6
MeCasa: A Family Virtual Space Abstract We present MeCasa, a tool for connecting family members who have been geographically separated. MeCasa was designed with the intent to accomplish three objectives: 1. Increase the emotional connection between displaced family members, 2. Mimic the privacy provided by an actual home, 3. Make the interaction fun and interesting to use. A mid-fidelity prototype was built and tested to meet these objectives. Our results showed that MeCasa successfully bridged the emotional disconnect created when families physically drifted apart. Keywords Home; Threshold; Privacy; Family; Emotional Design ACM Classification Keywords H.5.2 [Information Interfaces and Presentation (e.g., HCI)]: User Interfaces – User-centered design; Introduction The idea of “family” or what it means to be a family has never been static. Economic, social, and technological factors have constantly shaped the family dynamic throughout the world. Now more than ever, families have become increasingly fractured due, in part, to a more globalized economy and the technological advances in long-distance travel [2]. Copyright is held by the author/owner(s). CHI 2012, May 5–10, 2012, Austin, TX, USA. ACM 978-1-4503-1016-1/12/05. Tyler Davis Missouri Western State University [email protected] Camie Steinhoff Missouri Western State University [email protected] Maricarmen Teran Vela Missouri Western State University [email protected] Human Factors & Usability Testing Missouri Western State University 4525 Downs Drive St. Joseph, MO 64507 USA Student Design Competition CHI 2012, May 5–10, 2012, Austin, Texas, USA 1261

[ACM Press the 2012 ACM annual conference extended abstracts - Austin, Texas, USA (2012.05.05-2012.05.10)] Proceedings of the 2012 ACM annual conference extended abstracts on Human

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

MeC

asa:

A F

amily

Virt

ual S

pace

Ab

stra

ct

We

pre

sent

MeC

asa,

a t

ool fo

r co

nnec

ting f

amily

m

ember

s w

ho h

ave

bee

n g

eogra

phic

ally

sep

arat

ed.

MeC

asa

was

des

igned

with t

he

inte

nt

to a

ccom

plis

h

thre

e obje

ctiv

es:

1.

Incr

ease

the

emotion

al c

onnec

tion

bet

wee

n d

ispla

ced f

amily

mem

ber

s, 2

. M

imic

the

priva

cy p

rovi

ded

by

an a

ctual

hom

e, 3

. M

ake

the

inte

ract

ion f

un a

nd inte

rest

ing t

o u

se.

A m

id-f

idel

ity

pro

toty

pe

was

built

and t

este

d t

o m

eet

thes

e obje

ctiv

es.

Our

resu

lts

show

ed t

hat

MeC

asa

succ

essf

ully

bridged

the

emotional

dis

connec

t cr

eate

d

when

fam

ilies

phys

ical

ly d

rift

ed a

par

t.

Keyw

ord

s H

om

e; T

hre

shold

; Pr

ivac

y; F

amily

; Em

otional

Des

ign

AC

M C

lass

ific

ati

on

Keyw

ord

s H

.5.2

[In

form

atio

n I

nte

rfac

es a

nd P

rese

nta

tion (

e.g.,

H

CI)

]: U

ser

Inte

rfac

es –

Use

r-ce

nte

red d

esig

n;

Intr

od

uct

ion

The

idea

of

“fam

ily”

or

what

it

mea

ns

to b

e a

fam

ily h

as

nev

er b

een s

tatic.

Eco

nom

ic,

soci

al,

and t

echnolo

gic

al

fact

ors

hav

e co

nst

antly

shap

ed t

he

fam

ily d

ynam

ic

thro

ughout

the

world.

Now

more

than

eve

r, f

amili

es

hav

e bec

om

e in

crea

singly

fra

cture

d d

ue,

in p

art,

to a

m

ore

glo

bal

ized

eco

nom

y an

d t

he

tech

nol

ogic

al

adva

nce

s in

lon

g-d

ista

nce

tra

vel [2

].

Copyr

ight

is h

eld b

y th

e au

thor

/ow

ner

(s).

CH

I 2012,

May

5–10,

2012,

Aust

in,

TX,

USA.

ACM

978-1

-4503-1

016-1

/12/0

5.

