50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Background

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

ieee bell labs

Citation preview

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    50TH ANNIVERSARY SPECIAL FEATURE:

    THE DISCOVERY OF

    COSMICMICROWAVE

    BACKGROUND

    ........................................

    Charles Bahr,

    Marcus Weldon, and

    Robert W. Wilson

    The world is becoming more closely connected every day. In 2014, the total

    number of mobile phone subscriptions will have exceeded the world's popula-

    tion. As a result, access to voice, Internet (data) and television (video) services

    are now ubiquitous for over half the world's population. The global telecom-

    munications industry generates about 5 trillion USD in annual revenue and this has

    been shown to strongly correlate with GDP growth [1]. Furthermore, broadband con-

    nectivity demands are expected to accelerate in all practical metrics, which will re-

    quire the industry to innovate in areas such as signal transmission, coding, materials,

    applications and sustainability.

    In the midst of this communications technology explosion, we look back 50 years

    to a discovery that provided important insights into an explosion of another sort: the

    Big Bang. We show that this seminal discovery was the result of investigations into

    solving a practical problem (radio communications) and it has connections to a multi-tude of other subsequent innovations and discoveries. As a result, this legacy con-

    tinues to inspire innovators to come together to invent technologies and methods that

    push the boundaries of information and communications technology and that will

    transform the way humans and machines connect and collaborate.

    Cosmic Microwave Background RadiationThe 20th century brought an astonishing series of scientific discoveries and technical

    achievements. When the century began, radio waves and radioactivity had just been

    discovered. There were few automobiles and no aircraft. By little more than halfway

    through the century, however, humans had built general-purpose mainframe com-

    puters, launched artificial satellites, and orbited the Earth.Not long after the first manned space flights, an experiment by Robert Wilson and

    Arno Penzias opened up an unexpected new area of discovery. Their work with a

    Horn-reflector antenna and maser (microwave amplification by stimulated emission of

    radiation) amplifier revealed the existence of cosmic microwave background radiation,

    the first direct experimental evidence of the origin and evolution of the universe.

    Serendipity played a key role in the discovery. It united two people with a com-

    mon interest in mapping and measuring intergalactic radio signals. It brought all the

    necessary technologies together and put Bell Labs at the forefront of improving com-

    munications technology within the Bell System. It also created the changing political

    environment that handed the right tools to Bell Labs researchers to continue to invent

    a wealth of pivotal communications technologies.

    1538-7305/142014ALCATEL-LUCENT V O L U M E 1 9 Bell Labs Technical Journal

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    Wilson and Penzias did not set out to measure the

    remnant radiation from an expanding universe. They were

    taking part in a long tradition of Bell Labs: pushing state

    of the art communications technologies and discovering

    new science as a result. The Horn antenna and maser

    were both new technologies that, when combined togetherby the right people, paved the way for a breakthrough in

    human understanding and technology. In order to under-

    stand this, we have to delve a bit deeper into Bell Labs

    history and look at a sequence of important developments

    in communications that made the Big Bang discovery

    possible at Bell Labs in 1964.

    From Transatlantic Phone Calls to Interstellar NoiseFounded in 1877, the Bell System grew to become a

    regulated monopoly that provided phone service for

    virtually all of the United States and Canada. It was led

    initially by the American Bell Telephone Company.American Telephone and Telegraph (AT&T) acquired its

    assets in 1899.

    Bell Laboratories was created from the combined re-

    search and engineering departments of Western Electric

    and AT&T in 1925 to solve the technical challenges

    AT&T faced in its quest to provide universal service. At

    that time, good quality voice calls were already possible

    across much of the U.S., but few people could afford ac-

    cess to a telephone [2, p. 3]. Technologies like carrier

    modulation, radio telephony, echo suppression and reli-

    able vacuum tubesVall either invented or refined at Bell

    LabsV

    made these phone calls possible.But connections that spanned continents were still a

    thing of the future in 1925. These connections would re-

    quire radio, a technology that was not yet sufficiently de-

    veloped. Limitations in electronics had confined radio

    transmission to frequencies in the sub-MHz region, in the

    ..............................................

