Upload
ospedalebambinogesu
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ABSTRACTS
XXXII
Italian Spine Society National Congress
Baia Samuele – Punta Sampieri, Ragusa
21–23 May, 2009
ABSTRACTS
123
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
DOI 10.1007/s00586-009-0962-4
ORAL PRESENTATIONS
DEFORMITY – Part 1
1
SPINAL DISORDERS IN PAEDIATRICS
(CLINICAL FINDINGS AND TREATMENT)
G. Stella
Genova, Italy
In 1968, there were two published books on scoliosis, one by Prof.
PierGiorgio Marchetti and one by Prof. Ugo del Torto. Both
reported the experience in new non-surgical and surgical treatments
of vertebral deformities and in particular of scoliosis. The efficacy
of surgical treatment of scoliosis according to Risser and the first
results of arthrodesis with Harrington distraction rod were con-
firmed. These books followed the monograph published by
Marchetti-Faldini in 1967 and the reports on scoliosis by V. Pie-
trogrande, L. Perugia, A. Maiotti, M. Pizzetti, P.G. Marchetti, A.
Faldini, A. Ponte and on kyphosis by L. Ranieri (LIII Congress of
the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Chairman M.
Paltrinieri). After about 10 years, the Italian Study Group on Sco-
liosis (G.I.S.) was created and then became the Italian Society of
Vertebral Surgery-G.I.S. In a period of great confusion about the
therapeutic approaches to be adopted in this deformity considered
‘‘the cancer of orthopaedic surgery’’, rational indications in the
treatment of scoliosis were finally given. Other authors with a
special interest in vertebral deformities had already paved the way:
among the Americans, W. Blount, J. Cobb, P.R. Harrington, J.H.
Moe, J. Risser; among the Europeans, Y. Cotrel, J.I.P. James, R.
Roaf, P. Stagnara and many others highlighted the overlooked role
of vertebral deformities in orthopaedics. Honestly, all the Authors
considered their experience only as a starting point while waiting for
further improvements in the knowledge and treatment of these
severe deformities. In the space of 40 years, the great advances in
the fields of biomechanics, imaging of pathologic anatomy of
deformities and spinal diseases, and especially of surgical therapy
were not accompanied by parallel advances in understanding the
etiology of scoliosis, in particular of idiopathic scoliosis. Even in
congenital scoliosis, whose pathogenesis and morphogenesis have
already been well interpreted by Putti and Junghanns, most etiologic
agents of embryiopathies and fetopathies remain unknown. To quote
Haglund (1902), the etiology of idiopathic scoliosis and of spinal
congenital deformities is still ‘‘a large ink stain’’. For these reasons,
our treatments are still today often symptomatic, not causal. How-
ever, over the last few years, patients had better clinical results and
less discomfort during treatment. Many books and treatises, mainly
in the English language, were published on this topic, especially by
important American specialists, focusing also on exclusively
paediatric vertebral deformities. The ‘‘tone’’ of the book I am going
to present is a bit different. Without claiming to be exhaustive and
without forgetting the recent past, the author presents not only the
recent knowledge and surgical solutions that are useful to solve the
problems of our patients, but also to obtain an improved picture of
diseases causing vertebral deformities. Actually, these are the tip of
the inceberg consisting of diseases or syndromes causing spinal
deformity and possibly complicating its treatment. The book is
subdivided into 20 chapters, each illustrating underlying disease, in
some cases the possibility of prenatal diagnosis, the evolution of
spinal deformity, the possible non-surgical solutions (including, in
some cases, medical therapy) or surgical solutions, which makes the
book a prevalently practical tool. In my opinion, this book could be
useful for doctors who decide to focus their interest on the study and
treatment of diseases and vertebral deformities in children. In other
words, it is addressed not only to the beginner or to the orthopaedist
with little experience in paediatric diseases, but also to all those
doctors interested in the vertebral column in paediatric age. Since
this monograph is not an atlas of surgical techniques, only the
operative procedures most frequently used in children are syntheti-
cally reported. Several surgical techniques of historical importance
now superseded in the clinical practice are also reported since, in
my opinion, they can help the reader understand the evolution over
time of osteosynthesis in the treatment of vertebral deformities.
References include the major national and international papers on
different topics published up to the date of publication of the book.
2
THE CLASSIFICATION OF IDIOPATHIC
SCOLIOSIS: CRITICAL EVALUATION
M. Petruzzi, B. Cedron, C. Lamartina
I. R.C.C. S. IstitutoOrtopedicoGaleazzi –Chirurgia Vertebrale II,Milan, Italy
Ideally, the classifications of the disease serve for framing a clinical
entity, to allow to the surgeon to point out a specific treatment, and to
allow comparisons of different Methods of treatment. In 1983, King
et al. classified curves of idiopathic scoliosis on radiographies in antero-
posterior projection, describing therefore 5 types of curves and pointing
out the area of fusion. All the patients in their study were submitted to
vertebral fusion with Harrington rod with the purpose to correct the
deformity on the frontal plan. King et al. did not include in their clas-
sification the curved toracolumbar, lumbar, double or triple primary.
The classification of King has continued to always be used despite
the increasing general acceptance to consider the scoliosis as a three-
dimensional deformity and to use for the surgical treatment a seg-
mental fixation. Besides in base to a study performed to 2 different
groups of surgeons, in the 1998 Lenke et al. have shown a low degree
of reliability, validity and reproducibility of the King classification.
A classification of the idiopathic scoliosis should respond to the
followings requisite:
1. be comprehensive and include all curve types
2. emphasize consideration of sagittal alignment
3. help to define treatment that could be standardized
4. be based on objective criteria for each curve type
5. have good inter-intraobserver reliability
6. be easily understood and of practical value in the clinical setting
7. reflect the current concept of a 3-dimensional analysis of scoliotic
deformities
8. consider the skeletal age
Lenke et al. have published in 2001 a classification of the idio-
pathic scoliosis of the teen-ager, that tries to answer to these requisite
and that could be useful in the clinical practice.
The main advantage of King classification is the simplicity; the
principal disadvantage is that it has been made and concepted for the
Harrington instrumentation, so it’s connected to a monodimensional
correction. Lenke classification goes over this limit because it con-
siders the deformity also in the sagittal plane. The main disadvantage
is the complexity and the fact that it doesn’t consider the rotation.
This study shows the limits of both classifications on the base of some
examples.
728 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
3
POST-SURGICAL EVOLUTION OF THE
SAGITTAL ALIGNMENT IN ADOLESCENT
IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS
A. Luca, G. De Giorgi, S. De Giorgi
Dip. di Metodologia Clinica e Tecnologie Medico Chirurgiche;U. O. Ortopedia e Traumatologia I Universita degli Studi di Bari,Italy. Chief: Prof. G. De Giorgi
Background: According the concept of the open linear chain pro-
posed by Berthonnaud the sagittal alignment of the spine is strictly
related to the shape and orientation of each anatomic segment of the
spinopelvic complex in order to maintain a normal posture with the
minimum of energy expenditure.
This relationship can be find out even in adolescent idiopathic
scoliosis and maintains its effectiveness in patients who undergo
surgery for the same pathology: in this case the modifications
in the alignment involve the segments not included in the fusion
area.
Aim of the Study: To evaluate the impact of the surgery on the global
sagittal alignment of the spine and pelvis.
