Upload
shandaveatch
View
223
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
1/115
0
Shanda L. Veatch
Instructional Design Project Report
EDTECH 503 (4172): Spring 2009
Submitted to: Dr. Ross A. Perkins
May 10, 2009
Project Goal:
Using preselected digital video clips and up to three audio selections, students will upload files
to Microsoft Movie Maker to edit, trim and add sound tracking in the creation of a three to five
minute demonstration video.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
2/115
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Synthesis Reflection Paper 2
1. Instructional Design Project Proposal 3
2. Front-end Analysis Plan 4
3. Front-end Analysis Report 8
4: Goal Analysis Document 10
5: Subskills Analysis & Entry Behaviors Flowchart 12
6: Learner and Context Analysis 18
7: Outline of Instructional Objectives 25
8: Learner Assessment Document 28
9. Instructional Strategies Packet 32
10. Instructional Materials for Learners 43
11. Formative Evaluation Plan 107
12. Formative Evaluation Results (SME Review) 109
Appendix 110
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
3/115
2
Synthesis Reflection
According to Smith and Ragan, instructional design is systematic and reflective. This
requires instruction to be repeatable and ordered in such a way as to be adapted to meet the needsof the student. The objective of instruction is to see that the student has been altered in a specific
way as a result of the instruction. While there are several models of instructional design and
development, they are all variations of the same essential process, the ADDIE process: analysis,design, development, implementation and evaluation.
Each part of the ADDIE process plays a critical role in the development of an Instructional
product, but in this developers opinion, the evaluative process may be the most critical to the
development of a meaningful product. The act of developing the instructional material cannot beunderstated, and while it plays a key role in producing worthwhile instructional design, it is only
part of the whole design process. If a design product is properly evaluated, then this too is critical
to its successful development. In learning the process instructional designers undertake in order to
create successful projects, I have gained an appreciation for the systems approach designinginstruction. Prior to embarking upon this project, I viewed instructional design as essentially linear
in its approach, but upon its conclusion, I have come to the realization that it is, in fact, quite non-
linear. The systems aspect of instructional design requires extensive revision of each individualpiece. As any segment of the process is impacted, so the entire product is impacted. Each step in
the process needs to be revised to embrace any changes made at every step, including the
evaluative process.This process will have a lasting impact on the implementation of all instruction that takes
place in my classroom. I will be evaluating all instruction with a systems approach, so when
choosing curriculum, when possible, I will have the tools to integrate instructional materials with a
systematic eye for program selection. I have also found that there are many lessons that I haveused that lie in the formative realm. I see now that many of these lessons have not reached their
potential as instructional products, and should be revisited, evaluated and reconstructed in order to
raise them to meet the design standards set forth in this course. It is easy, as an instructor, to moveon to the next unit of instruction without revisiting. If time is taken at the end of the unit to review
the instructional process of a given unit, the presentation will be superior when implemented in the
classroom the following year.Educational technology and instructional design are closely linked. Educational technology is
not limited to the use of media and technology in instruction; it is instruction as a technology.
Instructional design, when properly executed must be viewed as technology as well. Technology
in instruction, by its very nature, is systematic. Educational technology must be examined andevaluated by its components as well its educational goals. Instructional design is the first step in
integrating technology into education. While educational technology can be considered a
systematic approach for integrating instruction and instructional materials into the classroom,instructional design can be considered the path by which this takes place. This process, bothsystematic and reflective, allow for clarity in setting, maintaining and achieving clear educational
goals. By breaking the process of instructional design into individual pieces and evaluating these
pieces throughout development, instructional design lays the foundation upon which trueeducational technology can be built
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
4/115
3
Formal Proposal
Subject/Topic/Area:
The purpose of my ID project will be to instruct users in the use of Windows Movie Maker.
Audience:
My target audience will be middle school educators.
Rationale: There are many uses for media in the classroom. Supplementing instruction with
media can streamline the instructional process. Teachers regularly seek new approaches to
content delivery. By introducing them to the use of Movie Maker, which is a free and commonlyinstalled program in the Windows platform, teachers will gain the knowledge necessary to edit
pre-selected digital video clips in order to enhance their classroom instruction.
Subject Matter Expert:
My SME will be Emmy award winning video producer Joel Veatch, my brother and President of
Flying Spot Entertainment.
Changes:
My initial proposal included redundant information that needed to be edited from the audiencesection, as it was already outlined in the rationale section, where it was most appropriate. Irestructured my SME sentence as a result of the communications I received on the discussion
board. I also shifted my proposal from the creation and editing of digital video for opening day
activities, to introducing them to the use of Movie Maker. The scope of the initial proposal wasoutside the time constraints of this project, which is to take place in a 3 to 4 hour session. This
broader goal will allow for multiple uses by the learners in the long run.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
5/115
4
Front-end Analysis Plan
PARTICIPANTS
How many people will you survey or interview to collect needs assessment data? (it should be at least
ten).
I will interviewing ten people to collect needs assessment data
Where will you find these potential participants?
These people will be teachers and staff at Gaiser Middle School.
What are some of the characteristics of the participants?
Gaiser teachers are educators grades 6-8. They range in age from the late 20s to the mid 60s. They
teach English, Math, Science, dance and music.
LOGISTICS
What kind of instrument(s)/tools /techniques will you use to collect data for the analysis? (simply
describe here; the actual artifacts will be appear after this page)
I will be conducting a survey of teachers as a means to determine the background knowledge
and experience levels they have with video editing
What arrangements do you need to make to collect the data/input?
I will be distributing these questionnaires to my colleagues early next week
When do you plan to be collecting data for the front-end analysis? (the analysis report is due FEB 22,
2009)
I will ask that they be returned by Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Where will the actual collection of data for the analysis take place? (online? On the street? In a
school?) Be specific.
The data will be collected at Gaiser Middle School
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
6/115
5
DATA COLLECTION INSTRUMENTS
Survey
Video usage in the classroom takes many forms, whether in video/dvd format, online or interactive
presentation. Creating custom video for our classroom can be a daunting but rewarding task. It can
allow for a smooth, consistent and repeatable presentation, and can bring elements in to instruction
that otherwise might not be possible. I am studying video editing and classroom instruction. Please
take a few moments to answer the following questions about your background with this medium and
the classroom.
1. Do you use video (dvd/vhs) in your classroom? Yes No
2. Have you used online videos to share with your students? Yes No
3. Do you own a digital video camcorder? Yes No
If so, what kind_________________________
4. Do you have a laptop? Yes No
5. Which operating system do you use? XP Vista Linux
6. What is the year make and model of this computer? _________________________________
7. What classes do you teach?______________________________________________
8. Rate your experience working with digital video ( Circle 1-little or no experience/ 5-regular use)
1 2 3 4 5
9.
