Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
/"1%&+(&+$
)*
*�-ƿ01�+
6ʆǦDŽ6
-/&+1ǯ Ǜ�)) *,!")0 �/" 4/,+$ǒ �21 0,*" �/" 20"#2)ǑǛ ǰ
DZƾDz Ǜ�)) *,!")0 �/" 4/,+$ǒ �21 0,*" �/" 20"#2)ǑǛ
5 ʆǦ ƾǓƿ5 ʆǦ 5ǹƾƽ5 ʆǦ ),$ǯ5ǰ5 ʆǦ 02*ǯ5ǰ5 ʆǦ "5-ǯ5ǰ5
ƿƽƽ
5
= ( . )
= × ( . )
ǯ ),$ǯ ƽǑƽƾʋƿƽƽ ǰ ǰǯ ƿƽƽ ǹ ),$ǯƽǑƽƾǰ ǰ
DZƾDz Ǧ�+#DZƾDz ǦdžƿƾǑƽǀǁ
ȅ
ȅ �,�! 1%" !�1�Ǔȅ �/ �/�(&+$ !&01�+ "0 &+ #""1 -�&/"! 4&1% 0-""!0 &+ (*ǵ%ȅ 0"" ǘ �/0 #,/ !"1�&)0!�1�ǯ �/0ǰ
ȅ #&1 � )&+"�/ /"$/"00&,+ ,# !&01�+ " ,+ 0-""!* ʆǦ )*ǯ !&01 ʍ 0-""! ǒ !�1�ʅ �/0 ǰ
ȅ "01&*�1"! ,"##& &"+10 #/,* 1%" *,!") ,"#ǯ*ǰ
ȅ -),1 /"0&!2�)0 �$�&+01 0-""!-),1ǯ /"0&!ǯ*ǰ ʍ 0-""! ǒ !�1�ʅ �/0 ǰ
���� ��
/"1%&+(&+$
/"1%&+(&+$
/"1%&+(&+$ /01�+
/01�+ * Ǧ01�+Ǒ,/$
/01�+* Ǧ01�+Ǒ,/$
/"1%&+(&+$
&+01�))Ǒ-� (�$"0ǯ ǯǛ ,!�ǛǒǛ*31+,/*ǛǒǛ!"31,,)0Ǜǰǰ)&�/�/6ǯ!"31,,)0ǰ!"31,,)0ǓǓ&+01�))Ǯ$&1%2�ǯǛ/* ")/"�1%ǵ/"1%&+(&+$Ǜǰ
/"1%&+(&+$
/"1%&+(&+$$&1%2�Ǒ ,*ǵ/* ")/"�1%ǵ/"1%&+(&+$
H0
H1
“Evolution is neutral”
“Selection matters”
P0A
Neutral,non-equilibrium
P0B
Neutral, equilibrium
P1BFluctuating
selection
P1AConstant selection
MI
MII
MIII
Hypotheses Process models Statistical models
)&�/�/6ǯ/"1%&+(&+$ǰ!�1�ǯ/""!#/,$0ǰ! ʆǦ /""!#/,$001/ǯ!ǰ
ǚ!�1�Ǒ#/�*"ǚǓ ǁDž ,�0Ǒ ,# ǂ 3�/&��)"0Ǔɢ !"+0&16 Ǔ &+1 ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ƾƽ ǑǑǑɢ -/"! Ǔ � 1,/ 4ǵ ƿ )"3")0 Ǜ+,ǛǒǛ-/"!ǛǓ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƿ ƿ ǑǑǑɢ 0&7" Ǔ � 1,/ 4ǵ ƿ )"3")0 Ǜ�&$ǛǒǛ0*�))ǛǓ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƾ ƿ ƿ ƿ ƿ ƾ ƾ ǑǑǑɢ 02/3 Ǔ &+1 dž ƾƽ DŽ ƾƽ dž dž ƾƽ dž ǁ dž ǑǑǑɢ -/,-02/3Ǔ +2* ƽǑdž ƾ ƽǑDŽ ƾ ƽǑdž ƽǑdž ƾ ƽǑdž ƽǑǁ ƽǑdž ǑǑǑ
02/3 !"+Ǧ0&16
∼ ( , ) >OLNHOLKRRG@
( ) = α [ ] >XQLTXH�ORJ�RGGV�IRU�HDFK�WDQN @
α ∼ ( , ) >ZHDNO\�UHJXODUL]LQJ�SULRU@
*�- *�-ƿ01�+*�-ƿ01�+ *�-
)&�/�/6ǯ/"1%&+(&+$ǰ!�1�ǯ/""!#/,$0ǰ! ʆǦ /""!#/,$0
ȅ *�(" 1%" 1�+( )201"/ 3�/&��)"!ɢ1�+( ʆǦ ƾǓ+/,4ǯ!ǰ
ȅ #&1*ƾƿǑƾ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ
�)&01ǯ02/3 ʍ !�&+,*ǯ !"+0&16 ǒ - ǰ ǒ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ �Ǯ1�+(DZ1�+(Dz ǒ�Ǯ1�+(DZ1�+(Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ ƽ ǒ ǂ ǰ
ǰǒ!�1�ʅ! ǰ
-/" &0ǯ*ƾƿǑƾǒ!"-1%ʅƿǰ
�Ǯ1�+(
�Ǯ1�+(
∼ ( , ) >OLNHOLKRRG@
( ) = α [ ] >ORJ�RGGV�IRU�WDQN�RQ�URZ @
α ∼ (α,σ) >YDU\LQJ�LQWHUFHSWV�SULRU@
α ∼ ( , ) >SULRU�IRU�DYHUDJH�WDQN@
σ ∼ ( , ) >SULRU�IRU�VWDQGDUG�GHYLDWLRQ�RI�WDQNV@
α α σα
σα σ
α α ∼ (α,σ)α
α σ α ∼ ( , ) σ ∼ ( , )σα σ
*�-α σ *�-
*�-ƿ01�+
*ƾƿǑƿ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ�)&01ǯ
