Upload
others
View
9
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
���������� ������������ ������������ ������������ ��
������������ ��������
����������������
������������������������
������� �����������������
������� J a m e s S . C o l e m a n !"#$ F o u n d a t i o n s o f S o c i a l T h e o r y ( 1 9 9 0 ) %&�'��()*+��� ,-�%��./012��34567 R o b e r t D . P u t n a m � M a k i n g D e m o c r a c y W o r k : C i v i c T r a d i t i o n s i n M o d e r n I t a l y ( 1 9 9 3 )�83�9:;<7=��>3? ( s o c i a l c a p i t a l )@=��>3?�ABC DEF7���G� HIJKLMN ( F r a n c i s F u k u y a m a ) O7PPQQ&RSTUV�()W��3XYZ��[ [ T r u s t : T h e S o c i a l V i r t u e s a n d t h e C r e a t i o n o f P r o s p e r i t y ( 1 9 9 5 ) ] �4�:\� ]^_�!`a���*+%bc ( Y a m a g i s h i a n d Y a m a g i s h i 1 9 9 4 )� `de�7���f/g�hi� ���ajklmY��_n`opqrsthiCu�vwxy ( B e r g , D i c k h a u t , a n d M c C a b e 1 9 9 5 ; L a P o r t a , e t a l 1 9 9 7 )@z56`op{thi�|} ( K n a c k a n d K e e f e r 1 9 9 7 ; Z a k a n d K n a c k 1 9 9 8 )�
Y~����!8�2_���/g��#������ 8�;����� ��a:��w�X`a���Ll6��w��
�����������X�_��! ,-������,-���5���hi���>���xy����qr��X7!�
���9Ll��_��_6�w ���7�l ¡�8¢££¤¤���� _¥¦¢��%�`L§"kL¥¨O©ª« �K¬§f`ªK §�ªK O®¯O°±O²³� 8d´µ¶ª¢L¶ª·¸ ¶ªK 6¹©º»¼�w�X� »½8ª¾¿F7��� ,-� Àhi� ÁÁ�Â�ÃÄ� �!`LÅÆÇ����8ª¾¿`¶�¬aaÈ8]^��/g�ÉÊ
�aj� ��Ë�6|Ì�wÍ@ÎÍÏÐLl�MÑ��hi�
Ò��5�ÓÔÕÖ 3� ��Ll!ÕÖ×Ø9bÙ��klÚÛÜÝ�Þ>�!ßÞÀàáâã�äåæçèL�éêèL
2
�]� `���8ª>��5_ÚëÝ ( M c K e a n 1 9 7 5 )�,-� Ò��d´µìí� ²³îßÚÛïð!ìí�ñòóôê� õ���7²³îßvw�ö÷ø ( W a r r e n 1 9 9 9 )���� ùÇ���ú��aÈ9�û�ø�`�ü5�!ýþ��9ïð�� ( G e l l n e r 1 9 8 8 )�`ü���î��56���9( G a m b e t t a , 1 9 8 8 )�
3ñ�_� *+���hi,-���×`~�d�� !8(+ñ%��_7å�Þ@7õ�Þ� �l�Ã�7�*����@»½Y~���!_���9�E�7_�����l
���9KR�����n��f� 9K�!"#�èK�!
"Í$�§%&'��`a����(\+ï)`*+,� 3ñ-EYR¢DE�.�DE���8¢;<Í$�E»���/��
�ó3!"0120� .3DE!456� »½���`\+�óôê7���låæ�\+89�.:DE;<&9KR����
���l�=)Í$>?�1@�DE7¢AB��+�
��������CCCC�~�����~�����~�����~����
���������� ���������������
�������� !��"#$%�&�'()* +,-.��
�/.0��1�2�.��345��6���.789:; <= >
0��1�?@ABCDEFGHIEJKHIELME�NOME
PQRSEPQ/TEUVE�NW2EX5Y.Z[\2]��^
�_0��1�`78ab;K�.��c3���c3d� e ]
f�ghi� ��E� ��E��jE ��Ehi ���k
lm�n op�q
��r����s>0��1 +"#�/tu.d_�vd!
wK�dCrx.2yz{2�|}~����rx.2����
�����&����.���z{2��/����������
�t������������.����vd!.����rx
.2���.�G � ����� ¡¢�£¤¥� +wH2�
JKrx.2¦d§¨��6©ª{;«d!�gw0��1d�H
2�JKrx.2yz{2�¬JKrx.24®��J¯&�2
.�G(OM�G�°±.2�²(rx¡³�OM( +9:.�
�(±´µ¶.�¬W2·���(�¸9:.lm�¹º�UV»
»(¼���X¦�V½��¾x�/T»»(¼���PQ¿
À�¿À��;Á�UVy/T� +ª{OM�¬�&ÂCOM.
3
UVy/T²(W2¡³�ÃÄOM(��Å9.W2��OM.�
�3ÆÇ5È��NW2.��3ÉÊ����6©ª{;Ëd!�
gw0��1d�H2�OM�W2yz{2ËZ_�ÌÍÎÏËd
!�q
�Ш.s>0��1+ÑCÒ!kp r i n c i p a l c o m p o n e n tpq"#¼ÓdÔ��ÕÖt×ØZÙÐ��¼ÓÚÛ"#Ü�ÂÝk
v a r i m a x r o t a t i o np���ÞÏß; à ¼Ó�á�.âãÁäåæçß;èéêëìí�lm�n <�q
q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qn <EÑCÒ!¼ÓdÔq
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qîï¼ÓÚÛ( v a r i m a x r o t a t i o n ) Âq ðq q q q q
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
q q q q q q q q q q F 1 F 2 q F 3 q F 4
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
�ABCD.�� 0 . 0 4 9 0 . 1 0 8 0 . 8 2 9 - 0 . 0 6 3 �FGHI.�� 0 . 0 2 5 0 . 0 2 5 0 . 7 7 7 0 . 2 7 8 �JKHI.�� 0 . 2 4 6 0 . 1 9 6 0 . 5 1 4 0 . 5 2 1 �LM.�� 0 . 1 0 8 0 . 1 4 0 0 . 1 2 7 0 . 8 7 0 ��NOM.�� 0 . 6 4 6 0 . 1 4 0 0 . 0 3 7 0 . 5 2 1 �PQRS.�� - 0 . 0 0 1 0 . 8 5 2 0 . 0 4 8 0 . 0 4 0 �PQ/T.�� 0 . 2 6 4 0 . 7 9 3 0 . 1 5 5 0 . 1 4 0 �UV.�� 0 . 3 8 5 0 . 5 9 1 0 . 0 4 7 0 . 1 9 8 ��NW2.�� 0 . 8 0 4 0 . 1 8 5 0 . 0 0 4 0 . 2 0 0 �X5YZ[\2.�� 0 . 8 2 0 0 . 1 3 9 0 . 1 3 2 -
0 . 0 4 0 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ âãåæk%p 2 0 . 2 9 3 8 . 7 6 5 4 . 9 5 6 9 . 7 0 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ qq
q q îï¼ÓÚÛn}���NOME�NW2.����X5Y
Z[\2ñz{2ò.��ÚÛ�ó�¼ÓY�¡�RSE/TEUV
4
.���ÑÉÚÛ�óô¼ÓY��ABCDEFGHI.���
ÑÉÚÛ�ó«¼ÓY�£õ�¼Ó�ÑÉ�LM�JKHIö
�NOM&���lm(÷øù;Ëd!����.úû(,-
.�üýþ�óô�Âð + À(�W2�.����ó«
�Âð��ð.(�H2�.������(º�Áäó�yóË
¼Ó��.����ó˼Ó�A2yFGHI±.JKH
I�LM/I����� *����Á��FGHI��(HI
��Ä�ºA2yFGHIH��¬��NW2¾È�(ÉH��[
��(�JKHI.�����;�H2�.���y�OM�.�
���v¼Ó���������NOMy�NW2.��5�
�z{2.��ÚÛ��¼ÓY���NOMy�NW2�4(W
2��������.(�?��óô¼Ó�.«>W2��NO
My�NW2.¦�����a�(����½�G�ñ t r a p p e d r e l a t i o n s h i p s ò�g0��1ý!� Á!.�G�!�UV"A�/T7#�÷�K����$%UV&/T�G���>�G��ºm
�t'��JCÌ(Ê�Ãĺ��)�t*[.��(�+.�¡
�NOMy�NW2�z{2�6(>§,-.�G���&��.
