Upload
donguyet
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
INDEX NO .IMDZI6AKED0117469/2008 4PIIMED : N101119YMIRIC012191311711JEIZESRELV741412015 11 : 01 AMI WiffilenfaeE.migo?3a69 RECEIVEDAffargaDOgpAretha?.307/14/2015
1
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK : CRIMINAL TERM : PART 52
2
3 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
4 Indictment
5 TIBOR VARGANYI, 852/1C
6 Defendant.
7
111 Centre Street New York, New York
9
10 October 5, 3011
11 BEFORE:
12 HONORABLE JUSTICE THOMAS FARBER
Ia. A 2 . .. A. .N..0 E.
14 CYRUS R. VANCE,. JR., ESQ. District Attorney
15 New York County BY: DEBORAH HICKEY, ESO.
16, ELI CHERKASKY, ESQ. -Fq; the People
17
18 BRIEF, CARMEN S KLEIMAN; KSQS. 805 Third Avenue
19 New York, New York BY: MATTHEW J. BRIEF, ISO.
20 ELYSE L. DAYION, ESQ. For the Oefenaent
nIANA DiuvILA-MONGg Sr. • Court RepOrtty:.
•
21
22
23
.24
25
DriM
2
Plea
1 COURT CLERK: Calling number two on the
2 calendar Indictment Number 852 of 2010 the People
3 of the State of New York against Tibor Varganyi.
4 The defendant, his cOunsel and the
5 assistant district attorneys are present in the
6 courtroom.
7 Counsel, please state 'your appearance for
8 the record;
MS. HICKEY: For the People Deborah
10 Hickey.
1 1 MR. GAEAKASKY: Eli Cherkasky for the
12 'People.
MR. BRIEF: Brief,. Ce4nte4:1,.
14 Third Avenue, New York, New York by Matthew J.
15 Brief on behalf of Mr. Varganyi.
16 MS. DAYTON: Elyse L. Dayton also
17 appearing on behalf Of Mr. Varganyi.
18 THE COURT: All right. I just want fo
19 put quickly on the record what is happening here
20 and the reasons we are doing it.
21 . First of all, Mr. Brief, you requested
22 that the courtroom be closed.
23 Is that:correct?
24
MR. BRIEF: That's correct.
25
THE COURT: Otherwise, / .would not close
DDM
3
Plea
1 the couitroom; but if the defense is requesting Lt,
2 I will obviously go along with it, not that there
3 is anybody here.
4 I had not understood actually when you
yid me that there was a plea agreement that there
6 was going to .be a cooperation agreement as well.
That's between yqu and the district
attorney. 1 don't have anything to say about 13..
I thought this was :going to be.a plea with an
10 allocution and thar waS going to,be that. .
11 I See new that there is .a cooperation
12 a4reement; bilt.j.uSt to be clear this agreement is
.41 beine-efteel-o-sed.trthe ocr-defeSidan's-todnSier.
14 Right? ,
15 MR. RRIEF: That's'oorrect.
16, miss filckey is aware of that. Vlrtoally.
17 ithm-ediately Oftet rhe proceediiigs when TAehlsock
18 to. my'office. t'Pt going to be calLing Mr. Scheckman
19 :and Mr, tangier with whom r• have had the joint
20 privilege of. viorking With until now.
21 t do need to discleSe it.
22 THE 9ow6. there was sbme,questionlas 40,
273 .whether.I would seal the record as I might 4,0 ikt- a
21 ease :where tfieNft.i :cnOperati.1611 -agreement, .tut
25 the purpoS4,:,p1 eh4e'Wbul4 Me Aanae - limited
.POM
4
Plea
1 circumstances to keep it from the co-defendant,
2 which I would nut ordinarily do but could do in
- 3 certain circumstances.
4 So, 1 am not doing that.
5 Obviously as I mentioned I will do
6 nothing to advertise this to anybody. I am also
7 not doing anything to hide it.
8 It's a plea taken in my courtroom as you
requested. rou advanced the case to do that.
10 The only issue with respect to that was
11 Whether I would take the plea or whether Justice
12 C.Ouviser would take the plea.
_ 14hen_yoilAiret askeg mq_if t tcould.0*_., • •
14 this, the case-was in my part, and there was a
15 cOurt date scheduled in tart 52; but when the
16 defendants Indicated that they didn't need my'
intervention_ on the remaining issue that had to be
18 decided, I had the case transferred to Judge
19 Conviser-
.20 Now the casn is currently pending in
21 front of Judge Conviser, but I Asked the
22 .SUpervising JUdge, Anidge Obus, Whether !I should
take the Plea or Judge COnviser should take the
24 p1.e4.4 Of course, I asked Judge Cohviser what his
25 preference was as well.
