Click here to load reader

2010 JAM Junior Agricultural Mechanics San Antonio Livestock Show

  • View
    40

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

2010 JAM Junior Agricultural Mechanics San Antonio Livestock Show. CRITIQUEING PROJECTS AND EXHIBITORS. General Workmanship Square True to plan dimensions Evaluation of cutting, drilling, and welding Grinding has been kept to a minimum Project must be blue ribbon to place. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Text of 2010 JAM Junior Agricultural Mechanics San Antonio Livestock Show

  • 2010 JAM Junior AgriculturalMechanicsSan Antonio Livestock ShowCRITIQUEING PROJECTSAND EXHIBITORS

  • SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20Difficulty10

  • General WorkmanshipSquareTrue to plan dimensionsEvaluation of cutting, drilling, and weldingGrinding has been kept to a minimum

    Project must be blue ribbon to place

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • Trailer WorkmanshipUse trailer check sheetInspect for protected wiringLights meet DOT requirementsInspect spacing between tire and fenderAxle attachmentWeld spatter removalPainting

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • Electrical Project WorkmanshipConforms to NECProper PolarityAdequate wire length for repairNeat and OrganizedWire to terminal attachmentProper grounding

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • Design Look for evidence that student has thought through the project

    Projects should be planned and drawn before construction begins

    Material selection

    Practical use vs. cost

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • Trailer DesignSafety ChainsTxDOT standards (check sheet may be verified)Protected wiresFender clearanceTie downsOperator convenience

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • 3 Point Hookup and PTO DesignMust meet ASABE standardsSound construction and safeIdentification of pinch and wrap pointsShielding and SMV emblem use

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • Wood Project DesignProper fastener useSelection of finish (finish matches use)Flashing and sheet metal covers

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20

  • DocumentationTo be covered by additional presentation

    *Students will be given a copy this year*

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20

  • General KnowledgeQuality of projects has improved over the yearsPoints given for knowledge area are of greater importanceQuestioning provides the best evaluation of knowledgeFewer general questions more specific

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20

  • Knowledge: Judges QuestionsHigher quality projects require more in depth questions to differentiate scoresQuestions are tied to documentation and photosAnswers to questions should give the answer not a rehearsed speechStudent should be able to demonstrate project

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20

  • Knowledge: Judges Questions Questions should relate to project students have designed and builtBe prepared for an assortment of questions As basic student knowledge is revealed request detailed informationQuality Project + Quality Answers =Placing Project

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20

  • Knowledge: Question IdeasSpecification of material usedWelding informationDistortion control methodProject information sourcesProject work sources

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20

  • DifficultyBased on size, complexity and scopeIllustrated by a greater amount of skillsConstruction difficulty earns more pointsIntricate and moving parts earn more points

    *Simple projects can be blue ribbon*

    SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Design20Documentation20Knowledge20Difficulty10

  • Additional InformationAll members of a team built project should be able to answer questionsTry to maintain eye contactDemonstrate projectStudent must have the ability to sell themselves and their projectStudent should be familiar with doc. check sheet, trailer check sheet, and critique sheet

  • SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30+Design20okDocumentation20Needs workKnowledge20goodDifficulty10simple

  • SAN ANTONIO JAM JUDGES CRITIQUEClassItemEntry NumberCriteriaPossible PtsExplanation/CritiqueWorkmanship30Excellent corner fit up, good diag. Measurements, over-welding Design20Intricate trailer dumping mechanism,Quality latching mechanism Documentation20Project built to plan dimension, photos show project progression, complete BOMKnowledge20Excellent knowledge of welding process, knowledge of material sizing, Difficulty10Trailer dump shows additional effort

  • Partnerships to aid students and teachers Teachers and other courses in school Businesses Industry Family members

Search related