/ +01�t�¼��0��1'�.CÌ|2�Jlm(���
�§,�G�����°±�3É��.(����45{6Ö7
¯���NOM�à ��88��.OM�4 ���NW2�`
78aúû��9�:v ;YÖ��NOM�. �+�&
�¼�����Á������NOM.���5���X5���
��OM�.���v¼Ó��q
��wó�¼Ó��.��<��X5���=óô¼Ó�>
n.��<��W2�.���=ó«¼Ónç.��<��
H2�.���=£õ�¼Ó?�.��<��OM�.���
�q q q q q
��Ë>��¯���r�H2�.��35£µ�OM�.�
�3?�W2�.��3@?�X5��3£A�q
�¼ÓdÔ�Âð.d_.��Y�"�BCD�sÂð.d
E���&+F��GB.HI�q
q
q
n oE< = ��Âð.JdÈdEq
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
5
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q ���� � ���� � � � ���� � � � � ��� � � ����� ��
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q L q q q q q q q q q q q q L q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q L q q q q q q q
q L q
ABCD.��q q q q q q q q q q = M o q q q q q q q q q q = M N q q q q q q q= M O q q q q q q q< O M P q q q q q
q P o M o q q q q q q q q O O o q
FGHI.��q q q q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q< M Q q q q q q q qà à M à q q q q q
q e N M = q q q q q q q q O O o q
JKHI.��q q q q q q q q q q < M o q q q q q q q q q q R M o q q q q q q < e M < q q q q q q
q O O M = q q q q q q q P M e q q q q q q q q q O O o q
LM.��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q = M O q q q q q q q q q q à M Q q q q q q q qO M P q q q q q q qO à M Q q q q q q
q o N M N q q q q q q q q O O o q
�NOM.��q q q q q q q q q q o M N q q q q q q q q q o O M Q q q q q q o R M P q q q q q q
q à = M à q q q q q q q < M o q q q q q q q q q O O o q
PQRS.��q q q q q q q q q q à M < q q q q q q q q q < à M N q q q q q N o M N q q q q q q
q à e M o q q q q q q à M < q q q q q q q q O O = q
PQ/T.��q q q q q q q q q q = M R q q q q q q q q q < à M o q q q q q N R M P q q q q q q
q à à M < q q q q q q q = M R q q q q q q q q q O e R q
UV.��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q o M < q q q q q q q q q < N M Q q q q q q à N M o q q q q q q
q à = M e q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q q q O O o q
�NW2.��q q q q q q q q q q P M P q q q q q q q q q o Q M = q q q q q à N M Q q q q q q q
q o = M à q q q q q q q = M o q q q q q q q q q O O o q
X5YZ[\2.��q q q < = M à q q q q q q q q q < P M < q q q q q à < M Q q q q q q q
q o R M O q q q q q q q = M o q q q q q q q q q O O o q
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q
q��&0��1¯S2��H2.��3£Ê�r�ABCD
�ysd �.2Êç R RL�¡r�FGHI �ysd �.È4
sd.Ê�ç R Q M àL����HI��>�A2.����¯T.Ë
UV���&~W.×X��A2.���UV.YZdE�n N
�q
q
n NE�A2.��c3�˯TUV.dEq
6
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
�A2.��q q q q q q q q Y[ q q q q q q \] q q q q q q ^_ q q q q q q `aq
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q q q L q
hi���q q q q q q q q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q q q q= M = q q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q q = M = q
���q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < M < q q q q q q q q q q= M = q q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q q = M = q
�b-q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < M < q q q q q q q q q q< M < q q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q q = M = q
��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < à M Q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < O M P q q q q q q q q q o = M N q q q q q q q q
q < N M Q q
hi��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q P o M O q q q q q q q q q q q q q P o M < q q q q q q q q q q q q q Q R M Q q q q q q q q q
q P O M N q
kc\pq q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < R = q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < R = q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < P Q q q q q q q q q q q
q R e q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
C h i - s q u a r e = 1 3 . 1 8 1 , d f = 1 2 , p = 0 . 3 5 6 K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q
¬(���FGHI.��c3Y��ËUV�·nI�}~
.×Xñ�n à ò��Äw +���hi +��¶c.lm�ËUV
����×��¬Y[&d� O =L.2r�FGHIhi +���
¡�`a��Èe²&0 NPL�q
q
n àE�FGHI.��c3�˯TUV.dEq
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
�A2.��q q q q q q qY[q q q q q\]q q q q q^_q q q q q`aq
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q q q q q qL q
hi���q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q < M < q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q < M < q
���q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < M < q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q = M = q q q q q q q q q < M < q
�b-q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q q q = M e q q q q q q q q q N M Q q q q q q q q q q o M < q
7
��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q N Q M à q q q q q q q q à = M e q q q q q q q q q à P M Q q q q q q q q q q e Q M R q
hi��q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q O < M < q q q q q q q q e Q M R q q q q q q q q à Q M O q q q q q q q q N Q M R q
kc\pq q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q < R = q q q q q q q q q < R = q q q q q q q q q q < P Q q q q q q q q q q q qR e q
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
C h i - s q u a r e = 3 1 . 5 9 3 , d f = 1 2 , p = 0 . 0 0 2 K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q
2��OM.��c3V�óôQ��HLOM.��c3�f
?��A2yFGHI.���& P P M =L.2r�LM +yhi
+������.c3�ghd�;��NHI.���r��N
HI �yhi �.ȹ� Q à M eL��lm(�q��H�º�U
�.45ij¾�k.��UlÄ�(��&.UV�¡(��5¾
m�¨.LM�q
n�ó«Q.(�W2.������W2.����¼Ó¾
ZG.«Âð�g�PQRSE/TEW2.���op +��
�hi +��.JdÈ��� à= q e =L�¡�PQRSy/T.�
�c3�@È�UV.���Ê�n}PQ�¯T.eÉ+�q
��c3£2.(�NX5���g�:r¨�&�¨�.0
��1.�����HI���ðX5��.«Âð¯���NO
M.��c3£Ê� +���hi +��.ȹs à < M OL��Z
(¼���NOM���!.t;+uv(���NOM���
��.2Z �wá�Á�wÜ.OM�¡�����NOM���
���.2�wá�Á��NW2�& x.(�r�X5YZ[\
2ñz{2ò +��yhi +��.ȹ� o R M PL�Ê���NW
2.���r��NW2 +��yhi +��.ȹ²&
o= M OL�2���5��NW2.��3�z{2.��3�2
���>Áä(�v(y���NW2���.2�Zz(¼�{>
мÀ�COM.2�|�NOM��(�Ý}~��K�(���
3 þ.2�Ãĺ��X5YZ[\24�ÈK���. �+�
���q
��X5��£2�lm(÷ù8;����¯T(�2�
�3TA.�����&�¾�Já���X5��~�|2���
- �a¯T.X5��2�JáTA.X5�����.��8�
Y�&��8ù���²(�lÄ¡³�T8Y�?@¯T��.8
8
ù���üý¹±�ù}�¾���YZ[\TA¡��¯T(�
��3TA�q
¸ I n g l e h a r t qÑ%.�������p�������ó�?w¯T?@�78�1¯�lmHI�`78.Ës�TA¯�q¯T
¾�Z[\2����.ȹÊçJd�s�q»?�������
���nYóË��»Ê�Z[\ó«��TA�4Ê�?@�T�
�.Z[\/tHçTA��lmÕ I n g l e h a r t Z��Á�+���.78tu�;�q ñ I n g l e h a r t 1 9 9 7 : 1 7 3 ò�q���«��vQ4Ì�a��/���?�¯T"#;78�qK�.lm�ÄÈ
I n g l e h a r t q.É2���q¬�ÄÊ��&��ÑTAy ¡�ÑTAqñM a n a b e 1 9 9 5 ò�q������q I n g l e h a r t q"#; �¢.�����78���£Ës¤TAy�¦�¯T4?@���q�?.lm
��v?.lmZ/¥X��&d�Jd¦s.¯T2��K�¾
�Z[\2����q ñ I n g l e h a r t 1 9 9 9 : 9 1 ò�q�Ä I n g l e h a r t q�ý!Áä¯T2º�Ê.��3�¬K³��§þ��.\¨&�;
�����©�À.78~ª�&Jd«s.2¾�X5YZ[\
2������ȹÈ�)«78lm2�[���(¼���.
