q * lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -. e!qÙ�IzHs�q¿zHhwhÓm�g©��u�p�uw��q~uwx5��u¾cLzHp�uwx�|ÒpreOzjp²p�e�u¾��qR�+qHcvpC �z`��|^qLx!qLs�zjhÓp�g�zHhwhÓp�e!q±u�p�qLl��" uwx&�.qLq�?�ÓzHxÏqR�+qHcvp~��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p�����zI��uw|^xÇprqH��p -36 q3 ¬zjx�p�q�Íp�gÖcfe!q�c�HD �e!qLpre!qLspre!qti;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp��Wg^s�p�e!q²|`g�g���x!qH����gji�p�e!q²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�{zJ�+qHcvprq�np�e!qÙuws�h�qHzjsrx!uwx�| -AM g`spre!u¾��m!o�s�mOg���q��� {q²uwxOcvh�o5�.q�¿g`x!h��np�e!g©��q²p�sru¾zHh¾�; �e!qLx�pre!q²p[zjsr|`qLpC �z^� l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾c`�

�Ù�

Page 15: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4 5

Per

c C

orre

ctf

Blocks

Literals -- trueMetaphors -- true

Literals -- foilsMetaphors -- foils

M u�|`o!srq � � � qLs[cXqLx.p�zj|^qngji~cXg`s�srqHcvpzjxO�E �qLs��×u�x Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p � z`�¿z2iÕo!xOcXp�uwg^x8gHi�!h�g�c�H���gji�m!s�z`cvpru¾cvqH� -

zHx5�2 �q�h�g�g�H�q��zjp�pre!q²��hwg`mOqH��zHx5�2pre!q�u�x.prqLs[cvqÙm!p[�(gji�p�e�qSh�qHzjsrx!uwx�|±cvo!sr��qH� # �e!u¾c[ecLzHxÏ�OqÒiÕg`o�x5�Çuwx cvg`h�o!lnxO� � zHx5� Ð gHi . zH�!hwq �,�-D6 q�g`�!p�zjuwx�q�Çp�eyzjpW�Og^p�e'p�e!q|^g�g��.x!qH�r�ÒzHx5�Ïp�e!qÒi;zHlnuwh�u¾zHs�uwp��D �qÙs�qnlng���qLs[zHp�qLh��Ícvg^s�s�qÙh¾zjprq�� �u�p�eÏpre!qnhwq�zjs�x�uwx!|��hwg`mOq #'&Tç� �(ëÐ.� iÕg^s�|^g�g��.x!qH�r��zjx5� &�ç*(ëÐ!) iÕg`s�i;zjlnu�hwu¾zHs�u�p�� ,�- . e!q²cvg^s�s�qÙh¾zjpruwg^xÒiÕg`s|^g�g��.x!qH�r�Su¾��x!g`xG>­��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.pÙ����o!p²p�e!q¿cvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�uwg^xIiÕg`sti;zHlnuwh�u¾zHs�uwp��¿u¾��l�zHs�|`u�xOzjh�hw���uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.p #3gk#O+!,AçÛ��(Ä�� �N T V*(w�� ?, zjx5�nu�x5�.u¾cÙzjp�q��%|`srqHzjprqLs�h�qHzjsrx!uwx�|WiÕg`s�pre!q�i;zjlnu�h�>uÌzjsWl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s�� -0M g^sWp�e�qnuwx�p�qLs�cvqLm!p��v�Óp�e!qLsrq2 �z^�WzÍ��uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.pcvg`srs�qLhÌzjpruwg`xn �uwp�e|^g�g��.x!qH�r� #E&2çh(1+H� � gk#O+�,�ç���(�+) �/T VÄ �(ê `�?, zjx&�Çznl�zHs�|`u�xOzjh�hw�D��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p~cvg^sO>srqLh¾zHp�uwg^xÁ �uwp�e'i;zjlnu�hwuÌzjs�u�p�� #E&<çi(ëÐ^� � gk#O+!,Dç���(w�`� ��T V �(��K, �; �e!u¾c[e8u�x5�.uÌcLzjprqH�preOzjpn|^g�g�� g`s¿i;zjlnu�hwu¾zHs±lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�±l�zL�ÏeOzL��qÍ��p[zHs�p�qJ�¡ �uwp�eÛzÊcvg`lnm�s�qLe!qÙxO��u�g`xz!�.�^zjx�p[zj|^qWgH��qLs�pre!q²g`p�e�qLs�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� -� p]pre!q��OqL|^uwx!x!u�x!|�gHiOp�e!q�q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�pL�[pre!q�z`cLcXo!s[z^cv��iÕg`sÓp�s�o�q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c���qLxG>

prqLxOcvqH�?uÌ��h�g ²�`�!o!pÓuwpÓu¾�?e!u�|`eWiÕg^s�iÕg^uwh¾��uwx~p�e!q¬��zHlnq{cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`x - �tx�hwu`H�qÓiÕg`s(pre!q�gj��qÙsO>zHhwh���zjp[z��.pre!u¾��qR�+qHcvp�gHi(prs�o!prenu¾�{��e!g �x�p�g~�OqW��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�p���� �U$TX é � mOqLs�iÕg`srlnq�g^x!hw�Ïg^x8pre!q2lOs[��pÒ�!h�g�c�H #->\@k#��8N���)�,¤ç��!*�(³�?+ �UP*QYS @2ç �`�! �(ëÐ^� ��T @jV �(ë � ! .� �>�Bk#���NR+�,�çÇ+H��(�+�� �"PRQ�S Bsç ��)�(ëй �IT B_Vo �(ë ! � .�, �¢ �e�u¾c[eI��o!|`|^qH��p���p�eOzHptu�x!uwpru¾zjh�hw�mOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�� �qLsrqÒgHiÕp�qLxÏu�x.prqLs�m�s�qLpruwx!|�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcÒ��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH��hwuwprqLs[zHhwh�� -D¸ �Íp�e!qqLx&� gHi(pre!q²q�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.pÙ�jpre!q²mOqLs[cvqÙx.p�zj|`q²gHi�cvg^s�srqHcvp�zHxO�O {qLs[�%iÕg^stpre!q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c��qLx.prqLxOcvq��%�OqHcLzHlnq�cXhwg���q�p�g±pre!q~��zHlnqU��oOzHx.pruwp��×iÕg^s�p�e!q²h�uwp�qÙs[zjh+cvg^x5�.u�p�uwg^x -´6 e!qLxmOqLs�iÕg`s�l�uwx!| �U$TX é � g^x!hw�IiÕg^sWp�e�qnh¾z^��pW��hwg�c�HÍgji�p�e�qnq�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.pÙ��x�g`x!qngHi�p�e!qqR�+qHcXp[�þiÕg^o!x5�nuwx�p�e!q�gH��qLs�zjh�h¢��zjp[zWg^s�u�xnp�e!qu�!zjp�zSiÕg`s�p�e�qslOs[��p��!hwg�c�Ha �qÙs�q²��uw|`x�u½i�>

�Ù�

Page 16: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

2700

2900

3100

3300

3500

3700

3900

4100

4300

4500

4700

1 2 3 4 5

RT

for

corr

ect a

nsk

Blocks

Literals -- trueMetaphors -- true

Literals -- falseMetaphors -- false

M u�|`o!srq � ��p�qH��mOg^xO��q~p�uwl�qH�þiÕg^s�cvg^s�srqHcvp�zjxy�O �qÙs[��uwx Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � z`��zWiÕo!xOcvpruwg`xgHi(�!h�g�c�H���gjiþm!s[z^cvp�uÌcvq -

uÌcLzjx�p B -

l2����áA�5â]���nm{�.���â]�?à���� ï��O�poc+£�î=àÏâ�î%q ��â����â]�?����ã . e!q �U$TX é � g`x B o&�.|`qR>lnqÙx.p(hÌzjprqLxOcvu�qH�(��e�gK {q�Òl�zHuwx±qR�+qHcXp[�(gjiÓprs�u¾zHhOp���mOq #->\@�#���N[��)?,;ç �L��(�+�� �ePRQ�S @Zç��N� .�Ù��NL�k¹?)�(Ä�.� �XT @rV �(ë ! `� � >cBR#���NR+�,Nç )�(ë*^� �sP*QYS Boç ����Ð�N���)�)�(³�?+ �XT BRV �(ë `�?, zHx5�Ïgji��!h�g�c�H #?>A@�#;��NL�^�K+�,aç �!*�(ëÐ!) �tPRQ�S @aç�)`��Ð�N[��Ð��8(Ä�`� ��T @uVv �(ë � ! .� �>�Bk#5��N[�.�,¡ç ¹!¹I(³��� �sP*QYS B ç �K¹���N�Ð�)?+v(ê*`� �GT BwV �(ë � ! .�,�-Ö. e!qÏprs�o!preL �z^�x!g^p���u�|`x!u1l+cLzjx�pÍgH��qLs���o�� B qHcvp[� #->A@k#r�8N[�!)�,�ç �8(ëÐ! �aPRQ�S @oç �8N� `�`��N[�`�!Ð�(Ä��Ð�,�!o�p2u�pD �z`����uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.p�gH��qLsnu�p�qLl � #?>�BR#r�8NR+!,Sç *�(ê*�+ �XP*QYS B<ç �� � �N��.��*�(¥¹ Ð �T BaVr �(³�?,a-26 q�zjhÌ��g2iÕg^o!x5�'zI��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�pSu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`x��OqLpE �qLqLx�p�sru¾zHh%p���mOqnzHx5��!h�g�c�H #?>A@�#;��NL�^�K+�,�ç�+v(ê*�) � P*QYS @;ç *� � �NR+H�!Ð�(��� ��T @xV� �(ê � � �� � >�BR#;��N[���K,;ç ��(�+J) �PRQ�S BTç �^�`��N�*`�^��(¥¹ * �yT BXVÇ �(ë � ^��,�-W� |©zju�x��?p�e�u¾��u¾�tpre!q±lng���ptu�lnmOg`srp[zjx�p�uwx�p�qLsE>z^cvp�u�g`xÍ�OqHcLzHoO��q±u�p�uwx5��u¾cLzHp�qH��hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|ngHi�p�e�qWlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -9$ gng`pre!qLs�u�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xm!srgH��q�Çp�gÍ�OqD��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p -SM u�|`o!srq � cXg`x�p[zju�xO�W|`s�zjm!ey�iÕg^s±p�e!q��^zjsru¾zjpruwg^x gHi�srqR>��m�g^xO��q~h¾zHp�qLxOcXuwqH�(iÕg`s�p�e!q~cLz^��q²gji{cXg`s�srqHcvp¬zjxO�E �qLs�� -

6 qImOqLs�iÕg^s�lnqJ� �U$TX é � ��qLmyzjs[zHp�qLh��ÏiÕg`s¿p�e!q��!zHp[zËiÕsrg`l p�e!qDlOs[��pnzHx5�8h¾z^��p�!h�g�c�H�� -A� x�p�e�qulys[��p��!h�g�c�H+�.pre!qLs�q� ¬z`��z±��p�srg`x!|�qR�+qHcvp�gji�p�sru¾zHh�p���mOq #-> @ #��8N���)�,Zç�!*�(�+J* �XPRQ�S @ ç �8NÙ�R¹?Ð�N�¹����8(Ä�`� �GT @ V �(ê � � �� � > B #r�8NR+!,�ç ��Ð�(ê K¹ �zPRQ�S B ç{ Ü�ÝHá�Þ³îLèÕá�à;â[ã�èÕÞ³çXîÒë^á�è¾ä?á�á�î2èÕàÕÞ£âfü+è¾ìLæ`áÐâfîHê¿èéàÕåHèéÝnäðâfß{ßéÞÄívîHÞ�|^ãrâfîÙè�}!èÕÝHçvåHíXÝM~�� C ~é÷����;øvô��t�J��#J�J�}����I� C �MJ��j÷�� öXô�}?� C"� K��#K�J�}�� { ~Õ÷��'���I�Í÷�õ8� �vô��E���I� { �b��K��³÷X÷�}'� {A� K��#KH÷���ÿ�Ü!àéåHá�ß?ä+á�àéáßÕèéÞÄü³ü�útçXàÕá(â[ã�ã�åHà;âfèÕá�èéÝ^â[îtùÌâfüÄßéá�ß?ù�çvà+ü³Þ³èÕá�à5â[ü³ß�}LëjåHè�èÕÝHá%àÕá?4vá�àÕßéá{æ^âfèÕèéá�àÕî�ÝHá�ü³êtù�çvà�ú�á�è5â[æHÝHçvàÕß�ÿ

�k¹

Page 17: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

�¹?)�Nk+H��*�(³�! �"T B V» �(ë ��K, �7 �e!u¾c[em�.uÌ��zjm�m�q�zjs�qJ�Ë���Í�!hwg�c�H2iÕg^o!s #-> @ #���N[��)?,Tç ��(³�?+ �PRQ�S @ ç �`�^��N[�! .��(¥¹�� � > B #���NR+�,2ç�(Ä�`� �UPRQ�S B ç ��Ð� �N�¹? ^��(êÐ`��,�-Û� cvp�oyzjhwh����]x�gqR�+qHcXp[�(g`s�uwx�p�qÙs[z`cXp�uwg^xO�£ {qLs�q�iÕg`o!x&�iÕg^s�p�e�qC�!zjp�zÐiÕs�g^l�p�e!q�h¾z^��p��!h�g�c�H+����o!|^|`qH��p�uwx�|preOzjp~�.��p�e!q�qLx5�Ígji$p�e!qnq�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p�p�e!q¿lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcÒ��qLx.prqLxOcvq��u {qLs�q�cvg^lnm!s�qk>e!qÙx5�.q��z`��qHz^��uwh��nzHx5�Iz^�¬i;z^��p$z`��hwu�p�qLs�zjh+��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH� -

6 qWzHh¾��gÒh�g�g�H�q�Dzjp�p�e!q~��h�g`mOqH��zjx5��uwx�p�qLs�cvqLm!p��%gHi�p�e!q²hÌzjp�qÙxOcv��cvo�s���qH� -A. e!qLs�q {qLs�q¿l�zjsr|`u�xOzjh�hw�Í��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�pWcXg`s�srqLh¾zHp�u�g`xO��gji$��hwg^m�q��9 �uwp�eÍi;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp�� #E&Yç�(ëÐ^� �gk#O+!,;ç ��(ê �) ��T V� �(��K, zjx5�P �u�p�eD|`g�g��.x!q���� #E&9ç�(ëй � gR#E+�,ZçA��(ë !) �IT Vo �(w�,�-�6 qiÕg^o!x5�2x�g¿��uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p�cvg`srs�qLhÌzjpruwg`xy�¬iÕg^s�p�e!q²h¾zHp�qLxycv�Òu�x.prqLs[cXqLm!p[� -

åÇ���H��á7ñ£�O��á]���ï����K��âÓ�?�W��.�X�àÏâ�î7ãÖM uwxOzHhwh����� �q�h�g�g�H�q�±zHp{��o!� B qHcXp[�RQHm!srqviÕqLs�qÙxOcvqiÕg^sng`o!s�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��×��qLs���oO��zjhwprqLs�xyzjp�u���qIlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� -ÇM g`snpre!qIiÕg`o�snlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�oO��q�Çu�xÏp�e!q�q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ����o!� B q�cvp[�~��e!g �qJ� zD��prs�g`x�|ÇoO�rzj|^q2m�s�qviÕqLsrqLxOcvq±iÕg`s~p�e!qzHhwp�qÙs�xOzHp�uw��q$lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�v�+��qÙhwqHcvpruwx!|~g`o!s$lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�g`x!h��IzHxÍzL��qLs�zj|`q~gji �!-ë p�u�lnqH�v�zHx5�Òp�e�qtg^p�e!qLs ��-ë p�u�lnqH� -7� x¿p�e!q$cLz`��qtgHi�pre!q iÕg^o!s�l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��]x!g^p�oO��q�?����o!� B q�cvp[� {qLs�q�lÒoycfe±lng^s�q�qL��qLx!h��±��m!hwu�pL�!��qLhwq�cvp�u�x!|²g`o!s{lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�zjx z���qÙs[zj|^q�gji �!-�+ pruwlnqH�zHx5�Çp�e�qÒg^p�e!qLs~lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s �G-³� p�u�lnqH� -V. e!uÌ���.u��+qLsrqLxOcvqV �z^�W��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p� �e!qLpre!qLsprqH��prq�ngj��qÙs���o�� B qHcvp[� #�gk#5��)?,AçÛ��(Ä��*�N T V� �(ë `�?, g`s�uwprqLl�� #3gk#O+!,Aç�¹I(êÐ.�8N T V� �(ë .�,�-. e�oO�v�7 �q¿eOzL��q×iÕo�s�p�e�qLs²qL�.u8�.qLxOcXq±p�eOzHp9 �uwpreÇm�s[z`cXp�u¾cXqn��o!� B qHcvp��u {qLs�q¿x!gDhwg`x�|`qLssrqL|�zHs��.u�x!|tpre!q(lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c£ {g`s����]z^��lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��v�Hzjx&�S��gtpre!qA �g^s��!��eOz��²hwg©��pÓ��g^lnqgHi(pre!qLuws;ly|`o!s�zjp�u���q�iÕg`s[cXq -´6 q~zHh¾��g¿p�q���p�qJ� �e�qLp�e!qÙs�p�e!q��.u1�?qÙs�qLxOcXq�uwxni;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp��g^sW|`g�g���x!qH���W�OqLpE {qLqLx�p�e!q¿pE �gÍzHhwprqLs�xOzHp�u���q±lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[��eOz��Êzjx��ÍqR�+qHcvp[��g^xÏp�e!q��o!� B qHcvp��RQ.m�s�qviÕqLsrqLxOcvq -´. e!q �U$TX é � ��u��nx!g`p�lOx5��zHx.�nqk�?q�cvp[��g^stu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xO� -

�L¶EµI�`:tµ�µ�¶E¯t³� xApre!qSlOs[��pÍp�s�uÌzjhÌ�v�WmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�D �qLsrq'��h�gK {qLsÍzHx5� h�qH���Dz`cLcXo!s[zHp�q zjp B o5��|`uwx�|lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHh���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�SpreOzjx'hwu�p�qLs�zjh{��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH� -m. e!u¾�WqHzHs�h��ÇsrqH��o!h�p[�Wlnu�|`e�p²��q��uwq� {q�nz^�t��o!m!mOg`srp�uwx�|2b�q�zjs�h�q?Q³��qÙs�s�g^sO>;s�qHcXgj��qÙs��±p�e�qLg`sr�¢�(u�p�u¾��m!hÌzjoO��uw�!h�q�p�eOzHptmyzjsO>pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�3lOs���pÍzHp�prqLlnm!prq�¹z h�uwp�qÙs[zjh$uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qLp�zjpruwg`x¹gHi¿p�e!qÊlnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cÙzjh²��qLxG>prqLxOcvqH� -�� g �qL��qÙsL�5�.o!sruwx!|�pre!q±cvg^o!s[��qÒgHi{p�e!q±q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL��z`��mOzjsrp�uÌcvuwmOzHx.p��s �qÙs�qq�4�mOg���q�Òp�g��o!�y��q��o!qLx�p�qLxycvg`o!x�p�qÙs[�%gHiÓp�e!qÐ��zjl�q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�v��p�e!qÙuws�mOqLs�iÕg^s�l�zHxOcvqiÕg^s�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcLzjh�prs�u¾zHh¾���OqHcLzjl�q±cvg^lnmOzjs�zj�!h�q� �uwp�eÍpre!qWmOqLs�iÕg`srl�zjxOcXqWuwxDp�e!q~hwu�pO>qLs�zjh!prs�uÌzjh¾� -(� mOg��r��u��!hwq�q�4�m!h¾zHxOzjpruwg`x±uÌ�(p�eOzHpL���.�~p�e!q�qÙx5�Wgjiðp�e!q�q�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.pÙ�vpre!qL�iÕg^s�lnq��zIx!q� �l�qHzjx!u�x!|2iÕg^sWpre!qn��qLe!uÌcvhwq±gHi�pre!qnlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`szjx5�Ïp�e�qL�ÇsrqLp�sruwqL��qJ�pre!u¾�²lnqHzjx�uwx!|���pre.oy�Sm!srg�cvqH����uwx!|Dp�e!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cÙzjh���qLx.prqLxOcvq��Ðu�xÏp�e�qn�rzjlnqV �zL�z^��p�e!qL�¿m!srg�cvqH����q�Òpre!q�hwu�p�qLs�zjh+��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH� -´� x���o!lÍ��uwp(�.g�qH��x!g^p���qLqLl�preOzjp�mOqLg^m!hwq

