2012-05-04 - MDEC Memo in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings

8/2/2019 2012-05-04 - MDEC Memo in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings

1/24

2

FD WAH XDFWHG SWBWHS GFSW]FCW C@X]W

J@] WAH S@XWAH]D GFSW]FCW @J OFSSFSSFUUF

LBCIS@D GFZFSF@D

G]$ @]NV WBFW\. HSR$. M]FBD JHG@]IB. UNBFDWFJJSNBX]FH ]@WA. NHBA NBQ. bdg W@O

ObcNH]BD

ZS$ CFZFN BCWF@D D@$ 3


2/24

=

G`cihw D`$ :. u$u$ 21/=:_$ Wbfw|s `}fkfdbn swbwh c`x}w uhwfwf`d jx}wah} s`xkaw fdlxdcwfzh }hnfhj w` mn`ci

U}hsfghdw @mbob j}ò buuhb}fdk `d wah mbnn`w j`} wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch

u}fob}v hnhcwf`d. {afca {bs w` mh ahng d Ob}ca 23. =52=$ Wbfw|s `}fkfdbn c`x}w uhwfwf`d jx}wah}

bccxshs U}hsfghdw @mbob `j hnhcwf`d j}bxg b}fsfdk j}ò afs xsh `j b j}bxgxnhdw s`cfbn shcx}fwv dxomh}

bdg b j}bxgxnhdw mf}wa ch}wfjfcbwh$ Wbfw|s }fkfdbn c`x}w uhwfwf`d cfwhsOfss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:2 bs

wah lx}fsgfcwf`dbn mbsfs j`} m}fdkfdk ah} bcwf`d fd wah Afdgs C`xdwv Cf}cxfw C`x}w. {afca fs wah

u}`chgx}h j`} bd bkk}fhzhg ub}wv w` cabnnhdkh wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j b cbdgfgbwh fd Ofssfssfuuf shhifdk

w` mh hnhcwhg w` swbwh `jjfch mv jf}sw mhcòfdk b cbdgfgbwh fd wah ub}wv u}fob}v hnhcwf`d$

=$

M`wa wah Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv Hqhcxwfzh Còofwwhh bdg wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh jfnhg o`wf`ds

fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w w` gfsofss Wbfw|s uhwfwf`d `d dxoh}`xs k}`xdgs. fdcnxgfdk< !b& wabw fw {bs

xdwfohnv xdgh} Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2. !m& wabw wah Unbfdwfjj{bs d`w bd bkk}fhzhg ub}wv xdgh} Shcwf`d

=3/28/6:2 bdg `wah}{fsh nbcihg swbdgfdk w` m}fdk ah} bcwf`d fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w `j Afdgs C`xdwv.

Ofssfssfuuf. bdg !c& wabw dhfwah} wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh d`} wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc

Ub}wv Hqhcxwfzh Còofwwhh abg bdv gxwv xdgh} wah k`zh}dfdk swbwxwh j`} u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch

u}fob}fhs.Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/2516. w` ghwh}ofdh b u}hsfghdwfbn cbdgfgbwhs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds. wah}

wabd wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwhs nfofwhg }`nh fd fghdwfjvfdk khdh}bnnv }hc`kdf|hg cbdgfgbwhs j`}

U}hsfghdw w` mh unbchg `d wah ub}wv u}fob}v mbnn`w$

3$ @d Bu}fn 26. =52= Wbfw|. bn`dk {fwa j`x} bggfwf`dbn Unbfdwfjjs. jfnhg wah Jf}sw Bohdghg Còunbfdw!JBC& {fwa wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w. shhifdk. fdwh} bnfb. w` hdl`fd Mb}bci @mbob j}ò buuhb}fdk `d wah

Ofssfssfuuf =52= khdh}bn hnhcwf`d mbnn`w bs b cbdgfgbwh j`} U}hsfghdw j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs$2 Fd bggfwf`d

2 [afnh shzh}bn Unbfdwfjjs ux}u`}whgnv l`fdhg Wbfw|. {a` {bs wah `}fkfdbn s`nh unbfdwfjj. dnv wa}hh sxca Unbfdwfjjs abzh sfkdhgwah JBC bcc`}gfdk w` wah C`x}w ]hc`}g$ !Shh G`cihw D`$ :/27 bw =6 !O}$ Jhg`}ibs sfkdbwx}h ubkh& bdg G`cihw D`$ :/27 bw 35!O}$ Obc Nh}bds sfkdbwx}h ubkh&$ O`}h`zh}. d`dh `j wah `wah} ux}u`}whg Unbfdwfjjs abs u}`zfghg c`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d `}}hsu`dghg fd bdv {bv w` ghjhdgbdw OGHCs c`xdshns }hrxhsw wabw wahv c`djf}o wahv b}h u}`chhgfdk fd wafs bcwf`du}` sh bdgwabw wahv {fnn u}`zfgh sfkdhg unhbgfdks bdg u}ùh} c`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d$ Bggfwf`dbnnv. hbca bdg hzh}v hobfn shdw w` UnbfdwfjjObcNh}bd abs m`xdchg mbci w` wah xdgh}sfkdhg c`xdshn$ !Wah dnv c`dwbcw fdj`}obwf`d {bs h/obfn bgg}hsshs$& Wbfw| fs bdbww`}dhv {fwa b afsw`}v `j bwwhouwfdk w` }hu}hshdw Unbfdwfjjs cabnnhdkfdk U}hsfghdw @mbobs hnfkfmfnfwv fd swbwhs {ah}h sah fs d`w

Cbsh 3


3/24

3

w` wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv bdg wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh `j Ofssfssfuuf. Wbfw| bdg wah dh{

Unbfdwfjjs dbohg bs ghjhdgbdws U}hsfghdw @mbob. @mbob j`} Boh}fcb !wah U}hsfghdws u}fdcfubn

u`nfwfcbn cboubfkd còofwwhh&. Dbdcv Uhn`sf !d`{ wah ofd`}fwv nhbgh} `j wah X$S$ A`xsh `j

