35
1 Strategies for Education and Learning Hirotaka Onishi MD, MHPE International Research Center for Medical Education University of Tokyo

15 04-22 strategies

  • View
    208

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 15 04-22 strategies

1

Strategies for Education

and Learning

Hirotaka Onishi MD, MHPE

International Research Center for Medical Education

University of Tokyo

Page 2: 15 04-22 strategies

Strategies (Step 4)Terminologies

What is a lecture?

2

Page 3: 15 04-22 strategies

How Much Will the Memory

be Retained?

National Training Laboratories, Bethel, Maine, USA

5%

10%

20%

30%

50%

75%

80%

Lecture

Reading

AV Materials

Demonstration

Group Discussion

Practical Experiences

Teach Someone Else

Page 4: 15 04-22 strategies

Cone of Experience

(Dale, 1946)

4

Not cone

of learning!

Verbal

symbols

Page 5: 15 04-22 strategies

Terminologies

Educational/learning strategy

Method of learning/teaching

Content of learning/teaching

Sometimes difficult to divide method and

content

Lecture

Oral discourse on a given subject in front

of an audience for purposes of instruction

5

Page 6: 15 04-22 strategies

Balanced Performance

Overall Performance

Problem Solving Attitude

Recall Level Knowledge

Skill

Page 7: 15 04-22 strategies

Reading

Strengths

Low cost

Easy to cover broad areas

Less preparatory time for faculty

Weaknesses

Passive learning

Difficult to continue if motivation is low

Page 8: 15 04-22 strategies

8

Page 9: 15 04-22 strategies

Lecture

Strengths

Low cost

High learner-teacher ratio is possible

Systematic presentation of complex issues

Weaknesses

Passive learning

Teacher-centered

Quality depends on a speaker or AV

material

Page 10: 15 04-22 strategies

10

Page 11: 15 04-22 strategies

11

Page 12: 15 04-22 strategies

PBL (problem-based learning)

Strengths

Combines small-group learning, case-

based learning and self-directed learning

Easy to motivate with real context

Weaknesses

Low efficiency if self-directed learning is

insufficient

Resource intensive in faculty number

Difficult for good scenario writing

Page 13: 15 04-22 strategies

13

Page 14: 15 04-22 strategies

Learning Project

Strengths

Active learning

Facilitates self-directed learning

Effective even for problem-solving

Weaknesses

Requires motivation

Needs access to information source or

such an ability

Requires a tutor

Page 15: 15 04-22 strategies

15

Page 16: 15 04-22 strategies

Role-modeling

Strengths

Faculty can play this role

Deep and potential influence

Weaknesses

Few effective role-models

Difficult to evaluate intervention/outcome

Page 17: 15 04-22 strategies

17

Page 18: 15 04-22 strategies

Group Discussion

Strengths

Active learning

Integration is possible for multiple areas

Promotes collaboration/team work

Effective even for problem-solving or

affective objectives

Weaknesses

Requires group facilitation skills for teachers

Success partly depends on group members

Page 19: 15 04-22 strategies

19

Page 20: 15 04-22 strategies

Demonstration

Strengths

“Seeing is believing”

Possible high learner-teacher ratio

Weaknesses

Passive learning

Teacher-centered

Quality depends on the speaker/AV

materials

Page 21: 15 04-22 strategies

21

Page 22: 15 04-22 strategies

Role-play

Strengths

Simulation for practical contents

Deals with multi-area/integrative objectives

Low cost

Weaknesses

Requires well-trained multiple facilitators

Requires fundamental knowledge/skills

and experiences

Page 23: 15 04-22 strategies

23

Page 24: 15 04-22 strategies

Simulated patients

Strengths

Higher reality than role-play

Safe environment for skill training

Feedback is available for learners

Weaknesses

High cost

Requires an expert for development and

training/teaching

Page 25: 15 04-22 strategies

25

Page 26: 15 04-22 strategies

Simulator

Strengths

Safe environment for skill training

Self-directed pace for a learner

Weaknesses

Only available for some contents

Some simulators are highly costly

Requires an administrator/trained facilitator

Page 27: 15 04-22 strategies

27

Page 28: 15 04-22 strategies

Reflection with Playback

Strengths

Recording/videotaping became inexpensive

Feedback is available for the performance

Provides an opportunity for self-monitoring

Weaknesses

Requires a patient’s allowance

Requires a facilitator

Takes time for review/reflection

Recording/videotaping may distract practices

Page 29: 15 04-22 strategies

Clinical Experiences

Strengths

Use real settings

Promote learners’ responsibility/motivation

Facilitate various aspects of learning

Weaknesses

Requires faculty’s supervision/facilitation

Requires learners’ knowledge/skills

Reflection/follow-up is necessary

Necessary to monitor case mix

Page 30: 15 04-22 strategies

30

Page 31: 15 04-22 strategies

31

Page 32: 15 04-22 strategies

32

Page 33: 15 04-22 strategies

Taxonomy and Recommended

Learning Strategies

Taxonomy Recommended Strategies

Knowledge Reading, Lecture

Problem-solving

PBL, Learning project, PBL

Attitude Role-model, Role-play, Discussion

Skills Demonstration, Simulated experiences, Reflection with playback

Behavior Clinical experiences

Page 34: 15 04-22 strategies

Meetings for Education

Forum

Symposium

Panel discussion

Conference

Workshop

Workshop

World cafe

34

Page 35: 15 04-22 strategies

Theme for Discussion

Plan an educational course (3hrs x 5)

for communication skills for nursing

students in a developing country

35