�Ù�

Page 18: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

x!q�cvqH���rzjsruwhw��m!s�g�cvq�����lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c²��qLx.prqLxOcvq���hwuwprqLs[zHhwh�����z`�Sb�q�zjs�h�q²m!s�g^m�g©��q� -U� g ;>qL��qÙsL�jiÕg^s�g`o!s{s�qLhÌzjp�u���qLhw�~x!gH��qLh+zjxOzHm!e!g^s�u¾c�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�%pre!qL�¿��p[zjsrp�q�ng^o!p; �u�p�enpre!u¾��!uÌz`�; �e!uÌcfeD�E �uwp[c[e!q��z`��p�e!qL��|�zju�x!q�nq�4�mOqLs�u�qLxOcvqU �u�p�e�p�e�qSl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s�� -� iÕprqLs�cvg^lnm!h�qLp�u�x!|�pre!u¾�?q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�� �qZ�.qÙ��qLhwg^m�qJ��zjx � k . >qpÏcvg^lnm!o!p�zjp�u�g`xOzHh

lng���qLh%iÕg^s±p�e!uÌ�Wp[z`�EHÁ �e!u¾c[eÏq�4�m!h¾zHuwx!qJ�Çlng���p±gji$p�e!q�u�lnm!s�gH��qLl¿qLx�p�gH��qLsW��hwg�c�H!�z^�P�.o!q�p�g p�e!q�|`s�z��.oyzjh±z^c���o!u¾��uwp�u�g`xÛgji¿qLh�qLlnqLx�p[�WgHi¿x!q� �g`s�� lnqHzHx!uwx�|��ÒiÕg`spre!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[� -Á6 qP �uwh�h��.q���cvsruw�Oq�p�e!uÌ�×lng���qLh�zLiÕp�qLs¿p�e!qD��qHcvg`x&� q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p -� cÙcvg`s��.uwx!|²prgSpre!u¾�(lng���qLh5�`pre!qLsrqs {qLs�q�g^x!hw�±pE �g²qR�+qHcXp[�(gjiÓpre!qtoy��q�gjiÓlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -M u�s[��pL����o!� B qHcvp��Ò��p[zjsrp�q�8g^o!p2 �u�p�eÛzÇh�uwp�qÙs[zjh���u¾z`�X��zjx5�8g^x!qÍgji~p�e�qIs�q�z`��g^xO�ÒiÕg`spre!qLuws²e!u�|`eÊz`cLcXo!s[z^cv�Íg`xÏl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cSiÕg^uwh¾�U ¬z`�Wz�p�qLx&�.qLxOcv�Íprg�s�q B qHcXpW��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�preOzjp~oO��q�m �g`s��!�Wx!g^xG>5h�uwprqLs[zHhwhw� - b�qHcvg^x5�?�(p�e�qÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s²uwp���qLh£i�|^o!u��.qJ�Ï��o!� B q�cvp[�prgÇpre!q2iÕqHzHp�o!srqH�Wp�eyzjpD�.qklOx!q�Ïp�e�qIx!q� � �g`s��8zHx5�8��gÇi;z`cvu�hwu�p[zjprq�Çpre!qIlnq�zjx!u�x!|z^c��do�u¾��u�p�u�g`x -F. g¿p�qH��p�g^o!s�cXg`lnm!o�p[zjpruwg^xOzjh+lng��.qLhðzjx5��c[e!qHc�H±p�eOzHp�p�e!qH��q� �qLsrq�p�e!qpE �gWiÕq�zjp�o�s�qH��preOzjp��.u¾��p�u�x!|`o!uÌ��e!qJ� l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cs {g`s��!�v�� {qÐiÕqÙhwp�pre!q²x!qLq�nprg2�.g¿zHxq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p�preOzjp²zHh¾��gnoO��qJ�Ix!qLg`h�g`|^u¾��l � " preOzjp²uÌ�v�+cvg`lnm�hwqLprqLhw�¿x!q� Ç �g^s��!�C �uwp�ex!q� lnq�zjx!u�x!|�� -´. e!uÌ� uÌ��p�e!q²m!sruwxOcvu�mOzjhOiÕo!xOcvpruwg^x2gHi�p�e�qW��qHcvg^x5�nq�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p -

×LØ��SzUx;|Ù zT�V���

. e!q ��qHcvg^x5�Aq�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p¤ �z`�D��u�lnuwhÌzjsD �uwpreAp�e!qmlOs[��p -Ö¸ qHcLzHoO��qÏu�pÍzHm!mOqHzjsrq�preOzjp¿��o!� B qHcvp��T �qÙs�qnh�qHzjsrx!uwx!|Íx�q� r {g`s�� l�qHzjx!u�x!|��X�£ {q2u�x.prs�g��.oycvq�Çprs�u¾zHh¾�²p�eOzHpcvg^x.p�zju�x!q�ÏzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh; {g`s��!� -n� i$��o!� B qHcvp��T {qLs�qnh�qHzjsrx!uwx�|Íx!q� �lnqHzHx!uwx�|��ÐiÕg^s±p�e!qlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��v�.pre!qL�V �g^o!h���cvg^lnqtprg±p�srqHzjp{p�e!q²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�{zjx5�npre!q²zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh¢ {g`s����q��o!u��`zHhwqLx�p�h�� -2. gÍz^����qH���Wpre!qD�.qL|^s�qLq�p�gP �e�u¾c[eÇpre!qnmOzHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[�SsrqHzjh�hw�DhwqHzHs�x!q�pre!qU �g^s��!�X�� �q~z����.q��zWmOg���p�p�q���p�m!eOz^��q²uwx¤ �e!u¾c[e2 �q~z^�OH�q�Òpre!qLl/p�g¤�.qRlOx�q�p�e!q {g`s���� pre!qL�¿qLxOcvg^o!x.prqLs�qJ�Y��o!s�u�x!|±p�e!q²q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p -

6 q%oy��q��pE �g�H�uwx5���?gji!iÕg^uwh¾�k�?eOzHs��WzHx5�Sq�z`��� -£. e�q�s�q�z`��g^x9 ¬z`�?p�eyzjpL�^uwx²p�e!q´lOs���pq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�^zSmOg��r��u��!hwq~��prs[zHp�qL|^�×iÕg^s�mOzjsrp�u¾cXuwmOzHx.p��[ ¬z`��prgWuw|^x!g`srq�p�e�q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�zHx5� B o&�.|`q�p�e!q���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�Ò���¹c[e!qHc�H.u�x!|� �e�qLp�e!qÙsnp�e!qÍo�x5�.qLs���p[zHx5�!zH�!hwq�mOzjsrpIgHipre!q���qÙx.prqLxOcvq¿l�zjp�cfe�q�Ëpre!q���p�g`sr� -0. e!uÌ�±��prs[zjprqL|`�m �z^�Wm!s[z^cvp�uÌcLzjh�hw�Íu�x.i;zjh�hwuw��hwq±uwxpre!qÍ��qLp�pruwx!|ÍgHiWpre!q2lOs[��pnq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pWzHx5�8�rzL��q�Ïp�e!qDmOzjsrp�u¾cXuwmOzHx.p±pre!qIqR�+g^s�pngHim!srg�cvqH�r��uwx�|nza �g^s��Y �u�p�eDzjxDo!x�H�x!g �x�lnqHzjx�uwx!| -A. e!u¾��u¾��mOqLsreOzjmO�� �e�����o!� B q�cvp[�x!qÙ��qLs���e!g {q�Ízjx�z^cLcvo!s�z`cv��qR�+qHcvp�iÕg`s�i;zjh¾��q±lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcS��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH���!o!p�g^x!hw��iÕg`sprs�o!q²g`x�qH� -A. e!q²eOzHs��niÕg`uwhÌ�%u�x2pre!q~��qHcXg`x5�nq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p´ �qLsrq²��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�(iÕg`sC �e!u¾c[epre!u¾�;H�uwx5�ngHi(l�zHp[c[e!uwx�|±��prs[zHp�qL|^�Y {g`o!h8�Òi;zjuwh -

��Ð

Page 19: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

§©¨«ª5®C¯CÞß��!�L�àÕ�?àÏáÓ��â�����ã . e!qImyzjs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�a �qÙs�q ¹? k{zHs�x!qÙ|`uwqÖ}IqLhwh�g`x �tx!u���qLs[��uwp��Ío!xG>�.qÙs�|`s�z��.oyzjp�q��t �e!g¤ �qLsrq�xOzjpruw��q Ì x!|`h�u¾��eI��mOqHzKH�qLs��tzHx5�Y �e�gÒmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjprq�nuwx�p�e!qq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p]iÕg`s$cvsrq�.uwp -´$ g^x!q²gji�p�e!qÙl �z^�tz±mOzjsrp�uÌcvuwmOzHx.p{uwx Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p ��-

å �.����àé��æé��ã�6 q�oO��q��pre!q * lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s���mOzHuws[�?iÕs�g^lAp�e�q Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � �Hp�gC �e!u¾c[e {qWz!���.q�Ig^x!qWl�g`s�q²lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s # ����?^ � ]�\��������?c�����^R����º?g�e ,�-�6 q~oO��qJ�2p�e�q±��zHlnqg^h�� й myz`���rzj|^qH�Òm!h�oO� * lng^s�q�cvg^s�srqH��mOg`x&�.uwx!|Êp�g�p�e!qDx!q� /mOzju�s -�. e!qDzL��qLs�zj|`qh�qLx!|`preÍgji¬p�e!q±mOz^���rzj|`q��T �z^� �L�`� �g^s��!� -3. e�u¾�tpruwlnq��!iÕg`s$qHz`c[eÍmOz`�r��zH|`q2 {q¿cvg`xG>��p�s�oycvp�q� Ð m�g©����uw�!h�q2p�zjsr|`qLp¿��qLx.prqLxOcvq��R�ÒpE {gIhwu�p�qLs�zjh;�]pE �gÍlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c`��zjx5�ÏpE �gcvg^x.p�zju�x!uwx!|Özjx zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHhA �g`s�� -Í� �²�OqviÕg`srq��(p�e!q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾cWp�zjsr|`qLp��±cvg`x�p[zHuwx!q�zHxOzjm!e�g`s�uÌc2lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� -�M g`s¿p�e�qIzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s��'p[zHs�|`qÙp[�v�{p�e!q�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�a �qÙs�qsrqLm!h¾z^cvq�W���±z�x!g^xOcvqC �g`s�� - b©g`lnq�gHi�p�e�q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c{zjx5�¿hwuwprqLs[zHh!��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�£ �qÙs�qu8�.qLx�p�u¾cÙzjh5 �uwpreI��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH��oO��qJ� u�x Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p ��-

� zHh½i�mOz`�r��zj|^qH�(eOz��Weyzjs���i;zjhÌ��q�p�zjsr|`qLp��(z`�r��g�cvuÌzjp�qJ�9 �uwp�e~p�e!qÙl ò preOzjpÓu¾�X�jpre!g���qp�zjs�|^qLp[�$cvg`o!h8�2x!g^p��Oq±zHxO�O {qLs�q�ÍcXg`s�srqHcvprhw�2 �u�p�e!g^o!pUH�x!g �hwq�.|^qWgHi{zjh�h]pre!q9 {g`s����u�xÒpre!q���qLx�p�qÙxOcvq -F. e!q i;zHh¾��q���qLx�p�qLxycvqH��iÕsrg`l Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p � �qLsrqtx!g^p�eOzjs�� " qL��qLxu£i�p�e!qnmyzjs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[���.u���x!g`paH�x!g y �eOzjpU_�^�g�g�ôgk^nlnqHzHx.p²uwxÊp�eOzHp±cvg^x.prq�4.pÙ�]pre!qL�cvg^o!h���uwx.iÕqÙs�p�eOzHptpre!q±��qLx.prqLxOcvqj��cG�1�2e�f5g9�1�K\ke(^��?h«\T�O_9e�f5gA_�^�g�g�ôgk^�hig�^�g������]��=�Ïg�� ¬z`�ti;zjhÌ��q��Ó��u�xOcvq±pre!qLs�qa ¬z`��x!gDg`� B qHcvp$uwxÍp�e�qn��p�g`sr�0 �e!g���q0�?c��1�Y�1�K\keu^��?h«\ähigk^�g�����]��=�Ïg�� -Í� xÏq�4!zHlnm!hwq±gHi$zÍ��prg`s��m �uwpre'zjx z^����g�cXu¾zjprq�ÏeOzjs��Çi;zjh¾��q���qÙx.prqLxOcvq¿u¾�|^uw��qLxDuwx . zj��hwq ÐG-�� i�pre!qLsrqWu¾��x!g2H�x!g �hwq�.|^q±zH��g^o!p� �e!g`l©jRg��?^3�.qÙx!g`prqH�tuwxDp�e!q��qLx.prqLxOcvqV�¢f5g(jRg��?^;c���e@���Rg��9� � �?cT\k�`g�g%�=��c�dV��cV�R�1�K\�\X�`pre!q�zHxO�O {qLs�cLzjx!x�g`p(�Oq�|`u���qLx���Òl zjp[c[e!u�x!|�p�e�qSsrqH��p{gjiÓpre!q²��qÙx.prqLxOcvq�prgWpre!q�mOz^����zH|`q -(� x&�.qLq�?��u£i(jRg��?^ÐsrqviÕqLs[�(prg� � � �jpre!qLx±pre!q���qLx�p�qÙxOcvq�u¾�]prs�o!q©��zjx5�Wu£iOuwp�s�qviÕqLs���prgae�f5gC��e¦f��Ig�eOg��.p�e�qLxWpre!q���qLx�p�qÙxOcvquÌ�%i;zjh¾��q -

6 q���qLhwqHcXp�q�Wpre!s�qLq$zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh5 �g`s��!� # �=��cGeEgkc7�´ô���� �5gk^��[���?^��R�5g , p�eyzjp; {qLs�q�s[zHp�q�z^�Wp�e!qnl�g���p²m!hÌzjoO��uw�!h�q Ì x!|`h�u¾��eS �g^s��!�SiÕsrg`l z�hwu¾��pWgHi �k¹ zjs�pru�l+cXu¾zjhA {g`s���� -06 qz^����o�lnq�±p�eOzHp�x!g±qLp���lng`h�g`|^u¾cLzHh.g^s�lng^s�m!e!g^hwg^|`u¾cÙzjh5H.x�gK �h�q�.|^q�cvg^o!h��¿�!u¾z^�%mOzHs�p�uÌc�>u�mOzjx�p[��prgK ¬zjs��!�tz¿��mOqHcXu¾zjh+lnqHzHx!uwx!|~gji�pre!qH��qT {g`s��!� -

ß²����?�G�+Ó�K�5ã�6 q~oO��qJ�Ip�e!q��zjl�qWq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p[zjhOmOzHs[z!�.uw|^l�z`��iÕg`s Ì 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p�!-�� zHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[��p�g�g�HÖzj�Og`o�p ¹�� lnu�x.o!prqH�%prg3lOx!uÌ��eDp�e!q~p[z`�EH!� -�� p�s�uÌzjh�cvg`xy��u¾��p�q�gHiWpre!qÍ�rzjlnq�pre!s�qLqDm!eOz^��qH�nz^�Ò�OqviÕg`srq -L. e�qIg`x�hw�'q�4�cvqLm!pruwg`xÁ ¬z`�ÒpreOzjpnu�x8pre!u¾�q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p(p�e�qSp�zjsr|`qLp$cvg`o�h��n�OqSh�uwprqLs[zHh5�.l�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾c�g`s$zjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh�>@ �g`s�� -

M g`snq�z`c[e¹��o�� B qHcvpL��g`x�qÍp�e!u�s�� gHi~p�e!qDp[zjsr|`qLp��3 �qÙs�qIh�uwprqLs[zHh5��g`x!qÍpre!uws��< �qÙs�qlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c²zjx5�Ig^x!q±p�e�uws��P {qLs�qzjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh�>@ �g`s�� -s6 qWoy��q�Ipre!q¿��zHlnq��.qH��u�|`x�z^�

�+

Page 20: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q Ð � � ��prg`sr�'cvg`srs�qH��mOg`x5�.u�x!|Íp�gÍpre!qnmOzHuws � �K\�\����KgD��e�f��`g�eEg^�SjRg��?^�zjx&� u�p[�z^����g�cXu¾zjprq�I��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -õH¡£ª¹¥�¯L�Ó¯�¨�»`¡³®³¦H��¦^¨�»j·�Æ�¶�«`¡³¦^ [µ��é«�¦^«`��¦L¸O»`¡³�Ó�[®£¯L�����[�vÉ©»`��«`¦H¤�¡³�[�[�~¯�ØH�X 5·²ª²¯�����¡³ØH�(·H¦^¶�«`´ª²¯H«t¥{»`¦�¥�¯L�Ó¯L®³¥�¯v·^�?��®³�[�X¨`¡£«`´²¯H«`�~«`�[ØH�X �¨�¯L¡³�~¯j«H·�¯L¤�¤��X«j¤�¡³¦^«t¤�¦�¤r»`�(��¡³���X¶`����¡³¦^«`�vµ�Ã�»`���»�¯j �¯L�[¤��X ��X¯Hª��(¤�¦�¤r»`�(¦H¤r»`�X ?���XªÐ¡°«�¯j 5�XÉL¤�¦`¦�ÉH¢�¶`¤Ó«`¦H¤r»`¡£«`´����[�XªÐ�[�²¤�¦� �¯L¡³����»`¡³�Ó¡£«H¤��X 5�[��¤Xµ� «`�²��¯v·HÉ���¦^ª��X¢�¦`��·n¤�¦H®³�2õH¡£ª�¤r»`��ª²¯H«Ò¥�¯L��¯WØH�X 5·±´H¦`¦^�n®³¡£«`�X¢�¯L��öL�X �¤r»�¯�¤�»�¯L��¢��[�X«¯L®³®ÂÅÕ��¤r¯L¤���¡£«S¸Ì¦`¦H¤r¢�¯�®Ä®¾µÓÎ`¦�¤r»`��ªt·^��¤��X 5·²¥�¯L�]��¦H®³ØH�[�OºÓ»`��¥�¯L��¯L�[�[�X¨`¤��[�±¯L¤(¤r»`�¬¶�«`¡³ØH�X ­��¡³¤;·¸Ì¦` �»`¡³��¯L¤r»`®³�[¤��� �¯L¤r»`�X (¤�»�¯H«S¸Ì¦` �»`¡³��¨�»`¡³®Ä¦j��¦^¨�»`�X t��¶�¯L®³¡Ä¤�¡Ä�[�vµ

ü¤ýRþ�ÿ�����������ÿ�� ��ý���þ�ý����ý����Ã�»`��¢��X¯j �¥�¯L�(��®³�[�X¨`¡£«`´±¡£«±¤r»`��¨�»`¡³®³¦H��¦^¨�»j·¿�[®£¯L���Xµ��Ïþ�����ý��Ã�»`��¢��X¯j {«`¦H¤�¡Ä�[�[�n¯²ª²¯H«W��®Ä�[�X¨`¡£«`´±¡£«±�[®£¯L���Xµ�����ÿ�����ý��

� �`þ�ý��%ÿ�����ý��Gþ�ý����ý!���Ã�»`��¯L¤r»`®³�[¤��t¥�¯L�(��®³�[�X¨`¡°«`´±¡£«×¤r»`��¨�»`¡³®Ä¦j��¦^¨�»j·¿�[®£¯L���Xµ`��þ����!ý��Ã�»`��¯L¤r»`®³�[¤���«`¦H¤�¡³�[�[��¯Sª²¯H«W��®³�[�X¨`¡£«`´±¡£«±�[®£¯L���Xµ`�#��ÿ�����ý��

� ��þ�� �A��`ÿ����' "���E¡¢��ý���þ�ý����ý����Ã�»`���X¯H 5¦`¨���¥�¯L�(��®³�[�X¨`¡£«`´±¡£«±¤r»`��¨�»`¡³®³¦H��¦`¨�»H·Ò�[®°¯����Xµ��Ïþ�����ý��Ã�»`���X¯H 5¦`¨��$«`¦j¤�¡³�[�[��¯²ª²¯j«W��®³�[�X¨`¡°«`´±¡£«×�[®°¯����Xµ�����ÿ��£��ý��

u�hwhwoy��p�s�zjprq�nuwx . zj�!h�q � �+q�4!cXqLm!p�p�eyzjp�x!g p�e�qLs�q� �qLsrqWp�e�s�qLqcvg`h�o!lnxO�%iÕg^s�hwu�p�qLs�zjh5�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c�zHx5��zjs�pru�l+cXu¾zjh1>% {g`s�� �u�p�eDp�e!srqLq�p�g^m!u¾cÙ��uwx�qHz`c[e -

M g`s~qHz`c[e'��o�� B qHcvp� �qns�zjx5��g`lnh���z`����uw|^x!q�Ïp�e!srqLq¿p�g`m�u¾cL��iÕg`s±lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�²zHx5�pre!s�qLq�iÕg`s�zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh5 �g^s��!� -;. eyzjp�u¾�X�!z~��o!� B qHcXp�cvg^o!h��n��qLq�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c�p[zjsr|`qLp��%iÕg`szHhwh!pre!q���p�g^s�uwq��%cXg`xOcvqÙs�x!u�x!|!�jiÕg^s�uwxO��p[zjxycvq���l�z`�r��u���q�zjpre!hwqÙp�qH�X�`hwu�p�qLs�zjh!p�zjs�|^qLp[�]iÕg^s�zHhwhpre!q¿��prg`s�u�qH��cvg^xOcvqLsrx!uwx�|!�?iÕg`s�u�xO��p�zjxOcXq���cvg^h��Is�g�g^l��v�ÓzHx5�Ëp�zjsr|`qLp��ScXg`x�p[zju�x!uwx�|np�e!qzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh; {g`s��o���?^��R�5gWiÕg`s¿zjh�h���p�g`sruwqH�±cXg`xOcvqÙs�x!u�x!|Io!x�p[zHhwqLx�p�qJ�ÇlÒoy��u¾cXu¾zjxy� -0. e!qprg`m!uÌcL�ä {qLs�qÖz`�r��g�cvuÌzjp�qJ� �u�p�e¹zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjhC �g^s��!�Òs�zjx5��g`lnh����%u - q - g^xOcvqÍp�e�qIp�g^m!u¾c]�cGe@���`gkcGeEg�� � ]�\��������?cL �z^�2��qLhwq�cvp�q� iÕg^sDz ��o!� B qHcvpÙ�tu�pY ¬z`�D�.qHcXu��.q�8s�zjx5��g`lnh�� �e!qÙp�e!qLs����?^��R�5g[�?�=��cGeOg�cËg`sUô���� ��g�^T �g^o!h����.qLx!g^p�q²uwp�iÕg^s�p�eOzHp���o!� B qHcvp -

Ì z`c[eIp�zjs�|^qLpC �z`�$��qLh�qHcvp�qJ�Òp�g¿�OqWp�sro!qWg^s i;zHh¾��q±zjp�s[zHx5�.g^l -�� zHh½i�gji�pre!qSi;zHh¾��qp�zjs�|^qLp[�9 {qLs�q¤ �s�uwprp�qLxÊp�gÍ�Oq�eOzjs�� -S. eOzHp±u¾�X�]iÕg`s¿zÍ��o�� B qHcvpL��zH�Og`o!p¿eOzjh£i�gji$p�e!qp�zjs�|^qLp[�C �qLsrqSprs�o!q©�?zH��g^o!p²z2��oOzHs�p�qÙss {qLs�q²qHz^���niÕg`u�h¾��zjx5�ÍzHx!g`pre!qLs���oOzjsrp�qLsC �qÙs�qeOzHs��niÕg`uwhÌ� -� ���OqviÕg`srq���p�e!q±q�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p� �z^�²��p�sroOcvpro!s�q�Íuwx * mOz`�r��qH� -VÌ z^cfe�mOz^���Seyz�� )

prs�u¾zHh¾��cvg`x�p[zHuwx!u�x!| ) ��u��+qLs�qÙx.p�mOz^���rzj|`q��SmOqLs�p�zju�x!uwx!|¿p�g�p�e!q ) ��u��+qLs�qÙx.p�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s