    Taking part in a long tradition of

    pushing state of the art communications

    technologies and discovering newscience as a result.

    range of 100 KHz. By the mid 1920s, higher-frequency

    radio experiments by Guglielmo Marconi and re-

    searchers at Western Electric had shown the potential of

    transmission at 5 MHz and beyond. Bell Labs began to

    focus research on radio transmission theory, transoce-

    anic radio, and broadcast radio.

    The decade from 1919 to 1929 saw dramatic improve-ments in radio technology. In 1919, the cutting edge in

    long distance wireless communications had been described

    by Swedish-American electrical engineer Ernst Alexan-

    derson, who listed five transmitters in the world capable

    of long-range broadcast. These transmitters operated

    between 18 and 25 KHz, each one delivering up to 100

    words per minute. According to Alexanderson, their col-

    lective capabilities offered the potential to achieve a trans-mission capacity 175 times higher [3]. Long distance

    radio communication existed but it was highly impractical

    for everyday two-way communications.

    The earliest transoceanic radiotelephone circuit was

    noisy and took a circuitouspath [3]. A phone conversa-

    tion from the United States to the United Kingdom trav-

    eled to New York City, then to Rocky Point, on Long

    Island. It was then transmitted by long wave radio to

    Cupar, Scotland, then by wire to London, and finally to

    the subscriber. The return signal traveled through London

    to Rugby, England, then over long wave transmission to

    Houlton, Maine, and then back by wire through NewYork City. The 60 KHz transmitting system in Rocky

    Point used six antennae 400 feet high. Receivers were

    also massive: the receiving antennas in Scotland were dis-

    tributed over three miles [4, p. 178].

    Transmission at higher frequencies would require

    much more advanced antennas. AT&T engineer George

    Campbell developed the theory of multi-element antenna

    arrays in 1919, but it would take nearly a decade for

    Edmund Bruce, another Bell Labs researcher, to develop

    and implement a practical approach to highly directional

    antenna systems [2, p. 27]. His directional Grecian-Key

    antenna had about 16 dB gain. Higher-frequency trans-mission was important at the time because low-frequency

    (60 KHz) transmissions were susceptible to interference

    caused by thunderstorms. High-frequency transmissions

    (several MHz) were immune to thunderstorms but suscep-

    tible to ionospheric disturbances. AT&T addressed these

    challenges by building a transoceanic system that could

    support diverse frequencies, and by adapting the live car-

    rier frequencies to the weather.

    In 1928, Bell Labs hired Karl Jansky to solve noise

    problems in the transoceanic links. The signals were then

    being transmitted at both the 5000 meter wavelength

    band (

    60 KHz) and the 16

    33 meter wavelength band(510 MHz) [5]. Jansky aimed for even higher fre-

    quencies, and by 1931, he had a working 14.6-meter

    (20.5 MHz) receiver with a rotatable, directional antenna

    (Figure 1). After over a year of measurement, he was able

    to characterize noise sources, local thunderstorms, distant

    thunderstorms, and a steady hiss that appeared to be

    coming from outer space. Jansky realized the signal was

    both extraterrestrial and extrasolar because its direction

    varied with the time of year. He pinpointed the origin as

    the center of the Milky Way galaxy.

    Jansky reported this discovery at the International

    Scientific Radio Union in Washington D.C. in 1932, andradio astronomy was born. Although Jansky was trans-

    ferred to other assignments, his work inspired another

    Bell Labs Technical Journal V O L U M E 1 9

    2

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    young scientist, Grote Reber. Reber applied to work atBell Labs but was not hired. Undaunted, he became an

    amateur radio astronomer, building his own 9.6-meter pa-

    raboloid reflector. He eventually reproduced Jansky's

    measurement, and went far beyond into areas that re-

    vealed various cosmic processes. His pioneering work

    marks him as the real father of radio astronomy, although

    Jansky made the first measurements [6].