02/3 ʍ !�&+,*ǯ !"+0&16 ǒ - ǰ ǒ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ �Ǯ1�+(DZ1�+(Dz ǒ�Ǯ1�+(DZ1�+(Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ � ǒ 0&$*� ǰ ǒ� ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾǰ ǒ0&$*� ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰ
ǰǒ !�1�ʅ! ǒ &1"/ʅǁƽƽƽ ǒ %�&+0ʅǁ ǰ
ασ
*ƾƿǑƾ
,*-�/"ǯ *ƾƿǑƾ ǒ *ƾƿǑƿ ǰ
���� -���� !���� 4"&$%1 �� !��*ƾƿǑƿ ƾƽƾƽǑƿ ǀDžǑƽ ƽǑƽ ƾ ǀDŽǑdžǁ ��*ƾƿǑƾ ƾƽƿǀǑǀ ǁdžǑǁ ƾǀǑƾ ƽ ǁǀǑƽƾ ǃǑǂǁ
α0&$*� -/" &0 ,"#
*ƾƿǑƿ *ƾƿǑƾ
*�-
*ƾƿǑƾ *ƾƿǑƿ
ȅ "51/� 1 �1�+ 0�*-)"0-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑƿǰ
ȅ ,*-21" *"!&�+ &+1"/ "-1 #,/ "� % 1�+(ȅ �)0, 1/�+0#,/* 1, -/,���&)&16 4&1% ),$&01& !ɢ-/,-02/3Ǒ"01 ʆǦ ),$&01& ǯ �--)6ǯ -,01ɢ�Ǯ1�+( ǒ ƿ ǒ *"!&�+ ǰ ǰ
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
tank
prop
ortio
n su
rviv
al
1 16 32 48
small tanks medium tanks large tanks
ȅ !&0-)�6 /�4 -/,-,/1&,+0 02/3&3&+$ &+ "� % 1�+(-),1ǯ !ɢ-/,-02/3 ǒ 6)&*ʅ ǯƽǒƾǰ ǒ - %ʅƾǃ ǒ 5�51ʅǛ+Ǜ ǒ
5)��ʅǛ1�+(Ǜ ǒ 6)��ʅǛ-/,-,/1&,+ 02/3&3�)Ǜ ǒ ,)ʅ/�+$&ƿ ǰ�5&0ǯ ƾ ǒ �1ʅ ǯƾǒƾǃǒǀƿǒǁDžǰ ǒ )��")0ʅ ǯƾǒƾǃǒǀƿǒǁDžǰ ǰ
ȅ ,3"/)�6 -,01"/&,/ *"!&�+0-,&+10ǯ !ɢ-/,-02/3Ǒ"01 ǰ
ȅ *�/( -,01"/&,/ *"!&�+ -/,���&)&16 � /,00 1�+(0��)&+"ǯ %ʅ),$&01& ǯ*"!&�+ǯ-,01ɢ�ǰǰ ǒ )16ʅƿ ǰ
ȅ !/�4 3"/1& �) !&3&!"/0 �"14""+ 1�+( !"+0&1&"0��)&+"ǯ 3ʅƾǃǑǂ ǒ )4!ʅƽǑǂ ǰ��)&+"ǯ 3ʅǀƿǑǂ ǒ )4!ʅƽǑǂ ǰ1"51ǯ Dž ǒ ƽ ǒ Ǜ0*�)) 1�+(0Ǜ ǰ1"51ǯ ƾǃʀDž ǒ ƽ ǒ Ǜ*"!&2* 1�+(0Ǜ ǰ1"51ǯ ǀƿʀDž ǒ ƽ ǒ Ǜ)�/$" 1�+(0Ǜ ǰ
-/,-02/3
α
α
ασ
ȅ 0%,4 #&/01 ƾƽƽ -,-2)�1&,+0 &+ 1%" -,01"/&,/-),1ǯ ���� ǒ 5)&*ʅ ǯǦǀǒǁǰ ǒ 6)&*ʅ ǯƽǒƽǑǀǂǰ ǒ
5)��ʅǛ),$Ǧ,!!0 02/3&3"Ǜ ǒ 6)��ʅǛ�"+0&16Ǜ ǰ#,/ ǯ & &+ ƾǓƾƽƽ ǰ
2/3"ǯ !+,/*ǯ5ǒ-,01ɢ�DZ&Dzǒ-,01ɢ0&$*�DZ&Dzǰ ǒ �!!ʅ���� ǒ ,)ʅ ,)Ǒ�)-%�ǯǛ�)� (ǛǒƽǑƿǰ ǰ
ȅ 0�*-)" Džƽƽƽ &*�$&+�/6 1�+(0 #/,* 1%" -,01"/&,/ !&01/&�21&,+0&*Ǯ1�+(0 ʆǦ /+,/*ǯ Džƽƽƽ ǒ -,01ɢ� ǒ -,01ɢ0&$*� ǰ
ȅ 1/�+0#,/* 1, -/,���&)&16 �+! 3&02�)&7"
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
log-odds survive
Density
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
0.00.51.01.52.02.53.0
probability surviveDensity
*ƾƿǑƿ
!"+0ǯ ),$&01& ǯ0&*Ǯ1�+(0ǰ ǒ 5)��ʅǛ-/,���&)&16 02/3&3"Ǜ ǰ
α σ
σ
+Ǯ"##
∼ ( , )
( ) = α [ ]
α ∼ (α,σ)
α ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( )
!"5-ǯƾǰ
αα α
∼ ( , )
( ) = α [ ]
α ∼ (α,σ)
α ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
• α• σ• α
/�&+,*
α σ
� ʆǦ ƾǑǁ0&$*� ʆǦ ƾǑǂ+-,+!0 ʆǦ ǃƽ+& ʆǦ �0Ǒ&+1"$"/ǯ /"-ǯ ǯǂǒƾƽǒƿǂǒǀǂǰ ǒ "� %ʅƾǂ ǰ ǰ
�0Ǒ&+1"$"/ *�-ƿ01�+
α = . σ = .