DOS
S
Plea
All sides agree that I should do it since
2 I am the person who has been with the case for the
3 past yea:s.
4 Although Judge Conviser will be trying
toe case, he is going to need some time to get up
6 to speed.
-7 It Made Move sense from a practical and
8 administrative point of view for me dc that. 1
9
said I would he willing to do that.
10
I recognize that there Was interest in
11 this case from the media, from the family, from the
12 civil attorneys.
13 r_don't know.how any of-chem will reaet- —
14 to this or not. • It's really at this point I don't
15 think something that should really enter into my
16 consideration.
17 . Obviously at sentence I'm required to .
18 hear from the victim's family and will, of course,
19 If they want to be heard.
20 I assume that is something the district
.21 attorney takes care of when they deal with the
2? family in this case.
23 In any event between me and Judge'
24 Conviser it was decided that I would do the plea,
25 and that's why I'm doing it and for no other
DOM
Plea.
2 reason.
2 So, what I understand is that there is an
3 agreement that's in effect, and I have just been
4 presented with a copy of it.
5 its been signed by Mr. Varganyi the
6 defendant, by Mr. Brief as his attorney and by Miss
7 Dicke/ on behalf of the New York County District
ALLerneyYs Office and it's dated today. I will go
9 along with the plea agreement.
10 Me. Brief had'asked me it the nople
11 offeted a plea to criminally negligent homicide,
12. which. was a lesser Charge in this case, and
..recommeneled-;ultistateira-ton-i-ncarcera tory sent an-Ce
.14 whether I would go along with that.
/5 I said if it is the People's position
16 that based on all the factors they need to consider
17e that this-'is an appropriate sentence, ye, I would
, 16 impose anon-jail 'sentence if that was the
./9 agreement, of both parties following the coMpletion,
20 of this' agreement. •
21 '. I had not understood that there was
22 .cooperation. involved, but if there is then there
and if .f. lie-Peop,le. recommend that then, yes, iv
24 • .
will cettain4y impose a—pon"-lail sentenCe- ,
2A . 44/4. ORIEFt Thank you, Your ftonor. -• .
DOm
Plea
1 THE COURT: Okay. So, is there now an
application then for Mr. Varganyi tc withdraw his
3 plea of not guilty and to plead gui:ty in turn to
4 criminally negligent homicide?
5 MR. BRIEF: I have discussed very
significant issues involved in the defense of this
7 case and the defense that Mr. Varganyi has
asserted.
He after extensive consultation with both
10 myself and his family in particular has asked me on
11 his behalf to withdraw his plea of not guilty and
12 enter a plea of guilty in accordance with the plea
agreement.
14 THE-COURT: This case has been pending in
-15 my part for close to two years. This is a 20013
.16 incident. That I know.
17 A lot has been said about this case. I
18 know everybody's been apprised of my thoughts on
19 both the grand jury minutes, which I found to be
sufficient, and as we have always mentioned perhaps —
21 the difficulties in proving certain aspects of this
22 before the 'trier of fact, not that it. couldn't be '
23 proved but that this like many other cases before
24 me is a triable case.
28 There are obvious Tisks involvfick The
obm
B
Plea
1 top charge is a Class D Felony C Felony.
2 Excuse me.
3 It's a C Felony Manslaughter in the
4 Second Deg lee, which carries, of course, a state
. 5 prison sentence. of up to fifteen years.
6 On the other hand, if the defendant is
7 acquitted and the - burden of proof is beyond a
8 reasonable dc.vin, there would be no jail and no
9 felony convietior.
10 That has been discussed?
Li Hight?
12. Mn. BRLEF: Yes, Your Honor.
13 ....1HK 'COURT.: .4t.-Uarganyi, you-Itini* --•
14 discussed this with your lawyer f Assume.
15 TNE DEPENDANT: We talked about It, yes.
16 :THE cOORT: You can have a seat.'
17 You understood whit he's been saying?
IS . THE bEFENEANT: I understand.
19 THE COURT: You understand that at a
20 trial the People have to prove your quilt beyond a
21 reasonable deutt?
22 THE DEFENDANT: That .1 understand.
.23 THE COURT All, right. So, has anybody
24 forced you co plead guilty in any way?
