42
45 1389 180 - 139 : 1 / 11 / 88 : 20 / 2 / 90 . FUND PAYG . FUND . . . IRR) ( 47 85 % 53 ) % B/C ( 2.6 10.3 3.7 . 53 % . 30 . . % . : . JEL : H55 E61 . [email protected] [email protected] & [email protected]

?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

����� �!"#$%&'()*( +,"%-.( +"� /"01�,23"� 45"67 845 '"-9!: 81389;"<=> 8180-139

?@"6-A( BC!"D E�F#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( !"#$%$&'(%)*'+,- ./0' !1234*'#50'6

:������ !���"1/11/88 :#$�%& !���"20/2/90

?M*:IND :"NJ ,)O5"NO 8?@"6-A( BC!"D +"P!"Q3 +"�,)O5"O B*)D +,"C#J :( ?R*:( SNO)T � E�F#N> ?U"! ?�F3"!:"0 �J �-9J ,)O5"O B*( .F7"VC! "P.�F#> B*(

SCM.I!FUND �JPAYG :"J SC>"W +(5(, 8XRMU"J "* �"N* � +)Y. BCJ H*:ID�N6CJ E�F#N> 5, 4FN7 �N-&)Z )Q3 5, 5"O � :"0 8'I3". �J "#J .,I7 ?! ?$93 BCJ

[I3 :( 8'()*( ?@"6-A( BC!"DFUND \5 H*:ID :"J 8,�5 ?! 5"Q-3( B*()J"#J .S0( +"PJ"9T ?J"*:5( ]�5 :( +)CZ 4)PJ "J )^"T _C`<D .F7"J +)Y. BCJ [I3 :( 4,(,

F7 �6CJ +,()=3( 5, �O F�FC! '"Y3 a*"-3 .S0( �-W(,)� 81P! B*( 'I!:G �J '"Z4,:"J \)3 8bF� �M!"A c$-d! +"� e�,+5(fNZ �*"!)0 ?$W(,IRR) (47"ND

85 BCg3"C! "J %53) �#*2� �J H&"#! SV93 � %B/C 8(2.6 "D10.3 BCg3"C! "J3.7?N!�*"!)N0 4,:"J �-9*"J \)3 8F�FC! '"Y3 [I^I! B*( .F7"JE�F#N> +5(fNZ53 %

]INW 5Ih �J 8;F! F#$J 5, \)3 B*( 8,IAI! +"�,5�G)J �J "#J �RCU"T5, .S0( �3"#CJ30�*(2N&( )L( 'I!:G .S0( ?$93 BCJ H*:ID i6@ 8F�FC! '"Y3 �O .S0( %

E�F#> 4F#*G � /"T +"P$93 )-YCJ '"*: :( ?O"T "�F!G5, H*:ID :"J )J K5ID \)3 ?$93 BCJ H*:ID F*FYD �.F7"J ?!

4k(� :+FC$O +"�'($�( )*+�,-.( /01�" )2�3" )*456 /07 )8$9: /07 );�<3"<�7.�`Vh +F#JJEL:H55 )E61.

$0=> $01( *-?@A B�CD(� ;��@A *EF@G1 BFC96(� ��096(�[email protected]

6(� );��@A *EF@G1 BFC96(� )$0=> $01( *-?@A B�H96(�*+�,-.( 8��I-:( 8�G,-50E J�($K FD�( *E�@D��> 83L9 [email protected] & [email protected]

Page 2: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

140����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

1 .�!F`!�(� *+3M6 N OM63K P�0Q�1 ;�<3"<�7 F�(3� 8(�(� )'R 8( O,07 8��=.( JD3& N *+�,-.( /01�" 2�S6

�� .FD�7 *1 $K O,07 N BFD O,07 /07 �1 )F-E N�M1 �3M9> �� BTM�N OM7 N *+�,-.( /01�" 8�G,-50EB$MG7 .$MK OM,07 UNF@MA N �M1$���> )FM@1��> �M� $K��> :<( F@"��=+ *+�,-.( /01�" O6�K OE V�>$D

8W *X�KR N )*+�,-.( �Q(F+ 8($.( ���3Y1 �7 O6�K OE V�>$D <( Z� $X [�\-6( N 8F@1'�M?\6N ]G1 *+3^31 )UNF@A /�( �� J�3_ �0?^N <(.FD�7 *1 O.3" a7�:

;M�<3" :FM6�(� BFMG+ $M7 (� FM1R�� ;M�<3" [3M6 OME �M13,+ )*+�,-.( /01�" 8( O,07 8�G,-50EF1R��) ;�<3" N *b�( )8�3,+-*Mb�( N 8�3M,+ ;M�<3" )'�M01 /�( <( .*KF6< aC0E �� (c$I1

(8$9: /07) e4-f1 ��9:( /07 F1R�� ;�<3"<�7 '(3@+ O7 g0"$" O7 )�XF1R��1�7 N�� FM1R�� ;�<3"<(*45@Q( /07) $^�h a56 /0@i,X N �G456 /072.�3D *1 BF01�6

*M1 $M" ZM��j6 �3MY1 �Q(FM+ N O63K P�0Q�1 ;�<3" 23G\1 O7 8$9: /07 ;�<3"<�7 )/07 /�( <(<( )�$M0K *M1 P�3MA *4M5@Q( /0M7 �M� 8$M9: /0M7 ;�<3"<�7 '(j01 Ok $^�h l�h �� OC@�( N FD�7

��3_$7 8���< �0,X(.�E( �(2�3"3*+�M,-.( ;��M@1 N ;M�<3" <�M7 /M�( $M7 �(%K $0m�" a1(3+ <( *C� )F6(3" *1 j06-8��MI-:(

�� 2�3M" a1�+ 'F6�L@K N *?�<3"<�7 lF1 *7��<�( 8($7 *I_�D On(�( �7 (%Q .FD�7 )O6�K OE V�>$D.�(� !E�& j06 a1�+ /�( $0m�" O7 '(3" *1 )'R

7 $7 BFD 2�L6( O7�91 P�b0bY"JL@ME �$C�N� �7 )*+�,-.( /01�" 8�X 2�S6 �� F1R�� ;�<3"<���MCX(� /-��M� N $M0b� �($�( O7 F@,"N$m �($�( �,E <( F1R�� ;�<3" �� �X ]-50E /�( �0b�31 '(j018�MX UNF@MA �M��3Y1 �7 j06 P�b0bY" /�( <( 8�(F?" .�E( B�37 ]506�C1 /�( �3=G7 �G. )*n�X

*A3I_ 8( O,0744,+ JL@E NOMn(�( )oM0bY" /M�( �$MC�N� /C0Q .�E( O-�$K P�3A �G6R �$CZM� $MX O> FD�7 *1 [3^31 /�( '�3,6 pf91 N �3>%1 ;�<3"<�7 N� 8�$7��> ]0X�\1 '�1j,X

.��(� BFD O,07 [�\-6( $7 8$0m�" Ok N 2�L6( l�h �� �(Fb1 Ok O7 �1 �39> �� ;�<3"<�7 N� <(5

1. Within-cohort Redistribuation2. Intergenerational Redistribuation3. Inflation4. Private

5.8jM�� OM1�6$7 $M-�� o7�ME 'N�M?1 N ��MI-:( FMD�( q�@MD��> )�3Mr04+ s( �,?6 8�:R t�@. *E�@D��> P($S6 <( o0bY" /�( ��.]0n�,6 *1 2u+( (� J�3_ q�rE N $�Fb" g"($1 O> ]�( BFD F@1 B$G7 *+�,-.( /01�" '�1<�E *+�,-.( 8��I-:(

Page 3: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,141

2?@"6-A( BC!"D +)Q3 ?3"V! . ��v\54�Im05( *+�,-.( �Q(F+ [36 N� <(:�E( O-�� /fE?PCV#D SU(F@)P(<�ML1 J�FMX O>

*,6 ���+� (� P(�$b1 N /06(3: O> �E( *6�5> 2�," N .F@@>?M*:ID SU(F@)( P��=+ O><( �ME�0Q3x51 '�01 gE�@" ���+�*H-M5��D �M� P(��Mf-�( N �MXJMD3> N �MX2�ML6( �$M� $MX OM> *��MX

*1.FX�1

;,L" <( 8$0H90& N P�0Q�1 *+36 o�$y <( *?�<3" <�7 Jb6 a1�D �QN� �Q�_� 3zE�( $S6 <( $S6 O7 �1( .�E( 8�(%H636�: o�$y<( PN$m2#CO��(FMX N 8��MI-:( 8�G-0Q�?� �� O4_(F1 �7 �QN� )

*1 �G6RO��1$E 2�S6 *"(W N BF,+ pb6 N� F6(3"3" a1(3+ a1�> l�{-D( 2F+ *@?� )�(<R 8�(�N FM0Q.�<�E c$y$7 (� F1R�� N PN$m O6|��+�6 ;�<3"

2U�(5B�H-E�_ )�:�0Q $7 O0C" �7*1 JQ�k O7 )(� '�56( $7 *z0Y1 }�($D N 8$7($7�6 8�X N F9>�0?:31 /�( <( 2(FCi0X*,6 8$7($7�6 BF@@> O0.3" (� �X a7�b1 vzb6 �� j06 $S6 /�( <( N F6(� eN*"�

*1 �($:Mb-?1 ZM��X .�$0K'�M9�( 8�(<R l�M=: �� BFMD ��ML�( �0Q3xM51 <( jM06 }�($MD OM> �3M7 F*,68�(<R )}�($D <( ~��� *+36 O7 N FX�>*,6 *��> (� �XO0.3" �" �56(�8$7($7�6 $KN .FMD�7 �MX

*M1 *M\6 )P�M6�C1( ;�<3" <�7 �� (� �13Ch v4_(F1 N *?�<3" �Q(F+ O63K$X q�E( /�( $7 .�3M,6 �7 jQN(� OC6R l�h*�(�(� $7 �($�( �0CQ�1 '�$,D 2$-Y1 *M�(�(� /�( ;�<3" )'�9�( 8$z� 8�X(� �MX

.F��,6 *1 *b4" *13,+ *�(�(� ;�<3"2

8�3x" �7 )8$S6 *6�=1 SCRU"! _T nF3)CZ )J5, ?0()OI!, N�*"!)04"&5 SU�, )J ?#-V! +5(, .F7�01 #$-5K4"&5 SU�,*+�,-.( 8�GC,> *XF6�1<�E �E�E( )3 jM06 NOM1�6$7 8($M.(/01�M" 8�MX

*+�,-.(4 *+�M,-.( 8�GC,> <( �3S@1 .��(� BFG+ $7 (�)ZM,> N P�1FM_ 2�M5:( N [(3M6(*��MX FM�F. *E�0E N *+�,-.( 8�X<�06 *_$7 J�(F0& g5h $7 '�F1 O?1�. �� O> �E()(FM0& �M0,X(N 8��ML" �3ME '(FMb� N '�3M7 OM@�jX $M& aM0Q� OM7 gM4�( �MG6R 2�L6( N �E( B�$>2FM+ OML0-6 ��

*M1 ��MS-6( �QN� <( )(*13,+ 8|�>) O@01< /�( �� �0Q�?� O7 *A3I_ 8�(%K O��1$E 8F@,:u+.�N��� P($y�Mf1 JX�M> �3MS@1 OM7 *M4> �3My OM7 OM> �E( *��X O1�6$7 *+�,-.( /01�" <( �($1

*��X O1�6$7 .�$�%& *1 P�3A O?1�. �($�( <( ���,h N *KF6< O>�( N l3& �_(�$& �7 P�1F_ On(1 .) )*4E3"1383 � )(56-582.))jQ(�1383 � ) (100

3. Social Aids4. Social Security

Page 4: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

142����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

$7($7 �� (� 2�$1 )O@�jX ]> �� '�H�(� *6�1�� P�1F_ /01�" N *+�,-.( 8�X O,07 N ��MGk<( BN$MK P($y�f1:F@C01 ���,h $�<

1.*K��-�(��> <() .��(� ��(3h N 8��,07 �� O9�� O>2. .8�(�( $0� N O-E(3_�6 8��C073.36�_ B<(F6( '�37 ��j7 <( *D�6 *+�,-.( N 8��I-:( ��9� .B�(4.$0K(N 8�X 8��,07 BT�37 )�X 8��,07�(�*M7 N OM?1�. �1uME '��-�( $z_ O7 g.31 O> )

.�3D *1 *+�,-.( *6�1�E*@?� $97 !���" �$-91 *+�,-.( �6� [36 ��Gk ���-6 N ��mR �7 O47�b1 *+�,-.( /01�" [3^31 )

+5"RCJ )+5"6CJ ))`& � +2Co ?J )cM^ � ?D5F. ?JFD�7 *1. 23G\1�� cFMX ZM� P�3MA OM7 B�(3M,X N FME� *M1 8$M97 !���" �1F: O7 *+�,-.( /01�"

BFD BF�� $97 *KF6<)�E('R O0QN( 8�X O-5X ) '$: ��19 <( N 8�(%K O��&8��MI-:( 8�MX F1�0&*+�,-.()�3D *1 *b4" *-?@A tub6(. aM7�b-1 8�GC,> 8�X /,L6( a0C9")N c3@MA gM4: ��

*6N�?" N *4{D 8�X BN$K*+�M,-.( 8�MX) .�3M7 �-ME(� /M�( �� OM0QN( 8�MX �M>$h'(�N� /M�( ��FM@6(3-7 �M" FM6�$> *M1 �M����� *=ME�@1 �j,-ME� �M,h< O7 O> F@-�$K �($: *-0?^N �� '($K��>e0?M^ F6�$> *1 ��> O> *6�5> g0"$" /�( O7 .F@@> /01�" (� �3_ 8�X B�(36�_ N �3_ P�.�0-h(

�(3D� �7 N F6FD *1 $" e0?^ N$0& O7 )8<(F6( �& '(3" O63Hi0X 'NF7 N 88 .F6F0ME� *18($M7 l�E �� ��7 /0QN(1883OM04+ *13M,+ 8�MX *@07 J0& 'FD 8��=.( O9�F6( )'�,QR �39> /06(3: ��

/01�M" '�MD��> l3MIY1 <( ($IY@1 �G6R �90?1 O> 8�($�( O7 'R '�(� 8$5" N *+�,-.( P($z_.FD �$z1 )F��$K *11 P|3Y" /�( ��9:( <( ���,h �� 8F�F. 8�X ��-_�E 'F1R F�F& O7 $L@

O?1�. e4-f1)*6�MG. �M@. <N$M7 �M7 P|3MY" /�( ��$90& F@k $X .FD 8$K��> ;1(3. BT�37��M> *M44,Q( /0M7 $M-�� o�3M9" $Mm( �� (�FML1 *MQN )FMD *6�1< O\:N ��k� )lN((ILO)1gM0"$" �M7

2N� *6�G. �@. '(�N� �� .���� O1(�( 8F�F. ��12 PN(1941) '�-54H6( �QN� 8�^�b" O7 �@7 O> FD F0: Z0-6u"R �39@1 ]L@& aA( ��"}�($MD )8��MC,X oM�$y <( F@-M5X ],MI1 �MX �QN�

*+�M,-.( /01�M" 8($M7 $"�M0G1 8( O@01< N 8��I-:( ��$90& 8($7 $"F+�51 *?^N )��> 8($7 8$-G7�M& N �($M:$7 2(3M:( N a41 O04>F6<�ME �M.$7". <( �M&N an�M51 'FMD $"��Mh N 2N� *6�MG. �M@.

�@. /�( <( *D�6 8��I-:( N *+�,-.( PuC91)2�S6 P�3A O7 *+�,-.( /01�" O7 <�06$M7 N FM@11. International Labour Organization

Page 5: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,143

*41 *H-5=,X O��&) *+�,-.( /01�" B<N$1( O> �L6R �" )��$K �3_ O7 $" O-5.$7 N $" 8F. *4CD4A ��L�( N $0K($� *+�,-.( �Q(F+ 8�($:$7 �3S@1 O7��ML�( cFMX �M7 N *6�G. �(F��& J1(�R N �

.�E( BFD a�F=" '�G. $E($E �� �G6�56( *KF6< $�%&�6 *n(F. Jf7 O7 *+�,-.( *n35,X N ��Y"($GD *E�E( U3bh O4,.<( *+�,-.( /01�"�� O> �E( 8F6NO1�6$7 gQ�:*+�M,-.( /01�M" 8�X

P�1F_ N*13,+�QN� }E3" ��"F,+ *X����1<�E �� N �X*��G683E<( O>BF�F& �G-QN�BF1RF6( )*1 O���"�$K�.

e�$?" O7 �@7 )*+�,-.( /01�")�E( *13,+ O@01< �� *4,+ �� *636�: ��> B(�)�M0@1( 8($M7 OM>)8$M0& )8��C07 <( *D�6 8F1R�� '�Ib6 l�=: �� '�6R B�(36�_ N ��fD( *+�,-.( B��� N 8��I-:(

�( /0@i,X N P3� �� N 8��,07*Mh($y 8��I-:( 8�X ���,h N *13,+ P�1F_ o�$y <( B��� V�b" .F63D *1 /�(N B�M�� P�1FM_ N �1uME )*+�M,-.( 8�MX O,07 8�X O1�6$7 a1�D F6(3" *1 [3^31

O1�6$7 <( *\0y .FD�7 8F1R�� BF@X� 8��� 8�X�3901 ��� *+�,-.( /01�" '(3@+ O7 'R <( l�L1 /�( �� O> Oi6R)M7 *M@-=1 �13,+OM,07 eM�$?" $

.�E( *+�,-.( /01�" 8(O1�6$7M" 8�MX� B(� �� *+�M,-.( /01OM,07 8�MX��>OM,07 $M7 ��"FM,+ 8(8�MX�E( �(3-E( 8��=.(.OM7 �3M_ �j,-E� <( *-,5: �_(�$& �7 ��=.( N $�jK�6 O7 �($�( �G,-50E /�( ��

" O,07 oh N P�0Q�1 '(3@+�1 �($: �G,-50E /�( JD3& �Y" *+�,-.( /01*.F6$0KO1�6$7 /�(�� �MX��MIY6( *+3M6 N BFD B��0& *13,+ Jf7 ��IY6( gQ�:�� N �(<�7 ]506�C1 <( ���_ *13,+ �Q�h

*1 ]>�h (� *-QN�F@��,6 �$MA�@+ �uM,+ ]-M50E /M�( �� .��(F6 (� 'R <( �N$_ *��6(3" pfD O>O��&*,6 N O-D(F6 8�$7��> �E( �7�:� N t�f-6( '�,X O> �(<�7 8(.F@@> a,+ F@6(3"

BT�N B�H��. <( *+�,-.( /01�" P�07�( �� )'R O63K P�0Q�1 Jb6 N F1R�� ;�<3" <�7 [3^31 �1(.�E( �(��3_$7 8(

8�MX �(jM7( <( *MC� N F6�(� B��� J�(j�( �� *?E gE�@1 8�X �E�0E W�f"( �7 B��� 8�X �QN�F1R�� �FL1 ;�<3" *�(FX( /0@k O7 *E$-E� �� *E�E(1(.�EN *ME�0E B�KF�� N� <( ;�<3" /�(

