1
906 Methods and Devices A RAPID TEST FOR BETA-LACTAMASE PRODUCTION BY HÆMOPHILUS INFLUENZÆ MARY P. E. SLACK D. B. WHELDON D. C. TURK Department of Bacteriology and Regional Public Health Laboratory, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford OX2 6HE Haemophilus influenzae type b is a common cause of meningitis and other acute life-threatening infections of children which must be treated without delay. In the 1950s chloramphenicol was the treatment of choice. Since the introduction of ampicillin in 1961 many clini- cians, especially in the U.S.A., have preferred to use this drug alone, because of fears of chloramphenicol toxicity. In 1974 ampicillin-resistant strains of H. influenzce type b were reported’ and are now widely distributed. There is clearly a need for a test which rapidly establishes the true ampicillin sensitivity of strains of H. influenzae type b isolated from clinical material. Ampicillin resistance in H. influenzx is almost always due to the production of p-lactamase, intrinsic resistance being uncommon.3 3 Several methods for the detection of p-lactamase have been described.4-1O We describe a new rapid acidimetric test for the detection of p-lactamase production by H. in- fluenzae, which uses strips of filter-paper impregnated with penicillin and a pH indicator. These strips may be stored for several months, ready for use when required. The test can be performed as soon as there is visible growth on the primary culture plates. The principle of the method is that any p-lactamase present will hydro- lyse benzylpenicillin to form penicilloic acid, with a fall in pH which is demonstrated by a change in the colour of the indicator. Preparation of Test Strips 600 mg of unbuffered benzylpenicillin is dissolved in 4 ml of 0-1% aqueous solution of bromocresol purple. 0.05 ml 0 1 mol/l sodium hydroxide is added. Whatman’s no. 1 filter- papers (9 cm diameter) are immersed in the solution and then immediately dried in a vacuum desiccator with active desic- cant. After drying, the paper is cut into strips approximately 0.6 cmxl-2 cm. The strips are stored at 4°C with silica gel and will retain their activity for several months. Test One drop of distilled water is placed on a clean microscope slide and covered with a test-paper. The paper should be moist but not oversaturated. A bacteriological loop is used to sweep across the surface of a young culture of the isolate and is then streaked across one end of the strip. In older cultures, touching one colony is enough, but because sometimes only some of the colonies in a strain produce &bgr;-Iactamasell it is better to touch several colonies. If p-lactamase is produced the colour of the streaked portion of the strip changes from purple to yellow in 5-10 minutes. Non-&bgr;-lactamase-producing strains change the colour of the strip, if at all, to a deeper purple. Known positive and negative controls are applied to each strip. The test is easily read. When dry the colours on test-papers remain for 24 hours. Results 44 strains of H. influenzae, all recently isolated from patients, were tested for &bgr;-Iactamase production by this method and also by two methods in current use in our laboratory-the chromogenic cephalosporin substrate method’O and a modification of the Kjellander and Myr- bäch plate method.8 17 of the 44 strains were included because they had given positive results on earlier routine tests with one of these methods. All 17 gave positive results with all three methods, whereas the remaining 27 strains gave negative results by all three methods. Minimum inhibitory concentrations (M.l.c.) of ampi- cillin (with carefully standardised inocula and multi- point inoculation on chocolate-agar) were also estimated for 33 of the 44 strains. 21 strains gave MJ.c.s less than 0.6 mg/l, and all these had given negative results in all three tests for p-lactamase production. Of the remaining 13, all of which gave an nt.i.c. of 2.5 mg/tor more, 12 had given positive results in all three &bgr;-lacta- mase tests. The thirteenth (with an M.l.c. of 20 mgll) had given negative results in all three tests. This strain was therefore clearly an intrinsically resistant strain. Thus there was total agreement between our method and the others in the recognition of ampicillin resistance due to p-lactamase production. Discussion The test described here is simple and rapid, and relia- bly identifies j3-lactamase-producing strains of H. infl- uenzce. It may be performed as soon as there is any visible growth on the culture plates (5-6 hours), and requires only a small number of organisms. This feature could be of value in cases of partially treated meningitis, where there is often only a very scanty growth of the causative organism. The test gives the clinician a more reliable indication of the response he can expect to ampi- cillin in infections caused by H. influenzae type b than that provided by antibiotic disc sensitivity testing. It is also more rapid. The method may be used for routine surveillance for &bgr;-Iactamase-producing isolates of H. influence. Conventional antibiotic disc sensitivity test- ing of H. influenzce with ampicillin and chloramphenicol will ensure the detection of the rare ampicillin-resistant, non-p-lactamase producing strains and also those resis- tant to chloramphenicol. Requests for reprints should be addressed to M.P.E.S. REFERENCES 1. Gunn, B. A., Woodall, J. B., Jones, J. F., Thornsberry, C. Lancet, 1974, ii, 845. 2. Tomeh, M. O., Starr, S. E., McGowan, J. E., Terry, P. M., Nahmias, A. J., J. Am. med. Ass. 1974, 229, 295. 3. Thornsberry, C., Baker, C. N., Kirven, L. A., Swenson, J. M. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 1976, 9, 70. 4. Catlin, B. W. ibid. 1975, 7, 265. 5. Jorgensen, J. H., Lee, J. C., Alexander, G. A. ibid. 1977, 11, 1087. 6. Rosen, I. G., Jacobson, J., Rudderman, R. Appl. Microbiol. 1972, 23, 649. 7. Escamilla, J. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 1976, 9, 196. 8. Kjellander, J., Myrbäch, K. E. Acta path. microbiol. scand. 1964, 61, 494 9. McGhie, D., Clarke, P. D., Johnson, T., Hutchison, J. G. P. J. clin. Path. 1977, 30, 585. 10. O’Callaghan, C. H., Morris, A., Kirby, S., Shingler, A. H. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 1972, 1, 283. 11. Gray, B. M., Hubbell, C. A., Dillon, H. C. ibid. 1977, 11, 1021. ADDENDUM Two penicillin-resistant strains of Neisseria gonorrhaeae, kindly supplied by Dr A. Percival, were also tested for p-lactamase production using the method de- scribed above. Both strains gave well-defined and posi- tive results within 5 minutes. This suggests that the method may also be used for the routine screening for penicillinase production by gonococci isolated from clinical material.

