10
SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP Attorneys Counselors ACTED Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission Clerk Public Service Commission 2540 Shumark Oak Boulevard Tallahassee, FL 32399-0850 I[::n =F'S" I I.:. ) _ . - -' . '-..1 13 J AN 25 AM 9: 52 LL." I, ... " January 18, 2013 \,; __ claim of confidentiality of intent request for confidentiality __ filed b)' ope For DN OC4si-I'3 , which is in locked storage. You must be authorized to view this DN,-CLK 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE SUITE 4030 LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 PHONE (407) 830-6331 FAX (407) 830-8522 www.sfflaw .com Re: Docket No. 120152-WS- Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Orange County by Pluris Wedgefield, Inc. Our File No.: 43085.15 Dear Ms. Cole: Enclosed is Pluris Wedgefield, Inc.'s ("Utility") Summary of Pro Forma Plant and Expenses requested in this proceeding and the Request for Confidential Classification. Should you or Staff have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. MSF/der Enclosures cc: COM __ AFD APA "::CO ENG GeL __ 10M TEL CLK __ Maurice Gallarda (via e-mail) Ana VanEsselstine (via e-mail) Bart Fletcher (via e-mail) Steve Reilly, Esquire Michael Lawson Very truly your MARTIN S. F For the Firm ., o 0 45 7 JAN 25 F'pSC-c or 'lMI3sIOt l CLE RK BOCA RATON LAKE MARY TALLAHASSEE

766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

SUNDSTROM FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO UP

Attorneys Counselors

ACTED

Ms Ann Cole Commission Clerk Office of Commission Clerk Public Service Commission 2540 Shumark Oak Boulevard Tallahassee FL 32399-0850

r C ~I I[n =FS1 I I ) _ - - -1

13 JAN 25 AM 9 52

LL I January 18 2013 LI~

__ claim of confidentiality DOti~ of intent

~ request for confidentiality __ filed b) ope

For DN OC4si-I3 which is in locked storage You must be authorized to view this DN-CLK

766 NORTII SUN DRIVE SUITE 4030

LAKE MARY FLORIDA 32746

PHONE (407) 830-6331 FAX (407) 830-8522

wwwsfflawcom

Re Docket No 120152-WS- Application for increase in water and wastewater rates in Orange County by Pluris Wedgefield Inc Our File No 4308515

Dear Ms Cole

Enclosed is Pluris Wedgefield Incs (Utility) Summary of Pro Forma Plant and Expenses requested in this proceeding and the Request for Confidential Classification

Should you or Staff have any questions please do not hesitate to contact me

MSFder Enclosures

cc COM __ AFD APA CO ENG GeL __ 10M TEL CLK __

Maurice Gallarda (via e-mail) Ana VanEsselstine (via e-mail) Bart Fletcher (via e-mail) Steve Reilly Esquire Michael Lawson

Very truly your

~L~ MARTIN S F For the Firm

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FpSC-c orlMI3sIOtl CLE RK BOCA RATON bull LAKE MARY bull TALLAHASSEE

BEFORE THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

In re Application of PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC DOCKET NO 120152-WS for an increase in water and wastewater rates in Orange County Florida

------------------------------~

PLURlS WEDGEFIELD INCS REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIAL CLASSIFICATION

PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC (the Utility) by and through its undersigned counsel files

this Request for Confidential Classification in relation to the Utilitys Summary of Pro Fonna Plant

and Expenses filed with the Clerk electronically on January 18 2013 in redacted fonn

1 Pursuant to Section 367156 Florida Statutes this Commission has the authority to

classify certain material as proprietary confidential business infonnation This classification

exempts the material from public disclosure under Section 11907(1) Florida Statutes

2 The Utility requests that certain infonnation provided to Staff in the Summary of Pro

FOlma plant and Expenses be classified as proprietary confidential business information under

Section 367156(2) Florida Statutes and Rule 25-2206 Florida Administrative Code (the

Confidential Information) If this request is granted then the subject portions of said response to

will be exempt from Section 11907(1) Florida Statutes Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a