78*jb��(¼�¯T.X5��Ü�¬F®�q��s�>�
�T.X5��4¯°;�[q ñU s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g )�_DË�Ò`SEE:U�LmY��ê�2�LF¨��8!��êG^
Hpr��ßK � I
CD� <= Âð�ËUV.dE±²���HI�ËUV�
.×�|Z�Y[³_���Ê�JáUV�`a[_���2�J
áUV�¡\]�^_.[«��sd´��lm�n e�q
q
n eE< = ��Âð�¯TËUV.JdÈdEq
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � �� ��� � � � � � � � � � �� ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� ��� � � � � � � �
� C h i �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ������ � � � � � � � � ������ � � � � � � � � � ������ � � � � � � �
������ � � � � � � � � � s q u a r e �� � � � � � � � � � � �� ���� � � �� � ���� ��� � ������ � � � ��� � � T e s t �� � � � � � � � � � ��� ���� ���� ������� ������� � ���� � � � P q
µµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµµ
µµµµµµq
q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q q qL q q q q q q qL q q q qL q q q q q q qL q q q q q qL q q q q q q q qL q q q q q qL q q q q q qL q
9
ABCDq q q q q q < à M Q q q q q P o M O q q q < O M P q q q P o M < q q q q o = M N q q q q q Q R M Q q q q q < N M Q q q q
P O M N q q q q q = M N e O q
FGHIq q q q q q q N Q M à q q q q O < M O q q q à = M e q q q e Q M R q q q q à P M Q q q q q q à Q M O q q q q e Q M R q q q
N Q M R q q q q q = M = = o q
JKHIq q q q q q O à M Q q q q q < Q M à q q q Q N M Q q q q q e M P q q q q e R M R q q q q q q q à M N q q q q O e M N q q q q
à M o q q q q q = M = = = q
LMq q q q q q q q q q q q e Q M R q q q q N Q M à q q q O Q M à q q q o = M = q q q q O Q M R q q q q q < Q M < q q q q O O M N q q q
< N M Q q q q q q = M = = = q
�NOMq q q q q q e à M Q q q q q q N M o q q q q à o M O q q q q = M e q q q q o Q M N q q q q q q = M e q q q q N = M e q q q q
= M = q q q q q q = M = = = q
PQRSq q q q q q e o M < q q q q q o M < q q q q à à M à q q q q à M o q q q q à o M Q q q q q q q Q M = q q q q N Q M R q q q q
o M < q q q q q q = M < Q O q
PQ/Tq q q q q e < M O q q q q q < M < q q q q N R M e q q q q = M = q q q q à e M à q q q q q q < M O q q q q N e M P q q q q
< M < q q q q q q = M o Q < q
UVq q q q q q q q q q q à e M N q q q q q = M e q q q q N o M < q q q q = M e q q q q à O M e q q q q q q = M e q q q q N e M P q q q q
= M = q q q q q q = M = N < q
�NW2q q q q q q N = M = q q q q q = M = q q q q < o M < q q q q = M = q q q q < O M = q q q q q q = M e q q q q o O M N q q q q
= M = q q q q q q = M = = = q
Z[\2q q q q q N P M à q q q q q q = M = q q q q o P M R q q q q = M = q q q q o Q M P q q q q q q = M e q q q q < O M P q q q q
= M = q q q q q q = M = = à q
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K
K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K K q
q
C h i¶t·�~ª�ËUV����JKHI.��ELM.��E�NOM.��E�NW2.��Y�Ê3~W=¡��FGH
I.��yX5YZ[\2.��Y�4&|~W.×X=��UV
.��Y�È(~W.×X���ABCD.��EPQRS.��
EPQ/T.��Y��&��×X�q
:�³_0��1��3×X.iD�¸Õ2�¤¸¹º{.
�×»¼½�¢q ñ¸¹º< R à R ò�¸{Þ���¢(¦s��.T
;�¬��.78n}�9h¾4�¯TUV2¿ÀÄ1l�ÁFV
��6�$%ÂHÃ&».�G¼½uH2�.��Ê�OM�.�
��OM�.���W2�.���W2�.��@��z{2
.��� ¨��×»¼½��»Ä��ÁůT�4Ä��I>¯
T�"�B4���ÆÇ��>���×»¼½�(÷(¯TÆ
Ç�8�Y��×»¼½�4Ä��JáTA�B a n f i e l d ( 1 9 5 8 )�
10
ZÈÉÊ.��HI���.2��3Ø2�)*�Ë��¾��¬
K��A2(|��.�B a n f i e l d�&�� ZÈÉÊ2�³_0��1.��3�ÌÍ��.2����G4ÎI{>�×»¼½��
°�¹Ó(�T��T� ZÈÉÊÜϾ��(���3|Ê
.TAñ I n g l e h a r t.)?78�HI��T�¯T.X5��3�¾YF��Jd¦s+Yò������¸U.�?78n}���.�
�4(>�×»¼½�u�A2.��3çR Q M PL��/T.���
P R M NL��UV.���Q N M RL��z{2.���e Q% ( U s l a n e r : T a b l e 2 - 1 )� ZÈÉÊy�T.¹Ó>n;Ê��X5y2��X5.vØ�ÃÄ�×»¼½�Ä���6vX5���&�¸¾�
��×»¼½�4Ä��JáX5���/.²(c3Y.×�¡³
�q
ap���\+ap���\+ap���\+ap���\+JJJJ��������»½���»½���»½���»½���
ê�KL�7�/��EM�¾è�Nµ���úOPQR�S
TLl�kl����(fUU�n�(V�(_D�W
�/���ú ( t r u s t e e s )_��X�L ( t r u s t o r s )��ß¾èG^'��Y�Z^` 7 0 %�L_6��[�Ln\]`^ 3 0 %�LmY�2�[�Lf7F¨����8�K µ_`����úa¡X
��bê ~�c�LõY~�dõ�èL��eÌ�ª�fg
�Ò3K�Ã�7�*hi������Þ� jã�lk�l45»½���6�\+�!m+86�\+�
óôê3K��noq���låæ�\+=)�Z^!*+9�
l�pq����nA`�r!����ê�~�7�����ó
ô�87�la:�³B�X� �`\+�`\+�`\+�`\+
