PowerPoint PresentationCopyright © 2021, Creare LLC. An unpublished
work. All rights reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 1
5-kWe Closed-Loop Brayton-Cycle Microturbine for Residential-Scale
Combined Cooling, Heat, and Power
ARPA-E Energy Innovation Summit 24-27 May 2021
Steve Walker Founder/CEO, IMBY Energy
[email protected]
[email protected]
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 2
Company Backgrounds IMBY and Creare form a complementary team IMBY
(In My BackYard) is focused on decarbonizing building
energy consumption • Use high-volume manufacturing expertise to
transition most promising
technologies out of the laboratory • Provide direct path to
decarbonized energy
Creare is focused on developing innovative technologies • 60 years
of successful invention, development, and transition • Core
emphasis on thermodynamic components and systems • Over four
decades devoted to miniature high-performance turbomachines
and closed-loop Brayton systems
Vacuum Pumps for Mars Curiosity RoverBrayton Cryocooler for Hubble
Space Telescope
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 3
Turbomachine Technology
Rene 41 Turbine Rotor Inconel Nozzle Ring Shrouded and Unshrouded
Compressor Impellers
Turboalternator for Organic Rankine CycleTurbomachine Assembly for
Brayton Power System (Turbine, Compressor, and Internal Permanent
Magnet)
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 4
Overview
IMBY evaluated numerous engine technologies for small- scale
combined heat and power generation
Closed-loop Brayton-cycle microturbine (CBM) identified as the best
technology
Creare has developed closed-loop Brayton systems for NASA and DoD
applications
• High cost has limited use to critical missions IMBY and Creare
partnered to prototype a CBM designed for
mass-production Development funded by ARPA-E, NASA, IMBY, and
Creare
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 5
IMBY System
Problem • Antiquated HVAC appliances • Poor grid resiliency • High
carbon emissions
Solution • Provide building with all heating, cooling,
hot water, and electricity • Integrate microturbine, heat pump,
and
thermal storage Benefits
• Lower CapEx and OpEx • Fuel flexibility (including renewable
fuels) • On-grid or off-grid operation • Demand-side grid
management • Direct path to carbon-free energy
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 6
Sankey Diagram
*HP = heat pump (operating at a COP of 2 at -20°C ambient)
Building Building
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 7
Cold-Weather Operation
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 8
Warm-Weather Operation
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 9
Engine Technology Selection
Existing small engines are too inefficient, expensive, and/or
unreliable for IMBY system
Conventional Brayton engines are not appropriate • Features and
performance scale poorly down to 5 kWe
• Open-loop operation allows oxidation and contamination ingress
CBM is ideal
• Closed-loop operation enables dense working fluid with
exceptional thermodynamic properties
» High efficiency » Compact components that are inexpensive to
manufacture
• Closed-loop operation prevents contamination ingress and internal
oxidation
» High reliability » Long maintenance-free life
• Creare has addressed scaling challenges required to provide high
efficiency for small sizes
Closed-loop Brayton engines are not available presently as
commercial products
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 10
CBM Characteristics
High efficiency • Low fuel consumption
Compact size • Low material costs
Efficiency and power density scale favorably as power level
increases High reliability
• One moving component with non-contact gas bearings and clearance
seals • No wear mechanisms, lubrication, or maintenance
requirements
Long life • Limiting factor is high-temperature material
creep
Assembly can be packaged to utilize available space • Discrete
components connected by tubing/ducting • Customizable heat
exchanger dimensions
Continuous gas flow enhances thermal energy input and removal •
High efficiency • Low material costs
Vibration-free operation • No need for vibration cancelling
devices, control methods, or system configurations
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 11
CBM Schematic
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 12