Do you have Windows Movie Maker installed on any home computers? Yes No
If so, do you know the version?_________________________
10.Do you have experience working with Windows Movie Maker? Yes No
11.Do you have any prior experience working with digital editing software? Yes No
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
7/115
6
If so, what software have you worked with in the past?______________________
12. Have you ever created video to share with students, staff or parents?_________________
13. What type of activities do you typically include on your first day of a new school year? (checkthe activities)
____Getting to know you activities
____Classroom rules and procedures
____Assessment activities
14.What types of activities do you typically engage in on Parent Night? (Check the corresponding
activities)
____Curriculum
____Expectations
____Classroom procedures
____Q & A
____Distribute course syllabi
15.Have you uploaded videos to the web? If so, to what website(s)?
16.What is your position? (check your position)
1. ____Certificated teacher
2. ____Classroom aide
3. ____Administrator
4. ____Counselor
5. ____Office
6. ____Library
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
8/115
7
17. If you could create an opening day video for your classes, what information would you most
likely include?
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
18. If you could show parents footage of successes in your classroom on Parent Night, would you?
Yes No
19. Do you have an interest in digital video editing for classroom use? Yes No
20.How much time do you spend on the computer each week outside of school?
1-3 hrs 4-6 hrs 7-10 hrs 11+hrs
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
9/115
8
Front End Analysis Report
I managed to survey 11 teachers at Gaiser Middle School. Of these 6 were female and 5 weremale. The content areas represented in this survey was as follows
English- 4, Science-2,(1 aide) History-1, Special Ed- 2 (1 aide), Foreign language, Math-1.
All teachers had over five years experience in the classroom.
1. Describe some aspects about the context that you either already know OR that youlearned through your assessment.
All of the teachers surveyed use some sort of video presentation in their classrooms. With the
exception of a classroom paraeducator, none of the teachers used online digital video to enhance their
instruction. Our school recently made Safari Montage, an online educator video viewing program
available to teachers, but it seems the use of this in the classroom is limited due to its newness and the
infancy of the program to date. The firewalls are very strict in our school district, so online video
instruction has not been an option for teachers in the classroom. 9 of the 11 teachers surveyed
expressed their experience with editing software at a level 1 of 5 (1 being little or no experience). Three
of those surveyed stated that they had created some form of video to be shared with either students or
staff. All those surveyed stated that they would like to show footage of student success on parent night
2. Describe some of your major findings related to your subject area that you learned afterhaving conducted the analysis.
Approximately half (5 of the 11) the teachers surveyed said that they had an interest in digitalvideo editing for classroom use. Two of the remaining 6 were unsure and 4 said they had no
interest. Of the 4 who were not interested, two were certificated classroom teachers, and two
were classroom aides. One teacher mentioned an interest in uploading edited video to her teacherwebsite for homework instruction and all teachers surveyed expressed an interest in having
opening day videos to present the first day of school.
3. Discuss how your findings influenced your decision to develop an instructional goal.
My instructional goal has been modified to state
Using preselected digital video clips and photographs, students will upload
files to Microsoft Movie Maker which they will use to edit, trim and add sound
tracking to create a three to five minute demonstration.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
10/115
9
I have modified several things as a result of my needs assessment. I found that teachers were all
interested in making opening day videos and were equally as interested in creating video to
present to parents on Parent Night. This is going to help to guide the story orientation of theactual project. My SME has advocated that I center my IDP on a specific story that needs to be
assembled by the learner; so as a result, Ill focus on creating a music video, which will explore
different comedy artists. This will give learners the opportunity to utilize various video clips,
supported by background music, which can be directly translated to classroom video footage set
to music for Parent Night. While some of the teachers do not believe that digital video will
enhance their classroom instruction, enough were, which led to a marked increase in my
enthusiasm for this project.. Some participants also had interesting ideas such as uploading
video instruction onto teacher websites.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
11/115
10
Goal Analysis
1:Goal statement
Using preselected digital video clips and photographs, students will upload
files to Microsoft Movie Maker which they will use to edit, trim and add sound
tracking to create a three to five minute demonstration video in order to
enhance classroom instruction.
2:Classify the goal statement and describe why it fits that category
Video editing is a problem solving skill, so that places it in the domain of
intellectual skills. How does a person take video information and edit it for
classroom use? This skill is going to require that the learner engage a
unique cognitive activity (Dick, Carey and Carey). The learner will be
forming the concept of video editing while applying the rules as created by
the Microsoft Movie Maker program. The learner will also be solving
problems as he or she encounters the various challenges of uploading and
working with the program. The problem is well-structured in that the
applications and solutions are going to be readily available to the learner as
he or she goes through the process. The end piece they create will be a
unique creation, although the ingredients will be the same for all learners.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
12/115
11
3:Goal analysis outline
4: SME Review
Add Audio to initial step. Record the voice track as step #2. Then Edit clips.
Delete Trim clips edit/trim clips. Maybe create a script for them to read to narrate
the video. Create something watchable and personal. Superimpose a story into
this project. Pretend youve been handed an assignment as a student of a
television program. Heres the story and music, you must record this story and
deliver it to make more personal to the learner. Provide the building blocks that go
with this story. Heres the story, the pictures to use, and the script. Tell the story
in an interesting way and here are the materials. Come up with a page of scripted
bits for them to read. Base everything on the script. Give them four choices of
music. Allow for variety in how they put it together.
Capture video/ audio
Record narration (script)
Edit voice track
Edit video
Add background music
Add video effects and transitions
Render Movie File
CaptureVideo and
audio inMovieMaker
uploadvideo files
uploadpicture files
uploadmusic files
RecordNarration
Edit VoiceTrack
Edit Video
Place andtrim video
and picturefiles in
storyboard
AddBackground
Music
choose oneor combinesoundtracks
Add VideoEffects andTransitions
RenderMovie File
Author DVD
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
13/115
12
Subskills analysis Flowchart
This is a layout of the subskills necessary to complete the following instructional goal:
Using preselected digital video clips and photographs, students will upload
files to Microsoft Movie Maker which they will use to edit, trim and add sound
tracking to create a three to five minute demonstration video.
Entry level behaviors:
a. Ability to run Windows XP or
Vista
b. Ability to save filesc. Ability to click and drag files
d. Ability to upload files
Necessary tools:
a. Computer
b. Windows XP or Vista
c. Speakers
d. Movie Maker
e. Microphonef. Script
g. Preloaded video clips
h. Four sound files
Capture Video andaudio in Movie
Maker
upload video files
upload music files
Record Narration Edit Voice Track
Edit Video
Place and trimvideo and picturefiles in storyboard
Add BackgroundMusic
choose one orcombine
soundtracks
Add Video Effectsand Transitions
Render Movie File
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
14/115
13
Capture
video/
audio 1.0
In Movie Maker, click the
Tools menu, and then click
Narrate Timeline. 2.2.3
the file name,
nter the path and
ame of the file
eeded and then
ck Import 1.2
On the file menu,click Import into
collections 1.1
Connect
microphone
2.1
Speak normally into
microphone, and adjust the Input
level so that the bar is about
halfway up 2.2.1
consecutive files, click the
t file in the list, press and holdwn the SHIFT key, and then
k the last file in the list.