*n�MX ]M506�C1 N �MX �E�0E O7 F1R�� �FL1 ;�<3" 8��I-:( B�KF�� �� .�E( a1�" a7�: 8��I-:(��3M1 N eM4-f1 8�MX BN$MK N �($M�( /0M7 *M-QN� P�M6�C1( N F1R�� 'R O40E37 O> �3D *1 Uuy(

(���I-:( )*E�0E B�KF�� �� .�3D *1 ;�<3" '(�$,-QN� cFX*6�6$1N� F@6�12 �"$M7(� )3N �jM-41 )1. Income Redistribution2. Romer, (1975)3. Roberts, (1977)

Page 6: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

144����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

��<���i18(� O40ME37 �FML1 ;�<3" *E�0E ��?7( O> *E($>31� �13Ch �� O> F@-5X �N�7 /�( $7$-M907 *+�M,-.( 8�MX OM@�jX )$-M907 8FM1R�� 8$7($7�6 �3.N P�3A �� ��$K *1 /00?" '�KF@X�

.FD F@X(3_2

�� N NN �@0,�<'($H3 '(3@+ �7 8( O?Q�z1"�"B�M�� N FM1R�� ;�<3" $7 �QN� 8�X �E�0E $0m" N *6�1< N *?zb1 8�X B�(� <( B��\-E( �7 �G6R .F6�(� 2�L6( �C�$1R ��850*6�M1< B�N� *y BFX�91

1977-1981OM> OM?Q�z1 /M�( OML0-6 .F@-_(�$& F1R�� ;�<3" $7 �QN� 8�X �E�0E $0m�" *E�$7 O7 N �QN� *+�,-.( O,07 $0m�" *E�$7 aA�hB�M�� *Q3M,?1 8�MX ��M0?1 $7 �FL1 ;�<3" 8�X �E�0E

N *M@0. g�$^ )'R 8�G,-���HQ N F1R�� /0H6�01 c($Y6( )F1R�� ;�<3" P($00{" g�$^ '3i,XgM5> N P�M0Q�1 )FM1R�� �FML1 ;M�<3" $m3M1 B(� OM> FMX� *M1 '�96 )FD�7 *1 '35@0C"( p_�D

.�E( *"�0Q�1 8�X F1R���$� an31�E 8$H�� O?Q�z1 ���4 '(3@+ �7 *b0bY""OM7 unNj6N �� F1R�� �FL1 ;�<3" N ;�<3"

*-\6 �39> Z� '(3@+"8�MX l�ME 8�MX B�(� <( B��\-ME( �M7 8N .�ME( B�(� 2�L6( (�2005-1970 l�6�> '(3@+ O7 (� *+�,-.( 8�X O@�jX N *IfD F1R�� ;�<3" j06 N a1(3+ F1R�� ;�<3" *H63Hk

�$7 ��31 F1R�� �FL1 ;�<3" 8�X�FML1 ;M�<3" N ;M�<3" OM> FXF01 '�96 ���-6 .FX� *1 �($: *E*"�M0Q�1 ]-M50E N F0Q3" ��-_�E ($�< ��E( O-D(F6 *6(F@k $00{" unNj6N �� $0_( OX� OE *y F1R��

.�E( B�37 �7�m �39> /�( ��) *6u01 OQ(F=+ #3@G113798�($M:$7 c(FMX( /�$M-,G1 <( *C� O> ��(� *1 '�07 *b0bY" �� (

2�S6�ME( OM?1�. �($M�( '�M01 �� $b� JX�> N F1R�� ;�<3" O4x51 O7 /-_(�$& )*+�,-.( /01�" 8�X�($M: B��\-ME( ��3M1 O?1�. �� ;�<3" �0?^N �3=G7 8($7 �QN� $S6 ��31 8�X �E�0E �7 B($,X O>

M,-.( 8�MX O,07 )��(� �3.N *+�,-.( /01�" 8($7 O> *"N�\-1 8�X �$=X(� '�01 �� .�$0K *1 <( *+�*M1 �($M: JMD3& �MY" (� OM?1�. �($�( <( *K�j7 ]GE N B�37 �(��3_$7 *A�_ ��3QN( N �0,X(�M7 8�MX B�(36�M_ *ME�$7 OM7 '($M�( ��M1R jM>$1 �(36�M_ O.�37 ��1R <( B��\-E( �7 OQ�b1 /�( �� .FX�

. aM> �M7 )BN$MK /M�( �0?M^N )*?�<3M" 8�MX ��0?1 O7 O.3" �7 N O-_(�$& O-596<�7 �E$&$EOM?1�OM7 �=56 '�H-596<�7 /07 $b� FA�� }E3-1 �3z7 O> FX� *1 '�96 ���-6 .�E( BFD O5��b1 8$GD1. Meltzer & Richards, (1981)

2.) )*Q��+ )'�0E�=+1387(3. Ximing WU and others, (2002)4. Samuel, Freije, (2006)

Page 7: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,145

<( $-M907 O-M596<�7 �ME$&$E �M7 8�MX B�(36�M_ N �($�( O6|�E O6($E O@�jX N $-,> 8$GD O?1�. a>6 '�M1< *My �� N B�3M7 gME�@1�6 '�H-596<�7 /07 F1R�� ;�<3" �1( .FD�7 *1 8$GD O?1�.�3M=G7 jM0

.��(� *?�<3" }�($D 'FD $-G7 <( '�96 ���-6 8$GD O?1�. �� �1( .�E( O-��06) 3. oh $A�61381 Jf7 /0@i,X N *+�,-.( �31( P(��=-+( F6N� *E�$7 O7 �3_ o0bY" �� (

��3M1 *M41 B�M�� $7 (� 'R $0m�" N �E( O-_(�$& '($�( �� $0_( OX� N� �� *+�,-.( /01�" N *-5�jG7E�$7��3M1 (� *M4_(� pQ�M_�6 FM0Q3" <( *+�M,-.( �3M1( P(��=-+( ]GE BF@5�36 .�E( B�(� �($: *

}�($D �� P(��=-+( BF@�(j� FD� ]�� *4+ O> �E( B�3,6 8$0K OL0-6 N B�(� �($: a04Y" N *E�$7�1FM_ /M�( OM7 '�6R <�06 83HfE�& *6($�( �$� $X *+�,-.( /01�" N *-5�jG7 ��=-+( O6($E )*63@> P

.�37 FX(3f6) *+�(< �(3. N $� *,04E *\zI11384*+�M,-.( /01�M" 2�MS6 oM0�3" '(jM01 �3M_ OMQ�b1 �� (

8�GQ�E �� (� $b� }_ $�< �0?,. JX�> �� �39>1362-1380 �7 o0bY" /�( �� .F6�3,6 *E�$7 *\0A3" #N� Z� 8$0K��C7–m�M" B3MY6 N '(j01 *L@E ��I-:( lF1 Z� <( B��\-E( N *404Y" $0

�($M: '3M1<R ��31 O?1�. $0b� �($�( FA�� JX�> 8N� *+�,-.( /01�" Jf7 �� �QN� 8�X O@�jXaH6( *n($H,X #N� <( B��\-E( ���-6 .�$0K *1-8�MX OM@�jX J�(jM�( OM> FMX� *M1 '�M96 $L6$K

$b� }_ $�< 8�X B�(36�_ FA�� �(��@?1 JX�> g.31 )*-5�jG7 N *+�,-.( /01�" aI� �� �QN�1 o4z1.�3D *

/1jQ�X P$7(�1 '(3@+ �7 8( OQ�b1 ��"*H-M596<�7 2�MS6 �uA( ��31 �� *6�G. Z6�7 �$C�N�OM7 *+3M6 OM7 FM��7 OM?1�. �($M�( OM,X (lR BFM�() $H6�M1�R F�� <( O> F��,6 *1 B��D( [3^31 /�( O7

F@D�7 O-D(� *E$-E� 8$0& '(�N� F1R��-$b� �zE �� ]> �E�-'($K��M> OM,X ��3M1 �� NOM7/M�( $M7 'NjM�( *MQN .FM6( OM-_(�$& OM> 8( OM,07 oMh N ��M> Ob7�E gE�@" O7 )'�D F1R�� <( *9f7;M�<3" OM@01< �� �MX #uM" *M_$7 8N $S6 <( .�E( O.3" �3_ �� *456 /07 �Q(F+ O4x51 [3^31

�$C1 J�(j�( �1( )FD�7 O.31 8��I-:( �(%K l3y �� N �GH@. <( �& �E( /C,1 *456 /07 �FL1���MG. 'R <( BT�3M7 $M1( /M�( .FMX� JX�M> (� O��1$E a0C9" F6(3" *1 �G@" )8F@,"N�fE '(j01

*Mn(< $M& B�N� 8�MX aM56 FM@6�1 )*-_�@D �0?,. 8�X O6�C" 2�H@X O7 O> ��(� �0,X(2*Q�M1 ��M7 ) *,G1–*n(< $& B�N� a56 �($�( *H-596<�7 �7 '�1j,X- N F@> *1 ��L�( BF@�R �� a��D a56 8($7

1. Robert Halsman, (2002)2. The baby – boom generations

Page 8: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

146����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

P�3MA OM7 *H-M596<�7 2�MS6 8�MX BFM+N ($M�< FX� *1 lj@" (� *n(< $& B�N� a56 *X��� �zE ��.�3D *1 a�F?" *QNj6

) *6�_N��E1380[3M^31 �M7 *+�M,-.( /01�M" JXNT& *Q�+ O5E31 �� J�3_ *6($@fE �� ("*+�,-.( /01�" N *+�,-.( 8�X 8$7($7�6"�M,-.( /01�M" OM> FM��,6 *M1 B��MD( ]G1 /�( O72�MS6 *+

B<�"8�3Mx") F63MD ZM��j6 ]MX OM7 ]M50Q�0E3E N 8�(� O��1$ME 'R �� O> ��NR �3.37 �06� �� 8(<�M06 OM@01< �� �M1( )FM@6�1 *M1 $7($7�M6 '�D �(F?-E( N '(3" )��> $m( $7 �G6�56( 2�S6 /�( �� .(*n($H,X

( �3_ ��> B<(F6( O7 �> $X .F@@> *1 (F0& �E� 8$7($7 *+36 O7 *4A( 8�X �D(�$7 UNF@A /�( <*+�M,-.( P�M0h �� �G6�56( �>��91 N ��> $7 O> �E( *1�S6 *+�,-.( /01�" /�($7�@7 .�$> FX(3_/M�( 'N�� �� ��M506 $M97 '(�N�M. *M6($H6 $MH�� ... N 8��C07 )Om��h )8��,07 .��(� O0C" F0Q3" N

�Q(F+ 8�@?1 .F6$0H01 �($: *+�,-.( /01�" $-k $�< �G6�56( )2�S6*+�M,-.( /01�" 3"$& �� *+�,-.(�M1( .8FM@1<�06 2�MH@X OM7 '�M56( $X O7 /-_(�$& OC47 )o4z1 8$7($7 O6 N o4z1 8$7($7 �6 O6 :�E( /�(

.�E( F0Q3" N ��> 8�06� O7 �N�N N $-k /�( <( �G6R �N$_ *@?� )�G6�56( *n�\> �3_ $7 aA( aA( ��2901�" a1�> 23G\1 O7 '�1�39> *E�E( '36�:8�M@=1 $M7 .�ME( BFD B��D( *+�,-.( /

aA( /�("*M7 )*K��M-�(��> <( )8$M0& )8��MC07 )*H-596<�7 $S6 <( *+�,-.( /01�" <( 8�(��3_$7*CMDj& �=:($1 N *6�1�� N *-D(FG7 P�1F_ O7 <�06 )�6(3E N ��(3h )*KF6�1 B(� �� )*-E$&$E

�E( e4C1 �QN� .*6�H,X �E( *bh )B$0� N O,07 P�3A O78�MX FM1R�� aMY1 <( )/06(3: o=y�($M�( ZM� ZM� 8($7 (� *Q�1 8�X ���,h N P�1F_ )2�$1 �>��91 <( aA�h F1R�� N *13,+

F@> /01�" �39>".

3?@"6-A( BC!"D K"Q3 +"�,)V�(5 .�,-.( N 8��I-:( P|3Y" N $00{"+J�(jM�( $0S6 *�$M6 FM01( OM7)8�N��M7 �$M6 JX�M> )*KFM6<

-:( FD� �� P�6�E36�MG-QN� FM1R�� �� P�6�ME36 )l�{-MD( F6N� �� BFD ��L�( P|3Y" )8��I... NO@�jX O> BF��$K �+�7X�,-.( /01�" 8�Gh$y 8�+ * PFD O7*MC� $M1( /�( N FD�7 J�(j�( O7 N�

O�F�� /�$-,G1 <(8�X(� '($0K ]0,I" N '(�(%H-E�0E .FMX� *M1 a0CM9"(%MQ�X�3M9> OM04> �� �G. JX�> 8�X��9� )*+�,-.( /01�" 8�G1�S6 $7 B��(N *Q�1.�E( BFD 2�L6( *"�huA(

Page 9: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,147

*MM1 (� BFMM1R aMM,?7 P�huMMA( *MM4> �3Mz7P�huMMA( .�3MM,6 8FMM@7 ]0MM5b" gMMQ�: N� �� '(3M" .*,-50E P�huA( N Z�$-1(��&'R $7 *?E Z�$-1(��& P�huA( ��( N �X$0{-1 <( *_$7 O> �E

6 c��I1 N ;7�@1 $7 �(%K$m( 8�X$-1(��&,07 oh �$6 J�(j�( $0SO)U�bY-ME( }�($D 8<�E�NFY1 ) *H-596<�7 /E J�(j�(... N50E P�huA( �� �1( .F@7�� $00{"-'R $7 *?E *,(*Q�M1 2�MS6 �M" �ME

$H�� P��=+ O7 .F7�� $00{" �Gh$y2(F> );7�M@1 'R OM7 OM.3" �M7 �" �$0K �($: B��\-E( ��31 *Q�1 2�S6FG?" �_(�$& �G. 2<| *Q�1F0E�$E '�1< �� P() .FD�7 $�%& '�C1(

OM> �E( O-�$K �($: B��\-E( ��31 *63K�63K 8�X�$=X(� *+�,-.( /01�" 8�G-��,h On(�( �G.OM7 O1(�( �� .�E( O?1�. $7 ]>�h *E�0E N 8��I-:( )*+�,-.( a1(3+ <( $m�-1 �|3,?1 �X�$=X(� /�(

:FD FX(3_ B��D( �G6R <( *_$7 O7 ��I-_(�6CJ?@"6-A( +"�1:(� *+�M,-.( /01�M" 2�MS6 *4MA( O-M5X �X�39> <( 8��057 �� �$=X(� /�(

*1 aCD�M1$���> O40ME37 O,07 oh �_(�$& o�$y <( �$y *Q�1 /01�" .FX�-��3M�+ )BFMD OM,07OM,07 8T"($-ME( 8�MG0KT�N OM4,. <( BFMD O,07 �j,-E� �7 �G-��,h '(j01 N O,07 oh ��="�( )8��=.(

*+�,-.( .�E(?@"6-A( ;F@"9!2:2FM+ F@6�1 '3K�63K a4+ O7 O?1�. �($�( <( *\0y )�X�39> <( 8��057 ��

��M9:( /M�( .FM6�(F6 (� 8( OM,07 JMf7 8�MG-��,h <( B��\-ME( '(3M" ...N *Q�1 �+�z-E( 2F+ )l�{-D('R 8�X O@�jX N F6$0K *1 �($: ���,h ��31 *+�,-.( PF+�51 gQ�: �� �|3,?1 )F@1<�06aMY1 <(

*1 /01�" �QN� *13,+ 8�XF1R��.��$K?3"g6� K"Q33:*M1 �MQN� *13,+ 8�XF1R�� o�$y <( 'R *Q�1 /01�" �|3,?1 O> 2�S6 /�( ��

$MS6 �� 8�MG-��,h .�$�%M& *1 P�3A �($�( *Q�1 *��6(3" N l�{-D( ��YQ 'NF7 �G-��,h On(�( )FD�7: �� �|3,?1 )�$y /�( �($�( 8($7 BFD O-�$K BF6�1<�7 �� B��-�(��><( )F@,Q�E �($�( 8($7 8$,-51 gQ�

.FD�7 *1"!)&5"O SCUIp9!4: O40E37 )��> <( *D�6 ��(3h P($z_ a7�b1 �� Z,> On(�( )*4A( cFX

��(31 *_$7 �� N 8�(���7 N 8��,07 2��( �1($� �_(�$& F@6�1 *"�1F_ �_(�$& .FD�7 *1 �1$���>7 *6�1�� 8�X �=:($1 /01�"2�MS6 /M�( �� .FMD�7 *M1 �M1$���> BFG+ O7 �G6R B�(36�_ N '($K��> 8($

1. Social Insurance2. Social Aids3. General System4. Employer’s Liability

Page 10: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

148����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

*1 �1$���> BFG+$7 P(FG?" O04> ($�< .�3D *,6 BFX�91 )$z_ �� �>��91 <( *_$7 �� O-=Q( .FD�7.F@��,6 *1 O,07 )8( O,07 8�G->$D �j6 P($z_ a7�b1 �� (� �3_ '���1$���> ��(31

%W +5"VA( :(F3( X� +"P.�F#>?>I1:*n�M6(3" ��(3M1 g4�( �� *+�,-.( /01�" 8�G1�S6 FMM6�(F6 (� *1�3MM" P�6�MME36 aMM7�b1 �� �G�$,-MM51 #<�( �MM\h2 o�3MM9" gMM.31 $MMH�� 83MME <( N

F1R�� $& �($�( )$H�� P��=+ O7 �F6�$K *1 �XF1R�� O6|��+�6 ;�<3" N 2�H@X �N< 8�X *H-596<�7907 8F@1 B$G7 <( F1R�� ]> �($�( O7 �=56BFM0b+ /M�( $M7 '�M6R /0@i,X .F6�$K *1 �(��3_$7 8$-

O63H@�( ��(31 g4�( �� N B�37 O6(F@,"N�fE )8$,-51 �_(�$& 8($7 O-�$K ��C7 8�X l31$� O> F6()�3M_ 'uM> 8�G-ME�0E �� ��MYQ /0M,X OM7 .F@MD�7 *M1 *@0H@ME 8�(�( 8�MX OM@�jX 8(�(� �G1�S6

.( <(F6( �& 8�X UNF@A �,E O7 (� �X�39>UNF@MA O63H@�( .F@��,6 *1 ��(FX *A3I_ 8��=a1�> 8<�E B$0_W *Q�1 2�S6 q�E($7 �X3*1 *Q�1 /01�".F6�$K

?3"NPA eN3"J 4"ZFN*, :( ?@"6-A( BC!"D K"Q3 +"�,)V�(5 :)*6�MG. ZM6�7 '�ME�@D��>1�M" OM6�K OME 8�MX O�| '(3@+ �Y" O> BN$K OE �� (� *+�,-.( /01�" 8�G-��,h On(�( 8�GDN� /0

.FMM6�3,6 8FMM@7 O-MME� ,BFMMD O-_�@MMD *+�M,-.( 8($MM7 *KFMM6< a:(FMMh /0,MM�" cFMMX �MM7 lN( OMM�|�ME� <( F1R�� '($=. �3S@1 O7 O> �E( 8��=.( 8$,-51 8�Gh$y ;:(N �� 2N� O�| )*H-596<�7

8��0-_( 8�X<(F6( �&N �E( O-�$K aCD O-��� O?E3" 8�X�39> �� ���F-7 )��> �$" �4?7 O-��G:NF@A N*1 On(�( *A3I_ 8�G->$D O40E37 |3,?1 O> a,C1 8�*M1 a0CM9" (� 23E O�| ,�3D

.F@X�

4?@"6-A( BC!"D +"PT)h ?U"! BC!"D .�MG6R /�$M-,G1 <( OM> �3MD *M1 a0C9" *\4-f1 8(j.( <( *+�,-.( /01�" �$y Z� 8F1R�� ;7�@1

*1O,07 <( BFD 8�NR ;,. 8�X O,07 oh ,�QN� �>��91 O7 '(3"FM1R�� N '�M��1$���> N '�KFD.�3,6 B��D( )8�(%K O��1$E <( aA�h�(�3,61/01�M" '�1<�ME c��I1 N ;7�@1 O_$k <( 8$�3I"

.F@> *1 pf91 (� *+�,-.(

1. Private Compulsory Saving Fund�) )'NFQ31 N a6312008(

3. Fully F unded

Page 11: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,149

OMC47 )�506 *@� ��$A ]0,I" Z� )�X O@�jX ;�<3" N ;7�@1 c$I1 *H63Hk ��31 �� ]0,I"N *+�M,-.( ,8��MI-:( P�Shu1 q�E( $7 F��7/01�M" 8�MGh$y *Q�M1 /01�M" .�3MD W�Mf"( *ME�0E

aMY1 <( *Q�M1 /01�M" N O,07 oh aY1 <( *Q�1 /01�" .�$0K *1 2�L6( P�3A N� O7 |3,?1 *+�,-.(.P�0Q�11

5(,I631?@"6-A( BC!"D '"!:"0 b5"%! � HJ"#! �W)o .

