10. Opposition Argument for Denying Writ of Certiorari in SCOTUS 5.1.14

8/10/2019 10. Opposition Argument for Denying Writ of Certiorari in SCOTUS 5.1.14

1/25

!"# %&'%())

!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /"0$&1 '$2$&3

" #$%&' ( $) * )'+ , *-.$/) 0 &+ $1 20 .&+3+3*/' !"

' $11) 4&5&11 0 ' &,#&+$#) *6 +7& 3/+*# 0 &+ $1 2

#$ &'()()#$ *#+ , -+)( #* .'+()#+,+)(# (/' 0$)('1 2(,('2 .#0+( #* ,&&',32

*#+ (/' $)$(/ .)+.0)(

*+,-. ./+ +-01/!2-!30 ,! /11/0,3,/!

" */$1" (2 8 #3113 0 4# 2 245676849 :;


2/25

;3? @A?B >CDEFDB? A @=AFFBCGB HE H=B 'B@IBHAIJ EKH=B 3CHBI>EIL? MB@>?>EC CEH HE BNBI@>?B =>? OAIH>@PFAIQ>RBM APH=EI>HJ0 PCMBI AC AM =E@ ?HAHPHEIJ OIED>?>EC0"BOAIHSBCH EK H=B 3CHBI>EI0 &CD>IECSBCH0 ACM #BFAHQBM $GBC@>B? $OOIEOI>AH>EC? $@H0 TUVU0 .PW2 12/E2 VVVQXX0 Y VTZ0 VT[ 'HAH2 T\[T0 HE GIACH OBH>H>ECBI?A OBIS>H HE BCGAGB >C A OI>DAHB @ESSBI@>AF EOBIAH>ECHE @PFH>DAHB EJ?HBI? EC FACM? E]CBM WJ H=B :C>HBM'HAHB? >C .E>CH #BJB? /AH>ECAF 'BA?=EIB2 +=B ^PB?QH>EC? OIB?BCHBM AIB_

V2 5=BH=BI H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF?0 ]=>@= @EC?>MBIBMACM IB`B@HBM EC H=B SBI>H? AFF EK OBH>H>ECBI?L AIGPQSBCH? SBAC>CGKPFFJ BIIBM >C >H? MB?@I>OH>EC EK H=B?@EOB EK >H? IBD>B] PCMBI H=B $MS>C>?HIAH>DB .IE@BQMPIB $@H0 a :2'2,2 bUV;8 ?;V"

T2 5=BH=BI H=B 'B@IBHAIJ @ESS>HHBM OIB`PM>@>AFBIIEI PCMBI H=B /AH>ECAF &CD>IECSBCHAF .EF>@J $@H EKV\c\ ;/&.$CG =>? MB@>?>EC2


3/25

;333C>EC? WBFE] 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222224PI>?M>@H>EC 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222'HAHBSBCH 22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

$IGPSBCH 222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222,EC@FP?>EC 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

36*7- /. 6539/+,3,-0

,A?B?_

O=586E49; :=? W '5;7" .4" D2 $+1. 0 ZcT :2'2 Xb;V\X[< 222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

.=894< .


4/25

38

,A?B?e,ECH>CPBM_ .AGB

2D96EC?_

$@H EK *@H2 VX0 V\bc0 .PW2 12 /E2 \ZQaZZ0\U 'HAH2 TaVa 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

$@H EK *@H2 TU0 V\bc0 .PW2 12 /E2 \ZQacb0 Y [0\U 'HAH2 Tc\T 22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

$MS>C>?HIAH>DB .IE@BMPIB $@H0 a :2'2,2aaV ;8 ?;V2 22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222 D=??6E

a :2'2,2 bUV;AB? $@H EK V\b[0 Vc :2'2,2

Va[V ;8 ?;V2 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222/AH>ECAF &CD>IECSBCHAF .EF>@J $@H EK V\c\0

ZT :2'2,2 Z[TV ;8 ?;V" 22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222 D=??6EZT :2'2,2 Z[[T;TCH #BJB? /AH>ECAF 'BA?=EIB $@H0 .PW2 12/E2 XbQcab0 bc 'HAH2 a[X 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

5>FMBICB?? $@H0 Vc :2'2,2 VV[V;8 ?;V2 22222222222222222222222222222222222 [Vc :2'2,2 VV[V;A< 222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222


5/25

8

'HAHPHB ACM IBGPFAH>EC?e,ECH>CPBM_ .AGB

Vc :2'2,2 VV[[;@< 222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222ZU ,262#2_

.H2 VaUT 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

.H2 VaUX 2222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222

->?@BFFACBEP?_

72#2 #BO2 /E2 VcXU0 \ZH= ,ECG20 TM 'B??2 ;V\bc< 2222222222222222222 [72#2 #BO2 /E2 [[V0 VVTH= ,ECG20 V?H 'B??2 ;TUVT< 222222222222222222 a'2 #BO2 /E2 baT0 b\H= ,ECG20 V?H 'B??2 ;V\Za


6/25

;VC ]=>@= A@ESSBI@>AF EJ?HBI KA@>F>HJ =AM WBBC EOBIAH>CG ?>C@BH=B V\aU?2 )A" AH aQb2 3C V\bT0 H=B :C>HBM 'HAHB? OPIQ@=A?BM H=B K>DB A@IB? EK FACM WBFECG>CG HE H=AH KA@>F>HJ2

)A" AH b2 :CMBI H=B OPI@=A?B AGIBBSBCH0 H=B E]CBI EKH=B KA@>F>HJ IBHA>CBM A ZUQJBAI I>G=H EK E@@POAC@J ACMP?B HE OIE@B?? ACM ?BFF EJ?HBI?2 )]6A" +=B OPI@=A?BAGIBBSBCH OIED>MBM H=AH0 AH H=B BCM EK H=AH ZUQJBAI

HBIS0 H=B 'B@IBHAIJ EK H=B 3CHBI>EI fSAJg >??PB A?OB@>AFQP?B OBIS>H H=AH ]EPFM AFFE] AMM>H>ECAF EOBIAQH>EC?2 )]6A2V

3C V\bc0 ,ECGIB?? MB?>GCAHBM @BIHA>C OEIH>EC? EK.E>CH #BJB? /AH>ECAF 'BA?=EIB A? f]>FMBICB??g AIBA?PCMBI H=B 5>FMBICB?? $@H0 Vc :2'2,2 VV[V;8 ?;V2 $@HEK *@H2 VX0 V\bc0 .PW2 12 /E2 \ZQaZZ0 \U 'HAH2 TaVa;V\bc .E>CH #BJB? 5>FMBICB?? $@HFMBICB?? $@H0 ]=>@= OIEHB@H? fH=B WBCBK>H? EK ACBCMPI>CG IB?EPI@B EK ]>FMBICB??g KEI fOIB?BCH ACMKPHPIB GBCBIAH>EC?0g Vc :2'2,2 VV[V;AFMBICB??

AIBA SAJ CEH @ECHA>C06AFBCHBIOI>?B2g Vc :2'2,2 VV[[;@GQCAHBM EH=BI OEIH>EC? EK .E>CH #BJB? /AH>ECAF 'BAQ

V +=B OPI@=A?B AGIBBSBCH AMMIB??BM ECFJ H=B POFACM OIEOBIHJ

>H?BFK ACM M>M CEH IB?BIDB HE H=B EJ?HBI KA@>F>HJ H=B I>G=H HE @PFH>DAHBEJ?HBI? >C H=B B?HBIE >H?BFK2 ,2$2 &2#2 aX[QcUV2 3C TUUX0 H=B /AQH>ECAF .AId 'BID>@B >??PBM A HBSOEIAIJ OBIS>H0 ?BH HE BNO>IB EC H=B?ASB MAHB A? H=B ZUQJBAI IB?BIDBM I>G=H?0 H=AH APH=EI>RBM H=B >CQ

]AHBI EJ?HBIQ@PFH>DAH>EC EOBIAH>EC?2 )A" AH TUUQTTc2


8/25

[

?=EIB0 >C@FPM>CG "IAdB? &?HBIE0 A? fOEHBCH>AF ]>FMBIQCB?? AMM>H>EC?0g ?OB@>KJ>CG H=AH H=BJ ]EPFM WB @ECQ

DBIHBM HE ]>FMBICB?? AIBA? ]=BC H=B 'B@IBHAIJ @BIH>QK>BM H=AH AFF P?B? fOIE=>W>HBM WJ H=B 5>FMBICB?? $@H=AhMi @BA?BM2g $@H EK *@H2 TU0 V\bc0 .PW2 12 /E2 \ZQacb0 Y [0 \U 'HAH2 Tc\T2 3C MB?>GCAH>CG "IAdB? &?HBIEA? A OEHBCH>AF ]>FMBICB?? AIBA0 IAH=BI H=AC AC A@HPAF

]>FMBICB?? AIBA0 ,ECGIB?? fHEEd >CHE A@@EPCH H=B"BOAIHSBCH EK H=B 3CHBI>EIL? OE?>H>EC H=AH @ESSBI@>AFEJ?HBI KAIS>CG EOBIAH>EC? HAd>CG OFA@B >C "IAdB?&?HBIE0g A? ]BFF A? @BIHA>C I>G=H? >C H=B B?HBIE H=AH

]BIB IB?BIDBM HE H=B 'HAHB EK ,AF>KEIC>A0 fIBCMBIBMH=B AIBA j>C@EC?>?HBCH ]>H= ]>FMBICB??2Lg .BH2 $OO2 c;^PEH>CG 72#2 #BO2 /E2 VcXU0 \ZH= ,ECG20 TM 'B??2 c

;V\bcECBI? AIB H=B ?P@@B??EI?Q>CQ>CHBIB?H HE H=BE]CBI EK H=B EJ?HBI WP?>CB?? ]=E @ECDBJBM H=B WP?>QCB??L? FACM HE H=B :C>HBM 'HAHB? >C V\bT2 .BH2 $OO2 b23C TUUZ0 OBH>H>ECBI? AGIBBM HE OPI@=A?B H=B EJ?HBIKAIS0 ACM >C TUUa0 H=BJ @FE?BM EC H=AH OPI@=A?B2 )]6A" +=B OPI@=A?B ME@PSBCH? ?OB@>K>@AFFJ >CKEISBM OBH>QH>ECBI? H=AH H=B I>G=H HE EOBIAHB H=B KAIS >C H=B /AQH>ECAF 'BA?=EIB ]EPFM BNO>IB >C TUVT2 )]6A" 3C AMM>QH>EC0 H=B "BOAIHSBCH EK H=B 3CHBI>EI IBA@=BM EPH HEOBH>H>ECBI? HE BC?PIB H=AH WBKEIB H=BJ fj@FE?BM B?@IE]

EC H=B OPI@=A?B0Lg H=BJ ]BIB fA]AIB EK H=B h"BOAIHQSBCHL?i FBGAF OE?>H>ECg IBGAIM>CG H=B MB?>GCAH>EC WJ,ECGIB?? A? OEHBCH>AF ]>FMBICB?? EK KBMBIAFFJ E]CBM?PWSBIGBM FACM? ACM A??E@>AHBM ]AHBI? EK "IAdB?&?HBIE EC ]=>@= EJ?HBI? AIB @PFH>DAHBM2 )]6A" +=B "BQOAIHSBCH ?BCH OBH>H>ECBI? A @EOJ EK A FBGAF SBSEIACQMPS BNOIB??>CG H=B D>B] H=AH H=B "BOAIHSBCH ]A?fSACMAHBM WJ H=B 5>FMBICB?? $@H0 H=B .E>CH #BJB?

5>FMBICB?? $@H ACM >H? -ACAGBSBCH .EF>@>B? HE @ECQ


9/25

Z

DBIH OEHBCH>AF ]>FMBICB??0 >2B20 H=B hEJ?HBIQ@PFH>DAH>ECiHIA@H ACM H=B AM`E>C>CG &?HBIE0 HE ]>FMBICB?? ?HAHP? A??EEC A? H=B CEC @ECKEIS>CG P?B @AC WB BF>S>CAHBM2g

)A" AH X2 3C A ?BOAIAHB @ESSPC>@AH>EC ]>H= OBH>H>ECBI?H]E SECH=? FAHBI0 H=B "BOAIHSBCH fIB>HBIAHBM >H?GP>MAC@Bg IBGAIM>CG OBH>H>ECBI?L OPI@=A?B ACM ?OB@>K>Q@AFFJ >CKEISBM OBH>H>ECBI? H=AH fjWA?BM EC EPI FBGAFIBD>B]0 CE CB] OBIS>H? ]>FF WB >??PBMLg AKHBI TUVT2

)]6A" 3C TUU\0 ,ECGIB?? BCA@HBM H=B "BOAIHSBCH EK H=B

3CHBI>EI0 &CD>IECSBCH0 ACM #BFAHBM $GBC@>B? $OOIEQOI>AH>EC? $@H0 TUVU0 .PW2 12 /E2 VVVQXX0 VT[ 'HAH2 T\UZ;$OOIEOI>AH>EC? $@H@= >C@FPMBM A ?OB@>AF OIED>Q?>EC AMMIB??>CG EJ?HBI @PFH>DAH>EC >C "IAdB? &?HBIE2

'OB@>K>@AFFJ0 'B@H>EC VTZ EK H=B AOOIEOI>AH>EC? ?HAHPHBOIED>MBM H=AH0 fCEH]>H=?HACM>CG ACJ EH=BI OIED>?>EC EKFA]0g AH ACJ H>SB WBKEIB OBH>H>ECBI?L H>SBQF>S>HBMI>G=H? BNO>IBM >C TUVT0 fH=B 'B@IBHAIJ EK H=B 3CHBI>EI>? APH=EI>RBM HE >??PB A ?OB@>AF P?B OBIS>H ]>H= H=B?ASB HBIS? ACM @ECM>H>EC? A? H=B BN>?H>CG APH=EI>RAQH>ECg H=AH ]EPFM AFFE] OBH>H>ECBI? HE @ECH>CPB H=B>IEOBIAH>EC? KEI AC AMM>H>ECAF HBC JBAI?2 VT[ 'HAH2 T\[T2'B@H>EC VTZ AMM>H>ECAFFJ ?OB@>K>BM H=AH H=AH fhCiEH=>CG>C H=>? ?B@H>EC ?=AFF WB @EC?HIPBM HE =ADB ACJ AOOF>@AQH>EC HE ACJ FE@AH>EC EH=BI H=AC .E>CH #BJB? /AH>ECAF

'BA?=EIBk CEI ?=AFF ACJH=>CG >C H=>? ?B@H>EC WB @>HBM A?OIB@BMBCH KEI SACAGBSBCH EK ACJ OEHBCH>AF ]>FMBICB??EPH?>MB H=B 'BA?=EIB2g )]6A" ,ECGIB?? BCA@HBM 'B@QH>EC VTZ AKHBI @EC?>MBI>CG0 WPH PFH>SAHBFJ CEH AMEOHQ>CG0 A OIEOE?AF H=AH ]EPFM =ADB SACMAHBM H=AH H=B'B@IBHAIJ GIACH OBH>H>ECBI? A OBIS>H2 .BH2 $OO2 X2

3C TUVU0 OBH>H>ECBI? IB^PB?HBM H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJBNBI@>?B =>? APH=EI>HJ PCMBI 'B@H>EC VTZ HE GIACH H=BSA OBIS>H2 .BH2 $OO2 VU2 $? OAIH EK H=B 'B@IBHAIJL?


10/25

a

@EC?>MBIAH>EC EK ]=BH=BI HE ME ?E0 H=B "BOAIHSBCHOIBOAIBM AC &CD>IECSBCHAF 3SOA@H 'HAHBSBCH ;&3'F>CG H=B OEHBCH>AF BKKB@H? EC H=B BCD>IECSBCH EK>??P>CG EI CEH >??P>CG H=B IB^PB?HBM OBIS>H2 )A" AH VUl C2T2 +=B /AH>ECAF &CD>IECSBCHAF .EF>@J $@H EK V\c\;/&.$@= ]>FF >CKEIS0 WPH CEHM>@HAHB H=B IB?PFH EK0 AC AGBC@JL? MB@>?>ECAF OIE@B??e

]=BCBDBI A KBMBIAF AGBC@J OIEOE?B? A fSA`EI 6BMBIAFA@H>EChi ?>GC>K>@ACHFJ AKKB@H>CG H=B ^PAF>HJ EK H=B =PQSAC BCD>IECSBCH2g ZT :2'2,2 Z[[T;T


11/25

c

'B@IBHAIJ A f?@>BCH>K>@ @I>H>^PBg EK H=B K>CAF &3' >CAMDAC@B EK H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC AWEPH ]=BH=BI HE>??PB A OBIS>H2 .BH2 $OO2 VUQVV0 [[Q[Z2

+=B 'B@IBHAIJ PFH>SAHBFJ MB@>MBM HE AFFE] H=B BN>?HQ>CG EJ?HBIQ@PFH>DAH>EC I>G=H? HE BNO>IB EC H=B>I E]CHBIS? ]>H=EPH >??P>CG A OBIS>H2 .BH2 $OO2 Va[QVcck ?BB6A" AH VTQV[2 +=B 'B@IBHAIJ fBNOFA>CBM H=AH =>? MB@>Q?>EC ]A? jWA?BM EC SAHHBI? EK FA] ACM OEF>@J0L >C@FPMQ>CG H=B jBNOF>@>H HBIS? EK H=B V\bT @ECDBJAC@B KIEShH=B OIBD>EP? E]CBIi HE H=B :C>HBM 'HAHB?L ACM jH=BOEF>@>B? EK hH=B /AH>ECAF .AId 'BID>@Bi @EC@BIC>CG@ESSBI@>AF P?B ]>H=>C A PC>H EK H=B /AH>ECAF .AId'J?HBS ACM CEC@ECKEIS>CG P?B? ]>H=>C OEHBCH>AF EIMB?>GCAHBM ]>FMBICB??0 A? ]BFF A? ?OB@>K>@ ]>FMBICB??

FBG>?FAH>EC KEI .E>CH #BJB? /AH>ECAF 'BA?=EIB2Lg )A" AHVT2 +=B 'B@IBHAIJ BSO=A?>RBM >C OAIH>@PFAI H=AH f=>?MB@>?>EC ]A? jWA?BM EC H=B >C@ESOAH>W>F>HJ EK @ESSBIQ@>AF A@H>D>H>B? >C ]>FMBICB??2Lg )]6A" +=B 'B@IBHAIJ?HAHBM H=AH =B =AM KEPCM H=B MIAKH &3' ACM K>CAF &3'f j=BFOKPF0Lg WPH ?OB@>K>@AFFJ CEHBM OBH>H>ECBI?L ?@>BCH>K>@@I>H>^PB EK H=B K>CAF &3'k BNOFA>CBM H=AH =B =AM CEHIBF>BM EC &3' MAHA fjH=AH ]A? A??BIHBM HE WB KFA]BMLgkACM KPIH=BI BNOFA>CBM H=AH CB>H=BI H=B MIAKH CEI H=BK>CAF &3' =AM WBBC fjSAHBI>AF HE H=B FBGAF ACM OEF>@JKA@HEI? H=AH OIED>MBhMi H=B @BCHIAF WA?>?L KEI =>? MB@>Q

?>EC2g )A" AH VT0 [Z2[2 .BH>H>ECBI? K>FBM ?P>H >C M>?HI>@H @EPIH0 A??BIH>CGH=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC D>EFAHBM H=B $MS>C>?HIAQH>DB .IE@BMPIB $@H ;$.$EC VTZ fAKKEIMBM H=B'B@IBHAIJ M>?@IBH>EC HE SAdB =>? "B@>?>EC ]>H=EPH?PKK>@>BCH SBAC>CGKPF ?HACMAIM? KEI H=B ,EPIH HE IBQ


12/25

b

D>B]0g ACM >H A@@EIM>CGFJ @EC@FPMBM H=AH H=B MB@>?>EC ]A? PCIBD>B]AWFB PCMBI a :2'2,2 bUV;AMB? H=AH H=B $.$ MEB? CEH AOOFJ HE AGBC@J A@H>ECf@ESS>HHBM HE AGBC@J M>?@IBH>EC WJ FA]2g .BH2 $OO2V[Vk ?BB6A" AH VT\QV[c2 +=B M>?HI>@H @EPIH AMM>H>ECAFFJIBA?ECBM H=AH0 BDBC >K H=B MB@>?>EC ]A? IBD>B]AWFB0OBH>H>ECBI? ]BIB PCF>dBFJ HE OIBDA>F EC H=B SBI>H? ACM@EPFM CEH ?AH>?KJ H=B OIBIB^P>?>HB? KEI EWHA>C>CG OIBQF>S>CAIJ >C`PC@H>DB IBF>BK2 )A" AH V[cQVaV2

+=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? AKK>ISBM0 @EC@FPM>CG WEH= H=AHOBH>H>ECBI? ]BIB PCF>dBFJ HE OIBDA>F EC H=B SBI>H? ACMH=AH H=B B^P>H>B? M>M CEH KADEI A OIBF>S>CAIJ >C`PC@QH>EC2 .BH2 $OO2 VQ[bk ?BB6A" AH VU[QVUZ ;GIACH>CG >CQ

`PC@H>EC OBCM>CG AOOBAF?AGIBBhMi >C OAIHg ]>H= H=B M>?HI>@H@EPIHL? @EC@FP?>EC H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC ]A?PCIBD>B]AWFB2 )A" AH VZ2 #BFJ>CG EC >H? OIBD>EP? MB@>Q?>EC >C $;?? )H>ECQ


13/25

X

BI?L AIGPSBCH H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJ =AM S>?>CHBIOIBHBM'B@H>EC VTZ ACM EH=BI KBMBIAF FA]?06A" AH TTQTX2 +=B@EPIH EK AOOBAF? AF?E @EC@FPMBM H=AH0 AFH=EPG= H=B'B@IBHAIJ =AM WBBC >C@EIIB@H >C =>? WBF>BK H=AH 'B@H>ECVTZL? fCEH]>H=?HACM>CGg @FAP?B IBCMBIBM /&.$ ]=EFQFJ >CAOOF>@AWFB0 H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC CEH HE >??PB ACB] OBIS>H =AM CEH D>EFAHBM /&.$2 )A" AH Vc0 TXQ[Z2+=B @EPIH ]A? f?dBOH>@AF H=AH H=B MB@>?>EC HE AFFE] H=BOBIS>H HE BNO>IBg ^PAF>K>BM A? H=B HJOB EK A@H>EC KEI

]=>@= /&.$ IB^P>IB? AC &3'0 6A" AH [Uk @=AIA@HBI>RBMH=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC A? fB??BCH>AFFJ AC BCD>IECQSBCHAF @EC?BIDAH>EC BKKEIH0g A HJOB EK A@H>EC H=AH =AMfCEH HI>GGBIBM /&.$ >C H=B OA?H0g6]6A"k ACM IBA?ECBMH=AH H=B fIBFAH>DBFJ S>CEI =AIS?g >MBCH>K>BM >C H=B

K>CAF &3' fME CEH WJ H=BS?BFDB? j?>GC>K>@ACHFJ AKKB@HLH=B BCD>IECSBCH >C ?P@= A ]AJ A? HE >SOF>@AHB /&.$0g6A" AH [VQ[T ;^PEH>CG ZT :2'2,2 Z[[T;THHBMH fCBBM CEH IB?EFDB ]=BH=BI /&.$ @ESOF>AC@B ]A?IB^P>IBM WB@AP?B0 BDBC >K >H ]A?0 H=B 'B@IBHAIJ @ECQMP@HBM AC AMB^PAHB /&.$ IBD>B] OIE@B?? ACM ACJ@FA>SBM MBK>@>BC@>B? AIB ]>H=EPH @EC?B^PBC@B2g )A" AH[T2

+=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? EW?BIDBM H=AH H=B fGEDBICQSBCH OIEMP@BM A FBCGH=J &3'0 ]=>@= H=B 'B@IBHAIJ

@EC?>MBIBM ACM KEPCM j=BFOKPF2Lg .BH2 $OO2 [T2 $FHQ=EPG= H=B 'B@IBHAIJ =AM A@dCE]FBMGBM >C F>H>GAH>ECH=AH /&.$ @ESOF>AC@B =AM WBBC fFB?? H=AC OBIKB@H0gH=B @EPIH IB@EGC>RBM H=AH fhIiBF>BK >? ADA>FAWFB PCMBIH=B $.$ ECFJ KEI jOIB`PM>@>AF BIIEILg ACM IBA?ECBMH=AH OBH>H>ECBI? ]BIB fPCF>dBFJ HE ?P@@BBM >C ?=E]>CGH=AH H=B h/&.$i BIIEI? ]BIB OIB`PM>@>AF2g )]6A" ;^PEH>CG a :2'2,2 bUc ACM @>H>CG $=86465A;9? D2 1;@;


14/25

\

ca\ ;TUUbH>ECBI?L @FA>S?H=AH fH=B K>CAF &3' ]A? WA?BM EC KFA]BM ?@>BC@B ACMH=AH H=B AW?BC@B EK hAi H=>IHJQMAJ @ESSBCH OBI>EM hECH=B K>CAF &3'i MBC>BM hH=BSi AC EOOEIHPC>HJ HE KPFFJA>I hH=B>Ii @I>H>^PB0 ?OB@>K>@AFFJ ]>H= IBGAIM HE @EC@FPQ?>EC? IBGAIM>CG H=B j?EPCM?@AOBL EK H=B B?HBIE2g )A" AH[[2 +=B @EPIH KEPCM0 =E]BDBI0 H=AH fhCiEH=>CG >C H=BIB@EIM ?PGGB?H? H=AH hOBH>H>ECBI? ]BIBi OIB`PM>@BM WJACJ ?=EIH@ES>CG? >C H=B K>CAF ?EPCM?@AOB MAHA2g )]6A" +=B @EPIH EW?BIDBM H=AH OBH>H>ECBI? f?BCH H=B 'B@IBQHAIJ hH=B>Ii ?@>BCH>K>@ @I>H>^PB WBKEIB =B >??PBM =>?MB@>?>ECg ACM H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJ f?OB@>K>@AFFJ IBKBIQBC@BM H=AH @ESSPC>@AH>EC ACM ?HAHBM H=AH =B M>M CEHIBFJ EC H=B jMAHA H=AH ]A? A??BIHBM HE WB KFA]BM2Lg )A"

AH [[Q[Z2 +=B @EPIH AF?E IBA?ECBM H=AH /&.$L? IBQ^P>IBSBCH EK A fIBA?ECAWFJ H=EIEPG= M>?@P??>EC EK H=B?>GC>K>@ACH A?OB@H? EK H=B OIEWAWFB BCD>IECSBCHAF@EC?B^PBC@B?g M>M CEH IB^P>IB H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJMBK>C>H>DBFJ IB?EFDB AFF @ECHIEDBI?>B? AWEPH H=B MAHA2

)A" AH [Z ;^PEH>CG 2;=885; ,>A4]4< 247XC D2 '?DC 0 \\X62TM c\\0 bU[ ;\H= ,>I2 V\\[? D>B]0 H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC CEH HE >??PB H=B OBIS>H=AM IBF>BM EC AC >CHBIOIBHAH>EC EK H=B V\bc .E>CH#BJB? 5>FMBICB?? $@H H=AH ,ECGIB?? =AM IB`B@HBM WJ

BCA@H>CG 'B@H>EC VTZ0 ACM ]A? H=P? fAIW>HIAIJ0 @AOI>Q@>EP?0 EI EH=BI]>?B CEH >C A@@EIMAC@B ]>H= FA]2g )A" AH[XQZ\2 4PMGB 5AHKEIM AF?E WBF>BDBM H=AH H=B B^P>H>B?KADEIBM A OIBF>S>CAIJ >C`PC@H>EC2 )A" AH Z\QaV2

6+=5H>ECBI? @ECHBCM H=AH H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? AOQOF>BM AC BIIECBEP?FJ CAIIE] ?@EOB EK IBD>B] PCMBI H=B

$.$ ;.BH2 VZQTbC@EIIB@HFJ @EC@FPMBM H=AH /&.$MEB? CEH AOOFJ HE H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC ;.BH2 TbQ[T


15/25

VU

ACM S>?AOOF>BM H=B OIB`PM>@>AFQBIIEI ME@HI>CB >C H=B@ECHBNH EK H=B>I /&.$ @FA>S ;.BH2 [TQ[[EC?0 ]=>@= FAIGBFJ IB?H EC A S>?PCMBI?HACM>CG EKH=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF?L MB@>?>EC0 FA@d SBI>H2 +=B MB@>?>ECWBFE] MEB? CEH @ECKF>@H ]>H= ACJ MB@>?>EC EK H=>? ,EPIHEI ACJ EH=BI @EPIH EK AOOBAF?0 ACM KPIH=BI IBD>B]0 >CH=>? >CHBIFE@PHEIJ OE?HPIB0 EK OBH>H>ECBI?L @=AFFBCGB HEH=B 'B@IBHAIJL? M>?@IBH>ECAIJ MB@>?>EC PCMBI H=BPC>^PB HBIS? EK 'B@H>EC VTZ >? PC]AIIACHBM2

V2 A2 +=B $.$ OIED>MB? KEI `PM>@>AF IBD>B] EK fK>CAFAGBC@J A@H>EC KEI ]=>@= H=BIB >? CE EH=BI AMB^PAHBIBSBMJ >C A @EPIH2g a :2'2,2 bUZk ?BB a :2'2,2 bUT;AFFE]>CG KEI IBD>B] EK @BIHA>C @FA>S? f?BBd>CG IBF>BKEH=BI H=AC SECBJ MASAGB?gC@FPMB? APQH=EI>HJ KEI H=B IBD>B]>CG @EPIH HE f=EFM PCFA]KPF ACM?BH A?>MB AGBC@J A@H>EC0 K>CM>CG?0 ACM @EC@FP?>EC?KEPCM HE WB m m m AIW>HIAIJ0 @AOI>@>EP?0 AC AWP?B EKM>?@IBH>EC0 EI EH=BI]>?B CEH >C A@@EIMAC@B ]>H= FA]2g+=B $.$ ?BOAIAHBFJ ?OB@>K>B?0 >C a :2'2,2 bUV;AAF IBD>B] >? CEH ADA>FAWFB fHE H=B BNHBCH H=AHm m m AGBC@J A@H>EC >? @ESS>HHBM HE AGBC@J M>?@IBQH>EC WJ FA]2g

.BH>H>ECBI?L A??BIH>EC ;.BH2 VT< H=AH H=B @EPIH EK AOQ

OBAF? f=BFM H=AH >H FA@dBM `PI>?M>@H>EC EDBI hH=B>Ii $.$@FA>Sg >? S>?HAdBC2 $FH=EPG= H=B GEDBICSBCH AIGPBMH=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC ]A? ]=EFFJ PCIBD>B]AWFBWA?BM EC 'B@H>EC bUV;AH? IBD>B]EK ]=BH=BI H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC >C H=>? @A?B fD>EQFAHBM ACJ FBGAF SACMAHB @ECHA>CBM >C 'B@H>EC VTZ EIBF?B]=BIB2g )]6A" +=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF?L @EC@FP?>EC EC


16/25

VV

H=AH OE>CH ?PW?HACH>AFFJ A@@EIM? ]>H= H=B AIGPSBCH?H=AH OBH>H>ECBI? H=BS?BFDB? =AM SAMB AWEPH H=B ?@EOBEK IBD>B] AOOF>@AWFB HE H=B>I $.$ @FA>S2 'BB .BH2 ,2$2(I2 TUQTZk ?BB AF?E .BH2 $OO2 Va ;IBFJ>CG EC $;?? )CG H=AH OBH>H>ECBI?FA@dBM ?HACM>CG HE IA>?B A ?BOAIAHB AIGPSBCH @=AFQFBCG>CG H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? CEH>@B >C H=B 6BMBIAF #BG>?HBIEK =>? >CHBCH HE MB?>GCAHB "IAdB? &?HBIE A? ]>FMBIQCB??K>@AFFJ AMMIB?Q

T 3C A KEEHCEHB >C H=B>I EOBC>CG WI>BK0 OBH>H>ECBI? A??BIHBM H=AH

H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC ]A? AIW>HIAIJ ACM @AOI>@>EP? WB@AP?B >H@ECHA>CBM >C@EC?>?HBCH ?HAHBSBCH? H=AH ]BIB CEH AMB^PAHBFJ BNQOFA>CBM ACM M>M CEH f@FAI>KJ EI BNOFA>Cg =E] H=B 'B@IBHAIJ >MBCH>QK>BM H=B OEIH>EC? EK H=B &3' EC ]=>@= =B IBF>BM2 .BH2 ,2$2 (I2 TcC2b2 +E H=B BNHBCH H=AH H=E?B AIGPSBCH? ]BIB AMB^PAHBFJ OIBQ?BIDBM0 ?BB0;"B"0 '?8=8; 4@ 2=>?BM ECFJ >C KEEHCEHB?m m m AIB GBCBIAFFJ MBBSBM ]A>DBM2gDBFJ AMMIB??BM H=BS2 6>I?H0 >H @EC@FPMBM H=AH0 >C @ECHBNH0 H=B


17/25

VT

?BM ACM IB`B@HBM H=B DAI>EP? AIGPSBCH? SAMB WJ H=BM>??BCH>CG PMGB2 )A" AH VbQVX l C2a0 Ta C2X2

W2 /EH]>H=?HACM>CG H=AH H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? AMQMIB??BM EC H=B SBI>H? AFF EK OBH>H>ECBI?L AIGPSBCH?0OBH>H>ECBI? CBDBIH=BFB?? @ECHBCM ;.BH2 VZQTb< H=AH H=>?,EPIH ?=EPFM GIACH @BIH>EIAI> HE MBHBIS>CB ]=BH=BIH=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? AOOF>BM H=B OIEOBI ?@EOB EK IBQ

D>B] PCMBI H=B $.$2 +=AH @ECHBCH>EC >? S>?GP>MBM2+=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? ?HAHBM H=AH >H @EPFM CEH fIBQ

D>B] H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? PFH>SAHB M>?@IBH>ECAIJ MB@>?>EC ]=BH=BI HE >??PB A CB] OBIS>Hg ACM ?>S>FAIFJ ?PGGB?HQBM H=AH >H @EPFM CEH fIBD>B] AC AFFBGBM AWP?B EK M>?@IBQH>EC IBGAIM>CG jH=B SAd>CG EK AC >CKEISBM `PMGSBCHWJ H=B AGBC@J2Lg .BH2 $OO2 VZQVa ;^PEH>CG $;?? )8" ,>84" )EC @ECHA>CBM CE SBAC>CGKPF >C@EC?>?HBC@J0 IB@EGQC>R>CG H=AH H=>? ,EPIHL? OIB@BMBCH? IB^P>IB A IBD>B]>CG @EPIH HEfPO=EFM BDBC jA MB@>?>EC EK FB?? H=AC >MBAF @FAI>HJL ?E FECG A? jH=BAGBC@JL? OAH= SAJ IBA?ECAWFJ WB M>?@BICBM2Lg .BH2 $OO2 T[ ;^PEHQ>CG *.. D2 *4\ (;5;!6?64< 28=864


18/25

V[

>H? M>?@IBH>ECE;9;5C WJ MB@>M>CG AC >??PB0 >CDEFD>CGAGBC@J BNOBIH>?B0 AMDBI?BFJ HE A @ESOFA>C>CG OAIHJ2g

$;?? )

,??X< 0 Zc[ :2'2 AH Z[2 (PH >H >? CEH @FBAI H=AH H=B @EPIHEK AOOBAF? >CHBCMBM HE SAdB ?P@= A M>?H>C@H>EC0 ACM >H ]EPFM WB >CAOOIEOI>AHB HE IB?EFDB ACJ ASW>GP>HJ >CH=B @EPIHL? FACGPAGB >C A SACCBI H=AH OIB?PSB? H=BFBGAF BIIEI H=AH OBH>H>ECBI? A??BIH >H @ESS>HHBM2 ,K2

2D96? AMMBMCKEI@>CGH=AH H=B ECFJ HJOB EK AIGPSBCH? >H WBF>BDBM HE WB PCIBQ

D>B]AWFB ]BIB AIGPSBCH? H=AH ]EPFM >CD>HB ?B@ECMQGPB??>CG EK H=B AGBC@JL? OEF>@J @=E>@B?2 'BB ^4849[;G675; ^@9?" ,??X


19/25

VZ

H>ECBI? A@HPAFFJ SAMB2 +=B OBH>H>EC MEB? CEH >MBCH>KJACJ OAIH>@PFAI0 ?OB@>K>@0 IBD>B]AWFB AIGPSBCH? H=AH

]BIB OIB?BCHBM HE0 WPH M>?IBGAIMBM WJ0 H=B @EPIH EKAOOBAF?2 ,ESOAIB0;"B"0 .BH2 TV ;A??BIH>CG H=AH OBH>QH>ECBI? fAIGPBM >C hH=B>Ii WI>BK? H=AH H=B AGBC@J MB@>Q?>EC ]A? AC AWP?B EK M>?@IBH>EC >C D>EFAH>EC EK $.$Y bUc;T? CEH >C >H?BFK >SOEIHACH BCEPG=HE `P?H>KJ KPIH=BI IBD>B] ;OAIH>@PFAIFJ >C H=B >CHBIFE@PQHEIJ OE?HPIB EK A OIBF>S>CAIJQ>C`PC@H>EC IB^PB?H?>EC WBFE] =ADB ACJ EWD>EP? OIE?OB@H>DB>SOEIHAC@B KEI $.$ IBD>B] EK MB@>?>EC? PCMBI EH=BI?HAHPHB?2 3H >? KAI KIES @BIHA>C H=AH ACJ KPHPIB OACBF>C H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? ]EPFM >CHBIOIBH H=B @EPIH EK

AOOBAF?L ?HAHBSBCH? >C H=>? @A?B H=B ]AJ H=AH OBH>H>ECQBI? ME0 EI IBFJ EC H=E?B ?HAHBSBCH? HE KEIB@FE?B @ECQ?>MBIAH>EC EK ?ESB OAIH>@PFAI AIGPSBCH >C ?ESB AFHBIQCAH>DB ?HAHPHEIJ @ECHBNH2 '=EPFM H=B MB@>?>EC WBFE]>C KA@H G>DB I>?B HE ?P@= >??PB? >C KPHPIB @A?B?0 H=BIB

]EPFM WB H>SB BCEPG= KEI H=>? ,EPIH HE GIACH@BIH>EIAI> AH H=AH OE>CH0 WJ ]=>@= H>SB H=B @ECHEPI? EK@>I@P>H FA] ]EPFM OIB?PSAWFJ WB @FBAIBI ACM SBAC>CGQKPF IBD>B] ]EPFM WB OE??>WFB2


20/25

Va

@2 .BH>H>ECBI?L ?PGGB?H>EC ;.BH2 VZQTb< H=AH H=B,EPIH ?=EPFM GIACH IBD>B] >C H=>? @A?B HE IB?EFDB A?Q?BIHBM @>I@P>H @ECKF>@H? EDBI H=B AOOF>@AH>EC EK H=B

$.$L? fCE FA] HE AOOFJg ?HACMAIM >? S>?OFA@BM2 +=AH?HACMAIM >? MIA]C KIES H=>? ,EPIHL? MB@>?>EC >C.686MY;


21/25

Vc

'B@ECM0 WB@AP?B H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? IBD>B]BM H=B'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC >C H=>? @A?B KEI @ESOF>AC@B ]>H=BDBIJ ?HAHPHEIJ OIED>?>EC EC ]=>@= OBH>H>ECBI? IBF>BM0?BB .BH2 $OO2 TVQ[Z0 OBH>H>ECBI? ]EPFM CEH WBCBK>H KIESACJ IBD>B] EK H=B @>I@PS?HAC@B? PCMBI ]=>@= $.$IBD>B] >? PCADA>FAWFB2 'BB .BH2 VaQVb l CC2TTQTc2 /EI

]EPFM H=>? @A?B WB AC AOOIEOI>AHB DB=>@FB KEI IBD>B]Q>CG H=AH >??PB0 G>DBC H=B PC>^PB ACM F>S>HBM ?@EOB EKH=B ?HAHPHB ;'B@H>EC VTZ< H=AH APH=EI>RBM H=B 'B@IBQHAIJL? MB@>?>EC >C H=>? @A?B2 +=>IM0 ACM IBFAHBMFJ0 H=>?@A?B @BIHA>CFJ MEB? CEH >SOF>@AHB ACJ A??BIHBM @>I@P>H@ECKF>@H AWEPH H=B AOOF>@AH>EC EK $.$ IBD>B] >C H=B@ECHBNH EK ?HAHPHB? H=AH KEISBM CE OAIH EK H=B WA@dQMIEO KEI H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC AWEPH OBH>H>ECBI?L

OBIS>H2 'BB .BH2 V\QTU l CC2TbQ[V2T2 .BH>H>ECBI? CBNH @ECHBCM ;.BH2 TbQ[T< H=AH H=B@EPIH EK AOOBAF? BIIBM >C =EFM>CG H=AH /&.$ MEB? CEHAOOFJ HE f@EC?BIDAH>EC BKKEIH?g WJ KBMBIAF AGBC@>B?2+=AH @ECHBCH>EC IBKFB@H? A S>?PCMBI?HACM>CG EK H=B@EPIH EK AOOBAF?L MB@>?>EC2 $FH=EPG= H=B @EPIH EK AOQOBAF?L EO>C>EC @ECHA>CBM ?ESB M>?@P??>EC EK ]=BH=BI/&.$ AOOF>BM HE H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC0 .BH2 $OO2T\Q[T0 H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF? ]BCH EC HE @FAI>KJ H=AHfhPiFH>SAHBFJ0_; B] OIEQ@B?? ACM ACJ @FA>SBM MBK>@>BC@>B? AIB ]>H=EPH @EC?BQ^PBC@B0g6A" AH [T ;BSO=A?>? AMMBM?@P??>EC EK /&.$L? AOOF>@AW>F>HJ >? A@@EIMQ>CGFJ M>@HPS ACM ]EPFM CEH W>CM ACJ KPHPIB @>I@P>HOACBF2[

[ $ IB@BCH />CH= ,>I@P>H MB@>?>EC IBKBIIBM HE H=B M>?@P??>EC EK/&.$L? AOOF>@AW>F>HJ >C H=B MB@>?>EC WBFE] ]>H=EPH ?PGGB?H>CG >H

]A? M>@HPS2 2=< 3>6? W 1;58=M^;8G" D2 F;_;55 0


22/25

Vb

+=>? @A?B ]EPFM0 >C ACJ BDBCH0 WB AC PC?P>HAWFB DBQ=>@FB KEI IBD>B]>CG H=B @>I@PS?HAC@B? >C ]=>@= ACAGBC@J =A? PCMBIHAdBC A fSA`EI 6BMBIAF A@H>EChi ?>GQC>K>@ACHFJ AKKB@H>CG H=B ^PAF>HJ EK H=B =PSAC BCD>IECQSBCHg H=AH ]EPFM HI>GGBI H=B IB^P>IBSBCH? EK /&.$2ZT :2'2,2 Z[[T;TCG H=B @EPIHEK AOOBAF?L M>?@P??>EC EK H=AH >??PB ]BIB CEH M>@HPS0H=B @EPIH EK AOOBAF?L @EC@FP?>EC H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJ M>M?PKK>@>BCHFJ @ESOFJ ]>H= /&.$0 .BH2 $OO2 [T0 SBAC?H=AH H=B ^PB?H>EC EK /&.$L? AOOF>@AW>F>HJ >? CEH EPHQ@ESBQMBHBIS>CAH>DB >C H=>? @A?B2 'B@ECM0 ACJ IBD>B]EK /&.$L? AOOF>@AW>F>HJ >C H=>? @A?B ]EPFM IB^P>IB@EC?>MBIAH>EC EK H=B H=IB?=EFM >??PB EK ]=BH=BI 'B@QH>EC VTZL? fCEH]>H=?HACM>CG ACJ EH=BI OIED>?>EC EK

FA]g ?POBI?BMB? /&.$L? IB^P>IBSBCH?0 ]=>@= @EPFMEWD>AHB ACJ CBBM HE IBA@= H=B ^PB?H>EC OBH>H>ECBI?OIB?BCH2 Y VTZ0 VT[ 'HAH2 T\[T2 +=>IM0 BDBC OPHH>CGH=B fCEH]>H=?HACM>CGg @FAP?B HE ECB ?>MB0 IBD>B] EK

]=BH=BI /&.$ AOOF>B? >C H=B PC>^PB @ECHBNH EK AFFE]Q>CG A OBIS>H HE FAO?B PCMBI 'B@H>EC VTZ ]EPFM CEH WBB?OB@>AFFJ F>dBFJ HE OIED>MB P?BKPF GP>MAC@B >C @A?B?>CDEFD>CG MB@>?>EC? PCMBI EH=BI ?HAHPHB?2 #BD>B] >CH=>? @A?B ]EPFM CEH CB@B??AI>FJ IB?EFDB0 KEI BNASOFB0ACJ @ECKF>@H WBH]BBC H=B />CH= ACM +BCH= ,>I@P>H?IBGAIM>CG H=B AOOF>@AH>EC EK /&.$ HE H=B MB?>GCAH>EC

EK A @I>H>@AF =AW>HAH PCMBI H=B &CMACGBIBM 'OB@>B? $@HEK V\b[0 Vc :2'2,2 Va[V ;8 ?;V" 'BB .BH2 TX26PIH=BISEIB0 OBH>H>ECBI? AIB >C@EIIB@H >C H=B>I

WEHHESQF>CB OE?>H>EC H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJL? MB@>?>EC >CH=>? @A?B ]A? A fSA`EI 6BMBIAF A@H>EChi0g ZT :2'2,2Z[[T;T?>EC >C H=>?

bZb 62[M aXV0 caT ;TUVZCBM0 =E]BDBI0 HE IBAM H=B MB@>?>ECWBFE] fHE ?HACM KEI H=B OIEOE?>H>EC H=AH BKKEIH? HE OIB?BIDB H=BCAHPIAF BCD>IECSBCH AIB OBI ?B BNBSOH KIES /&.$2g )]6A"


23/25

VX

@A?B M>M CEH AFHBI H=B FBGAF ?HAHP? ^PE2 +=>? >? CEH A@>I@PS?HAC@B >C ]=>@= AC AGBC@J >? IB^P>IBM WJ ?HAHQPHB EI IBGPFAH>EC HE A@H EC A OBIS>H AOOF>@AH>EC2 #AQH=BI >H >? A @>I@PS?HAC@B >C ]=>@= I>G=H? IB?BIDBM >C A@ECHIA@H @ECDBJ>CG FACM HE H=B :C>HBM 'HAHB? ]BIB ?BHHE BNO>IB EC H=B>I E]C HBIS?0 ACM H=B AGBC@J M>M CEH=Q>CG HE @=ACGB H=AH ?>HPAH>EC2 $FFE]>CG ?P@= I>G=H? HEBNO>IB >? CEH CAHPIAFFJ @=AIA@HBI>RBM A? fSA`EI AGBC@JA@H>EC2g $CM CECB EK H=B @>I@P>H MB@>?>EC? IBF>BM EC WJOBH>H>ECBI ?PGGB?H? H=AH /&.$ ]EPFM AOOFJ >C A @>IQ@PS?HAC@B F>dB H=>?2 'BB.=894< .CG /&.$ HE A @I>H>@AFQ=AW>HAH MBHBIS>CAH>EC PCMBI H=B &CMACGBIBM 'OB@>B?

$@H


24/25

V\

"B@>?>EC -BSEIACMPS IAH=BI H=AC A #B@EIM EK "B@>Q?>EC2g .BH2 $OO2 [Tk ?BB6A" AH [TQ[Z2 3C OAIH>@PFAI0 H=B@EPIH EK AOOBAF? EW?BIDBM H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJ f]A? ]BFFA]AIB EK g OBH>H>ECBI?L @I>H>@>?S EK H=B &3'k ?OB@>K>@AFFJIBKBIBC@BM H=AH @I>H>@>?S >C =>? MB@>?>EC CEH HE >??PB AOBIS>Hk ACM SAMB @FBAI H=AH H=B M>?OPHBM BCD>IECSBCQHAF MAHA fM>M CEH @AIIJ ]B>G=H >C =>? MB@>?>EC2g )A" AH[Zk ?BB6A" AH [[2

.BH>H>ECBI? BII >C ?PGGB?H>CG ;.BH2 [[< H=AH H=B@EPIH EK AOOBAF?L MB@>?>EC >? >C HBC?>EC EI @ECKF>@H ]>H=H=B "2,2 ,>I@P>HL? MB@>?>EC >C:;9];9 D2 $4984< 0 T\Z62[M Vb[ ;TUUTFBM HEM>?@FE?B >CKEISAH>EC =>G=FJ IBFBDACH HE A OBIS>H AOOF>Q@AH>EC MPI>CG H=B OPWF>@Q@ESSBCH OBI>EM0 H=BIBWJ MBQ

OI>D>CG H=B OFA>CH>KK? EK H=B EOOEIHPC>HJ HE IA>?B >??PB?@EC@BIC>CG H=AH >CKEISAH>EC PCH>F AKHBI H=B OBIS>H ]A?AOOIEDBM2 )A" AH VbcQVbX2 +=B "2,2 ,>I@P>H KEPCM H=BOIE@BMPIAF BIIEI HE WB OIB`PM>@>AF2 )A" AH VXTQVXZk ?BB6A" AH VbXQVXT2 +=B "2,2 ,>I@P>H IB`B@HBM H=B AGBC@JL?AIGPSBCH H=AH H=B AGBC@J A@HPAFFJ dCB] AWEPH ACM@EC?>MBIBM0 WBKEIB APH=EI>R>CG H=B OBIS>H0 H=B >??PB?H=AH H=B OFA>CH>KK? FAHBI IA>?BM2 )A" AH VXTQVX[2 +=B"2,2 ,>I@P>H AF?E IB`B@HBM H=B AGBC@JL? AIGPSBCH0

]=>@= IBF>BM EC OE?H =E@ MB@FAIAH>EC?0 H=AH H=B fOIE@BQMPIAF BIIEI ]A? =AISFB?? WB@AP?B0 AKHBI hH=B OFA>CQ

H>KK?i K>FBM H=B>I @ESOFA>CH ACM BFAWEIAHBM EC H=B>I@EC@BIC?0 H=B AGBC@J CECBH=BFB?? @EC@FPMBM H=AH >H ]EPFM CEH =ADB @=ACGBM >H? MB@>?>EC =AM >H dCE]C EKH=E?B @EC@BIC? AH H=B H>SB >H >??PBM H=B OBIS>H2g )A" AHVX[2

3C H=>? @A?B0 WJ @ECHIA?H0 H=B 'B@IBHAIJ ]A? f]BFFA]AIBg EK OBH>H>ECBI?L EW`B@H>EC?];@49; =B SAMB =>?MB@>?>EC2 .BH2 $OO2 [[Q[Z2 $CM H=B @EC@FP?>EC H=AHH=E?B EW`B@H>EC? ]EPFM =ADB CE BKKB@H EC H=B MB@>?>EC


25/25

TU

]A? CEH A fOE?H =E@ IAH>ECAF>RAH>EChi0g:;9];9 0 T\Z 62[MAH VXZ0 WPH >C?HBAM A MBHBIS>CAH>EC H=AH H=B 'B@IBHAIJBNOIB??FJ IBA@=BM AH H=B H>SB EK =>? MB@>?>EC0 ?BB .BH2

$OO2 [Z2 /E KPIH=BI IBD>B] >? ]AIIACHBM28/!8750,/!

+=B OBH>H>EC KEI A ]I>H EK @BIH>EIAI> ?=EPFM WB MBC>BM2

#B?OB@HKPFFJ ?PWS>HHBM2" */$1" (2 8 #3113 0 4# 2

245676849 :;

Documents

10. Opposition Argument for Denying Writ of Certiorari in SCOTUS 5.1.14