25 THR DWFSINDANT: No.
DON
9
Plea
1 THE COURT: Has anybody promised you
2 anything in exchange for your plea of guilty?
3 THE DEFENDANT: No.
4 THE COURT: Now, there is a cooperation
5 agreement, a plea agreement here.
6 THE DEFENDANT: r have the copy.
7 THE COURT: Have you read the entire
6 agreement?
9 THE DEFENDANT: r read it through, yes.
10 TSE COURT: Did you understand it in
11 full?
12 'THE DEFENDANT: - I understand.
1.3 _THE .COURifl RUYA yolt4iscu55e4 the
14 agreement with your lawyer?
15 THE DEFENDANT: Yea, 1 did.
16 THE COURT: Dc you have any questions?
17 THE DEFENDANT: I did put a question and
18 we talked about it, yes.
19 THE COURT: They are all resolved now?
20 THE DEFENDANT: They arc resolved.
21 THE COURT: Are you satisfied with the
22 services of your attorney?
23 • THE DEFENDANT: Yes.
24 THE cooRT:-, od you- understand that you do
25 ,.not have to plead guilty, that you have a right to
EDM
10
Plea
1 a trial if you want a trial?
2 THE DEFENDANT: Yes, I understand.
3 THE COURT: At that trial it would be the
4 district attorney's burden as I mentioned to prove
5 your quilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
6 Do you understand that?
THE DEFENDANT: 1 understand.
THE COURT: Okay. So,.at a criminal
9 trial you have certain rights that you do no; hen,
10 that is you give up, when you plead geilty.
It's important for me to know that you
.understand these rights, so I have to mention them
- for the record.
The first right would be the right to a
trial by juty.
i Understand that as it presently stands
17 it may be your lawyer's intention to give up or the
18 co-defendant's intention to give up that right and
19 try the case before a judge; but if you wanted to
20 you have the right to have twelve jurors determine
21 whether you were guilty or not guilty, and their
22 verdict would haveto be unanimous. That means all
23 twelve would have to agree.
24 Do.you understand?
25 THE DEFENDANT: 7 understand.
DDth
11
12
13
14
15
16
II
Plea
1 THE COURT: Also at a criminal trial
2 everything happens in open court, so when the
3 witnesses testify your lawyers would have the
4 chance to ask them questions to try to prove that
5 they are not worthy of belief.
6 That's called cross-examination or
7 confrontation of witnesses. You see them testify.
a Your lawyer has a right to question them.
9 Do you understand that?.
10 THE DEFENDANT: Yes.
31 THE COURT: At a criminal trial you have
12. the right to testify if you want.
— -
You- cen- put an a—defense. You ca7a tS17-
14' witnesses, and you can testify if you want to, but
15 you don't have to. You have the tight to remain
16 silent.
11 So, at a criminal trial they have to
18 prove your quilt. beyond a reasonable doubt.
19 You can decide whether you testify or
. 20 don't testify. If you deterniine not to testify.
21 then you have that right.
You. have the right., to remain silent 4nd
23, 'not testify; and the People Still have to prove
H20 yOur.. guilt tfeyOed a reasonable doubt.
25 Db yop. understand tPat?,
DOM
12
Plea
1 THE DEFENDANT: Yes, I do, sir.
THE COURT: When you plead guilty you
3 admit yout guilt, so in a few minutes / 3M going to
put you under oath. You are actually going to be
al/ocuted.
6 Miss Hickey is going to read a set of
facts that 1 think you agreed to with your
attorney.
9
She is going to ask you whether you did
10
what is claimed: and in order to take the plea, you
11
have to admit that you did what they say you clic.
Do you understand that?
13
THE DEFgNDANT: Yes.
14 THE COURT: You give up the right to
15 remain silent in that regard.
'IG You also give up every other right you
. 13 have at a trail.
18 A conviction by plea of guilty is the
' 19 same as a conviction by verdict after trial in that
20 it goes on your record the same 'way.
21. The sentence might be different depending
22 on certain factors because this is an agreed upon.
23 plea,, but the fact of the conyiction, the fact gf
the felony conviction, is the same.
It still goes on your re-cord as a
DDM
13
- Plea
conviction for criminally negligent homicide as a
2 Class E Violent Felony.
3 Do you understand that?
4 THE DEFENDANT: .Yes.
5 THE COURT: Let me just say this.
6 I understand that you have consulted or.
7 your lawyer has coesulted with immigration
attorneys with respect to this plea becaose'there
9 ace circumstances under which e- plea to a felony
10 can result in serioUs immigration .consequences for
11 somebody who is net a citizen.