Justification Matrix providing a justification for the Utilitys request The information is filed

herewith in both highlighted and redacted fonnat

3 The infOlmation produced includes employee compensation information which is

intended to be and is treated by the Utility as private and confidential and has not been disclosed

externally and has been strictly controlled internally

4 A portion of the information consists of employees name and title base salary

benefits taxes pension information and total compensation This infonnation sh~ould be classified

as proprietary confidential business infonnation because its disclosure would irnp~tr~tbF Ut~~yen~ _ [t-r r

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COHMISSIOH CLERK

competitive interests provide other utility companies information to lure employees away (thereby

driving up salaries and rates) and create circumstances under which infighting and employee

morale could be negatively affected See Florida Power amp Light Company et al v Public Service

Commission 31 So 3d 860 (Fla 1 st DCA 2010) This Commission has routinely protected salary

information since this opinion was rendered

5 Requiring the disclosure of each employees compensation information violates each

employees right to privacy under Article I Section 23 of the Florida Constitution

WHEREFORE PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC prays for the entry of an order treating the

information identified in this Motion as confidential and exempt from disclosure

Respectfully submitted this 18th day of January 2013 by

Sundstrom Friedman amp Fumero LLP 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030 Lake Mary FL 32746 Phone (407) 830-6331 Fax (407) 830-8522 mfriedmansfflawcom

Florida Bar No 0199060 For the Firm

2

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DOCKET NO 120152-WS

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Request for Confidential

Classification has been sent to the PSC Clerk by hand-delivery and furnished by US Mail to the

following parties this 18th day ofJanuary 2013

Stephen Reilly Associate Public Counsel Office of Public Counsel Co The Florida Legislature 111 W Madison Street Room 812 Tallahassee FL 32399-1400

Michael Lawson Senior Attorney Office of General Counsel Florida Public Service Commission 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee FL 32399-0850

For the Firm

3

Exhibit JUSTIFICATION MATRIX

request wpage

Disclosure amounts in titled data data and salary Amount under description would ability of the Utility to

new controller Addition of contract for employees on favorable terms two call center employees)

Disclosure would impair

as described the amounts

employee for each listed

and the salary and to prevent dialogue) employees to n-gtgt-n

and infigh ting employees have the same varying

of the Florida information would

employee

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 2: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

BEFORE THE FLORIDA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

In re Application of PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC DOCKET NO 120152-WS for an increase in water and wastewater rates in Orange County Florida

------------------------------~

PLURlS WEDGEFIELD INCS REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIAL CLASSIFICATION

PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC (the Utility) by and through its undersigned counsel files

this Request for Confidential Classification in relation to the Utilitys Summary of Pro Fonna Plant

and Expenses filed with the Clerk electronically on January 18 2013 in redacted fonn

1 Pursuant to Section 367156 Florida Statutes this Commission has the authority to

classify certain material as proprietary confidential business infonnation This classification

exempts the material from public disclosure under Section 11907(1) Florida Statutes

2 The Utility requests that certain infonnation provided to Staff in the Summary of Pro

FOlma plant and Expenses be classified as proprietary confidential business information under

Section 367156(2) Florida Statutes and Rule 25-2206 Florida Administrative Code (the

Confidential Information) If this request is granted then the subject portions of said response to

will be exempt from Section 11907(1) Florida Statutes Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a

Justification Matrix providing a justification for the Utilitys request The information is filed

herewith in both highlighted and redacted fonnat

3 The infOlmation produced includes employee compensation information which is

intended to be and is treated by the Utility as private and confidential and has not been disclosed

externally and has been strictly controlled internally

4 A portion of the information consists of employees name and title base salary

benefits taxes pension information and total compensation This infonnation sh~ould be classified

as proprietary confidential business infonnation because its disclosure would irnp~tr~tbF Ut~~yen~ _ [t-r r

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COHMISSIOH CLERK

competitive interests provide other utility companies information to lure employees away (thereby

driving up salaries and rates) and create circumstances under which infighting and employee

morale could be negatively affected See Florida Power amp Light Company et al v Public Service