If prompted, click
OK 2.2.2
In the Save Window
Media File dialog b
type a name for the
narration and click
Save 2.5
When finished with
narration, click
Stop Narration
2.4
ClickPlay in the
Preview Monitor to
listen to the narration
2.5.1
Speak scripted
material into your
micro hone 2.3
Under
Narrate
Timeline
clickStart
Narration
2.2
Record
Scripted
Narration
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
15/115
14
Edit voice track
3.0
View clips in the
Collections view
4.1.2
Build a Storyboard4.1
To delete narration to re-record it,
ight-click the narration on the
imeline, and then clickDelete
3.2.1
Click
OK
3.3
In the Audio Clip Volume
dialog box, move the slider to
the left to make the narration
quieter, or move it to the right
to make it louder. 3.2
If the narration is too loud or toosoft, right-click the narration on the
timeline and then clickVolume
3.1
Edit video
4.0
Double click on each
clip to see how it
looks in the preview
window 4.1.3
Click and drag the clips to
the Storyboard in the
order in which the learnerwill like them to appear in
the final movie 4.1.4
To rearrange the
clips on the
storyboard, just drag
and drop them to a
different location
4.1.5
Edit clips4.2
On the Clip menu, clic
Set End Trim Point
4.2.6
Drag the
progress
indicator unti
the desired en
point is reach
4.2.5
On the Clip
menu, click
Set Start
Trim Point
4.2.4
Stop
desir
point
4.2.3
In the Preview
window, drag the
scroll bar slowly
and watch as the
video progresses.
4.2.2
In the storyboard
view, click on the
clip to trim 4.2.1
A
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
16/115
15
Add
background
music
5.0
Movie Maker shows the song
on the timeline. Drag the right
edge of the song so that it ends
at the same time as the movie
5.5
ClickOK
ClickPlay in the Preview
Monitor to watch the movie
and listen to the background
music. 5.6
Drag the song from the
collection to the video clip
where the music is to start
playing 5.3
In the Import File dialog box, click
the name of the song you want to use
in the background. Then click
Import 5.2
In the Movie Tasks pane
in Movie Maker, under
Capture Video, click
Import audio or music
5.1
If the background
music is too loud or
too soft, right-click the
music on your timeline
and click Volume 5.7
In the Audio Clip Volume
dialog box, move the slider
to the left to make the music
quieter, or to the right to
make it louder 5.8
Click OK 5.9
B
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
17/115
16
Add video effects and transitions
6.0
Upon locating the desiretransition, drag it from t
Video Transitions pane,
under Edit Movie pane t
the box between two of
your clips. This inserts t
transition between the tw
clips. 6.2.3
Preview
transitions by
double-clicking
them and
watching the
Preview Monitor.
6.2.2
In the Movie Tasks pane,
under Edit Movie, click
View video transitions.
6.2.1
Add a transition
between two clips 6.2
Drag desired effect onto the clip
in the storyboard and place it on
top of the star in the lower left-
hand corner of the clip 6.1.3
Double-click the
effects to see how
they look in the
preview window
6.1.4
In the Movie
Tasks pane, under
Edit Movie
clickView video
effects. 6.1.2
On the storyboard/timeline,
select the video clip needed to
add the video effect. 6.1.1
Add Video effects 6.1
In the Preview Monitor, click
Video Transitions pane, under
Play button to watch the
transition in action. 6.2.4
Right-click the transition
on the storyboard, and
click Delete if the effect
is not needed. 6.2.5B
Click OK. 6
C
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
18/115
17
Render Movie File 7.0
ClickBest quality for playback on
my computer 7.2.4
Choose a File Name and Location in the pop up b
that prompts Name the movie you are
publishing7.2.3
Select This
Computer in the popup window that says
Where do you want to
publish your movie?.
7.2.2
On the File menu,clickPublish
Movie 7.2.1
Save the project as a
movie. 7.2
In the File
name box, type
the file name,
and then click
Save. 7.1.2
On the File
menu, click
Save Project
7.1.1
Save a project 7.1
To watch movie aftercompleting the wizard,
select the Play movie
when I click Finish check
box. 7.1.3
After the movie is
saved, clickFinish.
7.1.4/ 7.2.5
D
EPresent final project to class for
feedback and review 8.0
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
19/115
18
LEARNER ANALYSIS
Entry Behaviors/KnowledgeCharacteristics: Learners are educators in a public middle school setting located in a
greater metropolitan area. The target learners come from all content
areas, some electives as well as some instructional aides. Uncompensated
instruction is a challenging motivator. Managing to include this instruction
into a teacher inservice will increase attendance and improve motivation
Implications: Learners from the fields of education can be impatient and somewhat
resistant to instruction.
Data Source(s): Interview target learners, supervisors, questionnaire
Prior knowledge of topic area
Characteristics: All learners utilize personal desk top computers and the statewide SIS
system on a daily basis. The minimum computer competency level is
attendance and grading on SIS. Prior technological experience varies
greatly from there. Some learners are currently incorporating multimedia
presentations into their existing instruction.
Implications: Basic computer skills allow for instruction while the broad range of
technological experience will require multi-tiered instruction
Data Source(s): Interview target learners, observe in performance setting, supervisors
Attitudes toward content and potential delivery system
Characteristics: Learners will be utilizing standard hp personal computers and working in
the Gaiser Middle School 403 computer lab. There is a general interest
among the Gaiser community to increase the use of technology in the
classroom.
Implications: The hardware is the same throughout the building. The familiarity with the
equipment will allow for ease in instruction in the use of Movie Maker
Data Source(s): Interview tech support, site visit
Motivation to learn
Characteristics: Learners are stressed for time to complete their teaching assignments,
adding extra instruction can be met with resistance.
Implications: Uncompensated instruction is a challenging motivator. Managing to
include this instruction into a teacher inservice will increase attendance
and improve motivation
Data Source(s): Observations, interview administration and target learners
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
20/115
19
Education ability and levels
Characteristics: Target learners have varying levels of higher education, ranging from
associates to graduate degrees.
Implications: Attaining higher level of education will allow for streamlining the languageof the presentation and the target learners will comprehend at an
advanced level of communication.
Data Source(s): Interview target learners and questionnaire
General learning preferences
Characteristics: Learners tend to respond positively to information that they can
immediately translate to classroom use. Time is at a premium, so
instruction needs to be streamlined, and delivered with confidence. They
prefer hands-on instruction with the opportunity for immediate feedback
during instruction. Clarity of instructional objectives and linking instruction
to concrete classroom implementation is paramount when presenting to
this learner population. These learners like to have visual representations
of instruction.
Implications: Instructional objective needs to be made clear prior to instruction.
Instructional delivery needs to move rapidly while allowing for consistent
feedback. Posting the steps required to complete the Movie Maker
process needs to be placed in the shared folder for access by learners in
the future.
Data Source(s): Interview target learners and tech support, questionnaire
Attitudes towards person(s) or organization providing the training or education
Characteristics: Target learners have a relatively positive attitude toward the organization.
