48
HAL Id: inria-00073008 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073008 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus Silvano Dal Zilio To cite this version: Silvano Dal Zilio. A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus. RR-3664, INRIA. 1999. <inria-00073008>

A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    11

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

HAL Id: inria-00073008https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073008

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

A Bisimulation for the Blue CalculusSilvano Dal Zilio

To cite this version:

Silvano Dal Zilio. A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus. RR-3664, INRIA. 1999. <inria-00073008>

Page 2: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus

Silvano Dal-Zilio

N° 3664

Avril 1999

Page 3: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL
Page 4: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65

� �������������� ������������� ������������� ���!"�#����

$�%'&'(*),+�-/.0)*&2143"%5&'%5-76

8:9<;�=?>?@BADCFE�GH>�IKJML�>4NOGHPMGQNR;�=?>�GSUTRVXWQ>�NOY[ZU\^]_Z

C`IXaba,VKTHN`cM>dTR>�ef9b>�TRef9b>hg7ikjKl_lXmnA oqprTRsutU@wvKvKvdADmKm?a<IKxK>wG

y�z�{�|�}�~b�K|K� 8:9b>O�"t�Jb>`e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G�s�G�I�cMs�TH>we�N�>�LrNH>�g*G^s�VKg?VX���,VXNR9?NH9b>`t�IX=��,c<I�IXg<c�NR9b>`abs7e�IKt�e�Jbtus���\�gNR9bs�G`TR>�a,VKTHN��b�">�cM>��<gb>�IKg#>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>d�2V_TFNH9<s�G�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<GO�<IKGH>�c#V_g#�*IXTR�*>wc[e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K�<IKg<c#��>a<THV�p_>`NH9<>�p�IXt�s�cMs�NQP�VX��NR9b>�TH>�abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg�t�I��`G����<VKT:>4LbIK=�a<tu>_���">BabTHV�p_>`NR9<I�N`I�TH>�abtus�e�IXNH>wc�TR>�GHVKJbTfe4>_�GH9<IKTH>wc��rP�=�IXgrP�a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G��Me�IKg��,>�GHIX�2>�t�P�e4V_abs�>�c#IXg<c#cMs�GQNRTHs��bJMNR>�c���[���7�R �¡ }�¢�{K� a<s�£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��M�bt�Jb>�£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��MpK>�TRsu�*e�IXNHs�VKg��r�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��M�<IKTH�,>�c0e�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>

¥�¦*§`¨f©«ªb¬*­5©«ª ®�¨f¯�°�± ²�¨fª«³^©«ª«©«°�´�­5°�µ�¶�©·¨w± ©«¯�¸'©·¨w± ¹u¸

Page 5: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

� �����0�4���������� ��4�����n����� 4��� ��4!:�# ����`�

��� {�� � � � >�e�IXt�e4Jbt,�bt�>�J�>wGQN:Jbgb>�>4LrNH>�g<GHsuV_g���t�Id�2V_s�G"cMJ�absu£�e�IXt�e4J<t*>�N:cMJ�t�IK=��7cbI�£�e�IKt�e�Jbt5���BIXg<Ge�>�TRIKaba*V_T^Nw�MgbVKJ*GFcME4�<g<s�GRG^V_g<G"Jbgb>dEw�_J<sup�IXt�>�g*e4>�a*V_JbT`e4>�e�IXt�e4Jbt��b��Jbs�GH>B�*IKGH>�GHJbTFt�I?e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>���*IXTR�*>wG��*>4NOgbV_J<GOcbE�=?VKg�NHTRVKg*GFt�I�p�IKtus�cMsuNHE�cb>�G`t�VKs�GOcb>�THE�abt�s�e�I�NHs�VKgq�:SkIKT`>4LM>�=?abt�>K�,gbV_J<G`abTRVKJ<pKVKg*G��J�� Jbgb>��QTR>�GRG^V_JbTfe4>:THE�abt�s���JbE�>����_a<IKT^NfIXx_E�>Fa<IKT�abt�J<G^s�>�J<TRG�abTHVMe�>�GRG^J<G��Ka,>�JbN��4NRTH>�e4VKa<suE�>`>4N:cMs�G^NHTRs��bJbE�>cb>��'I��4V_g#GHJbTR>K�� ¡ |w{ � ��� � {#� absu£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt��be�IKt�e�Jbt��bt�>�J��<pKE�TRsu�*e�IXNHs�VKg��r�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��be�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4> ���<IXTR�,>�G

Page 6: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j

) * �� ����,+0��!� ��4���

8:9<>��bt�Jb>�e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G.-u@0/21¤��cM>�g<VXNH>wc436509b>�TR>�IX� NH>�Tw�ks�G�I p�IKTHs�IXg�N�VK�FNH9b>0IKGHPrg<ef9bTRVKgbV_J<G877£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G9 cM>�g<VXNH>wc,3;:kNR9<I�N:cMs�TH>we�NHt�P?e4VKg�NfIXs�g<GU�2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg*G��rs�g�NH9b>BG^>�g<GH>FNH9<IXN�suN"e�VKg�NRIKsug<G�NH9b>�t�IK=��7cbI�e�IXt�e4JM£t�J<G��;<�VK=?a<IXTR>�c��FsuNH9=3>-@?A?01¤�<suN�9<I_GFgbV�ef9<VKs�e4>dVKTO=?IXNRef9bs�gbx�V_a*>�TRIXNHVKTfG��"Y0V_TH>�V�pK>�Tw�r��>�e4VKg*G^s�cM>�Ts�gnNH9bs�G�TH>�a*V_T^NdI#p�IXTRs�IKg_NdIXt�TR>�IKcbP#J*G^>wc s�gB-�@0?21��qGHJ<ef9nNH9<IXN�NH9b>?J<GRIXx_>�VK��g<IK=�>wGBs�G�TR>�G^NHTRs�e4NH>wc[NHV�2V_TH�<s�c?cM>we4t�IXTfI�NHs�VKg*G�V_g�I�TR>�e�>�s�pK>wc�ef9<IKgbgb>�t�CqNH9<IXN�s�GUV_gbt�P�NH9<> �� ��DE �F'G��D �IH���(���J VX�7g<IX=?>wGk=?I�P��*>NRTRIKg<GH=�suN^NR>�c��LK >�g<IX=?>�NR9bs�G�e4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg#NH9b> ���M'N�&�!���JODE�P��D �Q����J �7G^s�g<e4>�s�NOs�=?abt�su>wGFNH9*I�N`gbV�TR>�e�>�s�pK>�TV_g InxKs�pK>�g g<IX=?>[e�IKg �,>#cbP�g*IX=?s�e�IXt�tuP e�TH>wI�NR>�c�� 8:9rJ<G�365[s�G��,>4NHNH>�T�cM>4�<g<>�c/IKG?I p�IKTHs�IXg�N�VK�NR9b> �^tuVMe�IXtR77£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G �,-�@�v21¤�,I�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G�e4V_g<G^s�cM>�TH>wc#I_G:NH9<>��<I_G^s�GFVX��>�LMa*>�THs�=?>�g�NRIKt�abTRVKxKTfIX=?=?s�gbxt�IXg<xKJ<IKxK>�G�t�s�S_>OT;UWVEX4-@?&Y21�Z�VKT\[E]RU^_-u@wl21¤�

`OVKgb>�NH9b>�tu>wGHGL3�5�s�G"gbVKN:IKg�IKtut�>�prs�I�NH>wc�p_>�TfG^s�VKg�VK��NH9b>�77£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��U8:9b>B=�IXs�g�gbV�p_>�tuNQPK��sug0e4V_=�£a*IXTRs�GHVKg �FsuNH9 NR9b>�e�IXt�e4Jbt�s"IKtuTR>�I_cMP =?>�g_NRsuV_gb>�c���s�G�NH9<IXN�IX�*GQNRTRI_e�NHs�VKg*GQC.a�bdcRegf?�UIXTR>�abTRVMe4>wGHGH>�GdVK�NR9b>?e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G���IXg*c[NH9*I�NdIXgrP0abTHVMe�>�GRGO=�I�P0�*>�IKababt�su>wc[NHV0IXgrP0g<IK=�>_��o`gbVKNH9b>�TB�2>�I�NRJbTR>�VK�h3�5?s�GNR9<I�N`TR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg#s�GFTR>�a<t�I_e4>�c#�rP�TR>�e�JbTRGHs�VKg���8:9b>�e4VKg*GQNRTHJ<e4N8a�ikjIlRmonpfrq�s�t�eR�<e�IKtut�>�c0cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg��s�G�e4V_=?a<IXTfIX�bt�>�NRV NH9b>��^tu>�NHTR>�e4£¤e�VKg<G^NHTRJ<e�N ��VX�O�2J<g<e�NRsuV_g<IXt`t�IXg<xKJ<IKxK>�G�� ��>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g<G?9<I�pK>0IXt�GHV IKgs�g�NH>�THabTR>4NfI�NRsuV_g�s�g?NH>�TH=�G�VX�u3 abTHVMe�>�GRG^>wG���8:9b>�P�e�IXg��,>Oprs�>��">�c?IKGUNH9b>�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g�N�VX�,NH9b>�a<IXTfIKcbsuxK£=�IXNHs�e�a<THVMe4>wGHG�v�wyxEzgaP{ mkaQ|c}eP~ f��Rt�eR���F9bs�ef9ns�GdI�N�NR9b>�e4V_TH>�VX��NH9b>?s�g_NR>�TRabTR>4NRIXNHs�VKgnVX���2J<g<e�NRsuV_g<Gds�g3d�%�r>�>,- ?b@�1�IKg<c�-@?�m&1��2VKTF>�LMIK=?abtu>_�

`OV�� NH9*I�Nd��>�9<I�p_>�s�g�NHTRVrcbJ<e4>wcnI�gb>�� e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G���NR9b>?abTRVK�bt�>�= IKTHs�GH>�GONHV#�<g<c I0GHIXNHs�GQ�'I_e�NHV_THP�,>�9*I�p�s�VKTfIXtU>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>��,>4NQ�">�>�g�3�5�£�NH>�TR=�G�IXg*c NRV abTRV�pK> �HG^>�g<G^s��bt�>��?t�I��`GdV_g NH9b>�e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<GdJ*GQ£s�gbx NH9bs�G?>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>K� o a<THV_�btu>�= abTHV�p_>�c NRV �,>09<IXTfc �2VKT�NH9<>o77£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G�� \�g NH9bs�G�a<IXa,>�T���>ef9<V�V�G^> HP�&�MHG�G��'G�&�I�A��"����'N� -@?Xj�1 9 cM>�g<VXNH>wc�����:�IKG�VKJbT:e�IKg<cMs�cbI�NR>O>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g*e4>�IKg<c��">�a<THV�p_>FNH9b>GHVX£�e�IKtut�>�c �P��DE�!��'N���������r�����N���G��� �hK >d�bTRsu>Q�<P�cM>��<gb>dNR9b>�GH>�NQ�"V�NR>�TR=�G:gbV��d� �\���MHG�N�.'N�����&��"�Q��'N� s�GI��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g[�<IKGH>�c0�,>�9<I�prs�VKTfIXt�>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>dNR9<I�NBabTR>�GH>�TRpK>�GFI�gbVXNRsuV_g[VX�UVK�*G^>�THp�IX�<sut�s�NQP_�*e�IXt�tu>wc�*IXTR�<G��UY0V_TH>`a<TH>we4s�G^>�tuP_�K�<IKTH�,>�c�e�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>Os�G�NH9b>Be4V_IKTRGH>�T�e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>:NH9<IXN�p_>�TRs��<>wGkNH9<>�GH>OabTRVKaM£>�T^NRsu>wG��d8:9b> �P��DE�!��'N�&�����&����� �N���P�Q� GQNfI�NR>�G�NH9<IXNBa<THs�p�I�NH>�TH>wG^V_JbTfe4>�G�e�IKg �*>�GRI��2>�tuP[cMJba<tus�e�IXNH>�c����bVKT>�LbIX=?abt�>B�">�abTRV�pK>�NH9b>��2V_tut�V��Fsug<x�>w�_J*I�NHs�VKgRC

ikj�l�m.n�frq�s,agt�����e�� � a�i}j�l�m�npfrq�sOt�e,�ka�i}j�l�m�n�f�q�s��Oe

K >BTH>��2>�T�NH9b>BTH>wIKcM>�T�NRV�NR9b> � >�=?=�I�l<�u@_�_�F9<>�TR>`NH9<>Be�VK=?abt�>4NH>�GH>4N:VX��TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g�t�I��`G"IXTR>Ot�s�GQNR>�c��\�g NH9b>.77£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G���IXg >w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g�N�VK�`NH9<s�G�abTRVKa,>�THNQP e�IXg �,>��2V_Jbg<c s�g NR9b>�GH>�=?s�g<IXt�NHJMNRVKTRs�IKt��rPC��*Y0s�tugb>�T�-@?&/M�E�M>�e�Nw�E� ~ �&1¤�M�F9b>�TH>�NR9b>d>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>BJ*G^>wc�s�G`G^NHTRVKgbx�xKTRVKJ<g<c�e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>�-@?A?21����"JMNNR9bs�G:>���J<IXt�suNQP�9bVKt�cbG"VKgbt�P��FsuNH9�NH9b>dGHs�cb>�e�VKg<cbs�NRsuV_g�NR9<I�N:NH9<>Bt�s�g�S�NHV�NH9<>dTH>wG^V_JbTRe�> 9 NH9b>def9<IKgbgb>�t�ms�g0NH9<s�G�>4LbIX=?abt�>0:F=?I�P�gbVXN��*>�>�=?s�NHNH>wc��*s�� >K�`cMVr>�GOgbVXNBIXaba,>�IKT`sug VK�MWQ>we�N`a,V_GHs�NRsuV_g[VX��IXg0V_JMNHabJbN��oOgbVXNR9b>�T�GHs�cM>#e�VKg<cbs�NRsuV_g s�G�NH9<IXN,m cMVr>�G?gbVKN�IKaba,>�IXT?s�g/GHJb�MWQ>we�N�a,V_GHs�NRsuV_g VK�BIXg sug<abJMN�����gbt�PTR>�e�>�g�NHt�PK�rY0>�TRTRV�IXg<c��bIXgbx_suV_THx_su-u@wv21,a<THV�p_>:NH9b>OGRIX=?>`>w��J<I�NRsuV_g��_�FsuNH9<VKJMN�NH9b>O�<TRG^N�GHs�cb>Oe4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg���2V_TF�<IXTR�,>�c#e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>�s�g�77£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G:�FsuNH9#NH9<>dtuVMe�IKtusuNQP�abTRVKa,>�THNQPK�

� ¶�°��u��®��Q¸7°�¯2�q­�¶�°���ª«²F¯w°N���R��¶�¨G�,©«¯ �k !¡2¢I£��5¶2�Q¸���¨f¸��q¯�°�©«§Fµ�ª«©@¤Q© �<¸��Q­��5¸'©@¤��5©«°�¯�­�°�¯6�5¶2�R��­��q°f¹r¨U¸���¤��Q© ®��Q² ¤¤¶�¨f¯�¯0�^ª�±

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 7: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

m � ����2�&�������������R��!���

8:9b>�ef9bV_s�e�>OVX���<IXTR�*>wc�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g<e4>`9*IKG�NQ��V�=�IXs�g�=?VXNHs�p�I�NRsuV_g<G��U��s�TRG^N�� � ��%���8�� �"� ���&��� HG�2������ �8�A��%���\HG������0�����G�������Q � �2�&���Q��'N���;�&�.��� �;�Q�P�Q�"�"DE�P�0'N���N� 'G�&��'Q �!� ��- l�1��k8:9rJ<G�s�Nks�GkIK=�>�g<IX�<tu>�NHV�e4V_=�£a*IXTRs�GHVKg��Fs�NR9�>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>�GUV_g�3 IKg<c�NH9b>UWQV_sugb£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��d�r>we4V_g<c��XNR9b>`J<GH>`VK�7IKg�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>:NR9<I�Ns�G�I��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg�IKg<c?I�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g<e4>_�X>�I_G^>wGUabTRV�VK�'GUVX��e�VKTRTH>we�NHg<>�GRG��2VKT�abTRVKx_TRIK=�G�NHTfIXg<G^�2VKTR=�I�NHs�VKg*GIKg<c0s�g_NR>�TRabTR>4NRIXNHs�VKg<G 9 VKTB>�g*e4VMcMs�gbx_GN::VX�Ut�IXgbx_J<IXx_>�G���``VKg<>4NH9<>�t�>�GRG`NR9b>�TR>�s�G�I�=�IXWQVKTOcMTfI��F�<I_eNS�s�gNR9b>�ef9bV_s�e�>�VX�U�<IKTH�,>�c[e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�bg<IK=?>�t�P�NR9<I�NBabTHVrVK�'GFVX���bs�GHsu=?s�t�IKTHsuNQP�TR>�GHJbtuNRG`s�grpKV_tup_>�I���J<IXgM£NRs��,e�I�NRsuV_g0V�pK>�T`IKtut�e4V_g_NR>4LrNRG���oOg >4LbIK=�a<tu>dVK��NR9bs�G`ab9b>�gbVK=?>�gbVKg0s�G`xKs�pK>�g0sug��r>we�Nw�*jb��@K�"8qV�I�p_VKs�cNR9bs�G:abs�NH�'IXt�t5�<��>dcM>��<gb>dI�t�IK�*>�tu>wc�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg#G^PMG^NH>�=#�bIKg<c#I�e�VKTRTH>wG^a,VKg*cMsug<x�t�IX�,>�t�>�c��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_gNR9<I�N?s�G��<g<>�T�NH9<IKg �<IKTH�,>�c e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K�4��JbT�x_V_IKt�C?NR9<I�N?s�G�abTRV�prsug<x[NH9b>#TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g NH9b>�VKTR>�=�2V_TONR9b>?�<IXTR�,>�c e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�7s�G�I_ef9bsu>�pK>wc[�rP[abTHV�prs�gbx�NR9<I�N�NH9<s�GB�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg p_>�TRs��*>�GONH9b>?TR>�abt�s�£e�I�NRsuV_g0NH9b>�VKTR>�= 9 GH>�> � >�=?=�I�l<�u@2:��O8:9bs�G�s�G�gbVXN�NH9b>�VKgbt�P0TH>wG^J<t�NOVK�UNH9bs�GBTH>�a*V_T^Nw�O8:9b>�cM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_gVK��NH9<>�t�IX�,>�t�>�c NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_gnGHPMGQNR>�= s�G�s�g�NH>�TH>wGQNRsugbx#G^s�g<e�>�suNBPrs�>�t�cbG�I��,>4NHNH>�TBJ<g<cM>�TfG^NRIXg*cMsug<x�VK��NH9b>�<tuJb>de�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G:IXg<c�suNRG"�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg<IKt�IXg<c �^9bsux_9b>�TH£¤VKTfcM>�T �F�2>�I�NRJbTR>�G���\�g#a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IKT��rsuNFP�s�>�t�cbGFI��,>4N^NR>�TJ<g<cM>�TfG^NRIXg*cMsug<x�V_g�NR9b>de4V_gbgb>�e4NHs�VKg#�*>�NQ��>�>�g0abTRsup�IXNH>�TH>wG^V_JbTfe4>�G�s�go365r�M>4LMabt�s�e4suNOG^Jb�*GQNRs�NRJbsuV_g<GFIXg*cNR9b>��2Jbt�t��b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��

{�|�} ���X| ��} � ¡�� |�� ��� ~ ��� } 8:9b>dTR>�G^N`VX��NH9b>�a*IXa,>�TFs�G`VKTRx_IKgbs���>�c�IKG"�2V_tut�V��`G���\�g �M>�e�Nw��?b�b��>dTR>4£prs�>�� NR9b>O�bt�Jb>Be�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G�IXJbx_=?>�g�NH>wc��Fs�NR9�>4LrNR>�g<GHsu�<tu>�TH>we4VKTfcbG�IKg<c��">�cM>��<gb>��<IXTR�*>wc�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�\�g��r>�e4N���m<���">�abTR>�GH>�g�N�NH9b>"t�IK�*>�tu>wc�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg�GHPMGQNR>�=0�q\�g��r>�e4N����M���">�GPSK>�NRef9dNR9b>�a<THVrVX�bVK�bp�IXt�s�cMsuNQPVK��NH9b> �^JbaM£�NHV�e�VKg�NH>�LrN �OabTRVrVX��NH>wef9bgbs���Jb>O-@?Xl217�2V_T�NR9b>Ot�IX�,>�t�>�c��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��U8:9b>�e�VK=?abt�>4NH>BabTRVrVX�s�G"xKs�pK>�g�s�g#oOaba*>�g<cMsuL#o��FKn>�J<GH>ONR9bs�G:TH>wG^JbtuN:NHV�abTRV�pK>K�MIXN�NR9b>dGHIK=�>�NHs�=?>K�MNR9bTR>�>BabTHV_a*>�T^NRsu>wGQC6a�PeNR9b>Ot�IX�,>�t�>�c��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g�s�G"I�e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�"a���Pe�s�N:e4V_g_NfIXs�g<GUNR9b>�GQNRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXt*>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>�IXg*c�a������PesuNUpK>�THsu�<>�GqNH9<>"TR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg�t�I��`G 9 GH>�>��r>�e4N��XlI:���\�g��r>we�Nw���r���">"a<THV�p_>�NH9*I�NkNH9b>:t�IX�,>�t�>�c��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_gs�GFI?�<IKTH�,>�c��bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��bIXg*c�NR9rJ<G"NH9<IXNFNH9b>dTR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg#t�I��`GFIKTH>Bp�IXt�s�c��2VKT_���k�FK >�e4V_g<e4t�J<cM>s�g.�r>we�Nw��Y��Fs�NR9�GHVK=?>`>4LbIK=�a<tu>wG�VK�qIXababt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g�VX��NR9b>�TR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg�t�I��`G�IXg*c�G^V_=?>`�<g<IKt*TR>�=�IKTPSMG��

� ����� ��4!:������

8:9<>`�bt�Jb>Oe�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G�s�G�Idp�IKTHs�IXg�N�VX�7NR9b>`=?sug<s,I_G^Prg<ef9bTRVKg<VKJ<Gk77£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G;-!�01���sug��F9bs�ef9?�2J<g<e�NRsuV_g<G���VKTIK�<G^NHTfIKe�NRsuV_g<G�sug#NH9<>"�b£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G"NR>�TR=?sugbV_tuV_xKP_�rIKTH>�cMs�TH>we�NRtuP�>�=��,>�cbcb>�c��U\¤N`9<I_G"gbV�ef9bVKs�e4>_�M=?IXNRef9M£s�gbxnVKT�x_J<IXTfcM>wc VKJMNRabJMN?VKa,>�TfI�NHV_TRG��=K 9bs�t�>.3�>�gM�2VKTfe4>wG�IXg sug<cbsuTR>�e4N?G^NQPrtu>�VK�OabTRVKx_TRIK=�=?s�gbx<��s�gNR9b>�GH>�g<GH>�NR9<I�N�VKgb>�9*IKG�NRV >4LMabt�s�e4suNHt�Pn=�IXg*IXxK> �^TR>�GHJbt�N�ef9<IXgbg<>�t�G �?NHV s�=?abt�>�=?>�g�N��2J<g<e�NRsuV_g<G��d3�5a<THV�prs�cM>�G`I��*>�N^NH>�T �QabTRVKx_TRIK=?=�s�gbx?gbVKNRI�NRsuV_g ���2VKTB9bsux_9b>�TH£¤VKTfcM>�T`e�VKg<e�JbTHTR>�g*e4PK�F\�g*cM>�>wc$#��,�"V_J<cMVKtGH9bV��`G"s�g�-�@M/�1�NH9<IXN 3��<e4V_=�a*IXTR>�c�NRV,3�5_�Ms�G`I �He4VKg�NRsugrJ<IXNHs�VKg�a*IKGRG^s�gbx�GQNQPrt�>de�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G ���

8:9b>?NR>�TR=�GdVX�63�5 9 >�LrNH>�g*cM>�c �FsuNH9 TR>�e4V_TRc<GG:�IXTR>?xKs�pK>�g s�g 8�IK���U@K��\�g NR9b>�cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g VX�"NH9b>e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G�����>?J<GH>�NQ��V0cMs�G2WQV_sug�N�e�IXNH>�xKVKTRs�>�G`VK��g<IK=?>�GMCBef9<IKgbgb>�tUg<IX=?>�G���cM>�gbVXNR>�c m�%'&(%')4~Q~Q~��qIXg*ct�IX�,>�t�G��kcb>�gbVKNH>�c+*(%-,�%-. ~M~Q~��n8:9b>#G^>�=?IKg�NHs�e�G�VK�:NH9b>0e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G�s�G�x_sup_>�g s�g I ef9b>�=�s�e�IKt"G^NQPrtu>�- ��1���<VKTOe�VKgrpK>�gbs�>�g<e�>K�<�">�GHabt�s�N�NH9b>�cb>�GRe4TRsuaMNRsuV_g[VX�UVKJ<T�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GOIKtuV_gbx?NH9bTR>�>�G^Prg�NRI_e�NHs�e�IKtqe�IXNH>�xKVKTRs�>�G���<VKT">�I_ef9�e�IXNH>�x_VKTRPK�_��>B>4LbIX=?s�gb>`NR9b>BTH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g�TR>�t�I�NHs�VKg0/ �rIKg<c�NR9b>�GQNRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXt,>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>21��8:9<>BcM>wGHe�THs�aMNRsuV_g�J<GH>�G�NH9b>�G^NRIXg*cbIXTfc�gbVKNHs�VKg�VK� �3�2�&�!"��������� 'N�&�"� �'4 � �F<�V_g_NR>4LrNRG��McM>�g<VXNH>wc657%'89%M~Q~Q~

:<;k¥=: >

Page 8: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� �

� ~bz�� �����MP�g�NfI�L�VK��NR9b>��"tuJb>O<"IKt�e�JbtuJ*GQCd3�5f %Gt %G� ���!n m��� agbdm}e�f��� a�f�mRe��� ikj�l�mon�frq�s�t�� 9 �2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg*IXt�a<IKT^N�: �� a�f��Rt�e �� vwyx�z�f ���� x� f�� �� 9 77£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G:a<IXTHNN:��� �� � � % ,unpf � �� a�f ,�e 9 TR>�e�VKTfc�a<IKT^N�:

IKTH>�cM>��<gb>�c�J<GHsug<x�NR9b>�G^Prg�NRIXL�VX�k3L5w£�NH>�TH=�G���a<tuJ<GFI?e�VKg<G^NRIKg_N ����� �FKn>dcM>�gbVXNR> 5 � f � NH9<>Ba<THVMe4>wGHGV_�MNRIKsug<>�c �rP �<t�t�sugbxnNH9<>#9<VKt�>�s�g+5 �Fs�NR9 NR9b>0abTHVMe�>�GRG�f?� Z�p�IKtuJ*I�NHs�VKg/e4V_g_NR>4LrNRG����7%�� %Q~M~Q~4�"IXTR>e�VKg�NH>�LrNRG:G^J*ef9�NH9*I�N:NH9b>�9bV_tu>�cMVr>�G"gbVKNFVre�e4JbT:�FsuNH9bs�g0IXg0IX�<G^NHTfIKe4NHs�VKg��rI�TR>�e�VKTfc�VKTFI�cM>�e�t�IKTRIXNHs�VKg�C

�����!n ����� �� a��ymRe �� a�� ��f�e �� a�f � � e �� v�wLxEz!� �� ikj�l�mon�f�q�s"� �� a�� ,�eo�G"J<G^J*IXt��F|m0cb>�gbVKNH>�G�NR9b>ONRJbabt�>�VX��g*IX=?>�G a�m$#�%M~Q~M~ %�m&%�eH�bIKg<c�NR9b>dG^Pr=��,VKt ':s�G:J<GH>�c�NRV�cb>�gbVKNH>BNH9b>>�=?aMNQP�NRJbabt�>K�hK >��Fs�tut�G^V_=�>�NHs�=?>�GFJ<GH>,a b�|mRegf s�g<G^NH>�I_c#VX�6agbkm$#0eG~Q~Q~Ma�bdm&%�e�f?�,IXg<c=v�w)(xEzf�s�g<GQNR>�I_cVK�kv�wLx+*Azg~M~Q~Nvwhx�,Ez�f?�FKn>BIXt�G^V�cM>�g<VXNH>�a�f�|m}eqNR9b>�a<THVMe4>wGHG;a�f�m$#k~Q~M~�m&%�eH�U8���V�xK>�g<>�TfIXt<TRJbt�>�G"e�IKg��*>x_sup_>�g�VKg#NH9b>dTR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g�C

f / f"- f 1 tt / f"- . ¸��Q²��0/M�w© ®21

f / f"- � >�p�IKtuJ*I�NHs�VKg0e4V_g�NH>4LrN� � f � /3� � f - � . ¸��Q²�¤Q°�¯����54Q�51

<�V_g<e4>�THg<sugbx�NH9<>�GQNRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXt�>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>_�M��>dIKGRGHJb=?>�NR9<I�N76q£�e4VKgrp_>�THNHs��btu>BabTRVMe4>�GRGH>�G:IXTR>�>w��J<IXt��8:9�; <>=@?BA&CED0F7GHD�IKJLIKM�G+NO=QPOR7JSATG+D0IKJ7UWVXP:CEUZY\[]=�JKG^I�M�_X`8:9<>��2J<g<e�NRsuV_g<IXt�a*IXTHN:VK��V_JbTFe�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G:s�GFx_>�gb>�TRIXNH>wc��rP�NR9b>�xKTfIX=?=�IXT

f %Gt %P�B~Q~Q~a���@n m �� a�bFmRegf �� a�f�mRe �� ikj�lumon�f q�s�t8:9rJ<G�s�N�s�G7NR9b>��HGH=?IKtut � �b£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<Gq>4LrNH>�g<cM>wc��Fs�NR9�NH9b> 9 TR>�e4J<TRGHsup_>0:,cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKgdVKa,>�TfI�NRVKTw��K >�J<GH>UNH9b>I_c�WQ>�e4NHs�pK>�G^=�IXt�tkG^s�g<e4>?I�a<THVMe4>wGHGBe�IKg VKg<tuP0�,>�IKababt�su>wc[NHV0I�g*IX=?>�IKg<c[gbVKN�NRV�IKgbVXNR9b>�TBabTRVre�>�GRGQC�"> GRI�P NH9<IXN�NH9b> �btuJ<> e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G�s�G �����,��D��2�N����I� � `OVKgb>�NH9b>�tu>wGHG���NH9b>��^9bs�xK9M£¤VKTfcM>�T �6�b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<GIKababt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g#e�IXg#�*>dTR>�e�V�pK>�TR>�c�J<G^s�gbx�NH9<>�cM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g

a�f�t�eknSbdcfekikjIl�mon�t�q�s�a�f�mRe a�mhgi l sya�f�eTj.l sya�t�ePe8:9<>�TR>�s�G�I =�IXs�g cMs�k,>�TH>�g<e4>#9b>�TH>��Fs�NR9 TR>�GHa*>we�N�NHV NR9b>#VKTRsux_sug<IKt�a<TH>wG^>�g_NfI�NRsuV_g VX�;3�5r-�@M/21¤�4Kn>9*I�pK>�TR>�abt�IKe�>�c����<V�I�NHs�gbx�cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg*G � � xml f����7>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g�NBNHV�IKg s�gM�<gbsuNH>�a<IXTfIXt�t�>�tke4VK=?a,V_GHs�NRsuV_gVK� �QV_gb>4£�G^9<VXN �`cM>we4t�IXTfI�NHs�VKg*G��X�rP?I�e4V_g<G^NHTRJ<e�NRsuV_g?NH9<IXN�=?s�LM>wGUNHV_xK>�NH9b>�T�TR>�G^NHTRs�e4NHs�VKg��_TH>�abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg�IXg*ccb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKgRC�a�ikjIlRmonpfrq�s�t�ekn bncfe v�wyxEzga � xol f��=�Rt�eH�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 9: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

l � ����2�&�������������R��!���

8�V�>�g*G^JbTR>BNH9b> ���M'N�&�!���JODE�P��D �Q����J �7s5� >K��NH9*I�N`gbV�TR>�e�>�s�pK>wc�g<IK=?>�G`e�IXg0�*>�J<G^>wc[IKG`GHJb�MWQ>we�N`a<IKT^NVK�BI cM>we4t�IXTfI�NRsuV_g����"> G^abt�suN�NH9b> e�I�NH>�xKV_THP VX�def9<IKgbgb>�tFg*IX=?>�G?s�g/NQ��V*�pKn> e�VKg<GHs�cb>�T?p�IXTRs�IK�btu>wGQCc�%�� %�� %Q~M~Q~FVKg[V_gb>�GHs�cM>_�,IKg<c#TH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>�GMChm % &�%Q~M~Q~FVKg0NR9b>�VKNH9b>�T�GHs�cM>_�FCF>4�2>�TH>�g<e4>wG`IXTR>d�*V_Jbg<c0�rPTR>�G^NHTRs�e�NHs�VKg*GQC,v�whx�zf?�k�F9bsut�>�p�IKTHs�IX�bt�>�G�IXTR>��*V_Jbg<c �rP �M£�IX�<G^NHTfIKe4NHs�VKg<GMC�agbdc�e f?�UIXg<c cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg*GQCikj�l��$n�� q�sOf?�8:9b>�TH>�s�G�IXgbVKNH9b>�T�e�VKgrpK>�g_NRsuV_g�� � >�N�� �,>�NR9b>�GH>���Jb>�g<e4>�a�� # n f # %Q~Q~M~3%�� % n f % eR�7GHJ<ef9[NR9<I�N

NR9b>�� � G`IXTR>�a<IXs�TH�Fs�GH>�cMs�G^NHs�g<e4N��hK >�e�IXt�t�� IXg ���(�M��G���"�,�Q�"� ��8�V�G^s�=?abtusu�2P�g<VXNRIXNHs�VKg<G��b�">�cM>�g<VXNH>�rP=a�i}j�l��pq�s�f�eUNR9b>��2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx?abTRVMe4>�GRG��

i}j�l�� q�sOf n bdcfe ikj�l��&#�n�f #�q�s�a�ikj�l��� ;n�f� }q�s,aP~Q~M~PikjIl��E%,n�fZ%6q�s�f�e�eK >�IKt�GHV�IKtut�V�� >�=?aMNQP cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg<G���G^J<ef90NR9<I�N��rn��b��\�g[NH9bs�G�e�I_G^>_�*�">�cM>�gbVXNR>�� �rP��M�7IXg*c[��>TR>�x�IXTfc a�ikj�l��%q�s8f�e�IKG:s�cM>�g_NRs�e�IXt7NRV$f?�

K > IKGRGHJb=?>nNR9b> TR>�I_cM>�T[s�G0�'IX=?s�tus�IXT[�FsuNH9 NR9b> gbVKNHs�VKg<G0VK���2TR>�> IKg<c �*V_Jbg<c p�IXTRs�IX�bt�>�G��"6�£e�VKgrpK>�TRGHs�VKg IKg<c G^Jb�*GQNRs�NRJMNHs�VKg 9 cM>�gbVKNH>wc f��Mm���c��0:4��K > cM>�gbVKNH>=l sha�f�e 9 TH>wG^a����ksha�f�e :�NH9b> GH>4NVK�q�2TR>�> 9 TH>wG^a��M�,VKJ<g<c":"g<IK=�>wGFIXg<c�p�IXTRs�IK�bt�>�G:s�g�f?�U8:9b>wG^>�GH>4NfGFIXTR>Bcb>4�<gb>wc0IKG:J<GHJ<IXt�e�VKg<GHs�cM>�TRsug<xNR9<I�N��bs�g<cM>�TRGBIXTR>�IK�<GQNRTRI_e�NRsuV_g<GOIKg<c cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg<G��8Kn>?cM>�gbVXNR>�ikjIl a�� e"NR9b>?G^>�NBVK��g<IX=?>�G�cM>��<gb>wc�rP�� �MNH9<IXN`s�G"NR9b>�GH>4N �!�&# %Q~M~Q~-%��E%"�d�FsuNH9#NH9<>dgbVXNfI�NHs�VKg#J<GH>�c#IX�,V�pK>_��<VKT:NH9<>��2Jbg<e�NRsuV_g<IXt�G^Jb�*G^>�N:VK�k3 5 �MNR9b>dI�LMsuV_=�GFcM>4�<g<sugbx�G^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTfIXt�>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>dIXTR>�- v21gC

a�i}j�l���np��q�s�f�e,��t 1 ikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f��Rt�e a�� gi l shagt�e�eikj�l���n�� q�s$agv�wLxEzWf�e 1 v�wyxEzga�i}j�l���n�� q�sOf�e a�mhgi l sha���e�ea�i}j�l���n�� q�s�f�e�m 1 ikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f�m}e a�m�gn$�ue

a v�wLxEzf�e& 1 v�wyxEzga�f2&"e a�m�gn &"e

��g NH9b>#�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg<IKt"�2TRIKxK=?>�g�N��kNR9b>#TH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g s�G�cb>4�<gb>wc �rP NH9<> �HG^=�IKtut ��% TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg/IXg<c NH9b>TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�TRJbt�>��2V_T`cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g<GMC

a�a bdc�egf�e�m / f��Qm��2c��^. ¸��Q²�&&� �¤¨ 1a��!���\j.l s%a���e�e(')�ds%a � ekn*�

i}j�l���n�� q�s"� � � � / i}j�l#��n���q�s�� � � � . ¸��^²B²2��¹518:9 8 <>=@?BA&CED0F7GHD�IKJLIKM�G+NO=*+-, A&U V�A RSV�R7?hP:C+UWYK[ =@J\GhI�M _ `\�g#NR9bs�GFGH>�e4NHs�VKg��<��>de4V_g<GHs�cM>�T"NH9b>dV_a*>�TRIXNHVKTfG:cMs�TH>we�NHt�P�cM>�THs�pK>wc��2TRVK= NH9b>877£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��rNR9<I�N`s�G

f %Gt %G� ���!n �� � xo f��o�� a�f �uf�e"�� vwhxEzWf

:<;k¥=: >

Page 10: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� �

8:9<>�gb>�� e�VKg<G^NHTRJ<e�Nks�g_NRTHVMcMJ*e4>�c�9b>�TR>"s�G�NR9b>FcM>�e�t�IKTRIXNHs�VKg�C � x� f�����NH9<IXNke�IXg��*>"s�g_NR>�TRabTR>4NH>wc�I_G�ITR>�GHVKJ<TRe�>K�wtuVMe�IXNH>wcdI�N}m��XIKe�e4>wGHGHsu�<tu>�V_gbt�P�V_g<e4>_��CFV_JbxK9bt�PdG^a,>�IASrsugbx*��NR9b>:cM>�e�t�IKTRIXNHs�VKg � xo a�bdcRegf��s�G"NH9<>d>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g�N:VK�qNR9b>877£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G:s�gbabJMN`x_J<IXTfcuCdmka�c�eG~ f?�<�F9bsut�>BNH9b>�IKababt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g a�m(&�#k~M~Q~'& %�e�s�GNR9b>�>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g�NOVK��NR9b>O77£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GFVKJbNHabJMN0C��m � |&��f�F8:9b>�cM>�e�t�IKTRIXNHs�VKg#s�GOJ<G^>��2Jbt�NRV�=?VMcM>�t�abTHVMe�>�GRG^>wG�FsuNH9[I�=�JbNRIX�<tu>dG^NRI�NR>K�

o�G�G^NRIXNH>�c�sug�NR9b>Oa<TH>�p�s�VKJ*G�GH>�e�NRsuV_g��rIXg<c�I_e�e�VKTfcMsug<x�NHVdNR9b>Be�VKg<e�tuJ*G^s�VKg�VK�,NR9b>BVKTRsux_sug<IKtbabTR>�GH>�gM£NfI�NRsuV_g�VK��3�58-�@M/&1���NR9b>FJ<GH>FVX�,TH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>�Gks�GkTH>wGQNRTHs�e�NR>�c�sug?VKJ<T�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<GMC�IKt�NR9bVKJ<xK9�NH9b>�P�e�IKg�IKaba,>�IXTJ<g<cM>�TBI �M£�IX�*GQNRTRI_e�NHs�VKgq�MNH9b>�P[e�IXg<gbVXN`�,>�IK�<GQNRTRI_e�NR>�c#Jba,VKg��F�bV_TO>�LMIK=?abtu>_��a bkmRe � xo f��Bs�GOgbVXNI�p�IXt�s�c�abTRVre�>�GRG���8:9bs�G�TR>�G^NHTRs�e4NHs�VKg�>�g<GHJbTR>�GqNH9b>"tuVMe�IXt�s�NQPdabTRVKa,>�THNQPK���bJbNksuN�IXt�G^V�>�g<GHJbTR>�GqNH9<IXNkI�g<IK=�>e�IXgbg<VXN��,>UJ<G^>wc��*VKNH9�s�g�IFcM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g�IXg<cBs�g�IFcb>�e4t�IXTfI�NRsuV_g���t�s SK>Us�g,a�ikjIlRm.n���q�s$a � xo f��=�Rt�e�e�2V_T�>�LbIX=?abt�>K�O��NRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXt�TRJbtu>wG`�2V_TBNH9b>�77£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<GO�2TRIKxK=?>�g�N�IXTR>�NH9<> �HGRe4VKa,>�>�LrNHTRJ<G^s�VKg �dTRJbt�>�VK�3d�rNR9b>dJ<GHJ<IXt�TRJbt�>�G"�2V_T:NH9b>�e�VK=?=�JMNfI�NRsup_>B=?V_gbVKs�c�a�f %%� % e�IKg<c�THJbt�>�G:=�IKg<IXx_sugbx?IXa<abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg�C

f��Fagt�����e 1 a�f��Rt�e���� f �Rt 1 t���f

��f 1 f & 1 agvwyx�zf�e���t 1 v�wyxEzga�f ��t�e a�m�gi l sha�t�ePe

v�wLxEz�v�w��Izf 1 v�w��Iz�v�wLxEz�f

a�f �Rt�e�m 1 a�f�mRe��Fa�t8mRe � xo f���& 1 � xo f��<�V_g<e4>�THg<sugbx:NR9b>�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g���NR9b>�TR>�s�GqI`e�VK=?=�J<gbs�e�I�NRsuV_gBTRJbt�>kNH9<IXN�e�VKg<GHJb=?>�G�IFcb>�e4t�IXTfI�NRsuV_gIKg<c��2>4NRef9<>�G:NR9b>dTH>wG^V_JbTfe4>�IXNFNH9b> �^t�Vre�I�NRsuV_g ��VX��NH9b>d=?>wGHGRIXx_>AC

� xo f��=�Fa�m�&�#k~Q~M~ & %�e / a�f2&�#F~Q~Q~ & %�e . ¸��^²B²2��¤^ª�18:9� <>=@?BA&CED0F7GHD�IKJLIKM�G+NO=� =@A&I�C�� P:C+UWYK[ =@J\GhIKMo_X`C`>�e4V_TRc<G�IXTR>Usug*e4TR>�=?>�g�NRIKtut�PO�<JbsutuNq�2TRVK= NH9<>�>�=?aMNQPBTH>we4V_TRc � � ��J<G^s�gbx:NR9b>�>�L�NR>�g<c� �Jba7cbI�NR>�VKa,>�TfI�NRsuV_g� t %=,�n�f � NR9<I�NUIKcbc<G� �V�pK>�TRTRs�cM>wG,NH9b>��<>�t�c��b�Fs�NR9�p�IXt�Jb>yf?��NRV`NR9b>�TR>�e�VKTfc�t?�q\�g�NRJbs�NRsup_>�t�PK�XIFTR>�e�VKTfcs�GdI#�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg �2TRVK= I��<g<s�NR>�G^>�N�VX�:t�IK�*>�t�GBNRV[abTHVMe�>�GRG^>wG��qIKg<c G^>�tu>we�NHs�VKg s�GB�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg IXa<abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg��8:9<s�G�sug�NRJbs�NRsuV_g s�G�G^NHTR>�g<xXNH9<>�gb>wc[�rP�NR9b> �^cMVKN^£¤tu>wGHG �dgbVXNfI�NHs�VKg �2VKT�G^>�tu>we�NHs�VKgRCF��>�J<G^>�NH9b>�gbVKNRI�NRsuV_ga�f ,�eH�bs�g<G^NH>wIKc�VX��NH9b>d=?VKTR>��'IX=?sut�s�IXTFgbVKNRI�NRsuV_g a�f����geR�\¤NF�"VKJbt�c��,>�e�VKgrpK>�gbs�>�g�N�NHV?IKc<c�I�G^PMG^NH>�= VK�RSrsug<c<G�NRV�NfIXx�NH9b>BJ<GH>�VK�qg<IK=�>wG�s�go3 5 9 NHV_xK>4NR9b>�T

�FsuNH9 IngbVXNRsuV_g VK�O��>�tutu£��2VKTR=�>wc NR>�TR=?GN:���sug/VKTfcM>�T�NRVn�2V_TH=�IKtus���>�NH9b>[cMs�G^NHs�g<e�NRsuV_g =�IKcb>��,>4NQ�">�>�gt�IX�,>�t�G��*p�IXTRs�IX�bt�>�G�IXg<c[TR>4�2>�TH>�g<e4>wG��;Kn>��*>�tus�>�p_>�NH9*I�NONR9b>?cM>4NfIXs�t�G�VX�UNR9bs�GBGHPrG^NH>�= IXTR>�e4t�>�IKT`NHV�NH9b>TR>�I_cM>�Tw�KIKg<c��">`VK=?suN�NHV�cb>4�<gb>�s�N"9b>�TR>K��\�g�NR9b>`TR>�=�IXs�g<cM>�T�VX�7NR9bs�G�a<IKa*>�T��_��>OI_GHGHJb=?>FNR9<I�N�g*IX=?>�GIKTH>FIKtu�:I�PMGqJ<GH>�c?e�VKTRTH>we�NHt�PK�XIKg<c���>:J<GH>:NH9<>Ftu>�N^NH>�TRG���%���%Q~M~Q~�NHV�cM>�gbVXNR>`IXgrPdg<IK=�>wGUs�� >_�u��I�p�IKTHs�IX�bt�>K�I�TR>4�2>�TH>�g<e4>:V_T�I�t�IK�*>�t5�U8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>K��NR9b>:NH>�TH= a�f��Ee�cb>�gbVKNH>�G�IXg�IXaba<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg?VKT�I�TR>�e�VKTfc�GH>�t�>�e4NHs�VKg��

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 11: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

Y � ����2�&�������������R��!���

8:9b>�G^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTfIXt�THJbt�>�G��2V_TBTR>�e�VKTfc GH>�t�>�e�NRsuV_g_a�f ,�e:IKTH>�NH9b>�GRIX=?>�I_G�NH9b>?VKg<>�G��2VKTdIXa<abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg���<VKTF>�LMIK=?abtu>_�M��>�9<I�p_>ONR9b>��2VKt�t�V��Fsugbx?>w�_J*IXt�s�NRsu>wG��

a�f ��t�e ,$1 a�f ,�e��Fagt ,�e � xo f��,$1 � xo f��K >�J<GH> � , #�n�fW#%Q~Q~M~3% , %�n�fZ% � �bs�g<G^NH>�I_c�VK� �n�d� � %=, # n�f # � %�~Q~M~3, %$npfZ% � �M�F9<>�gb>�pK>�T"NR9b> , � � GFIXTR>cbs�G^NHs�g<e�Nw��8:9b>�TR>dIXTR>BNQ��V?TR>�cMJ<e4NHs�VKg#THJ<tu>wG"�2VKTFTR>�e4V_TRc<GQC

a � t %=,un�f � ,�e / f . ¸��^²B­��Qª�1* gn ,

a � t %=,�n�f � *Ee / agt *"e . ¸��Q²�°H®��Q¸ 18:9<s�Gk�2V_TH=�IKtus���IXNHs�VKg�VK�,TR>�e�VKTfcbG�s�G�e4t�V_GH>�t�P�TH>�t�IXNH>wc�NRV�NH9b>FV_gb>:abTRVKa,V_GH>�c���P�K IKg<co- ?Kv21¤�_GHsug<e�>:NH9b>�TH>s�GFI?G^s�gbx_tu>�VKa,>�TfI�NRsuV_g�NRV?>�suNH9b>�T`=?Vrcbs��2P�VKTFIKcbc0I��<>�t�c�NHV�I�TR>�e4V_TRc��

� � � �F���� ��4������������#���B��4�`��!��

\�gnNH9<>?cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKgnVX�:I�e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��7NH9b>�ef9bV_s�e�>�VK��NH9b>?>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g*e4>?TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg J*G^>wc NRV�TR>�I_G^V_g IX�,VKJMN>w��J<IXt�s�NQP��,>4NQ�">�>�g�NH>�TH=�G�s�G�IBcMs�e�JbtuN�NfIKGPS7�q\�g�NR9bs�G�a*IXa,>�Tw�Xe4VKg�NRTRIKTHP�NHVBabTR>�prsuV_J<G�abTH>wG^>�g�NRI�NRsuV_g<G�VK�NR9b>��bt�Jb>�e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G����">�ef9bVrV_GH>k�2VKT�e�IXg*cMs�c<I�NH>�I`�*>�9<I�prsuV_TRIKtw>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>UNR9<I�N�s�G�IKt�GHV`I:�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��8:9<s�G?TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g���e�IKtut�>�c �<IXTR�,>�c/e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�> 9 ���R:��"s�G�NH9<>[�bsux_xK>wGQN?�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g NR9<I�N�abTR>�GH>�TRpK>wGGHs�=�a<tu>#VK�<GH>�TRp�I�NRsuV_g<G�e�IXt�tu>wc �<IXTR�<G�IXg<c NH9<IXN?s�G�Ine�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>�-u@0Y21�� �<VKT�a*>�VKabt�>��'IK=?sut�s�IKT��FsuNH9�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg �2VKT,3d�"suN�s�G�I p�IXTRs�IKg�N?VK��NR9b>0��>wI&S �*IXTR�*>wc e�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>�-@?Xj21¤� o`gbVKNH9b>�T�TR>�t�I�NH>wc>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>�s�G"NR9b>�V_gb>�cM>4�<g<>�c��2VKT�NH9b>"WQVKs�gM£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G;- l�1¤�k\�g�a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IXTw�KNR9b>�TR>�I_cM>�T:GH9bVKJbt�c�g<VXNH>NR9<I�Nw�MIKG"sug ["]}U^k�M�">�e4V_g<GHs�cM>�T�NR9b>de4V�IXTfG^>wGQN��*IXTR�*>wc��bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg�NR9<I�NFs�G"I�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K��s�g<GQNR>�I_cVK��e�VKg<GHs�cb>�TRsugbx�NH9<>�e4t�V_GHJbTH>�Jbg*cM>�TF>�pK>�TRP�e4V_g�NH>4LrN`VK���<IKTH�,>�c��bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��

`OVKgb>�NH9b>�tu>wGHG��<NR9b>�cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg VK�kNH9bs�GO>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>�cbV�>wG`gbVKN�cMs�TH>we�NRtuP��2VKt�tuV�� �2TRVK= s�NfG 3 e�VKJbgM£NR>�TRa<IXTHN���\�g<cM>�>wc��<�F9<>�TR>�IKG"NR9b>dVK�*G^>�THp�IX�<tu>��,>�9<I�prs�VKTfGFe4VKg*G^s�cM>�TR>�c�s�g <�<6��IKg<co3 IKTH>BNR9b>�prs�GHs��btu>V_JMNHa<JMNRG 9 I ef9bV_s�e�>�>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g�N�NHV VK�*G^>�THprs�gbx[�2TR>�>0g<IX=?>wG�s�g 9<>�IKc a*V�G^suNHs�VKg/s�g_3�5�:����">0ef9bVrV_GH>s�g<G^NH>wIKc[NRV0VK�<GH>�TRpK>�NH9b>�abTR>�GH>�g*e4>�VX��p�IKtuJb>wG��7�2V_tut�V��Fs�gbx�NR9b>?sug�NRJbs�NRsuV_g NH9<IXNBNR9b>?�<IKGHs�e�p�IXt�Jb>wGdIXTR>IK�<G^NHTfIKe�NRsuV_g<G��R``VKNH>:NH9*I�N�NR9bs�G�ef9bVKs�e4>:VX� �^VK�<GH>�TRp�IX�bt�>�G ��IXx_TH>�>�G��Fs�NR9?NH9b>`cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg?VK��Y0V_THTRs�GQ£�GQNQPrt�>>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>wGU�2VKT�NH9<>2�b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G\- m<��>�L����� �~@� ~@�21¤�d�Msug<e�>O�">�IKTH>`s�g�I�e4V_g<e4JbTRTR>�g�N�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G����">�IXt�GHVe�VKg<GHs�cM>�T"NH9*I�NOI�p�IXt�Jb>dsug0a<IKTRIKtut�>�t7�FsuNH9[IXg0IXTR�bsuNHTfIXTRP�abTRVre�>�GRG"s�GFI?p�IXt�Jb>_�

�#������� | �2¡������ ����� ~M}�z�{ � o �<IXTR���w��>"GHI�PBIXt�G^V�I �����!"� ��s�G�IFabTRVMe4>wGHGqxK>�g<>�TfI�NH>wcB��PBNR9b>��2V_tut�V��Fsug<xx_TRIK=?=?IKT��

! ���!n>a bkc�e f �� � t %���npf � �� a"! ��f�e �� a�f �#!�e �� vwhxEz$! �� i}j�l���n�� q�s%!

&�IKtuJ<>�G�IKTH>�NH9<> �QV_�<G^>�THp�IK�btu>�NH>�TH=�G �?VK�y3�5���K >�cM>�g<VXNH>$f('�NH9b>?�'I_e�NdNR9<I�NOf s�G�I0p�IKtuJ<>K��8:9b>�">�IAS0pK>�TfGHsuV_g[VX���<IKTH�*GOJ<GH>�cns�g NH9<>�cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg VX� ��� s�G�f*)���G^J*ef9 NH9*I�N�f+) s���NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�Ip�IKtuJb>,! GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXN;f /.-/!��

:<;k¥=: >

Page 12: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� v

K suNH9 NH9bs�G�cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g���I�p�IKtuJb>�s�G�I�abTHVMe�>�GRGFNH9*I�Nde�IXg TH>wcMJ<e4>��F9b>�gns�N�s�GBIKababt�su>wc0NHV0I�g*IX=?>K�7VKT�F9<>�g suN?s�G?GH>�t�>�e�NR>�c�� \�g a<IXTHNHs�e4Jbt�IXTw�kNH9<>�>�=�abNQP TH>we4VKTfc � � s�G�gbVKN?Inp�IXt�Jb>K� 8:9b>0cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg VK��^�,>�s�gbx�I?p�IKtuJ<>��B>�LrNH>�g*c#NHV�e4V_g_NR>4LrNRG`sug[I?GQNRTRIKsux_9�N^�2VKTR�:IXTfc��"I�P_�FKn>�GRI�P�NR9<I�N 5�'�su�kIKg<c#VKgbt�P�su�5 � � '��:\¤NOs�GO>�I_G^P�NHV�GH>�>�NR9<I�N 5�'�su=?abt�s�>�GFNR9<I�N"5 � f � '��2VKT�IXt�tqabTRVMe4>�GRGH>�G�f?�F�">4�2VKTR>dxKs�prsug<x�NH9b>cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg0VK���<IKTH�,>�c#e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�M�">dcM>4�*gb>�NH9b>�gbVKNHs�VKg0VX� 'N���\D ���N������������ TR>�t�I�NHs�VKgq�

�#������� | �2¡�������� ����¡ ��¡ { � | �2¡ � ~ � � 8:9b>OTR>�t�I�NRsuV_g��s�G"e4V_=�a,V_GHsuNHs�VKg<IKt5�_VKT�e�tuV�G^>wc?Jbg<cM>�T�>�pK>�THPe�VKg�NH>�LrN��Msu���2V_T`IXt�t�e4VKg�NR>4LrN75 IKg<c�e�VKJba<tu>,a�f %Gt�e i � �M�">d9<I�pK> Cya 5 � f � %�5 � t � e i � �

�:IKTH�,>�c#e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>Bs�G"NR9b>d�bs�xKxK>wGQN`e�VK=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg*IXt7�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g�NR9<I�N`a<TH>wG^>�THp_>�G"�<IXTR�<G��

�#������� | �2¡������ � ��� ~M}�z � ¢ ��¡ ��� } � � � � � � o TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg�� s�G�I �N����HG���MHG�N� ����� ����������� s��"�2VKT>�pK>�THP�e�VKJbabt�>�a�f %Nt�e i � �b��>�9<I�p_>ACa��Ge,f / f"-�s�=?abt�su>wG t /.-,t"-�IKg<c�a�f"-%Gt"-�e i� ��a� �Ge,f 'ds�=?abtus�>�G\t�)��8:9<>FTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg���s�G�IB��>wI&S��<IKTH�,>�c��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg��Ks�����IKg<c���� # IKTH>:�">�I&Sd�*IXTR�*>wc�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g<G��8:9<>�abTRVMe4>�GRGH>�G�f IKg<cOt IKTH>�V_�<GH>�TRp�IXNHs�VKg<IKtut�PO>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_Nw���FTHsuN^NR>�gOfp� � t��wsu�*IKg<c�VKgbt�P�s��}a�f %Gt�e i� �2VKT`GHVK=?>��">�I&S��<IXTR�*>wc��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg�� NH9<IXN:s�G`e�VK=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg*IXt��

�:9�; � C+I�F"=$C+GHD�=@? I�M�� UZC��"= ��� IKJ7Y�CERO=�J7A&=\�g NR9bs�G�G^>we�NHs�VKgq���">?abTHV�p_>�NH9<IXN��*>�NRI[e4V_grpK>�TfGHsuV_g s�G�I �Qp�IKtus�c t�I�����VK�F�<IXTR�*>wcne�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>AC�NH9<s�Gs�GB�2VKTR=�IXt�tuPnGQNfI�NH>wc s�g � >�=�=�I0jb� jb��8:9bs�G�>4LbIK=�a<tu>?s�Gdsug�NR>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx#GHs�g<e4>?suN�G^9bV��`G�9<V�����J<IXg�NRs��b£e�I�NRsuV_g V�pK>�TBIKgrP e4VKg�NR>4LrN�IXaba,>�IKTRG�sug cMs�TR>�e�N�abTRVrVX�'GBVX�:e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>�a<THV_a*>�T^NRsu>wG�����>��2VKTR>�a<THV�prs�gbx� >�=?=�I�jb� jb�_��>:�*TRG^N�xKs�pK>�G^V_=�>Fs�g�NH>�TH=?>�cbs�IKTHP�TH>wG^JbtuNRG���\�g � >�=?=�I�j<�u@_�K�">OGQNRJ<cMP�NH9b>�sug�NR>�TfIKe�NRsuV_g�,>4NQ�">�>�g�e�VKg�NH>�L�NfGkIXg<c�VK�<GH>�TRp�I�NHs�VKg*G���\�g � >�=�=�IBjb�@?M���">�x_sup_>"I�abTRVKa,>�THNQPBNH9<IXNkIKtut�V��`G�NRVdG^s�=?abtusu�2PNR9b>dTR>�IKGHVKg<sugbx�VKg#NH9<>dTH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g<G�NH9<IXNOI�TH>wcM>4L�e�IXg#a*>�T^�2V_TH= Jbg<cM>�TOI?e4VKg�NR>4LrN����� ~ �#��� � � ~M}�z�{�~ � ¢ ��¡ � | � � |�{ �"! �%�����RD��P�M'N���N� 5 � f � ���L�7�����!"�$#u��� �y��� ���P���&�P�L� �\'N�2�Q���&%' ���� ��� a��Ge ������'G�&�"� �'4 � 5 'N���"� ����"��� �����("�8�(%�)%*# 5 ',+ �Q������Q� a���Pe ������'N���"� � 4A� 5 �����&� �3�2�&�!"���������'N�&�"� �'4 �y�&��� f ���O� �2�&�!"�-%. } ¡�¡����"P�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg0VKg#NH9<>�GHs���>dVX� 5�� /

K > cM>4�<g<>nNR9b> �A��DE��� ���r�p'N���"� � 4A� 5��BcM>�gbVXNR>�c10�a 5;eH��IKG�NH9b> grJb=��,>�T0VK��IX�*GQNRTRI_e�NHs�VKg*G�IXg*ccb>�e4t�IXTfI�NRsuV_g<G�NH9<IXN�VKg<>�xKVr>�G�NR9bTRVKJbx_9 NRV[TH>wIKef9 NH9b>�9<VKt�>K��K >�IKt�GHV[G^Jba<a*V�G^>�NR9<I�NdNR9b>�cM>�aMNH9 VK�NR9b> e4V_g�NH>4LrN=a�i}j�l���n05.q�s�f�eR�"s�G20Ra�5;e43 �K� <�t�>�IKTHt�PK��NH9b>ncM>�aMNR9 s�G�a<TH>wG^>�THp_>�c �rP/GQNRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXt=�IKgbsua<Jbt�IXNHs�VKg0IXg<c�suN`>���J<IXt�G ��>�THV?su�kIKg<c�VKgbt�P�su� 5 s�GFIKg0>�p�IXt�J<I�NRsuV_g#e�VKg�NH>�LrN��

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 13: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

@0/ � ����2�&�������������R��!���

��� ~ �#� �.� ��� ¢ � � ~ � ¢ ��¡�� | � � |�{ ��! � 5 � aPagbkcRegf�e � � / t #���� ������� ���P� ���G��� �LD ���N�N��H���!��������a��Ge ������������ ��������� ���������������������� ��������� �"! �����Q�P�$� 4A���������='N�&�"� �'4 � 8 #��N"'��������&� t 1

8 � a�a bdcRegf �Ee�� � � �"� � # ���Q�P� � � � �"� �,��J_HG�o��� �����A�Q�"�����J���EH��N����� �����&�$#g�(%�)% �on ��% #��&��� ���Q�P� 8 �,��J�� ������ �,����� ��� #h�(%�)% � �.�M'N'Q ���P�Q��'N������� � &7� %('����P�N����Q� #E�������&�� DE�G�M'N���G�Q���� # �8� ���� 5 � � � / 8 � ��� � � ��� � #y�&��� 0Ra�8�e*) 0�a 5;e +

a� �Ge �����+������ ��������, �-���.�/�0����1���2�+���3���3! t 1 5 � f�� �#�2c�� � %. } ¡�¡���K >�VKgbt�P�x_sup_>�NR9b>�GPSK>�NRef9#VX��NH9bs�GFabTRVrVX�k9b>�TR>K��o�GOG^NRI�NR>�c�sug4-�@M/�1��b>�pK>�THP�a<THVMe4>wGHG:s�G`G^NHTRJ<e�£NRJbTfIXt�tuP�>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_N:NRV?I?g<VKTR=?IKt,�2VKTR=oC

v w�(xEz a�ikjIl��pq�s,a"! # � ��� ����!-4���5 # ����� �6�6587�� � � * � # �=��� � �6� � �:9 �<;d��e�e 9 @0:�F9<>�TR>�NR9b> ! � G�IXTR>?IX�<G^NHTfIKe4NHs�VKg<GBVKTdTR>�e�VKTfcbGMC�a bkc�e f V_T � t %���n�f � ��IKg<cnNH9b>�5 � G�IXTR>�IKababt�s�£e�I�NRsuV_g<GOV_TdG^>�tu>we�NHs�VKg*GQC�a�f �EeH��IXg<c �F9b>�TR>�f IXg<c�t IXTR>�IKt�GHV#sugngbVKTR=�IXt��2VKTR=#�OKn>�e�IKgnIKtu�:I�PMGGHJbaba,V_GH>?NH9*I�N�G^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTRIKtU>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>�s�GdJ*G^>wcnV_gbt�PnI�NdNR9b>��,>�x_sugbg<sugbx IKg<c I�NdNR9b>�>�g<c VK�:I0TR>4£cbJ<e�NRsuV_g��"8:9*I�NOs�G��<�2VKT`>�pK>�THP�TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g=f / f"-5�<�">�e�IKg IXt��"I�PMG:G^J<aba*V�G^>�NH9<IXN`NH9b>�TH>d>�LMs�G^N`NQ�"Va<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G�t IXg<c t - GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�N0C�f 1 t?��IKg<c t / t - �"IXg<c t - 1 f - �"IKg<c/G^J<ef9 NH9<IXN�NH9b>s�gM�2>�TH>�g<e4>dVK�%t / t"-�cMVr>�GFg<VXNOJ<GH>�TRJbt�> 9 TR>�c0>���Jbs�p�:��`Y0V_TH>�V�pK>�Tw�r��>�e�IXg[GHJbaba,V_GH>�NH9<IXN t s�G`s�gNR9b>dgbV_TH=�IXt,�2V_TH= cb>4�<gb>wc#��P�>���J<IXNHs�VKg 9 @0:4�\�g VKJbT�e�IKGH>K���">�e�IXg G^J<aba*V�G^>�NR9<I�N�NH9<>?e�VKg�NH>�LrN�5hs�G�s�g gbVKTR=�IXt��2VKTR=0��8:9b>?abTRVrVX��s�G�=�IKcM>

�rP�sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g[VKg#NH9b>�G^s���>dVK� 5��LK >�VKgbt�P�G^NHJ*cMP�NQ�"V�e�I_G^>wG��"8:9b>��<TfGQNOs�GF�F9b>�g�5pn bncfe a�8 �0eH�"\¤�5 � a�agbdc�e f�e � � / t?�rNR9b>�TR>dIXTR>BNQ��V?a,V_GRG^s��bs�tusuNHs�>�GMC

= �K~b{ � 8 � aPagbFc�e f�e � � } � ¢���� � {K� �">BJ*G^>�NR9b>dsug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_g�9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G �= �K~b{ � |�� � } � � {�~ %�� } � ¢����X| �2¡��   � | � ~b} � �� � � | � � IKg<c�NH9b>�TH>wcM>4L�s�GFs�g 8���\¤�kNH9b>d9bV_tu>����� ��s�GBgbVKN�s�g NR9b>?TH>wcM>4L��7NR9b>�g ��>?IXTR>�s�g e�IKGH>�a�GeH���FsuNH9 ��n �,��\¤� ����� s�G�s�gnNH9b>?TR>�cM>�L7�G^s�g<e�>98 s�GOs�g gbV_TH=�IKtq�2V_TH=0�7��>�9<I�pK>�8 � a�a bdc�e f�e � � 1 a�agb ��e?> � a�a�bFc�e f�e � � eR��IXg<c[NH9b>�TH>��2VKTR>t 1@> � a�a�bFc�e�f�e � � � � � �"�X��8:9bs�GFs�GFe�IKGH>�a��GeH�

8:9<>�GH>�e4V_g<c[s�g�NH>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx�e�IKGH>�s�GO�F9<>�g 5 nSbncfe;a�i}j�l���n 8rq�s"� � � � eH��IKg<c[�F9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg s�G5 � a�agbdc�e f�e � � / a�i}j�l���n 8 � aPagbdcRe�f�e � � q�s�� � 8 � a�agbdc�e f�e � ��� eR�k8:9<s�G�s�G�e�IKGH>8a��GeR�_�F9b>�TH> ��n �7�_IXg*cNR9b>�TR>�GHJbtuNHs�gbx�e4V_g�NH>4LrN`9<I_GFNQ�"V�9bVKt�>�G��6``VXNR>dNH9*I�NONR9b> 9 TH>wc[cM>4�G:`THJ<tu>�s�GFNR9b>�V_gbtuP#TR>�cMJ<e4NHs�VKg0TRJbtu>NR9<I�NOe�IXg0cMJbabt�s�e�I�NR>BNH9b>d9bV_tu>ds�g0I�e4VKg�NR>4LrN�� /

K suNH9#NR9b>�GH>�NQ��V?t�>�=?=�IKG��M��>de�IXg#abTHV�p_>ONR9b>dabTRsug*e4s�a<IXt�TR>�GHJbtuN:VK��NR9bs�G`G^>we�NRsuV_g����� ~ �#� � � ��� |�~ ��¡ � A*� }�{ �2¡�� �CB ������ ���8������HG�Q�g���P�N�&"'��������p���=�����&� � �2H��P����'���� �����& ���J2��� ��� ! aPagbkcRegf �Ee�� � f�� � ��c�� %. } ¡�¡��,� ��� ~ �#� � � � >4N � �*>�NR9b>dTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg�C

� nED�F�jHG"a�5 � agbFc�e�f � � % 5 � f�� � ��c�� � e �� �2VKT`IXt�t 57%Pf IXg<c �2I`OVXNR>[NH9<IXN�NH9<s�G�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg s�G�e4t�>�IXTRt�P e4V_=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg<IKt5� K > abTRV�pK>#NH9<IXN � IXg<c � � # IXTR>[��>wI&S�*IXTR�*>wcnGHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg*G�� � >4NOf # IXg<crf �*>?NR9b>�abTRVMe4>�GRGH>�G�cM>4�*gb>�c �rP�C�f # nSbncfe 5 � a�bFc�e f � � IXg*c

:<;k¥=: >

Page 14: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� @_@

f� ;n bncfe 5 � f�� � ��c�� � �h�rJba<a*V�G^>�fW#OTR>�cMJ*e4>�G�s�gof"-# �M�">�a<THV�p_>FNH9<IXN:NH9b>�TH>B>4LMs�GQNfG"I�abTRVre�>�GRGyf"- G^J*ef9NR9<I�N�f� / f"- IKg<c=f"-# �Bf"- ���OGHsug<x � >�=�=�I�jb�@?M�,��>�e�IXg >4LM9bs��bs�NBNQ�"V�e�I_G^>wG��BZUs�NR9b>�T�f"-# n f� K�IKg<c[�">�J<GH>�NR9b>��'I_e�NONR9<I�N�f� �Bf� X�7VKT f -# n 8 � a�a bdc�e f �Ee�� � � �"� � �O\�g[NR9bs�GBe�IKGH>K��f� �e�IKg[TH>wcMJ<e4>NRV.f"- n 8 � f�� �#��c�� � � � �"� � IXg<c4a�f"-# %Pf"- e:s�G`s�g � ��8:9b>�abTRV�VK�Us�GBG^s�=?sut�IXT�s����">�GHJbaba,V_GH>dNR9<I�N�f TR>�cbJ<e4>wG��LKn>�abTRV�pK>dIXt�G^V?NR9<I�N�a�f # %Gf e i � IKg<c f # ' 9 TH>wG^a,>�e4NHs�pK>�t�P.f '2::s�=?abtus�>�G\f ) 9 TR>�GHa��f # )}:�C