)�3&3C06 :;=@11386�)144

��;"CU"! q<! :( ?U"! BC!"D2+ 8�XF1R��)�M� �M0?7�"$7 *M@-=1 *6�MH,X �M��,h )(*13M,/M�( .(*-��,h 2�S6) �E( *+�,-.( P�1F_ N *+�,-.( PF+�51 a1�D O> �E( '(F6N$GD �1�:(a0QFM7) OM?1�. $�%M& g0MER ��M9:( a1�MD 'R �?EN B$�(� N B�37 O-57(N *-QN� P(��=-+( O7 ]-50E

N *,5. '�K��-�(��> <( N /0Q34?1 ,(F1R�� g5> *6(3"�6B�(36�M_ ,�ME$&$E *7 '�>�3> ,*@XW .8j�� O1�6$7 $-��) )*+�,-.( 8��I-:(1384� )(5

2. Tax Financing

Page 12: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

150����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

$Mb� JX�M> �� ,*+�M,-.( 8�X O,07 8�Gh$y �7 O5��b1 �� )*��Gh$y /0@k .�3D *1 ...N '�06(F6<.FD�7 *1 'R '�37 O@�jX $& �$y /�( g��?1 <( N .F6$"$m31

�6CJ _T q<! :( ?U"! BC!"D1)c$My <( *+�M,-.( /01�M" �$My *Q�M1 ;7�M@1 O> �E( *6�1<$���>P�3MA �M_(�$& q�ME( $M7 jM06 '($K��M> <( �MX �M��,h N �3D �_(�$& '($K��> N '���1

�_(�$& /�( .FD�7 O-�$K"O,07 oh2"�M� FMD�7 [3Mzb1 �$M6 �M7 �ME( /MC,1 O> �3D *1 BF6(3_.�3D /00?" F1R�� �7 }="$13

<( *Q�1 /01�" O7 �=56 ��j1 Z� '(3@+ O7 O,07 oh o�$y <( *Q�1 /01�" <( g4�( )P�0Q�1 o�$y]-M50E .�ME( gME�@1 *Q�M1 ]-50E t�f-6( )�$y /�( *@� PuC91 /�$-,G1 <( .�3D *1 B�$7 2�6)�MX ���,h On(�( �G. )�$b1 '�1< �� �$y 8��+( O7 �G6R q�E($7 O> F@-5X *��GDN� *Q�1 8�X

MD3& OM@1(� OM7 '(3M" *M1 *Q�M1 8�G,-M50E ]MG1 8�MX$0{-1 O4,.<( .F7�� *1 p0If" *X3.N )JN �M7�m ��-=56 O,07 oh 8�G_$6 O7 <�06 N B3.N 8�(%K O��1$E 8�G-A$� )$��_W 8�(FGH6 P�N$^

.�3,6 B��D( $�< ��(31 O7 '(3" *1 (��> *Q�1 8�X ]-50E �F6( <( .�3,6 B��D( �G6R ~3474

6-9! )J ?#-V! �3r"0 ?J"*:5( K"Q3)+5:N OM@�jX '<(3M" 2�MS6 'R $MH�� 2�6 O> #N� /�( ���3M1( N �M�(j1 O6|�ME OM@�jX N �3MD *,6 O-D(%K ��@> 8( O-_NF6( �0X (F-7( �� )FD�7 *1 j06 F1R��

#N� /�( �� .�3D *1 *Q�1 /01�" )l�E '�,X *-����� O,07 oh aY1 <( a1�> �3y O7 �$y *n($.(� l�ME $MX N �ME( /0n�& �zE �� �$y *n(F-7( 8�GQ�E �� O,07 oh �$6 )c��I1 83HQ( o=yFMD

O7 ]-50E �" F7�� *1["V7( FT68�MX3HQ( P($00{" ��YQ O7 N �$y /�( �� OC0n�L6R <( .FE$7 �3_�M:� �� J�(jM�( �3MS@1 OM7 �$0K *1 �($: $0m�" �Y" �X 8$,-51 �_(�$& PF1 N �(F?" )*-0?,.

2�6 O7 *X3.N )BF@�R �� ��(j1 �_(�$& �� �X��NR$7?h"C-T( 4)CWs7J�(jM�( '($M=. 8($78�MX.�3D *1 O-�$K $S6 �� *-_(�$& 8��(j1 #<�( N �(F?" )BF96 *@07 J0&8

1. Premium Financing2. Premium or Contribution Rate

3.8( O,07 2�S64.� );=@1 '�,X6

5. PAYG (Pay-As-You-Go)

6.O7��YQ8�3x"N*@�*h$yO7B�N�[�=D(*1FE�O>��'R��-_�E*-0?,.O,07'�KFDN8$,-51'($0H7"�=�$b�7�mFD�7 .��/�(�Q�h�$6O@�jXPAYG�7�m*1F6�1N$7($7�7�$6ohO,07�E(.

7. Contingency Reserve

8.))*6�G\A( B�(< /5h1386� )(67

Page 13: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,151

8$n3i>( 8�X *@07 J0&1*M"R P|�,-h( 8<�E lF1 .��(� *E�E( Jb6 �$y /�( �0b�31 ��'($M0H7 �M�(j1 �0?M^N N }�($MD )2�3M" �� �j,-E� FD� �$6 F@6�1 8��I-:( a1(3+ O7 �$y /�( ��

N F1R�� �zE )Ob7�E F@6�18N$M06 �M0?,. <( 'FMD ���M_ <( FM?7 *KF6< O7 F01( )P($y�f1 [36 .��(� *H-M57 ... N *K�(36�M_ }�($MD N �0?:31 /0@i,X N ��>2]-M50E ��PAYG8�MX FM1R��

BFD O-D�=6( 8�X *n(�(� ($�< .F6N� *1 ��,D O7 8F1R�� �0,X( *7 �4=1 Z� )BFD 8�(%K O��1$E 8($7 |3A( N B�37 j0k�6 �-=56.F6N� *1 ��C7 8��I-:( 8�X �@H-" 2�H@X )�X ���,h /01�"3/M�( ��

.�3D *1 ;�<3" *456 /07 P�3A O7 Z5�� ]-50E4

�ME( �$M� l�{-MD( '�M1< �j,-ME� }ME3-1 <( 8FMA�� )8$,-51 '(j01 |3,?1 ]-50E /�( ��.�j,-E� /�$_R F6(3" *1 �j,-E� }E3-1 )$_R l�E N� }E3-1$M_R l�ME ZM� ) N *M-h13-}ME

.FD�7 l�{-D( B�N� l3y8�M&N�( 8�X�3M9> �� �3MIf7 '�MG. 8�X�3M9> $-M907 �� ]-M50E /�(�0Q($-E( N (��6�> )*7$�.��(� �3.N O-C6 �1((FD�7 *1 �$z1 ]-50E /�( �� O> 8)OMk O> �E( /�(

O,07 oh �$6( .FD�7 *1 2<| �G�$,-51 c��I1 /01�" �G. 87 *Q�1 '<(3" 8�($:$7 F��$" *7UNF@A c��I1 N ;7�@1 /0)*ME�$7 ��3M1 B�N� *y) MC�* <(

O�F���X �$y '(�(%K ]0,I" N '(�(%H-E�0E 8$M0{-1 /�FM@k <( ]MG1 $M0{-1 N� �M7 O1(�( �� .�E(.]�3D *1 �@DR �$y /�( �� �(%K $0m�"

?#*2g*"NNA \)NN35)RR(OM>�j,-MME� /0H6�MM01 OM7 8$,-MM51 /0H6�MM01 �=M56 <( �MME( P��MM=+O,07'�KFD.�(e4-f1 8�X�39> �� �$6 /N1 O7 O.3" �73�G:NF@A �0?:FD�7 *1 PN�\-1.

?g-9J(� \)36)DR( j06 8�GI_�D <( *C� $H��OM> �ME( *+�M,-.( /01�M" 8�MX �$y ]G1FD�7 *1 �$y *Q�1 �0?^N $H6�07 .OM,07 OM7 '($M0H7 8$,-51 �(F?" �=56 <( *H-57(N �$6'�KFMD

*1 aA�h.��$K$6 l��1 8($7 $7($7 *H-57(N �81 )$0H7 8$,-51 $X 8(<( O7 *@?�8BFMD O,07 $\6

.��(� �3.NN� <( $m�-1 '($0H7 8$,-51 �(F?"O-E�+3+ N *-0?,. a1(3 .�ME( 8�(%H-ME�0E aM1(<( �M& *KFM6< FM01( )*H-M596<�7 /ME <( �M& $01 N �$1 �$6 )*@E ��-_�E $0S6 *-0,. a1(3+

1. Actuary

2.� )'�,X683.))8$0911381� )(104.) )F631��� N ��72009�)(9N4

5. Replacement Rate6. Dependency Rate

Page 14: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

152����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

H-596<�7*1 8�(%H-E�0E a1(3+ <( N *(3"<( B��\-ME( }�($MD )*H-596<�7 /E )JD3& B3Y6 O7 '<( $m�M-1 jM06 '�KFD O,07 �(F?" .�3,6 B��D( '�KF6�1<�7 N '�K��-�(��> <( 8$,-518�FM?-1 aM1(3+

*1 �G6R /�$-,G1 <( O> F@D�7 *1 .�3M,6 B��MD( 8�(%H-ME�0E N 8��MI-:( ,*M-0?,. aM1(3+ O7 '(3"+1�/ME $0S6 8��I-:( a1�+ )P$.�G1 N $01 N �$1 �$6 )O-D%K �� 8�N��7 �$6 $0S6 *-0?,. a

ME�F1 �$M"O18�(%H-ME�0E aM1�+ /0MM@i,X N ��M> 8N$M06 �>��M91 �$MM6 J�(jM�( ) )/MME $M0S6 .FD�7 *1 O,07 oh �$6 N JD3& �zE )*H-596<�7�$M6 JX�> )O-D%K �� 8�N��7 �$6 '�37 |�7

P$.�G1 N $01 N �$1.FD FX(3_ '�KFD O,07 �(F?" J�(j�( g.31 �?z: a_(� O71�D }b� UNF@A 8�X O@�jX O> �$� /�( �7a<( ��$MA UNF@MA ;7�M@1 N 8$,-M51 8�MX O@�jX

z7(� .��$K *1 /01�" �X O,07 oh ������ aY1O UNF@A c��I1 N ;7�@1 '<(3" 8�($:$7 �G. $�<*1 On(�(��$K.2

B$,-51 /0H6�01 =8)P" ='($0H7 8$,-51 �(F? )CO,07 oh /0H6�01 = )E'�KFD O,07 �(F?" = 8$,-51 /0H6�01(B) O,07 oh /0H6�01 N(C) o=y�}7(N3D *1 e�$?" $�<6F:

= CR3O,07 oh �$6 )= W4�j,-E� /0H6�01 )= RR*@�jH��. �$6 /0H6�01:�D(� ]0X(3_ /�($7�@7

,07 oh �$6 /�($7�@7O)<( $m�-1 �$6 a1�+ N�*@�jH��.�M7 �ME( *G�FM7 .FMD�7 *1 *H-57(N �$6 N=m �$��@,7 FM7�� J�(jM�( *H-57(N �$6 B�K$X )*@�jH��. �$6 P MS2N(FM" <( '�M@0,y( l3MIh �3

oh �$6 F��7 c��I1 N ;7�@1 /07 '<(3"70,O.�(� J�(j�( (��$M6 OM> �3MD �$M� $MK( l��1 '(3@?7

1. School Leaving Age2.) )�6�0"�"2002 � )(4

3. CR (Contribution Rate)4. W (Average Wage)

Page 15: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,153

l��?1 UNF@A �� *@�jH��.60��$7($7 *H-57(N �$6 N U3bh FA81(�E )$M7($7 OM,07 oh �$6

:�7 �37 FX(3_

%.% 578160 !"!CR

O7 *H-57(N �=56 $K( l�h81 FM7�� J�(j� �M� NO-MD(� (� �3M_ ~3M47 '(�N� UNF@MA *"��M=+ OM7

�7.FDRB�H6:

%% 302160 !"!CR

�$M6 P($M00{" <( �M0?=" OM7 )OM,07 oMh �$M6 '(jM01 )*@�jH��M. �$6 P�=m �$� �7 $H�� P��=+ O7*H-57(N ) M,07 oh �$6 J�(j�( '�C1( $K( l�h .F@> *1 $00{"O OM7FMD�=6 �NFMb1 *M4�|�)B(� �MG@"

@A c��I1 N ;7�@1 /07 '<(3" �\hF �$6 <( B��\-E( )UN*@�jH��..�E(

,07 oh �$6 $K( )U3� Oz7(� o=yOFD�7 �7�m) )UNF@A '<(3" �\h 8($7 )*H-57(N �$6 J�(j�( �7O@�jX JX�> $H�� P��=+ O7 �(� JX�> (� *@�jH��. �$6 F��7X ah B(� �G@" UNF@A 8$,-51 8�

.FD�7 *1 '<(3" 8($:$7 ��L�(�$y 8�@=1 $7 '($�( *+�,-.( /01�" '�1<�EBFMD eM�$?" 8�M�(j1 �M7 8$,-M51 �M_(�$&1OM��&

.�E( BFD 8�(%K8�Mb"�( N �\h 2F+ <( *D�6 Z5�� )2�+ �3y O7 )*KT�N /�( �7 *n�X UNF@A*4=: '�KFD O,07 O7 c$y Z� <( (� $n�_W-*4?� '($0H7 8$,-51-�� ���NFMY1 ��L�( gQ�: ��

�M7 $MH�� c$My <( N FM@@> *1 a0,Y" )�X 8$,-51 �_(�$&'�KFMD OM,07 8�MX OM,07 oMh c$MA]MX( <( $n�M_W #<�( V�Mb"�( N �M\h OM7 OM.3" )/�($7�M@7 .FM6<(F6�01 $Mz_ OM7 (� �G6R BF@�R )*63@>/01�MM" 8�MMX UNF@MA �� 8�(%MMK O��1$MME *4MA( �MM��31�1 .�N� *MM1 ��,MD OMM7 �MMG6R 8�MX�$>��>

1. PAY As You Go Defined Benefits (PAYG-DB)

Page 16: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

154����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

3" F��7 �1( .�E( 'R ��3X �\h N UNF@A P�0h �(F-1( ;:(N �� )*+�,-.(O��1$ME OM> �MD(� O..�E( �(��3_$7 8( BT�N 8�X ���NFY1 N P�1(jQ( )*KF0i0& <( �X UNF@A /�( 8�(%K1

/0M?1 O,07 oh �7 �_(�$& �$y a7�b1 �� BFD e�$?" 8��(j1 �7 8$,-51 �_(�$& �$y2�($M:.��(�

OM7 N *+�M,-.( /01�" '�1<�E 8�X �$>��> N �0X�1 <( �_�@D '�Ib6 $0_( 8�GQ�E ��'R ;M="/���M0@7 8�MX�$>��> N *-0X�M1 N *Mz0Y1 P�0M�-b1 �M7 '�1<�ME 'R 'N�� o7�Mz" �� aC91 �3.N

.�3D O.(31 BF,+ N 'u> O4x51 ��Gk �7 '�1<�E /�( O> B�< ]:� (� *z�($D )'�1< l3y �� '�1<�E 8��I-:( P|3Y" OL0-6 �� *H-57(N �=56 JX�>–gM.31 OM> *M6N$07 8�MX ��M9� N *+�M,-.(

�>BF@7�-MD FD� .�E( BFD 8�(%K O-_NF6( �G. (�0?,. '�37 '(3. ]�� *4+) 2<| ;7�@1 JX8($M7 B$y�Mf1 <N$M7 OML0-6 �� N JMD3& B$-M5K gME�-1�6 FD� ��@> �� ;7�@1 O7 �=56 c��I1 $"

/�( *6(3f,X 2F+ N $H�FC� �7 *6�1<�E 8�X 2�S6 *H@X�,X N 8F1R<N� '�Ib6 )UNF@A 8�(F��& �7 �X 2�S68�MX O,07 <( 8( O?E3" F^ *b4" O> 8�X O9�F6( <( *n��� 8$0K aCD N '�1< P�0�-b1

�M@X$� �� *+�M,-.( /01�M" OMQ3b1 <( O> 8( B�$-5K *n�@DR�6 ��@> �� )��(� B($,X O7 (� *+�,-.(.�E( B�(� #$-5K (� '�1<�E /�( $7 B��(N 8�X ��9� )B�3,6 �� *IIf" N *13,+3

,-.( /01�" UNF@A ��OM,07 oMh �$M6 )'($�( *+�33�M_(�$& OM> FMD�7 *M1 %23FMG?" 'R % )�1$���>7 N BFD O,07 FG?" %3.FD�7 *1 �QN� FG?" %

@7 ;,. ��F50E O> �\K F��7 8-P($M00{" aM7�b1 �� 8$,-M51 $M7 *M@-=1 O6|�E *7��<�( 2�S6 ]FMD�7 *M1 q�M5h ��057 *-0?,.. (�MX 8�N�N) '�KFMD OM,07 �� *M-0?,. aM1(3+��3M1 �� ]MX N

.�E( $m31 (�X *.N$_) '($0H7 8$,-51OM,07 *>FM6( �(FM?" )OM?1�. 8F@,Q�E N UNF@A [�=D( �7(� UNF@MA OM@�jX F��$" *7 O> �D(� FX(3_ �3.N $0H7 8$,-51 $\6 Z� O@�jX '($=. 8($7 BFD

OM.3" a7�: O-C6 .�(� FX(3_ J�(j�(OMC@�( ]-M50E ��PAYG M+$M7 UNF@MA 8<�ME B$M0_W 2F 8(*"R P(FG?"�E(O>#N� /M�( �� *"��M=+ O7 .FX� *1 J�(j�( (� UNF@A '�G@& P(FG?" B�(3,X

.F7�� *1 l�b-6( *"R 8�X a56 O7 *4?� a56 '�G@& P(FG?"'�ME�@D��> }ME3" BFMD 2�ML6( P�?Q�z1R <( *>�h *6�G. Z6�76<( '�MG@& P(FMG?" '(j01 *-?@A 8�X�39> g4�( �� O> �5100FMA��

1.))�3&3C061386�)(1402. Full Funding Defined Contribution Scheme (FF-DC)

3.) )�3&3C061386� )(141

Page 17: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,155

0Q3" *4_(� pQ�_�6 F(GDP)�37 $-907 B <( '(j01 /�( j06 �X�39> <( *_$7 �� N200F0Q3" FA��BFM��$K gM.31 )]-50E /�( �3I_ �� BF1R �3.37 PuC91 .�E( O-�� $"|�7 *4_(� pQ�_�6

]0,I" N '(�(%H-E�0E O>�3M.31 ;6(31 ;�� �G. 8��CX(� l�=6F7 *+�,-.( /01�" 8�G1�S6 '($0K .F@D�7.�E( B�3,6 ��G@90& (� ��CX(� N� *6�G. Z6�7 �3I_ /�( ��

'R �� O> Z�$-1(��& P�huA( �5f6)*H-M596<�7 8�M�(j1 '�$M> �NFMY1 a0=: <( *"�1(F:(/ME J�(jM�( )�MX �M,0: p_�MD q�ME( $M7 �MX ���,h N ��(j1 a�F?" )*H-596<�7 8��(j1 a�F?"