    The Right Combination of People and TechnologyRadio provided the only practical transoceanic telephone

    link in the 1920s and 1930s, but AT&T had a broader vi-

    sion to further develop wired communications. One of themost important developments in long-distance signal

    transmission was a negative feedback amplifier invented

    by Harold Black, a Bell Labs electrical engineer. Bell

    Labs president Mervin Kelly offered this assessment of

    Black's amplifier in 1957: Although many of Harold

    Black's inventions have made great impact, that of the

    negative feedback amplifier is indeed the most out-

    standing. . . without the stable, distortionless amplification

    through Black's invention, modern multichannel transcon-

    tinental and transoceanic communications systems would

    not be possible[2, p. 61].

    Black's achievement is considered by many to be oneof the most important advancements of the 20th century

    in applied electronics. He had been working on amplifier

    distortion for years, with a goal of reducing distortion

    sufficiently to enable communications systems to employ

    thousands of repeaters. In a moment of inspiration, he fed

    a portion of the output signal in opposite polarity back

    into the input. This reduced the gain slightly but dropped

    the distortion by about 50 dB or a factor of 100,000. The

    idea was so revolutionary that it took 10 years for his pat-

    ent to be accepted.

    In anticipation of future needs, Bell Labs embarked on

    an effort to replace vacuum tubes with components ofboth lower cost and improved reliability. This led to the

    development of the transistor by Shockley, Bardeen, and

    Brattain at Bell Labs in 1947. Continuing efforts to im-

    prove the signal-to-noise ratio of communications links

    resulted in an understanding of the theoretical underpin-

    nings of information theory, which were first described in

    a two-partBell System Technical Journalpaper by Claude

    Shannon in 1948 [7, 8]. Even today, we strive to achievethe Shannon Limit in any communication system.

    To further illustrate the connections between inven-

    tions and ideas, as post-transistor semiconductor work

    continued, Bell Labs scientists Gerald Pearson, Calvin

    Fuller, and Daryl Chapin created an array of silicon

    strips, placed them in sunlight, captured the electrons

    freed by the light and turned them into electrical current.

    In 1954, they used the results of this work to create the

    first solar battery.

    The increasing demand for more cost-effective and

    longer range wireless telephone links fostered a need for

    better antenna systems. The 1941 invention of a horn-reflector antenna by Bell Labs scientists Alfred Beck and

    Harald Friis provided a key enabling technology. Com-

    posed of a parabolic section with shielded sides that taper

    .........................................

    The idea was so revolutionary it took

    10 years for the patent to be accepted.

    to a waveguide, the antenna combined the high direc-tionality of a dish reflector with the low noise properties

    of a horn. The horn reflector design was successful and

    eventually overtook competing designs for wireless

    communications applications. Within 10 years of the

    horn-reflector's invention, AT&T had built a network of

    microwave relay towers across the U.S. and extended

    long-distance voice and television signals across all

    types of terrain. Horn-reflector antennas were installed

    on many of these towers.

    Around the same time, another breakthrough technol-

    ogy was being developed in the Soviet Union. In 1952,

    Nicolay Basov and Aleksandr Prokhorov developed thetheory of the maser. The first working model was built by

    Charles Townes, James Gordon, and Herbert Zieger at

    Columbia University in 1953. Townes helped bring the

    maser to Bell Labs, a development that helped inspire

    Arthur Schawlow to invent its optical analog (the laser).

    The maser had several applications, for example as a pre-

    cision frequency standard or a very sensitive radio ampli-

    fer. Its superior performance as a low noise radio signal

    amplifier made it a key technology in the early days of

    satellite communications.

    Meanwhile, in wired communications, AT&T installed

    the first transatlantic telephone cable, TAT-1, which wentinto service in 1956. TAT-1 carried 36 two-way channels

    at a cost of over $1 million per channel [2, p. 341]. The

    FIGURE 1. Karl Jansky with his 100-foot rotatable antenna.

    V O L U M E 1 9 Bell Labs Technical Journal

    3

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    cable used 51 vacuum tube-based repeaters over its 1950

    nautical-mile link. Transistors were still too new at that

    time to be relied on for the cable. Transatlantic voice

    communications were greatly improved, but the improve-

    ments came at a high cost.

    The Horn Antenna and the Dawn ofSatellite CommunicationsIn 1957, the Soviet Union kicked the Space Race into

    high gear by launching Sputnik, a beach-ball-sized radio

    transmitting sphere. This satellite crossed the U.S. several

    times a day, and led to a political uproar that prompted

    the U.S. to step up its efforts to compete with the Soviet

    Union. Space investment increased, and within a few

    months, the U.S. had launched a similar, but smaller, sa-

    tellite called Explorer. Explorer, like Sputnik, was only

    capable of transmitting measurements of the space

    environment.As the space race began to unfold, the Bell System re-

    cognized that it was in an ideal situation to exploit space

    for communications. Millions of people were connected

    by telephone wires, microwave relays or radiotelephones.

    Yet there were gaps across the world that could only be

    filled by space-based communications. Satellites were en-

    visioned as a way to greatly extend the reach of voice

    and video. Most of the required technologies existed, but

    had not yet been integrated into such a radical new sys-

    tem, and the proposal for satellite communications be-

    came another important challenge for Bell Labs.

    In 1960, NASA launched Echo 1A, a 30-meter Mylarballoon coated with aluminum. Its aim was to develop

    and test communications relaying between widely sepa-

    rated points on earth. Data from Echo 1A would be used

    to adjust the design of subsequent satellite systems so that

    a working satellite communications network could be de-

    ployed. Bell Labs designed and built the powerful trans-

    mitters and sensitive receivers needed for Project Echo. It

    also developed the Echo tracking and rocket guidance

    systems.

    For a receiver, Bell Labs constructed a horn-reflector

    antenna in Holmdel, New Jersey, and used a maser as the

    low-noise amplifier that was essential for voice signal re-covery. The Holmdel horn-reflector, shown in Figure 2,

    was built with a gain of 43 dB and a beam-width of

    1.5 degrees. Voice communications were successful, and

    as the balloon circled the Earth, it was possible to bounce

    the signals off the satellite from Goldstone, California to

    Holmdel and back for a few minutes during each orbit.

    The requirements for the receiver were demanding.

    Because the satellite was passive (i.e., merely reflected

    radio waves without amplifying them), the signal incurred

    a loss of about 180 dB from source to destination (for

    example, from Holmdel to Goldstone). To track the satel-

    lite as it sped across the sky, the antenna had to rotate at1.5 degrees per second and achieve an aiming accuracy

    of 0.02 degrees [9]. The Echo experiment was successful,

    and AT&T (and Bell Labs) immediately began work on

    the Telstar satellite project.

    Telstar was driven and funded entirely by AT&T. The

    company built and installed a 340 ton horn-reflector on a

    new site outside Andover, Maine, and protected it with

    the largest inflated structure (radome) ever built. The newsite was conceived, designed, built and made operational

    in about two yearsVan extraordinary achievement.

    AT&T hired NASA to launch Telstar, which turned out to

    be a technical masterpiece.

    Telstar, shown in Figure 3, was powered by solar cells,

    and boasted receivers and transmitters with sufficient sig-

    nal-to-noise ratio to relay television signals. AT&T envi-

    sioned a globe-circling constellation of Telstar satellites

    that would provide continuous video and voice communi-

    cations around the world.

    Shifting Gears: From the Space Race to the Big BangU.S. President Eisenhower had been in favor of allowingAT&T to extend its monopoly, but in 1962, President

    Kennedy decided with Congress to assign the satellite

    monopoly to a new corporation, Comsat, thereby exclud-

    ing AT&T from the satellite business. AT&T had invested

    several million dollars into the Telstar project, but its fu-

    ture work would be relegated to more routine activities.

    The company decided to complete its initial Telstar exper-

    iment and exit the satellite business.

    However, for Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson, the

    decisions that brought AT&T into and out of the space

    communications business were fortunate. Had AT&T notinvested in the horn-reflector and maser amplifier and

    then been compelled to stop using it for satellite projects,

    FIGURE 2. Robert Wilson and Arno Penzias with the Holmdelhorn-reflector antenna.

    Bell Labs Technical Journal V O L U M E 1 9

    4

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    the two scientists may not have had the opportunity to

    pursue their research into radio astronomy with the same

    focus.

    Before coming to Bell Labs, Robert Wilson had

    mapped part of the Milky Way during his graduate work

    at Caltech, but he was still looking for a halo around the

    galaxy that he might have missed. Because the Owens

    Valley radio telescope dish he was using at Caltechpicked up terrestrial noise, he had to point at a fixed posi-

    tion and wait for the earth to scan across the Milky Way,

    so he was looking forward to the use of the horn antenna,

    with its better rejection of terrestrial noise, when he ar-

    rived in New Jersey. Arno Penzias was interested in emis-

    sion from neutral hydrogen atoms in clusters of galaxies.

    Together they wanted to use the 20-foot horn for tests at

    4 GHz, and then move to 1.42 GHz, or 21 cm, where the

    hydrogen emission line was a practical radiation source to

    map galaxies. As Wilson tells the story, the two were

    hired by Bell Labs to work on communication technol-

    ogy, but with permission to pursue radio astronomy intheir spare time. Because of this dual mission, they were

    given access to the best radio communications equipment

    in the worldVnamely the Holmdel horn reflector and ma-

    ser amplifierVwith which to conduct their measurements.

    In a short time, they perfected their equipment and experi-

    ment, and rapidly exceeded the state of the art in micro-

    wave receiver sensitivity. Then they found a noise floor

    they could not explain (Figure 4).

    Penzias was told by his friend Bernard Burke, an MIT

    physics professor, about a preprint from Robert Dicke,

    Jim Peebles, Peter Roll, and David Wilkinson, which

    described a theory predicting detectable remnant radiationfrom the Big Bang. Dicke's theory predicted that the

    young, hot universe would have eventually cooled to the

    point where the hydrogen plasma could condense into a

    gas and become transparent. The universal expansion

    would then red-shift thermal radiation, dropping its tem-

    perature to a few degrees Kelvin at the present day. The

    presence of remnant radiation was a critical test of the

    theory. Penzias spoke to Dicke, got a copy of his preprint,

    and the extended team collaborated to interpret the data.

    In 1965, they published their contributions separately in

    .........................................

    They found a noise floor they could

    not explain.

    Astrophysical Journal Letters [10]. In 1978, Penzias

    and Wilson were awarded half of the Nobel Prize in

    physics for their discovery of cosmic microwave back-

    ground radiation.

    Bell Labs continued to support astronomy through the

    1990s. Bell Labs alumnus and University of California

    Davis professor Anthony Tyson pursued studies of mass

    distribution and nonuniformity in the universe. Later, he

    used gravitational lensingVthe bending of distant light

    by massive objects such as galaxiesVto create a map of

    dark matter distribution. His measurement of faint (and

    distant) galaxies required him to collect light using highly

    sensitive charged coupled devices (CCDs). Once again,

    the coupling between Bell Labs inventions and discov-

    eries came into playVCCDs were a Bell Labs invention

    spawned from research into bubble memory data storage,and their inventors, William Boyle and George Smith,

    were awarded the Nobel Prize in physics in 2009.

    FIGURE 4. Raw data illustrating unexplained noise measured withthe horn antenna system.

    FIGURE 3. The Telstar satellite, showing solar cells and arrays ofantennae.

    V O L U M E 1 9 Bell Labs Technical Journal

    5

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    Opening New Chapters in CommunicationsAs the 1960s unfolded, AT&T was faced with continually

    increasing voice traffic as well as a new demand for

    data networks. To address future communications needs,

    AT&T conceived a plan to crisscross the U.S. with

    60 mm diameter waveguides, transmitting 274 Mb/s in theform of 475,000 two-way voice circuits at frequencies be-

    tween 40 and 110 GHz [11]. Repeaters would be spaced

    every 50 to 60 km apart. The project required further

    R&D into waveguides but also included a significant civil

    engineering component laying these waveguide pipes

    underground across North America. The project actually

    reached the trial stage, but before its deployment, optical

    fiber emerged as a superior technology. Optical fibers are

    today the dominant technology for wired communications.

    The first demonstration of mobile telephony punctu-

    ated wireless communications development in 1946, and

    in 1947 Bell Labs developed the cellular concept. Thefirst practical trials of the concept of cellular mobile

    communications were conducted by AT&T in Chicago,

    Illinois and Newark, New Jersey in 1978.

    Bell Labs also pioneered the concept and implementa-

    tion of combining multiple input multiple output (MIMO)

    antenna systems with spatial division multiplexing to im-

    prove wireless throughput and achieve data rates higher

    than the single channel Shannon limit. It is an extension

    of earlier multiple-antenna systems that exploit high-

    speed digital signal processing to obtain the benefits of

    multiple signal path transmission. The MIMO innovation

    became practical in the early 2000s. It has been incorpo-

    rated into WiFi as 802.11n, and is also part of 4G cellularcommunications.

    The telecommunications industry was dominated by

    AT&T for most of the 20th century. It is clear from the

    preceding that many of the most important innovations in

    communications during the century can be traced back to

    Bell Labs. Figure 5 offers a timeline that shows how Bell

    Labs has contributed to the evolution of communications

    technology over the last nine decades.

    The Horn Antenna and HistoryWith its central role developing, supporting, and enhanc-

    ing the technologies used by AT&T, Bell Labs had the re-sponsibility for being at the forefront of communications

    technology. This role gave Bell Labs the ability to attract

    the best scientists with challenging problems and sub-

    stantial resources. Sometimes, as in the case of radio as-

    tronomy and the discovery of Big Bang radiation, new

    understanding of physics came about through serendipity,

    collaboration between parties with different perspectives,

    FIGURE 5. Timeline of selected Bell Labs innovations in telecommunications and related fields.

    Bell Labs Technical Journal V O L U M E 1 9

    6

  • 5/21/2018 50th Anniversary Special Feature the Discovery of Cosmic Microwave Backgroun...

    http:///reader/full/50th-anniversary-special-feature-the-discovery-of-cosmic-micro

    the existence of a real practical problem, and a touch of

    genius.

    The horn-reflector antenna was invented at Bell Labs

    as a means to make long-distance phone calls. It subse-

    quently became a key element of the first satellite-based

    voice and video transmission systems. It was not expectedto play a role in providing direct experimental evidence

    of our universal origin, and yet the important discovery

    by Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson may not have been

    made without it.

    This culture of innovation continues to drive Bell Labs

    researchers to expand the boundaries of communications.

    Today, Bell Labs is using the same approach of hiring the

    brightest minds from diverse disciplines and applying

    them to practical problems in information and commu-

    nications technology and networking. We stand on the

    verge of another revolution in information and communi-

    cations networking as we seek to deliver another massiveleap in capacity and ubiquity using virtualization and

    software-defined networking, smaller access nodes and

    cells, and other related technologies, and it is reasonable to

    conjecture that Bell Labs will once again play a profound

    role in enabling this new reality.

    References[1] B. Rooney, Broadband Penetration and Economic Growth, Jul. 19,

    2013. Ghttp://blogs.wsj.com/tech-europe/2013/07/19/broadband-penetration-

    and-economic-growth/9

    [2] E. F. O'Neill (ed.), A History of Engineering and Science in the Bell

    System: Transmission Technology (19251975), Indianapolis, IN, USA:

    AT&T Bell Laboratories, 1985.[3] E. F. W. Alexanderson, Transatlantic Radio Communication, Proc.