]hu}hshdwbwfzhs bdg j`}oh} cabf} `j wah =551 Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d&. G}$ Bnzfd @dbib

!]hkfsw}b} `j wah Ab{bff Ghub}wohdw `j Ahbnwa&. N`}hwwb Jxggv !Gf}hcw`} `j wah Ab{bff Ghub}wohdw `j

Ahbnwa& bdg Ofcabhn Bsw}xh !Còofssf`dh} `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs S`cfbn Shcx}fwv Bgofdfsw}bwf`d&$

Wah JBC cfwhgOfss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:3. {afca fs wah u}`chgx}h j`} cabnnhdkfdk b cbdgfgbwh {a`

jfnhg w` }xd fd wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d. bs wah mbsfs j`} wah dh{ cabnnhdkh w` U}hsfghdw @mbobs cbdgfgbcv

j`} U}hsfghdw fd wah D`zhomh} =52= hnhcwf`d fd Ofssfssfuuf$ Wah JBC bns` bgghg b jhgh}bn ]FC@

cbxsh j bcwf`d bkbfdsw wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv bdg wah dh{ ghjhdgbdws. mxw d`w wah Shc}hwb}v

`j Swbwh$ Bs `j wafs gbwh. d`dh `j wah dh{ ghjhdgbdws abzh mhhd sh}zhg {fwa u} chss `} `wah}{fsh

buuhb}hg fd wah cbsh$

7$ Wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh. l`fdhg mv wah OGHC. }ho`zhg Unbfdwfjjs cfzfn bcwf`d w` wafs A`d`}bmnh C`x}wmbshg `d wah hqfswhdch `j b jhgh}bn rxhswf`d b}fsfdk j}ò wah jhgh}bn ]FC@ cnbfo fdcnxghg j`} wah jf}sw

wfoh fd wah JBC$

nfchdshg w` u}bcwfch nb{$ Shh. h$k$. ]a`ghs z$ ObcG`dbng. :;5 J$ Sxuu$=g 23:3. 23:1 !22wa Cf}$ =556& !Mhcbxsh `j wahbnnhkhg x}khdw dbwx}h `j wah }hrxhsw. wah C`x}w {bfzhg fws n`cbn }xnh wabw }hrxf}hs c`xdshn bgofwwhgu}` abc zfch w` bss`cfbwh n`cbnc`xdshn$ Fw mhcboh buub}hdw gx}fdk wah ahb}fdk `d wah o`wf`d wabw wah C`x}w+s {bfzh} `j wafs n`cbn }xnh {bs b ofswbih bs c`xdshnbmxshg ah}u}` abczfch u}fzfnhkhs$&9 Jb}}b} z$ @mbob. D`$ =52=CZ=22361 !Kb$ Jxnw`d C`xdwv Sxuh}$ Cw$ Jhm$ 28. =52=&!ghdvfdk Wbfw|s }hrxhsw j`} bgofssf`d u}` abc zfch j`} jbfnx}h w` còunv {fwa }xnhs buunfcbmnh w` sboh&$ Bs sxca. jx}wah}}hjh}hdchs w` Unbfdwfjjs fs {fwa`xw u}hlxgfch w` OGHCs c`dwhdwf`d wabw Wbfw| fs wah `dnv bcwxbn unbfdwfjj. j`} wah }hbs`ds swbwhg$

Cbsh 3


4/24

7

WAH SXFW FS WFOH MB]]HG XDGH] OFSSFSSFUUF HNHCWF@D NB[

8$ Unbfdwfjjs JBC shhis w` cabnnhdkh wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j U}hsfghdw @mbob bs b cbdgfgbwh }xddfdk `d wahkhdh}bn hnhcwf d mbnn`w j`} U}hsfghdw fd =52=$ Unbfdwfjjs }hnv `dOfss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:3$

A`{hzh}. Shcwf`d =3/28/6:3 `dnv buunfhs w` fdghuhdghdw!d`w u`nfwfcbn ub}wv& cbdgfgbwhs {a`

rxbnfjfhg j`} jjfch mv `mwbfdfdk wah sfkdbwx}hs `j rxbnfjfhg hnhcw`}s d b uhwfwf`d$ U}hsfghdw @mbob.

{a` fs shhifdk wah Gho`c}bwfc dòfdbwf`d. {`xng d`w hzhd mh sxmlhcw w` wafs swbwxh sfdch ah fs d`w

}xddfdk bs bd fdghuhdghdw$

:$ Wah `dnv u`ssfmnh u}`chgx}h w` cabnnhdkh wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j b cbdgfgbwh }xddfdk fd b ub}wv u}fob}vfd Ofssfssfuuf fs xdgh}Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:2. {afca. bs d`whg bm`zh. {bs xshg mv Wbfw| bs wah

lx}fsgfcwf`dbn mbsfs j } jfnfdk wah }fkfdbn uhwfwf`d fd Afdgs C`xdwv Cf}cxfw C`x}w `d Jhm}xb}v 2=. =52=$

;$ A`{hzh}. bssxofdk. b}kxhdg`. wabwOfss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:3 fs buunfcbmnh fd cabnnhdkfdk bcbdgfgbwhs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds j`} wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d. wafs c`gh shcwf`d c`dwbfds sw}fcw wfoh nfofwbwf`ds.