α σ
�Ǯ-,+! ʆǦ /+,/*ǯ +-,+!0 ǒ *"�+ʅ� ǒ 0!ʅ0&$*� ǰ
�Ǯ-,+!
!0&* ʆǦ !�1�Ǒ#/�*"ǯ -,+!ʅƾǓ+-,+!0 ǒ +&ʅ+& ǒ 1/2"Ǯ�ʅ�Ǯ-,+! ǰ
!0&*
+2*"/&
)�00ǯƾǓǀǰ )�00ǯ ǯƾǒƿǒǀǰǰ
DZƾDz Ǜ&+1"$"/ǛDZƾDz Ǜ+2*"/& Ǜ
*�-ƿ01�+
+2*"/& �0Ǒ&+1"$"/ *�-ƿ01�+
=(α )
+ (α )
!0&*ɢ0& ʆǦ /�&+,*ǯ +-,+!0 ǒ -/,�ʅ),$&01& ǯ!0&*ɢ1/2"Ǯ�ǰ ǒ 0&7"ʅ!0&*ɢ+& ǰ
α !0&*ɢ1/2"Ǯ� !0&*ɢ+&
!0&*
!0&*ɢ-Ǯ+,-,,) ʆǦ !0&*ɢ0& ǵ !0&*ɢ+&
!0&*
*�-ƿ01�+
*ƾƿǑǀ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ�)&01ǯ
0& ʍ !�&+,*ǯ +& ǒ - ǰǒ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ �Ǯ-,+!DZ-,+!Dzǒ�Ǯ-,+!DZ-,+!Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ � ǒ 0&$*� ǰǒ� ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾǰǒ0&$*� ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰ
ǰǒ
!�1�ʅ!0&* ǒ &1"/ʅƾ"ǁ ǒ 4�/*2-ʅƾƽƽƽ ǰ
ασ -/" &0
-/" &0ǯ*ƾƿǑǀǒ!"-1%ʅƿǰ
�"�+ �1!�"3 ),4"/ ƽǑDždž 2--"/ ƽǑDždž +Ǯ"## �%�1�Ǯ-,+!DZƾDz ƾǑǁǂ ƽǑdžǂ ǦƽǑƾƾ ƿǑDždž džƽƽƽ ƾ�Ǯ-,+!DZƿDz ƾǑǁDŽ ƽǑdžǂ ǦƽǑƽƿ ƿǑdžǃ džƽƽƽ ƾǑǑǑ�Ǯ-,+!DZǂdžDz ƾǑDžƾ ƽǑǁDŽ ƾǑƽƿ ƿǑǂƿ DŽǀƾǁ ƾ�Ǯ-,+!DZǃƽDz ƿǑƽǀ ƽǑǂƽ ƾǑƿǁ ƿǑDžƿ džƽƽƽ ƾ� ƾǑƾǀ ƽǑƿǀ ƽǑDŽDž ƾǑǂƽ ǂDžǁDž ƾ0&$*� ƾǑǂdž ƽǑƿƿ ƾǑƿǂ ƾǑdžǀ ƿDŽƽǂ ƾ
-Ǒ-�/1-,,)
"01&*�1"!Ǒ�Ǯ-,+! ʆǦ �0Ǒ+2*"/& ǯ ,"#ǯ*ƾƿǑǀǰDZƾǓǃƽDz ǰ!0&*ɢ-Ǯ-�/1-,,) ʆǦ ),$&01& ǯ "01&*�1"!Ǒ�Ǯ-,+! ǰ
1/2"Ǯ�
!0&*ɢ-Ǯ1/2" ʆǦ ),$&01& ǯ !0&*ɢ1/2"Ǯ� ǰ
+,-,,)Ǯ"//,/ ʆǦ ��0ǯ !0&*ɢ-Ǯ+,-,,) Ǧ !0&*ɢ-Ǯ1/2" ǰ-�/1-,,)Ǯ"//,/ ʆǦ ��0ǯ !0&*ɢ-Ǯ-�/1-,,) Ǧ !0&*ɢ-Ǯ1/2" ǰ
-),1ǯ ƾǓǃƽ ǒ +,-,,)Ǯ"//,/ ǒ 5)��ʅǛ-,+!Ǜ ǒ 6)��ʅǛ��0,)21" "//,/Ǜ ǒ ,)ʅ/�+$&ƿ ǒ - %ʅƾǃ ǰ
-,&+10ǯ ƾǓǃƽ ǒ -�/1-,,)Ǯ"//,/ ǰ
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
pond
abso
lute
err
or
1 10 20 30 40 50 60
tiny (5) small (10) medium (25) large (35)
*ƾƿǑǀ
� ʆǦ ƾǑǁ0&$*� ʆǦ ƾǑǂ+-,+!0 ʆǦ ǃƽ+& ʆǦ �0Ǒ&+1"$"/ǯ /"-ǯ ǯǂǒƾƽǒƿǂǒǀǂǰ ǒ "� %ʅƾǂ ǰ ǰ�Ǯ-,+! ʆǦ /+,/*ǯ +-,+!0 ǒ *"�+ʅ� ǒ 0!ʅ0&$*� ǰ!0&* ʆǦ !�1�Ǒ#/�*"ǯ -,+!ʅƾǓ+-,+!0 ǒ +&ʅ+& ǒ 1/2"Ǯ�ʅ�Ǯ-,+! ǰ!0&*ɢ0& ʆǦ /�&+,*ǯ +-,+!0ǒ-/,�ʅ),$&01& ǯ !0&*ɢ1/2"Ǯ� ǰǒ0&7"ʅ!0&*ɢ+& ǰ!0&*ɢ-Ǯ+,-,,) ʆǦ !0&*ɢ0& ǵ !0&*ɢ+&+"4!�1 ʆǦ )&01ǯ0&ʅ!0&*ɢ0&ǒ+&ʅ!0&*ɢ+&ǒ-,+!ʅƾǓ+-,+!0ǰ*ƾƿǑǀ+"4 ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ *ƾƿǑǀ ǒ !�1�ʅ+"4!�1 ǒ &1"/ʅƾ"ǁ ǒ 4�/*2-ʅƾƽƽƽ ǰ
*�-ƿ01�+ *ƾƿǑǀ*ƾƿǑǀ+"4
*ƾƿǑǀȃ01�+#&1 01�+ ,!"ǯ*ƾƿǑǀǰ*ƾƿǑǀȃ!�1�
!�1�ǯ %&*-�+7""0ǰ
� 1,/�), (
� 1,/�), (
!�1�ǯ %&*-�+7""0ǰ
*ƾƽǑǁ
α
∼ ( , )
( ) = α+ α [ ] + (β + β )
α ∼ ( ,σ )
α ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
α α
6ƾ ʆǦ /+,/*ǯ ƾ"ǁ ǒ ƾƽ ǒ ƾ ǰ6ƿ ʆǦ ƾƽ ʀ /+,/*ǯ ƾ"ǁ ǒ ƽ ǒ ƾ ǰ
6ƾ 6ƿ
*�-ƿ01�+ � 1,/�), ( α
)&�/�/6ǯ/"1%&+(&+$ǰ!�1�ǯ %&*-�+7""0ǰ! ʆǦ %&*-�+7""0!ɢ/" &-&"+1 ʆǦ ���� ȅ $"1 /&! ,# ��0