��*

Page 21: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

prg`m!uÌcL� -F� qLxOcvq©�vuwx~p�g^p[zjh;�`��o!� B qHcvp��?s�qHz!� +�� ��p�g`sruwqH� -(� ���OqviÕg`srq��Hx!g���o!� B qHcvpÓ�rz� Ïp�e!q�rzjlnq²mOz^����zH|`q±g^stpre!q±�rzjlnq²p[zHs�|^qLptpE �uÌcvq��!e!qLxycvq²uwp� �z^�tuwl�m�g©����uw�!h�qtiÕg`s$��o!� B q�cvp[�prgÒoO��q~za�.qHcvuÌ��uwg^x�s�qLprs�uwqÙ�`zHh���p�s[zHp�qL|^� -� iÕprqLs B o5�.|^uwx!|nq�z`c[eÍ��qÙx.prqLxOcvq��O��o!� B qHcvp�� mOqLs�iÕg`srlnq��zÒ��p�qLl cvg^lnm!h�qLp�u�g`xnp�z`�OH

z^��uwx Ì 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p � ·O��u�xOcvq�x�g±uwx�p�qLsrqH��pruwx!|²qR�+qHcvp��; �qLsrq���uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�p�iÕg`s�p�e�u¾�%p�z`�EH?� {qT �u�hwh+x!g`p��.u¾�rcvoO�r��uwp�uwx�pre!q²s�qH��o!hwp�����qHcvpruwg^x -� p]pre!q�qLx5�WgHi�p�e�q�q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�LmOzHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[�£ {qLs�q¬z`�OH�qJ�Wp�g��.qklOx!q�p�e�q�lnqHzjx�>

u�x!|���gHi�p�e!q²lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s���zjx&�2gjiþp�e!q~zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh¢ {g`s���� qLxycvg`o!x�p�qÙs�q�2��o!s�u�x!|±p�e!q²q�4?>mOqLsruwlnqLx�p -ZÌ z`c[eImOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�pteyz��2prgD�.qRlyx!qWpre!q9 {g`s��2lOs[��p�g`o�p�gji{cXg`x�p�q�4�pL�OzHx5�pre!qLx� �uwpre±zjx~q�4�zjlnm!h�q(gjiyuwp[�?oy��zj|^q�g`x~p�e!q{��cXs�qLqLx -£. e�q�q�4�zjlnm�hwqH�5 �qLsrq���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�preOzjp�eOz��ng�cLcXo!s�srq�2u�xnp�e!q²q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p -

9�¨7µ;:=<%ª�µ� �±iÕg`s Ì 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p � �C �qP �u�hwh�s�qLmOg^s�p��Og`p�e >\@ zHx5� >�B�-Ç� g {qL��qLsL�A �qÍx�g`p�qpreOzjpÙ�O��uwxycvq²l�zjprqLs�uÌzjh¾�A �qLsrq�s[zHx5�.g^lnhw��z`�r��uw|^x!q��p�g�cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`xO�%iÕg^stq�z`c[eI��o!� B qHcvpÙ�pre!q±uwprqLl���p[zjpru¾��p�u¾cÙ��zjsrq¿��g`l�q� �eOzjp²srq�.o!x5��zjx�p -96 q±qLhwu�lnuwxyzjp�qJ��iÕsrg`l g`o!s~zjxyzjh�>����uÌ�Sp�e�g���qD��qLx.prqLxOcvq��$iÕg^sa �e!u¾c[e�p�e!q�zL��qLs�zj|^q�z`cLcXo!s[z^cv� # zj|^|`s�qÙ|�zjprq� gH��qLs²�Og`prelnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c²zjx5��hwu�p�qLs�zjhÓcvg^x5�.uwpruwg^xO� , �z^�thwqH�r� preOzjx �! mOqLs[cXqLx.p�u�xI�Og`pre Ì 4.mOqLsru�>lnqÙx.p � zjx5� Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p ��¤-´M g`sÓp�sro!q�p�zjsr|`qLp�zHxOzjh��!��u¾�X�� �q�qLh�uwlnu�xOzjprq� � mOz`�r��zj|^qH�g^o!p]gHi +H�9#�¹�-w��Ð mOqLs�cvqLx�p , ·`zHx5�SiÕg`s�i;zjhÌ��q�p�zjsr|`qLp�zHxOzjh��!��u¾�� �q�qLh�uwlnu�xOzjprq� + mOz`�r��zj|^qH�g^o!ptgHi +��Y#@)G-1+H� m�qÙs[cvqLx�p ,�-

ßC�.�H�?��â��H��î¢�^L����H����`�?ãÛ. e!q�mOqLs[cXqLx.p�zj|^q�gjiÓcXg`s�srqHcvp�zHxO�O {qLs[��u¾�(m!h�g`p�prq�Wuwx M u�|K>o!srq ��-A. e!qH��q�s�qH��o!hwp��%zHs�q���qLs����u�lnuwhÌzjs7 �uwp�e¿p�e�qtsrqH��o!h�p[�]g^�!p[zHuwx!qJ�Òuwx Ì 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p�U# ��qLq M uw|^o!s�q �K,�-´6 e!uwh�q%pre!u¾�Óq�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pOuwx���g`h���q��x!q� '��qLx�p�qLxOcXq�zjx&�Wp�s�uÌzjh�p��.mOqH�# eOzjs��2iÕg`uwhÌ�v��zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s���p�sru¾zjhÌ� , �?p�e!q¿cXg`s�srqLh¾zHp�u�g`xI�OqLpE {qLqLxIpre!q¿cvg^lnlng`x cvg`xG>�.u�p�u�g`xO��uwx M uw|^o!s�q � zHx5� M uw|^o!s�q�� � u¾� &äç/ �(ê*� �-�� zHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[����p[zHs�prq�2������qÙuwx!|u�xOz`cLcXo!s[zHp�q2iÕg^sÒx�g`xG>;hwu�p�qLs�zjh�p�s�o�qI��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�v����o!pÒ��qÙs��'��g�g`xÛp�e!qLu�s±mOqLs�iÕg^s�l�zHxOcvqu�lnm!s�gH��q�¿zjx&� �OqHcÙzjlnq²cXg`lnmOzHs[zH�!hwqU �u�p�e�p�eyzjp�iÕg`s�hwuwprqLs[zHh?prs�u¾zHh¾� -

. e!q �U$TX é � g^x'm�qÙs[cvqLx�p[zH|`qDcvg^s�s�q�cvpa�.o�s�uwx�|Ï��qLx.prqLxOcvq B o5�.|`qÙlnqLx�pW��e!g �q���uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.p²qR�+qHcXp[�tiÕg`s~p�e!q¿p�sru¾zjh�p���m�q # hwu�p�qLs�zjh5��lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�g^s±zHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh�>@ �g^s�� ,�ò>A@�#5��NR+*?,sç �� �(¥¹ Ð �APRQ�S @�ç )K¹ *�(w�� �/T @ZV� �(ê � � �� � >�Bk#5��NÙ��Ð�,Cç/*�(1+) ��PRQ�S BUç¹  � �(êÐ�* �]T B¥VÛ �(ê � ^� ��zHx5�8iÕg`s�p�sro!p�e #?>A@�#;��NR+J*�,mç +v(��`� �¢PRQ�S @�ç ��N[�!)�)�(1+Ð �T @^V �(ë � ^� � >cBR#5��NL��Ð?,3ç ¹¦(ëÐ?+ �]PRQ�S BYç Ð�*?+v(³�!Ð �AT BMV �(ë ^��, zjx5�'��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p§ ïLá�á%ù�çLçXèéîHçXèéá�÷Xÿ]Ü�ÝHá�àéá�äðâfßÓçXîjá{æ^âfßÕß5â[íXá%èÕÝ^âfè�çLã�ã�åHàÕàéá�ê±çXîHü³ì�Þ³î¨FIHLæ`á�àÕÞ³ú�á�îÙè(ö�âfîHê²ä�â[ßá�ü³Þ³ú�Þ³î^â[èéá�ê�ÿ

��)

Page 22: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

u�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xO���OqLpE �qLqÙxÇprs�o!pre'zjx5�Ï�!h�g�c�H #-> @ #%Ð�N[�`�¹G,Vçv¹I(³�?+ �tPRQ�S @ ç�)!)�)�(ê*�+ �T @ V �(ë ! � `� � > B #@Ð�N�¹ *�,0ç ��(Ä��) �¢PRQ�S B çÛ¹?Ð!*�(ê*� �©T B VÖ �(ë ^��,�-Ç. e!qÍ�!hwg�c�HqR�+qHcXp9 �z^�±��u�|`x!u1l+cLzjx�pW����p�e!q���o!� B qHcvpzjxOzHhw����uÌ� #-> @ #5��NÙ�`�K+!,2ç ��(�+©� �]PRQ�S @ ç*¹?Ð�(Ä�� �`T @aVv �(Ä��, �!o�pWx!g^pW���Çpre!qnuwprqLl zjxyzjhw����uÌ� #?>�B�#5��N[�K¹�,açª(êÐ�* �tPRQ�S B2ç�^�`��(Ä�`�?,�-Ä. e!qIg^p�e!qLs�uwx�p�qLs�z`cvpruwg`xy�ä {qLs�qDzjhÌ��g ��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p¿g`x!h��ÏiÕg`snpre!qÍ��o!� B qHcvpzHxOzjh��!��u¾�R�Ó�OqLpE �qLqLx~p�sru¾zjh�p��.mOq¬zjx5�±p�sro!p�e #?>A@�#�¹INL�Ù��Ð�,ZçÛ��(Ä��Ð � P*QYS @;ç �8N[�!*�Ð�(êÐ�Ð �T @�VÖ �(ê � � ^� � >�BR#�¹IN[�^��,Pç*��(¥¹ Ð �GPRQ�S B0ç �K¹©��(ë !Ð�, �t�OqLpE �qLqÙx8p�sru¾zHh�p���mOqÍzHx5��!h�g�c�H #->A@�#%Ð�N[�`�¹G,mç ��(ê)�* �XPRQ�S @mç +!+)�(Ä�`� �]T @¥V �(ë �� � >�B�#%Ð�N�¹?*?,�ç �8(³��� �PRQ�S BtçÛ�!*.��(³��)?, zHx5�S�OqLpE {qLqLx�prs�u¾zHh�p��.mOq��Lprs�o!pre±zjx&�Ð��hwg�c�H #->A@�#��Ù��N�¹ Ð�*�,�ç ��(�+�� �PRQ�S @;çL+J)`��(³�`� ��T @]V� �(ë ! `� � >�Bk#��L��N�)�Ð?,;ç ��(ëÐ?+ �ePRQ�S BtçÛ�¹�¹I(ê)�* ��T BUV� �(w�K,�-�U$TX é � g`xÍpre!qTlys[��p$�!hwg�c�H��!zjp�z×iÕg`o!x&�Il�zju�x2qk�?q�cvp[��gji{p�sro!p�e #?>A@�#;��NR+J*�,Cç

�!Ð�(ë)! �tPRQ�S @aç �8N���*�+O(ë*!Ð ��T @uVy �(ë � ! .� � >�Bk#5��NL��Ð?,9ç�Ð�(êÐ� �tP*QYS Bäç ���R¹I(1+�+ �T BUV� �(ë .�, zjx5�±gji+p�sru¾zHh!p��.mOq #->\@�#5��NR+*?,;çÛ�!Ð�(ê)� �IPRQ�S @;ç�Ð!*.��(³�`� �8T @]V� �(ë � ! .� �>�Bk#5��NL��Ð?,sç/�� �(ë)^� �`P*QYS BTç ��+*�(³�!* �/T BXV/ �(ê � .�, �Äzjx5��zjxÍu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xI�OqLpE {qLqLxprs�u¾zHh�p��.mOqÖzjx5�¹p�sro!p�e #?>A@k#Ϲ¦NL�L�!Ð�,mç �� �(ê `� �XP*QYS @mçÛ)^�K¹¦(ë)`� �]T @«VÛ �(ë � ! .� �>�Bk#Ϲ¦N[�`�?,aç ��(w�Ù� �YP*QYS B3ç �K¹©��(ë*!Ð ��T BaVy �(ë ^��,�-ÑM g^sWqHz^���IiÕg^uwh¾�X�]mOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[� {qLs�qDz`cÙcvo!s[zHp�qniÕs�g^l p�e�qI�OqL|`u�x!x!u�x!| # ��qLq M uw|^o!s�q ��, �; �e!uÌcfe ��o�|`|`q���p[�¿qL�.u8�.qLxOcXqiÕg^s±zÍcvg^x.prq�4.p~l�zjp�cfe�uwx!|���p�s�zjp�qÙ|`�Ïu�xÏp�e!qVlOs[��p±�!hwg�c�H - b�o!� B qHcvp��²��e!g �qJ� ��g`lnqk> �eOzHp�|`srqHzjprqLs²z^cLcvo!s�z`cv��g`x�zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s��Iprs�o!q��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH��p�eOzHxÍg`xÍlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cprs�o!q²��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�v���!o!p�hwg {qLs�z^cLcvo!s�z`cv�¿g`x�eOzHs��IzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s��±iÕg`uwhÌ��p�eOzHx�g`x�eOzjs��lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾ctiÕg`u�h¾� -�. e�u¾����o!|^|`qH��p[�²znhwuwprqLs[zHh�uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qÙp[zjpruwg^xÍ��prs[zHp�qL|^�2iÕg`s$m!s�g�cvq����q>u�x!|²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�]uwxV �e!uÌcfe¿��o!� B qHcvp��[ {qLs�q�u�xOcvh�uwx!q�WprgWsrq B qHcvp�z^�]i;zjh¾��q�zHhwhlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c���qLx.prqLxOcvq�� -

X x¹p�e!qÍg^p�e!qÙsneOzjx&�?��uwx¹p�e�qIh¾z^��pn��hwg�c�H8p�e�qIqR�+qHcvp�gji~p�sru¾zjh�p��.mOq� �z`�nm!srqR>��qLs���q�±iÕg`s�p�e�qW��o!� B qHcvp¬zjxOzHhw����uÌ� #?> @ #;��NR+J*�,;çN¹I(ì¹�� �cPRQ�S @ çËÐK¹��8(�+©�8N T @ VË �(ë ^� �> B #5��NL��Ð?,aç¬(ë)?+ �tPRQ�S B ç �.�Ù��(³���K, ·%e!g {qL��qLs�pre!qLs�qV �z^�Sx!g���p[zHp�u¾��p�uÌcLzjh{��u�|`x!u1l�>cLzHx.pZ�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvqt�OqLpE {qLqLx¿p�e!q�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�zHx5�Òhwu�p�qLs�zjhOcXg`x5�.u�p�u�g`xO� #-> @ #��8N���)�,Zç)(ëÐ^� �PRQ�S @ çr+J `��(��`�, �£ �e�u¾c[e���o!|^|`qH��p[�SpreOzjp²pre!qnzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh´ {g`s��!�U �qLsrq±s�qH��m�g^xO��u��!hwqiÕg^sSpre!q±p�sru¾zHh(p��.mOq±qR�+qHcvp$uwx�p�e!q±hÌz`��p²�!h�g�c�H -a. e!qÙs�qviÕg^s�q��¢ {q¿cLzjxÊcvg^xOcvhwo&�.q±p�eOzHpL� �e!u�hwq{mOzjsrp�u¾cXuwmOzHx.p��]m!s�g�cXqH����q�WlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�]u�x±p�e!q��rzjlnqZ �zL�±z^�(hwuwprqLs[zHh¾�Ózjp(pre!q�qLx5�gHi(pre!q²q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ�`p�e!qÙ����pruwhwh+eOz��D��g^lnq��.u1W�cvo�hwp��a �uwpreIp�e�qWzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh= �g`s��!� -� ��iÕg`s Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p � �5 �qcvg`l�m!o!p�qJ� pre!qWh�qHzjsrx!uwx�|n��hwg`mOqH�$zjx5�Iu�x.prqLs[cvqÙm!p[��gHi

qHz^cfe~gjiðp�e!q{uwp�qÙl�� - ��x!hwuIH�q%u�x Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � �? �qC�.u8�Sx!g^p[lyx5�±z���u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p�cXg`s�srqR>hÌzjp�u�g`xD��qÙpO {qLqLx�p�e�qSh�qHzjsrx!uwx�|n��hwg`mOqH��zjx&�2p�e�qSi;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp�� #E&9ç)(ì¹�¹G, g`s$|`g�g��.x!q����#'&Tç)(w�^�K, gji+lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -7� g �qL��qLsÙ�Lp�e!q¬cvg`srs�qLhÌzjpruwg`x� �uwpreSi;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp��� �z^�]zHp(hwqHz^��p �u�p�eÍp�e�qn�rzjlnq��.uwsrqHcvp�u�g`x�z^�Ðu�x Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p ��-a. e!q���h�g`mOqH�tiÕg`s²pre!q±lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� {qLs�qDx!g`p���uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�p�hw�'|^s�qHzHp�qLs¿p�eOzHx N#3gk#%*?,Pç (Ä�`��, ���!o!pnpre!q���h�g`mOqH�×iÕg^snp�e!qzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjhA �g^s��!�� �qLsrq #�gR#@*�,�ç ��(ë)^��,�-�. e!qnu�x.prqLs[cXqLm!p[�tiÕg^sWp�e�qÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��T �qÙs�q

�!

Page 23: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

x!g^p�cvg`srs�qLhÌzjprq�3 �uwprenqLu�p�e!qLs�|^g�g��.x!qH�r�tg`s�i;zHlnuwh�u¾zjsruwp�� -�. e�qU �qHzH�qLs�qk�?q�cvp[��uwxnpre!u¾�q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p?l�zL�²s�qkÕOqHcvpÓp�e!q�iÕq� �qLsÓg`�O��qLs��^zHp�uwg^xO�(mOqLs(uwprqLl3>;�.�?>;p���mOq{cvg`l¿�!uwxyzjp�u�g`x -

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# z ,�. s�o!q~��qLx.prqLxOcvq��

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct

­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct

­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# � ,ZÌ z`��� M g^uwhÌ� # c ,Z� zjs�� M g`uwhÌ�M u�|`o!srq � ��z , � qLs[cXqLx.p�zj|^qWgji¬cvg^s�srqHcvp$zjxO�E �qLs��tp�gnprs�o!q¿��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� u�x Ì 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p� z^�ÒzIiÕo!xOcvpruwg^xÏgji²��hwg�c�H!�WgHi�m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq - � ,~� qÙs[cvqLx�p[zH|`qngHi²cXg`s�srqHcvp¿zHxO�O {qLs[�WprgqHz^����i;zjh¾��q¿��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�tu�x Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � z^�SzÒiÕo!xycvp�u�g`xÍgji¬�!hwg�c�H��tgji¬m!s[z^cvp�uÌcvq - c ,� qÙs[cvqLx�p[zH|`q±gHi�cvg^s�s�q�cvp²zjxy�O �qÙs[��p�g�eOzHs��Ii;zjh¾��qn��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� u�x Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p � z^�²ziÕo!xycvp�u�g`x�gji��!hwg�c�H���gji�m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq -

l2����áA�5â]���Tí�àÏðÁ�_®��O�¢q ��â����â]�?�Uoc+£�î=�GðÁ��â��?ãÖ. e!q B o5�.|`qÙlnqLx�p�hÌzjprqLxOcvu�qH��iÕg`sÌ 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p � zjsrq�m!s�q���qLx�p�q��u�x M u�|`o!srq ¹�-A. e�q �U$TX é � g`x B o&�.|`qLl�qLx.p�hÌzjprqLxOcvu�qH���e!g �q�Ïl�zHuwxÏqR�+qHcXp[�WgjiÐp�s�o�p�e #?>A@�#;��NR+J*�,2ç �� �(³�¹ �UPRQ�S @Dç �K+vN�Ð�Ð�)�N[�.��)�(êÐ`� �T @MV �(ë ! � .� � >�BR#;��NL��Ð�,2ç ¹I(Ä�`� �=PRQ�S BYç �8NÙ�L�`��N�*`�¹I(Ä��* �©T BMV �(ê `�?, zHx5� gHi�!h�g�c�H #->A@�#5��NL�`�+�,UçÄÐ!Ð�(¥¹!¹ �APRQ�S @Tç���N� `�!Ð�NL��*.��(ë)K¹ �"T @GVÇ �(ë ! � .� � >�Bk#5��N[�K¹�,U繩��(ë !* �XPRQ�S B¡ç +�+�¹¦N�¹? !)�(ê*� �ZT B[V �(ë � ! .�,�- . e!q�qR�+qHcvpngHi±prs�u¾zHh²p���mOq0 �z^���uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.pÓiÕg`s���o!� B qHcvp��v�`��o!p�g`x!h��±l�zjsr|`uwxyzjhwh��~��uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p(iÕg`s�uwprqLl�� #->A@�#5��Nk+*�,Zç