Tyle

r D

avis

Mis

souri W

este

rn S

tate

Univ

ersi

ty

TD

avis

30@

Mis

souriW

este

rn.e

du

Cam

ie S

tein

ho

ff

Mis

souri W

este

rn S

tate

Univ

ersi

ty

CSte

inhoff1@

Mis

souriW

este

rn.e

du

Mari

carm

en

Tera

n V

ela

Mis

souri W

este

rn S

tate

Univ

ersi

ty

MVel

a@M

isso

uriW

este

rn.e

du

Hum

an F

acto

rs &

Usa

bili

ty T

esting

Mis

souri W

este

rn S

tate

Univ

ersi

ty

4525 D

ow

ns

Drive

St.

Jose

ph,

MO

64507 U

SA

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1261

In a

dditio

n t

o t

hes

e fa

ctors

, a

par

adig

m s

hift

in m

any

wes

tern

culture

s has

tra

nsf

erre

d t

he

colle

ctiv

e fo

cus

from

the

fam

ily t

o t

he

indiv

idual

. In

centive

s, s

uch

as

a bet

ter

educa

tion,

mili

tary

wag

es,

or

hig

h p

ayin

g job in

the

city

is

enou

gh t

o e

nco

ura

ge

the

indiv

idual

to b

reak

aw

ay fro

m t

he

trad

itio

nal

idea

l of an

inta

ct n

ucl

ear

fam

ily [

4].

This

outc

om

e, w

hile

not

neg

ativ

e per

se,

is

oft

en r

esponsi

ble

for

a fe

elin

g o

f em

otional

dis

tance

th

at is

direc

tly

rela

ted t

o th

e phys

ical

dis

tance

of

fam

ily

mem

ber

s [6

].

Our

team

’s g

oal w

as t

o d

esig

n a

dig

ital

spac

e th

at

would

acc

om

modat

e fa

mili

es w

ith d

ispla

ced m

ember

s.

The

des

ign p

roce

ss b

egan

with a

use

r re

sear

ch p

has

e,

whic

h led

to t

he

crea

tion o

f th

ree

per

sonas

. Then

, a

mid

-fid

elity

pro

toty

pe

was

em

plo

yed for

usa

bili

ty

test

ing,

while

tw

o s

epar

ate

surv

eys

wer

e ad

min

iste

red

to g

ather

res

ults.

Fin

ally

, th

ese

resu

lts

wer

e in

terp

rete

d

and s

ugges

tions

wer

e m

ade

for

futu

re ite

rations

of th

e des

ign.

U

ser

Rese

arc

h

Our

insp

irat

ion for

this

des

ign c

ame

from

within

: an

in

tern

atio

nal

tea

m m

ember

was

exp

erie

nci

ng d

ifficu

lty

mai

nta

inin

g a

ric

h a

nd m

eanin

gfu

l re

lationsh

ip w

ith h

er

fam

ily in M

exic

o.

Ther

e w

ere

tools

ava

ilable

to h

er t

hat

del

iver

ed t

he

audio

and v

isual

com

ponen

ts o

f co

mm

unic

atio

n (

such

as

the

tele

phone

or S

kypeT

M),

but

thes

e w

ere

lack

ing in a

few

im

port

ant

area

s. P

rim

arily

, phone

conve

rsat

ions

did

not

pro

vide

the

visu

al c

ues

nec

essa

ry for

a r

ich e

mot

ional

connec

tion

, w

hile

priva

cy

conce

rns

mad

e Sky

peT

M a

n u

ndes

irab

le o

ption [

5].

In

ord

er t

o d

elve

dee

per

into

thes

e is

sues

, ou

r te

am m

ade

a co

nfe

rence

cal

l to

Mex

ico,

whic

h initia

ted o

ur

use

r in

terv

iew

phas

e.

The

dem

ogra

phic

ass

ort

men

t am

ongst

inte

rvie

w

subje

cts

was

inte

ntional

ly b

road

. Par

ents

, gra

ndpar

ents

, st

ep-p

aren

ts,

child

ren,

and a

ny

indiv

idual

that

fel

t an

em

otional

connec

tion t

o a

gro

up

of peo

ple

they

consi

der

ed “

fam

ily”

wer

e in

cluded

in t

he

rese

arch

. The

only

req

uirem

ent

from

the

subje

cts

was

th

at t

hey

be

geo

gra

phic

ally

sep

arat

ed fro

m a

fam

ily

mem

ber

by

a dis

tance

gre

ater

than

30 m

iles.