}hrxf}fdk wahuhwfwf`d cabnnhdkfdk wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d cbdgfgbwhs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds w` mh jfnhg d`w nbwh}

wabd 32 gbvs bjwh} wah gbwh `j wah jf}sw u}fob}v hnhcwf`d bdg wabw bdv sxmshrxhdw uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn

}hzfh{ mh jfnhg d`w nbwh} wabd 28 gbvs bjwh} wah gbwh wabw wah uhwfwf`d {bs jfnhg {fwa wah buu}ù}fbwh

hnhcwf`d jjfcfbns$ B uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn }hzfh{ jfnhg ux}sxbdw w` Shcwf`d =3/28/6:3 bns` }hrxf}hs wah

u`swfdk `j b '355$55 c`sw m`dg bdg wah sfkdbwx}h `j w{` `} o`}h sxjjfcfhdw sx}hwfhs c`dgfwf`dhg w` ubv

bnn c`sws fd wah hzhdw wah uhwfwf`d fs gfsofsshg$

1$ Wah}h fs d` u}``j wabw Wbfw|. `} bdv `j wah dh{ Unbfdwfjjs. jfnhg bdv uhwfwf`d {fwa wah Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wvHqhcxwfzh Còofwwhh `} bdv wah} hnhcwf`d m`gv bs b u}hgfcbwh w` jfnfdk wah jf}sw JBC$ ]bwah}. wah

`dnv c`dchfzbmnh jfnfdk {fwa bd hnhcwf`d `jjfcfbn {bs bd hobfn wabw Wbfw| shdw w` wah xdgh}sfkdhg

c`xdshn j`} wah OGHC. gbwhg Bu}fn 2. =52=. {afca wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh abs bwwbcahg w` fws O`wf`d j`}

Lxgkohdw `d wah Unhbgfdks bdg {afca fs }hjh}hdchg mv Unbfdwfjjs fd ub}bk}bua 27 `j wah JBC$

D`wbmnv. wah xdgh}sfkdhg c`xdshn fs d`w bd `jjfch} `j wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv d`} b ohomh}

Cbsh 3


5/24

8

`j wah Swbwh Hqhcxwfzh Còofwwhh. bdg fs d`w wah OGHCs bkhdw j`} sh}zfch `j u}`chss$ O`}h`zh}.

Wbfw|s hobfn gfg d`w dboh wah j`x} bggfwf`dbn Unbfdwfjjs$ Wbfw|s hobfn bsis wabw ah} `}fkfdbn uhwfwf`d

cabnnhdkfdk U}hsfghdw @mbobs cbdgfgbcv fd wah u}fob}v hnhcwf`d mh c`dzh}whg w` b khdh}bn hnhcwf`d

cabnnhdkh. kfzhd wabw wah u}fob}v hnhcwf`d abg bn}hbgv w}bdsuf}hg$ Bssxofdk wabw Wbfw|s hobfn w` wah

xdgh}sfkdhg c`xdshn fd sòh {bv c`dswfwxwhs b uhwfwf`d n`gkhg {fwa wah Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv. Wbfw|s

sxmshrxhdw uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn }hzfh{. c`dwbfdhg fd wah JBC. fs d`dhwahnhss xdwfohnv bs Wbfw| {`xng

abzh abg w` abzh jfnhg wafs unhbgfdk fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w j Afdgs C`xdwv bdg ubfg wah c`sw m`dg {fwafd

28 gbvs `j wah Bu}fn 2 hobfn uhwfwf`d$ A`{hzh}. wah JBC {bs d`w jfnhg xdwfn Bu}fn 26. =52= bdg.

o`}h`zh}. gfg d w fdcnxgh wah }hrxf}hg m`dg bdg sx}hwfhs$ Mhcbxsh Wbfw| {bs }hrxf}hg w` jfnh b Cf}cxfw

C`x}w uhwfwf`d d` nbwh} wabd Bu}fn 28. =52=. bdg nfih{fsh w` u`sw b m`dg. ah} jbfnx}h w` g` s` fd hfwah}

}hsuhcw obihs bdv khdh}bn hnhcwf`d cabnnhdkh w` U}hsfghdw @mbobs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds wfoh mb}}hg bdg

swbwxw`}fnv ghjfcfhdw xdgh} Shcwf`d =3/28/6:3$

6$ Bnwh}dbwfzhnv. w` wah hqwhdw unbfdwfjj Wbfw| bdg wah j`x} dh{ Unbfdwfjjs shhi w` cabnnhdkh wahrxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j U}hsfghdw @mbob bs b cbdgfgbwh fd wah u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch u}fob}v.= wabw cnbfo fs

nfih{fsh wfoh/mb}}hg xdgh} Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2$ Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/6:2 u}`zfghs wah hqcnxsfzh

ohwa`g mv {afca wah rxbnfjfcbwf`d `j b cbdgfgbwh shhifdk uxmnfc `jjfch bs b ub}wv dòfdhh obv mh

cabnnhdkhg$

25$Wah Unbfdwfjjs b}h }hrxf}hg w` jfnh fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w b uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn }hzfh{ cabnnhdkfdk wahcbdgfgbwhs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds d` nbwh} wabd jfjwhhd gbvs bjwh} wah gbwh wah c`dwhsw uhwfwf`d {bs `}fkfdbnnv

jfnhg {fwa wah buu}ù}fbwh ub}wv hqhcxwfzh còofwwhh$ Bcc`}gfdk w` ah} `}fkfdbn swbwh c`x}w uhwfwf`d.

Wbfw| jfnhg ah} c`dwhsw uhwfwf`d cabnnhdkfdk @mbobs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds {fwa wah OGHC `d Lbdxb}v 1.

