2004 Florida Bar Exam Q&A

8/4/2019 2004 Florida Bar Exam Q&A

1/44

!"#$%&'()#'$&(#*()'$(+,'-%./$0(!"#$%$&'(!'$)*+,-!("+-.+'/*+&01(*#*+2-0('+-.+.3-($"!+!

!

!

"#$%&'(!)(%!*+(,&-(.&$-!

/.0'1!20&'3!(-'!/3#34.3'!5-673%6!

!

"38%0(%1!9::;!

3!/.0'1!20&'3!7#!83!?08#&6>3'!63,&(--0(##1!7&.>!366(1!@036.&$-6!

A%$,!.7$!?%3B&$06#1!(',&-&6.3%3'!3+(,&-(.&$-6!

(-'!6(,?#3!(-673%6C!

++

"0.0%3!64>3'0#3'!%3#3(63!'(.36D!!50E06.!9::F!(-'!G(%4>!9::H!!!I$!?(%.!$A!.>&6!?08#&4(.&$-!,(1!83!%3?%$'043'!$%!.%(-6,&..3'!&-!(-1!

A$%,!$%!81!(-1!,3(-6!7&.>$0.!.>3!?%&$%!7%&..3-!4$-63-.!$A!.>3!"#$%&'(!

)$(%'!$A!)(%!*+(,&-3%6C!

++++

J$?1%&E>.!!!9::F!81!"#$%&'(!)$(%'!$A!)(%!*+(,&-3%6!!

5##!%&E>.6!%363%B3'C!


2/44

!

! 4


3/44

=5)K*!L"!JLI=*I=/!

"#$%&'(!)(%!*+(,&-(.&$-!

/.0'1!20&'3!(-'!/3#34.3'!5-673%6!

!'!,3*+-.+2-%'*%'&555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 6+

1!('++$+7+*&&!8+90*&'$-%&+!%"+&*3*2'*"+!%&:*(& 55555555555555555555555555555555555555 ;+

*&&!8+*

.*,(0!(8+4>>?+,!(+*

.*,(0!(8+4>>?+,!(+*

C038+4>>?+,!(+*

C038+4>>?+,!(+*

#03'$13*D2/-$2*+*


4/44


5/44

M5N=!!O!P!*//5Q!RS*/=OLI/!5IT!/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N/!

!

!.*,(0!(8+4>>?+!%"+C038+4>>?++.3-($"!+,!(+*

+++1IJK+$+LM+KN6O+PQRS6TIK6LU+TLUKI6UO+KNV+VOOIW+XQVOK6LUO+MJLY+KNV+.VRJQIJW+4>>?+IUZ+CQSW+4>>?+.SLJ6ZI+,IJ+*[IY6UIK6LUO+IUZ+LUV+OVSVTKVZ+IUO\VJ+MLJ+VITN+XQVOK6LU5+

'NV+ IUO\VJO+ JVTV6]VZ+ N6^N+ OTLJVO+ IUZ+ \VJV+ \J6KKVU+ RW+ IPPS6TIUKO+ \NL+ PIOOVZ+ KNV+V[IY6UIK6LU5+ + 'NV+ NIUZ\J6KKVU+ IUO\VJO+ \VJV+ KWPVZ+ IO+ OQRY6KKVZ5+ + 'NV+ IUO\VJO+ IJV+JVPJLZQTVZ+NVJV+\6KN+KNV+TLUOVUK+LM+KNV6J+IQKNLJO+IUZ+YIW+ULK+RV+JVPJ6UKVZ5+

!PPS6TIUKO+ IJV+ ^6]VU+ KNJVV+ NLQJO+ KL+ IUO\VJ+ VITN+ OVK+ LM+ KNJVV+ VOOIW+ XQVOK6LUO5++$UOKJQTK6LUO+MLJ+KNV+VOOIW+V[IY6UIK6LU+IPPVIJ+LU+PI^V+45+

;!


6/44

*//5Q!*V5GOI5=OLI!OI/=NSJ=OLI/!

OI"LNG5=OLI!N*K5=OW*!=L!5I/U*NOI2!)5N!*V5GOI5=OLI!RS*/=OLI/!

+5??#&4(8#3!K(7!9QVOK6LUO+ LU+ KNV+ .SLJ6ZI+ ,IJ+ *[IY6UIK6LU+ ONLQSZ+ RV+ IUO\VJVZ+ 6U+ ITTLJZIUTV+ \6KN+

IPPS6TIRSV+SI\+6U+MLJTV+IK+KNV+K6YV+LM+V[IY6UIK6LU5++9QVOK6LUO+LU+1IJK+!+IJV+ZVO6ÛVZ+KL+KVOK+WLQJ+_UL\SVZ^V+LM+RLKN+^VUVJIS+SI\+IUZ+.SLJ6ZI+SI\5++:NVU+.SLJ6ZI+SI\+]IJ6VO+MJLY+^VUVJIS+SI\`+KNV+XQVOK6LU+ONLQSZ+RV+IUO\VJVZ+6U+ITTLJZIUTV+\6KN+.SLJ6ZI+SI\5+

5443?.(8#3!*66(1!5-673%!

"# !UISWO6O+LM+KNV+1JLRSVY+D+'NV+IUO\VJ+ONLQSZ+ZVYLUOKJIKV+WLQJ+IR6S6KW+KL+IUISWaV+KNV+XQVOK6LU+ IUZ+ TLJJVTKSW+ 6ZVUK6MW+ KNV+ 6OOQVO+ LM+ SI\+ PJVOVUKVZ5+ + 'NV+ IUO\VJ+ ONLQSZ+ZVYLUOKJIKV+WLQJ+IR6S6KW+KL+IJK6TQSIKV`+TSIOO6MW+IUZ+IUO\VJ+KNV+PJLRSVY+PJVOVUKVZ5++!+RJLIZ+^VUVJIS+OKIKVYVUK+LM+SI\+6UZ6TIKVO+IU+6UIR6S6KW+KL+O6U^SV+LQK+I+SVÎS+6OOQV+IUZ+IPPSW+KNV+SI\+KL+6KO+OLSQK6LU5+

"# HUL\SVZ^V+ LM+ KNV+ 3I\+ D+ 'NV+IUO\VJ+ ONLQSZ+ZVYLUOKJIKV+ WLQJ+ _UL\SVZ^V+ LM+ SVÎS+

JQSVO+IUZ+PJ6UT6PSVO+IUZ+WLQJ+IR6S6KW+KL+OKIKV+KNVY+ITTQJIKVSW+LU+KNV+V[IY6UIK6LU+IO+KNVW+JVSIKV+KL+KNV+6OOQV+PJVOVUKVZ+RW+KNV+XQVOK6LU5++'NV+SVÎS+PJ6UT6PSVO+IUZ+JQSVO+^L]VJU6U^+ KNV+ 6OOQVO+ PJVOVUKVZ+ RW+ KNV+ XQVOK6LU+ ONLQSZ+ RV+ OKIKVZ+ TLUT6OVSW+ IUZ+OQTT6UTKSW+\6KNLQK+QUZQV+VSIRLJIK6LU5+

"# !PPS6TIK6LU+ IUZ+ (VIOLU6U^+ D+ 'NV+ IUO\VJ+ ONLQSZ+ ZVYLUOKJIKV+ WLQJ+ TIPIT6KW+ KL+JVIOLU+SL^6TISSW+RW+IPPSW6U^+KNV+IPPJLPJ6IKV+JQSV+LJ+PJ6UT6PSV+LM+SI\+KL+KNV+MITKO+LM+KNV+XQVOK6LU+ IO+ I+ OKVP+ 6U+ JVITN6U + I+ TLUTSQO6LU5+ + 'N6O+ 6U]LS]VO+ YI_6U + I+ TLJJVTK+PJVS6Y6UIJW+ ZVKVJY6UIK6LU+ IO+KL+ \N6TN+LM+ KNV+ MITKO+^6]VU+ 6U+KNV+XQVOK6LU+IJV+ SVÎSSW+6YPLJKIUK+ IUZ+ \N6TN`+ 6M+IUW`+ IJV+ SVÎSSW+ 6JJVSV]IUK+ 6UOLMIJ+ IO+ KNV+ IPPS6TIRSV+ JQSV+ LJ+PJ6UT6PSV+ 6O+TLUTVJUVZ5++ 'NV+ S6UV+LM+ JVIOLU6U^+IZLPKVZ+RW+ WLQ+ONLQSZ+RV+TSVIJ+ IUZ+TLUO6OKVUK`+\6KNLQK+ÎPO+LJ+Z6^JVOO6LUO5+

"# &KWSV+ D+ 'NV+ IUO\VJ+ ONLQSZ+ RV+ \J6KKVU+ 6U+ I+ TSVIJ`+ TLUT6OV+ V[PLO6KLJW+ OKWSV+ \6KN+IKKVUK6LU+KL+LJÎU6aIK6LU+IUZ+TLUMLJY6KW+\6KN+^JIYYIK6TIS+JQSVO5+

"# 2LUTSQO6LU+D+$M+KNV+XQVOK6LU+TISSO+MLJ+I+OPVT6M6T+TLUTSQO6LU+LJ+JVOQSK`+KNV+TLUTSQO6LU+ONLQSZ+ TSVIJSW+ IPPVIJ+ IK+ KNV+ VUZ+ LM+ KNV+ IUO\VJ + OKIKVZ+ TLUT6OVSW+ \6KNLQK+ QUZQV+VSIRLJIK6LU+ LJ+ VXQ6]LTIK6LU5+ + !U+ IUO\VJ+ \N6TN+ TLUO6OKO+ VUK6JVSW+ LM+ TLUTSQO6LUO`+QUOQPPLJKVZ+RW+OKIKVYVUKO+LJ+Z6OTQOO6LU+LM+KNV+JQSVO+LJ+JVIOLU6U^+LU+\N6TN+KNVW+IJV+RIOVZ`+6O+VUK6KSVZ+KL+S6KKSV+TJVZ6K5+

"# &Q^^VOK6LUO+!""L+ULK+IUK6T6PIKV+KJ6T_+XQVOK6LUO+LJ+IKKVYPK+KL+JVIZ+6U+N6ZZVU+YVIU6UÔ+LJ+

MITKO+ULK+TSVIJSW+V[PJVOOVZ+RW+KNV+XQVOK6LUO5+!"(VIZ+IUZ+IUISWaV+KNV+XQVOK6LU+TIJVMQSSW+RVMLJV+TLYYVUT6U^+WLQJ+IUO\VJ5+

!"'N6U_+KNJLQ^N+KL+WLQJ+TLUTSQO6LU+RVMLJV+\J6K6U^+WLQJ+LP6U6LU5+!"!]L6Z+IUO\VJO+ OVKK6U^+ MLJKN+V[KVUO6]V+ Z6OTQOO6LUO+ LM+KNV+ SI\+ 6U]LS]VZ+ LJ+

KNV+N6OKLJ6TIS+RIO6O+MLJ+KNV+SI\5+!":NVU+KNV+XQVOK6LU+6O+OQMM6T6VUKSW+IUO\VJVZ`+OKLP5+!

! 4


7/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,)-)"*)NS5NQ!9::;!)5N!*V5GOI5=OLI!P!JLI=N5J=/X*=YOJ/!

!-U+ -TKLRVJ+ ;`+ ,QWVJ+ OI\+ I+ OPVT6IS6aVZ+ ]IU+ \6KN+ I+ .-(+ &!3*+ O6 U+ KNIK+ 6UTSQZVZ+ I+KVSVPNLUV+ UQYRVJ+ IUZ+ I+ PJ6TV+ LM+ bc4E`>>>+ TION5b+ + 'NIK+ U6^NK`+ ,QWVJ+ TISSVZ+ &VSSVJ5++,QWVJ+V[PSI6UVZ+KNIK+NV+\LQSZ+NI]V+KL+RLJJL\+KNV+YLUVW+RQK+TLQSZ+^VK+6K+UV[K+\VV_5++&VSSVJ+PJL]6ZVZ+N6O+IZZJVOO+KL+,QWVJ+IUZ+KLSZ+,QWVJ`+b$M+WLQ+\IUK+KNV+]IU`+YI6S+YV+I+TNVT_+MLJ+cE>>>5++1IW+KNV+RISIUTV+RW+%L]VYRVJ+;5b++3IKVJ+KNIK+ZIW`+,QWVJ+YI6SVZ+&VSSVJ+I+cE>>>+TNVT_5+

'NV+UV[K+U6^NK`+IK+,QWVJdO+;GKN+R6JKNZIW+PIJKW`+,QWVJ+Z6OTQOOVZ+KNV+ZVIS+\6KN+$U]VOKLJ5++!MKVJ+RQW6U^+KNV+]IU`+,QWVJ+PSIUUVZ+KL+OKIJK+I+ZLTQYVUK+TLQJ6VJ+OVJ]6TV`+IUZ+NV+NIZ+OPVUK+c;4>>+LU+RQO6UVOO+TIJZO`+MSWVJO+IUZ+I+TVSSQSIJ+PNLUV5++,QWVJ+PJLeVTKVZ+I+PJLM6K+LM+

cE>`>>>+6U+KNV+M6JOK+WVIJ5++$U]VOKLJ+\IO+6YPJVOOVZ+\6KN+,QWVJdO+PSIUO+IUZ+I^JVVZ+KL+SLIU+,QWVJ+c4>`>>>+KL+RQW+KNV+]IU5+

-U+ -TKLRVJ+ 4E`+ ,QWVJ+ TISSVZ+ &VSSVJ+ KL+ P6T_+ QP+ KNV+ ]IU5+ + &VSSVJ+ JVMQOVZ+ IUZ+ OI6Z+OLYVLUV+NIZ+LMMVJVZ+N6Y+cAE`>>>+MLJ+KNV+]IU5++&VSSVJ+NIZ+ULK+TIONVZ+,QWVJdO+TNVT_+WVK5++&VSSVJ+LMMVJVZ+KL+ZVPLO6K+KNV+TNVT_+IUZ+^6]V+N6Y+KNV+]IU+6M+,QWVJ+\LQSZ+PIW+&VSSVJ+c4>`>>>+UL\+PSQO+c?>>+I+YLUKN+MLJ+4E+YLUKNO5++,QWVJ+SIQ^NVZ+IUZ+OI6Z`+b8VIN`+J6^NK5b++,QK+\6KNLQK+I+]IU`+,QWVJ+\6SS+ULK+RV+IRSV+KL+OKIJK+N6O+TLQJ6VJ+OVJ]6TV5+

$U]VOKLJ+\IUKO+KL+ N6JV+ WLQ+ KL+RV+ ,QWVJdO+ IKKLJUVW5++ $U]VOKLJ+\6SS+MQUZ+KNV+ S6K6^IK6LU+IUZ+PIW+ WLQ+ IK+ WLQJ+ NLQJSW+ JIKV5+ + $U]VOKLJ+ \IUKO+ WLQ+ KL+ JVTL]VJ+ PQU6K6]V+ ZIYI^VO+ IUZ+

IKKLJUVWdO+MVVO5++$U]VOKLJ+ZLVO+ULK+\IUK+WLQ+KL+OVKKSV+KNV+TIOV5++$U]VOKLJ+^6]VO+WLQ+I+cE>>+JVKI6UVJ+IUZ+IO_O+MLJ+YLUKNSW+QPZIKVO5+

1JVPIJV+I+YVYLJIUZQY+LM+SI\+IZZJVOO6U^+MQSSW+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+YIKKVJOf+

;5+ ,QWVJdO+PLKVUK6IS+TSI6YO+I^I6UOK+&VSSVJ+IUZ+&VSSVJdO+PLKVUK6IS+ZVMVUOVO5+45+ 8LQJ+PJLPLOVZ+I^JVVYVUK+\6KN+$U]VOKLJ+6UTSQZ6U^+IUW+VKN6TIS++TLUO6ZVJIK6LUO5+

A!


8/44

+

+

/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!Z!["38%0(%1!9::;!)(%!*+(,&-(.&$-\!!

"#$%&'(%)!*+,!

-$!#&./&!%#!0#&1!'!2'34.!(#$%&'(%!%5/&/!16)%!7/!'$!#00/&8!'((/9%'$(/8!'$.!(#$)4./&'%4#$:!

;00/&!5/!?;@!A=BC!)4D$!E#63.!$#%!7/!(#$)4./&/.!'$!#00/&8!4%!E#63.!7/!'$!4$24%'%4#$!%#!1'F/!'$!#00/&:!!G5/$!H6I/&!('33/.!A/33/&!%5'%!4)!%5/!#00/&:!

=((/9%'$(/!

;9%4#$!+!

A%'%6%/!#0!?&'6.)!5/!A;?!&/O64&/)!

%5/!*V,!$'1/!#0!9'&%4/)!%#!7/!(5'&D/.8!*\,!)4D$'%6&/!#0!9'&%4/)8!*],!)67Z/(%!1'%%/&8!*^,!%/&1)8!'$.! %5/! *Q,! 9&4(/:! !A;?!('$!7/!#2/&(#1/!7I!9'&%!9'I1/$%! '$.!9#))/))4#$!#&!419/1/$%):!! -$!%54)!(')/!%5/&/!E')!#$3I!9'&%!9'I1/$%:!!>5/&/0#&/!%5/&/!14D5%!7/!'!9I/1!E4%5!/$0#&(4$D!6$./&!A;?:!

W/%&41/$%'3!@/34'$(/!

! ?


9/44

;9%4#$!

M""! 5/! '9934('73/! 3'E!E433! 7/! %5/!M$40:! "#11:!"#./! 7K(! %54)! ('&! 4)! (#$)4./&/.!

[;;WA:!

=$%4(49'%#&I!@/96.4'%4#$! -B!U#2:!V:!

A/33/&! E433! '&D6/! %5'%! %5/&/! E')$N%! '! 2'34.! +! '$.! %5'%! %5/&/! E')! #$3I! 9&/3414$'&I!$/D#%4'%4#$):!!A!E433!'&D6/!%5'%!5/!D'2/!'!(#6$%/&!#00/&:!

W'1'D/)!

411/.4'%/3I! 0#&! %5/! &/%6&$!#0!54)!PQRRR!(5/(F!'$.!0#&!'$I!(#$)/O6/$%4'38!'(%6'38!'$.!)9/(4'3!.'1'D/):!!_#E/2/&8!H6I/&!5')!'!.6%I!%#!14%4D'%/!.'1'D/):!!-$!#&./&!%#!#7%'4$!"#$)/O6/$%4'3!W'1'D/)!A/33/&!16)%!5'2/!F$#E$!'7#6%!3#))/)!%5'%!(#63.!)%/1!0!%54)!H&/'(5:!

A9/(404(!T/&0#&1'$(/!

-0!H6I/&!.#/)$N%!E'$%!AT!5/!('$!)6/!0#&!'(%6'3!.'1'D/)8!E54(5!E#63.!7/!%5/!.400/&/$(/!4$!9&4(/!7K%!%54)!2'$!'$.!'!(#19'&'73/!#$/:!!_/!('$!'3)#!#7%'4$!)9/(4'3!.'1'D/)!E54(5!E#63.!7/!(#)%)!)%/114$D!0!7&/'(5!34F/!%41/!'$.!1#$/I!E')%/.!3##F4$D!0#&!'!$/E!2'$:!

H6I/&!E433!'&D6/!5/!E433!3#)/!PV\RR!#$!('&.)8!03I/&)8!'$.!(/33!95#$/!'$.!%5/!PQR8RRR!9%:!!A/33/&!E433!'&D6/!H!4)!$#%!/$%4%3/.!%#!%5'%!1#$/I!7K(!5/!('$!14%4D'%/:!!>5/!(#6&%!E433!9'73I! $#%! D42/! H! %5/)/! .'1'D/)! 6$3/))! %54)! 2'$! 4)! )#! 6$4O6/! %5'%! H! ('$N%! .#!76)4$/))!EK#!'$.!('$N%!04$.!'$#%5/&!#$/:!!H6I/&!14D5%!7/!'73/!%#!&/(#2/&!3#)%!9%)!0#&!54)!76)4$/))!6$%43!5/!04$.)!'$#%5/&!2'$:!

C%54('3! "#$)4./&'%4#$)! 5/!=%%#&$/I!16)%!F//9!%5/!(')/!(#$04./$%4'3!7K%!%5/!76I/&!*(34/$%,!'$.!

%5/!=%%#&$/I:!!_/!('$$#%!.4)(3#)/!'$I%54$D!'7#6%!%5/!(')/!6$3/))!(34/$%!(#$)/$%):!

>5/! -$2/)%#&! ('$! 5'2/! $#! )'I! 4$! %5/! 5'$.34$D! #0! %5/! (')/:! ! ;$3I! %5/! (34/$%! ('$:!!>5/&/0#&/8!-$2/)%#&!('$N%!%/33!%5/!3'EI/&!5/!.#/)$N%!E'$%!%5/!(')/)!)/%%3/.8!#$3I!%5/!(34/$%!('$!4$)%&6(%!%5/!B'EI/&!E5/%5/&!%#!)/%%3/:!!-$2/)%#&!4)!$#%!/$%4%3/.!%#!1#$%53I!MTW=>CA:!

T6$4%42/! W'1'D/)!


10/44

-0!1#%42'%/.!7I!?4$'$(4'3!['4$!%5/$!%5/!('9!4)!^!%41/)!(#19/$)'%#&I!#&!\!14334#$:!!-0!'$!4$%/$%4#$'3!%#&%!#&!.&6D)!#&!'3(#5#3!4$2#32/.!%5/$!%5/&/!4)!$#!('9:!!T6$4%42/!E433!$#%!7/!'33#E/.!4$!%54)!(#$%&'(%)!(')/:!

=%%#&$/IN)!0//)!


11/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,).)"*)NS5NQ!9::;!)5N!*V5GOI5=OLI!P!=LN=/!

!:N6SV+CL^^VJ`+I+WLQU^+IUZ+OQTTVOOMQS+PNWO6TIS+KNVJIP6OK`+\IO+JQUU6U^`+ONV+OI\+"LKK6V`+-\UVJdO+"ISYIK6IU+ZL^`+OKIUZ6U^+LU+KNV+PQRS6T+O6ZV\IS_+6U+MJLUK+LM+CL^^VJ5++"LKK6V+NIZ+

eQYPVZ+KNV+MLQJ+MLLK+MVUTV+KNIK+TLYPSVKVSW+VUTSLOVZ+-\UVJdO+WIJZ5++CL^^VJ+Z6Z+ULK+\IUK+KL+ZV]6IKV+MJLY+NVJ+JLQKV`+IUZ+IO+ONV+PIOOVZ+"LKK6V`+ONV+\IO+IKKIT_VZ+IUZ+R6KKVU+RW+KNV+ZL^`+TIQO6U^+SITVJIK6LUO+JVXQ6J6U^+OK6KTNVO5+

$YYVZ6IKVSW+ IMKVJ+ KNV+ IKKIT_`+ -\UVJ+ ZJL]V+ QP+ KL+ N6O+ JVO6ZVUTV5+ + -\UVJ+ V[TSI6YVZ+KJQKNMQSSWf++b"LKK6V+IUZ+$+NI]V+S6]VZ+NVJV+MLJ+M6]V+WVIJO+IUZ+"LKK6V+NIO+UV]VJ+eQYPVZ+KNIK+MVUTV+ULJ+R6KKVU+IUWLUVhb+

-\UVJ+ZJL]V+CL^^VJ+KL+/LOP6KISdO+VYVJ^VUTW+JLLY5++-U+KNV+\IW+KL+/LOP6KIS`+-\UVJ+\IO+6U]LS]VZ+6U+IU+ITT6ZVUK+TIQOVZ+RW+KNV+UV^S6^VUTV+LM+RLKN+-\UVJ+IUZ+I+NLJOVRIT_+J6ZVJ+i(6ZVJj5++CL^^VJ`+\NL+\IO+ULK+\VIJ6U^+NVJ+OVIK+RVSK`+\IO+KNJL\U+IRLQK+6U+-\UVJdO+TIJ`+IUZ+IO+I+JVOQSK`+OQMMVJVZ+OVJ6LQO+RQK+ULUDS6MVDKNJVIKVU6U^+NVIZ+6UeQJ6VO5+

CL^^VJ+\IO+ KJIUOPLJKVZ+ RW+IYRQSIUTV+ KL+/LOP6KISdO+ VYVJ^VUTW+JLLY`+\NVJV+ ONV+\IO+KJVIKVZ+ RW+ "LTKLJ + IU+ VYPSLWVV+ LM+ /LOP6KIS`+ $UT5+ + "LTKLJ+ \IO+ 6UKL[6TIKVZ+ \NVU+ NV+KJVIKVZ+CL^^VJ`+IUZ+IO+I+JVOQSK+LM+"LTKLJdO+6UKL[6TIK6LU`+NV+UV^S6^VUKSW+KJVIKVZ+CL^^VJ5+"LTKLJdO+ KJVIKYVUK+ TIQOVZ+ KNV+ ZVKVJ6LJIK6LU+ LM+ CL^^VJdO+ TLUZ6K6LU+ IUZ+ NVJ+ ZVIKN`+6UKVOKIKV`+ K\L+ \VV_O+ SIKVJ5+ + /LOP6KIS+ NIZ+ UL+ JVIOLU+ KL+ _UL\+ LM+ "LTKLJdO+ 6UKL[6TIK6LU+\NVU+NV+KJVIKVZ+CL^^VJ`+ULJ+IUW+QUM6KUVOO+LM+"LTKLJ+KL+PJITK6TV+YVZ6T6UV5+

CL^^VJ+V[PVJ6VUTVZ+OV]VJV+PI6U+IUZ+OQMMVJ6U^+MJLY+NVJ+IQKLYLR6SV+ITT6ZVUK+6UeQJ6VO+6U+KNV+ K\L+ \VV_O+ PJVTVZ6U^+ NVJ+ ZVIKN5+ + CL^^VJ+ \IO+ OQJ]6]VZ+ RW+ NVJ+ TQJJVUK+ NQORIUZ+i/QORIUZj`+\6KN+\NLY+ONV+NIZ+LUV+O6[DWVIJDLSZ+TN6SZ+i2N6SZj5+

/QORIUZ+ 6O+ KNV+ PVJOLUIS+ JVPJVOVUKIK6]V+ i1(j+ LM+ CL^^VJdO+ VOKIKV+ IUZ+JVKI6UO+ WLQJ+ SI\+M6JY+ KL+ PQJOQV+ OQJ]6]IS+ IUZ@LJ+ \JLU^MQS+ ZVIKN+ ITK6LUO+ I^I6UOK+ -\UVJ+ IUZ+ /LOP6KIS5++%V6KNVJ+(6ZVJ+ULJ+"LTKLJ+TIU+RV+SLTIKVZ5++

.SLJ6ZIdO+OQJ]6]IS+OKIKQKV`+OVTK6LU+?g5>4;`+PJL]6ZVOf+++b%L+ TIQOV+ LM+ ITK6LU+ Z6VO+ \6KN+ KNV+ PVJOLU5+ + !SS+ TIQOVO+ LM+ ITK6LU+ OQJ]6]V+ IUZ+ YIW+ RV+TLYYVUTVZ`+PJLOVTQKVZ+IUZ+ZVMVUZVZ+6U+KNV+UIYV+LM+KNV+PVJOLU+PJVOTJ6RVZ+RW+SI\5b+

.SLJ6ZIdO+:JLU^MQS+"VIKN+!TK`+OVTK6LU+BgG5;F`+PJL]6ZVOf+++b:NVU+ KNV+ ZVIKN+ LM+ I+ PVJOLU+ 6O+ TIQOVZ+ RW+ KNV+ \JLU^MQS+ ITK`+ UV^S6^VUTV555LM+ IUW+PVJOLU555KNV+ PVJOLU555i\NLj+ \LQSZ+ NI]V+ RVVU+ S6IRSV+ 6U+ ZIYI^VO+ ONISS+ RV+ S6IRSV+ MLJ+ZIYI^VO+IO+OPVT6M6VZ+6U+KN6O+ITK5b+

B!


12/44

&VTK6LU+BgG54>+PJL]6ZVOf+b'NV+ i\JLU^MQS+ ZVIKNj+ ITK6LU+ ONISS+ RV+ RJLQ^NK+ RW+ KNV+ ZVTVZVUKdO+ PVJOLUIS+JVPJVOVUKIK6]V`+\NL+ONISS+JVTL]VJ+MLJ+KNV+RVUVM6K+LM+KNV+ZVTVZVUKdO+OQJ]6]LJO+IUZ+VOKIKV+iKNVj+ZIYI^VO+OPVT6M6VZ+6U+KN6O+ITK+i\N6TN+IJVj+TIQOVZ+RW+KNV+6UeQJW+JVOQSK6U^+6U+ZVIKN5b+

2LJPLJIK6LUO+IJV+bPVJOLUOb+MLJ+KNV+PQJPLOVO+LM+KNV+:JLU^MQS+"VIKN+!TK5++

&VU6LJ+PIJKUVJ+MLJ+WLQJ+M6JY+IO_O+WLQ+KL+ZJIMK+I+SVÎS+YVYLJIUZQY+IZZJVOO6U^+VITN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+M6]V+6OOQVOf++;5+ :NIK+6O+KNV+RIO6T+Z6MMVJVUTV+RVK\VVU+KNV+TSI6YO+IOOVJKVZ+IUZ+KNV+ZIYI^VO++++++++++

JVTL]VJIRSV+6U+I+OQJ]6]IS+ITK6LU+IUZ+I+\JLU^MQS+ZVIKN+ITK6LUk++++45+ !Î6UOK+\N6TN+"VMVUZIUKiOj+ONLQSZ+I+OQJ]6]IS+ITK6LU+RV+M6SVZ`+IUZ+IÎ6UOK+\N6TN+

ONLQSZ+I+\JLU^MQS+ZVIKN+ITK6LU+RV+M6SVZk+A5+ :6KN+JVOPVTK+KL+"LKK6VlO+IKKIT_+LU+CL^^VJ`+\NIK+6O+KNV+RVOK+TSI6Y+1(+TIU+IOOVJK+

IÎ6UOK+-\UVJk++:NW+6O+KN6O+KNV+RVOK+TSI6Y+IUZ+\NIK+ZVMVUOViOj+TIU+-\UVJ+IOOVJK+IÎ6UOK+1(k+

?5+ :NIK+ZVMVUOVO+YIW+-\UVJ+IOOVJK+IÎ6UOK+1(+\6KN+JVOPVTK+KL+KNV+IQKLYLR6SV+ITT6ZVUKk+E5+ :NIK+6O+KNV+RVOK+TSI6Y+1(+TIU+IOOVJK+IÎ6UOK+/LOP6KISk++:NIK+ZVMVUOVO+YIW+

/LOP6KIS+IOOVJK+IÎ6UOK+KNV+TSI6Y`+IUZ+\NIK+6O+KNV+S6_VS6NLLZ+LM+OQTTVOO+LM+KNLOV+ZVMVUOVOk+

!+

! G


13/44

+

+

/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!9!["38%0(%1!9::;!)(%!*+(,&-(.&$-\!+

-:!!>5/!7')4(!.400/&/$(/)!7K%!%5/!(3'41)!4)!%5'%!?3#&4.'!3'E!9/&14%)!%5/!(#$%4$6'%4#$!#0!'!3'E)64%!24'! %5/! )6&242'3! )%'%6%/8! %5#6D5! %5/! 9'&%I!)6((/))42/3I!.4/):! ! >5/! /)%'%/! %5/$!('&&4/)!0#&%5! %5/!)64%! '$.! .'1'D/)! &/(#2/&/.!1'I! 4$(36./!1/.4('3! /L9/$)/)8! 3#))! #0!E'D/)! *9')%,8!a! 3#))!#0! 06%6&/! /'&$4$D)! &/.6(/.! %#!9&/)/$%!2'36/:! ! =!E$D063! ./'%5!'(%4#$!1'I! 7/! (#11/$(/.! %#!'..&/))!'! 3#))! #0! 340/! &/)63%4$D! 0! %#&%4#6)! (#$.6(%:!!A6(5!4)!#0%/$!./9/$./$%!69#$!E5/%5/&!%5/!./(/')/.!4)!)4$D3/!#&!1'&&4/.8!'!14$#&!*\Q!#&!6$./&,8!5')! )6&2424$D! 9'&/$%)!#&! (543.&/$8! 4$! %/&1)! #0!(3'41)!'$.!'E'&./.!.'1'D/):!!W'1'D/)! 1'I! 4$(36./! 3#))! #0! (#$)#&%461! 0#&! 56)7'$.! a! '! (543.8! 06%6&/! /'&$4$D)8!1/.4('3!/L9/$)/)8!06$/&'3!/L9/$)/)8!/%(:!

--:!!_6)7'$.8!#$!7/5'30!#0!%5/!/)%'%/!#0!E40/8!)5#63.!043/!'!E$D063!./'%5!'(%4#$!'D'4$)%!%5/!5#)94%'3!'$.!%5/!.#(%#&!*%5#6D5!5/!5')!$#%!7//$!3#('%/.,:!!_6)7'$.!)5#63.!'3)#!043/!)64%! 6$./&! %5/! )6&242'3! )%'%6%/! 'D'4$)%! %5/! ;E$/&! '$.! %5/! @4./&! *%5#6D5! '3)#! $#%!3#('%/.:,!

---:!!>5/!7/)%!(3'41!%5/!T@!*56)7'$.,!('$!'))/&%!'D'4$)%!;E$/&!E4%5!&/)9/(%!%#!W#%%4/N)!'%%'(F!4)!#$/!#0!)%&4(%!34'7434%I:!!?3#&4.'!3'E!9./)!%5'%!'!.#Db74%/!4)!)%&4(%!34'7434%I!0#&!%5/!#E$/&8! &/D'&.3/))! #0! E5/%5/&! .#D! 5'.! 9/$)4%I! %#! 74%/! #&! '! 54)%#&I! #0!74%4$DK24(4#6)$/)):! ! >5/&/0#&/8!#E$/&N)! )%'%/1/$%!#0! )5#(F! %#!c#DD/&! *4:/:! dW#%%4/!5')!$/2/&,!4)!4&&/3/2'$%:!!A%&4(%!B4'7434%I!E433!7/!419#)/.!'D'4$)%!;E$/&!0#&!%54)!V)%!74%/!'$.!

'$I!#%5/&!)6((/))42/!74%/!&/)63%4$D!4$!4$Z6&I:!!;E$/&N)!7/)%!./0/$)/)!'&/!*V,!%5'%!c#DD/&!E')!$/D34D/$%!7/('6)/!)5/!5'.!%5/!3')%!(3/'&!(5'$(/!%#!'2#4.!%5/!.#D!7I!./24'%4$D!'!74%!0! 5/&! %/8! I/%! )5/! '))61/.! %5/! &4)FKE')! (#$%&476%#&43I! $/D34D/$%! ')! )5/!/$(#6$%/&/.! %5/! .#D! E4330633I:! ! *\,! ;E$/&! 1'I! '3)#! '%%/19%! %#!'&D6/! %5'%! '3#$D! %54)!$/D34D/$(/8!)5/!9#F/.!%5/!.#D!%#!74%/!5/&!7I!&6$$4$D!$/'&!.#D:!!_#E/2/&8! %5D5!7#%5!#0!%5/)/!./0/$)/)!'&/!'./O6'%/!6$./&!?3#&4.'!3'E8!$/4%5/&!E433!7/!)6((/))063!4$!'33!34F/345##.!a!#E$/&!E433!7/!5/3.!)%&4(%3I!34'73/:!

-Y:!!W/0/$)/)!%5'%!#E$/&!1'I!'))/&%!'D'4$)%!%5/!T@!E4%5!&/)9/(%!%#!%5/!('&!'((4./$%!1'I!4$(36./e!!*V,![##.!A'1'&4%'$:!!;E$/&!1'I!(3'41!%5'%!5/!)5#63.!$#%!7/!34'73/!#&!54)!.'1'D/)!&/.6(/.!7K(!5/!E')!&/)(64$D!%5/!c#DD/&:!!*_#E/2/&8!#$/!1'I!'3)#!'&D6/!%5'%!

5/!5'.!'!.6%I!%#!.#!)#!D42/$!%5'%!5/!(&/'%/.!%5/!9/&43!7I!54)!.#D:,!!_4)!dD##.!)'1'&4%'$f!./0/$)/!E433! 0'438! 5#E/2/&8! 7/('6)/! ?3#&4.'! 3'E! 9./)! %5'%! #$/! 1'I! 7/! 34'73/! 0#&!;@W-U=@g!UC[B-[CU"C!4$!('&&I4$D!#6%!%5/!&/)(6/8!$#%!D))!$/D34D/$(/:!!?!%5/!D42/$! 0'(%)8! 4%! '99/'&)!;E$/&! (#114%%/.! #&.4$'&I! $/D34D/$(/! 4$! %5/! ('&! '((4./$%! a!%5/&/0#&/!E433!7/!5/3.!34'73/:!!_/!'))61/.!'!.6%I!%#!('&/!0#&!c#DD/&8!7&/'(5/.!%5'%!.6%I!E4%5!54)!$/D34D/$(/!E54(5!E')!%5/!9L41'%/K'(%6'3K"-?!#0!5/&!4$Z6&I:!!*\,!;E$/&!1'I!'3)#!'))/&%!%5/!./0/$)/!#0!*=))619%4#$!#&!&4)F,K(#$%&476%#&I!$/D34D/$(/!7/('6)/!c#DD/&!.4.!$#%!E/'&!5/&!)/'%7/3%!a!)6(5!4)!9./.!0#&!6$./&!?B!3'E!')!&'4)4$D!'!9&/)619%4#$!

F!


14/44

#0!"U:!!;E$/&!1'I!'&D6/!%5'%!c#DD/&N)!4$Z6&4/)!E/&/!$#%!('6)/.!7I!%5/!'((4./$%!4%)/30!76%! 0!%5/! &/)63%4$D! 419'(%!dE')! %5E$!'7#6%! 4$!;E$/&N)! ('&8!'$.!=A!=!@CAMB>8!)600/&/.f!4$Z6&4/):!!>54)!1'I!7/!'!24'73/!./0/$)/!0#&!%5/!96&9#)/)!#0!&/.6(4$D!;E$/&N)!34'7434%IK.'1'D/)8! ')! c#DD/&! E#63.! 7/! &/)9#$)473/! 0#&! %5/! '1#6$%! #0! 5'&1! E54(5!&/)63%/.!0!5/&!(#$%&47:!$/D3:!4$!$#%!E/'&4$D!%5/!)/'%7/3%:!!_#E/2/&8!6$3/))!c#DD/&!4)!0#6$.!%#!7/!VRRh!&/)9#$)473/8!E54(5!4)!6$34F/3I8!;E$/&!E433!)%433!7/!34'73/!a!16)%!9'I!

.'1'D/)!0#&!54)!$/D34D/$(/:!!*dH6%!0#&!54)!$/D3:8!)5/!E#63.$N%!7/!4$Z6&/.f!&/1'4$),:!!*],!;E$/&!1'I!'%%/19%!%#!'&D6/!%5'%!%5/!'((4./$%!E')!)69/&)/.4$DK4$%/&2/$4$D8!76%!%54)!E433!34F/3I!0'43!7/('6)/!4%!E')!(#193/%/3I!0#&/)//'73/:!

Y:!!T@!)5#63.!'))/&%!'!E$D063!./'%5!(3'41!'D'4$)%!%5/!_#)94%'3:!!*_/!1'I!'3)#!E4)5!%#!043/!'!$/D34D/$%! 54&4$D! (3'418! 76%! %5'%! 4)!$#%! %5/! 7/)%! (3'41:,! !_/&/! %5/! .#(%#&!E')!'$!/193#I//! #0! %5/! 5#)94%'3:! ! >5/&/0#&/8! '$! 4))6/! #0! 24('&4#6)! 34'7434%I! '&4)/)! *#&! &/):!)69/&4#&,! ')! %5/&/! 4)!'$! /193#I/&K/193#I//! &/3'%4#$)549:! ! T@!1'I!)6/!5#)94%'3! *'$.!.#(%#&8!%5#6D5!6$'2'43'73/,!0#&!%5/!D))!$/D34D/$(/!#0!4%)!/193#I//!

$/D34D/$(/! 4$! %&/'%4$D! c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c#DD/&8! 7&/'(5/.! %5'%! .6%I!7I! 54)! $/D34D/$(/! 24'! 4$%#L4('%4#$!E54(5!('6)/.!a!&/)63%/.!4$!c#DD/&N)!./'%5:!!-%!4)!'3)#!E#&%5!'&D64$D!%5'%!.#(%#&!)5#63.!7/!5/3.!%#!'!5/4D5%/$/.!)%'$.'&.8!E54(5!1'F/)!54)! 4$%#L4('%4#$!/2/$!1#&/!#0!'$!'DD&'2'%4$D!(4&(61)%'$(/! %#! %5/! 9#4$%! #0! AKB:! ! -$! '..4%4#$! %#! %5/! '0#&/1/$%4#$/.! ./0/$)/! #0! d$#!F$#E3/.D/f8!E54(5! E433! 0'43i! %5/! _#)94%'3!1'I! '&D6/! %5'%!E5/$! %5/! .#(%#&! %&/'%/.! %5/!

E#1'$!$/D34D/$%3I!E543/! 4$%#L4('%/.8! %5'%! )6(5!(#$)%4%6%/.!'$!4$%/$%4#$'3!%#&%! #&!D))!14)(#$.6(%!E54(5!)5#63.!&/1#2/!541!0!%5/!)(#9/!#0!/193#I1/$%:!!_#)94%'3!4)!$#%!34F/3I!%#!)6((//.!#$!%5/)/!1/&4%)!'$.!')!'!&/)63%!E433!7/!0#6$.!24('&:!34'73/!0#&!.'1'D/)!4$(36.4$De!!3#))!#0!(#$)#&%461!%#!56)7'$.!a!)#$8!1/.:!/L9/$)/)8!3#))!#0!06%6&/!/'&$4$D)8!06$/&'3! /L9/$)/)8! a! 9#%/$%4'3! 96$4%42/! .'1'D/)8! E54(5! 1'I! $#%! 7/! ('99/.! '%! '$I!'1#6$%!D42/$!%5'%!('9)!#$!.'1'D/)!'&/!/L(/9%/.! 0#&!%5#)/!(3'41)!E5/&/!4$%#L4('%4#$!7I!.&6D)!#&!'3(#5#3!4)!'%!4))6/:!!_#)94%'3!1'I!'%%/19%!%#!&/(#2/&!.'1'D/)!%5D5!'$!4$./1$404('%4#$!'(%4#$!'D'4$)%!%5/!.#(%#&:!

! ;>


15/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,)/)"*)NS5NQ!9::;!)5N!*V5GOI5=OLI!P!=NS/=/!

!&VU6LJ+1IJKUVJ+IO_O+WLQ`+CQU6LJ+!OOLT6IKV`+KL+ZJIMK+I+KJQOK+MLJ+&VKKSLJ`+I+.SLJ6ZI+JVO6ZVUK`+PQJOQIUK+KL+&VKKSLJdO+\6ONVO5++&VKKSLJ+TLYVO+KL+KNV+IPPL6UKYVUK+\6KN+WLQ+IUZ+KVSSO+WLQ+NV+6O+ KVJY6UISSW+ 6SS`+ IUZ+ NV+ \IUKO+ KL+ YI_V+ KNV+ KJQOK+ \N6SV+ NV+ 6O+ OK6SS+ IS6]V5+ + !TTLJZ6U^+ KL+&VKKSLJ`+NV+6O+KI_6U^+YLJPN6UV+P6SSO+MLJ+KNV+PI6U`+IUZ+NV+KI_VO+IULKNVJ+K\L+P6SSO+\N6SV+6U+KNV+LMM6TV5++/V+\6ONVO+KL+SVI]V+ISS+N6O+PJLPVJKW+6U+I+KJQOK+MLJ+N6O+K\6U+TN6SZJVU`+\NL+IJV+4E+WVIJO+LSZ`+IUZ+&VU6LJ+1IJKUVJ5++'NV+Z6]6O6LU+\6SS+RV+I+KN6JZ+i;@Aj+KL+&VU6LJ+1IJKUVJ`+I+KN6JZ+i;@Aj+KL+LUV+TN6SZ+IUZ+I+KN6JZ+i;@Aj+KL+KNV+LKNVJ+TN6SZ5++/V+6O+IMJI6Z+KNIK+N6O+K\6U+TN6SZJVU+IJV+ULK+YIKQJV+VULQ^N+KL+NIUZSV+KNV+YLUVW+IUZ+ZLVO+ULK+\IUK+KNVY+KL+NI]V+ITTVOO+KL+KNV+YLUVW+QUK6S+KNVW+IJV+E>+WVIJO+LSZ5++&VU6LJ+1IJKUVJ+\LQSZ+ISOL+JVTV6]V+NVJ+ONIJV+6U+4E+WVIJO5++!SS+KNV+PJLPVJKW+\LQSZ+RV+Z6]6ZVZ+IK+KNIK+K6YV5++&VKKSLJ+6O+\LJJ6VZ+KNIK+LUV+TN6SZ+

\6SS+SLOV+NVJ+YLUVW+KL+NVJ+NQORIUZ+6U+I+Z6]LJTV+OTNVZQSVZ+MLJ+UV[K+WVIJ+IUZ+KNV+LKNVJ+TN6SZ+\6SS+SLOV+KNV+YLUVW+\N6SV+NV+\LJ_O+KNJLQ^N+I+b^IYRS6U^+IZZ6TK6LU5b++&VKKSLJ+6O+IMJI6Z+KNIK+KNV+TN6SZJVU+\6SS+KJW+KL+RJVI_+KNV+KJQOK5+

'NV+&VKKSLJ+ISOL+\IUKO+KL+SVI]V+ULKN6U^+KL+N6O+\6MV+6U+KNV+KJQOK5++/V+\LQSZ+S6_V+WLQ+KL+RV+KJQOKVV+IUZ+KL+6U]VOK+KNV+YLUVW+6U+KNV+KJQOK5++/V+IO_O+WLQ+KL+6U]VOK+KNV+YLUVW+6U+KNV+L6S+ZJ6SS6U^+TLYPIUW+KNIK+&VU6LJ+1IJKUVJ+L\UO5++/V+KVSSO+WLQ+KNIK+N6O+6U]VOKYVUK+TLQUOVSLJ+KLSZ+ N6Y+ KNIK+ KNV+ 6U]VOKYVUK+ 6U+ KNV+ L6S+ ZJ6SS6U^+ TLYPIUW+ \IO+ V[KJVYVSW+ J6O_W5+ + "JIMK+ I+YVYL+ IZ]6O6U^+ &VU6LJ+ 1IJKUVJ+ \NVKNVJ+ IUW+ PJLRSVYO+ V[6OK+ 6U+ 6YPSVYVUK6U^+ IUW+ LM+&VKKSLJdO+\6ONVO5++

;;!


16/44

+

+

/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!]!["38%0(%1!9::;!)(%!*+(,&-(.&$-\!+

>#e!A/$4#&!T'&%$/&e!?e!!c6$4#&!=))#(4'%/!@/e!>&6)%!0#&!A/%%3#&!!M$./&!?3#&4.'!3'E!'!A/%%3#&!('$!(&/'%/!'!>&6)%!7I!%&'$)0/&&4$D!%5/!%&6)%!&/)!*9/&%I,!%#!%5/!%&6)%//!EK%5/!4$%/$%4#$!%#!(&/'%/!'! %&6)%!0#&!%5/!7/$/04%!#0!')(/&%'4$/.!7/$/04(4'&4/):!!_/&/! A/%%3#&! 4$%/$.)! %#! (&/'%/! '! %&6)%! 0#&! %5/! 7/$/04%! #0! 54)! %E4$! (543.&/$! '$.! )/$4#&!9'&%$/&:!!W/342/&I!#0!%5/!%&6)%!&/)8!EK%5/!A/%%3#&N)!4$%/$%!%#!(&/'%/!%5/!%&6)%8!%#!'!%&6)%//8!4$!%54)! (')/! A/%%3#&! E4)5/)! %5'%! -! )/&2/! ')! %&6)%//8! E#63.! (&/'%/! '! %&6)%8! '$! /L9&/))!

4$%/&242#)!%&6)%!0#&!%5/!7/$/04%!#0!)/%%3#&N)!%E4$)!'$.!)/$4#&!9'&%$/&:!

T#%/$%4'3!TI/1)!

?4&)%!40!%5/!%&6)%!&/)!4$(36./)!'$I!&/'3!9/&%I!A/%%3#&!16)%!./342/&!'!.//.!%#!%&6)%//!*1/,!)67)(&47/.!7I!%E#!E4%$/))/)8!'$.!%5/!%&6)%!'D&//1/$%!16)%!7/!4$!E&4%4$D!%#!)'%4)0I!%5/!)%'%6%/!#0!0&'6.):!!*>5/!)%'%6%/!#0!0&'6.)!&/O64&/)!%5'%!'$I!(#$%&'(%!(#$2/I4$D!'$!4$%/&/)%!4$!9/&%I!7/!4$!E&4%4$D!)4D$/.!7I!%5/!9/&)#$!%#!7/!(5'&D/.,:!

?6&%5/&1#&/8!'!A/%%3#&!16)%!5'2/!%5/!('9'(4%I!%#!(#$%&'(%!4$!#&./&!%#!(&/'%/!'!%&6)%:!!=)!4$.4('%/.!A/%%3#&!4)!(6&&/$%3I!6$./&!%5/!4$036/$(/!#0!1#&954$/!9'4$!9433)!'$.!')!)6(5!54)!

('9'(4%I! %#!(&/'%/! %5/! %&6)%!1'I! 7/!O6/)%4#$/.:! ! -0! 0#6$.! %5'%! %5/! A/%%3#&! 3'(F/.! %5/!&/O64)4%/!('9'(4%I8!%5/!%&6)%!E433!0'43!'$.!'!&/)63%4$D!%&6)%!0#&!%5/!7/$/04%!#0!%5/!A/%%3#&N)!/)%'%/!E433!7/!(&/'%/.:!

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

1'%/&4'3!96&9#)/!#0!%5/!%&6)%:!!_#E/2/&!%&6)%)!EK)9/$.%5&40%!(3'6)/)!'$.!04L/.!9/&4#.)!('$$#%!7/!%/&14$'%/.!4$!%54)!0')54#$,:!

@/D'&.4$D!A/%%3#&N)!0/'&!%5'%!#$/!(543.!E433!3#)/!5/&!1#$/I!%#!5/&!56)7'$.!4$!.42#&(/e!!"&/.4%#&)!('$!D/$/&'33I!&/'(5!'!7/$/04(4'&IN)!4$%/&/)%!4$!'!%&6)%!6$3/))!%5/!%&6)%!4$(36./)!'! )9/$.%5&40%! (3'6)/:! ! HI!'..4$D! '! )9/$.%5&40%! (3'6)/! '$I! (&/.4%#&! E433! $#%! 7/!'73/! %#!'%%'(5! %5/! 7/$/04(4'&IN)! 4$%/&/)%! 6$3/))! %5/! (&/.4%#&! 9./.! $/(/))'&4/)! %#! %5/!7/$/04(4'&I! #&! '! 0#&1/&! )9#6)/! )//F)! %#! (#33/(%! 9')%! .6/! '341#$I! #&! (543.! )699#&%!

! ;4


17/44

9'I1/$%)! '0%/&! '33! #%5/&! '2/$6/)! #0! &/(#2/&I! 5'2/! 7//$! /L5'6)%/.:! ! ?6&%5/&1#&/!7/('6)/! %5/! %&6)%!$'1/)! %5/! (543.!#$3I!')!%5/!7/$/04(4'&I8! '$.!$#%! %5/! (543.!'$.!5/&!56)7'$.8! 5/&! 4$%/&/)%! E433! 7/! (#$)4./&/.! )/9'&'%/! 9/&%I!7I! %5/! .42#&(/! (#6&%8! $#%!)67Z/(%!%#!%5/!/O64%'73/!.4)%&476%4#$!#0!1'&4%'3!9/&%I:!

@/D'&.4$D! %5/! (543.! EK%5/! D'1734$D! '..4(%4#$! )//! %5/! .4)(6))4#$! '7#2/! &/D'&.4$D!

)9/$.%5&40%!(3'6)/):!!;$(/!'D'4$!'!)9/$.%5&40%!(3'6)/!E433!9&/2/$%!%5/!(543.N)!D'1734$D!(&/.4%#&)!0!#7%'4$4$D!5/&!4$%/&/)%!4$!%5/!%&6)%:!!_#E/2/&8!#$(/!4$(#1/!#&!9&4$(49'3!4)!4$!%5/!5'$.)!#0!%5/!7/$/04(4'&I!'!(&/.4%#&!E433!7/!'73/!%#!#7%'4$!4%:!!=)!3#$D!')!%5/!9&4$(49'3!&/1'4$)! 4$! %5/! %&6)%! EK! '! 2'34.! )9/$.%5&40%! (3'6)/8! %5/&/0#&/8! %5/! (543.N)! D'1734$D!(&/.4%#&)!E433!$#%!7/!'73/!%#!&/'(5!5/&!4$%/&/)%:!

@/D'&.4$D! A/%%3#&N)! E40/8! '! )9#6)/! 5')! '! &4D5%! %#! %'F/! '$! /3/(%42/! )5'&/! 69#$! %5/!./(/./$%! )9#6)/N)! /3/(%42/! /)%'%/! /O6'3! %#! ]Rh! #0! %5/! /3/(%42/! /)%'%/:! ! T/&%I!4$(36./.8!'1#$D!#%5/&! %54$D)8!4$! '$!/3/(%42/!/)%'%/! 4$(36./)! %5/!A/%%3#&N)! 4$%/&/)%! 4$!'!@/2#('73/!-$%/&242#)!%&6)%:!

>&6)%)! '&/! 4&&/2#('73/! 6$3/))! %5/! A/%%3#&! )9/(404('33I! &/)/&2/)! %5/! &4D5%! %#!1#.40I! #&!&/2#F/!%5/!%&6)%:!!-$!%54)!(')/!A/%%3#&!5')!$#%!4$.4('%/.!%5'%!5/!E4)5/)!%#!1'4$%'4$!'!&4D5%!%#!1#.40I! #&! &/2#F/! %5/! %&6)%8! %5/&/0#&/! E4%5#6%! &/)/&24$D! )6(5! &4D5%! %5/! %&6)%! E433! 7/!4&&/2#('73/!'$.!#6%)4./!%5/!/3/(%42/!/)%'%/:!

!C%54('3!"#$)4./&'%4#$)!

M$./&! %5/! @63/)! #0! T/))4#$'3! "#$.6(%! *@T",! '$! '%%#&$/I! 1'I! $#%! /$%/&! 4$%#! '!&/9&/)/$%'%4#$!E5/&/!%5/&/!1'I!/L4)%!%5/!9#%/$%4'3!0#&!'!(#$034(%!#0!4$%/&/)%:!!-$!%54)!(')/!'! 9#%/$%4'3! (#$034(%! '&4)/)! 4$! %5'%! A/$4#&! T'&%$/&! 4)!'! 7/$/04(4'&I! %#! %5/! %&6)%):! ! C2/$!%5#6D5!)/$4#&!9'&%$/&!4)!$#%!.&'0%4$D!%5/!%&6)%!.#(61/$%)8!c6$4#&!T'&%$/&N)!'))#(4'%4#$!4$!%5/! )'1/! 04&1!')!A/$4#&!T'&%$/&!E#63.! 7/! %5/! )'1/!')! 40!A/$4#&!T'&%$/&!.&'0%/.! %5/!%&6)%:! ! >5/! 9#%/$%4'3! (#$034(%! #0! 4$%/&/)%8! 5#E/2/&8! (#63.!7/! E'42/.! 7I! A/%%3#&! 40! '0%/&!(#$)63%'%4#$!5/!(#$)/$%)!%#!%5/!&/9&/)/$%'%4#$:!

M$./&! %5/!@T"!'$!'%%#&$/I! 4)!9%/.! 0!/$%/&4$D! 4$%#! '!(#$%&'(%6'3!&/3'%4#$)549!EK'!(34/$%!6$3/))!%5/!%&'$)'(%4#$!4)!0'4&!%#!%5/!(34/$%8!%5/!'%%#&$/I!7/34/2/)!5/!('$!)%433!&/9&/)/$%!%5/!(34/$%8!'$.!%5/!(34/$%!4)!D42/$!%5/!#99#&%6$4%I!%#!(#$)63%!'$#%5/&!'%%#&$/I:!!A/%%3#&! ')F)! %5'%! %5/! %&6)%//! 4$2/)%! %5/! 1#$/I! 4$! %5/! %&6)%! 4$! A/$4#&! T'&%$/&N)! #43!(#19'$I:! !>54)! (#$)%4%6%/)!'! %&'$)'(%4#$!7K%!%5/!'%%#&$/I!A/$4#&!T'&%$/&!*4$! %5/!)'1/!04&1!')!c6$4#&!T'&%$/&,!'$.!A/%%3#&:!!A/%%3#&!E433!5'2/!%#!7/!4$0#&1/.!#0!54)!'7434%I!%#!)//F!#6%)4./!(#6$)/38!c6$4#&!T'&%$/&!16)%!&/')#$'73I!7/34/2/!%5'%!54)!&/9&/)/$%'%4#$!E433!$#%!7/!'00/(%/.!7I!%5/!%&'$)'(%4#$8!'$.!%5/!4$2/)%1/$%!%&'$)'(%4#$!16)%!7/!0'4&:!!-0!$#%!c6$4#&!

T'&%$/&!'$.!A/$4#&!T'&%$/&!E433!5'2/!24#3'%/.!%5/!@T":!

?6&%5/&1#&/!A/%%3#&!16)%!7/!4$0#&1/.!%5'%!)4$(/!%5/!4$2/)%1/$%!4$!%5/!#43!(#19'$I!4)!2/&I!&4)FI!#0!E5'%!1'I!5'99/$!6$./&!?3#&4.'! 3'E!40!%5/! 4$2/)%1/$%!4)!6$./&9.6(%42/:!!M$./&!?3#&4.'!3'E!40!'33!#0!%5/!4$2/)%1/$%)!4$!'!%&6)%!%'F/$!')!'!E5#3/!.#!$#%!9.6(/!'%!3/')%!]h!4$%/&/)%!9/&!'$61!%5/!7/$/04(4'&4/)!5'2/!'!&4D5%!%#!9'I1/$%!#0!%5/!]h!#6%!#0!%5/! %&6)%!9&4$(49'3! *]h! 4)!7')/.! #$! %5/! 0'4&!1'&F/%!2'36/! #0! %5/! %&6)%!9&4$(49'3,:! ! A4$/!A/%%3#&! 4)!'0&'4.! %5'%! %E4$)! '$.!A/$4#&! T'&%$/&!E433!D/%! %&6)%!9&4$(49'3! 7/0#&/! \Q! I/'&)!

;A!


18/44

5'2/!9'))/.!%54)!4)!'!2'34.!(#$(/&$:!!-0!%5/!#43!4$2/)%1/$%)!(#$%4$6'33I!6$./&9/&0#&1!%5/!%&6)%! (#&96)! E433! 7/! ./93/%/.:! ! W/9/$.4$D! #$! %5/! '1#6$%! #0! %5/! 2'36/! #0! %5/! %&6)%!9/&%I! 40! %54)! ('6)/)! %5/! 2'36/! %#!.! 7/3#E! PQR8RRR! %5/! %&6)%//! ('$! 9/%4%4#$! %5/!(#6&%)!%#!%/&14$'%/!%5/!%&6)%!7K(!#0!%5/!(#)%!#0!'.14$4)%&'%4#$:!!>54)!1'I!('6)/!%5/!%&6)%!%#!%/&14$'%/!7/0#&/!%5/!\QbI/'&!9/&4#.!%5/!A/%%3#&!./)4&/):!

! ;?


19/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,)-)>>5++'N6O+PJ6TV+6UTSQZVZ+I+c?>`>>>+]LSQYV+Z6OTLQUK+LMM+#IÎa6UVlO+OKIUZIJZ+IZ]VJK6O6U^+JIKV+LM+c4E`>>>+PVJ+PI^V5++#6TNIVS+NIZ+LJISSW+I^JVVZ+\6KN+2IJLS+KNIK+#IÎa6UV+\LQSZ+PSITV+I+2LYPIUW+^LSM+TSQR+LU+KNV+TL]VJ+LM+#IÎa6UVlO+

!Q^QOK+ 6OOQV`+ RQK+ KN6O+ KVJY+ \IO+ ULK+ 6UTSQZVZ+ 6U+ KNV+ MLJY+ MI[VZ+ KL+ 2IJLS5++ -UV+ LM+ KNV+OKIUZIJZ+ PJL]6O6LUO+ 6UTSQZVZ+ 6U+ KNV+ MLJY+ \IO+ I+ TIUTVSSIK6LU+ TSIQOV+ PJL]6Z6U^f+ m!U+IZ]VJK6OVJ+ SLOVO+ IUW+ ]LSQYV+ Z6OTLQUKO+ 6M+ 6K+ ZLVO+ ULK+ PQJTNIOV+ KNV+ I^JVVZ+ UQYRVJ+ LM+PI^VO5+ + 2IUTVSSIK6LU+ LM+ JVOVJ]VZ+ IZ]VJK6O6U^+ OPITV+ 6O+ KJVIKVZ+ IO+ I+ RJVITN+ LM+ KN6O+I^JVVYVUK+IUZ+\6SS+JVOQSK+6U+KNV+IZ]VJK6OVJ+PIW6U^+KNV+OKIUZIJZ+JIKV+MLJ+PI^VO+ITKQISSW+QOVZ5n+

+0PLU+JVTV6]6U^+KNV+MI[`+2IJLS+KWPVZ+K\L+IZZ6K6LUIS+KVJYO+LU+KNV+MLJY`+O6ÛVZ+6K`+IUZ+MI[VZ+6K+RIT_+KL+#6TNIVS5++'NV+IZZ6K6LUIS+KVJYO+\VJVf+!

"# #IÎa6UV+m^QIJIUKVVO+I+Y6U6YQY+T6JTQSIK6LU+LM+A>>`>>>+TLP6VO+PVJ+YLUKNn+"# #IÎa6UV+\6SS+m6YPJL]V+6KO+PNLKL^JIPNW+IUZ+TL]VJO5n++

%V6KNVJ+ #6TNIVS+ ULJ+ IUWLUV+ VSOV+ IK+ #IÎa6UV+ V]VJ+ O6 UVZ+ KNV+ MLJY+ \6KN+ 2IJLSlO+IZZ6K6LUO5++$UOKVIZ`+#6TNIVS+OVUK+2IJLS+I+MI[+OKIK6U^+#IÎa6UV+\IO+mV[KJVYVSW+PSVIOVZ+KNIK+2LYPIUW+NIO+ZVT6ZVZ+KL+eL6U+LQJ+S6OK+LM+IZ]VJK6OVJO5n++#IÎa6UV+PQRS6ONVZ+LUV+PI^V+LM+2LYPIUWlO+IZ]VJK6OVYVUK+6U+VITN+LM+#IÎa6UVlO+#IW`+CQUV`+ CQSW`+ IUZ+ !Q^QOK+ 6OOQVO5+ + 2LYPIUW+ NIZ+ OQRY6KKVZ+ KL+ #IÎa6UV+ I+ PNLKL+ LM+2LYPIUWlO+UV\VOK+^LSM+TSQR+MLJ+Z6OPSIW+LU+KNV+TL]VJ+LM+KNV+!Q^QOK+6OOQV +RQK+#IÎa6UV+JVMQOVZ+KL+PQRS6ON+KNV+PNLKL5++2LYPIUW+KNVU+OVUK+I+SVKKVJ+KL+#IÎa6UV+TIUTVS6U^+KNV+SIOK+PI^V+LM+IZ]VJK6O6U^+KNIK+2LYPIUW+NIZ+PQJTNIOVZ+6U+KNV+&VPKVYRVJ+6OOQV5++!O+JVIOLUO+

MLJ+KNV+TIUTVSSIK6LU`+2LYPIUW+T6KVZf+i;j+#IÎa6UVlO+MI6SQJV+KL+PSITV+I+2LYPIUW+TSQR+LU+KNV+ TL]VJ+ LM+KNV+ !Q^QOK+ 6OOQVo+ IUZ`+ i4j+#IÎa6UVlO+MI6SQJV+KL+6YPJL]V+ 6KO+ PNLKL^JIPNW+IUZ+TL]VJO5++++'NJLQ^N+6KO+IKKLJUVW`+2LYPIUW+ZVYIUZVZ+I+4>+PVJTVUK+JVMQUZ+LM+KNV+cGE`>>>+TLUKJITK+PJ6TV+KNIK+6K+NIZ+PJV]6LQOSW+PI6Z+KL+#IÎa6UV5++0PLU+JVTV6PK+LM+KNV+SVKKVJ+MJLY+2LYPIUWlO+IKKLJUVW`+#IÎa6UV+OVUK+2LYPIUW+IU+6U]L6TV+MLJ+c;E`>>>5++'N6O+IYLQUK+JVPJVOVUKVZ+KNV+Z6MMVJVUTV+RVK\VVU+c;>>`>>>`+KNV+TLOK+LM+KNV+MLQJ+PI^VO+LM+IZ]VJK6O6U^+ITKQISSW+QOVZ+RW+

;E!


20/44

2LYPIUW+IK+KNV+OKIUZIJZ+JIKV+LM+c4E`>>>+PVJ+PI^V`+IUZ+KNV+LJ6^6UIS+TLUKJITK+PJ6TV+LM+cGE`>>>+KNIK+2LYPIUW+ISJVIZW+NIZ+PI6Z5+++

+2LYPIUW+JVMQOVZ+KL+PIW+KNV+6U]L6TV5++2LYPIUW+TSI6YVZ+KNIK+6K+\LQSZ+RV+IROQJZ+KL+PIW+YLJV+ KNIU+ KNV+ TLUKJITK+ PJ6TV+ MLJ+ MV\VJ+ PI^VO+ LM+ IZ]VJK6O6U^+ ic;>>`>>>+ MLJ+ MLQJ+ PI^VO+JIKNVJ+KNIU+cGE`>>>+MLJ+M6]V+PI^VOj5+++

+#IÎa6UV+NIO+JVKI6UVZ+WLQ+KL+V]ISQIKV+KNV+PLOO6R6S6KW+LM+M6S6U^+OQ6K+IÎ6UOK+2LYPIUW+KL+TLSSVTK+ KNV+ c;E`>>>5+ + "6OTQOO+ KN6O+ PLKVUK6IS+ S6K6ÎK6LU+ 6UTSQZ6U + KNV+ S6_VSW+ ZVMVUOVO+ KNIK+2LYPIUW+\LQSZ+IOOVJK+IUZ+KNV+PJLRIRSV+LQKTLYV+LM+KNV+OQ6K5+

+$U+PJVPIJ6U^+WLQJ+V]ISQIK6LU+LM+#IÎa6UVlO+TIOV`+WLQ+Z6OTL]VJVZ+KNIK+2IJLS+UL+SLU^VJ+6O+VYPSLWVZ+ RW+ 2LYPIUW5+ + 8LQ+ \6ON+ KL+ TLUKITK+ 2IJLS+ KL+ Z6OTQOO+ KNV+ MITKO+ LM+ KNV+ TIOV+\6KNLQK+ LRKI6U6U^+ PVJY6OO6LU+ MJLY+ 2LYPIUWlO+ IKKLJUVW5+ + + $UTSQZV+ 6U+ WLQJ+ Z6OTQOO6LU+\NVKNVJ+WLQ+IJV+PVJY6KKVZ+KL+ZL+OL5+

! ;g


21/44

+

/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!Z!![54)!/))'I!E433!'..&/))!%5/!9#))47434%I!#0!J'D'`4$/!0434$D!)64%!'D'4$)%!"#19'$I!%#!(#33/(%!PVQ8RRR8!"#19'$4/)N!9#))473/!./0/$)/)8!'$.!%5/!9'73/!#6%(#1/:!!-%!E433!'3)#!.4)(6))!E5/%5/&!4%!4)!'99&4'%/!0#&!1/!%#!(#$%'(%!"'!EK#6%!"#19'$IN)!'%%#&$/I)!9/&14))4#$:!

?4&)%!4%!16)%!7/!./%/&14$/.!E5'%!3'E!D#2/&$)!%54)!9I/1:!!>5/!M""!.#/)!$#%!D#2/&$!7/('6)/!%5/&/!4)!$#!)'3/!#0!D##.):!!-$)%/'.8!4%!4)!'!)/&24(/)!(#$%&'(%!'$.!%5/!(#11#$!3'E!D#2/&$):!

U/L%!4%!16)%!7/!./%/&14$/.!40!'!2'34.!(#$%&'(%!/L4)%/.:!!=!(#$%&'(%!&/O64&/)!16%6'3!'))/$%!*#00/&!a!'((/9%'$(/,8!(#$)4./&'%4#$8!'$.!$#!./0/$)/):!

G5/$!J4(5'/3!0'L/.!%5/!0#&1!%#!"'&!%54)!E')!'$!#00/&:!!>5/!#00/&!(#$%'4$/.!&/3/2'$%!

%/&1)!*9&4(/8!)67Z/(%8!%41/8!/%(:! 0#&!9/&0#&1'$(/,:! !H/('6)/!%54)!4)!'!)/&24(/)!(#$%&'(%8!%5/!(#11#$!3'E!14&&!41'D/!&63/!'9934/):!!G5/$!"'!'../.!%5/!'..4%4#$'3!%/&1)8!%54)!E')!'!&/Z/(%4#$!#0!J4(5'/3N)! 4$4%4'3!#00/&!'$.!E')!'!(#6$%/&b#00/&:! !G5/$!J4(5'/3! )/$%!"'!%5/!)/(#$.!0'L8!%54)!(#63.!7/!)//$!')!'$!'((/9%'$(/!#0!"'N)!(#6$%/&b#00/&!

=$#%5/&!4))6/!4)!E5/%5/&!%5/!#&'3!'D&//1/$%!4)!4$(36./.!')!9'&%!#0!%5/!(#$%&'(%:!!>54)!./9/$.)!#$!E5/%5/&!%5/!0'L!E')!1/'$%!%#!7/!'!0633I!4$%/D&'%/.!(#$%&'(%:!!-0!4%!E')!1/'$%!%#! 7/! 0633I! 4$%/D&'%/.!

%5/!(#2/&!E')!$#%!9'&%!#0!%5/!(#$%&'(%:!

>5/&/! E')! (#$)4./&'%4#$! *./%&41/$%! %#! #$/! 9'&%I! #&! 7/$/04%! %#! %5/! #%5/&,! 7/('6)/!"#19'$I!'D&//.!%#!9'I!%5/!1#$/I!'$.!J'D'`4$/!'D&//.!%#!&6$!%5/!'.2/&%4)/1/$%):!

?4$'33I!4)!%5/!4))6/!#0!./0/$)/)!%#!%5/!(#$%&'(%:!!-0!J'D'`4$/!)6/)!"#19'$I!0#&!7&/'(5!#0!(#$%&'(%8!"#19'$I!14D5%!'&D6/! %5'%! %5/&/!E')!$#!(#$%&'(%!7/('6)/! %5/!A%'%6%/!#0!?&'6.)!*A!#0!?,!E')!$#%!)'%4)04/.:!!H6%!%5/!A!#0!?!.#/)!$#%!'993I!%#!%54)!)/&24(/)!(#$%&'(%!


22/44

"#19'$I!14D5%!'3)#!'&D6/!%5'%!4%!3/D4%41'%/3I!('$(/33/.!%5/!(#$%&'(%!'0%/&!J'D'`4$/!.4.!$#%!96734)5!%5/!D#30!(367!#$!%5/!(#2/&!76%8!')!1/$%4#$/.8!%54)!#&'3!'D&//1/$%!E')!$#%!9'&%!#0!%5/!(#$%&'(%:!

"#19'$I!14D5%!'&D6/!%5'%!%54)!E')!'!.424)473/!(#$%&'(%!)#!%5'%!4%!E#63.!#$3I!5'2/!%#!9'I!0#&! %5/! '.)! '(%6'33I! 96734)5/.:! ! =! .424)473/! (#$%&'(%! &/O64&/)! %5'%! %5/&/! 7/! '$! /O6'3!

$617/&!#0!.424)4#$)!#$!/'(5!)4./!#0!%5/!(#$%&'(%!5/!34O64.'%/.!.'1'D/)!(3'6)/!5/&/!E4338! 4$! /00/(%8! 96%! %5/! 9'&%4/)! E5/&/! %5/I! E#63.! 5'2/! 7//$! 40! "#19'$I! 5'.! $#%!7&/'(5/.:!!"#19'$I!D#%!0#6&!'.):!!>5/!'.)!E/&/!\Q+!/'(5!*./)94%/!%5/!0'(%!%5'%!4%!E')!D42/$!'!.4)(#6$%,8!)#!"#19'$I8!#E4$D!'!%#%'3!#0!VRR+8!$#E!#E/)!J'D'`4$/!VQ+:!

=!3'EI/&!1'I!$#%!)9/'F!4$!9/&)#$!%#!'!&/9&/)/$%/.!9'&%I!(#$(/&$4$D!%5/!)67Z/(%!1'%%/&!#0! 34%4D'%4#$!E4%5#6%! %5'%! 9/&)#$N)! 3'EI/&N)! 9/&14))4#$:! ! >5/! )'1/! &63/! '9934/)! E5/$!34%4D'%4#$!4)!E4%5!'!76)4$/))!/$%4%I!'$.!%5/!3'EI/&!E4)5/)!%#!)9/'F!%#!'$!/193#I//!

4)!$#!3#$D/&!E4%5!%5/!(#19'$I:!!H/('6)/!%5/!34%4D'%4#$!4)!'D'4$)%!%5/!(#19'$I!'$.!$#%!"'&!-!1'I!)9/'F!E4%5!"'!E4%5#6%!%5/!(#19'$IN)!9/&14))4#$:!

! ;G


23/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,).)>>+PVJ+WVIJ5++ +:6MV+6O+I+OKIWDIKDNLYV+YLKNVJ5++:6MV+\IO+I+OTNLLS+KVITNVJ+IUZ+VIJUVZ+cAE`>>>+PVJ+WVIJ+RVMLJV+ONV+OKLPPVZ+\LJ_6U^+IMKVJ+KNV+R6JKN+LM+&LU5+++'NV+MIY6SW+S6]VO+6U+I+YLZVOK+NLYV+\6KN+I+OYISS+YLJKÎ^V+KNIK+\IO+PQJTNIOVZ+ZQJ6U^+KNV+YIJJ6I^V+IUZ+K6KSVZ+6U+eL6UK+UIYVO5+++

+/QORIUZ+LPVUVZ+I+OKLT_+ITTLQUK+K\L+WVIJO+I^L+MJLY+YLU6VO+KNV+PIJK6VO+JVTV6]VZ+MJLY+I+KI[+JVMQUZ5++'NV+ITTLQUK+6O+UL\+\LJKN+c4>`>>>5++:6MV+NIO+c4>`>>>+LM+05&5+&I]6UÔ+,LUZO+NVJ+YLKNVJ+Î]V+NVJ+SIOK+WVIJ5+

+-UV+ZIW+/QORIUZ+TIYV+NLYV+]VJW+QPOVK+RVTIQOV+NV+SVIJUVZ+KNIK+:6MV+\IO+NI]6U^+IU+IMMI6J+\6KN+ %V6 NRLJ`+ \NVU+ KNV+ TN6SZJVU+ \VJV+ IK+ PJVOTNLLS5+ + + /QORIUZ+ PQUTNVZ+ :6MV`+RJVI_6U^+NVJ+TNVV_+RLUV+IUZ+TIQO6U^+NVJ+^JVIK+PI6U5+++&LU+\6KUVOOVZ+KNV+6UT6ZVUK5++++$U+KNV+PIOK`+/QORIUZ+IS\IWO+IT_UL\SVZ^VZ+KNIK+:6MV+\IO+I+ ^JVIK+YLKNVJ5+!MKVJ+M6UZ6U^+LQK+ IRLQK+ KNV+ IMMI6J + /QORIUZ+ UL\+ MVVSO+ NV+ ONLQSZ+ ^VK+ TQOKLZW+ LM+ KNV+ TN6SZJVU+ 6M+ I+Z6]LJTV+ 6O+ ^JIUKVZ5+ + /QORIUZ+ ZLVO+ ULK+ \IUK+ I+ Z6]LJTV5+ + $UOKVIZ`+ NV+ \IUKO+ KL+ ^L+ KL+TLQUOVS6U^+\6KN+:6MV5++:6MV+ 6O+ LPPLOVZ+ KL+ TLQUOVS6U^`+ \IUKO+ I+ Z6]LJTV`+ IUZ+ TQOKLZW+ LM+ KNV+ TN6SZJVU5+ + :6MV+

\IUKO+KL+TLUK6UQV+KL+S6]V+\6KN+KNV+TN6SZJVU+6U+KNV+YIJ6KIS+NLYV5++:6MV+ISOL+\IUKO+KL+_VVP+KNV+OI]6UÔ+RLUZO`+JVTV6]V+ISS+LM+KNV+YIJ6KIS+IOOVKO+KL+\N6TN+ONV+6O+VUK6KSVZ`+IUZ+LRKI6U+M6UIUT6IS+IOO6OKIUTV+MJLY+NVJ+/QORIUZ5++:6MV+ISOL+\IUKO+/QORIUZ+KL+PIW+MLJ+KNV+Z6]LJTV5++:6MV+TLYVO+KL+WLQJ+LMM6TV+KL+Z6OTQOO+KNV+M6S6U^+LM+I+Z6]LJTV+ITK6LU5++$ZVUK6MW+IUZ+Z6OTQOO+\6KN+:6MV+ISS+LM+KNV+PVJK6UVUK+6OOQVO+KNIK+\6SS+TLYV+QP+6U+NVJ+Z6]LJTV+ITK6LU+IUZ+6UTSQZV+WLQJ+IZ]6TV+IO+KL+NL\+VITN+LM+KNVOV+6OOQVO+\6SS+S6_VSW+RV+ZVT6ZVZ5++++$U+IZZ6K6LU+KL+KNV+Z6]LJTV+ITK6LU`+:6MV+\IUKO+KL+OQV+/QORIUZ+MLJ+PQUTN6U^+NVJ5++!Z]6OV+:6MV+IO+KL+KN6O+YIKKVJ5++"L+ULK+Z6OTQOO+IUW+PLOO6RSV+TJ6Y6UIS+PJLOVTQK6LU+LM+/QORIUZ5+

;F!


24/44

+

!/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!9![54)!1/1#&'$.61!E433!.4)(6))!G40/N)!.42#&(/!'(%4#$8!4$(36.4$D!'$I!9#%/$%4'3!(3'41)!0#&!'341#$I8!(543.!)699#&%!'$.!(6)%#.I:!! -$!'..4%4#$8!%54)!1/1#&'$.61!E433!.4)(6))!G40/N)!9#))473/!('6)/!#0!'(%4#$!'D'4$)%!_6)7'$.!&/)63%4$D!0!%5/!d96$(54$Df!4$(4./$%:!

01234567))?3#&4.'!4)!'!$#!0'63%!.42#&(/!Z6&4).4(%4#$:!!=!.42#&(/!1'I!7/!D&'$%/.!E5/&/!%5/!9'&%4/)! (#$%/$.!%5'%! %5/4&!1'&&4'D/! 4)! 4&&/%&4/2'73I!7F/$:!!_#E/2/&8!E5/&/!%5/&/!'&/!14$#&! (543.&/$!#&!E5/&/! #$/! #0! %5/! 9'&%4/)! (#$%/)%)! %5'%! %5/!1'&&4'D/! 4)! 4&&/%&4/2'73/!7F/$8!%5/!c6.D/!1'I!#&./&!%5/!9'&%4/)!%#!6$./&D#!1'&&4'D/!(#6$)/34$D:!!_/&/8!E5/&/!%5/&/!'&/!14$#&!(543.&/$!'$.!_6)7'$.!.#/)!$#%!E'$%!'!.42#&(/!%5/!c6.D/!1'I!(#$)4./&!#&./&4$D!%5/!9'&%4/)!%#!6$./&D#!(#6$)/34$D!7/0#&/!(#$%4$64$D!E4%5!%5/!W42#&(/!'(%4#$:!

018941:;9136)?88698)

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

5#1/!0#&!/O64%'73/!.4)%&476%4#$,:!!-$!#&./&!%#!/00/(%6'%/!/O64%'73/!.4)%&476%4#$8!%5/!(#6&%!16)%!04&)%!.4)%4$D64)5!DA419AB)A


25/44

1'&4%'3!06$.):!!_#E/2/&8!G40/N)!)'24$D)!7#$.)!E#&%5!P\R8RRR!'&/!'!$#$b4$%/&)9#6)'3!D40%!'$.!%56)!'&/!$#%!1'&4%'3!9/&%I!

$F3;8AB)$;FF349)

G40/!4)!&/O6/)%4$D!%5'%!_6)7'$.!9./!5/&!E4%5!04$'$(4'3!'))4)%'$(/:!!G40/!1'I!7/!/$%4%3/.!%#!=341#$I:!!-$!?3#&4.'!%5/&/!'&/!0#6&!%I9/)!#0!=341#$I:!!=341#$I!('$!7/!&/O6/)%/.!7I!/4%5/&!9'&%I!4$!'!.42#&(/!9(//.4$D:!!-$!./%/&14$4$D!E5/%5/&!%#!'E'&.!'341#$I!%5/!(#6&%!1'I!(#$)4./&!'1#$D!#%5/&!%54$D)e!

"# %5/!.6&'%4#$!#0!%5/!1'&&4'D/!

"# 'D/!#0!%5/!9'&%4/)!

"# 04$'$(4'3!$//.!

"# '.63%/&I!*5#E/2/&!$#%/!%5'%!'.63%/&I!('$$#%!7/!%5/!7')4)!0#&!'E'&.4$D!#&!./$I4$D!'341#$I!6$3/))!%5/!'.63%/&I!./93/%/.!1'&4%'3!'))/%),!

"# )%'$.'&.!#0!3424$D!.6&4$D!%5/!1'&&4'D/!

"# (#$%&476%4#$!%#!%5/!1'&&4'D/!

"# $//.!0#&!&/5'7434%'%4#$!54)!%I9/!#0!'341#$I!4)!1#.404'73/!69#$!'!)5#E4$D!#0!)67)%'$%4'3!(5'$D/!4$!(4&(61)%'$(/):!!-%!%/&14$'%/)!69#$!%5/!./'%5!#0!/4%5/&!9'&%I!#&!69#$!%5/!&/1'&&4'D/!#0!%5/!&/(494/$%!)9#6)/:!

%6DF34A4G)?B1D3/19#&'&I!'341#$I!4)!9'4.!.6&4$D!%5/!9/$./$(I!#0!34%4D'%4#$:!!j!

J;DF)$;D)?B1D3I94('33I!4%!4)!'2'43'73/!E5/&/!%5/&/!4)!'!)5#E4$D!%5'%!#$/!%5/!)9#6)/!4)!4$!433!5/'3%5!'$.!9/&1'$/$%!9/&4#.4(!'341#$I!E433!$#%!)/&2/!4%)!96&9#)/!#0!40!%5/&/!4)!/L%&/1/!5#)%434%4/)!7/%E//$!%5/!9'&%4/):!

,6>A:1B19A9126)?B1D3


26/44

'&D6/!%5'%!)5/!4)!/$%4%3/.!%#!9/&1'$/$%!9/&4#.4(!'341#$I!)4$(/!)5/!4)!/$%4%3/.!%#!&/1'4$!4$!%5/!340/)%I3/!)5/!342/.!E4%5!5/&!56)7'$.N)!)'3'&I!40!PkQ8RRR!'!I/'&:!!=!%/'(5/&N)!)'3'&I!4)!'!.&'1'%4(!(5'$D/!4$!5/&!)%'$.'&.!#0!3424$D:!!_#E/2/&8!5/&!'&D61/$%!4)!E/'F:!!>5/!1'&&4'D/!E')!&/3'%42/3I!)5#&%!*$#%!1//%4$D!%5/!3#$D!%/&1!1'&&4'D/!*Vl!I/'&),!9&/)619%4#$!0#&!%54)!%I9/!#0!'341#$I,:!!A5/!'$.!_6)7'$.!E/&/!#$3I!1'&&4/.!)4L!I/'&):!!-$!'..4%4#$8!)5/!E433!7/!&/(/424$D!&/5'7434%'%42/!'341#$I!'$.!)5/!1'I!04$.!'!Z#7!%5'%!9'I)!

1#&/!%5'$!'!%/'(5/&N)!)'3'&I:!!G40/!'3)#!E'$%)!'%%#&$/IN)!0//):!!G40/!1'I!7/!/$%4%3/.!%#!)6(5!0//)8!5#E/2/&8!5/&!'E'&.!#0!%/19#&'&I!'341#$I!1'I!'))4)%!5/&!4$!%54)!1'%%/&:!

K>1BC)K;893CG)

"543.!)699#&%!'$.!(6)%#.I!'&/!'3E'I)!./%/&14$/.!6$./&!%5/! :689)16)5>1BC))%'$.'&.:!!H#%5!9'&/$%)!'&/!&/)9#$)473/!0#&!%5/!)699#&%!#0!%5/4&!(543.&/$:!!>5/&/!4)!$#!9&/)619%4#$!4$!0'2#&!#0!'$I!9'&/$%8!_6)7'$.!#&!G40/!(#63.!7/!'E'&./.!(6)%#.I:!!=3E'I)!(#$)4./&4$D!%5/!7/)%!4$%/&/)%)!#0!%5/!(543.!%5/!(#6&%!1'I!'3)#!(#$)4./&!'1#$D!#%5/&!%54$D)!%5/!0#33#E4$De!

"# '7434%I!#0!9'&/$%!%#!9./!$/(/))4%4/)!%#!%5/!(543.!*0##.8!(3#%54$D8!)5/3%/&,!

"# ./)4&'7434%I!#0!(#$%4$64%I!

"# %5/!(543.N)!9&/0/&/$(/!*40!#0!'$!'./O6'%/!'D/!'$.!6$./&)%'$.4$D,!

"# %5/!34F/345##.!%5'%!%5/!9'&/$%!E433!(#193I!E4%5!24)4%'%4#$!'$.!0#)%/&!'!3#24$D!&/3'%4#$)549!E4%5!%5/!#%5/&!9'&/$%!

"# 04%$/))!#0!%5/!9'&/$%!

;$/!9'&/$%!E433!7/!%5/!9&41'&I!&/)4./$%4'3!9'&/$%:!!>54)!9'&/$%!E433!&/%'4$!95I)4('3!

(6)%#.I!#0!%5/!(543.&/$:!!_#E/2/&8!&/D'&.3/))!#0!E5#!7/(#1/)!%5/!9&41'&I!&/)4./$%4'3!9'&/$%!%5/!(#6&%!D/$/&'33I!#&./&)!)5'&/.!9'&/$%'3!&/)9#$)47434%I:!!>54)!1/'$)!%5'%!7#%5!9'&/$%)!5'2/!/O6'3!)'I!4$!%5/!(543.N)!1/.4('3!'$.!/.6('%4#$'3!$//.)!'$.!'((/))!%#!%5/!(543.N)!&/(#&.):!

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

7/5'24#&!E#63.!)67Z/(%!%5/!(543.!%#!5'&1:!!_/&/8!_6)7'$.!54%!G40/!4$!0$%!#0!A#$8!%56)!%5/!Z6.D/!1'I!(#$)4./&!%54)!7/5'24#&!5'&1063!*95I)4('33I!#&!/1#%4#$'33I,!%#!%5/!(543.!'$.!./$I!_6)7'$.!(6)%#.I:!

_6)7'$.!1'I!'&D6/!%5'%!G40/!4)!1#&'33I!6$04%!E5/&/!)5/!5')!(#114%%/.!'.63%/&I:!!_#E/2/&8!%54)!'&D61/$%!4)!34F/3I!%#!0'43!E5/&/!%5/&/!4)!$#!)5#E4$D!%5'%!%5/!G40/N)!7/5'24#&!4)!5'&1063!%#!%5/!(543.&/$:!!=..4%4#$'33I8!%5/!(543.&/$!E/&/!$/2/&!5#1/!E5/$!4%!5'99/$/.:!

! 44


27/44

_/&/8!%5/!(543.&/$!'&/!%##!I#6$D!0#&!%5/!(#6&%!%#!(#$)4./&!%5/4&!9&/0/&/$(/:!!G40/!E433!'3)#!'&D6/!%5'%!%5/!(543.&/$!)5#63.!)%'I!E4%5!5/&!4$!%5/!1'&4%'3!5#1/!')!%5/I!1'I!5'2/!0&4/$.)!4$!%5/!$/4D57#&5##.8!'3%5#6D5!%5/I!'&/!%##!I#6$D!%#!'&D6/!%5'%!%5/I!D#!%#!)(5##3!4$!%5/!$/4D57#&5##.:!

[/$/&'33I8!%5/!(#6&%!E433!$#%!)934%!%5/!(543.&/$!69:!!-%!4)!4$!%5/!7/)%!4$%/&/)%)!#0!%5/!(543.&/$!

%#!&/1'4$!%#D/%5/&!)4$(/!%5/I!'3E'I)!5'2/!'$.!%54)!E#63.!0#&(/!(#$%4$64%I!0#&!%5/!(543.&/$!'$.!'3)#!%54)!E#63.!'33#E!%5/!(543.&/$!%#!5'2/!/'(5!#%5/&!0#&!)699#&%:!

=3)#8!%5/!(#6&%!1'I!#&./&!W"?!%#!(#$.6(%!'$!4$2/)%4D'%4#$!'$.!1'F/!'!)6DD/)%4#$!%#!%5/!(#6&%!0#&!%5/!'E'&.!#0!(543.!(6)%#.I:!

K>1BC)$;FF349)

H#%5!9'&/$%)!5'2/!'!&/)9#$)47434%I!%#!)699#&%!%5/4&!(543.&/$:!!-$!?3#&4.'!(543.!)699#&%!4)!'E'&./.!96&)6'$%!%#!%5/!)%'%6%#&I!D64./34$/)!%'F4$D!4$%#!'((#6$%!4$(#1/!'$.!$617/&!#0!(543.&/$:!!>5/!.6%I!#0!(543.!)699#&%!(#$%4$6/)!6$%43!%5/!(543.!&/'(5/)!%5/!'D/!#0!VX!#&!('$!

(#$%4$6/!40!%5/!(543.!5')!'!.4)'7434%I!#&!4)!)%433!4$!54D5!)(5##3!0!'D/!VXbVk:!!>5/&/!4)!$#!#734D'%4#$!%#!(#$%4$6/!)699#&%!0#&!%5/!(543.&/$N)!(#33/D/!/.6('%4#$!'3%5#6D5!%5/!9'&%4/)!1'I!/L9&/))3I!'D&//:!!-$(#1/!1'I!7/!4196%/.!#$%#!'!9'&/$%!40!%5/!9'&/$%!4)!2#36$%'&43I!6$/193#I/.!#&!6$./&/193#I/.:!

=!Z6.D/!1'I!./24'%/!0!%5/!D64./34$/)!7I!Qh8!5#E/2/&!'!./24'%4#$!7/I#$.!Qh!16)%!7/!'((#19'$4/.!7I!E&4%4$D!04$.4$D)!Z6)%40I4$D!)6(5!'!./24'%4#$:!!=!Z6.D/!16)%!./24'%/!7I!Qh!40!%5/!(543.!)9/$.)!'!)4D$404('$%!'1#6$%!#0!%41/!E4%5!%5/!9'I/&!)9#6)/:!

=!(543.!)699#&%!#&./&!16)%!'3)#!(#$%'4$!'!9)4#$!9$D!1/.4('3!4$)6&'$(/!0#&!%5/!(543.&/$!40!4%!4)!&/')#$'73/!')(/&%'4$'73/:!

"543.!)699#&%!4)!1#.404'73/!69#$!'!)5#E4$D!#0!'!)67)%'$%4'3!(5'$D/!4$!(4&(61)%'$(/):!

L1=6M8)$;19)=34)NI;1


28/44

!"#$%&'()("*+#,)/)


29/44

+

+

/*K*J=*T!5I/U*N!=L!RS*/=OLI!]![5/!'$'3I)4)!#0!/'(5!9)4#$!4)!')!0#33#E)e!

T)4#$!V!

>54)! 9)4#$!9&/)/$%)! 6)!E4%5! '!?/./&'3! '$.!?3#&4.'!/)%'734)51/$%!(3'6)/!9I/1:!!A%'%/!'(%4#$!%5'%!./'3)!)#1/E'I!4$! &/34D4#$!16)%!5'2/!'!9&41'&43I!)/(63'&!96&9#)/8!4%)!#2/&'33!96&9#)/!#&!/00/(%!16)%!7/!$/4%5/&!%#!4$5474%!#&!'.2'$(/!&/34D4#$8!'$.!4%!16)%!$#%!(&/'%/!'$!/L(/))42/!/$%'$D3/1/$%!7/%E//$!&/34D4#$!'$.!D#2/&$1/$%:!!>5/!9)4#$!4)!D#4$D!%#!5'2/!9I/1)!E4%5)%'$.4$D!'!(#$)%4%6%4#$'3!'%%'(F:!!G543/!4%!'99/'&)!%#!5'2/!'!

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j1#&'3N! 3/'./&)!')! #99#)/.! %#! &/34D4#6)! 3/'./&)! 4)! Z6)%! %##!%&'$)9'&/$%:!!>5/&/!'&/!)#1/!%54$D)!%5'%!I#6!)4193I!('$N%!%'F/!%5/!&/34D4#$!#6%!#0:!!=)!)6(58! -! E#63.! '.24)/! %5/! )(5##3! 7#'&.! %5'%! %54)! 9)4#$! 4)! 34F/3I! %#! 7/! )%&6(F! ')!6$(#$)%4%6%4#$'3:! ! -%! 4)!9#))473/! %5'%! %5/!04&)%!95&')/!.4&/(%4$D!)(5##3)!%#! 9./!1#&'3!2'36/!4$)%&6(%4#$)!(#63.!7/!)/2/&/.!'$.!)%'$.b'3#$/!%5#6D5:!

T)4#$!\!

>5/!9I/1!E4%5!%54)!9)4#$!)%'&%)!E4%5!4%)!04&)%!)/$%/$(/:!!=!(5'33/$D/!%5'%!4)!34F/3I!%#!7/!&'4)/.!4)!%5'%!%54)!9)4#$!4)!2'D6/!'$.!#2/&7#'&.:!!=!9#34(I!#&!&/D63'%4#$!)5#63.!7/!(3/'&!/$#6D5!#$!4%)!0'(/!%#!96%!'!&/')#$'73/!9/&)#$!#$!$#%4(/!#0!E5'%!4)!(#2/&/.:!!_/&/8!%5/! )(5##3! '.14$4)%&'%#&)!'&/! D42/$! %#%'3! .4)(&/%4#$! 4$!./%/&14$4$D! E5#! 4)! d'%b&4)F! 0#&!24#3/$%! 7/5'24#&:f! ! -%! 4)! 34F/3I! %5'%! %54)! 9)4#$! 4)! D#4$D! %#! 7/! 5/3.! ')! 4$2'34.! ')!6$(#$)%4%6%4#$'33I!2'D6/!6$./&!/4%5/&! %5/! 0/./&'3!#&! %5/!?3#&4.'!"#$)%4%6%4#$:! ! =$#%5/&!9I/1!E4%5!%54)!9)4#$!4)!%5/!9#%/$%4'3!%5'%!)%'%/!1#$/I8!%5D5!%5/!2#6(5/&)8!E433!7/! 6)/.! 7I! %5/! 9'&/$%)! %#!9'I! '! (3/&DI9/&)#$! #&!9')%#&'3! (#6$)/3! %56)! 24#3'%4$D! %5/!

/)%'734)51/$%! (3'6)/)! #0! %5/! ?3#&4.'! '$.! ?/./&'3! "#$)%4%6%4#$):! ! M$./&! %5/! ?/./&'3!"#$)%4%6%4#$!%54)!)/%!69!4)!D#4$D!%#!7/!5/3.!#F'I:!!>5/!MA!A69&/1/!"#6&%!5')!5/3.!%5'%!%5/)/!2#6(5/&!9D&'1)!.#!$#%!24#3'%/! %5/!0/./&'3!/)%'734)51/$%!(3'6)/!7/('6)/! %5/!1#$/I!4)!D#4$D!%#!%5/!9'&/$%)!0#&!'!2'34.!D#2/&$1/$%!96&9#)/!'$.!%5'%!4%!4)!%5/!9'&/$%N)!(5#4(/!E5/&/! %5/!1#$/I! 4)! )9/$%!'$.! ')!)6(58! %5/&/! 4)!$#! 9I/1!E4%5! %5/! 0/./&'3!/)%'734)51/$%!(3'6)/:! !>5/!MA!A69&/1/!"#6&%!5')!'33#E/.!%54)! d4$.4&/(%f!D#2/&$1/$%!1#$/I! /L9/$.4%6&/)! %#! &/34D4#6)! 4$)%4%6%4#$)! #&! 9/#93/:! ! _#E/2/&8! 6$./&! %5/! ?3#&4.'!"#$)%4%6%4#$!%54)!9)4#$!4)!34F/3I!%#!0'43:!!>54)!9D&'1!4)!)4143'&!%#!%5/!)(5##3!2#6(5/&!

4E!


30/44

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

?3#&4.'!"#$)%4%6%4#$:!!=D'4$8!%5/!9)4#$!1'I!7/!'73/!%#!)%'$.!40!'!(#6&%!E/&/!%#!)/2/&!%5/!&/0/&/$(/!%#!9')%#&'3!(#6$)/3#&)!'$.!#&.'4$/.!(3/&DI!9/&)#$):!

T)4#$!]!

T)4#$! %5&//! 9&/)/$%)!6)! E4%5! '! &4D5%!#0! 9&42'(I! 4))6/! '$.! '3)#!'! ^%5! =1/$.1/$%!6$&/')#$'73/! )/'&(5! '$.! )/4`6&/! 9I/1:! ! ?4&)%8! 4%! )5#63.! 7/! $#%/.! %5'%! ?3#&4.'N)!"#$)%4%6%4#$8!6$34F/!%5/!?/./&'3!"#$)%4%6%4#$!(#$%'4$)!'$!/L9&/))!&4D5%!%#!9&42'(I:!![42/$!%54)8!'%! %41/)! %5/! ?3#&4.'! A69&/1/!"#6&%!5')! 4$%/&9&/%/.!?3#&4.'N)! &4D5%! %#!9&42'(I!')!7'./&!%5'$!%5/!0/./&'3!&4D5%:!!M$./&!%5/!0'(%)!')!9&/)/$%/.!-!E#63.!'.24)/!%5/!)(5##3!7#'&.!%5'%!%54)!9)4#$!5')!'!2/&I!D##.!(5'$(/!#0!7/4$D!695/3.:!!-!E#63.!%/33!%5/1!%54)!

7')/.!#$!%5/!0'(%!%5'%!%5/!D#2/&$1/$%!5')!'!2/&I!)4D$404('$%!4$%/&/)%!4$!4$)6&4$D!'!(543.N)!)'0/%I! '$.! 4$)6&4$D! %5'%! D#2/&$1/$%! &6$! )(5##3)! '&/! 0&//! 0! (#$%&'7'$.! '$.! %5'%!)%6./$%)!'$.!%/'(5/&)!E4%54$!%5/1!'&/!)'0/:!!=3%5#6D5!%5/!&4D5%!%#!9&42'(I!4)!D&/'%!'$.!'!06$.'1/$%'3!#$/8!-!E#63.!0//3!)'0/!%#!)'I!%5'%! %5/!D#2/&$1/$%N)!4$%/&/)%!4$!)'0/!96734(!)(5##3)!4)!(#19/334$D!/$#6D5!%#!'33#E!%54)!9)4#$!%#!)%'$.:!

^%5!=1/$.1/$%!"#$(/&$)!