    Amer. Inst. Electr. Eng., 38:10, 10771093, Oct. 1919.

    [4] O. B. Blackwell, Transatlantic TelephonyVThe Technical Problem,

    Bell Syst. Tech. J., 7:2, 168186, Apr. 1928.

    [5] C. M. Jansky, Jr., The Discovery and Identification by Karl Guthe

    Jansky of Electromagnetic Radiation of Extraterrestrial Origin in the Radio

    Spectrum,Proc. IRE, 46:1, 1315, Jan. 1958.

    [6] J. A. Tyson, Grote Reber, Phys. Today, 56:8, 6364, 2003.

    Ghttp://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/magazine/physicstoday/article/56/8/

    10.1063/1.16113609

    [7] C. E. Shannon, A Mathematical Theory of Communication, Bell

    Syst. Tech. J., 27:3, 379423, Jul. 1948.

    [8] C. E. Shannon, A Mathematical Theory of Communication, Bell

    Syst. Tech. J., 27:4, 623656, Oct. 1948.

    [9] Telstar Project Internal File, 1962, Bell Laboratories.

    [10] A. A. Penzias and R. W. Wilson, A Measurement of Excess An-

    tenna Temperature at 4080 Mc/s,Astrophys. J., 142, 419421, Jul. 1965.

    [11] D. A. Alsberg, J. C. Bankert, and P. T. Hutchison, WT4 Milli-

    meter Waveguide System: The WT4/WT4A Millimeter-Wave Transmis-

    sion System,Bell Syst. Tech. J., 56:10, 18291848.

    (Manuscript approved May 2014)

    AcknowledgementsThe authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance of

    Edward Eckert, Corporate Archivist, Alcatel-Lucent.

    AuthorsCharles Bahr is Director of Integrated Information Solu-

    tions at Alcatel-Lucent. His broad experience includes

    manufacturing information systems, fundamental research

    in molecular surface dynamics, manufacturing R&D in

    sol-gel for optical fiber, as well as work in the corporate

    marketing division to promote digital video, ad insertion,

    and quality of service. His current responsibilities include

    managing the corporate library system, and developing

    publication channels such as Bell Labs News and the Bell

    Labs website. He received a B.S. degree in chemistry

    from Texas A&M University, College Station, and a Ph.D.

    in physical chemistry from the University of California,

    Berkeley.

    Marcus Weldon is President of Bell Labs and Chief Tech-

    nology Officer for Alcatel-Lucent. He is responsible for

    harnessing the power of Bell Labs to address the biggest

    technical challenges in information and communications

    technology, for coordinating technical strategy across the

    company, and for driving technological and architectural

    innovations into the portfolio. He was named CTO of

    Alcatel-Lucents Fixed Access Division and Wireline Net-

    works Product Division following the merger of the two

    companies in 2006. Prior to that, he was CTO of the

    Lucent Technologies Broadband Solutions business

    group. Dr. Weldon began his career at AT&T Bell Labs

    as a postdoctoral member of technical staff, winning sev-

    eral scientific and engineering awards for his work on

    electronics and optical materials. He received a B.Sc. in

    chemistry from Kings College, London, and a Ph.D. in

    physical chemistry from Harvard University, Cambridge,

    Massachusetts.

    Robert W. Wilson is a Senior Scientist at the Smithsonian

    Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) of the Harvard

    Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge,

    Massachusetts. Until his recent partial retirement, he was

    the technical leader of the Sub-Millimeter Array, an

    8-element synthesis radio telescope near the summit of

    Mauna Kea, Hawaii built by SAO in conjunction with the

    Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics

    (ASIAA). He studied as an undergraduate at Rice Univ-

    ersity, Houston, Texas and did his graduate work at the

    California Institute of Technology. Dr. Wilson is best

    known for his part in the discovery of the 3 degrees K

    cosmic black body radiation thought to have originated in

    the early stages of the Big Bang. He won a Nobel Prize

    in 1978 for that discovery. t

    V O L U M E 1 9 Bell Labs Technical Journal

    7