���

Page 24: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

���8(ëÐ! �XPRQ�S @ ç �8N���)�+ON�Ð�*!*�(Ä�.� �GT @ V �(ê � � �� � > B #;��NL��Ð�,Sç ��(³�!Ð �XPRQ�S B ç��N[�.�Ù��N� !*`��(ê `� �tT B V �(w�K,�-<6 qniÕg`o!x&�8z���uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p±uwx�p�qLs�z`cvpruwg^xÏ�OqLpE �qLqLxÊp�s�uÌzjhp���m�qDzHx5� �!h�g�c�H #-> @ #%Ð�N��`�K¹�,2ç ¹I(¥¹!¹ �UP*QYS @ ç �8N[�!).�k¹IN�¹��L��(Ä�`� �tT @ V �(ë � ! `� �>�Bk#%Ð�N�¹?*?,9ç ��(¥¹ Ð ��PRQ�S Baçv*.�^�8NL�Ù��*�(ê*K¹ �"T BsV¾ �(ë ^��,�-2. �g�g^p�e!qLs~uwx�p�qLs�z`cvpruwg^xO� {qLs�q¬��uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p]iÕg`s{��o!� B qHcvp�zHxOzjh��!��u¾�X�`�!o!p�x!g^pþiÕg^s(uwprqLl�zjxOzHhw����uÌ�R�]�OqLpE {qLqLx±p�sro!p�ezHx5�2�!h�g�c�H #?>A@�#@Ð�N[�^�K¹G,�ç ��(ëÐ`� �cP*QYS @�ç��8N�*^�� �N�*� !)�(³�^� �/T @=V� �(ë `� � >cBR#%Ð�N�¹?*?,�ç��(w�K+ �¯P*QYS B3ç���NL�`��*�N�)!)�)�(ëÐ�+ ��T B^V �(��K, zjx5�Ï�OqLpE �qLqÙxÏp�sru¾zjh�p���m�q©�(p�s�o�p�e'zHx5��!h�g�c�H #?>A@�#r�L��N�¹?Ð!*�,Vç �8(ê*`� �tP*QYS Bäç ��N[�`���8N[�?+H��(ì¹G+ �AT @°Vr �(ë ^� � >�Bk#��L��N�)�Ð?,aç(1+�� �GPRQ�S B�ç©*�+���N[�^��Ð�(ê*.�,�- $ gÏg`pre!qLsnu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`xO�a �qLsrqIiÕg`o!x&� ��uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.p -. e!q~h¾zHp�qLxOcX�2qk�?q�cvp[��zjsrqW��qLsr����u�lnuwhÌzjs; �u�p�eDp�e!q~g`x!qH��uwx Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p �Uò pre!qLs�quÌ��z &9ç)(ë*!* cvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�uwg^x���qÙpO {qLqLx�p�e�q±cvg^x5�.uwpruwg^xO� preOzjp�gH��qLs�hÌzjm�uwx M u�|`o!srq � zHx5�M u�|`o!srq ¹�-

M g`s±pre!q3lOs���p±�!h�g�c�H+�(p�e!q�hÌzjp�qÙxOcv�Ís�q���o!h�p[�9 �qÙs�q�cvg^xO��uÌ��prqLx.p� �uwpre pre!qnsrqH��o!h�p[�g^�!p[zHuwx!q�ÇiÕg^sÒmOqLs�cvqLx�p[zj|^qngjiScvg`srs�qHcvpzjxO�E �qLs�� -Á. e!q �U$�X é � zjxOzHhw����u¾�±��e!g �q�znl�zHuwxIqk�?q�cvp�gji¬p�sru¾zjhÓp��.mOq #?>A@k#5��NR+*?,Uç �^�8(1+ �APRQ�S @�ç���N�¹����8N�Ð!)`��(ê).� �"T @¨V �(ë � ! .� � >�BR#;��NL��Ð�,mç Ð�(1+* �XPRQ�S BSç *! �Ð�N�)K¹�¹¦(�+�� �=T B¥VÛ �(ê .�,�-yÌ ��qLsr�G �e!qÙs�q��o!� B qHcvp��u {qLs�q���h�g �qH��pSg^xÏp�e�q�zjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh�>@ �g`s��Ç��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -¤Ì 4�cvqLm�pÐiÕg^sWpre!qnqHz^���iÕg^uwh¾�X��p�e�qL�S �qÙs�q2i;z^��prqH��p±iÕg`snpre!q�hwu�p�qLs�zjh���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH� -�. e!qLsrqP ¬z`�Òx!gÊ��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.pqR�+qHcXp�gji�p�s�o�p�e -

¸ �¿p�e!q²qLx5�ngHi(pre!q²q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ�`p�e!q²prs�u¾zHh?p���m�q$qR�+qHcvp� �z^����pruwhwh+m!s�q���qLx�p -A. e!q�U$�X é � mOqLs�iÕg^s�lnqJ�Òg`x!h��ng`x�pre!q²h¾z`��p��!hwg�c�HD�!zHp[z¿��e!g {q��zWl�zju�xnqR�+qHcvp{gji�p�s�uÌzjhp���m�q²iÕg`s²��o!� B qHcvp�� #?>A@k#5��NR+*?,sç ��(Ä�`� �APRQ�S @sçǹ Ð� �N�)`�^��(¥¹©� �yT @ZVÇ �(ë ^� · , �e!u¾c[e�.u8�.x�Q pns�qHz^cfeÛ��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjxOcvq�zHp�p�e!qÍu�p�qLl zjxyzjhw����uÌ� #->�Bk#5��NÙ��Ð�,mç (Ä�`� �XPRQ�S BSç�¹���N���Ð`��(³�!)�, �OzHx5�?����uwlnu�h¾zHs�hw�©�Hztl�zju�xWqR�+qHcXp(gji+p�sro!p�eð����u�|`x!u1l+cLzjx�p(g^x!hw�²iÕg`s���o!� B qHcvpzHxOzjh��!��u¾� #-> @ #5��NR+*?,9ç �Ù��(�+J ��PRQ�S @ çvÐK¹©��N�й���(Ä�� �`T @ V¾ �(ë ! � �� � > B #5��NÙ��Ð�,�ç��(³�`� �ePRQ�S B ç�*`�^��N[�!*`��(³�`�?, �¢ �u�p�e�eOzHs�� iÕg^uwhÌ����p�u�hwh+p[zKH�uwx�|±hwg`x�|`qLs�p�g±o!x&�.qLs[��p[zHx5�preOzjxDp�e!q~g`p�e�qLstp���mOqH��gji{��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -{� ��iÕg`s�m�qÙs[cvqLx�p[zH|`qcvg`srs�qHcvpÙ�!p�e!q²prs�u¾zHh�qR�+qHcvp ¬z`���.o!q²prg±p�e!q~zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh�>@ �g^s��np�sru¾zjhÌ�R�Óp�e!q �U$TX é � mOqLs�iÕg^s�lnq�¿g`x!h��ÒiÕg`s�h�uwp�qÙs[zjhÌ�zHx5�×l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s���u�x±p�e!q�hÌz`��p(�!hwg�c�H±��e!g �q�Wx�gW��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�p(p�sru¾zjh�qR�+qHcvp #-> @ #��8N���)�,Zç(1+H� �eP*QYS @;ç˹���*�N�Ð`�^��(Ä�K¹G,�-� �Òi;zjsÖz`��p�e!q�h¾zHp�qLxOcX�¹��h�g`mOqH�Dzjx5� u�x.prqLs[cXqLm!p[�X��p�e!qLsrq� {qLs�qÍx�g¹��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p

cvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�uwg^xO�; �uwpre�qLuwpre!qLs�|^g�g��.x!qH�r��g`s�i;zjl�uwhwuÌzjsruwp�� -

�^�

Page 25: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# z ,�. s�o!q~��qLx.prqLxOcvq��

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# � ,ZÌ z`��� M g^uwhÌ� # c ,Z� zjs�� M g`uwhÌ�M u�|`o!srq ¹ ��z , p�qH��mOg^xO��q~p�uwl�qH�þiÕg^s�cvg^s�srqHcvp�zjxy�O �qÙs[�tprgÒprs�o!q~��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��u�x Ì 4�m�qÙsO>u�lnqLx�p ��- � , p�qH��mOg`xy��q�p�u�lnqH�ÐiÕg^s¿cvg`srs�qHcXp±zjxy�O �qÙs[�±p�gIi;zjhÌ��q�qHz^���'��qLx.prqLxOcvq��SuwxÌ 4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p �G- c , p�qH��mOg^xO��q~p�uwl�qH��iÕg`s�cXg`s�srqHcvp�zHxO�O {qLs[��prgWi;zjh¾��q²eOzjs��2��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�u�x Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p ��-

�n���v+Ó�H�!���m�GïA²Ä�O�³mZ�.���Kâ7à�â«î7ã � pÓp�e!q�qLx&�Sgji+pre!q�q�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.pÙ�vmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[� {qLs�q�z`�EH�q�Çp�gm��qRlOx!q¿p�e!q¤ �g`s��!�WqLxOcXg`o!x�p�qLsrq�ÍuwxÏpre!qnq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p -2Ì z^cfeÁ��qRl�>x!u�p�u�g`x0 �z^��s[zjprq�Ig`xÊz���cLzHhwqWiÕsrg`l prg �!-a. e!q¤�.qRlOx�uwp�u�g`xO�C �qLsrqWs[zHp�q�Íg`x�pE �g�.u�lnqLxO��uwg^xO�R�Wg^x'e!g y �qLh�h%pre!qL�ÊcLzjm�p�o!srq�Ïp�e!q��rzjh�uwqLx�p�iÕqHzjpro!s�qngHi�pre!qnlnq�zjx!u�x!|# q - | - �diÕg^s�jRg��?^f��p�eOzHp�iÕqHzjpro!s�q� ¬z`� � �K\�\����Kg , zHx5�ng`xDe!g o {qLhwh+p�e!qL��cLzHm!p�o!srq�np�e!qcLzHp�qL|^g`sr� # q - | - iÕg`s�jRg��?^[�.p�e�q²cLzjprqL|`g^s��2 ¬z`����e�f��`g�eEg ,�-;� iÓpre!q��.qRlyx!uwpruwg`x cvg`x�p[zHuwx!q�z~��o!mOqLsrg`s���uwxOzHp�q # q - | - iÕg`sujRg��?^f�!��g�^�\��?c , g`s�z~��o!�Og^s��.u�xOzjprq # q - | - h´^�g�\ke��`gk^ , gHiÓp�e!qcLzHp�qL|^g`sr���� �q²|�zL��q �(Ä� cXs�q�.u�p�g^o!ptgHi�p�e�q � l�z4.u�lÒo!l cLzjprqL|`g^s��D��cXg`s�q -;. e!q²s�zjpO>u�x!|��s {qLs�q��.g`x�q±pO �uÌcvq?�ilys[��pÙ��iÕg`s� �g`s��!��g`o!p$gji¬cvg`x�p�q�4.pÙ�?zHx5�Í��qHcXg`x5�?�OiÕg`sU {g`s����g�cLcXo!s�sruwx!|Ïu�x¹zÏ��qLx�p�qLxOcXq -�. zj�!h�q + cvg`x�p[zHuwxO�¿zL��qLs[zH|`qÖz`cLcvo�s[z`cX� iÕg`s¤�.qRlyx!uwpruwg`x

�^�

Page 26: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q + � � cLcvo!s�z`cv�¿gjii�.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`xO��g^xÍz±��cÙzjhwq�iÕsrg`l p�g �!-

$ g±q�4!zHlnm!h�qH� Ì 4�zjl�m!hwqH�M qHzHp�o!srq k{zjprqL|`g^s�� M q�zjp�o�s�q k{zHp�qL|^g`s��

}IqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -ëÐ`� -Ä�� -ëÐ! -³�?+� srp�u1l+cvu¾zHh 6 g`s��!� -³�� -ì¹?) -³�¹ -ëÐ��

s�zjp�u�x!|�� -M g`s²p�e�u¾��mOzjsrp²gji�pre!q¿q�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ�!p�e!q¿uwx5��qLmOqLx5�.qLx�p��^zjsru¾zH�!hwqH�U {qLs�q #r�K, p�e!q

o!x�H.x!g �xD �g^s��np��.mOq # lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�g^s�zjs�pru�l+cXu¾zjh= �g^s�� , � #5��, pre!q�m!srqH��qÙxOcvq�gHi(q�4�zjlV>m!h�qH�v��zjx5� #5�?, pre!q²p�s[zHuwp # cLzjprqL|`g^s��ng^s iÕqHzHp�o!srq ,�-

. e!q ��$TX é � ��e!g �qJ�Òl�zju�xÒqk�?q�cvp[�]iÕg`s� {g`s��Òp��.mOq ò lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s���qLs[��oO��zHs�pru�>l+cXu¾zjh7 �g^s�� #-> @ #r�8N[�!)�,CçA�^��(ì¹�� �APRQ�S @ ç �(ê �) �¦T @ VL �(ê � ! .� � > B #���N�*�,�ç/¹?)�(ê*�Ð �PRQ�S B ç (ë �� �]T B VÛ �(ë ! .�K, �tiÕg`s�m!srqH��qLxycvqIgHi±q�4�zjlnm�hwqH� #-> @ #���N[��)?,�ç �L��(ê `� �PRQ�S @ ç� �(ë ^� �"T @ Vy �(ê � � ^� � > B #r�8N�*?,aç ��Ð�(w�k¹ �]PRQ�S B çv �(ë �� �"T B Vv �(ë � ^��,�-. e!qDp�s�zjuwp±qk�?q�cvp # cLzHp�qL|^g`sr� ��qÙs[��oy�SiÕqHzjpro!s�q , �z^�×x�g`p���uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p -N. e!qLsrqP �qÙs�qzHh¾��g���u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p�uwx�p�qLs�z`cvpruwg^xO���OqLpE �qLqLxD {g`s���p��.mOq~zjx5�Iprs[zHuwp #-> @ #��8N���)�,Zç �`��(ê)�* �PRQ�S @ ç �(��`��N T V �(ê � ! .� � > B #���N�*�,Nç +O(�+�� �sPRQ�S B ç (ë ?+ �_T B V �(ê `�?,zHx5� �OqLpE {qLqLx� �g`s�� p���mOq�zjx5� pre!q�m!s�qH��qLxOcvqÍgHi±q�4�zjl�m!hwqH� #->\@k#��8N���)�,nç +v(�+�� �PRQ�S @9ç¾ �(ê `� �yT @°V» �(ë .� � >�B�#r�8N�*?,�çr+O(¥¹�� �YPRQ�S Bäç¾ �(ê .� �yT BuVy �(ê `��,�-2. e!qpre!s�qLqZ �zL�Wu�x.prqLs[z^cvp�u�g`x� �z`����uw|^x!u�l�cLzjx�p(���W��o!� B qHcvp�zjxyzjhw����uÌ�v���!o!p�g`x!h��Wl�zHs�|`u�xOzjh�hw���uw|`x�u�l+cLzHx.p����8u�p�qLl zjxOzHhw����u¾� #?>A@k#���N[��)?,Sç ¹I(ê)� �XP*QYS @Sç (ê `� �]T @Áç �(ë ^� �>�Bk#���N�*�,Z硹¦(ë)`� �cP*QYS Btç �(ë ! `� �vT B_VN �(ë ^��+���,�-

� xIg^p�e!qLs� {g`s��!�v����o!� B qHcvp��; �qLsrq²lng`srq²z`cLcXo!s[zHp�q±zHpU��qRlOx!u�x!|Òl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s���p�eOzHxzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh� �g^s��!�X��zjx&�8lng`srq�z`cLcXo!s[zHp�qP �e�qLx8pre!qL�S {qLs�q�|`u���qLx'oO��zH|`qÍq�4�zjl�m!hwqH�iÕg^sSpre!qa �g^s��!�X�� �uwp�eÍpre!q¿zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh´ �g^s��!���OqLx!qklOp�u�x!|�lng`srqSiÕs�g^l pre!q±q�4�zjlnm!h�qH� -� hÌ��g��¢ �e!uwh�q±p�e!q�cLzHp�qL|^g`s���z^cLcvo!s�z`cv�� �z^�ScXg`lnmOzHs[zH�!hwqWiÕg^sS�Og^p�e�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[��zHx5�zHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh¢ {g`s��!�v�Op�e!q�iÕqHzHp�o!srqH�; �qÙs�q��OqLprp�qLs�cLzHm!p�o�s�q�ÒiÕg`s�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -

6 qSeyz���q~zHh¾��g¿hwg�g!H�q�IzHptpre!q²s�qLhÌzjpruwg`xy��e!u�m2�OqLpE {qLqLx��.qRlOx�uwp�u�g`xDz`cÙcvo!s[z^cv��zHx5�i;zHlnuwh�u¾zjsruwp���zjx5�Í|`g�g��.x�qH���SiÕg^s�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� -9� x�p�qLsrqH��pruwx!|^hw���Op�e!qWiÕq�zjp�o�s�q¿z`cÙcvo!s[z^cv�u�xWp�e�q�m!srqH��qLxycvq�gjiOq�4�zjl�m!hwqH�¢ ¬z`�Ócvg`srs�qLhÌzjprq�T �u�p�eWpre!q�|^g�g��.x!qH�r�(gji+p�e!q{lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s#'& ç´(1+) � gR#@*�,Uç���(³�!* �/T VÇ �(ê `�?, zHx5�Íg`x!h��Il�zHs�|`u�xOzjh�hw�Dcvg^s�s�qÙh¾zjprq�Y �u�p�eÍi;zjlnu�h�>uÌzjs�u�p�� #'&�ç�(êÐ�+ � gk#@*�,;ç ��(³�!Ð ��T V� �(ë ^�� �Ð?,�-�6 e!qLxDp�e!qÙs�q� �qLsrq²x!gÒq�4!zHlnm!hwq��v��p�e!qcvg^s�srqLh¾zHp�uwg^xW�OqLpE �qÙqLx�iÕqHzjpro!s�q¬z`cLcvo�s[z`cX�WzHx5�W|`g�g���x!qH���´ ¬z`�]l�zHs�|^uwxOzHhwhw�$��u�|`x!u1l+cLzHx.p#'& ç´(êÐ`� � gk#%*?,sç ��(ê �+ T VÄ �(��K,�-�. e.oO�X�?p�e�qÒ�OqLprp�qLs�pre!q±lnqLp�zjm!e�g`sL�+p�e!q±|^s�qHzHp�qLs

�¹

Page 27: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

pre!q²c[eOzjxOcXqtpreOzjp���o!� B qHcvp��%u���qLx.pru½iÕ�±pre!q²cvg^s�s�q�cvp(iÕqHzjpro!s�qtiÕg^s�p�e!qu�.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`x -F$ g`x!qgHi(pre!q²g`p�e�qLs�cXg`s�srqLh¾zHp�u�g`xO�; {qLs�q²��uw|^x!u�l+cÙzjx�p -

. e!qLsrq¿zjsrq¿z2cXg`o!m!h�q±gji¬x!g`prq� �g^s�p�e��IsrqH��o�hwp[��uwxÍp�e�qH��qV�.qklOx!uwpruwg^xO� -�M uws���pÙ�?p�e!qgH��qLs�zjhwh �.qRlOx�uwp�u�g`xÖz`cLcvo�s[z`cX�ÒiÕg`s$zjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh� �g`s��!��qL��qLx�uwxDp�e!q²m!srqH��qLxycvq²gji�q�4�zjlV>m!h�qH�a �z`�±g`x�hw� zj�Og`o�p ¹G+ T;µ &�¶ µ¸· gk-�. e!uÌ�×srqH��o!h�pÒprg`|^qLp�e!qÙs3 �u�p�e¹zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh� {g`s����p�zKH�uwx!|¿hwg^x!|`qLs�p�g�cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLx5�np�eyzjxIpre!qWg^p�e!qÙstp���m�q���gji{p�sru¾zjhÌ��uwxDp�e!q²h¾z^��p��!hwg�c�Hu�x5�.u¾cÙzjp�q±preOzjp~p�e!qÙs�q¿u¾�²zP�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvq±�OqLpE �qLqLxÍl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s²h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|DzHx5�Ïzjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh {g`s��Íhwq�zjs�x�uwx!| -9. e!uÌ�²��p[zHp�qLl�qLx.p�u¾��iÕo!s�pre!qLs²��o!m!mOg`srp�q�Ç���Ipre!q±s�q���o!h�p�p�eOzHp~��o!�G>B qHcXp[�´ �qLsrq�cXg`xO��u��.qLs�zj�!h��a �g^s[��qÐzjp�q�4.prs[z`cXp�uwx�|Spre!q��.uÌ��pruwx!|^o!u¾��e!uwx!|²iÕqHzjpro!s�q�iÕg`s{p�e!qzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh� {g`s����%p�eyzjxÒiÕg^s�p�e�qtlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s -´. e!uÌ�þuÌ��zjxnu�xO��p�zjxOcvq�gjiÓe�gK lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�cLzHxWi;z`cvu�hwu�p[zjprq�p�e!q�m�s�g�cvqH�r�(gji�l�qHzjx!u�x!|$cvs�qHzHp�u�g`x -F. e!qL�W��s�uwx�|WzHp�prqLx.pruwg^x±p�g� �e!u¾c[eiÕqHzHp�o!srqH��zjsrq~cvs�u�p�u¾cÙzjh?prgÒpre!q~z`c���o!uÌ��uwpruwg^xngji�pre!q²lnqHzHx!uwx!|~gji�p�e!q� {g`s�� -

