28.10.15 critical appraisal.ppt

8/18/2019 28.10.15 critical appraisal.ppt

1/21

CRITICAL APPRAISAL WORKSHEET

A format for examining journalarticles*

* !ase" on #e"ical $ournal of Australia %&&'(%) +,-&.&/0Presente" 12 3ic4 Heller5 Professor of Pu1lic Healt65 T6e 7ni8ersit2 of #anc6ester5 7K3ic49Heller:man9ac9u4 THE ;EWCASTLE

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]


2/21

Critical appraisal is the process of carefullyAnd systematically analyze the researc6


3/21

When should you Critically Appraise?@ Con"ucting literature re8ie=s for grant


4/21

What is critical

appraisal?

Critical a


5/21

Buestions to As4

@ W6at 4in" of re


6/21

Buestions to As4

@Is it of interest@W62 =as it "one@Ho= =as it "one@W6at 6as 1een foun"

@W6at are t6e im


7/21

Criticall2 A


8/21

%% items

@Can 2ou fin" t6is information in t6e


9/21

%% items

@ %9 W6at is t6e researc6 uestion@ '9 W6at is t6e stu"2 t2


10/21

%9W6at is t6e researc6 uestion

@ (Is the way this was done a problem?)

Is it concerne" =it6 t6e im


11/21

'9 W6at is t6e stu"2 t2


12/21

,9 W6at are t6e outcome factors

an" 6o= are t6e2 measure"@ (Is the way this was done a problem?)

a0 are all rele8ant outcomes assesse"

10 is t6ere measurement error

@ (Does this problem threaten the validity of the study?)

a0 6o= im


13/21

/9 W6at are t6e stu"2 factors an"

6o= are t6e measure"@ (Is the way this was done a problem?)

Is t6ere measurement error

@ (Does this problem threaten the validity of the study?)

Is measurement error an im


14/21

)9 W6at im


15/21

F9 W6at are t6e sam


16/21

9 Buestions of internal 8ali"it2


In an ex


17/21

-9 Are statistical tests consi"ere"

@ (Is the way this was done a problem?) Were t6e tests a


18/21

&9 Are t6e results

clinicall2Gsociall2 significant@ (Is the way this was done a problem?)

Was t6e sam


19/21

% 9 Are et6ical issues consi"ere"


3oes t6e


20/21

%%9 W6at conclusions "i" t6e aut6ors

reac6 a1out t6e stu"2 uestion@ (Is the way this was done a problem?)

3o t6e results a


21/21

@Eac6 stu"ent =ill 1e as4e" to fin"% article from #J#I journal

@#a4e a a

Documents

28.10.15 critical appraisal.ppt