=52=$ Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2 swbwhs wabw wah cabnnhdkh oxsw mh jfnhg {fwa wah hqhcxwfzh còofwwhh {fwafd

= Bw ubkh 73 `j wah JBC. wah Unbfdwfjjs shhi w` abzh wah Shc}hwb}v j Swbwh ghch}wfjv } bddxn bnn z`whs j`} U}hsfghdw @mbobfd wah u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch u}fob}v$

Cbsh 3


6/24

:

whd gbvs bjwh} wah rxbnfjvfdk ghbgnfdh$ Wah rxbnfjvfdk ghbgnfdh j } wah u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch

u}fob}fhs u}`zfghg fdOfss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/2563 {bs Lbdxb}v 27. =52=$ Xdgh} Shcwf`d

=3/28/6:2. wah OGHC fd wx}d oxsw }xnh `d wah cabnnhdkh uhwfwf`d {fwafd whd gbvs `j }hchfzfdk fw$

Bssxofdk wabw Wbfw| jfnhg ah} c`dwhsw uhwfwf`d d Lbdxb}v 1. =52=. wah uhwfwf`d {`xng abzh dhhghg w` mh

}xnhg `d mv wah OGHC mv Lbdxb}v 21. =52=$ Fj fw {bs d`w }xnhg d mv wah OGHC. {afca fs wah cbsh

ah}h. Wbfw| abg jfjwhhd gbvs j}ò wah gbwh wah uhwfwf`d {bs jfnhg {fwa wah OGHC w` jfnh b uhwfwf`d j`}

lxgfcfbn }hzfh{ {fwa wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w$ A`{hzh}. Wbfw| gfg d`w jfnh ah} Cf}cxfw C`x}w uhwfwf`d xdwfn

Jhm}xb}v 27. =52=. jb} `xwsfgh `j wah jfjwhhd gbv {fdg`{ j`} g`fdk s`. waxs obifdk ah} `}fkfdbn Cf}cxfw

C`x}w uhwfwf`d wfoh mb}}hg bdg }hrxf}fdk gfsofssbn$ K`x}nbv z$ [fnnfbos. 1;7 S`$=g 61;. 611 !Ofss$

=557&$

UNBFDWFJJS NBCI SWBDGFDK

22$Wah cnbfo bwwbcifdk @mbobs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds w` }xd fd wah Ofssfssfuuf u}hsfghdwfbn u}hjh}hdch u}fob}v`} buuhb} `d wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d mbnn`w sa`xng mh gfsofsshg mhcbxsh. hqchuw j`} Jhg`}ib. d`dh `j wah

Unbfdwfjjs b}h rxbnfjfhg hnhcw`}s `j wah Swbwh `j Ofssfssfuuf. bdg wah}hj`}h nbci swbdgfdk w` m}fdk wafs

bcwf`d fd wah Cf}cxfw C`x}w j Afdgs C`xdwv } wafs A`d`}bmnh C`x}w$ Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2 u}`zfghs wabw

bdv ub}wv bkk}fhzhgmv wah bcwf`d `} fdbcwf`d `j wah buu}ù}fbwh hqhcxwfzh còofwwhh obv jfnh b

uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn }hzfh{ fd wah cf}cxfw c`x}w. bs wah hqcnxsfzh u}`chgx}h j`} cabnnhdkfdk b cbdgfgbwh

}xddfdk bs b ub}wv cbdgfgbwh$ Nfih{fsh. Shcwf`d =3/28/6:3 bjj`}gs bdv ub}wv bkk}fhzhg mv wah

fdbcwf`d `} bcwf`d `j wah buu}ù}fbwh hnhcwf`d `jjfcfbns wah }fkaw w` jfnh b uhwfwf`d j`} lxgfcfbn }hzfh{ fd

wah cf}cxfw c`x}w$ Wah}h fs sfounv d` {bv bdv `j wah d`d}hsfghdw Unbfdwfjjs cbd mh bd bkk}fhzhg ub}wv

`} `wah}{fsh abzh swbdgfdk$ ShhMhnabzhd Fou}`zhohdw Bssd. Fdc$ z$ Cfwv `j Lbcis`d. 85; S`$=g 72.

7; !Ofss$ 261;& !a`ngfdk wabw Yj`}_ swbdgfdk. wah uh}s`d!s& bkk}fhzhg {ahwah} `dh `} o`}h. sa`xng

bnnhkh bd bgzh}sh hjjhcw gfjjh}hdw j}ò wabw j wah khdh}bn uxmnfc&9]`h z$ W`{d `j Dh{ Jbf}jfhng. =52=

[N 77;8:2 !Lbdxb}v 2;. =52=& !C`dd$ Sxuh}$& !W` abzh swbdgfdk bs bd hnhcw`}. wah unbfdwfjjs }fkaw w`

Cbsh 3


7/24

;

z`wh oxsw mh founfcbwhg$&9Bnnfbdch Ob}bdb z$ K}`shcn`sh. 688 U$=g 73. 78 !B}f|$ 2661&

!D`d/}hsfghdw nbcis swbdgfdk w` jfnh {}fw `j obdgboxs }hkb}gfdk n`cbn }hjh}hdgxo&9 Xdfwhg Swbwhs z$

Abvs. 828 X$S$ ;3;. ;78 !2668& !Bs b obwwh} `j swbdgfdk. Unbfdwfjjs swbwfdk }bch/mbshg hrxbn u}`whcwf`d

cabnnhdkhs w` }hgfsw}fcwfdk oxsw mh z`wh}s {a` bcwxbnnv }hsfgh fd wah gfsw}fcws wahv b}h cabnnhdkfdk&$

2=$O`}h`zh}. d`dh `j wah Unbfdwfjjs b}h gfjjh}hdw wabd bdv `wah} cfwf|hd `} z`wh} `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs bdgwaxs abzh sxjjh}hg d` gfsc}hwh fdlx}v }hrxf}hg w` sbwfsjv swbdgfdk$ Shh A`nnbdgh} z$ OcCbfd. 8:: J$

Sxuu$ =g :3. :1 !G$D$A$ =551& !z`wh} nbcihg swbdgfdk w` cabnnhdkh c`dswfwxwf`dbn rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j

u}hsfghdwfbn dòfdhh fd wabw ah sxjjh}hg d` c`kdf|bmnh fdlx}v bdg {bs d`w u}hzhdwhg j}ò z`wfdk j`}

sòh`dh hnsh&9G}bih z$ @mbob. ::7 J$3g ;;7. ;15/;12 !6wa Cf}$ Ghc$ ==. =522& !j`}oh} bdg bcwfzh

ofnfwb}v uh}s`ddhn gfg d`w abzh swbdgfdk w` b}kxh wabw U}hsfghdw @mbob fs c`dswfwxwf`dbnnv fdhnfkfmnh w`

mh U}hsfghdw j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs bs wahv gfg d`w sa`{ c`dc}hwh fdlx}v&9 Mh}k z$ @mbob. 8;7 J$ Sxuu$=g

