Upload
gaurav-jain
View
225
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
1/52
Logistics and inrastructureExploring opportunities
Business BankingYour Partner In Growth
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
2/52
Contents
1. Executive summary 3
2. Macro-economic overview 6
2.1. I - I 6
2.2. T w I 10
2.3. I w w 10
2.4. T 12
3. Logistics industry overview 13
3.1. E 13
3.2. O 14
3.3. T I 16
3.4. S SME I 23
4. SMEs in logistics: Succeeding in the market place 24
4.1. C SME 24
4.2. A & 31
4.3. S-W-O-T A 31
5. Transport inrastructure 33
5.1. T 33
5.2. Rw 34
5.3. R 36
5.4. P 38
5.5. A 41
5.6. I 44
5.7. T PPP 45
6. Conclusions 46
Abbreviations
Bibliography 49
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
3/52
3
1. Executive summary
Macro-economic outlook
C
w
w
w
, w,
I
. Hw I A
. T GDP w 6.7
2008/09,
2009. A ,
, w,
w .
H w - w
w. T
w ,
z SEZ, FDI -
. Hw
(
, , w),
w. G
w
.., G , , ,
. T
. I ,
w . T
I ( 13-14 GDP )
w U.S (9.5 ) & E
(7.15 ). T
,
.
Logistics industry overview
T
.
S, ,
,
.
A ,
w - z
, - .
C
. I
D, w
w w . T w
,
. S
w /
-.
Largelogisticsspend
Relativelyhighvalueproducts
Manageacrossmultiplemodes
Managecomplex,timesensitivesupplychains Diversesupplychainfootprintsincludingtheirown
,
Maturityinoutsourcingcycle(currentlymanaging
3PLs)
Decentralizedmanagementoflogistics
Complementarytocurrentbaseof4PLbusiness
Highcubeandhighweightproducts
Competitiveness o SMEs in logistics
T SME
w . A z
,
SME . T, ,
, I
SME ,
w
. S S &
M E
, w
SME w
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
4/52
4
D S & M
,
I
,
particularlyfromtheperspectiveofaLogisticsService
Provider(LSP).Thesurveycoveredplayersacrossa
w
w, , , , w, -
&
.
T
thebiggestgrowthopportunitybytheIndianLSPs.
B, , z
w
. I w, w
, . T
w
w
w
. G ,
competitivenessofIndianLSPs.
O
, , ,
- .
Further,theLSPsaretypicallyresortingtoinitiatives
,
z, , w
,
. W
-
w & ,
G
S T (GST) G
. O
, j
I . T ,
, .., ww
. T
,
w . O ,
, w .
Transportation inrastructure outlook
T 11 A P
4.6
GDP, w 7 & 8 . T C
R I M
S P I,
w
FY 2008-09. T I
w 2008-09 833
850 . T Rw M
- w
. T Rw w
w - .
P
w. F, w
,
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
5/52
5
T j 530.35
2008 2009, w w 7.9
w
2.1 519.31
. T
j
. I ,
, , /
. O , w G
,
-j
. T w G
w 6
20 PPP R. 3300
, w 3 ,
w . W w
,
w . S
, ,
, w,
, , ,
. I
, ,
MRO , ,
w, w
.
I
j
. H , w
,
. A
R 1,00,000
12,000 F.Y 2009-10
- , w
. I j ,
w ; F I (FI)
w . Nw w -
, , - ,
/ w /
j.
T w
w. T
, w,
j, / -
j.
P P P (PPP)
. G
, PPP
w ,
.
Conclusions
Gz, ,
w
w
. F
,
w . A
w
. I
. T w
w
SME
. T
w
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
6/52
6
US $ 251.7 2007-08,
w 14.3 . I
w
I ,
w
.
Indias EXIM trade trends in billion US $
S : D G F T
2. Macro-economic overview
2.1 Indian economy - Impact o global economic
decline
M
w . I
w w G
D w w,
. A ,
. T
j , w -
w ww. C
w
w
w
, w,
,
I
.
T w I
w :
TradeDecit:Astheglobaleconomyshrank,so
w I . T
w w w
. F,
2008 ,
. I
2008-09 w US $
168.7 US $ 163.1 2007-08,
w 3.4
. O ,
2008-09 w US $ 287.8
A are up in petroleum prices in 2008 led toa sharp rise in import bill, thereby adding tothe amount o net imports
$
300
250
180
120
60
0
2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
E I
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
7/52
7
Fiscaldecit:Fiscaldecitisaneconomic
, w G
(
w). I
w .
I C
9.5 GDP 2008-09
w. I 4 j
(.., 2008-09 -- 2007-08). T
w 2007-08
2008-09
G w
ww w
. T , F M,
, A
A .
Combined scal decit (as a % o GDP)
S : M F, GOI
A j
w, w
, w
w . F,
w
2009-10 -
5.5
w . A ,
w
G z
.
IndustrialProduction:Closeontheheelsofglobal
, I 2.6
2008-09, w 8.5 2007-08.
I 0.75 M 2009.
M 1.4
R.1.25 J-M 2009,
j 0.9 2008. I , A w
1.4
. T
. T
A 0.7
. T
. Hw,
w
. I , - w
j .
Indias combined fscal defcit o the Centreand the states at close to 10 per cent o GDPin 2008-09 is among the highest in the world
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
8/52
8
Ination:ConsumerPriceIndex(CPI)-based
--
. T,
j RBI
, ,
CPI- .
C w
9.6 F.
A , w 8
. A 6
2009 4.7 2010, w
A & w .
T ww I
,
w
w 2003/04 2007/08.
Nw , I
A
.
Percentage Y-o-Y GDP change
S : IMF, WEO
I w M
2009,
w . T
I w
& . A
w
w 5.8
-- M 2009.
T GDP w 6.7 2008/09,
2009.
10
8
6
4
2
0
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Consumer price infation (average %)
S : E I U E
W A ( J) I 2010 2009
-10 10-5 50
V
T
M
I
C
S
K
H K
J
I
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
9/52
9
Real GDP growth (% change)
S : E I U E
Industry Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
A 3.0 2.7 -0.8 2.7
M & 4.6 3.7 4.9 1.6
M 5.5 5.1 0.9 1.4
E 2.7 3.8 3.5 3.6
C 8.4 9.6 4.2 6.8
T, , . 13.0 12.1 5.9 6.3
F, 6.9 6.4 8.3 9.5
C 8.2 9.0 22.5 12.5
GDP 7.8 7.7 5.8 5.8
S : M F, GI
The real GDP grew by 6.7 per cent in 2008/09,
and expects a revival in the latter part o 2009
10
6
2
-2
-6
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
W A ( J) I
Quarterly estimates o GDP or 2008-09 (at 1999-2000 prices) % chg
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
10/52
10
2.2 The way ahead or the Indian economy
I
, ,
w
ww. A
, ,
w, w
. F Oz EC- D (OECD), A
D B (ADB) E I
U
. T OECD j
2009 w, 5.9 . T
ADB w w w ,
5 .
N z
bouncebackuntilmid-2010.Lookingatabroader
, I C
M I E (CMIE) 5.8 w 2009-10
w 9 w 2011, w
w .
W B j 8 w
I 2010, C w
7.7 .
T w . O
, w
6 , w
w , .
T w
w . W
w , w
w w
w , -
. I w
w .
T
- PSU,
, w, , ,
.,
. F
, , W B
,
.
2.3 Interlinking sustainable economic growth
with logistics
T, - w
w. T
w ,
z SEZ,
FDI -
. Hw ,
w. A
w, w
. T
w EXIM , w
w .
G
w ..,
G , , ,
. T
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
11/52
11
A w
w ,
,
w, w, . I
w
, j
z 37 w
I , .
A E F Y P
w. Hw, w - w
ww,
. B , w
w, w
w w w .
Transportation inrastructure Decit, eleventh plan targets, & permissible FDI
Sector Defcit Eleventh plan targets FDI Envisaged
investment size
R / w 65,590
w:
Compriseonly2%ofnetwork
Carry40%oftrafc
Ofwhich12%is4-laned;50%
2-; 38%
6-lane6,500kminGQ
4-lane6,736kmNS-EW
4-lane20,000km
2-lane20,000km
1,000kmexpressway
100 % FDI US$ 78.5
P I
Berths
Rail/roadconnectivity
Nw :
485millionMTinmajor
345millionMTinminor
100 % FDI US$ 22
A I
Runways
Aircrafthandlingcapacity
Parkingspaceandterminal
Modernize4metroand35
-
3greeneldinNorthEastern
R (NER) 7othergreeneldairports
100%FDIforexistingairports
(FIPB FDI
74%)
100%FDIunderautomatic
49%FDIispermissiblein
,
US$ 7.74
Rw Oldtechnology
Saturatedroutes
Slowspeeds(freight:avg
22; :
50)
Lowpayloadtotareratio(2.5)
8132kmnewrail
7148kmgaugeconversion
Modernize22stations
Dedicatedfreightcorridors
100% FDI w
US$ 65.45
S: P C, IBEF
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
12/52
2.4 The logistics cost actor
Logisticscostisanimportantfactorthataffectsthe
w . Hw,
I w
U.S. & E,
I . I
w j ..,
60 . I I, 13-14 GDP
US (9.5 ) E (7.15 ).
A , I .
D j
, w
w
. T j
z ,
w, providing3PLservices.Themajorelementsoflogistics
I I ,
w, -
. T
,
.
W I
, w
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
13/52
13
3. Logistics industry overview
Logisticshasalwaysbeenacentralandessentialfeature
. D ,
z
. T
.
Hw, ,
,
z w :
Appreciationofhighlogisticscostandopportunities
j
Increasingcompetitionforbothusersandprovidersof
, w
Newtypesofoperations,whichcanforcechanges
j--,
, ,
.
Needforimprovedtechnologyforidentifying,
R , w w
,
w
. A,
.
3.1 Evolution o the global logistics industry
Gz, ,
w
. T
w w
. A
, w
- z ,- .
Evolution o the logistics model
S : D R
C -
w
. T
, ,
IT
. T
specializedfunctiontofourthpartyLogistics(4PL)and
fthPartyLogistics(5PL)companies.
FirstandSecondPartyLogisticshandlealllogistics
, w, w
w
w . W
one-stopsolutions,many2PLhaveevolvedinto3PL
w
. T
;
to2PLs.Whilethe2PLputsinhardcashtangibleasset,
the3PLputsinintellectualproperty.
F
, , w
z z , . T
gurebelowillustratesthegamutofservicesthata4PL
w .
5PL(electronicco-ordinationof
-- w)
Reducedassetinte
nsity
Increasedinformation
intensity
3PL(Supplychainexpertise
w )
2PL(pre-dominatly
)
4PL(SCMlimitedassetprovision)
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
14/52
14
A ,
4PLmustcomprehendbroadanddeepexpertiseand
capabilities.Sincetheadventofthe4PLservice,the
- ..
z - -.
Akeyfunctionofthe5PListoaggregatethedemands
ofthe3PLintoabulkyvolumefornegotiatingmore
w
w
.
3.2 Opportunity indicators or global logistics
sector
I
D, w
w
w
. T w
,
. T w
. T
w /
w -
Largelogisticsspend
Relativelyhighvalueproducts
Manageacrossmultiplemodes
Managecomplex,timesensitivesupplychains
Diversesupplychainfootprintsincludingtheirown
,
Maturityinoutsourcingcycle(currentlymanaging
3PLs)
Decentralizedmanagementoflogistics
Complementarytocurrentbaseof4PLbusiness
Highcubeandhighweightproducts
The 4PL will serve as the single point o contact orcustomers, managing a comprehensive set o supply chainand logistics services that are executed by other providers
4PL Provider managed services
4 P L
Order to deliver supply chain services
Transition & support services
Provider managed services
3PLprovidedservices D C
C T
F
Fw T T
B W O
S : D R
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
15/52
15
Largelogisticsspend Industrieswhoselogisticsspendissignicantrelativetothevalueofitsproductsnaturallyplaceahigh
R Industrieswithhighvalueproductsplaceahighdegreeofimportanceonlogisticswhichcanimpact
M Logisticsfunctionsoperatingmultiplemodesoftransportfacesignicantissuesindealingwiththe
M ,
Themorecomplexasupplychain,andthemoreimportantitistomanagetimeacrossit,themorelikely
D ,
w ,
Diverseandwidespanningsupplychainsarecomplexanddifculttomanage.Companieswithsuch
w
M
(currentlymanaging3PLs)
Historyhasshownthatoutsourcingisanevolutionaryprocessandthatindustriesthathavealonger
w
Dz
Thelogisticsfunctionisdifculttomanageacrossgeographicboundaries.Companieswithdecentralized
C
of3PL/4PLbusiness
Industrieswhoselogisticsand/orproductattributesarecomplimentarytothe3PLs/4PLsbaseofbusiness
( w , .) (..,
z )
H w
Industrieswiththeseproductattributesoffergreateropportunitytoleverageandbetterutilizecommon
The description o the logistics requirements or each o the attributes, is mentioned below:
B , w w
.
A OEM & Thisindustryoffersobvioussynergies,largemarketpotentialandthemostimmediateopportunitiesfor
3PL/4PL
However,autosuppliersarehighlyfragmentedwithveryfewhavinglargelogisticsspend
H Thisindustryissimilartotheautoindustryintermsofshipmentattributes
Howevertherearechallengestopenetratingthisindustry,duetothesmallersizeandregionalfocusof
M Logisticsowbalanceopportunitiesexistwithintheindustry;majorityshipmentsowtoautomotiveand
However,theseindustriesarefairlyverticallyintegratedandtraditionallymanagelogisticsoperations
-
T Thisindustryisattractiveintermsofmajorityshipmentattributesinclud ingcomplexsupplychainswith
--
R Thisindustryofferstremendousopportunitiesfromsynergiesinshipmentattributes;largeplayersare
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
16/52
16
3.3 The Indian logistics sector
T I
w /
w
,
/ w, -,
, , w
. I w GDP1 R31,297 13
GDP z R.
4,068 . T w
-- w 2002
USD 120 ( R.5,400 )
2015.
W w I
z
w, z
z . Tw
w- w
I 80% . T
w
& w
, w .
I
, I
w
third-partylogisticsserviceproviders.TraditionallyLSPs
(LogisticsServiceProviders)concentratedmainlyon
j
. Hw, w
, w
,
, .
Transporters with eets smaller than fve trucks accountor over two-thirds o the total trucks owned and operated
in India and make up 80% o revenues
3.3.1 The growth drivers
T
,
w
. F , w z
I
w.W ,
, z ,
w I,
w:
Key growth drivers or the logistics sector
Riseof3PLservices-Thelogisticscostisad irect
. I ,
-
shareof3PLserviceprovidersvis--vistheshareof
.
S
I of3PLservices
R
Gz
I
w
I
Gw D
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
17/52
17
I J,
U S, C E U
,
,
w
. T
hasindeedbeenderivedfromtheshareofthe3PL
. H
w (I, C, Bz).
National logistics cost vis--vis the share o 3PL in the
logistics market
T
w
3PLsinnationallogisticsmarket.Thegreaterthe
shareof3PLsthelesseristhenationallogisticscost
thushighlightingtheimportanceof3PLsinlogistics.
M I z
w
.
C
requirementofspecializedThirdPartyLogistics
S P w
. A
estimates,itisexpectedthat3PLsolutionsinIndia
w w CAGR 20%
2009-15.
Investmentsininfrastructure-Awell-knitand
w
. I
w
w w . T
I
w, . T w
w w ,
. W j
,
j N M
D P
,
I .
G w ,
w 4.6% GDP C w 10% GDP. T P
-
8% 2011-12. P
w w
j . I
2009 w w w
I . T
j
,
w, w, w, , w
. I
PPP j
w w
w
PPP w .
T
, w w w
.
Country Logistics cost as a
% o GDP
Share o 3PL
I 13.0 14.0% Lessthan10%
C 18.0% Lessthan10%
USA 9.9% 34%
E 7.1% 54%
S : V
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
18/52
18
Recognitionoflogisticsasanintegralpartof
-O ,
I .
T w
w
- w
.
F ,
w .
A ,
, ,
.
A w
/
.
Qualiedworkforce-Foranindustrytoprosper,the
w. W
w
w w
w . Hw w
w
, w
w .
F w ,
w
z :
Toleadthedesign,creation,congurationand
Tocreatetheframeworkandthedialoguethat
w
Todrivethesystemsandmonitorandreportthe
Toreviewhowproblemscanbesolvedand
Relationship o logistics with other corporate unctions
With production With marketing With fnance
P
P
P w
Rw
C
P
D
I
O
S-
S
E
D
S
Source:HandbookofLogisticsandDistributionManagementbyAlanRushton,PhilCroucherandPeter
B
There is an inverse relationship betweenlogistics cost o a nation and the share o 3PLsin national logistics market. The greater theshare o 3PLs the lesser is the nationallogistics cost
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
19/52
19
E I
, ,
,
w .
I ,
HR w
. G
I , I
w w
w .
Streamliningoftheindirecttaxstructure-InIndia,
w
. M
w
C & FwA (CFA) , w ,
- C S T (CST). S
w 25 50 w I,
w
( 5) C (
10). T V A T (VAT)
G
S T (GST)
w,
,
.
Globalizingofmanufacturingsystems-
Gz
w
. T
, w
.
3.3.3 Opportunities in the logistics space
T I
w ,
, , ,
FMCG ,
z .
S w
.
Cold chain storage and related logistics
C
. E z I -
R. 8,000-10,000 (US$ 1.80 - US$ 2.27
) w 20 25
. I w w
R. 40,0002 (US$ 9.09 B) 2015.
A ,
4,762 I w 196 , w
81
.
I w
w, .
P - w,
. T A-
- ,
, ,
.
There has been a growingimportance o the role and
contribution that the logistics /distribution manager makes tocorporate strategic planning
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
20/52
20
Volume wise perishable products share in India
N: O ,
S: V
A , 104
/
. O 100
- 4
. O
100 96
. O
, 86
w
w w
10
w
. A
.
S
-
ContainerCorporationofIndia(CONCOR)ismoving
w
w --
.
Withaviewtoincreaseshareofprocessedfood 20% 6%,
30 2012
- . T
w w,
. T
SEZ
. C
,
w R 50
.
Thegovernmentplanstoestablish50coldchainw,
, w w
- .
I , -
, w.
TheAgriculturalandProcessedFoodProductsExport
D A (APEDA)
C P C B, Nw
D, C, T, H,
M . T
CPC 2.16
. T
CPC. I ,
APEDA MU CPC
C, A, A, K, B,
Lucknow,andGoa.
M
F
F
O
57%
1%
39%
3%
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
21/52
21
Air cargo
T
w .
W
w ,
. T G
w
. I
. A
N M C A. T
.
A I 1% w
. T j (M, D,
K, C B)
88% I. Gw
/ - ,
. I j
. T
( F.Y 2008-09) w
w
. T 2008-09
ww.
Cargo volume handled at international and domestic
airports in India
S: A A I
T j I
, , ,
, ,
, w, . D
C ,
, & jw, , IT &
ITES . T C A M
w
. T w
j . U w
, C P C (CPC)
w , w w
.
C 000 T
2000
1600
1200
800
400
0
2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
I
D
T
The Civil Aviation Ministrys
proposal to rame a policy or thedevelopment o airportsexclusively or cargo operations isencouraging and oncommissioning o these cargoairports in due course o time will
provide a much needed trigger tothe air cargo segment
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
22/52
22
S w
:
Providingvendorsandindustryinthenon-metrocities
w w
Investmentinaircargoinfrastructurewould
w
w, , D
C .
Theefciencyandthereachoftheexpresscargo
w
IndiancompaniescanexploittheirinherentIT
, ,
-
Domesticairlinescanleverageonthedevelopment
H--
Material handling equipment
T I M H E (MHE)
R 5,000 . T
I
. M
, , ,
, , .
T, w
, w
w ; w
w . T w ,
, ,
w.
D
w . O
w w
. A w
, w
. S
w ,
, ,
, . I ,
j w
,
w .
Reverse logistics
M
. T
, ,
,
/ - .
R w ,
, .
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
23/52
23
W
I ,
w
w w .
T w
. A w
j w w-- .
W ,
-,
w
w . Hw
w
,
w w
, .
T
w
. A,
w,
w
. F ,
w
. T
w
, w
C C
w. W
;
I. T
w .
T w I, w
.
3.4 Signicance o SMEs in the Indian logistics
industry
S -z (SME) ,
.
A W A S M
E (WASME), 5 SME
I 80%
. I
, 20
, 35%
40%
.
T SME
w . I
z
SME I . T
S M
E (SME) w j
. I
w
4 .
T
.
W , G I
,
w
. S S & M
E
, w
SME w
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
24/52
24
4. SMEs in logistics: Succeedingin the market place
T w
w . T,
j
. T
w w
w, .
T j SME ,
, w . R,
, w w ,
w,
.
Logisticsserviceprovidershavinginvestmentin
( )
R.10 (US$ 0.2 ) R.2 (US$
4.1 ) S
R. 2 R.5 (US$10.3
) M 3 . T,
w ,
. T
, , w
inthelevelofcompliance.Landtransportationin
w
w
,
.
U
zzw ;
. H, SME
.
SME
. M SME
w-,
w w
.
A I
, w
I. M
I w : w , ,
w . T w j
,
-- .
I ,
- w
, w SME
ww.
4.1 Competitiveness o SMEs in logistics
D S & M
I
,
particularlyfromtheperspectiveofaLogisticsService
Provider(LSP).Therespondentcompaniesbelongedto
w
w, , ,
, w,
- .
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
25/52
25
A , D
, w w
-- . I
, ,
,
w
. T , w.
4.1.1 Internal actors aecting competitiveness
Services
I , w
w
z w
w T
. T w
, w
w .
F,
w
z
/ . W
w
, z
,
w
. Oz
j .
I I, w
w ,
w
.
Foreign alliances
Anothertrendwhichisfastpickingup,isthatofLSPs
w
. H ,
SME
. I ,
, w
.
Key value propositions o alliances
S: D
Cost
T ww
j . T
w w
w w 10 30
70 .
R
I
Sz
P
C
C
T
F
M
V
K
Users o logistics services are no longer lured by
buzzwords or big names; the ocus is clearly on costs anddelivered value. Hence, the emergence o SMEs as strongregional or sectoral players is imminent
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
26/52
26
The ear o price sensitive Indian market, notbeing able to bear the additional cost otechnology acts as an impediment
W j
,
. : B
I U.K. w US $1000
TEU , w US $300 TEU. U
w ,
.
T ,
. T
. Oz
w w
w SME
. T
.
Training
A
z,
w
. T
, w
w w ,
w .
A
/ w w, w j
, w
. A
,
, w
j . T
,
.
Technology
G,
z . Hw,
implementedbytherespondentLSPsismoreorless
,
. A ,
--
. T z
G P S
(GPS), W M S (WMS), R
(RFID) SME I
w.
T I ,
. A, w
& w, w w
z.
T w w
theperceptionofLogisticsSMEsthatwerecoveredby
. T w
w, w
UPS, SME I. T
w
, w w
D . F , w
thebiggestgrowthopportunitybyLogisticsSMEstoday.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
27/52
27
Perception o growth opportunity by logistics SMEs
P w
. Nw ,
thecustomerschoiceofanLSPisdrivenbyasetof
, w
.
Key determinants o choice or selecting a LSP
S: D
R SME
R w w
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
0%
Oz I w
M
F &
IT
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Choice o an LSP
T
C
&
Sz
Nw
C
S
E
R
S: UPS A B M 2009; D S A
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
28/52
28
I ,
/
w
& w . B
, z
,
quantumofordersexecutedbytheprospectiveLSPin
. T , , IT , --
, , .
O
:
Transactionalrelations:Thisismostlydrivenbythe
& w
theservicesoftheLSP.Althoughonanaveragemost
-- ,
LSPsaretryingtopitchinforlongerrelationshipsas
w w .
Servicelevelagreements:ServiceLevelAgreements
(SLAs)setoutperformancestandardstobe
, ,
, . S
efciencyandaccountabilityinthebusiness.SLAsare
w
. I
w, ,
likelytodemandstringentSLAs.Itisunderstoodthat
adherencetoSLAsinIndiaisaround80to85per
w 95
. T
aboutSLAsastheyaremoreworriedaboutthecost,
ascomparedto3PLswhomonitortheSLAsclosely.
Benchmarking:Eachplayerseemedtobeguided
w . I
w
w SOP
,
w, ,
. E , w, widelyundertakenbytheIndianLSPsyet.
Innovation:Thisisonesuchfactorthatcanhelpa
.
T
,
. I
, , ,
.
U, I
SME
4.1.2 External actors aecting competitiveness
T
. I
, w, , ,
I C D (ICD) & C F
S (CFS), w
& .
The survey responses indicate that pure play transporters
generally are not very conscious about SLAs as they aremore worried about the cost, as compared to 3PLs whomonitor the SLAs closely
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
29/52
29
C
Nature o
bottleneckArea Cause Eect
I
P
I j H j
U -j
O I
Lackofwarehousing Longwaitingtime
A
Fw (D, M, K,
C, B, H)
C
N &
Lackofequipmentforodd-sizedpackages,
,
I /
H (
)
R
B D w &
I / B ,
I I
Rw
T /
/
C w & w
Limitednetworkandterminalsofprivateplayers
( )
T &
I / T
C
C/ CFS/ ICD
U / z Lessintegratedservices,inefciency&resultant
I I
R
C
O . H
E EDI
I &
C C
I w
T NCR
C
B
A ,
M, P, .
I &
w
I
(.
)
E B ,
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
30/52
30
T ,
respondentLSPsareresortingtothefollowing
:
Negotiating&re-negotiatingcontracts
N w w
, w
. N w (
) w
w -.
Loadoptimization
T j
w &
z.
EfcientRoutescheduling
T w
w w
, &
w
w. T
w
advantagebytheLSPs.
Nature o
bottleneckArea Cause Eect
A ,
. B ,
. : T
timeforcontainerfromLudhianaJNPT(1500kms)
2-3 . Hw,
, w .
TheLSPshavefoundawaytomitigatethisproblem
w , w
ww. T
, w,
-j . F,
w
w .
F , w
& ,
:
Variablevesselchartercosts
Fluctuatingoil/fuelprices
Fluctuatingexchangerates
Non-availabilityofreturnloads
Highhaulagerates
R
T
A
/
w
D w
H P / A,
j w
M (T + 12
)
R I
R /
I
C M ICD / CFS / SEZ,
, M S
T R, & S M P
/ S
C , &
Law
A Rw A,
M S A, I P A, MMTG
A
Sj -
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
31/52
31
Areas or improvement / challenges
T j
w ,
I .
T w ,
SME. R
, I,
w w ,
.
4.3 S-W-O-T Analysis
S
. T, ,
&
w (), & ().
The ability to provide the most cost eectivedistribution network is being used as acompetitive advantage by the LSPs
Levelofimprovementdesired
R w w
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
R
I
IT A
A
Qualityofmanpower
T
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
IncreasedadoptionofIT
T IT
w
w . T w
w .
A w MIS
,, ., S
IT
w
ERP .
Savingonlogisticsrelatedcommunication
I
,
w. M w . T
,
.
Cuttingdownonmanpower
T ERP
, w
. M w
j
.
Othermeasures
T w ,
w .
4.2 Assessment o challenges: Internal & external
A
, w
w SME
, w:
S: UPS A B M 2009; D S A
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
32/52
32
A
, w,
,
w . T
S-W-O-T w I
LogisticsSMEs,whichiselaboratedinthegurebelow:
Strengths
Mostenterprises,byvirtueofbeingownerdriven,
Relativeeaseatllingupvacanciesinoperations
Withoperations&agencynetworkprimarily
, j
Lowattrition,partlyaidedbythecurrentdownturn,
&
HR
Weakness
Thefragmentednature,aninherentweaknessof
,
, ,
AcommonproblemfacedbySMEsisthatoflimited
,
( ) z
SME
Lackofuseofstateofarttechnologies,ifsuitably
I , w
Inadequatecontrols&costconsciousnessamongstdriveLSPs,particularlyroadtransporters,oftenlead
w :
Opportunities
AlikelyboominConstructionandPharmaceutical
/ H w
opportunityforLSPsintermsofincreasedmultimodal
w & ,
w .
ProgressivereformssuchasintroductionofsingleG S T (GST) w z
w -
LSPstotrimtheirlogisticscosts
Governmentsplantoawardprojectsworth
R. 3,300 (US$ 67.9 )
/
schemeofIIFCLprovidethemuchnecessarypushto
w
theLSPs
Threats
Competitionfromlargeforeignplayerscanbe
,
&
Thedealtodealtransactionsandpricesensitive
natureofIndianmarketscompelstheLSPstocharge
w , w ,
Theimpactofglobalmarketconditionsonlogistics
w
,
w
S-W-O-T Analysis or Indian logistics SMEs
S: D
Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats
Ownerdriven
Adequate
Regional
Lowattrition
Highlyfragmented
Lackofaffordable
Lackofuseofstate
Lowsafety
Promising
( &
)
Progressive
(GST)
Infrastructure
Competition
Pricingpressure
Inuenceof
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
33/52
33
5. Transport inrastructure
T 11 A P
4.6%
GDP, w 7 & 8%. W 8%
11 10% w I
,
w w
; w
, FDI I.T C R I
M S P I,
w
FY 2008-09. A
.
5.1. Trac perormance
R T w
2008 2009 833.31 MT w 2.0 w
, w
4.9 20072008.T 2008-09 833
850 . F
w,
w , w . T
882
PT j 530.35
2008 2009, w
w 7.9 w
. A 80
w ,
w ,
z
Trac handled at the major ports
S: M S
I
600
500
400
300
200
100
02004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
(P)
Railways reight loading in million tonne
M Rw
I
1000
800
600
400
200
0
2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09(RE)
2009-10(BE)
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
34/52
34
A: T j (M, D,
K, C B)
80-85 I.
T I A 5,3,382
2008 2009, w w 3.4
. T w ,
w, w w 7.5 2007-2008.
F, 4,29,527 w
w 5.7 . T w
w 19.7 2007-2008.
Air cargo trac handled at Indian airports.
S : A A I
T w
,
.
5.2 Railways
I Rw (IR) I
,
w
. T z w A
w
63,332 . F
65% . T Rw M
I 000
1200
900
600
300
0
2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09
I D
(
& ) R
5,479 C w R 8,722 , 31%
w R 12,683 () 2008-09.
T w z
w
, z
( ),
w R 2,642 R 6,356
2008-09. A, RwM
- . T
w , z
, .
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
35/52
35
5.2.1 Development needs
T w w
. T
j w
. T w
(DFC) ( w D
F C R B) ,
w I 2,739 . O
, DFC w w
. I
100 ,
. T j
2016-17.
Proposed dedicated reight corridor
Source:DedicatedFreightCorridorCorporationofIndiaLimited
5.2.2 Challenges
T Rw
. T Rw
R.6,600
R. 7,000
F.Y 09-10. A 60%
2009-10.
T w ww w . I w , Rw
R. 28,000 w .
T w
92.5%. S
Rw z ,
w ,
.
w ,
, ,
w
.
5.2.3 Opportunities
T J 2006
w
. A 16
. I
, w
Rw w w
w
- . P
w.
Ludhiana
D
Kj
A
V
S N
Hw
JNPT
Implementation details o the Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation o India Limited
Source:DedicatedFreightCorridorCorporationofIndiaLimited
Western corridor Stretch Implementation period
P I Rw V (920 ) 2009-2016
P II V JNPT (430 ) 2010-2017
P III Rw D (140 ) 2010-2017
Eastern corridor Stretch Implementation period
P IA S M 2009-2016
P IB M Kj (710 ) 2010-2016
P II KhurjaLudhiana
(D)
2011-2017
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
36/52
36
T w
w .
T
--
. T w w
,
.
I Rw C T C
(IRCTC)
, z j
.
IRCTC
j w P
P . 20
w. S
:
Multi-functionalcomplexeshavingshoppingfacilities,
, 50
w ,
Privateownershipofspecialpurposerollingstock
w
MegalogistichubsbeingplannedalongsideEastern
W D F C
5.3. Roads
A w
w
. R
- ,
w , w . I
w w,
3.34 U S.
I 61
85 . A w
w 66,000
( 2% ), w 40% .
5.3.1. Development needs
Road sector breakup
S : M R T Hw
T w,
N Hw
D P (NHDP) .
T N Hw A I (NHAI)
NHDP T NHDP w
50,000
R.3,000
w w
I.
80%
4%
14%
2%
N w
S w
D
R
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
37/52
37
T
j .
H , w
, .A
R 1,00,000 12,000
F.Y 2009-10 -
, w .
I -
. R j
R 2,00,000 w,
M R T Hw
w
j
. E
, ,
w , ,
. T
w 20 .
5.3.2 Challenges
T
. T
Hw, w j
,
. I
. T NH w w,
G
N Hw.
Requirement o unds or maintenance o Highways as per the norms and unds provided
Phase Length(km) Description Target completion date
I 7,521 Comprises5,846kmofGQ,981kmofNSEWcorridor,380kmof
315 w
December2009(GQby
D 2008)
II 6,805 C 6,319 NSEW 496
w
D 2009
III 12,109 F- 12,109 w w ,
P IIIA IIIB, BOT
M 2012
IV 20,000 Tw- w 20,000
w BOT
D 2015
V 6,500 S- 6,500 w DBFO D 2012
VI 1,000 C 1,000 w DBFO D 2015
VII - C , , , . BOT D 2015
Year Requirement
as per norms
Amount
provided
Shortall % Shortall
2002-2003 2200.00 800.00 1400.00 63.64
2003-2004 2200.00 731.74 1468.26 66.74
2004-2005 2480.00 745.56 1734.44 69.94
2005-2006 2100.00 868.10 1231.90 58.66
2006-2007 2012.00 814.38* 1197.62 59.52
A ,
w
, w ,
,
,
w
NH w.
H
N Hw.
S ,
w,
, , w
, w ,
, . T w . O
, C V
I 240-280, 680-700
.
S: R w R ( 2007-12) 11
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
38/52
38
D C (DFC)
D-M I C (DMIC)
5.3.3 Opportunities
The Delhi-Mumbai Industrial Corridor
I w
w I
. O I
j , D-M
I C (DMIC) j
1,500 w N. D M. I
. J
j,
T-O
. DMIC w
,
. T $ 90 j
.
T w w 150
1,483 w
. I w I
D (22 ), H (148 ), U P
(22 ), Rj (578 ), Gj (565 )
M (148 ). T w
, 4,000 MW w
w I w 10 w
D, F, M, J,
A, V, S, N, P G
M. T
(MIR), DMIC.
5.4 Ports
P w
- . I
12 j (K, M,
Jw N, M, Nw M, C,T, C, E, V (Vz),
P K H 187
-j . O -j ,
48 ; .
5.4.1 Development needs
I 11 j , 1
&187 -j . O -j
, 48 ;
. A 7 12 j I
100 ,
70-80 z.
Road projects in the country require around Rs 2,00,000crore over the next three years or which, the Ministry o
Road Transport and Highways are considering innovativefnancing instruments
Stretch covered by DFC and DMIC
Source:DedicatedFreightCorridorCorporationofIndiaLimited
Rj
Gj
M P
I
M
J
A
S
U
P
H D
I
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
39/52
39
Capacity utilization at the major ports ( 2007-08)
S: I P A
F, w
j
. W w 14.8 456.2
M MT j 2005-06,
2006-07 w 10.6
. D 2007-08, w w
5.4 j
4.4 2008-09.
M % C z
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
K H P Vz E C T C NMPT MGPT MPT JNPT K
13.74 43.58 42.43 64.59 57.15 11.56 21.48 15.81 36.01 35.12 57.03 55.83 64.92
14.56 46.70 56.00 61.15 53.35 13.00 20.75 28.37 43.50 33.05 44.70 54.34 62.60
94 93 76 106 107 89 104 56 83 106 128 103 104
T C Uz (%)
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
40/52
40
5.4.2 Challenges
Lackofproperfacilities,deeperdrafts,goodconnectivity
/
. A , w
- . T j I 1.77
4.82 . Dw EXIM
I w 1-3
adayatSingapore.Largervessels,havingthepotential
, I
. T
12 23 w, I
K, M,
E, G & K,
8 12 T
w w
w I C
T T V, C P.
P w
. M
j.
T j P
Commission,LawMinistry,andMinistryofFinance.
T
- , C
. T ,
N M D P (NMDP)
w w j
. S , 41 253 j 5 111 j
. O I
,
-j . A, j
, w
j.
G w, w
. F, w
.
A , w j
. W j w ,
j w
.
5.4.3 Opportunities
O , w G
, -j
. T -j
w 26 28
2004-05. W -j
2008-09 228.3 M MT, w 220 M MT.
T w G w 6
20
PPP R. 3300 , w
3 , w .
P w w
-
w
,
. F
I
I
w
.
Container TEUs handled by oreign operators at various
Indian ports (2008)
Foreign
operator
Million
TEUs
Ports
M 1.48 JNPT, P
D W 2.85 JNPT, C, K,
V, M
PSA S 0.45 T, C
S: B I M 31, 2009
Aggregate capacity & capacity additions at major ports (2005-2009)
Year Capacity in
million tonnes
Additional
capacity in
million tonnes
% Increase
A 31-03-2005 397.50 - -
A 31-03-2006 456.20 58.70 14.8
A 31-03-2007 504.75 48.55 10.6
A 31-03-2008 532.07 27.32 5.4
A 31-03-2009 555.67 23.60* 4.4
S: M S
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
41/52
41
PSA ABG K C T,
w K P. D &
G M O
C T
T - SEZ
I
M P SEZ. I
-,
.
5.5 Aviation
C A w
. A
,
I,
j . I $100
$325
100 j
610 w j. H z
, I
, 2004.
C w
, .
Private Equity investments in non-major ports
Company PE Investor Amount (Rs. crore)
Gj P P IDFC PE 192
SICAL IDFC PE 116
M P GIC, 3 450
C C
T
G I
P
25%
D P IL&FS 20%
K P 3 994
G P W P 150 (30% )
S : B I M 31, 2009
5.5.1 Development needs
T w w
. A , I
w w
. T
w
, . Hw,
w , w ,
z
, w w B H,
D M.
T 454 / w
,
, w w
w:
Ownership pattern o the airports/ airstrips (operational /
non-operational) in the country (2008)
21%
14%
35%
30%
AAI
P w
S
D
S: 11 F Y P C w
C A
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
42/52
42
T G w
w
(z D M ,
G j H
B, z 35 ).
T D
R. 7,531 ; w M R. 11,553 .
G j
G, N M, P, G N K.
T j
,
j . AAI
. T C A
M 500
2020. T w
, G
, w
.
5.5.2 Challenges
D w w
,
z . T :
Highwaitingtimeandcongestioninairportscausing
w
Airlinesincurringlosses
Taxationissues
Aviationsecurity
Shortageofskilledtechnicalmanpower
Highairportandsecuritycharges
Inadequatenightparkingfacilities
Lessnumberofgatesandcounters
Inadequatesecuritymachinesandshortageofsecurity
Requirementofgoodbaggagesystem
Lackofmaintenancefacilitiesatairports
I , w w
,
w .
5.5.3 Opportunities
Maintenance and repairs overhaul
MRO . T ,
,
, j
. A , j MRO w
I
E S. W
- MRO
, MRO
I . T I MRO
w 15 . T A
P MRO
US$ 12.9 2011. Mj MRO I
. T, 60
MRO .
The Civil Aviation Ministry hasset a target o getting around 500
airports operational in thecountry by 2020
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
43/52
43
Ownership pattern o the airports/ airstrips (operational /
(2008)
S : www.w.
R, j w I
A, B
SIA E
MRO. A MRO C
A P. Gj
MRO
Gj, MRO .
Airport and ground support equipment
A
w
z US$ 359 I 2008
US $ 400 . W
- z ,
w. N , z
w w
w
. I
-
,
w
.
T w
D S C Nw
(DSCN), A M H S(AMHS), F I D S (FID),
A T Nw (ATN), V
C C S (VCCS)
. I 60%
. T AAI
US$ 60
. T
w
. G ,
I,
w , w z
w I.
Indiaas an air cargo hub
I
SAARC ASEAN
- w . T C A
N I
N. T
I w
w . T G
. C
G
w w 150
j
I .
LineMaintenance
C
M
A (H)
E O
O
17%
20%
40%
7%
12%
4%
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
44/52
44
5.6 Inrastructure nance
I j , w
; F I (FI)
w
. M j
: 70: 30. T w
:
MultilateralagencieslikeWorldBank,International
F C (IFC), A D B
(ADB).
DevelopmentFinancialInstitutionslikeIndustrial
F C I (IFCI), I
D B I (IDBI), S I
D B I (SIDBI), I
D F C (IDFC), Pw
F C (PFC) .
IndiaInfrastructureFinanceCoLtd(IIFCL),a100per
w SPV
J, 2006.
ForeignCommercialBanks
DomesticBanks
D
j
, w
. Hw w
, w
j. Pj
. T
,
w j. A
; w
. O w ,
,
j
, j.
Nw w - ,
, - , / w
/
j. T j
, j w
. T w
w. S
w, , ,
,
w . T
, w,
j, / -
j.
Civil aviation ministry proposalto set up dedicated cargo airportsand Governments plan to allowcargo airports within 150 kmsradius o existing airportsthrough automatic routes aremajor steps taken to the cause odeveloping India as a cargo hub
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
45/52
45
5.7 The PPP approach
S I w
w
. I I w
US$492
11 P P,
P C. S
,
(PPP) .
PPP
. G
,
PPP
w ,
.
I I, , P
P P (PPP)
w
w,
& . PPP
BOT, BOOT , w
M C A (MCA)
w. T
MCA PPP
. I j
-
,
40% w
, .
T j
PPP :
Astrongerpolicyandregulatoryframeworkbothat
Appropriatemarketinstrumentsandcapacitytoraise
Credibleandbankableinfrastructureprojects
StrengtheningofgovernmentcapacitytomanagePPP
j.
PPP I
w-w
.
Inrastructure development in India wouldrequire a massive investment o US$492billion during the 11th Plan Period, accordingto an estimate by the Planning Commission
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
46/52
46
6. Conclusions
T w
,
. Gz,
,
w
w
.
I w
interdependentfactorswillshapetheGlobalLogistics
I 5-10 :
Globalizationandconsolidation-Mergersand
. Gz
, w , , .
Increasedoutsourcing-Companiesareutilizing
. G
.
Securityandriskmanagement-SupplyChainSecurity
R M w
w, ,
, SARS, .
Technologicaladvancements-Rapidadvancementsin
( RFID) w
.
Increasedcustomerexpectations-Customerswillbe
w
.
F
, w . A
w
. USA
GDP 17% 1980 9.5 %
w
. I
. I w j .
T
w
SME
.
G SEZ,
, , z
, PPP .,
w
. M, w
, , ,
, , .
w ww w
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
47/52
47
India has got a huge opportunityo reducing its national logisticscost by studying and beneftingrom other success stories
D /
w
z, , ,
, w , w w
, ,
.
SME, , w
j w
w
, , ,
z, , ,
, ,
-
.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
48/52
48
Abbreviations
2 S
3 T
4 F
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A
A A w
B B,
C C & w
C C
C C
C C
C C
C C
C C
D D, ,
D D D D w
E E
Erp Enterprise resource planning
Exim Export import
Fdi Foreign direct investment
Fids Flight information display system
Fy Financial year
Gdp Gross domestic product
Gps Global positioning system
Gq Golden quadrilateral
Gst Goods and service tax
Hr Human resource
Icd Inland container depot
Idbi Industrial development bank of india
IDFC I D F
C
IFCI I F C I
IIFCL IndiaInfrastructureFinanceCompanyLimited
IRCTC I Rw C T
C
ITES I T E S
JNPT Jw N P T
LSP LogisticsServiceProvider
MHE M H EMIR M I R
MRO M R O
MT M T
MW M W
NH N Hw
NHAI N Hw A I
NHDP N Hw D P
NMDP N M D P
NSEW N S E W
OECD Oz E C-
PFC Pw F C
PPP P P PRBI R B I
RFID R F I
SAARC S A A R
C
SCM S C M
SEZ S E Z
SIDBI S I D B I
SME S M E
SOP S O P
SWOT S-W-O-T
TEU Tw E U
VAT V A T
VCCS V C C S
WMS W M S
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
49/52
49
Bibliography
Websites
www...
www.w.
www.-.
www...
www..
www...www..
www..
www..
www..
www...
www..
www..
www...
www.w..
www..
www...
www..www...
www.w.
www...
www..
Others
C R I
2008-09, M S A P
I
CygnusResearchTransportationandLogistics
E S 2008-09
GlobalLogistics&DistributionPlanning:Strategiesfor
M D W
HandbookofLogisticsandDistributionManagement
A R, P C P B UPS A
B M 2009
11 F Y P W C R A S / R T / A
I I
B I P P S
T G C R 2008-09, W
E F
D ATS R w APAC
End Notes
1 GDP :1999-00
2 F SCS A C (S A
I A R
W (IARM))
3 USD / INR = 48.63 16 J 2009
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
50/52
50
Contacts
Mr. Hemant Bhattbhatt
S D
DeloitteToucheTohmatsuIndiaPvt.Ltd.
31, N B S,
A
B-390 007
T.: +91 (265) 2333 776
M: +91 98240 14075F: +91 (265) 2339 729
E: @.
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
51/52
8/7/2019 A Logistics and Infrastructure 6 Aug
52/52
D
ThismaterialpreparedbyDeloitteToucheTohmatsuIndiaPrivateLimited(DTTIPL)isintendedtoprovidegeneralinformationonaparticular
j j j(). A,
, , , , , . T
w . B
, . N D T T,
, w w
.
Theinformationcontainedhereinisprovidedasis,andDTTIPLmakesnoexpressorimpliedrepresentationsorwarrantiesregardingthese
materialsortheinformationcontainedtherein.Withoutlimitingtheforegoing,DTTIPLdoesnotwarrantthatthismaterialorinformation
containedhereinwillbeerror-freeorwillmeetanyparticularcriteriaofperformanceorquality.DTTIPLexpresslydisclaimsallimplied
w, , w , w , , , -, ,