Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1.1. Introduction
PujaSaluja Ph D. TJ..sis, IMTECH Challdigarh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review o/LiteruhJre
The biodiversity of yeasts has not been as much appreciated as that of several other
microbes . The reasoning (although erroneous) behind this lack of attention has been
that they play only a minor role in the biosphere. All this has been despite of their well
known and wide-ranging roles in a) fermentation, b) as established model organisms
(Saccharomyces cere visiae , Schizosaccharomyces pombe), c) as pathogens (Candida
albicans, Cryptococcus neoformans), d) heterologous expression systems (Hansenula
polymorpha, Pichia pastoris), e) as probiotics, f) for production of industrially
important compounds; g) vitamins, h) carotenoids, i) lipids, j) organic acids and the list
continues on.
Despite the realized and/or unrealized biopotential of yeasts, the rate of species
discovery of yeasts has not increased significantly over the past 50 years . There has not
even a proper estimation of number of yeast species yet. However, Fell et al. (2000)
suggested that the presently described 800 species constitute only 1 % (may be even less
than) that existing in nature. Based on Fell's estimation, the number of yeast species
should be in the proximity of 1 lakh. The development of rapid molecular tools in late
nineties helped in the discovery of new yeast species to some extent, inspite of these
developments only about 1000 yeast species were described till 2005 (Fig. 1.1).
Number of Yeast Species Since 1952
1200 .-------------------------------------~__.
1000 +------------------------------------II) G/
1800 +-----------------------------~----II)
OJ ~800 +-------------~~---->-'0 ~ 400 +---------=-------
..0 E ~
z 200 +------
o
Year
• Number of Described Yeast Species
Fig. 1.1. Histogram showing the number of yeast species discovered and characterized since 1952. (modified from Daniel et aI. , 2006).
2
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Yeasts are explored from both natural (terrestrial and aquatic) and man-made
habitats (food and beverages), Although yeasts have been explored from variety of
habitats, the diversity of yeasts from natural habitats is mostly appreciated from plant
parts (flowers, fruits, phyllosphere, bark etc.), insects and soil among terrestrial habitats
and from fresh and marine water in aquatic habitats. Even though yeasts are not
considered as ubiquitous as bacteria, they were found even in the extreme environments
of Antarctica (Shivaji & Prasad, 2009; Vishniac & Hempfling, 1979a). The occurrence
of yeasts have also been marked in hydrothermal vent, (Gadanho & Sampaio, 2005),
hypersaline environment (Butinar et ai., 2005), even in the extreme acidic
environments of Iberian pyrite belt (Gadanho et ai., 2006). Yeasts are supposed to be
key players in the Yeast-Flower-Insect ecosystems, phyllosphere ecosystems and
extreme environments. In Yeast-Flower-Insect ecosystems and phyllosphere
ecosystems, they are suggested to play their roles as symbionts, as competitors or
antagonists (Rosa et aI., 2003; Buck & Burpee, 2002). In the extreme environments,
yeasts may hold keys to nutrient cycling, metal detoxification, and these psychrophillic
yeasts may serve as producers of industrially important compounds (de Garcia et aI.,
2007; Gadanho & Sampaio, 2005; Gadanho et ai., 2006).
Phaff et al. (1978) expressed optimism that, " we are convinced that imaginative
research by yeast ecologists will lead to the discovery of many additional interesting
associations and the isolation of novel yeast species". This optimism has become reality
when beetle gut was identified as a diverse source of yeasts by Suh et al. (2005a). A
limited sampling of beetles of only 27 families from a limited geographical region
yielded 650 isolates of which about 200 were putative new species on the basis of
DIID2 domain sequencing. This provided an indication of how dramatically limited our
knowledge is about these organisms and the extent to which they have been ignored.
The authors predicted on the basis of their statistical analysis that every .one of the
beetle species potentially corresponds to one new yeast species. If this were true, then
by studying the Erotylidae group alone (estimated number of species is about 4500) in
the limited geographical region explored by the authors, would increase the number of
yeast species four to five times of what are currently known. Further extension of this
prediction to other group of beetles, bees, flies and other insect species and
consequently to the other habitats throughout the world, would make the estimated
3
PUjaSalt-{/a Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chondigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
number of yeast species to be extremely high. Such studies would make the number of
currently recognized species almost negligible.
Traditionally, the generIc description of yeasts is performed by usmg the
information gathered from morphology, vegetative biology, sexual state, shape(s) of the
sexual spores and physiological tests. Species are usually differentiated by
physiological tests, in particular through their utilization of carbon and nitrogen
sources. It is usually necessary to perform nearly 90 tests to obtain reliable biochemical
identification of yeasts at the species level, and it takes at least 2-4 weeks to obtain the
final results (Barnett et aI., 2000). As an alternative approach, DNA reassociation
experiments are performed between closely related species to confirm their relatedness
(Martini & Kurtzman, 1985). Over the past few years, the development and use of
molecular techniques have provided new dimensions to the knowledge on
characterization and identification of medically (Sugita et al., 2000) and industrially
important yeasts (Petersen et aI., 2001). The molecular techniques include use of
species-specific PCR primers (Hierro et aI., 2004), analysis of Restriction Fragment
Length Polymorphism (RFLPs), randomly-amplified polymorphic DNA and micro
satellite fingerprinting (Howell et aI., 2004). The development of these techniques has
provided us with several new approaches for rapid identification of yeasts at species
level which have become indispensible tools for understanding the biodiversity of
yeasts.
Direct comparison of genomic DNA sequences is the best means of determining
phylogenetic relationship between two different microbes. The ribosomal RNA (rRNA)
genes have been found to be the best molecular chronometers, because a) they are
universal, b) evolve at approximately the same rate, and c) behave like a single copy
region. Comparative sequence analysis of rRNA sequences reveals stretches of highly
conserved, semi-conserved and other regions with considerable amount of variability.
The coding regions are highly conserved but show enough sequence variability to allow
global-level classification. The Internal Transcribed Spacer region (ITS) and D1ID2
variable domain of 26S rRNA have proved very useful in measurements of close
genealogical relationships (Kurtzman, 1993b; Scorzetti et al., 2002). The nucleotide
divergence of more than 1 % in the combined sequence analysis of ITS region and
D1ID2 domain is generally accepted for describing a novel yeast species.
4
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
A great majority of known yeast species comes from Western Europe, Japan
and North America. Larger parts of Africa, Antarctica, Asia, Australia and America are
mainly virgin territories in this respect (Boekhout, 2005). This indicates that a lot of
natural habitats of yeasts have yet to be investigated. Consequently, we can only
assume that many additional species await discovery. Because yeasts are widely used in
traditional and modem biotechnology, the exploration for new species should lead to
additional novel technologies. On the other side correct identification, naming and
placing of yeasts in their proper evolutionary frameworks is also essential for their
exploration and utilization in various fields and also for determining the intellectual
property rights. Surprisingly, despite of rich tradition of mycology in India over several
decades, yeast diversity in India is largely unexplored except for a few studies recently
(Bhadra et aI., 2008; Rao et ai., 2008).
Majority of the yeasts are mesophilic in nature, capable of growing at 25 to
30°C. The capability of a yeast species to grow at higher temperatures than those of
mesophilic yeasts is defined as thermophily. The demarcation of mesophilic,
thermotolerant and thermophilic yeasts is not very clear but, the yeasts which can grow
upto 37°C are regarded as mesophilic yeasts and those which can grow optimally above
37°C are regarded as thermotolerant or thermophilic yeasts. However, the mechanisms
for thermophily are not well studied. It becomes important to know the basis of high
temperature growth. As reviewed from the literature, it is well accepted that several
mechanisms are responsible for high temperature growth in some thermophilic bacteria
and archaea. Among those thermostability of proteins, presence of compatible
molecules like trehalose, cDPG, DGP and derivatives of myo-inositol phosphate
(Arguelles, 2000; Santos & da Costa, 2002) are already known. Some of the most
important parameters in thermal adaptation are changes in membrane fluidity (Arthur &
Watson, 1976); post-translational modifications (Olsen & Thomsen, 1991), presence of
some unique genes like reverse gyrase (porterre et ai., 2000; Takami et ai., 2004). The
molecular basis of thermophily in yeasts can be summarized as a composite of genes,
proteins, protein modifications and metabolites.
As yeast diversity is quite unexplored in India, we initiated this work to
examIne the diversity of yeasts from soil and flowers from two high temperature
5
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter}: Introduction andReview o/Literature
regions of Indian state of Rajasthan and coal-belt of Khammam district in Andhra
Pradesh, where temperatures in summers range between 40°C - 50°C. The reason
behind selecting such regions is that yeast diversity from high temperature regions was
not much explored. We felt that it would be interesting to explore yeasts from these
regions as well as to get insight to look at the phenomenon of high temperature growth
in yeasts, The following objectives were proposed for the current study.
1) Isolation of yeasts from high temperature regions ofIndia.
2) Molecular characterization of yeast.
3) Comprehensive analysis of interesting isolates by polyphasic approach.
4) To examine the basis of thermo tolerance in yeast.
During the course of our studies, we have isolated and characterized about 215
isolates of yeasts. More than 30 species turned out to be potentially novel yeast species
and among them 17 were characterized more extensively by polyphasic approach and
proved to be novel species. Three new species have been described as; Cryptococcus
rajasthanensis, Debaryomyces singareniensis, Candida ruelliae (Saluja & Prasad,
2007a; Saluja & Prasad, 2007b; Saluja & Prasad, 2008). Interestingly, our exploration
of high temperature regions did not yield any novel thermophilic yeasts.
Further to examme the basis of thermophily in yeast, a thermophlic yeast
Hansenula polymorpha (Pichia angusta) has been used as a model organism. We
designed a genetic screen to look for gene(s) that could confer thermophilic traits upon
a non-thermophilic yeast. The details of our experiments and the pertinent literature are
discussed in Chapter-7.
6
1.2. Review of Literature
1.2.1. History of Yeasts
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chand;garh
Chapler 1: lnrroduclion and Review o/Lilerature
The word "yeast" comes from old English words gist, or gest which mean foam or froth
and from the Indo-European root jes-, meaning boil, foam, or bubble. Yeasts are
probably one of the earliest domesticated organisms. Even prior to 7000 B. c., beer was
being produced in Sumeria. Archaeologists digging in Egyptian ruins found early
grinding stones and baking chambers for yeasted bread, as well as drawings of 4,000
year-old bakeries and breweries. It is interesting that yeasts were being used far back in
history as industrial organisms, without people actually realizing them to be yeasts (or
even living organisms). It has been recently reported through chemical analyses of
ancient organics and preserves in pottery jars from Northern China that a mixed
fermented beverage of rice, honey, and fruit was being produced as far back as 9,000
years ago. It was approximately the same time that barley beer and grape wine were
beginning to be made in the Middle East (McGovern et ai., 2004).
Yeasts were first observed as globular structures rather than living organisms by
Antonie van Leeuwenhoek under microscope in 1680. It took until 1857 when Louis
Pasteur, a French microbiologist, first proved in his paper -Memoire sur la
fermentation alcoolique- that yeasts were the organisms responsible for alcoholic
fermentation (Barnett et ai., 2000). Yeasts have been classified under the kingdom
Fungi and are defined as a) organisms which survive as unicellular forms for at least a
small part of their life cycle and b) whose sexual states are not enclosed in perfect
fruiting bodies like that of fungi. Sexually reproducing yeasts are called perfect or
teleomorphic yeasts and the ones whose sexual state could not be determined are
known as asexual, anamorphic or imperfect yeasts.
1.2.2. Yeast Taxonomy Taxonomy is the science of classification, identification and nomenclature of
orgamsms. Classification implies the grouping of organisms into taxa, according to
actual similarities, presumed ancestral relationship or both. Identification requires the
comparison of unnamed species with similar, named species. Finally the nomenclature
is the naming of taxa as per rules of nomenclature codes (Mayr, 1942).
7
1.2.3. Classification and Nomenclature of Yeasts
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Yeasts and Fungi are classified using the rules of International Code of Botanical
Nomenclature. The most recent version of this code was adopted at the Seventeenth
International Botanical Congress at Vienna, Austria in July 2005. The official version
of the Code has been published as "International Code of Botanical Nomenclature
(Vienna Code)" (McNeill et ai., 2005). We are here describing briefly the Botanical
Code as it applies to Yeasts. The rules of this code are similar for describing genera,
families and orders to as of describing a new species. Some of the important rules
concerned with species description are described below.