12 1 know 'what. your citizerishiP status is.
.44. -"PI" imequit7e WIP—A0—ssY. it on:the...taco:4,
14 never do,
15 Have you dticussed the iMmigration
16 consequences or tkis.plea or the potential
17- consequences with your attorney) -
THE DEFENDANT: Yes,. I did.
19 THE COURT: You have consulted people'
20 • about, that?
.21 • MR. DRIEp: if I just - ralY for the record
Mr. vargan0 °ailed two separate: and distinct
. 23 immigration attorneys David. GlaA4Man and Alexandra
- Tsit)in:*
-25 • • dIreed that a qui.lty..alea to
DpK.
14
Plea
1 criminally negligent homicide should not effect his
2 legal status as an alien. He's been in Amerind: for
3 thirty years.
4 . THE COURT: Strange things have happened
5 in Immigration Coert.
6 You cinderstand that if there are
immigration consequences that you did not.
6 anticipate I will not let you take back your plea?
9 THE-DEFENDANT: I understand.
10 THE COURT: Okay. Is there a discussion
/1 about his right to appeal in here?
12 Is there any agreement?
13 ,There is .a waiVer.
14 MR. BRIEF: Paragraph three, Your Honor.
15 . MS. HICKEY: Paragraph three.
16 THE COURT: There are certain rights of
17 appeal that are non-waivabie just so we all know.
16 MS. HICKEY: Yes.
19 THE COURT: So, what this says is that
20 you are giving up your right to the extent legally
21 permissible to appeal your conviction to any higher
22 court.
23 :Do you undeistand what that means?
24 :rue Di7S4NDAOT: I -understand.
. 25 TRE COURfl Ordinarily when you plead
- DOR
15
Plea
1 guilty your right to appeal your conviction
2 survives the plea. You give up your right to
3 trial.
4 . However, as a condition of entering into
this agreement you give up your right to appeal
6 except for those matters that you are not permitted
to waive.
. 8 Have you discussed that with your lawyer? •
9 ThE DEFENDANT: Yes, I did.
10 THE COURT: usually the waiver sets forth
11 chose specific non-wadvable issues, but 1 guess you
12 discussed this.
13 -Okay.- Kr Vaegabyk, ple&se.rtaise:your • --
14 right hand.
15 (Whereupon the defendant was sworn.)
16 THE COURT: Miss Hickey is going cc read
r17 . the allocution, which 1 think is what the agreement
18. is.
19 . MS. HICKEY': 61r. Vsrganyi, you will
20 allocute under oath that you engaged in the
21 Eolloaing criminal conduct end failed to perceive
22 substantial and unjustifiable risk of death in
23 doing so! .
a."1 . that you were an employee of New York
25 Crane- and J.F. Lomma Incorporated whose duties
DDM
e
16
Flea
1 included the service and maintenance of James
2 Lomma's Kodiak Cranes.
3 Kodiak was the manufacturer of a
particular make of tower crane that Lomma
5 Incorporated owned an, Tented to contractors for
use on construction sites many of which were in New
7 York City.
V You also supervised others in the service
9 and maintenance of those cranes.
10 gleginning in May o/ 2007 it became
1! apparent that those cranes required the repair of
12 their turntables by the replacement of a component
part- 41-beari44-..
14 Even though at least two companies
15 located in the United States could provide the
16 replacement biarings that the cranes needed, one of
17 which was the original manufacturer of the original
18 bearings inthe cranes, Mr. Loma was dissatisfied
19 with the time it would take those companies to
20. : deliver tke bearings. e
21 tou understood, that your supervisors did
27r not want ro.wait for the S.S. cdmpanies to replace
bearirign; and in late June or July 'of- -2007 and
with LoMma cs.knowledgep• Oermissiovi ancrauthority
yo4 located a bearing. manUfActistrer cailtd gt8,that
DDM
17.
Plea
1 was located in the People's Republic of China.
2 Lomma lever asked you any questions about
3 this company and never required you to make any
4 inquiries regarding that company's reputation or
5 the quality -ef Lts work nor did Lemma require you
6 to locate and speak to other customers of RTR or to
7 independently verify any of the claims on the RTR
8 webslte.
