Om

-

THe COVRT OF APPEA\...S Of 1'~£ S1"ATE. OF WI\S\-hwGl0N D\v\s, ON ON E

S'TATE of' WAs",'~&ToN I RESPOt\\OEN, ~

\I S.

-z..AC.\-\~"''V D.. NElU-yE N) APP"ELLANT

C'· ,; r'" . ( , ', ·W··.···.··· :·'··· '.:······- .· -·'

-~. . ... . ', '

',-,:, "' , ":' .. "

. . )-

p~o SE S'T A'1'-e.M EN, of' Abb,,., oNA\.... Gt<ou l'\OS ~o~ Rt:V'EW

-ZAC\-tA~'" b. ~GV~(N A\>Pt. \...\-A N1'

. . -

-

-

t.,. IssuES

\) \~ tr\ G\ \ cou~-t ~\A\'"\f\'3 c\t)~\fV3 ~r<j""mQ..n-\SJ th~ ?r-ose.c..~jH:)('\t·\o\Q.te.c\ m"J dUe, vr~c.e..ss r\'jh,"\s cCW\tv'\\-\\nq VY"()se..cu*()\\Q. \ 'M\s(.(:)nd'-tV\ b~ . \M?V-M\S~\>\'1 \lo",c..~\n~ ~~(' S-\a~Q..~ 'v'I\-\,,~'Se..,s' C'(~d\b'd\~~ .

2.)lhe., s-\Q-\--e...s. ~\-\(\~S \I\o\(\-\~cl '" 3.5 ~\.\\\{\S cl~r;(\<3 h\s 1-~~-t\ M~n'1 .'P~ \n-\\odu~\n~ o.no1h~x cr\\V\~ to -\~~ JU'"''1- .

~a~Fi:~f~~~~~~~i~st~!i:~;,ii~~~:rSS )~ror \N\-\(\Q.SS~o. Yr\~ ~~~ out 0, ~~t. .... toU.t-\'f"ooM

\n ~o.f\dcufts. \1\S-\~d. of {e~\r\(\9 tlVl .'nqU\s\-\\on +o.-{\nd CU1 \f. -\t\~ j\A{~"O()'. wo.s -1-<A \f\t Q.d. J -\h~ -rf\a\ c..our\- d\s~"s.s~d -\hQ. J\l.~o(" and c..orr;-\nuQ.d w\-\n '10\ r cle.,r~.

4) M'j a~1QX\se Cou.'f'~~\ 'Wo.s \(\~-t'Q.c-t'''''(. ck\tQ.-\o lA fa.·\\\'\{~ -to mO\}~ ~or Cl '{Y\\s-\-·(\Q \ Or ~n •

\~9.U\s\t\on -to s~~ \( -the.. jU{~ yoo\ W"'s -\-cun-\ed.

6)-rh~~Ul,-\ \-os"\vuc-t\ons fo..'\e.d -\() Y''e.Cl".\\re lJ.,(\Gw\\1l\\i~ o.s -\() V4~\Cn ac..-r Co\'\s~lr'u-\~~ --fu~ S\.l.bS1 arri\u \

.SiQ;p towaxd COMm\ss.l()(\ o~ (l~1Q.~"'~.d 'f~pb~x~ \n -\h~ {\rs-\ c\.~fe~1 ,n '-AY\\Ch \S 0.. \L\o\ut\on

-+0 M~ Co ",st,-\ ut io no \ r \q Yt\ -10 a~Q, y\()~SS C\Vlcl (X Uhan\ mollS 'V~y~ic.;t. . .

On AUCJu.st 2 \ st }20 \:l. , \ I . -z.A C\-\A~'1 .\). N EtU'lE N}

w~s C()r\\l\c..-\~d \V\ a "h"'o.\ Cc\).~-\ bj a... jur~ ·of Yn,,\ ve,~r.s 4'0(' -\\'\~ c\'\o.r~~ of ~~t~ \"'{'1,. \Y\ -\'n~ ~\(s:t nQ.q r((.~ J Aii E!-mvtw-- Ro 'o'b\:X~ \l\ ~~~ -;-\ ~ s~ d.~rQ.\t J

A~u\-t \n -\"'~ S~cY\d dtqrQ..Q.. 1\\\ 2> cr\fV\Q.s W~XQ G\(('oM~(AV'l\edt P'j . 3 ~\ t~rtY\ ~'(\ho.Y\ttme.,r'\"s. \ Wo. s s~vr\~Y\c~d to ~ \ ~ rnoy'rtns \YV\~{\ soome-n-\. ov\ Ot1ob~r 2.lc>-\h J 1.0 \'2.. \V\\ 'S df?eA' ~() \\ ow Q~.

