1
Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Aerosol Al (ng m -3 ) 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 Agadir Laayoune Dakhla A case study of aerosol trace element deposition to Moroccan coastal waters Rachel Shelley*, Géraldine Sarthou, Georges Tymen*, Rémi Losno, Luis Tito de Morais, Ali Benhra, and Fa>ma Zohra Bouthir *[email protected]; [email protected] Ra$onale Aerosol deposi>on is an important source of trace elements (TEs) to the surface ocean. Proximity to the Sahara Desert/Sahel means that the North Atlan>c receives some of the highest inputs of mineral dust globally (100-220 Tg yr -1 ; [1]; [2]). This input of TEs contributes to the greater efficiency of the Canary Current Upwelling System rela>ve to its Pacific counterpart [3]; both of which support socio-economically important fisheries. However, mineral dust is just one component, human ac>vi>es (e.g. fossil fuel burning, agricultural prac>ces) also contribute to the atmospheric load. In the study region upwelling water also fuels high primary produc>on via the supply of macro-nutrient-rich (N, P and Si) deep water. This deep water may also be enriched in TEs, such as those with water column distribu>ons that mirror the macronutrients, e.g. Cd & P. A tangible concern for the fisheries off West Africa is the poten>al for toxic effects at all levels of the marine food web, due to inputs of Cd (and other poten>ally toxic TEs). The aim of this project was to inves>gate the TE composi>on and rela>ve levels of enrichment of aerosols delivered to the Atlan>c coast of Morocco. Methods Conclusions § No strong seasonal paaern in aerosol Al concentra>on/dust deposi>on, but tendency towards higher frequency of dust events in winter § Mineral dust propor>onately contributes least to the bulk aerosol in Agadir, most in Dakhla § Dust events are characterised by aerosols that originate from sources in Sahara/Sahel § In terms of elemental ra>os, Cd/Al looks like other loca>ons in the region, but it was significantly enriched in samples from all loca>ons & had liale to no mineral dust source during this study § Mineral dust dilutes anthropogenic TE aerosols during dust events Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Conseil Général du Finistère, & the EPURE programme. Air mass back trajectories were simulated using the NOAA HYSPLIT model (hap://ready.arl.noaa.gov) References [1] Prospero et al., 1996; [2] Kaufman et al., 2005; [3] Carr et al., 2003; [4] Rudnick and Gao, 2003; [5] Gelado-Cabellero et al., 2012; [6] Fomba et al., 2013; [7] Torres-Padron et al., 2002; [8] Guieu et al., 2010 Three sampling sites 100-800 m from the coast, upwind of: Agadir Laayoune Dakhla Aerosol samples were collected using a low-volume aerosol sampler manufactured in-house: two downward-facing, open face, polycarbonate filter holders (NILU) coupled to two pumps (NOVAIR NTV 0625) & two volumetric counters (Gallus 2000) operated in series, interfaced with a laptop wind speed (> 0.9 m s -1 ) & sector-controlled in order to minimise the sampling of local industrial emissions & sample aerosols delivered from specific sectors (see table) Sectors AGADIR LAAYOUNE DAKHLA MAR 230-350° 230-10° 270-10° TER1 10-110° 20-120° 30-150° TER2 110-170° 120-220° The red line points north (0°) for reference (30.46 °N, 9.67 °W) (27.10 °N, 13.41 °W) (23.78 °N, 15.90 °W) Examples of aerosol samples: ler& middle = Dakhla, right = Agadir Sampling from March 2015-March 2016 Agadir = 44 samples Laayoune = 66 samples Dakhla = 56 samples Aerosol concentra>ons following: Sequen>al digests: (1) 5:1 HNO 3 : HF, (2) HNO 3 in capped, Teflon ® vials at 130 °C Solu>ons re-dissolved in 0.48 M HNO 3 and analysed by ICP-MS (Thermo, Element 2) Posi>ve Matrix Factorisa>on using EPA PMF v.5 for source appor>onment (1) Aerosol Al concentraRons, March 2015-2016. 