Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2011 Judicial Evaluation
Questionnaire Results
Presented by:
Page 1 of 54
Total Respondents: 657
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?4137 1377 5514 75.03% 4137 N/A 4137 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 4843 430 5273 91.85% 4529 418 4947 91.55%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?4683 579 5262 89.00% 4365 564 4929 88.56%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?4427 810 5237 84.53% 4110 793 4903 83.83%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 4546 659 5205 87.34% 4221 650 4871 86.66%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?4581 648 5229 87.61% 4264 635 4899 87.04%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
25 3.81% No trial work 20
60 9.13% Civil 36 109 359
143 21.77% Criminal 2 4 52
190 28.92% Family Court 1 19 34
239 36.38%Orphans'
Court13 7 1
657 100.00%
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Background data of all respondents Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Summary Schedule
All Judges
All respondents who have
evaluated the Judges
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 2 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?56 22 78 71.79% 56 N/A 56 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 61 10 71 85.92% 48 8 56 85.71%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?53 16 69 76.81% 44 10 54 81.48%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?61 10 71 85.92% 48 8 56 85.71%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 45 25 70 64.29% 36 20 56 64.29%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?54 17 71 76.06% 45 11 56 80.36%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 2.50% No trial work 1
9 11.25% Civil 1 7 24
18 22.50% Criminal 1 2 41
21 26.25% Family Court 1 2
30 37.50%Orphans'
Court
80 100.00%
Background data of all respondents
RE: Judge: Joan A. Brown
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
Schedule 3
Judge: Judge: Joan A. BrownAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Page 4 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?83 62 145 57.24% 83 N/A 83 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 139 2 141 98.58% 82 1 83 98.80%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?131 5 136 96.32% 78 4 82 95.12%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?130 5 135 96.30% 79 4 83 95.18%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 122 11 133 91.73% 72 10 82 87.80%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?130 7 137 94.89% 75 6 81 92.59%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 0.67% No trial work 5
11 7.38% Civil 10 17 56
32 21.48% Criminal 1 3 42
46 30.87% Family Court 1 6 8
59 39.60%Orphans'
Court
149 100.00%
All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Denis P. Cohen
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 4
Judge: Denis P. Cohen
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
Page 5 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?58 25 83 69.88% 58 N/A 58 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 75 0 75 100.00% 58 0 58 100.00%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?69 4 73 94.52% 55 3 58 94.83%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?65 9 74 87.84% 49 9 58 84.48%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 69 4 73 94.52% 55 3 58 94.83%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?68 4 72 94.44% 54 3 57 94.74%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 2.38% No trial work 1
10 11.90% Civil 1 11 20
21 25.00% Criminal 2 1 44
19 22.62% Family Court 1 3
32 38.10%Orphans'
Court
84 100.00%
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Background data of all respondents
RE: Rose Marie DeFino-Nastasi
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 5
Judge: Rose Marie DeFino-NastasiAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 6 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?55 23 78 70.51% 55 N/A 55 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 67 4 71 94.37% 53 2 55 96.36%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?68 3 71 95.77% 53 2 55 96.36%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?66 5 71 92.96% 52 3 55 94.55%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 67 4 71 94.37% 51 4 55 92.73%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?64 6 70 91.43% 51 3 54 94.44%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 1.25% No trial work 2
10 12.50% Civil 15 20
17 21.25% Criminal 1 2 37
17 21.25% Family Court 2 1
35 43.75%Orphans'
Court
80 100.00%
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Judge: Thomas DempseyAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Total Responses
Background data of all respondents
RE: Thomas Dempsey
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 6
Page 7 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?66 52 118 55.93% 66 N/A 66 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 95 15 110 86.36% 57 9 66 86.36%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?96 12 108 88.89% 58 8 66 87.88%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?91 16 107 85.05% 53 13 66 80.30%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 100 7 107 93.46% 61 5 66 92.42%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?96 12 108 88.89% 57 8 65 87.69%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
4 3.36% No trial work 5
11 9.24% Civil 2 21 28
29 24.37% Criminal 2 1 37
35 29.41% Family Court 1 7 15
40 33.61%Orphans'
Court
119 100.00%
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Less than 5 years
Judge: Kevin M. DoughertyAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Kevin M. Dougherty
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 7
Page 8 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?168 41 209 80.38% 168 N/A 168 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 198 5 203 97.54% 162 5 167 97.01%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?193 10 203 95.07% 157 10 167 94.01%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?189 14 203 93.10% 155 12 167 92.81%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 188 10 198 94.95% 155 9 164 94.51%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?189 13 202 93.56% 153 13 166 92.17%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 0.95% No trial work 1
19 9.05% Civil 4 43 140
40 19.05% Criminal 1 1 17
66 31.43% Family Court 1 1
83 39.52%Orphans'
Court1
210 100.00%
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
Schedule 8
Less than 5 years
Judge: Gary S. GlazerAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Gary S. Glazer