-596<�7 8��(j1 O=E�Y1 l31$� $00{" )*H-596<�7<( J0M& *H-M596<�7 BjM0H6( OM> 8( OM63K OM7 *H'�ME�@D��> <( 8( BFM+ .�$M0K *M1 P�3MA OM,07 oh �$6 J�(j�( B$_|�7 N FX� JX�> (� F+31*M1 aCM91 /-_(FM6( o�3?" O7 *+36 O7 N �506 3HfE�& PF1 F@47 �� ��CX(� /�( O> F@-5X Fb-?1

(%Q N FD�76 a�F=" *@?� *,-50E P�huA( )2N� ��CX(�OM7 8$,-M51 $M7 *M@-=1 O6|�E *7��<�( 2�S<�E B$0_W $7 *@-=1 2�S6 8 a1�>F��,6 *1 On(�( (�N P�0M�-b1 OM7 OM.3" �M7 �X�39> <( Z� $X O>

$D(.F@@> t�f-6( (� 'R F@6(3" *1 �3_ }�N 8<�ME *A3I_ '3i,X *n�X �E�0E #N� /�( �� �$z1 8�(%K O��1$E $7 *@-=1 8�($\6( 8�X t�5h ��L�(.�3D *1

�6CJ _T )J ?#-V! q!"O +:"0 4)CWs K"Q31: <( BFD ������ 8�X O,07 oh ,]-50E /�( �� ,�3MD *M1 B�(� �($M: �($M�( 8�($M\6( 8�G7�M5h �� �1$���> ]GE �� BFD O,07 ]GE <( ]+( )BFD O,07

�Mb"�( /0M@i,X N �($�( 8�X<(F6( �& #<�( �\h �3S@,7 /C0Q( �Q�M=1 �MG6R $n�M_W *M?:(N V�MD�=6O��1$E ,BFD�($M�( 8�($M\6( 8�G7�M5h OM7 8�(%K O��1$E <( aA�h �3E /0?1 aA(3� �� N 8�(%K

OM,07 oMh ,�MX �M��,h �M����� 8($M7 '�M6R 'FMD }�($MD FM.(N 2�H@X�� N ��$K *1 O��^(8�MX*1 �_(�$&<�7 '�0^�b-1 O7 8$,-51 �� �LC� gQ�: �� BFD aA�h �3E O��^( O7 *-_(�$& �� .��$K

( *,6 ��L�( O6(3-9& 'NF7 P(FG?" �� '�G@& *XF7 O63Hi0X ,O6|�E *7��<�( 2�S6 cu_ $7 ]-50E /�.�3DN O��1$ME �9K<�7 �$6 ,�($�( 8�($\6( �j,-E� O,07 oh �$6 O7 ]-50E /�( �� 8$,-51 '(j01

.��(� *H-57 l�{-D( 8�GQ�E O7 8$,-51 ������ 8�GQ�E �=562

$E '(j01 ,]-50E /�( ��) BFD a0C9" O��1AC(�3D *1 O=E�Y1 $�< l31$� O40E37:

# $ # $ # $rcrCrCAC nnn %%%%%%! & 111 1

21 ...

1. Fully Funded Defined Contribution Systems

2.) )�6�0"�"2002 � )(22

Page 18: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

156����� �!"#$%& /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +"�1�,23"� 45"6745

'R �� O>:n)l�{-D( 8�GQ�E �(F?"r)*X�<�7 �$6 �� O,07 oh l�Et OM>),,,,( nt 321!

N l�E �� O,07 oh �$6t N,-E� l�E �� /04��D �jt*1 .FD�7FMD�7 �$Mz1 '3K�M63K 8�X B30D O7 F6(3" *1 8$,-51 �_(�$&.'(jM01 �X�3M9> <( *M_$7 ��

8($M7 OM> *Q31$� .��$K *1 �_(�$& 8$,-51 P�3I7 $H�� *_$7 �� N �LC� P�3I7 8$,-511:�7 �E( $7($7 �3D *1 B��\-E( �X 8$,-51 '(j01 O=E�Y

# $ # $ # $'! %

!%

%%%

%%

!m

tt

tm

m

r

B

r

B

r

B

r

BAC

12

21

1111 ...

'R �� OMMM>'�MMM1< �� 8$,-MMM51t Nm .FMMMD�7 *MMM1 8$,-MMM51 �MMM����� 8�GQ�MMME �(FMMM?"),,,,( mt 321!

a1�> 8<�E B$0_W 2�S6FD�7 *,6 q�5h *-0?,. P($00{" a7�b1 ��. /�($7�@7 �� O> *"uC91E05-B$0_W ]-50E g"$-1 ��(� �3.N *4=: ]�� OMC@�( OM.3" aM7�: OM-C6 .�3M7 FX(3f6 a1�> 8<�E

O> *-Q�hFD�7 �7�m *@�jH��. �$6),07 oh �$6O�� .�3M7 FMX(3_ O��1$ME �M9K<�7 �$6 <( $m�-1FD�7 $-907 8�(%K O��1$E �9K<�7 �$6 Ok $X �Q�h /�()]0X(3M_ 8$M-,> OM,07 oh �$6 F@1<�06

��� 8�GQ�E �=56 )Ok $X 'R $7 BNu+ .�37 FMD�7 $-,> 8<(�$& O,07 8�GQ�E O7 8$,-51 ���)�$M6.�37FX(3_ $" /0n�& j06 O,07 oh <(FMD�7 *M1 �3MI-1 a1�> 8<�E B$0_W 2�S6 8($7 O> *��X ��j1

:O7 '(3" *18$,-51 �$y 8�b7 J�(j�()OM,07 oMh �_(�$& <( j�$K JX�>1)FMD� �$M6 J�(jM�(8��I-:( )�G456 /07 F1R�� �FL1 ;�<3" JX�>.�3,6 B��D(2

5 ._C`<D ]�5 � 4"ZF*, )*+�,-.( /01�" '�1<�E '($0H7 8$,-51 /07 �� F1R�� ;�<3" �0?^N *E�$7�5f6 ;,. 2j4-51

'�1<�ME /M�( '�KFMD O,07 P�+uy( 8N�> B�(� N 8�NR/M�( #<(�$M& )2N� OM4h$1 �� .FMD�7 *M151 ������ N O,07 oh �_(�$& F6N� O7 /-��� �E� N P�+uy(N 8<(�$M& O,07 B�N� l3y �� 8$,-

<( �X�j,-ME� J�(jM�( �M7 2�MH,X N *7�� 'N�� #N� q�E( $7 O> ��$K *1 2�L6( 8$,-51 ������

1. Decrase Evasion

2.) )�6�0"�"2002 � )(27

Page 19: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

H*:ID:"J'G )J K5ID )L( � '()*( ?@"6-A( BC!lD E�F#> 5, F!G5,157

���1354 !"#1383 $%&'( )�*+, )-./0 1�- 23 / 245+6 7*# 8# 9: .1�# 2;<+= >.?@1+&A B&* )#?CD 23 !EFG6 H*ICJ K+( �3 L%M -�* )�*+, !4N< O8.# PL%(/+:$.#Q&= 2*�6+&� )�&*+,

/ -+R= !6 .#+S !�.+3 -.?6 !D�T;,# 7R6�J U/%C@ .- $-+<B/C2 P3NPV /IRR4)�&*+, +A

7R&3 V&*8?J 8�&3 )#I&R6 / -+&< +&A $.#Q= 2*�6+� !GF3 -?� WJ#+6 / L%M 2X��Y6 $.#Q= 2*�6+�.-+R= !6 .#+S !�.+3 -.?6 P!4[C"#

6 .����� ��! "##$%T( \]5 7RRNJ $#+3)#+^_ �?6+< 8# 2(?5.1�# L%M L-�`;�#

!2

22

0d

Varzn

"/#$

L%M +_a �?6+< .- 2_2%Z )�CRTb# cd� $#+3 -.#%(�;�# ��6+( .#%'695+&3#+3 P%@.-1.96!&6

/ %M�3R6 �]C*# .- 2_ $-./0+3 +;6#.�: 9(�*.#/ .#%'6 -IT;�- )#I�?TG6e&5 1&<�*.- $�A ��� !b 2TR31373 !"#1383��&� .- 1&RT_ 7&*# P 2&^Rf�](0 8# .%&M�3 !&613837*+;&GR3

2&(?T( \&]5 7*+;&GR3 2&_) 1&�# L%&M L-�`;&�# >�X��Y6 $#+3 .#%'6 7*# 8# P1�# 2;M#- #. .#%'6, .- !J�6%&'6 $+&R= 2&(?T( .- -IT;&�- 9(�&*.#/ .#%&'6 .(%M %A#?g H@�5+&3#+3 $.�&60 2&N6�

1170876517497 .#%'6 7RChTA .%M�3 !6d +3#+3 e4d6 $�dg �*45000 L%M 2;<+= +i( .- ��*. )�CRTb# �3 P.?3I6 2(?T( 8# L-�`;�# �3 2_ 1�# !CN6 )#%3 7*# .1�#958# P-IT;&�- -./0+&3 P%@.-

+j_#%5 )0 !NS#/ .#%'64500 .1M#- %A#?g kl;g# )�6?J!f�&m( 2&(?T( \&]5 .#%&'6 1*�m( .- .#%'6 2_ 2X��Y62221.%*0 !6 1�- 23

$�A ��� .- �A 9(�*.#/ 7Rn(�R6 8# 2_ !J.?@ .-1373 !"#13831&4D 2&3 P%&M !6 L-�`;�# 23 2(?T( \]5 P9(�*.#/ )%M Bo?_512.1<�* !6 pA�_ -.?6

7*# .- !X[( $�dgeR'YJ0.0176 1X[( �-�N6 2_ P1�# L%M 2;<+= +i( .-450002&3 ��&*. ��� .- -IT;�- q�?;61383 )2561825.%M�3 !6 (��*.

1. Cash Flow2. Benefit/Cost3. Net Present Value4. Internal Rate of Return5. Cochran’s Sample Size Formula

Page 20: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

158&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

!D�&T;,# / $-�&E;S# >�X&��Y6 / .�&60 +&;<- q�?J P!<-�EJ r�F;(# >.?@ 23 $+R= 2(?T( )�R6 8# / !f#+,# >.?@ 23 ($-�E;S# >�X��Y6 L/+=)139�� s4;F6 2XNM!D�&T;,# 7R6�J )�68

H6�M $.�60 2N6�, !(?C_ $�A 2(?T( .1�# 2;<+= >.?@ P.?G_ $�m(�;�# !6�TJ cd� .-2591 ��� .- 2_ %M�3 !6 !(#+Rn3 $+T;[6 8# -.?61383�&3 �&m(0 $# 2&TR3 t�&XJ.# / %&(# L%&M 2;[G(8�3

) .1&�# L-?3 $.�X,# L%M 2TR3 W"�S .- !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68��2221>2591(-#%&NJ -. 8# 9&: .192 H6�M .?_Q6 !f�m( $�A L-#- P-.?62202 / )#-+6 $.�60 2N6�, 8# -.?6310 2N6�, 8# -.?6

V*8?J $#.#- PL%M %Rf�J $�A 2(?T( !(#/#+< V*8?J .1�# )�(8 $.�6088 / )#-+6 %@.-12%&@.-P)�;&�# u�&( 24T, 8# !J�Dlb# $#.#- .?_Q6 $�A 2(?T( .%M�3 !6 )�(8)#I&R6 P��v;&M# 2'3�&� )#I&R6

.- $.�&, 2"�&�/- +T;&[6 $�*#I6 / 2"��/- !NRT]J -IT;�- P-IT;�- q�?;6 )#IR6 P$+T;[6 w4X6 $�m"�� !(�68 L8�31373 ��� �J1383.%CM�3 !6

7 .,' <848 ?#.@% ( �6;�% $+T;[6 $�*#I6 P .?_Q6 $�A-#- .-2&��Y6 +&*8 H^&M 23 $+T;[6 �?6+< / $.�, 2"��L%&M 2X

.1�#

P-?&T( r�&F;(# #. !6?&TD \RT&EJ B&* $.�&60 2&N6�, B&* $#+&3 )#?J !T( L.#?TA 2^C*# 23 +i($�&A L-#- $�&CX6 +&3 / ��&� L- !b -+< +A %60.- 7Rn(�R6 .?iC6 7*%3 / L%M 7*/%J +*8 $?*.�C�

$�m"��1373 �J1383 ��� .- 2_1383&3 2&,?J �&3 / L%*-+= WJ+6 1�# L%M .#+S+3/ HS#%&5 2 �/%, x+M 23 P$%60 .- BA- L- 23 $-IT;�- w4X6 7*# P-#%D# +j_#%51.%M $%C3 \R['J

�/%, .-1 2N6�, H_ ��v;M# 2'3�� 7Rn(�R6 P26.1.-.#- .#+S !3?4d6 cd� .- 2_ P1�# ���-/./ P$8#-+&: 2&TR3 y&CA+< 2N&�?J 2&4T, 8# !&`4;F6 H&*z- %(#?J !6 r?4d6 cd� 7*# �?E5

$/+R(P.�&_ 8# !&M�( {-#?5 pA�_ P��v;M# $#%;3# 8# 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: / .�_ .#8�3 23 )#?, .�_+;&GR3 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� 2_ P%M�3 +6# 7*# 8# !M�( %(#?J !6 7RChTA / >?< P!=-�;<# .�_ 8#

Page 21: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8159

�&X| 8# �A L�=.�_ 7*# 7R4}�M 2_ 1�# L-?3 e<?6 ~.I3 $�A L�=.�_ 7R4}�M $# 2TR3 pM?: .- > 8# !M�( .#+< / L-?3 .#-.?g+3 $+;GR3 !4vM�NC,2 3,�9O .1�# +;T_ �A L�=.�_ 7*# .-

1(LI1P#Q-I R#ST% �C ( �$+,I ?O =8 7L+D=8 7,' R'8 �C 7=,+D �$+,I 7L-C �#QN% ..- ��*. 23 $+T;[6 w4X6 7Rn(�R6 .- BA- +A 2'3�� 7Rn(�R6 .- H_ 8# 1X[( $+T;[6 q�?;6!n;[G(8�3

)�(8 )#-+6 H_2N6�,

)�(8 )#-+6 H_2N6�,

z�3 %5 7Rf�: %5 BA-

$%60.-735.914 1.064.180 985.562 15 19 18 18.2% 8.0% 9.2% 572.045 389.165 BA-850.741 1.210.228 1.139.894 19 24 23 22.9% 13.0% 14.2% 745.936 572.046 BA-

1.084.333 1.652.604 1.579.176 19 26 25 14.6% 13.7% 13.8% 919.826 745.937 BA-1.412.915 2.334.421 2.278.034 21 26 26 12.7% 14.4% 14.2% 1.093.716 919.827 BA-1.631.454 2.334.421 2.616.966 21 27 27 9.6% 15.1% 14.5% 1.267.609 1.093.717 BA-1.741.338 2.694.402 3.199.881 22 28 27 8.3% 12.9% 12.4% 1.441.497 1.267.608 BA-2.828.877 3.229131 3.673.155 30 28 29 6.1% 10.6% 10.1% 1.615.387 1.441.498 BA-3.196.274 3.707.789 4.259.306 31 29 29 4.1% 7.9% 7.4% 1.789.277 1.615.388 BA-3.933.727 4.273.160 4.259.306 34 30 30 1.3% 4.1% 3.8% 1.963.168 1.789.278 BA-4.218.939 3.331.597 3.849.214 32 26 29 202% 0.2% 0.5% 2.137.059 1.963.169 BA-1.415.231 2.267.220 2.163.729 24.4 26.3 62.1 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 2.137.059 398.156 2N6�, H_

eR'YJ 7*# >�X��Y6 :VXC6

D# $�A -IT;�- cd� �?Eg .- )#?J !6 #. �?�?6 7*#8# !D�&T;,# 7R6�&J )�68�&� 23 !6l1&g#-+: .- !&@�g p&m, #+*8 .-?T( L%A�G6 IR( (pM?: 1YJ $�A L�=.�_ ) )�=%M 2TR3 $?��?&( 7*# .- !J.�XD 23 / -?M !T( L%A�G6 -+< +A $8#-+: 2TR3 +g0 ��� /- .- 2TR3 e5 )#IR6 $�A

>.?E3 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: 8# I*+= �A L�=.�_ 7B485* �O_ ulD#))�68�&� 2&3 -IT;&�- )#IR6 +;T.-?M !6 L%A�G6 +;T_ (!D�T;,# 7R6�J

BA- 23 t?3+6 !(#/#+< V*8?J 7*+;T_8 �&J108# !_�&5 2&_ %&M�3 !&6 \&A- B&A- L�*?&3 /.1�# 8#-+: 2TR3 2N6�, .- 7Rf�: 23 q�?;6 $�A %60 .- 1<�*.-.- B&A- +&A .- 2&^C*# 23 2,?J �3