�L¶EµI�`:tµ�µ�¶E¯t³� xApre!qSlOs[��pÍp�s�uÌzjhÌ�v�WmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�D �qLsrq'��h�gK {qLsÍzHx5� h�qH���Dz`cLcXo!s[zHp�q zjp B o5��|`uwx�|lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHh.g^s�zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s��¿��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�Óp�eOzHxÒh�uwp�qÙs[zjhy��qLx�p�qLxycvqH� -Ó� �(u�x Ì 4�m�qÙsO>u�lnqLx�p � �.u�x!uwpru¾zHhwhw�©�LmOzjsrp�u¾cXuwmOzHx.p��[ {qLs�q���u¾z`��q�±p�g²s�q B q�cvp(p�e�q�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s�u¾c���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�z^� i;zjhÌ��q��¢ �e�u¾c[eÍ��o�|`|`q���p[�²p�eOzHp�p�e�qL�D �qLsrq9lOs[��p�m!s�g�cXqH����uwx!|npre!q±lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcW��qLxG>prqLxOcvqH��hwu�p�qLs�zjhwh�� -�. e!q²u�x!uwpru¾zjh=�.u1�+qLs�qLxycvqH�(uwx�z^cLcvo!s�z`cv��zjx&� hÌzjprqLxOcvu�qH�(��qÙpO {qLqLx¿p�e!qeOzHs���zjx&� q�z`���±iÕg`u�h¾�{��o!|^|`qH��p[��p�eOzHpL�.u�x�zjx�u�lnmOz`�r��q��.o!q²p�g~lnqLqLpruwx!|~zHxno!x�H�x!g �x {g`s��+�%mOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[�²oO��q�'zÍcvg^x.prq�4�pWl�zHp[c[e!uwx!|D��p�s[zHp�qL|^� -S. e�u¾�W��p�s�zjp�qÙ|`�'lnuw|^e.peOzL��qzjh¾��g�e!qLhwmOq�Ipre!qLl p�g�u�x.iÕqLs�p�e!q±lnq�zjx!u�x!|ÒgHi�pre!q±o!x�H�x!g �x0 �g^s��IiÕs�g`l p�e!qcvg^x.prq�4�p -� pnp�e!qÍqÙx5�8gji~p�e�qÍq�4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.pÙ����qLx.prqLxOcvq��Òcvg^x.p�zju�x!uwx!|Á {g`s����3 �uwpreAzHs�p�u1l�>

cvuÌzjh5 �g^s��!��l�zju�x.p�zju�x!q�±zWcXg`lnm!srqLe!qLxy��uwg^x2��u�W cvo!hwp��� �uwprens�q���mOqHcvp�p�g±h�uwprqLs[zHh¾�(zHx5�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� -�. e!uÌ��lyx5�.uwx�|Ïu¾�±x!g`p�cvg^x.prs[z���u¾cvprg`s��Á �u�p�e8pre!qIu8�.qHzÍp�eOzHpÒpre!qIm�s�gK>cvq�����u�x!|ÏgHi±hwu�p�qLs�zjh$zjx5�8x�g`xG>;hwu�p�qLs�zjh²��qLx.prqLxOcvq��×�OqHcvg^lnqH�n��uwlnu�h¾zHs¿z�iÕp�qÙsns�qLmOqHzHp�q�q�4�mOg���o!s�q -Z� p�l�zL� B oy��p��OqWpreOzjp�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[��u�x5�.u¾cÙzjp�q$p�e!q~��zHhwu�qLx.p�iÕq�zjp�o�s�qH��gHi�p�e!qx!q� AlnqHzHx!uwx!|��?zHx5�Í��g�p�e!q~hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|Òm�s�g�cvqLqJ�!� i;z`��p�qLs�uwxDp�e!q¿cÙz`��q~gji{lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -b�o�m!mOg`s�pruwx!|Ípre!u¾�²uwx�p�qLsrm!s�qÙp[zjpruwg^xÇuÌ�Ðpre!q3lOx&�.uwx!|Dp�eOzHp±p�e!q �.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`xO�tiÕg`s~x!qLg^hwgK>|^u¾��l �%uwx . zj�!h�q + �qLsrqU �g^s[��q~p�eOzHxniÕg`s�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[��u�x�p�qLsrl��(gji�pre!qtiÕqHzHp�o!srq��!�!o!px!g^ptu�x�p�qLsrl��(gji{cLzHp�qL|^g`sr� -

�^�

Page 28: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

¹Ö� ¹�ºh»½¼&� ºv}3Ù ��~D�F�T�A|�}3���6¾�� }À¿�z¢¾�}zÁa }axt¿ ÃnzU�9x;�^¼|�bÄ

b�g²i;zjsÙ�G �q�eOzL��q$�OH�qLp�cfe!qJ�Wp�e!q�|`qLx�qLs[zHh?g`o�p�hwu�x!q�gjiÓg^o!s�o�x5�.qLs���p[zHx5�.u�x!|±gjiÓpre!qtm�s�gK>cvq�����q��]g�cLcvo!srs�u�x!|²uwx±p�e�qtq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p -56 q��OqLh�uwqL��q{p�eOzHpL�? �uwpreÒsrqLmOqHzjprq�Wq�4�mOg���o�s�q����o!� B qHcvp��×eOzL��q�uwxycvs�qHz^��q�'m!s�g^�Ozj��uwhwu�p��Ïgji�lO|^o!s�u�x!|Çg^o!pnpre!qÍcvg^lnmOg`x!qÙx.p��×gHi²p�e!q {g`s��Il�qHzjx!u�x!| -9X xOcXqWp�e�qL�Íz^c��do�uws�q~p�e!qa {g`s��IlnqHzjx�uwx!|���pre!qLs�q±uÌ� x�gP��u��+qLs�qÙxOcvqu�x2pre!qWm�s�g�cvqH�r��u�x!|ÒgHi{��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��u�x.��g^hw��uwx!|~p�e!uÌ�t {g`s��Izjx&�Igji�g^p�e!qLs���qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -Z� i��o!� B qHcvp��T��gIx!g^pWeOzL��q¿p�e!q¿lnqHzHx!uwx!|niÕg^sSpre!q2 {g`s��+�]p�e�qL�Ii;zjh�h%�yz`c�HÍuwx�p�gD��mOqHcvuÌzjhm!srg�cvqH�r��qH� -´M g`s(l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��v�^��o!� B q�cvp[��eOzL��q{ztp�qLx&�.qLxOcv�$p�g�p�zKH�q{zthwu�p�qLs�zjh�zHm!m!s�g©z`c[ezHx5�Ësrq B qHcvp�p�e�qn��qLx.prqLxOcvq -9X pre!qLs� �u¾��q©�?p�e!qÙ�Ip�qÙx5�Ip�g B o5�.|^q3 �e�qLp�e!qÙs�p�e!q±srqH��p²gHipre!q���qLx.prqLxOcvq�l�zjp�cfe!q��?p�e!q{��prg`sr� -´. e!uÌ��uÌ��x�g`p�z�mOzjsrp�uÌcvo!h¾zHs�h��²cvg`l�m!hwq�4$�OH�qÙp[c[e��L�!o!pu�p�u¾�(x!g^p�uwlnl�q�.u�zjprqLhw�²g`����uwg`oy�%p�eyzjp�u�p[���`zHs�u�g`oO��m!u�qHcvqH�´ �u�hwh+cvg`l¿�!u�x!q�p�g~m!s�g��.oycvqpre!q��!zjp�z -

� p�uÌ��zjh¾��g±p�e!qÐcLz`��q�p�eOzHp�p�e!qÙs�q²zHs�q~cvqLsrp[zju�xnp�srqLx5�!��uwx�p�e�q��!zjp�zWx!g`p�z!���.srqH����q����8pre!u¾�nlng��.qÙh - b�o�� B qHcvp[��zjm!mOqHzHsIp�g |`qLp¿i;z`��prqLsIg^xAzHhwh²��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�v��uwxOcvh�o5�.u�x!|h�uwp�qÙs[zjhÌ� -m. e!uÌ�WlnqHzjxy�Sp�eyzjp±p�e�qLs�q�u¾�~��g^lnqn|`qÙx!qLs[zHh���mOqLq�Ïo!m'preOzjpV �qnx�qLq�Çprglng���qLh� �uwpreIp�e�qWs�q���p�gji{p�e!q��!zjp�z -�� p�uÌ�tzHh¾��gnp�e!qcLz`��qWpreOzjp�u�xIx!g cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`xÖzjs�q��o!� B qHcvp��%s�q���mOg`x5��uwx!|¿mOqLs�iÕqHcXp�hw� -´. e!uÌ��m!s�g^�Ozj�!h��ns�qkÕOqHcvp�����g`l�q�lnu`4~gji{��hwg^m!m!uwx�qH���u�x2srqH��mOg^x5�.uwx�|�zjx5�2i;zHuwh�o!s�qH��gHi{cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLxO��uwg`x -�� |©zju�x��� {q²x!qLq��p�g�z����Ipre!u¾��prgzWiÕo!hwh+q�4�m!h¾zHxOzjpruwg`x�gHi�p�e!q��!zHp[z -

6 qÇeOzL��q�c[e!g���qLxÛp�e!q � k . >qp zHs[c[e!uwprqHcvpro!s�q�z^�2zÏiÕs[zHlnq� �g^s�H'uwx� �e!uÌcfe¹prg�.qÙ��qLhwg^mÍzncvg^lnm!o!p�zjpruwg`xyzjhÓlng��.qLh�preOzjp� �uwh�hÓz�����s�qH�r�SzHhwhÓgji¬p�e!q��!zjp�z -aX o�s²cvg`lV>m!o�p[zjpruwg^xOzjh!l�g��.qLh�oO��qH�(ztm!srg��.oOcvpruwg^x¿������p�qÙl l�g��.qLh�gji+hÌzjx!|^oOzj|^q�cvg`lnm�s�qLe!qÙxO��u�g`xg^m�qÙs[zjpruwx!|¿g`xÍpre!q��.qHcvhÌzjs�zjp�u���qUH�x!g �hwq�.|^q²�Oz`��q -�. e!q~m!s�g��.oycvp�u�g`xÍ���!��p�qLl s�qLm!srqR>��qLx.p��]p�e�q�s�o!h�qH�ðiÕg^s�m!s�g�cvq�����u�x!|²p�e!q¬��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�(zHx5�SiÕg`s�mOqLs�iÕg`s�l�uwx!|�p�e!q B o&�.|`qLl�qLx.pp�z`�OH�� -�. e!qD��qHcvh¾zHs[zHp�uw��qaH�x!g �hwqJ�.|`q¿u¾��oO��q�Çp�gDs�qLm�s�qH��qLx.p²pre!qn��p�g^s�uwq��v�]pre!q���qLxG>prqLxOcvqH��prgI�Oq B o5�.|`qJ�?�(zHx5�Ïp�e!qVH.x�gK �h�q�.|^q�zj�Og`o�p±p�e!qnl�qHzjx!u�x!|���gHi�p�e!q2 {g`s��!� -6 qa �uwh�h]x!g^p��.qH��cXs�uw�Oq±g^o!s�H.x!g �h�q�.|`q±srqLm!srqH��qLx�p[zHp�u�g`xÍuwxm��qLp[zHuwh5�+�!o!p²p�e!qa �e�g`hwq���!��p�qLl u¾��zL�^zjuwhÌzj�!h�qW���niÕg`hwh�g �uwx!|npre!qsÅ(]�jR�1��\�f5g��aÆm��Gg��¥\±h�uwx�H¿iÕs�g`l p�e!q � k . >qpe!g^lnq�mOzH|`q Ç�È�È�ÉxÊ�Ë�Ë�Ì�Í�ÈxÎ3ÉeÏ�ЩÎÑÍ�Ò�ÓxÎ-ÔvÕvÓIË -

�!Ð

Page 29: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

f

1/32/3

PredicateProcess

t2

t1

ProcessSubject

Retrieve StorySentence t3

Succeed

Succeed

No

Yes

Fail

Fail

f

t4

Guess

t3SentenceRetrieve Story

Fail

Succeed

f

False

FalseTrue

False

Look for homonym True

Types? t5Features Match?

Same Subject

1-pp

Not Found

Found

Try

Analogy

True

t6

t7

t8

No

Yes

f

M uw|^o!s�q � � M hwg Ûgji{cvg^x.prs�g^h?iÕg`s���qÙx.prqLxOcvq B o&�.|`qLl�qLx.p -

�?+

Page 30: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

M u�|`o!srq � �OH�qLp�cfe�qH��g`o!p±pre!q3ÕOg /gjiÐcvg`x�p�srg`h; �e�qLx B o5�.|^uwx!|�zÍ��qLx�p�qLxOcXq×Ö -�� pprs�qHzHp[�?p�e�q���qLx�p�qLxOcXq(z^�]cvg^xO��uÌ��pruwx!|�gHiOz9Í���o!� B qHcXp�Î # �e�u¾c[e�u¾�?mOg`prqLx�p�u¾zHhwh���z lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sg^s±zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHhA �g`s�� , zjx&�Ïz<Írm!s�q��u¾cLzHp�qÎ��´ �e!u¾c[eÏ��p[zHx5�!�SiÕg`s~p�e!q�s�qH��pWgji�pre!q���qLxG>prqLxOcvq -�. e!q±p�u�lnqH����e!g �xÇu�xIp�e�u¾�tÕOg ¬cfeOzHs�p²cÙzjxÍ�^zjsr�ÍzÒh�uwp�prhwq�iÕs�g^l���qLx.prqLxOcvq²prg��qLx.prqLxOcvq©���.qLmOqLx5��uwx!|�g`xn�.qLp�zju�h¾��gji¬p�e!q � k . >Ep�zHs[c[e!uwprqHcvpro!s�q -�. g�q�4�m!h¾zHuwxÍpre!u¾�ÕOg ¬cfeOzHs�pÙ��h�qLp²oO�slOs[��p±cvg^xO��u8�.qLs²p�e�qn��uwp�oyzjp�u�g`xS �e�qLs�q¿p�e!q¿lng��.qÙh´H.x�gK ���g^sWeOz^�h�qHzjsrx!q�Çpre!q�lnqHzjx�uwx!|Dgji²pre!qD��qLx�p�qLxycvqn��o!� B qHcvp -Á� xÏp�e!uÌ�±cLz`��q���p�e!q�lng��.qÙh; �uwh�h��oOcLcvqH�r�­iÕo!h�hw�~m!s�g�cvq����%pre!q�m!s�q��u¾cLzHp�q�zjx&�Òp�e!q$��o�� B qHcvpL��p�zKH�uwx!|~p�uwl�q g!@�5^g�B�-F. e!qLx��u�ps �u�hwh�p�sr�Iprgns�qLprs�u�qL��q²zn��p�g`sr�Í��qLx.prqLxOcvq� �e!uÌcfeÖcvg`srs�qH��mOg`x5�!��prgnp�e!q~m!s�g^�Oq��?p[zH�>u�x!|�p�uwl�q g ¤ -2� i�pre!q¿s�qLprs�uwqÙ�`zHh]i;zju�h¾�X��pre!q¿lng��.qLh´ �u�hwh�s�q���mOg`x5�D_����¥\g¿z�iÕprqLsWp�zKH�uwx!|zHx'z�����uwp�u�g`xOzHh�pruwlnq°Ø �OqHcLzHoO��qngHi�p�e!q±i;zju�hwo!srq # i;zju�hwq�Ís�qLprs�u�qL�^zjh¾��p[zKH�q¿hwg^x!|`qÙsWuwx� k . >Ep ,�-�� i�z±��p�g^s�����qLx�p�qÙxOcvq²cLzHxn�Oq²s�qLprs�uwqÙ��q�?�`pre!q�lng��.qÙh¢ �uwh�hOl�zjp�cfe¿p�e!qÐ��o!�G>B qHcXpSgHi�p�e!q ��qLx�p�qLxycvq¿zj|©zjuwxy��p±p�e�q���o!� B q�cvp²gji�p�e�q���prg`s�� -PM u�s[��pL�]pre!q¿lng��.qLhA �uwh�hcvg^lnmOzHs�q²p�e!qÙuws�|^qLx!qLs�zjhÓp���mOqH�v�Op[zH.u�x!|npruwlnq g Ö -�� i�pre!qL�Dzj|^s�qLq # q - | - ��g^p�e0 {g`s�����.qÙx!g`prq±m�qÙs[��g^xO� , �Ózjx5�Ipre!qL�DzjhI �zL�!�C �uwhwh�zj|^s�qLqWiÕg^s�hwu�p�qLs�zjh���qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�X�!p�e!q±lng���qLh �u�hwh{cvg`x�p�u�x.o�qa �uwp�e z2lng^s�q�cLzjsrqviÕo!h(iÕqHzjpro!s�q¿p�q���pL�Óp[zH.u�x!|Ipruwlnq g�ÙR-�� i�p�e!q¿lng^s�qsrqRlOx!q�ÒiÕqHzHp�o!srqH��l�zHp[c[e���p�g�g!�Op�e�qSl�g��.qLh?srqH��mOg^x5�!��e%^k]&g!·!g`pre!qLs� �u¾��q©�!uwp�s�q���mOg`x5���_����¥\g -�M uwxyzjhwh����.u�xÍzHhwhÓcLz^��qH�X��pre!qLs�q²uÌ��zÒp�u�lnq g?Ú prgnl�zKH�q�p�e�qWs�q���mOg`xO��q -�. e�oO�v�Ouwxpre!q~cLz`��qT �e�qLx�p�e!q²lnqHzHx!uwx�|±u¾�;H�x!g �x��!p�e!q²pruwlnqH��zHs�q?�

g!@"5Wg�BA5Wg ¤ 5Wg Ö 5Wg�Ù`5Wg?Ú iÕg`s�p�sro!q~��qLx�p�qLxycvqH��zHx5�2eyzjs��niÕg`u�h¾� Ùg!@"5Wg�BA5Wg ¤ 5 Ø 5Wg?Ú iÕg`s�qHz`���ÒiÕg`u�h¾�

$ g ²��hwqLp$oO�²cvg`xO��u��.qÙsSpre!q±p�u�lnqH��iÕg`s~lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�s �e!qÙxÇpre!qn��o!� B qHcvp$eOz`��x!g^ph�qHzjsrx!q�Ïp�e!qDx!q� {g`s�� lnqHzHx!uwx�| -N. e!qIpruwlnqH�tiÕg^snqHz`���ÇiÕg`u�h¾�¿zjsrqIp�e�qI�rzjlnqDz^�zH��gH��q -F� g �qL��qÙsL�`u�xÒpre!q�cÙz`��q$gjiÓp�sro!qH�(g`s{eOzjs��×iÕg`u�h¾�X�dpre!q�m!s�q��u¾cLzHp�qC �uwhwh�qLxOzj��hwq$z��p�g`sr����qÙx.prqLxOcvq�prgÒ�Oq~s�qLprs�uwqÙ��q� -7. e!q²p��.mOq²gji�p�e!q~��p�g`sr�D��o!� B qHcXp� �uwhwh+x!g`p�l zjp[c[epre!q²p���mOqWgHi�p�e!q~��qLx.prqLxOcvq~��o!� B qHcvp -i6 e!qÙxIp�e�u¾��eOzjm!mOqLxy�v�Op�e!q~lng��.qLh= �uwhwhÓ��qHzjs�cfeiÕg^s�z±e!g`l�g`x��.lÍ�`i;zHuwh�zjx5��qLuwpre!qLs�s�q���mOg`x5�3_����ì\gSg^stprs��nprgn�!o!u�h���z±x!q� Alnq�zjx!u�x!|zHx5�Ïs�qH��m�g^x5��e%^k]�g -m. e!q3lOs���p±�!s�zjxOc[eÏg�cLcvo�s[�9 �uwpreÏm!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp�� �XÛ T'zHx5�Ïp�e!q��qHcvg`x&�Ò�!s[zHxOc[eÒg�cLcXo!s[�A �uwp�e¿m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��GT - :Og�g!H.u�x!|WiÕg`s¬zSe!g^lng`x��.l�p[zH�qH�(p�uwl�qg?Ü ·�p�sr�.u�x!|²p�g±�!o!u�h��¿zSlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHh!lnqHzHx!uwx!|²p�zKH�qH�(p�u�lnq g�ÝR-A. e�oO�v��p�e!q�s�q���mOg`xO��qpruwlnqH��zHs�q?�

g!@"5Wg�BA5Wg ¤ 5Wg Ö 5Wg?ÜA5Wg?Ú iÕg`s���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��prs�qHzHp�q�nh�uwp�qÙs[zjh�hw�g!@"5Wg�BA5Wg ¤ 5Wg Ö 5Wg?ÜA5Wg�Ý`5Wg?Ú iÕg`s���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH��prs�qHzHp�q�nlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cLzHhwhw�

Þ ýHçvà+útçXàéáÓêHá�è5â[Þ³ü³ß�}Lã�çvîHßÕåjüÄè�èéÝHá�útçÙêjá�ü^çvî�èÕÝHá D á�ë�ÿ

�!*

Page 31: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. e!qUlOxOzHh(cÙz`��q~cvg^xOcvqLsrxO�; �eOzHpteOzHm!mOqLxO�� �e!qLxÖzjxDzjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh� �g`s��nu¾��qLxOcvg^o!xG>prqLs�q��zHx5�Ip�e!q~��o!� B qHcvp�eOz`��x!g`p���qLp�hwq�zjs�x�q��zÒlnqHzHx!uwx!|²iÕg`s�preOzjpC �g^s�� -C� x�p�e!uÌ�v�cLz^��q�pre!q�zjprp�qLlnm�p]prg�s�qLprs�u�qL��q{zS��o!� B qHcvpÓlnqHzHx!uwx�|s �u�hwh�i;zjuwh;�`p[zH.u�x!|�pre!q�q�4�p�s[z�p�uwl�qØ # zH|�zHuwx�����q�cLzjoO��qtsrqLp�sruwqL�^zHh.i;zju�hwo!srqH�]p[zH�q�q�4�p�s[z�pruwlnq{uwx±p�e�qtlng���qLh ,�-£. e�qtlng���qLh �u�hwhÓp�e!qLxDp�sr�Ip�g�s�qLprs�uwqÙ��qSpre!q¿��prg`sr�Í��qÙx.prqLxOcvq -�� xIp�e�q¿cLz`��q±gji{qHz`���2iÕg^uwh¾�X�?uwpC �uwh�hi;zHuwh�zjx5�±s�qH��mOg`x5�U_����¥\g[��p[zH.u�x!|²p�u�lnq g ¤ 5 Ø -´� x±pre!q�g`pre!qLs�cLz^��qH�X��p�e!q�srqLp�sruwqL�^zjh� �uwh�h��oOcLcvqLqJ�?��zjx5�Òpre!q�lng���qLh5 �uwhwhOeOzL��q�p�g~|`o!qH�r��u½iðp�e!q²��qLx�p�qLxOcXqtuÌ�%p�sro!q�g`s�i;zjhÌ��q -76 qz^����o�lnq²uwp� �uwh�h?|^o!qH����e@^R]�g �7ßH� gji�pre!q²p�uwl�q�����uwxycvq²p�e!uÌ��u¾��p�e�qW�Oz^��qWs�zjprqÐiÕg^stprs�o!q��qLx.prqLxOcvq��£ �e!qLx¿p�e!q$��qÙx.prqLxOcvq{m!s�q��u¾cLzHp�q�l�zHp[c[e!qH�]pre!q���prg`s�� -A. e!u¾�(u¾��zHxÒu�xO��p�zjxOcvqgHi�m!s�g^�Ozj��uwhwu�p��2l zjp[c[e!u�x!| # :Ogj��qÙp�pL� ��)!)�*?,�-U� p�p[zH�qH� pruwlnq g�Ý p�g¿l�zKH�q²p�e�u¾��|`o!qH�r� -. e�oO�v�!pre!q²p�u�lnqH��zjsrq?�

g!@"5Wg�BA5 Ø 5Wg ¤ 5 Ø 5«g-Ú iÕg`s�qHz^���ÒiÕg^uwh¾�; �u�p�eDzjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh� �g^s��g!@"5Wg�BA5 Ø 5Wg ¤ 5Wg?àA5Wg?Ú iÕg`s�p�sro!qH��zHx5�2eOzHs��niÕg`uwhÌ�; �uwpreIzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh= �g`s��

6 e!u�hwqWpre!qLsrq �� p�uwl�qSmyzjs[zHlnqLprqLs[��uwxDp�e!qH��qWq��oOzHp�uwg^xO�v�+p�e!qLsrq±zHs�q±g`x�hw� Ð �.qR>|^s�qLqH�WgHitiÕsrqLq�.g^lÍ�(��uwxOcXq g!@t5ág�B¯5âg ¤ 5ág?Ú zjm!mOqHzHs[�±uwx'zHhwh�q��oOzHp�uwg^xO�±zjx&� g Ö u¾�x!g^p±uwx5��qLmOqLx5�.qLx�p²gji�pre!qng`pre!qLs~p�uwl�qH� -�. e.oy�v�(uwxÊcvsrqHzjpruwx!|ÖzÍ��uwl¿o!hÌzjp�u�g`xÍlng���qLh {qSq���p�u�l�zjprqtpre!q²mOzjs�zjlnqÙp�qLs��%p�eyzjp$cvg`x�p�srg`hwh�q�Òpre!q²uwx�p�qLs�cvqLm!p g!@`5«g�B`5Wg ¤ 5Wg?Ú � g�Ù# p�e!q¿p�u�lnq±p�gDl�zjp�cfeIiÕqHzHp�o!srqH� , � g?Ü2# p�e!q¿p�u�lnq±p�gÖcvg`xy��u���qLs~z2e!g^lng`x��.l , � g�ÝR# p�e!qpruwlnq±prgÍm�qÙs�iÕg`srl zHxOzjh�g`|^� , � g-àD# p�e!q�p�uwl�q±p�gIl zKH�q�z2|`o�qH��� , �{zjx5�WØ # p�e!q�p�uwl�qiÕg^s²zns�qLprs�uwqÙ�`zHh�i;zHuwh�o!s�q ,�-�. �g�mOzHs[zjl�qLp�qLs��tcXg`x�p�s�g^h(p�e�q±m!s�g^�Ozj�!u�hwu�p��Dgji¬cvg^s�s�q�cvp�h��srqH��mOg`x&�.uwx!| -;X x!q�uÌ�eT?�? �e!uÌcfe��.qLp�qÙs�lnu�x!qH��pre!q�m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��²gji+p�sr�.u�x!|�z�lnqLp[zHm!e!g^sO>uÌcLzjhÓq�4�p�qLxO��uwg^x -C. e!q¿��qHcXg`x5�IuÌ� pre!qzã���pre!q±m!s�g^�Ozj��uwhwu�p��ngji{m!srg��.oOcvu�x!|np�e�qa �s�g`x�|srqH��mOg`xy��q -Z. e!u¾��myzjs[zHlnqLprqLs�lng��.qLhÌ����o�� B qHcvp[��x!g`p��OqLu�x!|±mOqLs�iÕq�cvp�h��¿z`cLcvo�s[zjprq²qL��qLxu�xÍp�e!q�cLz`��qÒgHi�h�uwp�qÙs[zjhÓp�sru¾zHh¾��g`s²lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcSqHz^���IiÕg^uwh¾�X�� �e!qLx�zjh�h{cvhwo!q��tuwx5��u¾cLzHp�q �eOzHp²p�e!q¿cvg^s�srqHcvp�srqH��mOg`xy��q¿u¾� - b�oOc[eÍqLs�srg`s[�$cLzjx�g�cLcvo!s$��q�cLzjoO��qÒgHi�lnuÌ��cvg^lnm!srqR>e!qÙxO��u�g`x��!lng^p�g^s���h�uwmO�X�!g`s��do�u¾c�H±|`o!qH�r��qH� -

. e!qLsrq~zjs�q~pE �g¿m!s�g�cvq�����q�� preOzjp$cvg`x�p�srg`hÓhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|±gH��qLs�p�u�lnq -;X x!q²u¾��p�e�qSm�s�gK>cvq�����u�x!|npruwlnqH����mOqLqJ�.uwx!|�o!mÊz`�²mOgK {qLstiÕo!xycvp�u�g`xO��gji¬m!s[z^cvp�uÌcvq -a. e�oO�X��u£i g-ä uÌ�tp�e!qu�x!uwpru¾zjh�p�uwl�qWg`x��!h�g�c�H � ��pre!qLx g?ä"å ·cæOç�è Ù uÌ�Ðpre!q¿p�uwl�qWg`xÊ�!hwg�c�H�· -2. e!uÌ�uH�uwx&�ËgHih�qHzjsrx!uwx!|$u¾��z��Oz`��u¾c�mOzHs�p�gHi�pre!q � k . >qp8zHs[c[e!uwprqHcvpro!s�q��©zjx5�±uwp(m�s�g��.oOcXqH�(p�e!q$��mOqLq�o!mÊuwxÏpre!qnhwu�p�qLs�zjh{cvg^x5�.uwpruwg^x -0. e!q �(³� q�4�mOg`x!qÙx.p~u¾�WzDcvg`xy��p[zHx.p±u�xÏp�e�q � k . >qppre!qLg`sr� -

� g �qÙ��qLsL�Xp�e!qLsrq(u¾��zHx!g`pre!qLs�h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|�m�s�g�cvqH�r�?p�eOzHp�u¾�?u�lnmOg`s�p�zjx�p?u�x�p�e!q�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`szHx5�Ihwu�p�qLs�zjh�cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`xO�X�?zHx5�Íp�e!uÌ� uÌ�tp�e!qz`c���o!uÌ��uwpruwg^xIgjiZ {g`s��Il�qHzjx!u�x!|�� - :OqHzHs�xG>u�x!|Òx�q� AlnqHzHx!uwx�|���eOzHm!mOqLxO�tqLu�p�e!qÙs� �e!qLxÍzHxÍzHxOzjh�g`|`uÌcLzjh�q�4.prqLxO��uwg`x�uÌ� prs�uwqJ� # ��qLqM u�|`o!srq ��, u½i�pre!qnx!q� y {g`s�� uÌ�SlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾c`��g`s¿zLiÕp�qLs~p�e!q�lng��.qLh�u¾�²|`u���qLxËiÕqÙq��>

�!)

Page 32: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

�Oz^c�H�zH�Og`o!p¿zHxÏqLs�srg`s~uwxÏu�p[�²zjxO�E �qLs -Y6 q�z^����o�lnqÒpreOzjp~p�e!q���o�� B qHcvp²hwqHzHs�xO�²p�e!qcLzHp�qL|^g`sr� gHi~zjx��Ïx!q� �g^s�� pre!q2lOs[��pÒpruwlnq¿uwp±g�cÙcvo!s[�¿uwx zËprs�o!qD��qLx.prqLxOcvq�g`s�zeOzHs��ÇiÕg`u�h -0. e�u¾�Wu¾�²�OqHcLzjoy��q�p�e!q¿iÕqLq�.�Oz^c�HÍu�x'cvg^lÒ�!u�xOzjpruwg^x� �u�p�e'p�e!q�m!s�q��u¾cLzHp�qpreOzjp�l�zHp[c[e!qH�]pre!q²��p�g`sr��cvh�qHzjsrhw�±u���qLx.pru�lOq��þpre!q²cLzHp�qL|^g`sr�ÒgHi(pre!q�s�qXiÕqLs�qLx�p -AX xnp�e!qg^p�e!qLs~eOzjx&�?�´ �q�z`�r��o!lnq¿p�eyzjp¿��o�� B qHcvp[�²cLzHx!x!g^p±hwqHzHs�xm �uwp�eÊqHz`���ËiÕg^uwh¾�X�]�OqHcLzHoO��qpre!qIm!srq�.uÌcLzjprq i;zHuwhÌ�×prgÏu��.qÙx.pru½iÕ�'zHx.� ��qÙx.prqLxOcvq�uwx p�e!qÖ��prg`s�� -o6 qÍzjhÌ��g'z^����o!lnqpreOzjp�pre!q�iÕqHzjpro!s�q�gHi(pre!q²lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌcLzjh5 �g^s��nu¾��hwqHzHs�x!qJ�Òg`xDp�e!qslys[��p�zHm!m!srg`m!sru¾zjprqprs�u¾zHh5���OqHcLzjoy��q�p�e!qDlnqLp�zjm!e!g^sWu�x5�.u¾cÙzjp�q��9 �e!u¾c[eÏiÕqHzjpro!s�q�u¾�±cXs�uwpru¾cLzHh - b�u�xOcvqnprs�o!q��qLx.prqLxOcvq��tzHx5�Ëeyzjs��IiÕg`u�h¾�tg�cÙcvo!s�g^x �vß�¹ gji¬p�e!q±prs�u¾zHh¾��zHx5����uwxycvqWpre!q±lng��.qLhÓeOz^�z ��ßH�Àé T 5 �vßH�Àén#��_Û T ,=êÄ �(Ä� Ü c[eOzjxOcXqWgji{l�zH.u�x!|�zjxÍqLsrs�g`s�iÕg`s�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cprs�u¾zHh¾�(o!x�p�u�h.u�p%h�qHzjsrxO�(p�e!q�x!q� lnqHzHx!uwx!|��jpre!qLsrqtuÌ�%zHm!m!srgK4�uwl zjp�qÙhw�²z (¥¹ m!s�g^�Ozj��uwhwu�p��gHi(h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|~p�e!q���q²qLhwqÙlnqLx�p[� # cLzHp�qL|^g`s�� zjx5�niÕqHzjpro!s�qtiÕg^s�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[� , uwx zjx��np�sru¾zjh -M g`s¬zjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh¢ �g^s��!�X�!p�e!qÙs�q�u¾��z ��ßH�séD��ß��¯5Ê�7ß��6é��7ß��6ê�(³�^� cfeyzjxOcvq�gji�l�zH.u�x!|zHxIqLsrs�g`sÙ�!�!o!pC �q²mOg���p�o!hÌzjp�q¿z±hwg Ûm!s�g^�Ozj��uwhwu�p���� & �!gji�h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|¿p�e�qÐiÕq�zjp�o�s�q²gji{zHxzHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh� {g`s��±g`x ��oOc[e¿zjxnqÙs�s�g^s�p�s�uÌzjh -´. e!qLsrq�zjsrqtl�zHx.�~mOg�����uw�!h�q iÕq�zjp�o�s�qH�(gjiðp�e!qsrqviÕqLs�qÙx.p�uwx�qHz^cfe ��p�g^s����OzHx5�np�e!q~zHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh¢ {g`s�� |^uw��qH��x!g±|`o�u��!zHxOcvq~z`��prg±e!g prgh�qHzjsrxÍp�e!qV �g^s��!� - :Oq�zjs�x�uwx!|Dp�e!qWiÕqHzHp�o!srqÒuÌ�²cvs�u�p�u¾cÙzjhÓ��q�cLzjoO��qÒu�p�u¾�U �eOzHp²qLxOzj��hwqH�pre!qnlng��.qÙh%prgÍ��qLhwqHcXpSpre!q�zHm!m!s�g^m!s�uÌzjprqns�qviÕqÙs�qLx�p�iÕs�g`l p�e�q���prg`s�� -0Ì ����qÙx.pru¾zjh�hw����u£ipre!qÒiÕqHzHp�o!srqÒeOz^�W�OqLqLxÏh�qHzjsrx!q�Çpre!qnlng��.qÙh�cLzjx'oO��qnp�e�qnx!q� y {g`s��Ê��oOcLcXqH���5iÕo!hwh��iÕg^s B o5�.|^uwx!|npre!q¿��qÙx.prqLxOcvq��+zjx&�?�?u½iþuwp�eOz^��x�Q p��OqLqLxDhwqHzHs�x!q�+�?p�e!q~lng��.qLhÓu¾��hwqviÕp�prg|^o!qH��� -

. e�oO�v��p�e!qÍm!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��'mOzjs�zjlnqÙp�qLs��Òp�gÏ�Oq�qH��pruwl�zHp�qDzjsrq^T # m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��8gHiprs���uwx!|Öz2lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh�q�4�p�qÙxO��u�g`x , �Aã # m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��Ígji$l�zH.u�x!|�p�e!qno�x!uwx�p�qLx&�.q�srqH��mOg`xy��q , �Ozjx5� &2# m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��ÒgHi�uwx&�.oOcvu�x!|Wpre!q�iÕqHzjpro!s�q²gji%zjxÍzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh= �g`s�� ,�-

§©¯sÞU¨�<zë0°5¨£Þ�¶-�¢ª�¶E¯t³Cµ$ g^x!qngHi�p�e!qnpruwlnq��tg`s±m!srg`�OzH�!uwh�uwp��ÍmOzHs[zjl�qLp�qLs��²zjs�q �.uwsrqHcvp�h��Í��qLp�p�zj�!h�qnuwx � k . >p²�]�!o�p2�.qÙs�uw��q±iÕs�g^l o!x5��qLs�h��.u�x!|ImOzHs[zHlnqLp�qÙs[�WcXg`x�p�s�g^hwh�uwx!|Ö��m!srqHz��.u�x!|Êz`cvpruw�^zjpruwg`xzHx5�Ïe!g zHhwp�qÙs�xOzHp�uw��q¿m!srg��.oOcvpruwg`xy�±zjs�q�qL�^zHhwoOzHp�q� -m$ g^x!qLpre!qLhwq����v�7 �q�cÙzjx ��p�zjp�qpre!qDzjm!m!srg4.u�l�zjprq2�^zHhwo!qH�±p�e�q2m�s�g`�yzj�!u�hwuwpruwqH�±zHx5�8p�u�lnq¿mOzjs�zjlnqLprqLs[�Wp�zKH�qDuwx'p�e!q��uwl¿o!h¾zHp�uwg^x -7. e!qH��qWzHs�q~|`uw��qÙxnuwx . zj�!h�q *�-ì ýHçvàOèÕÝjáÓÝ^âfàÕê�ùwçXÞ³ü³ß ~é÷�ívø�çvåHèOç[ù�èéÝHá�ø�í[õ×�?}vßÕåHë�î5á�ã�èÕß]ä�ÞÄü³üHú�â!ïváðâfî�á�àéàÕçXà?ÞÂù�èÕÝHá�ì�èÕàÕì�âfî^â[ü³çvíXìâ[îHêSã�çXútá�åHæ²ä�Þ³èÕÝWèÕÝjá{ä�àéçXîHítçXîHáXÿ�ýjçXà]èÕàéåHá�ß=~wö�íXø çXåHè]ç[ù+èéÝHá�ø�í[õ×�?}`ßÕåjë�î5á�ã�èéß�ä�Þ³üÄü.ú$â�ïXá�â[îá�àÕàéçXàOÞÂù^èéÝHá�ì%ùÌâ[Þ³üLèÕç(ú�â!ïXáOâfî¬âfî^â[ü³çXívìÙÿ D á?åHßÕá�ê�â[î�á�ßÕèéÞÄú�â[èéá�ê©4Xâfü³åHáOç[ù��]�bK�� õÙøeð�ßéá�á�ÜOâ[ëHü³á"ñHÿ

�!

Page 33: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj��hwq * � � m!m!srg4.u�l�zjprqtmOzHs[zHlnqLp�qÙs��^zjh�o!qH�%iÕg`s�p�e�qW��uwl¿o!h¾zHp�u�g`x¿lng��.qLh -

� zjs�zjlnqÙp�qLs Ì 4.m!srqH����uwg^x é{zjhwo�q� x.prqLs[cvqÙm!p g!@"5«g�BA5Wg ¤ 5«g-Ú ��(Ä�`� �. ��mOq×k�e�qHc�H g Ö �(��� �M qHzjpro!s�q²l�zHp[c[e g�Ù �(Ä�.� �� g`l�g`x��.l/��qHzjs�cfe g?Ü ��(ê K¹ �� xOzHhwg`|^� g�Ý �(ê)�* �$ g`x� �g^s��n|`o�qH��� g?à �8(Ä�`� �}Iu¾��l�zjp�cfe�cvg���p Ø �(1+H� �. sr��zjxyzjhwg^|`� T �(ì¹��Ì s�s�g^s ã �(Ä�`�� x5�.oOcvq�iÕqHzHp�o!srq & �(ì¹��

. e!qnsrqHz���qLsWuÌ�Ss�qÙlnuwx5��q�Ip�eOzHp¿zjh�h%pre!qnprqLlnmOg`s�zjh�mOzjs�zjlnqÙp�qLs��SzHs�q�x!g^pWuwx&�.qR>mOqLx5��qLx.p�zHx5�2pre!qLsrqviÕg`srqT {q²eOzL��qtiÕq� �qÙsC�.qL|`srqLqH��gHi(iÕs�qLqJ�.g`l preOzjxDmOzjs�zjlnqÙp�qLs��%uwxpre!q²p[zj��hwq -Z. e!q²s�qHz!�.qLs�u¾��zHh¾��g¿s�qÙlnuwx5��q�Òp�eyzjp�p�e!q~z`cXp�oOzHh��`zHhwo!q��tcLzHxI�^zjsr��z±�!uwp�.qÙm�qÙx5�.uwx�|Òg^xIp�e�q9��qLp[zHuwh¾��gHi�p�e�q±��u�lÒo�h¾zjpruwg^x -´. e!qÙs�qviÕg^s�q��!pre!qWsrqH��o!h�p[�; {qSsrqLmOg`srpzHs�q~zL��qLs[zH|`q�ngH��qLs �! � ��uwl¿o!h¾zHp�u�g`x���o!� B qHcXp[� -

M u�|`o!srq Ð ��e�gK ��²p�e!q±m�s�q�.uÌcvp�qJ�Íz`cLcvo�s[z`cX�Ís�qH��o!hwp�� -V. e!q¿mOzjprp�qLsrxO�U �q���qLq±iÕg`sprs�o!q²��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�(uwx¿p�e!q���zjp[zSiÕsrg`l Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p � zjs�q$s�qLm!srg��.oOcvqJ� ���±p�e�q � k . >qplng���qLh%�$z`cLcvo�s[z`cX�Íu¾�te!u�|`eÊzjx5�Ê��p[zH�!hwqWiÕg^sWpre!q±qHz`���IiÕg`u�h¾�R·Óp�e!qV��u��+qLs�qÙxOcvq¿zjl�g`x!|cvg^x5�.u�p�uwg^xO��zHhwlng©��pZ�.uÌ��zjm�m�q�zjs[��iÕg`s{p�sro!qH�v��zjx5�npre!q�zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh1>% {g`s���cvg`x5��uwp�u�g`xnhÌzj|©��OqLe!u�x5�Òpre!q�g`pre!qLs��þiÕg`s{eOzjs��ÒiÕg`uwhÌ� -F. e!q�gH��qLs[zHhwh+cvg^s�s�qÙh¾zjpruwg^xÒ�OqLpE �qÙqLxÒpre!q�m!h�g`p��%uwxM u�|`o!srq Ð zjx5��p�e!q~g`x!q�� u�x M uw|`o�s�q � u¾� &9ç/ �(ë*���-C. e!q�i;z`cXptpreOzjp�pre!q~cvg`srs�qLhÌzjpruwg`x�OqLpE �qÙqLx Ì 4.mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p � zjx&� Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p � ¬z`� �(ë*� ��o�|`|`q���p[�� �q�eOzL��q�z`cLcXg`o!x�p�q�iÕg^s�lng���p�gji�p�e!q²s�qÙhwu¾zH�!hwq$p�s�qÙx5�!��uwx�pre!q��!zjp�z -

���

Page 34: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct

­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# z ,�. s�o!q~��qLx.prqLxOcvq��

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct

­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

2030405060708090

100

1 2 3 4

Per

c C

orre

ct

­

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# � ,ZÌ z`��� M g^uwhÌ� # c ,Z� zjs�� M g`uwhÌ�M u�|`o!srq Ð ��z ,�� qLs[cvqÙx.p�zj|`q�gjiþcvg^s�s�q�cvp�zHxO�O {qLs[��prg±p�s�o�qW��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH��z^��zSiÕo!xOcvpruwg`x�gHi�!h�g�c�H���gji{m!s[z^cvp�uÌcvq ò lng��.qLh�m!srq�.uÌcvp�u�g`x - � ,�� qLs�cvqLx�p[zH|`qWgHi¬cvg`srs�qHcvp$zjxy�O �qÙs[�tprgqHz^���Wi;zHh¾��qÐ��qLx�p�qLxycvqH�(z^��zÐiÕo�xOcvp�u�g`x¿gjiÓ�!h�g�c�H��(gjiÓm!s�z`cvpru¾cvq " lng��.qLh�m!s�q��u¾cvpruwg`x - c ,� qÙs[cvqLx�p[zH|`q�gHi�cXg`s�srqHcvp�zHxO�O {qLs[��prgÒeOzHs��Òi;zjhÌ��q~��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�{z`��zSiÕo!xOcvpruwg^x2gHi(��hwg�c�H!�gHi(m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq ò lng���qLh?m!srq�.uÌcvp�u�g`x -

M u�|`o!srq + ��e!g ��Wlng��.qLh�m!srq�.u¾cXp�uwg^xO�tiÕg`s±pre!qnp�u�lnqH�tprg B o5��|`qnpre!q���qÙx.prqLxOcvqH� -. e!q�gH��qLs�zjh�h�cvg`srs�qLhÌzjp�u�g`x±�OqLpE �qÙqLxWpre!q�m!h�g`p��þu�x M u�|`o!srq + zjx&�Wp�e!q�g^x!qH�]u�x M uw|^o!s�q ¹uÌ� &Êç� �(ë*�*�-m. e!qnlng��.qÙh%m�s�g��.oOcXqH�W��qLs��Íh�uwprp�hwqV��u��+qLs�qÙxOcvq¿��qÙpO {qLqLx�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�zHx5�Ëh�uwprqLs[zHh¾� iÕg^s�qHz`���IiÕg`u�h¾�v�� �e!u�hwqz hÌzjsr|`q¿uwx!u�p�u¾zHh´��u��+qLs�qÙxOcvqWiÕg`s$p�s�o�qH�²zjx5�ÍeOzjs��iÕg^uwh¾� -;. e�qWp�sro!qH�C�.u��+qLsrqLxOcvqu�.u¾�rzjm!mOqHzHs[�tgH��qLs�pre!qWprs�u¾zHh¾� -;Ì 4�cvqLm!p�iÕg^stlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sru¾cprs�o!qH��u�x�p�e!qUlOs���p��!hwg�c�H?��p�e!q~zHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh�>@ �g^s��np�sru¾zHh¾��p�qÙx5�np�g±�OqWpre!q~��hwg {qH��p -