A RAPID TEST FOR BETA-LACTAMASE PRODUCTION BY HÆMOPHILUS INFLUENZÆ

  • Upload
    dc

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

906

Methods and Devices

A RAPID TEST FOR BETA-LACTAMASEPRODUCTION BY HÆMOPHILUS

INFLUENZÆMARY P. E. SLACK D. B. WHELDON

D. C. TURK

Department of Bacteriology and Regional Public HealthLaboratory, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford OX2 6HE

Haemophilus influenzae type b is a common cause ofmeningitis and other acute life-threatening infections ofchildren which must be treated without delay. In the1950s chloramphenicol was the treatment of choice.Since the introduction of ampicillin in 1961 many clini-cians, especially in the U.S.A., have preferred to use thisdrug alone, because of fears of chloramphenicol toxicity.In 1974 ampicillin-resistant strains of H. influenzce typeb were reported’ and are now widely distributed. Thereis clearly a need for a test which rapidly establishes thetrue ampicillin sensitivity of strains of H. influenzae typeb isolated from clinical material. Ampicillin resistance inH. influenzx is almost always due to the production ofp-lactamase, intrinsic resistance being uncommon.3 3

Several methods for the detection of p-lactamase havebeen described.4-1O We describe a new rapid acidimetrictest for the detection of p-lactamase production by H. in-fluenzae, which uses strips of filter-paper impregnatedwith penicillin and a pH indicator. These strips may bestored for several months, ready for use when required.The test can be performed as soon as there is visiblegrowth on the primary culture plates. The principle ofthe method is that any p-lactamase present will hydro-lyse benzylpenicillin to form penicilloic acid, with a fallin pH which is demonstrated by a change in the colourof the indicator.

Preparation of Test Strips600 mg of unbuffered benzylpenicillin is dissolved in 4 ml

of 0-1% aqueous solution of bromocresol purple. 0.05 ml 0 1mol/l sodium hydroxide is added. Whatman’s no. 1 filter-

papers (9 cm diameter) are immersed in the solution and thenimmediately dried in a vacuum desiccator with active desic-cant. After drying, the paper is cut into strips approximately0.6 cmxl-2 cm. The strips are stored at 4°C with silica geland will retain their activity for several months.

