Upload
timothy-wheeler
View
217
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Fishery science and policyConnecting information and decision
Serge M. Garcia
D4 Science World User Meeting. FAO Rome 25-26 November 2009
2
Outline
1. The fishery system
2. The advice & decision process
3. Current situation
4. Conclusions
RespondentsBaran, Eric; Brenton, Bob; Chavance, Pierre; Farmer, Tina;
Fulton, Beth; Grainger, Richard; Guitton Jérome; Hall, Martin; Le Fur, Jean; Laloé, Francis; Maguire, Jean-Jacques; Mahon, Robin;
O’Boyle, Bob; O’Dor, Ron; Rice, Jake; Sainsbury, Keith; Sibert, John; Sinclair, Michael; Taconet, Marc; Vanden Berghe, Edward;
Williams, Meryl; Ye, Yemin
3
Outline
1. The fishery system
2. The advice & decision process
3. Current situation
4. Conclusions
4
The fishery system
ResourcesEcosystem
Industrial fleet
ArtisanalFleet
Fish processors
Fishtraders
Fisheryresearch
Fisheryagency
Shipyards
Maritime transport
Ports Marinas
AquacultureAgriculture
Tourism
Defence
Oil & GasCablesPipes
Chemical industries
Media
Banks
NGOs
Consumers
Government
Demography
Global economy
Climate change
Int. Instruments
Global market
5
Complex processes
6
Nested scales
7
12 coastal ecological realms19 FAO Main Fishing Areas
Overlapping systems of boundaries
Longhurst, A.R. 2007. Ecological geography of the sea2nd Edition. Academic Press
57 open ocean provinces62 coastal provinces
http://www.seaaroundus.org/lme/lme.aspx
64 Large Marine Ecosystems
SAUP: http://www.seaaroundus.org/eez/eez.aspx
160 Exclusive Economic Zones232 Ecoregions1km
2km
O° 10° 20° 30° 40° 50° 60° Latitude
Dep
th
Equatorial Epipelagic
Central Epipelagic
TransitionalEpipelagic
Subpolar Epipelagic
Equatorial-Central mesopelagic
Subpolar Mesopalegic
Bathypelagic
Longhurst, A.R. 2007. Ecological geography of the sea2nd Edition. Academic Press
Equator Poles
8
Multiple time units
Century: the evolutionary scale of the sector Decade: the scale of natural oscillations Year: base of formal fishery statistics and quota regulations Season: basic biological, fishery & management pattern Trip: often the base of fishery reporting Day: fishery reporting, log books Haul: fishery reporting < hour: VMS recording Continuous: Plankton recorder. Bioborne sensors
9
Administration
Regulation
Lobbying
Functions
Arenas
Public
Private
A complex governance
Regional Councils
Fishery Associations
Parliament
Management Agency
Government
Fishery Committees
Statistics
Enterprises
Households
Fishery Research
Traditional rules Taboos
Fishing operations
Constitution
Fisheries Authority
Legislation
Fishery Chambers
NGOs
Other stakeholdersOther citizens
Courts
Média
Garcia, S.M. & Cochrane, K.L. 2009
10
Environmental policy
Socio-economic
policy
Maritime policy
Foreign policy
Cross-sectoral connections
Fishery policy
11
Fisheries
Market
Civil society
Science
State
Global
Fisheries
Market
Civil society
Science
State
Regional
Market
Civil society
Science
State
Cross-scale connections
National
Fisheries
12
Information requirements
INSTITUTIONS Conventions Regulations Financing Organization Process
OTHER ACTIVITIES
VALUES
CLIM
ATEO
TH
ER
EC
OS
YS
TEM
S
MA
RK
ETS
FISHING Capture Processing
Competition
PO
LIC
Y
ABIOTIC Weather
Physical habitat Water Contaminants
BIOTIC Target species Other species
Interactions
Living habitat Predators Preys
Global change
Impacts
Impac
ts
Fluctuations Survival
Working conditions
Pro
tectio
n
R
eh
ab
ilitatio
n
Protection
Restoration
Demand
Supply
Management
DevelopmentInformation
LobbyingBehavior Votes
Remov
als
Deple
tion
Gear
imp
act
Pollu
tion
Clu
es
Ris
ks Att
ract
ion
HabitatChange
Source: Garcia et al. 2003
13
Policy-makers
SCIENTISTSStakeholders
NGOs
Adv
ice
Data
Com
pliance
Regulations
Information
Obj
ectiv
es
Media Public NGOs
Courts
Pressure
Com
munication
Query
Info
Complaints
Evidence
Sentences
Sen
tenc
es
Evidence
Evi
denc
e
Participation
Mod
ifie
d fr
om G
arci
a (2
005)
Communication channels
Conventional
New
Integration Negotiation
Coordination
14
Outline
1. The fishery system
2. The advice & decision process
3. Current situation
4. Conclusions
15
Demand
Arena
Co-assessment
Options
Advicel
Co-implementation
Performances assesmt.
Decision
Monitoring
New policy Crisis
Good practices
Stakeholder participation
Sci. Disciplines
Trad. knowledge
Extended knowledge
Integrated decision process
16
Integrating:
Relevant disciplines
Science and other knowledge
Facts, values and perceptions
Quantitative and qualitative analyses
Science and negotiation processes
Knowledge and sectoral policies
Development and management
Sectoral policies in a given area
Sectoral policies and societal demand
Integrating information
Environment
Development
Societal demand
Science Other knowledge
Facts
Perceptions
Values
Quantitative & quantitative analyses
Fishing
Coastal zones
Sectoral policies
17
Outline
1. The fishery system
2. The advice & decision process
3. Current situation
4. Conclusions
18
Catalogues of expertiseACCESS Processing Diffusion
19
Bibliographic recordsACCESS Processing Diffusion
20
Ocean bathymetry
WWW. VIRTUALOCEAN.ORG
ACCESS
21
Hydroclimatic dataACCESS Processing Diffusion
22
Biological informationACCESS Processing Diffusion
23
Biodiversity informationACCESS Processing Diffusion
24
Migration and environmental dataACCESS Processing Diffusion
25
Fishery statisticsACCESS Processing Diffusion
26
Regional fisheries monitoring
27
Information on stocks & FisheriesACCESS Processing Diffusion
28
Processing platforms
http://www.r-project.org/
ACCESS Processing Diffusion
29
Interactive mapping
http://www.marinebiodiversity.ca/OBI07/sessions/talks-pdf/May.pdf
ACCESS Processing Diffusion
IMAPS Caspian
Rhincodon typus
AQUAMAPS
30
Global diffusionACCESS Processing Diffusion
31
Globefish: Fish Trade PortalACCESS Processing Diffusion
32
Information portalsACCESS Processing Diffusion
33
Thematic groupsACCESS Processing Diffusion
34
Outline
1. The fishery system
2. The advice & decision process
3. Current situation
4. Conclusions
35
Demand
Arena
Co-assessment
Options
Advicel
Co-implementation
Performances assesmt.
Decision
Monitoring
New policy Crisis
Good practices
Stakeholder participation
Sci. Disciplines
Trad. knowledge
Extended knowledge
A complex decision-support system
36
Demand
Arena
Co-assessment
Options
Advicel
Co-implementation
Performances assesmt.
Decision
Monitoring
New policy Crisis
Good practices
Stakeholder participation
Sci. Disciplines
Trad. knowledge
Extended knowledge
A complex decision-support system
Informal knowledge
Best practices
Resources data
Environment data
Communication
Legislation
Cross sectoral data
Catch/Fleet data
Economic data
Intl. Agreements
Policies & Plans
Education
Training
Compliance data
Bibliography
INPUTSPROCESSINGOUTPUTS
Methods
Models
Stat. software
WGs
37
Social networks
Decision-support system (cont…)
Best practices
Communication
Legislation
Intl. Agreements
Policies & Plans
Education
Training
Inf. knowledge
Resources data
Environment data
Cross sectoral data
Catch/Fleet data
Economic data
Compliance data
Bibliography
Methods
Models
Stat. software
WGs
Open Libraries Repositories
Data bases
Wikise-Meetings
Contacts
Open Source platforms e-Training
Knowledgebases
Glossaries
38
Ideal system properties
Nested Evolutive
Authoritative
Affordable
Flexible
Building capacity
Action-oriented
End user-oriented
Ethical
Multisource
Multipurpose
Multidisciplinary
Multicultural
Multilingual
Multiple outputs
Multiscale
Interactive
Inter-operable
39
TO DO list
Improved access to authoritative data systems
More systematic geo-referencing
3-D displays
Visualisation of uncertainty
More dynamic representations
Google Oceans applications
Platforms for building atlases
Standardized publication platforms
E-training
40
Development of a community of practiceOpen-source modelling platforms for inter-disciplinary, bioeconomic, behavioural and ecosystem models and role games
Pool computing for large model runs
D4 Science dream list
Fishery Management Knowledge Network
Fishery Management Knowledge Network
Thank you for your attention
42