24
Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary  Bartholomew                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            1 Memorandum To: Mr. Dennis G. Goderre, ASLA, AICP CUD, LEEDGA  From: Adam Feldman, PE  Date: 31617  Subject: Bartholomew Avenue Project  Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary  On Wednesday, March 8, 2017, CDM Smith Inc, (CDM Smith), City of Hartford (COH) and the Metropolitan District (MDC) presented the “Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape: Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure and Streetscape Project” at the monthly Parkville NRZ Meeting in Hartford. The meeting was intended to engage the community in the initial conceptual planning stage of the project by presenting potential elements of design that could be incorporated into the final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew Avenue. To foster community ownership of Bartholomew Avenue and the streetscape design. The meeting format is detailed in the attached agenda in Attachment A. Meeting Summary The meeting was opened for regular business reporting by the NRZ committee. Dennis Goderre, COH, followed with a short project presentation (Attachment B) that set the table for the community engagement portion of the meeting. The remainder of the meeting, led by CDM Smith, COH, and MDC staff, revolved around involving the community that included the following: Attendees were asked to express their preference for various alternative design elements provided on five presentation boards by placing stickers on the image that they thought was most appropriate for this project. Each board represented a general category of street design including: streetscape, traffic calming, bicycle facilities, green infrastructure, and placemaking (Attachment C). The NRZ attendees then broke into three separate discussion groups where they were asked to discuss their sticker preference and the streetscape project in general, then report out to all NRZ meeting attendees. The following summarizes the talking points, concerns, and recommendations of each of the three discussion breakout groups.

) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1 

Memorandum 

To:  Mr. Dennis G. Goderre, ASLA, AICP CUD, LEED‐GA  From:  Adam Feldman, PE  Date:  3‐16‐17  Subject:  Bartholomew Avenue Project – Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary  

OnWednesday,March8,2017,CDMSmithInc,(CDMSmith),CityofHartford(COH)andtheMetropolitanDistrict(MDC)presentedthe“BartholomewAvenueStreetscape:ParkvilleTODStormwaterInfrastructureandStreetscapeProject”atthemonthlyParkvilleNRZMeetinginHartford.Themeetingwasintendedtoengagethecommunityintheinitialconceptualplanningstageoftheprojectbypresentingpotentialelementsofdesignthatcouldbeincorporatedintothefinaldesign.Theformatofthemeetingfocusedontwokeyoutcomes:

ToencouragecommunityfeedbacktoguidethefinaldesignofBartholomewAvenue.

TofostercommunityownershipofBartholomewAvenueandthestreetscapedesign.

ThemeetingformatisdetailedintheattachedagendainAttachmentA.

Meeting Summary 

ThemeetingwasopenedforregularbusinessreportingbytheNRZcommittee.DennisGoderre,COH,followedwithashortprojectpresentation(AttachmentB)thatsetthetableforthecommunityengagementportionofthemeeting.Theremainderofthemeeting,ledbyCDMSmith,COH,andMDCstaff,revolvedaroundinvolvingthecommunitythatincludedthefollowing:

Attendeeswereaskedtoexpresstheirpreferenceforvariousalternativedesignelementsprovidedonfivepresentationboardsbyplacingstickersontheimagethattheythoughtwasmostappropriateforthisproject.Eachboardrepresentedageneralcategoryofstreetdesignincluding:streetscape,trafficcalming,bicyclefacilities,greeninfrastructure,andplacemaking(AttachmentC).

TheNRZattendeesthenbrokeintothreeseparatediscussiongroupswheretheywereaskedtodiscusstheirstickerpreferenceandthestreetscapeprojectingeneral,thenreportouttoallNRZmeetingattendees.Thefollowingsummarizesthetalkingpoints,concerns,andrecommendationsofeachofthethreediscussionbreakoutgroups.

Page 2: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page2

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       2 

Discussion Group 1 

Suggestedverticalflexpostsforvisibility. Bumpoutswithbikeparkingandplanters Concernsoftravelandsignaldelaysattherailroadandbuswaycrossings. Safetyissues–thestreetisverydarkandneedslighting. Treesandgreenelementsareneededbutmaintenanceisanissue.The“green”mustbelow

maintenance. Shrubs,bio‐swalesandraingardens(maybeincurbbumpoutareas)werediscussed. Stampedconcretewithcreativedesigns. Trashcans Parkingisnotsufficientduringareaevents. Speeding–trafficcalmingisneeded.

Discussion Group 2 

Concernsaboutlightingandsecurity–shouldbebothadultandchildfriendly. On‐streetparkingisimportant,butastheareadevelops,bikelanesmaybeaddedasa

substituteforon‐streetparkingifthedynamicsoftheneighborhoodchanges(maybeadditionaloff‐streetparkingisprovidedtoallowforbikelanesiftheneedpresentsitselfwithadditionalresidentialdevelopment).

FloodingofcurblineandsidewalksontheeastcornerofBartholomewAvenueandParkStreet.

Concernsofspeedingcars/impatientdrivers. Concernsofimpactsduringconstruction(suchasdelaysandschoolbusstops)

Discussion Group 3 

PedestriancrossingsfromonesideofBartholomewAvenuetotheother.CurrentlythereareonlycrosswalksatHamiltonStreetandParkStreet.Amid‐blockcrossingwouldbebeneficial.

Preferencewasformoreparkingratherthandedicatedbikelanes. Expressedinterestinstreettreesandbenches. Wantednewlightsontheeastsidetoreplacetheexistinglightsandlightsonthewestside

ofBartholomewAvenueifbudgetisavailable. PedestrianaccessfromBartholomewAvenuetoPopeParkthroughprivateproperty. Movableplantersandbikecoralswithinexistingon‐streetparkingareaswerelookedatas

morefavorablethanpermanentcurbbumpouts. AnundergroundutilitytunnelwasdiscussedcrossingBartholomewAvenuefrom#30on

theeastsidetothewestside.

Page 3: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page3

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       3 

Basedontheinformationgatheredduringthediscussiongroups,theimportanceofon‐streetparkingandoverallsafety/pedestrianaccesswithintheneighborhoodstoodout.Safetyconcernscouldbeaddressedthroughenhancementsinlighting,pedestriancrossings,andspeedcontrolofvehiclestravellingalongBartholomewAvenue.

Preference Boards 

AsexplainedaboveandshowninAttachmentC,fivedesignelementpreferenceboardsweredisplayedforthecommunitytoexpresstheirthoughtsonimportance.Thepreferences,basedonstickercount,wereanalyzedleadingtotheresultsbelow.

Intotal,therewere260stickersplacedonthe5preferenceboards.

Streetscape–62stickersplaced

Sidewalk–21

18Stickers(86%) 3Stickers(14%)

Fencing–18

12Stickers(66.6%) 2–50/50(5.6%) 5Stickers(27.8%)

Page 4: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page4

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       4 

LEDWallDownlighting–23

3Stickers(13%) 20Stickers(87%)

TrafficCalming–58stickersplaced

TrafficCalming–21

8Stickers(38%) 13Stickers(62%)

HighVisibilityCrosswalk–17

4Stickers(24%) 13Stickers(76%)

Page 5: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page5

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       5 

BumpOuts–20

3Stickers(15%) 2–50/50(10%) 15Stickers(75%)

BicycleFacilities–53stickersplaced

BikeLanes–17

3Stickers(18%) 14Stickers(82%)

SharedStreet–16

1Stickers(6%) 15Stickers(94%)

Page 6: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page6

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       6 

BicycleParking–20

5Stickers(25%) 15Stickers(75%)

GreenInfrastructure–44stickersplaced

PavementReduction–23

21Stickers(91%) 2Stickers(9%)

StreetTrees–21

15Stickers(71%) 6Stickers(29%)

Page 7: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page7

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       7 

Placemaking–43stickersplaced

StreetFurniture–13

3Stickers(23%) 10Stickers(77%)

ActivatedAlley–15

2Stickers(13%) 13Stickers(87%)

PublicArt–15

8Stickers(53.33%) 2–50/50(13.33%) 5Stickers(33.33%)

TheCDMSmithdesignteamintendstousethissummaryasaguideasweprogressintothefinaldesignoftheBartholomewAvenueStreetscapeProject.Followupcommunitymeetingswillbeheldthroughoutthedesigntoupdatethecommunityandtogainadditionalfeedbackthatwillshapetheoutcomeoftheproject.

Page 8: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Mr.DennisG.Goderre3‐16‐17Page8

Parkville NRZ Meeting Summary – Bartholomew       8 

AttachmentA–MeetingAgendaAttachmentB–PresentationAttachmentC–PresentationBoardsAttachmentD–SigninSheet

cc: JoeLaliberte,PE,BCEE(CDMSmith)DavidSousa,ASLA,AICP(CDMSmith)NickAddamo(CDMSmith)MikeCurley,PE(MDC)RichNorris,PE(MDC)

Page 9: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Attachment A  

Page 10: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

 

AGENDA 

Bartholomew Avenue Project, Hartford Date:3‐8‐17Time:6:00PM–8:00PMLocationDetails:ParkvilleSeniorCenter,11NewParkAvenue,HartfordProjectName:BartholomewAvenueStreetscape: ParkvilleTODStormwaterInfrastructureandStreetscapeProject

ProjectStaff:DennisGoderre,AdamFeldman,JoeLaliberte,DaveSousa,NickAddamo,MikeCurley,RichNorris

Attendees:SigninSheetwillbeprovided

MeetingObjective:StreetscapeConceptDesignElementsandCommunityInvolvement

Meeting Format: 1. 6:00PM–6:15PM:NRZPresident,Mr.DaveMorintoopenmeetingwithregular

business.

2. 6:15PM–6:30PM:ProjectandMeetingFormatInformation

a. Presentationofoverallproject

b. Overviewofthismeetingandpurpose.

3. 6:30PM–7:15PM:Breakintogroupsforroundtablediscussions

a. Streetscapedesignelementvotingboardswithstickers(6:30PM–6:45PM)

i. Streetscape

ii. Placemaking

iii. TrafficCalming

iv. BicycleFacilities

v. GreenInfrastructure

b. Roundtablediscussiongroups(6:45PM–7:15PM)

4. 7:15PM–7:45PM:Reportout–eachgrouptopresenttheirdiscussionhighlightpoints.

5. 7:45PM–8:00PM:Meetingwrapup,NextSteps,andQuestions.

Page 11: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Attachment B

Page 12: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Public Workshop #1

Bartholomew Avenue StreetscapeParkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

March 8, 2017

Funded byOPM Responsible Growth & Transit Oriented Development Grant Program

&The Metropolitan District Commission

Page 13: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Workshop Format

• Meet the team

• Introduce project scope & schedule

• Please participate• Help guide the vision

• Roundtable discussion

• Report out

• Wrap-up

Page 14: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Bartholomew Avenue: Project Area

Hamilton Street

ParkvilleSeniorCenter

Streetscape &StormwaterImprovements

Lighting Enhancement

Sidewalk replacement

Page 15: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Opportunities

Community Spirit Identity Transit Investment

Architecture Housing Business Entrepreneurship

Page 16: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Challenges

Brownfields Aging Infrastructure Lack of Street Cohesion

Disconnected Safety Unwelcoming

Page 17: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Streetscape Improvements

• Total Budget - $3.6 million (construction & design)• $2 Million TOD Grant• $1.6 Million MDC• $25,000 City

• Tentative Schedule• Concept Design: Dec. 2016 - March 2017• Final Design: Spring through Fall 2017• Bid: Fall/Winter 2017• Construction: Spring 2018 - Fall 2018*

* May vary based upon various factors including economic climate & weather

Page 18: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Bartholomew Avenue Streetscape:Parkville TOD Stormwater Infrastructure & Streetscape Project

Public Communication

• Project Website:http://www.hartford.gov/bartholomewstreetscape

• Future public forums (dates to be announced)• Contact Information

Dennis Goderre @COHEcoDev860-757-9074 [email protected] COHEcoDev

Page 19: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew

Attachment C

Page 20: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew
Page 21: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew
Page 22: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew
Page 23: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew
Page 24: ) FINAL DRAFT - hartford.gov€¦ · final design. The format of the meeting focused on two key outcomes: To encourage community feedback to guide the final design of Bartholomew