Test

One drop of distilled water is placed on a clean microscopeslide and covered with a test-paper. The paper should be moistbut not oversaturated. A bacteriological loop is used to sweepacross the surface of a young culture of the isolate and is thenstreaked across one end of the strip. In older cultures, touchingone colony is enough, but because sometimes only some of thecolonies in a strain produce &bgr;-Iactamasell it is better to touchseveral colonies. If p-lactamase is produced the colour of thestreaked portion of the strip changes from purple to yellow in5-10 minutes. Non-&bgr;-lactamase-producing strains change thecolour of the strip, if at all, to a deeper purple. Known positiveand negative controls are applied to each strip. The test is easilyread. When dry the colours on test-papers remain for 24 hours.Results

44 strains of H. influenzae, all recently isolated frompatients, were tested for &bgr;-Iactamase production by thismethod and also by two methods in current use in our

laboratory-the chromogenic cephalosporin substratemethod’O and a modification of the Kjellander and Myr-bäch plate method.8 17 of the 44 strains were includedbecause they had given positive results on earlier routinetests with one of these methods. All 17 gave positiveresults with all three methods, whereas the remaining 27strains gave negative results by all three methods.Minimum inhibitory concentrations (M.l.c.) of ampi-

cillin (with carefully standardised inocula and multi-point inoculation on chocolate-agar) were also estimatedfor 33 of the 44 strains. 21 strains gave MJ.c.s lessthan 0.6 mg/l, and all these had given negative resultsin all three tests for p-lactamase production. Of theremaining 13, all of which gave an nt.i.c. of 2.5 mg/tormore, 12 had given positive results in all three &bgr;-lacta-mase tests. The thirteenth (with an M.l.c. of 20 mgll)had given negative results in all three tests. This strainwas therefore clearly an intrinsically resistant strain.

Thus there was total agreement between our methodand the others in the recognition of ampicillin resistancedue to p-lactamase production.Discussion

The test described here is simple and rapid, and relia-bly identifies j3-lactamase-producing strains of H. infl-uenzce. It may be performed as soon as there is anyvisible growth on the culture plates (5-6 hours), andrequires only a small number of organisms. This featurecould be of value in cases of partially treated meningitis,where there is often only a very scanty growth of thecausative organism. The test gives the clinician a morereliable indication of the response he can expect to ampi-cillin in infections caused by H. influenzae type b thanthat provided by antibiotic disc sensitivity testing. It isalso more rapid. The method may be used for routinesurveillance for &bgr;-Iactamase-producing isolates of H.

influence. Conventional antibiotic disc sensitivity test-ing of H. influenzce with ampicillin and chloramphenicolwill ensure the detection of the rare ampicillin-resistant,non-p-lactamase producing strains and also those resis-tant to chloramphenicol.Requests for reprints should be addressed to M.P.E.S.

REFERENCES

1. Gunn, B. A., Woodall, J. B., Jones, J. F., Thornsberry, C. Lancet, 1974, ii,845.

2. Tomeh, M. O., Starr, S. E., McGowan, J. E., Terry, P. M., Nahmias, A. J.,J. Am. med. Ass. 1974, 229, 295.

3. Thornsberry, C., Baker, C. N., Kirven, L. A., Swenson, J. M. Antimicrob.Agents Chemother. 1976, 9, 70.

4. Catlin, B. W. ibid. 1975, 7, 265.5. Jorgensen, J. H., Lee, J. C., Alexander, G. A. ibid. 1977, 11, 1087.6. Rosen, I. G., Jacobson, J., Rudderman, R. Appl. Microbiol. 1972, 23, 649.7. Escamilla, J. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 1976, 9, 196.8. Kjellander, J., Myrbäch, K. E. Acta path. microbiol. scand. 1964, 61, 4949. McGhie, D., Clarke, P. D., Johnson, T., Hutchison, J. G. P. J. clin. Path.

1977, 30, 585.10. O’Callaghan, C. H., Morris, A., Kirby, S., Shingler, A. H. Antimicrob.

Agents Chemother. 1972, 1, 283.11. Gray, B. M., Hubbell, C. A., Dillon, H. C. ibid. 1977, 11, 1021.

ADDENDUM

Two penicillin-resistant strains of Neisseria

gonorrhaeae, kindly supplied by Dr A. Percival, were alsotested for p-lactamase production using the method de-scribed above. Both strains gave well-defined and posi-tive results within 5 minutes. This suggests that themethod may also be used for the routine screening forpenicillinase production by gonococci isolated fromclinical material.