L%M .#+S +3 $+T;[6 )#IR6 P$%60!n;&[3 IR( -+< ��v;M# 2'3�� +;6#.�: 23 P-IT;�- cd� +3 L/lD P (��v;&M# 2'3�&�) $# 2'3�� s4;F6 $�A L/+= 23 BA- +A $%C3 \R['J Pu/- $?*.�C� P-.#- \R';[6

�/%, e3�d6 BA- +A .?iC6 7*%3 2_ .-?32 ) 2&(�= 2&� $# 2'3�� $�A L/+= 2311�&J18P (��&�)18 �J26)/ (26 (z�3 23 7;<+= +i( .- P$%C3 \R['J 7*# 1m, L%M a�FJ# 1��R� .%M $%C3 \R['J

%&Co 2&3 L8�&3 7&*# 2&^C*# 2&]R;( �6# P1�# L-?3 $.�60 2N6�, H_ .- ��v;M# 2'3�� +j_#%5 / HS#%5 $�A L/+=) L/+=10 �* 2"��5 / >�X��Y6 \]5 p*#I<# W,?6 P-?M $%C3 \R['J ( +;T_ �* 2"��

�5 �*�;( 1S- p*#I<#$�&A L8�3 W*+'J 7R"/# )#?CD 23 .--+= !6 )0 8# H@10%&M r�&F;(# 2"�&�

Page 22: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

160&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

7;M#- �3 / HXS >�YR�?J 23 2,?J �3 2_109*+J�&6 B&* �&3 $%&60 .- L/+=3×10)10 :s&*-.) / ($%60 .- L/+=3!&6 !J0 >�'R'YJ .- 7*#+3�C3 .%M \RA#?g 2,#?6 (��v;M# 2'3�� L/+= :)?;�

9*+J�6 7*# -�N3# )#?J .#+S +J eRS- / 23�G6 HR4YJ / 2*I]J -.?6 #. )0 8# H@�5 �*�;( / +;=.I3 #..-#- $�A BA- .- $.�60 2N6�, \_ $�A 2(?T( -#%NJ 23 2,?J �38 /9 /10$%&C3 \R&['J )�&^6# P

-.?&6 $�&A L/+&= -#%&NJ #Q&" / 1&M#%( -?&,/ #I&]6 ��v;&M# 2'3�� �3 !*�A L/+= 23 BA- 2� 7*# ��;*�m( !�.+324 .%M�3 !6 BA- L- .- L/+=

1(LI2 R#ST% �C 74 �NC,2 7,' <(5U ( 7L+D=8 7,' R'8 �C 7=,+D �$+,I 7L-C �#QN% .P#Q-I

1X[($+T;[6

2N6�, .- $+T;[6 w4X6 7Rn(�R6 2N6�, .- 2'3�� 7Rn(�R6 2'3�� L+;[= $# 2'3�� L/+= BA-$%60.-

2N6�, /- )�(8 )#-+6 H_ )�(8 )#-+6 H_ ��)(�1.5 698,162 1,022,990 917,175 13 13 13 11 �J18��� BA-1- L/+=1

BA-11.3 853,473 1,069,028 1,038,775 20 22 22 18 �J26��� BA-1- L/+=21.3 849,725 1,143,909 1,107,886 28 29 29 26z�3 23 BA-1- L/+=31.4 722,657 1,044,268 975,926 14 14 14 11 �J18��� BA-2 - L/+=1

BA-21.3 937,838 1,224,906 1,165,594 22 22 22 18 �J26��� BA-2 - L/+=21.1 1,161,043 1,276,260 1,255,562 30 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-2 - L/+=31.4 773,760 1,119,170 993,566 14 14 14 11 �J18��� BA-3 - L/+=1

BA-31.3 1,249,972 1,599,777 1,565,028 22 22 22 18 �J26��� BA-3 - L/+=21.2 1,459,905 1,744,182 1,708,453 30 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-3 - L/+=30.9 1,178,480 1,069,188 1,086,002 17 15 15 11 �J18��� BA-4 - L/+=1

BA-41.3 1,446,406 1,841,973 1,805,053 22 22 22 18 �J26��� BA-4 - L/+=21.1 1,921,635 2,044,391 2,029,949 31 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-4 - L/+=31.2 1,039,188 1,244,332 1,229,679 14 14 14 11 �J18��� BA-5 - L/+=1

BA-51.4 1,690,681 2,351,148 2,296,564 22 22 22 18 �J26��� BA-5 - L/+=21.1 2,194,002 2,390,396 2,374,783 30 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-5 - L/+=30.9 1,439,322 1,301,289 1,335,797 18 15 16 11 �J18��� BA-6 - L/+=1

BA-61.5 1,791,674 2,681,948 2,627,992 22 23 23 18 �J26��� BA-6 - L/+=21.1 2,446,922 2,721,360 2,697,330 30 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-6 - L/+=3

2(?T( %S�< 2,789,431 2,789,431 %S�<2(?T( 15 15 11 �J18��� BA-7 - L/+=1

BA-71.3 2,496,064 3,190,440 3,166,496 22 23 23 18 �J26��� BA-7 - L/+=21.1 2,868,032 3,248,283 3,215,799 31 30 30 26z�3 23 BA-7 - L/+=31.2 3,196,274 3,707,789 3,673,155 31 29 29 11z�3 23 \;GA BA- BA-81.1 3,933,727 4,273,160 4,259,306 34 30 30 11z�3 23 \m( BA- BA-90.8 4,218,939 3,331,597 3,849,214 32 26 29 11z�3 23 \A- BA- BA-101.4 1,588,005 2,267,220 2,184,716 24.4 26.3 26.1 n(�R62N6�, H_ !(8/ 7R

eR'YJ 7*# >�X��Y6 :VXC6

Page 23: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8161

��v;M# 2'3�� �3 L/+= 23 t?3+6 (-+6 / )8) 2N6�, H_ .- !(#/#+< 7*+;GR326!&6 z�&3 2&3 ��&�$#.#- )#-+&6 2&N6�, 7R&ChTA .-.#- U#%&E6 )#-+&6 / )�&(8 2&N6�, /- +&A .- �?&�?6 7&*# .%M�3

7Rn(�R62�(8 23 1X[( +;GR3 ��v;M# 2'3�� ���L%&M .#+&S+3 $+T;&[6 7Rn(�&R6 w&4X6 �&6# .%M�3 !6 ) ��X*+'J )#-+6 $#+31.4.- )#-+&6 2&3 1X[( )�(8 $-IT;�- 7R*�: x?d� 8# !_�5 2_ %M�3 !6 +3#+3.%M�3 !6 .�_ .#8�3

�/#%&, >�&Dlb# 7R&ChTA / +&Rg# $?*.�C� /- 23 2,?J �31 /2+&A 8# >#%A�&G6 -#%&NJ 2&_7Rn(�R6 / -+6/ )8 2N6�, )#?J !6 P%C_ !6 �FG6 #. �m(0 !;<�*.- $+T;[6 w4X6 / ��N;M# e3#?�

%60.- 9*+J�6 2*#.- +A 23 2_ -+_ �+<-9*+J�6 B* +��5 ��5 .- 2_ 2'3��3*10P%&M�3 !&6 �A 2*#.- 7*# 8# B* +A )8/ 9�� / -#- 1X[( #. $+T;[6 w4X6 / ��v;M# 2'3�� 14Eg /- )#?J !6

�, .- %*%, >�R@?Eg �3 #. �/%&, .- �.%C6 >�Dlb# .-?T( �FG6 -+6 / )8 $.�60 2N61 /2!(�R6 BA- L�*/ 23 �A BA- 8# $-#%NJ .- $+T;[6 w4X6 / ��v;M# e3#?� 7R3 #. !@�g >/�`J2

�J67R&ChTA / )#-+&6 / )�&(8 7R3 .�_ .#8�3 23 -/./ 7� >/�`J +n(�R3 %(#?J !6 2_ P%A- !6 )�G(_ 8�3 8# )�(8 +J-/8 �/+gP$%&60 .- BA- +A .- $# 2'3�� $�A L/+= HR^GJ 8# 9: �6# .%M�3 .�

>/�&`J !&"/ -.#%&( -?&,/ -+&6 / )8 2&N6�, /- ��v;&M# 2'3�&� 14&Eg 7R&3 !&@�g >/�`J+n*-u?&� BA- 7R3 !=%C_#+: 7*+;GR3 .-?M !6 L%*- 2N6�, /- 7*# 7R3 $+T;[6 w4X6 +i( 8# !EFG6

*- -+6 / )8 $.�60 2N6�, .- \]C: �J.-?M !6 L%$�m"�&� !(�68 L8�3 .- )8 / -+6 $.�60 2N6�, /- .- �A -IT;�- %M. %(/.1373�&J1383 .-

�/%,3q&�?J 2&_ L-?&3 ��&� +&A r?&E6 -IT;&�- HS#%&5 8# �&A -IT;�- p*#I<# 1RNXJ +n(�R3.--+= !6 �l3# / W*?EJ .�_ !"�N*#.?M

�/%,32TR3 !;<�*.- -IT;�- 1X[( 2_ %A- !6 )�G( 7R3 -+6 / )8 8# \D# )#8#-+:1.9 �J2.4 2^(0 1[F( .-?GR6 ��T;5# 2� !�.+3 23 +]C6 �?�?6 7*# .%M�3 !6 ��� +A -IT;�- HS#%5 +3#+3

�?( 8# -IT;�- HS#%5 1g#-+: $#+3 PL%M 2TR3 / �6+<.�_ 7R3 !(�XJ �*7B485V* �VO1)0 V&XJ 2&3 / P+;T_ 2TR3 e5 1g#-+:,W65N%&�# L%&M !`;C6\&_ .- !(�&XJ �?&�?6 )�&ChTA +&=# 2&^C*# �&* / 1

B&o?_ $�&A 1_+&M / -#80 H}�&G6 / k+&5 .- +;&GR3 !(�&XJ 7&*# P%&M�3 2;&M#- -?,/ $8#-+: -/%5 eR'YJ 7*# $�A L-#- $/�_ L-#- ���# +3 2_ 2;M#- 1RD?�?622#. $.�&60 2N6�, H_ 8# %

1. $�A )�68�� k.�E6 / V3�C6 �-�NJ #+j_# 2_ �?�?6 7*# )�68�� $�A 2}%}- 8# !^* L.#?TA P%*�T( !6 L+b�F6 .�o- #. += 2TR3.1�# L-?3 !D�T;,# 7R6�J

Page 24: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

162&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

%CA- !6 HR^GJ1#I� 23 +R|�J p*?g \_ !(8/ \m� ��Y" 23 /#+&*8 .%&(# 2;&M#%( %C*#+< 7*# .- !f/ U?&'5 u�&i( / -.#%&( -?&,/ !(�&XJ )�&^6# (+;&GR3 / +&`( L- $z�3) ~.I3 $�A L�=.�_ .- �����#

.%M�3 !6 $-�E;S# )l_ $�A 1��R� 8# +|�;6 -IT;�-

1(LI3 R#ST% �C 1,2 X�/+ 85�928 ?:4L! �C ��,#Y,2 G90,6=8 8;�928 "#Z�,#+ 34;#+ �Q6,N+ .(�Y,2 <8) P#Q9I

)�(8 2N6�, )#-+6 2N6�, -IT;�- HS#%5

��� r?E6 23 -IT;�- 1X[(-IT;�- HS#%5

-IT;�- 7Rn(�R62(�R"��

23 -IT;�- 1X[(-IT;�- HS#%5

-IT;�- 7Rn(�R62(�R"��

1.8 215.125 2.2 261.663 116.8201.8 285.410 2.2 354.361 159.9901.8 376.831 2.2 457.433 207.2101.9 473.350 2.3 591.946 254.4601.9 576.177 2.5 739.736 301.5302.0 714.647 2.5 916.623 361.8302.0 914.623 2.5 1.133.373 458.0102.0 1.129.915 2.5 1.392.562 567.9002.0 1.422.314 2.5 1.733.533 698.4602.0 1.743.507 2.5 2.152.924 853.3802.0 2.105.276 2.5 2.619.756 1.066.201.9 2.4

>�X��Y6 :VXC67*#eR'YJ

-#+&<# $�&A -IT;&�- %&M. K+&( �+;C_ +3 !CX6 !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� %*%, $�A 1��R� 2;X"# .%&M�3 L-?&3 .#Q&= +&|# P%(#?J !6 IR( !n;[G(8�3 8# HXS ��� �C: �?b .- $+T;[6 $.#+S +3 1m,2

*# 2^(0 u?��&* / !@?Eg 2TR( �3 !@?Eg $�A 1_+M $�A 1��R� >/�`J 23 t?3+6 �?�?6 7.%M�3 !6 1_+M !(?(�S $�m3�[5 .- )0 �.- / �A -IT;�- / U?'5 1[R" 2f#.# L?Y( .- !;"/-

1.) .?:?^R(1386 #. $.�R;g# $�A 2TR3 / -#80 H}�G6 / k+5 \m� P(151_+&M )-/I&<# 2&3 t?3+6 kl;g# .1�# L-8 7RTFJ %.%M�XR6 2D?T]6 7*# 23 Bo?_ $�A

2.) P$-�E;S# >�X��Y6 L/+=1387� P(22

Page 25: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8163

2&TR3 s&4;F6 $�&A 2&*z 7R&3 #. %&60 .- V&*8?J �3 uIR(�^6 2_ \*-?3 )0 ��X(- 23 eR'YJ 7*# .-)#+Rn3 $+T;[6 / )�=%M#. $+&n*- $?*.�C� .?iC6 7*%3 / \RA- �RFGJ (9*+J�6 $�A 2*#.-)

.\Rf�T( !6 !5#+bB&A- B&* .-) 9*+J�&6 7*# $�A 2*#.- 8# !^* .- +Rn3 $+T;[6 �* L%M 2TR3 2_ %RC_ �+<

��v;M# $�m"�� !b #. !v"�X6 +Rn3 $+T;[6 .-.#-.#+S (�FG6 ��v;M# 2'3�� L/+= B* �3 $%60.-) p*?g30T;�- %P2&TR3 e&5 1&3�3 !D�&T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� 23 (!4N< )?(�S ���# +3 #. p*?g -I

.1�# L-?T( 1g#-+: \S. 7*# 8#9P-+&< +&A )�6.- \m� )0 %3/ $.�&^R3 2&TR3 !b�&R;5# L+&Rga 1&3�3 %18\m&� %

P1�# L%M �+< !J.�XD 23 .%M�3 !6 !n;[G(8�318.- $/ $#+&3 P-+&< 2&TR3 e&5 !;g#-+: w4X6 %$�A ���L%&M 2&TR3 #Q" .%M %A#?g 2C*IA P-+< >?< �J !n;[G(8�3 8# 9: $�A ��� / $8#-+: 2TR3

2&3 -/./ �&Y6 2&3 / 1&�# L-?&T( L+&Rga U/%C@ 7*# .- #. !v"�X6 $8#-+: 2TR3 $�A ��� !b .-.- 9&: .--+&= %&C6 L+&m3 )�68�&� 7&*# .- p*?&g +*�&ga H&Y6 8# �J 1�# .#+S P!n;[G(8�3 ���

O8.# ��Y" >.?@) $/ $.#Q= 2*�6+� �"�g !4N<NPV P�FG6 H*ICJ K+( B* �3 )#?J !6 (2&N6�, !n;&[G(8�3 ��&� e&R'YJ 7&*# .- 2&_ 2&*�: ��� B* .- #. $/ $.#Q= 2*�6+� !4N< O8.#

) $.�601383.-./0 1�- 23 #. 1�# L%M 2;<+= +i( .- ( ��� ��5 O8.# 2X��Y6 $#+3 L-�`;�# -.?6 H*ICJ K+( eR'YJ 7*# .-1383)19L%&M 7R&RNJ (%

1�#1��&� L- .- -+&< +A $-IT;�- >�Dlb# $/�5 q'< L-�`;�# -.?6 $�A L-#- 2^C*# 23 2,?J �3 .) $/ !n;[G(8�3 8# HXS +Rg#1373 �J1383��&j6 $#+3 )#?;3 �J -?3 $+n*- $?*.�C� 23 8�R( P%(-?3 (

BA- .-1 L/+= &2 q�?;6 ��v;M# 2'3�� $#.#- 2_22�3 !6 ��� .- #. -+< +A %60.- P%M12 ��� 1X[( 23 +Rg# ��� L- .- -+< +A %60.- 1X[( 7Rn(�R6 .?iC6 7*%3 .-8 7RTFJ PU?< $�m"�� HXS �6

1.!&6 )�[^* !6.?J q*#+M .- L%M 2TR3 $#+3 $+R= \RTEJ q*#+M -+^*/. 1'R'5 .- eR'YJ 7*# .- H*ICJ K+( r�F;(# -+^*/.+u.?J K+() 2d3#. 8# !;[*�3 P\Rf�T( 2,?J H*ICJ K+( 7*# 23 $-�E;S# -+^*/. �3 \RA#?F3 +=# .%M�31 +!^(�&3 L+m3 K+()*(1.- 2&_ (

� K+( )�TA 1'R'5 2*�6+� .?iC6 23 L%M 2TR3 B* $#+3 23�G6 $+R= \RTEJ q*#+M .- ��j6 $#+3 �6# .\RC_ L-�`;�# P%M�3 !6 $+A�)�&[^* !6.?&J q*#+&M P!^(�&3 �&* $-�E;S# x+b B* .- $.#Q= 2*�6+� �* $# 2TR3 x+b B* W"�S .- !D�T;,# 7R6�J .- $.#Q=

G6 q*#+M .- $+R= \RTEJ -+^*/. 2^R6�nCA #Q" .1�##. H&*ICJ K+&( 7*# )#?J !6 �--+= $-�E;S# 2X��Y6 -+^*/. 7*In*�, P23� .- / +_Q"# U?< �?6+< / $-�E;S# -+^*/. 23 2,?J �3 !;5 .1<+= +i( .- !"�6 $�A .#8�3 �* $-�E;S# $�A x+b !A-8�3 K+( e3�d6

u.?J K+( 7;<+= +i(10 !^(�3 L+m3 K+( >.?@ 7*# .- 2_ 1`= )#?J !6 %8.2'4J % .%�+R6 +i( 23 !'dC6 \A 8�3 2_ .1�# L%M !.%CM�3 !6 u.?J 8# +|�;6 -?g �A B(�3 !(?C_ !^(�3 L+m3 $�A K+( #+*8

Page 26: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

164&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

$�A-IT;&�- HS#%&5 .- 7Rn(�&R6 7&*# / %&M 2X&��Y6 ��&� +&A r?&E6 $�A -IT;�- HS#%5 %M.0 1�%3 )0 8# HXS $�m"�� -IT;�- �J %M r+� )0 HXS �6 )�R"�� r?E6%*.