?3#&4.'N)! 9%/(%4#$!'D'4$)%! 6$&/')#$'73/! D#2/&$1/$%!)/'&(5!'$.! )/4`6&/)! 5')! 7//$!4$%/&9&/%/.!%#! (#4$(4./!E4%5! %5/!0/./&'3!4$%/&9&/%'%4#$!#0! %5/!^%5!=1/$.1/$%!%#!%5/!MA!"#$)%4%6%4#$:!!=!9/&)#$!E4%5!'!&/')#$'73/!/L9/(%'%4#$!#0!9&42'(I!)5'33!$#%!7/!)/'&(5/.!E4%5#6%!'!E'&&'$%8!)67Z/(%!%#!/L(/9%4#$)8!'$.!/24./$(/!)/4`/.!4$!24#3'%4#$!#0!%54)!&4D5%!)5'33! 7/! /L(36./.! 0! (&414$'3! 9(//.4$D)! 'D'4$)%! %5/! 9/&)#$:! ! [42/$! %5'%! %5/)/!)/'&(5/)!'&/!(#$.6(%/.!'%!&'$.#1!%5/I!1'I!7/!5/3.!24#3'%42/!#0!'!)%6./$%)!&4D5%!'D'4$)%!6$&/')#$'73/! )/'&(5! a! )/4`6&/):! ! [42/$! %5'%! E/! 5'2/! D#2/&$1/$%! '(%4#$! '$.! E5'%!'99/'&)!')!'!&/')#$'73/!/L9/(%'%4#$!#0!9&42'(I8!(#$%&'7'$.!0#6$.!7I! %5/)/!)/'&(5/)!E#63.!7/!/L(36./.!6$./&!%5/!^ %5!=1/$.1/$%!4$!&/3'%/.!(&414$'3!9(//.4$D):!

-$! '338! %54)! 04$'3! 9)4#$! E#63.! 34F/3I! 7/! 695/3.! D42/$! %5/! D#2/&$1/$%N)! )4D$404('$%!4$%/&/)%!4$!)'0/%I!76%!%5/!^ %5!=1/$.1/$%!(#$(/&$)!)5#63.!7/!$#%/.:!!=..4%4#$'33I8!%5/&/!4)!'!9#%/$%4'3!%5'%!%5/!&'$.#1!)/'&(5!#0!7'(F9'(F!a!96&)/)!9)4#$!(#63.!7/!5/3.!%#!())! %5/! 34$/!'$.! 24#3'%/! %5/!)%6./$%)! &4D5%! %#!9&42'(I:! !G543/! %54)!1'I!7/8!'3%5#6D5!54D53I! 6$34F/3I8! -! 0//3! )'0/! %#! )'I! %5'%! %5/! 3#(F/&! )/'&(5! 9)4#$! E#63.! 7/! 695/3.!

&/D'&.3/))!D42/$!%5/!3#E/&!/L9/(%'%4#$!#0!9&42'(I!4$!'!)(5##3!9./.!3#(F/&:!

B=A>Bg!

G5'%!)5#63.!5'2/!7//$!.4)(6))/.!4$4%4'33I!4)!.4)(6))/.!5/&/:!!-%!4)!419#&%'$%!%#!$#%/!%5'%!'!)(5##3!7#'&.N)!'(%4#$)!E433!7/!.//1/.!d)%'%/!'(%4#$f!%5/&/7I!1'F4$D!'33!#0!%5/!'7#2/!'$'3I)4)!'9934('73/:!!=3)#8!4%!)5#63.!7/!$#%/.!%5'%!'!(#6$%IN)!'(%)!E433!7/!9&//19%/.!7I!

! 4g


31/44

%5/!?3#&4.'!"#$)%4%6%4#$!'$.!%5/!?/./&'3!"#$)%4%6%4#$!6$./&!%5/! %&'.4%4#$'3!54/&'&(5I!#0!3'E!)%&6(%6&/:!

!

!

4B!


32/44

M5N=!!OO!^!/5GMK*!GSK=OMK*^JYLOJ*!RS*/=OLI/!5IT!5I/U*N/!

!

!

1IJK+ $$+ LM+ KN6O+ PQRS6TIK6LU+ TLUKI6UO+ OIYPSV+ XQVOK6LUO+ LM+ KNV+ .SLJ6ZI+ YQSK6PSVDTNL6TV+PLJK6LU+LM+KNV+V[IY6UIK6LU5++&LYV+LM+KNV+YQSK6PSVDTNL6TV+6KVYO+LU+KNV+.SLJ6ZI+PJVPIJVZ+PLJK6LU+ LM+ KNV+ V[IY6UIK6LU+ \6SS+ 6UTSQZV+ I+ PVJMLJYIUTV+ TLYPLUVUK5+ + !PPS6TIUKO+ \6SS+ RV+JVXQ6JVZ+KL+JVIZ+IUZ+IPPSW+I+PLJK6LU+LM+ITKQIS+.SLJ6ZI+JQSVO+LM+PJLTVZQJV`+OKIKQKVO+IUZ@LJ+TLQJK+LP6U6LUO+KNIK+\6SS+RV+6UTSQZVZ+6U+KNV+KV[K+LM+KNV+XQVOK6LU5++&IYPSV+6KVYO+4;+KL+4A+IJV+ V[IYPSVO+ LM+ YQSK6PSVDTNL6TV+ 6KVYO+ \6KN+ PVJMLJYIUTV+ VSVYVUKO+ 6UTSQZVZ5+ + 'NV+XQVOK6LUO+ IUZ+ IUO\VJO+ YIW+ ULK+ RV+ JVPJ6UKVZ+ \6KNLQK+ KNV+ PJ6LJ+ \J6KKVU+ TLUOVUK+ LM+ KNV+.SLJ6ZI+,LIJZ+LM+,IJ+*[IY6UVJO5+++

'NV+IUO\VJO+IPPVIJ+LU+PI^V+?>5+

! 4G


33/44

GSK=OMK*^JYLOJ*!*V5GOI5=OLI!OI/=NSJ=OLI/!

+'NVOV+6UOKJQTK6LUO+IPPVIJ+LU+KNV+TL]VJ+LM+KNV+KVOK+RLL_SVK+^6]VU+IK+KNV+V[IY6UIK6LU5+

;5+ 'N6O+RLL_SVK+TLUKI6UO+OV^YVUKO+? +E+IUZ+g+LM+KNV+=VUVJIS+,IJ+*[IY6UIK6LU5++$K+6O+TLYPLOVZ+LM+;>>+YQSK6PSVDTNL6TV`+YITN6UVDOTLJVZ+6KVYO5++'NVOV+KNJVV+IMKVJULLU+

OV^YVUKO+NI]V+KNV+OIYV+]ISQV+IO+KNV+KNJVV+YLJU6U^+OV^YVUKO5+

45+ 'NV+PVJOLU+LU+ VITN+ O6ZV+ LM+ WLQ+ONLQSZ+NI]V+ I+RLL_SVK+\6KN+ I+Z6MMVJVUK+TLSLJVZ+TL]VJ5+1SVIOV+ZVKVJY6UV+KNIK+KNV+PVJOLU+LU+VITN+O6ZV+LM+WLQ+6O+QO6U^+I+Z6MMVJVUK+TLSLJVZ+TL]VJ5++$M+NV+LJ+ONV+6O+QO6U^+IU+V[IY6UIK6LU+PIPVJ+\6KN+KNV+OIYV+TLSLJVZ+TL]VJ`+PSVIOV+ULK6MW+I+PJLTKLJ+IK+LUTV5+

A5+ :NVU+6UOKJQTKVZ`+\6KNLQK+RJVI_6U^+KNV+OVIS`+KI_V+LQK+KNV+IUO\VJ+ONVVK5+

?5+ 0OV+I+%L5+4+PVUT6S+KL+YIJ_+LU+KNV+IUO\VJ+ONVVK5+

E5+ -U+KNV+IUO\VJ+ONVVK`+PJ6UK+WLQJ+UIYV+IO+6K+IPPVIJO+LU+WLQJ+RIZ^V`+KNV+ZIKV+IUZ+WLQJ+RIZ^V@$"+UQYRVJ5+

g5+ $U+ KNV+RSLT_+ LU+ KNV+J6^NK+ LM+ KNV+IUO\VJ+ONVVK +PJ6UK+ WLQJ+ RIZ^V@$"+ UQYRVJ+ IUZ+RSIT_VU+KNV+TLJJVOPLUZ6U^+RQRRSVO+QUZVJUVIKN5+

B5+ 'NVU+ &'-15++ "L+ ULK+RJVI_+ KNV+OVIS+QUK6S+ IZ]6OVZ+KL+ZL+OL+RW+KNV+ V[IY6UIK6LU+IZY6U6OKJIKLJ5+

G5+ 0OV+WLQJ+6UOKJQTK6LU+ONVVK+KL+TL]VJ+WLQJ+IUO\VJO5+

F5+ 'L+ MQJKNVJ+ IOOQJV+ KNV+ XQIS6KW+ LM+ MQKQJV+ V[IY6UIK6LUO`+ KN6O+ V[IY6UIK6LU+ TLUKI6UO+

OLYV+XQVOK6LUO+KNIK+IJV+RV6U^+PJVDKVOKVZ+IUZ+ZL+ULK+TLQUK+KL\IJZ+WLQJ+OTLJV5++'6YV+S6Y6KO+NI]V+RVVU+IZeQOKVZ+ITTLJZ6U^SW5+

;>5+ $U+^JIZ6U^+KNVOV+YQSK6PSVDTNL6TV+ 6KVYO`+ IU+QUIUO\VJVZ+6KVY+\6SS+RV+TLQUKVZ+ KNV+OIYV+IO+IU+6KVY+IUO\VJVZ+6UTLJJVTKSWo+KNVJVMLJV`+6K+6O+KL+WLQJ+IZ]IUKI^V+KL+YIJ_+IU+IUO\VJ+V]VU+6M+WLQ+YQOK+^QVOO5+

;;5+ #IJ_+WLQJ+IUO\VJO+KL+ISS+XQVOK6LUO+RW+YIJ_6U^+KNV+TLJJVOPLUZ6U^+OPITV+ LU+KNV+OVPIJIKV+ IUO\VJ+ONVVK5+ + #IJ_+ LUSW+ LUV+IUO\VJ+ KL+VITN+ 6KVY5++ *JIOV+ WLQJ+ M6JOK+YIJ_+TLYPSVKVSW+IUZ+YIJ_+WLQJ+UV\+TNL6TV+KL+TNIU^V+IU+IUO\VJ5+

;45+ !K+KNV+TLUTSQO6LU+LM+KN6O+OVOO6LU`+KNV+,LIJZ+\6SS+TLSSVTK+RLKN+KN6O+XQVOK6LU+RLL_SVK+IUZ+WLQJ+IUO\VJ+ONVVK5+ + $M+WLQ+TLYPSVKV+ WLQJ+ IUO\VJO+RVMLJV+ KNV+ PVJ6LZ+6O+ QP`+IUZ+YLJV+KNIU+KVU+Y6UQKVO+JVYI6U+RVMLJV+KNV+VUZ+LM+KNV+OVOO6LU`+WLQ+YIW+KQJU+6U+WLQJ+XQVOK6LU+RLL_SVK+IUZ+IUO\VJ+ONVVK+LQKO6ZV+KNV+V[IY6UIK6LU+JLLY+KL+LUV+LM+KNV+PJLTKLJO5++$M`+NL\V]VJ`+MV\VJ+KNIU+KVU+Y6UQKVO+JVYI6U`+PSVIOV+JVYI6U+IK+WLQJ+OVIK+ QUK6S+ K6YV+ 6O+ TISSVZ+ IUZ+ KNV+ ,LIJZ+ NIO+TLSSVTKVZ+ ISS+ XQVOK6LU+ RLL_SVKO+ IUZ+IUO\VJ+ONVVKO5+

4F!


34/44

;A5+ '/*&*+90*&'$-%&+ !%"+8-0(+!%&:*(&+ !(*+'/*+ 1(-1*('8+ -.+ '/*+,-!("+!%"+!(*+%-'+'-+,*+(*#-)*"+.(-#+'/*+*


35/44

9]!/5GMK*!GSK=OMK*^JYLOJ*!RS*/=OLI/!+

;5+ !MKVJ+KNV+TSLOV+LM+KNV+PSVIZ6U^O+RLKN+PSI6UK6MM+IUZ+ZVMVUZIUK+ZQSW+YIZV+YLK6LUO+MLJ+OQYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK5++:N6TN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+OKIKVYVUKO+6O+TLJJVTKk+

i!j+ &QYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK+TIU+RV+VUKVJVZ+LUSW+IMKVJ+ISS+Z6OTL]VJW+NIO+RVVU+TLYPSVKVZ5+i,j+ #LK6LU+MLJ+OQYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK+6O+KNV+PJLPVJ+YLK6LU+LU+KNV+^JLQUZ+KNIK+PSI6UK6MMdO+

TLYPSI6UK+MI6SO+KL+OKIKV+I+TIQOV+LM+ITK6LU5+i2j+&6UTV+RLKN+PIJK6VO+NI]V+M6SVZ+OQYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK+YLK6LUO+KNIK+IOOVJK+KNVJV+IJV+

UL+^VUQ6UV+6OOQVO+LM+YIKVJ6IS+MITK`+OQYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK+MLJ+PSI6UK6MM+LJ+ZVMVUZIUK+\6SS+RV+^JIUKVZ5+

i"j+ $M+PSI6UK6MMdO+PJLLMO+OQRY6KKVZ+6U+OQPPLJK+LM+N6O+YLK6LU+MLJ+OQYYIJW+eQZ^YVUK+IJV+ULK+TLUKJIZ6TKVZ+IUZ+6M+PSI6UK6MMdO+PJLLMO+ONL\+KNIK+UL+^VUQ6UV+6OOQV+LM+YIKVJ6IS+MITK+ V[6OKO`+ OQYYIJW+ eQZ^YVUK+ \6SS+ RV+ ^JIUKVZ+ V]VU+ 6M+ ZVMVUZIUKdO+ IUO\VJ+ZVU6VZ+PSI6UK6MMdO+TLYPSI6UK5+

45+ 1VKV+ &Y6KN+ 6O+ KNV+ ITK6]V+ PIJKUVJ+ IUZ+ ,6SS+ CLUVO+ 6O+ KNV+ O6SVUK+ PIJKUVJ+ 6U+ I+ ^VUVJIS+PIJKUVJON6P+_UL\U+IO+b1VKV+&Y6KN+1SQYR6U^5b++!MKVJ+O6[+WVIJO++LM+RV6U^+QU6U]LS]VZ+6U+ KNV+ YIUI^VYVUK+ LM+KNV+ PIJKUVJON6P+ RQO6UVOO`+ ,6SS+ PQJTNIOVO+ ;>>+ KL6SVKO+ MLJ+ KNV+RQO6UVOO5+ + 1VKV+ 6O+ 6UTVUOVZ+ RVTIQOV+ 6K+ \6SS+ PJLRIRSW+ KI_V+ WVIJO+ KL+ QOV+ QP+ KNV+6U]VUKLJW+LM+OL+YIUW+KL6SVKO+IUZ+OVV_O+WLQJ+IZ]6TV5++'NV+RVOK+IZ]6TV+6O+

i!j+ ,6SS+TIU+R6UZ+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P+RW+N6O+ITK5+i,j+ O6SVUK+PIJKUVJO+IJV+6U]VOKLJO+LUSW+IUZ+TIUULK+R6UZ+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P5+i2j+QUSVOO+N6O+ UIYV+6O+ 6U+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P+UIYV + KN6JZ+PVJOLUO+IJV+bLU+ULK6TVb+KNIK+

NV+6O+QUIQKNLJ6aVZ+KL+TLUKJITK+MLJ+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P5+i"j+,6SS + IO+I+ O6SVUK+ PIJKUVJ + 6O+ULK+ IQKNLJ6aVZ+KL+ PQJTNIOV+ IUZ + KNVJVMLJV + KNV+ OISV+

YIW+RV+OVK+IO6ZV5+

A5+ "VMVUZIUK+\IO+OVVU+SVI]6U^+%V6^NRLJdO+WIJZ+\6KN+%V6^NRLJdO+UV\+c;>+^IJZVU+NLOV5++%V6^NRLJ+ TISSVZ+ KNV+ PLS6TV`+ \NL+ TNIJ VZ+ "VMVUZIUK+ \6KN+ KNV+ OVTLUZDZV JVV+Y6OZVYVIULJ+ LM+ PVK6K+ KNVMK+ RW+ 6OOQ6U^+ N6Y+ I+ ULK6TV+ KL+ IPPVIJ+ 6U+ KNV+ TLQUKW+TLQJKNLQOV+LUV+\VV_+SIKVJ5+

"VMVUZIUK+ IPPVIJVZ+ IK+ KNV+ OTNVZQSVZ+ PSITV+ IUZ+ K6YV+ IUZ+ IO_VZ+ KNV+ eQZ^V+ KL+IPPL6UK+I+SI\WVJ+KL+JVPJVOVUK+N6Y5++'NV+eQZ^V+MLQUZ+"VMVUZIUK+KL+RV+6UZ6^VUK5++'NV+

eQZ^V+

i!j+ YQOK+IPPL6UK+"VMVUZIUK+I+SI\WVJ5+

i,j+ YQOK+IPPL6UK+"VMVUZIUK+I+ SI\WVJ+6M+KNV+&KIKV+OQROVXQVUKSW+TNIJ^VO+"VMVUZIUK+RW+6UMLJYIK6LU5+

i2j+UVVZ+ ULK+ IPPL6UK+ "VMVUZIUK+ I+ SI\WVJ+ 6M+ KNV+ eQZ^V+ OKIKVO+ 6U+ \J6K6U^+ KNIK+"VMVUZIUK+\6SS+ULK+^L+KL+eI6S+MLJ+YLJV+KNIU+O6[+YLUKNO+6M+TLU]6TKVZ5+

i"j+UVVZ+ ULK+ IPPL6UK+ "VMVUZIUK+ I+ SI\WVJ+ 6M+ KNV+ eQZ^V+ OKIKVO+ 6U+ \J6K6U^+ KNIK+"VMVUZIUK+\6SS+ULK+^L+KL+eI6S+IK+ISS+6M+TLU]6TKVZ5+

A;!