856 !H$G$ Uhdd$ =551&. bjjg. 81: J$3g =37. =36 !z`wh}s swbih d` k}hbwh} wabd bdv `wah} z`wh} bdg waxs

sxjjh}hg d` fdlx}v fd jbcw$&

UNBFDWFJJS JHG@]IB. ]@WA. NBQ BDG OBCNH]BDS JBFNX]H W@ JFNH BDV

UHWFWF@D [FWA WAH OGHC MB]S WAHF] BCWF@D

23$@dnv Unbfdwfjj Wbfw| hzhd bwwhouwhg w` bgah}h w` wah u}`chgx}h j`} cabnnhdkfdk b cbdgfgbwh shhifdkuxmnfc `jjfch mv cnbfofdk w` abzh jfnhg b uhwfwf d {fwa wah OGHC$ Wah `wah} Unbfdwfjjs gfg d`w

buuhb} xdwfn wahf} dbohs {h}h fdcnxghg fd wah JBC$ Shcwf`d =3/28/6:2 }hrxf}hs bd bkk}fhzhg ub}wv

w` jf}sw jfnh b c`dwhsw uhwfwf`d {fwa wah ub}wv hqhcxwfzh còofwwhh. bdg Shcwf`d =3/28/6:3 sfofnb}nv

}hrxf}hs jf}sw jfnfdk fd buu}ù}fbwh hnhcwf`d `jjfcfbns$ Jbfnx}h w` bgah}h w` wabw }hrxf}hohdw mhj`}h

jfnfdk d Cf}cxfw C`x}w fs lx}fsgfcwf`dbnnv ghjfcfhdw bdg }hrxf}hs gfsofssbn `j wah cnbfo$ K`x}nbv z$

[fnnfbos. 1;7 S`$=g 61;. 25 !Ofss$ =556&$ Bnwh}dbwfzhnv. hqchuw j`} Wbfw|. d` unbfdwfjj jfnhg uhwfwf`ds

{fwa wah OGHC cabnnhdkfdk U}hsfghdw @mbobs rxbnfjfcbwf`ds bdg waxs cbdd`w mh ub}wfhs w` bdv bcwf`d

jfnhg ux}sxbdw w` Shcwf`ds =3/28/6:2 `} =3/28/6:3$ Fg$ bw 611$

Cbsh 3


8/24

1

WAH OFSSFSSFUUF GHO@C]BWFC UB]WV ABS D@ SWBWXW@]V GXWV

W@ GHWH]OFDH U]HSFGHDWFBN CBDGFGBWH RXBNFJFCBWF@DS

27$Xdgh}Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/2516. }hsu`dsfmfnfwv j`} unbcfdk U}hsfghdw @mbobs dboh `d wahu}fob}v mbnn w fs zhswhg fd wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v j Swbwh. d`w wah OGHC$ Fd wabw }hkb}g. wah

Shc}hwb}v j Swbwh fs }hrxf}hg mv nb{ w` unbch hbca khdh}bnnv }hc`kdf|hg cbdgfgbwh d wah u}hsfghdwfbn

u}fob}v mbnn`w$ Cnhb}nv. U}hsfghdw @mbob fs b dbwf`dbnnv }hc`kdf|hg cbdgfgbwh$ Shcwf`d =3/28/2516

g`hs d`w }hrxf}h hfwah} wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh `} wah OGHC w` }hzfh{ {ahwah} b khdh}bnnv }hc`kdf|hg

cbdgfgbwh ohhws wah jhgh}bn c`dswfwxwf`dbn suhcfjfcbwf`ds w` mh u}hsfghdw. sxca bs {ahwah} b cbdgfgbwh fs

b dbwx}bn m }d cfwf|hd$ Xdgh} Shcwf`d =3/28/2516. wah OGHC abg bms`nxwhnv d` }`nh fd unbcfdk

U}hsfghdw @mbob `d wah Ob}ca =52= u}fob}v mbnn`w$

28$Fd Ihvhs z$ M`{hd. 216 Cbn$ Buu$ 7wa :7;. 22; Cbn$ ]uw}$ 3g =5; !Cbn$ Buu$ 3 Gfsw$ =525& wahCbnfj`}dfb C`x}w `j Buuhbns c`dsfgh}hg b swbwxwh dhb}nv fghdwfcbn w` Shcwf`d =3/28/156 bdg bjjf}ohg

wah gfsofssbn `j b obdgboxs bcwf`d bkbfdsw wah Cbnfj`}dfb Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh }hkb}gfdk U}hsfghdw

@mbobs cbdgfgbcv$ Wah Cbnfj`}dfb swbwxwh }hrxf}hg b cbdgfgbwhs dboh w` mh unbchg `d wah

u}hsfghdwfbn u}fob}v mbnn`w fj fw {bs ghwh}ofdhg mv wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh wabw wah cbdgfgbwh fs

khdh}bnnv bgz`cbwhg j`} `} }hc`kdf|hg wa}`xka`xw wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs `} Cbnfj`}dfb bs bcwfzhnv shhifdk

wah d`ofdbwf`d `j wah Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv j`} U}hsfghdw `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs Fg$ bw :81$ Wah C`x}w

j`xdg wabw wah Cbnfj`}dfb swbwxwh gfg d`w fou`sh bdv gxwv `d wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh w` ghwh}ofdh

{ahwah} b u}hsfghdwfbn cbdgfgbwh ohhws wah hnfkfmfnfwv c}fwh}fb `j b cfwf|hd xdgh} wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs

C`dswfwxwf`d$ Bcc`}gfdknv. xsfdk wah }hbs`dfdk fd Ihvhs z$ M`{hd. wah fdswbdw nb{sxfw m}`xkaw mv wah