Commission 31 So 3d 860 (Fla 1 st DCA 2010) This Commission has routinely protected salary

information since this opinion was rendered

5 Requiring the disclosure of each employees compensation information violates each

employees right to privacy under Article I Section 23 of the Florida Constitution

WHEREFORE PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC prays for the entry of an order treating the

information identified in this Motion as confidential and exempt from disclosure

Respectfully submitted this 18th day of January 2013 by

Sundstrom Friedman amp Fumero LLP 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030 Lake Mary FL 32746 Phone (407) 830-6331 Fax (407) 830-8522 mfriedmansfflawcom

Florida Bar No 0199060 For the Firm

2

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DOCKET NO 120152-WS

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Request for Confidential

Classification has been sent to the PSC Clerk by hand-delivery and furnished by US Mail to the

following parties this 18th day ofJanuary 2013

Stephen Reilly Associate Public Counsel Office of Public Counsel Co The Florida Legislature 111 W Madison Street Room 812 Tallahassee FL 32399-1400

Michael Lawson Senior Attorney Office of General Counsel Florida Public Service Commission 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee FL 32399-0850

For the Firm

3

Exhibit JUSTIFICATION MATRIX

request wpage

Disclosure amounts in titled data data and salary Amount under description would ability of the Utility to

new controller Addition of contract for employees on favorable terms two call center employees)

Disclosure would impair

as described the amounts

employee for each listed

and the salary and to prevent dialogue) employees to n-gtgt-n

and infigh ting employees have the same varying

of the Florida information would

employee

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 3: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

competitive interests provide other utility companies information to lure employees away (thereby

driving up salaries and rates) and create circumstances under which infighting and employee

morale could be negatively affected See Florida Power amp Light Company et al v Public Service

Commission 31 So 3d 860 (Fla 1 st DCA 2010) This Commission has routinely protected salary

information since this opinion was rendered

5 Requiring the disclosure of each employees compensation information violates each

employees right to privacy under Article I Section 23 of the Florida Constitution

WHEREFORE PLURIS WEDGEFIELD INC prays for the entry of an order treating the

information identified in this Motion as confidential and exempt from disclosure

Respectfully submitted this 18th day of January 2013 by

Sundstrom Friedman amp Fumero LLP 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030 Lake Mary FL 32746 Phone (407) 830-6331 Fax (407) 830-8522 mfriedmansfflawcom

Florida Bar No 0199060 For the Firm

2

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DOCKET NO 120152-WS

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Request for Confidential

Classification has been sent to the PSC Clerk by hand-delivery and furnished by US Mail to the

following parties this 18th day ofJanuary 2013

Stephen Reilly Associate Public Counsel Office of Public Counsel Co The Florida Legislature 111 W Madison Street Room 812 Tallahassee FL 32399-1400

Michael Lawson Senior Attorney Office of General Counsel Florida Public Service Commission 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee FL 32399-0850

For the Firm

3

Exhibit JUSTIFICATION MATRIX

request wpage

Disclosure amounts in titled data data and salary Amount under description would ability of the Utility to

new controller Addition of contract for employees on favorable terms two call center employees)

Disclosure would impair

as described the amounts

employee for each listed

and the salary and to prevent dialogue) employees to n-gtgt-n

and infigh ting employees have the same varying

of the Florida information would

employee

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 4: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DOCKET NO 120152-WS

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Request for Confidential

Classification has been sent to the PSC Clerk by hand-delivery and furnished by US Mail to the

following parties this 18th day ofJanuary 2013

Stephen Reilly Associate Public Counsel Office of Public Counsel Co The Florida Legislature 111 W Madison Street Room 812 Tallahassee FL 32399-1400

Michael Lawson Senior Attorney Office of General Counsel Florida Public Service Commission 2540 Shumard Oak Boulevard Tallahassee FL 32399-0850

For the Firm

3

Exhibit JUSTIFICATION MATRIX

request wpage

Disclosure amounts in titled data data and salary Amount under description would ability of the Utility to

new controller Addition of contract for employees on favorable terms two call center employees)

