Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2017IRISDataSummit September21,2017AnnArbor,MIEXECUTIVESUMMARYThankyoutothosewhoattendedthe2017IRISDataSummit.Wefoundthediscussionsveryusefulandwritenowtofollowupontherichthreadsofconversation.TurnoutattheSummitwasexcellent:atotalof57representativesfromIRIS,theU.S.CensusBureau,21IRISmemberuniversities,4prospectivememberuniversities,andtheAssociationofPublicLandGrantUniversities(APLU)attendedtheevent.Attendanceatthisyear’sDataSummitincreasedbyaboutathirdoverlastyear’sevent,andrepresenteda49%increaseoverthefirsteventheldin2015.About1in5attendeesatthisyear’seventattendedlastyear’sSummitinWashington,DC.Themeetingagendaandlistofparticipantsareappendedtotheendofthissummary.Presentationslidesarealsoattached.Threebroadthemesemergedfromtheday’sdiscussions:Communicationiscritical.ThepowerofIRISreportsisdiminishediftheyaren’tcommunicatedeffectivelytotherightstakeholders.Athoughtfulgovernancestructurethatincludesadiversesetofrepresentativesfacilitatesgoodcommunication.Ensuringthatreportsreachthepeoplewhocanusethemtotellauniversity’sstorydemandsidentificationofkeyallies,bothinternallyandexternally.Contextualizingthedataisessential.Simplypostingreportsonlineoraspartofalargercompendiumofinstitutionaldatawithnoinformationtohelpputthemincontextisperhapsworsethanprovidingnoinformationatall.AsuniversitiestakestepstosharetheirIRISreportswithkeyconstituents,theymustthinkcarefullyabouthowtoframethemsotheycanbestbeunderstoodincontext.Leveragingthepowerofaggregationshouldbeapriority.IRIShasstrongrelationshipswithanumberofhighereducationassociationssuchastheAssociationofAmericanUniversities(AAU)andtheAssociationofPublicandLand-grantUniversities(APLU),butshouldcontinuetoexpandtoorganizationsliketheCouncilonGovernmentRelations(COGR).Inaddition,IRISshouldexplorewaystocreateaggregatereportsbyconferenceand/orregion.Actionitemsandnextsteps:• Dataupdates:
o IRISwilldevelopamatchreportforthevendorreportthatshowsthedollarsnotmatchedagainsttotaldollarsspent.
o IRISwillcontinuetodevelopitsobjectcodeclassificationsystemtobettercaptureinternalspending.Forthosememberswishingtosubmitnon-federaldata,IRISwillprovideguidance.
o IRISwillpursuetheidentificationandincorporationofnewdatasetsandtoolsthatmightprovidefruitfulintermsofinterestinglinkages,doingsoinwaysthatrequirerelativelylittleworkonthepartofmembers.
o Possibleaggregatereportswillbedeveloped,suchasAAUinstitutions,state/regionlevelreports,etc.
• Toolsandsupport:o IRISwillrefineguidanceformembergovernancetoenhancecommunicationandtobetter
leveragedataproducts.o IRISwillworktomakeTAGmeetingdiscussionsmoretransparentbymakingmeeting
summariesavailableintheIRISportal.• Overall:
o MembershipinIRISisgrowingandthismustcontinue;IRISleadershipwillcontinuetopursuenewmemberstoenablethekindofaggregationthatwillpermitmorepowerfulreporting.
o FutureDataSummitsshouldspantwodaysandshouldincludetimefornetworkingandinteractionamongattendees.
Pleasetakeafewmomentstocompleteabriefevaluationofthiseventtohelpusimprovefuturesummits:IRIS Data Summit EvaluationMarkyourcalendar!Savethedateforthe2018DataSummittobeheldinAnnArbor:October15-16,2018Lookformoredetailstocome.Thankyouandwehopetoseeyounextyear!TheIRISTeam
UniversityofMichiganInstituteforSocialResearch426ThompsonStreet,Room1430*
Agenda8:30-9:00 Continentalbreakfast
BuffetinRoom1450
9:00-9:15 Welcome DavidLam,Director,UniversityofMichiganInstituteforSocialResearch(ISR)
9:15-9:45 KeynoteAddressAliceMeadows,DirectorofCommunityEngagement&Support,ORCID
EnterOnce,ReuseOften:MakingORCID’sVisionaRealityforResearchersandTheirInstitutions
ORCID'svisionisaworldwhereallwhoparticipateinresearch,scholarship,andinnovationareuniquelyidentifiedandconnectedwiththeirworksandaffiliationsacrossdisciplines,borders,andtime.Thisvisionisstartingtobecomeareality.Forexample,researcherscanalreadychoosetoautomaticallyandreliablyconnecttheirpublicationstotheirORCIDrecord.Animportantnextstepisforinstitutionstoasserttheirresearchers'affiliations,enablingthisauthoritativeinformationtobeenteredonceandreusedoften-inresearchinformationmanagementandprofilesystems,infundingapplications,duringthemanuscriptsubmissionprocess,andmore.Doingsowillbenefittheresearchers,theirinstitutions,andthewiderresearchcommunity.