= G^J<aba*V�G^>8f # '_�bGHs�g<e4>,aPa�bdcRegf �"e�s�G:gbVKNOI�p�IKtuJb>_��5 � � � 'd�2V_T`IXt�t�� IXg*c�NR9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>�f ' �= G^J<aba*V�G^>�f� '���8:9b>�TH>dIKTH>�NQ�"V�e�IKGH>�G�� a�Pe��2VKT`IXt�tR��� 5 � � � '��<IXg<c��bsug[a*IXTHNHs�e4Jbt�IXTw��fW# ' � a���Pe5 s�GFIXg0>�p�IKtuJ*I�NHs�VKg0e4V_g�NH>4LrN`IXg*c.f����#��c�� '_�k\�g#NH9<s�G`e�IKGH>K��f # / f� '�IKg<c�NR9rJ<G f # )��

8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K� � IXg*c ��� # IXTR>���>wI&S��*IXTR�*>wc��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg*G��<IKg<c�NH9rJ<GMC;a�f %Gt�e i ��� fp� � t?�8:9<>B>�LMa*>we�NH>wc#TH>wG^JbtuN:�2VKt�tuV��`G:�rP�ef9<V�V�G^s�gbx 5Bn ����� � /

K suNH9 I GHsu=?s�t�IKT�abTRVrVX�Q�FsuN#s�G�a*V�GHGHsu�<tu> NHV a<THV�p_> I GHsu=?s�t�IKT�TR>�GHJbt�N��2VKT0cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g �2>4Nfef9bs�gbx<�OGH>�>S�THV_a*V�G^suNHs�VKg0jb��@��,>�t�V��d��8:9b>�abTRVrVX��s�GFV_=�suN^NR>�c#s�g�NR9bs�G:TH>�a*V_T^Nw�

. } ¡���¡ { � | �2¡ � ��� � ������� �#� | �2¡ ���q� |��� �$� � � ikj�l���np��q�s � ���4i}j�l���n�� q�sO�

� � � � �`���+ ���������� ��4�����?�� ��`� � �f ��� ���0�#�f k�4�����

\�g NH9bs�G�G^>we�NRsuV_g�����>�cM>4�*gb>�I�t�IX�,>�t�>�c[NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_gnGHPrG^NH>�= �2VKTBNH9b>��bt�Jb>�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G���K >�TR>�e�IXt�tqNR9<I�Na�f��EeUcb>�gbVKNH>�G:>�s�NR9b>�T`IKg#IKababt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g a�f�mReR�MVKT`I?G^>�tu>we�NRsuV_g a�f ,�eH�FK >�cb>4�<gb>��2V_JbT`cMs�k,>�TH>�g�N6Srs�g<cbGVK��I_e�NHs�VKg*G:sug#NH9<>dt�IK�*>�tu>wc�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg0GHPrG^NH>�=�C

� ���!n�� �� � � �������� mk~�a�|&��0|��e��� q�s8mk~�a |���M|�"e8:9<>�GH>��2V_JbT`IKe4NHs�VKg<GFIKTH>BTR>�GHa*>we�NHs�pK>�tuP�C{ � � � � |�~b�K| �2¡ � ��� ��� �F9bs�ef9/e4V_THTR>�GHa*V_g<cbG�NHV sug�NR>�TRg<IXt"TH>wcMJ<e4NHs�VKg�� � s�S_>�s�gB3d�UNQ�"V a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G�s�g

a<IXTfIXt�t�>�t�e�IXg GHPrg<ef9bTRVKgbs���>�cMJ<THs�gbx I e�VK=?=�J<gbs�e�I�NRsuV_g�� 8:9bs�G�s�G�TRJbt�> 9 a<IKT�e�VK=$:�VX�FNR9b>�t�I�£�*>�tu>wc�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg�G^PMG^NH>�= 9 t5� N�� G��@:��FK >�IXt�G^V�9*I�pK>FNRV�e�VKg<GHs�cb>�T�NQ�"V�VKNH9b>�T�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg�a<I�NHNH>�TRg<GNH9bV_JbxK9q�F��gb>:�2V_T�IXa<abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg��_e4VKTRTR>�GHa*V_g<cMs�gbxONRV�NH9b>OTH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g�TRJbt�> 9 TR>�c��,>4NRII:UIXg*c�NRV�NH9b>THJ<tu> 9 IXaba�e�VK=$:�VX�7NR9b>`t�� Nw� G��u�U8:9b>OVXNH9<>�TU�2V_T�cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g��_NH9<IXN�e4V_THTR>�GHa*V_g<cbG�NRV�NH9b>`TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_gTHJ<tu> 9 TH>wc�cM>��G:FIKg<c�NRV?NH9b>dTRJbt�> 9 cM>��ke�VK=$:"VX��NH9b>dt�� Nw� G�� �

�'~ z�¢�~ ~b�X| �2¡ � � � � ��� �F9<s�ef90s�GOIXg[I_e�NHs�VKg#a,>�TH�2VKTR=�>wc#��P#I?p�IXt�Jb>K�,G^>�>dTHJbt�>�G 9 t�IX=��7cbII:"�*>�tuV��d�IXg<c#�F9bs�ef90e4VKTRTR>�GHa*V_g<cbG�NHV�I �M£�IX�*GQNRTRI_e�NHs�VKg#VKTFI�TR>�e4V_TRc �

� � ~b�X| �2¡��+��q�sOm}~ a |���0|�Ee ��� �F9bs�ef9 s�G�IXg sug<abJMN�VK�"NR9b>�g<IK=?>�G$|�nVKg NH9b>�ef9<IXgbg<>�t%m���8:9b>?NRJbabt�> |���s�G�J<GH>�cnNHV[TR>�=?>�=��*>�TdNH9<>�IXaba<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg<G �GH>�t�>�e4NHs�VKg<G�NH9*IXg VKg<>�xKVr>�GBNR9bTHV_JbxK9 NRV[TH>wIKef9 NH9b>cM>�e�t�IKTRIXNHs�VKg �

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 15: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

@2? � ����2�&�������������R��!���

¡ �q|�~b�K| �2¡ � � ����� mk~�a�|&��2|�"e ��� �F9bs�ef9 s�GBIKg VKJbNHabJMN�VX�UNR9b>�g<IX=?>�GBs�gB|�,��VKg[NR9b>?ef9<IXgbg<>�tkm��B\�gnIKgVKJMNRabJMN`IKe4NHs�VKg�Cdf���������� �� ��� ���������������� /�a�� �Gf"-WeR�rNH9b>�NHJba<tu>.|&�s�G�NH9<>�GH>4N"VX� �^VKa,>�g<>�c �OTR>�G^NHTRs�e4NHs�VKg<G�s�� >_�u�NH9b>�G^>�N�VX�:TH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>�G�s�g�|�[NR9<I�N��">�TR>?TH>wGQNRTHs�e�NR>�c IXg*cnV_a*>�gb>�c 9 GHe�VKa,>�>4LrNHTRJ<GHsuV_gE:���\�g NH9b>GHIK=?>�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g��rNH9b>d>�grp�s�TRVKgb=?>�g�N� e4VKTRTR>�GHa*V_g<cbG�NHV�NH9<>dVKa,>�gb>wc#cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg*G��

8�V cMs�GQNRsug<xKJbs�G^9 NR9b>�cbs�k7>�TR>�g�N�I_e�NHs�VKg*G�����>��Fs�t�t�VX� NR>�g J<GH>�NR9b> ��S�s�g<c VK�"NR9b>�I_e�NHs�VKg � ���kcM>�gbVKNH>wc� a � eR��GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�N � a � e i ��� % � % � � � %Pq�s �_�?\�g VKJbTBNRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg GHPrG^NH>�=�G��qcb>4�<gb>wc s�g��r>�e4N���m*�u@_��NH9b>NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g<G�e�IKg �*>#GHef9b>�=�I�NHs�e�IKtut�Pncbsuprs�cM>�c s�g NQ��Vne�I�NR>�x_VKTRsu>wG��#8:9b>��<TfGQN�e�I�NR>�x_VKTRP e4V_THTR>�GHa*V_g<cNRV0NH9b>�NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g<G�f����� / f"-'�UGHJ<ef9 NH9<IXN � a � e i � � %��=%Gq�s �_��8:9<>�G^>we4V_g<c e�I�NR>�x_VKTRP e4V_THTR>�GHa*V_g<cNRV >�=�s�GRG^s�VKg<GMC,f�� �������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Gf"-�eR� \�g NH9bs�G�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�� � cM>�g<VXNH>wG�NR9b>�>�grp�s�TRVKgb=?>�g�N�a � # n� # %M~Q~M~3%�� % n�� % eR�<IXg*cof"-�s�GFI�abTRVMe4>�GRG����� ~M}�� \�g�NR9b>dcM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g�VK�qNH9<>BV_JMNHa<JMN`IKe�NRsuV_g � � � mk~ a�|&��0|�EeH�M�">�s�=?abt�s�e�s�NRtuP�e�VKg<GHs�cM>�T"NH9*I�N:NH9b>NRJbabt�>�VX�UTR>�G^NHTRs�e4NH>wc�g*IX=?>�G�|&�s�G`gbVKN`VKTfcM>�TR>�cuC���>�e�VKg<GHs�cM>�TFNR9<I�N�s�NOs�GOI �^GH>4N �f�:8:9bs�G`s�GFsu=?a,VKTHNRIKg_NNRV?abTHV�p_>�a<THV_a*>�T^NRsu>wGFG^J<ef90IKGMChv�wLxEzWv�w��IzWf! #"Lv�w��Iz�v�wyxEzf?� /

8�V GHsu=?abt�s��2P NR9b>�abTR>�GH>�g�NfI�NHs�VKg VX�:NR9b>�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg TRJbt�>�G�IKg<c NH9<>�abTRV�VK�'G����">�VK=?suN�NHV cb>4�<gb>�NH9b>GHPr=?=�>�NHTRs�e�VX��NH9b>�THJ<tu>wGBe�VKg<e�>�TRgbs�gbx�a<IKTRIKtut�>�t�e4V_=�a,V_GHsuNHs�VKg��8K >�IXt�G^V#cMV�g<VXNBNRI&S_> 6q£¤e�VKgrpK>�TRGHs�VKgs�g�NHV�IKe�e�VKJbg�Nw�kY0V_TH>`�2VKTR=?IKtut�PK���">�e4V_g<GHs�cM>�T�NR9<I�N"�*V_Jbg<c�g*IX=?>�G�IXTR>OIXt��"I�PMG�Jbgbs��_J<>�IXg*c�cMs�k,>�TH>�g_N�2TRVK= >wIKef9 VKNH9b>�TMC�suN?s�G?GHJ �e4s�>�g�N�NRV s�=?abtus�e4suNHt�P NfI&SK>#IXg Jbg<cM>�THt�PrsugbxnTH>�abTR>�GH>�g�NRIXNHs�VKg VX�`g*IX=?>�G�*IKGH>�c[V_g �O>?�"THJ<s WQgnsug<cbs�e�>�G�-u@��01��8`OVKgb>�NH9b>�tu>wGHG��7��>��Fsut�tkgbVXNB>4LMabt�s�e�s�NRtuP[J<GH> ��>?��TRJbs WQg s�g<cMs�e4>wG��8:9<s�G�G^V_tuJMNRsuV_g?s�G�IXt�TH>wIKcMP�g<VXN�NRTRI_e�NRIK�bt�>:�2VKT�9<IKg<c?=�IKcM>OabTHVrVK�'GUsug?NR9b>7�b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��_IKg<c?s�N�s�G�TH>wIXt�tuPa*IXs�gM�2Jbt<s�g?NH9<> 77£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<GMC�GH>�>:NR9b>`�"VKTGS�VK� ���%$OsuTfGRef9�SKV k=-u@�M1���VKg�e�VK=?abJMNR>�TH£¤IKs�cb>�c��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_ga<THVrVX�'G��2V_T 3��

8:9b>�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g#TRJbt�>�G:abTR>�GH>�g�NR>�c�sug0NR9bs�GOG^>we�NHs�VKg0IXTR>�gbVKgb£¤G^NRIKg<cbIXTfc��M>�pK>�g#su�kTRJbt�>�GFe�VKg<e�>�TRgbsug<xt�IX=��,c<I�I_e�NRsuV_g<GFIXTR>�abJMNOIKGHs�cM>K��SkIXTHN`VX��NH9b>�suT�e4VK=?abt�>4LMsuNQP�TR>�GHJbt�NF�2TRVK= NH9b> �^a*V_tuP�IKcMs�e ��g<I�NRJbTR>BVK�NR9b>Fe�IKt�e�JbtuJ*GQC�=?V_TH>�NH9<IKg�V_gb>"g<IX=?>:=�I�Pd�*>:>4Lbef9<IKgbxK>wc�s�g�IBe4V_=?=�Jbgbs�e�IXNHs�VKg���o`gbVKNH9b>�TUG^V_JbTRe�>�VK�e�VK=?abt�>4LMsuNQP��2V_tut�V��`G��2THV_= NH9b>B9bs�xK9b>�T^£¤VKTfcM>�T�abTH>wG^>�g�NRI�NRsuV_g�VX�qNH9b>BVKJMNRabJMN`IKe4NHs�VKg<G���\�g�I�NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_gf&�'�������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-�eH�7�2V_TO>4LbIK=�a<tu>_�*NR9b>?G^>�N�� s�G�G^V_=?>�9bV�� �^a<IXTHN ��VX��NH9b>�t�IK�*>�t5�d8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>���>IKTH>?s�g I#GHsuNHJ<IXNHs�VKg e4V_=�a*IXTfIX�bt�>�NRV0NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg G^PMG^NH>�=�G��F9b>�TH>�a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G�IKaba*>wIXTds�g t�IK�*>�t�G,-@? �21����J<TOt�� Nw� G��Oe�IKg[�*>�cMs�GQNRsugbx_Jbs�G^9b>wc#�2THV_= NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g G^PMG^NH>�= �2V_T`NH9<>O77£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G`�2VKT�VXNH9<>�TOTR>�I_G^V_g<G��\�g*cM>�>wc��<s�g[VKJbTOt5� N�� G������r£5NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg*G`IXTR>dgbVXN`>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_NONHV�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKg*GFVK�MNfIXs�gb>�c#�rP�NH9b>�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g/ ���<VKTF>�LMIK=?abtu>��">�9<I�pK> C

� xo t � ��ikj�l��$n�� q�s�a�m � ��f�e / i}j�l���n�� q�s$aPa�t*�ue,��f�e��(� / 1 i}j�l���n�� q�s$aPa�t*�ue,�Fa�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf�e�e

8:9b>BG^V_JbTfe4>`VK��NH9bs�G�cbs�k7>�TR>�g<e�>Ot�su>wG�s�g�NR9b>ONRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�THJbt�>�G��2VKT ����� I_e�NRsuV_g<G�IKg<c��r=?VKTR>`a<IXTHNHs�e�£J<t�IKTHt�P�s�g�NR9b>�TRJbt�> 9 cM>4�UV_a*>�gE:��<NH9<IXNOe4VKg*e4>�TRg<G"NR9b>�cM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g[VKa,>�TfI�NRVKTw��\�g�NRJbs�NRsup_>�t�PK�MNR9b>�a,VKs�g�N`s�GNR9<I�N`I�abTRsup�I�NR>�TR>�GHVKJ<TRe�>O=�I�P�gbVXN:�,>�e4VK=?=�Jbgbs�e�I�NR>�c�VKJMNfG^s�cM>Bs�N`GRe4VKa,>K�k\�g<G^NH>wIKc��bI_G"s�NFs�G"cbVKgb>�s�gTRJbt�> 9 cM>���V_a*>�gE:��b�">de4TR>�IXNH>dI?e4VKarP�VK�qNR9b>dTH>wG^V_JbTfe4>BJ<G^s�gbx�I��2TH>wG^90g<IK=?>K�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 16: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� @wj

�79�; <>=�� JSD5G+D0IKJ I�MoGHN7=���U �"=@V0= ��� C+U JS? D0G+D0IKJ��O?�GH=@[y ���2¡ {

a�bdcRegf ��� ���� / f��Qm��2c��� �������������� � ��������� ��� � � �� ����������� / a�� � e� �� �"!#�

� � %���n%$ � ���'&� � /($ ���� �����"�)� � � % �un*$ � ���'+��� / a��9*"e a5s��-, gn � e� ��������������

� x� f�� �/. 0 �� � 1 � ���� ��������� / a�f |�Ee� 2��3546�7�

� � � � { �¤¡ }�|�~ �-8��2~ z�¢�~ ~ � ¢ �$� ~<�X| �'¡�� {

f ��� ���� / f"-f ��t � � ���� / f"- �Fa�t �Ee . µ�¨f¸�ª·¨f§�&K²�¨ 1

f ��� ���� / f"-f � � (� / f"- . ¨fµ�µ�¤Q°�§71

f!�'(� / f"-f �Rt!� (� / f"- �Rt . µ�¨f¸���¨N� 1

f!��(� / f"-f � � (� / f"- � . ¨fµ�µ;�¤¨N�21

f!���� /�f"- a � a � e i ��� % � %Pq�s �:9 m gi l sha � e�ev�wLxEz�f � �� / v�wyxEzf"- . ¯0��� §y� 1

f ���� / f"- a � a � e i � � %��=%Gq�s �;9 � gi l sya � ePei}j�l���n�� q�s�f � �� / i}j�l���n�� q�sOf"- . ²2��¹<§L� 1

� � � � { �¤¡ } �$� ~b�K| �2¡ � {

f � . 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / f"-f��Rt �<. 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / f"-��Fa�t |�0e . µ�¨f¸q©«¯ 1

f � . 0 �� � �>=@? 1 ��� ������������������ / f"-a�fBA�e �<. 0 �� � 1 � � ������������ / f"- . ¨fµ�µ�©«¯ 1

� � � � { �¤¡ } ¡ ��|?~b�X| �2¡ � {

f � �������� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Pf"-�e a�|&�%Pikj�lAa���e�e�'$l sya�t�ekn �f��Rt ���������� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Qa�f - �ut�e�e . µ�¨f¸�°��0�f1

f!�'�������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Gf"-We A gi a�|&�%Gi}j�l a���ePea�fCA2e � � ������ �� ��� � � ?D= � ������������������ / a�� �Ma�f"-EA2ePe . ¨fµ�µ�°��M�51

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 17: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

@�m � ����2�&�������������R��!���

f ���������� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Pf"-�e a�& gi m %2|&�%0|�(%Pl sha���ePev�w��IzWf ���������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� ��v�w��Izf"-�e . ¯2� � °��0�f1

f ���������� �� ��� � �������������� / a�� �Pf"-�e a�m gn+&Eevw ��zf � �������� � � � ? � ��� � ������������������ / a�� �Pf - e . ¯2� � °�µ&�^¯21

f!� �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Gf - e a�� gi m�%�|&(%0|�(%Gl s%a���e�eikj�l���np��q�sOf!� �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Gi}j�l���n�� q�s�f"-�e . ²2��¹<°��0�f1f!� �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Gf"-We a���gi m %�|&�%Pikj�lAa���e�e

ikjIl���n�� q�sOf � � ������ �� ��� ���������������� / aPa���n�� % ��e �PikjIl���n�� q�sOf"-�e . ²2��¹<°�µA�Q¯ 1

��¡ � �#� �K~M| �2¡�� } � � � {

f ��������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-�e t �/. 0 �� �>� � ���� ��������� / t"-f��Rt � (� / v w (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s�a�f"- �Rt"-�e�e . µ�¨f¸R¤Q°�§71

f!� �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Gf"-Weikj�l��$n�� q�sOf!�'(� / ikj�l���np��q�s�v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s,a�� |� ��f"-WePe . ²2��¹"¤Q°�§71

�79 8 <>=�� JSD5G+D0IKJ I�MoGHN7=�<>=$M ,)�SD ?BD�[ RSV0UZG+D0IKJ��G^s�gbx�NH9b>?t�IX�,>�t�>�c NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKgnGHPMGQNR>�= �2V_T�NR9b>?�bt�Jb>�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G���suN�s�GBa*V�GHGHs��btu>�NHV[cM>��<gb>�I�t�IK�*>�tu>wc�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq�rcb>�gbVKNH>�c " �bGRI�P�cM>4� £¤�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��U8:9b>�VKa,>�TfI�NRVKT���|���rcM>�g<VXNH>wG"NH9b>dGHs ��> 9 grJb=��,>�TVK��>�tu>�=�>�g�NRGN:"VX�qNR9b>�NHJ<abtu>.|�<�

�#������� | �2¡����#� ������� � �2~M}#|� � � � { � �bVKT�>�pK>�THP�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg � ���">�cM>�g<VXNH>�a�i}j�l��pq�s.|�"e � a�ikjIl���-Qq�s |�0eNR9b>��'IKe4N:NH9<IXNFNH9b>�NQ�"V��2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx�abTHV_a*>�T^NRsu>wG:9bVKt�c��a��Ge |��IKg<c |��9<I�p_>ONR9b>�GRIX=?>dG^s���>_�bGHI�P �U�U8:9<IXN`s�GMC��|��In�� |���An � �a� �Ge��2VKT`IKtut=� i � �A~ ~ � � �rNR9b>dg<IX=?>wG � UIKg<c � kt�sug�S�NHV�TR>�t�I�NH>wc�TR>�GHVKJ<TRe�>�G�s5� >K���

a�ikj�l��pq�s�� e ��a�i}j�l���-Mq�s�� eH�

K >�cM>��<gb>K�*sug ��>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g[m<�@?M�MNR9b>dTR>�t�I�NHs�VKg0VK�kcM>�� £��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq�MNH9<IXNO>���J<IXNH>wGFabTRVre�>�GRG^>wG:VK�M£NfIXs�gb>�c��rP� `TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g�VX�*NH9b>FcM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg�VKa,>�TfI�NHV_TRG��_�Xt�s�S_>��2V_T�>�LbIX=?abt�>AC%a�i}j�l���n���q�s,a�f �Rt�e�e

:<;k¥=: >

Page 18: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� @��

IKg<c a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�a�a�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf�e,�Rt�e�eH��\�g��r>we�Nw�(��IXg<c#lb�M�">�abTHV�p_>ONR9<I�NFNR9bs�G:>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>s�G:s�g<e4t�J<cM>wc�s�g0�<IXTR�,>�c#e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K�

�#������� | �2¡����#��� ����� �5� z � { � � �2~M| �2¡�� � 8:9b> TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg�� s�G�I GQNRTHV_gbx��X£�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��:su�d�2VKT�IKtuta�f %Gt�e i � NH9b>�NR9bTH>�>��2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx�abTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G:9bV_t�cuCa��Ge?s��hf&���� / f"-�IKg<c � a � e"gi � ����� �_�*NH9<>�g[NR9b>�TR>�>�Lrs�G^NRGOI�abTHVMe�>�GRG;t"-�G^J<ef90NR9<I�N8t ���� / t�-qIXg*c

f"- � t�- �a� �Ge?s��Lf&� �������� �� ��� 1 �� ����������� / a�� �}f"-WeR�7NH9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�>�Lrs�G^NRGBI�abTRVMe4>�GRG\t�-�IKg<c IKg >�grprsuTRVKg<=�>�g�N ��-kG^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t ���������� �� ��� = �� ����������� / a��o- �Nt"-WeR�<IXg*c.f"- � t"-5�<IXg<c a�ikj�l��pq�s |�Me ��a�i}j�l���-Qq�s�|A2e �

a��� �Ge��2VKT`IKtutqGHJb�<G^NHsuNHJbNHs�VKg<G��k�*VX��g*IX=?>�G"�2V_TFp�IKTHs�IX�<tu>wG��r�">d9<I�pK>�f���� t��k�o TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g NR9<I�N�p_>�TRs��*>�GBabTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G�a��GeOIKg<c a����Ge:s�G�e�IXt�tu>wc I �A�P�� ���o����� � ��������� ��K >�GHI�P[NR9<I�N� s�G`I��K£��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg��<s��U�,VXNH9 � IXg*c ��� # IXTR>��X£�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg<G���8:9b>�G^NHTRVKg<x?cb>4� £¤�bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_gTR>�t�I�NRsuV_g #"F��s�G?cM>4�<g<>�c �rP�C�f #"ht?��s��`NR9b>�TR>#>4LMs�G^N�I G^NHTRVKgbx��X£¤�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g � ��GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�Nf � t?�

\¤N�s�G�>wIKGHP[NHV abTHV�p_>�NR9<I�N�NH9b>�cb>4� £¤�bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g cbV�>wGdgbVKN�ef9<IXTfIKe4NH>�THs���>��<IXTR�,>�c e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�\�g*cM>�>wc��*IKg[su=?a,VKTHNRIXg�N�IKtux_>��bTfIXs�eBt�I�� VX�kNR9b>�I_G^Prg<ef9bTRVKg<VKJ<GL77£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<GO-u@0Y21¤�bNH9*I�N�s�GF�'IKt�GH>ds�g[NH9b>GHPrg<ef9bTRVKgbV_J<G�VKgb>_��s�G�mka�cReP~�mEc�� �?\�g NR9b>��bt�Jb>�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G��">�e�IKg abTRV�pK>?I0G^s�=?sut�IXT�t�I��d��NH9<IXNds�G� x m$�F� � �7�bJMNdVK�rprs�VKJ<GHtuP � x m$�Sg " � ��GHsug<e�>�NR9b>��2VKTR=�>�T�e�IXgncbV�IXgnsug<abJMNdIKe�NRsuV_g IXg*cNR9b>#t�IXN^NH>�T�s�G�sugb>�T^Nw� 8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�UI �<TRG^N �^s�=�a<THV�p_>�=?>�g�N ��e�VKJbt�c �,>�NRVncM>��<gb>0IXg �HIKGHPrg<ef9bTRVKgbV_J<G�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg �f�bI_G:�"I_G"cbVKgb>B�2VKT�3 s�g�- j21¤�

K suNH9�IXg?IKGHPrg<ef9bTRVKgbV_J<G��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g���NH9b>F>w��J<IXt�s�NQP � xo m$�6� �X�,>�e�VK=?>�GUIKg�IKtux_>��bTfIXs�e�t�I��VK�MNH9b>:GHPrG^NH>�=0�}``V_gb>4NR9b>�t�>�GRG��w�">��,>�t�s�>�pK>�NH9*I�NqNR9bs�G�>w��J<IXt�s�NQP�s�GqVK�btusuN^NRtu>"J<GH>K��>wG^a,>�e�s�IKtut�P�sugdNR9b>:e�IKGH>�G�F9<>�TR>"V_gb>:�"IKg�NRG�NHVda<THV�p_>�abTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G�VK�*NRTRIKg<GQ�2V_TH=�IXNHs�VKg<G�VKTUs�g�NH>�THabTR>4NfI�NRsuV_g<G��XI_Gks�N�s�GkNR9b>`e�I_G^>:s�g�M>�e�Nw�blb��@K��\�g<cM>�>�c��rNR9b>�abTHVMe�>�GRG � x� m$�`e�TH>wI�NR>�G:I��HGHsut�tuP�t�s�g�S����*>�NQ��>�>�g#I�g<IK=?>�IKg<c�suNRGH>�tu��CkNH9<s�Ga<THVMe4>wGHGBgb>�pK>�T�IKaba,>�IXTfGBsug abTfIKe4NHs�e�IXtU>�LbIX=?abt�>�G���o"N�NH9<>�VKaba,V_GHs�NR>K���">�e�IKg abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN�NH9b>�abTRVX£e�>�GRGFa�ikj�l���n�m;q�s�f�ePC�NR9b> �^>���J<IXNHVKT ��VK� ��IXg<c�m�sug�f?��s�GqGHJ<ef9�NH9*I�Nha�i}j�l"�,n�m;q�s�f�e�� " f��Mm�� ���K�

8:9b>�TH>�s�GBIXgbVKNH9b>�T`>4LbIK=�a<tu>�VK�UabTHVMe�>�GRG^>wG:NH9<IXNBIKTH>dgbVKNBcM>�� £��<s�GHsu=?s�t�IKT��*�F9bs�tu>�NH9b>�P#IKTH>��,>�9*I�p_£s�VKTfIXt�t�P�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g�N�� � >�N;f�IKg<cot �,>�NH9b>dabTRVMe4>wGHGH>�G

f nSbncfe v�w F�zga�i}j�l���n v�w�0z � 7l��H��q�s,a�m � � � F) � # �0ePet nSbncfe v�w F�zga�i}j�l���n q�s$a�m � � � F) � �2ePe

�Msug<e�> �QgbV_�*VMcMP#e�IKg#e�VK=?=�Jbg<s�e�I�NH> ���FsuNH9#NH9b>dg*IX=?> AOs�g�v�w�Mz � 7l �B���bs�N`s�G:VK�rprs�VKJ<G"NR9<I�Nvw�0z � Sl �H�F��� ��8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�qGHsug<e�>�NH9b>�g<IK=?>��[TH>�=�IXs�g<GBabTHs�p�I�NR>K�qg<VK�,VrcbP e�IKg e�VK=?=�J<gbs�e�I�NR>�FsuNH9�NH9b>dcM>we4t�IXTfI�NRsuV_g � F� �"���F``VKg<>4NH9<>�t�>�GRG�NR9b>BabTHVMe�>�GRGyf e�IXg�=?IASK>ONH9b>dIKe4NHs�VKg � ��� m}~ a�������eH�� ¨f¯�²\��®��^¯������������� �"! £M�q¶2�Q¸�� � � ©«­u��¶2�d���H¨$#O²2��¹&% &�©«­�©«§y��ª·¨G�5©«°�¯�±

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 19: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

@wl � ����2�&�������������R��!���

�F9<sut�>�t e�IXg[VKg<tuP0=�I&S_>�NH9b>�IKe�NRsuV_g � � � mk~�a '����ueR�O8:9<IXN�s�G��,VKgbt�P#sug[NR9b>��*TRG^NONRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKgq�<�">�e�IKgV_�<GH>�TRpK>�NH9<IXNFI?a<THs�p�I�NH>�g<IK=?>Bs�GF>�L�NRTHJ*cM>�c��8:9bs�GFt�IKG^NF>4LbIX=?abt�>�s�G:NQPrabs�e�IKt�VX�k�F9<I�NF9<IKaba,>�g<GFs�g09bs�xK9b>�T^£¤VKTfcM>�T"abTRVMe4>�GRGFe�IKt�e�Jbt�s5�M�F9b>�TH>�abTRVX£

e�>�GRG^>wG���IXg<cngbVXN�g*IX=?>�G���IKTH>?>4Lbef9<IKgbxK>wc cMJ<THs�gbx[I[e4V_=�=�Jbgbs�e�IXNHs�VKg����bV_Td>4LbIX=?abt�>K�qNH9b>�a<THVMe4>wGHGf e�IXgn�*>?s�g�NH>�TRabTR>4NR>�c I_G�v�w F"zga �m � v�w�0zgaDA&a�c�eG~ �� � �Ge ���d~M~Q~�ef��IXg*c t IKG8v�w F�zga �m � �$�F~Q~M~�eH� � s SK>�NH9b>a<THV_�btu>�=�e4VKg*e4>�TRgbs�gbx�I_G^Prg<ef9bTRVKgrP�IXg<c #"`���">B�*>�tus�>�p_>`NH9*I�N"NH9bs�G:e�I�NR>�x_VKTRP�VK��gbVKgM£¤�bs�G^s�=?sut�IXTw��PK>4Ne�VKgbx_THJ<>�g�N"a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G��rs�G`gbVXNFs�=�a,VKTHNRIKg�N��

� �����������#4�� ������ � ��� �

\�g�NH9<s�G�GH>�e4NHs�VKg��K��>FG^NHJ<cMP�NH9b> �^JbaM£�NHVde�VKg�NH>�L�N ��abTRVrVX�<NR>�ef9bg<s���Jb>�-@?Xl21¤�_IKg<c��">FabTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN�I��<s�GHsu=�£J<t�IXNHs�VKg�J<aM£5NRVBe�VKg�NH>�LrN�s�GkI�cM>�� £��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq��8:9b>Fe4V_=?abtu>�NH>"abTRV�VK�*e�IKg��,>��2V_Jbg<c�sug�o`aba,>�g*cMs�L?o����g<>BVK�qNR9b>dsug�NR>�TR>�G^NRG:VX��NH9<s�GFa<THVrVX�qNH>�ef9<gbs���Jb>_�bs�G"NH9<IXN`s�NOIKtut�V��`G"J<G:NHV�I�p_VKs�c�I?cMs�TH>we�N`abTRVrVX�qNR9<I�N " s�G�I[e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g<e4>_�.�ONH9b>�T�abTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G�NR9<I�Nd�2V_tut�V�� �2TRVK= NH9b>�abTHVrVK��VX�`8:9�� �M��@�IXTR>�t�s�GQNR>�c s�g�M>�e�Nw�<lb�

K >�G^NRIKT^NB�rP0cb>4�<gbs�gbx�NH9b>�gbVXNRsuV_g VX��J<aM£5NRV�e�VKg�NH>�L�NfG�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��B�<VKT�>�IKef9 TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg � �7��>cb>4�<gb> ��� I_GFNH9<>�GH=?IKtut�>�G^N�e�VK=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg*IXt�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g0NH9<IXN�e4V_g_NfIXs�g<GFNR9b>�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsup_>�IXg<c0TR>��<>�LMsup_>e�tuV�G^J<TH>BVX� � �MNH9<IXN`s�GMC

= �2VKT`IKtut�a<THVMe4>wGHG6f?�b�">�9<I�pK>�f ����f �= s��Ff � t?�rNR9b>�g f � � t �= s��Ff ����t IKg<c�t �������rNR9b>�g f ����� �= s��Ff ����t?�rNH9<>�g�Cyv�wLxEzWf ����v�wLxEz�t?�bIXg<c a�f��Ee ����agt��EeH�<IKg<c agbkcRegf ����agbkcRe t��bIXg<c� xo f�� ��� � xo t�� �

= s���f � � t IXg<c�� � � ��NR9b>�gRC%a�f ����e � � a�t � eH��IXg<c�a�ikj�l���n�f q�sO��e � � a�ikj�l���n t�q�s eH�IXg<c � f % �un�� � � � � t %���n � �

�#������� | �2¡���� � ���� } ¡ � � ¢ �#� � �2~M| �2¡ ��6��� � ¡ ��¡ � | � � |�{ � 8:9b> TR>�t�I�NHs�VKg � s�G I xKTRVKJ<g<cGHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g 2D�� �g�$'N�&�"� �'4 ��� �rs����2VKTOIKtutFa�f %Gt�e i � ��>d9<I�p_>ACa��Ge?s�� f����� / f"-�IXg*c � a � e�gn � � � ��NR9b>�g NH9<>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I0abTRVre�>�GRG�t"-�GHJ<ef9 NH9<IXN�t����� / t"-�IXg*c

f"- � � t"- �a� �Ge?s��Lf&� �������� �� ��� � �������������� / a�� �}f"-WeR�,NH9b>�g[NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�a<THVMe4>wGHG t"-�IXg<c IKg >�grprs�THV_gb=?>�g�N ��-�G^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t � �������� �� ��� 1 �� ����������� / a���-8��t�-e��FsuNH9=f"-�����t"-qIXg<c a�ikj�l��pq�s.|��e����,a�ikjIl���-0q�s |�0eR�

� s�S_>��Fs�G^>_�q�">�e�IKg cb>4�<gb>�I0g<VXNHs�VKg VK�:�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg Jbab£5NRV GQNRTHJ<e4NHJbTfIXtU>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>_��K >�cM>�g<VXNH>� ��NH9b>dTR>�t�I�NRsuV_g�cM>��<gb>wc��rP�C ���>nSbdcfe G a�f %Gt�eZ��� a�f"-%Nt"-�e i ��~ f 1�f"-E9 t 1�t"- I �

:<;k¥=: >

Page 20: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� @�

�#������� | �2¡���� ��� �� } ¡ � � ¢ �#� � �2~M| �2¡ ��6��� � ¡�� � 8:9b>`TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g�� s�G�I�xKTRVKJ<g<c?G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g2D�� �g� 1��Ms��k�2VKT`IKtutFa�f %Gt�e i � ��>d9<I�p_>ACa��Ge?s�� f�� �� / f"-�IXg*c � a � e�gn � � � ��NR9b>�g NH9<>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I0abTRVre�>�GRG�t"-�GHJ<ef9 NH9<IXN�t�� �� / t"-�IXg*c

f"- � � t"- �a� �Ge?s��Lf&� �������� �� ��� � �������������� / a�� �}f"-WeR�,NH9b>�g[NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�a<THVMe4>wGHG t"-�IXg<c IKg >�grprs�THV_gb=?>�g�N ��-�G^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t ���������� �� ��� 1 �� ����������� / a���-8��t�-eH�*�Fs�NR9 f"- � � t"-�IXg*c a�i}j�l��pq�s$|�Ee � � a�ikj�l���-0q�s |�0eH�

K >�cM>��<gb>�I0NR9bs�TRc gbVKNHs�VKg VX�F�bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg JbaM£�NHV*��g*IX=?>�t�P NR9b>�gbVKNHs�VKg VX� H�������� ���&�����&�B2D��� �r�P��DE�(��'G�&�����&� � �bV_T�>�I_ef9 TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g � �:�">[cM>4�<g<> ��� IKG�NH9<> G^=�IKtut�>�G^N�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>[TR>�t�I�NRsuV_ge�VKg�NRIKsug<sugbx�� �MNR9<I�N`s�GFe4t�V_GH>�c�Jbg<cM>�T:NH9b>dTR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg#t�I��`G 9 GH>�> � >�=?=�I?lb��@0:��rNR9<I�N`s�GMC

= �2VKT�IXt�tqabTRVMe4>wGHG\f ��>�9*I�pK>Of ���Of?��Y0VKTR>�V�p_>�Tw�r�2VKT�IXt�tqabTRVMe4>wGHGH>�G\f?��t�IKg<c ���7��>�9*I�pK>ACs��Ff ����t��rNH9b>�g t ���Of?�<IXg*c�su�df ����t�IKg<c�t ���O���MNH9<>�g f ����� �

= s��Ff � t?�rNR9b>�g f ����t �

= s��6a�ikj�l�� q�s��Ee ���,a�i}j�l�� - q�s��0eR�<IXg<c�su��Chl s%a�f�e(' a�i}j�lIa�� e&j.i}j�l a�� - e�edn �M�MNR9b>�gRCa�ikj�l��pq�s�a�f��Ee�e�� � a�i}j�l��o-Qq�s$a�f �0ePe �

= �2VKT`IKtut�a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G6f�IXg<c�t���>�9<I�p_>ACa�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�f �Rt�e�e ��� a�i}j�l"�$n���q�s,aPa�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e���t�e�ea�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�f �Rt�e�e � � a�i}j�l"�$n���q�s,a�f��Fa�ikj�l���n���q�s�t�ePe�ea�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�f ��ePe � � a�i}j�l"�$n���q�s,aPa�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e ��e�e

a�ikj�l���n�� q�s$a�a bdc�egf�ePe � � aPagbFc�ePa�i}j�l"�$n���q�s�f�ePe a�c�gi lgsya��OePea�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a � xo f��2ePe � � a � xo a�ikj�l��$n���q�s�f�e5�2ea�ikj�l���np� %���n q�sOf�e � � a�i}j�l"�$n�� %��8n q�s,a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e�e a�� gi lgsya��OePea�ikj�l���np� %���n q�sOf�e � � a�i}j�l"�$n�� %��8n a�i}j�l"�$n�� q�s e q�s�f�e a�� gi lgsya��OePe

K suNH9#NR9b>dTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg�� � �b�">de�IXg0cM>��<gb>�NH9<>dgbVXNRsuV_g�VK�kGHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg#JbaM£�NHV?TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g��

�#������� | �2¡���� � � �� } ¡ � � ¢ �#� � �2~M| �2¡ ��6��� � ¡ ��� � � � �_~M| �'¡�� � 8:9b>`TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g���s�G�I�xKTRVKJ<g<cGHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g 2D�� �g���G� D��!��'N��������� �*su���2V_T`IXt�tFa�f %Nt�e i � Ca��Ge?s��;f ���� / f"-"IXg<c � a � e gn ����� ��NR9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�>�LMs�G^NRG�I[abTRVre�>�GRG�t GHJ<ef9 NH9*I�N�t ���� / t"-"IXg*c

f"- � � t"- �a� �Ge?s��6f ��� ������ �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �}f - eR��NR9b>�gnNH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�abTRVMe4>wGHG8t IKg<c IKgn>�grp�s�TRVKgb=?>�g�N�� - G^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t � �������� �� ��� 1 �� ����������� / a���-8��t�-eH�*�Fs�NR9 f"- ���Ot�-�IXg<c a�ikj�l��pq�s.|�"e ���$a�i}j�l���-Qq�s |�MeH�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 21: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

@0Y � ����2�&�������������R��!���

\�g�NH9bs�G"TH>�a*V_T^Nw�_�">OabTRV�pK>`NH9<IXN:I��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g<G�J<aM£5NRV�s�G�I�cM>�� £��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg��_NH9*I�N:s�G���>�9<I�pK>ONH9b>�2V_tut�V��Fs�gbx�NR9b>�V_TH>�=0�� � �r¡ } � ����� � � � � �q� � ¡ . } ¡�¡(� � � �� ����� � � ��� �Q� � HG� � �P��� ����������'�� �2�Q�N��H�J��NEH�������� ��������=���;�����,���}���&�7���������IH�� ���&% a��Ge�� ! � � ����� ��� # ���P���A�P�� ��������� ���&�����&��2D(� � ��'N�&�"� �'4 ����#k��� ���� ���.�r�A�����PH�������� ������������#���� ������� ��� " % a� �Ge�� ! � � ����� ��� # ���P���A�P�� ��� ����� �����������2D�� �g���N����"'Q�� �P�&�h���� � �������Q��'N�$#\�����Q� ��� " % a������Ge ! � � ����� � � # ���G���A�P�& ���o����� �����������2D�� �g�,�P� D��!��'N����������#y�����Q� ��� " %8:9b>0e4V_=?abtu>�NH>#abTRV�VK�OVX�B8:9�� �M��@�s�G�x_sup_>�g s�g o`aba,>�g<cbs�L o�� 8:9bs�G�a<THVrVX��s�G�pK>�THP NH>wef9bgbs�e�IKt5�

NR9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_��s�g NH9<s�G�G^>we�NRsuV_g��k��>�V_gbt�Pnx_sup_>?NH9b>#G�S_>4NRef9 VK�FNH9b>�a<THVrVX�Q�[\�g NR9bs�G�abTRVrVX�Q����>�J<G^>�NH9b>�2J<g<e�NRsuV_g��a�4e�cM>4�*gb>�c#�rP�C

��a�4e_n Lj " j G a�f %Nt�e ��� ��~ a�f %G��e i IXg*c a�� %Gt�e i Ij G agvwyxEzf %�v�wLxEzWt�e��� a�f %Nt�e i Ij G�aPa�f �"e %Qagt �EePe �� a�f %Nt�e i �Ij G a � xo f���% � xo t��2e@�� a�f %Gt�e i Ij G�aPagbkcRegf %MagbkcRe t�e �� a�f %Nt�e i �Ij G a � f # %���npf � % � t # % ��n�t � e@�� a�f # %Gt # e�IXg<c�a�f %Nt e i Ij G a�fW#���f� �%Gt # �Rt &e �� a�fW#�%Gt #Me�IXg<c�a�f� �%Gt �e i Ij G�a�i}j�l���n�f #�q�s�f� �%PikjIl��$n�t�#uq�sOt &e �� a�fW#�%Gt #Me�IXg<c�a�f� �%Gt �e i �Ij$� a��eTj� \�g NH9bs�GdGH>�e�NRsuV_g����">?cbV�gbVKN�cb>4�<gb>�NR9b>?TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg� IXg<c NH9b>��2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg �[��8:9<>�TR>�I_cM>�T�e�IKg �<g*cNR9b>�GH>dcM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g<GFs�g[o`aba,>�g<cbs�L0o��8:9b> �2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg���a�4e�s�G#I �2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg NR9<I�Nw�`xKs�pK>�g I TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g� �F=�I&SK>wG�NR9b>ne�tuV�G^JbTR> Jbg*cM>�T

�HIXt�tkNH9<>�VKa,>�TfI�NHV_TRGBVK�L3�5 �f��\�g a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IXTw���2VKTd>�pK>�TRP TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g�� ��s�N�s�G�e4t�>�IKT�NH9<IXNdNH9b>�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g� %���� � % a ��e 9 >4LMs�GQNfG`IXg<cE:�s�G`e�VK=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg*IXt�IXg<c�NH9*I�N`suN`pK>�TRsu�<>�G"NR9b>dTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg�C

� � ���%���� �% a ��e

��g<>�e�IKg GH>�>�� IKG?IXg >4LbIX=?abt�>�VK��� �P���gD �N'Q� �N � ���2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg��"IKG�cM>4�*gb>�c �rP ���h�MIKgbxKs�VKTRxKs�sug�-@?Xl�1��]KJ<G^N�NHV�xKs�pK>`IXg?s�g�NHJbsuNHs�VKg��_NH9<>OTR>�t�I�NHs�VKg*G � a��e�IXg<c� IXTR>`GHJ<ef9?NH9<IXN�NH9<>�P 9 TR>�GHa*>we�NHs�pK>�tuP�:k=�IASK>�GI e4t�V_GHJbTH>[J<g<cM>�T �Q�*IKGHs�e[TR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKg t�I��`G � 9 GH>�> � >�=?=�I lb��@ IKg<c �O>��<gbsuNHs�VKg0�b� ? :�IXg*c �^G^NHTRJ<e�£NRJbTfIXtB>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>nt�I��`G ����\�g a<IXTHNHs�e4Jbt�IXTw�`�"> abTRV�pK> NH9<IXNMC � ��� � %���� � % a ��eH�BIXg<c NH9<IXNMC1�� � %���� � % a� �eR�<IXg*c�NR9<I�N� � � � %���� � % a ��eH��OgM�2VKTHNHJbg*I�NH>�tuP_���">?9<I�pK>�NRV[abTHV�p_>�NH9b>?NR9bTH>�>�abTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G�VX�F8:9����b�u@?NRVKx_>4NH9<>�Tw��8:9<I�N�s�G�����>

e�IXgbg<VXN�G^a<tusuN�NH9<>�abTHVrVK�"s�g NH9bTR>�>�cMs�k7>�TR>�g�N�a<IKT^NfGQCdV_gb>?�2VKT�NR9b>�JbaM£�NHV e�VKg�NH>�LrN�a<THVrVX�"NH>wef9bgbs���Jb>K�NR9b>�VXNH9<>�T��2VKT�NH9b>�JbaM£�NHV 1���IXg<c NH9b>�t�I_GQN��2VKTBJbaM£�NHV#TH>�abt�s�e�I�NHs�VKgq�B8:9bs�GBs�G��F9rP0NH9b>?cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg VK���a�4eUs�GOG^V�e4V_=?abtu>�L��

K >�cM>�gbVXNR> � � NH9b>�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg1� � n bdcfe � %���� � % a ��eH�k\�g�a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IXT;a ��� j � � j � � e!�� � ��C`IXNH9b>�T�NH9<IKg a<THV�prs�gbx#8:9q� �M��@?cbsuTR>�e4NHt�PK�q�">?abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN � � s�G�I0cM>�� £¤GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq��Y[VKTR>a<TH>we4s�G^>�tuP��">dabTRV�pK> � >�=?=�I �M��@K�rNR9<I�NFs�G`I�=�V_TH>�x_>�gb>�TRIKt,a<THV_a*>�T^NQP?NR9<IXg[8:9��(�b�u@ C

:<;k¥=: >

Page 22: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� @wv

�#������� | �2¡���� � �.�� } ¡ � � ¢ �#� � �2~M| �2¡ ��6��� � ¡�� � �">�GHI�P�NH9<IXN � s�G�I�xKTRVKJ<g<c0G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_gJ<aM£5NRV �?�bs����2VKT`IKtutFa�f %Gt�e i � ��>�9<I�p_>ACa��Ge?s��;f � �� / f"-"IXg<c � a � e gn ����� ��NR9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�>�LMs�G^NRG�I[abTRVre�>�GRG�t GHJ<ef9 NH9*I�N�t � �� / t"-"IXg*c

f - � � t - �a� �Ge?s��6f � � ������ �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �}f"-WeR��NR9b>�gnNH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�abTRVMe4>wGHG8t IKg<c IKgn>�grp�s�TRVKgb=?>�g�N���-UG^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t ���������� �� ��� 1 �� ����������� / a���-8��t�-eH�*�Fs�NR9 f"- � � t"-�IXg*c�a�i}j�l��pq�s�|�Ee � � a�ikj�l���-Mq�s |�MeR�

\¤N:s�G"e�tu>wIXT�NH9<IXN�NR9b>�NH9bTR>�>BgbVXNRsuV_g<G�VX��GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg�JbaM£�NHV?cM>4�<g<>�c�IXN�NR9b>��*>�xKs�gbgbs�gbx�VK��NH9bs�G:G^>we�NRsuV_gIKTH>�sug*GQNfIXg<e�>�G�VX��GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg JbaM£�NHV �?��8:9b>�g��UNHV abTRV�pK>#8:9�� �M��@K��suN�s�G?G^J �e�su>�g�N�NRVnabTRV�pK>�NH9b>�2V_tut�V��Fs�gbx�a<THV_a*>�T^NQP_���� ~ ����� � � � { � � �2~M| �2¡�� �q� � ¡�� � � � � ����� ��� # ���G�8�&�P�& ���.����� �����������"�O2D(� � � � #�&����� � � ��� 'Q�������N��H�J���EH�������� �����&�������G�����Q�P�Q��'N���u����� �2�&����� H������ #d��� ��� � � ���;�O� �����PH�������� ���&�����&� #�����&�h��� � � � " %

. } ¡�¡��?\¤N�s�G�>wIKGHP NHV abTHV�p_>?NH9<IXN���s��� s�G�e�tuV�G^>wcn�rP G^J<�<GQNRs�NRJMNHs�VKg VK�FTH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>�G��2V_T�p�IXTRs�IK�btu>wG��NR9b>�g NR9b>�GRIX=?>?abTHV_a*>�T^NQP 9bVKt�cbGB�2VKT � % a ��eH��IXg<cnNR9�J*G��2VKT � � ��8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>K���">�VKgbt�P gb>�>�cnNHVa<THV�p_>�NR9<I�N�� � s�G�Idx_THV_Jbg<c��bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��U8qV�abTHV�p_>"NH9bs�G�t�IKG^N�abTRVKa,>�THNQPK�_��>`a<THV�p_>:NH9b>`a<THV_a*>�T^NQPa��GeGCU�2VKT`IKtut�s�g�NH>�x_>�T ,7�MNR9b>dTR>�t�I�NHs�VKg���Ia ��e�s�G`I?GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg#JbaM£�NHV �?��Y0V_TH>�abTR>�e�s�GH>�t�PK�r�">dabTHV�p_>�rP�s�g<cMJ*e�NHs�VKg0V_g ,�NH9*I�N`su�La�f %Gt�e i ����a ��eH�MNR9b>�g�Ca��Ge?s��;f ���� / f"-"IXg<c � a � e gn ����� ��NR9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�>�LMs�G^NRG�I[abTRVre�>�GRG�t GHJ<ef9 NH9*I�N�t ���� / t"-"IXg*c

f"- � � t"- �a� �Ge?s��6f ��� ������ �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �}f"-WeR��NR9b>�gnNH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�abTRVMe4>wGHG8t IKg<c IKgn>�grp�s�TRVKgb=?>�g�N���-UG^J*ef9NH9<IXN\t ���������� �� ��� = �� ����������� / a�� - ��t - eR�b�Fs�NR9 f - � � t - IXg*c a�i}j�l��pq�s$|�Ee � � a�ikj�l�� - q�s.|A�eH�

8:9<>�abTRVrVX��s�gnNH9b>�e�I_G^> ,�n ��s�GdG^NHTfIXs�xK9�N^�2V_TH�:IXTfc��*GHs�g<e4> � � a ��e"s�GBNH9<>�s�cM>�g_NRs�NQP[TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g���8:9b>x_>�gb>�TRIKt�e�IKGH>�s�G:a<THV�p_>�c�s�g[IXaba,>�g*cMs�L0o��

��g<e�>dabTRV�pK>�c�NH9b>da<THV_a*>�T^NQP=a��GeR�<suN`s�GFe�tu>wIXT:NH9*I�N� � s�GFI�cM>4� £¤�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��U\¤NF�2V_tut�V��`G"NH9<IXNMC� � � " �O8:9b>�g��,NHV�a<THV�p_>�8:9�� �b�u@_�<�">�J<GH>�NR9b>��'I_e�N�NH9<IXNMC"� ����a ��e � � %���� � % a ��eyn� � � " � /

`OVXNH>�NH9<IXN���sug�NR9b>�cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKgdVK� ��a�4eH�w�">�J<GH>kNH9b>�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g! " �q\�g<cM>�>�c��">U9<I�pK>!��a�4ekn� j " j ~Q~M~k8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>�IBe4V_THV_tut�IXTRPBVX� � >�=?=�I �b�u@"s�GqNR9<I�NU�bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg �QJbab£5NRVBG^NHTRVKgbx��bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g �IKTH>�cM>4� £¤�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��d8:9��=�M��@�s�G�IKt�GHV�I�e4V_THV_tut�IXTRP�VK��NH9bs�GBtu>�=?=?I<�B�<VKTB>4LbIX=?abt�>K��GHJbaba,V_GH>�NR9<I�N� s�G�e4t�V_GH>�c Jbg*cM>�T�GHJb�<G^NHsuNHJbNHs�VKg<G���IKg<cnNH9<IXN�� IXg<c ��� # IXTR>��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg*GdJbaM£�NHV e�VKg�NH>�L�NfG��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�bGHs�g<e4>dV_��prs�VKJ<GHt�P���� � � � �<��>d9<I�p_>BNH9<IXN � IKg<c ��� # IKTH>dGHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg<G:J<aM£5NRV �IKg<c��bJ*G^s�gbx � >�=�=�I �b�u@��">�e�IXg0abTRV�pK>�NH9*I�N� � s�GFI�cM>4� £¤�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg[IXg<c�NH9rJ<GMC � � � � � #"F�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 23: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

?A/ � ����2�&�������������R��!���

� � ��� � �F�q ��4�F����� ���� �F� �*�������������� ������

o cbsuTR>�e4N�e4VKg*G^>w�_J<>�g<e�>FVX��8:9����M��@Fs�GkNH9<IXNUNH9b>�GQNRTHV_gbx��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g�s�G�Ide�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>�NH9*I�N�e�VKg�NRIKsug<GG^NHTRJ<e4NHJbTfIXt7>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g<e�>K�

� � �r¡ } � �� ��� B ���O�����P�����.� �����PH�������� ���&�����&�r�����.'N�����&��"�Q��'N�������.'N���E�g�&�����������"'Q�� �P���R���Q � �2���� ����'G�$#%�������L��� ! 1�� " #y������#E���&�O���EJ�'G�&�"� �'4 � 5 # �8� ���� f " t � 5 � f � " 5 � t � %. } ¡�¡���8:9b>ns�cM>�g�NHsuNQP/TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g8D�F7��s�G#I a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IXT�>�LbIX=?abt�> VX���bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg J<aM£5NRV e�VKg�NH>�L�NfG��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�*J<GHsugbx�NH9b>�abTRV�VK�UVX��8:9�� �M��@K�,��>�abTHV�p_>�NH9<IXNMC � %���� � % a D F�e � #"F��IXg*c#NH9b>?G^>we4V_g<ca<THV_a*>�T^NQP?�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_=�NH9<>��'IKe�NFNR9<I�N71 � � % ��� � % a D�F�eR�

� s�S_>��Fs�G^>_��NRVOabTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN " s�G�I�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K���">�J<GH>�NR9b>��'IKe�N�NH9<IXN�suN�s�GkIFa<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IKTq>�LMIK=?abtu>VK���bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg�JbaM£�NHV�e4V_g_NR>4LrNRG��k\�g<cM>�>�c��MJ<GHs�gbx�NH9b>�gbVKNRI�NRsuV_g�VK�qNR9b>�abTHVrVK��VX��8:9��(�M��@K�r�">�abTHV�p_>NR9<I�N � %���� � % a " e�s�GOI�G^NHTRVKg<x��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq�<IXg<c�NR9�J*GQC � %���� � % a " e � " ��8:9bs�GFs�=�a<tus�>�GNR9<I�N ��a� " e!� " �bNH9<IXN`s�G " s�GFe�tuV�G^>wc�J<g<cM>�T�e4VKg�NR>4LrNRG�� /

8:9<>Bt�IKG^NFTH>wG^J<t�N`G^NRI�NR>�G"NR9<I�NOcM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg<GOe�IXg#�,> �^cMs�G^NHTRsu�bJbNH>�c�Jbg<cb>�TF>�p_>�TRP�e4V_g_NR>4LrNRG ���k8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg*GFIKe�N`t�s SK>dG^J<�<GQNRs�NRJMNHs�VKg*G���8:9bs�G:�Fs�tut��,>d>4LM>�=�a<tusu�<>�c0IXN"NR9b>d>�g*c�VK�F�M>�e�Nw�<lb��@K���� ~�� ��� � ��� � � � �_~M| �'¡���� ~   { �CB ���L�������� ��I�o��� ������� � !a��Ge ! � � gi l s%a�f�e #%��� �� ikjIl���n�� q�sOf " f +a� �Ge,i}j�l���n�� q�s$a�f��Rt�e " i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�a�i}j�l"�$n�� q�sOf�e��Rt�e +a��� �Ge � � � gn � �&��� �ogi l s%a���e #%�����Q�

i}j�l���n���q�s$a�i}j�l �8n q�s�f�e #" i}j�l��,n�� %��8n q�s$a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�ei}j�l���n���q�s$a�i}j�l �8n q�s�f�e #" i}j�l ��n a�ikjIl"�$n���q�s e q�s$a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f�e

a� &Ee$i}j�l���n�� q�s$a � xo f��0e " � xo a�ikjIl���np��q�s�f�e0�)+a�&Ee � � c gi l s%a��Oe #%��� ��� i}j�l���np��q�s,aPagbkcRegf�e " a�bkcReGa�i}j�l���n���q�sOf�ea&��Ge �����,� ���Q��Jo'N���E�g� 4 � 5 ��� ���;�A�0���O���&� H�����o�����������,���y�N�G�G���� � #6�&��� ������� ���Q��JOD��P�M'N���N� f #

��� �h���&���� ����o��� ����� � ! ikjIl���np��q�s,a 5 � f � e #"hi}j�l��$n�� q�s,a�5 � a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e � e %oOgdsu=?=?>�cbs�IXNH>�e4V_THV_tut�IXTRPFVX�rt�I��`GFa��Ge<IXg*c�a���PeR��s�G7NR9<I�N0C�i}j�l���n�� q�s$a�f��Rt�e #" a�ikjIl���np��q�s�f�eR�a�i}j�l���np��q�sOt�eR�b�F9bs�ef9�s�G:NR9b>dt�I�� IXgbg<VKJbg<e�>�c�sug0s�g�NHTRVrcbJ<e�NRsuV_g�VK�qNH9<s�GFTR>�a,VKTHN��. } ¡�¡���8:9b>BabTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G a��Ge�NHVoa�&EeUIKTH>�cMs�TH>we�NFe4V_g<G^>w��Jb>�g<e�>�G�VX��NR9b>��'IKe�N:NR9<I�N ��a #"6e!� #"F�U8qVa<THV�p_> � >�=?=�I�l<�u@�£Ga&��GeR�M��>�abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXNFNH9b>�NQ�"V�abTHVMe�>�GRG^>wGLf # IKg<c.f GHJ<ef9�NR9<I�N0C

8 n bncfe ikj�l��$n�� q�s 5 IXg*c fW#;n bncfe 8 � f � IKg<c f� \n bncfe 8 � i}j�l���n���q�sOf �

:<;k¥=: >

Page 24: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� ?b@

IKTH>B�bs�G^s�=?sut�IXTw� � >�N���~ ���,>�NH9b>��2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg0V_g#a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�G:GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXN 9 s�g#>wIKef90e�I_G^>_���">dG^J<aba*V�G^>�NR9<I�N�">�9<I�pK>BJ<GH>�c 6q£¤e�VKgrpK>�TRGHsuV_g�NHV�I�p_VKs�c�NR9b>�e�IKaMNHJbTR>BVX���2TH>�>Bg*IX=?>�G:s�g ��:�C

��ikj�l���n�� q�s�m�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s�m��ikj�l���n���q�s�a�agbdc�e f�e�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s$a�bdcReGa���ikj�l���n���q�s�f��&e��i}j�l���n���q�s$a�f �Ee�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s$a��i}j�l"��np��q�s�f�� �Ee��i}j�l���n���q�s$a v�wLxEzf�e�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s�v�wLxEzga��ikjIl���n�� q�s�f�Ae��i}j�l���n���q�s$a�f��Rt�e�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s$a��i}j�l"��np��q�s�f��r����i}j�l���n�� q�sOt��Ae��i}j�l���n���q�s$a � xo f��2e�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s � xo a��i}j�l���n���q�sOf��Ae0���ikj�l��$n�� q�s$a�ikj�l �8n q�s�t�e�� n ikjIl���n������}q�s� ikj�l �8n���i}j�l"��np��q�s �q�s���ikj�l��$n���q�s�t�� �IKg<c�GHJ<ef9�NR9<I�N��P~ ��s�G"IKg�9bV_=?VK=?VKTRab9bs�G^= s�g�NH9<>BVKNH9b>�T"e�IKGH>�G���8:9<>O�2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg��P~ ��s�G�J<GH>�c�NHV �Q=�IXL�£s�=�IXt�tuP���cMs�GQNRTHs��bJMNR>�cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg*G���\¤����>�IKcbc[NH9b>�e4VKg*GQNfIXg�N ���\� ��G^J<ef9 NH9<IXN���i}j�l"�,n���q�s ���\� ��n����� �7NH9<s�GO�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg >4LrNH>�g<cbGONHV0I��2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg �2THV_= e�VKg�NH>�LrNRGONHV�e�VKg�NH>�LrNRG�����G^s�gbx�NH9b>?cMs�GQNRTHs��bJMNRsuV_gt�I��`G���s�N�s�Gd>�I_G^P0NRV0abTHV�p_>�NR9<I�Nw���2V_T�IXt�tUabTHVMe�>�GRG f?����>?9<I�p_>AC���f�� " f IKg<cuC��8� � f � " 8 � f � �8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>Bs�N`s�GFVK�rprs�VKJ<G�NH9*I�NMC

f # #"���f # ��n��8� � ��ikjIl(�$n�� q�sOf�� � IXg*c 8 � ��i}j�l"��n�� q�sOf�� � #"Ff 8:9<>B>�LMa*>we�NH>wc#TH>wG^JbtuNFs5� >K���"f # " f� _�r�2VKt�tuV��`G"�2TRVK=�NR9b>�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�prs�NQP�VK� " � /

�:9�; � J\GB=@C+F7C+=$GBUZG+D0I\J I�M�GHN7=���, � UWV A R7V R7?� >4N�� cM>�gbVXNR>�G"NR9b>dJbg�NQPra*>wc �b£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G��

5 %#$ %�� ���!n c��� ���}~ 5 �� a 5 $re

K > e4V_g<GHs�cM>�T?NH9b>0�2J<tutBe�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G���NH9<IXN�s�G��FsuNH9<VKJMN�IKgrP a<IXTHNHs�e4J<t�IKT�TH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g/G^NHTfI�NR>�x_PK�:IXg<c ��>cb>�gbVKNH>��! dNH9<>�%�£�e4V_grpK>�TfGHsuV_gBTR>�t�I�NRsuV_g���NH9<IXN�s�G�NR9b>:G^=�IXt�t�>�G^N�e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>�GHJ<ef9dNR9<I�NLa ���R~ 5�e 5"�! 5 ��$ ��c��K� 8:9b>0TH>�abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg/t�I��`G�e�IXg/�*>[J*G^>wc NRV abTRV�pK>�NH9b> e�VKTRTH>we�NHg<>�GRG�VK�BI 9 pK>�TRP�:�G^s�=?abtu>s�g�NH>�THabTR>4NfI�NRsuV_g��2TRVK="� NRV�3�5�IXt�TH>wIKcMP�GPSK>�NRef9b>wc�s�g �r>�e4N��E?b�u@_�%��J<TFsug�NH>�THa<TH>�NRI�NRsuV_g�VK�#� s�G$ c&% n c$ ���R~ 5�% n agbdc�e $ 5�%$ a 5 $4e'% n ikj�l���n $ $(%uq�s,a $ 5�%-�ue � gi l s%a 5 %#$re\�g NH9b>��2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx<�*��>��Fsut�t�=�IASK>dgbV#cMs�G^NHs�g<e4NHs�VKg �,>4NQ�">�>�g[p�IKTHs�IX�<tu>wG`VX��� IXg<c[g*IX=?>�GOVX�%365_�\Kn>a<THV�p_>�NR9<I�N�NR9b>�s�g_NR>�TRabTR>4NRIXNHs�VKg VX�FI)��£¤TR>�cM>�L7�qs�G�I0TR>�cb>4L VK�L3�5�� � >4NOf � c@�!n�t � �,>�NH9b>�a<THVMe4>wGHGcb>4�<gb>wc#��P

f � c@�!n�t � nSbncfe�i}j�lRc.n�trq�sOf su�Fc gi l sya�t�e8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�rJ<GHs�gbx � >�=?=�I�jb� jb�r�">d9<I�pK>$ a����}~ 5�e $(% n a�a bkc�e $ 5�%-�ue � �@�@n $ $(% � ���da $ 5�% �!�(�2c��Ae � �$�!n $ $(% �

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 25: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

? ? � ����2�&�������������R��!���

8�V�TR>�IKGHVKg0IX�,VKJbN`NH9b>�sug�NH>�THa<TH>�NRI�NRsuV_g�VK� % TH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_g��b�">�IKGRGHJb=?>�NH9<IXN`NH9b>�TH>�abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg#t�I��`GOIXTR>p�IKtus�c �2V_T?�<IXTR�*>wc e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K� 8:9<s�G?TR>�GHJbtuN���G^NRIXNH>wc s�g/8:9q� �r��@K��s�G?abTRV�pK>wc t�IXN^NR>�Tw�BK suNH9/NH9<s�G9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G��M��>de�IXg#abTHV�p_>ONR9<I�N0C

a $ 5�% � �"��c��Ae � �@�@n $ $(% � � � $ 5�% � $ $(% �2c�� n $ 5 �)$ ��c�� %8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>B��>de�IKg�a<THV�p_>ONR9<I�NFNR9b>dsug�NR>�TRabTH>�NRIXNHs�VKg#VX���,>4NfI�e4V_g�p_>�THNHs��bt�>ONR>�TR=?GFIKTH>�>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g�Nw�

� � �r¡ } � �� � � ! � 5 �! $ #%��� ��� $ 5�%%� � $ $(% %Y[VKTR>FabTH>we4s�G^>�tuP_�_�">Oe�IXg�cMTfI��/I�a<IXTfIXt�tu>�t<�,>4NQ�">�>�g?NH9b>�TH>�abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg?t�I��`G�IXg*c�NH9b>ONHTfIXg<G^�2VKTR=�I�NHs�VKg*Gcb>4�<gb>wc�s�g�NR9b>"�M£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��FsuNH9 �'4QD��!��'���y��EHN������� �������"� -@?01��U\�g*cM>�>wc��rs�����>B>4LrNH>�g<c��/�FsuNH9#>4LMabt�s�e�s�NGHJb�<G^NHsuNHJbNHs�VKg<GMC 5 � c��@n�$ � ��IKg<cns��:��>�cM>��<gb> $ 5 � c@�!n�$ � %�NHV0�*>?NR9b>�abTRVMe4>�GRG $ 5�% � c@�!n $ $ % � ����>e�IXg#abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXNMC

t�>4N�c % ���,>�NQ��V?p�IXTRs�IK�bt�>�G:G^J*ef9�NR9<I�N c�gn ��IKg<c�� gi l sha���ea�f � �&�@n�t � e � c@�!n � � � � a�f � c��@n8� � e � �&�@nOagt � c��@n � � e �

c � c@�!n � � � � � a�SUTRVKa,V_GHs�NRsuV_g#j<�u@�e� � c@�!n � � � � � a � >�=�=�I?lb��@4£Na��Ge�e$ � � ~ 5�% � c@�!n $ $(% � � � a b���ePa $ 5�% � c@�!n $ $ % � e a � >�=�=�I�l<�u@�£Ga&"e�e$ 5 � % � c@�!n $ $(% � � � $ a 5 � c@�!n�$ � e a�� � c@�!n�$ � e'% a � >�=?=?I�l<�u@�£Ga���Pe e

8:9<s�G�t�I_GQN�TH>wG^JbtuN�9*IKG�NHV �,>�e�VK=?a<IKTH>wc �Fs�NR9 NH9b>#TR>�=�IXTGS VK�OCd�kY[sut�gb>�To-@?M@X�h�r>we�Nw�k�A1���NR9<I�N�NH9b>e�VKTRTH>wG^a,VKg*cM>�g<e�>��,>4NQ�">�>�g�NR9b>��b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G:�FsuNH9[>4LMabt�s�e4suNOG^Jb�*GQNRs�NRJMNHs�VKg[IXg*c�NR9b>877£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J0=�I�P��*>e�tuV�G^>�T"NH9<IKg#�,>4NQ�">�>�g�NR9b>��b£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<GFIXg*c�NR9b>877£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<G��

� � �`��� ������ � �" ����F�`� ���������� ��4����� ���.+ � ��+#��!� ��4���

\�g NH9bs�G?G^>we�NRsuV_g����">�abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN�NR9b>0t�IK�*>�tu>wc NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg GHPMGQNR>�=�s�G ���'IKs�NR9M�2Jbt ��NHVnNH9b>#gbVKNHs�VKg VK�TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�� 8:9<IXN�s�G��"I TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_gBf / t s�g NR9b>0VKTRsux_sug<IKt"e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G?e�IKg �,>�=�IKaba*>wc NRV I �r£NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_gBVK�_NR9b>�t�IX�,>�t�>�c�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKgdGHPMGQNR>�= 9 NH9<s�Gqs�G � >�=?=�I7�r�@?A:4�R``V_gb>4NR9b>�t�>�GRG��wI:=�IXs�g�cMs�k,>�TH>�g<e4>�FsuNH9[t�IX�,>�t�>�c0GH>�=�IXg�NRs�e�G`cM>4�*gb>�c��2VKT;3 s�GFNR9<I�N �r£�IKe4NHs�VKg<G`IKTH>�gbVKNO>���Jbs�p�IXt�>�g�NFNHV�TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g���8:9b>�2V_tut�V��Fs�gbx�>�LbIX=?abt�>B�:IKGFIKtuTR>�I_cMP�xKs�pK>�g�s�g �r>�e4N��bm*� ?