Unbfdwfjjs bkbfdsw wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh bdg wah OGHC oxsw mh gfsofsshg mhcbxsh wah

Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh abg d` gxwv w` ghwh}ofdh {ahwah} b cbdgfgbwh fs rxbnfjfhg w` mh u}hsfghdw mhj`}h

unbcfdk afo `d wah ub}wv u}fob}v mbnn`w$

Cbsh 3


9/24

6

OFSSFSSFUUF HNHCWF@D @JJFCFBNS ABZH D@ LX]FSGFCWF@D @ZH] WAH

RXBNFJFCBWF@DS @J CBDGFGBWHS J@] U]HSFGHDW @J WAH XDFWHG SWBWHS

2:$Ofssfssfuuf hnhcwf`d `jjfcfbns abzh d lx}fsgfcwf`d `zh} wah sxmlhcw j b cbdgfgbwhs hnfkfmfnfwv xdgh} wahX$S$ C`dswfwxwf`d j } wah `jjfch `j U}hsfghdw `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs$ Bs wah Ihvhs z$ M`{hd ghcfsf`d

d`whg. wah u}hsfghdwfbn dòfdbwfdk u}`chss fs d`w sxmlhcw w` hbca `j wah jfjwv Swbwhs hnhcwf`d `jjfcfbns

fdghuhdghdwnv ghcfgfdk {ahwah} b u}hsfghdwfbn dòfdhh fs rxbnfjfhg. bs wafs c`xng nhbg w` cab`wfc

}hsxnws$ 216 Cbn$ Buu$ 7wa bw ::5$ ]bwah}. jhgh}bn nb{ shws j }wa wah hqcnxsfzh u}`chgx}h mv {afca

`mlhcwf`ds w` wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j b u}hsfghdwfbn cbdgfgbwh obv mh }hkfswh}hg bdg }hs`nzhg$

Ohcabdfsos hqfsw xdgh} wah W{hnjwa Bohdgohdw bdg 3 X$S$C$ 28 j`} bdv cabnnhdkh w` bdv

cbdgfgbwh w` mh zhdwfnbwhg {ahd hnhcw`}bn z`whs b}h c`xdwhg. bdg wah W{hdwfhwa Bohdgohdw u}`zfghs

kxfgbdch }hkb}gfdk a`{ w` u}`chhg fj b u}hsfghdw hnhcw sabnn abzh jbfnhg w` rxbnfjv$ Fssxhs }hkb}gfdk

rxbnfjfcbwf`ds j`} u}hsfghdw b}h rxfdwhsshdwfbnnv sxfwhg w` wah j`}hk`fdk u}`chss$ 216 Cbn$ Buu$ 7wa bw

::2$ Wah}hj`}h. bdv cabnnhdkh w` U}hsfghdw @mbobs hnfkfmfnfwv w` }xd bs b cbdgfgbwh. hfwah} fd wah

u}fob}v `} wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d. fs còofwwhg xdgh} wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs C`dswfwxwf`d w` wah u}hsfghdwfbn

hnhcw`}s bdg wah nhkfsnbwfzh m}bdca. bw nhbsw fd wah jf}sw fdswbdchd`w w` wah Ofssfssfuuf Shc}hwb}v `j

Swbwh. wah Ofssfssfuuf Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv. } wafs C`x}w$ Shh]`mfds`d z$ M`{hd. 8:; J$ Sxuu$ =g 2277.

227; !D$G$ Cbn$ =551&$

2;$Mhcbxsh `j wah Hnhcw`}bn C`nnhkh svswho `j u}hsfghdwfbn hnhcwf`ds shw j`}wa fd wah Xdfwhg SwbwhsC`dswfwxwf`d. Ofssfssfuuf z`wh}s bcwxbnnv z`wh j`} wah hnhcw`}s j`} b cbdgfgbwh j`} u}hsfghdw. bdg d`w j`}

cbdgfgbwhs wahoshnzhs$ Bw wah Gho`c}bwfc Swbwh C`dzhdwf`d. wah Ub}wv ghsfkdbwhs b snbwh j hnhcw`}s

{a` bdd`xdch bdg cnhb}nv hqu}hss ghsfkd bdg ux}u`sh w` sxuu`}w wah u}hsfghdwfbn cbdgfgbwh shnhcwhg

bw wah Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d$ Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/;;2$ Hnhcw`}s b}h ca`shd mv

z`wh}s wah jf}sw Wxhsgbv bjwh} wah jf}sw O`dgbv fd D`zhomh} fd u}hsfghdwfbn hnhcwf`d vhb}s$Ofss$ C`gh

Bdd$ =3/28/;12$ Wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh ch}wfjfhs w` wah cf}cxfw cnh}is `j bnn 1= c`xdwfhs fd

Cbsh 3


10/24

25

Ofssfssfuuf wah dbohs `j wah u}hsfghdwfbn dòfdhh bdg zfch u}hsfghdwfbn dòfdhh shnhcwhg bw wah

Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d$ Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$ =3/28/;18!2&$ Mhj`}habdg. wah Dbwf`dbn

Gho`c}bwfc Ub}wv u}`zfghs wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh fws dòfdhhs dbohs mv sxmofwwfdk b ch}wfjfcbwh `j

dòfdbwf`d sfkdhg mv wah u}hsfgfdk `jjfch} bdg shc}hwb}v `j wah Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d bdg

mv wah OGHC Cabf}obd bw nhbsw :5 gbvs u}f`} w` wah D`zhomh} khdh}bn hnhcwf`d$ Ofss$ C`gh Bdd$