\. 0" Au~",s-1 2..\1iit I 20\'2 1 dur\n5 1~~ ~ros~(.,utors C\OS\Y\Cj

a.,(~UMQ.n-\S, of ~h~ Cnse J Shq CfJ~YY\\+t~ 1lV\ lAC-\- O~ \' m@.cu-tonll \ VYI \S.~h d Ild P"d \I'\l ~(~\lQ..\' \~ VO IkC'v\ Il\<j . -\or -\-h~. ~'fQd:\b\\\-t\j O~ m~ t~-de.{e."aanis J\~ W~\ch -\y\~ cr~d\ '0\ \\\y (Sf -\V\v. .s\O.-\~s. w\-\nts&~s ~().s ~ S\Cj Y'l \f' "ant -fa c--\0 Y a. 9 ~ i 11 s1 vY\ Q. \-\. \5 C \ Q 0. r -\\'Io.t -\n t \/(OS~C\k\O \' :'5 \'\0--\ ~\'~U\'(\Cj ~\'\ ·\~-fQ.r~n(l -ffOYY'\ -\\\Q, ,Q,V\d~V\CQ 'out \~st~d \5 e,x Vr ~sS.\ Y\') d V~Y5tl na. \ a?' 1\ \ on abou-t CYQct\'o\'\1~ .S-\C\:\~". t\Df-\c')f'" \\'cV4V\. AfT'- 90<1 1 a;:2..\" lob Y f 3c\ \\t.l-S , 5t~~ v. :r<'\t-~on" \50 ~V"\. AW' 81'1

........... ...... S 8~.I2.C~, . ?, ~.~ .•... S C; 3. R~tf~ 'C" (\~ ",0 -\Y\'e '( ~ t.o ro.. i).

'~"~~:~,~:~e~:~l:!i;~~~;::';'~!~~~~~~?:.i "'\1Q. v.hi\1~sSQS ar-Q. C(Qd·,b\~. '\1~'(Q.\S a sv..b~o..n",,\Q\ \\ '¥:..~.\\ naDa .,~O\\ --t"'~ yY\ '.s(o\"\d\AG-\ a~..fec--\ed ~~ j \1\ ('1 s \I~rd·\ct. S-\~'"\e. y .. \)Y\cA\\Y;~\ 1\'00 \Nn. 2d 55<1,5'18,,'1 1'. ~d 4-32..

2. On Au.I\\l.!)t \'S~", 1.0\2. , o.uTiYlq -\YI~ -\~~iW\oV'\~ . of -\V\~ ~a,\~s W\1V\~SS OC{\C€t ~~t\\1~w \1lA~ I -\\'\e s-\ct\-e Was \ n v', 0 \a{ \ 0 n ~.{ Q. '( '" \\ V\~ \'Y\ a d ~ '\1)

3·'S 'n~ax\{\~ of MCr"()nS \n \\M"oe ) \I.,.? 0'6/r~/?-O\2 vo..<j~ \'0-2..\ J w'ne.tQ.. i~t V'(oSQ.C-U1;or WO-S ()'o\\~C\i~d

4() \Y\$-\ ruc-\ 1'n~ otf\ cer of -\Y\£. ,~xo¥V\Q1~(S h~ w~s -\0 \I'.j,",\'\s-to.V'\~ \V\ V\\S -1Q.s-\ \VV\on~ ttlncQ.YY\\Y\<1 -\\1e tas~ ~res£'n1Qd ~t -\-('\0.\ . \y\~ o"f\c€r- \'(\1tod~c~d -\l) -\\\e., :\Ullj lAVlo1h~r '\V\c\d~Y\l "'Y\Y'~'o.tQo. 10 --\h~ cas~. ",\~?. Ob/\s/2-0r2- V(ACO~ \5/- \~S. S-\l:\-\~ \/. '?~-\y\~XI \\8

WOtSn. Ayry- \\)1>

-Th~ \ n-\ rco.\l.c.+' c nof i-h',s \r\{o fMa.1,·O n W ~S "?r~~v\d\c~(\\ o.V\d VV\OSt "\::Q.\~ nad an H~~t.-r GV\ -1~l, l \"\n~s \J~Xd'C1 -\\\0:\ W(\S \i~~()V\d havm \~.ss .

