17.09.12 - Item 4(iv)(b) - 485 - Perth and Kinross

>.;$&&$&)!'+(" V &*$%%&)%$166 V <FBKJHMLFMQ NG SFIJDRKBOBDDFPP BME BKQFOBQJNMP QN CNRMEBOU TBKK BQ -KBJOJMHNMF.IRODI# 7BJM =QOFFQ# -KBJOJMHNMF# /NKKBO# 15&' *8A

;6,88482 /0.4=498 89>4.0 !14-2;./. 14

+6621-+49<8 8;,3188154# 8// 6+0/8 (**$)%%"

<0;9<> 91 3,8/6482 !14-2;./. 14 +6621-+49<8

8;,3188154# 8// 6+0/8 )%&$)&%"

<010<08.0 /9.?708>= !6+79 14-2;./. 14

+6621-+49<8 8;,3188154# 8// 6+0/8 )&&$)&'"

'!JS"!C"0*.#$$#$'!%(&"

413

414

q��

��

e��

��

c�

e�

��t

��

e��

��

� o

�O

fe

k��HR

X

fOe

��

�

e

��

��

G

d�

��

��

��

� t

��

��

�O

l��

��

Md��

��

�� q

��

�Md

��

��

M

�

� e

��

��

��

Mlz

RS Y

mr

u��\

QRTYT Y

YSTYS

q��

��

��

� b

��

�� b

��

��

��M

c��

��

��

� d

��

��M

n�

�� t

��

�M c

��

��

��

�O

mp

db

ujp

oq

mb

oO

RWQT

Od

OQT

R[R

QMQ

QQ

� � � � �

WZWS

QQ�

WZW

SQQ

�

WZW

TQQ

�W

ZWT

QQ�

WZW

UQQ

�W

ZWU

QQ�

WZW

VQQ

�W

ZWV

QQ�

WZW

WQQ

�W

ZWW

QQ�

WZW

XQQ

�W

ZWX

QQ�

WZW

YQQ

�W

ZWY

QQ�

WZW

ZQQ

�W

ZWZ

QQ�

WZX

QQQ

�W

ZXQ

QQ�

WZX

RQQ

�W

ZXR

QQ�

WZX

SQQ

�W

ZXS

QQ�

WZX

TQQ

�W

ZXT

QQ�

WZX

UQQ

�W

ZXU

QQ�

WZX

VQQ

�W

ZXV

QQ�

WZX

WQQ

�W

ZXW

QQ�

WZX

XQQ

�W

ZXX

QQ�

WZX

YQQ

�W

ZXY

QQ�

t��

��

c��

��

��

�

q��

��

��

qx

r�

��

�

t�

��

l��

�H�

d�

��

��

g�

��

t��

��

l�

��

�

d�

��

��

n��

x�

��

c��

�

c��

��

�� x

��

�

x�

��

c��

��

��

c��

��

��

j��

��

j��

��

j��

j��

�

x

j��

�

t��

��

j��

t��

��

j��

��

t��

��j�

��

�

j��

�

c��

��

��

��

g�

��

d��

��

�x

��

��

�

g��ô�

��

c��

��

��

��

d�

��

��

�

c��

��

��

��

��

n�

��

�

c��

��

��

��

c��

��

x��

��

c��

��

��

��

d��

��

�

m�

��

��

��

x�

��

��

c��

�� n

��

�

s��

��

YY

�

ZT�

VW

�

ZX�

RQR

�

RRT

�

XU�

RRQ

�

RRV

�

UV

�

RRV�

YV�

YV

�

YV

�

YV�

m�

��

� q

��

O

ROR

QMQ

QQ

QR

QQ

UQ

Q

ROR

QQ

QQ

��

��O

RV

Q

SQQ

TQ

QV

QQ

RQQ

Q

PFQ

B

415

f��

��

� c

O If

��J

R[V

Q

f��

��

� b

O It

��

��J

R

[VQ

s�

��

��

�O

bO

fe

M Q

XPQ

SPR

Xq

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

M�

��

��

� ��

��

� �

��

��

��

O

bZ

XX

d��

��

��

��

��

��

�O

��

��

� �

��

��

��

YOT

V

XOT

Y

YOU

Z

YOW

V

q��

��

e��

�� c

�e

��

t��

e��

��

� o

�O

fe

k��HR

X

fOe

��

�

e

��

��

G

d

��

��

��

� t

��

��

�O

l��

��

Md��

��

�� q

��

�Md

��

��

M �

� e

��

��

��

Mlz

RS

Ymr

u��\

QRTYT Y

YSTYS

q��

��

b��

�� b

��

��

�M

c��

��

��

� d

��

��M

n��

t��

��M

c��

��

��

��

O

fy

jtu

joh

cm

pd

lq

mb

oG

fy

jtu

joh

fm

fw

bu

jpo

tO

RW

QTO

dOQ

UR[S

QQ

R[V

Q

� � � � �

f��

��

c��

�� q

��O

R[S

QQ

Q

R

S

T

U

V

W

X

Y

Z

RQ

RV

SQ

TQ

UQ

VQ

QR

ST

UV

RQ

t��

��

��

��O

R[V

Q

t��

��

� �

��

��O R

[SQQ

��

��

� �

��

��

�O

��

��

��

��

��O

��

��

� �

��

��O

416

'(/*), /0$0(+(,0

.63<;8>=6>B ?7 (E;AB;>8 169;4C<3@ $446AA#

-3@B '6=?<;B;?> 3>5 (@64B;?>

?7 0D? /64B;?>A ?7 %?C>53@F 23<<

3B 7?@=6@ %<3;@;>8?>6 -3@;A9 &9C@49

%<3;@;>8?>6

/LLHF@?JO. 8M 9BFH 6FJJBHH

/DBJO. B[ ? ;R]cYJ][RLT

+,[M

;NK[^J[b +)*0

417

%#$ 5JOMKAP@OFKJ

*'* GQR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] R\ \^KVR]]NM RW \^YYX[] XO Y[XYX\JU\ Kb B[ CNRU @RWWNUU XO D[XORUN D[XSNL]\ A]M

OX[ ]QN YJ[] MNVXUR]RXW XO J YX[]RXW XO ]QN KX^WMJ[b `JUU JWM N[NL]RXW XO J YX[]RXW XO KX^WMJ[b `JUU J]

]QN OX[VN[ DJ[R\Q 7Q^[LQ J] 6UJR[RWPXWN' GQN Y[XYX\JU\ J[N J\\XLRJ]NM `R]Q ]QN [NJURPWVNW] XO ]QN

_NQRLÛJ[ JLLN\\ J] R]\ S^WL]RXW `R]Q ]QN \R]N JWM ]QN 5200 JRVNM J] RVY[X_RWP [XJM \JON]b' GQN OX[VN[

7Q^[LQ K^RUMRWP R\ 7J]NPX[b �7� AR\]NM' 5\ J [N\Û] ]QN KX^WMJ[b `JUU R\ UR\]NM Kb J\\XLRJ]RXW'

*'+ DXURLb DB+ XO ]QN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW +)*- JM_R\N\ ]QJ] Y[XYX\JU\ `QRLQ J[N

LXW\RMN[NM ]X JOONL] ]QN LQJ[JL]N[ JWM(X[ JYYNJ[JWLN XO J AR\]NM 6^RUMRWP `RUU [NZ^R[N ]X KN \^YYX[]NM

Kb J MN\RPW \]J]NVNW]' GQR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] R\ \^KVR]]NM RW [N\YXW\N ]X ]QN [NZ^R[NVNW]\ XO DXURLb

DB+ JWM \NNT\ ]X \N] X^] ]QN MN\RPW R\\^N\ [NUN_JW] ]X JW J\\N\\VNW] XO ]QN Y[XYX\JU\ `R]QRW ]QN

LXW]Na] XO L^[[NW] MN\RPW J\\N\\VNW] YXURLb JWM VN]QXMXUXPb'

&#$ 0?@GDMKPJA

+'* GQN WJ]RXWJU YXURLb LXW]Na] [NUJ]RWP ]X MN\RPW LXW\RMN[J]RXW\ RW ]QN J\\N\\VNW] XO MN_NUXYVNW]

Y[XYX\JU\ QJ\ KNNW \N] X^] Kb ]QN FLX]]R\Q <X_N[WVNW] `R]QRW J \N[RN\ XO MN\RPW KJ\NM MXL^VNW]\'

GQR\ L^[[NW] \^R]N XO MN\RPW J\\N\\VNW] ]XXU\ LX_N[\ \^KSNL]\ \^LQ J\ LXW\N[_J]RXW J[NJ VJWJPNVNW]%

MN\RPWRWP \JON[ YUJLN\% RWLU^\R_N MN\RPW% QX^\RWP RW ]QN LX^W][b\RMN% JWM MN\RPWRWP \][NN]\' >W ]N[V\ XO

[NUN_JWLN ]X ]QN MN\RPW LXW\RMN[J]RXW\ Y[N\NW]NM `R]Q ]QN MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XYX\NM ^WMN[ ]QR\

JYYURLJ]RXW OX[ YUJWWRWP YN[VR\\RXW ]QN TNb FLX]]R\Q <X_N[WVNW] Y^KURLJ]RXW\ J[N FLX]]R\Q DUJWWRWP

DXURLb #FDD$% DUJWWRWP 5M_RLN CX]N #D5C$ /1 � 8N\RPW F]J]NVNW]\% JWM ]QN =R\]X[RL 9W_R[XWVNW]

FLX]UJWM D^KURLJ]RXW �BJWJPRWP 7QJWPN RW ]QN =R\]X[RL 9W_R[XWVNW] � 6X^WMJ[RN\'�

+'+ FDD NVYQJ\R\N\ ]QN RVYX[]JWLN XO MN\RPW RW ]QN MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XLN\\ JWM QRPQURPQ]\ ]QN [XUN XO