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Page 9 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?65 12 77 84.42% 65 N/A 65 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 63 7 70 90.00% 58 7 65 89.23%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?57 13 70 81.43% 54 11 65 83.08%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?50 18 68 73.53% 46 17 63 73.02%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 56 13 69 81.16% 51 13 64 79.69%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?56 13 69 81.16% 53 11 64 82.81%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 2.60% No trial work 1
8 10.39% Civil 10 14
21 27.27% Criminal 1 5
23 29.87% Family Court 16 28
23 29.87%Orphans'
Court1 1
77 100.00%
21 – 30 years
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Elizabeth Jackson
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
Schedule 9
Judge: Elizabeth JacksonAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Page 10 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?134 48 182 73.63% 134 N/A 134 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 125 52 177 70.62% 98 34 132 74.24%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?120 57 177 67.80% 97 36 133 72.93%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?119 57 176 67.61% 96 35 131 73.28%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 96 76 172 55.81% 77 52 129 59.69%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?109 65 174 62.64% 88 42 130 67.69%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 0.54% No trial work 4
21 11.29% Civil 2 34 102
36 19.35% Criminal 1 1 19
52 27.96% Family Court 9 11
76 40.86%Orphans'
Court1 2
186 100.00%
11 – 20 years
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Judge: James Murray Lynn
21 – 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: James Murray Lynn
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Schedule 10
Page 11 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?53 18 71 74.65% 53 N/A 53 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 62 1 63 98.41% 52 1 53 98.11%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?64 0 64 100.00% 53 0 53 100.00%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?63 0 63 100.00% 53 0 53 100.00%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 60 2 62 96.77% 51 1 52 98.08%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?63 0 63 100.00% 53 0 53 100.00%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 1.37% No trial work 4
5 6.85% Civil 12 14
20 27.40% Criminal 1 4
18 24.66% Family Court 13 23
29 39.73%Orphans'
Court1 1
73 100.00%
11 – 20 years
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Margaret T. Murphy
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
21 – 30 years
Schedule 11
Judge: Margaret T. MurphyAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
More than 30 years
Total Responses
Page 12 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?285 50 335 85.07% 285 N/A 285 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 333 3 336 99.11% 281 3 284 98.94%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?331 5 336 98.51% 278 5 283 98.23%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?320 14 334 95.81% 268 13 281 95.37%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 327 7 334 97.90% 276 6 282 97.87%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?328 3 331 99.09% 276 2 278 99.28%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
6 1.75% No trial work 5
30 8.77% Civil 11 53 254
64 18.71% Criminal 13
106 30.99% Family Court 1 1 3
136 39.77%Orphans'
Court1
342 100.00%Total Responses
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Arnold L. New
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Judge: Arnold L. New
Less than 5 years
Schedule 12
Page 13 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?71 34 105 67.62% 71 N/A 71 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 95 3 98 96.94% 69 1 70 98.57%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?91 8 99 91.92% 65 6 71 91.55%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?96 4 100 96.00% 68 3 71 95.77%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 92 7 99 92.93% 66 4 70 94.29%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?93 5 98 94.90% 67 3 70 95.71%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 2
12 11.21% Civil 4 12 59
24 22.43% Criminal 1 2 23
32 29.91% Family Court 1 1 2
39 36.45%Orphans'
Court
107 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: George W. Overton
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 13
Judge: George W. OvertonAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 14 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?226 43 269 84.01% 226 N/A 226 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 254 15 269 94.42% 215 11 226 95.13%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?241 27 268 89.93% 200 24 224 89.29%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?248 17 265 93.58% 207 15 222 93.24%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 234 26 260 90.00% 195 24 219 89.04%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?240 26 266 90.23% 199 23 222 89.64%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
8 2.91% No trial work 4
31 11.27% Civil 8 55 171
55 20.00% Criminal 1 15
84 30.55% Family Court 6 12
97 35.27%Orphans'
Court1 2
275 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Paul P. Panepinto
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 14
Judge: Paul P. PanepintoAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 15 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?133 29 162 82.10% 133 N/A 133 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 148 12 160 92.50% 123 9 132 93.18%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?142 18 160 88.75% 119 13 132 90.15%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?142 14 156 91.03% 118 10 128 92.19%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 145 15 160 90.63% 120 12 132 90.91%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?142 16 158 89.87% 118 12 130 90.77%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
3 1.82% No trial work 3
9 5.45% Civil 6 26 120
38 23.03% Criminal 7
54 32.73% Family Court 2 1
61 36.97%Orphans'
Court
165 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Nitza I. Quinones Alejandro
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 15
Judge: Nitza I. Quinones AlejandroAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 16 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?115 41 156 73.72% 115 N/A 115 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 141 11 152 92.76% 103 8 111 92.79%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?143 12 155 92.26% 105 9 114 92.11%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?137 17 154 88.96% 100 13 113 88.50%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 139 13 152 91.45% 102 10 112 91.07%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?141 14 155 90.97% 103 11 114 90.35%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 0.62% No trial work 3
21 13.04% Civil 9 25 84
33 20.50% Criminal 1 2 32
47 29.19% Family Court 2 3
59 36.65%Orphans'
Court
161 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Lisa M. Rau