�^�

Page 35: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# z ,�. s�o!q~��qLx.prqLxOcvq��

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

2500270029003100330035003700390041004300450047004900510053005500

1 2 3 4

RT

for

corr

ect a

ns

±

Blocks

LiteralsMetaphors

Artificial words

# � ,ZÌ z`��� M g^uwhÌ� # c ,Z� zjs�� M g`uwhÌ�M u�|`o!srq + ��z , p�qH��mOg`xy��qWpruwlnq���iÕg^s�cXg`s�srqHcvp¬zjxO�E �qLs�� prgÒprs�o!q~��qÙx.prqLxOcvqH�{z`��ziÕo�xOc�>pruwg`xDgji{�!h�g�c�H���gji{m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq " lng���qLh�m!s�qJ�.u¾cvpruwg^x - � , p q���mOg`xO��q±p�u�lnqH�þiÕg^s�cXg`s�srqHcvpzHxO�O {qLs[�²p�g2i;zHh¾��qÒqHz^���Ê��qLx�p�qÙxOcvqH�²z`�~z iÕo!xycvp�u�g`x�gji��!h�g�c�H��SgHi�m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq " lng���qLhm!srq�.uÌcvp�u�g`x - c , p�qH��mOg^xO��q�pruwlnq���iÕg`s¬cvg`srs�qHcvp{zHxO�O {qLs[��prgSi;zjhÌ��q�eyzjs�����qLx�p�qLxycvqH��z`�{ziÕo!xycvp�u�g`x�gji��!hwg�c�H���gji�m!s�z`cvpru¾cvq " lng���qLh?m!srq�.uÌcvp�u�g`x -

. e!q~lng��.qLh�l�zH�qH��m!srq�.u¾cXp�uwg^xO��zj�Og`o!p$p�e!qz`cLcvo�s[z`cX�2gHi{p�e!q��.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`xO� -s. zJ>�!h�q ) ��e!g �� pre!q�lnq�zjx¿x.o!l¿�OqLs(gHi(lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s���zjx&�2zHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh5 �g^s��!�; �u�p�e�cXg`s�srqHcvp�.qklOx!uwpruwg^xO� -a. e�u¾�tsrqLm!s�g���oOcvqH��p�e�q±s�qH��o!hwp�gHi�h�gK {qLs²z^cLcvo!s�z`cv��iÕg`s�iÕqHzjpro!s�q��tgji zjsO>pru�l+cvuÌzjh7 �g^s��!� -9. e!q¿gH��qLs[zHhwh�h�qL��qLh�gji z`cLcXo!s[z^cv�IuÌ�tlÒoycfe�e!u�|`e!qLs$p�eOzHxÇu�x . zj�!h�q +# q�4!cXqLm!p(iÕg`s�pre!q�iÕqHzjpro!s�qH��gjiþzjsrp�u�l�cvu¾zHh¢ �g^s��!� , �!�!o�p�p�e!uÌ�%lnu�|`e�p%srqRÕOqHcXp��.u1�?qÙs�qLxOcXqH�u�x2srqLmOg`srp�uwx�|nzHx5��zjxIgH��qLsrhw����prs�uwx�|`qLx�p���cvg^s�u�x!|¿cvs�u�p�qLsruwg^xng`xDg`o!s�mOzjsrp -

�^�

Page 36: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. zj�!h�q ) � � cLcvo!s�z`cv�~gjiF�.qRlyx!uwpruwg`xy�%g`x z±��cLzHhwq�iÕs�g`l prg �sò lng��.qÙh�m�s�q�.uÌcvp�u�g`xO� -M qHzjpro!s�q k{zjp�qÙ|`g`sr�

}IqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -ë)¹ -ê)�+� srp�u1l+cvu¾zHh¢ {g`s���� -³�^� -ê*K¹

X ��qLs[zHhwh�pre!q�lng���qLh���g�qH�(zt|^g�g�� B g^�±gjiðz`cLcXg`o!x�p�u�x!|tiÕg`s�p�e!q(�!zjp�z�zjx5�Wm�s�gH�.u8�.qH�oO�� �uwpre±z�cvg`l�m!o!p[zHp�u�g`xOzHh��.u�q� Ïgjiye!g ÏmOqLg`m!h�q�l�zL��|`g²zH�Og`o!p(h�qHzjsrx!uwx�|s {g`s����]zHx5�oO��uwx!|�pre!qLl uwx�cvg^x.prq�4�pU �e!qLxÍpre!qH��qa {g`s��!�²zjs�q±oy��q�Ís�qviÕqÙs�qLx�p�uÌzjhwh�� -U. e�u¾�tlng���qLhoO��qH�Spre!q¿m�g^s�pruwg`xÊgji$zI��qLx�p�qLxOcXq±p�eOzHpWuwp��.g�q��9H.x!g ²�7 �e!u¾c[eÇu�xÇg^o!sWq�4.mOqLsruwlnqLx�p ¬z`�tpre!qWm!srq�.uÌcLzjprq��!p�g¿u��.qÙx.pru½iÕ�npre!qWsrqviÕqLs�qÙxOcvq�gHi�pre!q9 {g`s��2uwxDp�e!q~mOz`��p²cvg^x.prq�4.p -. e!qÙx¹uwpnoO��qH�np�e!qIiÕq�zjp�o�s�qH�ÒgHi±pre!qÍs�qviÕqÙs�qLxOcXqIp�gÊl�zKH�qDe.��mOg`p�e�qH��qH��zj�Og`o!pDp�e!qiÕqHzHp�o!srqH�WgjiÐp�e!q�g`� B q�cvp -Á� pa �z^�ÒzH�!hwq�prgÇh�qHzjsrx iÕsrg`l l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��Wlng`srqns[zHm!u���hw��OqHcLzHoO��q�pre!qL����qÙp�p�qÙs±xOzjsrs�g �q�Ïpre!q�s�qLh�qL�^zjx�pSiÕqHzHp�o!srqH� -n. e!q�lng��.qLhA �z^�3��o!u�p�q��oOcLcvqH�r�­iÕo!h;�.l�z^��prqLs�u�x!|Wpre!qWlnq�zjx!u�x!|WgHi )^� mOqLs�cvqLx�p�gji�pre!q²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[�%u�x * prs�u¾zHh¾�zHx5�Çl�z^��p�qÙs�uwx�|IzHpWh�qHz`��pSmyzjs�pru¾zHhwhw�Ípre!q¿lnqHzjx�uwx!|ngHi + mOqLs�cvqLx�p�gji�pre!q�zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh {g`s���� u�x2pre!q~��zHlnq�p�u�lnq -

. e!q�lng��.qLh� �z^�;ÎHh¾zKÜÙ��Î�uwx±u�p[�(hwq�zjs�x�uwx!|�u�x±p�eOzHp�u�p(g`x!h��±hwqHzHs�x!qJ�9 �e!qLx¿uwp(l�z!�.qzHx2qÙs�s�g^s�u�xnp�e!q B o5�.|^qLlnqLx�p�p[z^�OH -A. e!u¾�{z`����o!lnm!pruwg^xns�qRÕyqHcvp[��p�e!q$�.u�q� 8preOzjpZ �g`s��h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|�u¾�¤�.s�u���qLx8���'x!qLq� -/� iWpre!qIl�g��.qLh�eOz��8h�qHzjsrx!q�8g`x¹qÙ��qLs��Ïprs�uÌzjh�p�eOzHpu�pWcXg`o!h8�?��hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|D �g`o�h��ÍeOzL��qÒ�OqLqLxÍi;z`��p�qLs - b�pruwh�h5��p�e!uÌ��lng��.qLh(myzjuwx�p[�²z�m!s�qLprp��g^m!p�u�lnu¾��p�u¾cnm!uÌcvp�o�s�qÍgjip�e!q�zH�!uwh�uwp��'gjiuwxOcvsrqLlnqLx�p[zHh� �g^s��¹hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|Ïp�g ��oOcLcvqLqJ� -b�u�xOcvq���o!� B q�cvp[�� �qLsrqÒx!g^p¿z`�~z`cLcvo�s[zjprqnuwxÊp�e!qLu�s� �g`s��Á�.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`xO�~z`�Spre!qnlng���qLh#@. zH�!hwq + ��qLs[��oO� . zH�!hwq )?, �Og`x!q±lnu�|`e�pC�do�qH��pruwg`x� �e!qLpre!qLs�p�e!q~lng��.qLh�z`cLcXo!s[zHp�qLh��cLzHm!p�o�s�qH�n��o!� B qHcvp��RQ�s�zjprqÇgHi9 {g`s�� h�qHzjsrx!uwx!| -y� g �qÙ��qLsL�; {qÍp�e!u�x�H8pre!qÍq�4�m!hwuÌcvuwp�.qklOx!uwpruwg^x p�z`�EH'��oG�+qLs��iÕsrg`l cXs�uwprqLs�u�g`xÁ��u�W cvo!hwp��Í�Og`pre8g^x8g`o�s±mOzjsrpnz^�Ò�rcvg`srqLs[�zHx5�8g`x¹pre!qÍ��o!� B qHcvp��RQ(mOzHs�p�z^�2�.qRlOx�uwp�u�g`x |`uw��qÙs[� -�� x8g^o!s¿�.u�q� ²��p�e�qÍz`cÙcvo!s[z^cv�zHx5�Çh¾zHp�qLxycv�ÍuwxÏpre!q B o5�.|`qÙlnqLx�p�p[z^�OH�uwx M u�|`o!srqH� � zjx5� ¹S# zHx5�ÇsrqLm!s�g���oOcvq�Ç���pre!q�lng��.qLh�u�x M uw|`o�s�qH� Ð zjx5� +�, zjsrqIlng^s�qnprgÇpre!q�m�g^uwx�p -�¸ ��p�e�qIqLx5�ÏgHi²p�e!qq�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�pL�(pre!qLs�qÖzjsrqÍx!gN�.u��+qLsrqLxOcvqH�±�OqLpE �qLqÙx8p�e�qÍz`cÙcvo!s[z^cvuwq��nzjx5�8hÌzjprqLxOcvu�qH�iÕg^sÒh�uwp�qÙs[zjhÌ�±zjx5�8l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��v��zHx5� pre!qÍz^cLcvo!s�z`cv� zHx5�8h¾zHp�qLxOcX�Á�.u��+qLsrqLxOcvq��9 �uwp�ezHs�p�u1l+cvuÌzjh� {g`s����%eOzL��q���qÙqLxÒ|^s�qHzHp�h��±s�q�.oycvq� - b�o!� B qHcvp��´ �qLsrq���qÙeOzL�.u�x!|±z^�%u½i+pre!qL�eOz!�2l�z^��prqLs�q�¿p�e!q²x!q� � �g^s��nlnqHzHx!uwx�|��v��zjp�hwqHz^��p�u�x2pre!q~cLz`��q²gji�lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� -

X xWpre!q�g^p�e!qLsÓeOzHx5�?��g`x!q{lnuw|^e.pÓzHs�|^o!q�preOzjp(g^o!sÓhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|���uwproOzjpruwg`xa ¬z`��gH��qLs�h��|^qLx!qLsrg`oO�²p�g�p�e!q ��o!� B qHcXp[��uwx�p�eOzHp �7ß�¹ gHi�prs�u¾zHh¾� # p�sro!qH�²zjx&�ÇeOzjs��ËiÕg`u�h¾� , g�+qLs�q���o!� B qHcvp��(zjx¿g`m!mOg^s�p�o�x!uwp��±p�g²u�x.iÕqLs(pre!q�lnqHzHx!uwx!|$gji�pre!q�x!q� N �g^s�� -�� qLs�eyzjmO�(lng^s�qgHiÕp�qLx� �e!qLx9 {g`s��!��g�cÙcvo!s(u�xWcXg`x�p�q�4�p�uwx~s�qHzHh�hwu½iÕq�pre!q�cvg^x.prq�4�p7�.g�qH�]x!g^p]m�s�gH�.u8�.q�p�e!q�rzjlnq²g`m�m�g^s�pro!x!uwpruwqH��iÕg`s�uwx.iÕqLsrs�u�x!|±p�e!q~lnqHzHx!uwx!|±gHi{p�e!q� �g`s�� - b�g!�+z`�C �q±�rzju8�2uwx

�¹

Page 37: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

pre!q�uwx�p�srg��.oOcvpruwg`xð�`p�e!uÌ�]mOzHm�qÙs%srqHzjh�hw���.g�qH�(x!g^p{zjxO�E �qLs�p�e�qC�do!q���p�u�g`x±gHi¢ �e�qLp�e!qÙs(uwpuÌ��mOg��r��u��!hwq�iÕg`sÓoO��prgth�qHzjsrx±zHhwh�p�e�q; �g^s��²lnqHzjx�uwx!|©�¢ �q���gt����uwxycvs�qLl�qLx.p�zjhHhwq�zjs�x�uwx!|iÕsrg`l cvg^x.prq�4�p -´$ g`x!qLpre!qLh�qH���X�.uwpC��g�qH�t��e!g Ap�eyzjp�uwxOcvsrqLlnqLx�p[zHh� �g^s���hwqHzHs�x!u�x!|¿cLzjx�Oq��do�uwp�q~��oOcLcvqH�r�­iÕo!h -

M u�|`o!srq � gK�+qLs�qJ�Çz�m!u¾cvpro!s�q¿gji¬e!g y �g^s��!�~zjs�q¿m!srg�cvqH����q�� �e!qÙxÏp�e!qÙ�Íg�cLcvo!su�x8cXg`x�p�q�4�p -m� x'p�e!q�cÙz`��q�gHi²hwu�p�qLs�zjh¾�X�]pre!q�lng��.qLh B oO��p±m!srg�cvqH�r��q�Ïp�e�qI��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH�x!g^s�l�zHhwh��WzHx5�±uwx¿p�e!q�cLz^��q�gji�zjs�pru�l+cXu¾zjh� �g^s��!��p�e!qÙ�Wuwl�m!hwqLl¿qLx�prq�²zS��g`m!e�u¾��pru¾cLzHp�q�|^o!qH����uwx!| ��p�s[zHp�qL|^� -Ç. e!qÍlng©��p¿uwx�p�qLsrqH��pruwx!|ÊcLz^��q�cvg^xOcvqLsrx!q� pre!qÍm!srg�cvqH����uwx!|'gHilnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�� -´$ g`p�g^x!hw�V��u��±p�e!q�l�g��.qLhGlOs���p{p�s��¿z²hwu�p�qLs�zjh!u�x.prqLs�m!srqLp[zHp�u�g`x����!o!p{gH��qLs�! mOqLs[cvqÙx.p�gHi�p�e!q~p�u�lnq�uwpC��u��2qÙ��qLx�|`gng^xIp�g�p�s�� zÒlnqLp�zjm!e!g^s�uÌctuwx�p�qLsrm!s�qÙp[zjpruwg^x -� g {qL��qLsL�A �uwpre¹m!s[z^cvp�uÌcvqIpre!qIl�g��.qLh$z`c���o!uwsrq� x�q� lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌc2lnq�zjx!u�x!|��WiÕg`spre!qH��q� {g`s����tzHx5�2 �z`��gjiÕprqLxIsrqLp�sruwqL��uwx�|Spre!qLl �OqviÕg^s�q²p�e�qSh�uwprqLs[zHh?lnqHzHx!uwx�|�� -

ºv}3�0�=¾K~0�F|�}3�0�

. e!q±srqH��o�hwp[��uwx&�.u¾cLzHp�q~p�eOzHp�p�e!qcvg`x�p�q�4.p�l�zjp�cfe�uwx!|¿��p�s[zHp�qL|^�ÍcLzHxÍ�Oq¿��oOcLcXqH���5iÕo!hwh��oO��q�ÇiÕg`s¿lnqHzHx!uwx!|Öcvs�q�zjp�u�g`x # z^�×pre!qLg^s�uwq��Wgji� �g`s�� h�qHzjsrx!uwx!|Íu�x cvg`x�p�q�4�p±z^����qLs�p ,zHx5� cXg`lnm!srqLe!qLxy��uwg^x - k�g`x���qLs�|^qLxOcvqÍgHi±hÌzjp�qÙxOcvuwq��nzjx5�¹mOqLs[cXqLx.p�zj|^qH�ngji¿cXg`s�srqHcvpzHxO�O {qLs[��uwxnpre!q�hwu�p�qLs�zjhOzHx5�nx!g`x�>5h�uwp�qÙs[zjhðcvg`x&�.uwpruwg`xy����o�m!mOg`s�p���p�e!qÐcvh¾zHuwl�p�eyzjp�myzjsO>pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[��zHs�q~z`cvproOzjh�hw�n��o!uwh8�.uwx!|¿x!q� ÛlnqHzHx!uwx�|��%iÕg`s�p�e�qWzHs�pru�l+cvuÌzjh� {g`s����tzHx5�2iÕg`spre!q²lnqLp[zHm!e!g^s���qLe!uÌcvhwq��%zHx5�noO��q²pre!qLl prg±o!x5�.qLs���p�zjx5��p�e!q²��qLx�p�qLxOcXqH� -´6 qtiÕg`o�x5�x!g~qL��u��.qLxycvq�iÕg`s{p�e!q²cXh¾zju�l preOzjp¬zjs�pru�l+cXu¾zjh1>% {g`s��ÒhwqHzHs�x!u�x!|²u¾�{zSm!srg�cvqH����q�����qÙx.pru¾zjh�hw��.u1�+qLs�qLx�p�iÕs�g`l lnqÙp[zjm�e!g`sÓhwqHzHs�x!u�x!| -F� g �qL��qÙsL�LlnqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcLzjh�l�qHzjx!u�x!|��� �qÙs�q�q�z`�q>u�qLstprgnm!uÌc�Hno�m��tmOzHs�pru¾cvu�mOzjx�p[��uwxÍg^o!s�q�4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p�|�zL��q~lng`srqSm�s�qHcvuÌ��q��.qRlOx!u�p�u�g`xO�iÕg^s���oOcfeD {g`s���� preOzjx�iÕg`s�zjsrp�u1l+cvu¾zHh� �g^s��!� -;� p���qÙqLl��%pre!qLsrqWzHs�q~zjp�hwq�z`��p�pE {g¿cvo!qH�mOqLg^m!hwq²oO��qSprgÒu�x.prqLs�m�s�qLp{o!p�prqLs[zHxOcvqH�k�(hwuwprqLs[zHhwu�p��¿zHx5��cvg`x�p�q�4.p -

� pWuÌ�Suwx�p�qÙs�qH��p�uwx�|Ie!g v��o!u¾c�H.h���zjxOzHm!e!g^s�u¾cnlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s��Wc[eOzjx!|^q�Çpre!qLuws��p�zjp�oy�zHx5�W�OqHcLzjl�q%o�x5�.qLs���p�g�g���z`�]srqHz��.u�hw�²z^�(hwuwprqLs[zHh¾� -£� gK {qL��qLsÙ� Ì 4�mOqLs�u�lnqLx�p � ��e!g �q�preOzjp²uwxycvs�qHz^��q�Ioy��zj|^qÒl z��.q±pre!qLl h�qH���$zjm!mOqHzHhwuwx�| iÕg^s�iÕo!s�pre!qLs�oO��q -V. e!u¾��s�qH��o!hwpzHs�|`o�qH�%u�x×i;zL��g`s�gHiÓhwqHzHs�x!q�±lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[�(�OqLeOzL��uwx!|²h�u`H�q�hwu�p�qLs�zjhÌ�v�`u£i� �q$z`�r��o!l�q�p�eOzHph�uwp�qÙs[zjhÌ�%eOzL��q²hwq�����q�4�m!s�q�����u���q�mOg �qLs�preOzjxDlnqLp[zHm!e!g^s[��zjx&�2p�eyzjp�m�qÙg`m!h�qW��p�sruw��q�prgz^cfe!u�qL��q�l�zK4�uwl¿o!l q�4.m!srqH����uw��uwp�� -� zHs�p�uÌcvuwmyzjx�p[�U �qLsrqnzH�!hwq¿p�gÑ�.g2i;zHuwsrhw�P {qLhwh�uwxÊcvg`lnm�s�qLe!qÙxO��u�g`xm �uwp�e�g`o!p²l�z^�q>

prqLs�u�x!|~cvg`lnm�hwqLprqLhw�²p�e�q�uwx�p�qLx&�.q�±lnqHzjx�uwx!|²gjiÓpre!q�x!q� � �g`s��!� -A. e�u¾�%srqH��o�hwp{��qLqÙl��prg¿��o!m!mOg^s�p�p�e�qS��uwq� 8p�eyzjp� �g^s��nhwq�zjs�x�uwx!|~u¾�%u�xOcvsrqLlnqLx�p[zHh #%$ zH|`�¿qLp�zHh - � ��)!*�+!,iòpre!qtq�4!z^cvp�lnq�zjx!u�x!|�u¾��x!g`p¬z`c���o!u�s�q�¿zjhI �zL�!�(iÕs�g^l z~��uwx�|`hwq�q�4�zjlnm�hwq -7� p�u¾��zHh¾��gWuwxzH|`s�qÙqLlnqLx�pA �uwp�e�p�e!q²cXh¾zju�l gHi;:+zHx5�!zHo!qLs$zjx5�D�to!l zju¾� #���)�)�+!, preOzjp�pre!q�lnq�zjx!u�x!|

�^�

Page 38: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

gHi�za �g^s��2uÌ��x!g`p�m!srqHcvu¾��q����!o!p�s[zHp�e!qLsC��qLp�qLsrlnuwx�q�×���npre!q²�`zHs�u�qLp��ÒgHi�cvg^x.prq�4�p[��uwx �e!uÌcfe�uwp�g�cLcvo�s�s�qJ� -