1

P+_Q"# U?< >�X��Y6 u�](# 8# 9:2(PV) . %M 2X��Y6 +*8 x+M 23 L/+= / BA- +A .- -+< +A

-%D0.18 +[_ 8# 9:9)�6.- \m� % /3 8# $.�^R3 2TR3 %30-+&< +&A !&;g#-+: 2&TR3 e5 H_ % .%*0 !6 1�%3 2X��Y6 8# 9:PVP��&� +ANPV�?&T]6 8# 2&_ -+&< +&A $8#-+&: 2&TR3 )#./- H&_PV)�R"�&�

.--+= !6 2X��Y6 P%*0 !6 1�%3 s4;F6$+T;&[6 $�&*#I6 8# $-�&T;6 )�R"�&� !n;&[G(8�3 8# 9&: P+i( %6 9*+J�6 2*#.- +A .- -+< +A)#-+&6 $#+&3 r?E6 7R(#?S >/�`J 23 2,?J �3 .--+= !6 %C6 L+m3 !D�T;,# 7R6�J U/%C@ !;g#-+:

>?< 8# 9: -+6 +Rn3 $+T;[6 -.?6 .- P)�(8 /8# )�&ChTA %&C(#?J !&6 $/ )#%&(8+< / +[TA P$/ P.-�( / ��g -.#?6 8# +R} 23 P)8 +Rn3 $+T;[6 >?< 8# 9: 7^R" .%CM�3 %C6 L+m3 $+T;[6 $�*#I6.- >/�&`;6 -+^*/. /- 2_ -?M !6 W,?6 +6# 7*# .%M %A#?F( 1g#-+: $/ )�=%(�68�3 23 !v4X6

.\RM�3 2;M#- ()8 / -+6) 2N6�, /- >�X��Y62&&6?;F6 $�&&A L%&(/+: !F*.�&&J / !&&NS#/ $/�&_ L-#- )#?&&CD 1&YJ 2&&_ !&&M.#I= 2&3 2&&,?J �&3

)�n;[G(8�332(�R"�&� $.�&60 / !"�&6 r?&E6 >�M.#I= 23 2,?J �3 7RChTA / 1�# 2;<+= >.?@ PP)8 / -+&6 )�=%&M 2&TR3 P7Rn(�R6 >.?@ 23 !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68��14!n;&[G(8�3 8# 9&: ��&�

.%C*�T( !6 !=%(8 7R6�J )�68�� .- !n;[G(8�3 7� q�?;6 +��5 ��5 .- 2^C*# 23 2,?J �3 +6# 7*# !D�T;,#3/57 7� .- -+< 2_ %*�T( !6 r�]*# P%M�3 !6 ���71 �J72P%&M�3 L-+_ >?< !n"��

) )#-+6 .- !=%(8 23 %R6# �g�M 23 2,?J �3 2_72) )�(8 / (���747&*# 1Y&@ P)#+&*# .- (��� !6 %Rf�J W*+'J$#.#- $# 2&TR3 $�&A U/%C@ .- !=%(8 23 %R6# �g�M 2_ 1�# 2,?J H3�S .-?M

1.L/+&=) -.#- 1&'3�d6 1&�# 2&;<+= >.?&@ !D�&T;,# 7R6�&J )�68�&� q�?J 2_ !'R'YJ 8# !GF3 8# H@�5 �*�;( �3 W*+'J 7*# P$-�E;S# >�X��Y61387� P22.(

2. Present Value

3.) P)�CRTb#1385(

Page 27: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8165

P%&(/. 7&*# +3 )0 !]C� +|# / 2X��Y6 +3 )#?J !6 !J0 $�A eR'YJ .- 2_ %M�XR6 !@�g >�X��Y6 .-?T( I_+TJ

+_Q"# U?< O.#I= 7RChTA126?;F6 $�A L%(/+: $/. +3 2_28# !_�&5 �1�# 2;<+= >.?@T]6 2_ 1�# )0q&�?;6 >.?&@ 2&3 $/ )#%(8+< �* / +[TA 8# \D# -+< +A )�=%(�68�3 �?6��&�

!&6 .?_Q&6 $�&A W*+'J �3 .%C*�T( !6 L-�`;�# $+T;[6 $�*#I6 8# P-+6 +Rn3 $+T;[6 >?< 8# 9: P)#-+6 $.�60 2N6�, 2_ 1<+*Q: #. ?*.�C� 7*# )#?J20)�&(8 / !n;&[G(8�3 8# 9&: ���14��&�

# !n;[G(8�3 8# 9:H&XS >�X&��Y6 23�G6 !;[*�3 #Q" / P%C*�T( !6 L-�`;�# $+T;[6 $�*#I6 8PV / 1*�m(.-NPV) 2*�: ��� 23 #. -+< +A $+T;[6 1<�*.- )#./-1383H&*ICJ K+&( )�&TA �&3 / (19 %

8# 9&&: +&&Rn3 $+T;&&[6 +&&A $-IT;&&�- >�&&Dlb# $/�&&5 $�&&A L-#- 2&&^C*# 2&&3 +&&i( .-?&&T( 2X&&��Y6" �-?X( -?,?6 !n;[G(8�3 %C68�R( P!n;[G(8�3 8# %N3 $�A ��� 7RTFJ $#+3 !4XS $?*.�C� 23�G6 #Q

!&6 )�G( +Rg# )�R"�� >�R3+]J .\R;[A +Rn3 $+T;[6 +A !;<�*.- 7RTFJ $#+3 $%*%, $?*.�C� 23 �-�N6 !;3�| W*+� 2(�R"�� 2_ %A-10L/l&N3 H&XS ��� -IT;�- %0.2r?&E6 -IT;&�- HS#%&5 %

23 P1"/- q�?J 2(�R"��1&�# L%M �+< eR'YJ 7*# .- .%M %A#?g 2<��# )#+Rn3 $+T;[6 -IT;�- 13�| W*+� 2_10 ��� /- +A %1��&� )�*�: .- ��j6 $#+3 2^*.?b 23 %3�* !6 p*#I<# %1402 .-

23 W*+� 7*# )#-+6 $.�60 2N6�,19 )�*+, 8# $# 2(?T( PL%C(#?g !f�CM0 .?iC6 23 .%R�. %A#?g % BA- $%'(2-L/+=3P �/%, .- )#-+64.1�# L%60

L-�6 +n*- 1RTA# If�5 2;^(1112&h(�Co P)0 ��&�# +&3 2&_ %&M�3 !&6 !D�&T;,# 7R6�J )?(�Sr?&E6 -IT;�- HS#%5 8# +;T_ $-IT;�- $#.#- P!J#?C� $�A p*#I<# !6�TJ ��TD# 8# 9: $-+<

2(�R"�&� r?E6 -IT;�- HS#%5 1g#-+: 23 s�?6 )�68�� P%M�3 ��� .- 1"/- .%&M�3 !&6 $/ 2&38# $-#%&NJ 2&_ -?&GR6 �D�3 �?�?6 7*#24!(�&R6 $�m"�&� .- Ps&4;F6 $�&A B&A- .- PL/+&=

-IT;&�- HS#%&5 cd&� +*8 2(�R"�� $�A-IT;�- .- !J#?C� p*#I<# \}. !4D -?g $+Rn3 $+T;[6T;&�- HS#%&5 s'� �J $+;GR3 u�S.# 1g#-+: 23 s�?6 !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� #Q" / %(+R= .#+S -I

.%M�3 !6 �A L/+= 2(?nC*# 23

1.VXC6 )�TA2.�?T&G6 q*#+&M 8# �/+&g �3 $/ )#%(8+< �* +[TA P+Rn3 $+T;[6 >?< 8# 9: 2_ -?M !6 2;`= !*�A L%(/+: 23 26?;F6 L%(/+:

.%CM�X( $+T;[6 1<�*.- $#+3 !d*#+M %,#/ +n*- ( ... / �#/-8# P>?< ) $+Rn3 $+T;[6

Page 28: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

166&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

!&J0 r?E6 2(�R"�� $�A-IT;�- HS#%5 23 #. >�X��Y6 7*# !n;[3#/ 2_ +n*- \m6 .�R[3 2;^(/ e&R'YJ 7*# .- .%M�3 !6 /. pR: .- $�A ��� .- �A HS#%5 7*# %M. 1X[( 24�[6 �%A- !6 )�G(

u�S.# / >�R3+]J ���# +3301&*�CD �&3 7RChTA / P2;MQ= �����&�# +&3 u.?&J K+&( 7Rn(�&R6 2&3.- !(�&m, B(�3 O.#I=30�A-IT;&�- HS#%&5 %&M. 1X&[( P2;&MQ= ��&�20+&i( .- ��&� .- %

W*+� / %M 2;<+=1.2 .%M ��TD#

1(LI4 R'8 7,' P0,6=8 ( ,' P\485* 7LN� 3,65I .2- <(5U3 ��#C 7,]Y,2 =8 (3485+) 7B485*1354 ,%1383 GZ9Q �̂B,C 1,2 _1383 _ <L�(5* 3L> �+�9`+ 1,21402

1354 1355 1356 1357 1358 1359 1360 1361 1362 136311.329 - 12.507 - 17.185 - 20.049 - 54.227 - 60.624 - 60.624 - 60.624 - 60.624 - 60.624 -1364 1365 1366 1367 1368 1369 1370 1371 1372 137368.739 - 68.739 - 72.558 - 79.241 - 79.241 - 95.471 - 159.150- 216.432- 285.840- 395.791-1374 1375 1376 1377 1378 1379 1380 1381 1382 1383

519.789- 667.205- 816.135- 988.006- 1.174.615- 1.447.819- 1.800.905- 2.174.029- 2.610.866 3.106.918-1384 1385 1386 1387 1388 1389 1390 1391 1392 1393

1.406.338 1.557.003 1.830.000 2.196.000 2.635.200 3.162.240 3.794.688 4.553.626 5.464.351 6.557.2211394 1395 1396 1397 1398 1399 1400 1401 1402

7.868.665 9.442.398 11.330.878 13.597.053 16.316.464 19.579.757 23.495.708 28.194.849 33.833.819 :$8#-+: 2TR3 )�68 >%630 :�*#I6 8# L-�`;�# )�68 >%6 P���19 :2*�: ��� P���1383

(NPW=209,578,078) -(B/C=4.0)- (IRR=47.9%)

>�X��Y6 :VXC67*#eR'YJ

V&*8?J 8�3 +3 u.?J +|# 7;<�* ��X(- 23 eR'YJ 7*# P%M +_a eR'YJ k#%A# .- IR( �lXS 2_ .?d(�TAC*# / %M�3 !6 !n;[G(8�3 2TR3 $�A %60.-!J.�&XD 2&3 .\Rf�T( !6 -.?g+3 �?�?6 7*# �3 2_ 1��]

HS#%5 p*#I<# 23 .?X]6 1"/- �%*�T( #%R: $%*%M $-?N@ %M. )�m=�( .?G_ .- u.?J )#IR6 +=#>�X&��Y6 !6�&TJ -IT;&�- HS#%&5 7&*# +RRvJ �3 VXd"�3 / -?3 %A#?g u.?J K+( �3 W��C;6 �A-IT;�-

NPV+RRvJ P9*+J�6 7*# $�A 2*#.- !J0\RA#?&g )0 H&R4YJ 2&3 $%&N3 1T&[S .- 2_ -+_ %A#?g.1g#-+:

!&4XS %&(/. 23�&G6 / .?_Q6 >�YR�?J 23 2,?J �3NPV+&3 -+&< +&A $+T;&[6 1&<�*.- )#./- 2*�: ��� ���#1383 H*ICJ K+( /197;&M#- 1�- .- 23 2,?J �3 .%M 2X��Y6 %NPV2&TR3 )#./-

R4YJ )#?;R6 P$+Rn3 $+T;[6 )#./- / $8#-+:8# )#?&J !&6 #%&;3# .- .-?&T( 2&f#.# #. !J/�&`;6 $�A H1X&[( \R&['JNPV$+&Rn3 $+T;&[6 )#./-)NPV22&3 (NPV ) $8#-+&: 2&TR3 )#./-NPV12&3 (

Page 29: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8167

2C*IA HR4YJ / 2*I]J-L%*�<1H^&M 2&3 eR'YJ 7*# .- 2_ �1<�* 1�-.�&E;g# 2&3 �&* / �/%, .- .-?GR6 L%R6�(5# P/ ��v;&M# 2'3�� 7;<+= +i( .- )/%3 $%60.- $�A BA- .- 1X[( 7*

.1�# 2;<+= .#+S HR4YJ / 2*I]J / !�.+3 -.?6 ��v;M# 2'3�� 7;<+= +i( .- �3 7RChTA

1(LI5�-6;' �Q6,N+ .- ( 7L+D=8 7,' R'8 =8 85+ ( 3B 7=,+D �$+,I (8 =8 5T� 5' <L6,0a(,T9+ 74 �NC,2 7,' <(5U

1X[(B/C6)�(8 23 )#-+ )�(8 2N6�, )#-+6 2N6�,

L/+= +A BA- H_ L/+= +A BA- H_ L/+= +A BA- H_ 2'3�� L/+=

$# BA-$%60.-

1.41.2

7.16.1

10.37.6

18-11 BA-11.3 5.3 7.1 26-18

1.5 3.5 5.1 26z�3 231.5

1.45.6

3.68.2

5.018-11

BA-21.4 4.0 5.6 26-181.4 2.8 4.0 26z�3 231.5

1.44.2

2.96.2

4.018-11

BA-31.4 3.5 4.8 26-181.4 2.5 3.4 26z�3 231.5

1.43.3

2.55.0

3.518-11

BA-41.5 2.8 4.3 26-181.3 2.4 3.1 26z�3 231.6

1.42.9

2.44.5

3.418-11

BA-51.6 2.7 4.3 26-181.4 2.2 3.0 26z�3 231.7

1.42.5

2.34.2

3.318-11

BA-61.7 2.4 4.1 26-181.4 2.2 3.0 26z�3 23

2(?T( %S�<1.4

2(?T( %S�<2.4

5.23.4

18-11 BA-71.5 2.8 4.2 26-18

1.3 2.4 3.2 26z�3 231.4 1.4 2.5 2.5 3.6 3.6 BA-\;GA

BA-1.3 1.3 2.8 2.8 3.5 3.5 \m( BA-1.0 1.0 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6 \A- BA-

1.3 2.9 3.7 2N6�, H_>�X��Y6 :VXC67*#eR'YJ

1. Benefit Cost Analysis

Page 30: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

168&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

�/%&, .- +&&n*- 1&RTA# If�&&5 2&;^(5 pA�&&_ P1T&&� 2&&3 �/# $�&m^A- 1T&&� 8# 1&_+5 .- L%*�< 1X[( 8# )�G( / %M�3 !6 \A- $�m^A-7&*# 8# .%&M�3 !&6 %60.- \_ $�m^A- +Jz�3 2C*IA 23

2&_ -?&T( �&D-# )#?&J !&6 P%&A- !&6 )�&G( -?g 8# !J/�`;6 .�;<. 2_ \;GA BA- 8# +R} 23 L�=%*-%&Co +&A .%&M�3 !&6 %60.- \_ .�GS# 1T� 23 %60.- .?Y6 1"#%D V*8?J 8�3 $#.#- !(?C_ \;[R�

!4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J �lTD U/%C@ .- V*8?J 2_�&3 >�&'Xb -?&� 2&3 !4&[C"# 7R&3 V*8?J 7*# �6# P1�# 1X[( )-?3 z�3 7RChTA .1�# +;T_ %60.-!&6 !D#%&J #. 2&;^( 7*# P)�(8 23 1X[( )#-+6 2N6�,

V&*8?J .- l&TD / %CM�3 !6 )�(8 23 1X[( $+;GR3 $%C6 L+m3 $#.#- \;[R� 7*# .- )#-+6 2_ %*�T(pR3 )#-+6 !4[C"# 7R32&3 t?&3+6 !(%&6 7R(#?&S 8# !&M�( +&6# 7&*# 2&_ %&(-+= !6 %C6 L+m3 )�(8 8#

.%M�3 !6 )0 $�*#I6 8# )#-+6 )�=%(�68�3 $%C6 L+m3 2]R;( .- / .#?(�g !;�+:+�1X&[( 8# L-�`;&�# �3 )#?J !6 2_ $+n*- HR4YJ!A-8�&3 K+&( )-./0 1&�- 2&3 P-?&T( 2&f#.#

+A $.#Q= 2*�6+� !4g#-) -+<IRR(+&A !A-8�&3 K+( )#IR6 2^C*# HR4YJ 2f#.# .- K+( 7*# .%M�XR6L-?&3 2&(?no $+T;&[6 1&<�*.- / $8#-+&: 2&TR3 $-�T;6 )�R"�� .- -+< +A q�?J P$.#Q= 2*�6+�

.-+_ %A#?g $.�* #. �6 P1�#K+&( 2X&��Y6 .?&iC6 23IRRO/. 8# L/+&= +&A / B&A- +&A $#+&3What–If Analysis�&3 /

?];[,) �FG6 k%A B* $Goal Seek7&*# k%&A .1&�# L%&M L-�`;&�# H&[_# .#I<# u+( .- (1X&[( 7&*# )#?J !6 $.#Q= 2*�6+� L-8�3 K+( .- +RRvJ )#IR6 2o �3 2_ 1�#B/CB&* -%&D 2&3 #.

�/%, .- !,/+g �*�;( PO/. 7*# 8# L-�`;�# �3 .%(��.62&N6�, 7RChTA / 2N6�, H_ BR^`J 23T, )8 / -+6 $.�60.1�# L%M $./0 V

P2_ 1�# 7*# 2,?J H3�S 2;^(IRR+&A !&J0 / H&XS $�A $.#Q= 2*�6+� H@�5 2_ 2N6�, H_$.#Q&= 2*�6+&� !&4g#- !A-8�&3 K+&( 8# P%M�3 !6 !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� .- -+<53.#-.?&g+3 %

$�]3 Pp*?g $8#-+: 2TR3 !"#?;6 )�R"�� .- 8#-+: 2TR3 +=# 2_ 1��CN6 )#%3 7*# / 1�#1&g#-+: -?T( !6 $.#Q= 2*�6+� �A B(�3 8# !^* .- #. p*?g 2*�6+� !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� 23 2TR3 e5

K+( �3 /197R6�&J )�68�&� .- $.#Q&= 2*�6+� 23 1X[( \A 8�3 P1M#- !6 #. L+m3 1<�*.- .�i;(# % P!D�T;,#34W&[_ +&3 L/l&D .?_Q&6 L%&M 2&TR3 2^C*# 8# +i( k+@ .-?3 !6 W'D %348�&R;6# %

!&4_ !=-�&;<# .�_ 8# P8# !M�( $�A B[*. PU/%C@ 7*# .- $.#Q= 2*�6+� !A-8�3 K+( .- +;GR3

Page 31: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8169

HS#%&5 2&3 I&R( #. -?&g !4v&M >#+b�&F6 +&n*- / >?< P.�_ 8# !M�( {-#?5 / >#+dg P!fI,/.1�# )#%R6 L%(+3 IR( .QnA. 7*# 8# / L%(��.