*ƾƿǑǁ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ�)&01ǯ
-2))"!Ǯ)"#1 ʍ !�&+,*ǯ ƾ ǒ - ǰ ǒ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ � ʀ �Ǯ� 1,/DZ� 1,/Dz ʀ ǯ�- ʀ �-�ǹ ,+!&1&,+ǰǹ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1 ǒ�Ǯ� 1,/DZ� 1,/Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ ƽ ǒ 0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ǰǒ� ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾƽǰǒ�- ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾƽǰǒ�-� ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾƽǰǒ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰ
ǰ ǒ!�1�ʅ! ǒ 4�/*2-ʅƾƽƽƽ ǒ &1"/ʅǂƽƽƽ ǒ %�&+0ʅǁ ǒ ,/"0ʅǀ ǰ
-),1ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǰ 0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/�%�1
α ��Ǯ� 1,/ �
α + α [ ]
α � 1,/� �Ǯ� 1,/
-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǰ1,1�)Ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ ʆǦ 0�--)6ǯ ƾǓDŽ ǒ #2+ 1&,+ǯ� 1,/ǰ -,01ɢ� ʀ -,01ɢ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǒ� 1,/Dz ǰ/,2+!ǯ �--)6ǯ1,1�)Ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ǒƿǒ*"�+ǰ ǒ ƿ ǰ
DZƾDz ǦƽǑDŽƾ ǁǑǂdž ǦƾǑƽƿ ǦƾǑƽƿ ǦƽǑDŽƾ ƽǑƿǀ ƾǑDŽǃ
�), (� 1,/
α [ ]
∼ ( , )
( ) = α+ α [ ] + α [ ] + (β + β )
α ∼ ( ,σ )
α ∼ ( ,σ )
α ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
σ σα
α� 1,/ �), (
ȅ -/"- !�1�!ɢ�), (Ǯ&! ʆǦ !ɢ�), ( ȅ +�*" ǚ�), (ǚ &0 /"0"/3"! �6 �1�+
*ƾƿǑǂ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ�)&01ǯ
-2))"!Ǯ)"#1 ʍ !�&+,*ǯ ƾ ǒ - ǰǒ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ � ʀ �Ǯ� 1,/DZ� 1,/Dz ʀ �Ǯ�), (DZ�), (Ǯ&!Dz ʀ
ǯ�- ʀ �- ǹ ,+!&1&,+ǰǹ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1ǒ�Ǯ� 1,/DZ� 1,/Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ ƽ ǒ 0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ǰǒ�Ǯ�), (DZ�), (Ǯ&!Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯ ƽ ǒ 0&$*�Ǯ�), ( ǰǒ ǯ�ǒ�-ǒ�- ǰ ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾƽǰǒ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰǒ0&$*�Ǯ�), ( ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰ
ǰ ǒ!�1�ʅ!ǒ 4�/*2-ʅƾƽƽƽ ǒ &1"/ʅǃƽƽƽ ǒ %�&+0ʅǁ ǒ ,/"0ʅǀ ǰ
��/+&+$ *"00�$"Ǔ�+ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ�)&01ǯ-2))"!Ǯ)"#1 ʍ !�&+,*ǯƾǒ -ǰǒ ),$&1ǯ-ǰ ʆǦ � ʀ �Ǯ� 1,/DZ� 1,/Dz ʀ Ǔ�%"/" 4"/" ǀ !&3"/$"+1 &1"/�1&,+0 !2/&+$ 0�*-)&+$Ǒ
�%" ( 1%" %�&+0 ǯ1/� " -),10ǒ +Ǯ"##ǒ �%�1ǰ �/"#2))6 1, "+02/" 1%"6 �/" 3�)&!Ǒ