There is much pressure currently on the district to cut positions in order to
meet budgetary constraints, and negotiations between the union and thedistrict are currently underway toward contractual agreements. The
learners who have previously worked outside the district or in other
buildings have generally a more positive feeling toward the organization.
Implications: Concern about budget restrictions may impact learning through increased
class sizes and reduced tech support in the upcoming school year.
Data Source(s): Interview target learners, questionnaire
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
21/115
20
Group characteristics
Characteristics: Learners come from a variety of backgrounds and reside both inside and
outside the district boundaries. Many commute from neighboring
counties, or across the state border. There is a variety of teachingexperience represented in this group, ranging from 2-20+ years. There is
an equal representation of age, gender and cultural backgrounds.
Implications: Asking learners to come in to the school on their own time is out of the
question. Too many commuters will restrict the learning to take place
during the work week. Most advantageous will be the presentation of this
material during a teacher inservce day. Early scheduling will be of critical
importance toward the success of this project.
Data Source(s): Observation, interview target learners and administration
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
22/115
21
INSTRUCTIONAL ANALYSIS
ENVIRONMENT: Public Middle School, Vancouver, WA
Support
Characteristics:Existing technology standards for Washington State teachers include:1. Facilitate and Inspire Student Learning and Creativity
2. Design and Develop Digital-Age Learning Experiences andAssessments3. Model Digital-Age Work and Learning4. Promote and Model Digital Citizenship and Responsibility
5. Engage in Professional Growth and Leadership
Implications: Learners are being evaluated on a regular basis on the level of technologyintegration into their curriculum. The standards for Washington State are
clearly designed to include evolving technology use in the classroom.
Data Source(s): Interview target learner, IT support and administration
Physical aspects
Characteristics: The Gaiser 403 computer lab has 30 desktop pcs. The lab is equipped with
a projected video display screen for demonstration purposes. Currently 10
computers have Movie Maker installed. More are available upon request.
Implications: There are adequate facilities for instructional delivery. The software isavailable upon request. Identifying the number of students prior to
instruction will be the key to having the correct number of computers
installed with Movie Maker.
Data Source(s): Interview tech support, site visit
Social aspects
Characteristics: Learners will be learning in a group setting. They will be working
independently on their projects, but will be allowed to work collaboratively
with a partner if they wish.
Implications: Allowing for both collaboration and independent work on the instructional
project will allow for a more relaxed, interactive, creative and upbeat
learning environment.
Data Source(s): Interview target learners and administration, observation
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
23/115
22
Relevance
Characteristics: Learners will be made aware of their ability to access Movie Maker, which
is not currently installed on their operating systems. Learners will be given
the opportunity to explore Movie Maker as not only as a teaching tool, but
as a format for sharing work that otherwise takes place in relative isolation.
Implications: Instruction is intended to provide learners with the ability to createinstructional materials for regular use and the ability to share with parents
and peers instructional practices that are taking place in their classrooms.
Data Source(s): Interviews target learners, questionnaire, observation
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
24/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
25/115
24
of videos from the web, but the work with Movie Maker is supported by
the network. There will be a limited number of microphones, and as yet,
digital video equipment is of limited availability.
Implications: We will require the use of digital video cameras and microphones.
Streamlining this process and making learners aware of the steps needed
to secure these items for future use will be critical to seeing theimplementation of the use of this program into their instruction.
Data Source(s): Interview Tech support administration, Site visit
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
26/115
25
Instructional Objectives
GOAL: Using preselected digital video clips and up to three audio selections,
students will upload files to Microsoft Movie Maker to edit, trim and add sound
tracking in the creation of a three to five minute demonstration video.
1.0Using the windows operating system and the preloaded video and audiofiles, students will correctly capture the audio and video files into the Movie
Maker program.
1.1Students will create a path for importing the video and correctly identify
the name and location of the new collection folder that has beencreated for each video and audio file.
2.0Using a microphone and a script, students will record and upload thenarration into the Movie Maker program by correctly:
2.1connecting the microphone.
2.2 Speaking scripted material into microphone.
2.3adjusting the input level to the halfway point.
2.4Clicking the tools menu and then clicking Narrate Timeline.2.5Clicking stop narration when finished reading the script.
2.6Naming and saving the file into Media Player.
2.7Previewing the narration by clicking Play in the preview monitor.
3.0Students will use Movie maker to properly Edit the voice track by correctly:3.1Utilizing the volume slider to modify the volume of the narration track.
3.2Right clicking the timeline to delete narration and re-record if
necessary.3.3Previewing the audio track in the preview monitor.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
27/115
26
4.0Students will use Windows Movie Maker to correctly edit uploaded movieclips by:
4.1Clicking and dragging clips to the storyboard.
4.1.1 Rearranging the clips into the preferred order for the final
movie.4.2Students will click on individual clips within the storyboard.
4.2.1 Using the scroll bar within the preview window, students
will select the desired trim point.
4.2.2 On the clip menu, students will:
4.2.2.1.1 Click start trim point.
4.2.2.1.2Scroll to desired end point.
4.2.2.1.3Click set endtrim point.
4.3Students will preview the edited video in the preview monitor.
5.0Students will use Movie Maker to properly add background music to theirvideo projects by:
5.1Selecting the Movie Tasks pane, under capture video and selecting
import audio or video.
5.2Clicking on the name of the song sample(s) needed, and clicking
import.
5.3Dragging the song selection to the specific location on the storyboard
requiring music.5.4Dragging the right edge of the song to the end point needed in the
video timeline.
5.5Clicking play to watch the movie and preview the background music.
5.6Using the audio clip volume slider to adjust the music volume
6.0Students will use Movie Maker to add video effects to their projects bycorrectly:
6.1Using the storyboard/timeline to select the video clip needed to add the
video effect.
6.2Use the view video effects within the movie tasks pane, under edit
movie; drag the desired effect to the desired location on the
storyboard, covering the star on the lower left hand corner of the clip.
6.3Double click the effect to preview the effect in the preview monitor.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
28/115
27
7.0Students will use Movie Maker to add video transitions to their projects bycorrectly:
7.1Clicking view video transitions in the Movie Taskspane, under Edit
Movie.
7.2Previewing the transitions by double-clicking them and viewing them inthe Preview Monitor.
7.3Locating the desired transition and dragging it to the box between the
two desired transition points on the storyboard.
7.4Using the Preview monitor and clicking the Video Transitions pane,
under the Play button to watch the transition in action.
7.5Right clicking on the transition point (deleting the transition if the effect
is not desired) and clicking ok if the effect is the desired one.
8.0Students will use Movie Maker to render a movie file by correctly:8.1Using the File Menu to click save project on Movie Maker.
8.1.1 Typing the File name into box.
8.1.2 Checking the Play movie when I finish box.
8.1.3 Clicking the finished box when saving is completed.
8.1.4 Previewing the movie in the Preview monitor.
8.2Using the File Menu to click save movie file on Movie Maker
8.2.1 Typing a name of the movie file in the enter a file name for
the saved movie box.8.2.2 Clicking best quality for playback on my computer box on the
movie setting pane.