T;,# 7R6�J U/%C@ +=# 2_ 1�# 7*# +n*- HR4YJU/%C&@ B&* >.?&@ 2&3 1�#?g !6 !D�)FundL-8�&3 K+&( $#.#- HS#%&5 2&_ %&M !6 !*�A $.#Q= 2*�6+� .#8�3 -.#/ !;[*�3 %*�T( HTD (

$.#I= 2*�6+�53 )�68�� $.#Q= 2*�6+� $�A 1_+M $#+3 !6�R: %(#?J !6 �?�?6 7*# / .%CM�3 %.%M�3 !D�T;,# 7R6�J

23 +=#IRRN6�, H_ .- $%60 .- $�A BA-2&,?J $# 2'3�&� $�&A L/+&= 7;<+= +i( .- �3 2��v;&M# 2'3�� )#IR6 7;<+= +i( .- )/%3 2N6�, 7*# �/# BA- L.#?TA 2_ 1<�* \RA#?g .- �\Rf�T(

8# ($8#-+: 2TR3 >%6)IRR ) 1&�# .#-.?g +3 7Rn(�R6 23 1X[( !*z�3 .�R[31.6)�&G( 2&_ P(+&3#+3%5 1g#-+: +3 !CX6 )�68�� 1��R� %A- !6 L-�6 eXb -IT;�- HS#111 #. !D�T;,# 1"#%D P)?(�S

.%*�T( !6 �`*# !3?g 23 $%60 .- BA- 7*# �?Eg .-7^R&" .%&3�* !&6 26#-# )�ChTA u?� BA- )�*�: �J %60 .- \_ .�GS# .- 1"#%D V*8?J 1RN�/

)#-+6 $.�60 2N6�, ��v;M# 2'3�� 7Rn(�R6 2^C*# 23 +i(26.3 &� $�A L/+= P%M�3 !6 ����&3 $# 2'3� BA-) %C(�6 -%D 7*# 8# +;GR3 ��v;M# 2'3��2 L/+=3 BA- ) / (3 L/+=3 $#.#- P(IRR $+;T_

!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J )�68�&� 2&_ 1�# 7*# L%CA- )�G( +6# 7*# / %CM�3 !6 2N6�, H_ 7Rn(�R6 23 1X[( 1m, #. !X��C6 1��R� !;[*�3&>�*.�G<# +;m3/ s4;F68# .#+&< 8# $+&R= ?&4,e&5 1&g#-+:

8# !&M�( $%&C6 L+&m3 )#I&R6 8# 2_ P+_Q"# U?< kl;g# �J %A- >.?@ (��v;M# )�T;_ �?( 8#) 2TR3!(�]6 $.#?� L%*%:1$%&C6 L+&m3 )#I&R6 +n(�&G( ��<+@ kl;g# / --+= V`J+6 P%M %A#?g H@�5

%&D P�?&�?6 7&*# .%&M�3 !=%(8 L./- �?b .- ��v;M# $�*#I6 8# P.#-.?g +3 +;T_ -#+<#+&3 .- 1"#$�&A B&A- ) +Jz�&3 %&60 .- �3 $�A/+= .- .%A- !6 .#+S %R_�J -.?6 #. $.#--.?g7/8/92&3 (

\&_ -#%NJ / �A L-#- 1RA�6 23 1*�CD �3 7RChTA / !4vM 2'3�� +3 $+T;[6 w4X6 O8.# $+J+3 ��Y"dS +i( 1"#%D 2(?= 7*# $#+,# L?Y( +3 !4vM e3#?� +|# �?Eg .- )#?J !T( P�m(07^R&" �-#- !N

K+&( / %&M�3 !&6 !4v&M 2'3��+|# 8# +J $?S .�R[3 P$%60 .- +|# %�+R6 +i( 23IRR+&Rn3 $+T;&[6.-.#- -+< 2'3�� 23 1X[( $+;T_ !n;[3#/

�&3 $+T;&[6 )#I&R6 24&@�< )-?3z�&3 HR"- 23 2_ -?T( 2f#.# HR4YJ 7*# �3 )#?J !6 #. �?�?6 7*#� 23 1X[( 1R��[5 P1g#-+: )#IR6 L/+= / 1�# L%M \_�5 $%60 .- +|# / 1�# 2;<. 7R3 8# 2'3�

1. Free Riding

Page 32: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

170&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

2(�R"�&� $�&A -IT;&�- %&M. )-?3 +|�;6 23 �C3 / %60.- cd� 7*+Jz�3 )-?3 #.#- ��Y" 23 BA- \A-7&*# / %&M�3 !&6 !A-8�&3 K+( 7*+;T_ $#.#- P�A -IT;�- HS#%5 %M. 1X[( 8# !n;[G(8�3 8# 9:

+= 2_ 1�# �?�?6 7*# 7RX6 1'R'5H&_ .- 2&^C*# 8# +&i( k+@ BA- $z�3 $%60 .- $�A L/) !"?XS H3�S !*.#Q= 2*�6+� !A-8�3 K+( $#.#-46.8P%C;&[A !D�&T;,# 7R6�&J $�&A U/%C@ .- (%

) +&;T_ %&60 .- �3 -#+<# �3 2[*�'6 u�'6 .- !"/85.38# !&^* 7&*# / %&(.#- $+&;T_ $%&C6 L+&m3 P(%.�GS# 7R3�6 !D�T;,# 1"#%D V*8?J k#%A#-.#/ )0 2&3 $-#+&*# / %M�3 !6 %60 .- +: / %60 .- \_

2;&M#- H&6�J $�&, %&(#?J !6 $-/%5 �J !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8# +GS 7*# $%C6 L+m3 2_ %Co +A .1[R(.%M�3

�/%, .-6 2[*�'6 8# H@�5 .�;<.IRR 23 1X[( )8 / -+6 2N6�, /-IRR P2N6�, +A 7Rn(�R6 .%&M�XR6 2N6�, H_ .�;<. 23�G6B&A- .-4�&J6+&*8 �&A L/+&= 8# $+;&GR3 -#%&NJ )�&(8 2&N6�, .-

7Rn(�R6IRR7R&3 +;&GR3 V*8?J8�&3 )#I&R6 +n(�R3 P%(#?J !6 �?�?6 7*# / %(+R= !6 .#+S 2N6�, H_.%M�3 2N6�, 7*# .- $+GS

�/%, +n*- HR4YJ6 2[*�'6IRR$#.#- )�&(8 2N6�, H_ .- 2_ %M�3 !6 )�(8 23 1X[( )#-+6IRRJ!&4D 2&_ %&C_ !6 #%R: 1RTA# !(�68 L�*/ 23 �?�?6 7*# .%C;[A )#-+6 23�G6 / )�[^* �X*+' \}.6%A�&M \&A 8�&3 !n;&[G(8�3 8# 9: P)#-+6 23 1X[( )�(8 +;T_ $%C6 L+m3 ���IRR)�&[^*

�6# / \R;[A \_ kl;g# 7*#IRR 8# 2(�*#+=#/ $+|# P%(#?J !6 >%6 %C43 .- )#-+6/ )�(8 2N6�, .-�g�M .- +6# 7*# 2_ -.#Qn3 p*�T( 23 $.#-.?g+3 )#IR67&*# / 1&�# +J -?mG6 )�(8 / )#-+6

) 2'3�&� )#I&R6 >/�`J +|# %C*0 +3 �?�?626.3H&3�'6 .-4/24)-?&3 z�&3 / ()�&(8 $#+&3 ��&�1.4 7RChTA / -IT;�- cd� $+3#+36 !6 )�(8 H3�'6 .- )#-+6 +;GR3 $%C6 L+m3 ���.%M�3

)?;� .- 2_ 2(?n(�TAIRR �/%, .- 2N6�, H_6 -/%5 -?M !6 L%*-48 $.�60 2N6�, 8# %!CN* 2N6�, H_ 7Rn(�R6 +*8%53.2IRR=L-#- )�&G( !J/�&`;6 $?n"# �3 �/%, .- 2_ P%(.#- .#+S

7&*# 7R&3 P$+&GS 7R3 %60 .- V*8?J 8�3 \[R(�^6 B* 2_ -?T( �D-# )#?J !6 #Q" .1�# L%M48 &3 % 2 1T�52.%M�3 !6 \_�5 L%(�TRS�3 %

�/%, 23 2N,#+6 �37 ) $+&GS 7R&3 V&*8?J 8�&3 7&*# 2&_ %*- )#?J !629#. V&*8?J �&3 H&_ 8# (% / %A%R6 HR^GJ71 !4[C"# 7R3 $%60.- V*8?J 8�3 e*+b 8# L%(�TRS�3 % ,V62*�6+&� H&Y6 8# L-�`;&�#

.%M %A#?g e'Y6 )�68�� $�A $#.Q=

Page 33: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8171

1(LI6 �Q6,N+ .IRR 7,' <(5U ( 7L+D=8 7,' R'8 =8 85+ ( 3B 7=,+D �$+,I (8 =8 5T� 5'a(,T9+ 74 �NC,2

1X[(IRR )#-+6)�(8 23

)�(8 2N6�, )#-+6 2N6�, 2N6�, H_

+AL/+=

H_BA-

+AL/+=

H_BA-

+AL/+=

H_BA-

+AL/+=

H_BA-

2'3�� L/+=$#

BA-$%60.-

1.170.92

105.490.6

123.183.6

117.385.3

18-11 BA-10.97 80.2 78.1 78.4 26-18

1.07 53.9 57.6 57.1 26z�3 231.13

1.0281.5

56.392.1

57.489.8

57.218-11

BA-21.05 61.4 64.3 63.7 26-181.03 46.3 47.9 47.6 26z�3 231.09

1.0663.1

49.768.9

52.966.8

52.518-11

BA-31.10 57.4 63.3 62.7 26-181.07 43.4 46.6 46.2 26z�3 231.05

1.0753.2

46.855.6

50.355.2

49.918-11

BA-41.21 49.6 60.1 59.1 26-181.00 45.2 45.4 45.4 26z�3 231.13

1.1346.4

45.052.6

51.052.2

50.518-11

BA-51.35 50.0 67.5 66.1 26-181.06 43.2 46.0 45.8 26z�3 231.15

1.1543.9

43.550.3

50.148.7

49.618-11

BA-61.41 44.8 63.3 62.2 26-181.07 43.1 46.0 45.7 26z�3 23

1.09 47.787.6

52.087.6

51.718-11

BA-71.18 56.7 67.1 66.7 26-181.04 47.0 48.8 48.6 26z�3 231.13 1.13 49.3 49.3 55.8 55.8 55.4 55.4 \;GA BA-

BA-0.97 0.98 55.5 55.5 54.0 54.0 54.1 54.1 \m( BA-0.81 0.81 50.9 50.9 41.0 41.0 46.8 46.8 \A- BA-1.02 52.2 53.3 53.2 7Rn(�R6IRR2N6�, H_

59% 48% 48% +*8 %@.-IRR2N6�, H_$#.#- 2&_ %C;&[A !f�&A L/+&= L%&CA- )�G( P�/%, 7*# .- >/�`;6 y(. �3 $�A �?4�IRR+&*8

IRR.%CM�3 !6 2N6�, 7Rn(�R6>�X��Y6 :VXC67*#eR'YJ

Page 34: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

172&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

1(LI7 �Q6,N+ .NPV75^: "#C A6B�%B,C �W2,@+ ( �$+,I ?O "#Z�,#+ "#b,* ( c,C 7,' R'8NPV 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: )#./-

�3 -#+<#IRR 2N6�, 7Rn(�R6 +*8(��*. )?R4R6)

NPV $+T;[6 1<�*.- )#./- �3 -#+<#IRR 7Rn(�R6 $z�3

(��*. )?R4R6) 2N6�,2(?T( -#%NJ $# 2'3�� L/+= BA-

$%60.-

- 245 132 18-11 BA-1- 262 57 26-18

- 265 49 26z�3 23- 255 80 18-11

A- B2- 259 121 26-1870 - 167 26z�3 23- 242 22 18-11

BA-3- 284 151 26-1889 - 183 26z�3 23- 262 13 18-11

BA-4- 301 150 26-18105 - 204 26z�3 2362 - 14 18-11

BA-5- 350 121 26-18121 - 239 26z�3 2370 - 4 18-11

BA-6- 397 99 26-18137 - 217 26z�3 23- 425 3 18-11

BA-7- 478 58 26-18154 - 199 26z�3 23- 550 192 \;GA BA-

BA-- 641 98 \m( BA-191 - 12 \A- BA-

142,028 487,898 2585 2N6�, H_29% $+GS 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 1X[(

>�X��Y6 : VXC6 7*#eR'YJ

2,?J H3�S 2*�6+� / !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 e*+b 8# �lXS IR( )�68�� $�A $.#Q= 2*�6+� 2_ 1�#P$+&GS 7R&3 V*8?J8�&3 2X��Y6 .?iC6 23 .%(# 2;<+= H^M )0 8# H@�5 $�A1X&[( 8#NPV )#./-

Page 35: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8173

�3 $-#+<# 2TR3 e5 1g#-+:IRR +*8IRR 23 2N6�, 7Rn(�R6NPV$-#+&<# $+T;[6 1<�*.- )#./- �3IRR3 $z�IRR.1�# L%M L-�`;�# 2N6�, 7Rn(�R6

1(LI8 &64;04 5F4 .5 =8 E=�% d5� %IRR�$+,IIRR K+( .- 2N6�, H_

u.?J25%IRR u.?J K+( .- 2N6�, H_20%

%M.IRR L/+= +A BA- H_ L/+= +A BA- H_ $# 2'3�� L/+= $%60.- BA-0.5 117.8

86.2117.3

85.3 BA-1- L/+=1

BA-11.1 79.5 78.4 BA-1- L/+=21.6 58.7 57.1 BA-1- L/+=30.8 90.7

58.889.8

57.2BA-2- L/+=1

BA-21.4 65.1 63.7 BA-2- L/+=21.9 49.5 47.6 BA-2- L/+=31.2 68.0

54.166.8

52.5BA-3- L/+=1

BA-31.3 64.0 62.7 BA-3- L/+=21.8 48.0 46.2 BA-3- L/+=31.7 56.9

51.355.2

49.9BA-4- L/+=1

BA-41.2 60.3 59.1 BA-4- L/+=21.5 46.8 45.4 BA-4- L/+=31.8 53.9

51.352.2

50.5BA-5- L/+=1

BA-50.5 66.5 66.1 BA-5- L/+=20.9 46.7 45.8 BA-5- L/+=31.8 50.5

50.048.7

49.6BA-6- L/+=1

BA-60.3 62.4 62.2 BA-6- L/+=20.6 46.3 45.7 BA-6- L/+=30.1 87.7

51.887.6

51.7BA-7- L/+=1

BA-70.0 66.7 66.7 BA-7- L/+=20.1 48.7 48.6 BA-7- L/+=30.1 55.5 55.5 55.4 55.4 \;GA BA-

BA-0.0 54.1 54.1 54.1 54.1 \m( BA-0.1 46.9 46.9 46.8 46.8 \A- BA-0.8 54.0 53.2 7Rn(�R6IRR2N6�, H_0.0 48% 48% +*8 %@.-IRR2N6�, H_

-3% 26% 29% $+GS 7R3 V*8?J8�3 %@.->�X��Y6 :VXC67*#eR'YJ

Page 36: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

174&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

J �&3 2&_ -?&M x+d6 L%C(#?g $#+3 �#?� 7*# 7^T6 eR'YJ 7*# .-!A-8�&3 K+&( 2&3 2&,?53 P%.#+&S+3 Pp*?&g $�&A !&,/+g / �A $-/./ 7R3 !'dC6 $# 2(8#?6 2(?no !D�T;,# 7R6�J U/%C@7R&3 / !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J8�3 )#?CD �3 eR'YJ 7*# .- 2_ 1�# $# 2;^( )�TA 23 L.�M# P���: P-8�� !6

( 8# !D�T;,# 7R6�J U/%C@ !J.�XD 23 .\*# L%M I_+T;6 )0 +3 $+GSH&[( 2&3 / -+&R= !6 !4N< H[ !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J8�3) %A- !6 !4XS71/ 2&(?= >�&R"�6 V&*8?J P$+&GS 7R&3 -+&^*/. 2&^R"�5 .- (%

8# PH&[( B&* .- +Jz�3 %60.- �3 -#+<# 8# 2_ %*�T( !6 \RiCJ $# 2(?= 23 #. !f#-8 +'< .?Y6 1"#%D�C6 $+[_ .%3�* ��';(# ($%60.- $�m^A-) +n*- +GS 23 $+GS)�68�&� +&Rg# $�m"�&� k.�E6 / V3

.%M�3 !6 �?�?6 7*# L#?= !D�T;,# 7R6�J

8 E=�% 5F4 ?#.@% .+&3 )0 +|?&6 >#+&RRvJ / V&*8?J 8�3 7*# +3 #. u.?J K+( +|# !;[*�3 26#-# .-IRR9*+J�&6 2&*#.- +&A

+|# Pu.?J +|# !�.+3 .?iC6 23 .\RC_ !�.+35 8#) u.?J K+( p*#I<# $%@.-202&325%�%&6 .- ( �/%, .- 2_ .?d(�TA .%M 2;<+=+i( .-8 8# u.?J K+( p*#I<# P-?M !6 L%A�G6202&325�&mCJ %

.- %@.- B* !X*+'J p*#I<# W,?6IRR �?b .- 2N6�, H_207&*# .- !&"/ %&M %&A#?g ���1X[( 7R3)#-+6 2N6�, +;GR3)4.2H3�'6 .- ()3.2%C(�M?: )�(8 2N6�, .- (!&6 \_ kl;g# 7*# L

$#.#- $�A L/+= 8# $-#%NJ 7R3 7*# .- .%M�3IRR %M. .- $+;GR3 ��`;(# 2N6�, 7Rn(�R6 +*8IRR P \A +3 W,?6 u.?J K+( p*#I<# 2_ %A- !6 )�G( +6# 7*# .1M#- %CA#?g u.?J K+( p*#I<# 2d�#?3

2&o +&=# / .-?&GR6 +&= 2&TR3 U/%C&@ k.�&E6 / V3�&C6 �-�&NJ +;&GR3 )-.?g!T&�# K+&(IRR #. �lTD U/%C@ 2_ !J.?@ .- !"/ %A- !6 p*#I<# !T_.#%'6Fund2*�6+&� L-8�&3 /) %&*�T( HTD

�-�N6 �A $.#Q=IRR 8# $+GS 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 pA�_ �D�3 (.%M�3 2N6�, H_29 2326 p*#I<# / %3&3 %*%&GJ �&D�3 u.?&J p*#I&<# !J.�&XD 23 --+= !6 !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 $%@.-7R&3 V&*8?J 8�

.-?M !6 L%C*0 / +��5 $�m4[( )�*8 23 !4[C"#

98,]-^#* ( 75#U ��#9� .1. �?( 8# 2_ )#+*# !D�T;,# 7R6�J 2TR3 U/%C@ .�;g�� 23 2,?J �3FUND !6 .�i;(# P1�#

U/%C&@ .�&GS# 7R&3 %&60 .- V&*8?J 8�&3 P%&M�3 $+GS 7R3 �?( 8# L-#- K. V*8?J 8�3 -/.+&3 %(#?J !6 !6�nCA$?&n"# ��&�#FUND2*�6+&� >%&6 %&C43 L-8�&3 K+&( 2&_ %&M�3

Page 37: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8175

�-�N6 )�68�� $.#Q=53$.#Q&= 2*�6+&� �l6�&_ -#+<# 2TR3 e5 8# H@�5 V3�C6 / L-?3 %$+T;&[6 2&N6�, s&4;F6 $�&A B&A- 7R&3 $+&GS 7R&3 V&*8?J 8�3 >.?@ 7*# .- .-?M

$?&� 8# $+&GS 7R3 %60 .- V*8?J 8�3 2_ -?3 %A#?g !J.?@ 23 )#+Rn348�&3 -#+&<# 8# % 1T� 23 +Jz�3 $�A %60.- �3 $�m^A-52.--+nR6 \_�5 L%(�TRS�3 %

2.2&(�CR3 O?&g .?&b 2&3 P>%&6 %C43 .- $.#Q= 2*�6+� L8�3 K+( P-?,?6 $�A-./0+3 23 �C3307R6�&J )�68�� �lTD / .1�# !4[( 7R3 lTD V*8?J8�3 P%A%R6 )�G( #-%]6 2_ .1�# %

$?n"# ���#+3 !D�T;,#PAYG��&�# +&3 !;&[*�3 )�68�&� 7&*# #Q&" .-?&M !&6 L.#-#) 7R3�6 8#+J $+[_IRR (53 >%6 %C43 K+( / %30 -/%5 .- 2_ %23 1X[( P%M�3 !6 %

8�&3 )-?&3 7Rf�&: 7R&ChTA .%&*�T( u#%&S# p*?g $.#Q= 2*�6+� $�A 1��R� $+n(8�3 23 $.?Y6 1"#%D 23 2,?J �3 P!4[C"# 7R3 23 1X[( $+GS 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 )-?3 2(?= >�R"�6 /

.%M�3 !6 !(?C_ V*8?J \[R(�^6 $+n(8�3 $#+3 $-%]6 %R_�J P$+GS 7R3 V*8?J3./ B&A- +&A ��v;M# 2'3�� 14Eg / %60.- )#IR6 14Eg /- 23 %60.- V*8?J8�3 $?n"#

.-.#- !n;&[3 (k%A 2N6�, .- )8 / -+6 ) 2N6�, -#+<# 8# B*+A !J.�XD 23 �* / L/+= +A >/�`J 7^R".-.#%( -?,/ -+6 / )8 2N6�, /- ��v;M# 2'3�� 14Eg 7R3 !@�g

4. 1X[( )-?3 +Jz�32&3 1X&[( B&A- B&* .- +&;T_ ��v;M# 2'3�� �3 $-#+<#�&3 -#+&<#-#+&<# $8#-+&: 2&TR3 L./- �?&b 2&3 1X&[( L-8�&3 2&_ %&A- !&6 )�G( P+;GR3 ��v;M# 2'3��

.1�# ��[55.IRR0 2N6�, 23�G6 �X*+'J )#-+6 $.�6IRR�?&�?6 7*# / %M�3 !6 )�(8 $.�60 2N6�,

$#.#- )�(8 2^C*# 23 2,?J �362&3 1X&[( $+T;&[6 $�&*#I6 8# +&;T_ L-�`;&�# 2'3�&� ��&�1X&[( 2&3 2&,?J �&3 !&"/ .%M�3 IRn(#+3 �#?� 1�# 7^T6 P%CM�3 !6 )#-+62&N6�, .-

)#-+63.7 2N6�, H3�'6 .- )�(82.9P%&(#?J !6 7RChTA / .1�# �.- H3�S �?�?6 7*#L./- �?&b 2&3 1X&[( )�=%&M 2&TR3 $.#Q&= 2*�6+&� L-8�&3 )#I&R6 \&_ 1R&��[5 +n(�R3P)�=%&M 2&TR3 !&;g#-+: 2&3 1X&[( !;<�&*.- $z�3 1X[( +n*- >.�XD 23 .%M�3 $+T;[6

.1�# L-?T( !f#-8 1R��[5 +n*- $�A +;6#.�: 8# lTD6.# If�5 2;^( P2^C*# +n*- 1RTAIRR$�&A $.#Q&= 2*�6+&� H@�5 2_ )#-+6 2N6�, H_

2*�6+&� !&4g#- !A-8�&3 K+( 8# P%M�3 !6 !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� .- -+< +A !J0 / HXS

Page 38: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

176&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

$.#Q=53 2TR3 !"#?;6 )�R"�� .- L%M 2TR3 +=# 2_ 1��CN6 )#%3 7*# / 1�# .#-.?g+3 %8�� 23 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: $�]3 p*?g $8#-+:�&A B(�3 8# !^* .- P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�6

) H*ICJ K+( �3 / -?T( !6 $.#Q= 2*�6+�19 \A 8�3 P1M#- !6 #. L+m3 1<�*.- .�i;(# ( % !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� .- $.#Q= 2*�6+� 23 1X[(34P2&]R;( 7&*# 2&_ .-?&3 !6 W'D %

( k+@ .1�# U/%C@ 7*# .- $.#Q= 2*�6+� .- $/ -�T;D# 23 !3?g ���:2&^C*# 8# +&i W[_ +3 L/lD .?_Q6 L%M 2TR334.- $.#Q&= 2*�6+&� !A-8�&3 K+&( .- +;GR3 8�R;6# %

{-#?&5 / >#+&dg P!&fI,/ !&4_ !=-�&;<# .�_ 8# P8# !M�( $�A B[*. PU/%C@ 7*#7&*# 8# / L%(�&�. HS#%&5 2&3 I&R( -?&g !4v&M >#+b�&F6 +&n*- �* / >?< P.�_ 8# !M�(

L-?3 )#%R6 L%(+3 IR( .QnA..1�#7. ��v;M# 2'3�� 7Rn(�R626.1 cd� 7*# �?E5 .-.#- .#+S !3?4d6 cd� .- 2_ P1�# ���

.�&_ $/+&R( -/./ P$8#-+: 2TR3 yCA+< 2N�?J 24T, 8# !`4;F6 H*z- %(#?J !6 r?4d6 8# P.�_ 8# !M�( {-#?5 pA�_ P��v;M# $#%;3# 8# 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: / .�_ .#8�3 23 )#?,

/ >?< P!=-�;<# .�_ )�68�� 2_ P%M�3 +6# 7*# 8# !M�( %(#?J !6 7RChTA .%M�3 !6 L+R}1&�# L-?&3 e&<?6 ~.I&3 $�A L�=.�_ 7R4}�M $# 2TR3 pM?: .- +;GR3 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J)�&T;_ 8# !&M�( .#+&< / L-?3 .#-.?g+3 $+;GR3 !4vM >�X| 8# �A L�=.�_ 7*# 7R4}�M 2_

6�_ !"/ P1�# +;T_ �A L�=.�_ 7*# .- 2'3��7&*# +n*- !J.�XD 23 / .1�# 2;<+( 7R3 8# l #. �?�?6 7*# .1�# 2;M#%( Bo?_ $�mA�=.�_ O?: .- !(#%Co eR<?J � lTD P)�68��)�=%&M 2&TR3 $?&� 8# )�68�&� 2&3 !&6lD# $�&A -IT;&�- cd&� �?&Eg .- )#?J !6$�&A 1&g#-+: .- !&@�g p&m, #+&*8 . -?&T( L%A�&G6 IR( (pM?: 1YJ $�A L�=.�_)

)#IR6.- !J.�&XD 2&3 / -?&M !&T( L%A�G6 -+< +A $8#-+: 2TR3 +g0 ��� /- .- 2TR3 e5)#I&R6 +&;T_ ul&D#) $8#-+&: \_ >.?E3 2TR3 e5 1g#-+: 8# I*+= �A L�=.�_ �?( 7*#

.-?M !6 L%A�G6 +;T_ (!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� 23 -IT;�-8.�*8 8# !_�5 �A%60.- V*8?J 8�3 +3 u.?J K+( p*#I<# +|# )?680/ ��&5 $�m4&[( +;&GR3 )

1&<+= 2&]R;( )#?&J !6 !4_ ��Y" 23 .%M�3 !6 !4[( 7R3 V*8?J %*%GJ / U/%C@ L%C*0 +3 #. !@�g +R|�J Pu.?J p*#I<# 2_IRR 2_ %A- !6 )�G( +6# 7*# / -.#%( k%A 2N6�,

!T&�# K+&( 2&o +&=# / L-?&3 +&= 2&TR3 U/%C@ )�*8 W,?6 u.?J K+( p*#I<#IRR #.

Page 39: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8177

.�R[3 .#%'6p*#I&<# / $+&GS 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 pA�_ W,?6 !"/ %A- !6 p*#I<# !_%(#-%&]6 �/+&g / !D�&T;,# V<�&C6 pA�_ W,?6 +6# 7*# .--+= !6 !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8�3

1"�5 8# += 2TR3 U/%C@FUND 23PAGE.-?M !69. B* $#+3 / -?M !6 %"?;6 $8/. P$# 2TR3 +n*- U/%C@ +A �* / !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68��

�X*+'J) !n;[G(8�3 L./-26!(�&6.- $�&A 2C*IA 8# +R} 23/ %C_ !6 1<�*.- ��<+@ P(���u�&*# 7&*# .- .%&*�T( !&T( 1&g#-+: $+T;&[6 1&3�3 $# 2&C*IA P+n*- !fI, $�A 2C*IA /L+&Rga w"�X6 cRY@ $I*. 26�(+3 �3 P%(#?;3 %*�3 / -.#- .#+S ?T( / %M. 245+6 .- U/%C@

2TR3 L?,/ HY6 8# L%M2&;X"#) .%&*�T( $.#Q&= 2*�6+� 7�Td6 $�A $.#Q= 2*�6+� .- #.$�&A x+&b 1*+*%&6 $�]3 $-�E;S# $�A x+b !f#+,# 1*+*%6 $%EJ .- )%M +R=.-8# H&@�5 L?&,/ BT_ 23 !J.�XD 23 (.1�# !;*+*%6 L�X;M# B* +i( 23 P$.#Q= 2*�6+�

!&GF3 %&(#?J !&6 )0 8# H@�5 %*#?D / !4[C"# 7R3 $�A %60 .-V&*8?J 8�&3 uIR(�&^6 8#)#I&R6 2&o 2&_ �?&�?6 7*# 7^R" .%*�T( I_+T;6 !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 +3 P#. -?g %60.-!&;RTA# �&3 2"?'6 �%M�3 !6 8�]6 !4[C"# 7R3 V*8?J 8�3 )#IR6 2o �* / $+GS 7R3 V*8?J 8�3

#%&D 1��R� $#+,# %�. !6 +i( 23 !"/ .1�# V6�, !'R'YJ %C68�R( -?g / %M�3 !6 1" +;GR3 !;[*�3 P%60.- \_ .�GS# 23 %60.- +: .�GS# 1T� 8# !J�R"�6 2XM V*8?J 8�3 2(�*#+=

.%(.#%( !*z�3 !*#.�_ !(?C_ $�A 1��R� +i( 7*# 8# / -+R= .#+S +i( %6

Page 40: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

178&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

AC,-+eY4-G2=,0

��� 26?;F6 $�A L%(/+: 2N"�d6 O.#I= Pu�m"# P)�CRTb#1385,# 7R6�J )�68�� )�n;[G(8�3!D�&T; P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� P$.�60 -+^*/. �31387P

Pu#+m3 P!A�C:"!D�T;,# 7R6�J yCA+<" P!D�T;,# 7R6�J pA/�: !"�D 2[�?6 P)#+mJ P1384 P.?: )?*�TA I6+A P�.�T(#- !D�T;,# >�'R'YJ 2[�?6 �HRdNJ �* 2N�?J :�:/.# .- !D�T;,# 7R6�J

P!D�T;,# 7R6�J pA/�: !"�D 2[�?61379P!(�&[(# u?&4D W&;_ 7*/%J / 2N"�d6 )�68�� P)#+mJ P!��CM 2N6�, $�A 2*+i( P��XN6l} P!4�?J

1383 P%R]6 P!(�m`@# L-#8 7[5"/ $+T;&[6 $�&A x+&b) !D�&T;,# 7R6�&J .- !"�&6 7R6�J $�A O/.

($+f?h_0 p'(" P!D�T;,# 7R6�J pA/�: !"�D 2[�?6 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J 26�C4E< P1386 ��� P L.�TM P\m(29 �@ P59-77 P+@�( P?, e5"2&A- /- !b !D�T;,# 7R6�J / !;[*Im3 pF3 / !D�T;,# .?6# >#.�X;D# +3 !4R4YJ

) +Rg#81-1358(" )�;[3�J P!D�T;,# L�<. P1381 P1)4 �@ P(81-104 P$I*. 26�(+3 / $-�E;S# 1(/�N6 P!D�T;,# / $-�E;S# $I*. 26�(+3 +;<-"?n"# !�.+3 O.#I= $�A

)�68�&� 2"�&� �C&: 26�(+3 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J $�m6�i( .- !n;[G(8�3"P!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J )�68�&� P1384 L.�TM P6

P$I&*. 2&6�(+3 / $-�&E;S# 1&(/�N6 P!D�&T;,# / $-�E;S# $I*. 26�(+3 +;<-"+&3 $./+&6 O.#I&=)�68�� 2"�� �C: 26�(+3 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J $�A x+b .- !"�6 V3�C6 7R6�J $�mM/." 7R6�J )�68�� P

P!D�T;,#1384 L.�TM P13 P$I*. 26�(+3 / $-�E;S# 1(/�N6 P!D�T;,# / $-�E;S# $I*. 26�(+3 +;<-" 2'Xb +3 $%60.- O.#I=

)�68�� 2"�� �C: 26�(+3 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J $�m6�i( $%C3"P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� P1384 L.�TM P18

P!D�&T;,# / $-�E;S# $I*. 26�(+3 +;<-P$I&*. 2&6�(+3 / $-�&E;S# 1&(/�N6"/ $-�&E;S# O.#I&=���) !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� !D�T;,#1383("P!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J pA/�: !"�D 2[�?6 P)#+mJ P

P)#+n(#?J1385 P�?C'S P)#+mJP!;3�| )�<+D Pk�E(# 23�j6 23 1"#%D P)�, PI"/#.1383

Page 41: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

A6B�%B,C3D 5C E=�% 5F4 ( 34564 GH,�9I4 "#+J% K(L-M =8 L+D=8179

)#?CD �3 !(#+CF� P+S�3 P!(�g/.��"$�&A $+3#+3�&(!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J / !D�&T;,#"7R6�&J 26�C4&E< P P!D�T;,# 7R6�J pA/�: !"�D 2[�?6 P!D�T;,#1380 �@ P1[F( L.�TM Pu?� ��� P303 -

304 P-#?, P!f#Ig / !`dE6 P+< !TR4�"+&'< pA�&_ .- )#+&*# !D�&T;,# 7R6�&J u�&i( 1R'<?6"2&6�( P

$- P%R`61384 P11)51 �@ P(($-�E;S# 26�()51-70%XD PO?Cm6 P!(lR6 2"#" (.#?(�&g 2&,-?3 ��&�# +&3) )�n;&[G(8�3 %60.- V*8?J !�.+3"pA/�&: P

)�;[68 P)#+*# $-�E;S# $�A1379 P3)7 �@ P(79-100 PlmM P.?: !T��_")#+*# .- !D�T;,# $�A 2TR3 7*?^J $�A 2CR68" pA/�: !"�D 2[�?6 P)#+mJ P

O.#I= P!D�T;,# 7R6�J97S# >�X��Y6 L/+=P!D�&T;,# / $-�&E;S# >�X&��Y6 / .�60 +;<- P$-�E;"!]C&� )�&^6# O.#I&=

�?T&G6 -IT;&�- %&M. K+&( %(/. HR4YJ +3 %R_�J �3) $+T;[6 �?6+< .- B*+;6#.�: >�5l@#(2TR3 e5 +[_" P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� P1387

�68�� P%60.- !C< 1(/�N6 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J $�A x+b !"�6 7R6�J P7R[5 P$+RG6 P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )1381

P!D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68�� %60.- / !C< 1(/�N6" ��� r�;_1380P>#.+&'6 P)?(�S) $+= 2TR3 .?6#(!f#+,# q3#?�" P!nCA+< !T4D >#.�G;(# P)#+mJ P1380

Pu�[5 P.?:?^R(" e<# .- !D�T;,# 7R6�J )�68��1404"!"�&D 2&[�?6 P!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J 26�C4&E< P7R6�J pA/�: P!D�T;,#1386 L.�TM P\m( ��� P29 �@ P139-171 P>+3#. P76I"�A"!n;[G(8�3 u�i( xl@# -.?6 .- !(�m, B(�3 -+^*/." P.?: c"�@ ��. %TY6 P

P!D�&T;,# 7R6�&J pA/�&: !"�&D 2&[�?6 P!D�&T;,# 7R6�J 26�C4E<1380L.�T&M Pu?&� ��&� P �@ P1[F(77-79

X-GQ#.Z�4Alicia H. Munnell and Dan Muldoon, THE IMPACT OF INFLATION ON

SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFITS, Center for Retirement Research atBoston College (CRR),N 8-15, 2008, P 4

BARR, NICHOLAS and PETER DIAMOND, Reforming Pensions,CESIFO WORKING PAPER NO. 2523, 2009, P 3-24

Bogomolova, Tatyana, Pension Economic: Basic Concepts and

Page 42: ?@6-A( BC!D EçF#> 5, F!G5, H*:ID:Jijer.atu.ac.ir/article_3355_1647148e01ee8d2d0a3b807284348593.pdf2)) 8 3

180&'()* �+,-./0 1,2 34564 78,/9:4 7,'�'8;�,* <=,�>45

Relationships, Word Bank, 2002Casey B. Mulligan, Xavier Sala-i-Martin, Social Security in Theory and

Practice (II): Efficiency Theories, Narrative Theories, and Implicationsfor Reform, Columbia University, Universitat Pompeu Fabra, and NBER,1999, P 2-7

Damjanovi, Tatiana, On the Possibility of Pareto-improving PensionReform, University of St. Andrews, 2004, P 7-12

David Robalino and Albert Musalem and Tatyana Bogomolova, IslamicRepublic of Iran the Pension System in Iran: Challenges andOpportunities, Document of the World Bank, Volume I, II, Report No.25174-IR, 2003

Don Fullerton and Brent Mast, Income Redistribution from Social Security,The AEI Press, ISBN 0-8447-4214-7 (pbk. : alk. paper),2005, P 14-16,22-30,64-66

Freije, Samuel, “Income Distribution and Redistribution in an Oil-RichEconomy: the case of Venezulea”. Unplished, 2006.

John A. Turner, Inflation And The Accumulation Of Assets In PrivatePension Funds, social security administration office of policy, N 14,1980,P 2-6,14-16

John B. Shoven and Gopi Shah Goda, ADJUSTING GOVERNMENTPOLICIES FOR AGE INFLATION, NATIONAL BUREAU OFECONOMIC RESEARCH, Working Paper 14231, 2008, P 3-17

Schnabel, Reinhold, Rates of Return of the German Pay-As-You-Go PensionSystem, Department of Economics, University of Mannheim, WorkingPaper, 1998, p 3-7

Ximing WU & others, “Effects of Government Policies on IncomeDistribution and Welfare”, Institute for Research on Labor andEmploymet, Working Paper Series, 2002.