Upload
adbimpactevaluation
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
1/20
T^dfgk Egtkma}lgk Bdac}b Dqtl}| akm Elkakflac ^xg}df}lgklk Avla xg`df}^xdvdk}dm h|0 Acdcl M+ Oxae}
Avlak Mdudcg~jdk} Hako Fgkedxdkfd lk Lj~af} Duacta}lgk
Jaklca# @tc| 11# 8>18
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
2/20
Gkd ge jalk }bxtv}v ge }bd MGBv Oactvtiaki akioacaba}ak "Tkludxvac Bdac}bFgudxaid, lv }g ~xgulmd elkakflac xlvo ~xg}df}lgk}bxgtib }bd dkxgccjdk} ge ahgt} 4jlcclgk ~ggxdv} eajlcldv yl}b ^blcBdac}b }gyaxmv tkludxvac bdac}b lkvtxakfdfgudxaid h| 8>14 Jalk udblfcd lv }bd V~gkvgxdm xgixaj ybdxd ka}lgkac akm cgfac igudxkjdk}
vbaxd lk ~xdjltjv egx dkxgccdm ~ggx eajlcldv# akm ca}dc| }bd KI fgudxlki }bd~xdjltj egx }bd ~ggxdv} qtlk}lcd Ahgt} 6=+89$ ~dxfdk} ge }g}ac jdjhdxv axd V^ jdjhdxv "av ge Mdf+ 8>11,
Bgydudx# fgudxaid ge }bd kdax~ggx akm lkegxjac vdf}gx lv v}lcc cgy Gkc| ahgt} 4844 ~dxfdk} ge }bd lkegxjac vdf}gx ybg axd cdvv dmtfa}dm# clud lk
txhak axdav akm baud cgy lkfgjdv# axd fgudxdm "Qtljhg# d} ac# 8>11, Exgj 1+99 jlcclgk lk 8>>6 }g 6+11# }bd ktjhdx ge L^^
jdjhdxv affgtk} egx axgtkm gkc| 12$ ge }bd }g}ac ^blcBdac}b jdjhdxv+ Udblfcd egx BLF fgudxaid lv }bd Lkmlulmtacc| a|lki ^xgixaj Ugctk}ax| dkxgccjdk} yl}b }bd etcc ~xdjltj vbgtcmdxdm h| }bd jdjhdx+
Elkakflac xlvo ~xg}df}lgk v}lcc a ~xghcdj av }bd kdax ~ggx axd dqtacc| utckdxahcd }gbdac}b vbgfov Dr~dxldkfd ge bdac}b vbgfov vclib}c| blibdx egx }bd vdfgkm lkfgjd qtlk}lcd
"8=+6$, fgj~axdm yl}b }bd elxv} "8>+6$, "Havdclkd BDE^A Bgtvdbgcm Vtxud|,
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
3/20
6^ V}tm| ak akac|vlv ge }bd deedf} ge }bd ^blcBdac}b ^xd~alm ^xdjltj"6^, fdx}lelfa}d gk }bd dkxgccjdk}# bdac}b faxd t}lclpa}lgk akm bdac}b faxd~a|jdk}v ge }bgvd dclilhcd }g hd Lkmlulmtacc| ^a|lki ^xgixaj "L^^,jdjhdxv ybg axd xakmgjc| vdcdf}dm }g xdfdlud }bd fdx}lelfa}dv+
^ax}kdxvbl~ hd}yddk blcBdac}b akm T^dfgk Egtkma}lgk }g ~xgulmd ~gclf|lk~t}v }g lj~xgud }bd fgudxaid# vtv}alkahlcl}|# akm elkakflac ~xg}df}lgkav~df}v ge }bd Lkmlulmtacc| ^a|lki ^xgixaj+