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 16
Judge: Lisa M. RauAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 17 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?38 16 54 70.37% 38 N/A 38 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 40 7 47 85.11% 30 6 36 83.33%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?38 9 47 80.85% 27 9 36 75.00%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?34 14 48 70.83% 25 13 38 65.79%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 35 13 48 72.92% 26 12 38 68.42%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?37 9 46 80.43% 27 9 36 75.00%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 4
9 15.00% Civil 1 7 11
16 26.67% Criminal 1 1 26
14 23.33% Family Court 2 7
21 35.00%Orphans'
Court
60 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Robert J. Rebstock
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 17
Judge: Robert J. RebstockAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 18 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?72 26 98 73.47% 72 N/A 72 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 78 16 94 82.98% 62 10 72 86.11%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?66 27 93 70.97% 52 20 72 72.22%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?72 19 91 79.12% 57 13 70 81.43%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 68 24 92 73.91% 54 17 71 76.06%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?68 25 93 73.12% 54 18 72 75.00%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 1.01% No trial work 1
12 12.12% Civil 2 12 64
19 19.19% Criminal 1 17
33 33.33% Family Court 1 1
34 34.34%Orphans'
Court
99 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Gregory E. Smith
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 18
Judge: Gregory E. SmithAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 19 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?64 23 87 73.56% 64 N/A 64 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 77 3 80 96.25% 60 2 62 96.77%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?74 7 81 91.36% 58 6 64 90.63%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?72 5 77 93.51% 57 4 61 93.44%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 72 5 77 93.51% 57 4 61 93.44%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?78 3 81 96.30% 61 2 63 96.83%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 2
10 10.99% Civil 4 14 44
16 17.58% Criminal 1 25
29 31.87% Family Court 1
36 39.56%Orphans'
Court
91 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Albert John Snite, Jr.
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 19
Judge: Albert John Snite, Jr.All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 20 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?30 13 43 69.77% 30 N/A 30 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 30 6 36 83.33% 27 3 30 90.00%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?30 5 35 85.71% 26 3 29 89.66%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?29 5 34 85.29% 25 4 29 86.21%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 31 4 35 88.57% 26 4 30 86.67%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?31 5 36 86.11% 27 3 30 90.00%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 1
8 18.18% Civil 1 4 10
9 20.45% Criminal 2 24
14 31.82% Family Court 1 1
13 29.55%Orphans'
Court
44 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Earl W. Trent, Jr.
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 20
Judge: Earl W. Trent, Jr.All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 21 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?40 19 59 67.80% 40 N/A 40 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 46 6 52 88.46% 35 5 40 87.50%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?47 5 52 90.38% 35 5 40 87.50%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?44 6 50 88.00% 33 5 38 86.84%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 47 4 51 92.16% 35 4 39 89.74%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?46 5 51 90.20% 34 5 39 87.18%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 1.61% No trial work 3
7 11.29% Civil 1 12 15
12 19.35% Criminal 2 1 27
16 25.81% Family Court 1
26 41.94%Orphans'
Court
62 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Chris R. Wogan
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 21
Judge: Chris R. WoganAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 22 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?79 24 103 76.70% 79 N/A 79 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 77 22 99 77.78% 64 15 79 81.01%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?74 26 100 74.00% 62 17 79 78.48%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?77 22 99 77.78% 63 15 78 80.77%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 68 31 99 68.69% 57 22 79 72.15%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?70 29 99 70.71% 58 19 77 75.32%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 0.95% No trial work 1
11 10.48% Civil 2 14 26
28 26.67% Criminal 1 3 45
32 30.48% Family Court 4 7
33 31.43%Orphans'
Court2
105 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: James M. DeLeon
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 22
Judge: James M. DeLeonAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 23 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?50 9 59 84.75% 50 N/A 50 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 56 2 58 96.55% 49 1 50 98.00%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?55 2 57 96.49% 49 1 50 98.00%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?53 4 57 92.98% 47 3 50 94.00%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 52 4 56 92.86% 46 3 49 93.88%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?52 4 56 92.86% 46 3 49 93.88%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
1 1.64% No trial work 2
10 16.39% Civil 1 4 16
14 22.95% Criminal 1 1 33
13 21.31% Family Court 1 2
23 37.70%Orphans'
Court
61 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Thomas F. Gehret
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 23
Judge: Thomas F. GehretAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 24 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?45 8 53 84.91% 45 N/A 45 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 43 7 50 86.00% 39 6 45 86.67%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?38 12 50 76.00% 34 11 45 75.56%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?38 11 49 77.55% 34 10 44 77.27%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 38 12 50 76.00% 34 11 45 75.56%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?37 12 49 75.51% 33 11 44 75.00%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 1
7 12.96% Civil 2 16
12 22.22% Criminal 2 30
15 27.78% Family Court 3
20 37.04%Orphans'
Court
54 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Nazario Jimenez, Jr.
