649690 Landscape of energy efficiency policy packages in a multi … · 2017-01-11 · /0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-! Landscape of energy efficiency

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&!'()*+,-!.&)/!0120234/!5+678+(9:6+!5;<;<!!

=>&5?@>A#!%B!#&#$CD!#BBE@E#&@D!A%=E@D!

A>@F>C#?!E&!>!GH=IEJ=#K#=!C%K#$&G#&I!

?D?I#G!

A>$I!%B!L%$F!A>@F>C#!</!G>AAE&C!%B!#&#$CD!#BBE@E#&@D!A%=E@D!E&?I$HG#&I?!>&5!

>K>E=>M=#!I#@"&%=%CE#?!E&!MHE=5E&C?!>&5!I$>&?A%$I!

&>IE%&>=!$#A%$I!B%$!#?I%&E>!

"#$%&!''(#)*)+$!,-'.!A9(-N+(/!!"#$%&#'()*+,-.#+(/+")0+1"-"2"/)34''-++)5/+"./!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

)

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!

Landscape of energy efficiency policy packages in a multi-level government system p. 2 of 27

)

0+1"-"2"-#+6)!"#$%&#'()*+,-.#+(/+")0+1"-"2"/)34''-++)5/+"./!

)

!"//.-+7)5#((-""//)(/(8/.)9:;6)3--")<4''41"/))

!

=./>4./?)8@6)3--")<4''41"/A)B4.-)CD11-A)</.'-)<-.1-(44A)=-./")<2'?+4)

!!"#$%&'$()''*+,-$./00+))''$0'01'*$&23$)&'$*'34/,3+1+5+)6$7/*$',38*+,-$)&'$9825+)6$/7$)&'$*'4/*):!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&/!B)(O9(P!Q!6))R7NS!T),7)J+,)N)U7,!(+T+9(,V!)N!#N+(SW!#XX7,7+N,W!7N!#H!,)YN-(7+T!!

!

$E4F!!G6>H2A@!!E7F!!62A2452I!!JK?I4?L!!J6>M!@E2!%K6>G27?!)?4>?NF!9>64O>?!,-,-!62F276AE!7?I!4??>57P

@4>?!G6>L67MM2!!K?I26!!L67?@!!7L622M2?@!!<>!!BCDBD-(!!$E2!A>?@2?@!>J!@E4F!I>AKM2?@!62J32A@F!>?3Q!

@E2! 7K@E>6FN! 542RF! 7?I! @E2! %#+S%! 4F! ?>@! 62FG>?F4832! J>6! 7?Q! KF2! @E7@!M7Q! 82!M7I2! >J! @E2! 4?J>6P

M7@4>?!4@!A>?@74?F!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


!@)N-+N-T!

ACRONYMS ........................................................................................................................................... 4!

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................ 5!

1.! THE ROLE OF GOVERNANCE AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY POLICY PACKAGES ON THE NATIONAL LEVEL ................................................................................................................................. 6!

1.1! POLICY PACKAGES AND POLICY GOVERNANCE IN EUROPEAN MEMBER STATES .................................................. 6!1.1.1! Buildings Sector ........................................................................................................................................................... 6!1.1.2! Transport Sector ........................................................................................................................................................ 10!

1.2! National Programmes and Initiatives ..................................................................................................... 15!1.2.1! Green Investment Scheme implementation in building sector ................................................................................... 15!1.2.2! Green Investment Scheme in transport sector ........................................................................................................... 17!1.2.3! ELMO – Estonian Electromobility Programme in transport sector ............................................................................. 19!

1.3! Conclusions and Lessons Learned of other Projects about the Performance of the National Policy Packages for Energy Efficiency .......................................................................................................................... 20!

1.3.1! Buildings sector .......................................................................................................................................................... 20!1.3.2! Transport sector ......................................................................................................................................................... 22!

2.! INTERACTION BETWEEN THE NATIONAL AND THE SUB-NATIONAL LEVELS .................... 24!

REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................................... 25!

!!

!

!

!

I9:6+!)X!I9:6+T!

!

I9:6+!<!I(9NT')(-!T+,-)(ZT!+N+(SW!,)NTYU'-7)N!-9(S+-T!7N!#T-)N79!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;!<<!

I9:6+![!#T-)N79ZT!C(++N!EN8+T-U+N-!?,V+U+!I(9NT9,-7)NT![3<3J<[!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;!<0!

I9:6+!\!CE?!'()S(9UT!(+S9(P7NS!-(9NT')(-!9NP!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;!<]!

I9:6+!1!?YUU9(W!)X!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NP9-7)NT!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;![<!

I9:6+!^!E#>!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NP9-7)NT!X)(!#T-)N79!7N!-(9NT')(-!T+,-)(!;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;![\!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


ACRONYMS !

##)! !!!P!#FF4L?2I!#M>K?@!)?4@F!K?I26!)<!T===!

"9! !!!P!"4F@64A@!E27@4?L!

%U=! !!!P!%?546>?M2?@73!U?52F@M2?@!=2?@62!

%VS;! !!!P!%F@>?47?!%32A@6>PS>8434@Q!06>L67MM2!

%<S#W!!!!P!%F@>?47?!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!"2523>GM2?@!037?!

*U+! !!!P!*622?!U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!

%0X"! !!!P!%?26LQ!026J>6M7?A2!>J!XK43I4?LF!

%0=! !!!P!%?26LQ!026J>6M7?A2!=26@4J4A7@2F!!

%)!%$+! !!!P!%)!%M4FF4>?F!$67I4?L!+AE2M2!!

%Y! !!!P!%32A@64A!Y2E4A32!

ZU! !!!P!Z>4?@!UMG32M2?@7@4>?!!

WUW! !!!P!%F@>?47?!%?546>?M2?@73!U?52F@M2?@!TK?I!

W62I%[! !!!P!=62I4@!7?I!%[G>6@!*K767?@22!TK?I!

V%X! !!!P!V>RP%?26LQ!XK43I4?L!!

S%#=! !!!P!$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!

<%%#0! !!!P!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?!!

?\%X! !!!P!?2763Q!\26>P%?26LQ!XK43I4?LF!!

;"%]! !!!P!%?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?I2[!>J!4?IKF@6Q!

:W#+! !!!P!+@7@2!:273!%F@7@2!=>MG7?Q!V@I!^:44L4!W4??4F5767!#+#!

+%#0! !!!P!+KF@74?7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?!!!

)<T===!!!P!)?4@2I!<7@4>?F!T67M2R>6_!=>?52?@4>?!>?!=34M7@2!=E7?L2!

!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY !

$E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!@76L2@F! J>6! @E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!762!L452?! 4?! @R>!M7H>6!?7@4>?73!G6>L67MM2F(!

T46F@3Q1!$E2!<7@4>?73!:2J>6M!06>L67MM2!`%F@>?47!,-,-a!I2FA6482F!@E2!>8H2A@452F!2F@7834FE2I!@>! 4MP

G6>52!A>MG2@4@452?2FF!7?I!7A@454@42F!?22I2I!@>!7AE4252!@E2F2!>8H2A@452F(!T4?73!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!4F!

@76L2@2I!@>!62M74?!7@!@E2!32523!>J!,-'-!4?!,-,-(!!$E4F!!!M27?F!@E7@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!MKF@!82!F4L?4J4P

A7?@3Q!674F2I! 4?!G76@4AK376! 4?!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6(!$E2!%F@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!E7F!M7I2!@7?L4832!G6>P

L62FF!4?!M22@4?L!@E2!@76L2@F!F2@!F>!J76(!+@76@4?L!J6>M!,-'b!M>62!F@64?L2?@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!62cK462P

M2?@F!2F@7834FE2I!@>!?2R!7?I!62A>?F@6KA@2I!8K43I4?LF!8Q!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>MQ!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?1!

E754?L!>526733! 62FG>?F48434@Q! 4?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ(! ! UMG32M2?@7@4>?!>J! @E2! 62cK462M2?@F!>J!%0X"!"4P

62A@452!4F!J>62F22?!4?!@E2!J46F@!>6I26!4?!GK834A!8K43I4?LF!@>!627AE!@E2!M7[4MKM!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!

@>!I2M>?F@67@2!@E2!2[7MG32(!$E2!62J>6M!G6>L67MM2!4?A3KI2F!@E2!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!@E2!4?52F@M2?@!

G7A_7L2! J>6! 2?26L2@4A! 62JK684FEM2?@! >J!MK3@4G32! 7G76@M2?@! E>KF2F1! 73F>! @E2! JK23! FR4@AE! FK8F4I42F!

J6>M!>43!@>!M>62!2JJ4A42?@!@QG2F!>J!JK23F!4?!G6457@2!E>KF2F(!

+2A>?I3Q1! @E2! %F@>?47?! <7@4>?73! "2523>GM2?@! 037?! >J! @E2! %?26LQ! +2A@>6! K?@43! ,-b-! ^%<S#W!

,-b-de!R4@E!@E2!54F4>?!@433!,-.-!4F!>?2!>J!@E2!A2?@673!F@67@2L4A!I>AKM2?@F!RE4AE!J4[!@E2!M74?!G7@ER7QF!

>J!I2523>GM2?@!>J!M7?Q!>@E26!G6>L67MM2F(!!%<S#W!,-b-d!I67RF!@E2!M74?!A>?A2G@!34?2F!>J!2?26LQ!

F2A@>6!I2523>GM2?@!KG!@433!,-b-(!$E2!G6>L67MM2!4F!@E2!M>F@!KGI7@2I!I>AKM2?@!I2FA6484?L1!4?!J7A@1!

@E2!54F4>?!>J!G>FF4832!I2523>GM2?@!G7@EF!>J!733! F2A@>6F! 4?A3KI4?L!@E2!8K43I4?LF(!"2@7432I!I2FA64G@4>?!

>?!2[4F@4?L!F@>A_!>J!8K43I4?LF!4F!L452?!87F2I!>?!RE7@!@E2!JK6@E26!I2523>GM2?@!G7@EF!J>6!2?26LQ!F754?L!

762!J>6MK37@2I(!$2AE?4A73!2?26LQ!F754?L!G>@2?@473!J>6MF!76>K?I!f-g!^D(b!$/EhQe!>J!G62F2?@!2?26LQ!

A>?FKMG@4>?! >J! 8K43I4?LF! 7?I! 4@! A>MG64F2F! 6>KLE3Q! 'hb! >J! @>@73! J4?73! 2?26LQ! A>?FKMG@4>?! ^bbPbC!

$/EhQe!4?!%F@>?47!

$E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ! @76L2@! J>6! @E2! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>6! 4F! F2@! 4?! @E2! %F@>?47?!$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!

037?!,-'Ci,-,-&!@>!62@74?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6NF!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!8Q!@E2!Q276!,-,-!>?!@E2!32523!>J!

@E2! Q276! ,-',! 7?I! @>! A627@2! 7! 87F4F! J>6! 62IKA4?L! 2?26LQ! A>?FKMG@4>?! 7J@26! @E2! Q276! ,-,-(! $E2!

M27FK62F!I2FA6482I!4?!@E2!F@67@2LQ!@76L2@!8>@E!FKGG3Q!7?I!I2M7?IPF4I2!M7?7L2M2?@!7?I!A>526!733!

@E622!2JJ4A42?AQ!I4M2?F4>?F&!FQF@2M!2JJ4A42?AQ1!@67523!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!52E4A32!2JJ4A42?AQ(!*622?!U?52F@P

M2?@!+AE2M2F!E752!822?!7?!4MG>6@7?@!?7@4>?73!G6>L67M!4?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6!2?7834?L!@67?FG>6@!

F2A@>6! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! 4?52F@M2?@(! $E2! 62G>6@! G62F2?@F! @67?FG>6@! FAE2M2F! FKGG>6@2I!8Q!*U+! 7?I!

@E2!84LL2F@!?7@4>?73!G6>L67M!6237@2I!@>!@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!j!%F@>?47?!232A@6>PM>8434@Q!G6>P

L67M!%VS;!@E7@!E7F!FKGG>6@2I!@E2!GK6AE7F2!>J!''BC!%YPF!4?!%F@>?471!4?A3KI4?L!.-k!4S4%YF!J>6!F>A473!

R>6_26F! 733! >526! %F@>?471! G6>54I4?L! 7! ?2@R>6_! >J! 'B.! cK4A_! AE76L26F! 7?I! %VS;! 62?@! FQF@2M(!

!

S>F@!4?@26?7@4>?73!@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!6237@2I!G6>H2A@F!E4LE34LE@!@E2!E4LE!G>@2?@473!>J!2?26LQ!

F754?L!4?!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6(!;"l++%lPS):%!G6>H2A@!A>?A3KI2I!@E7@!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?I2[!;"%]!

J>6!@67?FG>6@!4?!%F@>?47!E7F!4?A627F2I!8Q!'k(bg!^J6>M!,---!@>!,-'-e!M27?4?L!@E7@!@E2!2?26LQ!4?@2?F4P

@Q!E7F!4?A627F2I(!$E2!I4JJ262?A2!>J!2?26LQ!4?@2?F4@Q!>J!@67?FG>6@!4?!%F@>?47!7?I!@E2!%)!4F!526Q!2FF2?P

@473&!4?!%F@>?47!-(-fk!_L!>2h%):,---!7?I!@E2!%)!75267L2!-(-b,!_L!>2h%):,---!4?!,-'-(!U%#!7?I!;%="!

E752!62A>MM2?I2I!%F@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!@>!4MG32M2?@!M>62!G>34A42F!6237@2I!@>!@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!2JP

J4A42?AQ!4?A3KI4?L!M7?I7@>6Q!52E4A32!JK23!2JJ4A42?AQ!F@7?I76IF1!M27FK62F!@>!4MG6>52!52E4A32!JK23!2JJ4P

A42?AQ1!4MG6>54?L!>G267@4>?73!2JJ4A42?AQ!@E6>KLE!2A>PI6454?L!7?I!>@E26!M27FK62F(!

!

!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


1. THE ROLE OF GOVERNANCE AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY

POLICY PACKAGES ON THE NATIONAL LEVEL !

1.1 POLICY PACKAGES AND POLICY GOVERNANCE IN EUROPEAN

MEMBER STATES

1.1.1 Buildings Sector

!

;JJ4A473! I>AKM2?@F1! ?7@4>?73! G6>L67MM2F1! F@67@2L42F1! 7A@4>?! G37?F! 2@A(1! L452! @E2! @76L2@F! J>6! JK6@E26!

4MG6>52M2?@! 4?!2?26LQ!F754?L!7?I!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ! 4?!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6! 4?!7!I4JJ262?@!R7Q(!+>M2!>J!

@E2M! L452! cK734@7@452! 7FF2FFM2?@F! >6! 8642J! L2?2673! I2FA64G@4>?F! >?3Q! 7?I! FKLL2F@! @E2! >526733! 4MP

G6>52M2?@!7GG6>7AE2F(!$E2!>@E26F! 4?@6>IKA2!@E2!?KM264A73!I7@7!>?!@E2!2?26LQ!F754?L!>6!2JJ4A42?AQ!

@76L2@F! KG! @433! ,-,-! >6! ,-b-(! %?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! E7F! 822?! 62J2662I! 7F! 7! G64>64@Q! >6! 7?! >8H2A@452! 4?! 7!

?KM826!>J!?7@4>?73!I2523>GM2?@!G37?F1!G>34AQ!I>AKM2?@F!7?I!62G>6@F!@>!%K6>G27?!=>MM4FF4>?(!!!!

$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!4F!62FG>?F4832!J>6!@E2!2378>67@4>?!7?I!4MG32P

M2?@7@4>?!>J!',!I4JJ262?@!F@67@2L4A!I>AKM2?@F!J>6!%F@>?47!RE4AE!762!34F@2I!>?!S%#=!R28F4@2!^S%#=1!

,-'.e(! +252?!>J! @E2M!762! 6237@2I! @>! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! 4FFK2F! 4?! 8K43I4?LF! 7?Ih>6! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>6F(!

$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@!cK>@2F!@>!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?!4@F!@R>!<7@4>?73!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!@>!

)<!T===!7F!@E2!G6257434?L!FE762!>J!L622?E>KF2!L7F!2M4FF4>?F!4F!IK2!@>!4?2JJ4A42?@!L2?267@4>?!>J!2?26P

LQ!87F2I!>?! 3>A73! J>FF43! JK231!>43! FE732(! ! U?! @E2! J>33>R4?L! @E2F2!M74?!?7@4>?73!>JJ4A473!I>AKM2?@F!762!

34F@2Im!!

!

• <7@4>?73! :273! %F@7@2! +@67@2LQ1! 7GG6>52I! 4?! ,--k(! $E2! F@67@2LQ! 4F! 74M2I! @>! 82@@26! KF7L2! >J!

F@7@2P>R?2I! 6273! 2F@7@2! 7?I! I67J@F! @E2! JK6@E26! I2523>GM2?@! G7@E1! 62G62F2?@4?L! %F@>?47NF!

F@67@2LQ!@>!7AE4252!@E2!`%K6>G2!,-,-a!>8H2A@452Fm !

• %F@>?47?!<7@4>?73!9>KF4?L!"2523>GM2?@!037?!,--f!j!,-'b(!062G762I!8Q!@E2!S%#=1!@E2!S4?4FP

@6Q!>J!ZKF@4A2!7?I!W62I2[!4?!,--km!!

• %F@>?47NF! T4J@E! <7@4>?73! =>MMK?4A7@4>?! K?I26! @E2! )<! T67M2R>6_! =>?52?@4>?! >?! =34M7@2!

=E7?L2(! 062G762I! 8Q! @E2! %F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q! >J! @E2! %?546>?M2?@! 7?I! @E2! %F@>?47?! %?546>?P

M2?@73!:2F276AE!=2?@62!4?!,--D(!