+Ǯ"## �%�1
-/" &0ǯ*ƾƿǑǂǒ!"-1%ʅƿǰ ȅ !"-1%ʅƿ !&0-)�60 3�/6&+$ "##" 10-),1ǯ-/" &0ǯ*ƾƿǑǂǒ!"-1%ʅƿǰǰ ȅ �)0, -),1
�"�+ �1!�"3 ),4"/ ƽǑDždž 2--"/ ƽǑDždž +Ǯ"## �%�1�Ǯ� 1,/DZƾDz ǦƾǑƾDŽ ƽǑdžǀ ǦƿǑǂDŽ ƽǑƿdž ƿǀǀǀ ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZƿDz ǁǑƾǁ ƾǑǂdž ƾǑdžƿ ǃǑǀǀ ǁǂǁǀ ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǀDz ǦƾǑǁDž ƽǑdžǁ ǦƿǑdžƾ ǦƽǑƽƿ ƿǀƾƽ ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǁDz ǦƾǑǁDž ƽǑdžǁ ǦƿǑdžƿ ǦƽǑƽƾ ƿǀǃƽ ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǂDz ǦƾǑƾDŽ ƽǑdžǁ ǦƿǑǃǀ ƽǑƿDŽ ƿǀǂǁ ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǃDz ǦƽǑƿƿ ƽǑdžǀ ǦƾǑǃǂ ƾǑƿǂ ƿǀǂdž ƾ�Ǯ� 1,/DZDŽDz ƾǑǀƿ ƽǑdžǃ ǦƽǑƾǂ ƿǑDžǁ ƿǁdžǃ ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZƾDz ǦƽǑƾDž ƽǑƿƿ ǦƽǑǂǀ ƽǑƾƾ ǀDžǁDž ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZƿDz ƽǑƽǁ ƽǑƾDž ǦƽǑƿǀ ƽǑǀǁ Džǂdžǂ ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZǀDz ƽǑƽǂ ƽǑƾdž ǦƽǑƿǀ ƽǑǀǂ DŽƿǀDŽ ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZǁDz ƽǑƽƽ ƽǑƾDž ǦƽǑǀƽ ƽǑƿDž džǂǀƿ ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZǂDz ǦƽǑƽǁ ƽǑƾDž ǦƽǑǀǁ ƽǑƿǂ DžǀƿDŽ ƾ�Ǯ�), (DZǃDz ƽǑƾƾ ƽǑƿƽ ǦƽǑƾDŽ ƽǑǁǀ ǂǁƿƽ ƾ� ƽǑǁǃ ƽǑdžƿ ǦƽǑdžDž ƾǑDžDž ƿƿǃǀ ƾ�- ƽǑDžƿ ƽǑƿǃ ƽǑǁƾ ƾǑƿǂ ǃDždžƽ ƾ�- ǦƽǑƾǀ ƽǑǀƽ ǦƽǑǃƿ ƽǑǀǀ Džǀǃƽ ƾ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ƿǑƿǂ ƽǑdžƽ ƾǑƽƿ ǀǑǀǀ ǁDždžƿ ƾ0&$*�Ǯ�), ( ƽǑƿƿ ƽǑƾDž ƽǑƽƾ ƽǑǁǀ ƿƽDŽdž ƾ
-/" &0+Ǯ"##
0&$*�Ǯ�), (
�%�1
0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ 0&$*�Ǯ�), (
-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǂǰ!"+0ǯ -,01ɢ0&$*�Ǯ�), ( ǒ 5)��ʅǛ0&$*�Ǜ ǒ 5)&*ʅ ǯƽǒǁǰ ǰ!"+0ǯ -,01ɢ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ ǒ ,)ʅ/�+$&ƿ ǒ )4!ʅƿ ǒ �!!ʅ���� ǰ1"51ǯ ƿ ǒ ƽǑDžǂ ǒ Ǜ� 1,/Ǜ ǒ ,)ʅ/�+$&ƿ ǰ1"51ǯ ƽǑDŽǂ ǒ ƿ ǒ Ǜ�), (Ǜ ǰ
sigma_blocksigma_actorbpcbpaa_block[6]a_block[5]a_block[4]a_block[3]a_block[2]a_block[1]a_actor[7]a_actor[6]a_actor[5]a_actor[4]a_actor[3]a_actor[2]a_actor[1]
-2 0 2 4 6Value
0 1 2 3 40.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
sigma
Density
actor
block
*ƾƿǑǂ�Ǯ� 1,/ �Ǯ�), (
�Ǯ� 1,/�Ǯ�), (�), (
� 1,/
,*-�/"ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǒ*ƾƿǑǂǰ
���� -���� !���� 4"&$%1 �� !��*ƾƿǑǁ ǂǀƾǑǂ DžǑƾ ƽǑƽ ƽǑǃǂ ƾdžǑǂƽ ��*ƾƿǑǂ ǂǀƿǑDŽ ƾƽǑǂ ƾǑƿ ƽǑǀǂ ƾdžǑDŽǁ ƾǑdžǁ
-���� *ƾƿǑǂ*ƾƿǑǁ
0&$*�Ǯ�), (�Ǯ�), (
�Ǯ� 1,/
�Ǯ� 1,/ -����
*ƾƿǑǁ
�Ǯ�), (0&$*�Ǯ�), (
0&$*�
)&+( 0&*
!�1�ǯ %&*-�+7""0ǰ*ƾƿǑǁ
)&+(
%&*- ʆǦ ƿ!Ǒ-/"! ʆǦ )&01ǯ