Ñks�� J a n e M a n s b r i d g e ( 1 9 9 9 ) mY��`t�����7óp�
kL5�ß�uv5�ßr����5�ßÔ��_���!w
8�xyóp v����`~�F¨Æz�ºâ�����
ù_��{|h?}~�kL5�ß_r�G^�d¬�klW
�åæê`�]f!*_� 8����7Ñks���Ñks��7F¨Æz� õYü��µ�kL����d�~�L156�Ñks���� ]^7Ñk³��À�ªåæ���L�
h?}~�l��ê�`Ñks��� !�l���L�9Ò_¯�`Ñk³��� �X7 `8����L\]_2�OAB
11
�7&8�\+��»½��!_�L�M�E�� ¾�����!Ò�Ll��~�L_��~�L�³B��7�"5�ß�u
v� {|�ª¬���ê�2�L7F¨���Lf�Ú7�pÑk����8�Ò� �ù_���_�h�_���·¸�L�_�!7���ê���#��¾è�
��ñò A l m o n t a n d V e r b a ! < C i v i c C u l t u r e > ( 1 9 6 3 ) 9���t¢
�²³K (JKÀ�K )À:¢�²³K ( ¡d�ÑÀ¢ £ )�klÇ������@¤JKÀ�KB§"üK r���k
l¥Ç�Ll�"ü�צß!8ªK f���'��¾Q� �8�§A l m o n t À V e r b a ¨ÆY,-ñò ?� ©�kl�¯�,-ñò7ªLl���«¬�:\®�õ�_������¯�_
��,-ñò�"@ I n g l e h a r t ( 1 9 7 7 1 9 9 0 1 9 9 7 ) Ñ&O�°8�±K�M�²��³��� `ª��´`r��ß�,-ñò@"ü���,-ñò�7�Ô��ßYµ¶�� P u t n a m ( 1 9 9 3 ) ùÍ�·³�{|!�¢K ¸D (�d�Ñ�¹DÀºD )��ñòf56'_�c� F u k u y a m a ( 1 9 9 5 ) O»¼k ��ê�K ½Yt�/�/¾Ô�����/¾¿r����
� À7���»½ ñò�ú�L��2�Á¬���73��
ñòÂÃ��DE@ñòÂÃúóõ�c7�¶�ÄÅ�âÆ�Ç
¬È��� F u k u y a m a �mY��å=ÉÈ�Ê\ËÌ? ( 1 9 9 5J3 4 )73��-Í�z¡°Î�¯¬ ( 1 9 9 5J 3 3 6 )�
ñò¾¿5�&»½_�����Ïß�rÔ n_�����Ïß�rÔÐ�_6ÑÑ&ñò¾¿»½@zÐ�_6³B
&ñò¾¿»½� F u k u y a m a ÒÓapr���� /Ô�����\+"�Ô7ïð!k¢L�ÕúEê�`���³óô� I n g l e h a r t :l�ÖU¢K (�×9K ) Í$�=��ØF��?Ç��(@¤ç�ÙÀÚ �Òhi�K §çÛ³ÙÜFÙÝÞßÙh
i�K OíÖ¯��� 8àáÕ³�ñò»½� n���� I n g l e h a r t Ç��K�����ßf�hiÇâãäÀ,-î߬a ( 1 9 9 9 )�
ñòÒ1���ås!püæ"ÞÔ6&»½_���M��
ß�¾è ��»½����¸D��ß�¾è� ´çÒñò\+��l»½9K]Ç��9����;_êèõYR¢���
ñòéê���¿ � ��R¢�����ß�¬ëì n�!�l¥�`³�5�ÒR¢���ñòÂÃ_�c�3ñ�_�R��
EM���ß¾¿Í$»½� 8�»½Ô`]�l�R���{téê`O2�»��`56Í$�
12
���míÇ�+ ©�8¢\+Ll���ß�7�åb¥�h?%�Ë��
��¥î�L�Õz'Áê]�l�'�d¬�LW�8ªL�
l�_mí� ¬ï ��¥î�L�Õzðñ¥é�ò��ó �l���kLæôõ� W�8ªL7�l�öL����míÇ�\+µèÌ�÷�:\Çø·ù�h?���÷�ú�×!ûü�
ìýþR¿��ç¡ýþ��� '�|L��D��¯���e� �c ��÷��}!�������%Ã�À� �Ì���Ì���kLf7UE���� ¬ï }p9ê·¸�������pÀ�Jô� ì��e56OíÖ¯��!8¢
d�ê r��e7�vh?��¯�� ���míÇ�\+7��A�:\Çøú�h?��pü7
+��e�_��e�h� _ÖÏ�� ����� �_��e �@B`�Þ¬ï�h?�6�"��« ����� ���e �@fB`�Þçé�h���|E � ( E r i c k s o n 1 9 6 3 )�
B>?8¢\+ �l!B�».���ú÷� }� ì��À�����ýþ7�R¿ýþ7�"#�÷$���ek
l�×�������kl }��Ç7�`Ñp"�Ll%�M
���e&�5��7 '�1@�(�l�`"ü�Þ����
\s)*+ \s)*+�Ç�L¬7 C o l e m a n À H a r d i n�C o l e m a n m
Y ��èL7+'���«� ��èL�&p�åæ,`�>�³Ør¡L %� \s�L¿���+«!�7Y�|Íåæ�MÑ ��Á_-.åæ�MÑ� !�_��kL�Xê \sL��Ç`/0f7�p�c���� ����èL�|åæñó�� \sL¼_���èL� Ô`!��èL'56|åæç��!"jk�� ��L� õ�Ò \sL!¼¯7���kL�ÚÛ�1tcÜ �72!���2!-3¬§4A45 37�â3��56s`2� ( C o l e m a n 1 9 9 0 : 9 9 - 1 0 1 )� óp8t¢��\s)*+mY���7¶6�¶7!¶«ê���� 8k 6��77`åß�� k!¶ª«!ê��7�_d´µk!*`«!ê���7� 7®k9:î;�<= 65���º90k« n7��7T>9�?@: 6�_�¯6��k�� "l 6E*���7 7õYkå��»7 Az7{|�påB��f_�3�� 8�å�Ô6ïð!CC��óôê� fg�Ò \s)*+�Ò����¯7%�D¬UE�»�LEM��� �EFM öLM����
\»)*\+GH&IJ+»½Y~���56!\sLEM
¯�� !KLM+�IJ9IJNâ!t�!"j7_O56�w� �7�PQ;R �7� «kAzST7`U`�� [�L
13
EM�aÈF©´V8t¢µ` õ�[�LEM�Õz C��Cñó� p7 ¬DWé �1©�/�XY� öLÀEFEM�aÈù_�� _D7�«Z�O[¥7EF���l`¶�\¯�aÈ� kl���Õz_7�ÛtÛ@7hCB�« kl���aÈf_��^!¶�ÛU�� kl��Wé�_Ñ�@��!!B�è�¨¡��]@z56!�«MZ�MO[M�E
FM^¨Å_`a� õ� �öLEFO[�bÂaÈ|¨kl`d�!���Õz���� ï¥ 'p�»8�`��kl����Br�ª� &IJ+�c¤Ò 2lAdz�åú�ST56efLl�w (�� ) ( A x e l r o d 1 9 8 4 )
]^ 8�_d´µ��O[EFÀöL����g��(@¤ C���aÈUb�U��C� ¥î�8ªL�Õz�h?f�hi��kl���ß� ��ªðh3�p��L �]^�hisOr�ª�
�êã�205� � \s)*\+mY¼¯���aj�Þ76�k¨`a�âØlÀ6��æE�m�no�õ 8¢�ÞUEABü»½�Y~��l�� Lp¥EF ��EFp¥öL��öLp¥[�L� 5��7 \s)*\+�������qGrApsG\s�*+ ( H a r d i n 1 9 9 3 , 1 9 9 9 2 0 0 0 ; L e v i , 1 9 9 9 ) ¥�`�\+twò�
\s)*\+`t¢uvbw� .� ü_6»½Y~�`L���[�L� xy\s)*\+�=)��6_�»7k7_���7�� @��77[�L�� 6�k5�Ò7���»� !_�»7�!"j��78z{ï�\s)*\+�ó3=)� n7 F� I n g l e h a r t �±K��*|}��K�`�~L¬���ê�2�L75����� {|!��ß1Ô�� f`^SEET�L8� �[�L� ��ÒSEET5�& "\]`L�_O\s "����º�K SEE6U���L8� ���»½�� �l�_6Ò �2�º�L�_\s��
\s)*\+�.3¢bw7ü=)*`L�7����!6�
�7��09 0\+ÔÌ��6�7�»2Á@_�6À77~�L kl!��9�åop~�º� kl�å��2Á��>�� �K��³>��} ��e!_�·¸9E�7_���� �(@¤��º�Ur ��U��LO®p¬�èL� �l���9KR���!"7�f7���
îß+ îß���>�7 I n s t i t u t i o n m a t t e r s� 0��mY¶ªîß
��§"üîß��O`Ñp��e�¯�� 8k �_�!�¢`x�,��aAB� ��ÞmY�`�-��çî���Ú¯7Ll����D¬������ !���"jLl7��%�����
14
]^�_7*`/9�,��`Ñp|Í����� �Á,�/0�������3���8�BÂ`�y��î�!�y��îj 3��Çع�8cLl�O56�kL¯���e� ��,�6Í�·&îßï)�âÆY�² (�"7op���¸�L� ) q ��®y¡|kl_ÚТ���P£�¤ U��É¥8c��
��ÓÔkL3��2!-.� !8�îß��j ����`56¨¡|Ì� OÍ�·��,�|¦åbvw�§�ß ¨©�²ª¥��«z�¬kl�,Xr©À_ô ��åæ�*w*Y®�²®Ll��|Ì�,-îß3b�Fs¯¯sÀ5°±s��
:� �îß��:ï¥5�|ÌLl%�M���e� !�������9`'2Lµèjd���²³îß�aÈ�
Y�!�²²²�³´���µ���µ��3XYZ²³��
�[�+ñ¶ ( W a r r e n , 1 9 9 9 )��ª��jA��7�`ÑpÇâÀ·¸²³îß ( I n g l e h a r t 1 9 9 0 , 1 9 9 7 ; P u t n a m 1 9 9 3 )@�~��ùaj²³îß7�`Ñp|ÍLlEM�%����`L¹¤
Ô`!²³îßj���7�\s�IJ�!��çîj¥ß��
kL7UEº���õ�],��»Û�Ll�2Ô6��å
æ� LÀÂF ( L e v i 1 9 9 6 )� Ô`]Ll¼½!²³�¾¿�kl�56��[�L ( M u e l l e r a n d S e l i g s o n 1 9 9 4 )�
�³��Ç�²³çîj����ß��¹r� n7²³���¬a�_d´µ²³fu���«¬aaÈ56d´µ7��
fu�²³� ¥`��56s7¶ª"ü�Þ��hi²³À���ÃÀapt�aÈ�Á+G!ÂÃ�
îß\+�ñò\+�cü5�&»½_���M��ß�
¾¿���»½����9Y~�`ª�����ßrp"ü�
�� 8�0\+=)îß�*`L���g`a� n����%���îß®Ä�_�79s�� �c�îß®Ä (�¯�îß )¶ª·¸56ç�2ª �ª·¸ç�Áª� ç�2�·¸íÖ¯�®ye kl56��eÌ�ª� @ç�Á�·¸bÙ®ye õ@kl���ef��ª� f©Ô`=)îßÅ`®s�îß\+�6»½����%Y~���e!L��_��E� nàá¥�`L�8�ÅÆ�e³�ÇÈ�îß\+v&p�����
z¡óô+ z¡óô+�Ã�ÉU\s)*+����Ê´s»½� \s
)*+mY��Ô56!`¥Õ�h?� LO[EFöLE
M¯� n_D!W¢���`�ªL�}�d¬��2�L7F¨���«!`ªK �8� ��Lr¬�L>��Ë�ê�'�
�&\s)*��»½8¢�ú� ��åæmí�LÌ�7�kl��»"óôf©7\s�n7��åæ���¥Õz�[�L
15
"óô_567\s�p7`Lq�����z¡óô+ ( U s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g )�
z¡óô+mY��5�½Yt�/�míL���7=XY
s��? ( s t r a t e g i c t r u s t )@�[�L���7=z¡s��?( m o r a l i s t i c t r u s t )� z¡s��ïÍ�7��L�¦ß"óô7����Ît¦ß@_7�L�Õz�h?� �¢Ît�L�0åæ*_mí�LO2����{|ñ¥�tlèLé�ò��óf!*
_�G^Ï�åæ���e���ÎtL�¦ß���7~��� "���7¬�"kL!ó3ØFê�åæ�`~�¾è����å
æ7=æ*_ÐÑXpL?�¬�"kLfÒ�8¢�Óp7
��`~�\'_��èLW�kl7����¥Õzq@f_
�Ô�Õz�L� �X7~��|L�åæ�kL��Õ`��Ît®ê�
¦ß��z¡óô+�mY��2Ö¢Lh�_OAB« AB�7{t���klµèÌ���ÀׯE��_ä&567L�Î
t¦ß�uv��klt�¡W%_ä&�ò�%����ß
��jÓ�!JK��!"üK f7��� z¡óô+ap��_ä&���¯�ãhi��»'`ØÇ
d�� ���lÙ� I n g l e h a r t ÀH3���������=)�l�R�����ïÍ�9K����ßjÓ�ÚÛ��_ä&Ü
�������hi7UE`de�� 5��7�l�`�M�²��±��§¹f_ÖÍ$õ�8¢�X¥BÝ��Í�·�*
� _¥ �CíÞ¹ z¡óô+�ap¢L�ß�L�¦ßh
i_��Ò�F¨àõ� ��ê`LÎt`Lát��0w�»½�8!B �_��צß�L7��NlE��¦���_7
NlE��¦ �l�B��¢L*o���º�Àk*,`�>�!2�Ïßêhik��צß�f©Ll��צßÔ7hi"�
�e�9M�Þ@z� ���l�;<Í$���
�������������\�\�\�\ssss»½»½»½»½
�lmY67���7â¼pt¢��J ( 1 ) 6�73�56s�Þ¹« ( 2 )6�73�56Å�-3`2�ãç6��& S z t o m p k a ( 1 9 9 9 : 1 2 7 ) ��Ò 6�¬�Ö-s ( r e l a t i v e v u l n e r a b i l i t y )� 8%�75�7��L�×OLEFöLÀ[�L�
êã45�6�\+��µ_`r!.�¢¸ã ({6�73�56s�Þ¹ )ê�
16
• Ñks��J`�`Ñk³�¼¯��73�56s�Þ
¹ • ��ñò+Jñò¼¯��73�56s�Þ¹ • míÇ�+J6�÷�h�¼¯��73�56s�Þ¹ • \s)*+J6�7¥îÕ��h?¼¯��73�56
s�Þ¹ • îß+Jîß�y��¼¯��73�56s�Þ¹ • z¡óô+J6�L�¦ß¼¯��73�56s�Þ¹ 6�73�56s�Þ¹\^ABn8¼_7hi6�_��
7�ä�õå� �lmY.3¢¸ã ({6�¬�Ö-s ) �cABõY{|t¢L���¢.:��3�56sw��c�Þ¹k
lG�`_��$Y� &�¢YQf©5�Ò�8¢z\�=)`tæç��7è?éê��7�ªL� Ô=)`���OEè®klë9�?ì:� 8%�O3��56s�t�7¬��@z{|���ªLf#¨��?ì���kl9MW���9:0���O
�� �;7��è?éê�dõ'Aí���è?éêÒõèL3�@-3? ì_¥7²î�ï«@��¢Ô`Ö?ì ���
ªLÒ�?ì7¢_���Ã�õ� ãð���!�À�5��¨g�@@��¯�õ�AA� 8¢YQf5�&»½~�¾¬�Ö-s� ���O3��è?éêÀk��ªLæç@¤ñ�-3�7�?ì�nkë�¬�Ö-s�_��¬�Ö-sâ¼
p2!-3�ñ�F!2!ç-�*,`��>�9ò2�§A� ¬�Ö-s = 2!-3�ñ�F /2!ç-�*,`��>� !�����ñ,9'Á`Lq¡G i d d e n sn G i d d e n s àá
zhjd¡¬�Ö-s!»½��9�ABsZ^k�`&8¢;
<�kmYò`�Þ>�5�|L´`��O¦TrO¦Ît
Oé�!:Oå!�L�¦ß@8�L�¦ß5�|Ì�kL�
��e ( 1 9 9 1J 7 9 )�ï¥ÒbÙ>�56|L�"kLæôõ:�87õY�klÒèL3��2!-3567ó�s��8
%=ó�ô? ( d i s a s t e r t h r e s h o l d ) �rÔ�´çL*,`�>�2Ö`a� �(@¤�¢L���>�UÁ"=ó�ô?UÔ¬�Ö-sUrkU_�d����èL� ïE�¢L���>�U2"=ó�ô?Ur ¬�Ö-sUÔkU�d����èL( L u h m a n n 1 9 9 4 : 2 - 3 )�
��´ç@¤�lÒ�>�¡�ª�7~�Ü �� 8k7��À×é�êã�YQzhÒ�õL��èL�56
ÇØ7ºqåæÀ L���« éL�`3:î��¬�èL�
17
"l7¯¯�Êw�!�Ç��%Êw!L�9ò�µAB�
��� �`�öÊw��`Êwn_¯¯��|L_¨_ Û�×!÷Ð_®9� 8c��¦7_O56�L�øù��Õ`��¦ß��¬ï�ú���LO56��èL�
.:7�����d´µ��*`�_ÚY�lÇû�ü�*`
��(,`¯¯�ü�¹r���À¹2�×é� `8�§wÏý��èL�þ�75�ã�¨g��
.R7Ùø�Ùø7��´`rß5�fs�>�� ¹r�Ùøãä5�|L�¡¹©�Êw«�����öÊwü5�|L§
¹íÖº�¡�öÊw�¹r�Ùøãä¥56Źr��Õ
*�=49å`���?�78¢de�OAB�7Ùø567ª
®��E���!�Ç��%����Öá�7Aí���'
pÙø�ê0:�>� ¬��l5�7+Ùøãär�L/
0§ÙøãäÔ�LOíÖ¯���e� .T7��¡����¡�f7��´`5�fs�>�õY