3. On "\I.~lI.s-\ lif'''' I 2012., m~ '(iq~ts -to duQ, yfOc:t~s we.xQ.. v\o\<A--\Qd ; WhQJl +h'tJ\Ao.~Q., tY\toM fo.. ~ seo tA c.l)~-\ \1: ut \t) Y\ ~ \ (k\;v..s~ ()-\-~\bc-rQ.,+\()Y1 o.~r\"g \JO\'( ~~rQ. )\A~~ S~\~-l--\\OY\ a.+ wh\(:~h ~ j\'\r~r w\-\~\'es~~d me aepor{ -Uw. C~ux-\( ()cV\'\ ,yt hoV\dcuf{s J \I' 0 \(,\t\Y\~ YY\':)~~Y\ S-\ \1 t~t'()~G\ \ y \ qh-\ s; S1o.-\-\ ~g a.bS~~ .Q.x,ya. C}ro 'Y\~('j () ~ (\1,)\'\5\:o \'\CQS , ~ a~{~V\dar\1 \Y1 (\ CX"'Y\\~<l\ cuse \S ~YI-\\l\~d 10

(\,,~~~ x-~j .. -1\'\ .Q.l .. {rQQ. -\'v0\1'\0 \\ ~nds 0 r s"o.G~\ QS .

t~i'~~!;~~~~h~~ EV;1t~~~~:~:~!~~'~f ~~~ \ s"sUQ. \"J~S b:oUCJ~~ -i ~ a -t1~xrl \OV\ I \ws~~(\d ,0+

r~~ \A\r \'Y\~ ()..Y\, \ nqu \ $\--\-' u" -Teat' ~c..t \, ,1\\~ j'" r~ v.0c\ w().~ -\lA\Y\~\.~d 't>~ -\Y1~ .\U~or-, -\\tlt j\Ad.~e a\~m\ss~d -\"'~ ~~'(~'{ ~nc) r<\c)\;e~ i\ww~'(~ W\-\y\ -\'V\~ \) () \\' "'~X~ J \A r ~ \V\ ~-\ Y \A c.-h 0 ~ , "·T·? 0 ro I \Lf J 11-

. ?o..~Q. W l\~e \0 - 2"2-

4. ()n AV.0y.~-t \Lt~~ 1.1.b \2-, m~ c\9.fQV\s~. t~uY\s~.\ I E~~~Y\Q. Y\C-U.\\~\ V'lo.-s, \V\e.-\f~(;\\"~ -To a.SS\S1- VY\Q -f~\\'t'\~ -Tt) VY\~V~ -\0'( fA yY\·'$-\r\(A\. or vY\l\'f:\Y\9 ~V\ oby~C\\lWl -\\) 1Y\Q.. o.\~'M\SSo.\ of (A luro\'" -tha~ w\-\V\~SsQa wrQ. \y"\ "" Q.V\a C\\-\~s ~x I··b n Cj' -\-n~ . t\)U f -\- rooM \ \j."\. \J. tJ~/I4-I'2. 1'a.ge (Q Lw'~ \1·ICi . \n w\t\\c)(\ (AY\

o b j ~c., t', c \'\ W (JU\(). \\ \<eJ~ ~~\I~'o~Q.V\ S\J.S-\O. \ \'\ ~d) ~'( (A vY\O\JQ\'r\~\'\t -\'0'( fA rt1\str,a\ WO\A\d \\\(e'~ h~'J~ b~~V\ qf~V\1 ~c\. Str,(.,~\o.Y\.d \J. W~Sh\ng-t{)\/\, 44w ~·S. (QtQB) eeS1 J tot} I S, c.;-. 1..0$2, COD L. td\. 2a Co7tf.