-/,0, Ǯ)"#1 ʅ ǯƽǒƾǒƽǒƾǰǒ ȅ /&$%1ǵ)"#1ǵ/&$%1ǵ)"#1 ,+!&1&,+ ʅ ǯƽǒƽǒƾǒƾǰǒ ȅ ,+1/,)ǵ ,+1/,)ǵ-�/1+"/ǵ-�/1+"/� 1,/ ʅ /"-ǯ %&*-ǒǁǰ
ǰ)&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ʆǦ )&+(ǯ *ƾƿǑǁ ǒ !�1�ʅ!Ǒ-/"! ǰ-/"!Ǒ- ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ǒ ƿ ǒ *"�+ ǰ-/"!Ǒ-Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǰ
)&+(
-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǰ01/ǯ-,01ǰ
�&01 ,# ǂɢ �Ǯ� 1,/ Ǔ +2* DZƾǓDžƽƽƽǒ ƾǓDŽDz ǦƾǑDžǁƿ ǦƽǑƿƿǂ ǦƾǑDžƾƾ ǦƽǑDŽǂdž ǦƾǑDžDžƿ ǑǑǑɢ � Ǔ +2* DZƾǓDžƽƽƽǯƾ!ǰDz ƾǑƿdžƾ ǦƽǑǃǀƿ ƽǑƿDžǂ ǦƽǑƾƽdž ƾǑƿƿdž ǑǑǑɢ �- Ǔ +2* DZƾǓDžƽƽƽǯƾ!ǰDz ƾ ƾǑƽǃǁ ƾǑƽDžDŽ ƽǑƿǂǁ ƽǑdžƽDž ǑǑǑɢ �-� Ǔ +2* DZƾǓDžƽƽƽǯƾ!ǰDz ǦƽǑƿDŽƿ ǦƽǑǂǀdž ǦƽǑƿdžǂ ƽǑǀDŽǂ ǦƽǑƿƾDž ǑǑǑɢ 0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/Ǔ +2* DZƾǓDžƽƽƽǯƾ!ǰDz ƿǑƾǀ ƿǑǁdž ƿǑǀƿ ƾǑǂƾ ǁǑƾƿ ǑǑǑ
�Ǯ� 1,/
!"+0ǯ -,01ɢ�Ǯ� 1,/DZǒǂDz ǰ
DZǒǂDz4&1%
-,01ɢ
-Ǒ)&+( ʆǦ #2+ 1&,+ǯ -/,0, Ǯ)"#1 ǒ ,+!&1&,+ ǒ � 1,/ ǰ dz),$,!!0 ʆǦ 4&1%ǯ -,01 ǒ
� ʀ �Ǯ� 1,/DZǒ� 1,/Dz ʀ ǯ�- ʀ �-� ǹ ,+!&1&,+ǰ ǹ -/,0, Ǯ)"#1ǰ/"12/+ǯ ),$&01& ǯ),$,!!0ǰ ǰ
Ǵ
�Ǯ� 1,/
-/,0, Ǯ)"#1 ʆǦ ǯƽǒƾǒƽǒƾǰ ,+!&1&,+ ʆǦ ǯƽǒƽǒƾǒƾǰ-/"!Ǒ/�4 ʆǦ 0�--)6ǯ ƾǓǁ ǒ #2+ 1&,+ǯ&ǰ -Ǒ)&+(ǯ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1DZ&Dzǒ ,+!&1&,+DZ&Dzǒƿǰ ǰ-/"!Ǒ- ʆǦ �--)6ǯ -/"!Ǒ/�4 ǒ ƿ ǒ *"�+ ǰ-/"!Ǒ-Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ -/"!Ǒ/�4 ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǰ
)&+(
�Ǯ� 1,/� 0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/
� α
!Ǒ-/"! ʆǦ )&01ǯ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1 ʅ ǯƽǒƾǒƽǒƾǰǒ ȅ /&$%1ǵ)"#1ǵ/&$%1ǵ)"#1 ,+!&1&,+ ʅ ǯƽǒƽǒƾǒƾǰǒ ȅ ,+1/,)ǵ ,+1/,)ǵ-�/1+"/ǵ-�/1+"/� 1,/ ʅ /"-ǯƿǒǁǰ ǰ ȅ -)� "%,)!"/
ȅ /"-)� " 3�/6&+$ &+1"/ "-1 0�*-)"0 4&1% 7"/,0ȅ ƾƽƽƽ 0�*-)"0 �6 DŽ � 1,/0�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ7"/,0 ʆǦ *�1/&5ǯƽǒƾƽƽƽǒDŽǰ
)&+(/"-)� "
�Ǯ� 1,/
ȅ #&/" 2- )&+(ȅ +,1" 20" ,# /"-)� " )&01)&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ʆǦ )&+(ǯ *ƾƿǑǁ ǒ +ʅƾƽƽƽ ǒ !�1�ʅ!Ǒ-/"! ǒ
/"-)� "ʅ)&01ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ʅ�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ7"/,0ǰ ǰ
ȅ 02**�/&7" �+! -),1-/"!Ǒ-Ǒ*"�+ ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ǒ ƿ ǒ *"�+ ǰ-/"!Ǒ-Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǒ -/,�ʅƽǑDž ǰ-),1ǯ ƽ ǒ ƽ ǒ 16-"ʅǛ+Ǜ ǒ 5)��ʅǛ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1ǵ ,+!&1&,+Ǜ ǒ
6)��ʅǛ-/,-,/1&,+ -2))"! )"#1Ǜ ǒ 6)&*ʅ ǯƽǒƾǰ ǒ 5�51ʅǛ+Ǜ ǒ5)&*ʅ ǯƾǒǁǰ ǰ
�5&0ǯ ƾ ǒ �1ʅƾǓǁ ǒ )��")0ʅ ǯǛƽǵƽǛǒǛƾǵƽǛǒǛƽǵƾǛǒǛƾǵƾǛǰ ǰ)&+"0ǯ ƾǓǁ ǒ -/"!Ǒ-Ǒ*"�+ ǰ0%�!"ǯ -/"!Ǒ-Ǒ�� ǒ ƾǓǁ ǰ