��z_Á?z�xiz��0��zT�

� x&�.qLs[��g`x��x$ - ��'Û:OqL�!u�qLs�q���k -»#r��)!)�*�,�- �¢f5g���e%� � ���0��� � ���?c�g�cGe¦\Ñ�O_�e�f��?]KdKf�e?ò}ÍzHeG ¬zje�� $ q� R$`qÙs[��qÙ�¢�A:+zJ �srqLxOcvq Ì s�h��Ozjo�l � ����g�cvu¾zHp�qH� � o!�!h�u¾��e�qLs[� -

¸ hÌz`c�H?��} -0#r��)!Ð`��,�- Æm��Gg��ì\¤�?c�� � g�e%�R��f��?^�\�ò � preOz`cLz�� $Uó �]k�g`srx!qLhwh{�tx�uw��qLs���uwp��� srqH��� -

¸ hÌz`c�H?��} -A#r��)�+J)�,�- }Ig`srq�zH�Og`o!p�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s -�� x �9-�X s�p�g^x.� #%Ì � -1, �IÆSg�e%�R��f��?^U�?c��e�f��?]dKf�e-ò{k{zjl¿�!s�u8�.|`q²��x!uw��qLs���u�p�� � srqH��� -

k{z^cLcvu¾zHs�u;�.k - �?' ¼ hwoOc�H����OqLs�|��.b -7#���)�)`�?,�- ��x5�.qLs���p[zHx5�.u�x!|slO|^o!s[zHp�uw��q�hÌzjx!|^oOzj|^q -=� x} -5¼ qLs�xO���Oz`c[e!qLs #@Ì � -�, �eô��?c��?j���Kºä�O_s��\��!��f����1��c�d ]G��\ke@����\�ò�b�zjxÑ�tuwqÙ|`g!�?k ��-

k{zHs�x!u�x!q��5� - � à zjlnqÙqLx.o�u5� Ì�- $ - ��'�k�gH�.h�q�� ¼�-�#���)�*¹G,�- �tp�u�hwu`Ü�zjp�u�g`x¿gji{cXg`x�p�q�4�p�oOzHhu�x.iÕg`srl�zjpruwg^x2u�x0�.qÙp�qLsrlnuwx!u�x!|Wpre!qWl�qHzjx!u�x!|±gjiþo!x.i;zjl�uwhwuÌzjs� {g`s���� -_õ g��?�?��c�dõ g�\g��?^���f�ö�]���eEgk^��Ó�j�A÷�ø`� ��*!*J"d�� K¹�-

k�hÌzjs�H+� �9-´#r��)�+���,�-A. e!qthÌzjx!|^oOzj|^qR>­z`�q>�l54�q��>;qR�+qHcvp�i;zHhwh¾z^cv�=�(zWcXs�uwpru���o!q�gjiÓhÌzjx!|^oOzj|^q��p[zHp�u¾��p�uÌcL�Òuwx mO����c[e!g`h�g`|`uÌcLzjh$s�qH��qHzjs�cfe -ù� �?]�^Rc����C�O_ûú�gk^kj����¯üFg��?^Rc���c�d¡�?c��ú5gk^Rj����¢¿�g�f��?�����?^[�A÷�ý�� �`�^� > �`��)�-

��z^��cLzHh5��} -�#���)!*�+!,�- �tqviÕqÙx5�.uwx�|�hwuwprqLs[zHh`lnq�zjx!u�x!| -"þ ��d?c��`e%���Kg À ���Ïgkc��Rg��c÷v÷H� �`�!) > ��*���-M uÌ��c[e!qLsÙ��� -D#���)�)K¹�,�- :OqHzjsrx!uwx�|Y {g`s��!�ÐiÕsrg`l cvg^x.prq�4.pÐzjx5�S��u¾cvpruwg`xyzjs�u�qH�R� � xÇq�4?>

mOqLsruwlnqÙx.p�zjh+cvg`l�mOzjsru¾��g^x - ½Z�?�5�1�Ïg��sÅA\�����f����Ó��c�d?]���\ke%����\X��÷�ÿ`� �`����"d��+�¹�-¼ qLx�p�x!qÙsL�5� - �5' M s[zHxOcvq�� ��-C#���)!*�*?,�-C. e!qW��qÙs���lÒo�p[zj��uwhwu�p��WqR�+qHcvp�����p�o5��uwqH��gHi�p�e!q

cXg`l¿�!uwxOzHp�g^s�u¾zHh���qLl zjx�p�u¾cÙ�?gji+x!g`o�xO��zjx5�W��qLsr�O� -�� xnb - b©l�zjh�h5� ¼9- k�g`prp�srqLhwh;�?'} -5. zjx�qLx!eOzHoO� #%Ì �!� -�, �cüFg�É!�������7� � j��ëd?]��`e@�2^�g�\����Ó]�e@���?c�\��;�5gk^�\E�5g��Re@���Kg�\A_�^�� ���\��!��f����1��c�d ]G��\ke@����\!� c�gk]�^��R��\�����f����1��d?�Á�?c��¡�?^�e%� bi�������U��c�eOg��I�1�ëdGgkc5�Rg # m -{�K¹�� >�!*`�?,�- }Ig`s�|©zjx à zHoG�+l�zjx -

¼ qLsrs�uw|��?p -¢#���)�*!)�,�- . e!q�p�u�lnq�cvg^o!s[��q�gjiÓ��qLxO��q�cvsrqHzjpruwg`x - ÆSg � �?^k�U�?c�� þ ��d?c��`e@���?c.�÷��L� ��)?+R"��! �+ -

�!Ð

Page 39: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

¼ qLsrs�uw|��5p - �5' � qHzHhw��� �9-s#r��)!*`��,�- �toOzjhÓm!srg�cvqH����qH��uwxIl�qLp[zHm!e!g`s�o�x5�.qLs���p[zHx5�.u�x!|��cXg`lnm!srqLe!qLxy��uwg^xnzHx5��zjm!m�s�qHcvuÌzjpruwg`x -t� �?]G^kc������O_��AÉ��5gk^k� � gkcGe@���eÅi\��!��f����1��d?���Æng � �?^k�a�?c�� þ ��d c��`e%���?c���ø`� Ð�Ð�+k"�Ð?+H�G-

¼ uw���O�v�?p -7#���)!)� ?,�- k�g`lnm!srqLe!qLx&�.uwx!|�lO|^o!s[zHp�uw��q�srqviÕqLsrqLx.pru¾zHh��.qH��cXs�uwm�p�uwg^xO� -"� �?]�^Rc�����O_��AÉ��5gk^k� � gkcGe@���IÅA\�����f����1��d?���YüFg��?^Rc���c�d��"ÆSg � �?^R���?c�� þ ��d?c��`e@���?c.�"÷��H� ��Ð�"Ð!ÐG-

¼ hwoyc�H����OqLsr|!�]b - � ¼ h�u��.q�z.� �7- �7' ¸ g�g!H.u�x�� �9-2#r��)�*^��,�-YX xÇo�x5�.qLs���p[zHx5�.u�x!|�hwuwprqLs[zHh��mOqLqHc[e��(k{zjxnmOqLg^m!hwq�uw|^x!g`srqtlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s���� � �?]G^kc����5�O_jú�gk^kj����Iü´g��?^kc���c�da�?c��ú5gk^Rj����¢¿�g�f��?�����?^[�"ýI÷H� *`��"�)�*�-

� qÙs�l�zHx�� �7- � � x5��qLs[��g`x��Fp - � � qHzHs[��g^x�� �7- �7' $ zH|`��� 6Ç-�Ì�-�#���)!*�+!,�-2� xOcXu��.qLx�p[zHhz^c���o!u¾��uwp�u�g`x~gji� {g`s��×lnq�zjx!u�x!| iÕsrg`l�q�4�mOg���uwp�u�g`xO�7 �uwp�e±�^zHs�uwqJ�×prq�4.p�iÕqHzHp�o!srqH� -õ g��?�?��c�d õ g�\g��?^���f�ö�]���eEgk^��Ó�j�"ývý�� ��Ð^�J"d��*K¹�-

� x!e!g��� ��- �£:Ou�l�z.�]b - ��' k{zjsrs�g`h�h5� �£-¤#���)!*K¹�,�- k�g`x�p�q�4�p�oyzjh(qR�+qHcXp[��g`x�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^scXg`lnm!srqLe!qLxy��uwg^xnuwx�srqHz��.u�x!| - Æng � �?^k�a�?c�� þ ��d c��`e%���?c��"ý�� �`��* > �!Ð�+ -

à qL����zHsL� ¸U-´#���)�*!)�,�-AX xnp�e!q�iÕo!xOcXp�uwg^xOzjhOq��o!u��`zHhwqLxycvq�gjiÓh�uwp�qÙs[zjhyzjx5�Òl�qLp[zHm!e!g`sru¾cLzHhu�x.prqLs�m�s�qLp�zjp�u�g`xO�±uwx���u¾��cXg`o!s���q -ù� �?]G^kc������O_^ÆSg � �?^k�S�?c��Wü7�?c�d?]���dGg[�Gý�`��?+H� > �!*`�G-

:+zHx5�!zjo�qLsL� .U-7Ãa- �7' �to�l�zjuÌ�v�(b -�.U-0#r��)�)?+�,�-�� ��g`hwo�p�uwg^xÏp�g � h¾zHp�g�Q³�Sm�s�g`��hwqLl0�pre!q±h¾zHp�qLx�p~��qLl zjx�p�u¾c²zHxOzjh��!��u¾�Spre!qLg^s��IgHi$z`c���o!uÌ��uwpruwg^x��?uwx&�.oOcvpruwg`x�zHx5�ÇsrqLmG>srqH��qÙx.p�zjp�u�g`x�gjiFH�x!g �hwq�.|^q - ÅA\�����f����Ó��d ������� õ gk���Ïg�h]�A÷��ÿ`� �`����"��¹? �-

:OgH��qLprpL�!} -Z#���)�)�*?,�- k�e!g`uÌcvq -F� xj$ -O� x5�.qLs���g^xP' k - :OqL��uwqLsrq #%Ì �!� -�, �Z�¢f5g���e%� � ������ � ���?c�g�cGe¦\��O_�e@�?]dKf�e-òZ:+zJ �srqLxOcvq Ì s�h��Ozjo�l � ����g�cvu¾zHp�qH� -

}Íc à qLg �x���} -�#r��)!*`��,�-¡. e�qIz^c���o!u¾��uwp�u�g`x'gji� �g^s��'lnqHzjx�uwx!|�iÕs�g`l cvg`x�p�q�4�pW���c[e!u�h��.srqLx�gji{e!uw|^e�zjx5�Ih�g zH�!uwh�uwp�� -_õ g��?�?��c!d õ g�\g��?^���fpö�]G��eEgk^��1�j��ý�H� ¹?*^�J"¹ )�Ð�-

}Ig^x5�.s�uÌz.�"$ - ��' 6 u�pO>q�.q ¸ g�qLsL�ð} -3#r��)�)��K,�-a. e!q¿qR�+qHcvp[��gji¬cvg`x�p�q�4.proOzjh(sru¾c[e!x!qH�r�g^xÏp�e�qn|`o!q�����zH�!uwh�uwp���zjx&� pre!q¿s�qLprqLx.pruwg^xÇgHiU {g`s����Suwx z iÕg`srqLuw|^xÏh¾zHx!|`oyzj|`q -½Z�?�5�1�Ïg��sü[��c�d?]���\ke%����\X�A÷�ý�� �¹?)�"���Ð?+?-

$ zH|`��� 6Ç- � � x5�.qÙs[��g^x��Zp - �´' � qLs�l�zHx�� �£-N#���)!*�+!,�- :OqHzHs�x!u�x!|0 �g^s��ÏlnqHzHx!uwx!|©�iÕsrg`l cXg`x�p�q�4�p��.o�s�uwx�|Òx!g^s�l�zHh?srqHz��.u�x!| - ý��!� �^��+k"���+J G-

�?+

Page 40: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

$ zH|`��� 6Ç- �=' ¼ qLx�p�qLsÙ�¢� -�#���)�)� ?,�- b�qÙl�zjx�p�uÌc�cvg`xy��p�s�zju�x.p��tg`xÍh�q�4.uÌcLzjhðcLzjprqL|`g^s�u�qH� -ü«�?c�d?]���dGg��?c�� þ ��d?c��`e@���?cÀÅ(^���Rg�\�\g�\X�yÿ`� ��Ð!)J"d�� .�!-

$ zH|`��� 6Ç- � � qLs�l zjx�� �£- ��' � x5�.qÙs[��g^x��?p -¢#r��)�*^��,�- :OqHzHs�x!u�x!|U {g`s�����iÕsrg`l�cvg^x.prq�4.p -õ g��?�?��c�d õ g�\g��?^���f�ö�]���eEgk^��Ó�j�"ý�H� �`�^�J"d�`�`��-

$ zH|`��� 6Ç- �'¹b�cvg^p�pL��$ -H�9-�#r��)!)� �,�-G6 g`s��S�rcfe�qLl�z`�k� Ì 4.mOqHcXp[zjpruwg^xO��zj�Og`o�p(p�e!q(iÕg^s�lzHx5�2l�qHzjx!u�x!|WgHi(x�q� L �g^s��!� -Gþ ��d?c��`e@���?c0�?c��� kc�\ke@^R]��Re@���?c�\X���L� �� ^� > �L�?+?-

X Q ¸ sruwqLxð� Ì�- �7' }I��qÙs[�v� $ -Y#r��)!*`��,�-26 e!qLxÊcvg`l�m!s�qLe�qLxO��u�g`xÑ�.u�W cvo!h�p���u�lnm!s�gH��qH�l�qLlng`sr��iÕg`s(prq�4�p -e� �?]�^Rc������O_��AÉ��5gk^k� � gkcGe@����ÅA\�����f����1��d?���AüFg��?^Rc���c!d��eÆng ����?^k�a�?c�� þ ��d?c��`e@���?c.�A÷v÷H� �L� > ����-

X x!uÌ��e!u;� Ãa- �£' }Io!s�m!e���� ¼�-P#r��)�)^��,�- }IqLp�zjm!e�g`s�uÌcWs�qviÕqÙs�qLxOcXq?�U �e!qLx�lnqLp�zjm!e!g^s[�zHs�qDx!g`p¿o!x5�.qÙs[��prg�g��¹z`�Òq�z`��u�hw�Êz`�Òh�uwprqLs[zHh�cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLxO��uwg`x - ÆSg � �?^k���?c��þ ��d?c��`e%���?c.�"ýI÷H� +JÐ`� > +!+H�G-

X s�prg`x���� �9- �%b�c[eOzjh�hwqLsrpL�7� - �Ap qL��x!g^h��!�X�Ap - �´' � x.prg��v��b -Á#���)�+*?,�-n� x�p�qÙs�m!srqLp�u�x!|l�qLp[zHm!e!g`s��ÒzHx5�¹u��.u�g`l��k� b©g`lnqDqR�+qHcvp[�±g`x cvg^lnm!s�qÙe!qLxO��uwg`x -½� �?]G^kc������O_ú5gk^Rj����eüFg��?^Rc���c�d2�?c��¥ú�g�^Rj����¢¿�g�f��?�����?^[�A÷��L� ¹?Ð`��"?¹�+�+?-

X s�prg`x���� �9- �!é%g^x5�.sroO�OH^z.��p - � M g��r�v�!} -©�9- �?'*$`g`x!qH�X��: -´#r��)!*`��,�- b�zjh�uwqLxOcXq��`��uwlnu�hwqH�zHx5�Ïp�e!q z`����lnlnqÙp�s���gHi$��uwl�uwh¾zHs�u�p�� -M� �?]G^kc����Z�O_sÆng � �?^k�P�?c��pü«�?c�d?]���dGg[�ý��!� ��Ð!) > ��)K¹�-

b�q�zjs�h�q��A$ -Á#r��)�+J)�,�- }IqÙp[zjm�e!g`s -�� x ��-[X srp�g`x�� #@Ì � -�, ��ÆSg�e@�R��f��?^2�?c��0e�f��?]KdKf�e?òk{zHlÒ��s�u���|`q²�tx�uw��qLs���uwp�� � srqH��� -

b�e�qviÕqLhw��uwx!q���$ -�#r��)�)! �,�- b�p�o&�.qLx�p%i;z`cXp�g`s�� srqLh¾zHp�q�nprg±�`zHs�uÌzj�!u�hwuwp��¿uwx�hwq�zjs�x�uwx!|� �g`s��l�qHzjx!u�x!|���uwxDcvg^x.prq�4.p -t� �?]G^kc����7�O_ õ g��?�?��c�dä¿�g�f��?�����?^[�"ývý�� +��!-

b�e�uwx B g��.} - ��'A}I��qLs[�X�v$ -A#���)�*�+!,�-7. e!q�s�g^hwq�gji�cvg^x.prq�4.p�u�xÒlnqÙp[zjm�e!g`s�cXg`lnm!srqLe!qLx�>��uwg^x -]� �?]�^kc����7�O__ÆSg � �?^R�a�?c��sü«�?c�d?]���dGg[��ý��H� �`�!Ð > �K¹���-

b�prqLs�x��OqLs�|���p - ��' � g �qLh�h5�y$ -3#r��)!*`��,�- k�g`l�m!s�qLe�qLx5�.u�x!|Ò��qÙs��OzHh�cvg`l�m!s�qLe�qLxO��u�g`x -½ � g�^R�����?caÅi\��!��f����1��d?��\keÕ����`� *�+J*J"�*!)`��-

. g`o!s�zjx!|^qHzjoð��p - �5'yp u�mO�v�¢: -�#���)!).�,�-C� x.prqLs�m!srqLp�u�x!|¿zjx&�2qL�^zjh�oOzjpruwx!|¿lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s[� -� �?]�^Rc���� �O__ÆSg � �?^R�V�?c��sü7�?c�d ]G��dGg�����H� ¹��`� > ¹�+H��-

. g`o!s�zjx!|^qHzjoð�Ap - �£' b�prqLs�x��OqLs�|��7p -�#���)!*.�,�-D� m!p�x�qH����uwx�lnqLp�zjm!e�g`s -«þ ��d?c��`e@���KgÅA\��!��f����1��d?�j��÷��`� ��+ > �^�G-

�!*

Page 41: act-r.psy.cmu.eduact-r.psy.cmu.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... · 2013-07-15 · O ] lnqÙp[zjm e!g`sðcvg`lnm s qLe!qÙxO u g`x XhwqHzHs x!u x!| lnqLp zjm!e!g^s[ X LhwqHzHs

. g �xO��qLx&�?�I$ -´#r��)?+�¹G,�-´� ����o!qH�{zjx5�Òl�g��.qLh¾��cvg^xOcvqLsrx!uwx�|Spre!q�m!s�g�cvq�����u�x!|±gji�zulOx�uwp�qx�o!l¿�OqLs(gjiÓu�x!m!o!p�� -7� x ¸U-�à zjx�p�g �uwp�Ü #@Ì � -�, �/ô�] � �?cP��c�_��?^ � ��e@���?c9�=^���Rg�\�\ ���c!d��a��]�e@�?^R�����ì\���cT�5gk^8_��?^ � �?c��Rg(�?c��a����d?c��`e@���?c # m -��L�`� > ��*�Ð?,�-7� uwhÌ���!zHhwq�� $ $��:+z� �srqLxOcvq Ì s�h��Ozjo!l � ����g�cvu¾zHp�qH� -

�th�hwl�zHx!x��.b -�#���)!Ð�Ð?,�- ü7�?c�d?]���dGgu�?c��3\ke%��`g×ò $ q� ó g`s�H¢� ¸ zHs�x!qH��zHx5� $ g`��hwq�� � xyc -�^zjxÑ��z`zHhwqLx "�à zjm!prqLu B xy�v�O} - } - ��' Ì hÌ��e!g^o!pO>­}Ig`e�sL�+} -�#���)!*.�,�-Z. e!q±z^c��do�u¾��u�p�u�g`x

gHiU {g`s�� l�qHzjx!u�x!|��~z`�¿zÍcvg`|^x!uwpruw��qnh�qHzjsrx!uwx�|Im!srg�cvqH��� -á� �?]�^kc������O_ ú�gk^kj����üFg��?^Rc���c�d2�?c��¥ú�g�^Rj����¢¿�g�f��?�����?^[�"ý�H� ��*!ÐJ"d��)�)�-

� gkj�\keEgk^&Æ \6ø�e¦fÑc�g�ho�����I�`g�d?����eEg2�?���ke%���?c��?^k�7ò #���)�).�,�- b�m!s�u�x!|KlyqLh��?�+} � �O}IqLsrs�uÌzjl3>6 qL�O��p�qLs -

6 qLs�x�qLsL� �9- �´' à zHm!h¾zHx�� Ì�-¡#r��)`�! z ,�-Á. e!qDz`c��do!uÌ��u�p�uwg^xÇgHiU {g`s�� l�qHzjx!u�x!|��k�¿z��qL��qLhwg^m!lnqLx�p[zHhO��pro5�.� - ÆÊ�?c���d?^��R��f?\��O_ue¦f5g À ����Ïg�e%�t_��?^ õ g�\g��?^���fD��c þ f��`�Ó�.�gk�Kg��1�R� � g�cGeé�©÷�ÿ #5���K,�-

6 qLs�x�qLsL� �9- �5' à zHm!h¾zHx�� Ì�-9#r��)`�! � ,�- �tqL��qLh�g`m!l�qLx.p{gjiZ �g^s��Ilnq�zjx!u�x!|±p�e!srg`o!|^e��qÙs��OzHh!cvg^x.prq�4�p��Ózjx¿q�4�m�qÙs�uwl�qLx.p�zjh���p�o5�.� -`� �?]G^kc����5�O_©ÅA\�����f����1��d?�H�/ý�ø`� �`����"�^��+ -

� uÌzjg^hwg`x�|!��: -£#r��)!*�*�,�-�Ì �+qHcvp[�(gHiÓcvg^x.prq�4.proOzjh�cvo!q��þg^xÒu�x.iÕqLsrs�uwx�|�zHx5�×srqLlnqLl¿�OqLs�u£x!|l�qHzjx!u�x!|���gjiA {g`s��!� - ½Z�?�5�1�Ïg��süA��c!d?]G��\ke@����\X�\ø`� ¹  `�J" ¹!�Ù�G-

�!)