^ax} ge }bd Bdac}b Dqtl}| akm Elkakflac ^xg}df}lgk lk Avla "BDE^A,^xg`df}# a egtx|dax# DTetkmdm xdvdaxfb ~xg`df} ge a fgkvgx}ltj ge }dkxdvdaxfb lkv}l}t}lgkv lk Dav} Avla akm Dtxg~d+
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
4/20
Ylcc a xdmtf}lgk lk }bd elkakflac akmlkegxja}lgkac haxxldxv lkfxdavd }bd ugctk}ax|
dkxgccjdk} ge }bd lkegxjac vdf}gx lk }bd L^^7
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
5/20
8=6 jtklfl~acl}ldv ka}lgkylmd "drfd~} 8 xdilgkv, xakmgjc|avvlikdm }g hd }xda}jdk} akm fgk}xgc vl}dv
8 bgtvdbgcmv : 888> lk }xda}jdk} vl}dv / 96> lk fgk}xgcvl}dv
]xda}jdk} vl}dv lkfctmd 1129 yl}b ^blcBdac}b "dr~akmdmvaj~cd egx utckdxahlcl}| jgmtcd,
Fctv}dx : haxakia| gx ~xdflkf} "4 1> bgtvdbgcmv,
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
6/20
]XDA]JDK] AKM
FGK]XGC VL]DV]XDA]JDK] AKM FGK]XGCTKL]V
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
7/20
Fgk}xgc vl}dv ]xda}jdk} vl}dv ]dv} ge
~xg~gx}lgkv
"~uactd,
]g}ac ^dxfdk} ]g}ac ^dxfdk}
Ylcclkikdvv }g ~a|
Hdcgy 4> ~dvgv
4> ~dvgv akm ahgud
524
5+>>
>
8>69
9+>>
>
>+8>6
>+8>6
Bgtvdbgcm lkfgjd
Elxv} qtlk}lcdVdfgkm qtlk}lcd
]blxm qtlk}lcd
Egtx}b qtlk}lcd
Ele}b qtlk}lcd
986
8>+4>88+4>
1
12+2>
81+>88>+>8
12+9>
8>+5>
8>+=>
>+24+12>
>+=4=
>+199
>+645
VABV "bgtvdbgcm bdam,
^ggxEalx
Iggm
Udx| iggm
Drfdccdk}
96>
8+9>1>+6
=>+2
89+6
12+
8+2>1>+4
6+=
>+22+2+498
>+998
>+6 69+6> 96> 6=+ >+84> / Lkegxja}lgk Ol} / VJV
xdjlkmdxv
Geedxdm }g acc dclilhcd a} havdclkd "Edhxtax| 8>11,0
Gxlilkac }aodt~ ~dxlgm0 Jaxfb 8>11 }g Edhxtax|8>18
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
11/20
1>> ~dxfdk}vthvlm| egx }bd elxv}5 jgk}bv gefgudxaid# gx
4> ~dxfdk} vthvlm|egx 18 jgk}bv gefgudxaid
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
12/20
Yba} ylcc ba~~dk le j| fblcm bav
blv ea}bdxv vtxkajd ht} yd axd
kg} jaxxldm7 Fak bd v}lcc hd j|
md~dkmdk}7
Vdkmdx exgj Vgt}b Fg}aha}g
Iggm aj xdiaxmlki |gtx ~blcbdac}b ~xgjg#yd vbgydm l} }g }bd mtjaitd}d ~blcbdac}bgef # }bd| valm }bd| ylcc elxv} fbdo hdfatvd}bd| mgk} okgy ahgt} }bd t~dfgk bde~a}daj }ba} mlm a vtxud| bdxd++}bd| yak} }gfbdfo yl}b }bd bdam geelfd elxv} le l} lv }xtd+
Vdkmdx exgj Kdixgv Gxldk}ac
L baudk} elcdm }bd ~blcbdac}begxj |d} hdfatvd yd mgk}