DUJWWRWP 5^]QX[R]RN\ RW MNUR_N[RWP JYY[XY[RJ]N MN\RPW \XU^]RXW\' FDD JM_R\N\ ]QJ] YUJWWRWP J^]QX[R]RN\

\QXÛM LXW\RMN[ \Ra TNb Y[RWLRYUN\ OX[ ]QN L[NJ]RXW XO \^LLN\\OÛ YUJLN\ `QNW J\\N\\RWP ]QN MN\RPW

Z^JUR]RN\ XO J Y[XYX\NM MN_NUXYVNW]' 8N_NUXYVNW] \QXÛM KN MR\]RWL]R_N% \JON JWM YUNJ\JW]%

`NULXVRWP% JMJY]JKUN% [N\X^[LN NOORLRNW]% JWM NJ\b ]X VX_N J[X^WM JWM KNbXWM'

+', 5\ JW JRM ]X`J[M\ ]QN MN\RPW J\\N\\VNW] Y[XLN\\ ]QN FLX]]R\Q <X_N[WVNW] _RN`\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW]\

J\ J TNb LXVYXWNW] RW ]QN MN\RPW ]XXUTR]' GQNb XOON[ JW RVYX[]JW] VNJW\ XO LXVV^WRLJ]RWP ]QN

MN\RPW [J]RXWJUN J\\XLRJ]NM `R]Q \YNLRORL Y[XSNL]\ ]QN[NKb NWJKURWP DUJWWRWP 5^]QX[R]RN\ ]X NOONL]R_NUb

OÛORU ]QNR[ [XUN RW ]QN J\\N\\VNW] Y[XLN\\' FYNLRORL P^RMJWLN XW ]QN WJ]^[N JWM \LXYN XO MN\RPW

\]J]NVNW]\ QJ\ KNNW \N] X^] `R]QRW D5C /1 & 8N\RPW F]J]NVNW]\' >W YJ[]RLÛJ[ D5C /1 Y[X_RMN\

MN]JRUNM JM_RLN RW [NUJ]RXW ]X ]QN VN]QXMXUXPb ]X KN JMXY]NM OX[ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW]\ \X J\ ]X NW\^[N

]QJ] MN\RPW \XU^]RXW\ J[N ]JRUX[NM ]X ]QN \YNLRORL MN\RPW LXW]Na] `R]QRW `QRLQ MN_NUXYVNW] R\ ]X ]JTN

YUJLN' GQR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] QJ\ KNNW Y[NYJ[NM `R]Q [NON[NWLN `QN[N [NUN_JW] ]X ]QN P^RMJWLN \N]

X^] `R]QRW D5C /1 JWM \NNT\ ]X J\\R\] DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ 7X^WLRU RW J\\N\\RWP ]QN MN\RPW VN[R]\ XO ]QN

MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XYX\NM'

'#$ 8BOEKAKHKDS

,'* 7XW\RMN[J]RXW\ [NUJ]RWP ]X MN\RPW JWM ]QN RVYJL] XO J YJ[]RLÛJ[ Y[XYX\JU XW ]QN RVVNMRJ]N

NW_R[XWVNW] J[N RWQN[NW]Ub \^KSNL]R_N RW_XU_RWP _JU^NM S^MPNVNW]\ `QRLQ LJW _J[b \RPWRORLJW]Ub O[XV

YN[\XW ]X YN[\XW RW [NUJ]RXW ]X ]QN NaJL] \JVN Y[XYX\JU' B^LQ MNYNWM\ _^ @ `Gab_^�b `Gab`GBdYmG @^F

]QN [NUJ]R_N `NRPQ] J]]JLQNM ]X ]QN _J[RX^\ OJL]X[\ RW ]QN MN\RPW NZ^J]RXW' ;X[ ]QR\ [NJ\XW R] R\ XO]NW

MROORLÛ] ]X MNORWN ]QN OJL]X[\ `QRLQ VJTN XWN MN\RPW \XU^]RXW VX[N JLLNY]JKUN RW [NUJ]RXW ]X JWX]QN['

418

,'+ GQR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] R\ JRVNM J] NWJKURWP \XVN XKSNL]R_R]b ]X KN JYYURNM ]X ]QN J\\N\\VNW] Y[XLN\\

Kb RMNW]RObRWP ]QN TNb Y[RWLRYUN\ ^WMN[YRWWRWP J YJ[]RLÛJ[ MN\RPW JWM ]QN OJL]X[\ `QRLQ QJ_N PR_NW

[R\N ]X \^LQ J MN\RPW \XU^]RXW'

,', GQN MN]JRUNM P^RMJWLN ^WMN[ D5C /1 \N]\ X^] OR_N TNb \]JPN\ RW ]QN MN\RPW JYY[JR\JU Y[XLN\\' <R_NW ]QN

URVR]NM \LJUN XO ]QN Y[XYX\NM MN_NUXYVNW] J] ]QN Y[XYN[]b WX] JUU LXVYXWNW]\ XO ]QN MN\RPW

O[JVN`X[T J[N [NUN_JW] ]X ]QN MN\RPW J\\N\\VNW] Y[XLN\\ ^WMN[ ]QR\ JYYURLJ]RXW' GQN TNb

LXW\RMN[J]RXW\ J[N3

# FR]N JWM 5[NJ 5YY[JR\JU4

# >MNW]RORLJ]RXW XO ]QN 8N\RPW D[RWLRYUN\4

# 8N\RPW 5WJUb\R\4

# GQN 8N\RPW FXU^]RXW'

GQN\N TNb LXW\RMN[J]RXW\ OX[V ]QN X_N[JUU O[JVN`X[T OX[ J\\N\\VNW] `R]QRW ]QR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW]'

(#$ <FOB ?JA /MB? /LLM?FN?H

-'* GQN JYYURLJ]RXW \R]N R\ MXVRWJ]NM Kb ]QN OX[VN[ 6UJR[RWPXWN 7Q^[LQ K^RUMRWP `R]Q ]QN J\\XLRJ]NM P[J_N

bJ[M JWM KX^WMJ[b `JUU LXVY[R\RWP TNb ONJ]^[N\ RW N\]JKUR\QRWP ]QN \N]]RWP XO ]QN <[JMN �7� AR\]NM

6^RUMRWP' GQN =9F UR\]RWP OX[ ]QN Y[XYN[]b VJTN\ WX [NON[NWLN ]X ]QN KX^WMJ[b `JUU' =X`N_N[% ]QN `JUU

R\ WN_N[]QNUN\\ UR\]NM Kb J\\XLRJ]RXW `R]Q ]QN LQ^[LQ K^RUMRWP' >W YJ[]RLÛJ[ ]QN KX^WMJ[b `JUU OX[V\ JW

RVYX[]JW] ONJ]^[N RW ]N[V\ XO Y[X_RMRWP _R\^JU LXW]JRWVNW] OX[ ]QN K^RUMRWP JWM LUNJ[Ub N\]JKUR\QRWP

]QN Na]NW] XO ]QN J\\XLRJ]NM L^[]RUJPN'

)#$ 5ABJOFCF@?OFKJ KC 2BNFDJ ;MFJ@FLHBN#

.'* "^ bGG[Y^V d_ B_]`\Y]G^d dXG ]_aG VG^Ga@\ FGbYV^ B_^BG`db G]A_FYGF nYdXY^ dXG %$$�b bYo [Gp

Y[RWLRYUN\ OX[ \^LLN\\OÛ YUJLN\% ]QN =9F Y^KURLJ]RXW BJWJPRWP 7QJWPN RW ]QN =R\]X[RL 9W_R[XWVNW] �

6X^WMJ[RN\ \N]\ X^] J W^VKN[ XO TNb MN\RPW R\\^N\ [NUJ]RWP ]X KX^WMJ[b `JUU\' GQN VJRW R\\^N\ J[N

LXW\RMN[NM ]X KN J\ OXUUX`\3

# JWb Y[XYX\NM JU]N[J]RXW\ ]X JW QR\]X[RL KX^WMJ[b ONJ]^[N \QXÛM ]JTN RW]X JLLX^W] ]QN MN\RPW

JWM VJ]N[RJU LQJ[JL]N[R\]RL\ XO ]QN NaR\]RWP KX^WMJ[b `JUU4

# JWb Y[XYX\NM JU]N[J]RXW\ ]X JW QR\]X[RL KX^WMJ[b ONJ]^[N \QXÛM OXUUX` ]QN \JVN URWN J\ ]QN

QR\]X[RL LX^[\N XO ]QN NaR\]RWP KX^WMJ[b4 JWM

# JWb Y[XYX\NM JU]N[J]RXW\ ]X JW QR\]X[RL KX^WMJ[b ONJ]^[N \QXÛM \NNT ]X J_XRM JWb \RPWRORLJW]

LQJWPN ]X ]QN N\]JKUR\QNM L^[]RUJPN XO ]QN J\\XLRJ]NM \R]N'

.'+ 5U]QX^PQ CJ]RXWJU YXURLb R\ ^\NOÛ RW \N]]RWP X^] ]QN PNWN[JU O[JVN`X[T OX[ ]QN MN\RPW J\\N\\VNW]

Y[XLN\\% ]QN LXW]Na] `R]QRW DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ OX[ ]QN J\\N\\VNW] XO MN\RPW LXW\RMN[J]RXW\ J\\XLRJ]NM

`R]Q \YNLRORL MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XYX\JU\ R\ \N] J] ]QN UXLJU UN_NU `R]QRW J W^VKN[ XO TNb MXL^VNW]\' >W ]QR\

[NPJ[M ]QN UXLJU YXURLb LXW]Na] [NUN_JW] ]X JW J\\N\\VNW] XO ]QN MN\RPW VN[R]\ XO ]QN MN_NUXYVNW]

Y[XYX\JU\ OX[ ]QN Y[XYN[[]b R\ \N] X^] `R]QRW ]QN OXUUX`RWP \X^[LN\3

# GQN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW +)*-4

# GQN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ DUJLNVJTRWP <^RMN � HR\RXW OX[ 6^RUMRWP\ JWM CN` 8N_NUXYVNW]'

419

)#&#% ;BMOE ?JA 6FJMKNN 7K@?H 2BQBHKLIBJO ;H?J &$%(

.'+'+ DXURLb DB*5 XO ]QN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW +)*- \]J]N\3

&.?.4785.6= 5><= ,76=;2+>=. 87<2=2?.4B# =7 =1. 9>*42=B 7/ =1. <>;;7>6-260 +>24= *6-

6*=>;*4 .6?2;765.6=$ %44 -.?.4785.6= <17>4- +. 84*66.- *6- -.<206.- @2=1

;./.;.6,. =7 ,425*=. ,1*60.# 52=20*=276 *6- *-*8=*=276$ )1. -.<206# -.6<2=B *6-

<2=260 7/ -.?.4785.6= <17>4- ;.<8.,= =1. ,1*;*,=.; *6- *5.62=B 7/ =1. 84*,.# *6-

<17>4- ,;.*=. *6- 258;7?. 4263< @2=126 *6-# @1.;. 8;*,=2,*4# +.B76- =1. <2=.$

(;787<*4< <17>4- *4<7 26,7;87;*=. 6.@ 4*6-<,*8. *6- 84*6=260 @7;3< *88;78;2*=. =7

=1. 47,*4 ,76=.A= *6- =1. <,*4. *6- 6*=>;. 7/ =1. -.?.4785.6=$

.'+', GQR\ YXURLb R\ \^YYUNVNW]NM Kb ]QN Y[X_R\RXW\ XO DXURLb DB*6 `QRLQ \]J]N\3

5UU Y[XYX\JU\ \QXÛM VNN] JUU ]QN OXUUX`RWP YUJLNVJTRWP L[R]N[RJ3

#J$ 7[NJ]N J \NW\N XO RMNW]R]b Kb MN_NUXYRWP J LXQN[NW] \][^L]^[N XO \][NN]\% \YJLN\%

JWM K^RUMRWP\% \JONUb JLLN\\RKUN O[XV R]\ \^[[X^WMRWP\'

#K$ 7XW\RMN[ JWM [N\YNL] \R]N ]XYXP[JYQb JWM JWb \^[[X^WMRWP RVYX[]JW]

UJWMVJ[T\% _RN`\ X[ \TbURWN\% J\ `NUU J\ ]QN `RMN[ UJWM\LJYN LQJ[JL]N[ XO ]QN J[NJ'

#L$ GQN MN\RPW JWM MNW\R]b \QXÛM LXVYUNVNW] R]\ \^[[X^WMRWP\ RW ]N[V\ XO

JYYNJ[JWLN% QNRPQ]% \LJUN% VJ\\RWP% VJ]N[RJU\% ORWR\QN\ JWM LXUX^[\'

#M$ EN\YNL] JW NaR\]RWP K^RUMRWP URWN `QN[N JYY[XY[RJ]N% X[ N\]JKUR\Q XWN `QN[N

WXWN NaR\]\' 5LLN\\% ^\N\% JWM X[RNW]J]RXW XO Y[RWLRYJU NUN_J]RXW\ \QXÛM [NRWOX[LN

]QN \][NN] X[ XYNW \YJLN'

#N$ 5UU K^RUMRWP\% \][NN]\% JWM \YJLN\ #RWLU^MRWP P[NNW \YJLN\$ \QXÛM L[NJ]N \JON%

JLLN\\RKUN% RWLU^\R_N YUJLN\ OX[ YNXYUN% `QRLQ J[N NJ\RUb WJ_RPJKUN% YJ[]RLÛJ[Ub XW

OXX]% KRLbLUN JWM Y^KURL ][JW\YX[]'

#O$ 6^RUMRWP\ JWM \YJLN\ \QXÛM KN MN\RPWNM `R]Q O^]^[N JMJY]JKRUR]b RW VRWM

`QN[N_N[ YX\\RKUN'

#P$ 9aR\]RWP K^RUMRWP\% \][^L]^[N\ JWM WJ]^[JU ONJ]^[N\ ]QJ] LXW][RK^]N ]X ]QN UXLJU

]X`W\LJYN \QXÛM KN [N]JRWNM JWM \NW\R]R_NUb RW]NP[J]NM RW]X Y[XYX\JU\'

#Q$ >WLX[YX[J]N P[NNW RWO[J\][^L]^[N RW]X WN` MN_NUXYVNW]\ JWM VJTN LXWWNL]RXW\

`QN[N YX\\RKUN ]X P[NNW WN]`X[T\'

.'+'- DXURLb =9+ XO ]QN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW +)*- [NUJ]RWP ]X UR\]NM K^RUMRWP\ \]J]N\ J

Y[N\^VY]RXW RW OJ_X^[ XO \bVYJ]QN]RL [N\]X[J]RXW% LX[[NL] VJRW]NWJWLN JWM \NW\R]R_N VJWJPNVNW] XO

UR\]NM K^RUMRWP\ ]X NWJKUN ]QNV ]X [NVJRW RW JL]R_N ^\N' >W YJ[]RLÛJ[ DXURLb =9+ JM_R\N\ ]QJ] Y[XYX\NM

JU]N[J]RXW\ \QXÛM WX] JM_N[\NUb JOONL] ]QN \YNLRJU RW]N[N\] XO J UR\]NM K^RUMRWP'

)#&#) =EB ;BMOE ?JA 6FJMKNN ;H?@BI?GFJD 4PFAB , >FNFKJ CKM 0PFHAFJDN ?JA 9BR 2BQBHKLIBJO

.'+'/ GQN DUJLNVJTRWP <^RMN \N]\ X^] ]Q[NN TNb Y[RWLRYUN\ J\ YJ[] XO R]\ _R\RXW OX[ ]QN MN\RPW XO K^RUMRWP\ JWM

WN` MN_NUXYVNW]3

# GX VJRW]JRW JWM RVY[X_N ]QN RMNW]R]b JWM LQJ[JL]N[ XO DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\4

# GX NWLX^[JPN RWWX_J]RXW JWM \^\]JRWJKRUR]b RW MN\RPW4

# GX NWLX^[JPN `NUU LXWWNL]NM `NULXVRWP YUJLN\'

420

*#$ 2BNFDJ /J?HSNFN

/'* GQN \Ra TNb Y[RWLRYUN\ OX[ ]QN L[NJ]RXW XO \^LLN\\OÛ YUJLN\ \N] X^] `R]Q RW FDD Y[X_RMN ]QN PNWN[JU

Ha@]Gn_a[ H_a dXG FGbYV^ @^@\pbYb à_BGbb� &XG b`GBYHYB B_^bYFGa@dY_^b l^FGa G@BX _H dXG %$$�b bYo TNb

Y[RWLRYUN\ `QRLQ J[N LXW\RMN[NM ]X KN XO [NUN_JWLN ]X ]QN WJ]^[N JWM \LJUN XO MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XYX\NM

`RUU RW_XU_N J MN_NUXYVNW] `QRLQ R\ LXW\R\]NW] `R]Q ]QN MN\RPW Y[RWLRYUN\ MN[R_NM O[XV ]QN =9F

Y^KURLJ]RXW BJWJPRWP 7QJWPN RW ]QN =R\]X[RL 9W_R[XWVNW] � 6X^WMJ[RN\% J\ \N] X^] J] YJ[JP[JYQ .'*

JKX_N'

/'+ 5] ]QN VX[N MN]JRUNM UN_NU ]QN MN\RPW \XU^]RXW OX[ ]QN Y[XYX\NM \NL]RXW XO [NJURPWNM JLLN\\ JWM

JU]N[J]RXW\ ]X ]QN KX^WMJ[b `JUU `RUU [NZ^R[N ]X LXW][RK^]N ]X Y[N\N[_RWP J \NW\N XO RMNW]R]b OX[ ]QN

J\\XLRJ]NM 7Q^[LQ K^RUMRWP RW ]N[V\ XO JYYNJ[JWLN% QNRPQ]% \LJUN% VJ]N[RJU\% LX^[\RWP JWM LXUX^[ RW

X[MN[ ]X LXVYUb `R]Q ]QN [NZ^R[NVNW]\ XO DXURLRN\ DB* JWM =9+ XO ]QN AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW'

+#$ =EB 2BNFDJ <KHPOFKJ

0'* >W \NNTRWP ]X J[[R_N J] J MN\RPW \XU^]RXW `QRLQ [NOUNL]\ ]QN JKX_N JWJUb\R\ XWN XO ]QN VX\]

O^WMJVNW]JU [NZ^R[NVNW]\ R\ ]QJ] ]QN Y[XYX\NM YX[]RXW\ XO WN` KX^WMJ[b `JUU JLQRN_N J \bVYJ]QN]RL

[NUJ]RXW\QRY `R]Q ]QN NaR\]RWP KX^WMJ[b ONJ]^[N RW ]N[V\ XO \LJUN% VJ]N[RJU\% LX^[\RWP XO ]QN

\]XWN`X[T% JWM ]QN URWN XO ]QN WN` YX[]RXW XO `JUU' 5 O^[]QN[ TNb [NZ^R[NVNW] R\ ]QJ] ]QN YX[]RXW XO

`JUU ]X KN MNVXUR\QNM \QXÛM WX] JM_N[\NUb JOONL] ]QN \N]]RWP XO ]QN UR\]NM K^RUMRWP Kb \RPWRORLJW]Ub

JU]N[RWP ]QN N\]JKUR\QNM L^[]RUJPN JWM MNP[NN XO _R\^JU LXW]JRWVNW] OX[ ]QN 7Q^[LQ K^RUMRWP `QRLQ ]QN

X_N[JUU KX^WMJ[b ONJ]^[N L^[[NW]Ub Y[X_RMN\' >W JMMR]RXW% ]QN VJ]N[RJU\ ^\NM ]X OX[V ]QN `NJ[RWP

LX^[\N OX[ ]QN [NJURPWNM JLLN\\ \QXÛM [NOUNL] ]QJ] XO ]QN NaR\]RWP JLLN\\ `R]Q `QRLQ R] R\ ]X KN

LXWWNL]NM'

0'+ >W ]N[V\ XO ]QN Y[XYX\NM WN` YX[]RXW\ XO KX^WMJ[b ]QN Y[XYX\NM MN\RPW R\ LXW\RMN[NM ]X LXVYUb `R]Q

]QN MN\RPW Y[RWLRYUN\ \N] X^] JKX_N RW ]QJ] ]QN Y[XYX\NM QNRPQ]% VJ]N[RJU\% URWN JWM \]XWN`X[T

LX^[\RWP J[N JUU LXW\R\]NW] `R]Q ]QN \NL]RXW\ XO ]QN X[RPRWJU KX^WMJ[b `JUU `R]Q `QRLQ ]QNb `RUU

LXWWNL]' >W JMMR]RXW% ]QN WN` YX[]RXW\ XO `JUU `RUU \N[_N ]X NWQJWLN ]QN MNP[NN XO _R\^JU LXW]JRWVNW]

OX[ ]QN \R]N JWM LXW\XURMJ]N ]QN X_N[JUU LJ[]RUJPN XO ]QN J\\XLRJ]NM UR\]NM K^RUMRWP'

0', GQN Y[XYX\NM MNVXUR]RXW XO ]QN \NL]RXW XO ]QN NaR\]RWP KX^WMJ[b `JUU R\ LXW\RMN[NM ]X KN LXW\R\]NW]

`R]Q ]QN MN\RPW Y[RWLRYUN\ \N] X^] JKX_N RW ]QJ] ]QN URVR]NM \LJUN XO MNVXUR]RXW `X[T\ `RUU NW\^[N ]QJ]

]QN _R\^JU LXW]JRWVNW] JWM RW]NP[R]b XO ]QN L^[]RUJPN XO ]QN UR\]NM K^RUMRWP J[N WX] JM_N[\NUb JOONL]NM'

0'- ;RWJUUb% ]QN Y[XYX\NM \NL]RXW XO [NJURPWNM JLLN\\ R\ LXW\RMN[NM ]X KN LXW\R\]NW] `R]Q ]QN JKX_N MN\RPW

Y[RWLRYUN\ RW ]QJ] ]QN `NJ[RWP LX^[\N `RUU VJ]LQ ]QJ] XO ]QN NaR\]RWP JLLN\\ [X^]N `R]Q `QRLQ R] R\ ]X KN

LXWWNL]NM'

,#$ 3PMOEBM 1KJNFABM?OFKJN

1'* 5] J VNN]RWP QNUM J] ]QN \R]N XW ]QN *-]Q

;NK[^J[b +)*0 ]X JMM[N\\ R\\^N\ [NUJ]RWP ]X ]QN [NUXLJ]RXW XO

]QN IJ[ BNVX[RJU JWM Y[X_R\RXW XO J \N[_R]^MN [RPQ] XO _NQRLÛJ[ JLLN\\ ]X ]QN M`NUURWPQX^\N% R\\^N\

[NUJ]RWP ]X ]QN YJ[TRWP XO _NQRLUN\ ]X ]QN O[XW] XO ]QN UR\]NM K^RUMRWP `N[N MR\L^\\NM' >W ]QR\ [NPJ[M R]

\QXÛM KN WX]NM ]QJ] ]QN L^[[NW] Y[XYX\JU\ MX WX] [NUJ]N ]X ]QN OX[VJ]RXW XO LJ[ YJ[TRWP \YJLN\'

5U]QX^PQ ]`X LJ[ YJ[TRWP \YJLN\ J[N RWMRLJ]NM XW ]QN \^KVR]]NM YUJW\ ]QN\N \RVYUb [NUJ]N ]X NaR\]RWP

J[NJ\ `QN[N J _NQRLUN LJW YJ[T JWM ]QN[N R\ WX RW]NW]RXW ]X LJ[[b X^] JWb `X[T\ ]X [N\^[OJLN X[

MNURWNJ]N ]QN\N ]`X J[NJ\' GQN\N ]`X YJ[TRWP \YJLN\ QJ_N QR\]X[RLJUUb KNNW ^\NM OX[ YJ[TRWP XW

XLLJ\RXW\ `QNW _NQRLUN\ ^\RWP ]QN NaR\]RWP _NQRLÛJ[ JLLN\\ QJ_N KNNW YJ[TNM JMSJLNW] ]X ]QN

K^RUMRWP' 5\ \^LQ ]QN ]`X LJ[ YJ[TRWP \YJLN\ \QX`W MX WX] RW_XU_N MN_NUXYVNW] ^WMN[ ]QN ]N[V\ XO (

421

]QN MNORWR]RXW XO \^LQ \N] X^] ^WMN[ FNL]RXW +/ XO ]QN GX`W JWM 7X^W][b DUJWWRWP #FLX]UJWM$ 5L]*220'