• %F@>?47?!:2?2R7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?!J>6!,-,-!^<:%#0e1!,-'-1!4?!7AA>6I7?A2!R4@E!"462A@452!

,--Dh,fh%=!>?!@E2!G6>M>@4>?!>J!@E2!KF2!>J!2?26LQ!J6>M!62?2R7832!F>K6A2Fm!!

• %F@>?47NF! F4[@E! <7@4>?73! =>MMK?4A7@4>?! K?I26! @E2! )<! T67M2R>6_! =>?52?@4>?! >?! =34M7@2!

=E7?L2(!062G762I!8Q!@E2!%F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@!7?I!%F@>?47?!%?546>?M2?@73!

:2F276AE!=2?@62!4?!,-'b(!!

• <7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?!^<%%#0e1!,-'C(!%F@>?47nF!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!@>!@E2!%K6>P

G27?!=>MM4FF4>?!K?I26!#6@4A32!,C^,e!>J!"462A@452!,-',h,kh%)m!

• %F@>?47?!<7@4>?73!"2523>GM2?@!037?!>J! @E2!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!K?@43!,-b- (R4@E! @E2!54F4>?!KG! @>!

,-.-e(!!062G762I!8Q!@E2!%F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!4?!,-'Cm!

• +@67@2L4A! %?546>?M2?@73! UMG7A@! #FF2FFM2?@! >J! @E2! %F@>?47?!<7@4>?73! "2523>GM2?@! 037?! >J!

@E2!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!K?@43!,-b-( 2015(!062G762I!8Q U(!So3I621!%F@>?47?!"2523>GM2?@!TK?I(!

• `%F@>?47!,-,-a1!$E2!<7@4>?73!:2J>6M!06>L67MM21!J4?733Q!7GG6>52I!4?!,-'.(!$E2!G6>L67MM2!

,-.-e!@>!82!FK8M4@@2I!J>6!7GG6>573!@>!%F@>?47?!*>526?M2?@!7?I!076347M2?@!4?!,-'.(!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


!

IV+!&9-7)N96!$+96!#T-9-+!?-(9-+SW!M74?!@76L2@F!762!@>! 4MG6>52!@E2!I2523>GM2?@!>J! @E2!6273!2F@7@2!

G6>G26@Q!RE4AE!823>?LF! @>! F@7@2! J6>M!2A>3>L4A731! 2A>?>M4A!7?I! FG7@473!G37??4?L!G>4?@!>J! 542RF(! $>!

2?FK62! @E2!M74?@2?7?A2!>J! 6273! 2F@7@2! 4?! 7! 82F@! G>FF4832!R7Q! A>?F4I264?L! 2A>?>M4A! 2JJ4A42?AQ! 7?I!

E4LE2F@! @2AE?4A73! F@7?I76IF! J>6!M74?@2?7?A2! 4?A3KI4?L! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ(! $E2! F@67@2LQ! J>62F22F! @E2!

4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!2?26LQ!F754?L!@2AE?>3>L42F!7?I!A>?F@6KA@4>?!M7@26473F!@>!82!KF2I! 4?!?2R3Q!8K43@!

>JJ4A2!8K43I4?LF!^:44L4!p1!,--ke(!$E2!F@67@2LQ!E7F!822?!A>MG432I!8Q!@E2!%F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!

#JJ746F! 7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?! 4?! A3>F2! A>>G267@4>?!R4@E! $E2! %F@>?47?!)?4>?!>J! =>P>G267@452!9>KF4?L!

#FF>A47@4>?F!Ê@@G&hhRRR(2_Q3(22hq37?Lr2?e(!

!!!!

IV+!#T-)N79N!&9-7)N96!")YT7NS!5+8+6)'U+N-!A69N!X)(![33]J[3<\!A>?F@4@K@2F!7!F@67@2L4A!87F4F!J>6!I2P

523>G4?L!@E2!E>KF4?L!F2A@>6(!U@!E7F!F2@!>K@!@E2!I462A@4>?F!7?I!G64?A4G32F!J>6!62F>354?L!@E2!4?I454IK73!4FP

FK2F!FG2A4J4A!@>!@E2!E>KF4?L!F2A@>6(!$E2!G64?A4G73!74MF!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!E>KF4?L!762!2?FK64?L!7AA2FF!@>!

FK4@7832!7?I!7JJ>6I7832!E>KF4?L!J>6!@E2!G>GK37@4>?!>J!%F@>?471!7AE4254?L!E4LE!cK734@Q!7?I!FKF@74?7832!

E>KF4?L!F@>A_!7?I!8K43I4?L!I4526F4J42I!62F4I2?@473!7627F!RE4AE!762!I2523>G4?L!J>33>R4?L!@E2!G64?A4G32F!

>J! FKF@74?7832!I2523>GM2?@(!$E2!037?!R7F!G62G762I! 4?! A3>F2!A>>G267@4>?!R4@E! @E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>P

?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F1!@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!+>A473!#JJ746F1!@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!U?@26?73!#JJ746F1!@E2!

S4?4F@6Q!>J!ZKF@4A2!7?I!@E2!=62I4@!7?I!%[G>6@!*K767?@22!TK?I!W62I%[(!$E2!>8H2A@452F!7?I!M27FK62F!>J!

@E2!"2523>GM2?@!037?!F2652I!7F!7!87F4F!J>6!G37??4?L!@E2!F@7@2!8KIL2@!62F>K6A2F!7F!R233!7F!J>6!JK?I4?L!

J6>M!@E2!%)!+@6KA@K673!TK?IF!7?I!@E2!=>E2F4>?!TK?I!IK64?L!@E2!G264>I!>J!,--kP,-'b(!$E2!M>62!4MP

G>6@7?@!4?I454IK73!7A@454@42F!7?I!A>K6F2F!>J!7A@4>?!E752!822?!4I2?@4J42I!J>6!@E2!?276!@26M(!#!I2@7432I!

4MG32M2?@7@4>?!G37?!E7F!822?!I2523>G2I!>?!7?!7??K73!87F4F! 4?! 34?2!R4@E!@E2!F@7@2!8KIL2@!F@67@2LQ!

^%F@>?47?!p1!,--fe(! !+22! J>6!M>62!7@!X73@4A!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!<2@R>6_! J>6! @E2!8K43I4?L!+@>A_! ^X%%<e!

G6>H2A@!R28G7L2!7@&!E@@G&hhRRR(822?P>?34?2(?2@hS4@L342I26PI2FP<2@OR26_F(,.-(-(E@M3qsVr'(!

!

#T-)N79ZT!B7X-V!&9-7)N96!@)UUYN7,9-7)N!YNP+(!-V+!H&!B(9U+O)(R!@)N8+N-7)N!)N!@67U9-+!@V9NS+!

E7F!822?!G62G762I!8Q!@E2!%F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@!7?I!@E2!%F@>?47?!%?546>?M2?@73!:2P

F276AE!=2?@62!4?!A>>G267@4>?!>J!K?4526F4@42F!7?I!62F276AE!4?F@4@K@4>?F!4?!,--D!^%F@>?47?!p1!,--De(!$E2!

A>MMK?4A7@4>?!cK>@2F!>?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4FFK2F!4?!6237@4>?!R4@E!@E2!2?546>?M2?@73!G>33K@4>?!FG2AP

@6KM!7?I!4?!G76@4AK376!@E2!2M4FF4>?F!IK2!@>!2?26LQ!L2?267@4>?!87F2I!>?!M74?!3>A73!2?26LQ!A7664261!>43!

FE732(!!!!

!

IV+!&9-7)N96!$+N+O9:6+!#N+(SW!>,-7)N!A69N!YN-76!W+9(![3[3! 4F!7!A>MG62E2?F452!I2523>GM2?@!G37?!

FKMM764O4?L!@E2!?7@4>?73!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!G>34A42F1! J>62A7F@4?L!J4?73!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!7?I!F2@P

@4?L!>K@!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!@76L2@F!7?I!J>62A7F@!@67H2A@>642F!K?@43!,-,-(!U@!E7F!822?!R>6_2I!>K@!8Q!@E2!

%F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!^%2F@4!p1!,-'-e(!$E2!#A@4>?!037?!4F!>?2!>J!

@E2! JK?I7M2?@73!I>AKM2?@F! J>6! 7AE4254?L! @E2!%K6>G27?!)?4>?!:2?2R7832F!"462A@452! ^,--Dh,fh%=e!

@76L2@F!7?I!L452F!7!A>MG62E2?F452!>K@3>>_!>J!@E2!I2523>GM2?@!>J!@E2!62?2R7832F!F2A@>6(!U@!E7F!822?!

R>6_2I! >K@! 8Q! @E2!S%#=(! $E2! U?@26?7@4>?73! %?26LQ!#L2?AQ!R28PG7L2! ^<7@4>?73(((1! ,-'-e! I2FA6482F!

@E2!%F@>?47NF!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!,-,-!@76L2@F!7F!J>33>RF&!

!

• ;526733!@76L2@&!,.g!>J!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!4?!J4?73!A>?FKMG@4>?m!

• 927@4?L!7?I!=>>34?L&!'fg!>J!I2M7?I!M2@!8Q!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!F>K6A2Fm!

• %32A@64A4@Q&!.g! >J! 232A@64A4@Q! I2M7?I! M2@! 8Q! 232A@64A4@Q! L2?267@2I! J6>M! 62?2R7832! 2?26LQ!

F>K6A2Fm!

• $67?FG>6@&!bg!>J!2?26LQ!I2M7?I!M2@!8Q!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!F>K6A2F(!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


%F@>?47!E7F!4?@6>IKA2I!7!?KM826!>J!M27FK62F!J7A434@7@4?L!7AE4252M2?@!>J!78>52!2?34F@2I!@76L2@F1!@E2Q!

A>K3I!82!34F@2I!7F!@E2!J>33>R4?L!^<7@4>?73(((1!,-'-e&!

!

• T22IP4?!@764JJm!

• =26@4J4A7@2!>J!>64L4?m

• %[A4F2!IK@Q!2[2MG@4>?!J>6!84>JK23Fm

• U?52F@M2?@!FKGG>6@!J>6!:%+!G6>H2A@Fm

• <7@4>?73!%?26LQ!$2AE?>3>LQ!06>L67MM2!j!%$0m

#F!J>6!@E2!FE762!>J!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!4?!J4?73!A>?FKMG@4>?!%F@>?47!E7F!627AE2I!@E2!F2@!@76L2@!8Q!@>P

I7Q1!73F>!@E2!G62F2?@!FE762!>J!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!F>K6A2F!87F2I!232A@64A4@Q!L2?267@4>?!4F!526Q!A3>F2!@>!

,-,-!@76L2@(!!

!

#T-)N79ZT!T7_-V!&9-7)N96!@)UUYN7,9-7)N!YNP+(!-V+!H&!B(9U+O)(R!@)N8+N-7)N!)N!@67U9-+!@V9NS+!

V7F! 822?! G62G762I! 8Q! @E2! %F@>?47?!S4?4F@6Q! >J! @E2! %?546>?M2?@! 7?I! %F@>?47?! %?546>?M2?@73! :2P

F276AE!=2?@62!4?!,-'b!^%F@>?47?!p1!,-'be(!#3F>!@E2!F4[@E!A>MMK?4A7@4>?!cK>@2F!>?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!

4FFK2F!4?!6237@4>?!@>!@E2!L622?E>KF2!L7F2F!2M4FF4>?F!IK2!@>!@E2!2?26LQ!L2?267@4>?!87F2I!>?!M74?!3>P

A73!2?26LQ!A7664261!>43!FE732!^%F@>?47?p1!,-'be(!

!!

#T-)N79ZT!T+,)NP!&9-7)N96!#N+(SW!#XX7,7+N,W!>,-7)N!A69N! .&##>A4!R7F!G62G762I!8Q!S4?4F@6Q!>J!

%A>?>MQ!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!7F!GK6FK7?@!@>!"462A@452!,--Bhb,h%=(!<%%#0!34F@2I!DD!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?P

AQ!M27FK62F!4?!24LE@!G>34AQ!7627F1!4?A3KI4?L!bC!M27FK62F!4?!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6m!F252?!4?!@E2!GK834A!

F2A@>6!^2[A2G@!8K43I4?LFem!',!4?!4?IKF@6Qm!'C!4?!@E2!2?26LQ!F2A@>6m!'k!4?!@67?FG>6@m!J>K6!4?!E>KF2E>3I!

7GG347?A2F!7?I!@E2!F2654A2!F2A@>6m!J>K6!4?!7L64AK3@K62!7?I!F252?!4?!>@E26!7627F(!$E2!376L2F@!62IKA@4>?F!

4?!2?26LQ!KF2!762!2[G2A@2I!@>!A>M2!J6>M!@E2!J>33>R4?L!F2A@>6F!^<%%#01!,-'Ce&!

• 8K43I4?LF&!b(.!0Zm!!

• @67?FG>6@&!,(.!0Z!J6>M!AE7?L4?L!M>@>6!JK23F!@>!84>JK23F(!

• 4?IKF@6Q&!,(,!0Zm!A>MG64F4?L!-(D!0Z!>6I4?76Q!JK23F1!-(k!0Z!232A@64A4@Q!7?I!-(B!0Z!E27@m!!

%?26LQ! %JJ4A42?AQ!/7@AE! A>?IKA@2I! 7! cK734@7@452! 7?I!cK7?@4@7@452! FK652Q!R4@E! @E2! E23G! >J! ?7@4>?73!

2[G26@F!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34A42F!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!4?!%)!S2M826!+@7@2F(!$E4F!A>MG62P

E2?F452! >526542R! A>5262I! 8>@E! @E2! 8K43I4?LF! 7?I! @E2! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>6(! #F! 7! 62FK3@! ''! 2[G26@F! 7?P

FR262I!4?!@E2!4?@26542RF!>?!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?!@E7@!%F@>?47!E7F!M7I2!526Q!L>>I!

G6>L62FF! 4?! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! G>34A42F! F4?A2! @E2! T46F@! <%%#0! 7?I! 4F! 7M>?L! @E2! @E622! 82F@!S2M826!

+@7@2F(!..!g!>J! @E2!2[G26@F!8234252! @E7@! @E2!?7@4>?73!2?26LQ!F754?LF! @76L2@! 4F! 34_23Q! @>!82!7AE4252I(!

0>F4@452!I2523>GM2?@F!62G>6@2I!4?A3KI2!@E2!4?A627F2I!7574378434@Q!>J!JK?IF!^2FG2A4733Q!J6>M!2M4FF4>?!

@67I4?Le1!M>62!8KF4?2FF2F!7A@452!4?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!F2A@>6!^2FG2A4733Q!8K43I4?L!62?>57@4>?!7?I!2?26P

LQ!F2654A2Fe!7?I!M>62!KF2!>J!=90(!9>R25261!@E2!A64@4A73!4FFK2F!4?A3KI2!@E2!37A_!>J!7!A>E262?@!J67M2P

R>6_!J>6!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ1!A7G7A4@Q!4?!@E2!GK834A!F2A@>6F1!84?I4?L!@76L2@F1!J4?7?A4?L!7?I!JK?I4?L!G6>P

L67MM2F!^%LL26!=(!2@!73(1!,-',e(!!

!

`#T-)N79![3[3ab!IV+!&9-7)N96!$+X)(U!A()S(9UU+! 4F!7!62J>6M!G6>L67MM2!@E7@!I2FA6482F!@E2!>8H2AP

@452F!2F@7834FE2I!@>!4MG6>52!A>MG2@4@452?2FF!7?I!7A@454@42F!?22I2I!@>!7AE4252!@E2F2!>8H2A@452F(!T4?73!

2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!4F!@76L2@2I!@>!62M74?!7@!@E2!32523!>J!,-'-!4?!,-,-(!!T>6!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!@E4F!!!

M27?F!@E7@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!MKF@!82!F4L?4J4A7?@3Q!674F2I!4?!G76@4AK376!4?!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6(!$E2!%FP

@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!E7F!M7I2!@7?L4832!G6>L62FF!4?!M22@4?L!@E2!@76L2@F!F2@!F>!J76(!!+@76@4?L!J6>M!,-'b!

M>62! F@64?L2?@! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! 62cK462M2?@F! 2F@7834FE2I! @>! ?2R! 7?I! 62A>?F@6KA@2I! 8K43I4?LF! 8Q!

S%#=(!UMG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!@E2!62cK462M2?@F!>J!%0X"!"462A@452!4F!J>62F22?!4?!@E2!J46F@!>6I26!4?!GK834A!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


8K43I4?LF!@>!627AE!@E2!M7[4MKM!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!@>!I2M>?F@67@2!@E2!2[7MG32(!$E2!62J>6M!G6>P

L67MM2! 4?A3KI2F! @E2! 4MG32M2?@7@4>?! >J! @E2! 4?52F@M2?@! G7A_7L2! J>6! 2?26L2@4A! 62JK684FEM2?@! >J!

7G76@M2?@!E>KF2F1!73F>!@E2!JK23!FR4@AE!FK8F4I42F!J6>M!>43! @>!M>62!2JJ4A42?@!@QG2F!>J! JK23F! 4?!G6457@2!

E>KF2F!7?I!FK8F4IQ!G6>L67MM2!J>6!2?26L2@4A! 62JK684FEM2?@!>J! FM733!G6457@2!E>KF2F! ^%2F@4!,-,-!p1!

,-'.e(!

IV+!#T-)N79N!&9-7)N96!5+8+6)'U+N-!A69N!)X!-V+!#N+(SW!?+,-)(!YN-76![3\3!^%<S#W!,-b-de!R4@E!@E2!

54F4>?!@433!,-.-!4F!>?2!>J!@E2!A2?@673!F@67@2L4A!I>AKM2?@F!RE4AE!J4[!@E2!M74?!G7@ER7QF!>J!I2523>GM2?@!