� xo t � ��ikj�l��$n�� q�s�a�m � ��f�e / i}j�l���n�� q�s$aPa�t*�ue,��f�e��(� / 1 i}j�l���n�� q�s$aPa�t*�ue,�Fa�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf�e�e

8:9<>�sug�NHJ<s�NRsuV_g s�GBNH9*I�N���s�gnNR9b>�>4LrNRTHJ<GHs�VKg VX�:�*V_Jbg<c TH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>�G��qcM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg<G�IKTH>�cMJ<abtus�e�IXNH>wc���8qV>wGQNfIX�bt�s�G^9�NH9bs�G:�2V_TH=�IXt�t�PK�M�">Bg<>�>�c#I?abTR>�t�su=?s�g<IXTRP�TR>�GHJbt�NFabTRV�pK>wc�s�g[o`aba,>�g<cbs�L[�B�

��� ~�� ��� � ��� �'~M| �2¡ � ��� |  ���� � � }�~ � { � | �'¡�� {�~ � ¢ y?�X| �2¡�� { �a��Ge �������3 �������� � � � f!�'(� / f"- ����� � ���O�&���3�2�&�!"���������r'G�&�"� �'4 � #F��� ��� � � f � ��(� / � � f"- � +

:<;k¥=: >

Page 26: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� ?Kj

a� �Ge�� ������ � � ������-� � � � f ��� ���� /�f"- #%�����Q� a�f��Ee / f"- +a��� �Ge � � �3 �������� � � � f!� . 0 �� � 1 � � ������������ / f"- #%�����Q� a�f |�Me,�Fa�mk|�"e / f"- +a� &Ee ��� � �3 �������� � � � f!� �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� ��f"-We #%��� ��� ��� ���G��� 4 ���N������DE�G�M'N���G� � ��"'��o��� ��� !

f 1 v�w (�Izga�i}j�l�� q�s$a�mk|� ����e�e ����� v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s���e " vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�sOf - e\�g � >�=?=?I �M�u@_����>?9<I�p_>�TR>�t�I�NR>�cn>�IKef9 Srsug<cnVX�:IKe4NHs�VKg<GBNRV0I#TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKgnTHJ<tu>_�?�<VKT�>4LbIK=�a<tu>_���:£I_e�NRsuV_g<GOIKTH>�I_GHGHVMe4s�I�NR>�c#�Fs�NR9 NR9b> 9 TH>wc[�*>�NRII:`TRJbt�>K� K suNH9 NH9bs�GOa<THV_a*>�T^NQP_�*�">�e�IKg abTRV�pK>�NR9<I�NBNH9b>t�� N�� G���GHsu=�Jbt�I�NH>wG"NH9b>dTR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g��rNH9<IXN`s�GMC��� ~�� � �.������ { � � �2~M| � { �"! �������Q�P�\��� ���G�G�&"'����������N�P�&� �;D��P�M'N���N� f �g��� DE�P�0'N���N� f"- #�����Q�=�����Q�P���'4 �����������r���� � �������Q�"� #g��� HG�Q���N� % ���P���"��������&��2D(� � ��������"'��� �P���R���Q � �2�&���Q��'N� #y��� ���h��� !a��Ge � � f / f"- #%�����Q�=��� ���G��� 4 ���N��� � ��"'��.�����&� f 1�� #y����� �!� (� / � - #L�&��� �a-(1�f"- %

#%�&� �����N�Q�Q�!J�#8��� �o� 4 �����g�Q��'N�����o�=� ������P�&����������&�B��\DE�(������������� 4 ���N� �Q��'N�����.���P�N��"'Q������� % ! �B���I���'N�����$#%�����O�P�������&"���@���&�P��H���������� ���&% B ���&�y��� !a� �Ge � � f � (� / f"- #%�����Q�������Q�P���'4 ������� � ��"'��o��� ��� f / � #y����� � #"hf"- %

. } ¡�¡��,� ��� ~ � � � � 8:9<>�a<THVrVX�:VX�"abTRVKa,>�THNQP�a��Ge`s�Gd=�IKcM>?�rP s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg VKgnNH9<>�sugM�2>�TH>�g<e4>�VK�f / f"-'�

= �K~b{ � � } � ¢ ��� � � A ��� �">�9<I�p_>hf 1�t IKg<cOt+/ f"-'�k8:9rJ<G��wJ*G^s�gbx`NR9b>"sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG���IXg<c � -kGHJ<ef9 NR9<I�NOt 1������&� (� / �a-'���a- 1�f"-5��8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�NB�2VKt�tuV��`GO�2TRVK=NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�p�suNQP�VK��NR9b>�GQNRTHJ*e�NHJ<TRIKt,>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4> C%f 1 t 1�� � f 1p� �

= �K~b{ ��� } � ¢ � ¡ � | � � | ��� ��>�9<I�p_>Of nQ� � t � ��t / t"-kIXg*c=f"-kn � � t"- � ��8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>dNH9b>�TH>>4LMs�GQNfG � GHJ<ef9#NH9<IXN t 1 �!� (� / �a-�1 t"-5� ��G^s�gbx � >�=?=�I �r��@4£Na��Ge�IXg<c�NR9b>d�'IKe4NFNH9<IXN21 s�G`Ie4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�rsuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G"NR9<I�N;f 1 � � � � � (� / � � �a- � 1�f"- �

= �K~b{ � � } � ¢ z � |w~ � ~ � ¢ � } � ¢ { � � ��� s�g NR9b> �*TRG^N#e�IKGH>K�`�"> 9<I�p_>�f n a�a bkc�e�t�e�m IXg*cf"-6n t��Mm���c��K� 8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>�TRJbt�> 9 t�IX=��,cbII:�s�=�a<tus�>�G�NH9<IXNMC�a bkc�e�t���� ���� / t �Qm���c���IKg<c TRJbtu>9 IKaba0t�IK=��7cbI :�s�=�a<tus�>�G:NR9<I�N;f � (� / f"-'��8:9<>dabTHVrVK��s�GFG^s�=?sut�IXTFs�g#NH9b>�GH>�e�VKg<c�e�IKGH> �

= �K~b{ � � } � ¢ ¢ � ��� ��� � >�NO|���,>�NH9b>dNRJbabt�>,a� # %Q~Q~M~ % � % eR�%Kn>�9<I�pK>�f n a � x t��=�umk|�Ee�IXg*cf - n a�t$|�EeR��8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�rJ<G^s�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 cM>�e�t�:F��>�9<I�p_>AC � xo t�� � . 0 �� �>� � ���� ��������� / a�t$|�EeR��Y0VKTR>�V�p_>�Tw�J<GHsugbx�TRJbtu> 9 V_JMNN:"IXg*c 9 IKaba�V_JMNN:4�M��>B9<I�pK> Cha�mk|�Ee � �������� �>� � ���� ����������� / a�� � |�EeH�U8:9rJ<G��rJ<GHs�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 a<IXTe4V_=,:4�bsuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G�NH9*I�NMC%f � (� / i}j�l q�s$a�f"-��Fa |�"e�e 1�f"- �

= �K~b{ � � } � ¢ ¢ � � ��� �">�9<I�p_> f n a�i}j�l"�$n�� q�s�� � � � eUIKg<cof"-En a�i}j�l"�,n � q�s"� � � � eH�M�FsuNH9NH9b> GHs�cM>[e4VKg*cMs�NRsuV_g NR9<I�N � IKg<c NH9b>#�2TR>�>[g<IK=�>0VK��� IXTR>�gbVKN��*V_Jbg<c �rP��O� �OGHs�gbx NH9b>GQNRTHJ*e�NHJ<TRIKt�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>_�M��>de�IXg0IXt��"I�PMG:G^J<aba*V�G^>BNR9<I�NO� s�GFsug0gbV_TH=�IKt*�2V_TH= s5� >K���

��n v�w (��z a�ikjIl��pq�s,a ����� |� �Rt�ePe

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 27: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

?Xm � ����2�&�������������R��!���

8:9rJ<Gyf 1�� n bncfe v�w (��zga�ikj�l�� %���n�� q�s$a��}|� �Rt�e�eR�rIKg<c�J<GHs�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 V_JMNN:4� 9 IXa<a�VKJMN�:��MIXg*c9 cM>���e4VK=$:��">B9*I�pK>AC

f 1p� �'(� /�v�w (��zga�ikj�l�� %���np��q�s,a �O|� �Fa |�p��t�e�e�e 1pf -8:9<>�abTHVrVK��VX�"NH9<>�G^>we4VKg*cna<THV_a*>�T^NQP s�G�=�IKcM>��rPnsug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g V_g NH9b>�s�gM�2>�TR>�g*e4>�VX��f ��(� / f"-'�.Kn>=�IASK>�I�e�IKGH>�IXg<IKtuPMGHs�G:V_g�NR9b>dt�I_GQNFTRJbt�>K�

= �K~b{ � � � ~M}�|w~ � �/8 � ~ ��� |w~ � �/8 � �q��  ���d~ � ¢ � ¢ � � ����� NH9b>�TR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK=�TRJbtu>9 TR>�c0e4V_g�NH>4LrN�:�IKg<c�NH9b>B�'I_e�NFNH9*I�N� " s�GFI?e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g<e4> �

= �K~b{ � � ~ � � �2~ z�¢�~ ��� 9b>�TR>��">d9<I�pK>�I % TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKgq�bNH9*I�NOs�GQCLf�n�a�t��Ee�IKg<c t � � ���� / f"-'�8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_= � >�=?=?I �M�u@�£Ga� �GeR�k8:9<>�e�IKGH>�VX��TR>�e�VKTfc�GH>�t�>�e4NHs�VKg#s�GFGHs�=�s�t�IXT �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M}B� ¡ �F~ � ¢ � ¢ � � � ¡ ��� �">�9*I�pK>hf � �������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� ��f"-�e�IXg<cOt � . 0 �� �>� � �������������� / t"-_su=�£abt�su>wG%f>�At � (� / v�w (�Iz a�ikjIl��pq�s,a�f"-��Rt"-�e�eH�U8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>K��J<GHs�gbx � >�=?=�I �r��@4£Na������GeH�&t ��a�md|�Ee�/t"-�IXg<c��7J<GHs�gbx � >�=?=?I �r��@4£Na���&EeH�*NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�G^NRG\� G^J<ef9 NH9<IXN f 1�v�w (�Izga�i}j�l�� q�s$a�mk|� ����e�eIXg<c v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s���e " v�w (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s�f"-�eH� <�V_=��bs�gbs�gbx NR9b>�GH>�NQ��VnabTHV_a*>�T^NRsu>wG���>#VK�M£NRIKsug�C

a�f �Rt�e 1 vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�md|� ����e�e��Rt1 vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�� �Fagt��umd|�"ePe�e/ vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�� �Rt - e�e 9 ?A: " vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�f - �Rt - e�e 9 j :

�F9b>�TR>0TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg 9 ? :�s�G?abTRV�pK>wc J<GHsug<x � >�=?=�I �r��@4£Na������PedIXg*c TRJbt�> 9 TH>wc e4VKg�NR>4LrNN:4�"IKg<c TR>4£t�IXNHs�VKg 9 j :�s�G�a<THV�p_>�c/J<GHsugbx 8:9���l<�u@_�h\�g NH9b>nt�I_GQN�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g��:��>nIXt�G^V J<GH> NR9b>[�'I_e�N�NR9<I�Nl s%agt�e('�a�|& %Pikj�lAa���e�eFn*��s�=?abtus�>�G;lgsha�t - e�'=a�|&(%Gi}j�l a���ePeFn*�M��8:9b>da<THVrVX�ks�GFG^s�=?sut�IXTFs�g0NH9b>e�I_G^> 9 cb>4�Ue4VK=$:4�

/

K >dabTRV�pK>BgbV�� NR9<I�NBI�a<THVMe4>wGHG:s�GFI?p�IXt�Jb>K�<sug#NH9<>�G^>�g<G^>�VK����>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g jb��@K�Msu�kIKg<c#VKgbt�P�su�k�">de�IKgcb>�TRsup_>BI?t�IX=��,cbI?I_e�NHs�VKg��2TRVK= suN��

��� ~�� � � � � ��~M}�~b�X| � } � � ~M| �'¡�� ¡(��� ~ � � � { �CB � �dD��P�M'N���N� f ����� �����("� #k� ������� �N� f ' #u� �6�&����&�"�!J,� ����� ���P���'4 ���������$���&��� � ��"'��.�����&� f � � ���� / f"- %. } ¡�¡���8:9b>��<TfGQNksu=?abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g�s�Gqa<THV�p_>�cd�rP�sug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_g�V_gdNH9<>"GHs ��>�VK�Ef?�XIXg*cdNH9<>�TR>�p_>�TfG^>�a<THV_a*>�T^NQPs�G:abTRV�pK>wc��rP�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg#VKg#NH9<>dsugM�2>�TH>�g<e4>�VK�df �<� ���� / f"-5� /

��s�g<IXt�t�P��">`abTRV�pK>:VKJ<T�=�IXs�g�TH>wG^J<t�Nw�_G^NRI�NRsug<xdNH9<IXN�NH9<>�cM>�� £��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg�s�G�s�g<e4t�J<cM>wc?sug�NH9b>`�*IXTR�*>wce�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�

� � �r¡ } � � ��� B ����� �����PH�������� � ���������,���L��HG���MHG�N��PH����N��� ���&�����&� #������������ f #"ht ��;D��!����� fp����t %

:<;k¥=: >

Page 28: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� ?��

. } ¡�¡��?\�gB�r>we�Nw� �b�k��>#IXt�TH>wIKcMPnabTHV�p_>�c NR9<I�N " s�G�G^Pr=?=?>4NRTHs�e�IXg*c NH9<IXN�suN�s�G�I e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>�suN�s�G�>�g<VKJbx_9 NHV abTRV�pK>?NR9<I�Noa��AePC�NH9b>#cM>4� £¤�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g " s�G�I[�bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��UIXg*cNR9<I�N�a���eGCkNH9b>�cM>�� £��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg#abTR>�GH>�TRpK>wG�NR9b>d�<IXTR�<GMCFf! " t IKg<c�f '��Msu=?abt�su>wG;t '_�

a �&e$�rJbaba,V_GH> f! " t IKg<cBf / f"-5�_K >#a<THV�p_>�NH9*I�N?NH9b>�TH>#>4LMs�GQNfG?Ina<THVMe4>wGHG�t"-:GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�Nt / t"-�IXg<c=f"-% " t"-5���<THV_= � >�=?=�I �r�@?�£Na��GeH�,suNO�2VKt�t�V��`G:NH9<IXNONR9b>�TR>�>�Lrs�G^NRGOI�abTRVre�>�GRG �G^J*ef9 NR9<I�N$a��Ge"��f 1>���}�&��(� / �a-�IXg<cBa���e"��� - 1>f"-5���bTRVK= 8:9��qlb��@?IXg<c abTRVKa,>�THNQP4a �NeH�s�N��2V_tut�V��`G�NH9<IXN�t " ����8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_��G^s�g<e�>�f " t?��NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfGdI�abTRVMe4>wGHG GHJ<ef9nNH9<IXNMCt �'(� / �Fs�NR9��a-% " �kIXg*c IXt�G^V 9 J*G^s�gbx 8:9���lb��@�IXg<c abTRVKa,>�THNQP�a���eg:�C�f"- " �#��s�g<IKtut�PK�J<GHsugbx � >�=?=�I �r�@?�£Na����GeH��NH9b>�TH>�>�Lrs�G^NRGFI�abTRVre�>�GRG t"-�GHJ<ef9�NR9<I�N0Cyt / t�-�IXg<c t"- " �bIXg*cNH9rJ<G`GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXNMCht - " f - �

a���e$�rJbaba,V_GH>rf '_���bTRVK= � >�=?=?I �r� jb�`suN0�2VKt�tuV��`G�NH9<IXN�NR9b>�TR> >4LMs�G^NRG#I g*IX=?> � GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�Nf��<� ��� / f"-5�h�rs�g<e4> f " t?��NH9b>�TH>B>4LMs�GQNfG�I�abTRVre�>�GRGyt"-7GHJ<ef9�NR9<I�N t �<� ���� / t"-'�MIKg<c?NH9rJ<G�t '_�

/

8:9bs�Gdt�IKG^N�TH>wG^J<t�N�s�=?abtus�>�GdNH9<IXNdNH9b>�TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_gnt�I��`GdIXTR>�IXt�G^V0p�IXt�s�c �2V_T��<IKTH�,>�c e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�NR9<I�N`s�G:�">B9*I�pK>BNH9b>��2V_tut�V��Fs�gbx�a<THV_a*>�T^NRsu>wG��

� � �r¡ } � � � �.� ��� � � � �K~M| �2¡ ��� ~   { �

i}j�l���np��q�s,a�f �Rt�e ��� a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f�e��Fa�i}j�l���n���q�s�t�eikj�l���n�� q�s$a�f��Ee ��� i}j�l���n���q�s$aPa�ikjIl���np��q�s�f�e �Ee

i}j�l���n���q�s$a�i}j�l �8n q�s�f�e � � i}j�l �8n a�ikjIl���n�� q�s e q�s�a�ikjIl���np��q�s�f�ei}j�l���np��q�s,a � xo f��0e � � � xo a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f�e��a�ikj�l���np��q�s$a�a bkc�e f�e�e � � agbkcReGa�i}j�l���n���q�sOf�e a�c�gi l sha�t�ePe

� � ����!"������4���

8�V[=�P SrgbV��Ftu>wcMxK>_��NR9b>�TR>�s�GdgbV cMs�TH>we�N�a<THVrVX�:VX�FIXgrPngbVKgM£�NHTRs�p�s�IXtUt�I��`G��2V_T��<IXTR�,>�c e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�NR9<I�N`s�G`I?abTRVrVX�k>4LM9bs��bsuNHs�gbx�I?�<IXTR�,>�c#�bs�G^s�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g#NH9<IXNOe4VKg�NfIXs�g<G:NH9<>�cM>�GHsuTR>�c#>w�_J*IXt�s�NRsu>wG���\�g[9<s�GIKT^NRs�e�tu>�VKg�NH9b>Bsug�NR>�TRabTH>�NRIXNHs�VKg�VK� � s�g�3�- ?b@�1��bC��MY[sut�gb>�T:x_sup_>�G�IKg�s�g<GHsux_9_NH�2Jbt7sug�NRJbs�NRsup_>�TR>�I_G^V_g?�2VKTNR9bs�GO�'I_e�N0C`NH9<>�TR>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKgnTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg s�gM�2V_TH=�G�J<G�G^V_tu>�tuP0VKg NH9b>�s�g_NR>�TRg<IXt��,>�9<I�prs�VKTBVX��I�abTHVMe�>�GRG\f �suN�cM>wGHe�THs��,>�GF9bV�� f � G`a<IKT^NfGF=�I�P�s�g_NR>�TfIKe4N`�Fs�NR9 >�I_ef9#VKNH9b>�T��<�bJMN�g<VXN`9bV�� f =?I�P�sug�NR>�TfIKe�N`�FsuNH9NR9b>d>�grprs�THV_gb=?>�g�N��o �<TfGQNFG^V_tuJbNHs�VKg�NRV�TR>�cMJ<e�>`NR9b>�a<THVrVX�'G�NHV�IdNRTRI_e�NRIK�bt�>�GHs ��>K�rs�G�NHV�abTRV�pK>`I 'N���"� � 4A�d���Q����� �Mtus SK>

#��k�"VKJ<cbVKt�cbs�c s�g�-�@M/21"�2VKT�>4LbIK=�a<tu>_�kIKg<c NRV J<GH> �^JbaM£�NHV ��abTRVrVX�:NH>wef9bgbs���Jb>�G��n�"JMNw�U�Fs�NR9 NH9b>wG^>NR>�ef9bg<s���Jb>wG���V_gb>�e�IXgnVKgbt�P abTRJbgb>�NH9b>�GH>4N�VX�:e4VKg�NR>4LrNRG�NH9*I�Nd9<I�pK>�NHV#�*>�e�VKg<GHs�cb>�TR>�c���8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�NR9b>d=?V_G^N`J<GH>4�2JbtqGHVKt�JMNRsuV_g#s�G`e�>�THNRIXs�gbt�P�NHV�cb>4�<gb>�I?t�IX�,>�t�>�c#�bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg#NH9*I�N`s�GFsug*e4t�J<cM>�c#s�g0NH9b>e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>BIKg<c�NRV�abTRV�pK>�NH9b>ds�g�NH>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx�abTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G:�FsuNH9#NH9bs�GF>w�_J<sup�IXt�>�g*e4>K�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 29: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

?Kl � ����2�&�������������R��!���

\�g0NR9bs�GOTH>�a*V_T^Nw�<�">d9<I�pK>dJ*G^>wc�NR9bs�G`t�IKG^N�G^V_tuJbNHs�VKg#NHV�a<THV�p_>�NR9<I�NBIXg0>4LrNH>�g<cM>wc#�2VKTR=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g#VK�NR9b>�TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g NH9b>�VKTR>�= s�G�p�IKtus�c �2VKT��*IXTR�*>wc e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K� ��gbtuP TR>�e4>�g�NHt�PK�kI[G^s�=?sut�IXT�a<THV_a*>�T^NQP�:IKG�abTRV�pK>wc0�2VKTBNH9<>�t�VMe�IKtF77£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G�-u@wv21¤���"JMN�NH9bs�Gde�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GBs�GBgbVKN�a,VKt�P_I_cMs�e�IKg<c[NR9b>?t�IK�*>�tu>wc�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg#J<GH>�c�s�G`gbVXNF9bs�xK9b>�T^£¤VKTfcM>�T��8:9b>?=?>4NR9bVMc J<GH>�c sugnNH9<>�abTRVrVX��VK��NH9<s�G�S_>�P0TH>wG^J<t�N�s�G�IKt�GHV�s�g�NH>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx*��8:9b>�=�IXWQVKTBgbV�pK>�t�NQP

s�GBNH9*I�N �r£�NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg cMVr>�G�gbVKN�=?IXNRef9 TR>�cMJ<e4NHs�VKg��qs5� >K��f�� (� / f"-�cbV�>wGdgbVKN�s�=?abt�P f / f"- 9 GH>�>� >�=?=�I6�M� ? :���8:9<s�G ��NRTHs�eNS���9*IKG�xKTR>�I�NRtuP0GHsu=?abt�s��*>�c[V_JbTOabTRVrVX�'G���oOgbVXNR9b>�T SK>�P#G^NH>�a s�G`NR9b>�J<GH>�VK�NR9b>�JbaM£�NHV0e4VKg�NR>4LrNBa<THVrVX��=?>�NH9bVMc���s�g<G^NH>wIKc VK��I#cMsuTR>�e4NBa<THVrVX�UNR9<I�N #" s�G�I�e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>AC`s�g�3d�V_gb>BxK>�g<>�TfIXt�tuP?abTRV�pK>wG�NR9<I�N`I��bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g�s�GFI�e�VKgbx_THJb>�g<e4>_�r��P�>�LM9bsu�<s�NRsugbx?V_gb>��<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg��2VKT>wIKef90e4V_g<GQNRTHJ*e�NHV_T��MI�=?>4NR9bVMc�NR9<I�N`s�G:gbVKN`a*V�GHGHsu�<tu>B�2VKT�3�5��

8�V�e4VKg*e4t�J<cM>K�r\�abTH>wG^>�g�NH>�c�G^V_=?>BIKababt�s�e�I�NHs�VKg*G�NR9<I�N`G^NHTR>�GRG�NH9b>�s�=�a,VKTHNRIKg<e4>BVX��NH9b>�TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_gNR9b>�V_TH>�=0�/\�g��r>we�Nw��lb��@K����>09<I�p_>#J*G^>wc NR9b>[TH>�abt�s�e�I�NHs�VKg/t�I��`G�NHV abTRV�pK>�NH9b> e�VKTRTH>we�NHg<>�GRG�VK�BIKg>�g<e4VMcMs�gbx�VX�ha�� % � ueR��o GHs�=�s�t�IXT:TH>wG^J<t�N:s�G"x_sup_>�g�s�g�-u@_@�1��M�F9<>�TR>`NH9<>�GHVKJ<TRe�>Ot�IXgbx_J<IXx_>�e4V_g<GHs�cM>�TH>wcs�G�I0e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GdVX�:abTRsu=?suNHs�pK>�V_�MWQ>�e4NRG�-�@�1¤��\�g NH9bs�G�IKT^NRs�e�tu>_�q�">?cb>4�<gb>�I#GH>4N�VX�FcM>�TRsup_>�c e4V_g<GQNRTHJ*e�NRG�2V_T�s�=?a*>�TRIXNHs�pK> �Qg*IX=?>�c[V_�MWQ>�e4NRG �f�7�F9b>�TH>�s�=�a,>�TfI�NRsup_>�=?>�IKg<GONH9<IXNdIKg VK�bWQ>�e�Nde�IKg �,>�e�tuV_gb>�c��d\�gNR9bs�G�G^>�N^NRsugbx*��IKgnV_�MWQ>�e4N�s�GdI�365�abTRVMe4>wGHG��qcM>�gbVXNR>�c a � �����dq��%a � }n��&a�c"�egf� �� eIq�spf�eH��G^J*ef9nNR9<I�NGH>�t�>�e4NHs�VKg[VK�UNH9b>��<>�t�c � ��VKg NH9b>�TH>��2>�TR>�g<e�>��r�,NHTRsux_xK>�TfG:NR9b>�>�Lr>we4JMNRsuV_g VX�UNR9b>�=?>�NH9bVMc=f���FsuNH9 c��,VKJ<g<c�NHV��

� �����dq��ha � n��&a�c e�f �� eIq�spa�� ���, �Ae / - � �����dq��%a � n��Aa�c egf ��� e q�s�a�f � ��� ��c � �&e8:9<>�TR>�abt�s�e�I�NRsuV_g NR9b>�V_TH>�= s�GBJ<GH>�c NHV0abTRV�pK>�IKtux_>��bTfIXs�edt�I��`G�G^J<ef9 IKG���Jbg<cM>�Tde4>�THNRIKsugn9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GH>�GV_g�NR9b>dVMe�e�JbTHTR>�g*e4>�G"VK����sug f IXg<c�t?�Mg<IK=�>�tuP�NH9<IXN:NH9b>dV_�MWQ>�e4N���s�G:J<GH>�c#VKgbt�P��2V_T`e4t�VKgbs�gbx"C��� �� � �����dq��%a � n��Aa�c egf ��� e q�s�a���� � s}j�a��IePe � � � �����dq��ha � n��&a�c e�f �� e q�s��

� �����dq��ha � n��&a�c egf �� eIq�s a�f �Rt�e � � a � ��� �dq��%a � n!�Aa�c e�f ��� e q�s�f�e��a � ��� �dq��%a � n!�Aa�c e�f ��� e q�s_t�e

oOgbVXNR9b>�TUIXa<abtus�e�IXNHs�VKg�VK�<NR9b>�TR>�a<tus�e�IXNHs�VKgdNR9b>�V_TH>�=hs�G��2VKJ<g<c�s�g�NR9b>FcMs�G^NHTRs��bJMNH>wc�e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G�VX�R-�@�j�1���<JbsutuN`VKg�NHV_a0VX�}3�5��U\�g#NH9bs�G`e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��M��>de4V_g<GHs�cM>�T:NH9b>dTRJbt�>

a�"Ee i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�f �Rt�e 1 a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f�e��Fa�i}j�l���n���q�s�t�e

I_G�abTRs�=�suNHs�pK>�sug NH9b>#cM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g VX�FNR9b>�G^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTfIXt�>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>_��``VKNH>�NR9<I�N�NH9b> �^GHVKJ<g<cMgb>wGHG �?VK�NR9bs�GOGHPrG^NH>�= s�G`s�=?abt�su>wc[�rP � >�=?=�I�lb��@4£Na����GeH�:8:9b>�TR>�I_G^V_g�NR9<I�NB=?VXNHs�p�I�NR>�GFNR9bs�GOef9bV_s�e�>K�<s�GFNR9<I�NBs�NGHs�=�a<tusu�<>�GdNH9b>�cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg VK�:NH9b>�TR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g�� � >4N�J*G�cM>��<gb>�a<IKT^N�VK��NR9b>�GHPrg_NfI�L VX�:NH9b>cbs�G^NHTRsu�<JMNH>wc�3�5��qcM>�gbVXNR>�c�#$3 5 9<>�TR>K�7NHV[IKTHx_Jb=?>�g�N�NR9bs�G�e4t�IXs�=0��8:9bs�Gde�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GB>4LrNH>�g<c�3�5��FsuNH9t�VMe�IXNHs�VKg<GMC%$'&)(�(kf+*Q�qNH9<IXN�GQNfIXg<c<G��2VKT�NR9b>�abTRVre�>�GRG8f t�VMe�IXNH>�c I�NdNR9b>�GHs�NR>%&K�kIXg*c �FsuNH9 IKg C`SL<t�s SK>�e�VKg<G^NHTRJ<e4NMC-, � & -�~@t?�7J<GH>�c0NRV�GHa<I��Fg0NH9<>�abTRVMe4>wGHG t�I�N�NH9b>?G^suNH>.& -'�B\�g/#�3 5 �,NH9<>��2V_tut�V��Fsug<xTR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�s�GFIKcM=?s�GHGHs��btu>0 $1&2(( ikjIl���np��q�s,a�, � &d-�~ ����f�e�*��$1& -�(�(�t+* 3 /

0 $1&2((�ikjIl���n�� q�sOf+*��$1& -�(�( i}j�l���n�� q�s� �Rt+*43:<;k¥=: >

Page 30: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� ? �

8:9rJ<G��,THJbt�>$a�"Ee"IKtut�V��`GFV_gb>�NRV�e4V_g<G^s�cM>�T`NH9*I�N�a<THs�p�I�NH>�IXg<c[TR>�a<tus�e�IXNH>�c0TR>�GHVKJ<TRe�>�GFIXTR>��<I_G^s�ed�bTRs�eNSrGNR9<I�NOe�IXg0�,>�GHIX�2>�t�P�e�VKabs�>�c#s�g0I�e�VK=?=�J<gbs�e�I�NRsuV_g#�,>4NQ�">�>�g[cMs�G^NRIKg�N`tuVMe�IXNHs�VKg<G���oOgbVXNR9b>�T`s�g�NH>�THabTR>4£NfI�NRsuV_g s�G�NR9<I�Nw�qsu�:> �e4s�>�g<e�P s�GdgbVXNdNfI&S_>�g sug�NRV0I_e�e�VKJbg�N���IXg C`Sy<�e�VK=?=�Jbg<s�e�I�NHs�VKg IX=?V_Jbg�NRGBNHVGH>�g*c�NR9b>�e�VMcM>dVX�kNH9<>d�2Jbg<e4NHs�VKg[�,>�s�gbx�e�IKtut�>�c0IXN`NH9b>�tuVMe�IXNHs�VKg0VX�kNR9b>�e4t�s�>�g�N��F8:9bs�GFs�g_NRJbsuNHs�VKg[s�GOI�NNR9b>d9b>wIXTHN:VK�qNR9b>da<IXTfIKcbsux_=�VX�kTH>�=�VKNH>�>�p�IKtuJ<IXNHs�VKg�- ? �M1¤�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 31: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

?AY � ����2�&�������������R��!���

� � �������/��� ���� � � � � �F!U���#� ����� ���F�����`�

\�g NH9bs�G�GH>�e�NRsuV_g �">�a<THV�p_> � >�=?=?I �M��@K��`OVXNR>�NR9<I�N?�">�abTRV�pK>wc s�g/GH>�e4NHs�VKg � NH9*I�N�NH9bs�G?tu>�=?=?Is�=?abt�su>wGd8:9��=�M��@K� � >4N ��a�4eF�,>�NH9b>��2Jbg<e4NHs�VKgn�2THV_= TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg<G�NRV�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g<G�G�S_>4NRef9<>�c[s�gr�M>�e�Nw� �M�8:9*I�N�s�G ��a�4e n bncfe�� a�4e�j � a�4e�j ���F9b>�TH> � a�4e�s�G�Id�2Jbg<e�NRsuV_g�NH9*I�N�=�IASK>�G�I�e4t�V_GHJbTR>FV�pK>�T3�5 � GFVKa,>�TfI�NRVKTfG��MIXg*c �=a�4e�s�G`I��2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg#NR9<I�NO=�IASK>�GFI�e�tuV�G^J<TH>�V�pK>�T �Q�*IKGHs�e�cMs�GQNRTHs��bJMNRsuV_g0t�I��`G �f�IKg<c� s�GFI�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg#J<G^>wc�NRV�TH>we4V�p_>�T�NH9b> �HGQNRTHJ*e�NHJ<TRIKt,>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>�t�I��`G ���

� a�4e_n j #"mj G a�f %Nt�e��� � ��~ a�f %G��e i IXg*c a�� %Gt�e i Ij G agvwyxEzf %�vwyxEzWt�e �� a�f %Nt�e i Ij G aPa�f �"e %Qagt �EePe@�� a�f %Gt�e i Ij G�a � xo f���% � xo t �Me �� a�f %Gt�e i �Ij G�aPagbkcRegf %MagbdcRegt�e��� a�f %Nt�e i �Ij G�a � f # %���n�f� � % � t�#�% ��n�t � e �� a�fW#�%Gt�#0e�IXg<c�a�f� �%Gt 2e i �Ij G�a�fW#���f� %Nt�#=�ut &e@�� a�fW#�%Gt #0e�IXg*c�a�f� �%Gt &e i Ij G a�i}j�l���n�f #�q�s�f� %PikjIl���n�t�#uq�sOt &e �� a�fW#�%Gt #0e�IXg<c�a�f� �%Gt �e i I

� a�4e�n � a�ikj�l��pq�s$a�f �Ee'%Pikj�l���-Mq�s�a�f �2e�e � a�i}j�l��pq�s�m %Pikj�l���-Mq�s"&Ee i IKg<cl sha�f�e('�a�i}j�l a���e&j.ikj�lAa���-�e�ekn*� �j �Ia�ikjIl���np��q�s,a�f �Rt�e %Pikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�a�ikj�l���n���q�sOf�e,�Rt�e�e �j �Ia�ikjIl���np��q�s,a�f*��e'%Gi}j�l���n�� q�s,a�a�i}j�l"��np��q�s�f�e���e�e �j GEa�ikj�l���np��q�s$a�a bkc�e f�e'%Qagbdc�eNa�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf�ePe��� c�gi lgsha���e Ij �Ia�ikjIl���np��q�s,a � xo f��0e�% � x� a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e5�2e��j G a�ikj�l���np� %���n q�s�f %Gi}j�l"��np� %��8n q�s�a�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf�e�e �� �ogi l sya���e Ij GEa�ikj�l���np� %���n q�s�f %Gi}j�l"��np� %��8n a�i}j�l���np��q�s eIq�s�f�e �� �ogi l sya���e I

n �Ia�f � %Gf�e���j �Ia�f��Rt %Nt ��f�e���j��Ia�f��Fagt�����e'%Ma�f��Rt�e�����e��j GEa�ikjIl���np��q�s�f %Gf�e �� � gi l sya�f�e I j G"a v�wyxEzf %Pf�e �� m�gi l s%a�f�e:Ij � a�i}j�l���n�� q�s$a v�wyxEzf�e'%�v�wLxEzga�i}j�l���n�� q�s�f�e�e �j GEa�ikjIl���np� %��8n q�sOf %Gi}j�l �8n %��$n�� q�sOf�e �� � gn � %�� gi l s%a e'%�� gi l s%a���e:Ij � a v�wLxEz�v�w��IzWf %Nv�w��Iz�v�whx�zf�e��j GEagv�wLxEz�f �ut %Nv�wyxEzga�f �Rt�e�e �� m�gi l s%agt�e:Ij GEa�a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e��Rt %Pikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f��Rt�ePe@�� � gi l s%agt�e Ij G a�agvwyx�zf�e ��%Nv wLxEzga�f �Ee�e �� �mgn�m Ij G a�a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e ��%PikjIl���np��q�s,a�f �EePe@�� � gn � Ij � aPa�f �ut�e �(%Ma�f �Ee��Fagt �Ee�e �j � a � xo f�� ��% � xo f��0e ��j �Ia ��% e �8:9b>B�2Jbg*e�NHs�VKg� s�G:=?VKgbVKNHV_gbs�eBIXg*c��2V_T:IKtut(��� �_�M��>B9<I�p_> � ��a�4e � � % a�4eH��8:9rJ<G����2VKT

>�pK>�THP�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg � �*�">�e�IKg[cM>4�<g<>�NH9<>�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg � � n bncfe � %���� � % a ��eH�F\¤NOs�GOG^NHTfIXs�xK9�NH�2VKTR�"IKTRcNRV?abTHV�p_>`NR9<I�N`su� � s�G`e�tuV�G^>wc��rP�GHJb�<G^NHsuNHJMNRsuV_g�VK��g*IX=?>�G��2VKTFp�IKTHs�IX�bt�>�G���NH9b>�g#NH9b>dGRIX=?>�9bVKt�cbG��2VKT� % a ��eH�XIKg<cBNH9rJ<Gq�2VKT � � �UY0VKTR>�V�p_>�Tw�4s�G�>�I_G^PONHV�abTHV�p_>kNH9<IXN����2V_Tq>�p_>�TRPOTR>�t�I�NRsuV_g � ��NR9b>�TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g

:<;k¥=: >

Page 32: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� ?Kv

� %���� � % a ��e:s�G�I�e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�*IKg<c0NR9<I�N�NH9b>�TH>�t�IXNHs�VKg � %���� � % a� �eFe4V_g_NfIXs�g<G 1���<�VKg<e�>�TRgbsug<xNR9b>��2Jbg<e�NRsuV_g�� a�4eH�Ks�Nks�G�>wIKGHP�NRVOabTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN2� � � � � �UY0VKTR>�V�p_>�Tw��suNUs�G�a*V�GHGHs��btu>�NHVBabTRV�pK>UNR9<I�Na�i}j�l��pq�s8m}e � ��a�ikjIl�� - q�s"&EeH�rs�=�a<tus�>�G a�ikj�l��pq�sOf��Mm��2c��&e � ��a�ikjIl�� - q�sOf��3&#�2c��AeR���F9<>�gb>�pK>�Ta�i}j�l a���e j�ikj�lAa���-�e�e('�l sya�f�ekn*�M�\�g�NR9bs�G�GH>�e�NRsuV_g�����>`a<THV�p_>�NR9<I�N"s�� � s�G�I��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg�Jbab£5NRV � 9 GH>�> � >�=?=�I �M��@0:4�KNR9b>�g1� �

s�G`I�cM>�� £¤GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g��%K >�9<I�pK>dIKtuTR>�I_cMP�gbVKNH>�c�NR9<I�NOsuN`s�GOe4t�V_GH>�c��rP�GHJb�<G^NHsuNHJMNRsuV_g<G��bNH9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>�s�N�s�GGHJ �e4s�>�g�N�NRV�abTRV�pK>:NR9<I�N � � s�G�Idx_THV_Jbg<c?G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��k�">4�2VKTR>FNRV�>�G^NRIK�btus�GH9?NH9bs�G�TR>�GHJbtuN�����>OabTHV�p_>NQ�"V?sug�NR>�TR=�>wcMs�IXTRP�tu>�=�=�I_G��

��� ~ y � � � �Q� � HG���.H����N��� ���&�����&� 2D�� �g� � #y�&���$����� � � HG�O��� �8�P�Q���&�����&� � %���� � % a ��e #� ���h���N���IHG����-% � ��� |��%M|A HG��� �,��2DE� ��� #y����� � %!��- HP�O� ���A��%�E������&���8�!������� ��"'���������� !

a�i}j�l��pq�s�|�Ee � � a�ikj�l�� - q�s.|A�e % B ���y�������� ��I��D��P�ND������������ � ����� !a��Ge � � f � � t �&��� a�l sha�f�e('.ikjIl a�� e�edn a�l sya�t�e"'.ikjIl a��o-�ePedn � #%��� ���

a�ikj�l��pq�s�a�f |�"ePe�� ��a�i}j�l��o-Mq�s$a�t |A�e�e

a� �Ge � � f ��. 0 �� � 1 � � �� ��������� / f"- ����� l sha�f�e '�a�i}j�lIa�� eWj�i}j�l a���-�e�e�n � #8�����Q�p��� ���P� � 4 ������� �.DE�P�0'N���N�f - - �N"'��,��� ��� f ��. 0 �� � 1 � = ������������ / f - - ����� a�ikj�l��pq�sOf - e�� � a�i}j�l�� - q�s�f - - e %L�\����� � f �". 0 �� � ��� 1 ������������ /f"- �&��� l sha�f�e 'Ba�ikjIl a�� e�j�ikj�lAa���-�e�e,n � #O��� ���p�����Q�P� �'4 ������� �oDE�G�M'N���G� f"- - ��"'��_��� ���f �<. 0 �� � = � 1 ������������ / f"- - ����� a�i}j�l��pq�s�f"-�e � � a�ikjIl���-Qq�s�f"- -�e +

� �Q� ��%#A HG�O� �$�����,��� ��"'��.�����&� a�ikj�l�� q�s��Ee � � a�ikjIl���-0q�s A2e %a��� �Ge � � f��"� ���� / f"- ����� lgsha�f�e�'oa�i}j�l a���e j�ikj�lAa���-�e�ekn*� #d��� ���=�����Q�P��� 4 �������8� DE�P�0'N���N� f"- - ��"'��

��� ��� f!� � =�� / f"- - ���� a�ikj�l��pq�sOf"-�e�� ��a�i}j�l��o-Qq�s�f"- -We %. } ¡�¡�� � >�N\|��%2|A:�,>FNQ�"V�NHJbabt�>�G�VX�7NH9<>OGHIK=?>OG^s���>_�_IKg<c,f %Gt �,>FNQ�"VdabTHVMe�>�GRG^>wGUG^J<ef9?NR9<I�NLf � � t?��<VKT:NR9b>��<TfGQNFabTRVKa,>�THNQPK�r�">d=?IASK>�IXg0s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg0VKg�NH9b>�GHs���>�VX��|�<�

= �K~b{ � ��|���An � � GHs�g<e4> GEa�ikj�l���np��q�sOf %Pf�e��� � gi l sya�f�e:I?s�GOI�GHJb�<GH>4NFVK�2� � �b��>�9<I�p_>a�i}j�l��pq�s�f�e � � f � � t � � a�i}j�l�� - q�s�t�e

sug#NR9b>�e�I_G^>wG"GHJ<ef9#NH9*I�N�a�l sha�f�e('.ikj�lAa���e�edn a�l sya�t�e"'.ikj�lAa���-�e�edn � �= �K~b{ � ��|���An � 3�� � G^Jba<a*V�G^>BNH9*I�N�a�ikj�l��pq�s�a�f |�EePe � � a�ikj�l���-0q�s$a�t |A0ePeR��8:9b>da<IKsuTa�a�i}j�l��pq�s,a�f��"ePe'%Ma�ikjIl�� - q�s,a�f A2ePePe�s�G"sug�� � �rNR9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�_J*G^s�gbx�NH9b>BNHTfIXg*G^suNHs�prs�NQP?VX� � � �IXg<c�NR9b>��'IKe4N"NR9<I�N`suN`s�G`I?e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K�r�">B9*I�pK>AC

ikj�l��pq�s$a�f |� �B%��@#2e n ikjIl�� q�s$aPa�ikj�l��pq�s�f |�Ee �B%��@#2e� � ikjIl���-Qq�s,a�a�i}j�l�� q�sOf |�Ee A %���#2e� � ikjIl���-Qq�s,a�a�i}j�l���-Qq�sOt |A2e A %��@#�e� � ikjIl���-Qq�s,a�t |A�A %��@#�e

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 33: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

j / � ����2�&�������������R��!���

K >�abTRV�pK>�NH9b>�GH>�e�VKg<cnabTRVKa,>�THNQP �rP s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg VKg NH9<>�sugM�2>�TH>�g<e4>�VK�Lf�� . 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / f"-5� � >4N ��� nq�s8mk~�a |���M|�"e�IXg<c ��� npq�sOm}~ a |���2|A2ePC

= �K~b{ � � ¢ � ��� ��� �">B9*I�pK>�f n � xo fW# � � � ���� / f"-�n a�f #�|�EeH��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>ACFf � � =� � / a�fW#,|A2e�IKg<c��G^s�g<e�>$fW# � � f #���NH9b>�>�LMa*>we�NH>wc TH>wG^JbtuNMC,a�i}j�l��pq�s$a�fW#�|�EePe � � a�ikjIl�� - q�s$a�fW#,|A2ePeH���2VKt�tuV��`G�2THV_= � >�=?=?I�o��u@�£Ga�Ge �

= �K~b{ � �����_  ����� �">�9*I�pK>yf n�vwyx�zfW#�IXg*cOf # ��� ���� / f"-# s�=�a<tus�>�Gdf ��� ���� /�v�whx�zf"-# ��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�J<GHsugbx NR9b>[sug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_g 9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G���suN?�2VKt�tuV��`G�NR9<I�N?NR9b>�TR>0>4LMs�G^NRG�I abTRVMe4>wGHG�f"- -# GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�NfW# � � =� � / f - -# ���Fs�NR9 a�i}j�l��pq�s�f -# e�� ��a�i}j�l�� - q�sOf - -# eR� 8:9b>�TR>�GHJbtuN��2V_tut�V��`G��2TRVK= NR9b>��'IKe�NNH9<IXN� � s�GOI�e�VKgbx_THJ<>�g<e�>K�k8:9b>dabTRV�VK��s�GFG^s�=?sut�IXTFs�g#NH9b>�e�IKGH> 9 cM>4�U=�JE::IXg<c 9 a*IXTFs�gE: �

= �K~b{ ��� ~ ��� � � ��� �">�9*I�pK>AC\f n a�f # �2eFIKg<c�f # � . 0 �� � � 1 ? 1 ��� ������������������ / f"-# ��s�=?abt�su>wG�a�f �0e ��� ���� / f"-# ��OGHsug<x NR9b>0sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g 9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�G���s�N��2VKt�tuV��`G�NH9*I�N?NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�InabTRVMe4>�GRG�f"- -# GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�NfW# �<. 0 �� � � 1 ? 1 ��� = �� ������������� / f"- -# IXg<c_a�ikj�l��pq�sOf"-# e � ��a�ikjIl���-0q�s�f"- -# eH��8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�N��2VKt�tuV��`GO�2THV_= NH9b>�'IKe4NFNH9<IXN�a�f �0e ��� =� � / f"- -# �

K >?abTRV�pK>�NH9b>?NR9bsuTfcnabTHV_a*>�T^NQP[�rP s�g<cMJ*e�NHs�VKg V_g NR9b>�sugb�2>�TR>�g<e�>�VK�Lf �"� �� � / f"-5��8:9b>?abTRVKa,>�THNQP[s�GNRTHs�prs�IKtUs�� � s�G�I#t�IX�,>�t��qVKTdsu� ��n ����8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�qsug NH9<>?�2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx0abTRV�VK�Q���">�e4VKg*G^s�cM>�TBNR9<I�N�� s�G�,VKJ<g<c#��P)� C

= �K~b{ � � �2~ z�¢�~ ��� ��>�9<I�p_> f n a�bdcRegf #���8:9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN:�2VKt�tuV��`G"�2TRVK=�NR9b>��'IKe4N:NH9<IXNa�ikjIl��pq�s�f�� �#�2c��Ae � � a�ikjIl�� - q�s�f���A �2c��Ae

Kn>?V_�MNRIKsugnNH9bs�G�TR>�GHJbt�N��rP[J<GHsugbx#NR9b> �Qt�I��`GOs�g � a�4e �f�7NRV[cMs�G^NHTRs��bJMNH>�NR9b>�cM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g<G�V�pK>�TIXgrP�e4V_g<GQNRTHJ*e�N�VK�Rf?�k8:9<>�g��">OJ<GH>`NR9b>��'IKe�N�NH9<IXN����2VKT"IXt�t�t G^J<ef9�NH9<IXN\a�l sha�t�e '$a�i}j�l a���eHji}j�l a���-�ePe�edn �M�MNR9b>dTH>�t�IXNHs�VKg a�ikjIl��pq�s�a�t �"ePe � � a�ikj�l���-Mq�s$a�fCA�e�e�s�G:p�IKtus�c��

= �K~b{ ��� � ~M} �'~ z�¢�~ ��� 8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�N��2VKt�tuV��`Gk�2TRVK= abTRVKa,>�THNQP�a�Ge�IXg*c?NH9b>�THJ<tu>`VK�qcMs�GQNRTHs��bJMNRsuV_gVX�UcM>4�*gbs�NRsuV_g<G:V�pK>�T:a<IXTfIXt�tu>�t�e4V_=�a,V_GHsuNHs�VKg �

= �K~b{ � � �q��  � ��~ � ¢ � ¢ � � ����� NH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= � � �,>�s�gbx�I?e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g<e4>_�/

��� ~ y ���.��� � y?�K| �2¡ � {�~ � ¢ y ��� � � �_~M| �'¡�� � ! � f ��. 0 �� � 1 � � �� ��������� / f - #������Q�������Q�P�$� 4 �������,��� q�s ����P�&����������&� ��"'��o��� ��� f!� . 0 �� � � 1 ? � ��� � � ? ��� �� ������������������� / f"- -4 ���� f"- -(1 a�f"- �Ee %��G^s�gbx`TRJbt�> 9 IKabads�gE:����">�VK�MNfIXs�g���IKG�IOe4VKTRVKt�t�IXTRPK��NR9<I�N�s��"f ��. 0 �� ��� � � ������������ / f"-'�wNH9<>�g,a�f �Ee �/. 0 �� �>� � � � ? � � ���������������� /�f"- -�FsuNH9 f"- -(1 a�f"- �EeR�. } ¡�¡���8:9b>`a<THVrVX�7s�G��rP�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg�V_g?NH9b>`s�gM�2>�TH>�g<e4>`VK��f �<. 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / f"-'�U�<VKT�e�VKgrpK>�gbsu>�g<e4>:�">`�Fs�tutJ*G^> � NHV[cM>�g<VXNH>�NR9b>�IKe4NHs�VKgrq�s8mk~�a |���0|�"eH��IXg<c � � NHV cM>�gbVXNR>�NR9b>�IKe4NHs�VKg�q�s�mk~ a�a |�% �Ee �MaP|��% �Ee�eR�,Kn>=�IASK>�I�e�IKGH>�IXg<IKtuPMGHs�G:V_g�NR9b>dt�I_GQNFTRJbt�>K�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 34: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j<@

= �K~b{ ��� ¢ � ��� ��� ��>�9<I�p_> � x f�� � �� / a�f |�Ee:�2VKTdIKtut |��IXg<c |�,��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR> � x f�� � � ���� /a�f |� �Ee �= �K~b{ �+� �q��  ����� �">#9<I�pK>of n v�wLxEzWf # IXg<cBf # ���� / f"-# s�=?abt�su>wG�f ���� / f"-;n v�wyxEzf"-# �8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�UG^s�g<e4> �Qgn m��U�">�e�IXg J<GH>�NR9b>#sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g 9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�G�IKg<c TRJbtu> 9 gb>�� =�J�:�NHVabTRV�pK>�NR9<I�N�v�wyxEzf ��� ���� / v�wLxEz�f"- -# �Fs�NR9�f"- -# 1 a�f"-# �EeR��8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�NB�2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= v�wLxEz�f"- -# 1v�wLxEzga�f"-# �Ee 1 v�wLxEzf"-# �*�FK >�9<I�pK>dI?GHsu=?s�t�IKTFabTHVrVK��s�g�NR9b>�e�I_G^> 9 cb>4�U=�JE: �

= �K~b{ � � � ~b} �$� ��� ��>O9<I�pK> f n a�fW#,��t�#2e�IKg<c,fW# ���� / f"-# su=?abt�s�>�Ghf ���� / f"-En a�f"-# �Eagt�# |�MePeH��OGHsug<xdNH9b>Osug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g�9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G�IXg<c?TRJbt�> 9 a<IKT�s�gE:���suN��2VKt�tuV��`GUNH9<IXNyf � � ���� / a�f"- -# �Eagt�# |���Ee�e�Fs�NR9�f - -# 1 a�f -# �EeH��8:9<>�TR>�GHJbtuN��2V_tut�V��`G`�2TRVK=�a�f - -# �hagt�# |� �Ee�e 1 aPa�f -# �Ee.�ha�t�# |� �EePe 1a�f"-# �Fa�t�# |�0ePe � �

= �K~b{ � � ~ � ���$� ��� t�>4N����*>dNR9b>�IKe4NHs�VKg q�s�m}~ a�a A% |�0e �M|�EeH�hKn>�9*I�pK>8f n�a�fW# A�e�IXg<c�f # ���� /�f"-#su=?abt�s�>�G�f����� / f"-hn>f"-# � �OGHsug<x0NH9b>�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg 9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�GdIXg<c TRJbt�> 9 IXa<a s�gE:4��suNd�2VKt�tuV��`GNH9<IXN;f!� � ���� / f"- -# �FsuNH9 f"- -# 1 a�f"-# �EeR�b�F9bs�ef9�s�G:NH9<>d>4LMa*>we�NR>�c#TH>wG^J<t�Nw�

/K >`gbV�� abTHV�p_>�NR9b>F=�IXs�g?TH>wG^JbtuN�VX�*NH9bs�G�IKaba,>�g<cMsuL��XNR9<I�N�s�GQC�s���� IXg<c�� � # IKTH>:�bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg<G

J<aM£5NRV �?�kNH9<>�g � � s�G�I[xKTRVKJ<g<c G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg��nY[VKTR>�abTR>�e4s�GH>�t�PK�k��>�G^s�=�JbtuNRIKgb>�V_J<GHtuP abTRV�pK>?NQ�"Va<THV_a*>�T^NRsu>wGQCksu�La�f %Gt�e i ����a ��eH�MNR9b>�g

= s��Lf&���� /�f"-kIXg*c � a � e�gn � � � �,NH9b>�g NH9<>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�abTRVre�>�GRG\t"-kGHJ<ef9[NR9<I�N0C;t&���� / t�-'��IXg*cf"- � � t"- �

= s��;f ��������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-�eH�kNR9b>�g NR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I[a<THVMe4>wGHG�t"-�IKg<c IXg >�g�prs�THV_gb=?>�g�N���-�G^J*ef9NH9<IXNMCht ��� ������ �� ��� = �� ����������� / a���- �Gt"-�eH�b�FsuNH9 f"- � � t�-'�bIKg<c �(|���An � |A � 9 GRI�P �R:��<IKg<c��2VKT`IXt�t � i � �A~ ~ � ���>�9<I�p_>�a�ikjIl��pq�s � �e � � a�ikjIl���-Mq�s A �eH�

8:9<s�G:abTRVrVX��s�GF=�I_cM>���P�sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g#V_g ,�IKg<c�V_g#NH9b>�cM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg0VX� ��a�4eR��rs�g<e�> � � a�4eFn D F7�*NH9b>�e�IKGH>��2VKT ,.n ��s�G�GQNRTRIKsux_9�N^�2VKTR�:IXTfcuC�NH9b>�s�cM>�g_NRs�NQP#TR>�t�I�NHs�VKg0s�GOe�tu>wIXTRtuP

I?�<s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKgq���bV_TFNH9<>�e�I_G^> ,$n�a�� 3��&eR�bNR9b>�abTRVrVX�ks�G`cbsuprs�cM>�c[IKtuV_gbx?NH9b>�NR9bTR>�>�=�IXs�g[G^J<�<G^>�NRGVK� ��a�4eH� ``VXNR>#NH9<IXN���J*G^s�gbx NH9b>0abTRVKa,>�THNQP VX� DIXg*c � a��e�x_sup_>�g/I�N?NH9b>0�,>�x_sugbg<sugbx VK�ONH9<s�GIKaba,>�g<cMsuL��*suN�s�G�>�IKGHP�NHV�a<THV�p_>�NH9<IXN f 1�t su=?abt�su>wG\f � � t?� � s�S_>��Fs�G^>_�*J<GHs�gbx�NH9<>�abTRVKa,>�THNQP�VK�� a�4eH�<s�N`s�G:>�I_G^P�NRV?abTHV�p_>ONR9<I�N� � s�GFe4V_=?a*V�G^suNHs�VKg<IKt5�� 9 ; �R7V�=@? M I�C�� IKJ7Y�CERO=�J7A&=�_~b{ � f � t ¡ } f " t � �rP/cM>4�<g<s�NRsuV_g��"NH9b> TR>�t�I�NRsuV_g<G�� IXg<c " IXTR>0sug<e�tuJ*cM>�c s�g � � �8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>�NH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuNRG"�2VKt�t�V��`G"�2THV_=�NH9b>�cb>4�<gbsuNHs�VKg0VK�qNH9<>d�bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g�Jbab£5NRV �?��_~b{ � a�f %Gt�e i � % a ��e ~ � ¢ agt %P��e i � % a ��e � G^J<aba*V�G^>�NH9<IXN�f � �� / f"-:IXg*c � a � e gn ����� �K >?J<GH>�NR9b>?sug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_gn9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G�NHV0abTRV�pK>�NH9<IXN��&� �� / �a-UIKg<c�f"- � � �a-5�qIXg*c[NH9<>�sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G�IKx_IKsug�NHV`a<THV�p_>qNR9<I�Nkt � �� /�t - IXg<c�� - � � t - ��8:9b>�TH>wG^JbtuN��2VKt�t�V��`G7�2THV_= NR9b>UNHTfIXg*G^suNHs�prs�NQPVK� � � ��8:9b>�abTRV�VK��s�G`GHsu=?s�t�IKT"s�g#NH9b>�e�IKGH>�VX��V_JMNHa<JMNOIKe4NHs�VKg<G��

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 35: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

jI? � ����2�&�������������R��!���

�_~b{ �=f n v�wLxEzf # ~ � ¢ t n v�wyxEzWt�# �= �K~b{ � � a � eOgn � � � � NH9b>"t�I_GQN�THJ<tu>U�2V_T�s�gM�2>�THTRsug<x;f �'�� / f"-Ks�G 9 gb>�� =�JE:4�XIXg<c�f"-�n�v�wLxEzf"-# �FsuNH9fW#����� /�f"-# � ��G^s�gbx:NH9<>�sug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_gd9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��ws�Nq�2VKt�tuV��`G,NR9<I�Nkt #���� / t"-# �FsuNH9,a�f"-# %Gt"-# e i � �IXg<c���J<G^s�gbx�THJbt�> 9 gb>�� =�JE:4�7NH9b>�TH>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg t � �� / v�wLxEz�t - # ��8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�NB�2VKt�tuV��`G�2THV_= v�wLxEzf"-# � �pv�wyxEzWt"-# �

= �K~b{ � � a � ehn � ��� � su�kNH9b>�t�I_GQN�THJbt�>�s�G 9 gb>��hV_JMNN:4�<NR9b>�g0NR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfGOI�a<THVMe4>wGHG;f"-# IXg<c[IKg>�grprsuTRVKg<=�>�g�N�� G^J<ef9 NH9<IXN�f"-Fn a�� ��v�wLxEz�f"-# e`IXg*c�f # �'�� / a�� �Pf"-# eH� �OGHsug<x�NR9b>?sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��bsuN`�2V_tut�V��`G"NH9<IXN t�# � �� / a�� - �Gt - # e��FsuNH94a�f -# %Gt - # e i � � � � s SK>ds�g�NR9b>�abTR>�prs�VKJ<Ge�I_G^>_�rNH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN"�2V_tut�V��`G:J<GHsug<x�TRJbt�> 9 gb>�� V_JMNN::IKg<c�NR9b>��'IKe4NFNH9<IXN8a�f"-# %Nt"-# e i � � s�=�a<tus�>�GagvWwhxEzWf"-# %Nv wLxEzWt�-# e i � � ��rJbaba,V_GH>�NR9b>�t�IKG^N�THJ<tu>�s�G 9 gb>���V_a*>�gE:��[8:9rJ<G�f # ������� � �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Pf -# e�IXg<crm gn &,� �OGHsugbxNH9b>�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg�9�Pra,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��rs�N:�2V_tut�V��`G�NR9<I�N t�# � ����� � �� ��� = �� ����������� / a���- �Gt�-# ek�Fs�NR9�C�a�f"-# � � t"-# eUIXg*ca�ikj�l��pq�s.|�Ee � ��a�i}j�l���-Qq�so|A2eR�MNH9<IXN`s�G"NR9b>d>4LMa,>�e4NH>�c#TR>�GHJbtuN��

�_~b{ ��f n a�f # �Ee ~ � ¢ t n agt # �Ee � �">�=�IASK>�I�e�I_G^>"IXg<IKtuPMGHs�G�VKgdNR9b>:t�I_GQN�THJ<tu>"VX�MNR9b>"NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_gf ���� / f"-5�h�rJbaba,V_GH>�NH9*I�N fW# � ������ / f"-# 9 �FsuNH9 � a � #�eOgn � ��� :�C

= �K~b{ � � ~ � � |�~ ����� ��>B9<I�p_> � n � # n ���FKn>BJ<GH>`NH9<>�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg�9�Pra,VXNR9b>�GHs�G�NHV�abTRV�pK>FNR9<I�Nt # � (� / t"-# �FsuNH9 f"-# � � t�-# ��8:9b>�TR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`GFIXaba<tuPrs�gbx?THJbt�> 9 IKaba#NRIXJ�: �

= �K~b{ � � ~ � � � ¡ ��� �">�9<I�p_> � n � IXg*c � # n � �*���OGHs�gbx�NR9b>�s�g<cMJ*e�NHs�VKgn9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��,��>abTRV�pK>"NH9<IXNUNH9b>�TH>F>�LMs�G^NRG�IBNRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�t # � � �� � / t - # �FsuNH9$f -# � � t - # �U8:9b>FTR>�GHJbt�NU�2V_tut�V��`G��2TRVK=THJ<tu> 9 IXaba0e4V_=,: �

= �K~b{ � � ~ � ���$� ��� ��>d9<I�p_> � # n q�s�m}~ a�a �(% |�0e �0|�Ee�IXg<c � n q�s�m}~ a |� �M|�EeH���OGHsug<x�NH9b>�sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��kNR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg_t # � � �� � / t"-# �Fs�NR9_f"-# � � t�-# �n8:9<>�TR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G�2THV_= TRJbtu> 9 IXaba#s�gE: �

= �K~b{ ��� ~ ��� ¡ �q| ��� ��>?9<I�p_>�f # ���������� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Gf -# e`su=?abt�su>wG8f ��������� �� ��� � � ? = � ������������������ / a�� �Qa�f -# A2ePeH��OGHsug<x?NH9b>ds�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg09rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�G��<s�NF�2V_tut�V��`G"NH9<IXN\t # � � ������ �� ��� = �� ����������� / a���- �Gt"-# e��Fs�NR9 f"-# � � t"-#IXg<c�a�ikj�l��pq�s�|�"e�� � a�i}j�l���-Qq�s.|A2eH��8:9<>OTR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= THJ<tu> 9 IXa<a�VKJbNN:�IXg<c?NR9b>��'IKe�NNH9<IXN �mgi a�ikj�l a���e&j.ikjIl a��o-WePe�su=?abt�s�>�G�a�ikj�l��pq�s��Ee � � � � � a�ikj�l���-Mq�s �EeR�

�_~b{ ��f n�a�bdcRegf # ~ � ¢ t n�agbkcRe t # � NH9b>0t�IKG^N�TRJbt�>�s�G?gb>we4>�GRGRIXTRsut�P 9 t�IK=��7cbI :4� 8:9b>#TR>�GHJbt�N�2V_tut�V��`GO�2THV_= NH9b>��'IKe4N�NR9<I�N � � s�Gde�tuV�G^>wc[�rP[sug*GQNfIXg�NHs�I�NRsuV_g���8:9b>�abTRV�VK��s�GBGHs�=�s�t�IXT�sug NH9b>�e�IKGH>f n � f # %���npf � IXg<c�t n � t # % �un�t � IKg<cds�gdNH9b>:e�I_G^>yf n � xo f # �UIKg<cOt n � x� t # ����_~b{ � f n a�f # �Lf e ~ � ¢ t n a�t # ��t e � \¤�dNH9b>nt�I_GQN#THJbt�> VK��NH9b>�WQJ<cMx_=�>�g�Nof ���� / f"-s�G 9 a<IXT�NRIKJE:�� 9 a<IXT�t�IK=��7cbI :4� 9 a*IXT�s�gE:�VKT 9 a<IXT�VKJMN�:��FNR9b> TR>�GHJbtuN��2VKt�t�V��`G?�2THV_= NH9b>nsug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G�IXg<c NR9b> �'I_e�N�NH9<IXN a�f %Nt�e i � � s�=?abt�su>wG�a�f |� %Gt |�Me i � � �2VKT0IXgrP NHJbabt�> VK�g*IX=?>�G |���#8:9b>�VKg<tuPnsug�NH>�TH>wGQNRsug<x0e�IKGH>�s�G�G^J<ef9 NR9<I�NdNR9b>�t�IKG^N�THJbt�>?J<GH>�c s�G 9 a<IKT�e4V_=,:4�o�rJ<aba*V�G^>NR9<I�N�f # ��� ������ �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-# eBIXg<crf �/. 0��� ��� � � �� ��������� / f"- IXg<c4f"-yn v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s,a�f"-# �uf"- ePeH� �OGHsugbx

:<;k¥=: >

Page 36: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j_j

NR9b>#sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g 9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�G��UsuN��2VKt�tuV��`G�NH9<IXN,t�# � �������� �� ��� = �� ����������� / a��o- �Nt"-# e��Fs�NR9�a��0e)�%f"-# � � t�-# IXg*ca�i}j�l��pq�s$|�Ee � � a�ikj�l���-Mq�s.|A�eH� �OGHsug<x � >�=?=�I�o���@K�KNH9bs�GUt�IKG^N�abTHV_a*>�T^NQPds�=?abt�su>wGUNH9*I�NUNH9<>�TR>">�LMs�G^NRGf - - GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXNMC

f� � . 0 �� ��� � = �� ��������� / f - - �Fs�NR9 a�ikj�l��pq�sOf - e � � a�ikj�l�� - q�s�f - - e��s�g<IXt�t�PK����>�J<G^>ONH9b>Bs�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg�9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�G�VKg�NR9b>�a*IXs�T;a�f %Gt eqNHV�abTRV�pK>FNR9<I�N0CFt �/. 0 �� ��� � = �� ��������� / t"- �FsuNH9=t - � � f - - �b�F9bs�ef9�s�=?abtus�>�GFNH9<IXNMC

a��0eK��a�i}j�l�� - q�s�t - e � � a�i}j�l�� - q�s�f - - e�� � a�i}j�l��pq�s�f - e8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>dNR9b>�TR>�s�G�I �r£�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg[�2TRVK= t G^J*ef9[NH9<IXNMC�t ��(� / t"-kn vw (��zga�ikj�l���-Mq�s,agt"-# ��t"- eGeH��Msug<e�>BNH9b>dp�IXTRs�IX�bt�>�G:s�g i}j�l a���e 9 TH>wG^a��Fikj�lAa���-�eg::IXTR>�gbVXN:�2TR>�>ds�gof"-# 9 TH>wG^a��%t"-# :��b�">�9<I�pK>BNR9<I�Nf - n a�ikjIl��pq�s�a�f -# ��f - ePe � � a�f -# ��ikjIl��pq�s�f - e

� � agt"-# ��ikj�l���-Mq�s�t"- e � ��a�ikj�l���-0q�s$a�t"-# �Rt"- ePedn�t�-\�g�NH9bs�G"cM>�cMJ*e�NHs�VKgq�M��>BIXt�G^V�J*G^>�NH9b>BabTRVKa,>�THNHs�>�G;a��0eUIXg*c=a��2eH�MIXg*c�NH9<>`�'IKe4N�NR9<I�N"� � s�G"I�e�VKgbx_THJb£>�g<e4>_�

�_~b{ ��f n a�i}j�l���n�f # q�s�f e ~ � ¢ t n a�ikj�l���n t # q�s�t e � 8:9b>?sug�NR>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx[e�IKGH>�G�IKTH>��2VKTNR9b>dTRJbtu> 9 cM>4�kVKa,>�gE::IKg<c 9 cM>��ke�VK=$:��

= �K~b{ � � ¢ � �"¡���� � ��� GHJbaba,V_GH>�NH9<IXN6f � �������� �� ��� ���� ����������� /�a�� �Pf"- e�IXg*c?NH9<IXN:NH9b>BVKa,>�g�NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g�s�GQCf ���������� �� � � � �� ����������� / aPa���n�fW#% ��e,��f - e

�OGHsug<x?NH9b>ds�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg#9rP�a,VXNR9b>�GHs�G��MNR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfGFI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�t � ����� �� �� ��� = �� ����������� / a���- �Nt"- e��FsuNH9a�Pe\��a�ikj�l��pq�s�|�"e�� � a�i}j�l�� - q�s.|A2e a����Ge��Af - � � t - a� ���Ge��Af # � � t #

8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_=�NH9<>��'IKe�NFNR9<I�N8a�Pe�IKg<c�a������Geks�=?abt�su>wGQC

a�ikj�l���npf #�% �pq�s�|�"e�� ��a�i}j�l"�,n t�#% � - q�s.|A2eIXg<c�NR9<I�N�a� �Ge�IXg*c�a� ���GeUsu=?abt�s�>�GMC�a�ikjIl"�$n�f # q�s�f"- e � � a�ikj�l���n t # q�s�t"- e �

= �K~b{ � � ¢ � � � ¡ ��� GHJbaba,V_GH>�NH9<IXN f� �'����� �� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Pf"- eH�*IXg<c�NH9*I�NFNH9<> �r£�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg0s�GQCf � (� / i}j�l���n�f #�q�s�v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s,a�f #�|� ��f - eGe

�OGHsug<x:NH9b>�s�g<cMJ*e�NHs�VKgd9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G��4NR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfG�I�NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKgB�2THV_= t GHJ<ef9BNH9*I�Nkt � �������� �� � � = �������������� /a���- �Nt"- e`�FsuNH9nNH9b>�a<THV_a*>�T^NRsu>wG�a��GeH�ya����GeFIKg<cBa������PeFx_sup_>�g sug NH9<>�a<TH>�p�s�VKJ*Gde�IKGH>K�?8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>��>de�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuNOI ��NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg��2THV_= t�G^J<ef9#NR9<I�N0C

t � (� / i}j�l���n t # q�s�v�w (��z�a�i}j�l�� - q�s,a�t # |A=�Rt - e�e

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 37: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

jKm � ����2�&�������������R��!���

�rs�g<e4>ONH9b>Bp�IXTRs�IK�btu>wGUs�g�i}j�l a���e 9 TR>�GHa��FikjIl a��o-We :�IKTH>`g<VXN��2TR>�>�sug.fW#`IXg<c$f"- 9 TR>�GHa��dt #FIXg*ct"- :4�b�">B9*I�pK>BNH9<IXNMC

a�i}j�l��pq�s,a�f #�|�p�uf"- ePe � � a�a�i}j�l��pq�s$a�fW#�|�EePe,�uf"- ea�i}j�l��o-Qq�s$a�t�#,|A��Rt"- ePe � � a�a�i}j�l���-Mq�s,a�t #�|�"ePe,�ut�- e

�OGHsug<x � >�=?=�I?o���@4£Na��GeH�b�">de4V_g<e4t�J<cM>BNH9*I�N8a�ikj�l���-0q�s,agt�#�|A2ePe � � a�ikjIl��pq�s,a�fW#,|��eGeH��8:9b>TH>wG^J<t�NF�2V_tut�V��`G��2THV_=�NH9b>��'I_e�NFNR9<I�N� � s�GFI?e4VKg<xKTRJb>�g<e�>K�

� 9 8 <>D ?�GBC D �SROG+D0IKJ ��U��^?�_~b{ �=f n�i}j�l��pq�s,a�fW# �Ee ~ � ¢ t n�ikjIl���-Qq�s,a�f # �0e � �FsuNH9#NR9b>�IKGRG^J<=�abNHs�VKg�NH9<IXNa�i}j�l��pq�s8m}e�� % a ��eEa�ikjIl���-Qq�s &EeH�"IXg<c NH9<IXN,l sha�f #2e 'Ba�ikjIl a�� e j�ikjIl a��o-WePe�n �b� \¤N?s�G�>�I_G^PNRV abTHV�p_>�NR9<I�Nw���FsuNH9/NR9bs�G�abTHV_a*>�T^NQP_�hf � � t s�=?abtus�>�G�a�i}j�l��pq�s$a�f �EePe � � a�i}j�l���-Mq�s,a�t �0ePeH��MJbaba,V_GH>dNH9<IXN\f # � � ���� / f"-# �6Kn>�=�IASK>�I�e�I_G^>�IKg<IXt�PMG^s�GFV_g�NR9b>dNRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg[TRJbt�>�IXaba<tus�>�c#NRV�TH>wcMJ<e4>a�f �EeGC

= �K~b{ � � ~ � � |w~ ����� NR9b>�TR>�GHJbtuNq�2V_tut�V��`G��2TRVK=>a�i}j�l�� q�s$a�f"-# �Ee'%Gi}j�l���-Qq�s�a�f"-# �0ePe i � � IXg*cNH9b>B�'I_e�N:NH9<IXN8a��0e\�Al s%a�i}j�l��pq�s$a�f"-# �Ee�e�'�i}j�l a���ekn�l s%a�i}j�l���-Mq�s,a�f"-# �0ePe�'�ikjIl a��o-Wedn � �

= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� � ¡ ��� �">d9<I�p_> � #�n0� ��IKg<c�a�f # �Ee ��(� / f"-# ��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�rJ<GHs�gbx � >�=?=�I?o���@4£a������GeH�M�">�e4VKg*e4t�J<cM>BNH9<IXNFNH9b>�TH>�>�Lrs�G^NRG�f"- -# GHJ<ef9�NR9<I�N�a��0eK� fW# ���'1��� / f"- -# IXg<ca�a�i}j�l��pq�s�f"-# e�� � a�i}j�l��o-Qq�s�f"- -# ePeH�[8:9b>�TR>�GHJbtuNd�2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= NH9b>��'IKe4NdNH9<IXN�a��2e�s�=�a<tus�>�Ga�f # �0e � (� / f - -# �*IXg<c��2THV_= abTRVKa,>�THNQP=a��2e �

= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� �$� � ~ � ¢ � ~ � � ¡ �q| ��� s�g NH9b> �<TRG^N�e�IKGH>[��> 9*I�pK> � # n�q�s A�~ a��% |� �M|�Ee�IXg*ca�f #��Ee � . 0 =� � 1 � � �� ��������� /�f"-# �`8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�bJ<GHsug<x � >�=�=�I�o��u@�£Ga���PeR�bNR9b>�TR>�>4LMs�GQNfGOI�a<THVMe4>wGHG;f"- -# G^J*ef9NH9<IXN�f # � . 0 = � 1 ? 1 � ���������������� /�f"- -# GHJ<ef9[NH9*I�N,a�ikj�l��pq�sOf"-# e � ��a�ikjIl���-Qq�sOf"- -# eH��8:9b>�TH>wG^J<t�NB�2VKt�tuV��`G�2THV_= abTHV_a*>�T^NQP a��2eH��S�THVrVX�Us�G�GHs�=�s�t�IXT`s�g[NH9<>�e�I_G^>�VX��TRJbtu> 9 IXa<a VKJMN�:�C:s�g[NH9bs�GBe�IKGH>��">�IXt�GHVJ<GH>�NH9b>��'I_e�N:NH9<IXN;l s%a�fW#�e('.i}j�l a���ekn*��IXg<c�f # � ������=� �� ��� ���� ����������� /�f"-# s�=?abtus�>�GO|��'.i}j�l a���eFn �M�

�_~b{ ��f npikj�l���n���q�s�a�f #��Rt�#Me ~ � ¢ t npikj�l���n���q�s�a�a�i}j�l���n�� q�s�f #2e,��t�#2e � �">"GHJbaM£a,V_GH>?NH9*I�N�f # � ���� � / f"-# IKg<c �">�=�I&SK>�I[e�IKGH>�IXg<IKtuPMGHs�G�VKg NH9<>�t�I_GQN�NQ��V[TRJbt�>�GdVK�"NR9b>�cb>�TRsup�I�NRsuV_gf ���� / f"-'�%�rs�g<e4>`NH9b>�THV_tu>FVK��t #:s�G�GHP�=?=?>4NRTHs�eX�_��>O�Fsut�t*g<VXN�G^NHJ<cbP�NR9b>Oe�IKGH>�GU�F9b>�TH>`NH9b>ONHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_ge�VK=?>�G"�2TRVK= t�#��

= �K~b{ � � � ~M}�|�~ ��� �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � � � ��� �">�9<I�pK> � #�n �#IKg<cf"-�n ikj�l���np��q�s$a�f"-# �ut #0eH�:8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>K�bJ<GHs�gbx�THJ<tu> 9 cM>4�U=�J�:�� 9 a<IXT`NRIXJ�:FIXg<c 9 cM>4��=�JE:����>de�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuNOI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g

t ��(� / i}j�l��,n���q�s,a�i}j�l���n���q�s�f -# ��t #0e8:9b>dabTRVrVX��s�GFGHsu=?s�t�IKTFsug#NH9<>�e�IKGH> 9 a<IKTFt�IK=��7cbI :��2V_tut�V���>wc��rP 9 cM>4�k=�J�: �

:<;k¥=: >

Page 38: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} �$� � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � � ����� �">B9*I�pK> � #�n�q�s8mk~�a |���M|�"e�IXg<cf"-dn�ikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f"-# ��t # |�2eH���rs�g<e�>�NR9b>?t�I_GQNBTHJ<tu>�s�G 9 cM>4�"=�JE:4�7NH9b>?g<IK=?>�G�|�0=�J<G^Nd�*>cMs�k,>�TH>�g_N��2THV_= � 9 NR9bs�GBs�GOIKt�GHV�NHTRJb>��2VKT |�Q:���8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�*J<GHsugbx�THJ<tu> 9 cM>4��=�JE:4� 9 a<IXTBsug�:`IXg*c9 cM>��U=�JE:4�b��>de�IXg#>4LM9bs��bs�NOI�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg

t!� �� /�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�ikj�l��$n���q�s�f -# ��t # |�2e8:9b>dabTRVrVX��s�GFGHsu=?s�t�IKTFsug#NH9<>�e�IKGH> 9 a<IKTFVKJMN�:��2VKt�tuV��">�c��rP 9 cM>��U=�JE: �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} � ¡ � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � � ����� NR9b> =?V_G^N�s�g�NH>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx e�IKGH>[s�G�G^J<ef9 NR9<I�Nf # � � ������ �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-# eF�FsuNH9 � i |�,��\�gnNH9bs�G�e�IKGH>K���">�>4LM9bs��bs�N�I�NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg �2TRVK= t J<GHsugbxTHJ<tu> 9 cM>4�kVKa,>�gE:4� 9 a*IXT`e4V_=$:�IKg<c 9 cM>���=�JE:��U\�g0a<IKT^NRs�e�Jbt�IXT:��>�9<I�p_>

� f"-�n�i}j�l���n�� q�s,a vw (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s$a�fW#��Rt�#2e�e�et"-En�ikjIl���np��q�s,a v�w (�Izga�i}j�l���n�� % � q�s�a�a�i}j�l���n�� q�s�f # e,��t # ePePe

8:9b>�TH>wG^JbtuNO�2V_tut�V��`GO�2THV_= f"- � � t�-'��\�g NR9b>?e�IKGH> � gi |�*����>�>4LM9bs��bs�NdI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g[�2THV_= tJ<GHsugbx?TRJbt�> 9 cM>���V_JMNN:4� 9 a<IKT`e4V_=,:"IKg<c 9 cM>���=�JE: �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} ¡ �q| � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � �k¡���� � ��� ��>:9<I�p_>\a�f # �&t # e�� �������� �� ��� � �������������� / a�� �Ma�f"-# ��t # e�eIXg<c

f ��� ������ �� ��� ���� ����������� / f - n aPa���n��9%!��e���i}j�l#��n���q�s�a�f -# �Rt�#0ePe8:9rJ<G��<J<G^s�gbx?TRJbtu> 9 cM>4�kVKa,>�g�:�� 9 a<IXT`V_JMNN::IKg<c 9 cM>��k=�JE:��<��>de�IKg0>4LM9bs��bs�NOI�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg��2TRVK=t G^J<ef9�NH9*I�N

t!���������� �� ��� ���������������� / t - n a�a���n�� % ��e���ikjIl���np��q�s,aPa�ikj�l��$n�� q�sOf -# e��Rt�#0ePe8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_= f - � � t - IKg<c�NH9b>��'I_e�NFNH9*I�N��b�2VKT`IXt�t�f � � t,C

a�i}j�l���n�� q�s�f�e � � a�ikj�l���n�� q�s�t�e

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} ¡ �q| � ��¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z �+� ¢ � � � ¡ ��� �">�9<I�p_> � n � IKg<c � # n � � � �R~�a�|&��0|�Ee"IXg*cf"-yn i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�� |� �Fa�f"-# �Rt�e�eR�#8:9rJ<G��qJ<GHs�gbx TRJbtu> 9 cM>4�`e�VK=$:�� 9 a<IKTdNRIKJE:dIKg<c 9 cM>��=�JE:"�">de�IKg#>�LM9bsu�<s�NOI�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg

t � (� / t"- n i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�ikj�l���n���q�s�a�� |� ��f"-# e���t�e� � i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�a�i}j�l"�$n���q�s,a�� |�"e,��i}j�l���n�� q�s,a�f"-# e�e,�Rt�e� � f"-

8:9<>Oe�I_G^>wG�G^J*ef9?NH9<IXN�NH9b> �QTR>�cbJ<e�NRsuV_g?e�VK=?>�G��2VKTR= t�# �f�_NH9*I�N�s�G�GHJ<ef9?NH9*I�N6t #�� ���� � / t"-# �rIXTR>`G^s�=?sut�IXTIKg<c�J<G^>�NR9b>��'IKe4N:NH9<IXN�a�a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f�e �Ee � ��a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�a�f �EeGeH�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 39: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

j_l � ����2�&�������������R��!���

�_~b{ � f n ikj�l���n���q�s�a�f # �ue ~ � ¢ t n ikj�l���n���q�s�a�a�i}j�l���n�� q�sOf #0e ��e � �">�G^J<aba*V�G^>NR9<I�N6fW# � � ���� / f"-# IKg<c��">`=�I&SK>�I�e�I_G^>�IXg<IKtuPMGHs�GUV_g�NH9<>Ot�IKG^N�NQ�"V�THJ<tu>wG�VX��NR9b>�cb>�TRsup�I�NRsuV_g$f � �� / f"-�C

= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� |w~ ��� �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z ��� ¢ � � � ��� ��>U9<I�p_> � n � #�n �dIKg<c�f"-En�ikj�l��$n���q�s�a�f"-# �ueR�8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�MJ<GHsugbx?TRJbt�> 9 cM>4�k=�J�:�� 9 a<IXT:NfIXJE::IKg<c 9 cM>���=�JE:��b�">de�IKg�>�Lr9<su�bsuNOI�NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg

t!�'(� / ikj�l���np��q�s$a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f -# ��e= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� � ¡ � ��¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � � � ��� �"> 9<I�p_> � n ��� � #_n � � IXg<c�f"-�ni}j�l���n�� q�sOf -# �hKn>��2V_THx_VXN:9b>�TR>�NH9b>da<THVrVX��NH9<IXNFNH9b>�TH>�>�Lrs�G^NOI�a<THVMe4>wGHG�f - -# GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXNF�2VKTIXt�t�g<IK=�> �2CFf # ��� ���� /�f"- -# �3&#�2c��_�U\�g0a<IXTHNHs�e4J<t�IKT���NH9<s�GFs�=?abt�su>wG f"-# n�f"- -# � �"��c��K�8qV I�p_VKs�c g<IX=?>[e4t�IKGH9b>wG����">0J<GH>#In�2TR>�GH9 g<IK=�> �nIXg<c ��>0GHVK=?>4NRsu=?>�G?e�VKgrpK>�T^N�NH9b>0abTRVX£e4>wGHG�a�i}j�l���n���q�sOf�e:NHVra�i}j�l ��n�� � � � ���Rq�s�f�� � � ���&eR��CF>�=?>�=��*>�T�NH9<IXN��q�2VKt�tuV��Fs�gbx#NH9b>TH>�=�IXTGS�sug=�r>we�N��<m<�M�">�e�VKg<GHs�cM>�T:NR9<I�N76q£�>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g<e4>�s�G:su=?abt�s�e�s�Nw��OGHsug<x�THJbt�> 9 cM>���=�JE:�� 9 IXa<a�NfIXJE::IKg<c 9 cM>���=�JE:"��>de�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuNFNH9b>�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg*G

f ��(� / f"-�n�ikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f"- -# � �"��c��&et ��(� / t"-Enpikj�l���n���q�s�a�ikj�l �8n���� � � ����q�s�a�f"- -# � � � ��� � �(�2c�� e�e

8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_=�NH9<>��'IKe�NFNR9<I�N � � e�VKg�NRIKsug<G"NR9b>�GH>4NFVX�UIXt�t7NH9b>da*IXs�TRGMCa�a�ikj�l��pq�sOf��Mm��2c��&e'%Ma�ikjIl�� - q�sOf��3&#�2c��AePe

�Fs�NR9#NH9b>�GHs�cb>�e4VKg*cMs�NRsuV_g<G"NH9*I�N�a�ikj�l��pq�s�mRe�� ��a�i}j�l��o-Qq�s�&"e �= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� �$� � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢�z � � ¢ � � ����� ��> 9*I�pK> � # n q�s8mk~ a��=% |���0|�"e#IKg<c f"-=ni}j�l���n�� q�sOf"-# �h�Msug<e�>BNH9b>dt�IKG^N"TRJbt�>�s�G 9 cM>4�k=�JE:4�rNH9b>dg*IX=?>�G8|��=�J<G^N:�,>dcMs�k,>�TH>�g_N:�2TRVK= �9 NR9bs�G:s�GFIXt�GHV�NHTRJb>��2VKT |��:4��8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�_J<GHs�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 cM>���=�J�:�� 9 IKaba#sugE:"IKg<c 9 cM>4��=�JE:4�M��>�e�IKg>4LM9bs��bsuNOI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g

t!���� /�i}j�l#��n���q�s�a�ikj�l���n�� q�sOf -# e � � a�ikj�l��$n�� q�sOf -# ednpf -= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� ¡ �q| � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ¢ � �`¡���� � ��� ��>�9<I�p_> f # � � ������ �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-# e�IKg<c

f!� �������� �� ��� � � ? � � ����������������� / f - n aPa��.n�� % ��e �PikjIl���n�� q�s,a�f -# �ue�e8:9b>Bsug�NH>�TH>wGQNRsug<x�e�I_G^>`s�G"G^J<ef9�NH9<IXN ���"I_G�IXt�TR>�IKcbP�s�g |�,�U8:9�J*G���J<GHsugbx�THJ<tu> 9 cM>��qVKa,>�gE:4� 9 IXa<aVKJMN�:FIXg*c 9 cM>4��V_a*>�gE:��*��>�e�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuN�I�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg#�2TRVK= t GHJ<ef90NH9*I�N 9 �">�ef9bVrV�G^>dI��2TR>�GH9g<IX=?> ��NHV�TH>�abt�IKe4>ONH9b>B�,VKJbg<c�g<IX=?> ��s�g<GHs�cM>�f #OIKg<c��">Bcb>�gbVKNH>\���`NH9b>BabTRVre�>�GRGy��� � � ���0:

t �'�������� �� ��� � ?�� ��������������� /�t - n a�a ��n�� � %���n�� % ��e���ikjIl ��n�� � q�s,a�i}j�l���n���q�sOf -# eGe8:9b> TR>�GHJbtuN[�2VKt�tuV��`G#�2TRVK= a�ikjIl �8np���uq�s,a�i}j�l���n�� q�sOf"-# eGe � ��a�ikj�l���n���q�s�f"-# e�IXg*cNH9b>��'I_e�NFNR9<I�N0C

a�ikjIl���n�� %!� q�s$aG|�(%��uePe � � a�i}j�l ��n�� � %���n��9%!�pq�s,aG|��%��IeGe8:9<>UabTHVrVK��s�G�GHsu=?s�t�IKT�sugBNR9b>�e�I_G^>Ff n�ikj�l���n��9%���n q�s�f IKg<c8t n�i}j�l���n�� %���n q�s,a�ikj�l���n���q�sOf�eR�IKg<c�sug#NH9<>�e�IKGH>8f n�i}j�l���np� %��8n q�s�f IKg<c t n�ikjIl���np� %��8n a�ikjIl���np��q�s e q�s�f?�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 40: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j �

�_~b{ ��f npikj�l���n���q�s�a�agbdc�e f #0e ~ � ¢ t n agbdc�eGa�ikjIl"�$n���q�sOfW#�e � NH9<>:GHs�cM>"e�VKg<cbs�NRsuV_g�s�Gkc�gil sha���eH�k8:9b>�t�IKG^NqNQ�"V`TRJbt�>�G�VK�rNH9b>"cM>�TRsup�IXNHs�VKg�f � �� / f"-K9<I�p_>UNHVO�*> 9 t�IX=��7cbII:7�2VKt�t�V���>wc���P 9 cb>4�<=�JE:��8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR> � n ��m IXg*c.f - npikjIl���n�� q�s�a�f # �Mm��2c��&eH��8:9<>BTR>�GHJbtuN:�2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= TRJbt�> 9 t�IK=��7cbI :IKg<c0NR9b>��'I_e�NBNH9<IXN c gi l sha���e:su=?abt�su>wG�a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�f # e��Mm��2c���n ikj�l���n���q�s�a�f # �0m���c��&eR�d\�gNR9b>�GHP�=?=?>4NRTHs�e�e�I_G^>_�M��>�J<GH>BNH9b>��'I_e�NFNH9*I�NFNH9<>�cM>�TRsup�IXNHs�VKg t!���� / t"-7J<GH>�NH9b>�TRJbtu> 9 t�IK=��7cbI :4��_~b{ �_f n ikjIl���np��q�s,a � xo fW# �0e ~ � ¢ t n � xh a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�fW#2e5� � �">�J<GH>?NH9b>��'IKe�NNR9<I�N#NH9<>nt�IKG^N�NQ�"V TRJbt�>�G�VK��f ���� / f"-B9<I�p_> NHV �*> 9 cb>�e4t:��2VKt�tuV��">�c �rP 9 cb>4��=�JE:���8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR>� x f #n� �<. 0 �� � 1 � � ������������ / a�f |�Ee�IKg<c��*GHs�g<e4>�NR9b>�t�IKG^NOTHJ<tu>ds�G 9 cb>4��=�J�:�� �hgi |��j |�*�:8:9b>�TR>�GHJbtuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G�2TRVK= NH9b>��'I_e�NFNH9*I�N � gi |��su=?abt�s�>�G8a�i}j�l���n���q�sOf #0e;|� 1�ikj�l#��n�� q�s�a�f #�|�"ef�� 9 � �R7V�=@? M I�C �\GHCERSATGHR7C+U V�����R7D��ZU V�=@J7A&=�_~b{ ��f n f #B� ~ � ¢ t�n fW# � s�� � a � e gn � ��� ��NR9b>0t�I_GQN�TRJbt�>�VK� f ���� / f"-:s�G 9 a<IKT?NRIKJE:��9 a<IXTOt�IK=��7cbI :"V_T 9 a<IKT`s�gE:��,s�N�s�G 9 a<IKT`VKJMN�::VXNR9b>�TR�Fs�G^>_��8:9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN`�2VKt�tuV��`G"�2TRVK= a |�Ee � � IXg*ca�f�� e � �Bf?��8:9b>dabTRV�VK��VK�qNH9<>�G^Pr=?=?>4NHTRs�eBe�IKGH>�s�GFGHsu=?s�t�IKT���_~b{ � f n�fW# ��t�# ~ � ¢ t n t�#o��fW# � NH9b>�V_gbtuP�s�g�NH>�TH>wGQNRsugbx?e�I_G^>Bs�G�TRJbt�> 9 a<IXT`e�VK=$:��%�rJ<aba*V�G^>NR9<I�N%f # �'�������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-# eH� t�#%�/. 0 �� �>� � ���� ��������� /�t"-# IXg*cOf �'(� />v�w (��zga�ikj�l�� q�s�a�f"-# �Rt"-# ePeH�k8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>���>e�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuN�I?NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg#�2V_T\t G^J*ef9�NR9<I�N�t � (� / v�w (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s�a�t - # ��f -# eGeH�F8:9b>�TR>�GHJbtuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G�2TRVK=NH9<> �'I_e�N�NR9<I�N�f � � t s�=?abt�su>wG vw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s�f�e � � v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�sOt�eR� 8:9b>nabTRV�VK�ds�GGHs�=�s�t�IXTFs�g�NR9b>�e�I_G^>8f n�f #=�dagt�#��u�a#�e�IXg<c�t n a�fW#��Rt�#2e,�u�"#���_~b{ �=f n�i}j�l���n�� q�s�t ~ � ¢ � gi l sha�t�e �

= �K~b{ � � a � e gn � � � � NR9rJ<G�NR9b>#t�I_GQN�THJbt�>�VK�;f � �� / f - s�G 9 cM>��O=�J�:�IKg<c_t � �� / t - s�=�a<tus�>�Gf ���� / ikj�l���n���q�s�t"-'�%�rs�g<e�> � gi l sha�t�e�s�=?abt�su>wGUNH9*I�N�� gi l s%agt"-WeR�KNR9b>FTR>�GHJbt�NU�2V_tut�V��`G��2TRVK=a�ikj�l���n���q�s�t"-�e � �Bt�- �

= �K~b{ � � a � e�n � � � � t�>4N � �*>�NH9b>#IKe�NRsuV_g ����� mk~�a�|&��0|�Eeg:��r�rs�g<e4> � gi l s%agt�eH�kNR9b>�t�IKG^N�TRJbtu>e�IKgbgbVXN��,> 9 cb>4��e4V_=,:4�d�MJbaba,V_GH>:NH9b>Ft�IKG^N�THJ<tu>:s�G 9 cM>���VKJMN�:��K�">:9<I�pK> Ckt � �� / a�� - �Gt - eqs�=�a<tus�>�Gf ���� / a���- �PikjIl���np��q�sOt�-WeR��8:9b>�TR>�GHJbtuN��2VKt�tuV��`G,�2TRVK= NH9b>��'IKe�N�NR9<I�Nya�ikjIl���n�� q�sOt�-We � � t"-IXg<c�NH9*I�N�a�ikj�l���-Mq�s.|�Ee � � a�i}j�l��o-Qq�s.|�EeH�h�rJba<a*V�G^>BNH9<>Bt�IKG^NFTHJ<tu>�s�G 9 VKa,>�g[cM>��G:��hKn>�9<I�p_>f � �� / a�a ��n � % ��-�e��Ft"-�eH���Msug<e�> �>gi l s%agt�eH����>?e4V_g<e4t�J<cM>�NH9*I�N�>gi |� IKg<c ��gi l s%a���-�eH�8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>�a�i}j�l���n�� % ��-Mq�s$|�Ee � � a�ikj�l���-Mq�s.|��e 9 �F9bs�ef90s�G:NH9<>d>4LMa*>we�NR>�c�TH>wG^JbtuNN:4�

8:9<>Ba<THVrVX��s�GOG^s�=?sut�IXTFs�g�NR9b>�e�I_G^>8f n vwhxEz�t IKg<com gi l sha�t�eR��_~b{ ��f n i}j�l���np��q�s,a v�wLxEzf #0e ~ � ¢ t n v�wLxEz a�ikjIl���np��q�s�f #�e � NH9<>0GHs�cM> e4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg/s�GNR9<I�N�m gi l s%a��OeR���rJbaba,V_GH>�NR9<I�N,fW# � ������ / f"-# 9 �FsuNH9 � a��m#0e gn � � � :�� 8:9rJ<G�NR9b>#t�I_GQN�NQ��VnTHJbt�>�GVK�ONR9b>#NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g f ���� / f"-FIXTR> 9 gb>�� =�J�:��2V_tut�V��">�c �rP 9 cM>4��=�J�:�� 8:9rJ<G?��>[e�IXg/>4LM9bs��bs�N�IKg>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_N�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg �2THV_= t J*G^s�gbx THJbt�> 9 cM>���=�JE:�IXg<c NH9rJ<G?TRJbt�> 9 gb>�� =�JE:4�/8:9<>#a<THVrVX��s�GGHs�=�s�t�IXTOsu�yf # � �������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-# eR�B8:9b>�abTRV�VK��s�GBGHsu=?s�t�IKT�s�g[NH9<>�GHPr=�=?>�NHTRs�e�e�IKGH>K�,NH9*I�N�s�G�s��yf>n

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 41: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

j Y � ����2�&�������������R��!���

vwhxEz a�ikjIl���n�� q�s�fW#2e�IXg<c4t n ikj�l���np��q�s$agv�wLxEzf #0ef��\¤N�s�G�IKt�GHV[G^s�=?sut�IXT�s�g NH9b>�e�IKGH>AC�f na�i}j�l���np� %��8n q�s�f�e�IKg<c$t n a�i}j�l ��n %���n���q�s�f�eH�rIXg*c�sug�NH9b>Be�IKGH>ACdf n�v�wLxEzga v�w��Izf�eIKg<c�t n v�w��Izga v�wLxEzf�eR�

�_~b{ �4f n a v�whx�zfW#r�dt�#2e ~ � ¢ t n>v�wyxEzga�f #��Rt�#0e � NH9b>�=?V_G^NBs�g�NH>�TH>wGQNRsugbx0e�I_G^>�s�G�GHJ<ef9 NR9<I�NNR9b>�t�IKG^N�TRJbtu>�VK� f�� �� / f"-�s�G 9 a<IKT�e4V_=,:4��Kn>#e4VKg*G^s�cM>�T�NH9b>�e�IKGH>�G^J*ef9 NH9<IXN�fW#?=?IASK>wG�IXg � � �NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g 9 �FsuNH9�NH9<>Bt�IKG^N:THJbt�>B�*>�sugbx 9 gb>�� V_JMNN:P:"IXg<c�t�#`=?IASK>wG"IKg.q�snNRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g��U8:9b>�a<THVrVX��s�GGHs�=�s�t�IXT`su�kNH9b>dNRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g��2TRVK= f # >�g<c<G`�FsuNH9[TRJbtu> 9 VKa,>�g[gb>��;:��Fo`t�t�NR9b>�VKNH9b>�TOe�I_G^>wG`IXTR>�G^s�=?sut�IXTNRV�NH9b>�e�IKGH>�f n a vwyxEzf # �EeH�h�rJba<a*V�G^>�NR9<I�N0C

v�wyxEzf # � � ��� �� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �NvWwhx�zga�f -# ePe f - n�v�w (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$agvwyxEzga�f -# e��Rt - # ePe8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�r�">de�IXg#>4LM9bs��bsuNOI �Q=�IXNRef9bs�gbx�NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g ���2TRVK= t GHJ<ef9�NH9<IXNMC

t ��(� /�t - n v�wLxEzga v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s,a�f -# �Rt - # ePe�e8:9<>�TR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G��2THV_= NR9b>��'IKe�N�NH9<IXN�NR9b>�a<THVMe4>wGHGH>�GOf"- � � t"- 9 GHsug<e�>�NR9b>�P IXTR>�G^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTfIXt�tuP>w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_N�:���8:9b>�abTRVrVX��VX��NH9b>�GHPr=�=?>�NHTRs�e�e�I_G^>Bs�G`G^s�=?sut�IXTw�

�_~b{ ��f n�ikj�l��$n���q�sOfW#$��t # ~ � ¢ t npikjIl���n�� q�s�a�f #���t #Me � NR9b>OV_gbtuP�s�g_NR>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx�e�IKGH>s�g G^J*ef9nNR9<I�N�NH9b>�t�IKG^NdNQ��V[TRJbt�>�G�VK�6f����� / f"-�IXTR> 9 cM>��`e4VK=$:��2V_tut�V���>wc �rP 9 a<IKTdNRIKJE:���\�g >�pK>�THPVKNH9b>�T`e�I_G^>wG��">dIXTR>�sug[I?G^suNHJ*I�NHs�VKg0GHsu=?s�t�IKT:NHV�NH9b>da<TH>�p�s�VKJ*G:abTHVrVK�Q�k8:9rJ<G:�">�9<I�pK> C � n �#IKg<cuC

fW# ������� �� �� ��� ���� ����������� / a�� �Gf -# e f - n�ikj�l#��n���q�s�agv�w (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�� |�p�uf -# eGe�e��Rt�#8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>B��>de�IKg�>�LM9bsu�<s�NOI�NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg

t ��(� /�t - n�i}j�l���n���q�s,agvWw (��zga�ikj�l�� q�s�a�� |�p�uf -# �Rt�#2e�eGe8:9<> TR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G��2THV_=�NR9b>n�'IKe�N�NH9<IXNof"- � � t�- 9 G^s�g<e4> NH9b>�P IXTR> GQNRTHJ*e�NHJ<TRIKtut�P >w��Jbsup�IKtu>�g_N�:��8:9<> abTRV�VK�ds�G�G^s�=?sut�IXT�sug NR9b> GHPr=�=?>�NHTRs�ene�IKGH>K�h8:9b>nabTRV�VK�Bs�G#IXt�G^V GHsu=?s�t�IKT�s�g NH9b> e�I_G^>�f nikj�l��$n�� q�s$agv�wLxEzWf # e�IXg<c t n v�wLxEz�a�i}j�l"�$n���q�s�f # ef��_~b{ � f n a�i}j�l���n�� q�sOf #0e � ~ � ¢ t n i}j�l#��n���q�s�a�f #��Ee � NH9<>�GHs�cM>#e4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg s�G�NR9<I�N� gn*����8:9b>?VKgbt�P[s�g_NR>�TR>�G^NHs�gbx0e�IKGH>�sug G^J*ef9 NH9*I�N�NH9b>?t�IKG^N�NQ��V#THJ<tu>wG�VK�yf ���� / f"-UIXTR> 9 NRIKJ cb>4�G:�2V_tut�V��">�c �rP 9 IXaba NfIXJE:4� \�g >�p_>�TRPnVKNH9b>�T�e�I_G^>wG��">�IXTR>�s�g I GHs�NRJ<I�NRsuV_g G^s�=?sut�IXT�NHV[NR9b>�abTR>�prs�VKJ<Gcb>�=?VKg<G^NHTfI�NRsuV_g��k8:9�J*GF��>�9<I�p_>AC � n��[IXg<c�C

fW# � �������� �� � � � �� ����������� / a�� �Pf -# e f - n�i}j�l��$n�� q�s,agvw (��zga�ikj�l��pq�s$a�� |� ��f -# ePePe �8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>k��>�e�IXg�>4LM9bs��bsuN�I�NHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg�t � (� /�t"- -En�i}j�l��,n���q�s,a v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s,a�� |� �p�uf"-# �Ee�e�eR�8:9<>OTR>�GHJbt�N��2VKt�tuV��`G��2THV_= NH9b>O�'IKe�N�NH9<IXN6f"- � � t�- 9 G^s�g<e4>ONH9b>�P�IXTR>OG^NHTRJ<e�NRJbTRIKtut�P�>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g�NN:��U8:9b>a<THVrVX��s�GFGHs�=�s�t�IXTFs�g�NR9b>�GHP�=?=?>4NRTHs�e�e�I_G^>_�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 42: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� j_v

�_~b{ ��f n v�wLxEz�fW# � ~ � ¢ t n>v�wLxEz a�f #��Ee � ��>?e4V_g<G^s�cM>�T�NR9b>?t�I_GQN�NQ�"V�TRJbt�>�G�VX�Lf � �� / f"-'��\¤�� a � e�gn ����� �7NR9b>�t�IKG^NBNQ��V�TRJbt�>�GBIXTR> 9 g<>�� =�JE:F�2V_tut�V��">�c0�rP 9 IKaba t�IX=��7cbII:�� 9 IKaba NfIXJE:`VKT 9 IXa<as�gE:4�U\�g�NR9b>dVXNR9b>�T`e�IKGH>K�MsuN`s�G 9 gb>�� VKJbNN:"VKT 9 gb>�� VKa,>�gE:��2V_tut�V��">�c���P 9 IXa<a#V_JMNN:4�

= �K~b{ � � �q��  � � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ~ � � � ¡ ��� s�g�NH9bs�Gqe�IKGH>AC � n ����f #��<� ���� / f"-# ��f"-En vwhxEzWf"-#IXg<cn�">?e�IXg >4LM9bs��bsuN�I�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_grt ��(� / v�wyxEzf"-# ��8:9b>?TR>�GHJbtuNB�2V_tut�V��`GB�2TRVK= NR9b>��'IKe�NdNR9<I�Nv�wLxEzf"-# � �pv�wyxEzf"-# �U8:9b>dabTRVrVX��s�G`GHs�=�s�t�IXT:sug#NR9b>�e�I_G^> 9 g<>�� =�JE:��2V_tut�V���>wc��rP 9 IXaba0s�gE: �

= �K~b{ � � �q��  ��� ��¡ � � ¡r �� ¢nz � � ~ � � |w~ � ��� sug�NH9bs�G�e�IKGH>AC � n ���&f #'��(� / f"-# ��f"-En v�wLxEz�f"-# �IXg<c?�">Oe�IXg?>4LM9bs��bsuN"IBNHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg�t ��(� / v�wLxEz�a�f"-# �EeH�U8:9b>OTH>wG^JbtuN��2V_tut�V��`Gk�2TRVK= NR9b>`�'I_e�N�NR9<I�NagvWwhxEzWf"-# �Ee � �pv�wyxEzga�f"-# �Ee �

= �K~b{ � �����_  ¡ ��| � ��¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ~ � � ¡ �q| ��� sug0NR9bs�G�e�IKGH>AC � a � ehn � � � ��f # ���� / a�� �Gf"-# eH�f"-En a�� �MagvwyxEzf"-# �Ee�eqIKg<c���>`e�IXg?>4LM9bs��bsuN�IBNHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg,t ���� / a�� �Nv�wLxEzga�f"-# �EePeH�U8:9b>FTR>�GHJbt�N�2VKt�tuV��`GB�2TRVK= agv�wLxEz�f -# �Ee � � v�wLxEzga�f -# �Eef��8:9b>�abTRVrVX��s�G�GHsu=?s�t�IKTdsug NR9b>�e�I_G^> 9 g<>�� VKa,>�gE:�2VKt�tuV��">�c��rP 9 IKaba0VKJMN�:��

8:9<>Ba<THVrVX��VX��NH9b>�GHPr=?=�>�NHTRs�e�e�IKGH>Bs�GFGHsu=?s�t�IKT��

�_~b{ �Of n a�fW#;�Qt�#2e � ~ � ¢ t n a�f # �EeF�2agt�# �Ee � �">�G^NHJ<cbP�NR9b>"t�I_GQN�NQ��V`TRJbt�>�G�VX�MNR9b>"cb>�TRsup�I�NRsuV_gf!���� / f"-'��8:9b>B�<TfG^NFe�IKGH>Os�GFG^J*ef9�NR9<I�N:NH9<>�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�e4V_=?>�G �QV_gbt�P��2THV_= � fW# 9 TH>wG^a,>�e4NHs�pK>�t�P?�2TRVK=t #�:��bNH9<IXN:s�GFsuN`s�GFGHJ<ef9#NH9*I�N fW# �������� / f"-# s�=�a<tus�>�G:NR9<I�N�a�fW#��Rt�#0e ������ � / a�f"-# �ut�#�|�EeR�

= �K~b{ ��� � ~M} |w~ ��� �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢hz � � ~ � � |�~ ����� �">�9<I�pK> � n ����f # ���� / f"-# �Fa�f # �kt # e �'�� /a�f"-# �kt #0eFIXg<c=f&�'(� / a�f"-# �kt�#2eH�d8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR> 9 J<GHs�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 IXaba[NfIXJE:�IXg*c0NH9b>�g 9 a<IXT�NRIKJE:�:��>de�IXg0>4LM9bs��bsuNOI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_g�t ��(� / t"-En a�f"-# ��t #0e �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} �2~ z�¢�~ � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢�z � � ~ ��� |�~ ����� ��>�9<I�p_>AC � n ���df # � � ���� / f"-# �La�f # �t # e�� � ���� / a�f"-# �Et # �EeUIKg<c�f�� (� / a�f"-# ��t # �EeH��8:9b>�TH>��2VKTR> 9 J*G^s�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 IXaba�NRIKJE:"IXg<c?NR9b>�g9 a<IKTFt�IK=��7cbI :P:"��>de�IXg#>4LM9bs��bs�NOI�NRTRIKg<GHs�NRsuV_got � (� / t"-En a�f"-# ��t # �Ee �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} �$� � ��¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ~ � � �$� ��� sug�NH9<s�GUe�IKGH> � npq�s�&�~�a |���M|�EeH� � >�N � -r�*>"NH9<>`IKe�NRsuV_gq�s�&E~ a�a �(% |�0e �0|�EeH�K�">:9<I�pK> CRf # ��� �� � / f"-# ��a�f # �&t # e���� �� � / a�f"-# �At # � |�Me�IXg<c�f ���� / a�f"-# �&t # � |�MePeH�8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH> 9 J<GHs�gbx�THJbt�> 9 IXa<a�s�gE:kIXg<c�NH9b>�g 9 a<IXTks�gE:�:��">"e�IXg�>4LM9bs��bs�N�IONHTfIXg<GHsuNHs�VKg�t ���� /�t�-Ena�f"-# �Fa�t # �Ee |�0e �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} ¡ �q| � �¤¡ � � ¡r �� ¢ z � � ~ � � ¡ �q| ��� s�g NH9<s�G�e�IKGH> � n ����� &�~�a�|& �QaG|��% �"ePeH� � >4N� -k�*>�NH9<>?I_e�NRsuV_g ����� &�~�a�|& �M|�EeH���">�9*I�pK>AC f # � � �� � / a�� �Gf"-# eH�Fa�fW#4�kt�#2e � � �� � / a�� �Ma�f"-# �kt�#2e�eIXg<c f � �� / a�� �Qa�a�f -# ��t�#0e �Ee�eR� 8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR> �">ne�IXg >�LM9bsu�<s�N[I NRTRIKg<G^suNHs�VKg t � �� / t - na�� �Ma�a�f"-# �Ee,�Fa�t # �EePe�eH�

8:9<>�t�IKG^N�e�IKGH>�s�G�GHJ<ef9dNR9<I�N�NH9<>"t�IKG^NqNQ�"VOTRJbt�>�G�IXTR> 9 a<IXTke4V_=,:��2VKt�t�V���>wcd�rP 9 IXaba�NRIKJE:��k�bV_T�>�LMIK=?abtu>�">B9<I�pK>�fW# � �������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Gf"-# eH�"t�# � . 0 � ��� � �������������� / t"-# �ua�fW#=��t�#0e ��(� /�v w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s$a�f"-# �Rt"-# ePe�IXg*cf �'(� / v�w (�Iz a�ikjIl�� q�s�a�f"-# ��t�-# e�e��*�`8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�<J<G^s�gbx�TRJbt�> 9 IKaba[VKJMN�:`IKg<c � >�=�=�I�o�� ?b�*�">�e�IKg>�LM9bsu�<s�N"NH9b>�NHTfIXg*G^suNHs�VKg<G\a�f # �Ee ��� ������ �� ��� � � ? � � ������������������ /�a�� �Gf -# �EeUIXg<c�a�t�# �Ee �<. 0 � �>� � � � ? ��� ���������������� / t - -# �FsuNH9�t - -# 1agt"-# �EeH� ��G^s�gbx?THJ<tu> 9 a*IXT`e4V_=$:"s�NF�2V_tut�V��`G�NH9<IXN\t!� (� /�t"-�n v�w (�Iz a�ikjIl��pq�s�a�a�f"-# �Ee,�Rt"- -# ePe 1�f"-5�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 43: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

mI/ � ����2�&�������������R��!���

�_~b{ ��f n � x f #d� � ~ � ¢ t�n � x f # � � NH9<>#V_gbt�P a*V�GHGHsu�<sut�s�NQP s�G��2VKT � x> f #n��NHV�^=�I&S_>�IXg�q�sq£�IKe�NRsuV_g ���#\�g NH9bs�G�e�IKGH>K�k��>�9<I�pK>�t n � x f # � � . 0 � � 1 � �������������� / f #�|�,� �Msug<e�>��">�e�IKgIKt�GHV�cb>�TRsup_>�NR9b>�NHTfIXg<GHs�NRsuV_g � x f # � � . 0 � � � � ? 1 � � ����������������� / f # |�*�qs�N��2VKt�t�V��`G��7J<GHsug<x#TRJbt�> 9 IXaba s�gE:���NR9<I�Nf �<. 0 � � 1 � � ������������ / f #�|�*��8:9<>Ba<THVrVX��s�GOG^s�=?sut�IXT:s�g�NR9b>�e�I_G^>8f n a �EeH�

/

� � ������������� ���F!� k�4��� �

��� ~ � ��� � . } � { � } A ~M| �2¡�� ¡(��� ��� ¢����X| �2¡ � { ��! � f&�'(� / f"- �&��� � �����&�_� �����("���������B'N���(�� � 4A� #F��� ��� � � f � �'(� / � � f"- � %. } ¡�¡���8:9b>?abTRVrVX��s�GB=?I_cM>���P sug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g VKgnNH9<>?GHs���>�VX�K�����rJba<a*V�G^>�NH9<IXN�f � (� / f"-5��NH9b>�e�IKGH>�_n ����� s�GFGQNRTRIKsux_9_NH�2VKTR�"IKTRc �

= �K~b{ �4a � �Ee ~ � ¢ a�� ,�e � NH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuNF�2VKt�tuV��`G��2TRVK= TRJbt�> 9 IXa<a�NfIXJE: �= �K~b{ �4a � ��f�e ~ � ¢ a�f � � e � NH9<>dTH>wG^JbtuN:�2VKt�tuV��`G"�2TRVK= THJbt�> 9 a<IKT:NRIKJE: �= �K~b{ � v�wLxEz � � NH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN"�2V_tut�V��`G��2THV_= TRJbt�> 9 gb>�� =�J�: �= �K~b{ �4a�i}j�l��pq�s��;e � NH9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN"�2V_tut�V��`G"�2TRVK= TRJbt�> 9 cM>4�k=�J�:��

/

��� ~ � � �.� � ~ z�¢�~ y?�X| �'¡�� { �! � f!�"� ���� / f"- #%�����Q� a�f �Ee / f"- %. } ¡�¡��?\�gnNH9bs�G�abTRV�VK�Q���">�GHJbaba,V_GH>�NH9<IXN�9*I�pK>?IXgnIKababt�s�e�I�NRsuV_gnIXg*c gbVKN�I�TR>�e�VKTfc GH>�t�>�e�NRsuV_g 9 NH9b>a<THVrVX��s�GUNR9b>�GHPr=�=?>�NHTRs�eFe�IKGH>`s�G�G^s�=?sut�IXT�:��k8:9b>�abTHVrVK�7s�G�=�I_cM>`�rP�I�e�IKGH>`IXg*IXt�PrGHs�GUVKg�NR9b>`t�IKG^N�TRJbtu>VK�kf � � ���� / f"-��

= �K~b{ � � �2~ z�¢�~���� �">d9<I�pK>8f�n agbkcRe t IKg<c�f"-�n t����#��c��K�<NH9rJ<G:NR9b>�TR>�GHJbt�NF�2V_tut�V��`G"�2TRVK=THJ<tu> 9 TH>wc��,>4NfI : �

= �K~b{ � � � ~b} �2~ z�¢�~ ��� �">�9*I�pK>�f ��� ���� / f"-Us�=?abtus�>�G�a�f �dt�e �"� ���� / a�f"-��dt�eR�?8:9<>�TR>4�2VKTR>K�J<GHsugbx�NH9b>�sug*cMJ<e�NRsuV_g�9rPra*VKNH9b>wG^s�GQCLa�f �Ee / f"-'�U8:9b>�TH>wG^JbtuN��2V_tut�V��`GU�2TRVK= THJ<tu>wG 9 TR>�c�>���Jbs�p :IXg<c 9 TH>wc�e�VKg�NH>�L�N�:�C�a�f��Rt�e � 1 a�f �Ee��Fagt �Ee7/ f"- �Fa�t �Ee �

= �K~b{ � ������  � �?~ � ¢ � ¢ � � � ��� s�g[NH9<>��<TfGQNBe�IKGH>K�,�">�9<I�pK>�f>n v�w��IzWt���f"-Rn vw���zWt"-IXg<c t&�<� ��� / t"-'�B8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_�<J<GHs�gbx�NR9b>�s�g<cMJ<e4NHs�VKg 9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�GMC�a�t �Ee2/ t�-'�8��T`NH9<>�GHs�cM>e4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg<G�VX��TRJbt�> 9 gb>�� =�JE:Osu=?abt�su>wG�NH9<IXN �hgn &,�7NH9rJ<GMC�a�f �Ee 1 v�w��Izgagt �Ee / v�w��IzWt�-'�8:9b>dabTRVrVX��s�GFGHsu=?s�t�IKT:�2VKT:NH9<>�e�IKGH> 9 cM>���=�JE:��

/

��� ~ � � � ��� � y?�K| �2¡ � { �! � f �". 0 �� � 1 � � ������������ / f"- #%��� ��� a�f |�0e��Fa�m |��e / f"- %

:<;k¥=: >

Page 44: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� m*@

ohe�VKTRVKt�t�IKTHP?VK�qNH9<s�GFa<THV_a*>�T^NQP�s�G:NH9*I�NMCUsu�Ff!� . 0 �� �>� � ���� ��������� / f"-'�bNH9b>�g�f �Fa�m�|�Ee / f"-'�. } ¡�¡�� � >�N�|� 9 TH>wG^aq� |��:q�*>"NR9b>�NRJbabt�>\a � # %M~Q~Q~3% � % e 9 TR>�GHa��ha � # %M~Q~Q~-% �:4�eg:4�}K >:=?IASK>"IOe�I_G^>"IXg<IKtuPMGHs�GV_g�NR9b>dt�IKG^N:TRJbt�>�VX�Ff!��. 0 �� � 1 � � �� ��������� / f"-��

= �K~b{ � � ¢ � ��� ��� �">�9<I�p_>�f n � x t � �<. 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / agt �+#k~Q~M~ �B%�e8n f"-"IXg<cpa�f |�Me"1 f?�8:9b>�TR>4�2V_TH>_��J<G^s�gbxOG^NHTRJ<e4NHJbTfIXt_>���Jbs�p�IKtu>�g<e4>"IXg<c�THJbt�> 9 TH>wc�cM>�e�t�:4����>�9<I�pK> CFa�f |�0ed��a�m�|�Ee(/ f"- �

= �K~b{ ��������  ����~ � ¢ � ¢ � � ����� s�g NR9b>��*TRG^NBe�IKGH>��">�9<I�p_>Of n v�wyxEzWt?�uf"-}n v wLxEzWt"-IXg<c t ���� /�t"-5��8:9b>dGHs�cM>�e�VKg<cbs�NRsuV_g�s�=?abtus�>�GFNH9<IXN6mhgi ��%0|��% |���rNH9rJ<GMC

aPagv�wLxEz�t�e |�0e,�ka�m_|�Ee 1 vwhxEz a�t |� �da�mB|�"ePe8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_=�NH9<>dsug<cbJ<e�NRsuV_g[9�Pra,VXNR9b>�GHs�GFIKg<c�THJbt�> 9 TR>�c#e4V_g�NH>4LrN�:���8:9b>dabTRVrVX��s�GG^s�=?sut�IXTFs�g#NH9b>�e�IKGH> 9 cM>���=�JE: �

= �K~b{ � � � ~M} � � ��� ��>�9<I�pK>hf �<. 0 �� � 1 � �������������� / f"-_s�=?abt�su>wG}f ��t �<. 0 �� � 1 � � ������������ / f"-���a�t |�2e,IXg*c,a�f���t�e |� 1a�f |�Me �Eagt |�0eH�U8:9b>`TR>�GHJbtuN��2VKt�t�V��`Gk�2THV_= NR9b>Os�g<cMJ*e�NHs�VKg�9rPra,VXNH9<>�GHs�G�IXg<c?TRJbt�> 9 TR>�c�e�VKg�NH>�L�N�: �

= �K~b{ � � ~ ��� �$� ��� s�g NH9<s�G�e�I_G^>_�U��>�J*G^>�NH9b>��'IKe4N�NH9*I�N?�Fs�NR9 VKJbT�gbVKNRI�NRsuV_g<GMCoaPa�f�A2e |�0eBs�Gf a A% |�2eH�

/��� ~ � � � ��� ��|�y?�X| �2¡�� { �! � f � �������� �� ��� � �� ����������� / a�� �Pf"-�e #%�����Q�������Q�P���'4 ������� � ��"'��o��� ��� !

f 1�v�w (�Iz a�ikjIl��pq�s,a�m |�p�u��ePe ����� v�w (�Iz a�ikjIl��pq�s���e #"yv�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�sOf - e. } ¡�¡���8:9b>Fs�g�NHJbsuNHs�VKg?�,>�9bs�g<c � >�=�=�I��B� m�s�G�NH9<IXN��_Jbg<cM>�T�IXg�>�p�IXt�J<IXNHs�VKg?e4VKg�NR>4LrN��X�">Fe�IKg�IKtu�:I�PMG�^t�s�� N �FcM>��<gbsuNHs�VKg<G�Jba?NHV�NR9b>FNHV_aM£¤tu>�pK>�t��RK >`=�I&S_>FIde�IKGH>FIXg<IKtuPMGHs�GkV_g�NH9b>Ft�IKG^N�THJ<tu>FVK��f � � ������ �� ��� ���������������� /a�� �Pf"-�eH�

= �K~b{ �(�Q¡ �q| ��� ��> 9*I�pK>�f n � ���������� �>� � � �� ����������� / a � � eR� ��T � 1 v�wW'Nz�a�i}j�l�q�s$a � � ePe�IXg*c " v�wW'Nz�a�i}j�l�q�s eR�U8:9b>dTR>�GHJbtuN:�2VKt�tuV��`G:�rP�ef9bVrV�G^s�gbx�� n bncfe �= �K~b{ � � � ~b} ¡ ��| �)8 � ~ ��� ¡ �q| �)8 � �q��  ¡ �q| ��~ � ¢ � ¢ � ��¡ �q| ��� s�g�e�I_G^> 9 a<IXT�V_JMNN:4�K�2V_T�>4LbIK=�£abt�>K����>U9*I�pK>Ff � �������� �� ��� ���������������� / a�� �Pf"-�eH��8:9rJ<G7NH9<>�TR>U>4LMs�G^NRGR� GHJ<ef9BNH9<IXN}f 1 v�w (�Izga�i}j�l��pq�s$a�m�|� ����e�eIXg<c�NR9b>�G^s�cM>de4V_g<cMsuNHs�VKg�l shagt�e"'�a�ikj�lAa���e&jr|&"eFn ��s�=�a<tus�>�GMC

a�f ��t�e 1�v�wX(�Iz a�ikjIl��pq�s�a�m�|� �Fa�����t�e�e�e8:9b>dTR>�GHJbt�N:�2V_tut�V��`G"�2THV_= 1 � " IXg<c " s�GFI?e4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4> 9 GH>�>d8:9��<l<�u@2: �

= �K~b{ �+� �q��  ¡���� � � ~ � ¢ � ¢ � ��¡���� � ��� sug NH9b>0e�I_G^> 9 gb>�� VKa,>�g�:��">�J*G^>�NH9b>��'IKe4N�NR9<I�Nf #"%t s�=�a<tus�>�G=v�wyxEzf #"hv�wLxEz�t?� 8:9<s�G�s�G#I e�VKg<GH>���Jb>�g<e4> VX��NR9b> �'I_e�N#NH9<IXN #"�s�G�Ie4V_gbxKTRJb>�g*e4>K�k\�g�NH9b>�e�IKGH> 9 cM>���V_a*>�gE:��b�">dIXt�G^V?9<I�p_>ONRV�J<GH> � >�=?=�I?lb��@�NRV�abTRV�pK>`NR9<I�N0C

v�w (��zga�ikj�l���n % �pq�s���e #"yv�w (�Izga�i}j�l"�$n %!�pq�s,a�i}j�l���n q�s���e�e

/

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 45: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

m�? � ����2�&�������������R��!���

� �F���F���`��!"�F�

-u@Q1�Y IXTHN���g0oO�<IKcbs�IXg<c � J*e�I$<"IXTfcM>�t�t�s5� � B ���N�&��J.�����;H��Q�N'���� �h�rabTRsugbx_>�TH£ &U>�THt�IXx*�*@wvKv_lb�- ?�1�Y IXTHN���g o`�*IKcMs�� � J<e�I4<"IXTfcM>�t�t�s5��S�su>�THTR>4£ � V_Jbs�G,<�JbTRsu>�g���IKg<c/]K>�IKgM£Q]KI_e���Jb>�G � E�prP_� ZkLMabt�s�e�s�NGHJb�<G^NHsuNHJbNHs�VKg<G�� \�g�� �G�M')%\��� � � � �� ��� ���� ���4�\�E�""���F��#�' � J��\D��2��� � ��� � �����'�� D������ ���� �P�P�A�P�&������I� � ���I�A"�Q�I��� �<a<IXx_>�G:jb@���m_l<�r]_IXgrJ<IKTHP[@wvKv /b�

- j&1dC`VK�,>�THNHV�Y �<oO=?I_cMs�V<�M\�t�IXTRs�I,<"IKG^NH>�tut�IXgbs��bIXg*c��BI�prs�cM>��MIKgbxKs�VKTRxKs��%��g��bs�GHsu=�Jbt�IXNHs�VKg<G"�2V_T:NH9b>I_G^Prg<ef9<THV_gbVKJ<G�absu£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G�� B � �N���P�Q����'N�&�y#%���\DE � �Q� � 'Q������'G� ��@wv�� 9 ?A:�C ?Kvb@��Mj ?Xm<�b@wvKvAY<�

- mA1 $O>�g<cbTHs S S�su>�NH>�T��:IXTR>�g<cMTR>�xKN�� B � � � �&�,HG�A�_#%����'Q �!�� # ! ������J��E�g�-4��&��� � �Q���&�"����'�� ��``V_T^NR9$OVKt�t�IKg<c���@wvAY<@K�

- ��1 #BE�TRIKTRc ��>�THTRP0IXg<c #BE�TfIXTfc[��V_J<cMV_t5�d8:9b>?ef9b>�=?s�e�IKt�IK�<GQNRTRI_e�NO=�I_ef9bsug<>K� B ���N���P�Q����'G�&��#%��� �D� �g�Q� � 'Q���Q��'N� �*vKl�C@?M@����?�m Y<�b@�v_v ?b�

- l&1�Y[s�ef9b>�tu>���V_TH>wIXt�>K��<�E�cMTRs�eU�<VKJbTRgb>�N���IXg<c�<�V�G^s�=?V � IXg<>�pK>_�X�"s�GHsu=�Jbt�I�NHs�VKg*G7sugdNR9b>�WQV_sugM£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G��\�g���� #BTHs�>�G"IXg*c�Kh� S��McM>OCFVr>�pK>�Tw��>�cMsuNHV_TRG���� �G�M')%}��� ��� ��#�� ' ' B�� ��� � �P�G�&�G����������=#%���(�'N��DE���O����� '��������0�2� �<a*IXxK>wGFlAY���YKl<� <�9*IXab=�IXg�� $�IXt�t5�,]XJbg<>�@wvKv Yb�

-!�21 #BE�TRIKTRc#�"VKJ<cbVKt��ko�G^Prg<ef9<THV_g�P�IKg<c�NH9b>877£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��U8�>�ef9bgbs�e�IKt�CF>�a,VKTHNd@��&/ ?M�r\�`�CF\Qo���@wvKvI?M�- Y&1 #BE�TRIKTRc?�"VKJ*cMVKt��*8:9b>�77£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<GUs�g�cMsuTR>�e4N�GQNQPrt�>K�,\�g � �P�0'-%}��� � � � �� ��� �!#" �����\�"�""�&�I��#�'

� J��;D��2��� � ��� � �����'Q� DE��������� � �P�G�&�P�&������I� � �����&"�M� ��� �ba<IXx_>�G�?A?AY$��?�m<@_��]_IXgrJ<IKTHP[@wvKv �M�- v&1 #BE�TRIKTRc �"VKJ*cMVKt��h8�Prabs�gbx NR9b> J<GH> VK��TR>�GHVKJ<TRe�>�G?s�g I e4V_g<e4J<THTR>�g�N�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G�� \�g%� �P�M')%����

� � ! �'& � (�) � ������� #%���\DE ����I� � 'Q������'G��#%���0�����P�Q��'N� � � >we�NRJbTH>8`OVXNH>wG:sug�<�V_=�a<JMNH>�T;�Me4s�>�g<e�>K�*dIXNH9b=�IKg<cMJ�� ��>�e�>�=��*>�Td@�vKv �r���rabTRs�gbxK>�T^£"&U>�TRt�IKx<�

-�@M/&1"#BE�TRIKTRc��"VKJ*cMVKt��X8:9b>h77£�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G�s�g�cMs�TH>we�N�G^NQPrtu>_��+ �(�&���Q� ���L�G�A�Q�6�&��� � J��$HG���!��'�#%�&�;D� �g�&�����&� �@_@AC�@������ ?A/AY<��@wvKv Yb��>4LrNR>�g<cM>wc pK>�TRGHsuV_gnVK� - Y21¤�UIXt�G^V[I�p�IXs�t�IK�bt�>?I_G-,/.�.103254�4�6�6�687:9�;�03<>=�?/@A=�B�<C @(4#DFE(=�G�E/4�0�E1@A9�;�?�?(E�H�4�I/E�@/B1@�JK<ML(;�N�J/;�HO<M,/.�DAH<�

-�@K@Q18�Msut�p�IXgbV �BIXtu£QP7sut�suV*�6<�V_g<e4JbTRTR>�g�NFVK�MWQ>we�NRG`sug#NH9<>��bt�Jb>�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G���>�gbx_tus�G^90p_>�TfG^s�VKg#VX�6-u@�m�1¤�*IXt�GHVI�p�IKsut�IX�bt�>dIKGK,/.�.�0�254�4�6�6�63<R=#?/@A=�BS< C @�4#DAE(=�G1E/4�0(E�@:9�;�?�?(E�H�41T:=�H�U�B�?�;O<WV�B/H�X1Y(=�H(=$;/4<�

-�@0?�18�Msut�p�IXgbV �BIXtu£QP7sut�suV*��\�=?abt�s�e�s�N�a*V_tuPr=?VKTRab9bs�e�NQP�a,>�GHPMGQNR>�= �2V_TdNH9<>��btuJ<>�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G��#8q>wef9bgbs�e�IXtC`>�a,VKTHNOj ?�m_m<��\�`OCF\Qo����r>�aMNH>�=��,>�Td@wvKv �M�

-�@�j&18�Msut�p�IXgbV ��IKt�£5P,s�tus�V<�[Z�Jbs�>4NFIXg<c��*V_Jbg<e4s�gbx�VK�MWQ>we�NfGQCk8q�"V�=?s�xKTfI�NRsuV_g�IX�<G^NHTfIKe4NHs�VKg<G�s�g�I�G^s�=?abtu>cbs�G^NHTRsu�<JMNH>wc �bt�Jb>�e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G��0\�g � �N� ! �"� �����������������&�]\���� �0�G� �ND���� � �Q�,���"����'��$���^�;H��Q�G'Q���$���� �P�M'N���N����� �<�:CF\P<6�o``VKNH>�G �M>�TRsu>wG��<]KJbt�P @�v_vAY<�

-�@�mA18�Msut�p�IXgbV �BIXtu£QP7sut�suV*�����MWQ>�NRGUe�VKg<e�JbTHTR>�g�NfGUcbIXg<GkJ<g,77£¤e�IXt�e4JbtbIKababt�s�e�I�NHsu�Q�,\�g_� �P�M')%����'`�a � � � 1� �1��b ���c`��� ���FdN���eau�G����'N��D"���&�������A��� � �&�I�I�Q�I��� �6DADE�(��'G�&��� �G� �,�b>��<THJ<IKTHP @�vKv_vb�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 46: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

����������� ������������������������� �!"�$#%�&��'� �(�� m�j

-�@ ��1�`Os�e�VKt�IKI_G7#BV�pK>�T^NOcb>��"THJ<s WQg�� � IK=��7cbI�£�e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*GFgbVXNfI�NRsuV_g �Fs�NR9 g<IK=�>�tu>wGHG�cMJb=?=?su>wGQC`I�NHVrVKt�2V_T�IKJMNHV_=�I�NHs�e��2V_TH=�Jbt�I[=�IXgbs�abJbt�I�NRsuV_g �Fs�NR9 IKababt�s�e�I�NHs�VKg NRV NR9b> <�9rJbTfef9M£�CFV_GRGH>�T�NH9<>�VKTR>�=0�! ��� �Q� %�'������ % �*jKm 9 �A:�C jAY<@��MjKv ?b�<@wv �&?b�

-�@�l&1�<�EwcMTRs�e��bVKJ<THgb>�N�IKg<c #B>�V_THx_>�G9#BV_g�NH9bs�>�Tw� 8:9b>�TH>Q�<>4LMs�pK>�ef9b>�=�s�e�IKt"IK�<G^NHTfIKe�N�=?I_ef9bs�gb>�IXg*cNR9b>�WQV_sugb£¤e�IXt�e4Jbt�J<G��,\�g � �P�M')%k��� � � � �� � �!�� �P���\�"�E"���I��#�' � J��;D��2��� � �&� � �����'�� D������8���� �P�P�A�P�&������I� � ���I�A"�Q�I��� �<a<IXx_>�G:j �A?#�rj Y��b��]_IXgrJ<IXTRP[@�v_vKl<�

-�@��21 �BIXg<su>�t $`s�TfGHef9�S_V kk� ' ���Q� �Q� �0�Q �M�P���A��D��P�� �����=� ��H�������� � ��������� �h8:9b;wG^> c�� E�NRI�Nw����e4V_tu>`�I�NRsuV_g<IXt�>dcM>�G`S�V_g_NfG:>4N <�9<IKJ<GRG^E�>�G��,@wvKv_vb�

-�@MY&1-*�VK9<>�s $`VKg*cbI�IKg<c�`OVK�bJ"SKV���V�G^9<s�cbI<�d��g�TH>wcMJ<e�NRsuV_gM£¤�<IKGH>�c�a<THVMe4>wGHG"GH>�=�IXg�NHs�e�G�� B ���N�&�P������'N���#%�&�;D� �g�Q� � 'Q������'N� ��@��A? 9 ?A:�C m�j �#��m Y_lb�b@wvKv �M�

-�@�v&1dY IKGRG^s�=?VdY[>�TRTHV�IXg<c �BI�prs�cM> �MIKgbxKs�VKTRxKs��E��g�IKGHPrg<ef9bTRVKgrP�sug?g<IK=�>�£�a*IKGRG^s�gbx�e�IXt�e4J<tus��<\�g � �P�0')%��� ! #R� � � � �� ��p_VKt�Jb=?>F@�m_m_j"VX� � �N'Q�� �G� &���� ���h��o#%���\DE � ��� � 'Q������'N� �2�rabTRsugbx_>�TH£ &U>�THt�IXx*�X@�v_vAY<�

-@?&/&1�C`VK�bs�g Y0s�tugb>�T���8:9b>�a,VKt�P_IKcbs�e�77£�e�IXt�e4J<tuJ<GMC�I#NRJMNHV_THs�IXt���8�>�ef9bgbs�e�IKt�CF>�a,VKTHN�Zy<6�r£ � �k<6��£�vb@�£@0YA/<� � IK�*V_TRIXNHVKTRP?�2VKT��bVKJ<g<cbI�NRsuV_g<GFVK�h<�V_=?abJMNH>�T\�Me�su>�g<e4>_���`g<sup_>�TfG^suNQP�VX��Z�cbsugr�bJbTRxK9q�q@�v_vb@_�C`>�abTRsug�NR>�c�s�g � VKx_s�e`IKg<c�oOtux_>��bTfIdVK�k�ra,>�e4su�*e�I�NHs�VKgq�r�"�M�:IXJb>�T��IKh� ��TfIXJ<>�T�IKg<c $����Mef9r�Fs�ef9�N^£>�gr�*>�THx*�bZ�cbG��E�rabTRsug<xK>�T &U>�THt�IXx*�7@�vKv_jb��?&/Km���?�m_l<�

-@?M@Q1�C`VK�bs�gnY0s�tug<>�Tw���bJ<g<e�NRsuV_g<G�I_G`abTRVMe4>wGHGH>�G�� '��������Q���&����'N��� � ����"'Q�� �P������ #%���\DE � ��� � 'Q������'N� �?�Cu@_@�v��,@�m*@K�*@�vKvI?M�

-@?A?�1�C`VK�bs�g Y[sut�gb>�Tw�F]XV�IKef9bs�=�S�IKTHTRV��d��IKg<c �BI�prs�cBK IKt�S_>�Tw� o e�IKt�e�Jbt�J<G?VX�B=�V_�bs�tu>#abTRVre�>�GRG^>wG��a*IXTHNRG:sqIKg<c�s�s�� ` �& �����&�}��� ! �M�������,���������4����� #%���\DE � ��������� �q@0/A/�C�@�� � �M�<@�v_v ?b�

-@?Xj&1�C`VK�bs�g Y[sut�gb>�T�IKg<c ��I�prs�cM>��bIXgbx_suV_THx_s5���:IKTH�,>�c �bs�GHs�=�Jbt�I�NRsuV_g���\�grKh� *�Jbs�ef9���>wcMs�NRVKTw� �� ���! #R� � �:�qpKV_tuJ<=�>�lI?Xj�VX� � �N'Q�� �G�]&O�&�g���,���#%���\DE � �Q� � 'Q������'G� ��a<IXx_>�GdlAY �#�MlKv��b���ra<THs�gbxK>�T^£&U>�THt�IXx*��@�v_v ?M�

-@?�mA1 �BI�prs�cb>.�MIXg<xKs�VKTRxKs���8:9b>�t�I ��P t�IX=��,c<I e�IKt�e�JbtuJ*G�s�g I e4V_g<e4JbTRTR>�g<e�P GHe�>�g<IKTHs�V<� ! �0�������,����������&����#%���\DE � ��������� �q@K@K@ 9 @2:��7@�v_vXm<�

-@? ��1 �BI�prs�cb> �MIKgbxKs�VKTRxKs��,�"s�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg?�2VKT�9bs�xK9b>�T^£¤VKTfcM>�TUa<THVMe4>wGHG�e�IKt�e�Jbtus�� ! �0�������,�����������&���.#%��� �D� �g�&�����&� ��@wjb@ 9 ?A:�Cu@�m<@��,@��&Yb�b@wvKv_lb�

-@?Xl&1 �BI�prs�cb>r�MIKgbxKs�VKTRxKs��>��g NH9b> �bs�G^s�=�J<t�IXNHs�VKg abTRVrVX��=?>4NR9bVMc�� '��������Q���&����'N�&� � ����"'��� �P������#%�&�;D� �g�Q� � 'Q������'N� �"Y 9 � :�C mKm �#��m ��vb� �Be�NRVK�,>�Td@�v_vAY<�

-@?��21d]_IX=?>wG�Kh�k��NfIX=?V_GdIKg<c ��I�prs�c *?� #Bs�k7VKTfc���CF>�=�VKNH>�>�p�IKtuJ*I�NHs�VKgq� ��#�' B �P�&���Q�A'Q�����&�������� �P�P�A�P�&������I� � ���I�A"�Q�I�����&��� � J2���g�Q��� ��@2? 9 mI:�C!�Xj ��� �Xl��b���Be4NHVK�,>�T�@wvKvA/<�

-@?&Y&1 �BI�prs�c_`��U8qJ<THgb>�T�� B � � � �&�!J����&�gD"�I��' � � ��#%�&��'� �(�� ! B ���N����J��&��� ! �\DE���Q�,���E�g�&�����&� � SU9 �NR9b>�GHs�G�� �Ogbs�pK>�TfGHs�NQP�VK�kZ�cbsugr�bJbTRxK9q��@�v_v��M�

¥}¥ ¯�¦"§�¨�¨N©

Page 47: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

m_m � ����2�&�������������R��!���

-@?Xv&1dY[s�Nfef9b>�t�tdK IKg<c���<�V_=?abtu>�NH>�NQP�a,>�s�gM�2>�TH>�g<e4>��2VKT�G^s�=?abtu>�VK�MWQ>we�NfG���\�g � �P�0'-%L��� � ! # � � ���� �! ���� J��;D��2��� � ��� � �P�A��',���#F�&�;D� �g�Q� � 'Q������'N� ��a*IXxK>wG�j ���rmKm*��@wvAY �M��o e4V_THTRsux_>�g<cbJb= NHV#NH9b>IKT^NRs�e�tu>dIKaba*>wIXTR>�c�sug � \P<6� � Y Yb�

:<;k¥=: >

Page 48: A Bisimulation for the Blue Calculus - HAL

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles - B.P. 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - B.P. 101 - 54602 Villers lès Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot St Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399