GQN[NOX[N% JU]QX^PQ ]QR\ R\\^N VJb KN XO [NUN_JWLN RW ]N[V\ XO ]QN 7X^WLRU�\ X`WN[\QRY LXW\RMN[J]RXW\

[NUJ]RWP ]X P[JW]RWP J \N[_R]^MN [RPQ] XO JLLN\\% ]QN _R\^JU RVYJL] XO _NQRLUN\ YJ[TNM ]X ]QN O[XW] XO ]QN

UR\]NM K^RUMRWP MXN\ WX] OX[V J VJ]N[RJU LXW\RMN[J]RXW RW [NUJ]RXW ]X JW J\\N\\VNW] XO ]QN\N Y[XYX\JU\

^WMN[ FNL]RXW +. XO 5L]'

-#$ <PII?MS

2'* GQN NVYQJ\R\ `R]QRW <X_N[WVNW] <^RMJWLN R\ XW NW\^[RWP ]QN JLQRN_NVNW] XO JYY[XY[RJ]N MN\RPW

\XU^]RXW\ ]JRUX[NM ]X ]QN \YNLRORL MN\RPW LXW]Na] `R]QRW `QRLQ MN_NUXYVNW] R\ ]X ]JTN YUJLN' 5

\J]R\OJL]X[b MN\RPW \XU^]RXW R\ ]QN[NOX[N MNYNWMJW] XW MN]JRUNM NaJVRWJ]RXW XO ]QN MN_NUXYVNW]

LXW]Na] `R]QRW `QRLQ J WN` MN_NUXYVNW] R\ Y[XYX\NM \X J\ ]X Y[XVX]N JW ^WMN[\]JWMRWP XO ]QN TNb

MN\RPW LQJ[JL]N[R\]RL\ `QRLQ \QXÛM RWOX[V ]QN MN\RPW \XU^]RXW'

2'+ GQR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] QJ\ KNNW Y[NYJ[NM `R]Q [NON[NWLN ]X ]QN P^RMJWLN \N] X^] `R]QRW D5C /1 JWM

\NNT\ ]X J\\R\] DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ 7X^WLRU RW J\\N\\RWP ]QN MN\RPW VN[R]\ XO ]QN MN_NUXYVNW] Y[XYX\NM'

GQN \]J]NVNW] Y[X_RMN\ J MN]JRUNM JWJUb\R\ XO ]QN TNb MN\RPW Y[RWLRYUN\ [NUJ]RWP ]X ]QN Y[XYX\NM

MN_NUXYVNW] J] ]QN OX[VN[ 6UJR[RWPXWN DJ[R\Q 7Q^[LQ JWM MN\L[RKN\ QX` ]QN\N Y[RWLRYUN\ QJ_N KNNW

K[X^PQ] ]X KNJ[ RW MNORWRWP ]QN MN\RPW \XU^]RXW'

2', >] R\ LXW\RMN[NM ]QJ] ]QR\ MN\RPW \]J]NVNW] QJ\ MNVXW\][J]NM ]QJ] ]QN Y[XYX\JU\ J[N OÛUb LXW\R\]NW]

`R]Q ]QN UXLJU MN\RPW LXW]Na] JWM ]QJ] ]QN MN_NUXYVNW] LJW KN S^\]RORNM RW [NUJ]RXW ]X ]QN _J[RX^\

MN\RPW [NZ^R[NVNW]\ \N] X^] `R]QRW FDD [NUJ]RWP ]X ]QN \Ra TNb Y[RWLRYUN\ OX[ \^LLN\\OÛ YUJLN\ JWM ]QN

[NUN_JW] MN\RPW R\\^N\ \N] X^] `R]QRW ]QN =9\ Y^KURLJ]RXW BJWJPRWP 7QJWPN RW ]QN =R\]X[RL 9W_R[XWVNW]

� 6X^WMJ[RN\% J\ `NUU J\ ]QN YXURLb Y[X_R\RXW\ XO ]QN AXLJU 8N_NUXYVNW] DUJW' >W JMMR]RXW% ]QN Y[XYX\JU\

J[N LXW\RMN[NM ]X KN LXW\R\]NW] `R]Q ]QN P^RMRWP Y[RWLRYUN\ XO ]QN DN[]Q JWM @RW[X\\ 7X^WLRU

DUJLNVJTRWP <^RMN'

422

Documents

17.09.12 - Item 4(iv)(b) - 485 - Perth and Kinross