17
Nosipho Mkhize, Myra Taylor,Kai M. Udert, Teddy Gounden, Chris A. Buckley Acceptance, use and maintenance of urine diversion dry toilet (UDDT) at eThekwini Municipality

Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Nosipho Mkhize, Myra Taylor,Kai M. Udert, Teddy Gounden, Chris A. Buckley

Acceptance,  use  and  maintenance  of  urine  diversion  dry  toilet    (UDDT)  at  

eThekwini  Municipality  

Page 2: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Background    � VUNA:  Socio-­‐economic  boundaries    � Objectives:    (1)  Explore  the  use,  acceptance  and  maintenance  of  the  UDDT    (2)  Education  programme  to  enhance  the  level  of  acceptance,  use  and  maintenance  of  the  UDDT.          

Page 3: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Methods    Ø Mixed  methods:  qualitative  and  quantitative    Ø 3  rural  areas  situated  at  East,  North  and  South  of  Durban  in  eThekwini  

Ø Respondents  age:  22  -­‐63  years      Quantitative    

*40  households  per  area  random  selection    *Questionnaire    *Profiling    

Qualitative    

*Homogenous  groups  (maintainer,  non-­‐  maintainer,  non-­‐user)    *  12  focus  group  discussions      *121  participants  

Qualitative    

*  Purposive  sampling  *25  key  informants      -­‐ward  councillors      -­‐ward  committee  -­‐Previous  local  facilitators  

Page 4: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

 Quan2ta2ve  results  

Page 5: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Qualita2ve  results    Ø  Acceptance:  -­‐  acceptance  low    -­‐  aspire  for  flush  toilet    -­‐  role  models      -­‐  youth  more  accepting    -­‐silence  about  UDDT    -­‐mismatch  of  benefits        

Page 6: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Results  cont.  

Ø  Use:    -­‐97%  are  using  the  UDDT  -­‐  children  under  5yrs  discouraged  to  use  UDDT    

“I  tell  my  grandchildren  to  use  the  open  space  by  our  house  to  defecate…I’m  scared  they  might  fall  inside”  (female  focus  group  member)        

Page 7: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Results  cont.  Ø Maintenance:      -­‐  repairing      -­‐emptying        -­‐role  of  children  Ø Design    -­‐not  accustomed  to  needs  and          reality      “it’s  (UDDT)  too  technical,  having  to  make  sure  that  the  urine  goes  to  which  hole,  it  takes  the  comfort  and  peace  that  one  should  get  when  using  a  toilet”  (Ward  councillor)          

Page 8: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Different  traits  of    maintainers  and  non-­‐maintainers    

   Maintainers  

 Non-­‐maintainers    

�  small  family    �  information  more  detailed  �  more  children  �  teamwork    �  recipient-­‐  middle  aged  woman    

 

�  woman  exploitation  and  undermining  

�  drinkers  in  the  family    �  lack  information    �  recipient  migrated  or  deceased  

Page 9: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Development  of  H&H  educa2on  

Service  provider    

Perceptions  and  

experiences  on  the  ground  

Bridge  the  gap  through  health  and  hygiene  education    

Water  and    Sanitation    Agenda    

Equality  Self-­‐worth  

Page 10: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Issues  addressed  by  educa2on  

Page 11: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!
Page 12: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

   

Page 13: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Health  and  hygiene  educa2on  �  2  areas    �  1114  individuals  reached  

50  households    •  414  •  Weekends    •  Saturdays    

8  schools  •  583  •  4  primary  (grd  5  &  7)  •  4  high  school  (grd  8  &  9)    

9  groups    •  117  •  Community  care  givers,  women’s  group  and  youth  groups  

Page 14: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Expecta2ons  and  future  target    Expected  results     Target  group    Ø more  informed    Ø change  of  perception  Ø more  children  to  use  toilet            -­‐minimise  open  defaecation  Ø   clean  the  toilet  regularly    Ø regular  hand  washing  after  toilet  use    

 

Ø children    Ø teachers    Ø youth    Ø elders    Ø  leaders    Ø  influential  individuals  and  groups    

Page 15: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Summary    Ø poor  use  and  maintenance  of  UDDT  defeating  the  purpose  

Ø comprehensive  health  and  hygiene  education  is  vital            -­‐informed  by  community            -­‐  the  EWS  to  provide  regular  updates            -­‐  impart  knowledge  to  local  leaders          -­‐target  everyone            -­‐use  community  health  givers        Ø evaluate    

Page 16: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

Acknowledgements

Funding

Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology

eThekwini Water and Sanitation

University of KwaZulu-Natal School of Nursing and Public Health School of Agriculture Pollution Research Group

Page 17: Acceptance,useandmaintenanceof) urinediversiondrytoilet ...€¦ · Methods++! Mixedmethods:qualitativeandquantitative! 3ruralareassituatedatEast,NorthandSouthofDurbanin eThekwini)!

           !                                                            Ngiyabonga!  Thank  You  For  your  aKen2on!    

www.vuna.ch