Aft

er

com

ple

ting t

he

inte

rvie

ws,

thre

e co

mm

on c

om

pla

ints

w

ere

iden

tified

:

The

emotional

connec

tion

fel

t w

eak

in t

he

avai

lable

com

munic

atio

n m

ediu

ms.

Fa

mily

mem

ber

s w

ere

unco

mfo

rtab

le s

har

ing

priva

te info

rmat

ion t

hro

ugh F

aceb

ookT

M o

r oth

er s

oci

al m

edia

pla

tform

s.

The

avai

lable

com

munic

atio

n m

ediu

ms

wer

en’t

fun t

o use

.

Idea

lly,

our

des

ign w

ould

hav

e to

addre

ss a

ll of th

ese

com

pla

ints

in o

rder

to b

e co

nsi

der

ed a

succ

ess.

An inte

rest

ing s

upple

men

tary

fin

din

g d

uring o

ur

inte

rvie

w p

has

e w

as t

he

shee

r div

ersi

ty in

circ

um

stan

ces

that

cre

ated

the

dis

loca

tion

of

fam

ily

mem

ber

s. U

nex

plo

red fac

tors

such

as

hea

lth iss

ues

, lo

ve,

or

som

etim

es just

a h

ealthy

sense

of ad

ventu

re

would

oft

en lea

d t

o s

epar

atio

n.

This

dis

cove

ry indic

ated

th

at t

he

rese

arch

pro

ble

m m

ay b

e m

ore

wid

espre

ad

than

initia

lly t

hought.

Pers

on

as

Bas

ed o

n t

he

beh

avio

r pat

tern

s obse

rved

thro

ugh o

ur

use

r re

sear

ch,

thre

e per

sonas

wer

e built

. Thes

e

Fig

ure

1.

Dat

a ac

quired

fro

m

inte

rvie

ws

during c

onte

xtual

inquiry.

Fig

ure

2.

A c

olla

ge

of in

tere

sts

use

d t

o f

lesh

out

the

Gra

nnie

Sm

ith p

erso

na.

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1262

per

sonas

hel

ped

the

team

arr

ive

at a

conse

nsu

s ar

ound

the

pro

duct

fea

ture

s nec

essa

ry f

or t

he

des

ign [

3].

Am

élie

DuPo

nt

– I

nte

rnat

ional

Stu

den

t

Am

élie

is

very

adve

ntu

rous

studen

t. A

fter

tw

o

sem

este

rs a

t U

niv

ersi

te P

ierr

e et

Mar

ie C

urie,

sh

e dec

ided

to t

ransf

er t

o a

n A

mer

ican

U

niv

ersi

ty.

While

she

love

s th

e new

en

viro

nm

ent,

she

feel

s hom

esic

k ev

ery

now

an

d t

hen

. Am

élie

wis

hes

to p

rese

rve

an

emotion

al c

onnec

tion

with h

er fam

ily w

hile

3000 m

iles

away

fro

m h

ome.

Andy

Fullt

ime

– C

onst

ruct

ion w

ork

er/p

aren

t

Andy

work

s har

d a

nd h

as little

tim

e fo

r him

self.

His

tw

o so

ns

are

curr

ently

stat

ioned

in

Afg

han

ista

n.

He

trie

s to

cal

l th

em w

hen

ever

poss

ible

, but

the

tim

e diffe

rence

mea

ns

he

must

wai

t until 3 a

m b

efor

e he

can c

all his

so

ns.

Als

o,

he

is lee

ry o

f so

cial

net

work

s, a

s he

has

conce

rns

about

priva

cy.

Andy

would

lik

e a

way

to c

om

munic

ate

with h

is s

ons

that

does

not

require

losi

ng s

leep

or

per

sonal

in

form

atio

n.