9:45-10:45 Session1:SendingDatatoIRIS
AdministrativedatasenttoIRISbyitsmemberuniversitiescanposeuniquechallenges.TomaketheIRISdataproductionmostefficient,thereissometimesconsiderableworkthatisneeded.Thissessionoffersthreepresentationsthatwillfocusonmethodstoenhancespendingdata,allfocusedonqualityassuranceanddataenhancements.
EnhancingVendorReportsPresenters:AmyButchart&RobTruex,IRIS
TheprocessIRISusestotransformyouradministrativedataintothevendorreportsyouseecanseemopaque.Thispresentationshowsyou'howthesausageismade'andhowelementsofthedatayouprovidetoIRISareimportanttoproducingthereportmetricsyousee.
SendingNon-FederalSpendingData:CapturingInternalUniversitySpendingPresenters:ToddWoodman,UniversityofArizona
Theinclusionofnon-federalspendingdatacanenhancethecurrentreportsbyshowingallresearchdollarsversesfederaldollarsonly.Capturinginternaluniversityspendingwillprovideadditionalmetrics,moreactionablereporting,andidentifiableareasofopportunity.Thispresentationshowsyousomeofthechallengesofdatacollection,theimpactofincludingnon-federalspending,andpotentialnewdatapoints.
ObjectCodeClassification:SomeImplicationsPresenter:JasonOwen-Smith,IRIS
ManyIRISmemberinstitutionsshareobjectcodes,whichhavethepotentialtoallowustocharacterizethetypesofgoodsandservicespurchasedfromvendorsandsubcontractorsaswellastheirsources.Wehavebegunworkingtocreateahighlevelcategorizationscheme(similartotheoccupationalclassificationswecurrentlyuse)thatwillinformfuturereporting.Thispresentationdescribesthoseefforts,theirpotentialuses,andpresentsadraftobjectcodeclassificationforyourfeedback.
10:45-11:00Break
11:00-12:00Session2:UsingReportsIRISProduces(concurrentsessions)
MakingtheMostoftheIRISMembershipPanelists:KristinaKo,UniversityofMichiganMissyPeloso,UniversityofPennsylvaniaNickWigginton,UniversityofMichigan
UniversitieshaveavarietyofreasonsforwantingtojoinIRIS,andtheyeachfaceuniquechallengesinprovidingthedataandinusingthereportstheygetbackfromIRIS.Forexample,someinstitutionsjoinbecausetheyhavebeendirectedtodosobyapresident,andtheindividualstaskedwithmakingithappenmaynotbequitesurehowtobestutilizetheIRISresource.Thispanelwillfocusonwaystoachievegreaterinstitutionalbuy-in,enhancedataproducts,andplayaroleinmakingIRISatrulynationalresourceforuniversities.Weaimtoaddressatleastsomeofthefollowingquestions:
• Howdoyougetpeopleexcited/interestedinthisworkwhohaven’tbeenpartofthedecision-makingprocess?
• Whatcanyoudoifyourinstitutiondoesn’twanttosubmitallthedata?HowcanyouworkwithyourIRofficeandotherstoidentifyotherdatapointsthatmightbeusefultoinclude?
• HowcanyouworkwithIRIStoshapeusefulreportsthatfittheneedsofyourcampus?
• IstherearoleforIRISinproducingnationallyaggregateddatatosupportuniversityresearchadvocacy?
NavigatingtheIRISPortal(Room1440)Presenter:KevinBjorne,IRIS
ThissessionwillcenteronhowtoworkmosteffectivelyintheIRISportal,seekinginputfromparticipantsindesign,usability,anddesiredfeatures.
12:00-1:30 WorkingLunchBuffetinRoom1450
TAGReport(KevinBjorne,IRIS;TAGmembers)
PanelDiscussion:EngagingStakeholderswithIRISDataProductsPanelists:KimGriffin,NorthwesternUniversityJedMarsh,PrincetonUniversityMarvinParnes,UniversityofMichigan
IRISdataproductscanserveasavehicleforestablishingandstrengtheningnetworksandalliances,bothwithcampusstakeholdersandwithexternalconstituents.Throughthesenetworks,theIRISdatacanbecomemoreusefulandcontextualized.Developingtacticsforleveragingtheserelationshipscanbechallenging,however.PanelistswilldiscussexamplesofcreativestrategiesforengagingwithstakeholdersaroundIRISdataproducts,includingthosewhomightnotimmediatelycometomind,alongwiththebarriersthatmayexist.Weaimtoaddressatleastsomeofthefollowingquestions:
• HowdoyoudevelopasharedvaluepropositionwithothersoncampusaroundIRISdata?