Methods: Six sagittal parameters were evaluated on lateral radio-
graphs (preoperative, postoperative and follow up) of 65 patients with
adolescent idiopathic scoliosis surgically treated: C7 plumb line,
thoracic kyphosis, lumbar lordosis, sacral slope, pelvic tilt, pelvic
incidence. Two more parameters were evaluated on postoperative
radiographs: lumbar lordosis within the fusion (LLWF) and lumbar
lordosis below the fusion (LLBF).
The patients were classified according the caudal end of the fusion
in five different groups: 1 with caudal end on T12 (8 pts), 2 on L1 (6
pts), 3 on L2 (3 pts), 4 on L3 (27 pts), 5 on L4 (21).
For each patient, authors also evaluated social and functional
parameters in order to estimate quality of life after the surgery.
Results: No modifications about C7-plumbline alignment were seen
in preoperative, postoperative or FU radiographs.
No statistically SPSS significant changes in TK values were found
among the groups comparing the preoperative radiographs
(28�\TK\37,6�) with postoperative (30,1\TK\34) and F.U.
(34,2\TK\35).
Even LL does not show great differences comparing preoperative
data (50,8�\LL\57,2�) with postoperative (52,2�\LL\56�) and F.U.
(54�\LL\56�) ones. Considering the LLWF we found a slight decrease
after surgery. Looking at the F.U. in the group 5 the LLWF tends to
return to the preoperative value. Moderate changes were found even
considering the LLBF: it shows a progressive increase in all the groups
after surgery and at the F.U. The PI definitely increases after surgery and
at the follow up in each group with the exception of group 5 where no
changes were found.
The SS increases in all groups with the exception of group 3 (data
about group 3 could be affected by the meagre number of patients)
The PT tends to maintain its value unchanged or show a slight
increase not relevant from a statistical point of view.
Discussion: Our data show that surgery in adolescent idiopathic
scoliosis allows to achieve an optimal correction of the deformity in
both plane, coronal and sagittal. About lordosis, our data confirms a
correlation between LLWF and LLBF, as already stated in literature:
the decrease of LLWF is compensate by increase of LLBF.
Even the sacrum takes part in balancing the sagittal alignment
after surgery with a complex movement of anterior translation: this is
demonstrated by the increase of sacral slope.
No changes in PT were found: that suggests no changes in the
orientation of the pelvis relative to the hips.
According what we found a normal sagittal balance after surgery
can be easily reached just modifying the spine orientation without the
involvement of the hips
Conclusions: Our data show that in order to obtain a good results in
the middle-long follow up it is mandatory a detailed preoperative
selection of the fusion area in both plane, coronal and sagittal, and an
accurate tridimensional correction of the deformity during surgery
with implants of third generation.
If a good lumbar lordosis and thoracic kyphosis are achieved with
surgery it will be possible to reduce the overstress on the area below
fusion avoiding relevant changes in the pelvis.
4
ANALYSIS OF SAGITTAL BALANCE AFTER
POSTERIOR SURGERY IN ADOLESCENT
IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS (AIS): HOOKS
VS. SCREWS
M. Balsano*, P. Parisini�, M. Di Silvestre�, G. Bakaloudis�
*U. O. C. Ortopedia e Traumatologia, Centro Regionale diRiferimento per la Chirurgia Vertebrale - Thiene-Schio, Vicenza,Italy; �Spinal Surgery Department - IOR, Bologna, Italy
Since the introduction of Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation in 1984,
the techniques of correction in scoliosis’ surgery have changed from
Harrington principles of distraction of the concave side of the curve to
segmental realignment of the spine by using different Methods
(rotation, translation, cantilever, in situ bending, ecc).
In addition, the use of pedicles screws, at first in lumbar curves,
have enhanced correction and stabilization of scoliosis.
Various studies have showed significant better results and clini-
cal advantages of pedicle screws vs. conventional hook instru-
mentation.
Many Authors have focused their attention in the study of coronal
correction of scoliosis, and many papers have been written about this
theme, but not much about the behaviour of the sagittal curves pre and
post surgery.
The purpose of this study is to investigate the sagittal changes of
the curves of AIS (Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis) underwent sur-
gery correction and to compare segmental pedicle screw vs. hook
instrumentation.
Materials and Methods: We have selected 77 patients with Ado-
lescent Idiopathic Scoliosis (AIS) Lenke 1 and 2, operated in our
institutes with posterior fusion and instrumentation. The average age
was 16, 3 yrs. (11–25). The minimum follow-up has been 2 yrs., the
maximum 15 yrs. in 31 patients we have used only hook instru-
mentation (group A) and in 38 patients we have used only pedicles
screws (Group B).
The average of fused segments has been 7.7 segments in group A,
6.6 in the group B.
We have investigated the behaviour of sagittal curves, studyng the
kyphosis (T5-T12), Lumbar Lordosis (T12-S1), and Thoraco-lumbar
alignment (T10-L2).
Not significative differences between the 2 groups have been
noted related to age, pre operative magnitude of curves, length of
fusion (p\0.05).
Results: The pre-operative T5-T12 angle was similar in the 2 groups:
23,4 in the hook group and 21,4 in the screw group. The immediate
postoperative thoracic kyphosois averaged 25,6 in the hook group and
19,3 in the screw group. After a minimum f.up. of 2 yrs. the thoracic
kyphosis was 24,7 in grouip B and 29,8 in the group A.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 729
123
The lumbar lordosis (T12-S1) was similar in both groups: -56.6 in the
hook group and –51,5 in the screw group. The immediate post. op.
lumbar lordosis demonstrated some slight but significant differences
(-55.1 in the hook goup and – 41,7 in the screw group). At the last f.up
Lumbar Lordosis was –56.1 in group A and – 45.7 in group B.
The thoraco-lumbar junction (T10-L2) has showed the same trend:
Group A 10.8 pre-op, 11.3 post.op. and 12.1 at f.up.; group B 9.7 pre-
op, 8.9 post.op and 9,3 at the last follow-up.
Discussion: In the screw group (Group B) thoracic kyphosis has
decreased after surgery and a slight decrease has been noted also in
lumbar lordosis.
On the contrary the hook group (Group A) have showed a slight
but significant increase in both the angles, especially in the thoracic
kyphosis.
These results can be probably explained with the different mate-
rials utilized (SS and titanium). The use of titanium rod (5.5 mm.
diameter) in the pedicle screw instrumentation achieve a great and
strong correction in the coronal plane but, in reason of its axial
flexibility, produces a straight spine in both the planes.
The use of hook instrumentation in SS with rods of 6.35 mm.
diameter achieve less correction in the coronal plane but a significant
better sagittal balance. This can be explained with the less memory’s
shape of the SS vs. titanium.
In addition the anterior disc height decrease because posterior hook
instrumentation allows anterior settling during the fusion process.
However the strong 3-column purchase in the screw group pre-
vented disc settling.
These differences, even if not clinically relevant, must be con-
sidered during the planning of surgery and during the correction
maneuvers of the deformity.
5
COTREL-DUBOUSSET INSTRUMENTATION
IN NEUROMUSCULAR SCOLIOSIS
A. Piazzolla, S. De Giorgi, G. Solarino, G. De Giorgi
Universita degli Studi di Bari – Italy. Dipartimento diMetodologia Clinica e Tecnologie Medico Chirurgiche –U.O. Ortopedia e Traumatologia I, Italy. Chief: Prof. G. De Giorgi
Study Design: Retrospective.
Aim: To describe our experience about the treatment of patients with
NMS (neuromuscular scoliosis) using Cotrel-Dubousset
instrumentation.
Summary of Background Data: Neuromuscular scoliosis are diffi-
cult deformities to treat. A careful assessment and an understanding of
the primary disease and its prognosis are essential for planning
treatment which is aimed at maximising function. These patients may
have pelvic obliquity, dislocation of the hip, limited balance or ability
to sit, back pain, and, in some cases, a serious decrease in pulmonary
function. Spinal deformity is difficult to control with a brace, and it
may progress even after skeletal maturity has been reached. Surgery is
the main stay of treatment for selected patients. The goals of surgery
are to correct the deformity producing a balanced spine with a level
pelvis and a solid spinal fusion to prevent or delay secondary respi-
ratory complications. The instrumented spinal fusion (ISF) with
second-generation instrumentation (eg, Luque–Galveston and unit rod
constructs), are still considered the standard surgical technique for
neuromuscular scoliosis (NMS) even if the Cotrel-Dubousset (CD)
surgical technique, used since the beginning of the mid 1980 s has
represented the highest level achieved in correction of scoliosis by a
posterior approach. Today, 30 years after the introduction of CD,
reports are lacking on the results of third-generation instrumentation
for the treatment of NMS.
Methods: Patients with neuromuscular disease and spinal deformity
treated between 1984 and 2008 consecutively by the senior author
(G.D.G.) with Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation and minimum
6 months follow-up were reviewed, evaluating correction of coronal
deformity, sagittal balance and pelvic obliquity, and rate of
complications.
Materials: 24 patients (Friedreich’s ataxia: 1, Cerebral Palsy: 14,
Muscular dystrophy: 2, Polio: 2, Syringomyelia: 3, Spinal Atrophy:2)
were included. Mean age was 18,1 years at surgery (range 11y7 m -
max 31y). Mean follow-up was 118 months (range 8-259). The most
frequent patterns of scoliosis were thoracic (10 cases) and thoraco-
lumbar (9 cases). In 8 cases we had a hypokyphosis, in 6 a normal
kyphosis and in 9 a hyperkyphosis. In 8 cases we had a normal lordosis,
in 11 a hypolordosis and in 4 a hyperlordosis. In 1 case we have a global
T4-L4 kyphosis. In 8 cases there were also a thoracolumbar kyphosys
(mean value 24�. min 20-max 35). The mean fusion area included 13
vertebrae (range 6-19); in 17 cases the upper end vertebra was over T4
and in 11 cases the lower end vertebra was over L4 or L5. In 7 cases the
lower end vertebra was S1 to correct the pelvic obliquity. In 5 cases the
severity of the deformity (mean Cobb’s angle 84,2) imposed a preop-
erative Halo Traction treatment. There were 5 anteroposterior and 19
posterior-only procedures. In 10 cases, with low bone quality, the
arthrodesis was performed using iliac grafting technique while in the
other (14 cases) using autologous bone graft obtained in situ from
vertebral archs and spinous processes (in all 7 cases with fusion
extended untill S1, it was augmented with calcium phosphate).
Results: The mean correction of coronal deformity and pelvic
obliquity averaged respectively 57,2% (min 31,8%; max 84,8%) and
58,9% (mean value preoperative: 18,43�; mean value postoperative:
7,57�; mean value at last follow up: 7,57�). The sagittal balance was
always restored, reducing hypo or hyper kyphosis and hypo or hyper
lordosis. Also in presence of a global kyphosis, we observed a very
good restoration (preoperatory: 65�; postoperatory: 18� kyphosis and
30� lordosis, unmodified at last f.u.). The thoracolumbar kyphosis,
when present (33,3% of our group) was always corrected to physio-
logical values (mean 2�. min 0� - max 5�).The mean intraoperative
blood lost were 2100 cc (min. 1400 max. 5350).
Major complications affected 8,3% of patients, and included 1 post-
operative death and 1 deep infection. Minor complications affected
none of patients.
Conclusions: CD technique provides lasting correction of spinal
deformity in patients with neuromuscular scoliosis, with a lower
complications rate compared to reports on second-generation instru-
mented spinal fusion.
Keywords: Neuromuscular scoliosis, Cotrel-Dubousset, spinal
fusion.
6
SURGICAL TREATMENT OF NEUROLOGICAL
SCOLIOSIS BY MEANS OF HYBRID CONSTRUCT:
LUMBAR TRANSPEDICULAR SCREWS PLUS
THORACIC UNIVERSAL CLAMPS
G. La Rosa, G. Giglio
Department of Paediatric Surgery-Orthopaedic Unit;Research Institute and Paediatric Hospital Bambino GesuPalidoro (Rome, Italy)
The segmental spine instrumentation (SSI) in the nineties had a good
validation by most spinal surgeons but the technique have been
730 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
progressively abandoned for the intrinsic implant difficulty and neu-
rological complication risk in favour of the Cotrel-Dobousset spinal
system. The C-D instrumentation, based on the segmentation of
curves, improves the angular correction but over all actuates the
sagittal profile. Sublaminar acrylic loops (Universal Clamp) have the
same stress resistance in comparison with steel or titanium alloy su-
blaminar wires. The simplicity of implant and tensioning of the strips
is associated with the possibility of re-tensioning and progressive
correction. The increase of the contact area gives an improvement of
the corrective forces with a reduction of the laminar fracture risk. Our
aim has been to verify the validity of this spinal fixation implant in the
surgical treatment of neurologic scolioses.
Methods: We treated surgically 24 patients by using universal clamps
associated with Socore TM spinal assembly, transpedicular lumbar
screws and apical thoracic hooks. The ethiology was cerebral palsy in
twenty-two cases and Friedreich ataxia in two cases. The median
angular pre-operative value was 92.4�. The median age was of
14 years for all the patients included in the study (range: 10–17 yrs).
The average follow-up consisted of 18.3 months and we implanted an
average of 6 clamps for each procedure (range: 3–8).
Results: The average percentage of correction has been of 72.2%+/-
8%. The mean loss of correction at follow-up of two years was 4�+/-
2� The learning curve period is shorter if the surgeon has experienced
the SSI procedure. The operating time is reduced in comparison with
surgical procedures in which we used screws at each level and fur-
thermore there is a better capacity of managing the kyphotic
component in case of thoracic lordosis.
Conclusions: The technique using universal clamps appears safe and
effective and represents a valid contribution in association with
lumbar screws, reduced number of dorsal screws or pedicle-transverse
hooks at the upper end of the curve. The assembly stability is satis-
fying in the post-operative period. It is mandatory to analyse the
results in the long term follow-up in terms of correction loss,
pseudoarthroses, mechanical failure of the strips.
Significance: The use of a hybrid assembly (lumbar screws, dorsal
acrylic clamps, apical dorsal hooks) showed a mechanical effi-
ciency as in case of the use of transpedicular screws at all level.
The advantages connected with a shorter operating time and
diminished risk of vascular or neurologic complications permit to
judge the technique as valid between the actual options of thera-
peutic planning.
DEFORMITY – Part 2
7
POSTERIOR EMISPONDILECTOMY
IN CONGENITAL SCOLIOSIS
M. Crostelli, O. Mazza, M. Mariani
Children Jesus Paediatric Hospital Palidoro-Roma, Italy
The authors present 7 cases of congenital scoliosis with lumbar
emivertebra. Patients have been treated by posterior emispondi-
lectomy and peduncolar screws stabilization. In the past, techniques
of choice used in emivertebra scoliosis have been in situ fusion,
posterior emiphisiodesis or anterior and posterior emiphisiodesis,
alternative procedures are arthrodesis and emivertebra resection by
combined antero-posterior approach. In our study 7 congenital
scoliosis cases have been treated only by posterior approach
with emivertebra resection and 2 levels stabilization, 3 levels
stabilitazion in the case of deformity above or under emispondilus.
All operated patients had worsening curves or pain from deformity.
Mean follow up was 18 m years. Mean scoliosis curve value has
been 41 cobb grades, reduced to 15 Cobb grades after surgery.
Mean kyphosis value has been 24 grades, reduced to 10 grades
after surgery. There was no major complication (infection, instru-
mentation mobilization or failure, neurological or vascular
impairment, peduncolar fracture). In authors opinion emispondi-
lectomy with posterior approach instrumentation is an effective
procedure with significative advantages over congenital deformity
control: excellent frontal and sagittal correction, best stability, short
segment arthrodesis, low neurological impairment risk, no necessity
of additional anterior surgical approach. Surgery should be con-
sidered as soon as possible in order to avoid severe deformity and
the use of long segment arthrodesis. In our experience youngest
patient was 2ys and 6 months old.
8
THORACIC PEDICLE SUBTRACTION
OSTEOTOMY IN THE TREATMENT OF SEVERE
PAEDIATRIC DEFORMITIES
G. Bakaloudis, M. Di Silvestre, A. Cioni, K. Martikos, P. Parisini
Spine Surgery Department - Istituti Ortopedici Rizzoli – Bologna,Italy
Purpose: To determine the safety and efficacy of posterior thoracic
pedicle subtraction osteotomy (PSO) in the treatment of severe
paediatric deformities.
Material and Methods: A retrospective review was performed on
12 consecutive paediatric patients (6 F, 6 M) treated by means of a
posterior thoracic PSO between 2002 and 2006 in a single Insti-
tution. Average age at surgery was 12,6 years (range, 9–16),
whereas the deformity was due to a severe adolescent idiopathic
scoliosis in 7 cases (average preoperative main thoracic 113�; 90–
135); an infantile idiopathic scolosis in 2 cases (preoperative main
thoracic of 95� and 105�, respectively); a post-laminectomy kypho-
scoliosis of 95� (for a intramedullar ependimoma); an angular
kypho-scoliosis due to a spondylo-epiphisary dysplasia (already
operated on 4 times); and a sharp congenital kypho-scoliosis
(already operated on by means of a anterior-posterior in-situ
fusion). In all patients a pedicle screws instrumentation was used,
under continuous intraoperative neuromonitoring (SSEP, NMEP,
EMG).
Results: At an average follow-up of 2.4 years (range, 2–6) the main
thoracic curve showed a mean correction of 61�, or a 62,3 % (range,
55%–70%), with an average thoracic kyphosis of 38,5� (range,
30�–45�), for an overall correction of 65% (range, 60%–72%). Mean
estimated intra-operative blood loss accounted 19,3 cc/kg (range,
7.7–27.27). In a single case (a post-laminectomy kypho-scoliosis) a
complete loss of NMEP occured, promtly treated by loosening of the
initial correction, and a final negative wake-up test. No permanent
neurologic damage, or instrumentation related complications, was
observed.
Conclusions: According to our experience, posterior-based
thoracic pedicle subtraction osteotomies represent a valuable tool in
the surgical treatment of severe paediatric spinal deformities, even in
revision cases. A dramatic correction of both the coronal and sagittal
profile may be achieved. Mandatory the use of a pedicle screws-only
instrumentation and a continuous intraoperative neuromonitoring to
obviate catastrophic neurologic complications.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 731
123
9
LOW BACK PAIN IN PATIENTS WITH ADULT
IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS: COMPARISON OF
THREE REHABILITATIVE METHODS OF
TREATMENT
V. Pavone, M. Privitera, F. Cosentino, G. Sessa
Orthopaedic Clinic, University of Catania, Italy;Chief of Department: Prof. G. Sessa
Introduction: The adult form of idiopathic scoliosis is less com-
monly recorded than its counterpart in the juvenile age. Clinically, it
often presents as invalidating painful phenomena. Several rehabili-
tative techniques are used as treatment strategies mainly for reducing
the low back pain but prospective comparative studies are lacking.
Aim of Study: Aim of present study is to evaluate in an homogeneous
cohort of adult patients, characterized by mild scoliosis, three reha-
bilitative approaches [e.g., Mezieres, Calliet and Proprioceptive
Vertebral Stimulation (PVS)], so as to determine the efficacy of the
different techniques.
Materials and Methods: The three different rehabilitative approa-
ches were applied blindly in a total number of 30 patients, divided
into three groups (each as homogeneously possible). Each group was
formed by ten subjects equally distributed re gender, age, and type of
scoliosis. Every single patient was evaluated both clinically and
radiographically. Only patients with the following features were
enrolled in the study and distributed in three groups: (1) age between
40/55 years; (2) Cobb degrees between 10 and 25; (3) moderate
physical activity; (4) frequent low back pain; (5) absence of neuro-
logical complications and absence of relevant osseous alterations. The
pain was evaluated through the VAS (Visual Analogical Scale) and
the disability (coupled with the Oswestry) Methods. Each study group
was treated over eight weeks. At the end of treatment all patients were
evaluated clinically by means of a questionnaire, which had been
filled at the beginning and at the end of the study.
Results: The patients - at the beginning of the study - before starting
treatment, presented a questionnaire with similar values both in the
VAS scale and in the Oswestry disability Index, as demonstrated by
Student test applied to the different groups. At the end of treatments
all groups of patients showed modest improvements concerning dis-
ability and pain statistically relevant in the group where the Mezieres
method was applied.
Discussion and Conclusions: The Mezieres method with its global
approach with the entire body structure seems to determine a re-
balance of the muscular tension and of the kinetic chain, this seems to
being reflected positively on the reduction of painful phenomena.
However, it would be important to test the trial in a more consistent
group of patients, also by extending the treatment’s period, in order to
precisely determine the period of real pain relief. None of the dif-
ferent Methods seem completely remittent. The rehabilitative therapy
should be transformed in a ‘‘life style’’ that the patients should adopt
continuously, to better cope with their pathology.
10
DEGENERATIVE LUMBAR SCOLIOSIS IN
ELDERLY PATIENTS: DYNAMIC STABILIZATION
WITHOUT FUSION VS POSTERIOR
INSTRUMENTED FUSION
F. Lolli, M. Di Silvestre, T. Greggi, F. Vommaro, P. Parisini
Spine Surgery Department - Istituti Ortopedici Rizzoli – Bologna,Italy
Purpose: To compare the results of dynamic stabilization without
fusion and posterior instrumented fusion in the treatment of degen-
erative lumbar scoliosis.
Study Design: A retrospective study.
Patient Sample: 54 elderly patients (46 F and 8 M; age 64.1 years,
range 61 to 78) were included. Exclusion criteria: scoliosis angle
[35�, sagittal imbalance, age \60 years, previous spinal fusion or
instrumentation.
Methods: Patients were divided into 2 groups according to surgical
treatment made. 23 patients (DS Group) were treated with dynamic
stabilization (Dynesys), 25 patients (PIF Group) with posterior
instrumented fusion (always titanium instrumentation). The two
groups were well matched according to age (65.3 vs 62.6 years),
gender (female: 75.9% vs 72%), scoliosis Cobb angle (16.9� vs
19.2�), instrumentation extension (3.7 vs 4.3 levels).
Results: At a mean FU of 54 months (range 39 to 67), the
questionnaires showed no statistically significant differences (P [0.05) between 2 groups. ODI score improved in DS Group from a
preop. score of 51.8% to 28% at last follow-up, in PIF Group from
52.7% to 30.2%. VAS score improved in DS Group from 6.7 to
3.4, in PIF Group from 6.5 to 3.8. There were differences
according to mean surgical time (190 vs 245 min), blood loss (935
vs 1425 cc) and hospital stay (4.9 vs 7.5 days). Major complica-
tions occurred in 2 cases (6.9%) in SD Group (a sciatica due to a
misplaced screw on L5, treated with screw replacement, and a
junctional disc degeneration, treated with extension of fixation), in
4 cases (16%) in PIF Group (2 flat-back, treated with an extension
of fixation to S1 in one case and with a correction through a PSO
in the other case; a junctional kyphosis, treated with extension of
fixation; a paraparesis due to a hematoma, treated by surgical
drainage, but without neurological recovery).
Conclusions: These results showed that dynamic stabilization is a
safe procedure in elderly patients with degenerative lumbar scoliosis.
This technique resulted less invasive with minor surgical time, blood
loss and complications rate (6.9% vs 16%) than instrumented pos-
terior fusion.
732 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
DEFORMITY – Part 3
11
SURGICAL TREATMENT OF DEGENERATIVE
SCOLIOSIS IN THE ADULTS (DE NOVO SCOLIOSIS)
M. Palmisani, S. Boriani
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology - OspedaleMaggiore, Bologna, Italy.Dir: Dr. S. Boriani
From January 1997 to December 2005 we treated surgically 49 sco-
liosis and degenerative scoliosis and cyphoscoliosi at the Orthopedics
and traumatology Department of the Ospedale Maggiore from
Bologna.
They were 13 male and 36 female with an average age of 66 years
(55–80).
All cases had low back pain resistant to medical and physical
treatment, that was associated with a sciatica in 15 cases, with a
claudicatio neurogena in 20cases, and in 20 was neurolgical deficit.
The scoliosis had a angular average value of 27� (10�–45�).
In all cases was taken, at all levels, an arthrodesis with pedicular
screws associated with laminectomy in the cases with sciatica or
lumbar spine stenosis and in the cases with serious intability of
postero lateral interbody fusion. In 44 cases arthrodesi is performed
up to sacrum.
After the surgery, before resignation, all the patients has been
studied with rx associating tac to highlight the correct posizioning of
the screws and the decompression of neural structure.
40 patients were monitored at a minium distance of 3 years and
maxium of 10 years from the surgery with rx, Tac o Rmm.
Clinic results were evalutated according Withe e Coll. (Spine
1987) and we record 10 (25%) excellent cases, 12 (30%) good, 14
(35%) fair and 4 (10%) poor.
Among other complications, we report 3 cases of dural lesion in 1
case that required a revision with a complete healing, 2 cases of a bad
positioned screws that required the review of the system.
12
SELECTIVE THORACIC FUSION IN LENKE
TYPE B,C LUMBAR MODIFIER ADOLESCENT
IDIOPATHIC CURVES
M. Di Silvestre, G. Bakaloudis, T. Greggi, S. Giacomini,P. Parisini
Spine Surgery Department - Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli –Bologna, Italy
Purpose: To determine the efficacy of posterior selective tho-
racic fusion in the treatment of Lenke type B, C lumbar modifier
curves.
Material and Methods: A retrospective review was performed on
a consecutive series of 114 patients operated on, between 2000 and
2006 in a single Institution, by means of a selective pedicle screw
only thoracic fusion, with 45 (40 F, 5 M) responding to the fol-
lowing selection criteria: a main thoracic curve (Lenke type 1, 2,
3,and 4), with lumbar modifier type B (in 24 cases) and type C (in
21 cases). Average age at surgery was 15,4 years (range, 11–18),
with average Risser sign of 3,2 (range, 1–5). The lowest instru-
mented vertebra (LIV) was in 1 case T11, in 8 T12, in 18 L1, and
in 18 L2, corresponding to the stable vertebra (SV)-2 in one case,
to the SV-1 in 10 cases, in 31 cases was at the SV level, whereas
in the remaining 3 cases the LIV was the SV+1.
Results: At a mean follow-up of 4.5 years (range, 2–8), the main
thoracic curve presented an average correction of 60.2% (from
68.5� to 26.2�), while the secondary lumbar curve obtained a
spontaneous correction of 48% (from 40.8� to 22.4�), main thoracic
apical vertebra translation medially corrected from 4.8 cm to
1,9 cm (59 %), whereas the lumbar apical vertebra translation
remained unchanged (from 1.05 cm to 1,14 cm). Finally the lowest
instrumented vertebra tilt was corrected on average for a 67.63%
(from 18.19� to 5.8�). In nine cases we observed at latest follow-up
a mild decompensation of the secondary lumbar curve that didn’t
necessitated so far a revision surgery. In two cases, presenting a
lumbar modifier type B, an overcorrection of the main thoracic was
observed, whereas in the remaining 7 cases, being a Lenke 3C
curve, the LIV was always shorter than the SV.
Conclusions: According to our experience, selective thoracic fusion
in Lenke type B, C lumbar modifier curves, by means of pedicle
screw only instrumentations, present satisfactory results at a mid
term follow up. Lumbar spontaneous correction occurs mainly due
to upper lumbar vertebra’s tilt amelioration, and not as an apical
vertebra’s translation correction. A mild decompensation of the
lumbar secondary curve, observed in 20% of the present series, has
been found to be well tolerated and didn’t necessitated so far a
revision surgery.
13
THE CLAMP: AN EVOLUTION OF SUBLAMINAR
WIRE IN SURGICAL TREATMENT OF SPINAL
DEFORMITIES
P. P. Mura1, G. Costanzo2, D. Fabris Monterumici3, G. La Rosa2
Cagliari1, Roma2, Padova3, Italy
Scoliosis and other deformities are complex spinal problems that can
create many health problems for patients including pain, reduced
mobility and impaired organ function.
Surgical treatment of spinal deformities is considered when
medical treatment cannot control the deformity The absence of sur-
gical treatment might lead to an exacerbatio of the deformity, pain,
respiratory problems or, exceptionally, even paralysis. The surgical
procedures in question have two objectives. Correction or stabiliza-
tion of the deformity and preservation of the correction by means of
rods, hooks, screws or metal wires. To ensure the preservation of this
correction over time, bone grafts may be performed. Numerous
techniques have been developed to obtain fusion and correction:
system of hooks, steel wiring around a frame, and more recently
screws. The Universal Clamp is an innovative device that simplifies
the correction of scoliosis and other spinal disorders. The Universal
Clamp consists of a polyester band with titanium clamp and a set
screw. It may be used in place of, or in addition to screws, wires,
cables and hooks that are typical device in modern spine surgery and
permits surgical maneuvers including reduction, translation, distrac-
tion and compression to help anatomical alignment and balance. The
authors conducted a retrospective study on 12 patients who had
undergone operation operations for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis
with this device. The Clamp is an evolutional step in the scoliosis
treatment, with simple, safe and strong bone fixation.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 733
123
14
THORACOLUMBAR KYPHOSIS IN
MUCOPOLYSACCHARIDOSIS TYPE 1:
AN EMERGING DISEASE
M. Carbone, F. Vittoria
S. C. O. Ortopedia e Traumatologia Pediatrica e Centro per ilTrattamento della Scoliosi; I. R. C. C. S.Burlo Garofolo – Trieste, Italy
Introduction: The Mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS I) is a serious
metabolic genetic disease; according to its seriousness, three variants
are distinguished.
In the worst form (Hurler syndrome or MPS I-H), the main
symptoms are a psychomotor delay and skeletal deformities, as a
result of which these patients show the morphologic features of
gargoylism, with grotesque facial features, a stature much shorter
than the average, severe joint stiffness and an evolutionary angular
thoracolumbar kyphosis, with the apex on one or more malformed
vertebrae and a progressive neurological involvement.
Until recently, these patients had a short life expectancy - less than
ten years of age - and a definitive etiologic cure does not exist as yet;
however, recent indications for bone marrow transplantation, or other
enzyme replacement therapies, show promising results on the mani-
festations of the disease, thus extending the survival of these patients.
Within a multidisciplinary team, the spinal surgeon has therefore to
deal with a ‘‘new’’ disease for which possible indications to the
treatment are to be assessed: joint stiffness responds well to medical
treatment, while the worsening of the kyphosis is unchanged.
Materials and Methods: From 2005 to the 2008, 3 patients with
MPS I-H have come to our observation. All of them had undergone
bone marrow transplantation.
• C.G., 4 years old, with kyphosis apex at the level of malformed
vertebrae L1 and L2 and an initial alteration of sensory evoked
potentials of the lower limbs, has undergone surgery in two stages:
at first a posterior instrumented arthrodesis T12-L4, later on an
anterior arthrodesis with insertion of a carbon cage.
• G.E., 5 years old, suffering from kyphosis with apex in L2, is
being treated with an extension corset and she undergoes periodic
orthopaedic and electrophysiological controls.
• N.N., 3 years old, with a similar deformity and a recent history of
bone marrow transplantation, is temporarily undergoing ortho-
paedic treatment.
Results: The one patient who has been surgically treated has an
excellent clinical, radiographic and electrophysiological outcome,
with a follow-up of only 6 months. In the two other patients, the
corset application is a procrastination treatment awaiting a surgical
correction, while the effects of bone marrow transplantation are
assessed under careful orthopaedic, radiological and electrophysio-
logical supervision.
Discussion and Conclusions: Kyphosis occurring in dysmorphic
syndromes and bone dysplasias often appear similar to congenital
forms. Particularly in MPS I-H, kyphosis deformity, owing to the lack
of development of the anterior part of the vertebral body, is similar to
a type I form. The same characteristics occur in the patients affected
by achondroplasia with evolutive toracolumbar kyphosis due to a
posterior hemivertebra.
Relying on this analogy, we have opted for circumferential
arthrodesis, with a satisfactory result on the sagittal spine equilibrium,
even if with short follow-up. The highest premature treatment allows
us to prevent the unavoidable neurological complications and to treat
less rigid and more easily correctable deformities.
15
LUMBO- SACRAL SPONDYLOLISTHESIS
EVOLUTION IN THE SURGICAL TREATMENT
OF IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS
M. Crostelli, O. Mazza, M. Mariani
Children Jesus Paediatric Hospital Palidoro-Roma, Italy
The authors analyze lumbo-sacral spondylolisthesis evolution in
idiopathic scoliosis treated by posterior arthrodesis. There are 15 cases
treated by instrumented posterior arthrodesis, presenting grade 1 or grade
2 lumbo-sacral spondylolisthesis. In literature there is a significative
association between dorso-lumbar scoliosis and lumbo-sacral spondy-
lolysis, with or without vertebral listesis. Grade 1 or grade 2 listesis
without simptoms have no necessity of any tratment and their evolution is
not correlated to associated scoliotic curves severity. Our patients have
13ys and 4 months mean age, with mean Cobb grades value of major
scoliosis curve 50. They have been treated by posterior approach
arthrodesis with titanium instrumentation using peduncolar lumbar
screws and laminar hooks, or thoracic and lumbar screews. Mean main
curve value in Cobb grades after surgery has been 12�.
In all cases instrumentation was not after lithic level but arthrodesis
stopped 2 levels above. Mean follow up has been 5 years. No patient
presented in standard x-ray examination augmentation of vertebral
listesis and no patient had lumbar pain enhancement or neurologic
symptoms after surgery. There is no evidence of significative differences
between the two groups of listesis in the behaviour of olisthesis.
Above arthrodesis showed no sign of mobilization.
Avoiding long arthrodesis taking lower lumbar segment leave the
patient with good lumbar mobility, allowing him to attend daily
activities without pain and limitations. Even in grade 1 or 2 lumbo-
sacral spondylolysis our experience shows that functional overweight
on lower lumbar vertebrae caused by above arthrodesis does not
enhance listesis progression risk. The authors think that lumbar
spondylolysis presence should not modify surgical treatment of sco-
liosis and is not a cause to widen to the sacrum arthrodesis area.
FRACTURES AND VERTEBRO-KYPHOPLASTY
16
SPONTANEOUS LUXATION OF C1- C2 IN A CHILD
WITH TRISOMY 20
M. Broger, M. Campello, P. Rizzo, M. Tripodi, A. Schwarz
Dept. of Neurosurgery. Central Hospital of Bolzano, Italy
Introduction: Trisomy 20 is a genetic anomaly often responsible for
spontaneous abortion. In the surviving infants, psychomotor retarda-
tion and malformations involving multiple organs are easily
recognized soon after birth. Occipito-cervical malformations are
frequent spinal abnormalities for this group of patients.
Case Report: We report the case of an eight year-old girl, who came
to our attention with a history of persistent torticollis. No history of
neck trauma was reported. Upon physical examination she showed
diverging strabismus and a soft palate malformation; radiological
imaging displayed bony fusion at C1-C2 and C4-C5. An occipito-
cervical CAT scan showed complex changes involving C1 (absence
734 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
of the C1 articular facets), the C0-C1 complex (C1 retrolysthe-
sis[4 mm), and a C1-C2 fusion. Her torticollis was treated
conservatively by NSAIDs, muscle relaxants and a rigid cervical
collar, in order to achieve a relative, first-line stability to allow further
diagnostic and therapeutic steps.
Occipito-cervical MR imaging ruled out a spinal cord lesion and
misalignment of the vertebral levels (also due to the slight hyperex-
tension given by the collar), but did display a mild hyperintensity of
the apex of the C2 dens. This last finding is deemed to be the typical
indirect sign for an apex-ligament traumatic lesion, which per se has
no influence on segmental stability, but can be considered a warning
sign for a local derangement of bone-ligament structures.
Amongst the different therapeutic options we chose a posterior
stabilization procedure. A C0-C1-C2 instrumented posterior fusion,
strengthened with postero-lateral bone chips between the occiput, C1
and C2 was performed. The surgical procedure was uneventful.
Postoperative radiological control Xrays confirmed the correct
vertebral alignment without involvement of the spinal canal or
compression of the neurovascular structures. The postoperative neu-
rological condition was unremarkable. Due to ventilatory
disturbances a tracheostomy was put in place and kept in situ for three
weeks. At a six-month follow-up the patient’s neck stiffness was
improving. Control CT imaging showed strengthening of the postero-
lateral arthodesis.
Discussion: Patients affected by chromosomal abnormalities often
present with spinal malformations. This is true for rare genomic
variations, like in our patient’s case (trisomy 20), but also for the
more frequent syndromes (e.g. Down’s), mostly at the occipito-
cervical junction. For all of these patients the spinal ligaments
show a high tendency to give out under normal or slightly higher-
than-normal stress situations. In spite of these general issues, it is
common to reach a first-line diagnosis of ‘‘torticollis’’ because of
the patient’s young age, the absence of a previous history of
trauma and the difficulty to perform a complete examination due to
the patient’s associated psychomotor retardation. A misdiagnosed
and consequently untreated cervical instability bears a high mor-
tality rate (around 20% in trisomy 20).
Conclusion: Young patients with known cervical spine malfor-
mations and/or diagnosed chromosomal changes should be deemed
as ‘‘unstable’’ at the spinal level; in case of a prolonged, even if
minimally, axial cervical pain syndrome, with or without history of
a previous trauma (even if trivial), these subjects should undergo
prompt and complete CT and MR imaging (possibly coupled with
evoked-potential studies in selected cases). During this diagnostic
process all patients should wear a rigid cervical collar, or – when
forced by poor compliance – should be sedated and immobilized
until a spinal instability is ruled out.
17
THE TREATMENT OF FRACTURES
IN CHILDHOOD AND YOUTH
M. Palmisani, F. De Iure, G. B. Scimeca, A Gasbarrini,L. Boriani, S. Boriani
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology - OspedaleMaggiore, Bologna, Italy
From January 1997 to December 2007 came to our observation 2581
suffering from spine traumas. 83 (3,2%) younger than 16 years old. It
was of 38 cervical spine sprain traumas and 53 fractures (1,7%): 20
involving the cervical spine and 33 the thoracic and lumbar spine.
In the same period, we surgically treated 18 (2,2%) patients under
the age of 16 years old. In 10 cases was concerned the cervical spine and
in 8 cases the stretch of the thoracic and lumbar spine.
4 cases were SCIWORA: 1 case at cervical level with a incom-
plete neurological damage with a neurological recovery and 3 cases of
thoracic tract involvement with complete neurological damage
without neurological recovery.
In all the cases was reached a steady consolidation of the fracture
without major complications.
18
SHORT POSTERIOR PEDICLE SCREW FIXATION
WITHOUT FUSION FOR THE TREATMENT
OF THORACOLUMBAR BURST FRACTURES:
CLINICAL RESULTS OF 153 CASES TREATED
CONSECUTIVELY
P. Quaglietta, S. Aiello, G. Corriero
Azienda Ospedaliera di Cosenza - Dipartimento di Emergenza -U.O. di Neurochirurgia, Italy
Introduction: The treatment of burst fractures of the thoraco-lumbar
junction still remains controversial. The short posterior fixation
without fusion is one of the techniques used to treat these fractures.
This technique, extensively described in the literature, reduce and
stabilize the traumatic thoracolumbar fractures and it is easy to apply.
However, it may restore only indirectly the height of the vertebral
body and the reconstitution of the anterior column is quite limited.
The collapse of the system and the loss of kyphosis correction are the
major complications occurring in patients treated with this technique
because of the limit to support the anterior spinal column.
The aim of this retrospective study was to determine the clinical
results after surgical treatment with short posterior fixation without
fusion.
Methods: From September 1999 to December 2007 153 patients with
thoracolumbar unstable fractures (T11-L3) were operated with a short
posterior fixation. Mostly were young (mean age 30 years). The
average follow-up was 24.4 months. Their injuries, were due to
accidental falls from a height in 47.7% of cases, road traffic accident
in 32.7% of patients. In 8 cases (5.2%) following suicide attempts,
and in 13.1% of cases after working accidents. Finally, two cases
(1.3%) were due to other causes. In all patients was performed a X-
Ray and a spine CT scan while in 89 patients were performed MRI.
Twenty-six patients (16.9%) had multiple spinal trauma. Thirty
patients (20.2%) had abdominal and chest trauma and associated
fractures of other skeletal segments. Surgery was performed within 12
hours after injury in 17 cases (11.1%) with complete spinal cord
injury. In 115 patients (75.2%) surgery was performed between 24
and 72 hours. Finally, in 21 cases (13.7%) surgical procedure was
performed after 72 hours. We evaluated: neurological status (Frankel
Grade), spinal deformities, residual pain, and complications.
Results: At follow-up, 150 patients (98%) showed an postoperative
improvement. In agreement with the Frankel classification, all
patient classified as Frankel E remained stable. Three patients
(1.9%) presented an improvement of one degree (Frankel C). The
kyphosis angle was improved from 19.45 � to 11 � immediately
after surgery. In the follow-up there was a loss of 2 degrees with
an angle of 9 � of kyphosis. We had no operative mortality.
Complications occurred in 8 patients. In two cases wound infec-
tion, in 1 case liquoral fistula (treated surgically), in 3 cases screw
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 735
123
breakage where new surgery was no use and one patient required
implant removal because of implant dislocation after new motor
vehicle accident. Finally, in one case there was the early collapse
of the system with the complete loss of lordosis in which it was
necessary an anterior and posterior approach. The VAS at the final
follow-up was 2.2.
Conclusions: According to our experience, even compared with the
literature, patients with unstable burst fracture having [ 25 � of ky-
phosis,[50% loss of height of the vertebra or[40% impairment of
the channel can be treated with a short rigid stabilization without
posterior fusion. This technique can effectively restore and stabilize
the fractured vertebrae, can indirectly decompress the spinal cord,
maintain the stability of the column, reduce the risk of screw breakage
and the loss of height of the vertebral body. However, it is always
necessary to consider an anterior approach in fractures with initial
kyphosis angle greater than 30 degrees.
19
TREATMENT OF THORACOLUMBAR
VERTEBRAL FRACTURES WITH A NEW
PERCUTANEOUS TRANSPEDICULAR
STABILIZATION SYSTEM
G. Guizzardi, R. Morichi, A. Vagaggini, L. Paoli
Neurosurgery, University and City Hospital Careggi, Florence,Italy
Introduction: Within the last 30 years the management of thoracic
and thoracolumbar spinal fractures has evolved from one of conser-
vative management with external orthoses and bed rest to one of
operative intervention. The problem of invasiveness in the surgical
treatment of thoracolumbar vertebral fractures without neurological
deficits is well know to everyone. In the last few years a few authors
have proposed treatment, for type A1 and some A2 fractures,
according to Magerl through percutaneous Methods of vertebroplasty.
More recently we’ve seen appear the first treatments of even more
complex fractures with mininvasive percutaneous transpedicular
stabilization.
Material and Methods: We present the experience of the authors on
12 cases of thoracolumbar fractures without neurological defects,
treated between December 2008 and December 2009 with a new
screw-rod mininvasive percutaneous system (Silverbolt/Vertiflex).