8.2.3 Clicking Finished after movie is saved.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
29/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
30/115
29
13 4.2.1 students will
select the desired trim
point
application Observation in simulated setting by
peer
14 4.2.6 Preview theedited video in the
preview monitor
evaluation Observation in simulated setting byinstructor
15 5.2 import the song
samples
application Creation of product
16 5.3 Drag the song
selection to the
specific location
application Creation of product
17 5.4 Drag the right edge
of the song to the end
point
knowledge Creation of product
18 5.6 adjust the music
volume
application Creation of product
19 6.2 drag the desired
effect to the desired
location on the
storyboard
knowledge Creation of product
20 6.3 preview the effect analysis Observation in simulated setting bypeer
21 7.2 Preview the
transitions
analysis Observation in simulated setting by
peer
22 7.3 dragging it to the
box between the two
desired transition
points
knowledge Creation of product
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
31/115
30
23 7.4 watch the
transition in action
analysis Observation in simulated setting by
peer
24 8.1 save project knowledge Creation of product
23 8.1.4 Preview theMovie in the Preview
monitor
evaluation Observation in simulated setting by
instructor
25 8.2 save movie file knowledge Creation of product
26 8.2.1 enter a file
name for the saved
movie box
application Observation in simulated setting by
instructor
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
32/115
31
Assessment Plan
The final assessment for the Movie Maker video editing project would take the form of a meta-
evaluative assessment of the formative evaluations that have gone throughout the
development of the project. As written in the terminal goal, Using preselected digital video
clips and photographs, students will upload files to Microsoft Movie Maker to edit, trim and add
sound tracking in the creation of a three to five minute demonstration video.
The instructor will be responsible for evaluating the final product based on a rubric that includes
all the major objectives included in the objective analysis. The subskills that require creation of
a product as the formative assessment will be the indicator of the skills that will be needed to
be exhibited and included in meta-evaluative assessment.
The participants should not exceed ten students, or five completed projects, to properly assess
the final projects, and the final assessment will include the results of the formative assessments
throughout the class. Students, working in pairs, will have the entire given course time to work
on their projects and will be responsible for submitting their final project into a specified shared
folder at the conclusion of the course. The location of the instruction and assessments will take
place in the same computer lab.
A check list and rating based scoring assessment will be used to evaluate the final product.
These will include scoring time, narration, transition and soundtrack. The scoring will be
primarily for the use of the instructional designer to make any changes to the instruction in the
future.
The reason for choosing this type of assessment method is based on the fact that this is a
performance based activity, and the formative nature of this project based instruction lends
itself to a meta-evaluation rather than other types of assessment processes.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
33/115
32
Instructional Strategies
Clustering & Sequencing Objectives
Project Goal Statement (Terminal Objective): Using preselected digital video clips and up to three
audio selections, students will upload files to Microsoft Movie Maker to edit, trim and add sound
tracking in the creation of a three to five minute demonstration video.
CLUSTER TIME FRAME OBJECTIVES LISTED IN ORDER OF HOW THEY WILL BE
TAUGHT
1 10 minutes 1.2
1.1
1.0
2 25 minutes 2.1
2.2.1
2.2.2
2.2.3
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.5.1
3 10 minutes 3.1
3.2
3.3
4 30 minutes 4.1.2
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
34/115
33
4.1.2
4.2.3
4.1.4
4.1.5
5 30 minutes 4.2.1
4.2.2
4.2.3
4.2.4
4.2.5
4.2.6
7 20 minutes 5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
8 5 minutes 5.5
5.6
5.7
5.8
5.9
9 15 minutes 6.1.1
6.1.2
6.1.3
6.1.4
6.1.2
10 30 minutes 6.2.1
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
35/115
34
6.2.2
6.2.3
6.2.4
6.2.5
11 10 minutes 7.1.1
7.1.2
7.1.3
7.1.4
7.2.1
7.2.2
7.2.3
7.2.4
7.2.5
12 90 minutes
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
36/115
35
Motivational Strategies
Project Goal Statement (Terminal Objective): Using preselected digital video clips and up to three
audio selections, students will upload files to Microsoft Movie Maker to edit, trim and add sound
tracking in the creation of a three to five minute demonstration video.
Categories & Subcategories Strategies
ATTENTION
A.1. Perceptual arousal
A.2. Inquiry arousal
A.3. Variability
A.1. Students will be shown a video created with Movie Maker. It will
contain music, narration and video editing techniques that will be used
in this unit.
A.2. Students will be asked to brainstorm a list of ways that Movie
Maker can be used to enhance instruction in the classroom. Students
will be asked to brainstorm a list of ways that Movie Maker can be used
to enhance communication with peers and parents. The class will
discuss the results of both lists.
A.3. Students will be paired and will create the video in teams. Each
team will share their projects with the class, displaying the product
variations that are possible with the common tools presented.
RELEVANCE
R.1. Goal orientation
R.2. Motive matching
R.3. Familiarity
R.1. Each goal will be stated clearly at the beginning of the lesson, and
will build logically upon previous skills attained.
R.2. Students will be creating a video that gives multiple opportunities
for creative license within the editing process. This will allow for unique
approaches to the editing process which will be shared as a final project
with the class.
R.3. Students will be working in the 403 lab, which exactly replicates the
working environment in which they work on a daily basis. They will be
using the same network, materials, and operating systems.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
37/115
36
CONFIDENCE
C.1. Learning requirements
C.2. Success opportunities
C.3. Personal control
C.1. Students will view projected demonstrations of the video editing
process as they work. They will have the opportunity to simply
replicate the instructors work, or add variations of their own. The flow
charts will be saved in the shared folders for future reference.
C.2. As a learning approach, students will be given the opportunity to
simply replicate the instructors work, or add variations of their own.
The goal will be to follow the process from beginning to end. Quality
will not be important for evaluative purposes.
C.3. Students will be given feedback by the instructor and classmates
upon completion and presentation of their final project. The act of
completing the project will give the learner confidence in their ability to
manipulate the hardware in the future.
SATISFACTION
S.1. Natural consequences
S.2. Positive consequences
S.3. Equity
S.1. Moving from one lesson to the next, will allow for teams to work
through questions together and give them insight into possible
challenges they may meet when working independently in the future.
They will also have a working ally in the building with whom they can
consult in the future.
S.2. Students will enhance communication with students, peers,administration and parents by utilizing the skills learned in the Media
Maker class. Videos will be posted in the shared folder for future
viewing. Students will vote to choose one of the teams video to be
posted to the school website.
S.3. All students will receive feedback from instructor and fellow
classmates during final presentation. The completion of this project will
be the only final means of assessment.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
38/115
37
Instructional Strategies Plan
STATED OBJECTIVE: Students will use Windows Movie Maker to
correctly edit uploaded movie clips
Objective #
4.0
PRE-INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Motivational strategy: Students will have viewed the demonstration video which will give them an idea
of a few of the options available to them in the creation of this project
Pre-Assessment: Students will have imported the required video into Movie Maker collections. Mastery
of objective is will determine if they have the required knowledge base to proceed with the project.