36/44

?5+ :N6TN+ OKIKVYVUK+ RVOK+ ZVOTJ6RVO+ KNV+ PJLM6K+ ONIJ6U^+ JVSIK6LUON6P+ LM+ I+ ^VUVJIS+PIJKUVJON6P+ \NVJV+ KNV+ PIJKUVJO+ NI]V+ I^JVVZ+ LUSW+ LU+ ]LK6U^+ PVJTVUKI^V+ IUZ+ KNV+]LK6U^+ONIJVO+IJV+QUVXQISk+

i!j+ 1IJKUVJO+ ONIJV+ 6U+PJLPLJK6LU+ KL+KNV6J+TLUKJ6RQK6LUO+ KL+KNV+ TIP6KIS+ IUZ+ IOOVKO+LM+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P5+

i,j+ 1IJKUVJO+ONIJV+6U+PJLPLJK6LU+KL+KNV6J+]LK6U^+PVJTVUKI^V5+i2j+1IJKUVJO+ONIJV+VXQISSW5+i"j+ 1IJKUVJO+TIUULK+ONIJV+QUK6S+KNVW+QUIU6YLQOSW+I^JVV+QPLU+I+Z6OKJ6RQK6LU5+

E5+ ,6SSW+\IO+TNIJ^VZ+\6KN+^JIUZ+KNVMK5++'NV+KJ6IS+RVÎU+LU+I+'NQJOZIW+IMKVJULLU5++'NV+eQJW+\IO+VYPIUVSVZ`+O\LJU+IUZ+JVSVIOVZ+MLJ+KNV+ZIW5++&6UTV+.J6ZIW+\IO+KNV+.LQJKN+LM+CQSW`+KNV+eQZ^V+IO_VZ+KNV+eQJLJO+KL+JVKQJU+LU+#LUZIW5++'NV+KJ6IS+RVÎU+IÎ6U+LU+#LUZIW+YLJU6U^+IK+GfA>5++,W+SIKV+V]VU6U^+KNV+eQZ^V+NIZ+6UOKJQTKVZ+KNV+eQJW5++"QV+KL+KNV+SIKVUVOO+LM+KNV+NLQJ`+KNV+eQJLJO+\VJV+OVXQVOKVJVZ+MLJ+KNV+V]VU6U +KL+ISSL\+KNVY+KL+^VK+IU+VIJSW+ OKIJK+KNV+UV[K+YLJU6U^5++ 'NV+ eQJLJO+JVKQJUVZ+'QVOZIW+YLJU6U^+IUZ+\VJV+ QUIRSV+ KL+JVITN+ I+]VJZ6TK5++ 0UIRSV+ KL+JVITN+I+ ]VJZ6TK +KNV+KJ6IS+eQZ^V+ ISSL\VZ+

KNV+ eQJLJO+KL+^L+NLYV+KNIK+V]VU6U^5+ + -U+:VZUVOZIW+ YLJU6U^`+KNV+eQJW+IOOVYRSVZ+IUZ+JVKQJUVZ+I+]VJZ6TK+LM+^Q6SKW5+

-U+IPPVIS`+\N6TN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+6O+,6SSWdO+OKJLU^VOK+6OOQV+MLJ+OVV_6U^+I+JV]VJOISk++

i!j+ 'NV+MITK+ KNIK+ KNV+ eQJLJO+ Z6Z+ ULK+ RV 6U+ KL+ TLUO6ZVJ+ V]6ZVUTV+ QUK6S+OV]VJIS+ ZIWO+IMKVJ+KNVW+\VJV+VYPIUVSVZ5+

i,j+ 'NV+MITK+KNIK+KNV+eQJW+\IO+ISSL\VZ+KL+^L+NLYV+IMKVJ+RV6U^+O\LJU5+i2j+ 'NV+MITK+KNIK+KNV+eQJW+KLL_+OV]VJIS+ZIWO+KL+JVKQJU+I+]VJZ6TK5+i"j+ 'NV+MITK+KNIK+KNV+eQJW+\IO+ISSL\VZ+KL+^L+NLYV+IMKVJ+KNVW+RVÎU+ZVS6RVJIK6LUO5+

+g5+ HVUZISS+IUZ+'NLJUKLU+I^JVV+KL+MLJY+I+PIJKUVJON6P +RQK+RLKN+I^JVV+KNIK+LUSW+HVUZISS+

\6SS+YIUI^V+KNV+RQO6UVOO+IUZ+YI_V+ISS+RQO6UVOO+ZVT6O6LUO+IUZ+V[VTQKV+ISS+TLUKJITKO+\6KN+ KN6JZ+ PIJK6VO5+ + !MKVJ+ KNIK+ K6YV`+ 'NLJUKLU+ KNVU+ VUKVJO+ 6UKL+ I+ SLU^DKVJY+ OVJ]6TV+TLUKJITK+ MLJ+ KNV+ PIJKUVJON6P+ \6KN+ 2SIJ_ + \NL+ ZLVO+ ULK+ _UL\+ LM+ KNV+ 6UKVJUIS+I^JVVYVUK5++'NV+TLUKJITK+LM+'NLJUKLU+\6KN+2SIJ_+6O+

i!j+ VUMLJTVIRSV`+IO+KNV+PIJKUVJOd+I^JVVYVUK+TIUULK+\6KNNLSZ+OKIKQKLJW+IQKNLJ6KW+LM+I+^VUVJIS+PIJKUVJ+KL+R6UZ+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P5+

i,j+ VUMLJTVIRSV`+IO+2SIJ_+NIO+UL+_UL\SVZ^V+LM+'NLJUKLUdO+SIT_+LM+IQKNLJ6KW5+i2j+ QUVUMLJTVIRSV`+ IO+ 'NLJUKLU+ 6O+ QUIQKNLJ6aVZ+ KL+ V[VTQKV+ KNV+ TLUKJITK+ RW+ KNV+

PIJKUVJ+I^JVVYVUK5+

i"j+QUVUMLJTVIRSV`+IO+2SIJ_+NIZ+IU+LRS6ÎK6LU+KL+TLUM6JY+'NLJUKLUdO+IQKNLJ6KW+PJ6LJ+KL+VUKVJ6U^+6UKL+I+OVJ]6TV+TLUKJITK+\6KN+KNV+PIJKUVJON6P5+

! A4


37/44

B5+ 'NV+ &KIKV+ LM+ .SLJ6ZI+ 6O+ PJLOVTQK6U^+ I+ MLJYVJ+ PLS6TV+ LMM6TVJ+ MLJ+ V[KLJK6LU+ LM+ YLUVW+MJLY+ PJLOK6KQKVO5+ + -UV+ LM+ KNV+ &KIKVdO+ \6KUVOOVO+ 6O+ &ISSW5+ + &ISSW+ NIO+ IU+ IZQSK+TLU]6TK6LU+MLJ+]VN6TQSIJ+NLY6T6ZV5++&NV+\IO+TNIJ^VZ+\6KN+ZJ6]6U^+I+TIJ+6U+I+JVT_SVOO+YIUUVJ+JVOQSK6U^+6U+KNV+ZVIKN+LM+NVJ+O6OKVJ`+I+PIOOVU^VJ+6U+KNV+TIJ5++ &ISSW+PSVIZVZ+ULSL+ TLUKVUZVJV`+ \IO+ IZeQZ6TIKVZ+ ^Q6SKW+ IUZ+ JVTV6]VZ+ I+ OQOPVUZVZ+ OVUKVUTV+ISKNLQ^N+ONV+TLQSZ+NI]V+JVTV6]VZ+I+OVUKVUTV+LM+OKIKV+6YPJ6OLUYVUK+QP+KL+E+WVIJO5++

!K+KJ6IS`+V]6ZVUTV+LM+KN6O+TLU]6TK6LU+6O+

i!j+ IZY6OO6RSV+ KL+ 6YPVITN+ &ISSW+ RVTIQOV+ ]VN6TQSIJ+ NLY6T6ZV+ TIJJ6VO+ I+ YI[6YQY+PVUISKW+6U+V[TVOO+LM+;+WVIJ5+

i,j+ 6UIZY6OO6RSV+KL+6YPVITN+&ISSW+ RVTIQOV+ ONV+UV]VJ+ IZY6KKVZ+NVJ+^Q6SK+O6UTV+ONV+VUKVJVZ+I+PSVI+LM+ULSL+TLUKVUZVJV5+

i2j+ 6UIZY6OO6RSV+KL+6YPVITN+&ISSW+RVTIQOV+ONV+JVTV6]VZ+I+OQOPVUZVZ+OVUKVUTV5+i"j+6UIZY6OO6RSV+ KL+ 6YPVITN+ &ISSW+ RVTIQOV+ ONV+ 6O+ LUSW+ I+ \6KUVOO+ IUZ+ ULK+ KNV+

TJ6Y6UIS+ZVMVUZIUK5+

G5+ !+ ZVMVUZIUK+ TNIJ^VZ+ \6KN+ M6JOKDZV^JVV+ YQJZVJ+ ONISS+ RV+ MQJU6ONVZ+ \6KN+ I+ S6OK+

TLUKI6U6U^+UIYVO+IUZ+IZZJVOOVO+LM+ISS+PJLOPVTK6]V+eQJLJO+

i!j+ QPLU+TLQJK+LJZVJ5+i,j+ QPLU+JVXQVOK5+i2j+ QPLU+JVXQVOK+IUZ+ONL\6U^+LM+^LLZ+TIQOV5+i"j+QUZVJ+UL+T6JTQYOKIUTVO5+

F5+ 2LLPVJ+ 6O+ OQ6U^+ #IJTN+ MLJ+ YLUVW+ ZIYI^VO5+ + ,VTIQOV+ NV+ RVS6V]VO+ PLJK6LUO+ LM+#IJTNdO+ ZVPLO6K6LU+ IJV+ N6^NSW+ MI]LJIRSV+ KL+ N6O+ TIOV`+ 2LLPVJdO+ IKKLJUVW+ 6UKVUZO+ KL+JVIZ+ PIJKO+LM+ KNV+ ZVPLO6K6LU+ IK+ KJ6IS+ 6UOKVIZ+ LM+TISS6U^+ #IJTN+ KL+KNV+ OKIUZ5+ + #IJTN+LReVTKO+KL+2LLPVJdO+QOV+LM+KNV+ZVPLO6K6LU+IK+KJ6IS5++:NIK+6O+KNV+TLQJKdO+S6_VSW+JQS6U^k+

i!j+ 2LLPVJ+YIW+QOV+KNV+ZVPLO6K6LU+IK+KJ6IS`+RQK`+6M+JVXQVOKVZ +NV+YQOK+JVIZ+ISS+PIJKO+KNIK+6U+MI6JUVOO+LQ^NK+KL+RV+TLUO6ZVJVZ+\6KN+KNV+PIJK+6UKJLZQTVZ5+

i,j+ 2LLPVJ+ YIW+ QOV+ KNV+ ZVPLO6K6LU+ IK+ KJ6IS + RQK+ LUSW+ KL+ TLUKJIZ6TK+ LJ+ 6YPVITN+#IJTNdO+PJ6LJ+6UTLUO6OKVUK+OKIKVYVUKO+LJ+PSVIZ6U^O5+

i2j+2LLPVJ+YIW+ULK+QOV+KNV+ZVPLO6K6LU+IK+KJ6IS`+IO+#IJTN+6O+IRSV+KL+KVOK6MW+IUZ+UL+V[TVPK6LUIS+T6JTQYOKIUTVO+V[6OK5+

i"j+2LLPVJ+ YIW+ ULK+ QOV+ KNV+ ZVPLO6K6LU+ IK+ KJ6IS + IO+ KN6O+ \LQSZ+ YI_V+ #IJTN+ N6O+\6KUVOO+IUZ+6YYQUV+KL+6YPVITNYVUK5+

AA!


38/44

;>5+ CIU+OQVO+KNV+2N6TI^L+'6YVO+MLJ+ZVMIYIK6LU+ 6U+I+.SLJ6ZI+T6JTQ6K+TLQJK5+ + !K+KJ6IS`+CIU+\6ONVO+ KL+ LMMVJ+ 6UKL+ V]6ZVUTV+ I+ TLPW+ LM+ KNV+ VZ6K6LU+ LM+ KNV+ '6YVO+ TLUKI6U6U^+ KNV+ISSV^VZSW+S6RVSLQO+IJK6TSV5++,VMLJV+KNV+UV\OPIPVJ+YIW+RV+IZY6KKVZ`+CIU+YQOK+

i!j+ TISS+ IO+ I+ \6KUVOO+ IU+ VYPSLWVV+ LM+ KNV+ '6YVO+ KL+ KVOK6MW+ KNIK+ KNV+ PJLMMVJVZ+UV\OPIPVJ+\IO+6U+MITK+PQRS6ONVZ+RW+KNV+'6YVO5+

i,j+ NI]V+ I+ TVJK6M6TIK6LU+ IMM6[VZ+ KL+ KNV+ UV\OPIPVJ+ O6^UVZ+ RW+ IU+ VYPSLWVV+ LM+ KNV+'6YVO+IKKVOK6U^+KL+6KO+IQKNVUK6T6KW5+

i2j+VOKIRS6ON+KNIK+KNV+UV\OPIPVJ+NIO+RVVU+PJLPVJSW+TVJK6M6VZ+QUZVJ+KNV+SI\+LM+KNV+eQJ6OZ6TK6LU+\NVJV+KNV+UV\OPIPVJ+\IO+PQRS6ONVZ5+

i"j+ ZL+ULKN6U^+RVTIQOV+KNV+UV\OPIPVJ+6O+OVSMDIQKNVUK6TIK6U^5+

;;5+"VMVUZIUK+\IO+IJJVOKVZ+LU+.VRJQIJW+;+IUZ+JVSVIOVZ+LUV+YLUKN+SIKVJ+LU+#IJTN+;+IMKVJ+RV6U^+TNIJ^VZ+\6KN+I+MVSLUW5++-U+"VTVYRVJ+;+LM+KNV+OIYV+WVIJ+IO+N6O+IJJVOK`+NV+ M6SVZ+ I+ YLK6LU+ KL+ Z6OTNIJ^V+O6UTV+ UL+ KJ6IS+ LJ+ LKNVJ+ ITK6LU+ NIZ+ LTTQJJVZ+ KL+ KNIK+PL6UK5++'NV+TLQJK+NVSZ+I+NVIJ6U^+A+ZIWO+IMKVJ+KNV+YLK6LU+\IO+M6SVZ5++"VMVUZIUK+ONLQSZ+RV+

i!j+ Z6OTNIJ VZ+RVTIQOV+YLJV+ KNIU+;BE+ZIWO+PIOOVZ+RVK\VVU+IJJVOK+IUZ+KNV+ M6S6U^+LM+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+Z6OTNIJ^V5+

i,j+ Z6OTNIJ VZ+RVTIQOV+YLJV+KNIU+;BE+ZIWO+PIOOVZ+RVK\VVU+N6O+JVSVIOV+MJLY+eI6S+IUZ+KNV+M6S6U^+LM+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+Z6OTNIJ^V5+

i2j+ RJLQ^NK+KL+KJ6IS+\6KN6U+F>+ZIWO+LM+KNV+M6S6U^+LM+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+Z6OTNIJ^V5+i"j+ RJLQ^NK+KL+KJ6IS+\6KN6U+;>+ZIWO+LM+KNV+NVIJ6U^+LU+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+Z6OTNIJ^V5+

;45+,6SS +I+O6U^SV+YIU`+L\UVZ+PIOKQJV+SIUZ+6U+"VVJ\LLZO`+.SLJ6ZI`+\N6TN+NV+SVIOVZ+KL+I+KVUIUK5++/V+ISOL+L\UVZ+I+TLUZLY6U6QY+6U+#6IY6`+\N6TN+NV+NVSZ+MLJ+6U]VOKYVUK5++$U+N6O+\6SS +NV+ZV]6OVZ+KNV+PIOKQJV+SIUZ+KL+N6O+OLU+'LYYW+IUZ+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY+KL+N6O+ZIQ^NKVJ+CQS6V5++!SS+LKNVJ+IOOVKO+\LQSZ+PIOO+VXQISSW+KL+'LYYW+IUZ+CQS6V5+

,6SS+ YVK+ HIKNW+ IUZ+ YIJJ6VZ+ NVJ+ IMKVJ+ ONV+ V[VTQKVZ+ I+ ]IS6Z+ PJVUQPK6IS+ I^JVVYVUK+JVS6UXQ6ON6U^+ISS+J6^NKO+ONV+Y6^NK+LKNVJ\6OV+VUeLW+RW+YIJJW6U^+,6SS5++-U+KNV6J+#6IY6+NLUVWYLLU+KNVW+ZJL]V+RW+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY+IUZ+HIKNW+ZVTSIJVZ+ONVdZ+SL]V+KL+S6]V+KNVJV5+ + ,6SS+ \IO+ OL+ NIPPW+ \6KN+ HIKNW+ KNIK+ IMKVJ+ KNV+ NLUVWYLLU+ NV+ O6 UVZ+ IUZ+ZVS6]VJVZ+KL+HIKNW+I+ZVVZ+TLU]VW6U^+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY+KL+N6YOVSM+IUZ+HIKNW+IO+IU+VOKIKV+RW+KNV+VUK6JVKW+IUZ+YIZV+PSIUO+KL+S6]V+6U+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY+IO+OLLU+IO+KNV+KVUIUK+]ITIKVZ5++,6SS+Z6VZ+KNV+UV[K+ZIW5++/L\+IJV+KNV+MLJV^L6U^+IOOVKO+Z6OKJ6RQKVZk+

+

! A?


39/44

i!j+ HIKNW+ ^VKO+ KNV+ TLUZLY6U6QY+ JVÎJZSVOO+ LM+ KNV+ PJVUQPK6IS+ I^JVVYVUK + 'LYYW+KI_VO+KNV+PIOKQJV+SIUZ+IUZ+'LYYW+IUZ+CQS6V+OPS6K+KNV+JVOK+LM+KNV+VOKIKV5+

i,j+ "QV+ KL+HIKNWdO+ PJVUQPK6IS+ I^JVVYVUK`+ 'LYYW+JVTV6]VO+KNV+ PIOKQJV+ SIUZ`+CQS6V+^VKO+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY+IUZ+'LYYW+IUZ+CQS6V+OPS6K+KNV+JVOK+LM+KNV+VOKIKV5+

i2j+ HIKNW+^VKO+KNV+TLUZLY6U6QY +RQK+RVTIQOV+,6SS+NIZ+LJ6^6UISSW+6UZ6TIKVZ+N6O+6UKVUK+KL+ ZV]6OV+ VXQISSW+ KL+ N6O+ TN6SZJVU`+ 'LYYW+ IUZ+ CQS6V+ \6SS+ OPS6K+ KNV+ JVYI6U6U^+

VOKIKV5+i"j+ (VÎJZSVOO+LM+KNV+PJVUQPK6IS+I^JVVYVUK +HIKNW+6O+I+PJVKVJY6KKVZ+OPLQOV5++&6UTV+

,6SS+ SVI]VO+ OQJ]6]6U^+ S6UVIS+ ZVOTVUZIUKO+ \NL+ IJV+ ULK+ HIKNWdO`+ HIKNW+ JVTV6]VO+E>p+LM+KNV+VOKIKV`+'LYYW+^VKO+KNV+PIOKQJV+SIUZ`+IUZ+'LYYW+IUZ+CQS6V+OPS6K+KNV+JVO6ZQV+LM+KNV+VOKIKV5+

;A5+!UZVJOLU+ IUZ+ 1IJ_VJ+ ZVT6ZV+ KL+ MLJY+ I+ TLJPLJIK6LU+ \N6TN+ \6SS+ SLTIKV+ Y6OO6U^+TN6SZJVU5++:N6TN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+\LQSZ+RV+I+PJLPVJ+UIYV+MLJ+KNV+TLJPLJIK6LUk+

i!j+ !%"*(&-%+i,j+ .,$+2LUOQSKIUKO`+$UTLJPLJIKVZ+

i2j+1J6]IKV+*WV+1IJKUVJO+i"j+2N6SZ+.6UZVJ+2LYPIUW+

;?5+!K+ KJ6IS + ZQJ6U + KNV+ PSI6UK6MMdO+ TIOVD6UDTN6VM + KNV+ PSI6UK6MM+ TISSVZ+ IO+ I+ \6KUVOO+ KNV+YIUI^6U^+I^VUK+LM+KNV+ZVMVUZIUK+TLJPLJIK6LU`+\NL+\IO+KNVU+O\LJU+6U+IUZ+KVOK6M6VZ5++"VMVUOV+ TLQUOVS+ LReVTKVZ+ KL+ KNV+ PSI6UK6MMdO+ XQVOK6LUO+ V6KNVJ+ IO+ SVIZ6U + LJ+ IO+6YPVITN6U^+KNV+\6KUVOO5++$U+JQS6U^+LU+KNV+LReVTK6LUO`+KNV+KJ6IS+TLQJK+ONLQSZ++

i!j+ OQOKI6U+ ISS+ KNV+ LReVTK6LUO+ IUZ+ JVXQ6JV+ KNV+ PSI6UK6MM+ KL+ PQJOQV+ KN6O+ KWPV+ LM+6UKVJJLÎK6LU+LUSW+ZQJ6U^+KNV+PSI6UK6MMdO+TJLOODV[IY6UIK6LU+LM+KN6O+\6KUVOO+ZQJ6U^+KNV+ZVMVUZIUKdO+TIOVD6UDTN6VM5+

i,j+ OQOKI6U+ KNV+ SVIZ6U^+ XQVOK6LU+ LReVTK6LUO+ RQK+ L]VJJQSV+ KNV+ LKNVJ+ LReVTK6LUO+RVTIQOV+I+PIJKW+6O+ULK+PVJY6KKVZ+KL+IO_+SVIZ6U^+XQVOK6LUO+LM+N6O+L\U+\6KUVOO+IK+KJ6IS5+

i2j+OQOKI6U+KNV+6YPVITNYVUK+XQVOK6LUO+RQK+L]VJJQSV+KNV+LKNVJ+LReVTK6LUO+RVTIQOV+I+PIJKW+6O+ULK+PVJY6KKVZ+KL+6YPVITN+N6O+L\U+\6KUVOO+IK+KJ6IS5+

i"j+L]VJJQSV+ISS+ KNV+ LReVTK6LUO+ RVTIQOV+KNV+ \6KUVOO+ 6O+IZ]VJOV+KL+ KNV+ PSI6UK6MM+ IUZ+KNVJVMLJV+ YIW+ RV+ 6UKVJJLÎKVZ+ RW+ SVIZ6U^+ XQVOK6LUO+ IUZ+ OQReVTKVZ+ KL+6YPVITNYVUK5+

;E5+ (I6URL\+ 2LJPLJIK6LU+ NIO+ LQKOKIUZ6U^+ ;`>>>+ ONIJVO+ LM+ ]LK6U + TLYYLU+ OKLT_+ IUZ+;`>>>+ ONIJVO+ LM+ ULU]LK6U^+ PJVMVJJVZ5+ + 'NV+ PJVMVJJVZ+ NIO+ I+ S6XQ6ZIK6LU+ PJVMVJVUTV+VXQIS+KL+ 6KO+ PIJ+]ISQV+LM+ c;>>+PVJ+ ONIJV+PSQO+I+ A+PVJTVUK+ULUTQYQSIK6]V+Z6]6ZVUZ5++

(I6URL\+ OQRY6KO+ KL+ 6KO+ OKLT_NLSZVJO+ I+ PJLPLOIS+ KL+ IQKNLJ6aV+ I+ UV\+ TSIOO+ LM+PJVMVJJVZ+OKLT_+\6KN+JVZVYPK6LU+J6^NKO+KNIK+\LQSZ+TLYV+INVIZ+LM+KNV+LSZ+PJVMVJJVZ+OKLT_5++!K+I+ONIJVNLSZVJOd+YVVK6U^`+B>>+TLYYLU+IUZ+?>>+PJVMVJJVZ+]LKV+6U+MI]LJ+LM+KNV+PJLPLOIS5++:N6TN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+OKIKVYVUKO+6O+TLJJVTKk+

AE!