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 24
Judge: Nazario Jimenez, Jr.All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 25 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?56 20 76 73.68% 56 N/A 56 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 65 10 75 86.67% 51 5 56 91.07%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?65 9 74 87.84% 52 4 56 92.86%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?63 11 74 85.14% 50 5 55 90.91%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 66 9 75 88.00% 52 4 56 92.86%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?66 9 75 88.00% 52 4 56 92.86%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 2.53% No trial work 2
10 12.66% Civil 1 12 22
15 18.99% Criminal 2 36
17 21.52% Family Court 4
35 44.30%Orphans'
Court
79 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: William A. Meehan, Jr.
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 25
Judge:William A. Meehan, Jr.All respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 26 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?104 22 126 82.54% 104 N/A 104 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 122 7 129 94.57% 99 5 104 95.19%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?121 6 127 95.28% 99 4 103 96.12%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?117 9 126 92.86% 96 7 103 93.20%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 117 9 126 92.86% 95 7 102 93.14%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?121 6 127 95.28% 99 4 103 96.12%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 1.52% No trial work 4
12 9.09% Civil 7 25 48
20 15.15% Criminal 1 4 37
49 37.12% Family Court 2 2
49 37.12%Orphans'
Court2
132 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Bradley K. Moss
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 27
Judge: Bradley K. MossAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 28 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?43 16 59 72.88% 43 N/A 43 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 54 3 57 94.74% 42 0 42 100.00%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?46 10 56 82.14% 36 6 42 85.71%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?48 8 56 85.71% 38 4 42 90.48%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 45 11 56 80.36% 35 7 42 83.33%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?46 9 55 83.64% 36 5 41 87.80%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 2
7 11.29% Civil 1 6 16
14 22.58% Criminal 1 1 30
16 25.81% Family Court 1 4
25 40.32%Orphans'
Court
62 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Harvey W. Robbins
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 28
Judge: Harvey W. RobbinsAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 29 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?52 9 61 85.25% 52 N/A 52 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 57 4 61 93.44% 49 3 52 94.23%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?54 6 60 90.00% 47 5 52 90.38%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?55 5 60 91.67% 48 4 52 92.31%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 56 4 60 93.33% 49 3 52 94.23%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?56 4 60 93.33% 49 3 52 94.23%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
2 3.13% No trial work 2
8 12.50% Civil 3 4 15
16 25.00% Criminal 2 36
19 29.69% Family Court 2
19 29.69%Orphans'
Court
64 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: David C. Shuter
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 29
Judge: David C. ShuterAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 30 of 54
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses
to total
Yes NoTotal
Responses
% of Yes
responses to
total
Have you personally appeared before this judge in
the last 5 years?43 21 64 67.19% 43 N/A 43 100.00%
Do you have confidence in this judge’s integrity? 57 6 63 90.48% 40 3 43 93.02%
Does this judge demonstrate the requisite legal
ability to perform his/her judicial duties?55 7 62 88.71% 38 4 42 90.48%
Does this judge demonstrate proper judicial
temperament?56 6 62 90.32% 40 3 43 93.02%
Is this judge efficient and industrious? 53 7 60 88.33% 37 4 41 90.24%
In your opinion, with respect to this judge’s judicial
performance, is he/she qualified?56 7 63 88.89% 40 3 43 93.02%
Responses % Of Total 0-10% 11-50% over 50%
0 0.00% No trial work 3
10 14.93% Civil 3 10 10
17 25.37% Criminal 1 3 33
17 25.37% Family Court 4
23 34.33%Orphans'
Court
67 100.00%Total Responses
Less than 5 years
5 -10 years
11 – 20 years
21 – 30 years
More than 30 years
Background data of all respondents
RE: Karen Y. Simmons
Number of years admitted
to the practice of law
Percentage of practice
involving trial work
Schedule 30
Judge: Karen Y. SimmonsAll respondents who have
evaluated this Judge
Respondents who have personally appeared before
this Judge in the last 5 years
Page 31 of 54