CONTENT PRESENATION
Content: Viewing and determining the clips which will be used for the video will take place during this
portion of the unit. The order of the clips will be chosen, and placed on the storyboard.
Examples: Media files chosen from the media folder, the final demonstration project and the
PowerPoint lesson slides 6-10
Groups: Students will be working in partner teams (ongoing)
Media selection: Media files folder, Movie Maker PowerPoint lesson
STUDENT PARTICIPATION
Practice Items:
Clicking and dragging clips to the storyboard.
Rearranging the clips into the preferred order for the final movie.
Students will click on individual clips within the storyboard.
Using the scroll bar within the preview window, students will select the desired
trim point.
On the clip menu, students will:
Click start trim point.Scroll to desired end point.
Click set end trim point.
Students will preview the edited video in the preview monitor.
Feedback: Instructor will be available to guide and help simplify progress during this session.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
39/115
38
Assessment: When students have finished initial storyboard layout, instructor will ensure proper
progress by viewing and assessing progress
FOLLOW-THROUGH ACTIVITIES
Memory aids: PowerPoint will be available for review on server
Transfer: Student teams will be providing support to each other, as will the process. As students engage
in this process, a network of support will be built on site in order to assure practical resources, but allow
for future work and the planning of integration this media process into the classroom. Instructor will
guide students in the possible uses for classroom instruction.
STATED OBJECTIVE:Students will use Movie Maker to properly add
background music to their video projects
Objective #
5.0
PRE-INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Motivational strategy: Previewing finished project will give students an understanding of the possibilities
available for this project.
Pre-Assessment: Completion of the preceding objective (4.0) will ensure background skills necessary to
complete this phase of the lesson.
CONTENT PRESENATION
Content: Creating an audio background will bring video projects to life and add a professional feel to the
project. Students will choose from among four musical files to use as their music. The will import these
files into Movie Maker and drag the file to the storyboard. They will adjust the audio file volume.
Examples: : Media files chosen from the media folder, the final demonstration project and the
PowerPoint lesson slides 31-39
Groups: Partnered teams will continue work on their projects
Media selection: Media files folder, Movie Maker, PowerPoint lesson slides 31-39
STUDENT PARTICIPATION
Practice Items:
Selecting the Movie Tasks pane, under capture video and selecting import
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
40/115
39
STATED OBJECTIVE: Students will use Windows Movie Maker to
correctly edit uploaded movie clips
Objective #
6.0
PRE-INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Motivational strategy: : Previewing demonstration video as well as reviewing storyboard progress
Pre-Assessment: Completion of objective 5.0 will provide a foundation for continuing onto this
objective
CONTENT PRESENATION
Content:Movie Maker provides options for editing clips. Students will drag the desired
effect to their storyboard and preview their choices in the preview monitor.Examples: Demonstration Video
Groups: Students will remain in their partnered teams
Media selection: Storyboard with selected video clips, Movie Maker video effects, PowerPoint slides 11-
audio or video.
Clicking on the name of the song sample(s) needed, and clicking import.
Dragging the song selection to the specific location on the storyboard requiring
music.
Dragging the right edge of the song to the end point needed in the video timeline.
Clicking play to watch the movie and preview the background music.
Using the audio clip volume slider to adjust the music volume
Feedback: Teacher will facilitate feedback by circulating during process and providing guidance to teams
as needed
Assessment: completing the required steps of this objective
FOLLOW-THROUGH ACTIVITIES
Memory aids: Power Point will be uploaded to the network server
Transfer: Continued dialogue regarding the uses of this technique in the classroom during classroom
instruction
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
41/115
40
17
STUDENT PARTICIPATION
Practice Items:
Using the storyboard/timeline to select the video clip needed to add the videoeffect.
Use the view video effects within the movie tasks pane, under edit movie;
drag the desired effect to the desired location on the storyboard, covering the star
on the lower left hand corner of the clip.
Double click the effect to preview the effect in the preview monitor.
Feedback: Instructor will facilitate by circulation among the teams and provide needed feedback during
process
Assessment: Completion of Objective 6.0 will demonstrate readiness for the next step of instruction.
FOLLOW-THROUGH ACTIVITIES
Memory aids: Instructional PowerPoint will be uploaded to network server
Transfer: Ongoing discussion regarding the uses for Movie Maker in the classroom during instruction
STATED OBJECTIVE: Students will use Movie Maker to add video
transitions to their projects
Objective #
7.0
PRE-INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Motivational strategy: Previewing demonstration video as well as discussion of possible uses for Movie
Maker in the classroom
Pre-Assessment: Successful completion of objective 7.0 will provide the skills necessary to begin this
lesson.
CONTENT PRESENATION
Content: Transitions between clips will be necessary to move from one segment to another. Students
will learn how to create interesting transitions to create a professional look to their projects.
Examples: Demonstration video and a review of progress thus far
Groups: Students will continue to work with their partners on this lesson
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
42/115
41
Media selection: Students will be working with video transitions in Movie Maker as well as their edited
storyboard
STUDENT PARTICIPATION
Practice Items:
Clicking view video transitions in the Movie Taskspane, under Edit Movie.
Previewing the transitions by double-clicking them and viewing them in the
Preview Monitor.
Locating the desired transition and dragging it to the box between the two desired
transition points on the storyboard.
Using the Preview monitor and clicking the Video Transitions pane, under the
Play button to watch the transition in action.
Right clicking on the transition point (deleting the transition if the effect is not
desired) and clicking ok if the effect is the desired one.
Feedback: Instructor will circulate among teams and provide feedback as needed
Assessment: Completion of this objective will demonstrate readiness for the next step in this unit.
FOLLOW-THROUGH ACTIVITIES
Memory aids: PowerPoint will be uploaded to the network server
Transfer: Support networks are being put into place as a result of teamed instruction. Ongoing dialogue
in the uses of Media Maker will occur during instruction.
STATED OBJECTIVE: Students will use Movie Maker to render a movie
file
Objective #
7.0
PRE-INSTRUCTIONAL ACTIVITIES
Motivational strategy: Previewing demonstration video and a review of final project prior to beginningthis lesson
Pre-Assessment: Completion of objective 7.0 will provide the skills necessary to complete this lesson
CONTENT PRESENATION
Content: Once projects have been finished, students will learn how to save their projects as movie files
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
43/115
42
for future playback.
Examples: Demonstration video and finished video projects
Groups: Students will work with their partners to complete this lesson
Media selection: Windows Movie Maker and completed video project and PowerPoint slides 55-64
STUDENT PARTICIPATION
Practice Items:
Using the File Menu to click save project on Movie Maker.
Typing the File name into box.
Checking the Play movie when I finish box.
Clicking the finished box when saving is completed.