Gra

nnie

Sm

ith -

Ret

ired

Gra

ndm

oth

er

G

rannie

’s c

onst

ant

bac

k pro

ble

ms

hav

e re

legat

ed h

er t

o a

nurs

ing h

om

e. F

amily

m

ember

s vi

sit

oft

en,

but

she

feel

s lik

e a

burd

en t

o t

hem

. G

rannie

, st

ill c

onsi

der

ed t

he

chef

of

the

fam

ily,

enjo

ys s

har

ing r

ecip

es w

hen

sh

e ca

n.

How

ever

, her

culin

ary

input

has

dra

stic

ally

dim

inis

hed

sin

ce h

er s

tay

at t

he

nurs

ing h

om

e beg

an.

Gra

nnie

would

pre

fer

to

keep

her

sta

tus

as t

he

fam

ily c

hef

, ev

en

though s

he

cannot

atte

nd a

ll fa

mily

eve

nts

.

N

ow

, w

ith t

he

goal

s of

the

targ

et a

udie

nce

in m

ind,

the

initia

l des

ign p

has

e co

uld

beg

in.

Po

ten

tial D

esi

gn

an

d T

ho

ug

hts

To m

eet

the

goal

s of

the

per

sonas

, a

bra

inst

orm

ing

sess

ion w

as c

alle

d.

From

this

ses

sion,

the

conce

pt

of

a “d

igital

hom

e” w

as forg

ed.

Usi

ng a

hou

se a

s a

met

aphor

for

the

des

ign,

room

s w

ere

des

ignat

ed t

o

carr

y out

the

various

funct

ions

of

the

dig

ital

hom

e. T

he

nam

e M

eCas

a w

as g

iven

to t

his

des

ign.

It w

as insp

ired

by

the

adag

e, “

Mi ca

sa e

s su

cas

a,”

with a

n inte

ntion

al

mis

spel

ling o

f M

e to

em

phas

ize

the

inte

ract

ive

nat

ure

of

the

des

ign.

The

room

s an

d t

hei

r fu

nct

ions

are

as

follo

ws:

Fr

ont

Door

The

hom

e sc

reen

for

MeC

asa.

Her

e th

e use

r w

ill e

nte

r th

eir

use

r nam

e an

d p

assw

ord

. This

lo

gin

pro

cess

is

to e

nsu

re t

he

pri

vacy

for

eve

ry

use

r. O

nce

logged

in,

MeC

asa

would

ensu

re

that

no p

erso

nal

info

rmat

ion w

ould

be

shar

ed.

Fig

ure

3. The

house

met

aphor

repre

senting o

ur

des

ign (

with

room

s in

cluded

).

Fig

ure

4. The

Front

Door

(hom

e sc

reen

) fo

r M

eCas

a.

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1263

Livi

ng R

oom

The

mai

n r

oom

in M

eCas

a. A

chat

room

for

all

fam

ily m

ember

s is

the

prim

ary

funct

ion o

f th

is

room

. U

pon e

nte

ring t

he

Livi

ng R

oom

, th

e use

r w

ould

be

aske

d t

o indic

ate

thei

r em

otional

st

ate

by

sele

ctin

g f

rom

a lis

t of

“Per

maC

ons”

(o

r per

man

ent

emotico

ns)

, w

hic

h c

ould

be

alte

red a

t an

y poin

t during t

hei

r st

ay w

ithin

the

Livi

ng R

oom

. The

Perm

aCon

would

be

dis

pla

yed n

ext

to t

he

nam

e of

the

fam

ily

mem

ber

in t

he

chat

, in

ord

er t

o c

onst

antly

shar

e em

otional

dat

a am

ongst

fam

ily

mem

ber

s.

My

Bed

room

A p

erso

nal

spac

e w

ithin

the

dig

ital

hom

e.

Wher

eas

the

hom

e re

pre

sents

a t

hre

shold

bet

wee

n t

he

public

spac

e an

d p

riva

te s

pac

e,

one’

s bed

room

rep

rese

nts

a p

riva

cy t

hre

shold

w

ithin

the

hom

e itse

lf.

Her

e th

e use

r w

ould

be

able

to b

log t

hei

r ow

n t

houghts

in a

journ

al,

as

wel

l as

invi

te fam

ily m

ember

s to

hold

a p

riva

te

chat

. Kitch

en

The

kitc

hen

is

repre

sente

d b

y im

age

of

a re

frig

erat

or.