• Howcanyoucommunicatesuchpropositionseffectivelywithothers?• Howcanyouidentifywhoneedstobeinvolved?
1:30-2:30 Session3:ConceptsforFutureReports&Products
IRISisalwaysseekingtodevelopnewwaystoprovidevaluetoitsmemberuniversities.SpecializedprojectsusingIRISdatamayevolveintospecializedproductsformembersthatcanhelpuniversitiestelltheirownstoriestotheirstakeholders.Today’sfinalsessionwillfocusonseveralspecialprojectsthatposeinterestingpossibilities.
FederalAdvisoryCommitteeAct(FACA)DatabaseExplorationandRecordLinkage
Presenter:NatsukoNicholls,IRIS
Thispresentationaddressesthesocialimpactofresearch,focusingonthewaythatscientificknowledgeistranslatedintosocietythroughresearchers’pubicengagementandservice.ByusingandlinkingIRISdataonresearchandgrantactivitiestotheFederalAdvisoryCommitteedata,itisdemonstratedthatfederallyfundedresearcharerelatedtothosewhoareappointedtoserveonFederalAdvisoryCommitteesassignedbyfederalagenciesonparticularissues.ThepresentationfocusesonthecaseoftheUniversityofMichigan.
ImpactofCTSAGrantsonTranslationalResearchUsingIRISDataPresenters:NancyCalvin-Naylor,IRISEliasSamuels,UniversityofMichigan
TheClinicalandTranslationalScienceAward’semphasisoneducationandtrainingnecessitatesthetrackingofparticipantoutcomestodemonstrateimpact.IRISstaffandaUniversityofMichiganCTSArepresentativewillprovideanoverviewofinitialattemptstoutilizeIRISdatatotrackcareeroutcomesofprogramparticipants.
MatchingUMETRICSAwardDatawithPublicDatasets:AnExamplefromNYUPresenters:MichaelMiller,NewYorkUniversityRidhimaSodhi,NewYorkUniversity
AttherequestoftheNYUVPforResearch,anNYUteammatchedtheirUMETRICSawarddatawithfieldsofresearchderivedfrompublicabstractinformationproducedbyDigitalScienceResearchandcomparedittoAAUbenchmarks.Wewillshowtheresultsofthatmatch,aswellasaprototypetoolthatcouldbeusedforbothresearchplanningandfundraisingbyotherUMETRICSuniversities.
2:30-3:00 WrappingitUp(JasonOwen-Smith,IRIS)
▪ Highlightsoftheday▪ IRISgovernanceupdate▪ IRISresearchdata/callforproposals
Thankyouforyourtime,energy,andcommitmenttoIRIS.Safetravels!
2017IRISDataSummitAttendeesName Affiliation EmailChristopherAllan UniversityofMichigan [email protected] IRIS [email protected] IRIS [email protected] StonyBrookUniversity [email protected] IRIS [email protected] IRIS [email protected] MichiganStateUniversity [email protected] OhioStateUniversity [email protected] YaleUniversity [email protected] CornellUniversity [email protected] U.S.CensusBureau [email protected] IndianaUniversity [email protected] UniversityofVirginia [email protected] IRIS [email protected] WashingtonUniversity-St.Louis [email protected] UniversityofWisconsin-Madison [email protected] NorthwesternUniversity [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofRochester [email protected] UniversityofWisconsin-Madison [email protected] UniversityofTexasSystem [email protected] CornellUniversity [email protected] IRIS [email protected] UniversityofIowa [email protected] MichiganStateUniversity [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] PrincetonUniversity [email protected] RutgersUniversity [email protected] ORCID [email protected] NewYorkUniversity [email protected] UniversityofVirginia [email protected] IRIS [email protected] IRIS [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofPennsylvania [email protected] MichiganStateUniversity [email protected] APLU [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofWisconsin-Madison [email protected] NewYorkUniversity [email protected]
Name Affiliation EmailJohnStringer BostonUniversity [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] UniversityofKansas [email protected] IRIS [email protected] IRIS [email protected] UniversityofCalifornia-SanDiego [email protected] PennsylvaniaStateUniversity [email protected] PurdueUniversity [email protected] UniversityofMichigan [email protected] PurdueUniversity [email protected] UniversityofArizona [email protected] IRIS [email protected] NewYorkUniversity [email protected] IRIS [email protected] OregonStateUniversity [email protected]