Previewing the movie in the Preview monitor.Using the File Menu to click save movie file on Movie Maker
Typing a name of the movie file in the enter a file name for the saved movie box.
Clicking best quality for playback on my computer box on the movie setting
pane.
Clicking Finished after movie is saved.
Feedback: Feedback will be provided by instructor by circulating and providing guidance where
necessary
Assessment: Properly saved movie files will indicate mastery
FOLLOW-THROUGH ACTIVITIES
Memory aids: Instructional PowerPoint will be uploaded to the network server
Transfer: Engaging in dialogue about the possible uses of Movie Maker during class as well as the
support network provided by working in groups will ensure real world instructional support.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
44/115
43
Slide 1
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
45/115
44
Slide 2
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
46/115
45
Slide 3
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
47/115
46
Slide 4
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
48/115
47
Slide 5
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
49/115
48
Slide 6
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
50/115
49
Slide 7
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
51/115
50
Slide 8
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
52/115
51
Slide 9
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
53/115
52
Slide 10
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
54/115
53
Slide 11
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
55/115
54
Slide 12
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
56/115
55
Slide 13
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
57/115
56
Slide 14
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
58/115
57
Slide 15
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
59/115
58
Slide 16
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
60/115
59
Slide 17
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
61/115
60
Slide 18
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
62/115
61
Slide 19
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
63/115
62
Slide 20
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
64/115
63
Slide 21
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
65/115
64
Slide 22
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
66/115
65
Slide 23
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
67/115
66
Slide 24
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
68/115
67
Slide 25
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
69/115
68
Slide 26
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
70/115
69
Slide 27
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
71/115
70
Slide 28
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
72/115
71
Slide 29
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
73/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
74/115
73
Slide 31
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
75/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
76/115
75
Slide 33
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
77/115
76
Slide 34
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
78/115
77
Slide 35
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
79/115
78
Slide 36
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
80/115
79
Slide 37
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
81/115
80
Slide 38
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
82/115
81
Slide 39
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
83/115
82
Slide 40
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
84/115
83
Slide 41
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
85/115
84
Slide 42
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
86/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
87/115
86
Slide 44
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
88/115
87
Slide 45
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
89/115
88
Slide 46
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
90/115
89
Slide 47
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
91/115
90
Slide 48
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
92/115
91
Slide 49
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
93/115
92
Slide 50
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
94/115
93
Slide 51
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
95/115
94
Slide 52
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
96/115
95
Slide 53
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
97/115
96
Slide 54
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
98/115
97
Slide 55
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
99/115
98
Slide 56
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
100/115
99
Slide 57
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
101/115
100
Slide 58
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
102/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
103/115
102
Slide 60
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
104/115
103
Slide 61
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
105/115
104
Slide 62
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
106/115
105
Slide 63
Click Finish to watch your finishedroduct.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
107/115
106
Slide 64
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
108/115
107
Formative Evaluation Plans
One-to-One Evaluation of Instructional Product
In order to evaluate the effectiveness of my instructional design project, it would be critical for
me to have it evaluated by at least three target learner audience members as well as my SME.I would begin with the Data Collections Instrument survey in order to obtain the broadest range
of abilities possible. It is important for this project that I see ability levels that range from low
to high in order to get the clearest understanding of my instructional design as possible. Once
chosen, I would meet with each learner individually and instruct them in the purpose of this
evaluation. I then would provide them with a written print out of the instructional materials as
well as a computer with the uploaded files and software. This assessment could take place in
the learners home, or place of work, with my laptop.
As the learner began to explore the material, I would sit with him or her and make notes
regarding their response to the individual slides and the ease of accomplishing the task. I would
ask them to mark the pages they found unclear. It would be important for them to attempt to
complete the instruction, so if faced with overwhelming obstacles, and once noted, I would
assist them on to the next phase of the lesson. Given this approach, I would be able to go back
and make changes to any section of the instruction that was either vague or ungainly.
My SME was provided with the product as well, but it would have greatly benefitted this
developer to have sat in the room with the SME and followed the same approach as written
above. This would allow for an more in depth analysis of each objective and slide. Once Ive
collected all the feedback from these sources, I would then go back to my instructional designproduct and make the necessary changes based on the feedback of these four individuals.
Small Group Evaluation of Instructional Product
The group evaluation would require that I obtain at least 10 individuals to interact with this
design product. One of the additional features I would be adding to my evaluation process
would be a pre and post evaluation attitude assessment. This would give me an understanding
of the motivational value of my project. I am also, at this stage, concerned not only withcontent, but feasibility. The timing of this project will be critical, as it can become very involved
and is intended to be delivered in less than four hours of instructional class time.
At this point, the evaluation would take place in paired teams. This would be most appropriate
as the final product is intended to be delivered through partner-driven instruction, with the
instructor acting primarily as a facilitator. The instructional materials should be able to stand
on their own. I would conduct these evaluations on site using the school computers and
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
109/115
108
equipment. Again, it would be important for these learners to understand the nature of this
evaluation, and the role they are playing in the formation of the materials. I would then more
closely replicate the intended instructional setting by presenting the slide show while they
worked through the instruction together. I would time each segment of the lesson to note the
time needed to accomplish each objective as well as any added instructional support that was
necessary. In addition to the post evaluation attitude assessment, I could also solicit ongoing
feedback from the teams at the conclusion of each objective.
Field Test of Instructional Product
The field test would take place in an actual classroom setting. I would be using our teacher in-
service days to deliver this instruction. This would take place in two intervals, on two separate
occasions. I would be conducting this test in the computer lab at my school. I will have spent
much time reviewing and reworking my design project using the results of both my one on one
and small group assessments. The project would be presented to teachers using both the data
collections survey as well as the pre and post attitude assessment surveys. The materials would
be the same as the small group evaluations utilizing computers, video projector, the
PowerPoint slide show instructional material as well as the uploaded media files.
One of the main focus points of this field test will be to see if someone besides the developer is
able to deliver this instruction. While I will be on site to evaluate the process and assist where
needed, the goal will be to see how well the materials can be used to deliver instruction
through a third-party. The instructor will be provided with a print out of the slides so that he orshe can make notations regarding the delivery process. An evaluation of each of the objectives
as well as a summative evaluation of the entire process will be necessary for me to make
revisions to the project.
The field test will ensure the readiness of this product for more classroom use. Any changes
that are necessary will be made prior to any further use of this product. Instructor feedback
will give this product the information necessary for it to stand on its own as a viable classroom
tool.
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
110/115
109
Formative Evaluation Report
I engaged my Subject Matter Expert, Joel Veatch, in reviewing my Instructional Strategies
Document and the Instructional Materials by email correspondence. While his response was
positive overall, he had several points to make about improvements that could be made,
particularly in the flow of objectives.
I asked him if the overall instructional design seemed to support the learner context (ie: can this
product be delivered in using the information presented?). He said that it seemed a realistic
approach to the task, although, Using a PowerPoint presentation could, in the long run prove
to be cumbersome for individual learners using one computer. If this project is to be eventually
used by individuals, with no instructor on hand, it may be easier to for them to use the print
form of the instruction rather than moving between various frames on an already overcrowded
desktop.