Disclosure would impair

as described the amounts

employee for each listed

and the salary and to prevent dialogue) employees to n-gtgt-n

and infigh ting employees have the same varying

of the Florida information would

employee

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 5: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

Exhibit JUSTIFICATION MATRIX

request wpage

Disclosure amounts in titled data data and salary Amount under description would ability of the Utility to

new controller Addition of contract for employees on favorable terms two call center employees)

Disclosure would impair

as described the amounts

employee for each listed

and the salary and to prevent dialogue) employees to n-gtgt-n

and infigh ting employees have the same varying

of the Florida information would

employee

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 6: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

DACTED Pluris Wedgefield Inc Additional Proforma Costs - both Expenses and Capital

Description

Expenses

Amount

Capital

Amount

Cost of new controller $ 28689

Addition of two call center employees $ 14005

Increase in property taxes (above filed amount of $108 593) $ 67375

Water plant bio-filter $ 20100

Pipe break costs $ 87731

VFD and Scada at Water Plant $ 50 893

Wier Replacement at Wastewater Plant $ 12412

Total Proforma Costs $ 110069 $ 171136

See tab for hard quote of $15100 Pluris expects an additional $5 000 in concrete foundation piping and fabric on water tank

Proforma adjustments previously included on Schedule

A-3 of MFRs

o a 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC-COMM SSON CLERK

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 7: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

- Customer Care Center Staff Beverly Yopp f)irecio 0 Cils iomer r~le along WII 4 0 11 centel

staft WIllp isM the tolal umber 01 cali center personnellfl Ille Ol ) test VeRI The toial P _~ent I eQ11 test yea period) wfi cenier siaffs anl1u I salaries and bellefits are Plcvicied II tile fallowing

la Ie

Dlease note thai aE a resJII of comments made duang lIe Cllstomer meetmg in Weagcfieid

regardl1l9 hald times atong vifh managements revIewtn the other utilities tVO addltioal PIUfi5 calf center 51 ( wili be added fo Ihe call cenler (effectIVe dale IS 123112) in order to aridr ess hoias

dUlJng all in by cuSlOmers One of the lwo call cenier employees hired (Joyce Scor) II1iS hIAd 10 also address an Increasing bi-hflgual need In the Florida utiitles Boln Ms iilomas and Ms Scoir Iave accepted lhe pOSitio ns

Name of new employees Ihal have been hired after December 31 2011 and Iheir annualized

salary or wages Mr Dan Wrnter COl(folf)r (or Pluris lioldings LLC was Illred Gn Jlly 2 7012 a d Iipound ilnnuallzed salaz witli beneflls are _ lIS aiocrlled c os l~ to PilfIS WedlJefelLi Inc is U 3021 X =_ Also see lile aforementioned table for I]P COslS lealed 0

rile two lIew call cell er Silff- Vaeoe Thomas and Joyce Sea t who Witt s art Decernbel 31 201 2

New controller amount should be_x 0 2001 _

Two call center employees ShOUld~~ x 02001 = ~

Erica Gandy

Kristy Hairston

Amelia Moore

Beverly Yopp

o0 4 5 7 JAN 25 ~

FPSC - CO~1MSSJON CLERK

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 8: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

-----------------------------------

~ Pluri~ Wedg~eld Rate CaseDocket No 120152-W5 - Message (HTML)

M essage ESfT Adob PDF

X BrlanSarbara P 1 f~ M ark Unread a31) ~ Find Ru les ~ )( Ignor ~ Ieling

~~ ~ ~ L- To Manager -------J OneN o te I Categorize ~ Related ~ iii Jun K middot Dflete Reply Rep lv Fo rw a rd