=3/28/;18!=&$ Wah `jjfcfbn sbounh mbnn`w sxmofwwhg w` wah c`xdwfhs oxsw fdcnxgh wah {`}g

u}hsfghdwfbn hnhcw`}s j`} cbdgfgbwh j`} U}hsfghdw bdg cbdgfgbwh j`} Zfch U}hsfghdw. fd nfhx `j wah

hnhcw`}s dbohs `d wah mbnn`w$ A`{hzh}. z`whs cbsw j`} hnhcw`}s j`} wah dbohg cbdgfgbwhs oxsw mh

c`xdwhg bs z`whs j`} wah cbdgfgbwhs hnhcw`}s$ D`{ah}h fd wahsh swbwxw`}v u}`chgx}hs g` hfwah} wah

OGHC `} wah Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh u}`zfgh b gf}hcw }`nh fd ghwh}ofdfdk wah rxbnfjfcbwf`ds `j wah

Gho`c}bwfc dòfdhh j`} U}hsfghdw shnhcwhg bw wah dbwf`dbn c`dzhdwf`d$

O@@WDHSS/]FUHDHSS

21$W` wah hqwhdw Wbfw| `} wah `wah} Unbfdwfjjs c`dwfdxh w` cabnnhdkh U}hsfghdw @mbobs unbchohdw bs bcbdgfgbwh `d wah Ob}ca 23. =52= u}hsfghdwfbn u}fob}v mbnn`w. wah bcwf`d fs o``w mhcbxsh wah hnhcwf`d

abs bn}hbgv wbihd unbch$ Bnn}hg z$ [hmm. :72 S`$=g 2=21. 2==5 !Ofss$ 2667&$ Nfih{fsh. mhcbxsh

U}hsfghdw @mbob abs d`wmhhd dòfdbwhg mv wah Gho`c}bwfc Dbwf`dbn C`dzhdwf`d bs wah Ub}wvs

dòfdhh j`} U}hsfghdw. wah obwwh} fs d`w lxswfcfbmnh xdgh} wah g`cw}fdh `j }fuhdhss$ Swbwh hq }hn$

A`nohs z$ K}fjjfd. ::; S`$=g 2326. 23=8 !Ofss$ =558&$

UNBFDWFJJS B]H D@W HDWFWNHG W@ GHCNB]BWF@DS @] FDLXDCWFZH

]HNFHJ BS B OBWWH] @J NB[

26$Unbfdwfjjs }hrxhsw j`} ghcnb}bw`}v `} fdlxdcwfzh }hnfhj u}hzhdwfdk U}hsfghdw @mbob j}ò unbchohdw `dwah mbnn`w jbfn bs b obwwh} `j nb{$ Unbfdwfjjs shhi !2& b ghcnb}bw`}v lxgkohdw ghhofdk Mb}bci @mbob

d`w hnfkfmnh w` mh `d wah mbnn`w bs b cbdgfgbwh j`} wah X$S$ U}hsfghdcv gxh w` j}bxg. nbci `j hnfkfmfnfwv

bdg xsh `j j`}khg fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s9 bdg !=& bd fdlxdcwf`d u}hzhdwfdk Shc}hwb}v `j Swbwh j}ò

Cbsh 3


11/24

22

unbcfdk @mbobs dboh `d wah mbnn`w fd wah khdh}bn hnhcwf`d bdg gh/ch}wfjvfdkbddxnnfdk bnn z`whs j`}

@mbob fd wah u}fob}v hnhcwf`d$ Shh JBC !G`cihw D`$ 2/2& bw 73$ M`wa j`}os `j }hrxhswhg }hnfhj

b}h xdbzbfnbmnh w` Unbfdwfjjs bs b obwwh} `j nb{. bs u}hzf`xsnv b}wfcxnbwhg. bdg j`} wah }hbs`ds shw j`}wa

mhn`{$3

B$ Unbfdwfjjs nhkbn cnbfos ux}u`}wfdk w` hqubdg wah C`dswfwxwf`dbn }hrxf}hohdw wabw wahU}hsfghdw mh b Dbwx}bn M`}d Cfwf|hd jbfn bs b obwwh} `j nb{

=5$[afnh Unbfdwfjjs JBC fs fd obdv }hsuhcws fdcòu}hahdsfmnh. fw buuhb}s wabw wah nhkbn mbsfs j`}Unbfdwfjjs cnbfo wabw @mbob fs d`w hnfkfmnh j`} }h/hnhcwf`d fs w{`/j`ng< Jf}sw. Unbfdwfjjs c`dwhdg wabw

U}hsfghdw @mbob abs jbfnhg w` u}`gxch afs fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s$ ShhJBC bw ubkh 2: = !Yw_ah

o`sw knb}fdk hzfghdch `j @mbobs nbci `j dbwx}bn m`}d swbwxs bdg nhkfwfobcv j`} wah XS U}hsfghdcv. fs

@mbobs nbci `j o`sw mbsfc zbnfg fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s&$7 Shc`dg. Unbfdwfjjs c`dwhdg wabw hzhd fj

U}hsfghdw @mbob gfg u}`gxch afs ubuh}s. ah {`xng d`w rxbnfjv w` sh}zh bs U}hsfghdw mhcbxsh m`wa `j

afs ub}hdws {h}h d`w X$S$ cfwf|hds bw wah wfoh `j afs mf}wa$ Shh JBC bw ubkh 27 8$ M`wa b}kxohdws

b}h j}fz`n`xs bdg {a`nnv {fwa`xw oh}fw$

Wah C`dswfwxwf`d g`hs d`w c`xdwhdbdchUnbfdwfjjs ubuh}sunhbsh ghobdgs

=2$Unbfdwfjjs abzh d`wmhcbxsh wahv cbdd`wcfwhg bdv bxwa`}fwv {abws`hzh} w` lxswfjv wahf} ghobdg wabwU}hsfghdw @mbob sa`{ waho fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s sbwfsjbcw`}v w` waho$ Wah C`dswfwxwf`d. {afca

u}`zfghs fd }hnhzbdw ub}w wabw Yd_` uh}s`d hqchuw b dbwx}bn m`}d cfwf|hd $ $ $ sabnn mh hnfkfmnh w` wah