5. \n '<'!'~ s~t>p\Q.'mQf\~o..\ 'pr\~f 1\\ \s <A,(.~~~ -\,,~-\' .

-\V\~ J~\(~ .\t\S-\nkG1,'{)V\S ~~\\~a -\b r~qu\f~ \AY)On'm\1~ ~~ 1C wY\\t\\· 0-(.1-. C~~~1\-\\)~~<.\ -\Y\t 'Su.'o5\o~\C\\ ~-\~f

-\ OW. ox~ -\nt (omm \,SS\ ()\~ ,O~ ~-\·\ltvn~1Q~ ,,"0 bb'Qx':) W\ -\-\-\« -\\Ys-'t 0'~l?\'(~Q. ,n1 w\'\\c\t1 ,So l\ vw\lttfol1 10

. rv\~ \Ur,s1\-hAti()Vl~\ Y\Cj'A-\ -\0. G\\A~ VrocQ.ss Q.V\(k u\ UYHl.y\\yy\OUS \!~'((\\t-t, h'\ ?J'(\~S c\ x~st>Qy\a.~nT I .

-\,,~ S1().-t~ s;uejOjesttM C lei iVl'\S s\'lO\.\\O-'oIL X-~ ~oQ.c.-\~d O\\Q. ·to -\,,~ ",{\C.:\ 1\'\0-\ ··\~t ~~o<;,~(u-\OY yy\().{.\~ en'\ Q,\QG-hoV\ o.s 10 -\he act -t\'\a1" ·{o\W\~a -\'(\t 'oas\s ,

:fo£O,( -\Y'\~ u-\1- ~'(f\?1~(\ '(~'o~~X~ c~ V'\V \ t-\ \ \H1: ~~e.l\ ·~C~" ~I -\hfr\- -\\\~ 00\ at S-\Y\¥-\{)<1 ~\i\\\\\, V\~X\t W\ -\t\'t h~~d .~).-\"'}~~ .. ~\l" ) -\l\~ > .CkC-\ ~()'< ().~o.\l\* (\).X\\j\C1\~V\

~~~i~~~~\,~!~~l~&~~~~~i~~t~~~~'t1~¥. " 5(Q\q I lp63 V· U \,3, \\ \\'\ soW\Q., \\'\st~~tes ' , -\,Vle

l' fa '" \ ~ 1'\ i 0 ~ o.'jD. i 1'\ S-\ o.() \I.. '0\ ~ j £ () fll. rd ~ W'D. ~ YJQ., V \ C III tQ/i. b~ (t)V\\JtC-tlVl.9 -\V\Q. ~~tQ.vdo.V\\ · o-\, VV\\.\\-\~~\~ co~V\-\:s on -\~Q, 'o(A$\S c* a S\Y\9\~ (.1.(.,1-. w""~V\ -1~\S t'S -\nAQ.J

-\\1e.. .)uv-~ s\t\ou\d \r)~ c\~~r\~ -\0\(\ --\\10\' ~adt1 couYlt YQqu,y~S p'(o~ ,0' Q. d,f{Qye.,Vl-t ~t;\-. S-\a.-iQ.. \)' En,s I , \ W VI. A ff' %0, S SVJ p. 'LeA w 32. \\'\ S\(k\~ \J. \'Q..-1'(\CYl ,

.-\\lQ.,4t-~o;r C()uM hQ..\~ --\~01 \'f\ to.S~S \Y\ wh\u, ~~ ~\j \d~"ce ~W\o.\(,<l-\~ -\~o.-\ sQ.v~xct\ ~\s-\ \V\cA (~,X\V)1'Y'o.' 0<:'-\5 ~£j\V~ bQen COt'YI~i+t\?cl, bu-\ .\~e.. ,de.~Q.V\c\o.t)1 \S cil~~9~<\ wr\h ()V\\~ one. Cou~~ of Cr Hl'1\ (\a \ C~Vtduc-1, -\h~ ('6V'S1 i-tuti(}()a\ . YQquw-Qmtent of .iur~ l~YlanlrnH~ ',s assurQ6 'o~ €l-th€r: \)~eq\f,ril19 -\he, ~'f~s~Lui,lfJ(1 .10 ~\Qct -t~e. oc-+ lApoY(, WYlic~ .

. \\ W l\\ YQ.\q JiG\' COVlV IC~lon ; Or 2..) \V)s-\ruc-\\ng -\\1~ JU:~, -1\t\~1 C(\\ . \~ :) lAyors m~S1 a~re~ -\V\a-\--~. ~t SQmQ Dr,rt1 \ l'l~ \ oc4 ~os ~V\~ ro v~d bQ~ OYl c\ (A r()ctso n ap[e. 6Dll.bt. ~V\Q.V\ -\~~ ,?roS~(JA-\'\()\'\ C~OOSQS Y\oi- -\0 elQc-+

0: j\AYj \'f,S\\,\A(;\'CjY1 \lY\\\~1'o~ CO\V~V\ -\0 o.SS\\y~ -\\,~, ,\\A,Y~S V\Y\a\tysi~Y\d\Y\q ~ 1"'~ \A~',:,Vl\~'~~ \Q.R~\~Q.m~t1~

:ttC\\\urQ, \0 ~'\vvJ aY\~ ~,t.1~~ ~{)vtW\1s .. ,$ \\\J\()\(}'~\'JP of, !- d e. ~ Q.V\~GH1-\S s -\ a-\e t~ vtS~ \ -\\k1 \ OY\O. \ '( \{\ h ~5 , ~t) 0.. U Y\O V'\ \Yl'\ QU ) J~'(~ 'J£~' ti'C-\ aV1~ ~\rr\~d S-\lX\QS c6~:si ,-lui \~ Y\O 1 V\9"" ~b (} jV~'1 -\(\0..' . S'l~\~ V' ~\-\Cy'\eYl I \\~ WY\· 1.&. %?..:>,4-uq,75(P p.'Lcl lOS, S1 GI1e v,-I-/ef1oY],113 Wn. A Pf' . (e,13 I (Q co 4- I 5+ p. 3d. 2-33 I s-tct-te, V · ['ci. rna (,'II 0 / 115 Wn .W, Leo I ,"1'+, p.2-d t(j 50 .

-ni-e , issvt-e per·fcut1 il1\5 -1'-' the YneG,nq oJ -/he ASS (;\uH co n V /C.--II (\ n !Jv. d. a+1 en> fled rob'l5@ ~'1 cO,n v, I clIO n

-tOY' , ,dou b/e. .j Q(; pa rdtj pu (' rose 5 hOJ b'€Qn luYlced ed , b~ +he s·ttH~·

D~CONCLt.\-S1 ot)!r

As I hO\ve Qxp/t-tln-ed ,theye ay~ muH' I'p/~ '{1.n-ofS a. Vl ct v i () 'ct + " 0 VI s -I'" cH 0 ye b-e j 0 r1 d h ~ v m.1f1-s.f e rYa r . tmpropet' lj VDuchiYlj fof -f~e crted',b',litj of 0 , ~~l1~-e5S violqtQd M~ Y"\~~1 -\0 C\ -P~&\V o}"d IIt 7p.Cfrt,c,} J1l1,\ -\ (,fA I, -\\I.~ ~ye s{'c U-\o n (I. \ WI \ ~ (0 V\(h~(,-t h ~I~ (l. substaniia J It ke/, hoot! 1-~a+ -I~e WItS conduct af{\>cAed i ~e , LLA rjs ve (d i ct . 1l,,e ·,V!-e-F-r~C1IV.Q.

0SSIS1"'YlC-P o'f' h1j CDunsel r~\)\.(Hec,( 1\11 ().. -fal.,lied l\A v~ poc J f \I '10 \~f'Y\9 Yv\~\ l(\qh1 -\ {) 6-ffear h~ i'yo'/)1 6-r CA f(i\IY C\no\. 'W)pti'fi fcd , ltV1bIO'S('C.t, JLArj CAS wQ,)/ os M~ v;5rd 10 f:>{{e c1IVQ ,tASSLs,iaYlce -fr 0 rY\ Co tA n SQ.I , ~ ~ 5-\ crt e s w . Ii 11-€ s S / \ \'\ ire duct /' 0 n 01 ano-thQY CY",rne -\0, -t~~ ,iur~ VreJucl,ced m~ de{)YI,re -to ih-ejuy'1. ()lV\~ ,vloJaieJ c\ COur? rtAJI~q, l11e ~bu5e 6f a1S~rQ1 J()(1 a{ -1 he j t,1dge for {~l1ins -I () requlYQ., QV' InquIS"t;on of 4ht po-/eYl,f1al -+t1f1nfl~q

o{ -th~ .\\AY-~ . ~~c\ WO-S (A COY\~ '\U-\ i~y\<A\. ~'(ror. fQ\\\un? ,\0 r~1U\re. UnCi\Y\\md'j (As. -\0 w\\\cn O-l~ Co Y\ ~ --\ '\ -\ U-\~c\ -\ 'il e &\1 DS-\ C\ Y\-\; " C\. \ -S: ~ ~~ -\ () W (A '( A-\ \t\ £ Cl.) VV\ VV'. \C;S\ 0 f\ 0-\ O--\~ Q VVl?l ~c\ '( a 'o'o~x ~ \ V\ ~ \Ae -\\ {~\ o\~~(Q.Q... vJCl\ (A. V\O\O:\\()V1o\ \'\'\~ C'ty\S;~\"-\U:\H)tI(\\ \"\<:)\'\"1<; -1D ct\AQ ?(OCQ.~S-. ",,-e \CAW S1<A-\i~S -\"'-o.-\- o.V\ ~{'(of

()~ ~()V\s-\~-\\K\\·oV\o..' pyovar~'\o~s w\,\ V'QVer \?~. ~(.)V\s,(h~red ~OYW\\QSS \AVl\~SS ,-\ w05 ,,",ovW\\erS

'o'eJonc\. (). rQ(A,s-cV\ab\e dou\?-\. foy -\\r\~ (Q(XSOV\'S

S'~-t -tGyih (A'vJove I cr\\t\ey -\\'I£)\"" -\~e ~QW\o.Y\dC\-t HlY) .

4'0 (i~ e V Q C 0\1 /(H'1 of' -f lAe cA r SC\v{ 1-1 Carll! I'ci iOI1, f r(>JP~c-f[uJly VV'lov-e -Ihis COlAyi -/0 hold

WI -e r i .-) r1 D cd' -I ~ 5 € is s u. .p S a Y\ J r {J v t> y S -e a /I COVlVlcfiortf ovrd r.eW/~V/d for a nevJ iV-lttl.

Da~ed fA,'s oc;l~ dt1~ of ND.;em~r J 2013

~Sf~clruI{J SlAb..,.,ftt~4 /

-Pci1ar'1 D· N,4 vt~.en A fl?-e 1/ 01 n-1J "'0. f..p q 5 Lf~ - (J; - J

\0 CA''-( \ D t:. \' C>~ \ \ Eo\:) \ N \' \-\-~ ~ A 'L OF "\ \1: 12 \.A N l\ e'C)

STJ\\t.~ Of' A\V\'E:.B.\CA/V'OST~E1E.. "'f'\2~'?A\J':)1 A f>~C,)VE.'RLY 2>\AMPE..'V AN\) At)DRt'S.SE\) tN\[ELoP'E \:)\REC,'e\:>

,CJ -"\ 11\::' C t> \A \<-," o~ A t""f'€ A. LS D \ \j , ~ '0 N eN E

ON€ \).N\ON S<.l>UA,~ loot) \).~\\l\::.'t<'S.\\'< S\".

SE.Pr\-rLE:. I WA$,l·'\tJf;(TO~ cq610/-4-liO CONTA IrJlrJ6

A co:py OF Pr<.O St STAif;.MENT of .L\ P1)ITICNA L

G\~oUN\.)S. fo~ ~e..\J I e::w ~f" I 0. I O. Jr,J S'TA:r£ v. LAcl-lt\~Y NGk1'i£.1'~L C/lI!1S£ No. (gq543-Co - T I I r\J -r HE. Co U (2, c-F A ppeA LS) D I V'S) 0 rJ 0 N £, ;

, c e (2., I rYLAND Ef2- :PE. NA LI Y 6'- F8t2ILA tel" OP , I-J E" LAvJ~ OF vJASHlrJE710N S-r~-rt -rHA-T 7i-fe FD(2t~

_ Go I NG l.r {~t AND C c~(2E:c.....-r- .

1/ - 30 - J 3