Turndown Efficiency
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 13
Laboratory Prototype
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 14
Critical Technologies
Turbomachine assembly with specialized hydrodynamic gas
bearings
• Extremely low radial displacement enables exceptionally tight
clearance seals for high efficiency at small size
• High rotational speed enables compact size to limit material
costs • Contact-free operation enables long, maintenance-free
life
Binary working fluid mixture of krypton and helium • Enables high
efficiency and compact, low-cost components
Recuperated flameless combustion • Provides low exhaust
emissions
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 15
CBM Development Path
Preliminary design funded by IMBY and NASA SBIR Phase IIE project
(Contract NNX14CC09C)
Detailed design, fabrication, and testing funded by ARPA-E, IMBY,
and Creare
• DOE Contract DE-AR0001067 • Scaled from 340 We engine under
development for NASA RPS Program
(Contract 80GRC17C0028) Component fabrication and testing under way
Prototype system testing to begin in late 2021
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 16
IMBY-NASA Comparison
Critical Parameters for Converter Design Parameter NASA System IMBY
CBM
Working Fluid (Molar Composition) 85% Xe, 15% He 70% Kr, 30% He
Mass Flow Rate 44.6 g/s 201 g/s Compressor Inlet Temperature 100°C
22°C Turbine Inlet Temperature 730°C 780°C Compressor Inlet
Pressure 441 kPa (63.9 psia) 1,015 kPa (147 psia) Compressor
Pressure Ratio 1.63 1.66 Turbine Pressure Ratio 1.59 1.61 Rotor
Speed 161,000 rpm 137,000 rpm Heat Source Radioisotope (Pu-238)
Combustion Energy Input Rate 1,500 W 13.15 kW Heat Loss Rate from
Combustion Exhaust NA 0.37 kW Heat Leak Rate to Environment 150 W
0.59 kW Heat Rejection Rate 1,013 W 7.04 kW Unregulated Electric
Power 337 W 5.16 kW Regulated Electric Power 319 W 5.00 kW Engine
Efficiency 25.0% 39.2% Overall Efficiency 21.3% 38.0%
Critical Parameters for Converter Design
Parameter
NA
150 W
0.59 kW
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 17
NASA Engine
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 18
Turbomachine
Compressor, turbine, and alternator are a single assembly • Turbine
drives compressor and alternator directly with one set of
bearings
Specialized features enable high efficiency at small size •
Tilt-pad journal bearings and high precision enable tight clearance
seals
to minimize bypass leakage • Shrouded impellers minimize bypass
leakage and enhance aerodynamic
efficiency Impeller diameters are 1.1 inch and 1.2 inch Rotational
speed is 137,000 RPM
NASA Turbomachine Assembly NASA Rotor Assembly
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 19
Recuperator
Low-cost recuperator is critical for a cost-effective system •
Existing approaches are too expensive
Diffusion-bonded foil recuperator is a breakthrough innovation •
Inexpensive foil stamping • Single-step bonding without braze
material
Two subscale assemblies built to refine fabrication processes
Full-scale recuperator bonded
• Manifold attachment progressing
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 20
Combustion System (1 of 2)
External heat source enables flexible fuel type Flameless oxidation
(FLOX) chosen
• Limits peak temperature and associated NOx formation • Initial
testing with commercial FLOX burner complete
Hot interface heat exchanger will ensure effective heat transfer
Combustion recuperator will minimize waste heat discharge Burner
integration with interface heat exchanger under way Subsystem
testing planned during June
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 21
Combustion System (2 of 2)
Burner Testing Interface Heat Exchanger
Copyright © 2021, Creare LLC An unpublished work. All rights
reserved. MTG-21-05-7938 / 1010243 - 22
Conclusions
CBM is attractive for combined heat and power generation Technology
is based on specialized systems developed for
NASA and DoD Diffusion-bonded foil recuperator is a key
breakthrough to
enable low-cost manufacturing and commercialization Component
fabrication and testing are under way Prototype system testing to
begin in late 2021
Creare and IMBY are grateful for support provided by ARPA-E, DOE,
NASA, and DoD
5-kWe Closed-Loop Brayton-Cycle Microturbine for Residential-Scale
Combined Cooling, Heat, and Power
Company Backgrounds
Turbomachine Technology
Conclusions