~

ave Translate Zoom All

~ M o re ~ uJ Team E-mail --T tD Act io n s ~ Follow Up ~ Select

Delete Respond QUIck Steps M ove rJs EditIng Zoom

From MMbn Fnedmiln ltMFfledmanfflilN romgt Se nt Thu llJal201 2 1259 PM

To Ana VanEsse15 tine

Cc Bilr Fletcher MaurIce Gililarda Dan Win ters

Su bj ect Plu m Wedg ef ield RaU Case D o Cket No 1201 52 JS

J Message 1m WedJefield Property TaJ( Bills 2012pdf ri07 KBj

Ana During the test year the Utility had property taxes of $108593 The 2012 property tax bills (copies attached) which the

Utility just received totals $175968 an increase of $67375 When the Utility inquired as to why there was such a large I increase it was told that there was an error and actually the prior years bill should have been greater than it was

rPlease accept this as Pluris Wedgefields request for a proforma increase in property taxes Should you have any

questions or should you disagree that a proforma adjustment is appropriate please contact me Regards Marty

SUNDSTROM SUNDSTROM FRIpoundDI1AN amp FUMpoundRO LLP FRIEDMAN amp FUMERO LU Attorneys at La

~ 766 North Sun Drive Suite 4030

Lake lJary Florida 32746 T 4078306331

A l t o l Y 1 COutt o r

f 4078308522

rvl 4073102077 mfrledman sffaw CQm

wwwsffiawcom Tallahassee Lake Mary Boca Raton

shy[] Martin Friedman

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 9: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

J Fo B r l x )(

fa

4(rQ tHJ

~ AaBbCcO( AaBbCcDlt Ia BbC aBIJ c Aal) bull Rh 4oBbCcO A8M(I~ AUBbCcDt 40BbCcih AoUb( ( ~ No t r rHIpf 1~jIQJ I fl4middot ~ 1 r11c o1lltf JlolJff tfllllllU Ionl-mft 5 01111 Quatf 1ntmeQ chovt

Jl FIId

ArDUU

Scop e

Odor Control Systemmiddot Carbon

One (1) ECS V1-TM-200 adsorber systems a Rated for 200 cfm o 30 diameter FRP vessel with top mounted ran () Plain end inlet with fprnc flexible connector (1 Three (3) 2 carbon sample ports with PVC ball valves per media bed o One (1) 2 drainfill port with PVC ball valve o One (1) 2 overflow port with PVC ball o Three (3) y air sample ports with PVC ball valve and Magnehel ic gauge o 316 SST grounding rod in media bed o 15 ft3 of aClivated carbon media

Simple control panel w ith disconnect onoff switch and run light

Price for the above equipment including freight to the jobsite Is $ 1510000 Price includes spgcial watgr- eneJjble c~rbon which provid long c~rbon lifg

-

Proposa120515C

I I I

W bullbull middot

10 II

12

13 u 17

19 20

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G

Page 10: 766 NORTII SUN DRIVE I[::n - LAKE MARY, FLORIDA 32746 ... · SUNDSTROM, FRIEDMAN & FUMERO, UP . Attorneys Counselors . ACTED . Ms. Ann Cole, Commission Clerk Office of Commission

I

Vendor

Rangeline

Centrdl florida Tapping

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and Construction

SampK Utilities and ConstruCtion

SampK Utililies and Construction

TNT Sewer

Duda and Son

EMS of Central Florida

EMS 01 Central Flonda

EMS of Centrnl Florida

EMS of Central Florida EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Flonda

EMS of Central F londa

EMS or Central Florida

EMSof CentrRI Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMS of Central Florida

EMSof Central Florida

Invoice Amount Due

FL-26507-1 $ 1310000

Sub lotal $ 1310000

9509B

SubTotal $ 975000

2012-3 $ 673750

2012-4 280000

2012-5 195000 2012-7

2012-15

12-326

57930000 $ 31092

SubTotal S 31092

22281 $ 140000

22542 $ 95000

22543 $ 50000

71918 S 626500 21903 S 207500

22130 $ 738500

21t16 S 65000

21G28 $ 1144000

71291 $ 1049 An

22368 $ 140000

22550 $ 266445

22549 S 4BOO 00

Sub lotal $ 40~7931

Tolal Amount $ 877339G