>J!M7?Q!>@E26!G6>L67MM2F(! ! U@!E7F!822?!7GG6>52I!8Q! @E2!*>526?M2?@!73627IQ1!7?I!?2[@! 4@!R433!82!

7GG6>52I! 8Q! @E2! 076347M2?@1!M>F@! G6>8783Q! 4?! @E2! F2A>?I! E73J! >J! ,-'.(! %<S#W! ,-b-d! I67RF! @E2!

M74?!A>?A2G@!34?2F!>J!2?26LQ!F2A@>6!I2523>GM2?@!KG!@433!,-b-1!8K@!73F>!@E2!54F4>?!J>6!I2523>GM2?@!KG!

@433!,-.-(!$E2!G6>L67MM2!4F!@E2!M>F@!KGI7@2I!I>AKM2?@!I2FA6484?L1!4?!J7A@1!@E2!54F4>?!>J!G>FF4832!I2P

523>GM2?@!G7@EF!>J!733!F2A@>6F!4?A3KI4?L!@E2!8K43I4?LF(!"2@7432I!I2FA64G@4>?!>?!2[4F@4?L!F@>A_!>J!8K43IP

4?LF!4F!L452?!87F2I!>?!RE7@!@E2!JK6@E26!I2523>GM2?@!G7@EF!J>6!2?26LQ!F754?L!762!J>6MK37@2I(!$2AEP

?4A73!2?26LQ!F754?L!G>@2?@473!J>6MF!76>K?I!f-g!^D(b!$/EhQe!>J!G62F2?@!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!>J!8K43IP

4?LF!7?I!4@!A>MG64F2F!6>KLE3Q!'hb!>J!@>@73!J4?73!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!^bbPbC!$/EhQe!4?!%F@>?47!^9>KFP

4?Lp1!,-'.e(!$E2!I2523>GM2?@!G37?!E7F!822?!G62G762I!8Q!@E2!S%#=!R4@E4?!@E2!A3>F2!A>>G267@4>?!>J!

>@E26!M4?4F@642F1!L>526?M2?@73!4?F@4@K@4>?F1!K?4526F4@42F!7?I!62F276AE!4?F@4@K@2F!RE>!@>>_!G76@!4?!@E2!

G62G767@>6Q!F2M4?76F!7?I!8674?F@>6MF!>?!5>3K?@76Q!87F4F(!#3F>1!@E2!RE>32!G62G767@>6Q!G6>A2FF!R7F!

>6L7?4F2I!R28P87F2I!@>!733>R!2[G26@F!7?I!R4I26!GK834A!@>!G76@4A4G7@2! 4?!@E2!FG2A4734F2I!I4FAKFF4>?F!

7?I!G6>G>F2!@E246!A>MM2?@F!7?I!>G4?4>?F!>?!JK6@E26!I2523>GM2?@!>G@4>?F!>J!@E2!2?26LQ!F2A@>6!^%?P

26L47@73LKIp1!,-'.e(!!!!!

#33!?7@4>?73!I2523>GM2?@!G37?F!E752!@>!G7FF!@E2!%?546>?M2?@73!UMG7A@!#FF2FFM2?@(!$EKF!4F!73F>!5734I!

J>6!@E2!78>52M2?@4>?2I!2?26LQ!F2A@>6!I2523>GM2?@!G37?(!!

?-(9-+S7,!#N87()NU+N-96!EU'9,-!>TT+TTU+N-!)X!-V+!#T-)N79N!&9-7)N96!5+8+6)'U+N-!A69N!)X!-V+!#NJ

+(SW!?+,-)(!YN-76![3\3!R7F!G62G762I!8Q!@E2!%F@>?47?!"2523>GM2?@!TK?I(!$E2!37@@26!R7F!73F>!62FG>?P

F4832!@>!>6L7?4O2!@E2!G67A@4A73!R>6_!@>!G62G762!@E2!M7@26473!J>6!@E2!3>?L!@26M!2?26LQ!F2A@>6!I2523>GP

M2?@!G37?(! $E2! 4MG7A@! 7FF2FFM2?@!I273F!R4@E! @E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ! @7F_F! 6237@2I! @>!232A@64A4@Q! 7?I!

E27@!L2?267@4>?!7?I!KF7L2!4?!5764>KF!2A>?>M4A!F2A@>6F(!#M>?L!@E2!M7H>6!@7F_F!K?I26!A>?F4I267@4>?1!

@E2!E27@!L2?267@4>?!2JJ4A42?AQ!J>6!E>KF4?L!F2A@>6!547!A>?@4?K4?L!@E2!FKF@74?7832!M74?@2?7?A2!>J!@E2!

I4F@64A@!E27@4?L!?2@R>6_F1!73F>!@E2!>G@4>?F!7?I!3>?L!@26M!G26FG2A@452F!@>!4?A627F2!@E2!62?2R7832!2?P

26LQ!FE762!4?!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6!R262!7?73QF2I!^%?26L47M7H7?IKF2p1!,-'.e(!

!!

!

?WN-V+T7T!)X!')67,W!'9,R9S+T!!

U?! 8K43I4?LF! F2A@>6! F>M2! 2[7MG32F! A>K3I! 82! 86>KLE@(! $E2! <7@4>?73! 9>KF4?L! I2523>GM2?@! 037?! 4F!

A3>F23Q!34?_2I!@>!@E2!<7@4>?73!:2?2R7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?!7?I!%F@>?47NF!+2A>?I!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JP

J4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?(!$E2!L>526?M2?@73!4?F@4@K@4>?F!A3>F23Q!A>>G267@2!4?!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!F@67@2L42F!

7?I!7A@4>?!G37?F!RE4AE!M74?!34?2F!A>4?A4I2(!

!

I9(S+-!S()Y'T!

$E2!78>52!34F@2I!G6>L67MM2F1!7A@4>?!G37?F1!F@67@2L42F!2@A(!I>!?>@!FG2A4J4A733Q!@76L2@!>?!A26@74?!L6>KG!

7@!?7@4>?731! 62L4>?73!>6! 3>A73! 32523(! $E2Q! @2?I! @>!82! 67@E26!L2?2673! @>R76IF!733! 32523F(! U@! 4F! A>MM>?!

@E7@!?>?2!>J!@E2!>JJ4A473!I>AKM2?@F!FG2A4JQ!@E2!@76L2@!L6>KG1!4?F@27I!@E2Q!4?A3KI2!@E2!L2?2673!G64?A4P

G32F!@>!82!@7_2?!J>6!@E2!87F4F!4?!62L4>?73!>6!3>A73!32523!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!G67A@4A2F(!$E2!,-,-!@76L2@F!4?!

5764>KF!F2A@>6F!762!E7?I32I!7F!?7@4>?R4I2!7?I!762!62LK37@2I!R4@E!L>526?M2?@73!7?I!>@E26!32L4F37@452!

7A@F!7?I!3>A73!L>526?M2?@FN!I2A622F(!!

C)8+(N9N,+!X(9U+O)(R!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


$E2! L>526?7?A2! J67M2R>6_! 4?! %F@>?47! JK?A@4>?F! cK4@2!R233(! $E2!M4?4F@642F! 762! A>>G267@4?L! 4?! @E246!

A>MM>?!4?@262F@!7627F1!@E2Q!A>>6I4?7@2!R4@E!27AE!>@E26!RE2?!R>6_4?L!>K@!F@67@2L42F1!A>MG434?L!I2P

523>GM2?@!G37?F1!7A@4>?!G37?F1!@E2Q1!73F>!A>>G267@2!4?!@E2!GE7F2!>J!G67A@4A73!4MG32M2?@7@4>?(!!

$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!^S%#=e!E>3IF!@E2!>526733!7AA>K?@78434@Q!J>6!2?P

26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34AQ(!$E262!762!@R>!I2G76@M2?@F!62FG>?F4832!J>6!@E2!M>F@!>J!@7F_F!6237@2I!@>!2?26LQ!

2JJ4A42?AQ1!I4F@64A@!E27@4?L!7?I!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!G>34A42F!j!@E2!%?26LQ!"2G76@M2?@1!7?I!@E2!XK43I4?L!

7?I! 9>KF4?L! "2G76@M2?@(! $E2!M4?4F@6Q! R>6_F! A3>F23Q! R4@E! @R>! 623257?@! 2[2AK@452! 7L2?A42F! 4?! @E2!

J423I!>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ1!=62I4@!7?I!%[G>6@!*K767?@22!TK?I!W62I%]!7?I!%U=!^%?546>?M2?@73! U?52F@P

M2?@! =2?@62e(! $E2! J46F@!R>6_4?L!R4@E! @76L2@2I!M27FK62F! 4?! 62F4I2?@473! E>KF4?L! F2A@>6! 7?I! 232A@6>P

M>8434@Q!G6>L67MM21!7?I!@E2!7?>@E26!4MG32M2?@F!@E2!M27FK62F!@76L2@4?L!GK834A!4?J67F@6KA@K62!Ê27@!

7?I!232A@64A4@Q!L2?267@4>?e1!2?26LQ!I4F@648K@4>?!FQF@2MF!7?I!F@622@!34LE@4?L(!X>@E!7L2?A42F!R>6_!R4@E!

@E2!4FFK2F!34?_2I!@>!@E2!G6>M>@4>?!>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!^%?26LQp1!,-'be(!!

$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J! @E2!%?546>?M2?@! 4F! 4?A627F4?L3Q! 4?5>352I! 4?!2?26LQ!G>34AQ! 4@FN! 62FG>?F48434@Q! 4?A3KI2F!

@E2! I2523>GM2?@! >J! L622?! GK834A! G6>AK62M2?@! 6K32F! 7?I! LK4I234?2F! J>6! @E2! GK6AE7F2! >J! 2?26LQP

2JJ4A42?@!L>>IF(!$E2!@R>!M4?4F@642F!_22G!A3>F2!A>>G267@4>?!7?I!A>>6I4?7@4>?!>J!2?26LQ!7?I!2?546>?P

M2?@!G>34AQ!I2523>GM2?@F(!$E2!%?26LQ!7?I!/7@26!:2LK37@>6Q!"454F4>?!>J! @E2!%F@>?47?!=>MG2@4@4>?!

#K@E>64@Q!A76642F!>K@!@E2!G6>M>@4>?!>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!@E6>KLE!2?26LQ!@764JJF(!$E2!%F@>?47?!"2523P

>GM2?@!TK?I!E7F!7!K?4@!R>6_4?L!>?!3>?LP@26M!I2523>GM2?@!4?!@E2!2?26LQ!F2A@>6!^%?26LQ!p1!,-'be(!

!

$E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?1!@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@!7?I!@E2!S4?P

4F@6Q!>J! T4?7?A2! @>L2@E26!R4@E! F@7@2! L>526?2I! J>K?I7@4>?F!%F@>?47?!"2523>GM2?@! TK?I1!=62I4@! 7?I!

%[G>6@!*K767?@22!TK?I!W62I%]!7?I!%?@26G64F2!%F@>?47!R>6_!4?!A3>F2!A>>G267@4>?!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!2?26P

LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!8K43I4?LF(!$E2!4?F@4@K@4>?F!FKGG>6@!MK@K73!7A@454@42F!4?!A7F2!@E246!7627F!>J!4?@262F@!A>P

4?A4I2(!#?!2[7MG32!A>K3I!82!86>KLE@!78>K@!R4I26!I2G3>QM2?@!>J!F>376!2?26LQ! J>62F22?! 4?!<7@4>?73!

"2523>GM2?@!037?!>J!@E2!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!K?@43!,-b-!7?I!73F>1!@E4F!G64>64@Q!4F!J4[2I!4?!@E2!<:%#0(!$E2!62P

FG>?F4832!M4?4F@642F!A>>6I4?7@2!@E246!7A@4>?!G37?F!@>R76IF!7AE4254?L!@E2!@76L2@(!!

!

$E262!762!@R>!%?26LQ!7L2?A42F1!>?2!4?!$7334??!MK?4A4G734@Q!j!$7334??!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ1!7?>@E26!4?!$76@K1!

$76@K! :2L4>?73! %?26LQ! #L2?AQ1! 8>@E! R>6_4?L! R4@E! 8K43I4?LFN! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! 4FFK2F! 7?I! G6>A22I!

R4@E!@674?4?L!7?I!R4I26!FA>G2!4?J>6M7@4>?!I4FF2M4?7@4>?!4?!4MG6>54?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7@!3>A73!32523(!

9>R25261!J>6!@E2!FKAA2FFJK3!R>6_!@E2Q!F@433! 37A_!7GG6>G647@2!?KM826!>J!F@7JJ!7?I!623257?@!J4?7?A4?L(!

$E2!2?26L2@4A!62JK684FEM2?@!E7F!L74?2I!E4LE!G>GK3764@Q!4?!73M>F@!7@!733!3>A73!L>526?M2?@F(!%F@>?47!4F!

37A_4?L! @E2! ?7@4>?73! %?26LQ! #L2?AQ! 7@! G62F2?@1! F@433! 4@! R7F! J>K?I2I! 4?! ,--D! K?I26! L>526?7?A2! >J!

S%#=!7?I!4@!JK?A@4>?2I!J>6!@R>!Q276F!>?3Q(!$E2!M74?!@7F_!>J!@E2!7L2?AQ!R7F!@>!A>?@4?K2!@E2!2?26L2@P

4A!62JK684FEM2?@!R>6_!RE7@!W62I2[!E>KF4?L!I2G76@M2?@!E7F!F@76@2I!2763426(!!

!

1.1.2 Transport Sector

!

$E2!M74?!?7@4>?73!>JJ4A473!I>AKM2?@F!I2FA6484?L!G>34AQ!G7A_7L2F!J>6!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!

F2A@>6!762&!

• <7@4>?73!"2523>GM2?@!037?!J>6!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!@433!,-b-1!R4@E!@E2!54F4>?!@433!,-.-!^@>!82!FK8M4@P

@2I!J>6!7GG6>573!@>!%F@>?47?!*>526?M2?@!7?I!076347M2?@e!^%<S#W!,-b-d1!,-'.em!

• %F@>?47?!$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!037?!,-'Ci,-,-1!7GG6>52I!8Q! @E2!%F@>?47?!076347M2?@!>?!

'D!T286K76Q!,-'C!^$67?FG>6I4(((!,-'Cem!

• <7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?!^<%%#0e1!,-'C(!%F@>?47nF!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!@>!@E2!%K6>P

G27?!=>MM4FF4>?!K?I26!#6@4A32!,C^,e!>J!"462A@452!,-',h,kh%)(!^<%%#01!,-'Ce!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


• $E2! ?7@4>?73! 62J>6M! G6>L67MM2! `%F@>?47! ,-,-a1! 7GG6>52I! 4?! ,-''(! %F@>?47NF! F@67@2LQ! J>6!

7AE4254?L!@E2!`%K6>G2!,-,-a!>8H2A@452F(!^<7@4>?73(((!,-'.e!

!

$E2F2!I>AKM2?@F!762!I2FA6482I!823>R(!

!

IV+!&9-7)N96!#N+(SW!?+,-)(!5+8+6)'U+N-!A69Nc!`%<S#W!,-b-d!%2F@4!2?26L47M7H7?IKF2!762?LK_757!

77F@7?4!,-b-'a(!^%<S#W!,-b-de1!A>MG432I!8Q!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>MQ!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!4F!AK662?@3Q!

4?!@E2!J4?73!I67J@!526F4>?!^'b(-,(,-'.e!@>!82!G62F2?@2I!@>!@E2!076347M2?@(! U@!I2FA6482F!@E2!54F4>?!J>6!

@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!4?!,-.-!7F!J>33>RF&!

!

$E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!2?546>?M2?@73!FKF@74?78434@Q!>J!@67?FG>6@!E7F!4?A627F2I!@E6>KLE!@E2!4?@26P

7A@4>?!82@R22?!5764>KF!M27FK62F1!KG@7_2!>J!2?26LQ!F754?L!@2AE?>3>L42F1!4?A627F2I!KF2!>J!73@26?7@452!

JK23F!7?I!G76@473!M>I73!FE4J@!>J!J624LE@!@67?FG>6@!@>!6743(!

!

$E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ! @76L2@! J>6! @E2! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>6! 4F! F2@! 4?! @E2!%F@>?47?!I(9NT')(-!5+8+6)'U+N-!

A69N! [3<1d[3[3m! `$67?FG>6I4! 762?LK_757! ,-'CP,-,-,a(! ^=>MG432I! 8Q! S4?4F@6Q! >J! %A>?>MQ! 7?I!

=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!7?I!7GG6>52I!8Q!@E2!076347M2?@!>?!'D(,(,-'Ce&!@>!62@74?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6NF!2?P

26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!8Q!@E2!Q276!,-,-!>?!@E2!32523!>J!@E2!Q276!,-',!7?I!@>!A627@2!7!87F4F!J>6!62IKA4?L!

2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!7J@26!@E2!Q276!,-,-(!

!

I9:6+!<!I(9NT')(-!T+,-)(ZT!+N+(SW!,)NTYU'-7)N!-9(S+-T!7N!#T-)N79!!

ENP7,9-)(!e!D+9(!EN7-796!6+8+6!

[3<[!

EN-+(7U!6+8+6!

[3<f!

I9(S+-!6+8+6!

[3[3!

$67?FG>6@!F2A@>6NF!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!

^M4334>?!$Ze!bb! bb! bb!

+>K6A2&!^$67?FG>6I4!762?LK_757!,-'CP,-,-1!,-'Ce!

!

$E2!M27FK62F! @76L2@! 8>@E! FKGG3Q! 7?I! I2M7?IPF4I2!M7?7L2M2?@! 7?I! A>526! 733! @E622! 2JJ4A42?AQ! I4P

M2?F4>?F&!FQF@2M!2JJ4A42?AQ1!@67523!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!52E4A32!2JJ4A42?AQ(!$E2!M27FK62F!7?I!7A@454@42F!J>6!

@76L2@4?L!I2M7?I!7?I!4MG6>54?L!@E2!@67?FG>6@!TWT-+U!+XX7,7+N,W!762&!

P!(+'69,7NS!YNN+,+TT9(W!-(98+6!^M27FK62!'('e&!!

'( #A@454@42F! 6237@2I! @>! FK8F@4@K@4?L! >834L7@>6Q! A>MMK@2F! R433! 82! 4MG32M2?@2I! R4@E4?!

@E2!J67M2R>6_!>J!@E2!*622?!07G26!J>6!#667?L4?L!0K834A!+2654A2F!7?I!@E2!U?J>6M7@4>?!

+>A42@Q!"2523>GM2?@!037?!,-,-!^2P%F@>?47e(!

,( ;GG>6@K?4@42F!J>6!@232R>6_4?L!R433!82!I2523>G2I(!

!

!

P!(+PY,7NS!YNN+,+TT9(W!-(98+6!^M27FK62!'(,e&!!

'( U?F@6KA@4>?F1!LK4I234?2F1!82F@!G67A@4A2F1!2@A(!R433!82!G62G762I!J>6!FG7@473!G37??4?L!7?I!

M>8434@Q!7667?L2M2?@1!>?! @E2! 32523!>J! @E2! F@7@21! 3>A73! L>526?M2?@F!7?I! @E2!G6457@2!

F2A@>6(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

'!E@@G&hhRRR(2?26L47@73LKI(22h4MLt7K@E(GEGh.h.8h%<S#Wt,-b-(t%23?g=bgX.Kt'b(-,(,-'.(GIJ!

,!E@@GF&hhRRR(644L4@27@7H7(22h7_@434F7hb,'-h,,-'hC--'h762?LK_757(GIJ!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


,( <2R!A>K?@Q!G37?F!R433!82!2F@7834FE2I(!

!

S27FK62F!7?I!7A@454@42F!J>6!@76L2@4?L!FKGG3Q!7?I!4MG6>54?L!@E2!-(98+6!+XX7,7+N,W!762&!

!

P!S787NS!'(+X+(+N,+!-)!U)(+!TYT-97N9:6+!U+9NT!)X!-(9NT')(-!^M27FK62!'(be&!

'( V>A73!L>526?M2?@F!R433!82!FKGG>6@2I!J6>M!@E2!%)!F@6KA@K673!74I!4?!G62G764?L!7?I!4MP

G32M2?@4?L!FKF@74?7832!K687?!M>8434@Q!G6>H2A@F(!

,( $E46I! F2A@>6! G6>H2A@F!R433! 82! FKGG>6@2I1! >642?@2I! @>R76IF! 4MG32M2?@4?L! @E2!G64?A4P

G32F!>J!M>8434@Q!7667?L2M2?@(!

!

P!P+8+6)'7NS!7N-+667S+N-!-(9NT')(-!TWT-+UT!^M27FK62!'(Ce&!

'( $E2! @67?FG>6@! FQF@2MNF! 6273P@4M2! I7@7! A>332A@4>?! 4?J67F@6KA@K62! R433! 82! I2523>G2I1!

4?A3(!R4@E4?!@E2!J67M2R>6_!>J!>@E26!4?J67F@6KA@K62!4?52F@M2?@F!^2(L(!J>6!F2?F>6P87F2I!

L7@E264?L!7?I!J>6R76I4?L!>J!6>7I!4?J>6M7@4>?e(!

,( "2523>GM2?@!G6>H2A@F!>6!G43>@!G6>H2A@F!J>6!4??>57@452!F>3K@4>?F!>6!F>3K@4>?F!7I7G@2I!

@>!%F@>?47NF!?22IF!R433!82!4?4@47@2I!7?I!4MG32M2?@2I!4?!A>P>G267@4>?!R4@E!@E2!G6457@2!

F2A@>6!7?I!62F276AE26F&!

P! 4?!@E2!J423I!>J!F>3K@4>?F! J>6!G6>A2FF4?L!7?I!7?73QF4F!>J! @E2!@67?FG>6@!FQF@2MNF!I7@7!

^4?A3(! 6273P@4M2! 7?I! G6252?@452! 7?73QF4Fe1! 2?7834?L! @>! 2(L(! 4?A627F2! 6>7I! F7J2@Q! 7?I!

M7?7L2!@67JJ4A!3>7IFm!

P!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!F>3K@4>?F!J>6!FE764?L!I7@7!4?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!FQF@2M!^4?A3(!G6>@>@QG2!F26P

54A2Fe1!7?I!@E2!623257?@!F@7?I76IF!>6!4?@26>G2678434@Q!6K32F!^2(L(!J>6!I7@7!2[AE7?L2!82P

@R22?!6>7I!KF26Fem!

P!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!H>4?@!F>3K@4>?F!J>6!3>L4F@4AF!G37??4?L!7?I!M7?7L2M2?@(!

b( +KGG>6@!R433!82!G6>54I2I!J>6!I2523>GM2?@!>J!4?@2L67@2I!@67523!G37??4?L!82@R22?!576P

4>KF! @67?FG>6@! M>I2F! 7?Ih>6! 547! 7II4@4>?73! F2654A2F! ^2(L(! @4A_2@! F732Fe1! 7?I! >@E26!

@67?FG>6@!4?J>6M7@4>?!F2654A2F1!4?A3(!2FG2A4733Q!J>6!E7?IE23I!I254A2F(!

C( :2LK37@4>?!J7A434@7@4?L!@E2!F7J2!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!F23JPI6454?Lh7K@>?>M>KF!52E4A32F1!

@E2!623257?@!4?@26>G2678434@Q!7?I!F7J2@Q!F@7?I76IF1!7?I!@E2!FKG2654F4>?!G64?A4G32F!R433!

82!I2523>G2I(!

!

P!P+8+6)'7NS!N9-7)NO7P+!'Y:67,!-(9NT')(-!,)NN+,-7)NT!^M27FK62!.('e&!

'( U?!>6I26!@>!4?A627F2!@E2!A>MG2@4@452?2FF!>J!3>?LPI4F@7?A2!8KF!@67JJ4A1!@E2!62A>?F@6KA@P

4?L!7?I!A>?F@6KA@4?L!>J!8KF!F@7@4>?F!7?I!8KF!F@>GF!4?!JK?A@4>?73!7627!A2?@62F!R433!A>?P

@4?K21!7F!R433!A>??2A@4?L!@E2M!@>!@E2!A2?@62FN!4MG>6@7?@!I2F@4?7@4>?F(!

,( U?!>6I26!@>!2?FK62!@E2!cK734@Q!>J!6743R7Q!@67JJ4A1!4?52F@M2?@F!4?@>!4?J67F@6KA@K62!M>IP

26?4F7@4>?!R433!A>?@4?K21!F>!7F!@>!2?FK62!@E2!@>G!FG22I!>J!',-!_MhE!7?I1!4J!?>@!2?@743P

4?L!I4FG6>G>6@4>?733Q!376L2!A>F@F1!'C-!_MhE(!

b( U?!>6I26! @>!2?FK62!F2654A2!cK734@Q1! 4?52F@M2?@F! 4?4@47@2I! 4?! @E2!G264>I!>J!,--BP,-'b!

J>6! FE4GF! 7?I! E768>K6F! ?2A2FF76Q! J>6! 62@74?4?L! @E2! A>??2A@4>?F!R433! 82! A>MG32@2I(!

$E4F! 4?A3KI2F!62A>?F@6KA@4>?!>J! @E2!E768>K6F!?2A2FF76Q! J>6! @E2!A>??2A@4>?!82@R22?!

+7762M77!7?I!944KM771!7?I!7AcK4F4@4>?!>J!7!?2R!FE4G!J>6!>G267@4?L!@E2!34?2(!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


P!P+8+6)'7NS!(+S7)N96!'Y:67,!-(9NT')(-!,)NN+,-7)NT!^M27FK62!.(,e&!

'( V4?2!?2@R>6_F!R433!82!M>I26?4F2I(!

,( $2?I264?L!I>AKM2?@F!R433!82!7IHKF@2I!J>6!@E2!GK6G>F2!>J!JK3J4334?L!@E2!62cK462M2?@F!

F2@!R4@E!@E2!F2654A2!F@7?I76I(!

b( $E2!7667?L2M2?@!>J!62L4>?73!GK834A!@67?FG>6@!R433!82!@7_2?!J6>M!@E2!A>K?@Q!32523!@>!

@E2!32523!>J!376L26!62L4>?F!4?A3KI4?L!F252673!A>K?@42F(!

C( U?!62L4>?F!R4@E!3>R!G>GK37@4>?!I2?F4@Q1!J32[4832!GK834A!@67?FG>6@!F>3K@4>?F!R433!82!4MP

G32M2?@2I1!2(L(!>?PI2M7?I!8KF2F1!F>A473!@67?FG>6@!>6!F>A473!@7[4F(!

!

P!P+8+6)'7NS!6),96!'Y:67,!-(9NT')(-!,)NN+,-7)NT!^M27FK62!.(be&!

'( 0K834A!@67?FG>6@!G6>H2A@F!4?!JK?A@4>?73!7627!A2?@62F!R433!82!FKGG>6@2I!J6>M!%)!F@6KAP

@K673!74I(!

,( #AcK4F4@4>?! >J! 2?546>?M2?@PJ642?I3Q! 6>334?L! F@>A_! 4?! JK?A@4>?73! 7627! A2?@62F! R433! 82!

FKGG>6@2I!4?!@E2!2[@2?@!@E7@!@E2!2?546>?M2?@PJ642?I3Q!6>334?L!F@>A_!A>F@F!M>62!@E7?!

6>334?L!F@>A_!R4@E!I42F23!2?L4?2F(!

b( "4F@648K@4>?!>J!@7F_F!82@R22?!@E2!F@7@2!7?I!3>A73!L>526?M2?@F!KG>?!7667?L4?L!GK834A!

@67?FG>6@1!7?I!@E2!6237@2I!JK?I4?L!R433!82!7?73QF2I!7?I!G6>G>F73F!J>6!AE7?L2F!R433!82!

M7I2!4J!?2A2FF76Q(!

!

P!7N-+S(9-7NS!9NP!7U'()87NS!9,,+TT!-)!'Y:67,!-(9NT')(-!^M27FK62!.(Ce&!!

'( $E2!@4A_2@!FQF@2MF!>J!GK834A!@67?FG>6@!?2@R>6_F!>J!376L26!A4@42F!7?I!@E246!FK66>K?I4?L!

62L4>?F!^4?A3(!6743R7Q!@67JJ4Ae!R433!82!4?@2L67@2I(!$4A_2@!F732F!FQF@2MF!R433!82!4?@2L67@2I!

>?!7!A>K?@6QPR4I2!32523(!

,( #!FKGG>6@!M27FK62!R433!82!2F@7834FE2I! J>6! 3>A73!L>526?M2?@F1! @>!2?FK62! @E7@!GK834A!

@67?FG>6@! F@>GF! @E7@! F2652! A>K?@6QPR4I2! 34?2F!R433! 82! 82@@26! A>??2A@2I! @>! @E2! 3>A73!

A>MMK@4?L!7?I!M>F@!4MG>6@7?@!I2F@4?7@4>?F(!

b( :>334?L! F@>A_!R433! 82! A>?F4F@2?@3Q! 62G37A2I!R4@E!M>I23F! FK4@7832! J>6! F2654?L! G2>G32!

R4@E!M>52M2?@!I4F78434@42F(!

C( 0K834A! @67?FG>6@NF! 4?J>6M7@4>?! 7574378434@Q! R433! 82! 4MG6>52I1! 4MG32M2?@4?L! 4?J>6P

M7@4>?!FQF@2MF!A>?J>6M4?L!@>!@E2!?22IF!>J!G2>G32!R4@E!E2764?L!7?I!54F4>?!I4F78434P

@42F(!

!

S27FK62F!7?I!7A@454@42F!J>6!4MG6>54?L!@E2!8+V7,6+!+XX7,7+N,W!762&!

!

P!'()U)-7NS!-V+!YT+!)X!(+N+O9:6+!XY+6!T)Y(,+T!7N!()9P!-(9NT')(-!^M27FK62!C('em!!

$E2!7A@454@42F!@>!4MG32M2?@!R4@E!@E4F!M27FK62!762!FG2A4J42I!4?!@E2!%F@>?47?!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!"2523P

>GM2?@!037?!K?@43!,-b-&!

'( 06>54I4?L!7!M>@457@4?L!2A>?>M4A! J67M2R>6_! J>6!2?@62G62?2K6F!7?I! 4?52F@>6F! 4?! @E2!

G6>IKA@4>?!7?I!A>?FKMG@4>?!>J!84>JK23F!7?I!>@E26!73@26?7@452!JK23F(!

,( %?FK64?L!3>?LP@26M!4?52F@M2?@!F2AK64@Q!R4@E!@E2!F@7@2!@7[!G>34AQ!

b( #?73QF4?L!@E2!KF2!>J!73@26?7@452!JK23F!4?!GK834A!F2A@>6!7?I!@7_4?L!@E2M!4?@>!KF2!>?!F>P

A4>P2A>?>M4A!L6>K?IF(!

C( :2F276AE!7?I!I2523>GM2?@!7A@454@42F(!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


!

P!7U'()87NS!,9(!X6++-!+,)N)UW!^M27FK62!C(,em!!

$E2!7A@454@42F!@>!82!4MG32M2?@2I!R4@E!@E2!M27FK62&!!

'( #!FQF@2M!>J!2?26LQ!37823F!J>6!52E4A32F!R433!82!2F@7834FE2I!7?I!7R762?2FFP674F4?L!A7MP

G74L?F!R433!82!A>?IKA@2I(!

,( %?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!62cK462M2?@F!R433!82!G62FA6482I!J>6!GK834A!G6>AK62M2?@!A>?I4@4>?F!

KG>?!7AcK4F4@4>?!>J!52E4A32F!J>6!@E2!GK834A!F2A@>6NF!?22IF(!

!

#T-)N79ZT!T+,)NP!&9-7)N96!#N+(SW!#XX7,7+N,W!>,-7)N!A69N!.&##>A4\!R7F!G62G762I!8Q!S4?4F@6Q!>J!

%A>?>MQ!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!7F!GK6FK7?@!@>!"462A@452!,--Bhb,h%=(!#AA>6I4?L!@>!@E2!&##>A!.[3<141!

@E2!2F@4M7@2I!J4?73!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?! 4?!,-,-! 4?! @67?FG>6@!F2A@>6! 4F!bf(C!0Z(!$E2!<%%#0!2[A3KI2F!

@E2! J4?73!2?26LQ!KF2! 4?! @E2! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>6! J6>M!@E2!A73AK37@4>?!>J!>526733!2?26LQ!F754?LF! ^R4@E>K@!

JK6@E26!2[G37?7@4>?e(!$E2!>526733!7M>K?@!>J!2?26LQ!F754?LF!62G62F2?@F!7!@>@73!>J!DCBf!*/E!^bC0Ze!4?!

%F@>?47!IK64?L!@E2!G264>I!J6>M!'!Z7?K76Q!,-'C!@>!b'!"2A2M826!,-,-(!*7GF!4?!,-,-!J>62A7F@F!7?I!@E2!

J7A@! @E7@! @67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!F754?L!G>@2?@473! 4F!2[A3KI2I! J6>M!@E2!>526733!2?26LQ!F754?LF!A73AK37@4>?F!

FE>RF!@E7@!@E2!37@2F@!<%%#0!62G>6@!4F!?>@!4?!34?2!R4@E!@E2!$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!037?(!!

!

IV+!N9-7)N96!(+X)(U!'()S(9UU+!`#T-)N79![3[3a1! 1!G62G762I!8Q!%F@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!I2FA6482F!@E2!

>8H2A@452F!J>6!,-'.!7?I!,-,-!2F@7834FE2I!@>!4MG6>52!A>MG2@4@452?2FF(!$E2!>8H2A@452!4F!F2@!@>!62@74?!

@E2! J4?73! 2?26LQ! A>?FKMG@4>?!>?! @E2! 32523! >J! @E2! Q276! ,-'-! ^7GG6>[(! ,f'f! _@>2e! 4(2(! 62IKA4?L! J4?73!

A>?FKMG@4>?!>J! 2?26LQ!8Q! 7GG6>[(! ''g! A>MG762I! @>! @E2! 32523! J>62A7F@! J>6! ,-,-(! !S74?@74?4?L! @E2!

32523!>J!J4?73!A>?FKMG@4>?!7@!@E2!32523!>J!,-'-!M27?F!@E7@!2?26LQ!F754?L!MKF@!82!4?A627F2I!4?!?2763Q!

733!F2A@>6F1!4?!G76@4AK376!4?!@E2!E>KF2E>3I1!4?IKF@64731!@67?FG>6@!7?I!GK834A!F2A@>6F(!#A@4>?F!6237@2I!@>!

@67?FG>6@!762!4?!34?2!R4@E!@E2!$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!037?!I2FA6482I!78>52(!

!

I9(S+-!S()Y'T!

$E2! $67?FG>6@! "2523>GM2?@! 037?! ,-'Cj,-,-! I>2F! ?>@! FG2A4JQ! @E2! @76L2@! L6>KGF(! S>F@! >J! @E2!

M27FK62F!762!@76L2@2I!@>!@E2!?7@4>?73!7?I!62L4>?73!32523!^7F!62L4>?73!32523!4?!%F@>?47!62G62F2?@F!F@7@2!

>?!@E2!A>K?@Q!32523e1!@67?FG>6@!4?IKF@6Q1!@67?FG>6@!KF26F!7?I!3>A73!MK?4A4G734@42F(!

!

C)8+(N9N,+!X(9U+O)(R!

$E2!$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!037?!I2FA6482F!@E2!I2523>GM2?@!G37?NF!>526733!4MG32M2?@7@4>?1!M>?4@>6P

4?L1!A>F@!7?I!4MG32M2?@26F1!R4@E>K@!FG2A4J4A733Q!62J2664?L!@>!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ(!$E2!M74?!62FG>?F4832!

8>I42F!762!@E2!4?F@4@K@4>?F!^:>7I!#IM4?4F@67@4>?e.!7?I!F@7@2!2?@26G64F2F!4?!@E2!7627!>J!L>526?7?A2!>J!

@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?FB(!067A@4A733Q!733!>@E26!M4?4F@642F1!8K@!G64M7643Q!

@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@k!7?I!@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J! U?@26?73!#JJ746F

f! ^62FG>?F4832!J>6!G37??4?L!7?I!

62L4>?73!G>34AQ1!0>34A2!7?I!X>6I26!*K76I!X>76Ie!762!4?5>352I!4?!A26@74?!M7@@26F!>J!4MG32M2?@4?L!7AP

@454@42F!7?I!7GG3Q4?L!FKGG>6@!M27FK62F(!U?!7II4@4>?1!F@7@2!L>526?2I!J>K?I7@4>?F!34_2!%F@>?47?!"2523P

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

b!E@@GF&hh2A(2K6>G7(2Kh2?26LQhF4@2Fh2?26hJ432FhI>AKM2?@Fh,-'Ct?227Gt2?t2F@>?47(GIJ!

CE@@GF&hh644L4_7?@F2324(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432Fh644L4_7?@F2324hF@67@22L478K6>>h22F@4,-,-h22F@4,-,-t@2L25KF_757t'C(-.(,-'.(G

IJ!.!E@@G&hhRRR(M?@(22!

B!E@@G&hhRRR(M_M(22!

k!E@@G&hhRRR(2?546(22!

f!E@@G&hhRRR(F4F2M4?4F@2264KM(22!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


>GM2?@!TK?ID!^G76@3Q!J4334?L!@E2!@7F_F!>J!?7@4>?73!=34M7@2!7?I!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ!@E7@!2[4F@2I!,--DP,-''e1!

W62I%]'-!7?I!%?@26G64F2!%F@>?47

''!E752!7!6>32!4?!G6>M>@4?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7A@454@42F!7?I!FKGG>6@4?L!

F@76@PKGF!4?!%F@>?471!3>A73!L>526?M2?@F1!G64M7643Q!376L26!A4@42F1!E752!7?!4MG>6@7?@!6>32(!

$E262!762!@R>!3>A73h62L4>?73!32523!2?26LQ!7L2?A42F!4?!%F@>?47!j!$7334??!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ',!7?I!$76@K!:2P

L4>?!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ'b(! $E2F2!7L2?A42F!E752!7?!7A@452! 6>32! 4?! A7G7A4@Q!8K43I4?L1!?2@R>6_4?L!7?I!I4FP

F2M4?7@4>?!7A@454@42F(!

S>F@!>J! @E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!M27FK62F!7?I! J7A434@7@4?L! J>K?I7@4>?Fh7L2?A42F!762!?>@!A>5262I!R4@E!

3>?LP@26M! J4?7?A2F!7?I!762!E4LE3Q!I2G2?I2?@!>?!%)! JK?IF1!*622?! U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!?2L>@47@4>?F!

7?I!G6>H2A@P87F2I!JK?I4?L!4?!L2?2673(!

!

1.2 National Programmes and Initiatives

1.2.1 Green Investment Scheme implementation in building sector

!!

%F@>?47! 4F!KF4?L!@R>!J32[4832!M2AE7?4FMF!>J!)<!T===!WQ>@>!06>@>A>3&!%)!%M4FF4>?F!$67I4?L!+AE2M2!

^%)!%$+e!7?I!Z>4?@!UMG32M2?@7@4>?!^ZUe(!%F@>?47!E7F!@E2!64LE@!@>!>JJ26!K?KF2I!2M4FF4>?!cK>@7!J>6!F732!

4?@26?7@4>?733Q(! %F@>?47!E7F!E7I! F4L?4J4A7?@!5>3KM2F!>J!2[A2FF!#FF4L?2I!#M>K?@!)?4@F! ^##)e1!RE4AE!

62G62F2?@!A768>?!A62I4@F!@>!82!F>3I(!U@!L74?2I!@E2!2[A2FF!K?4@F!@E7?_F!@>!@E2!@E>6>KLE!627667?L2M2?@!

>J! @E2! 2A>?>MQ! RE2?! M>I26?! @2AE?>3>LQ! 7?I! 73@26?7@452! R7QF! >J! G6>IKA4?L! 2?26LQ! R262! 4?@6>P

IKA2I1!M>62!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!F>K6A2F!R262!@7_2?!4?@>!KF21!7?I!F754?L!M27FK62F!R262!4?@6>IKA2I!4?!

2?26LQ! G6>IKA@4>?(! $E4F! J4?7?A4?L!M27FK62!R7F! 7II2I! @>! %?546>?M2?@73! U?52F@M2?@! =2?@62nF! ^%U=e!

G>6@J>34>!7?I!4F!@4@32I!@E2!*622?!U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!^*U+e!GK6FK7?@!@>!RE4AE!@E2!6252?K2!4F!I462A@2I!

@>!4?52F@M2?@F!2?FK64?L!7!I2A627F2!4?!=;u!2M4FF4>?F!7F!7L622I!R4@E!@E2!8KQ26!>J!@E2!cK>@71!J>6!2[P

7MG32!2?FK64?L!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!GK834A!8K43I4?LF!>6!J4?7?A2!@E2!232A@6>PM>8434@Q!G6>L67MM2!4?!

@67?FG>6@! F2A@>6(! $E4F! 4F1! 4?! J7A@! @E2! J4?7?A4?L! 4?F@6KM2?@! L454?L! 2[A2332?@! >G@4>?! J>6! 276M76_2I! 4?P

52F@M2?@F!J>6!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!R4I26!I2G3>QM2?@(!!

%F@>?47!F@76@2I!F2334?L!##)F!4?!,--D1!K?I26!@E2!*U+!7?I!E7F!276M76_2I!@E2!G6>A22IF!J>6!G6>H2A@F!@E7@!

J7A434@7@2!2M4FF4>?F!62IKA@4>?F(!%[7MG32F!4?A3KI2!=90!4?F@7337@4>?F1!4MG6>54?L!"9!?2@R>6_F1!62@6>J4@P

@4?L!8>4326!E>KF2F1!4MG6>54?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?!8K43I4?LF!7?I!4?IKF@6Q1!R4?I!J76MF!7?I!4?@6>IKA4?L!

M>62!2JJ4A42?@!8KF2F!7?I!@67MF!4?!A4@Q!@67JJ4A1!7?I!232A@64A!52E4A32F(!U?!@E2!J67M2!>J!@E2!4?F@6KM2?@!@E2!

7627F!>J!J4?7?A4?L!R433!82!I2A4I2I!8Q!@E2!8KQ26F(!!

IW'+! )X! ')67,W! 7NT-(YU+N-/! T4?7?A473! 4?F@6KM2?@! 7F! 4@! G6>54I2F! J4?7?A473! FKGG>6@! @>! I4F@64A@! E27@4?L!

?2@R>6_F!FKGG3Q4?L!8>@E!GK834A!7?I!G6457@2!F2A@>6!R4@E!M>62!2JJ4A42?@3Q!7?I!E2?A2!AE27G26!E27@(!U@!

E7F!L74?2I!E4LE!G>GK3764@Q!7?I!FE>R2I!KG!526Q!L>>I!62FK3@! 4?!I2A627F2I!E27@!A>?FKMG@4>?(!U?F@6KP

M2?@!4F!73F>1!2JJ4A42?@3Q!KF2I!J>6!2?26L2@4A!62JK684FEM2?@!G6>H2A@F!4?!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6(!!

$E2!J46F@!L67?@F!AE7??2332I!@E6>KLE!%U=!R262!J>6!@E2!62?>57@4>?!>J!@E2!I4F@64A@!E27@4?L!?2@R>6_F1!62?P

>57@4>?!>J!A>M84?2I!E27@!7?I!G>R26!L2?267@4>?!G37?@F!7?I!M>62!2?546>?M2?@733QPFKF@74?7832!8>4326!

E>KF2F1!F22!J>6!M>62!7@&! Ê@@G&hhRRR(_4_(22h2@h2?26L22@4_7hE7F@4P@2E@KIe(!+@4331! @E2!M>F@!F4L?4J4A7?@!

J4?7?A4?L!E7F!822?! AE7??2332I! @>!2?26L2@4A! 62JK684FEM2?@!>J! GK834A! 8K43I4?LF1! 73F>!232A@6>PM>8434@Q!

G6>L67MM2(!U?!,-'-P,-'b!@E2!:44L4!W4??4F5767!#+!^:W#+e!E7F!2378>67@2I!@>!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!@E2!2?26P

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D!E@@G&hhRRR(762?LKJ>?I(22!

'-!E@@G&hhRRR(_62I2[(22!

''!E@@G&hhRRR(27F(22!

',!E@@G&hh!RRR(@7334??(22h2F@h2?26L477L2?@KK6!

'b!E@@G&hh!@627(22!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


L2@4A!62JK684FEM2?@!I462A@2I!@>!4?A627F4?L!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!.Cb!GK834A!8K43I4?LF!87F2I!>?!@E2!

#FF4L?2I!#M>K?@!)?4@F!@67I2!4?!@>@73!5>3KM2!>J!%):!'B.1Bk!M4334>?!Ê@@G&hhRRR(6_7F(22hA>,e(!

!

I9:6+![!#T-)N79ZT!C(++N!EN8+T-U+N-!?,V+U+!I(9NT9,-7)NT![3<3J<[!

A()S(9UU+! %:*+,-78+T! >,-787-7+T! I(9NT9,J

-7)N!-7U+!

G7N7T-(W!7N!

,V9(S+b!!

EU'6+U+N-7NS!

:)PW!

@)N-(9,-!

'9(-N+(!

I(9NT9,J

-7)N!

9U)YN-!

%F@7834FEM2?@!

>J!62?2R7832!

2?26LQ!87F2I!

A>M84?2I!

E27@!7?I!

G>R26!G37?@F1!

8>4326!E>KF2!

62A>?F@6KAP

@4>?1!F754?L!

2?26LQ!4?!I4FP

@64A@!E27@4?L!

?2@R>6_F!!!!!

^C'!G6>H2A@Fe!

UMG6>52!@E2!

G6>A2FF!2JJ4P

A42?AQ!@>!

L2?267@2!4?!

A>L2?267P

@4>?!@E2!

232A@64A4@Q!@>!

82!F>3I!@>!

L64I1!7?I!

E27@!J>6!

FKGG3Q4?L!

8K43I4?LF(!

"2A627F2!

=;,!2M4FP

F4>?F!J6>M!

JK23!8K6?P

4?L(!

TK23!

FR4@AE!

J6>M!J>FF43!

@>!84>P

M7FF!2[P

A3KI4?L!

@E2!=;,!

2M4FF4>?F!

4?@>!746(!

=E7?L2!>J!

@2AE?>3>P

LQ!>J!JK23!

8K6?4?L!

,-'-! S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!

%?546>?M2?@1!

%?546>?M2?@73!

U?52F@M2?@!=2?P

@621!%U=!

#KF@647!!

^,!A>?P

@67A@Fe!

,(D!S!

##)F!

%F@7834FEM2?@!

>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4P

A42?@!F@622@!

34LE@4?L!FQFP

@2MF!^k!A4@P

42Fe1!+754?L!

2?26LQ!4?!I4FP

@64A@!E27@4?L!

?2@R>6_F!7?I!

8>4326!E>KF2!

62A>?F@6KAP

@4>?!^,,!G6>P

H2A@Fe!

%?26LQ!F75P

4?L!4?!FKGP

G3Q4?L!E27@!

@>!7G76@P

M2?@!E>KFP

2F!

! ,-',! S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>P

?>M4A!#JJ746F!

7?I!=>MMK?4P

A7@4>?F1!S4?4F@6Q!

>J!%?546>?M2?@1!

%?546>?M2?@73!

U?52F@M2?@!=2?P

@621!%U=!!

#KF@647! '-1D!S!

##)F!

+>K6A2&!%U=1!E@@G&hhRRR(_4_(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432FhF@>642Fh:U+h77Kt@67?F7A@4>?Ft,-'-P',t2?Lt',(GIJ!

^-k(-f(,-'.e(!

%:*+,-78+T;! !U?!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!@E2!M74?!4I27!>J!@E2!G>34AQ!4?F@6KM2?@!4F!@>!L452!FK8F4I42F!@>!2?26LQ!

2JJ4A42?AQ!G6>H2A@F(!$E4F!G>34AQ! 4?F@6KM2?@!A>?A26?F! @E2!RE>32!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!7@!?7@4>?731! 62L4>?73!

7?I! 3>A73! 32523F! 4?A3KI4?L! 2?26LQ! FKGG3Q! F4I2! ^62?2R7832! 2?26LQ! 87F2I! A>M84?2I! E27@! 7?I! G>R26!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


G37?@F1!"9!?2@R>6_Fe!7?I!I2M7?I!F4I2! ^MK3@4G32!7G76@M2?@!E>KF2F1!>JJ4A2!8K43I4?LFe(! U@! 4F!74M2I!@>!

4MG6>52M2?@!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?!8>@E1!GK834A!7?I!G6457@2!F2A@>6F(!!#@!G62F2?@!@E2!4?F@6KM2?@!4F!

A>?@4?K>KF3Q!KF2I!7?I!?2R!G6>AK62M2?@F1!4?A3KI4?L!73F>!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!GK834A!8K43I4?LF1!762!

>G2?2I1!F22!J>6!M>62!7@!:W#+!E>M2G7L2!^06>AK62M2?@F1!,-'.e(!!

!

I9(S+-!S()Y'T;!$E2!G>34AQ!4?F@6KM2?@!A>?A26?F!@E2!RE>32!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>61!GK834A!7?I!G6457@21!E>KF2P

E>3IF!7?I!4?IKF@6473!8K43I4?LF(!

$Y6+T!9NP!7NX6Y+N,7NS!U+,V9N7TUT;!$E2!6K32F!J>6!@E2!F732!>J!##)!F@7@2!@E7@!733!@E2!M>?2Q!J6>M!@E2!

@67I4?L!MKF@!82!AE7??2332I!@>!2?546>?M2?@733Q!J642?I3Q!G6>H2A@F!@E7@!3>R26!@E2!2M4FF4>?!>J!=;,!7?I!

>@E26! L622?E>KF2! L7F2F(! /E4AE! 7627F! R433! 82! J4?7?A2I! R433! 82! I2A4I2I! 8Q! @E2! cK>@7! 8KQ26F(! $E2!

*622?!U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!4F!62LK37@2I!8Q!@E2!#M842?@!#46!06>@2A@4>?!#A@!^Yv34FwEK!p1!,--Ce(!

!

EU'6+U+N-9-7)N!N+-O)(R;!$E2!%F@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!A>G42I!7!FKAA2FFJK3!*26M7?!WJ/!FAE2M2!RE262!

J4?7?A2!J6>M!I4JJ262?@!JK?IF!R7F!>JJ262I!@>!G6457@2!87?_F!@>!M7_2!3>7?F!@>!E>M2P>R?26!7FF>A47@4>?F(!

%FF2?@473!232M2?@F!R262! 4?!G37A2(!T>6! 4?F@7?A21!2?26LQ!7KI4@F!R262!62cK462I!7F!G76@!>J!L67?@4?L!@E2!

3>7?F(!$E4F!F@76@2I! 4?!,--D!8K@!2?I2I! 4?!FKMM26!,-',!RE2?!@E2!FAE2M2!67?!>K@!>J! JK?IF(! U?@262F@!

67@2F!762!J4[2I!J>6!@2?!Q276F!7@!32FF!@E7?!A>MM26A473!67@2F!^C(Cg!M7[4MKM!R4@E!3>7?!75267L2!4?@262F@!

7@!Cge(!*67?@F!762!'.g!@>!b.g!>J!@E2!A>F@!>J!@E2!G6>H2A@1!FA732I!@>!@E2!2JJ>6@1!7?I!b.g!L67?@!J>6!A>MP

G62E2?F452!62@6>J4@F1!4?A3KI4?L!E27@1!52?@437@4>?!7?I!746PA>?I4@4>?4?L!KGL67I2F!7?I!@64G32!L37O4?L(!^%?P

26LQ!(((1!,-'be(!

!

1.2.2 Green Investment Scheme in transport sector $

C+N+(96! 7NX)(U9-7)N;!$E2!*622?! U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!^*U+e!E7F!822?!7! J4?7?A4?L!M2AE7?4FM!J>6! 4MP

G32M2?@4?L!G6>H2A@F!74M2I!7@!4MG6>54?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ(!)?I26!@E2!*U+1!6252?K2F!L74?2I!J6>M!@E2!

@67I4?L!>J!%F@>?47nF!=;,!cK>@7F1!7F!G6>54I2I!8Q!#6@4A32!'k!>J!@E2!WQx@>!06>@>A>31!762!AE7??2332I!4?@>!

2?546>?M2?@733Q! F>K?I!G6>H2A@F! 7?I!G6>L67MM2F! @E7@! 3>R26! @E2!2M4FF4>?!>J!=;,! 7?I!>@E26!L622?P

E>KF2!L7F2F(!$E2!*U+!4F!62LK37@2I!8Q!@E2!#M842?@!#46!06>@2A@4>?!#A@(!!

!

%F@>?47!E7I!2[A2FF!2M4FF4>?F!>J!78>K@!D'(.!M4334>?!@>??2F!>J!=;,!2cK45732?@1!>6!'f(b!M4334>?!@>??2F!

>J! =;,! 2cK45732?@! G26! Q276(!,'! I273F! E752! 822?! A>?A3KI2I! ,-'-P,-',! 4?! >6I26! @>! F233! k,(B!M4334>?!

##)F!^#FF4L?2I!#M>K?@!)?4@F1!4(2(!=;,!2M4FF4>?!K?4@Fe J>6!%):!bff!M4334>?(!$E2!I273F!E752!822?!A>?P

A3KI2I!R4@E!@E2!:2GK834A!>J!#KF@6471!@E2!W4?LI>M!>J!+G74?1!@E2!*67?I!"KAEQ!>J!VK[2M8>K6L1!7?I!Z7GP

7?2F2! A>6G>67@4>?F(! ^%U=1! RRR(_4_(22e(! *U+! FKGG>6@F! G6>H2A@F! 4?! @E2! J423I! >J! E>KF4?L1! R4?I! 2?26LQ1!

@67?FG>6@!7?I!F@622@!34LE@?4?L(!

!

IW'+!)X!')67,W! 7NT-(YU+N-/!%A>?>M4A!G>34AQ! 4?F@6KM2?@! 7F! 4@! G6>54I2F! J4?7?A473! FKGG>6@! @>!G6>H2A@F!

7?I!G6>L67MM2F(!0>34AQ!@QG2&!FK8F4IQ(!

$

%:*+,-78+T;!%?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4F!7M>?L!@E2!>8H2A@452F!>J!@E622!@67?FG>6@!G6>L67MM2F!K?I26!@E2!*U+!

^$7832!be(!

! !

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


I9:6+!\!CE?!'()S(9UT!(+S9(P7NS!-(9NT')(-!9NP!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!

A()S(9UU+! %:*+,-78+T! >,-787-7+T! G7N7T-(W!7N!,V9(S+b!!

EU'6+U+N-7NS!:)PW!

@)N-(9,-!

'9(-N+(!

I(9NT9,J

-7)N!

9U)YN-!

"2523>GM2?@!

>J!GK834A!

@67?FG>6@!

^,-'-e!

$>!G6>M>@2!GK834A!

@67?FG>6@!7?I!62P

IKA2!@67?FG>6@!

=;,!2M4FF4>?F(!

XKQ4?L!',-!JK23P2JJ4A42?@!

8KF2F!J>6!A>K?@Q!34?2F!

ÛI7PY46K!A>K?@Q1!976HK!

A>K?@Q1!$7334??e!

S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!

#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMKP

?4A7@4>?F1!!

:>7I!#IM4?4F@67@4>?!

+G74?! ,'!S!

%):!

%VS;!j!%32AP

@6>PM>8434@Q!

06>L67MM2!

^,-''P,-'Ce!

$>!G6>M>@2!2M4FP

F4>?PJ622!G26F>?73!

@67?FG>6@7@4>?!4?!

>6I26!@>!7AE4252!

82@@26!A4@Q!2?54P

6>?M2?@1!2?26LQ!

2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!JK23!

4?I2G2?I2?A2(!

'(!%F@7834FEM2?@!>J!?7P

@4>?PR4I2!cK4A_!AE76L4?L!

?2@R>6_!J>6!232A@64A!A76F!

,(!06>54F4>?!>J!232A@64A!

A76F!@>!F>A473!7?I!>@E26!

F@7@2!R>6_26Fm!

b(!%32A@64A!A76!GK6AE7F2!

FKGG>6@!FAE2M2!J>6!G64P

57@2!G26F>?F!7?I!>6L7?4P

F7@4>?F!!

S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!

#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMKP

?4A7@4>?F1!!

T>K?I7@4>?!W62I%[!

S4@FK84FE4!

=>6G>67P

@4>?!

'-!S!

##)F!

"2523>GM2?@!>J!232A@64A!GK834A!

@67?FG>6@!4?!$7334??!

06>AK62M2?@!>J!2?26LQ!2JP

J4A42?@!@67MF!J>6!$7334??!

34?2F!?>(!b!7?I!C!^,-!

@67MFe!

S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!

#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMKP

?4A7@4>?F1!V4??7P

@67?FG>6I4!#+!

+G74?! .b(C!

S%):!

+>K6A2&!%U=1!E@@G&hhRRR(_4_(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432FhF@>642Fh:U+h77Kt@67?F7A@4>?Ft,-'-P',t2?Lt',(GIJ!

^-k(-f(,-'.e(!

!

I9(S+-!S()Y'T;!0K834A!@67?FG>6@!>G267@>6F1!%Y!KF26F!

!

$Y6+T!9NP!7NX6Y+N,7NS!U+,V9N7TUT;!$E2!7627F!RE4AE!R433!82!J4?7?A2I1!762!?2L>@47@2I!7?I!I2A4I2I!8Q!

@E2!cK>@7!8KQ26F(!06>IKA@F!7?I!F2654A2F!762!8>KLE@!547!GK834A!G6>AK62M2?@F(!!

!

EU'6+U+N-9-7)N! N+-O)(R;!$E2!S4?4F@6Q! >J! %A>?>M4A! #JJ746F! 7?I! =>MMK?4A7@4>?F! A>P>6I4?7@2F! @E2!

@67I2! 4?! G26M4FF4832! 2M4FF4>?! 733>R7?A2(! $E2! S4?4F@6Q! >J! %?546>?M2?@! 4F! 62FG>?F4832! J>6! @E2! A>P

>6I4?7@4>?!7?I!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!=;,!cK>@7!F732F!7L622M2?@F(!$E2!*>526?M2?@!I2@26M4?2F!7?!7GP

G6>G647@2!M4?4F@26!7F!@E2!KF26!>J!@E2!6252?K2F!J>6!@E2!4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!27AE!*U+PFAE2M2(!$E2!4MP

G32M2?@4?L!7L2?A42F!4?!@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G6>H2A@F!762!@E2!:>7I!#IM4?4F@67@4>?1!T>K?I7@4>?!

W62I%[1!$7334??7!V4??7@67?FG>6I4!#+!^GK834A!@67?FG>6@7@4>?!A>MG7?Q!>R?2I!8Q!@E2!$7334??!A4@Qe(

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


1.2.3 ELMO – Estonian Electromobility Programme in transport sector

!

$E2!84LL2F@!?7@4>?73!32523!G6>L67M!@E7@!E7F!822?!4?4@47@2I!R4@E!@E2!*U+!FAE2M2!4F!@E2!?7@4>?73!232AP

@6>M>8434@Q!G6>L67MM21!%VS;(!

!

C+N+(96! 7NX)(U9-7)N;! %VS;! ^RRR(23M>(22e! 4F! M74?3Q! I6452?! 8Q! 4??>57@4>?! G>34AQ! 7L2?I7(! U@! 4F! 7!

*622?! U?52F@M2?@!+AE2M2!G6>L67MM21!RE4AE!F@76@2I! 4?!S76AE!,-''!RE2?!@E2!*>526?M2?@!>J! @E2!

:2GK834A!>J!%F@>?47!A>?A3KI2I!7!A>?@67A@!R4@E!S4@FK84FE4!=>6G>67@4>?1!Z7G7?1!J>6!@E2!F732!>J!=;,!cK>P

@7F!4?!@E2!7M>K?@!>J!'-!M4334>?!##)F(!$E2!G6>L67MM2!A>?F4F@F!>J!@E622!G76@F&!!

!

<;!ENX(9T-(Y,-Y(+!j!7!AE76L4?L!?2@R>6_!>J!232A@64A!A76F!R7F!A627@2I!@>!A>526!@E2!RE>32!%F@>?471!824?L!

@E2!J46F@!A>K?@6Q!4?!@E2!R>63I!A>?F@6KA@4?L!4@!4?!,-',(!$E2!cK4A_!AE76L4?L!?2@R>6_!R4@E!'B.!AE76L26F!

R7F!A>?F@6KA@2I!8Q!#XX(!$E2!AE76L4?L!G>4?@F!762!4?!733!6>7IF!R4@E!I2?F2!@67JJ4A!7?I!4?!733!F2@@32M2?@F!

R4@E!>526!.---!4?E784@7?@F1!2(L(!7@!G2@6>3!F@7@4>?F1!A7J2F1!FE>GF1!G>F@!>JJ4A2F1!87?_!8K43I4?LF1!G76_4?L!

3>@F! 7?I! 73F>! 4?! G>6@F(! $E2! I4F@7?A2! 82@R22?! cK4A_! AE76L4?L! G>4?@F! 4F! C-jB-! _M(! $E2! 3>A7@4>?! 7?I!

7574378434@Q!>J!cK4A_!AE76L4?L!G>4?@F!A7?!82!F22?!E262&!E@@G&hh23M>(22hAE76L4?LP?2@R>6_P,h!

!

[;!C(9N-!X)(!+6+,-(7,!,9(T!j!@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F!I2523>G2I!7!FKGP

G>6@!FQF@2M!J>6!?7@K673!7?I!32L73!G26F>?F!J>6!7AcK4F4@4>?!>J!232A@64A!A76F1!R4@E!7!GK6G>F2!@>!I2A627F2!

@E2!G>33K@4>?!3>7I!>J!@67?FG>6@!7?I!4?A627F2!@E2!KF2!>J!62?2R7832!2?26LQ!4?!@67?FG>6@!@E6>KLE!R4I26!

A>MM4FF4>?4?L!>J!232A@64A!A76F(!!

$E2! L67?@! G264>I! R7F! ,-''j,-'C(! #AA>6I4?L! @>! @E2! 62LK37@4>?! 7?I! @E2! G6>A2IK62! 2F@7834FE2I! 8Q!

T>K?I7@4>?!W62I%[1!@E2!GK6AE7F2!>J!7?!232A@64A!A761! 4?A3KI4?L!@E2!I>R?PG7QM2?@!>J! 327F4?L!7?I!@E2!

GK6AE7F2!>J!>?2!AE76L26!G26!>?2!232A@64A!A761!4?A3KI4?L!@E2!?2A2FF76Q!4?F@7337@4>?!R>6_1!R7F!FKGG>6@P

2I(!+4?A2!<>52M826!,-',1!@E2!GK6AE7F2!>J!G3KLPAE76L2I!EQ864I!52E4A32F!E7F!73F>!822?!FKGG>6@2I(!

U?!@>@731!W62I%[!E7F!FKGG>6@2I!B.k!^bbD!J>6!G6457@2!G26F>?F!7?I!b'f!J>6!A>MG7?QNFe!A76!GK6AE7F2!7?I!

b.-!E>M2!AE76L26F(!S>F@!7GG34A7?@F!^kCge!A7M2!J6>M!976HK!=>K?@Q!^4?A3(!$7334??e(!!

!

\;!5+U)NT-(9-7)N!9NP!9O9(+N+TT!(97T7NS!9,-787-7+T&!!

P!%F@>?47?!L>526?M2?@!GK6AE7F2I!7!J322@!>J!.-k!S4@FK84FE4!4S4%YF!+6+,-(7,!,9(T!X)(!-V+!T),796!O)(R+(T!

76>K?I!%F@>?47!J>6!@E246!GK834A!IK@42F(!!

P!>!P+U)!,+N-(+!j!7?!4?@267A@452!2[G>F4@4>?!4?@6>IKA4?L!@E2!@2AE?>3>LQ!>J!232A@64A!A76F!R7F!>G2?2I!4?!

ZK?2!,-'b!4?!+A42?A2!=2?@62!#99##!3>A7@2I!4?!$76@K(!

P!#=G%!$+N-96!j!7!G43>@!A76!FE764?L!G6>L67M!R4@E!,C!232A@64A!A76F!4?!$7334??!7?I!$76@K1!37K?AE2I!4?!ZK3Q!

,-'b(!!

U?!7II4@4>?1!W62I%[!4F!6K??4?L!G6>M>@4>?73!7A@454@42F!7?I!A7MG74L?F!J>6!232A@64A!A76F(!

!

IW'+!)X!')67,W!7NT-(YU+N-/!%A>?>M4A!^M74?3Qe!7?I!4?J>6M7@452!G>34AQ!4?F@6KM2?@(!0>34AQ!@QG2F&!FK8F4P

IQ!7?I!G6>54F4>?!>J! 4?J>6M7@4>?! J>6!FKF@74?7832! @67?FG>6@(!%VS;!G6>L67MM2! 4F! JK33Q! J4?7?A2I!KF4?L!

JK?IF!62A2452I!J6>M!=;,!2M4FF4>?!@67I4?L!FAE2M2(!

!

%:*+,-78+T;!$E2!L>73!>J!@E2!%VS;!G6>L67MM2!4F!@>!FG22I!KG!@E2!A>MM4FF4>?4?L!>J!232A@64A!A76F!4?!%FP

@>?471!7?I!J7A434@7@2!@E2!7AE4252M2?@!>J!@E2!L>73!K?I26@7_2?!8Q!@E2!F@7@2!@>! 4?A627F2!@E2!KF2!>J!62P

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


?2R7832!2?26LQ!@>!'-g!4?!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6!8Q!,-,-(!$E2!G6>L67MM2!G6>M>@2F!2M4FF4>?!J622!G26F>?P

73!@67?FG>6@7@4>?!7?I!232A@64A!A76F!4?!>6I26!@>!7AE4252!82@@26!A4@Q!2?546>?M2?@1!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!

JK23! 4?I2G2?I2?A2(! %32A@64A! 52E4A32F! 762! A>?F4I262I! 7F! >?2! >G@4>?! @>! 864?L! 62?2R7832! 2?26LQ! @>!

@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6(!

!

I9(S+-!S()Y'T;!06457@2!G26F>?F1!A>MG7?42F1!F>A473!R>6_26F1!2@A(!

!

$Y6+T!9NP!7NX6Y+N,7NS!U+,V9N7TUT;!$E2!L67?@!7M>K?@!J>6!@E2!GK6AE7F2!>J!7?!232A@64A!A76!7?I!I>R?P

G7QM2?@!>J!327F4?L!4F!KG!@>!.-g!>J!@E2!GK6AE7F2!G64A2!>J!@E2!232A@64A!A761!8K@!?>@!M>62!@E7?!%):!'f!

---!J>6!7!G26F>?!RE>!4F!?>@!7!Y#$!G7Q26(!T>6!Y#$!G7Q26F1!@E2!L67?@!4F!b.g!>J!234L4832!A>F@F1!8K@!?>@!

M>62!@E7?!%):!'f!---!G26!A76(!$E2!>R?26!>J!%YPF!GK6AE7F2I!R4@E!@E2!L67?@!E752!@>!A>526!@E246!232AP

@64A4@Q!A>?FKMG@4>?!R4@E!L622?!232A@64A4@Q!A26@4J4A7@2F1! @E2!L67?@!A>M2F!R4@E!7!.!S/E!L622?!A26@4J4P

A7@2(!

!

EU'6+U+N-9-7)N!N+-O)(R;!

"4F@648K@4>?!>J!@E2!GK6AE7F2!L67?@!7?I!@E2!7IM4?4F@67@4>?!>J!@E2!cK4A_!AE76L4?L!?2@R>6_!4F!>6L7?4F2I!

8Q!T>K?I7@4>?!W62I%[(!!

1.3 Conclusions and Lessons Learned of other Projects about the Performance of the National Policy Packages for Energy Efficiency

1.3.1 Buildings sector !

U?@26?7@4>?73!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ!M7I2!@E2!%?26LQ!0>34AQ!:2542R!>?!%F@>?47!4?!,-'b'C!^%F@>?471!,-'be(!$>!

FKMM764O2!@E2!I2@7432I!62G>6@1!4@!4F!F74I!@E7@!%F@>?47!4F!62A>L?4F2I!J>6!4@F!67G4I!62J>6MF!J>33>R4?L!4@F!

4?I2G2?I2?A21!R4@E!7!A3276!G62J262?A2!J>6! 3482673!2A>?>M4A!G>34A42F!R233!2?L7L2I!R4@E!62L4>?73!7?I!

4?@26?7@4>?73!2JJ>6@F!@>!7I57?A2!FKF@74?7832!2?26LQ!7?I!2JJ>6@F!@>!7II62FF!A34M7@2!AE7?L2!AE7332?L2F(!

%F@>?47!A32763Q!7FG462F!@>!7!M>62!2?26LQP2JJ4A42?@!7?I!FKF@74?7832!2A>?>MQ(!%F@>?47NF!G>34AQ!AE7332?LP

2F!7?I!>GG>6@K?4@42F!2[@2?I!82Q>?I!@E2!,-,-!E>64O>?!>J!%)!>834L7@4>?F(!$E2!L>526?M2?@!>J!%F@>?47!

74MF!@>!KF2!@E2!%)!I462A@452F!7F!7!F@2G!>?!@E2!R7Q!@>!FE7G4?L!3>?L26P@26M!>8H2A@452F!7?I!E7F!F@76@2I!

R>6_4?L!>?!%?26LQ!+@67@2LQ!>J!%F@>?47!@>!,-.-(!

!

$E2!%?26LQ!0>34AQ!:2G>6@!FKMM764F2F!@E2!U%#!,.!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!0>34AQ!:2A>MM2?I7@4>?F!7?I!G3>@F!

%F@>?47NF!G64>64@42F! 7L74?F@! @E2!,.! 62A>MM2?I7@4>?F! 7?I! FE>K3I!82! 62L76I2I!7F! 7! J67M2R>6_! J>6! 7!

A>MG62E2?F452!G>6@J>34>!>J!G>34A42F(!$>!7AE4252!F754?LF!4?!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>61!@E2!U%#!62A>MM2?IF!