In response to the learner objectives he pointed out that some of the objectives seemed out of
sequence with the PowerPoint slides. He noted that, You placed the audio, both thenarration and the background music objectives at different points in the slide show. Given the
changes you made to the overall format of the project, it makes sense, but you might want to
rearrange the order of your objectives to reflect this change.
His feasibility analysis was that I had, managed to make a huge project reasonable in size given
the changes you made to the content. I was concerned that you would have too much material
to present, but the shorter clips you gave your audience will really cut down on the working
time. But, he still has concerns that the entire project can be completed in the four hours
timeframe Ive provided. You may need more time if you want to include the presentation
time at the end of the unit.
I agree with his analysis of my project, although Im not sure that the intent of this particular
design is to be done entire independently. My intention is to have it delivered in a group
setting so that peer review plays a role in the process. He mentioned the changes I made to the
design during the process, which I found to be critical to delivery. While initially, the
instructional materials to include video of students and the school, I had to change it to open
source video and creative commons music tracks to allow for smaller video clips and simple
narrative tasks. The goal became one of veering away from the right way to for learners to
lay out their clips, to the many ways clips can be laid out.
Having submitted my information to my SME, I see that my objectives do not line up with my
slide show. I view the slide show as the final presentation, and would go back to make the
changes in the previous objectives to reflect that change of approach.
Joel summarized his review with the following statement: Nice job. I got the sense even I could
edit a video after reading that!
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
111/115
110
Appendix
Narrative Script
Literary Dictionary: Comedy
Comedy is written chiefly to amuse its audience by appealing to a sense of superiority over the
characters depicted. A comedy will normally be closer to the representation of everyday life
than a tragedy and will explore common human failings rather than tragedy's disastrous crimes.
Its ending will usually be happy for the leading characters.
http://www.answers.com/topic/comedy
Public Domain Movies- Voiceofreason.com
1. The Royal Wedding (1951)- Fred Astaire
2. The Kid (1921)- Charlie Chaplin
3. Work (1915)- Charlie Chaplin
4. The Inspector General (1949)- Danny Kaye
5. Balloonatics (1923)- Buster Keaton
6. Yankee Doodle Daffy (1943)
Creative Commons Music
1. Mr. Blue Boogie- Derek R Audette, derekaudette.ottawaarts.com
2. Wait for the dawn- Dan OConner
3. Heart of the Sea-Soundjay.com
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
112/115
111
Professional Standards Addressed (AECT)
The following standards, developed by the Association for Educational Communications and Technology (AECT),
and used in the accreditation process established by the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education
(NCATE), are addressed to some degree in this course. The numbers of the standards correspond to the numbers
next to the course tasks show on the list of assignments. Not all standards are addressed explicitly through student
work.
Assignments meeting standard in whole or partStandard 1: DESIGN
1.1 Instructional Systems Design (ISD) X Reading notes/test on Brown & Green text
1.1.1 Analyzing X IDP Part 2, 3, & 7; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
1.1.2 Designing X IDP Part 4, 5; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
1.1.3 Developing X IDP Part 10; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
1.1.4 Implementing X Final IDP Report; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
1.1.5 Evaluating XIDP Part 11 & 12, Discussion #11; Reading from Dick, Carey& Carey
1.2 Message Design
1.3 Instructional Strategies X IDP Part 9A, 9B, & 9C; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
1.4 Learner Characteristics X IDP Part 5, 6; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
Standard 2: DEVELOPMENT
2.0 (includes 2.0.1 to 2.0.8) X Overall ID project
2.1 Print Technologies X Overall ID project
2.2 Audiovisual Technologies
2.3 Computer-Based Technologies X Overall ID project
2.4 Integrated Technologies
Standard 3: UTILIZATION
3.0 (includes 3.0.1 & 3.0.2)
3.1 Media Utilization X IDP Part 9C, 10; Discussion #12
3.2 Diffusion of Innovations
3.3 Implementation andInstitutionalization X Overall ID project; Reading from Dick, Carey & Carey
3.4 Policies and Regulations
Standard 4: MANAGEMENT
4.0 (includes 4.0.1 & 4.0.3)
4.1 Project Management
4.2 Resource Management
4.3 Delivery System Management
4.4 Information Management
Standard 5: EVALUATION
5.1 Problem Analysis X IDP
Part 1, 4, 55.2 Criterion-Referenced Measurement X IDP Part 8
5.3 Formative and Summative Evaluation X IDP Part 11, 12; Discussion #11
5.4 Long-Range Planning
1.0 Design
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
113/115
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
114/115
113
2.0 Development
2.0.1 Select appropriate media to produce effective learning environments using technology resources.
2.0.2 Use appropriate analog and digital productivity tools to develop instructional and professional
products.
2.0.3 Apply instructional design principles to select appropriate technological tools for the development
of instructional and professional products.
2.0.4 Apply appropriate learning and psychological theories to the selection of appropriate technological
tools and to the development of instructional and professional products.
2.0.5 Apply appropriate evaluation strategies and techniques for assessing effectiveness of instructional
and professional products.
2.0.6 Use the results of evaluation methods and techniques to revise and update instructional and
professional products.
2.0.7 Contribute to a professional portfolio by developing and selecting a variety of productions for
inclusion in the portfolio.
2.1 Print Technologies
2.1.3 Use presentation application software to produce presentations and supplementary materials for
instructional and professional purposes.
2.1.4 Produce instructional and professional products using various aspects of integrated application
programs.
2.3 Computer-Based Technologies
2.3.2 Design, produce, and use digital information with computer-based technologies.
3.0 Utilization
3.1 Media Utilization
3.1.1 Identify key factors in selecting and using technologies appropriate for learning situations specified
in the instructional design process.
3.1.2 Use educational communications and instructional technology (SMETS) resources in a
variety of learning contexts.
3.3 Implementation and Institutionalization
3.3.1 Use appropriate instructional materials and strategies in various learning contexts.
3.3.2 Identify and apply techniques for integrating SMETS innovations in various learning contexts.
3.3.3 Identify strategies to maintain use after initial adoption.
4.0 Management
(none specifically addressed in 503)
5.0 Evaluation
5.1 Problem Analysis
5.1.1 Identify and apply problem analysis skills in appropriate school media and educational
technology (SMET) contexts (e.g., conduct needs assessments, identify and define problems,
8/4/2019 503 Final Project Idp
115/115
identify constraints, identify resources, define learner characteristics, define goals and
objectives in instructional systems design, media development and utilization, program
management, and evaluation).
5.2 Criterion-referenced Measurement
5.2.1 Develop and apply criterion-referenced measures in a variety of SMET contexts.
5.3 Formative and Summative Evaluation
5.3.1 Develop and apply formative and summative evaluation strategies in a variety of SMET contexts.
SMET = School Media & Educational Technologies