Her

e th

e use

r co

uld

per

form

thre

e fu

nct

ions.

They

could

post

rem

inder

s (P

ost

-it®

ic

on),

uplo

ad p

hoto

s or

artw

ork

(M

ona

Lisa

ic

on),

and a

ttac

h r

ecip

es t

o th

e re

frig

erat

or

(rec

ipe

book

icon).

All

fam

ily m

ember

s w

ould

hav

e ac

cess

to t

he

info

rmat

ion s

har

ed o

n t

he

refr

iger

ator

.

Gam

e Room

The

gam

e ro

om w

ould

pro

vide

use

rs t

he

option

to d

ow

nlo

ad g

amin

g a

pplic

atio

ns.

Her

e th

ey

would

com

pet

e in

rea

l tim

e ag

ainst

fam

ily

mem

ber

s. A

few

bas

ic g

ames

would

com

e st

andar

d w

ith M

eCas

a, s

uch

as

ches

s an

d

chec

kers

.

Att

ic

The

attic

would

act

as

a st

orag

e cl

oud o

f al

l th

e in

form

atio

n s

har

ed w

ithin

MeC

asa

(exc

ept

for

My

Bed

room

info

rmat

ion).

Spec

ific

info

rmat

ion

could

be

quic

kly

acce

ssed

thro

ugh t

he

use

of a

sear

ch e

ngin

e. A

lso,

info

rmat

ion c

ould

be

arra

nged

by

alphab

etic

al o

rder

, or

by

the

dat

e th

at it

was

shar

ed.

Our

per

sonas

direc

tly

info

rmed

our

des

ign in t

he

follo

win

g w

ays:

Am

élie

’s n

eed for

an e

mot

ional

co

nnec

tion insp

ired

the

Per

maC

on;

Andy’

s dis

trust

of

soci

al n

etw

orks

lea

d t

o t

he

secu

rity

pro

vided

by

the

Fron

t D

oor;

Gra

nnie

’s d

esire

to s

har

e her

rec

ipes

forc

ed

us

to t

hin

k of new

and c

reat

ive

way

s fo

r sh

arin

g

per

sonal

info

rmat

ion,

pro

vided

by

the

Kitch

en a

nd t

he

Gam

e Room

.

With a

concr

ete

des

ign in m

ind,

the

nex

t ta

sk w

as t

o

crea

te a

mid

-fid

elity

pro

toty

pe

to t

est.

Fig

ure

5. An e

xam

ple

of a

Perm

aCon (

left

). P

erm

aCons

are

alw

ays

availa

ble

to v

iew

during

chat

.

Fig

ure

6. The

Livi

ng R

oom

when

vie

wed

on a

mobile

dev

ice.

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1264

Meth

od

s The

mid

-fid

elity

MeC

asa

pro

toty

pe

was

cre

ated

in

Pow

erPoi

nt.

The

pro

toty

pe

use

d h

yper

links

to a

llow

nav

igat

ion b

etw

een r

oom

s w

ithin

MeC

asa.

Als

o,

two

surv

eys

wer

e use

d for

test

ing.

The

firs

t su

rvey

was

use

d t

o g

auge

how

effec

tive

the

Per

maC

on

was

at

shar

ing e

motional

dat

a (w

hen

com

par

ed t

o a

gen

eric

phot

o of a

fam

ily m

ember

or

no p

hoto

at

all)

. This

surv

ey w

as a

dm

inis

tere

d b

efor

e te

stin

g o

f th

e m

id-

fidel

ity

pro

toty

pe.

The

seco

nd s

urv

ey a

dm

inis

tere

d w

as t

he

Sys

tem

U

sabili

ty S

cale

(SU

S)

ques

tionnai

re [

1].

This

surv

ey

rate

d u

sabili

ty c

rite

ria

on a

fiv

e poin

t Li

kert

sca

le.

It

was

adm

inis

tere

d a

t th

e en

d o

f te

stin

g.

Six

par

tici

pan

ts w

ho w

ere

dis

pla

ced fro

m t

hei

r fa

mili

es

(at

leas

t 30 m

iles

away

) w

ere

test

ed o

n t

he

pro

toty

pe.

The

monitor

and t

hei

r re

actions

wer

e re

cord

ed u

sing

Mora

eTM s

oftw

are.

At

the

sam

e tim

e, t

wo t

eam

m

ember

s w

itnes

sed t

he

par

tici

pan

ts’ per

form

ance

and

mad

e note

s during t

he

test

ing.

Aft

er t

esting w

as c

om

ple

te,

the

surv

eys,

note

s, a

nd

obse

rvat

ions

wer

e co

mpile

d.

R

esu

lts

The

resu

lts

from

the

firs

t su

rvey

wer

e use

d t

o a

sses

s th

e su

cces

s of th

e Pe

rmaC

on w

hen

com

par

ed t

o o

ther

ch

at r

oom

ava

tars

. Fi

ve o

ut

of th

e si

x par

tici

pan

ts

surv

eyed

indic

ated

that

the

Perm

aCon w

as a

bet

ter

avat

ar for

sendin

g a

nd r

ecei

ving e

mot

ional

dat

a th

an

eith

er a

gen

eric

photo

or

no

photo

at

all.

Tab

le 1

. This

tab

le indic

ate

s th

e par

tici

pan

ts f

avore

d

Perm

aCons

when

shar

ing e

motional

info

rmat

ion w

ith fam

ily

mem

ber

s.

The

seco

nd o

bje

ctiv

e of M

eCas

a w

as t

o c

reat

e a

spac

e th

at m

imic

ked t

he

priva

cy o

f an

act

ual

hom

e. A

ll par

tici

pan

ts fel

t se

cure

when

usi

ng M

eCas

a kn

ow

ing

that

the

dig

ital

dom

ain w

as o

pen

only

to fam

ily

mem

ber

s. F

urt

her

more

, par

tici

pan

ts h

ad p

osi

tive

co

mm

ents

reg

ardin

g t

he

additio

nal

lev

el o

f priva

cy

affo

rded

by

the

room

: M

y Bed

room

.

Var

ious

com

men

ts incl

uded

:

“I lik

e th

at I

can

tal

k to

who

I w

ant

withou

t an

y ou

tsid

e in

terf

eren

ce.

It’s

com

fort

ing”

“Oh…

ok,

I s

ee n

ow

. The

bed

room

is

like

my

ow

n s

pac

e fo

r w

hat

ever

I w

ant.

And I

ass

um

e th

is I

nvi

te b

utt

on

lets

me

call

peo

ple

up t

o t

alk,

cor

rect

?”

“It’s

a good idea

. Som

etim

es I

just

wan

t to

tal

k to

fa

mily

. I

like

that

I c

an d

o t

hat

with t

his

.”

The

final

obje

ctiv

e w

as t

o m

ake

the

inte

ract

ion w

ith

MeC

asa

fun.

The

Gam

e Room

and t

he

Kitch

en w

ere

spec

ific

ally

des

igned

to a

ddre

ss t

his

obje

ctiv

e. S

urv

ey

dat

a in

dic

ated

that

MeC

asa

was

fun a

nd e

asy

for

Perm

aCon

Photo

No P

hoto

83%

pre

ferr

ed

16%

pre

ferr

ed

16%

pre

ferr

ed

Fig

ure

7.

The

Gam

e Room

when

vie

wed

on a

mobile

dev

ice.

Fig

ure

8.

My

Bed

room

,

show

casi

ng t

he

Journ

al an

d

Invi

te b

utt

on.

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1265

par

tici

pan

ts t

o u

se.

Rel

evan

t usa

bili

ty-s

urv

ey d

ata

is

pre

sente

d in T

able

2.

Tab

le 2

. This

tab

le c

onta

ins

mea

n p

artici

pan

t ra

tings

indic

atin

g h

ow

fun a

nd e

asy

MeC

asa

was

to u

se.

Thes

e m

ean

ratings

are

out

of 5 p

oin

ts p

oss

ible

(5 b

eing t

he

bes

t, 1

bei

ng

the

wors

t).

Reco

mm

en

dati

on

s The

mai

n c

om

pla

int

regar

din

g M

eCas

a co

nce

rned

nav

igat

ion iss

ues

. Spec

ific

ally

, th

e door

ico

ns

(loca

ted

in t

he

upper

lef

t han

d c

orn

er o

f a

scre

en)

did

not

succ

essf

ully

indic

ate

to w

hat

room

they

wer

e lin

ked.

In

futu

re ite

ration

s, w

e re

com

men

d m

odifyi

ng t

he

nav

igat

ion ico

ns

so t

hat

they

vis

ual

ly r

epre

sente

d w

hat

ro

om

they

wou

ld lin

k to

(e.

g.

a jo

urn

al p

age

would

re

pre

sent

My

Bed

room

, a

chec

ker

boar

d w

ould

re

pre

sent

the

Gam

e ro

om

, et

c.).

C

on

clu

sio

ns

MeC

asa

succ

essf

ully

cap

ture

s th

e des

ired

asp

ects

of

a hom

e: e

motion

al c

onnec

tion

with fam

ily m

ember

s, a

fe

elin

g o

f se

curity

, an

d fun.

Futu

re d

esig

ns

would

ad

dre

ss c

ompla

ints

and funct

ional

ity

issu

es.

The

nex

t st

ep f

or M

eCas

a is

the

imple

men

tation

of a

hig

h-f

idel

ity

pro

toty

pe.

Ack

no

wle

dg

em

en

ts

We

would

lik

e to

than

k al

l par

tici

pan

ts invo

lved

with o

ur

des

ign p

roce

ss.

Spec

ific

ally

, w

e th

ank

thos

e w

ho

gav

e th

eir

tim

e during t

he

inte

rvie

w a

nd u

sabili

ty t

esting

phas

es.

Refe

ren

ces

[1]

Bro

oke

, J.

(1996).

SU

S:

A “

quic

k an

d d

irty

” usa

bili

ty s

cale

. U

sabili

ty E

valu

atio

n in I

ndust

ry.

London:

Tay

lor

and F

ranci

s.

[2]

Cliq

uet

, R.,

D.

Avr

amov

(1998),

The

futu

re o

f th

e fa

mily

: A s

oci

obio

logic

al a

ppro

ach.

The

Fam

ily.

Conte

mpor

ary

Per

spec

tive

s an

d C

hal

lenges

. Fe

stsc

hrift

in

Hon

or

of W

ilfried

Dum

on.

Leuve

n:

Leuve

n U

niv

ersi

ty

Pres

s, 1

59-1

80.

[3]

Cooper

, A.,

Rei

man

n,

R.,

& C

ronin

, D

. (2

007).

About

face

3:

The

esse

ntial

s to

inte

ract

ion d

esig

n.

India

nap

olis

, In

: W

iley

Publis

hin

g.

[4]

Cre

ed,

G.W

. (2

000).

“Fa

mily

val

ues

” an

d d

om

estic

econom

ics.

Annual

Rev

enue

of Anth

ropolo

gy.

29,

329-

355.

[5]

Dupas

quire,

B.,

Burs

chka

, S.,

McL

aughlin

, K.,

Sak

ir,

S.

(2010).

Anal

ysis

of in

form

atio

n lea

kage

from

en

cryp

ted S

kype

conve

rsat

ions.

Inte

rnat

ional

Jou

rnal

of

Info

rmat

ion S

ecurity

. 9,

313-3

25.

[6]

Will

iam

s, L

. E.,

& B

argh,

J. A

. (2

007).

Kee

pin

g

one’

s dis

tance

: The

influen

ce o

f sp

atia

l dis

tance

cues

on a

ffec

t an

d e

valu

atio

n. Ps

ycholo

gy

Sci

ence

. 19(3

),

302-3

08.

“I t

hought

the

web

site

was

fun t

o

use

.”

“I t

hought

the

web

site

was

eas

y

to u

se.”

“I w

ould

im

agin

e

that

most

peo

ple

would

lea

rn h

ow

to

use

the

web

site

very

quic

kly.

4.0

4.1

6

3.8

3

Fig

ure

9. The

refr

iger

ator

icon

loca

ted in t

he

Kitch

en.

Stud

ent D

esig

n C

ompe

titio

nC

HI 2

012,

May

5–1

0, 2

012,

Aus

tin, T

exas

, USA

1266