ü5�ÓÔ��×Ø��m 3�=)`t¢éêÖáxy¬��
L"ä�_�o7"9�L���¡�§�LB¨É� W�����6�¹Ì�W����þ��6�¹Ì��ï�õ��7¡�
¹É���õY¡�5�ok�¡¹©�ÊwŹr���
�Ù�¡`�`Û�L�?�ñ�èL3��óf78��O56
¨¡EF�Â]À��� õ��l`\'=)��¡�ì�LOíÖ��kL�
�êT�>��`opÓÔ¬�Ö-s|¦Ll���e� ÚÛª��7@:�>�_Ñ`ÑpÓÔ6�¬�Ö-sf
`Ñp|Ì6�7����:� ��Y~�5�|Ì6�7����:��8���;<�¯��5 �J��7�|"kL¿kl3_
�d¿�«�6�� =¯kL3_�¿�«7��!������hjkl56_¨_��� õY�����L3�7+'º��«� ]^��kL3��d����O_ �X�� Ùø�w&75�|ÌLl�«¬�Þ¹6��×�kL7�����Þ¹6
�� ´V8�6��L_��Ã��èLf_������àõèL�`�8AÏýLl�kL���e/�OÌ���¡�3b�
��µ���õå� bÙ��xyïð!D¬Ñ&óôê�aÈ¡7_�Ì��¡���6E��7!�¸�EFÀöL"#��e
��!!B���6¨¡EFÀöL�o� ]^¡�¸���Ô7EFÀöLM���n8�µ����56Y�(��� (����) �jóô� �¢��¡�'��L56¨��+��ê�2�L�_F¨��� @�¢` ���¡��Lù56�åbh�9�������2�LOÎt� ��
�hi���t¢�Þ�����l7��j89J
18
6�7���Ïß = 1 - (73��56s X 6�¬�Ö-s ) �!��l!�E"�j~��hi=73��56s?À=
6�¬�Ö-s?8t¢�Þ� hi6�7��56sÞ¹�õå�×J
6�7��»Ïß�8%kâ�m�âÆ7��â7�`
DØh?�DØU#°��ßUr�Ll�EF���
É¥�öL���dõ�;�DØ#y`a (\s)*=) )�êã*+¥����=¾���?àáÕ³�8¢�Þ�ABs� 6!3º����M�6!3º����MU}k�E
FÀöLU2�3º!" (�×Ll��!" )��»fU! (\s)*�$%=) )� 6���¡�°8��(@¤ê0õå_&&p[�
L�n6���¡�UÉkß¡�L���U56Ç�
k��L��7¶¢.:��EF�8��¢.:��
���94J6���L7õY6�EF'��f7
7�EF�9K��%�aÈ¡àá�78�vw� (\s)*�$%=) )� 6��×h��8�×k��� ì�×h�À�Ç�×
h���lz*+¥À��@�f'AB�K����Ç
� }p¶ª�Ç�L§��ª�Ç�L��ßOr
(míÇ�+=) )� 6��צß��¢L�åæÃÀ��×�"Uôd�
�UÎtkU56�kLOíÖ¯���e�_¥
8567¢9M�ÞõYLl��צßÐ�_7Nl
E��"��º�56hi�×¦ß (z¡óô+=) )� 6�Þ¹6��ÙøÏß5�wY1ÞÞ¹6��ªÄ�
�l5�=)�¢LÙøÏßUr"Þ¹6�UÌ�
_¥!�Ç��%�(È)*ç�LlÞ¹«¬�6�
hi���õ�³B�m�f5&1Þ�¢L�Þ
¹6��JK���Ç� +�2�L��ßÔ@�
,ÕY³B�m��L��ß¹r ( P a t t e r s o n 1 9 9 9 : 1 9 2 - 1 9 3 )
19
6���º���¢L���º�Ur"kL�k3�
�ÇØU��õ���º�r�L�;�����ú2
�ö���!9K��º�ªC&7�-.�7�»D
1Þ�n�lmY�(-.���º��_§¬�ü
/�0-.L1r�õ�7�»D7O©�1ÞªÄ�
hi6ãç��ÇØ6��õå
êã²2��ª�Þ3�hi6�7��56s�Þ¹
f�hikãç��ÇØ�6��k���¡�Éß
ÙøÏßÀ��º�&� '�E�`:¢õå�hi6�®ye�@hik7
��d��¬�èL�.�¢õå7k�Êw7�¯¯�
��N�56�456�¢LÚÛUE�:�«�8�
L�(_O���¬�èL�1ÞÊw7�¯¯5�&Ö
�_��ªÄ�7�!77�`j738�h�
7�!¯¯s¹Ì�í�Êw (�K`98,�D�F°B:98�9�>98& )7��ºa²&�.3¢õå7k������OÔ�L_56¯�'Ì�®ye
«�`®ye'���kL�"7[�L�.:¢õå
7���Û����¢��38y'r��E��_ä
&Ll (�"7op���¸�L )�®ye�.;A ��®yeÓÔ�<= ��óô�`��Ç�JK�
������jÓ�_ä&Ü�q_®ye¦Ì`a
>DJKhiFopÜ?ú ( U s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g )�
����³³³³Ç�Ç�Ç�Ç�JCJCJCJC���Y~�������Y~�������Y~�������Y~���� IIII
IIII
��Ò.3K�@�~�c�LíÖ¨¡����3K;<�
@t¢�XJ~�c�LíÖ�kL¯����~�7»½���a
j�Þ�3K�A`7�����"ü��_�*+�©�AB
C!R�����>��l�E"Et·Í$�.�· ¦¢
í¢��Þ������aÈ.3·72ì�VE"� I
IIII
íìíìíìíìEEEE"""" IIII
8k��l �L�Õz�h?!2�ÏßêhiLl���
���:¢ªÄ.&1Þ�L�Õz�h?��7X�L!3º�
���M37"��¡��°8:7D¦¶çsçø×Ø�#y
��l=)LE¡�¢[����7_56�kL`'r��ß�
20
�ïE!�¢ºâ���MU}�øF�LÀ«UöG�Uí
Ö¯���e�<�Õ³�8�`�!]º��R��j�L��ß
1Ô@!]º��U��ê���H��ßùÖár��I� I
I
<<<<����JJJJ!3º!3º!3º!3º���������M�M�M�M�������������������� IIII
17.121
32.2
05101520253035
ËÄÄêÒÔÏ ÎåÖÁ¾ÅÄê Ê®ÄêÒÔÉÏ
�l&JKLÀMNÇâ��OKP�¡1Þ¡�°8ä�
¡�°87 Q R S RL THUÄV¾Y Q W S X¡�°8¾¿'���.Y
�¡�°8E��t�Ç�^:EE��¡�°8! W ZL�j:
EE�! [ \� Q RL�:EE�! Q RL Tä�� U�ê�õ��l
�.Y�EY:/��<3 ¡�°8������aÈÕ³��
l�=){¡�°8U��LUíÖ�kL¯���e� I
I
<3J<3J<3J<3J¡¡¡¡����°8°8°8°8�������������������� IIII
26.7 28.933.5
0510152025303540
19ÈËÒÔÏÂ 20ÖÁ35ÈË 36ÈËÒÔÉÏ
II
!��������9_Á��ª�D��]×Ø`Ñp¦
Ì���� TB r e h m a n d R a h n 1 9 9 7 )�]^f`���_� �( U s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g )�!�l�c39D¦�]×Ø�L^^�Ö�õ��l�7�D�_`a`Ä`×ØwYbÇ�8Ö
�`/×Ø`¢-�µ`Jül�7¶çs×Ø�D�8�×Ø��
�¯��w&/�D��]×Ø�w&¬��«�ê P u t n a m ��çøcÎD��]&� ( P u t n a m 1 9 9 3 )@ U s l a n e r Í@mYçø×ا�]×ØO`Ñp"����� ( U s l a n e r 1 9 9 9J 1 4 6 - 4 7 )�<:��hCD�¶çsçø×Ø��`Ñp"��kL���e�
I
21
<:J<:J<:J<:JDDDD¦¶¦¶¦¶¦¶ççøççøççøççø×Ø�×Ø�×Ø�×Ø�####y�����y�����y�����y����� IIII
100
35.3 31.8 26.1 30.1
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
ÿÌì ¾-³£ ÓÐʱ ºÜÉÙ ´Ó²»
�pL��×h�7��hi"��e�l�`.Y�÷�
ì�×h��>����"hiÍ$Þ¹�_¥.Y���d
6��l7¹"L�� �ú����×h���.Y��²²e�
��dv�l�kl½EYR¢�dCJ{ñf�@ }g��
Ç ( 1 9 - 2 9 g )ñf9 }g��Ç ( 2 9 - 3 8 g )ñfÀ }g��Ç ( 3 9 - 4 8 g )ïKE }g��Ç ( 4 9 g�ê )�'<R5� �_��dC���e7'_�c��_¥<R���5�w
t�»½��7�dU���eUÌ5�ÆEY�dx/«37_
���Ç }g�Lç�¢�Ç�hi��e�¿5�ÆE
YÇhx/�"üK ����(®��Çhx/ÒõY�%�
_7U��L��ßUr ( P a t t e r s o n 1 9 9 9 : 1 8 1 - 8 2 )�
<<<<RRRRJJJJ����ddddC�C�C�C����������������� IIII
16.3
25.530.1
35.4
0510152025303540
19-29Ëê 29-38Ëê 39-48Ëê 49ËêÒÔÉÏ
I
z¡óô+mY���ôdÀ��Ît�LOíÖ��kL
�<TÀ<6àáÕ³�8¢\+��åæ*o�"UEôd�L9
` X R i�=��ê�2�L?�}��@�åæ*o�"�_ôd
�L�kL�����_��� I
I
<<<<TTTTJJJJ�åæ �åæ �åæ �åæ ì�ì�ì�ì�××××ãäãäãäãä����mØmØmØmØ�������������������� IIII
22
0
18.225.1
30.9
75
01020304050607080
·Ç³£²»ºÃ ±È½Ï²»ºÃ Ò»°ã ±È½ÏºÃ ·Ç³£ºÃ
���°úf�����`���aÈ��<65� ��
�0CÎt�L�kLf§¹��@��0Cát�Lxy_
��kL� I
I
<6J<6J<6J<6J�åæ �åæ �åæ �åæ ììììT�T�T�T�@�@�@�@�××××ãäãäãäãä����°°°°úúúú�������������������� IIII
04.8
20.5
34.339.6
0
10
20
30
40
50
·Ç³£²»ºÃ ±È½Ï²»ºÃ Ò»°ã ±È½ÏºÃ ·Ç³£ºÃ
IIII
êãzhÒ¡�làõ���À�Ît��Ô7hi���
���¢9M�Þ�Ð��!µ¶�"ü�Þ3hiL�¦ßj
hi�kL����_¥!N�ÞE"9�l���¯8¢=)7
� ð� I
_Á��àõLl�mAÀÞ¹6�56���¯�hi��l
&t¢ªÄ1ÞÞ¹6�J�7çÙøÏß�7³B�m��<
k���(@¤ÙøÏßUr�L�kL���ßfUrnÙ
øÏß������aÈ_7ôsaÈ�É¥���3�ÙøLl
���ßï@ÓÔ��8¢!"f�!p"üK �JK ( U s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g ò� I
I
IIII
IIII
IIII
<<<<kkkkJJJJÙøÏÙøÏÙøÏÙøÏß�����ß�����ß�����ß����� IIII
23
0
24.2 23.226.3
30.9
40.1
33.3
051015202530354045
ÎÄä Сѧ ³õÖÐ ¸ßÖÐ ÖÐ× /̈¼¼Ð£ ´óר ±¾¿Æ¼°ÒÔÉÏ
I
³B�m�f�hi��ß�!��=��>3?�ñ,9
+���. wfu��jÓ� lm8�@,Õ.mY7O©��
m� ( P u t n a m 1 9 9 5 P a t t e r s o n 1 9 9 9 U�������(�jd�r!E" +��M����aÈê��lï"z@$E�jd�
r!,Õ���aÈê��<e*}8t�M`no�aÈ��ª
_,Õ�L��ß�Ô�,�ö�L56,�7p�qÕ+�ÕE
/�Õr"��ßr��ªnG_'r�@,t��êÕr�L
����ßBr��s� I
<<<<eeeeJJJJ¦¦¦¦ÛÛÛÛ,,,,ÕÕÕÕ����Þ�����Þ�����Þ�����Þ����� IIII
15.6
25.128.7
37.9
0510152025303540
Áã·Ý Ò»·Ý Á½·Ý Á½·ÝÒÔÉÏ
êãt¡�8ª�Þ56hi�kL�����Þ¹jã��
l �¢L*o���º��"��e`~�hi��l=)
��º�rÔ�hi�¢L�¬�Ö-s�@hik��¬�èL
�d��'� I�lÍ@=)��º�UÔ�kL���ßUÔ�
k§¹uv�>DïK�9Kwv�º�`�'��qrn�
�Òwv���º��^ÔpuL�<²��uvEM!��
ßê�`¾Qn¾Q_7'�� I
I
<<<<²²²²JsJsJsJsè�����è�����è�����è����� IIII
24
31.9
27.4
24
26
28
30
32
34
ÄÐ Å®
IIIIIIII
!9K��9´`9--x��.mY7��Àº��ú¶�
n79K`6y?-.ñ�2�-.�"kL¬§��`~�µ
��ºâ�õ��l=)9--._7º�ú¶�¢L7�-.
_�hi"����e�<Uàá³��8�`�Z^-.���ß
§�-����(�(Brn�_§²³-� .r�²³-��
7zF���cÎD�"����º�5�»½Y~�8�L���
ß1r��p-{].kl�7ñf@ }g��5L7kl
��d@_7kl�].böfu�¹Ô���ß� I
I
<<<<UUUUJJJJ,-ã,-ã,-ã,-ã||||�������������������� IIII
34.6
22.9
40
28.3
0
10
20
30
40
50
Öй²µ³Ô± ¹²ÇàÍÅÔ± ÃñÖ÷µ³ÅÉ ÎÞµ³ÅÉ
7�´`»Dbö71Þ��º��O©ªÄ�»D��(�1
��è!pkl��µ¹2���>��<U�|}op¹r��
º��»D��§�(�(´`Or���e� I
I
<<<<U�U�U�U�J»J»J»J»DºDºDºDº������������������������ IIII
39.2
32.8
28303234363840
¸É²¿ ·Ç̧ɲ¿
25
I
Ðѧ,+¨�¯TX54Ò[ÓÙ�Ô´ÕÖ×Ä|eÉ��
ØÀÄÙ¯�³fÚÊÛ¯�¬�ÜÕÖy�xÕÖ§ÝdÞßJá
X5ßà�¼��» Ô´ÕÖ(���á.�ÚÊâ�ÚÊ.�d4
ã�ä��(���å¯TUVX5V��d�;¦ßàuªæ¿
2�çæèé¿2�êæ2D�ë�2DyìíîæÑ�:ïsô
�ë�yêæ2D.��3£Ê��~Ä�K�X5�Q(Ê&
��ªæ¿2�çæèé¿2.��32�ë�yêæ2ð�¬K�
�4&'×X�4��(¼��ªæ¿2�N�T&ñæ�èé¿
2�N�Ùîñæ�Fò��5bß��v_ñæ)2.óiô|�
�6�ìíîæÑ�Ä �&õ�¬K�¯.Z[\ÀÄ(�X5
.ö÷ø{6�¼�K�.��3£2�q
q
<<<<UUUU3J3J3J3J·¸�����·¸�����·¸�����·¸�����
19.7
33.5 32.3
25.929.8
0510152025303540
˽Ӫ̧öÌåÒµÖ÷ ¹ÜÀíÈËÔ± ×Ò̈µÈËÔ± ÉÌÒµ·þÎñ¹¤ÈË ²úÒµ¹¤ÈË
�ðX5�Q.°�À!(iDÑi��r-������ù
X5�Q.��¯�2�4�w³>ÕÖ.sÖ�Cú;"û�º�
�¨�CD��r-���.üý(& ;.����.78�1
¯�)*�&2�r�I�X5.¯Yà&Yà�¬�ë����:
ïs« + ����r-.X5�QþÊ��34þµ�q
I
<<<<UUUU:J:J:J:Jå���¯å���¯å���¯å���¯������������������������ IIII
26
17.9
27.329.7 30.3
05101520253035
ÏÂϲã ϲã ÖÐϲã Öвã
II
��º�E*��hi��7õYühiL�¬�Ö-s�^
@16hi¬�Ö-s�}¥p�¢L�å�®ye����¢L
���¨_¡Ïý�l'�)~k���¬�èL���Ò¥î
9K���²¥ð,`¥�56���!�56�ü���5f
ñ_ ���Á!Å��°±�����¹Ô�Ll�®ye�K
����Ç�]38ê�_ä&�ò�Ll�®ye�jÓ
�<=�����óô��\38�Êw�`Ïý�L�èL��
�ßf¬�Ô�ª T P a t t e r s o n 1 9 9 9«U s l a n e r , f o r t h c o m i n g )�!�l�c39j7À38�L�z����ß1Ô@!ü!7�L
��ß�Br'2���ÀÔ�8L.���ß�pt�EM T�<U
R U I
I
<<<<URURURURJJJJ����8888����""""�������������������� IIII
33.4026.50 24.30
19.50
-
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
ÔÚ̧ÚÔÚÖ° ÍËÐÝ ÔÙ¾ÍÒµ ÏÂ̧Ú»òʧҵ
!=û¯?À=j7? Y�(�X�]Ç9K{|G^!ü
!7f_�¯`®ye�]^!_�/9�í�Êw®ye�`¾
¿�®ye�¾¿`56hiLl���e�<UT���'`de
��(@¤!K laÀK`9«8í�Êw�L��ßrp!¶
çÀB:9«8Êw�L TÔ`Bð«8í�Y� U��õ-,la
ÀK`98�Êw§¶çB:98�ÊwO`Ïý���Y~��
�e1r�7�ª!�>98Êw�L@��e1Ô�L7!�>
98Êw�L���>�(7�>�K`98��>��>98GÏ
ݵK`98��ªµ`�_6��»�ÊwL.n��'pü
7�>x�Ð�§�(K9©�!8�!"j�>98ÊwL.
27
�®ye56rp"ü*`/9�98�@�>98�"7�ª'
�>�>T��98�ØÓ+¾��»�ÊL��d�_ç^
�'��%�ÊwL.®ye561Ô� I
I
<<<<UTUTUTUTJJJJÊÊÊÊwwwwí�í�í�í�ssss������������������������ IIII
34.7 35.9 32.7
22.8 23.1 20.324
11.1
44.8
25
0
33.3
0
10
20
30
40
50
1@��l ��ãä���`~�hi�<U60�l
�Õú7!�¯ÎF¸��Ur��eUÌ«nÉ¥�¯Î
F��e�j�Y~����8�!"���lAz!8
R���ñ�2��²����!TS��yTSEM�!8¢Î
F¸��Ur����º�Ur���É¥�yTSì�L�;³
B`t/��/7B:¢ç8³�/7�9�.�@�ê<*
}8t/L���ßÔp"ü�/L��8f©�»½�Y~�r
���ç���ßï�1Ô� I
I
<<<<UUUU6J��ãä6J��ãä6J��ãä6J��ãäI
28.532.2
39.2
28
0
10
20
30
40
50
500ÔªÒÔÏÂ 500-999Ôª 1000-1499Ôª 1500ÔªÒÔÉÏ
II
êã�l&��âƱÞ���º�����hiklàá�
ª®��¢¬���+J��º������`*hi� I
!8�K%�l����ªí(�Þ������aÈ�8c
¿�»½¼¯���Bå`ØÇd�níìE"\]`'���å
s�j�K�����8ª�Þ����w&� I
2222ìììì����VVVVEEEE"""" IIII
IIII
28
�+�+�+�+
29
References Ýxª 1 9 4 9�Z��9K[ Axelrod, Robert M. 1984. The Evolution of Cooperation (New York: Basic Books). Banfiled, E.C. 1958. The Moral Basis of a Backward Society (Glencoe: Free Press) Berg, Jiyce, Dickhaut, John, and McCabe Kevin, 1999. "Trust, Reciprocity and Social
History." Game and Economic Behavior, Vol. 10, pp. 122-142. Brehm, John and Wendy Rahn. 1997. “Individual-level Evidence for the Causes and
Consequences of Social Capital.” American Journal of Political Science, Vol. 41 No. 3, pp. 999-1023.
Erickson, Erik H., Childhood and Society, 2d ed. (New York: Norton, 1963). Gambetta, Diego, 1988. "Mafia: The Price of Distrust." In Diego Gambetta, ed., Trust:
Making and Breaking Cooperative Relations (Oxford: Basil Blackwell ), pp. 158-175.
Gellner, Ernest, 1988. "Trust, Cohersion, and the Social Order." In Gambetta, Trust, pp. 142-157.
Glaeser, Edward L., et al, 1999. "What is Social Capital? The Determinants of Trust and Trustworthiness." NBER Working Paper, #7216.
Giddens, Anthony, 1991. Modernity and Self-Identity (Stanford: Stanford University Press).
Hardin, Russell, 1993. "The Street-level Epistemology of Trust." Politics & Society, Vol. 21 No. 4, pp. 505-530.
-----, 1999. "Do We Want Trust in Government." In Mark E. Warren, ed., Democracy and Trust (New York: Cambridge University Press), pp. 22-41.
-----, 2000. "Distrust." An unpublished manuscript, New York University. Inglehart, Ronald, 1990. Cultural Shift in Advanced Industrial Society (Princeton:
Princeton University Press). -----1997. Modernization and Postmodernization: Cultural, Economic, and Political
Change in 43 Societies (Princeton: Princeton University Press) -----1999. "Trust, Well-being and Democracy." In Warren, Mark E., Democracy and
Trust (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1999). Knack, Stepher and Keefer, Philip, 1997. "Does Social Capital Have an Economic
Payoff? A Cross-Country Investigation." Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 112, No. 4, pp. 1252-88.
La Porta, Rafael, Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, Andrei Shleifer, Robert W. Vishny, 1997. "Trust in Large Organizations." America Economic Review Paper and Proceedings, Vol. 87, No. 2, pp. 333-38.
LeviMargaret1996. "Social and Unsocial Capital," Politics and Society Vol. 24, pp. 45-55.
-----1999. "Do good Defenses Make Good Neighbors? A Transaction Cost Approach to Trust and Distrust." An unpublished manuscript, Sage Foundation.
Luhmann, Niklas, 1994. Risk: A Sociological Theory (New York: Aldine de Gruyter). McKean, Roland N., 1975. "Economics of Trust, Altruism, and Corporate
Responsibility," in Edmund S. Phelps, ed., Altruism, Morality, and Economic Theory (New York: Russell Sage): 29-44.
Manabe, Kazufumi, 1995. "People's Attitudes Toward Technology and Environment in China." Kwansei Gakuin University Annual Studies.
30
Mueller, Edward N. and Mitchell Seligson, 1994. "Civic Culture and Democracy: The Question of Causal Relationships." American Political Science Review, Vol. 88, pp. 635-652.
Patterson, Orlando, 1999. “Liberty Against the Democratic State: On the Historical and Contemporary Sources of American Distrust.” In Warren, Democracy and Trust.
Putnam, Robert D., 1993. Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy (Princeton: Princeton University Press).
-----1995. “Bowling Alone: America’s Declining Social Capital.” Journal of Democracy, Vol. 6 (January), pp. 65-78.
Sztompka, Piotr, 1999. Trust: A Sociological Theory (New York: Cambridge University Press).
Uslaner, Eric M., 1999. “Democracy and Social Capital.” In Warren,1999. Democracy and Trust, pp. 121-150.
-----Forthcoming. The Moral Foundations of Trust. An unpublished manuscript, University of Maryland.
Warren, Mark E., 1999. Democracy and Trust (New York: Cambridge University Press). Yamagishi, Toshio and Yamagishi, Midori, 1994. "Trust and Commitment in the United
States and Japan." Motivation and Emotion, Vol. 18, No. 2, pp. 129-66. Zak, Paul J. and Stephen Knack, 1998. "Trust and Growth." IRIS Working Paper, #211,
University of Maryland.