baud jgkd| xlib} kgy+
Ja|hd lk @tkd+
Vdkmdx exgj Cd|}d
Yb| mlmk} |gt xd~c|
daxcldx# }bd hga} bav~avvdm akm L kg cgkidx
baud a xlmd iglki }g }gyk+
Vdkmdx exgj Xlpac
Go yd ylcc `tv} elklvbbaxudv}lki xlfd akm yd ylccxdilv}dx+ ]bakov egx }bdxdjlkmdx+
Vdkmdx exgj Qtdpgk
"Kajd Fgkfdacdm, acxdam|
Dkxgccdm |dv}dxma| a} }bd ^blBdac}b
FALK]A HXAKFB#a~xlc 82 tvlki |gtx
T^DFGK BDE^A XG@DF]+ ]bako |gt
udx| jtfb egx }bd eaugx |gt iaud jd }g
hdfgjd a jdjhdx ge ^BlBdac}b+
Vdkmdx exgj Xlpac
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
13/20
Lk amml}lgk ^xdaffgj~clvbdm blcBdac}b Jdjhdxvbl~
Xdfgxm Egxjv "^JXE, / ^lfot~ ge Egxjv h|dktjdxa}gxv
Geedxdm }g xakmgjc| vdcdf}dm tkdkxgccdm ugtfbdx
xdfl~ldk}v av ge Mdfdjhdx 8>11
^dxlgm ge }aodt~ dr}dkmdm }g Edhxtax| }g Jaxfb8>18 }g acc }xda}jdk} bgtvdbgcmv
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
14/20
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
15/20
8# }g}ac vaj~cd bgtvdbgcmv
]xda}jdk} vl}dv : 888> Fgk}xgc vl}dv :
96>
Edh*
A~x
8>11
EdhMdf
8>11
Edh *
Jax
8>18
dclilhcd : 1>69 { dclilhcd : 1126
affd~} : 5 mdfclkd : 161
{ dkxgccdm : 26= dkxgccdm : 98
]aod t~ :9+ Ja| 8>18,
Dkxgccdm"L^^, : 2
X]V
: 6
Gudxacc }aod t~ : 6>+=$
"1 Edh*6> Ja| 8>18,
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
16/20
Lk}dk}}g}xda} 1 Vaj~cd 0 Acc dclilhcd bgtvdbgcmv lk hg}b }xda}jdk}
akm fgk}xgc vl}dv
Dl : > / 1]/R /l ] : }xda}jdk} vl}d "geedxdm ugtfbdxv,
Lk}dk}}g}xda} 1
Vthvaj~cd 0 Acc tkdkxgccdm# ugtfbdx xdfl~ldk}vDl :> / 1^/R /l
^ : ~lfot~ bgtvdbgcmv "vdk} elccdm gt} ^JXEv akm~lfodm t~ h| dktjdxa}gxv,
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
17/20
]ahcd 1+ Jaxilkac deedf}v ge ~xghl} dv}lja}lgk# Acc dclilhcdv
JaxilkacDeedf}
V}m+ Dxx+ ~uactd
]xda}jdk} >+8+>69 >+>>>***
Aud+ ~dx fa~l}a bgtvdbgcm dr~dkml}txdv 1+9 =+8D>9 >+546
Bdam lv edjacd >+>86 >+>2> >+995
Aid ge bdam >+>>1 >+>>1 >+16=
Bdam bav vgjd fgccdid dmtfa}lgk >+>=5 >+>64 >+12+>82 >+>65 >+=68
Bgtvdbgcm hdcgkiv }g a kgkxdclilgtv ixgt~ >+>69 >+>6= >+826
GEY lk }bd bgtvdbgcm >+>46 >+>=+894
Bdam bav ~ggx bdac}b >+>86 >+>96 >+948
Dr~dxldkfdm bdac}b vbgfo lk cav} }bxdd |daxv >+>62 >+>88 >+>24*
Ktjhdx ge fblcmxdk hdcgy 81 >+>>9 >+>>5 >+86+>4= >+>51 >+65+>=6 >+>85 >+>+>>6 >+>88 >+
Txhak >+>15 >+>84 >+418
Ctpgk drfctmlki KFX >+>11 >+>6> >+91>
Ulva|av >+>=5 >+>64 >+1+>6> >+>=> >+===
Ghvdxua}lgkv 18=8^vdtmg Xvqtaxdm >+>
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
18/20
]ahcd 8+ Jaxilkac deedf}v ge ~xghl} dv}lja}lgk# ammdm lk}dxudk}lgk vaj~cd
JaxilkacDeedf}
V}m+ Dxx+ ~uactd
Yl}b ~lfot~ >+85> >+>84 >+>>>***
Aud+ ~dx fa~l}a bgtvdbgcm dr~dkml}txd 8+6D>9 =+9D>9 >+565
Bdam lv edjacd >+>>5 >+>>8 >+>>1 >+>4+>>= >+>4> >++>1= >+>=4 >+951
Bgtvdbgcm hdcgkiv }g a kgkxdclilgtv ixgt~ >+>19 >+>=8 >+5+>6+>91 >+42>
Bdam bav ~ggx bdac}b >+>>= >+>++>1> >+>82 >+915
Ktjhdx ge fblcmxdk hdcgy 81 >+>>+>>2 >+8=9
Bgtvdbgcm bav g}bdx lkvtxakfd >+1>8 >+>26 >+81+>88 >+>68 >+=+>68 >+>89 >+8=8
Txhak >+>15 >+>61 >+5>=
Ctpgk drfctmlki KFX >+>>9 >+>69 >+2=1
Ulva|av >+>+>=4 >+>=1**
Jlkmakag >+1>5 >+>48 >+>=8**
Ghvdxua}lgkv 282^vdtmg Xvqtaxdm >+162
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
19/20
8+44$
86+5=$
>$
4$
1>$
14$
8>$
84$
6>$
64$
Fgk}xgc ]xda}jdk}
Aud+ ~xdmlf}dm ~xghahlcl}| ge
dkxgccjdk}# etcc vaj~cd
Fgk}xgc ]xda}jdk}
9+55$
6=+66$
>$
4$
1>$
14$
8>$
84$
6>$
64$
Yl}bgt} ~lfot~ Yl}b ~lfot~
Aud+ ~xdmlf}dm ~xghahlcl}| ge
dkxgccjdk}# B^ vaj~cd
Yl}bgt} ~lfot~ Yl}b ~lfot~
7/31/2019 3_Preliminary Results From the 3P Study (a. Kraft)
20/20
^xdcljlkax| akac|vlv lkmlfa}dv }ba} }bd 6^ }xda}jdk} fgkvlv}lki ge }bd~xd~alm ugtfbdxv# lkegxja}lgk ja}dxlacv akm ~lfot~ ge egxjv lvavvgfla}dm yl}b a blibdx clodclbggm }g dkxgc lk }bd ^blcBdac}b L^ + ]blv lkmlfa}dv }ba} ~xdjltj vthvlmldv fgtcm gudxfgjd vgjd ge }bd
elkakflac haxxldxv }g dkxgcjdk} akm fgudxaid ge }bgvd dclilhcd }g hd lk }bdL ^+
^lfot~ ge }bd affgj~clvbdm egxjv lv avvgfla}dm yl}b blibdxdkxgccjdk} lk }bd L^^+ ]blv lj~cldv }ba} avlmd exgj xdmtflki }bd elkakflac haxxldxv# xdmtflki }bd
}xakvaf}lgkac haxxldxv ja| xdvtc} lk blibdx fgudxaid ge }bd lkegxjac vdf}gxlk }bd L^^+
Bgydudx# geedxlki }bd ugtfbdxv acgkd lv jgxd clodc| }g dkfgtxaiddkxgcjdk} ge blibdx xlvo vdijdk} ge }bd lkegxjac vdf}gx+ Amml}lgkaclk}dxudk}lgkv ja| hd kdfdvvax| }g a}}xaf} }bd bdac}bldx vdijdk}+