40/44

i!j+ 'NV+PJLPLOIS+6O+]IS6ZSW+IPPJL]VZ+RVTIQOV+L]VJISS+I+ YIeLJ6KW+LM+ KNV+LQKOKIUZ6U^+ONIJVO+Z6Z+IPPJL]V5+

i,j+ 'NV+ PJLPLOIS+ 6O+ 6U]IS6ZSW+ IPPJL]VZ+ RVTIQOV+ I+ YIeLJ6KW+ LM+ KNV+ PJVMVJJVZ+ONIJVNLSZVJO+Z6Z+ULK+IPPJL]V5+

i2j+'NV+ ]LKV+ LM+ KNV+ PJVMVJJVZ+ OKLT_NLSZVJO+ ZLVO+ ULK+ YIKKVJ+ RVTIQOV+ 6K+ \IO+ULU]LK6U^+OKLT_5+

i"j+'NV+ PJLPLOIS+ 6O+6U]IS6ZSW+ IPPJL]VZ+RVTIQOV+I+ K\LDKN6JZO+]LKV+ LM+VITN+TSIOO+6O+JVXQ6JVZ5+

;g5+,LR+:6SOLU+RLJJL\VZ+c4>`>>>+MJLY+'VZ+3IYIJ+KL+LPVU+I+NIJZ\IJV+OKLJV5++'VZdO+LUSW+6UKVJVOK+6U+KNV+RQO6UVOO+\IO+KNV+JVPIWYVUK+LM+N6O+EDWVIJ+QUOVTQJVZ+SLIU5++,LR+\IO+ OL+ ^JIKVMQS+ MLJ+ KNV+ SLIU+ KNIK+ NV+ UIYVZ+ N6O+ RQO6UVOO+ b:6SOLU+ IUZ+ 3IYIJ+/IJZ\IJVb+ IUZ+ PQJTNIOVZ+ O6^UO+ IUZ+ IZ]VJK6O6U^+ Z6OPSIW6U^+ KN6O+ UIYV5+ + /V+ ISOL+S6OKVZ+,LR+:6SOLU+IUZ+'VZ+3IYIJ+IO+bPIJKUVJOb+LU+N6O+OKIK6LUVJW5++:NVU+'VZ+MLQUZ+LQK`+NV+\IO+MSIKKVJVZ+KL+KNV+PL6UK+KNIK+NV+]LSQUKIJ6SW+JVZQTVZ+,LRdO+6UKVJVOK+JIKV+MJLY+F+PVJTVUK+KL+G+PVJTVUK+PVJ+IUUQY5+++

!+MV\+\VV_O+SIKVJ`+1VKV+&Y6KN`+\NL+NIZ+IOOQYVZ+KNIK+RLKN+:6SOLU+IUZ+3IYIJ+\VJV+LPVJIK6U^+KNV+NIJZ\IJV+OKLJV+IUZ+\IO+ULK+MIY6S6IJ+\6KN+KNV+KJQV+O6KQIK6LU`+OLSZ+^LLZO+KL+ :6SOLU+ IUZ+ 3IYIJ+ /IJZ\IJV5+ + 1VKV+ &Y6KN+ NIO+ RVVU+ QUIRSV+ KL+ TLSSVTK+ MLJ+ KNV+^LLZO+IUZ+NV+OVV_O+WLQJ+IZ]6TV5++8LQJ+IZ]6TV+KL+1VKV+6O+

i!j+ LUSW+,LR+:6SOLU+6O+S6IRSV5+i,j+ ,LR+:6SOLU+IUZ+'VZ+3IYIJ+IJV+S6IRSV+eL6UKSW5+i2j+,LR+:6SOLU+6O+S6IRSV+MLJ+KNV+VUK6JV+IYLQUK+IUZ+'VZ+3IYIJ+6O+S6IRSV+LUSW+KL+KNV+

V[KVUK+KNV+ZVRK+TIUULK+RV+TLSSVTKVZ+MJLY+,LR+:6SOLU5+i"j+LUSW+KNV+ZV+MITKL+PIJKUVJON6P+IJ6O6U^+MJLY+KNV+JVSIK6LUON6P+RVK\VVU+:6SOLU+IUZ+

3IYIJ+6O+S6IRSV5+

;B5+!K+ KNV+ TSLOV+ LM+ ISS+ KNV+ V]6ZVUTV+ 6U+ I+ eQJW+ KJ6IS + "VMVUZIUK+ YL]VO+ MLJ+ I+ Z6JVTKVZ+]VJZ6TK5++!MKVJ+YQTN+IJ^QYVUK`+KNV+TLQJK+ZVU6VO+KNV+YLK6LU5++&QROVXQVUKSW +KNV+eQJW+JVKQJUO+I+]VJZ6TK+MLJ+1SI6UK6MM5+

'NV+ZIW+IMKVJ+KNV+eQJW+JVKQJUO+6KO+]VJZ6TK`+KNV+TLQJK+VUKVJO+eQZ^YVUK+MLJ+1SI6UK6MM5++-UV+\VV_+SIKVJ`+"VMVUZIUK+YL]VO+KL+OVK+IO6ZV+KNV+]VJZ6TK+IUZ+NI]V+eQZ^YVUK+VUKVJVZ+6U+ITTLJZIUTV+ \6KN+ 6KO+ YLK6LU+ MLJ+ Z6JVTKVZ+ ]VJZ6TK5+ + $U+ KNV+ YLK6LU`+ "VMVUZIUK+ JI6OVO+IJ^QYVUKO+KNIK+\VJV+ULK+JI6OVZ+IK+KJ6IS5++1SI6UK6MMdO+TLQUOVS+LReVTKO+KL+KNV+TLQJK+V]VU+NVIJ6U^+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+OVK+IO6ZV+KNV+]VJZ6TK5++&NLQSZ+KNV+TLQJK+TLUO6ZVJ+KNV+YLK6LUk+

i!j+ 8VO`+RVTIQOV+"VMVUZIUK+NIO+JI6OVZ+UV\+^JLQUZO5+

i,j+ 8VO + RVTIQOV+ "VMVUZIUK+ NIZ+KVU+ZIWO+IMKVJ+ KNV+ eQJW+ JVKQJUVZ+6KO+]VJZ6TK+\6KN6U+\N6TN+KL+YL]V+KL+OVK+IO6ZV+KNV+]VJZ6TK5+

i2j+%L`+ RVTIQOV+ KNV+ TLQJK+ ZVU6VZ+ KNV+ YLK6LU+ MLJ+ Z6JVTKVZ+ ]VJZ6TK+ JIKNVJ+ KNIU+JVOVJ]6U^+JQS6U^5+

i"j+%L`+RVTIQOV+KNV+TLQJK+VUKVJVZ+M6UIS+eQZ^YVUK+MLJ+1SI6UK6MM+RVMLJV+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+OVK+IO6ZV+KNV+]VJZ6TK+\IO+M6SVZ5+

! Ag


41/44

;G5+$U+ KNV+ IROVUTV+ LM+ I+ PJL]6O6LU+ KL+ KNV+ TLUKJIJW+ 6U+ KNV+ IJK6TSVO+ LM+ 6UTLJPLJIK6LU`+ KNV+Z6JVTKLJO+LM+I+TLJPLJIK6LU+VSVTKVZ+MLJ+I+OPVT6M6VZ+KVJY+

i!j+ TIU+RV+JVYL]VZ+MJLY+LMM6TV+IK+I+YVVK6U^+LM+KNV+ONIJVNLSZVJO`+RQK+LUSW+MLJ+TIQOV+IUZ+IMKVJ+IU+LPPLJKQU6KW+KL+RV+NVIJZ+NIO+RVVU+^6]VU+KL+KNV+Z6JVTKLJO5+

i,j+ TIU+RV+ JVYL]VZ+ MJLY+ LMM6TV+ IK+I+ YVVK6U^+ LM+KNV+ ONIJVNLSZVJO`+ \6KN+ LJ+\6KNLQK+

TIQOV5+i2j+TIU+ RV+ JVYL]VZ+ MJLY+ LMM6TV+ IK+ I+ YVVK6U^+ LM+ KNV+ ONIJVNLSZVJO`+ RQK+ LUSW+ MLJ+

TIQOV5+i"j+ TIU+RV+JVYL]VZ+MJLY+LMM6TV+PJ6LJ+KL+KNV+V[P6JIK6LU+LM+KNV6J+KVJY+LUSW+RW+I+ZVTJVV+

LM+KNV+T6JTQ6K+TLQJK+6U+IU+ITK6LU+RW+KNV+ONIJVNLSZVJO5+

;F5+#IJW`+I+\VISKNW+&K5+1VKVJORQJ^+\6ZL\`+V[VTQKVZ+NVJ+M6JOK+IUZ+LUSW+\6SS+LU+#IW+;E`+;FF>+ IUZ+ Z6VZ+ LU+ !Q^QOK+;G`+ ;FF>5+ + /VJ+\6SS+ PJL]6ZVZ+ KNIK+ NVJ+ VOKIKV+ RV+ Z6]6ZVZ+VXQISSW+RVK\VVU+NVJ+LUSW+TN6SZ`+CLIU`+IUZ+KNV+&IS]IK6LU+!JYW+LM+3IJ^L5++/L\+\6SS+#IJWdO+VOKIKV+ITKQISSW+RV+Z6OKJ6RQKVZk+

i!j+ ;>>p+KL+CLIU5+i,j+ ;>>p+ KL+ CLIU+ 6M+ ONV+ M6SVO+ I+ K6YVSW+ PVK6K6LU+ JVXQVOK6U^+ KNIK+ KNV+ ZV]6OV+ KL+ KNV+&IS]IK6LU+!JYW+RV+I]L6ZVZ5+

i2j+ E>p+KL+CLIU+IUZ+E>p+KL+KNV+&IS]IK6LU+!JYW5+i"j+ E>p+KL+CLIU+IUZ+KNV+6UTLYV+MJLY+KNV+JVYI6U6U^+E>p+KL+CLIU+MLJ+S6MV`+JVYI6UZVJ+

KL+KNV+&IS]IK6LU+!JYW`+6M+CLIU+M6SVO+I+K6YVSW+PVK6K6LU+PJLKVOK6U^+KNV+ZV]6OV+KL+KNV+&IS]IK6LU+!JYW5+

4>5+ (V^IJZ6U^+I+ZVPLO6K6LU+6U+I+T6]6S+OQ6K`+\N6TN+LM+KNV+MLSSL\6U^+6O@IJV+KJQVk+

++$5+ !+ZVPLO6K6LU+LM+I+ PVJOLU+I^I6UOK+ \NLY+IULKNVJ+PVJOLU+TLUKVYPSIKVO+M6S6U^+IU+ITK6LU+YIW+RV+TLYPVSSVZ+RW+KNV+PIJKW+TLUKVYPSIK6U^+KNV+ITK6LU`+\6KNLQK+SVI]V+LM+TLQJK`+RVMLJV+KNV+ITK6LU+6O+M6SVZ5+

+$$5+ !+ZVPLO6K6LU+LM+KNV+ZVMVUZIUK+6U+IU+ITK6LU+YIW+RV+KI_VU+RW+KNV+PSI6UK6MM+\6KNLQK+OVJ]6TV+LM+I+OQRPLVUI+LU+KNV+ZVMVUZIUK5+

$$$5+ !+ZVPLO6K6LU+YIW+RV+KI_VU+V]VU+KNLQ^N+ISS+ KNV+KVOK6YLUW+OVTQJVZ+RW+6K+\6SS+RV+6UIZY6OO6RSV+IK+KNV+KJ6IS5+

+i!j+ $$+LUSW5+i,j+ $+IUZ+$$+LUSW5+i2j+$$+IUZ+$$$+LUSW5+i"j+$`+$$`+IUZ+$$$5+

+

AB!


42/44

/5GMK*!GSK=OMK*^JYLOJ*!RS*/=OLI/!UO=Y!M*N"LNG5IJ*!=*/=!JLGMLI*I=!!

!OOQYV+ MLJ+ 9QVOK6LUO+ 4;+ D+ 4A+ KNIK+ MLSSL\6U + OKIKQKVO+ IUZ+ TIOV+ NLSZ6U^+ IJV+TLUKJLSS6U^+SI\+6U+.SLJ6ZIf+

"#$%&'(!/.(.0.36!;_C:ZZ!!!U>3%3!(4.&$-6!,(1!83!83E0-C!!TK6LUO+ONISS+RV+RJLQ^NK+LUSW+6U+KNV+TLQUKW+\NVJV+KNV+ZVMVUZIUK+JVO6ZVO`+\NVJV+ KNV+ TIQOV+ LM+ITK6LU+ ITTJQVZ + LJ+ \NVJV+ KNV+ PJLPVJKW+ 6U+ S6K6ÎK6LU+ 6O+SLTIKVZ5+

"#$%&'(! /.(.0.36! ;_C:9Z! ! 54.&$-6! (E(&-6.! '3A3-'(-.6! %36&'&-E! &-!'&AA3%3-.!4$0-.&36C!!TK6LUO+IÎ6UOK+K\L+LJ+YLJV+ZVMVUZIUKO+JVO6Z6U^+6U+Z6MMVJVUK+TLQUK6VO+YIW+RV+RJLQ^NK+6U+IUW+TLQUKW+6U+\N6TN+IUW+ZVMVUZIUK+JVO6ZVO5+

['%/)! 2:! A%6((#! "#&9f+ + 'NV+ IPPVSSVV+ TLUKVUZVZ+ KNIK+ RVTIQOV+ KNV+

ZVMVUZIUKO+\VJV+JVO6Z6U^+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW+IK+KNV+K6YV+KNV+TIQOV+LM+ITK6LU+ITTJQVZ`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`+IUZ+ULK+IO+LM+KNV+K6YV+LM+KNV+ITTJQIS+LM+KNV+TIQOV+LM+ITK6LU5+

4;5+1IWUV+6O+I+JVO6ZVUK+LM+"IZV+2LQUKW`+.SLJ6ZI+IUZ+\IO+6U]LS]VZ+6U+I+TIJ+ITT6ZVUK+6U+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW`+.SLJ6ZI5++1IWUV+OQROVXQVUKSW+M6SVZ+I+TLYPSI6UK+IÎ6UOK+,JWIUK+IUZ+"I]6O+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW+ISSV^6U^+KNIK+KNVW+UV^S6^VUKSW+LPVJIKVZ+KNV6J+TIJO+JVOQSK6U^+6U+PVJYIUVUK+6UeQJ6VO+KL+1IWUV5++!K+KNV+K6YV+LM+KNV+ITT6ZVUK`+,JWIUK+IUZ+"I]6O+\VJV+RLKN+JVO6ZVUKO+LM+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW5++!K+KNV+K6YV+KNV+TLYPSI6UK+\IO+M6SVZ`+"I]6O+NIZ+YL]VZ+IUZ+\IO+S6]6U^+6U+"Q]IS+2LQUKW`+.SLJ6ZI5++,JWIUK+M6SVZ+I+YLK6LU+KL+KJIUOMVJ+KNV+ITK6LU+KL+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW5++:NIK+ITK6LU+ONLQSZ+KNV+TLQJK+KI_Vk+

i!j+ =JIUK+KNV+YLK6LU+RVTIQOV+KNV+TIQOV+LM+ITK6LU+ITTJQVZ+6U+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW5+i,j+ =JIUK+ KNV+ YLK6LU+ RQK+ ISSL\+ 1IWUV+ KL+ OVSVTK+ V6KNVJ+ ,JL\IJZ+ 2LQUKW+ LJ+ "Q]IS+

2LQUKW5+i2j+ "VUW+KNV+YLK6LU+RVTIQOV+1IWUV+JVO6ZVO+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW5+["j+ "VUW+KNV+YLK6LU+6M+"I]6O+TLUOVUKO+KL+]VUQV+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW5!

445+!OOQYV+MLJ+KN6O+XQVOK6LU+LUSW+KNIK+"I]6O+YL]VZ+KL+"IZV+2LQUKW+IMKVJ+KNV+ITT6ZVUK+IUZ+\IO+JVO6Z6U^+6U+KNIK+TLQUKW+IK+KNV+K6YV+KNV+TLYPSI6UK+\IO+M6SVZ+RW+1IWUV5++:NIK+ITK6LU+ONLQSZ+KNV+TLQJK+KI_V+6U+JVOPLUOV+KL+I+YLK6LU+KL+KJIUOMVJ+KL+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW+RW+,JWIUKk+

!

! AG


43/44

i!j+ =JIUK+KNV+YLK6LU+RVTIQOV+KNV+TIQOV+LM+ITK6LU+ITTJQVZ+6U+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW5+i,j+ =JIUK+KNV+YLK6LU+RQK+LUSW+6M+"I]6O+TLUOVUKO+KL+KNV+KJIUOMVJ+KL+,JL\IJZ+2LQUKW5+i2j+ "VUW+KNV+YLK6LU+RVTIQOV+1IWUV+JVO6ZVO+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW5+i"j+ "VUW+KNV+YLK6LU+RVTIQOV+"I]6O+JVO6ZVO+6U+"IZV+2LQUKW5+

4A5+!OOQYV+MLJ+KN6O+XQVOK6LU+LUSW+KNIK+KNV+KJ6IS+TLQJK+^JIUKVZ+KNV+YLK6LU+KL+KJIUOMVJ+IUZ+

KNV+ ITK6LU+ RJLQ^NK+ RW+ 1IWUV+ \IO+ KJIUOMVJJVZ+ KL+ ,JL\IJZ+ 2LQUKW5+ + :NL+ 6O+JVOPLUO6RSV+MLJ+PIWYVUK+LM+KNV+OVJ]6TV+TNIJ^V+LM+KNV+TSVJ_+LM+KNV+TLQJK+KL+\N6TN+KNV+ITK6LU+\IO+KJIUOMVJJVZk+

i!j+ ,JWIUK+LUSW+IO+KNV+PIJKW+\NL+YL]VZ+MLJ+KNV+KJIUOMVJ5+i,j+ ,JWIUK+IUZ+"I]6O+IO+KNV+ZVMVUZIUKO+6U+KNV+ITK6LU5+i2j+ 1IWUV+LUSW+IO+KNV+PIJKW+\NL+TLYYVUTVZ+KNV+ITK6LU5+i"j+ 2SVJ_+LM+KNV+2LQJK+MLJ+"IZV+2LQUKW+IO+KNV+KJIUOMVJJ6U^+eQJ6OZ6TK6LU5+

AF!


44/44

5I/U*N!`*Q!"LN!GSK=OMK*^JYLOJ*!RS*/=OLI/+

+

R036.&$-!!! J$%%34.!!!I0,83%!! 5-673%!!

+

+ +;+ i"j+

+ +4+ i!j+

+ +A+ i"j+

+ +?+ i2j+

+ +E+ i"j+

+ +g+ i,j+

+ +B+ i!j+

+ +G+ i,j+

+ +F+ i!j+

+++ ;>+ i"j+

+++ ;;+ i"j+

+++ ;4+ i!j+

+++ ;A+ i"j++++ ;?+ i"j+

+++ ;E+ i,j+

+++ ;g+ i,j+

+++ ;B+ i,j+

+++ ;G+ i,j+

+++ ;F+ i2j+

+++ 4>+ i2j+

+ 4;+ i,j+

+ 44+ i"j+

Documents

2004 Florida Bar Exam Q&A