`jjfch `j U}hsfghdw. g`hs d`w sxuu`}w Unbfdwfjjs ghobdgs$ Shh X$S$ C@DSW$ b}w$ FF. 2$8 D`} cbd

3 Unbfdwfjjs b}h d`w bn`dh$ O`}h wabd dh axdg}hg mf}wah} cabnnhdkhs abzh mhhd jfnhg bdg }hlhcwhgsfdch =551 !fdcnxgfdk

o`}h wabd w{hdwv cabnnhdkhs jfnhg mv Wbfw| fdgfzfgxbnnv `} `d mhabnj `j `wah}s&$ Shh Hqafmfw B$7 Shh bns` fg$ bw ubkh 2= 2 !@mbob dhzh} u}hshdwhg w` bdv c`x}w `j nb{ `} bdv hnhcwf`ds còofssf`d bdv zbnfg `}fkfdbnfghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s `} bdv zbnfg ch}wfjfhg cùfhs. {afca cbd mh xshg w` zh}fjv wah `}fkfdbns$ &9 fg$ bw =3 Yxddxomh}hg ub}bk}buamhw{hhd 2: bdg 2;_ !Mbshg `d bnn `j wah bm`zh. @mbob g`hs d`w abzh bdv zbnfg fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s $ $ $ $ &9 fg$ bw =8Yxddxomh}hg shc`dg ub}bk}bua_ !Mb}bci Axsshfd @mbob g`hs d`w abzh bdv zbnfg X$S$ fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s bdg fsc`dswfwxwf`dbnnv d`w hnfkfmnh$&9 fg$ bw =: Yxddxomh}hg jf}sw ub}bk}bua_ !@mbob dhzh} abg bdv zbnfg fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s $ $ $ $&$

8 Unbfdwfjjs cbdd`w c}hgfmnv b}kxh wabw wah `}fkfdbn fdwhdw `j wah u}`zfsf`d {bs w` }hrxf}h cbdgfgbwhs w` u}`zfgh swbwh/fssxhg mf}wach}wfjfcbwhs. s`cfbn shcx}fwv cb}gs. `} shc}hw sh}zfch }hkfsw}bwf`d j`}os. kfzhd wabw d` sxca ubuh}s hzhd hqfswhg bw wah wfoh wahC`dswfwxwf`d {bs g}bjwhg$ Wah S`cfbn Shcx}fwv Bgofdfsw}bwf`d {bs c}hbwhg mv wah S`cfbn Shcx}fwv Bcw j 2638$ Shh 7= X$S$

Cbsh 3


12/24

2=

Unbfdwfjjs }hnv `d bdv swbwh `} jhgh}bn swbwxwh w` cnbfo wabw b cbdgfgbwh j`} wah U}hsfghdcv oxsw u}`zfgh

ubuh}s w` u}`zh hnfkfmfnfwv. mhcbxsh d` sxca nb{ hqfsws$ Bs sxca. wah hqfswhdch !`} nbci& `j

fghdwfjfcbwf`d ubuh}s sxca bs b s`cfbn shcx}fwv cb}g. shnhcwfzh sh}zfch }hkfsw}bwf`d. `} ub}wfcxnb} wvuh

`j mf}wa ch}wfjfcbwh fs sfounv f}}hnhzbdw w` b cbdgfgbwhs hnfkfmfnfwv w` sh}zh bs U}hsfghdw ux}sxbdw w`

C`dswfwxwf`d B}wfcnh FF Shcwf`d 2$

Wah C`dswfwxwf`d g`hs d`w c`xdwhdbdch Unbfdwfjjs ah}fwbkh/mbshg cnbfos

==$Unbfdwfjjs bns` c`dwhdg wabw sfdch YU}hsfghdw_ @mbob+s jbwah} {bs b j`}hfkd dbwf`dbn $ $ $ ah {`xng abzhmhhd b j`}hfkd dbwf`dbn j}ò mf}wa mbshg `d afs jbwah}+s cfwf|hdsafu. ah fs d`w hnfkfmnh j } afs `jjfch

mhcbxsh wah ohbdfdk `j dbwx}bn m`}d cfwf|hd bs fdwhdghg fd wah XS C`dswfwxwf`d. fs `dh m`}d fd wah

c`xdw}v w` w{` XS cfwf|hd ub}hdws$ Shh JBC bw ubkh 27 8$

=3$Wah c`dwhdwf`d wabw Mb}bci @mbob fs d`w b dbwx}bn m`}d cfwf|hd mhcbxsh afs Jbwah} {bs d`w b cfwf|hd{ahd U}hsfghdw @mbob {bs m`}d fs {fwa`xw oh}fw. bs }hchdwnv }hc`kdf|hg mv wah Gfsw}fcw C`x}w fd

Wfsgbnh z$ @mbob. {ah}h unbfdwfjj Cab}nhs Wfsgbnh }bfshg wah fghdwfcbn b}kxohdw$: Fd Wfsgbnh. unbfdwfjj

s`xkaw bd fdlxdcwf`d w` u}hzhdw wah Zf}kfdfb Swbwh M`b}g `j Hnhcwf`ds j}ò ch}wfjvfdk bdv cbdgfgbwh

{a` nbcis swbdgfdk bs b -dbwx}bn m`}d cfwf|hd- j}ò buuhb}fdk `d wah =52= hnhcwf`d mbnn`w$ Wah}h. bs

ah}h. unbfdwfjj b}kxhg wabw U}hsfghdw @mbob fs fdhnfkfmnh w` buuhb} `d wah mbnn`w. `d wah k}`xdgs wabw

Yah_ abg bw nhbsw dh ub}hdw {a` {bs d`w b cfwf|hd `j wah Xdfwhg Swbwhs$ Wah Gfsw}fcw C`x}w jf}onv

}hlhcwhg wafs j}fz`n`xs b}kxohdw. swbwfdk wah `mzf`xs

Documents

2012-05-04 - MDEC Memo in Support of Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings