If you can't read please download the document
Upload
dangdiep
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
)1(
- /
)2(
- /
/
:
" "
2009 5 - 3
12
2
)209(
:
. -
.
:
.
.
.
) (
.
:
.
3
ThePracticeofChangestrategiesinEncounteringCrisesanditsImpactonCorporatePerformance
AFieldStudyontheJordanianBankingSector
Submittedby
TaghridSalehSuifan(1)
AhmedAdnanAlTit(2)
AbstractThe aim of this study is to describe the impact of the practice of changestrategiesinencounteringcrisesanditsimpactoncorporateperformanceintheJordanianbankingsector.Thesamplestudyconsistedof(209)individualsworking in four banks: Arab Bank, Housing Bank for Trade and Finance,Bankof JordanandBankSocieteGeneral, andwasselected byusing thestratified random sampling method. A questionnaire was developed tomeasurethestudyvariableswhichhadtheacceptablevalidityandreliability.Appropriatestatisticalmethodswerealsousedtoanswerthestudyquestionsand to test the hypotheses.Thestudyconcludedasetof results, themost
importantare: Thedegreeof practicingchange strategies in encounteringcrises in
theJordanianbankingsectorwashigh,wherethedegreeofpracticingtheempiricalrationalandnormativereductivestrategieswasalsohigh,whereas the degree of practicing the power coercive strategy was
medium. The level of corporate performance in the Jordanian banking sector
washigh. Therewas a positive relationshipbetween the empirical rational and
normative reductive strategies and the corporate performance,whereastherewasanegativerelationshipbetweenthepowercoercive
strategyandthecorporateperformance. There was a statistically significant impact for change strategies
practices in encountering crises (empirical rational, normativereductive, and power coercive) on corporate performance in the
Jordanianbankingsector.
In light of these results, the study presented many recommendations themost important one is enhancing the practice of empirical rational andnormative reductive strategies and trying to merge them in the Jordanian
bankingsectorandavoidingtheuseofpowercoercivestrategy.
4
:
.
.
(Tichy & Devana)
:
). 1994 (
) 2001 (
.
). 2003 (
).2007 (
:
:
) (
:
:
5
:
:
. )2006 (
.
). 2002 (
.
:
.
.
.
.
6
.
:
-
-
:
:
-
.
-
.
-
.
. -
-
.
- :
.
.
:
7
- :
) 0.05( " :
(
( )
". )
:
) 0.05( " :
(
)
".
) 0.05( " :
(
)
".
) 0.05( " :
(
)
".
:
:
8
9
:
:
.
.
:
.
:
: -
. 2009 -
: -
.
10
:
:
:
" : "
" : "
).668:1972 (
).227:1994 (
(FrenchBell&Zawacki,1995)
.
)2003(
.
:
.(Pattanayak&Mishra,1999)
)2002(
.
11
:
)2006 : (
: -1
.
: -2
.
: -3
.
: -4
.
(Chin&Bennay,1997)
:
: .1
.
: .2
12
.
: .3
.
:
:
): ( :
(
2007.(
(Skibbines) : :
).2007 (
(
2006.(
: )2002(
: -1
.
: -2
.
13
: -3
.
:
(BalogunandHailey,1999)
:
: -1
.
: -2
.
: -3
.
-4
.
-5
.
).2006 (
).2006 (
(Paton&McCalman,2001)
:
14
. -1
-2
.
-3
.
-4
.
. -5
)2006 : (
: -1
.
: -2
.
: -3
.
: -4
.
: -5
.
: -6
.
) (
Balanced) Scorecard)
,Hendricks,Menor&Wiedman))1950(
15
Kaplan) (2004 & Norton)
)1991(
.(DavigElbert&Brown,2004)
: "
:
.(Charles&Pineno,2004)) (
)(Charles&Pineno,2004
,Kaplan( & Norton, )1992
:
: -1
.
.(Kaplan&Norton,1996)
: -2
:
.
Kaplan( &
Atkinson, ).1998
16
(OstrengaOzanMcilhattan&Harwood,1992).
: -3
(Kaplan&Atkinson,1998)
: -4
,Reeve(
1990.(
:
:
) 2005 (
.
) Jimmieson; White & Peach, 2004 (
.
(Stewart & Kringas, 2003)
:
.
17
) 2002 (
.
) 2001 ( .
.
:
.
:
.
( ) 8 ( ) 15 ( ) 23 (
). 2008
-
%) 40 (
. ) 1 (
) 1 (
64 159 13 83 208 17
117 292 38
18
13 32 4 - 277 691 72
) 277 (
%) 84 ( ) 232 (
) 23 (
) 2 ( ) 209 (
.
) 2 (
12 4
59.3 %
% 40.7 85
% 23 48
13 2
63.2 %
% 13.9 29
11 5 1
53.1 %
% 34.9 73 10 - 5
% 12 25 10
:
( ). 2002 (
: (Likert) ) 2005
( ) 4 ( ) ( ) 5 ( ) (
1 ( ) ( ) 2 ( ) ( ) 3 ( )
: )
( :
).
19
) 24 (
) 10 - 1 (
- 18 ( ) 17 - 11 (
24 .(
) 18 (
) 35 - 30 ( ) 29 - 25 (
). 40 - 36 (
20
:
.
:
(Cronbach Alpha) -
. ) 3 (
) 3 (
0.89 10 - 1
- 11 17
0.81
- 18 24
0.81
- 25 29
0.79
- 30 35
0.84
- 36 40
0.78
:
Statistical Package for Social)
Science) (SPSS)
- :
. . 1
. . 2
21
:
:
: "
"
. ) 4 (
) 4 (
3.70 0.66 1
3.66 0.70 2
3.38 0.70 3
3.59 0.45 -
) 4 (
) 3.59 (
.
) 3.70 (
) 3.66 (
). 3.38 (
. ) 5 (
22
) 5 (
1 0.96 3.95 1
7
2 0.94 3.78
8
3 0.95 3.77
2
4 0.98 3.73
5 0.99 3.62 6 3
6 0.94 3.59
7 0.99 3.58 9 8 0.98 3.57 10 9 0.96 3.54 5 10 1.06 3.49 4
1 0.93 3.89 15 2 0.91 3.87 13 3 0.93 3.84 17
4 0.96 3.76 14 5 1.02 3.70 16 6 0.98 3.54 11 12
7 1.06 3.33
1 0.91 3.72 21 2 0.94 3.47 20
3 0.92 3.46 22 19
4 1.11 3.44
5 1.12 3.29 18 6 1.08 3.14 24 23
7 1.07 3.12
" ) 1 ( ) 5 (
"
) 0.96 ( ) 3.95 (
" " ) 4 (
). 1.06 ( ) 3.49 (
" ) 15 (
"
" ) 12 ( ) 0.93 ( ) 3.89 (
23
"
). 1.06 ( ) 3.33 (
" ) 21 (
"
) 0.91 ( ) 3.72 (
" ) 25 (
) 3.12 ( "
). 1.07 (
: "
"
. ) 6 (
) 6 (
3.83 0.62 1
3.72 0.64 2
3.61 0.77 3
3.72 0.56 -
) 6 (
) 3.72 (
.
) 3.83 (
) 3.72 (
). 3.61 (
. ) 7 (
24
) 7 (
1 1.10 3.72 28 25
2 0.95 3.68
3 1.00 3.59 26 4 1.09 3.54 29 27
5 1.05 3.52
35
1 0.71 3.95
34
2 0.79 3.85
3 0.89 3.74 31 4 0.91 3.72 33 5 0.93 3.62 30 6 0.88 3.44 32
40
1 0.86 4.04
2 0.82 3.90 39 3 0.80 3.79 38 4 0.91 3.73 37 5 0.85 3.67 36
" ) 28 ( ) 7 (
"
) 27 ( ) 1.10 ( ) 3.72 (
" "
). 0.95 ( ) 3.68 (
" ) 35 (
"
) 32 ( ) 0.71 ( ) 3.95 (
" "
). 0.88 ( ) 3.44 (
" ) 40 (
"
) 0.86 ( ) 4.04 (
25
" " ) 36 (
). 0.85 ( ) 3.67 (
:
:
( ) 0.05(
)
. ) (
) (
. ) 8 (
) 8 (
) (Beta
R 2
0.43 5.85 0.00 *
0.23 3.12 0.00 *
- 0.18
- 3.41
0.00 *
0.45 58.53 0.00 *
) 0.05( *
) ( ) 8 (
) 0.05( ) 0.00 ( ) 58.53 (
%) 45 (
.
(
)
) (
) 0.00 ( ) - 3.41 3.12 5.85 (
26
)0.05 ( ) Beta ( 0.18 0.23 0.43 ( - (
.
.
) 0.05( "
(
) ( )
".
:
( ) 0.05(
)
.
) (
. ) 9 (
) 9 (
) (Beta
R 2
0.51 6.36 0.00 *
- 0.23
- 4.03
0.00 *
0.00 0.04 0.97
0.35 37.66 0.00 *
) 0.05( *
) 9 (
) 0.05( ) 0.00 ( ) 37.66 ( ) (
27
%) 35 (
.
(
)
) - 4.03 6.36 ( ) (
) 0.05( ) 0.00 (
) Beta ( ) - 0.23 0.51 ( .
) 0.04 ( ) (
) 0.05( ) 0.97 (
) Beta ( 0.00 ( .(
.
) 0.05( "
) (
".
) 0.05( "
".
:
( ) 0.05(
)
.
28
) (
. ) 10 (
) 10 (
) (Beta
R 2
0.35 4.35 0.00 *
0.24 2.87 0.01 *
- 0.15
- 2.61
0.01 *
0.34 37.29 0.00 *
) 0.05( *
) 10 (
) 0.05( ) 0.00 ( ) 37.29 ( ) (
%) 34 (
.
(
)
4.35 ( ) (
) 0.01 0.01 0.00 ( ) - 2.61 2.87
0.24 0.35 ( ) Beta ( ) 0.05(
. ) - 0.15
.
29
) 0.05( "
(
". )
:
( ) 0.05(
)
.
) (
. ) 11 (
) 11 (
) (Beta
R 2
0.38 4.33 0.00 *
0.17 1.96 0.05 *
- 0.04
- 0.68
0.50
0.26 25.59 0.00 *
) 0.05( *
) ( ) 11 (
) 0.05( ) 0.00 ( ) 25.59 (
%) 26 (
.
(
)
) 0.05 0.00 ( ) 1.96 4.33 ( ) (
30
) 0.05(
) Beta ( . ) 0.17 0.38 (
) 0.50 ( ) - 0.68 ( ) (
). - 0.04 ( ) Beta ( ) 0.05(
.
) 0.05( "
) (
".
) 0.05( "
".
:
:
:
. 1
.
.
.
31
. 2
.
.
.
. 3
.
.
.
. 4
) (
.
.
. 5
) (
.
.
32
.
. 6
) (
.
.
. 7
) (
.
.
.
:
:
. 1
:
.
.
.
.
. .
33
. 2
:
. .
.
.
. .
. 3
.
34
:
:
: ).2002" ( "
:
.
. : ). 2008 (
)2( ).2006(
. :
. : )1( ).2003(
: ).2003(
. :
).1994(
: ) ( :
.
).2002(
).88( ,
).2005(
. , : , ,
: )1( ).2001(
: )3( ).2007(
.
).2001(
).85(
).1994(
. : )1(
35
).2006(
. : )1(
2 2 1 ).1972(
: ).2005(
)32( :
.433-415 )2(
).2006(
. :
:
Balogun, J. & Hailey. H. V. (1999) Exploring Strategic Change.
London:PrenticeHall.
Charles, J., & Pineno, P, (2004), Balanced Scorecard Application and
Model Building A survey and Comparison of the Manufactured
Homes and Motor Homes Industries, Management Accounting
Quarterly,FallVol.(6),No.(1).Pp.2128.
Chin, Robert & Bennay, Kenneth, D. (1997). General Strategies for
Effective Change in Human Systems, New York: Rinehart and
Winston.
Davig,WilliamElbert,Norb,&BrownSteve, (2004), Implementinga
Strategic Planning Model for Small Manufacturing Firms: An
Adaptation of the Balanced Scorecard, Sam Advanced
ManagementJournal,Winter,Pp.1823.
French, L. Wendell Bell, Cecil, H. & Zawacki, Robert A. (1995),
Organization Development and Transformation. McGrawHill
Inc.
36
Hendricks, Kevin Menor, Larry & Wiedman, Christine, (2004), The
Balanced Scorecard: To adopt or not to adopt?, Ivey Business
Journal,November/December,Pp.118.
Jimmieson, N. White, Katherine, & Peach, Megan,(2004). Employee
ReadinessforChange:UtilizingtheTheoryofPlannedBehavior
to Inform Change Management, Academy of Management.
California:USA.
Kaplan R., & Atkinson A.A., (1998). Advanced Management
Accounting,PrenticeHall,N.J,ThirdEdition,
Kaplan, R., & Norton, D, (1992). The Balanced Scorecard: Measures
That Drive Performance, Harvard Business Review, January
February,Pp.7179.
Kaplan,R.,&Norton,D, (1996). TheBalancedScorecard:Translating
Strategy intoAction,HarvardBusinessSchoolPress,September,
P.324.
Ostrenga, M. Ozan, T. Mcilhattan, R., & Harwood, M, (1992). The
Erns&YoungGuidetoTotalCostManagement,JohnWilly&
Sons,NewYork
PatonR.A.&McCalmanJ.(2001).ChangeManagement:AGuideto
EffectiveImplementation.SecondEdition.SagePublications.
Pattanayak, B. & Mishra P.K. (1999). Change for Growth:
UnderstandingOrganizationalDevelopment.NewDelhi:Wheeler
Publishing.
Reeve, J., M., (1990). The Impact of Continuous Improvement on the
Design of Activity Based Cost Systems, Cost Management,
Summer,Pp.4350.
Stewart, J. & Kringas, P. (2003). Change ManagementStrategy and
Value in Six Agencies from theAustralian Public Service. Public
AdministrationReview.Vol.63,6,pp:675688.
37