-/,0, Ǯ)"#1
0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/)&+( /"-)� "
α ∼ ( ,σ )
σ/+,/*
ȅ /"-)� " 3�/6&+$ &+1"/ "-1 0�*-)"0 4&1% 0&*2)�1&,+0-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǰ�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ0&*0 ʆǦ /+,/*ǯDŽƽƽƽǒƽǒ-,01ɢ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ǰ�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ0&*0 ʆǦ *�1/&5ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ0&*0ǒƾƽƽƽǒDŽǰ
)&+( /"-)� "
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
prosoc_left/condition
prop
ortio
n pu
lled
left
0/0 1/0 0/1 1/1
average actor
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
prosoc_left/condition
prop
ortio
n pu
lled
left
0/0 1/0 0/1 1/1
marginal of actor
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
prosoc_left/condition
prop
ortio
n pu
lled
left
0/0 1/0 0/1 1/1
50 simulated actors
*ƾƿǑǁ
�Ǯ� 1,/
0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/
)&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǁ ʆǦ )&+(ǯ *ƾƿǑǁ ǒ +ʅƾƽƽƽ ǒ !�1�ʅ!Ǒ-/"! ǒ/"-)� "ʅ)&01ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ʅ�Ǯ� 1,/Ǯ0&*0ǰ ǰ
-/,0, Ǯ)"#1
-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǁǰ0&*Ǒ� 1,/ ʆǦ #2+ 1&,+ǯ&ǰ dz
0&*Ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ ʆǦ /+,/*ǯ ƾ ǒ ƽ ǒ -,01ɢ0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/DZ&Dz ǰ� ʆǦ ǯƽǒƾǒƽǒƾǰ� ʆǦ ǯƽǒƽǒƾǒƾǰ- ʆǦ ),$&01& ǯ
-,01ɢ�DZ&Dz ʀ0&*Ǯ�Ǯ� 1,/ ʀǯ-,01ɢ�-DZ&Dz ʀ -,01ɢ�-�DZ&Dzǹ�ǰǹ�
ǰ/"12/+ǯ-ǰ
Ǵ
&/+,/*
0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/ -� �
-
ȅ "*-16 -),1-),1ǯ ƽ ǒ ƽ ǒ 16-"ʅǛ+Ǜ ǒ 5)��ʅǛ-/,0, Ǯ)"#1ǵ ,+!&1&,+Ǜ ǒ
6)��ʅǛ-/,-,/1&,+ -2))"! )"#1Ǜ ǒ 6)&*ʅ ǯƽǒƾǰ ǒ 5�51ʅǛ+Ǜ ǒ 5)&*ʅ ǯƾǒǁǰ ǰ�5&0ǯ ƾ ǒ �1ʅƾǓǁ ǒ )��")0ʅ ǯǛƽǵƽǛǒǛƾǵƽǛǒǛƽǵƾǛǒǛƾǵƾǛǰ ǰ
ȅ -),1 ǂƽ 0&*2)�1"! � 1,/0#,/ ǯ & &+ ƾǓǂƽ ǰ )&+"0ǯ ƾǓǁ ǒ 0&*Ǒ� 1,/ǯ&ǰ ǒ ,)ʅ ,)Ǒ�)-%�ǯǛ�)� (ǛǒƽǑǂǰ ǰ
0&$*�Ǯ� 1,/
α σ *ƾƿǑǁ
∼ (µ )
(µ ) = α+ α [ ] + β
α ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
α ∼ ( ,σ )
σ ∼ ( , )
1,1�)Ǯ1,,)0 -,-2)�1&,+σ
α
ȅ -/"- !�1�)&�/�/6ǯ/"1%&+(&+$ǰ!�1�ǯ�)&+"ǰ! ʆǦ �)&+"!ɢ),$-,- ʆǦ ),$ǯ!ɢ-,-2)�1&,+ǰ!ɢ0, &"16 ʆǦ ƾǓƾƽ
ȅ #&1 *,!")*ƾƿǑǃ ʆǦ *�-ƿ01�+ǯ
�)&01ǯ1,1�)Ǯ1,,)0 ʍ !-,&0ǯ*2ǰǒ),$ǯ*2ǰ ʆǦ � ʀ �Ǯ0, &"16DZ0, &"16Dz ʀ �-ǹ),$-,-ǒ� ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾƽǰǒ�- ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒƾǰǒ�Ǯ0, &"16DZ0, &"16Dz ʍ !+,/*ǯƽǒ0&$*�Ǯ0, &"16ǰǒ0&$*�Ǯ0, &"16 ʍ ! �2 %6ǯƽǒƾǰ
ǰǒ!�1�ʅ! ǒ&1"/ʅǁƽƽƽ ǒ %�&+0ʅǀ ǰ
-,01 %" (ǯ*ƾƿǑǃǰ�Ǯ0, &"16
α σ
-,01 ʆǦ "51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0ǯ*ƾƿǑǃǰ!Ǒ-/"! ʆǦ )&01ǯ
),$-,- ʅ 0".ǯ#/,*ʅǃǒ1,ʅƾǁǒ)"+$1%Ǒ,21ʅǀƽǰǒ0, &"16 ʅ /"-ǯƾǒǀƽǰ
ǰ�Ǯ0, &"16Ǯ0&*0 ʆǦ /+,/*ǯƿƽƽƽƽǒƽǒ-,01ɢ0&$*�Ǯ0, &"16ǰ�Ǯ0, &"16Ǯ0&*0 ʆǦ *�1/&5ǯ�Ǯ0, &"16Ǯ0&*0ǒƿƽƽƽǒƾƽǰ)&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǃ ʆǦ )&+(ǯ *ƾƿǑǃ ǒ +ʅƿƽƽƽ ǒ !�1�ʅ!Ǒ-/"! ǒ
/"-)� "ʅ)&01ǯ�Ǯ0, &"16ʅ�Ǯ0, &"16Ǯ0&*0ǰ ǰ
ȅ -),1 /�4 !�1�-),1ǯ !ɢ),$-,- ǒ !ɢ1,1�)Ǯ1,,)0 ǒ ,)ʅ/�+$&ƿ ǒ - %ʅƾǃ ǒ
5)��ʅǛ),$ -,-2)�1&,+Ǜ ǒ 6)��ʅǛ1,1�) 1,,)0Ǜ ǰ
ȅ -),1 -,01"/&,/ *"!&�+*2Ǒ*"!&�+ ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǃ ǒ ƿ ǒ *"!&�+ ǰ)&+"0ǯ !Ǒ-/"!ɢ),$-,- ǒ *2Ǒ*"!&�+ ǰ
ȅ -),1 džDŽɵǒ Dždžɵǒ �+! ǃDŽɵ &+1"/3�)0 ǯ�)) -/&*" +2*�"/0ǰ*2Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǃ ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǒ -/,�ʅƽǑdžDŽ ǰ0%�!"ǯ *2Ǒ�� ǒ !Ǒ-/"!ɢ),$-,- ǰ
7 8 9 10 11 12
2030
4050
6070
log population
tota
l too
ls *ƾƿǑǃ
*2Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǃ ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǒ -/,�ʅƽǑDždž ǰ0%�!"ǯ *2Ǒ�� ǒ !Ǒ-/"!ɢ),$-,- ǰ*2Ǒ�� ʆǦ �--)6ǯ )&+(Ǒ*ƾƿǑǃ ǒ ƿ ǒ �� ǒ -/,�ʅƽǑǃDŽ ǰ0%�!"ǯ *2Ǒ�� ǒ !Ǒ-/"!ɢ),$-,- ǰ
α ∼( , ) α ∼ ( , )
∼ ( , )
( ) = α [ ] + β
α ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
∼ (µ ,σ)
µ = α [ ] + β
α ∼ ( , )
β ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
!�1�ǯ/""!#/,$0ǰ -/"!�1&,+ 0&7"
∼ ( , )
( ) = α [ ]
α ∼ (α,σ)
α ∼ ( , )
σ ∼ ( , )
α
%&*-�+7""0
∼ ( , )
( ) = α [ ] + α [ ] + (β + β )
α ∼ (α,σ )
α ∼ (γ,σ )
α, γ,β ,β ∼ ( , )
σ ,σ ∼ ( , )
!�1�ǯ��+$)�!"0%ǰ
!&01/& 120"Ǒ ,+1/� "-1&,+2/��+
!&01/& 1
!&01/& 1
0,/1ǯ2+&.2"ǯ!ɢ!&01/& 1ǰǰ
DZƾDz ƾ ƿ ǀ ǁ ǂ ǃ DŽ Dž dž ƾƽ ƾƾ ƾƿ ƾǀ ƾǁ ƾǂ ƾǃ ƾDŽ ƾDž ƾdž ƿƽ ƿƾ ƿƿ ƿǀ ƿǁ ƿǂDZƿǃDz ƿǃ ƿDŽ ƿDž ƿdž ǀƽ ǀƾ ǀƿ ǀǀ ǀǁ ǀǂ ǀǃ ǀDŽ ǀDž ǀdž ǁƽ ǁƾ ǁƿ ǁǀ ǁǁ ǁǂ ǁǃ ǁDŽ ǁDž ǁdž ǂƽDZǂƾDz ǂƾ ǂƿ ǂǀ ǂǂ ǂǃ ǂDŽ ǂDž ǂdž ǃƽ ǃƾ
!&01/& 1
!ɢ!&01/& 1Ǯ&! ʆǦ �0Ǒ&+1"$"/ǯ�0Ǒ#� 1,/ǯ!ɢ!&01/& 1ǰǰ0,/1ǯ2+&.2"ǯ!ɢ!&01/& 1Ǯ&!ǰǰ
DZƾDz ƾ ƿ ǀ ǁ ǂ ǃ DŽ Dž dž ƾƽ ƾƾ ƾƿ ƾǀ ƾǁ ƾǂ ƾǃ ƾDŽ ƾDž ƾdž ƿƽ ƿƾ ƿƿ ƿǀ ƿǁ ƿǂDZƿǃDz ƿǃ ƿDŽ ƿDž ƿdž ǀƽ ǀƾ ǀƿ ǀǀ ǀǁ ǀǂ ǀǃ ǀDŽ ǀDž ǀdž ǁƽ ǁƾ ǁƿ ǁǀ ǁǁ ǁǂ ǁǃ ǁDŽ ǁDž ǁdž ǂƽDZǂƾDz ǂƾ ǂƿ ǂǀ ǂǁ ǂǂ ǂǃ ǂDŽ ǂDž ǂdž ǃƽ
20"Ǒ ,+1/� "-1&,+ !&01/& 1Ǯ&!2/��+
!�1�ǯ�/,))"6ǰ
&! � 1&,+ &+1"+1&,+ ,+1� 1
01,/6&! 01,/6
σ α
�5&0
,"#1��
,*-�/"
!�1�ǯ�,4"))ƾǰ!�1�ǯ*&)(ǰ!�1�ǯ��##)"�&3,/ "ǰ!�"1��&+,*
!*3+,/*��
"+0"*�)"
"51/� 1Ǒ0�*-)"0
��ƿ
)&+(
),$Ǯ02*Ǯ"5-
*�-*�-ƿ01�+
* /"-)& �1"
+Ǯ"##
,-1&*
-�&/0
/)(' ,///2$$"!
0&*0&*Ǒ1/�&+Ǒ1"01