2783

I DEC - 9 RECD n m

INDEPENDENT REGULATORYBimmmmmM # # # B#rd REVIEW COMMISSION EI#RONMEmL OU«JW80«

!%#e A d M o w Me#erL Rowbnd & Gmbk, Iw /g mmmmm mgmidmg dm pmpomd

HgrmAM% M /77W

Oememl#l Tim 2006 BMP Mmmuml ia ao lo%# oun#mt hi immy mmm « d

Chapm*" 102 m&m t# the BHP &4sw%mai k A ^^qplkdiiy mW by

cm a sMk BMP MamW & # dwmft gm# « # the i)Ble*dif

ehmglmg Mo.mwmt#r fwldL Wt#$dl &# BMP HmwW #w( be

mpdawd !%%guAarty #id ChapWr 102 mw& W M m## &%&!# by

for im%iml. o#ite inAltratlGn m the s#me waiBmhml or BMPtmdmg. If #h#r lmdo%mem em m i ar will net mmgcmmWycooperate, $Wn allow W & GonWb#tiDm # a BMP Bank, h tkkmanner, w$wo#M #ap forcing iaOlWdan in #iea$ that don'i work

Gememl #3 DEP, #a CoqmmmtWm Dimieta « d m.gm*m% cammmniiy all

# m will Wlp %^# lm#r d # g # : #W WA qmmkmr # d mom

:Wdmg: #ay too Wmg im. mmm #f &-12 # # & $ fer wmy

m## m Impbmmi # #m## # # # # # # &###» hlmag

#m# g#iW # ISO #^# em mot:W MKW%d &r IWi^MuM NPDM

^ ^ ^ 1 ^ ^

Wtkm -A stream (W

Secern %0Z2j&

§w#m:.M

Why &m ck Depmimmi decided M) impkmeni. mW enform post(;#.$W0l# g#qmim#jr Bmm#g$m€!mE #g#l#io^$ in Chapter 102wkm A#m mm ##mr Dmpaitmml mW Weal progmma th^i almadyhm# gw%w## mgulalioms? TWm needs io W one

eW%#i#&cM#mtlmg ewmt WmM .MS-4 pmgmmi, Aet 167pmgmm, DEP m#W Bidimmm, mmMpml #rdm:mm#& mid DBFBMP Mimmml opmipiMmdW by $# mew pmpww Clmpler 102:&:####, Whkh #n#: lmk#$ pmmdeme? hi reality., engineers needw #$igm m the m#t remMi% of Ml whkb leadg to overdemignWd !nem#W #mgnAm#metW. com.

^^ l iii Ill2 ^ ^

^ ^ ^ ^ ^ i ^ 1112^^

^^ ^l^^ll^^^ ^ 1 ^11^1^^ ^ l l^^^ ^1^1 1^^^^^^^^^ ^^ ^^^^ ^^^^ ^

Section 1#U

&Ktk>aWZ6a,3

Sec&m #2.&i i3

CWfy - If an mpplicanl m mquimd # ebtmk m Section AW Pmmiiand a Water OWiruetloD aBd Emmimhiimm PemmL does Amgeciiom niean ihat an IS&S mppmwd m.d NPDES Pmcmlt k moimqwimd m be ohiamed? Am exmmpk would b# a bndge

"Othef infarmmdoii dm DepmrimmBi may mqul.#' - SiboMld allp^Ttmrnit iniammtwn the D^pMmem! may mmew b# meWdW mthe proposed mgulmwms? Would this %#ch ml!"m^Hmnmnt open the daar Air mwkweis to mk for Wakmrnt madsometimes c o # y mfDrimmim iha: doea aoi.8#HiflmmQy #:@#6t #epmjpowd BM!% mW plm?

How eim a PPC Plai* be prepamd duiimg w. mltiBl design ef a meif Ae design profemiamd does noi tmow who or by what nmam theeon^tmeiioD of the site will be mmpkWl? Should PPC plana beprepared by c{)atmemm who know what equipamml: amd. supplimwill he o m i % prior to Ae eommenqement #f an emth diamrbmBee

Chdfy if PPC plm^s ham to be BtibmilW for mv#w?

Why # ^ %###.#^^ r%giW w g@y #$ p#mtmppim#i#jn &## whan tbmy are # # # ( * fmmi: appiW$Wm fms fw

^ ^ 1 -^ I ^^^ ^^^ 11 ^ 1 I ^ 11 ^ 1^ I ^^^1^^ 1^ I

^ i ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ l ^ ^ ^ l i i ^ ^ ^ ^^^^ ^ ^ ^

Becdan #&&e.2

^^ l lll III^^^^

counties, should% be **Act

StmmiwmWr Management Piam ?

ward *%ammW^ be i%%n%0Y€Nl a#d Am wWWg he "Am 167

S W W l@2,&h TW ABACT BMPs am relereocai to the PABMP Manual which isa diKerem reference rheo in Secikm I02.4.b.6 (E&S Manual).

Wkm 10&&k Who is. mqmnMHe for emmnmg thmi a. llommmd pm&#iaoai 1$pmmmi dnrmg cdiieM slmges of impkm##imtW? The demgneHgimmer mmy mot be mnd#r eBWmei. with Qm dei^loper Eii the timeof wnswetkm. In. addition, who deWrmimB wbmi 'triiieml mages

Seetkm 1IXL8J How cam # Mcmsed pmlhssmiml pm%i& m cWifkmiiDD sMematom. Rmord Pmwing$ if #.#y mm mw # # ! # at mil limes? %%%u.Wtbm wHWiion better k sigaed by A# mmtmotmr #r :penml#e, mlieu of a licensed. Dro&MkmMd?

SeeGonlWU

Sectkm M2J4Lm.

As lleefmed: proibsslon.Mm mm f#qutr# to #ml drmmiiiga, wquW It W

the applkailom mi t k D#pmtmeiA or mm#iWGi3 di$We#

The impkmeniBtion of a 150' b#l&r will, be wry difBeuli, Someof the liiemtum suggest Aat. a Enmlbr buf&r woi# be jimi. asbeneAcial, We would recommend a. buffer elo$er io 50' fmm topof kmk which would be mm##ni w # the m#mti#$ almmdy mplac# im. Chmpmi 103 Ihmugh tlm impWrnntmlW of &e 50"Oeodwm^ rule,

#WW l#.M*m,2

SWkmMKLMmXi

or o##

BWW WMAmS ###&: #m metmrn W&mwe p#agm0K # ImWM. #f # ?

buf&rm w I y # i E V ###mheck, permWy-mK w any site

$«### 1:#,1W..,1; If m site aWim m mm#m, dmify If you. Im^e to pro^Kk a nparmnW8mr « / % ( # $i#$^ If y#w #W k not on both sides of the$tr##i % if yaw # # is om both mdm of m sgmm), but you mmwily proposing dmWAame (# {me-sM% is m buffer mqaked onbet mbs? O& #Wi if yow s&m is wiihim the mqmmd bufkr

%, b#:^#r, :h#m m mo(h#r Drap#rtv m Wtwmo war sW

mmdMons # d haw doeg tlm Dmparimmml want ihe buffers maAed?

i M2,M*g Cbrliy bow aEw^ Ae mpo# wed m b# subm#(L

& : & # M.2,:W^ Wham mm tlm. j#m &imm fm mpmmm. fomal. b%:.#r$ be Ihwd?

:Sm##m M^IS: Pmmmi by mle - Be$i#$ the pmpmed 30-day re 'iew tiime,. clanfyAm bewRia of Ihk promm. It ckm& mot mppemr ihmt the pr^mm ismmpUfmdmn-y.

$ # # m W&%& EmW# &a ;Ik#m*rmm#'$ WkMon of "low impacf.

B«##m%#2,15^W#* GW% #M0h -mpW#e g#kgkal. fWmmtmma mm exempt 5wnmmmg#nB#r l lm^gmtbymk,

Ami (bwrminm&im?

$ # # # i # J & c l » # WWi will the R(X]pmmWw(m m K # g # # M l m W mWkbb

§K*Wm 1 & 1 5 * ^ ShomM the l.*yamr/24-homr storm ewmt be m^kidecl am Ihe ammly$i&to W eomma#at with requimm#i# # ## IGNpmFtH%#mtis BMP

See#m 1#,1S,€,7JM Claniy exactly what consdtums 'overnight., Ha$ the DepmmmiMconsidered the imiks^ionB.:^ ob!igmi:ion.s, maihoriiy, amd limbiliiiesi%(ier this prOYi&ioB? What is the DepmtnmBi/m opiDimi on theimpact on the liiAiliiy expomm: to prolWrnonal Gn% E*# %weii imihe ImWHty of Ae kidividual Hemmed pr(#s$mmal? How does ih#Departrnmi expect a pm&ssmml w eonlml $lie opegmtWim if Aeyam mot wdei eontraGi with the conrnKtw?

# m i W . K j , l : Regaidmg impaired, wammlmds, the link w the Chapkr 3O3((I) !Won the De-pmrtmenfs m-ebsite iippeam to be down and iioikDCWnimg, TheDepartmmi should hmwaugef^Mmdly dam bmsefor impaimd tmams..

5,d,.l: If imii-dkeharge BMP5 am mqmmi a^d mm beimg used to pmieelwmier qumlity,. why does Am Depmlmmt IWl I k additmmal need

#eeAml#,15,L5: What am the Depwmafs inleats/aciioim going m be wilh ihe, coniaients genemied from the pahlle eomiimni p#riod for high

quality watersheds?

S # # m l# , i $ *L l Clmfy in what mimiiom the Depamimml would mwke eovemg^uimier a previoumly approved permit by mb.

#€###. l#2*32*kl This will be inierpreW tWM. all areas WA dmturWd for m#e than 3dmys Bmst be needed and mukhW. which i& imremlmtk.