90% of data falls below the dashed line (2000 ng Al m -3 ). ConcentraRons of ~ 100-2000 ng Al m -3 could be considered as an effecRve background concentraRon v No strong seasonal paaern in aerosol Al concentra>on, but tendency towards higher frequency of dust events from Dec- Feb v 8% Al abundance [4] used to es>mate total dust mass for the year of study v 3400-67000 ng m -3 (Agadir) v 350-26000 ng m -3 (Laayoune) v 205-74000 ng m -3 (Dahkla) v Maximum Al concentra>ons in this study are an order of magnitude lower than observed on islands downwind of the Saharan plume, e.g. Gran Canaria = 26200 ng m -3 [5] & Sal, Cape Verde = 26487 ng m -3 [6] v Despite large interannual variability in dust supply [7], this result was unan>cipated. Possibili>es that could account for the difference: v A ‘low dust’ year v Dust loadings could be higher offshore as the dust is transported in the Saharan Air Layer (SAL) at al>tudes of 1500-6000 m in boreal summer. However, the SAL is at lower al>tudes in boreal winter, so this hypothesis seems unlikely v We used low volume samplers (~ 1 m 3 air filtered h -1 ), [5] & [6] used high volume samplers (~ 1 m 3 min -1 ). Low volume samplers require longer sampling dura>ons in order to collect sufficient material on the filters. This would manifest as a reduc>on in the concentra>on of Al per air volume filtered per >me unit, due to the longer run >mes v We were sampling from specific sectors Results & Discussion (2) PMF output: factor fingerprint of aerosol sources Ø Used for aerosol source appor>onment Ø Mineral dust Ø = red, other factors do not necessarily represent the same source, but an aaempt has been made to colour-code them based on similar groupings of elements Ø Smallest contribu>on from mineral dust in Agadir, greatest in Dakhla Ø Some TEs have liale to no mineral dust source: Ø Agadir: V, Ni, Zn, Mo, Pb Ø Laayoune : P, Mo, Cd, Pb Ø Dakhla : P, Ni, Mo, Cd, Pb Ø P is an interes>ng case. We tend to think of P as being derived from mineral dust. However, contribu>on of mineral dust to aerosol P was low. P could be a special case in this region due to the presence of open cast P mines (Morocco is second largest exporter of P in the world) (3) RelaRonship between dust events & elemental raRos o Al is a proxy for mineral dust o Dust events (peaks in Al concentra>on) have liale effect on the mass ra>o of lithogenic elements to Al (e.g. Ti/Al), sugges>ng mineral dust is main source of these elements o Dust events reduce the ra>o of anthropogenic elements to Al (e.g. Cd), sugges>ng these elements have lower rela>ve abundances in mineral dust than industrial emissions o On low dust days (low Al) there were peaks in ra>o of anthropogenic elements to Al (4) Enrichment Factors q Normalised to Al q Only enrichment > 10 considered significant (marked by horizontal line) q Lithogenic elements not significantly enriched (top row) q Generally highest enrichment in Agadir samples q P most enriched in Laayoune samples q Cd enriched at all loca>ons but… q Cd/Al (mass/mass) at all sta>ons (Agadir = 2.1x10 -5 - 2.7x10 -4 ; Laayoune = 8.4x10 -6 - 2.9x10 -4 ; Dakhla = 3.0x10 -6 - 2.0x10 -4 ) fall close to the range observed at nearby loca>ons (e.g., Cap Spartel = 4.6x10 -5 - 2.3x10 -4 [8] & Gran Canaria = 4.6x10 -5 – 1.84x10 -4 [5] q Same trend seen for other anthropogenic TEs, e.g. Pb/Al Pumps Weather vane Aerosol sampler Filter holder Filter holder View publication stats View publication stats

A case study of aerosol trace element deposition to

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    7

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A case study of aerosol trace element deposition to

Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr

Aero

sol A

l (ng

m-3

)

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000Agadir LaayouneDakhla

A case study of aerosol trace element deposition to Moroccan coastal waters

RachelShelley*,GéraldineSarthou,GeorgesTymen*,RémiLosno,LuisTitodeMorais,AliBenhra,andFa>maZohraBouthir

*[email protected];[email protected]

Ra$onaleAerosoldeposi>onisanimportantsourceoftraceelements(TEs)tothesurfaceocean.ProximitytotheSaharaDesert/SahelmeansthattheNorthAtlan>creceivessomeofthehighestinputsofmineraldustglobally(100-220Tgyr-1;[1];[2]).ThisinputofTEscontributestothegreaterefficiencyoftheCanaryCurrentUpwellingSystemrela>vetoitsPacificcounterpart[3];bothofwhichsupportsocio-economicallyimportantfisheries.However,mineraldustisjustonecomponent,humanac>vi>es(e.g.fossilfuelburning,agriculturalprac>ces)alsocontributetotheatmosphericload.

Inthestudyregionupwellingwateralsofuelshighprimaryproduc>onviathesupplyofmacro-nutrient-rich(N,PandSi)deepwater.ThisdeepwatermayalsobeenrichedinTEs,suchasthosewithwatercolumndistribu>onsthatmirrorthemacronutrients,e.g.Cd&P.AtangibleconcernforthefisheriesoffWestAfricaisthepoten>alfortoxiceffectsatalllevelsofthemarinefoodweb,duetoinputsofCd(andotherpoten>allytoxicTEs).Theaimofthisprojectwastoinves>gatetheTEcomposi>onandrela>velevelsofenrichmentofaerosolsdeliveredtotheAtlan>ccoastofMorocco.

Methods

Conclusions§  NostrongseasonalpaaerninaerosolAlconcentra>on/dustdeposi>on,buttendencytowardshigherfrequencyofdusteventsinwinter§  Mineraldustpropor>onatelycontributesleasttothebulkaerosolinAgadir,mostinDakhla§  DusteventsarecharacterisedbyaerosolsthatoriginatefromsourcesinSahara/Sahel§  Intermsofelementalra>os,Cd/Allookslikeotherloca>onsintheregion,butitwassignificantlyenrichedinsamplesfromallloca>ons&hadliale

tonomineraldustsourceduringthisstudy§  MineraldustdilutesanthropogenicTEaerosolsduringdustevents

AcknowledgementsThisworkwassupportedbytheConseilGénéralduFinistère,&theEPUREprogramme.AirmassbacktrajectoriesweresimulatedusingtheNOAAHYSPLITmodel(hap://ready.arl.noaa.gov)

References[1]Prosperoetal.,1996;[2]Kaufmanetal.,2005;[3]Carretal.,2003;[4]RudnickandGao,2003;[5]Gelado-Cabelleroetal.,2012;[6]Fombaetal.,2013;[7]Torres-Padronetal.,2002;[8]Guieuetal.,2010

Threesamplingsites100-800mfromthecoast,upwindof:

•  Agadir•  Laayoune•  Dakhla Aerosolsampleswerecollectedusingalow-volume

aerosolsamplermanufacturedin-house:•  twodownward-facing,openface,polycarbonate

filterholders(NILU)coupledtotwopumps(NOVAIRNTV0625)&twovolumetriccounters(Gallus2000)operatedinseries,interfacedwithalaptop

•  windspeed(>0.9ms-1)&sector-controlledinordertominimisethesamplingoflocalindustrialemissions&sampleaerosolsdeliveredfromspecificsectors(seetable)

Sectors AGADIR LAAYOUNE DAKHLAMAR 230-350° 230-10° 270-10°TER1 10-110° 20-120° 30-150°TER2 110-170° 120-220°

Theredlinepointsnorth(0°)forreference

(30.46°N,9.67°W)

(27.10°N,13.41°W)

(23.78°N,15.90°W)

Examplesofaerosolsamples:ler&middle=Dakhla,right=AgadirSamplingfromMarch2015-March2016•  Agadir=44samples•  Laayoune=66samples•  Dakhla=56samples

Aerosolconcentra>onsfollowing:•  Sequen>aldigests:(1)5:1HNO3:HF,

(2)HNO3incapped,Teflon®vialsat130°C

•  Solu>onsre-dissolvedin0.48MHNO3andanalysedbyICP-MS(Thermo,Element2)