@E2!J>33>R4?L!^%?26LQp1!,-'be&!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

'C!%F@>?47!H>4?2I!@E2!U%#!4?!,-'C(!T>33>R4?L!4@F!7AA2FF4>?!@>!@E2!;6L7?4F7@4>?!J>6!%A>?>M4A!=>P>G267@4>?!7?I!"2523>GM2?@!^;%="e!4?!,-'-1!

%F@>?47!7GG342I!J>6!U?@26?7@4>?73!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ!Û%#e!M2M826FE4G!4?!,-''(!$E4F!62542R!>J!%F@>?47NF!2?26LQ!G>34A42F!4F!G76@!>J!@E2!U%#!7AA2FP

F4>?!G6>A2FF(!U@!7?73QF2F!@E2!2?26LQ!G>34AQ!AE7332?L2F!7?I!>GG>6@K?4@42F!J7A4?L!%F@>?471!7?I!G6>54I2F!A64@4cK2F!7?I!62A>MM2?I7@4>?F!J>6!JKP

@K62!G>34AQ!4MG6>52M2?@F(!U@!4F!4?@2?I2I!@>!LK4I2!@E2!A>K?@6Q!@>R76IF!7!M>62!F2AK62!7?I!FKF@74?7832!2?26LQ!JK@K62(!

E@@G&hhRRR(427(>6LhGK834A7@4>?FhJ622GK834A7@4>?FhGK834A7@4>?h2?26LQPG>34A42FP>JP427PA>K?@642FPPP2F@>?47P,-'bP62542R(E@M3(!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


I9:6+!1!?YUU9(W!)X!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NP9-7)NT!

?YUU9(W!)X!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NJ

P9-7)NT!

A(7)(7-W! &)-+T!

S7?I7@>6Q!8K43I4?L!2?26LQ!A>I2F!7?I!M4?4P

MKM!2?26LQ!G26J>6M7?A2!62cK462M2?@F(!

S2I4KM! :2LK376!62542R1!KGL67I2!AQA32!7?I!G43>@!

7A@454@42F!762!4MG>6@7?@(!

#4M4?L!J>6!?2@!O26>P2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!

8K43I4?LF(!

S2I4KM! 06>M>@2!O26>h3>RP2?26LQ!8K43I4?LF!

UMG6>54?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!2[4F@4?L!8K43IP

4?LF(!

94LE! :7@4>?734F2!7?I!2[@2?I!2[4F@4?L!FAE2M2F!

J>6!@E4F!G64>64@Q!2?IPKF21!4?@2L67@2!R4@E!

"9!G>34A42F(!

XK43I4?LFN!2?26LQ!37823F!7?I!A26@4J4A7@2F(! V>R! />6_!R4@E!%)!3782334?L(!

%?26LQ!G26J>6M7?A2!>J!8K43I4?L!A>MG>?2?@F!

7?I!FQF@2MF(!

S2I4KM! #34L?!3>A73!M7?KJ7A@K626F!R4@E!%)!

F@7?I76IF(!

!

XQ!G62F2?@!I7Q!R2!A>K3I!2573K7@2!@E7@!@E2!M7H>64@Q!>J!@E2!G>4?@F!4?!@E>F2!62A>MM2?I7@4>?F!E752!73P

627IQ!@7_2?!7?I!@E2Q!762!4?!R>6_(!$E4F!M27?F!@E7@!%F@>?47!E7F!822?!FKAA2FFJK3!4?!I2345264?L!@E2!2?26P

LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ(!9>R25261!%F@>?47!A7?!F@433!M>62!KF2JK33Q!F@6KA@K62!7?I! 4?@2L67@2!@E2!5764>KF!JK?A@4>?F!

I2345264?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34A42F!7?I!G6>L67MM2F(!!

$E2! 4MG32M2?@7@4>?!>J!L>526?M2?@! JK?I4?L!G6>L67MM2F! J>6!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ1!A34M7@2!AE7?L2!7?I!

"9!FKGG>6@!7GG276F!@>!82!FG627I!>526!I4JJ262?@!G6>L67MM2F!@E7@!F22M!@>!82!I6452?!8Q!JK?I26FN!A64P

@2647!7?I!@>!>52637G!R4@E>K@!A>?F4F@2?@!LK4I4?L!G64?A4G32F(!$E2!6237@4>?FE4G!82@R22?!@E2!S%#=1!7?I!

@E2!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@!7?I!>G267@4>?73!G6>L67MM2F!FE>K3I!82!62F@6KA@K62I!@>!62M>52!>GP

267@4>?73! >52637GF! 7?I! 4MG6>52! A>?F4F@2?AQ(! %F@>?47! FE>K3I! A>?F4I26! A627@4?L! 7?! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ!

K?4@1!RE4AE!R>K3I!82!7832!@>!A>MM4FF4>?1!62F276AE1!2573K7@2!7?I!4MG32M2?@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G64>64P

@42F! M7[4M4F4?L! I234526Q! 2JJ4A42?AQ1! 62G>6@4?L! @>! @E2! %?26LQ! "2G76@M2?@! 4?! @E2! S%#=(! $E2! 37@@26!

FE>K3I! 327I! A>P>6I4?7@4>?! >J! 2?26LQ! 2JJ4A42?AQ! G>34A42F! 7A6>FF! L>526?M2?@! @>!M264@! 62cK462I! J>AKF!

7?I!>G267@4>?73!A3764@Q!^%?26LQ!p1!,-'be(!

T4?733Q!@E2!U%#!%?26LQ!0>34AQ!:2G>6@!>?!%F@>?47!M7_2F!7!?KM826!>J!62A>MM2?I7@4>?F!4?!2?26LQ!2JJ4P

A42?AQ!J>6!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!^%?26LQp1!,-'be&!

• T>AKF!>?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34A42F!7?I!G6>L67MM2!7A@454@42F!@E7@!M22@!8>@E!%F@>?47NF!A>F@P

2JJ2A@452!G64>64@42F!7?I!@E2!62cK462M2?@F!>J!@E2!%)!I462A@452F(!

• T>6!?2R!8K43I4?LF1! F@62?L@E2?!8K43I4?L! A>I2F!R4@E! F@7L2I! 4MG6>52M2?@F! 4?! F@64?L2?AQ! 7?I!

7I>G@!7!M>62!7M84@4>KF!G7@ER7Q!@>!O26>P!7?I!3>RP2?26LQ!8K43I4?LF(!=>MG32M2?@!@E4F!R4@E!

A7G7A4@QP8K43I4?L!M27FK62F(!

• T>6! @E2! 2[4F@4?L! 8K43I4?L! F@>A_1! I2523>G! 7?! 4?@2L67@2I! G6>L67MM2! >J! J4FA73! 7?I! JK?I4?L!

M27FK62F!@E7@!2?7832!G64>64@42F!4?!@E2!8K43I4?L!F@>A_!@>!82!4MG6>52I!>526!7!I2J4?2I!@4M2!G2P

64>I(!U?A627F2!@E2!67@4>!>J!G6457@2PF2A@>6!JK?I4?L(!

• U?@2L67@2!8K43I4?L!M27FK62F!R4@E!G>34A42F!>?!"9!@>!2?FK62!@E7@!2?IPKF2!2JJ4A42?AQ!4MG6>52P

M2?@F! 4?!8K43I4?LF!762!@7_2?!KG!7?I!@E7@!A>?FKM26F!2[G>F2I!@>!K?FKF@74?7832!"9!FQF@2MF!

E752!G64>64@Q!J>6!4?FK37@4>?!7?I!E4LEP2JJ4A42?AQ!3>A73!E27@4?L1!FKAE!7F!7!E27@!GKMG(!

! !

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


1.3.2 Transport sector !

#N+(SW!#XX7,7+N,W!L9-,V!!;;;:','*-6<'77+=+',=6<;2)=&:/*-#>![3<\/!

$E2!%F@>?47?!<%%#0!4F!526Q!R233!2378>67@2I!7?I!8737?A2I(!%F@>?47!F22F!@E2!8K43I4?LF!F2A@>6!7F!G64>64@Q!

J>6!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!^%%e!RE4AE!4F!K?I2634?2I!8Q!M7?Q!L>>I!M27FK62F!4?!@E7@!F2A@>6(!U?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!

F2A@>61!M>F@!M27FK62F!762!>?3Q!G37??2I(!=K662?@3Q1!@E2!7A@454@42F!M74?3Q!J>AKF!>?!4MG6>54?L!@E2!%%!>J!

52E4A32F!8Q!7AcK464?L!?2R!GK834A!@67?FG>6@7@4>?!6>334?L!F@>A_!7?I!8Q!4MG32M2?@4?L!7?!%PM>8434@Q!G6>P

L67MM2(!#33!@QG2F!>J!M27FK62F!E752!822?!7II62FF2I!^G37??4?L!4?F@6KM2?@F1!62LK37@>6Q!4?F@6KM2?@F1!

2A>?>M4A! 4?A2?@452F1! 4?J>6M7@4>?!7?I!7I54A21!:s"e!7?I!I4JJ262?@!7A@>6F!E752!822?!A>?F4I262I1!8K@!

M>F@!M27FK62F!762!?>@!4MG32M2?@2I!?>6!I2FA6482I!4?!I2@743(!

$>! JK6@E26! F@62?L@E2?! 4@F! J67M2R>6_! 4?! @67?FG>6@! F2A@>61! %F@>?47! FE>K3I! 4MG6>52!:s"! FKGG>6@! 7?I!

@E262!4F!7!?22I!@>!7A@K733Q!4MG32M2?@!G37??2I!M27FK62F(!

!

!

%5D??##!i!GH$#![3<3b!#N+(SW!#XX7,7+N,W!A)67,7+T!9NP!G+9TY(+T!7N!#T-)N79!7N![3<[/!

$E2! 376L2F@! FE762!>J! J4?73!2?26LQ! 4F! F@433! A>?FKM2I!8Q!E>KF2E>3IF!8K@! @E2! FE762!E7F! @E2!I>R?R76I!

@62?I(!$E2!F2A>?I!376L2F@!G76@!>J!J4?73!A>?FKMG@4>?!L>2F!J>6!@67?FG>6@!7?I!4@F!FE762!4F!L6>R4?L(!

U?! 6>7I! @67?FG>6@1! @E2!A>?FKMG@4>?!>J!I42F23! JK23!E7F!822?! 4?A627F4?L!73M>F@! A>?F@7?@3Q1! @E2! @62?I!

@>R76IF!4?A627F4?L!FE762!>J!I42F23!JK23!A>?FKMG@4>?!4F!A32763Q!G6>?>K?A2I!F4?A2!'DD.(!

$E262!E752!822?!>?3Q!F34LE@!AE7?L2F!4?!@E2!F@6KA@K62!>J!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!8Q!@QG2!>J!@67?FG>6@!IK6P

4?L!'DD.j,-'-&!@E2!FE762F!>J!6>7I!@67?FG>6@!7?I!@>!F>M2!2[@2?@!73F>!>J!746!@67?FG>6@!E752!4?A627F2I1!

@E2!FE762!>J!6743!@67?FG>6@!4F!I2A34?4?L(!U?!6>7I!@67?FG>6@1!A>?FKMG@4>?!>J!8>@E!JK23F!j!G2@6>3!7?I!I42P

F23!j!E7F!822?!4?A627F4?L(!U?!%F@>?471!@E2!G6>G26!7?73QF4F!>J!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?!@67?FG>6@!A7??>@!82!

A76642I!>K@!7F!@E262!4F!7!37A_!>J!623257?@!62347832!I7@7(!X7F2I!>?!L2?2673!757437832!I7@71!4@!A7?!82!A>?P

A3KI2I!@E7@!@E2!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4?I2[!;"%]!J>6!@67?FG>6@! 4?!%F@>?47!E7F!4?A627F2I!8Q!'k(bg!^J6>M!

,---!@>!,-'-e!M27?4?L!@E7@!@E2!2?26LQ!4?@2?F4@Q!E7F!4?A627F2I(!$E2!I4JJ262?A2!>J!2?26LQ!4?@2?F4@Q!>J!

@67?FG>6@!4?!%F@>?47!7?I!@E2!%)!4F!526Q!2FF2?@473&!4?!%F@>?47!-(-fk!_L!>2h%):,---!7?I!@E2!%)!75267L2!

-(-b,!_L!>2h%):,---!4?!,-'-!^%?26LQ(((1!,-',e(!

!

%#@5eE#>b!#N+(SW!A)67,7+T!M+W)NP!E#>!@)YN-(7+Tb![3<\/!

%F@>?47NF!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?!^<%%#0e!2[A3KI2F!2?26LQ!KF2I!J>6!@67?FG>6@!J6>M!@E2!

A>K?@6QNF!J4?73!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?(!

%F@>?47!E7F!F4L?4J4A7?@!G>@2?@473!@>!62IKA2!2?26LQ!A>?FKMG@4>?!4?!@E2!8K43I4?LF1!I4F@64A@!E27@4?L!^"9e!

7?I!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6F(!

$67?FG>6@!JK23F!762!4MG>6@2I!J6>M!L3>873!M76_2@F!7?I!%F@>?47!E7F!2JJ2A@452!F@>67L2!7?I!7!?KM826!>J!

F27P!7?I!37?IP87F2I!6>K@2F!J>6!FKGG3Q(!

$67?FG>6@!4F!@E2!M74?!F>K6A2!>J!=;,!2M4FF4>?F!4?!@E2!?>?P%$+!F2A@>6(!U@F!2M4FF4>?F!4?A627F2I!8Q!bkg!

J6>M!,---!@>!,-'-1!RE2?!@E2Q!7AA>K?@2I!J>6!',g!>J!733!2?26LQP6237@2I!=;,!2M4FF4>?F!4?!@E2!A>K?@6Q(!

/4@E>K@!7M84@4>KF!M27FK62F1!2M4FF4>?F!762!F2@!@>!64F2!JK6@E261!7F!@E2!A>K?@6Q!L6>RF!R273@E426(!$E2!

G6457@2!A76!>R?26FE4G!67@2!4F!>?2PJ4J@E!3>R26!@E7?!4?!@E2!R273@E426!%)'.!A>K?@642F!^C-k!A76F!G26!'!---!

4?E784@7?@F! 4?! %F@>?47! 526FKF! .-b! 4?! %)'.! 4?! ,--De! 7?I! E7F! G32?@Q! >J! 6>>M! @>! 2[G7?I(! T624LE@!

@67?FG>6@1! 4?! @K6?1! @QG4A733Q! 4?A627F2F! 4?! @7?I2M!R4@E! L6>FF! I>M2F@4A! G6>IKA@! ^*"0e(! $E2! ,-'-!<7P

@4>?73!:2?2R7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?!G6>H2A@F!2?26LQ!KF2!4?!@E2!F2A@>6!@>!4?A627F2!8Q!'bg!J6>M!@E2!

75267L2!>J!,--.P-f!@>!,-,-(!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


$>!7AE4252!F4L?4J4A7?@!2?26LQ!F754?LF!4?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>61!@E2!U%#!62A>MM2?IF!J452!_2Q!G>34AQ!762P

7F!J>6!%F@>?47!^F22!B+V6+(g!K+(O+7ThY+66+!R)NN-+!N7,V-!S+XYNP+N!O+(P+N;.e(!

I9:6+!^!E#>!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NP9-7)NT!X)(!#T-)N79!7N!-(9NT')(-!T+,-)(!

?YUU9(W!)X!+N+(SW!+XX7,7+N,W!(+,)UU+NJ

P9-7)NT!

A(7)(7-W! &)-+T!

S7?I7@>6Q!52E4A32!JK23!2JJ4A42?AQ!F@7?I76IF(!!

S27FK62F!@>!4MG6>52!52E4A32!JK23!2JJ4A42?AQ(!

V>R!

V>R!:27F>?7832!J>6!7!FM733!@2AE?>3>LQP

@7_4?L!A>K?@6Q!@>!623Q!>?!%)!G6>A2FF2F(!

TK23P2JJ4A42?@!?>?P2?L4?2!A>MG>?2?@F(! V>R!

UMG6>54?L!>G267@4>?73!2JJ4A42?AQ!@E6>KLE!

2A>PI6454?L!7?I!>@E26!M27FK62F(!!

UMG6>54?L!@67?FG>6@!FQF@2M!2JJ4A42?AQ(!

S2I!

!

S2I!

=>F@P2JJ2A@452!2?26LQ!7?I!F7J2@Q!J6>M!

2A>PI6454?L(!!

0K6FK2!@67?FG>6@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!

G37?F(!

!

$E2!L>526?M2?@!>J!%F@>?47!FE>K3I&!!

" :2542R!@E2!G6>G>F2I!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34AQ!>G@4>?F! 4?!@E2!@67?FG>6@!F2A@>6!7?I!I2523>G!7!

F@67@2LQ!>J!G64>64@4F2I!M27FK62F!@>!4MG6>52!M>8434@Q!4?!G7FF2?L26!7?I!J624LE@!@67?FG>6@!4?!>6P

I26!@>!M4?4M4F2!@67?FG>6@!JK23!I2M7?I(!!

" #GG3Q!%)!G>34A42F!@>!7I57?A2!@E2!2JJ4A42?AQ!>J!@E2!52E4A32!J322@1!M22@4?L!@E2!K?4cK2!M>8434@Q!

?22IF!7?I!AE767A@264F@4AF!>J!%F@>?47NF!52E4A32!J322@(!!

" "2523>G!2JJ2A@452!G>34A42F!@>!4MG6>52!M>8434@Q!4?!A4@42F!7?I!@>R?F(!!

" %?FK62!@E7@!G64>64@42F!762!2A>?>M4A!7?I!@E7@!62734F@4A!JK?I4?L!4F!4I2?@4J42I(!!

" "2523>G!7!F@67@2LQ!@>!2?FK62!@E7@!J624LE@!@67?FG>6@!2JJ2A@4523Q!FKGG>6@F!@E2!2A>?>MQ!7?I!4MP

G6>52F!2JJ4A42?AQ!R4@E!2JJ4A42?@!52E4A32F1!M>I2F!7?I!3>L4F@4AF!M7?7L2M2?@!FQF@2MF(!

$

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


2. INTERACTION BETWEEN THE NATIONAL AND THE SUB-NATIONAL LEVELS

$

U?!@26MF!>J!@76L2@2I!F@67@2L42F!7?I!7A@4>?F1!4@!4F!@E2!F@7@2!32523!@E7@!4F!M>F@!7A@452!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!2?26P

LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ(!X2F4I2F!M4?4F@26473!4?F@4@K@4>?F1!73F>!F@7@2!L>526?2I!J>K?I7@4>?F!34_2!%F@>?47?!"2523>GP

M2?@!TK?I1!W62I%]!7?I!%?@26G64F2!%F@>?47!E752!7!6>32! 4?!G6>M>@4?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7A@454@42F!7?I!

FKGG>6@4?L!F@76@PKGF! 4?!%F@>?47(!%F@>?47?!"2523>GM2?@!TK?I!^F@7@2!L>526?2I!J>K?I7@4>?!@E7@!G76@3Q!

@>>_!>526!@E2!@7F_F!>J!%F@>?47?!=34M7@2!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ!,--DP,-''e!7A@2I!7F!7!A>P>6I4?7@>6!>J!@E2!<7P

@4>?73!%?26LQ!"2523>GM2?@!037?!,-b-d!^%<S#We1!RE4AE!R7F!7?!7A@452!G76@4A4G7@>6Q!G6>A2FF1!7?I!4?P

5>352I!@27MF!>J!2[G26@F!7?I!87A_L6>K?I!F@KI42F!4?!@E2!J423I!>J!E>KF4?L1!@67?FG>6@1!84>JK23F!7?I!232AP

@64A4@Q!G6>IKA@4>?!7?I!>JJ262I!7?!4?@267A@452!A>3378>67@4>?!G37@J>6M!RRR(2?26L47@73LKI(22(!

+4[! %F@>?47?! MK?4A4G734@42F! E752! F4L?2I! @E2! =>52?7?@! >J! S7Q>6F! ^$7334??1! :7_52621! $76@K1! ZwL2571!

Yw6K1!:wKL2e!R4@E!7!@>@73!G>GK37@4>?!>J!A7!..-!---!4?E784@7?@F(!$R>!A4@42F!E752!FK8M4@@2I!+KF@74?7P

832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?F!@>!@E2!=>52?7?@!>J!S7Q>6F&!:7_5262!7?I!$7334??!^C(bg!>J!%F@>?47?!A4@42F!7?I!

@>R?Fe(!$E2!+%#0!>J!:7_5262!E7F!822?!7AA2G@2I!8Q!@E2!=>52?7?@!>J!S7Q>6F(!+%#0!>J!$7334??!4F!G2?IP

4?L!R4@E!A3764J4A7@4>?F! 62cK2F@2I1!7F!>J!,C! ZK3Q!,-'.(!#3F>!$76@K!A4@Q1! ZwL257!A4@Q!7?I!Yw6K!A4@Q!E752!

GK834FE2I!2?26LQ!F754?L!7A@4>?!G37?!^K?I26!U%%!JK?I2I!S%+9#:$UVU$l!G6>H2A@e(!$

$E262!762!@R>!3>A73h62L4>?73!32523!%?26LQ!7L2?A42F1!>?2!4?!$7334??!MK?4A4G734@Q!j!$7334??!%?26LQ!#L2?P

AQ1!7?>@E26!4?!$76@K1!$76@K!:2L4>?73!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ1!8>@E!R>6_4?L!R4@E!8K43I4?LFN!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!4FP

FK2F!7?I!G6>A22I!R4@E!@674?4?L!7?I!R4I26!FA>G2!4?J>6M7@4>?!I4FF2M4?7@4>?!4?!4MG6>54?L!2?26LQ!2JJ4P

A42?AQ! 7@! 3>A73! 32523(! $E2! 2?26L2@4A! 62JK684FEM2?@! E7F! L74?2I! E4LE! G>GK3764@Q! 4?! 73M>F@! 7@! 733! 3>A73!

L>526?M2?@F(!$E2F2!7L2?A42F!E752!7?!7A@452!6>32!4?!A7G7A4@Q!8K43I4?L1!?2@R>6_4?L!7?I!I4FF2M4?7@4>?!

7A@454@42F(!+@4331!%F@>?47!4F!37A_4?L!@E2!?7@4>?73!%?26LQ!#L2?AQ!7@!G62F2?@(!

!

!

!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


REFERENCES !

"462A@452! ,--Dh,fh%=! >?! @E2! 06>M>@4>?! >J! %32A@64A4@Q! 06>IKA2I! J6>M! :2?2R7832! %?26LQ! +>K6A2F(!

#57437832! >?34?2&! E@@G&hh2K6P32[(2K6>G7(2Kh32L73P

A>?@2?@h%<h$]$h0"ThqK64r=%V%]&b,--DV--,fsJ6>Mr%<!^-b(-f(,-'.e(!

%2F@4!,-,-!@2L25KF_757!,-'.P,-,-(!^,-'.e(!y%F@>?47!,-,-!#A@4>?!037?z(!!#GG6>52I!8Q!@E2!L>526?M2?@!

'C(-.(,-'.(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hh644L4_7?@F2324(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432Fh644L4_7?@F2324hF@67@22L478K6>>h22F@4,-,-h22F@4,-,-t@2L25

KF_757t'C(-.(,-'.(GIJ!^-b(-f(,-'.e(!

%2F@4!@77F@K52?26L47!@2L25KF_757!77F@7?4!,-,-1!SWS(!i$E2!<7@4>?73!:2?2R7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!

037?!K?@43!Q276!,-,-z(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hhRRR(M_M(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432Fh@77F@K52?26L47t@2L25KF_757(GIJ!^-C(-f(,-'.e(!

%LL26!=(!2@!73(1!^,-',e(!+):Y%l!:%0;:$!06>L62FF!4?!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34A42F!4?!@E2!%)!S2M826!

+@7@2F!P!@E2!2[G26@F!G26FG2A@452(!T4?I4?LF!J6>M!@E2!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!/7@AE!06>H2A@!,-',(!#57437832!

>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(2?26LQP2JJ4A42?AQP

R7@AE(>6LhJ4327IM4?h22RtI>AKM2?@Fh%%/,h%%/t+K652Qt:2G>6@(GIJ!^b(-f(,-'.e(!

%U=(!#57437832!>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(_4_(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432FhF@>642Fh:U+h77Kt@67?F7A@4>?Ft,-'-P

',t2?Lt',(GIJ!^-k(-f(,-'.e(!

%?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!7?I!I4F@64A@!E27@4?L(!^,-'be(!U%#1!%?26LQ!0>34A42F!X2Q>?I!U%#!=>K?@642F1!U++<!,b-kP

-fDk1!GG(!CCP..(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hhRRR(427(>6LhGK834A7@4>?FhJ622GK834A7@4>?FhGK834A7@4>?h%F@>?47,-'btJ622(GIJ!-.(-f(,-'.e(!

%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!/7@AE(!^,-'be(!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!4?!%K6>G2!#FF2FFM2?@!>J!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!

037?F!7?I!0>34A42F!4?!%)!S2M826!+@7@2F(!#57437832!>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(2?26LQP2JJ4A42?AQP

R7@AE(>6LhJ4327IM4?h22RtI>AKM2?@Fh">AKM2?@Fh%%/,h%F@>?47(GIJ!^,b(-k(,-'.e(!

%?26L47M7H7?IKF2!762?LK_757!77F@7?4!,-b-!_2F__>??7MwHK!F@67@22L434?2!E4?I7M4?2(!^,-'.e(!y+@67@2P

L4A!%?546>?M2?@73!UMG7A@!#FF2FFM2?@!:2G>6@z(!U(!So3I62(!%F@>?47?!"2523>GM2?@!TK?I(!k.G(!#57437832!

>?34?2&!!!

E@@GF&hhRRR(M_M(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432Fh'C'-,bt2?M7_t,-b-t_FEt76K7??2t75734_KF@7M4F232(GIJ1!

^-f(-D(,-'.e(!!

%?26L47@73LKI(!^,-'.e(!y%?26LQ!8674?F@>6M4?L(!/28P87F2I!>?34?2!R>6_FE>G!@>!I2523>G!2?26LQ!I2523P

>GM2?@!G37?z(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

Ê@@G&hhRRR(2?26L47@73LKI(22h4?I2[(GEGq@4@32r%<S#W&#H7_757tH7t@2L25KF2I{%37MKM7H7?IKFt(,T!

^-f(-D(,-'.e(!

%<S#W!,-b-d!^,-'.e(!<7@4>?73!"2523>GM2?@!037?!J>6!%?26LQ!+2A@>6!@433!,-b-1!R4@E!@E2!54F4>?!@433!,-.-!

^J4?73!I67J@e!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7@4>?F1!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@G&hhRRR(2?26L47@73LKI(22h4MLt7K@E(GEGh.h.8h%<S#Wt,-b-(t%23?g=bgX.Kt'b(-,(,-'.(GIJ!

^b-(-k(,-'.e(!!

%F@>?47!,-'b(!%?26LQ!0>34AQ!:2542R(!^,-'be(!U%#1!%?26LQ!0>34A42F!X2Q>?I!U%#!=>K?@642F1!U++<!,b-kP

-fDk(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hhRRR(427(>6LhGK834A7@4>?FhJ622GK834A7@4>?FhGK834A7@4>?h%F@>?47,-'btJ622(GIJ(!^'-(-f(,-'.e(!

%F@>?47?!<7@4>?73!9>KF4?L!"2523>GM2?@!037?!J>6!,--f!j!,-'b(!^,--fe(!S%#=(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@G&hhRRR(822?P>?34?2(?2@h$E2P%F@>?47?P<7@4>?73P9>KF4?LP"2523>GM2?@P037?PJ>6P,--fP

,-'b(Cf.(-(E@M3qsVr'1!^'C(-k(,-'.e(!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


%F@>?47?!:2GK834A(!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@1!%F@>?47?!%?546>?M2?@73!:2F276AE!=2?@62(!^,--De(!%FP

@>?47NF!J4J@E!<7@4>?73!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!K?I26!@E2!)<!T67M2R>6_!=>?52?@4>?!>?!=34M7@2!=E7?L2(!

#57437832!>?34?2&!!E@@G&hhK?JAAA(4?@h62F>K6A2hI>AFh?7@Ah2F@t?A.(GIJ1!^'-(-D(,-'.e(!!

%F@>?47?!:2GK834A(!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?M2?@1!%F@>?47?!%?546>?M2?@73!:2F276AE!=2?@62(!^,-'be(!%FP

@>?47NF!F4[@E!<7@4>?73!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!K?I26!@E2!)<!T67M2R>6_!=>?52?@4>?!>?!=34M7@2!=E7?L2(!

#57437832!>?34?2&!!E@@GF&hhK?JAAA(4?@hJ432Fh?7@4>?73t62G>6@Fh?>?P

7??2[t4t?7@A>Mh7GG34A7@4>?hGIJh2F@t?AB(GIJ1!^'-(-D(,-'.e(!

9>KF4?L!F2A@>6!I2523>GM2?@!G37?F1!%<S#W!,-b-d(!^,-'.e(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@G&hhRRR(2?26L47@73LKI(22h4MLt7K@E(GEGh,h,.h%<S#Wt,-b-(t%23?g=bgX.Kt,b('-(,-'C(GIJ1!

^-b(-f(,-'.e(!

S%#=1!,-'.(!"2523>GM2?@!037?F(!#57437832!>?34?2&!E@@GF&hhRRR(M_M(22h2?h>8H2A@452FP

7A@454@42FhI2523>GM2?@PG37?F1!^b(-f(,-'.e(!

<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?1!-.(-.(,-'C1!$E2!*>526?M2?@!>J!%F@>?471!%F@>?47NF!=>MMK?4P

A7@4>?!@>!@E2!%)!K?I26!#6@4A32!,C^,e!>J!"462A@452!,-',h,kh%)1!,-'C(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hh2A(2K6>G7(2Kh2?26LQhF4@2Fh2?26hJ432FhI>AKM2?@Fh,-'Ct?227Gt2?t2F@>?47(GIJ1!^-b(-f(,-'.e(!

<7@4>?73!:2J>6M!06>L67MM2!`%F@>?47!,-,-a!^,-'.e(!<7@4>?73!:2J>6M!06>L67MM2!`%F@>?47!,-,-a(!

#GG6>52I!8Q!*>526?M2?@!>?!'C@E!>J!S7Q!,-'.(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hh644L4_7?@F2324(22hF4@2FhI2J7K3@hJ432Fh644L4_7?@F2324hF@67@22L478K6>>h22F@4,-,-h22F@4,-,-t@2L25

KF_757t'C(-.(,-'.(GIJ!!

<7@4>?73!:2?2R7832!%?26LQ!#A@4>?!037?1!<:%#0(!^,-'-e(!%F@>?47?!S%#=!7?I!S4?4F@6Q!>J!@E2!%?546>?P

M2?@(!U%#1!#57437832!>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(427(>6LhG>34A42F7?IM27FK62FhG7MFh2F@>?47h?7M2PbBCB'P

2?(GEG!^-k(-f(,-'.e(!!

<%%#0(!^,-'Ce(!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?(!S4?4F@6Q!>J!%A>?>M4A!#JJ746F!7?I!=>MMK?4A7P

@4>?F!^,-'Ce(!%F@>?47nF!=>MMK?4A7@4>?!@>!@E2!%K6>G27?!=>MM4FF4>?!K?I26!#6@4A32!,C^,e!>J!"462A@452!

,-',h,kh%)(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hh2A(2K6>G7(2Kh2?26LQhF4@2Fh2?26hJ432FhI>AKM2?@Fh,-'Ct?227Gt2?t2F@>?47(GIJ!^,b(-k(,-'.e(!

;"l++%%!i!S):%(!^,-',e(!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!0>34A42F!7?I!S27FK62F!4?!%F@>?47(!S>?4@>64?L!>J!%)!7?I!

?7@4>?73!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!@76L2@F(!$7334??!)?4526F4@Q!>J!$2AE?>3>LQ(!$7334??1!+2G@2M826!,-',(!#57437P

832!>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(>IQFF22PMK62(2KhGK834A7@4>?Fh?7@4>?73P62G>6@Fh2?26LQP2JJ4A42?AQP

2F@>?47(GIJ1!^,C(-k(,-'.e(!

;%="hU%#!(^,-'be(!%?26LQ!0>34A42F!X2Q>?I!U%#!=>K?@642F(!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@G&hhRRR(427(>6LhGK834A7@4>?FhJ622GK834A7@4>?FhGK834A7@4>?h%F@>?47,-'btJ622(GIJ!^,C(-k(,-'.e(!

06>AK62M2?@F(! ^,-'.e(!:W#+!R28PG7L2(!#57437832!>?34?2&!E@@G&hhRRR(6_7F(22hA>,P2?hG6>AK62M2?@F1!

^'-(-f(,-'.e(!

:44L4! _4??4F5767@2L25KF2! F@67@22L47(! ^,--ke(! y<7@4>?73! :273! %F@7@2! +@67@2LQz(! #57437832! >?34?2&!

E@@G&hh644L45767(J4?(22h36'hR28hLK2F@hF@67@22L471!^-b(-f(,-'.e(!

$67?FG>6I4!762?LK_757!,-'CP,-,-(!^,-'Ce(!S7H7?IKFP!H7!_>MMK?4_7@F4>>?4M4?4F@2264K@M1!,-'C(!!

y$67?FG>6@!"2523>GM2?@!037?!,-'Ci,-,-z1!#57437832!>?34?2&!

E@@GF&hhRRR(644L4@27@7H7(22h7_@434F7hb,'-h,,-'hC--'h762?LK_757(GIJ{1!^,b(-k(,-'.e(!

Yv34FwEK!_74@F2!F27IKF(!^,--Ce(!:44L4!$27@7H71!:$!U!,--C1!Cb1!,Df!y#M842?@!#46!06>@2A@4>?!#A@z1!#57437P

832!>?34?2&!!E@@GF&hhRRR(644L4@27@7H7(22h7_@h',b',,-'b-k,1!^'-(-,(,-'.e(!

/KGG26@73!U?F@4@K@2(!^,-',e(!9>R!@>!I2F4L?!7?I!4MG32M2?@!2?26LQ!2JJ4A42?AQ!G>34A42F(!#57437832!

>?34?2&!

/0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;<!=>?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-!


E@@G&hhRRR(84L22(?2@hM2I47hJ4326tGK834Ah,-'bh''h,fh84L22t@[@t---ktGLtE>Rt@>tI2F4L?t7?It4MG

32M2?@tG>34A42F(GIJ1!^-'(-k(,-'.e(!

/KGG26@73!U?F@4@K@2!7?I!%A>JQF(!^,--De(!%?26LQ!%JJ4A42?AQ!/7@AE(!%573K7@4>?!>J!<7@4>?73!%?26LQ!%JJ4P

A42?AQ!#A@4>?!037?F(!T4?73!:2G>6@(!/KGG26@731!=>3>L?21!,--D(!#57437832!>?34?2&!!E@@G&hhRRR(2?26LQP

2JJ4A42?AQPR7@AE(>6LhJ4327IM4?h22RtI>AKM2?@Fh">AKM2?@Fh:2FK3@Fh%%/tP

tT4?73t:2G>6@tZK3Qt,--D(GIJ1!^-'(-k(,-'.e(!

!

Documents

649690 Landscape of energy efficiency policy packages in a multi … · 2017-01-11 · /0!'1!"2345267832!'('! ! 9%:;?@67A@!?>&!BCDBD-! Landscape of energy efficiency