.9 You communicated via email with the sales
10 manager of that company and sent specifications and
12 drawings to the RTR sales manager to be used for
12 the manufacture of the bearing Lomma Incorporated
. wished to purchase.
14 At no time did you have an engineering
15 degree or any training in the design or manufacture
16 -of such equipment 'fact that Lomma knew.
17 Lomma never asked you what you were
18 providing to RTR for use in the design of the
19 bearing nor lid LOMM4 obtajn assistance or
20 oversight of a professional engineer or any other
21 person competent to design as complex a piece of
22 equipment as a bearing.
23 The specifications you sent to -the sales
24 'manager of RIR celled for weldj.ng to be done by the
25 manufacturer -et the bearing..
011M
18
Plea
1 The sales manager of RTR wrote to you in
2 an email warning you that the welding should be
3 done by New York Crane or a company other than RTR.
.4 You should not have accepted her
. 5 subsequent agreement to perform the welding.
6 During.the time that yo0 were arranging
7 for the manufacture and purchase of this bearing
8 Lomma never advised you about the requirements that
9 the New York City Department of Buildings had
10 communicated to him before such a bearing would be
11 allowed to be'placed in a crane that was operating
12 on a eonstrUccion site in New -York City.
13 leeembei.of 2217 the beari.414..that gou
14 . -ordered from RTR arrived after you had procured a
15 final drawing from RTR for the designed bearing at
16 the request of your supervisors for review. -
17 Neither - you or as 'far as you know Lorna
12 or anyone else wfio worked for Lomma arranged to
19 have the weld that was performed by RTR tested to. -
•
20 insure its quality.
21 in April or• 2008 this beering•was placed
. 22 . flito a Kodia.6 Cfeho that was being used Oh a
:.23 • construction'sitj on the .corner. Of 91st. Street and , . . . ,First Avenue •ih.New York•County.• .
• . • . , . _
25 . kat.st in April of 200ra second bearingi .. .
atm
19
. Plea
1 that you had ordered from RTR arrived. This second
2 bearing contained a weld that was overtly flawed.
3 You informed RTR about the condition of
4 this weld, and RTR agreed to pay for its repair an
5 arrangement about which Lomma knew.
6 Despite the visible inadequancy of the
7 weld on the second bearing RTR produced neither you
8 nor Lomma made any attempt to verify the adequacy
9 of the weld on the first bearing, which remained in
10 the turntable of the Kodiak Crane on the
11 construction site on 91st Street.
12 On May 30th, 2008, the manufacturer's
13 xeld
on the lirst.bearing_received from -RTR:broke
14 apart, and the upper portion of the crane fell to
15 the ground killing two men Donald Leo and Ramadan
16 Kurtash (phon).
17 Are those facts true?
18 THE DEFENDANT: It's true.
19 THE COURT: Okay. SO, let's enter the
20 guilty plea.
21 COURT CLORK: Tibor varganyi, do you now
22 withdraw your previously entered plea of not guilty
.23 and do you now plead guilty to the crime of
24 Criminally negligent homicide to cover and satisfy
25 '7Ihdictment 852 of 2010?
20
Plea
1 Is chat your plea, nir?
2 THE DEFENDANT: I'm guilty sir, yes.
3 I plead guilcy.
THE COURT: Okay. So, what do you want
5 to do?
6 MR. BRIEF: Can we set a January
sentencing late?
THE COURT: Sure.
9 January 18th.
10 MS. HICKEY: That's fine. .
11 THE COURT: How's the 25th?
11 MR. BRIEF: The 25th would be better.
)1. THE COURT: January 25.th.
14 MR. BRIEF: I have one quick question
15 about probation.
.16 Does Mr. Varganyi have to make an
17 appointment to. see probation now?
18 THE COURT: Why don't we set a date.
19 The problem is the probation report and
20 the sentence date has to be six weeks after the
21 order.
22 We can have him come in January 25th, and
23 we can sena him for .a probation report after that.
24 MR. BRIEF: All right.
25 THE COURT: Tuesday the 25th if that's
ODM
..•
DIANA DAVIE -Halle Sr. Court Reporter
21
Plea
1 okay we wtli pul, it down for sentence, and then we
wtii adjourn It.
It won't be for sentence. It will be to
order the probation report.
R. BRIEF: Thank you, Your Honor.
MS. HIM?: Thank you.
.7 -0-
8 CERTIFIED 'CC: BE A TRUE AND ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION OF TUE MINUTES TAKEN SY ME.
9
10
11
12
14
15
16
11
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
DDM
..