32

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained
Page 2: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 2

Income gaps grow with time

Page 3: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 3

Complex tasks

• Optimization of production

• Making predictions

• Making decisions with significant financial consequences

• Teaching

• Planning and organizing work of large teams

Simple tasks

• Following clear and simple instructions

• Cleaning or polishing surfaces

• Serving food

• Organizing limited amount of information

• Filling out forms with known information

• Copy-pasting

What is complex ?

Page 4: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4

Complex job holders experience a sustained growth of income

Page 5: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 5

Non-complex job holders experience no income growth

Page 6: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 6

The more complex the job, the faster, longer and higher the income

Page 7: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 7

Bottom quintile 2nd quintile 3rd quintile 4th quintile Top quintile

Levels of jobs complexity

The same patterns are also true for USA

Page 8: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 8

The returns to complexity keep on growing

40

% 6

0%

8

0%

6

,5%

7

% 7

,5%

Gains in the rate of return from moving from the least to the most complex job over time

Page 9: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 9

LLLight tested 1129 persons in 40 organization on their skill to solve complex problems

Page 10: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 10

The Complex Problem Solving Skills increase in the same way as complexity in the job increases

Page 11: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 11

Complex Problem Solving skills by company

Page 12: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 12

Complex Problem Solving skills by industry

Page 13: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 13

Complex Problem Solving skills by occupations

Page 14: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 14

Complexity by 220 regions in Europe

Page 15: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 15

With our economic model based on complexity we predict GDP per capita per region very well

Page 16: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 16

Page 17: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 17

• Returns to skills around the world

• Sources and returns to ICT skills

• Learning by problem solving

• The learning effects of skill mismatch

• Human capital effects in leadership

• How companies can overcome education investment barriers

• ….

Further economic analyses LLLight conducted

Page 18: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 18

So what to do? – for instance adult-oriented education

Page 19: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 19

“Solution and Innovation skills”

Mooc was equivalent to a brain

shift. It doesn’t just give

knowledge; it strives to give skills

to find and use the knowledge,

you may not even know you need!

Page 20: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 20

Source: Global Entrepreneurship Monitor, Bosma et al. 2013

Prevalence of different types of entrepreneurship (% 18-64 population iInnovation-driven economies)

Page 21: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 21

Adapted from Stevens and Burley (1997/2003)

Page 22: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Focus and research approach

• Employee-driven

– Agri-, food- & fibre industry

– 12 companies

– 234 employees

– > 50 groups

• Latent, independent entrepreneurs

– 257 Students from 2 universities

• Specific Human Capital (Opportunity Competence)

22

Page 23: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Innovative work behaviour and performance

23

Number of ideas adopted by management

Engagem

ent in

inn

ovatio

n

Page 24: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Opportunity competence and innovative work behaviour

24

Identification

Evaluation

Page 25: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Specific role of job tasks and context

Positive influence of:

• Job complexity – how often employees face complex problems in their daily work that take at least 30

minutes to find a good solution

• Job control – the instructions the employees receive regarding the process according to which daily

tasks should be performed

• Individual learning stock – perceived stock of knowledge on the individual level

• Feedforward learning – whether individual learning moves to group learning

25

Page 26: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Research Question

What lifelong learning strategies are in place in enterprises and how can they be used towards value creation?

26

Page 27: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 27

ENTERPRISE VALUE

CREATION

Learning Systems

& Incentives

Skills Development

Work Design &

Organisation of Work

Page 28: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Research Breadth • semi-structured interviews and confirmatory questionnaire:

28

• 47 interviews

• 182 questionnaires

• 31 EU enterprises

• 163 EU competitors

• 9 EU countries

• 13 EU competitor countries

• 53 industries

Page 29: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Main Finding 1

Soft skills development and transfer to the workplace requires attention

– most highly valued, lacking investment, demand gap

29

Page 30: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Main Finding 2

Workplace climate & contexts need more support

– sense of belonging, ownership, decision-making

– conflicts, burn-outs stress, job insecurity

30

Page 31: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Participating Universities

31

Page 32: © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September ...€¦ · © LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015 4 Complex job holders experience a sustained

© LLLightinEurope, Final Presentation, Brussels September 22, 2015

Thank you for your attention

and

please visit www.lllightineurope.com

32