•  Posi>veMatrixFactorisa>onusingEPAPMFv.5forsourceappor>onment

(1)AerosolAlconcentraRons,March2015-2016.90%ofdatafallsbelowthedashedline(2000ngAlm-3).ConcentraRonsof~100-2000ngAlm-3couldbeconsideredasaneffecRvebackgroundconcentraRon

v  NostrongseasonalpaaerninaerosolAlconcentra>on,buttendencytowardshigherfrequencyofdusteventsfromDec-Feb

v  8%Alabundance[4]usedtoes>matetotaldustmassfortheyearofstudyv  3400-67000ngm-3(Agadir)v  350-26000ngm-3(Laayoune)v  205-74000ngm-3(Dahkla)

v MaximumAlconcentra>onsinthisstudyareanorderofmagnitudelowerthanobservedonislandsdownwindoftheSaharanplume,e.g.GranCanaria=26200ngm-3[5]&Sal,CapeVerde=26487ngm-3[6]

v  Despitelargeinterannualvariabilityindustsupply[7],thisresultwasunan>cipated.Possibili>esthatcouldaccountforthedifference:

v  A‘lowdust’yearv  DustloadingscouldbehigheroffshoreasthedustistransportedintheSaharanAirLayer(SAL)atal>tudesof

1500-6000minborealsummer.However,theSALisatloweral>tudesinborealwinter,sothishypothesisseemsunlikely

v Weusedlowvolumesamplers(~1m3airfilteredh-1),[5]&[6]usedhighvolumesamplers(~1m3min-1).Lowvolumesamplersrequirelongersamplingdura>onsinordertocollectsufficientmaterialonthefilters.Thiswouldmanifestasareduc>onintheconcentra>onofAlperairvolumefilteredper>meunit,duetothelongerrun>mes

v Weweresamplingfromspecificsectors

Results&Discussion

(2)PMFoutput:factorfingerprintofaerosolsources

Ø  Usedforaerosolsourceappor>onment

Ø  Mineraldust

Ø  =red,otherfactorsdonotnecessarilyrepresentthesamesource,butanaaempthasbeenmadetocolour-codethembasedonsimilargroupingsofelements

Ø  Smallestcontribu>onfrommineraldustinAgadir,greatestinDakhla

Ø  SomeTEshavelialetonomineraldustsource:Ø  Agadir:V,Ni,Zn,Mo,PbØ  Laayoune:P,Mo,Cd,PbØ  Dakhla:P,Ni,Mo,Cd,Pb

Ø  Pisaninteres>ngcase.WetendtothinkofPasbeingderivedfrommineraldust.However,contribu>onofmineraldusttoaerosolPwaslow.PcouldbeaspecialcaseinthisregionduetothepresenceofopencastPmines(Moroccois

secondlargestexporterofPintheworld)

(3)RelaRonshipbetweendustevents&elementalraRos

o  Alisaproxyformineraldust

o  Dustevents(peaksinAlconcentra>on)havelialeeffectonthemassra>ooflithogenicelementstoAl(e.g.Ti/Al),sugges>ngmineraldustismainsourceoftheseelements

o  Dusteventsreducethera>oofanthropogenicelementstoAl(e.g.Cd),sugges>ngtheseelementshavelowerrela>veabundancesinmineraldustthanindustrialemissions

o  Onlowdustdays(lowAl)therewerepeaksinra>oofanthropogenicelementstoAl

(4)EnrichmentFactors

q  NormalisedtoAl

q Onlyenrichment>10consideredsignificant(markedbyhorizontalline)

q  Lithogenicelementsnotsignificantlyenriched(toprow)

q  GenerallyhighestenrichmentinAgadirsamples

q  PmostenrichedinLaayounesamples

q  Cdenrichedatallloca>onsbut…q  Cd/Al(mass/mass)atall

sta>ons(Agadir=2.1x10-5-2.7x10-4;Laayoune=8.4x10-6-2.9x10-4;Dakhla=3.0x10-6-2.0x10-4)fallclosetotherangeobservedatnearby

loca>ons(e.g.,CapSpartel=4.6x10-5-2.3x10-4[8]&GranCanaria=4.6x10-5–1.84x10-4[5]q  SametrendseenforotheranthropogenicTEs,e.g.Pb/Al

Pumps

Weathervane

Aerosolsampler Filterholder

Filterholder

View publication statsView publication stats