1.2.4. Description of Species or Taxa
The publication of a new species will be valid only if a) it provides the description of
essential characteristics and as well as diagnosis that distinguishes the taxon from the
previously described taxa, b) the description and name of taxa must be given in Latin
(since January, 1993), c) the species should be published in recognized journal. Non
compliance with any of the above criteria will invalidate the newly described species
and termed as "nomen invalidum". The other important recommendation is that the
type material known as Holotype should be deposited in a publicly accessible
herbarium or culture collection. The Holotype refers to the isolate on which the
description of particular taxa is based. With the amendment of the 1994 code (Greuter
et ai., 1994), lyophilized cultures are also accepted as valid type material (Holotype),
and the living cultures derived from it are considered as ex typo i.e. from the type.
1.2.5. Early Development in Yeast Taxonomy
The most important unit of yeast taxonomy is the species. The classical definition of
biological species was given by Mayr (1942). It states, "Species are groups of actually
or potentially interbreeding natural populations, which are reproductively isolated from
other such groups". The above definition is frequently referred to as the biological
species concept. This definition although seemingly adequate for species delineation in
general but was not completely applicable to yeasts for the following reasons.
a) Most of the described species of yeasts are anamorphic.
b) Many yeasts species are homothallic (self-fertile).
8
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Lilerature
1.2.5.1. Species Delineation Based upon Phenotypic Characteristics
Although the genus Saccharomyces was introduced in 1837, but the concept of yeast as
species emerged only after the introduction of pure culture techniques by Hansen
during his studies on brewery yeasts (Hansen, 1888). The criteria employed by Hansen
for differentiation of yeast isolates were a) cellular and ascospore morphology, b)
optimal temperature of growth and c) fermentation ability. Hansen designated the
isolates to different species based upon these phenotypic characteristics. For his work
he is regarded as the founder of the phenotypic characterization as a means for species
delineation in yeasts. Several investigators have used a combination of morphological
(colony and cell morphology) as well as physiological characteristics for species
delineation in yeasts. Historically (between 1920s-1940s), the physiological
characteristics that were utilized involved the ability of yeasts species to ferment and/or
assimilate certain sugars, and assimilation of ethanol, sulphate, asparagine, urea,
peptone and nitrate (Kreger-Van Rij, 1987). Apart from these, the standard description
also included characteristics of the novel species' life cycle. The difference(s) in one
(mostly) or more characteristics of a novel strain with another known strain formed the
basis for describing a new species. Strength of phenotype-based approach lies in
identification of unique trait(s) that can be associated with a taxon (or higher levels)
with confidence and should not be subject to variability with time, space and laboratory
conditions. With the isolation of more and more species over time, the utility of this
less number of phenotypic characteristics for designating new species became limited.
In the 1950' s, the spectrum of phenotype-based tests was further extended by
Wickerham (1952) and today approximately 90 tests are performed routinely. These
tests include fermentation and assimilation of carbon compounds, assimilation of
nitrogenous compounds, resistance to cycloheximide and temperature requirements for
growth. In addition, wherever possible the sexual structures and sexual cycles were also
being taken into account.
1.2.5.2. Phenotype-based Classification of Yeasts
The classification of yeasts above the species level was also based upon a limited set of
phenotypic characteristics which include mode of vegetative reproduction, sexual
reproduction, physiological and biochemical characteristics as described for species
delineation. In addition, ultra structural details and coenzyme Q analysis were also
9
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
implicated for taxonomic groupmg. Electron mIcroscopy revealed the differences
between ascomycetous and basidiomycetous yeasts and that became the basis of first
level of dichotomy in classification. Ascomycetous yeasts have electron-transparent
cell wall and thin electron-dense outer layers, whereas basidiomycetous yeasts have
lamellate and electron-dense layers (Kreger-van Rij & Veenhuis, 1971).The cell walls
of these two groups also react differently to a chemical known as Diazonium blue B
(DBB). The basidiomycetous yeasts give red color with this reagent while
ascomycetous yeasts do not give any reaction (Hagler & Ahearn, 1981; Simmons &
Ahearn, 1987; Van Der Walt & Hopsu-Havu, 1976). These differences were useful in
the grouping of imperfect yeasts to ascomycetous or basidiomycetous yeasts.
Other methods like coenzyme Q analysis provide resolution only upto genus
level for the most part. The coenzyme Q or ubiquinones are components of respiratory
chain. In this system, variations are found as the number of isoprene units per molecule
and the number varies from Q-5 to Q-lO among yeasts (Yamada et aI., 1976a; Yamada,
et aI., 1976b; Yamada et aI., 1981). For example, the coenzyme Q-9 was reported in the
genus Dekkera and Debaryomyces and Q-6 in Saccharomyces and Arixozyma. A
combination of CoQ has been observed among the member of the genus Pichia. As
more than one genus can share similar type of Co-Q system this can not be used
inclusively for grouping of taxa.
The phenotype-based classification of yeasts as per Kreger-Van Rij (1987) has
been briefly described below. According to this classification yeasts were divided into
three categories.
a) The ascosporogenous yeasts,
b) The basidiosporogenous yeasts
c) The imperfect yeasts, based upon their mode of reproduction.
a) The ascosporogenous yeasts were classified under hemiascomycetous yeasts that
lack ascocarps (fruiting bodies in which ascopsores are formed) and ascogenous hyphae
(Ainsworth, 1973). Saccharomycetaceae and the Spermophthoraceae are the two
families belonging to the order Endomycetales under Hemiascomycetes. The two
families differ in shape of ascospores which are needle shaped in Spermopthoraceae
10
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review a/Literature
and have different shapes in Sachharomycetaceae. Further classification of lower ranks
was based upon the following characteristics.
i) Type of budding (monopolar, bipolar or multilateral budding)
ii) Shape of ascospores
iii) Ability to ferment
iv) Type of Coenzyme Q
b) The basidiomyceteous yeasts are the haploid phase in the life cycle of most
heterothallic basidiomycetes, where they originate from the germinated basidiospore
(Kreger-Van Rij, 1987). The basidiomycetous yeasts were classified further mainly on
the basis of following features.
I) Formation of true mycelium with or without clamp connection.
II) Presence of ball is to spore.
III) Fermentation ability
IV) Presence of chlamydospore and type of coenzyme Q.
The basidiomyceteous yeasts were divided into three groups.
i) Teliospore-forming yeasts
ii) Filobasidiaceae with a yeast phase
iii) Unclassified genus Sterigmatosoridium
c) The fungi imperfecti comprised the anamorphic yeasts for which the sexual state
could not be determined either because of the laboratory conditions (non-natural
habitat) or because of the isolation of only one mating type. Several species of this
group have close resemblance to other perfect species but lack sexual state. These
yeasts were separated into different families and genera on the basis of vegetative
reproduction, presence or absence of mycelium, pigmentation, fermentation ability,
nitrate assimilation, formation of asexual structure like ballistoconidia and blastospore
(Kreger-Van Rij, 1987).
1.2.5.3. Limitations of Phenotype-based Classification
The yeast classification and species delineation solely based upon morphological,
physiological and biochemical characteristics soon became inadequate. The results
were frequently found to be inconsistent, time consuming and labour intensive.
11
PtljaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Outcome of many of these tests is highly dependent upon the media, purity of
chemicals, and methods used to conduct the tests. Some tests were found to be variable
even within strains of a species. For example, Ditlevsen in 1944 (as cited in van der
Walt, 1987) had found a strain of Saccharomyces italicus to be heterozygous for short
and long cells. With the discovery of newer species, the resolution of several
characteristics which were earlier thought to be decisive in delineation of species
became rather inadequate. A compelling example is shape of ascospores, which formed
the basis for separation of families Spermophothoraceae and Saccharomycetaceae,
became questionable with the introduction of Pichia ohmeri (Kodamaea ohmeri) which
produced both spherical and hat shaped ascospores (Kurtzman, 1998b). The above
example and many others like it indicated that the classification and species delineation
solely based upon such a limited set of characteristics was artificial.
1.2.6. Yeast Taxonomy Based upon Molecular Methods
1.2.6.1. Assessment of G+C Content
The transition phase from phenotypic characters to molecular taxonomy started with
the development of methods for assessment of DNA base composition. The G+C
content of the 800 yeast species, ranged between 27-70 mol%. In general, for the
ascomycetous yeasts, the G+C content was about 27-50% while in basidiomycetous
yeasts, it was 50-70 %. The G+C content measurement was also dependent upon the
method used for the assessment. It was suggested that strains differing by more than 1-
l.5% through thermal denaturation method (Phaff et al., 1985; Price et al., 1978) or 2-
2.5% using buoyant density method would potentially represent different species
(Meyer, 1979). But the G+C measurement can not be used as a sole criterion for
species delineation because it provides no information about the DNA sequence.
Therefore, many different species may share the same G+C content while being very
different in other respects.
1.2.6.2. DNA-DNA Hybridization
The DNA complementarity was so far the only technique that provided resolution at the
species level and could be applied to anamorphic species as well. This technique
provided a quantitative means for assessment of the relatedness of genetic materials
among species and strains. The commonly used methods include spectrophotometric
12
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Th"is, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
analysis and membrane-bound reassociation techniques using radioisotopes or other
markers (Kurtzman, 1993a). Results of DNA complementation are expressed and
interpreted as percent relatedness. The correlation between the biological species
concept and DNA relatedness has been examined using genetic crosses utilizing both
homothallic and heterothallic species. Percent relatedness of 65-70% was found in
agreement for conspecific species in both homothallic and heterothallic backgrounds. A
DNA relatedness value of less than 20% showed distant relationship between the two
strains. Test subjects showing such values were often found to be new species. An
intermediate value of 35-60% suggested that the two strains being compared belonged
to different varieties of the same species.
The taxonomic interpretation of DNA hybridization values between 20-35% are
often difficult to interpret as exemplified below. Two heterothallic species Pichia
amylophila and P. mississipiensis (Kurtzman et aI., 1980b) showed 25% DNA
relatedness, the crosses between them showed abundant mating but limited ascus
formation where ascospores were not observed. Similar results were obtained upon
crosses between Pichia americana and P. bimundalis with 21 % DNA relatedness
(Kurtzman, 2006). In Issatchenkia scutulata and its variety exigua exhibited 25% DNA
relatedness but showed ascospore formation similar to intravarietal crosses. The
ascospore viability was only 5% and sibmating (mating among siblings) of the progeny
showed 17% viability, but the back cross to the parents resulted in low ascosporulation
and viability (Kurtzman et ai., 1980a). Thus the tests indicated that these were two
separate species. Homothallic species also gave similar results and can be defined in a
similar way. The above results suggested that although mating between homothallic
and heterothallic species could occur over a wide range of DNA relatedness values but
the highly fertile ascospores or conspecificity was observed only in cases showing 70%
or higher DNA relatedness.
Although the technique of DNA-DNA hybridization proved to be highly
conclusive but was not suitable for routine analysis. First, this technique is very
cumbersome and requires that DNA from a single species be hybridized to all the
related species followed by reciprocal hybridizations. Second, the information gathered
from this technique is limited to being applicable at the sister-species level.
13
1.2.6.3. Sequence-based Yeast Taxonomy
PujaSaluja Ph D. Tlresis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: lntroduction and Review of Literature
The resolution of all the methods described above became limited with the increase in
the number of identified species and with the advent of new technologies. Sequence
based identification has revolutionized the taxonomy of yeasts. By using DNA
sequences, the phylogenetic relationships among the species can be easily established
and the sequence results are almost always consistent and not dependent upon space,
time and the method used. Such advantages have made it the method of choice. The
other major benefit of this technique is that the teleomorphic and anamorphic
relationship can be suspected by construction of phylogenetic trees. This reduces the
redundancy in nomenclature by combining the synonyms together.
Important Considerations for Selection of the Molecular Choronometer
The selection of a gene to be used for inferring the phylogeny is very crucial and
challenging task. A gene which can be used as a choronometer should fulfill the
following criteria (Kurtzman, 1994a; Valente et ai., 1999).
a) The gene must be present in all the organisms of interest. Thus, the genes which are
central (universal) to cellular functions are usually of choice. Examples include genes
whose products function in replication, transcription and/or translation - the processes
constituting the "Central Dogma" of molecular biology.
b) The gene of interest should not be subj ect to lateral transfer. The gene history may
not faithfully represent the history of the organism when a gene is capable of being
laterally transferred. When a gene performs a central function, an organism is unlikely
to acquire a copy by lateral transfer, since the organism must already have a functional
copy to be alive.
c) The gene must be large enough and contain appropriate level of conserved and
diverged regions so as to allow inference of its phylogeny at different taxonomic levels.
Divergent sequences have a tendency to become randomized, and therefore impose a
limit to which the divergence of sequences can be accurately inferred. If the sequences
are too conserved then there may be little or no change between the evolutionary
branches of interest, and it will not be possible to infer close (genus or species level)
relati onshi ps.
14
PujaSaluja Ph D. Thesis, IMTECH ChandiglITh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
1.2.6.4. Ribosomal RNA Gene (Ribosomal DNA)-based Phylogeny
The rRNA genes attracted interest almost universally to infer the phylogeny as they
accomplish all the criteria of the molecular chronometer mentioned above. The regions
of rRNA gene were used to infer phylogeny from higher taxonomic levels such as
kingdom, orders and consequently to the level of species in all domains of life (Chaw et
ai., 1997; Field et ai., 1988; Gouy & Li, 1989; Hori et ai., 1985; Leclerc et ai., 1994).
Organisation of Ribosomal RNA gene cluster (rRNA genes or rDNA)
In Saccahromyces cerevisiae, the rRNA genes (rDNA) are arranged in a tandem array
of 140-200 rDNA units comprising of small subunit (SSUI18S), internal transcribed
spacer region-l (ITSl), S.8S, internal transcribed spacer region-2 (ITS2), large sub unit
(LSU/26S) rRNA, intergenic spacer region-l (IGSl), SS rRNA and internal
transcribed spacer region-2 (lGS2) (Fig. 1.2). Three coding genes of the cluster SSU
(I8S), S.8S and LSU (26S) rRNA are transcribed in one direction and the SS rRNA is
transcribed in the opposite direction (Philippsen et ai., 1978). Comparative sequence
analysis of rRNA gene sequences revealed some stretches of highly conserved, semi
conserved and other regions with considerable amount of variability. The coding
regions are highly conserved but show enough sequence variability to allow
classification upto species level. The non-coding regions (spacer regions) are less
subject to evolutionary constraints due to functiomilloss, hence show lot of variation in
the sequences. These are useful for inferring the phylogeny of closely related species.
)
<i-
RS1 RS2 1GS1 1652 RS1 RS2 1651 1652
1 1 H ! 1 H ! -1 HH HH
185 5.85 265 55 185 5.85 265 55
Unit-l Unit-2
Fig. 1.2. Schematic organization of the ribosomal RNA gene cluster in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.
Regions of Ribosomal RNA gene cluster used to infer phylogeny
Use of5S rRNA gene (5S rDNA)
The SS rRNA was the first gene to be used to infer phylogeny because of its conserved
nature and short length (Ca.120 nucleotide). Walker and Doolittle (I982 and 1983)
IS
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH ChaIJdigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
used 5S rRNA sequences to assign the phylogeny of basidiomycetous fungi and yeasts
(including anamorphs). They correlated the phenotype- and sequence-based
information and separated basidiomycetes in five clusters. Phylogeny of ascomycetous
yeasts was also studied similarly on the basis of 5S rRNA sequences (Walker, 1985).
The sequence of 5S rRNA region was used to establish broad phylogentic relationships
but its rather small size soon became limiting in resolving the relationships.
Use of small subunit (SSU) and large subunit (LSD) rRNA gene sequences
Other regions explored for studying phylogeny of yeasts were small subunit rRNA gene
(SSU rRNA or SSU rDNA) (Ca. 1800 nucleotides) and large subunit rRNA gene (LSU
rRNA gene or LSU rDNA) (Ca. 3200 nucleotides). These regions are larger than the 5S
rRNA therefore better resolution can be expected. Comparisons of sequences from
wide variety of organisms suggested that these regions comprised of various conserved
and variable domains having different rates of nucleotide substitutions. Because of
these characteristics, these regions have been regarded as a collection of chronometers,
with each region offering a different glimpse of the evolutionary history of an organism
(W oese, 1987). It was suggested that the partial sequence analysis of rRNAs could
display the same phylogeny as the complete sequence and thus promoted partial
sequence analysis as a rapid and economical method for ascertaining phylogenetic
relationships (Mc Carroll et al., 1983; Lane et al., 1985).
Use ofSSU rRNA gene (I8S rRNA gene or 18S rDNA)
The SSU rRNA gene is about 1800 nucleotides long in S. cerevisiae. The SSU rRNA
variability map of S. cerevisiae is shown in the Fig. 1.3. The color coding represents the
extent of nucleotide variability among different organisms. In this map, 5 variability
classes were identified which ranged from very conserved (blue) to highly variable
(red). Positions that are identical in all organisms taken into account are indicated in
purple. Positions which are present in less than 25% of these organisms or for which
the alignment was unreliable are indicated in grey in the map. This map is available for
download and is distributed for free by its author at the ribosomal RNA database
(http://bioinformatics. psb. ugent. be/webtool s/rRNA).
16
saccharomyces cerevisiae SSUrRNA variability map
0 0
0' c::J. 0' c· C' e <2"'-
PujaSal'l/a Ph D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Fig. 1.3. Variability map of SSU rRNA of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The different colors represent the extent of variability and range from conserved (purple) to highly variab I e (red) (http://bioinformatics. psb. ugent. be/webtools/rRN N).
Petersen and Kurtzman (1991) selected four regions SSU rRNA gene to assess
their resolution in deliniating yeasts. The four regions selected of SSU rRNA (18S-566,
18S-901, 18S-1137 and 18S-1627) were found to be much too conserved to be useful in
delineation of individual species. However, the region 18S-1627 showed some
variability to differentiate among genera.
The complete sequencing of 18S rRNA gene was used to resolve the
phylogenetic relationships among the members of the genera Brettanomyces,
Debaryomyces, Dekkera, Kluyveromyces (Cai et al., 1996) and Saccharomyces (James
et aI., 1997). The teleomorph-anamorph relationship was established between
Brettanomyces (anamorph) and Dekkera (teleomorph), as members of these genera
formed a monophyletic group. The genera Saccharomyces (James et al., 1997) and
Kluyveromyces were suggested to be polyphyletic (Cai et al., 1996). In addition to this,
full sequencing of 18S region was used to infer phylogeny at higher taxa viz order, class
17
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
and family levels in fungi (Swann & Taylor, 1995; Swann & Taylor, 1993), and for
classifying yeasts and fungi of basidiomycetes (Sugiyama & Suh, 1993).
Use ofDI1D2 Domain ofLSU rRNA gene (DI1D2 Domain ofLSU rDNA) sequencing
The D1 and D2 domains are present towards the 5' end of LSU rRNA gene and
comprise of about 600 bases. The secondary structure showing the D11D2 domains is
depicted in the Fig. 1.4. The primer NL1 starts ahead of D1 region and primer NL4 is
beyond the D2 region.
Peterson and Kurtzman (1991) used the D2 regIOn (also known as the D2
domain) of LSU rRNA gene to assess its resolution at species level. The sequencing of
D2 region was found to be highly variable and it allowed separation of closely-related
species. Although D2 region was found to be much too variable to establish phylogeny
among distantly related species, several studies used the D2 sequences successfully to
differentiate among genera in ascomycetous as well as basidiomycetous yeasts (Fell &
Kurtzman, 1990; Fell & Statzell-Tallman, 1992; Fell et al., 1992; Walker, 1985;
Yamada et ai., 1994). Kurtzman and Robnett (1997) were the first to sequence the
D 11D2 domains of almost all the clinically important yeasts. They established
phylogenetic relationships upto species levels and also constructed the phylogenetic
trees to study anamorph-teleomorph relationships. Their results were verified and
correlated with nuclear DNA complementarity for closely-related representative species
included in the study. They further expanded the work to infer phylogeny of all the
ascomycetous yeasts and the database they generated has become an indispensible tool
for species identification (Kurtzman & Robnett, 1998).
18
.. ,
PujaSaJuja Ph D. Tlresis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Fig. 1.4. Schematic representation of the secondary structure of D 1 and D2 domains of LSU rRNA (modified from Inacio et aI., 2003).
On the basis of D IID2 domain sequences, it was suggested for ascomycetous yeast,
strains showing a difference of more than 6 nucleotides (1 %) would represent different
species whereas, conspecific strains usually exhibit 1-3 nucleotide divergence.
However, there are some exceptions like Clavispora lusitaniae, in which up to 5%
variation was observed in the DIID2 domain sequence among different strains
(Lachance et ai., 2003b). Fell et aI., (2000) sequenced DIID2 domains of
basidiomycetous yeasts thereby extending the database to encompass almost all the
yeasts known at that time.
Use of spacer regions
The other regions which gained interest in resolving phylogenetic relationships were
the spacer regions: internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) and intergenic spacer region
(IGS.). Although DIID2 variable domain was very useful in differentiating species of
yeasts, several studies have shown that the resolution of ITS region in general was
better than D IID2 region, and researchers started using this region to provide additional
information in support of differentiating species (Fell et al., 2002). The ITS region
comprises of two spacer regions viz ITSI and ITS2 which are separated by 5.8S rRNA
19
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
between them as shown in the Fig. 1.5. The length of these variable regions may vary
from 300-1300bp among different yeasts.
l8S
ITSln~2 Fig. 1.5. Schematic representation of a unit of r DNA to show Internal transcribed spacer region ITS 1 and ITS2 (modified from Nazar, 2004).
Sequencing of ITS from all known basidiomycetous yeasts was performed by
Fell et al. (2002). Their analysis suggested that combined sequence analysis (D11D2
and ITS) was more appropriate for species delineation of basidiomycetous yeasts as
their D11D2 region tends to be quite conserved (showed 2-3 base differences among
species of some groups) (Fell et ai., 2002). The ITS sequencing was suggested as a
rapid and accurate method for differentiation and identification of pathogenic yeasts
Peterson et ai, 2001; Leaw et aI., 2006; Wang et aI., 2007). ITS sequencing was also
performed to study the diversity of yeasts from arbuscular mycorrhizal roots (Renker et
ai., 2004), marine yeasts (Nagahama et ai., 2001), and yeasts from food (Foschino et
ai., 2004). Belloch et ai. (2002) used ITS sequence analysis along with electrophoretic
karyotyping and phenotypic characteristics for characterization of 39 strains belonging
to four species in the genus Kiuyveromyces. The ITS sequences sometimes could
resolve the relationship even below the species level. For example, five varieties of
Williopsis saturns containing identical 18S rDNA sequences, were resolved by ITS
sequences (James et ai., 1998). ITS sequence was found to be more useful than D11D2
sequence analysis for species delineation in the genus Taphrina (Rodrigues & Fonseca,
2003). Cadez et al. (2003) used both the ITS and D11D2 domain sequences to describe
four new species in the genus Hanseniaspora. Fifteen strains of Cryptococcus were
reclassified by combined sequence analyses of 18S, D11D2 and ITS regions and as a
result, three new combinations of yeasts viz Cr. aureus, Cr. carnescens and Cr. peneaus
were proposed (Takashima et ai., 2003).
Some studies on basidomycetous yeasts suggested that boundary for species
delineation using ITS sequence as 1% nucleotide divergence (Sugita et ai., 1999;
20
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Takashima & Nakase, 2000). In contrast Bai et al. (2001a and 2001b) found
approximately 2% divergence among some conspecific strains. Fell et al. (2000) found
that some yeasts species whose relationships could not be resolved by DIID2 sequence
could be resolved well using ITS sequences. On the contrary, Bai et al. (2002) reported
that species could have similar ITS and quite divergent DIID2 sequences. For example,
S strains of Sporobolomyces phaffi differed from S. ruberrimus by 3 nucleotides in ITS
sequences but exhibited 18-19 nucleotide differences in D IID2 domain sequences. It
can be concluded on the basis of above discussion that analysis based upon more than
one sequence provides more reliable information and is preferred for phylogenetic
analysis. Therefore a combination of ITS and D IID2 sequences is recommended for
obtaining more reliable conclusions.
The other spacer region used in phylogeny is IGS which is highly divergent
when compared to ITS. The IGS region was used for generating RFLP patterns for
phylogenetic analysis of the species in Saccharomyces group (Montrocher et al., 1998).
The difference in IGS length and sequence (upto 20%) was reported even among the
varieties of Cr. neoformans (Diaz et aI., 2000). The limitations in use of IGS are the
presence of homopolymeric regions and repetitive sequences which make its
sequencing rather problematic. Fell et al. (2007) used ITS and IGS sequences to reveal
the phylogenetic relationship between the species of Xanthophyllomyces which was not
resolved by DIID2 sequences. The level of differentiation that can be achieved from
different parts of rRNA gene cluster has been presented in Table 1.1.
Table 1.1. Taxonomic resolution of sequences of different parts of rRNA gene cluster.
Molecule Approx Higher Family Genus Species Sub Strains or region length category species
or variety
SSrDNA 120 bp + + + S.8S rDNA 158 bp + + + 18S rDNA 1800 bp + + + DIID2 600bp + + + + domain ITS 300-1300 + + + + +
bp IGS 2.4-4.1 + + + + + +
Kb
>,q' 5.{,2- 'T\-\- t6477 e 9eyC$ 81 (! Ubrary~' bL- ~ il 21 ~. ~
l#-
1.2.7. Modern Species Definition in Yeasts
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, lMTECHChandigarh
Chapter}; Introduction andReview of Litera hire
The development in tools and techniques helped to generate the phylogenetic concept
of species delineation as an alternative of biological species concept According to this,
"species is defined as a monophyletic group composed of the smallest diagnosable
cluster of organisms within which there is a parental pattern of ancestory and discent"
(Cracraft, 1983).
The above definition can be put in a simplistic form as follows. In a system of
classification, all the taxonomic categories should be monophyletic from an
evolutionary point of view. So, the classification whether based upon the phenotypic
characters or the molecular methods relies on a set of characters which results in
monophyly.
The modern classification system of ascomycetous and basidiomycetous yeasts
as described in "The Yeasts: A Taxonomic Study" (Boekhout et al., 1998a; Kurtzman,
1998a) and its relation with rRNA-gene phylogeny of ascomycetous and
basidomycetous yeasts is presented in brief below.
1.2.8. Current System of Yeast Classification
1.2.8.1. Classification of Ascomycetous Yeasts
Historically, ascomycetes were divided into two taxonomic classes or subclasses called
Hemiascomycetes and Euascomycetes. Several studies on the phylogeny of the
ascomycetous yeasts (Hausner et al., 1992; Hendriks et aI., 1992; Kurtzman, 1993b;
Kurtzman, 1994a; Kurtzman & Robnett, 1994b; Nishida & Sugiyama, 1994; Walker,
1985), utilized different parts of rRNA gene sequences. On the basis of those studies,
Kurtzman (1998a) suggested the following three major lineages in ascomycetous
yeasts.
a) Hemiasocomycetes (Order Saccharomycetales) includes budding yeasts and
yeast-like taxa such as Ascoidea and Cephaloascus. In this group asci are not
formed in or on the fruiting bodies.
22
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review of Literature
b) Euascomycetes is a sister group to the Hemiascomycetes and represents
the'filamentous' species, some of which are dimorphic. Here; the asci of nearly
all species form within or upon the fruiting bodies (Oosporidium).
c) Archiascomycetes represents a phylogenetically broad assemblage of yeast-like
taxa basal to the previous groups and comprised of the genera
Schizosaccharomyces, Saitoella, Protomyces, Taphrina and Pneumocystis.
The currently accepted classification is based upon the combination of phenotypic
and molecular methods. But this classification may be revised in future as the existence
of several orders, families and genera became doubtful on the basis ofDI1D2 sequence
analysis of ascomycetos yeasts by Kurtzman & Robnett (1998). For example, the
DIID2 sequence analysis showed that the family Lipomycetaceae to be monophyletic
and statistically well-supported (bootstrap = 98%). However, the seven presently
included teleomorphic genera were suggested to be paraphyletic, suggesting that ascus
morphology, ascospore ornamentation, and composition of coenzyme Q were
unreliable phylogenetic parameters. Similarly, the genera Nadsonia, Wickerhamia,
Hanseniaspora and Saccharomycodes all showed bipolar budding which would suggest
a close relationship among them. However, this character did not prove to be of
evolutionary significance on the basis of DIID2 sequences as the members of these
genera turned out to belong to entirely separate clades. Several such contradictory
results highlighted the poor resolution of phenotypic characters in inferring the
underlying phylogeny. The phylogenetic analysis of ascomycetous yeasts based upon
DIID2 alone was not sufficient to resolve basal lineages.
Kurtzman & Robnett (1998) suggested that additional DNA sequences (multi gene
sequence analysis) should be used to draw any genetic boundaries. They used the
combined sequence analysis of rRNA genes (18S, 26S and ITS), translation elongation
Factor Ia (EF-I a), actin-I, RNA polymerase II and mitochondrial-encoded gene
(SSUr DNA, COX II) to resolve the phylogeny of Saccharomyces species complex
(Kurtzman, 2003; Kurtzman & Robnett, 2003). This analysis identified 11 well
supported clades in the family Saccharomycetaceae and resulted in proposal of 5 new
genera and reassigned several species among currently accepted genera. This work was
further expanded to resolve phylogenetic relationship of Trichomonascus,
23
PujaSaJt{ja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chand;garh
Chapter]: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Wickerhamiella and Zygoascus yeast clades (Kurtzman & Robnett, 2007) and of
polyphyletic genus Pichia (Kurtzman et ai., 2008),
1.2.8.2. Classification of Basidiomycetous Yeasts
The ultra structure and molecular analysis based upon SSU rDNA, D1ID2 and ITS
sequence analyses of basidiomycetous yeasts suggested the occurrence of
basidiomycetous yeasts in three main phylogenetic classes of Basidiomycota namely
the Hymenomycetes, Urediomycetes and Ustilaginomycetes (McLaughlin et ai., 1990;
Swann & Taylor,1993; Swann & Taylor, 1995),
a) Hymenomycetous yeasts produce dolipore septa, and cell walls contain glucose,
mannose, and xylose (Fell et al., 2000). In these yeasts, inositol is usually
assimilated and starch-like compounds are also produced.
b) Uredinomycetous yeasts produce spores in which cell wall is attenuated towards
the central pore, Cell wall may contain mannose, glucose, fucose or rhamnose
but not xylose (Fell et ai., 2000). These yeasts donot produce starch-like
compounds and are unable to utilize inositol.
c) Ustilaginomycetous yeasts have microspore-like septa with or without an
inflated margin and which differ from simple pores because they do not have
tapering cell walls and probably lack a true pore (Bauer et al., 1989; Boekhout,
et al., 1998a; Boekhout et ai., 1992; McLaughlin et ai., 1995; O'Donnell &
McLaughlin, 1984), In these yeasts, glucose, galactose, and mannose are
present while xylose is absent in the cell wall, Inositol mayor may not be
present and strach-like compounds are not produced,
Phylogenetic analysis of basidiomycetous yeasts based upon DIID2 domain of
LSU rDNA was performed by Fell et al. (2000) and in combination with ITS was
performed by Scorzetii et al. (2002), In these studies several monophyletc clades were
identified in all the three classes and species boundaries were discussed, Members of
the class Uredinomycetes were distributed into Microbotryum, Sporidiobolus,
Agaricostilbum and Erythrobasidium clades, In the class Hymentomycetes;
Trichosporonales ord, nov., Filobasidiales and Cystofilobasidiales clades were
identified, Ustilaginales, Microstromatales and Malasseziales clades found their place
in the class Ustilaginomycetes. Members of some genera were distributed among more
24
PujoSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
than one clade and are thus polyphyletic. The Genera Cryptococcus, Rhodotorula and
Sporobolomyces are polyphyletic. In contrast, other genera, like Buliera,
Cystofilobasidium, Feliomyces, Filobasidielia, Filobasidium, Kondoa,
Kurtzmanomyces, Leucosporidium, Rhodosporidium, Sporidiobolus and Udeniomyces
are monophyletic.
Although these yeasts have been separated into many clades but the
phylogenetic trees based upon the ITS and DIID2 sequences do not adequately resolve
the relationships among taxa as most of the clades exhibit low boot strap values. This
may be due to the insufficient data as current estimates suggested that only about 1%
(or less) of the total number of basidiomycetous yeast species have been identified (Fell
et al., 2000). With more research it is very likely that there will be more pieces to fill
the vacant places in this puzzle. It is also highly possible that with the discovery of
more species several of the currently drawn phylogenetic trees would undergo
rearrangements that could reflect their more accurate placing and the resulting
bootstrap values would improve.
-1.2.9. Modern Approaches for Species Delineation in Yeasts The identification of species based on phenotypic characteristics is frequently
insufficient and moreover can lead to errors in identification of species. Therefore the
standard fermentation and assimilation tests can not be used solely to unambiguously
define a new species. The results from such tests may however be used to
diagnostically recognize some genetically defined species or groups of species. These
tests provide general information about the physiology of the strain and its metabolic
properties. In addition, these tests are of immense value to biologists, ecologists and
others that need to know about the physiological properties of the species/strains under
investigation. DNA sequence on the other hand provides no information regarding
biology of the species. Therefore the descriptions of any new species can not solely rely
on nucleotide data. As a result, the current approach in yeast taxonomy follows a
combination of phenotypic as well as molecular characterization of yeasts for species
delineation. This approach is regarded as the polyphasic approach which afso includes
the study of sexual structures wherever possible.
25
1.2.10. Yeast Diversity
PujaSa/uja Ph. D. Thesis, lMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Yeasts are not as ubiquitous as bacteria but have been isolated from a wide variety of
natural habitats. Yeasts are strictly chemo-organotrophic as they can not perform
photosynthesis. As a result they require fixed organic forms of carbon for growth. The
yeasts are known to utilize quite diverse compounds which include polyols, simple
sugars, aliphatic alcohols, hydrocarbons, various heterocyclic and polymeric
compounds, organic and fatty acids. The diversity of yeasts in a particular niche is
determined by its nutritional selectivity. Owing to that some species of yeasts which are
nutritionally heterogeneous have been isolated from many different habitats as a result
species of the genera e.g. Debaryomyces and Cryptococcus are considered as
cosmopolitan yeasts. The high surface/volume ratio of yeasts helps in rapid nutrient
absorption. The yeasts can grow over a wide range of pH values, but cannot grow at
very high temperatures. They generally grow in the range of 25°C -37°C (Ueno et al.,
2001). The maximum temperature of growth of yeasts is found to be 52°C. Yeast have
been explored from many diverse terrestrial as well as aquatic habitats. Terrestrial
habitats mostly include plants, animals and soil. Aquatic habitats include fresh-water
and marine habitats and study of estuaries as well. Study of fermentative and
pathogenic yeasts diversity is another point of focus in this field. Study of yeast
diversity is a broad wide-ranging topic, therefore we can not cover all of it, and instead
we have focused and described some of its important and pertinent aspects related to
our work.
1.2.10.1. Yeast Diversity from Flowers and Insects
Many insects are known to possess eukaryotic symbionts m their digestive tract.
Although this symbiotic relationship is not well understood but some studies have
indicated that certain microorganisms might play important roles for their hosts
including detoxifying food material and providing essential nutrients (Dowd, 1989;
Dowd, 1991; Vega & Dowd, 2005). Yeasts have been isolated from flowers and guts of
associated insects, examples include guts of basidiocarp-feeding beetles and several
other insects. Although the symbiotic relationship has been suspected but the
underlying mechanism is not understood. Clues about the unresolved question of
symbiotic relationship between the members of these ecosystems will help us
understand better the role of yeasts in ecosystem management.
26
Puja Saluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review of Literature
Three new yeast species were isolated during studies of yeasts associated with
ephemeral flowers in Brazil, Australia and Hawaii. Among them Kodamaea
nitidulidarum and Candida restingae were isolated from cactus flowers and associated
nitulid beetles in sand dune ecosystems (restinga) of Southeastern Brazil. Kodamaea
anthophila were isolated from Hibiscus and morning glory flowers (Ipomoea spp.) and
from associated nitulid beetles and Drosophila hibiscus in Australia (Rosa et al., 1999).
Since, these yeasts species were not isolated from any other habitat therefore; these
yeasts have been suggested to be the persistent members of yeast-flower-insect
community. Lachance and co-workers (2001c) studied the yeast communities of
ephemeral flowers and associated insects in the Neotropical, Nearctic and Australian
bio-geographic regions. They investigated the occurrence of yeasts from the flowers of
the families Malvaceae, Convolvulaceae and Cactaceae, and insects including beetles,
flies and bees, which regularly visit these flowers. They found some interesting
correlations between the yeast-flower-insect relationship. Australian community was
dominated by the insect Aethina concolor and the yeast species Kodamaea anthophila
where as the other regions dominated by Conotelus mexicanus and in turn by yeasts
species of Metschnikowia. Interestingly, in Hawaii region where both of these insects
are found, the yeast community also typically represents both geographic regions. This
specificity was further confirmed by the analysis of yeast diversity from other plants
which were not visited by insects. Thus the authors concluded that these yeasts were
the part of a specific insect-flower ecosystem.
Another comprehensive study of yeast-insect-morning glory system of Kipuka
Puaulu, Hawaii was performed by Lachance et al. (2003a). On the basis of their study,
they proposed that Metschnikowia hawaiiensis was confined to Hawaii as it has not
been isolated anywhere else after its first description by Lachance et al. (1990). They
concluded thatM hawaiiensis and Candida kipukae were specific symbionts ofNitulid
B (an unidentified beetle) and that other species like Candida ipomoeae and
Metschnikowia lochheadii are associated with Conotelus mexicanus (Beetle). This
study raised several interesting questions: what are the factors maintaining this type of
specificity? What type of interaction may be occurring there with the other species?
Another interesting distribution was found of ten putative new species of genus
Starmerella, which was specifically isolated from bees during the study by Lachance et
27
---- ---------~---------
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review a/Literature
al, (2000) and Rosa et al. (2003). Several species of the genus Starmerella (probable
anamorphs of Starmerella) viz Candida cleridarum, Candida tilneyi, Candida powellii
(Lachance et al., 2001a), Candida riodocensis, and Candida cellae (pimentel et aI.,
2005) have been described recently from such habitats. A mutualistic relationship
among species of yeasts of Starmerella complex and associated bees has been
suggested for Candida magnoliae, Starmerella bombicola and Candida batistae (Rosa
et aI., 2003). The yeasts appeared to be viable as high cell count was found in honey
and pollen provisions of these bees. The authors suggested that yeasts may be involved
in increasing the nutritional quality of these resources as they are known to provide
nutrients in many insects (Lachance et al., 1990; Morais et aI., 1994; Starmer, 1981).
Although some of these species like Candida etchellsii, have also been isolated from
other habitats and some are known to be spoilage yeasts in sugary substances but the
authors suggested that these yeasts were vectored by these bees which are mostly
attracted by sugary substances. The other genus which was suggested to be a part of
such systems is Wickerhamiella and the five species currently known in this genus have
been isolated from yeast-insect-flower ecosystem (Lachance et aI" 1998).
Recently in a breakthrough research, beetles that feed on basidiocarps were
recognized as a hyper diverse habitat, and a total of 650 yeasts were isolated from
beetles of 27 families. Of the 650 yeast species, nearly 200 species were suspected to
be putative new species on the basis of their D11D2 domain sequences (Suh et al.,
2005a). This study provided an important insight into an unrealized truth that the
number of yeast species is grossly underestimated. The studies on insects revealed that
these yeast are often well separated as unique clades. For example, during the study of
yeasts from baisdiocarp-feeding beetle, more than 30% yeasts from 1000 guts of
beetles were clustered in clades near Candida tazawaensis and Candida krusii (Nguyen
et al., 2006; Suh et aI., 2006). The other unique clades were related to Candida
mesenterica, Candida membranaefaciens, Pichia guilliermondii and Geotrichum
species (Suh & Blackwell, 2004; Suh & Blackwell, 2005; Suh et al., 2005b; Suh &
Blackwell, 2006). In another study, the yeasts Spathaspora passalidarum gen nov. sp.
nov. and its sister taxa Candida jeffriesii sp. nov were isolated and proposed from two
wood-ingesting beetles of the families Passalidae and Tenebrionidae (Nguyen et aI.,
2006). Although the yeasts isolated from insects are distantly related but showed
similar physiological profiles and also shared the ability to ferment xylose, a major
28
PujaSaluja Ph D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
component of hemicellulose and lignocellulosic mass (Nguyen et aI., 2006; Suh et aI.,
2003). The fermentation capability of these yeasts provided a clue about the symbiotic
relationship between yeasts and wood-ingesting beetles.
Another system which is studied in relation to insects is the 'cactus-yeast
insects' community. Several yeast species have been isolated from cactus nacrosis.
Although not unique, Drosophila is the most important and perhaps the most
predictable vector in this system. The core species of cactus-yeast communities are
Pichia cactophila, Sporopachydermia cereana and Candida sonorensis, which were
specifically reported from yeast communities of stems of many columnar cacti or
opuntia-cladode rots but were not isolated from decaying cactus-fruit tissues and tree
fluxes. Other yeast species that are frequently reported from cactus-rot pockets are
members of the Starmera 'amethionina complex' (St. amethionina var. amethionina,
var. pachycereana and St. caribaea), Candida ingens-like species (Dipodascus starmeri
and close relatives), Clavispora opuntiae and Myxozyma mucilagina (Starmer et aI.,
2003). The most interesting feature of these communities is the species specificity and
consistency in terms of space and time. During the study of yeast community of
Stenocereus gummosus from five distinct localities in Baja California, Norte, Mexico,
over the span of 15 years, Latham (1998) found that diversity was quite constant in
different regions studied, different location of the region, different plants within the
location and with in the plant necrosis. On the basis of rRNA gene analysis the
polyphyletic origin of these species was reported which can be further correlated to
some of the unique aspects of cactus chemistry, survival in the extreme environments,
vector association and interactions among the cacti, yeasts and insects. Although the
underlying mechanisms of these interaction would be a subject matter for
comprehensive research in future but some clues can already be gained from the studies
in such ecosystems. It has been suggested that the community as a whole rather than a
specific yeast of a cactus plant stimulate sexual behavior in insects, helps in larval
development and contribute to the size and fecundity of the adult insect (Starmer, &
Aberdeen, 1990). This helps in maintaining the vector-host specificity. On the other
hand maintenance of specific yeast communities on cacti has been suggested to be at
least partially because of the special functional traits that these communities confer
upon their hosts. It was found that C. sonorensis could utilize methanol as a source of
carbon and therefore would be specific to those environments where methanol is
29
PujaSaltlja Ph. D. ThEsis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
produced by plant cell-wall breakdown and it's the only species which can also ferment
glucose as well. S. cereana complex species can utilize inositol, a number of unusual
alcohols, aldehydes and ketones that are mostly produced in rotting cacti. This specific
utilization patterns might be responsible for maintaining its specificity in such
environments (Ganter, 1989).
1.2.10.2. Diversity of Phylloplane Yeasts
The external surface of leaves serves as a habitat for many microbes including yeasts.
This habitat is known as phyllosphere or phylloplane (Last & Price, 1969). The most
common yeasts of phylloplane are of basidiomycetous affinity and belong to the genus
Sporobolomyces, Rhodotorula (collectively referred to as the pink yeasts) and
Cryptococcus (white yeasts) (Inacio et ai., 2002; Phaff & Starmer, 1987). In addition,
members of the genera Bullera and Tilletiopsis are commonly isolated from leaves and
are thought to be especially adapted to leaf environment due to the production of
forcibly ejected ballistoconidia (Lindow & Brandl, 2003). Interestingly, the
ascomycetous yeasts were also isolated in equal proportions during studies of
phylloplane yeasts from Slovakia (Slavikova et al., 2007). Many new speCIes of
phyllolplane yeasts of genera Sporidiobolus (Wang & Bai, 2004), Dioszegia (Wang et
al., 2008), and Cryptococcus have been described recently (Inacio et al., 2005). Very
little is known about the ecology of phylloplane yeasts, and it has been suggested that
several factors including leaves and their surfaces determine the nature of yeast
community. Availability and the type(s) of nutrients available on the leaf surface are
considered as one of the important factor in determining the type of yeast community.
The availability of nutrients depends upon plant species, age of the leaf, and growth
conditions (Mercier & Lindow, 2000). The nutrients of the phylloplane, at least partly,
originate from the leaves themselves. Molecules leaching out of the plant leaves
include a variety of organic and inorganic compounds, such as sugars, organic acids,
amino acids, methanol and various salts (Slavikova et al., 2007). Other factors of the
leaf-surface environment to which the microbes needs to adapt, are thought to be
exposure of leaf surface to rapidly fluctuating temperature, relative humidity, and more
prominently the large fluxes of UV radiation from sun (Lindow & Brandl, 2003). Plant
surface represents a diverse habitat of microbes in general. So the occurrence of a
particular type of microbe(s) on a surface also depends upon their interactions with the
other microbes. In such habitats, yeasts are active as competitors for nutrients,
30
PtljaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECHChandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
antagonists or symbiotic associates, or as the victims of the behaviour of their
neighbours (Do Carmo-Sousa, 1969).
1.2.10.3. Diversity of Soil Yeasts
Yeasts were very frequently explored from soil in the 20th century (Atlas et aI., 1973;
Bouthilet, 1951; Danielson & Jurgensen, 1973). The species which were frequently
isolated from soil in the 20th century belonged to the genera Cryptococcus,
Debaryomyces, Kluveromyces, Lipomyces and, Pichia etc. (phaff & Starmer, 1987).
The estimated number of yeasts species from soil ranges between a hundred to
few thousand cells/gram of soil (Latham, 1998). Although not always true, but in
general the diversity of basidiomycetous yeasts dominate over ascomycetous yeasts in
soil (poliakova et aI., 2001; Slavikova & Vadkertiova, 2000). The frequent occurrence
of basidiomycetous yeasts of genus Cryptococcus, Rhodosporidium and Lipomyces
from soil was correlated with the presence of capsule due to which they can survive
better in pure nutrient conditions and during desiccation (Slavikova & Vadkertiova,
2000). But there may be additional reasons as well because some basidiomycetous
yeasts like Cryptococus spp. are also known to survive in oligotrophic conditions as in
oligotrophic-ocean waters and glacial melt water in Argentina (de Garcia et al., 2007;
Nagahama et aI., 2001). Most of the soil yeasts lack fermentation ability and are
therefore dependent upon the aerobic respiration and thought to occur mostly at the
depths of 5-15 cm. Although there are very limited exploratory studies of yeasts from
soil but a few studies have examined their diversity from several regions in different
parts of the world including Antarctic soils. In a very interesting study, viable yeasts
(upto 9000 CFUs) were reported from the permafrost soils of Siberia with an estimated
age of 3 million years (Dmitriev, 1997). Thus, despite the complexity of the
organization of a eukaryotic cell, eukaryotic microorganisms can be found to be equally
resistant under the conditions of Siberian permafrost soils as prokaryotes. The overall
diversity patterns were the same as the members of Cryptococcus, Rhodotorula, and
Sporobolomyces predominate there as well. Similarly, yeasts have been reported from
the extreme environments of Antarctic soil. In such extreme environments where first
colonizer are thought to be heterotrophic microbes rather than photosynthetic
organisms (Tscherko et al., 2003), yeasts are speculated to play key roles in nutritional
31
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: introduction and Review o/Literature
cycling and as members of food webs (Gadanho & Sampaio, 2005; Gadanho et aI.,
2006; Nagahama et aI., 2001).
The studies on soil yeasts based solely upon phenotypic characteristics (Mok et
aI., 1984; Slavikova & Vadkertiova, 2000; Slavikova & Vadkertiova, 2003; Vishniac,
1996) cannot be as informative and comparable to the current molecular studies
(Connell et al., 2008; Wuczkowski & Prillinger, 2004). The reason as explained earlier
is that the identification based solely upon phenotypic characters is often not reliable
and therefore as a result several species which were deposited in the culture collections
are being re-identified and reclassified based upon modern methods (Fonseca et aI.,
2000; Inacio & Fonseca, 2004; Takashima et al., 2003). A study on the diversity of soil
and litter yeasts from alluvial forest national park based upon molecular methods was
performed by Wuczkowski and Prillinger (2004). In their study, 136 yeast strains, with
36 different sequences belonging to 16 genera were identified. The dominating yeasts
from the soil and litter were related to Cryptococcus, Sporobolomyces and
Trichosporon. Study of yeast species from rhizosphere and non-rhizosphere soils of
Panax ginseng (a medicinal plant) cultivation field was performed recently (Hong et
al., 2006). Among the 34 isolated yeasts, 3 were ascomycetous and 14 were
basidiomycetous yeasts. Among the basidiomycetous yeasts, one was Uredinomycetous
yeast, Rhodotorula sloojiae and 12 were hymenomycetous yeasts of which, except one
isolate, all others were of different species of the genus Cryptococcus. Cryptococcus
podzolicus was originally isolated from forest soil in Siberia ( Fell & Statzell -Tallman,
1998a) and afterwards from rhizosphere soil in Korea. Cr. watticus which was isolated
from soil of Antarctica (Guffogg et aI., 2004), was also from rhizosphere soil of
Chinese balloon flower and apple tree (Hong et aI., 2002) and also from soil of Panax
ginseng field (Hong et aI., 2006). This type of species which have mainly been isolated
from soil samples provides clues towards understanding the ecology of such yeasts. As
the studies on the diversity of soil yeasts are rather limited throughout the world, a
comprehensive view cannot be drawn. Understanding the several different aspects of
their ecology in this habitat would require many more studies. Although biodiversity of
soil yeasts has been suggested to play only a minor role in soil but the occurrence of
specific types of yeasts in a limited survey of 3 millions years old soil and from
extreme environments of Antarctica strongly argue that they might be performing some
as yet unknown but important roles in those soils.
32
1.2.10.4. Diversity of Fermentative Yeasts
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
The foremost and oldest application of yeasts utilizes their fermentation ability to
produce ethanol, alcoholic beverages and fermented foods. The most popular yeasts
responsible for fermentation are the strains of Saccharomyces viz strains of S.
cerevisiae, S. exiguus and S. rosei. These include bakers yeast, wine yeasts (including
special flocculent strains for the production of champagne and film-forming strains for
the production of flor sherry), sake yeast, top and bottom fermenting brewing yeasts
and distiller stains used for alcohol production (Demain et aI., 1998). There is
continuing research on the role of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in beer, wine and bread
fermentations but with time research has expanded into exploring the role(s) of yeasts
in other products as well (Fleet, 2007). Several non-Saccharomyces yeasts in addition
to S. cerevisiae are attracting interests for many different applications that include
adding flavor, aroma, or improving the texture during cheese maturation (Addis et ai.,
2001), preparation of sausages (Cocolin et aI., 2006; Gardini et ai., 2001) and varieties
of sour dough (Fleet, 2007). Some of these non-conventional yeasts are: Debaryomyces
hansenii, Yarrowia lipoiytica, Kiuyveromyces maraxianus, Saccharomyces exiguus,
Candida milleri, C. humilis, C. krusei (Issatchenkia orientalis), Pichia anamoia, and P.
membranifaciens, Yarrowia lipoiytica is generating considerable research interest as it
showed lipolytic and proteolytic activities, both of which can be exploited for
biotechnological applications (Gardini et aI., 2001). Species of some other genera such
as Saccharomyces, Hanseniaspora, Candida, and Pichia contribute to generating the
precursors of chocolate flavor by fermentation of coca beans (Ardhana & Fleet, 2003;
Nielsen et aI., 2005).
Some yeasts can also have some detrimental effects on food and beverages.
These yeasts are known as spoilage yeasts and their examples include Candida stellata,
Pichia jermentans, and Metschnikowia puicherrima for fruit spoilage, species of
Brettanomyces for wine, beer and soft drink spoilage and certain strains of
Debaryomyces hansenii for meat products spoilage (Fleet, 2007). The yeasts of the
Zygosaccharomyces genus have had a long history as spoilage yeasts within the food
industry, The ability of these yeasts to function in food spoilage is due to their ability to
grow in the presence of high sucrose, ethanol, acetic acid, sorbic acid, benzoic acid, and
sulfur dioxide concentrations.
33
1.2.10.5. Pathogenic Yeasts
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chand;garh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review a/Literature
Yeasts are considered to be human friendly organisms, but some species of yeasts are
known as human pathogens. Two of the well-known pathogens are: Cryptococcus
neojormans and Candida albicans. C. albicans is considered as commensal because its
host-free occurrence is rare. It is found in the oral, gastrointestinal, or urinogenital
tracts in human and other warm-blooded animals. C. albicans can cause vulvovaginitis,
dermatitis, cystitis, fever, myosistis, hepatic dysfunction, and mental confusion.
Depending upon the nature of infection which may be superficial, invasive or deep, one
or more type of abnormalities can be seen. Different strains of C. albicans show
differences in virulence but parasitism depends upon the physical status of human host.
A high frequency of oral Candidiasis is reported from AIDS patients (phelan et aI.,
1987).
Pathogenic yeasts responsible for candidiasis in probable descending order of
virulence for humans are: Candida albicans, Candida tropicalis, Candida stellatoidea,
Candida glabrata, Candida krusei, Candida parapsilosis, Candida guilliermondii,
Candida viswanathii, Candida lusitaniae and Rhodotorula mucilaginosa. Candida
glabrata is the second most common Candida pathogen after C. albicans, causing
infections of the urogenital tract, and of the bloodstream (Candidemia) (Stoyan &
Carbon, 2004). During a survey of C. albicans and non C. albicans species of patients
with candidaemia at hospital of Heraklion, Greece, 46% had candidaemia due to C.
albicans and 54% due to non-albicans species (25%, C. glabrata; 40%, C. tropicalis;
26%, C. parapsilosis; 3%, C. lusitaniae; 4%, C. kruset; and, 3%, C. guilliermondii)
(Samonis et aI., 2008). Similarly, dominance of non C. albicans species has been
observed in Brazil (Colombo et al., 1999). Candida dubliniensis an another emerging
pathogen was described in 1995, which was misidentified earlier as C. albicans. This
yeast is capable of causing oropharyngeal, vaginal and bloodstream infections in human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected and acquired immune deficiency syndrome
(AIDS) patients (Sullivan et al., 1995). However, C. dubliniensis is rarely reported in
the oral microtlora of normal healthy individuals as compared to Candida albicans
(Sullivan et aI., 2004).
34
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review a/Literature
Cryptococcus neoformans is not usually commensal and is known to cause
Cryptococcosis in people. The cells of this yeast are surrounded by a rigid
polysaccharide capsule, which helps to prevent them from being recognized and
engulfed by white blood cells in the human body. Two varieties of Cryptococcus that
are known as pathogens are: Cr. neoformans var. neoformans and Cr. neoformans var.
gatti, Serotypes of Cr. neoformans var. neoformans (A, D, AD) are found in soil rich in
pigeon droppings. Cr. neoformans var. gatti serotype B has been associated with
flowerings of Eucalyptus camaldulensis. Cryptococus primarily infects the lungs. It can
produce pneumococcal-type pneumonia and can cause fatal meningoencephalitis In
untreated or immuno-compromised individuals (Hull & Heitman, 2002).
1.2.10.6. Diversity of Aquatic Yeasts
Aquatic yeasts occupy fresh water, estuary and marine habitats. In spite of recent
descriptions of new species from aquatic environments, updated information on the
ecology of aquatic yeasts is scarce. The fresh water and estuaries are difficult to be
classified as specific habitats as their microbiology is highly affected by the
surrounding fauna and flora, soil rain off and/or effluents of human sources. It was
found that the predominant yeasts from fresh waters were usually ubiquitous or were
associated with pollution (as cited by Lachance & Starmer, 1998). A very interesting
study on freshwater yeasts showed that the yeast community structure in the Patagonian
freshwater yeasts depends upon their ability to produce photoprotective compounds,
their tolerance to UV exposure and their success in colonizing habitats highly exposed
to UV radiations (Libkind et al., 2006). The yeast diversity of estuary of Tagus river,
Portugal has been studied recently by culturable and unculturable methods of yeast
identification. The dominant populations in the culturable class belonged to
Debaryomyces hansenii, Rhodotorula mucilaginosa, Oyptococcus longus, and in the
unculturable class to a basidiomycetous yeast phylogenetically close to Cr. longus
(Gadanho & Sampaio, 2004; Lachance, 1998). It was only recently that yeasts were
isolated from extreme aquatic habitats like glacial melt water rivers in Patagonia,
Argentina (de Garcia et ai., 2007; Libkind et al., 2003) and extreme acidic environment
of the Iberian Pyrite belt (Gadanho et al., 2006). Marine yeasts are considered as
versatile organisms for biodegradation. Marine yeasts are suggested to play an
important role in plant substrates decomposition, nutrient cycling and biodegradation of
oil compounds (Kutty & Philip, 2008). Yeasts were isolated from different sources in
35
PujaSaJuja Ph D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter J: Introduction and Review o/Literature
manne water viz seawater, manne deposits, seaweeds, fish, marine mammals and
seabirds. The number of yeasts varies from 10-1000 cells/litre of water near shores and
10 or fewer cells in deep sea and places with low organic contents. The number of
yeasts decreases with increasing depth, Aerobic forms are abundant in non-polluted
water while polluted water contains mostly the fermentative yeasts. Marine habitats
have been explored all over the world including India. Yeasts have been isolated from
Pacific ocean (Yamasato et aI., 1974), Indian ocean (Fell, 1967; Godinho et al., 1978),
Indo-Pacific ocean (Fell, 1976), North Sea (Ahearn & Crow, 1980) and Atlantic ocean
(Fell, 1970). The yeasts isolated from marine habitat frequently belong to the genera
Candida, Cryptococcus, Debaryomyces, Rhodotorula and Torulopsis. Ascomycetous
yeasts are more abundant than basidiomycetous yeasts from weed algae and animals.
These yeasts are usually of the genera Candida, Metschnikowia, Saccharomyces,
Pichia, and Debaryomyces (Kutty & Philip, 2008). There are also some recent reports
of yeasts from aquatic habitats from deep sea environment of Pacific ocean (Nagahama
et aI., 2001), from animals and sediment of deep sea floor of Suruga Bay (Nagahama et
al., 2003a; Nagahama et aI., 2003b) and from mid-atlantic ridge hydrothermal fields
near the Azores Archipelago (Gadanho & Sampaio, 2005).
1.2.11. Biotechnological Applications of Yeasts
1.2.11.1. Model Organisms
Yeasts such as the budding yeast, S. cerevisiae, and the fission yeast, S. pombe, are
among the most widely used eukaryotic model organisms for genetics, cellular and
molecular biology. Some of the properties that make yeasts particularly suitable for
biological studies include rapid growth, dispersed cells, the ease of replica plating,
mutant isolation, a well-defined genetic system, and most important, a highly versatile
DNA transformation system. Being nonpathogenic, these yeasts can be handled with
little precautions. S. cerevisiae was the first eukaryote with a fully sequenced genome
(Goffeau et aI., 1996). Fission yeast genome sequence followed a few years later
(Wood et aI., 2002). Over 20% of human disease genes have been reported to have
counterparts in yeast as revealed from the genome sequencing. This is largely because
the cell cycle in a yeast cell is very similar to the cell cycle in humans, and therefore the
basic cellular mechanics of DNA replication, recombination, cell division and
metabolism are comparable. Interestingly, many proteins important in human biology
36
PujaSa/uja Ph. D. Thesis, lMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: lntroduction and Review o/Literature
were first discovered by studying their homologues in yeast; these proteins include cell
cycle proteins, signaling proteins, and protein-processing enzymes.
In addition, yeasts have proved to be extremely valuable tools for studies of
other organisms including the use of the two-hybrid screening system for the general
detection of protein-protein interactions and the use of Y ACs for cloning large
fragments of DNA. Finally, availability of synthetic genetic arrays, single gene
knockout libraries, ease of generating conditional knockouts and carrying out over
expression screens have made these yeasts instrumental in generating a plethora of
scientific knowledge (Ostergaard et al., 2000).
1.2.11.2. Bioethanol Production
World is facing an energy crisis because of increasing energy demands due to
continuous development in science and technology and on the other side continuous
fear of exhausting the present oil and petroleum reserves. The bioethanol production is
attracting considerable interest across the world as a biofuel which can provide an
alternative to the presently used non-renewable sources. Saccharomyces cerevisiae has
been the leading microbe capable ofbioethanol production since centuries and no other
organism has ever come close to posing a challenge. Throughout the world researchers
are trying to increase the bioethanol production by genetic modifications and metabolic
engineering of known yeasts, and by isolating new yeasts which may have the promise
for higher ethanol production. Today the leading countries for bioethanol production
are Brazil (17 x 106 t) and the USA (15.1 x 106 t) (Branduardi et al., 2008).
1.2.11.3. Food and Beverage Production
The role of yeasts specifically, the S. cerevisiae strains for baking and production of
alcoholic beverages is among the oldest applications of yeasts which are still mostly
dependent upon yeasts. Besides that the roles of conventional yeasts, non
Saccharomyces yeasts such as Debaryomyces hansenii, Yarrowia lipolytica, Pichia
anomala, Candida mil/eri, Candida humilis, Hanseniaspora spp. have been expanded
to include production of many food ingredients and additives (Fleet; 2007).
1.2.11.4. Production of Heterologous Proteins
37
PujaSaiuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Yeasts' utilization for heterologous gene expression is of considerable interest for the
production of pharmaceutical proteins of therapeutic value (interferons, interleukins
and insulin, etc,) and commercial interest (industrial enzymes) (Gellissen, 2000).
Yeasts are advantageous than other expression systems as they do not contain toxic
cell-wall pyrogens (endotoxins) like prokaryotes and devoid of oncogenic or viral
DNAs of mammalian cells. As eukaryotes, yeasts are also capable of performing post
translational processing and modifications (disulphide bond formation, proteolytic
maturation of pro-hormones, N- and O-linked glycosylation etc.) on expressed
polypeptides, which may be essential for the functionality of many proteins
(Branduardi et ai., 2004). Several non-conventional yeasts viz Kluyveromyces lactis,
Yarrowia lipolytica, and two methylotrophs-Pichia pastoris and Hansenula
polymorpha have been utilized for the production of heterologous proteins (Gellissen et
al., 2005; Hull & Heitman, 2002).
1.2.11.5. Probiotics
Yeasts such as Saccharomyces boulardii are being used as probiotic supplements, to
maintain and restore the natural flora in the large and the small gastrointestinal tracts. S.
boulardii has been shown to reduce the symptoms of acute diarrhea in children
(Kurugol & Koturoglu, 2005), prevent reinfection of Clostridium difficile (McFarland,
1994); reduce the incidence of antibiotic diarrhoea (McFarland et ai., 1995), traveler's
diarrhoea (Scarpignato & Rampal, 1995) and mY/AIDS-associated diarrhoea (Saint
Marc et al., 1995). Other yeasts which can have potential as probiotics are suggested as
D. hansenii, Yarrowia lipolytica, Pichia jarinosa, Pichia anomala (Fleet & Bali a,
2006).
1.2.11.6. Production of Enzymes and Other Industrially Important Compounds
Yeasts have been explored for the production of many industrially important enzymes.
The foremost important among them are the production of Lipase (Pandey et ai., 1999)
and Uricase (Chen et ai., 2008). The lipase produced by Candida rugosa is fast
becoming one of the most frequently used enzyme industrially. This is because of its
use in a variety of processes due to its high activity, both in hydrolysis as well as
synthesis (Redondo et ai., 1995). The other lipase which is of equal interest is of
Pseudozyma antarctica lipase that exhibited unique property of being thermostable at
90°C, inspite of its production from a psychrophilic organisms. This lipase has
38
PujaSaltga Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o!Literahire
widespread application in food, pharmaceutical, agricultural, cosmetics and chemical
industries (Shivaji & Prasad, 2009), Uricase enzyme (used for the treatment of gout)
produced by Candida utilis was found to be less immunogenic when compared to that
produced by other fungi (Chen et al., 2008). In addition, yeasts are being utilized for
production of numerous industrially important compounds, all of which are difficult to
be listed here. Some of the important among them are a) citric acid, b) vitamins, c)
capsular polysaccharides, d) carotenoids, e) lipids and f) glycolipids etc.
1.2.11.7. Yeasts as Biocontrol Agents
Biocontrol provides a non-hazardous means for effectively controlling post-harvest
diseases, and producing safe foods with high quality. Cryptococcus laurentii has been
showed to have antagonistic activity against many post-harvest pathogens (Roberts,
1990), Aureobasidium pullulans has been reported to exhibit antagonistic activity
against Rhizopus sp. in strawberries (Lima et al., 1997); Rhodotorula glutinis has been
shown to be effective against Penicillium expansum in post-harvest apples (Cal vente et
aI., 1999) and Candida oleophila and Pichia anomala work against major post-harvest
diseases of citrus fruits (Lahlali et aI., 2004). The above-cited are only a small number
of examples in the growing list utilization of yeasts in biocontrol measures.
1.2.11.8. Bioremediation
Yeasts have been identified as potential targets for bioremediation. The yeast, Yarrowia
lipolytica, is known to degrade palm-oil mill effluent, TNT (an explosive) (Jain et aI.,
2004) and other hydrocarbons such as alkanes, fatty acids, and oils (Fickers et al.,
2005). Pichia guilliermondii and other yeasts have been explored recently for
bioremediation of different metals (Ksheminska et aI., 2003).
1.2.12. Methods for Studying Yeast Diversity
1.2.12.1. Methods of Sample Collection and Processing
Sampling methods and sample processing depend upon the objective of the study. A
very general consideration is that samples need to be collected aseptically. All the
equipment and accessories being used should be made sterile by an appropriate
procedure, The method of sterilization depends upon the sample type. For example,
aseptic sampling of flowers, fruits and insects often involves sterile bags/containers,
39
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review a/Literature
sterile spatulas, needles, cotton swabs, pipettes, hand sterilization and use of gloves etc.
For clinical samples, sterilization is often performed by swabbing the area with alcohol,
iodine or 2-propanal to remove surface contaminants and bacteria (Boundy-Mills,
2006). Rogers et al. (2004) have described several methods for the surface sterilization
of ice glaciers viz: exposure to bleach, ethanol, UV radiation and use of acid, base or
hydrogen peroxide.
Samples can be collected and processed in several ways. Nectar samples can be
collected with a sterile capillary pipette and can be plated as such on agar medium
(Herzberg et ai., 2002). Similarly, samples such as tree exudates and insect frass can
also be directly plated. To study the yeasts of external surfaces of flowers like corolla
or phyllosphere yeasts, the samples are usually pressed on the surface of the agar media
(Brysch-Herzberg & Lachance, 2004). In some cases the processing of sample is not
that simple, for example the yeast inocula used in brewing industry become stratified
(ASBC, 2003) therefore multiple samples from multiple sections of yeast cake or slurry
are recommended for use as inocula. When the distribution of an organism is suspected
to be non-uniform, homogenization of the sample is recommended to get the proper
representation of the community. Incomplete and/or improper homogenization and
dilution can results in erroneous enumeration of cell density as discussed by Fleet
(1999) .
Some samples where number of yeasts are known to be less as in aquatic
habitats (Kutty & Philip, 2008) and in soil (Wuczkowski & Prillinger, 2004), samples
can be concentrated by direct centrifugation followed by resuspension or else
concentration of samples can also be achieved by using membrane filters (Gadanho et
ai., 2003). Samples with higher concentration of yeasts such as those from flowers,
insects, fruits and plant leaves need to be diluted to obtain countable colonies on the
plate. Aliquots of each dilution are plated on appropriate media, and the number of
colonies is used to calculate the concentration of yeasts in the original sample,
expressed as CFU/ml.
Several different dilutants are recommended for enumeration of yeasts.
Examples include saline solutions used by brewers (0.85%) (ASBC, 2003 ; Mian et ai.,
40
PujaSaluja Ph. D. ThEsis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter J: lntroduction and Review o/Literature
1997); and milk or Butterfields phosphate-buffered water for dairy products (Boundy
Mills, 2006).
1.2.12.2. Isolation of Yeasts
Yeasts are isolated from both aquatic and terrestrial habitats. The number of yeasts per
gram of specimen is usually much lower than of bacteria and fungi which are
considered as more adaptive than yeasts. So during course of isolation growth of other
microbes should be suppressed in order to get colonies of yeasts.
Inhibition of Bacteria and Molds
The use of acidified media is suggested for retarding or suppression of bacterial growth.
The pH is maintained between 3.5-5.0 by using HCI or phosphoric acid. Alternatively,
antibiotics such as chloramphenicol, streptomycin, ampicillin, penicillin or cocktail of
these are used for yeast isolation (Martin, 1950; Saluja & Prasad, 2007b). Propionic
acid or calcium propionate decrease mold growth significantly, but also inhibit some
aerobic yeasts (Buhagiar & Barnett, 1971). Rose Bengal (Martin, 1950), oxgall (Miller
and Webb, 1954), eugenol, dichloran (Bell & Crawford, 1967), or oligomycin can be
added to inhibit rapidly spreading molds. The Rose Bengal Agar and/or
chloramphenicol agar has been used in some of the recent studies (Lachance et aI.,
2001b; Rodrigues et aI., 2001; Rosa et aI., 2003).
Media for Isolation of Yeasts
When yeasts are present in high numbers, they can be isolated on solidified media
either by using acidified media or antibiotics. The acidifying compound is added after
sterilization and cooling of media to 45°C as agar is hydrolyzed at low pH. Although
bacteria can be successfully inhibited at low pH but growth of some yeasts like
Schizosaccharomyces is also inhibited at that pH.
The liquid media can be used for the enrichment of yeasts if the yeast number is
less in the sample. Yarrow (1998) suggested that shaking of flasks with liquid media
would restrict the growth of molds, and in such a setting bacterial growth can be
inhibited by acidifying or addition of antibiotics to the media. Shaking inhibits the
sporulation in molds and they aggregate in pellets. The yeasts can then be separated
from molds by allowing the mold pellet to settle down and then streaking the
41
PtdaSa!uja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review a/Literature
suspension of yeasts on to agar in petri plates, or by removing the pellet by aseptically
filtering the liquid culture through a loose plug of sterile glass wool.
1.2.12.3. Morphological characterization
Characteristics of Vegetative cells
This includes the study of colony and cell morphology as described by Yarrow (1998),
production of filaments, modes of asexual reproduction. Details of study of cell and
colony morphology are given in detail in Chapter-2, Some of the yeasts form chains of
cells where the bud fails to detach and these cells convert into pseudohyphae. The
pseudohyhae are very common in the genus Pseudozyma. Pseudohyphae may be
rudimentary or may develop into elongated cells where each may produce blastospore
in regular or characteristic manner, Some of the yeasts also produce true septate
hyphae.
Modes of Asexual Reproduction:
The asexual reproduction includes formation of buds, by fission or conidia formation
on short stalks. The other mode of asexual reproduction is the formation of arthospore,
endospore and chlamydospore or ballistospore.
Vegetative Bud Formation: This includes study of mode of bud formation and
arrangement of successive buds if present. Budding cells may be monopolar,
bipolar or multipolar. Acropetal budding is the formation of successive buds in a
chain with the youngest at the apex while opposite is the case in basipetal budding.
Arthoconidia Formation: Hyphae of some cells break up or disarticulate to form
one-celled arthospore or arthoconidia. They are arranged in a zig-zag fashion on
solid media.
Fission: Reproduction by fission IS characteristics of the genus
Schizosaccharomyces in which cells form an inward septum which bisect the long
axis of the cell.
42
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Endospore Formation: Endospores are vegetative cells which are formed within
discrete cells and hyphae. Endospores are formed in the genus Trichosporon,
Candida, Cryptococcus, Oosporidium and Cystojilobasidium.
Chlamydospore Formation: These are thick-walled spores which may be terminal or
intercalary. They have been reported in C. albicans and Metschnikowia and rarely
from Trichosporon and Cryptococcus.
Ballistospore Formation: Ballistospores are specialized spores that form on
sterigmata which produced from vegetative cells. These spores are discharged into
the air by droplet mechanism.
Study of Sexual Reproduction
Many yeasts reproduce both asexually and sexually resulting in alteration of their
generations. A yeast that forms either asci or basidia is referred to as a perfect yeast or
in a perfect state. A yeast that does not form either asci or basidia is referred as an
imperfect yeast or in an imperfect state. Perfect state is also known as teleomorphic
state and the imperfect state is known as the anamorphic state. A yeast exhibiting the
combined states is termed as holomorph. The teleomorphic and anamorphic states of
the same yeasts have different names, for example Pichia jadinii (teleomorph) and
Candida utilis (anamorph). This study of sexual reproduction constitutes the mode of
karyogamy, plasmogamy, formation of sexual structures such as ascus or basidium,
formation of ascospores in ascomycetous yeasts and basidiospore formation in
basidiomycetous yeasts. Shape and number of ascospores is another interesting
characteristic of some genera, for example they are long and clavate in Metschnikowia
while sac-like in Lipomyces.
1.2.12.4. Physiological and Biochemical Characterization
Physiological and biochemical characterization involves a battery of about 90 tests
including assimilation and fermentation of several different carbon compounds, growth
and utilization of nitrogen sources, requirements for vitamins, growth at various
temperatures and media with high sugar content or sodium chloride, hydrolysis of urea,
and resistance to antibiotics. These tests are performed in liquid or solid media. For
fermentation tests, the Durham tube method is preferred and is performed in liquid
43
PujaSaJuja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
media containing 2% solution of different carbon sources. The liquid-based tests are
performed by inoculating the culture in the media containing the appropriate amount of
the carbon source under investigation that has been added to the basal medium. The
growth is compared to a positive as well as a negative control. The results of these tests
are interpreted as positive, negative, weak or delayed. The details for these tests are
provided in the Materials and Methods section of this dissertation.
For solid media, the tube method, replica plating and auxanogram are utilized.
In the tube and the replica plating methods the compounds are present in the media.
Results are read by comparing the growth of the strain under question with a negative
control consisting of the basal medium without the added compound. In the
auxanogram method, yeast cells are seeded in basal agar medium containing various
compounds at different points at the periphery. Results are read by examining the plates
for the formation of opaque zones at the points where the compound was added.
1.2.12.5. Molecular Methods to Study Yeast Diversity
Molecular methods include DNA-based techniques which are more rapid and accurate
than the traditional phenotypic methods. Several molecular methods are being used in
combination to study yeast diversity and for characterization of yeasts. These methods
include Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD), microsatellite fingerprinting,
Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP), electophoretic karyotyping and
sequencing of rRNA and other genes. Some culture-independent methods include use
of Temperature Gradient Gel Electrophoresis (TGGE), Denaturing Gradient Gel
Electrophoresis (DGGE) microarray, flow cytometry, single-cell conformation
polymorphism and cloning. Some of these methods are relatively recent and are being
used for specific purposes mostly in combination with sequencing. A brief description
of some of these methods is provided in the following sub sections.
Randomly Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD)
RAPD is a fingerprinting method based upon a single random primers of 10 bases
(Williams et aI., 1990). RAPD allows the separation of yeasts mostly at species level
and sometimes at strain level as well. It has been widely used to study yeasts diversity
in several different habitats. Balerias-Couto et al. (1994 and 1995) used RAPD to
differentiate spoilage and food-borne yeasts. They could assess variability among S.
44
PujaSaJ'!ia Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
cerevisiae and Zygosaccharomyces species by RAPD. The brine yeasts which were not
identified accurately by phenotypic methods could be discriminated by RAPD
(Prillinger et ai., 1999). RAPD was used to discriminate yeasts in dairy products
(Vasdinyei & Deak, 2003), sourdoughs of Italian sweet-baked products (Foschino et
aI., 2004) and brewery yeasts (Barszczewski & Robak, 2004). Although this method
seems to be useful in some specific cases, but it suffers from certain limitations. The
RAPD methods are not always reproducible among or even within the laboratories.
Conflicting results have been obtained by RAPD and sequence analysis during study of
yeasts from flowers (Herzberg et ai., 2002). The authors concluded that numerous
variables make RAPD PCR analysis unreliable, at least as a means of identifying yeasts
in ecological studies.
Simple Sequence Repeat Fingerprinting or Microsatellite Fingerprinting
Simple sequence repeats (SSRs), or microsatellites, are genetic loci where one or a few
bases are tandemly repeated for varying numbers of times (Katti et ai., 2001). These
repetitions occur primarily due to slipped-strand impairing and subsequent error(s)
during DNA replication, repair, or recombination (Levinson & Gutman, 1987). These
loci can mutate further by insertions or deletions of one or a few repeat units, and the
mutation rates generally increase with an increase in the length of repeat tracks (Wierdl
et aI., 1997). Eukaryotic genomes frequently contain several interspersed
microsatellites. Microsatellite loci show extensive length polymorphism, and hence
they are widely used in DNA fingerprinting and diversity studies. There may be several
locations in the genome where these loci may be present in such a way that they are not
too far away from each other and their directions converge such that a single PCR
primer could anneal at both of the loci and generate a unique PCR product. Several
such pairs of loci together can generate a pattern that is frequently referred to as the
Microsatellite fingerprint. PCR fingerprinting with the microsatellite primers (GTG)s,
(GACA)4, and the M13 sequence GAGGTGGCGGTTCT has been used for yeast
identification (Lavallee et aI., 1994; Lieckfeldt et ai., 1993).
In a study of diversity of S. cerevisiae strains from wine and beer, microsatellite
fingerprinting was used in combination with RAPD. The fingerprinting primer (GTG)s
was found to be more discriminatory as 16 stains were separated into 6 groups (a total
of 6 unique patterns) in comparison to the primer (GAC)s, which separated the 16
strains into only two different groups (Baleiras Couto et aI., 1996). Gallego et al.
(2005) compared SSR, RAPD, and AFLP (Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism)
45
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis. IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter1: Introduction andReview ofLilerarure
markers for the genetic analysis of yeast strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae isolated
from wineries. They used six microsatellite loci and appropriate primers needed for
their specific amplification. They considered SSR as reliable, fast, easy and highly
discriminatory method for identification and characterization of S. cerevisiae strains.
Microsatellite fingerprinting was also used to study the diversity of yeasts in marine
samples collected from Portugal (Gadanho et aI., 2003). In that study, a total of 31
MSP-PCR classes were formed, 8 for the pigmented yeasts and 23 for the non
pigmented yeasts. Similarly, microsatellite fingerprinting was successfully utilized to
study plant-associated yeasts in Brazil (Inacio et al., 2008), during polyphasic
taxonomy of the genus Rhodotorula (Gadanho & Sampaio, 2002), and for
differentiation of strains of Hanseniaspora uvarum isolated in the Finger Lakes
wineries in New York (Bujdos6 etal., 2001).
Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP)
RFLP is also a widely used fingerprinting technique in which different regions of
rRNA gene and mitochondrial DNA have been utilized for fingerprinting. The mt-DNA
RFLP has been employed for examining the authencity of S. cerevisiae commercial
strains of wine (F ernandez-Espinar et aI., 2001), for typing of D. hansenii strains from
dairy products (Petersen et aI., 2001). The ITS RFLP has been used successfully in
many studies for differentiation of S. cerevisiae strains isolated from wine (Guillamon
et al., 1998), wine and beer contaminants from a brewery (Hansen & Jakobsen, 2001).
The RFLP was also used to characterize non-Saccharomyces yeasts isolated from food
and beverages (Esteve-Zarzoso et aI., 2001; Fernandez et aI., 2000). However, during
characterization of yeasts from various food products, ITS-RFLP using the restriction
enzymes MspI and HaeIII, same patterns were obtained for D. hansenii and
Meschnikowia pulcherrima and several other yeasts (Senses-Ergul et aI., 2006).
Similarly, ITS RFLP was found to be ineffective in differentiating yeasts from dry
cured meat products (Andrade et aI., 2006), for strain typing of D. hansenii even after
using 9 different restriction enzymes (Petersen et aI., 2001) and even to discriminate,
different Debaryomyces species (Martorell et aI., 2005). In contrast, IGS-RFLP was used
successfully to differentiate among species and varieties of the members of the genus
Debaryomyces (Quiros et aI., 2006). Similarly, IGS-RFLP was used to discriminate D.
hansenii from other species isolated from intermediate moisture foods (Romero et aI.,
2005).
46
Electrophoretic Karyotyping
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, lMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
Karyotyping is the characterization of the number, size and form of the chromosome in
an organism, The electrophoretic karyotyping is performed by running the DNA sample
from the cells through an electric field such that chromosome-sized molecules get
separated according to their size. There are several electrophoretic systems available to
perform karyotyping and some of the widely used systems are: Pulse-Field Gel
Electrophoresis (PFGE), Orthogonal-Field Alteration Gel Electrophoresis (OF AGE),
Contour-clamped Homogeneous Electric Field Gel Electrophoresis (CHEF), and Field
Inversions Gel electrophoresis. Karyotyping using PFGE has been used to investigate
brewing contaminants (Jespersen et al., 2000), yeasts from dairy products (Hansen &
Jakobsen, 2001) and for wine yeasts (Fernandez et aI., 2000) as well.
Other Molecular Methods
There is ongoing research to develop new rapid and reliable tools/methodology to study
diversity and to help facilitate correct identification of yeasts. This becomes especially
valuable from industrial point of view. In addition, rapid identification is crucial from
clinical standpoint for identification of pathogenic yeasts. Some of the recently
developed methods includes Quantitative PCR, microarrays, TGGE, DGGE, Single
Strand Conformation Polymorphism (SSCP), and flow cytometry etc.
TGGE, DGGE and Cloning: TGGE refers to Temperature Gradient Gel
Electrophoresis and DGGE stands for Denaturating Gradient Gel Electrophoresis.
Both of these are electrophretic techniques which differ only in the nature of
gradient which is a denaturant in case of DGGE and Temperature in case of TGGE.
The double stranded DNAs are melted while passing through the gradient and
accordingly the mobility of DNA changes. As the DNA melting is sequence
dependent these techniques provide the separation of different sequences (of
different isolates of microorganisms under study) present in a community of DNAs
without the need for culturing the organisms.
Both of these are culture-independent methods which have been used to
assess genetic diversity in yeast populations from samples such as sourdough
(Meroth et al., 2003), during fermentation of coffee (Masoud et aI., 2004), wine
(Cocolin et aI., 2000; Cocolin & Mills, 2003), cocoa (Nielsen et aI., 2005), and
47
--------------------------------------
PujaSaluja Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review a/Literature
from slurry reactor systems (EI-LatifHesham et aI., 2006). PCR-DGGE was found
to be less sensitive than cl1lture-based approach for determining the yeast ecology
of grapes and could not reliably detect species present at populations less than 104
CFU/g. However, this method detected a greater diversity of species than traditional
agar plating (Prakitchaiwattana et al., 2004). During a survey of yeasts from estuary
of the Tagus river, Portugal, the number of species detected after enrichment was
higher than the number of taxa found using TGGE. Thus the authors suggested that
some yeast populations were present in densities below the detection threshold of
the method (Gadanho & Sampaio, 2004). Molnar et al. (2008) studied the yeast
biodiversity in the guts of several pests on maize by using culture-dependent and -
independent approaches; DGGE and cloning. Several genera could not be detected
through the culture-independent approaches. In addition, the most frequently
detected genera were the same as those found in classical isolation. Interestingly,
several fungi were also were detected along with yeasts, Yeasts diversity from
forest and grassland soil from Germany, could not be studied by unculturable
approach as only few yeasts were detected out of 102 clones sequenced. This study
implies, that yeast biomass in soil is smaller than other fungal groups (Kurth, 2008).
SSCP: In this method single-stranded PCR amplified DNAs are separated by
Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (pAGE) on the basis of small differences in
their secondary structures (generated by the DNA sequence). This method also
shares the limitation of DGGE and TGGE methods but is advantageous from them
as it does not require GC clamp like DGGE and TGGE. SSCP has been used to
detect polymorphism in clinical isolates of C. albicans (Graser et aI., 1996).
Flow cytometry: Flow cytometry has been used to detect as little as one yeast cell in
the background of 106 brewer's yeast cells (Jespersen et aI., 1993) and for clinical
isolates (Diaz & Fell, 2004; Page & Kurtzman, 2005). The major advantage of this
method is that multiple species can be identified from multiple samples by using a
mUltiplex assay.
Quantitative real time polymerase chain reaction (Q-PCR/qPCR): Q-PCR also
known as Real Time PCR is a technique based on the polymerase chain reaction,
which is used to amplify and simultaneously quantify a targeted DNA molecule. It
48
PujaSalr.ya Ph. D. Thesis, IMTECH Chandigarh
Chapter 1: Introduction and Review o/Literature
enables both detection and quantification (as absolute number of copies or relative
amount when normalized to DNA input or additional normalizing genes) of a
specific sequence in a DNA sample.
Q-PCR has been used to detect specific organisms in an environmental sample.
A very sensitive and accurate Q-PCR method has been developed for the detection
of six pathogenic Candida species in drinking water (Brinkman et al., 2003) and for
detection of spoilage yeast D. bruxellensis from wine based on specific D IID2
primers (Phister & Mills, 2003).
Microarray: Microarrays provide a new level of specificity to DNA-DNA
hybridization studies. A single array can contain several thousand specific DNA
sequences which can be used to detect a rather large number of target cells in a
given sample. These target sequences can be species-specific or function-specific
(to get functional diversity), Microarrays have been successfully used to detect
major microbial groups (EI Fantroussi et aI., 2003). Recently a sensitive microarray
has been developed to detect 10 most common pathogenic Candida species and
Aspergillus spp. by using specific ITS probes (Leinberger et al., 2005).
Some of the DNA-based methods have limitations and potential bias at
various steps including cell lysis, DNA extraction and purification. The efficiency
with which cells or mycelia are lysed can vary within and among microbial groups.
DNA and RNA extraction methods that result in DNA shearing, such as bead
beating, can also lead to biases (von Wintzingerode et aI., 1997). The use of some
of these methods is only restricted to studies of certain specific habitats of yeasts,
With time, these methods will probably be improved to overcome some of their
shortcomings and more widespread use of these methods will hopefully open new
horizons in the studies of yeast diversity.
49