This system is equipped with an extremely sophisticated instrumen-
tation set, but which is easy to use, which by means of the usual
distraction and compression mechanism, allows us to optimally
reduce even complex burst fractures.
Results: The follow up from 4 to 15 months has demonstrated a good
result in all cases both from a clinical point of view and the resto-
ration of the physiological alignment of the area and of the
preservation in time of the immediate result. We should highlight the
minimal haematic loss, the significantly reduces post-operative pain
in the patients and the rapidity of both the discharge from the hospital
and the resumption of work.
Discussions and Conclusions: Extremely positive appears our final
opinion, even if the cases are still limited, on this new path we have
taken and on which only a few already have a fairly good experience.
The brevity of the learning curve, the precision and the accuracy of
the instrumentation have surprised us and comforted us in continuing
and incrementing treatment of these fractures with mininvasive
percutaneous technique.
20
TREATMENT OF SPINAL FRACTURES IN
ANKYLOSING SPONDYLITIS
P. Viglierchio, L. Caruso, M. Girardo, P. Cinnella, S. Aleotti
Department of Spine Surgery – C. T. O. Turin, Italy
Introduction: Spinal fractures in Ankylosing Spondylitis (SA) are
characterized by an important instability, often result in neurolog-
ical deficits that necessitate early and aggressive surgical
management with a posterior or anterior and posterior fixation.
Aim of the study was evaluate the clinical, functional and radiological
outcomes in elderly patients with SA affected by cervical or dorsal
fracture treated with posterior or anterior and posterior stabilization.
Material and Methods: The present study is a retrospective review
and a radiological follow-up of 14 patients affected by SA treated at
our departement between 2000 and 2007, 11 were amielic and 3
mielic.8 male and 6 female were included with a mean age at surgery
of 65 years (47-82 years) Radiographs, magnetic resonance and CT
scan obtained before surgery, after surgery, and at the follow-up
evaluation were assessed for quality of fusion, sagittal balance and
kyphotic angle. Average follow-up time was 4,5 years (range 1–9).
Physical examination, spinal mobility, and nondynamometric trunk
strength measurements were used to assess, and Oswestry Disability
Index, SF-36 and Visual Analogic Score of pain (VAS) were used to
calculate outcome at the follow-up visit at the 1 month, 3 months,
6 months and at one year following treatment.
Results: In 10 patients the fracture level was the lower cervical
segment: (4:C6-C7, 3:C7-T1, 3:C5-C6).6 underwent posterior and
anterior fixation, 4 only long posterior fixation.
3 patients suffered a dorso-lumbar fracture (2:T10-T11, 1:T12-L1)
and were treated with a long posterior fixation
1 patient had 2 fractures non contiguous and concomitant (C2 and
T5) and received a double posterior fixation C1-C2 and T3, T4-T6, T7
All patients received immediate improvement in their pain. The
mean VAS reduction was 6.
All patients maintained stability or experienced improvement in
their neurological deficits after surgical intervention.
At the follow-up of 6 months there was demonstration, by CT, of
bone fusion.
There was no radiologic evidence of failure of fixation. There was
no new development of kyphosis deformity.
There were no complications.
Conclusion: Patients with AS are higly susceptible to extensive neu-
rological injury and deformity after spinal fracture caused by even
minor traumatic forces. These injuries are uniquely complex and
require considerable scrutiny and aggressive surgical management to
optimize spinal stability and functional outcomes. The result of the
present study indicate that a posterior fixation longer than commonly
used, or an anterior and posterior fixation is suited for treating spine
fractures in patients with ankylosing spondylitis.
736 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
21
PROPOSAL OF A NEW RISK SCORING SYSTEM
FOR OSTEOPOROTIC VERTEBRAL FRACTURES:
STUDY ON A POPULATION OF 400 PATIENTS
E. Pola, L. Proietti, L. A. Nasto, L. Scaramuzzo,C. A. Logroscino
Dipartimento di Scienze Ortopediche e Traumatologia – U.O.C.Chirurgia Vertebrale, Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore –Roma, Italy
Introduction: Osteoporosis is a disease characterized by a low bone
mass and the development of nontraumatic fractures, most commonly
in the spine. Approximately 500,000 elderly women in the United
States are newly diagnosed with vertebral fractures every year due to
the inability of the vertebral body to withstand the loads associated
with normal daily activities as skeletal mass and bone strength decline
with aging. Noninvasive measurements of bone mineral density
(BMD [g/cm2]) are central to the diagnosis and management of
osteoporosis. However, BMD alone is not completely satisfactory in
vertebral fracture risk assessment. Some others risk factors have been
identified for osteoporotic fractures but none, taken alone, is really
sufficient to predict for vertebral fractures. The aim of this study was
to identify clinical and laboratoristic factors associated with an
increased risk of vertebral fractures in osteoporotic Caucasian women
and to define a new clinically relevant scale of risk.
Methods: 400 patients (age: 55 – 87 years) consecutively admitted at
our ambulatory for the treatment of vertebral osteoporosis were inclu-
ded in the study. All patients were affected by post-menopausal
osteoporosis according to the WHO classification criteria. Exclusion
criteria were major infectious diseases, tumors, auto-immune diseases
and major diseases of sense organs. We attempted to determine whether
parameters such as age, body mass index, smoking and alcohol habi-
tudes, femoral and lumbar T-scores, femoral and lumbar Z-scores,
femoral and lumbar bone mineral density (BMD), total and bone
alkaline phosphatase and L3 and T7 vertebral volumes were associated
with the risk of vertebral fractures. The vertebral fractures were diag-
nosed by Morphometric CT and MRI for each patient. All bone
densitometric data were measured using an Hologic QDR 4500/A DXA
system. L3 and T7 vertebral volumes were calculated analyzing CT data
from patients without vertebral collapses in L3 and T7 with NIH Image
(Version 1.62, NIH, Bethesda, MD) and 3D Slicer (Version 3.2, NIH).
Results: 146 patients of the entire population presented at least one
vertebral fracture for a total of 411 fractures (201 thoracic and 210
lumbar collapses). When considered alone, age ([65 years -
p=0,0001), lumbar T-score (B -3,5 - p=0,0001), lumbar Z-score (B-
2,5 - p=0,0050), lumbar BMD (B 0,800 - p=0,0017), femoral T-score
(B -3,5 - p=0,0090), femoral Z-score (B -2,5 - p=0,0127), L3 volume
(B -2,0 SD – p=0,0023) and T7 volume (B -2,0 SD – p=0,0075) were
significantly associated with an increased risk of vertebral fractures.
Considering only the patients with two fractures or more, the same
parameters with the exception of the femoral T-score resulted
strongly associated with the risk of new vertebral fractures. Moreover,
there was a significantly increased risk of vertebral fractures when
two or more of these parameters were present together (p = 0.02). On
the base of the obtained data we have then defined a new scale of risk
(from grade I-low risk in patients without risk factors to grade IV-
very high risk in patients with 3 or more risk factors - p=0.0123)
confirmed in a prospective study conducted on 60 osteoporotic
patients followed for 2 years and that met the same inclusion and
exclusion criteria.
Discussion and Conclusions: Our findings indicate that clinical and
laboratoristic variables may have a synergistic effect on the risk of
vertebral fractures. Since the simultaneous analysis of these
parameters might help to stratify patients with different risks, we
propose a new clinical scale to easily identify the osteoporotic
patient with low, moderate, high or very high risk of new vertebral
fractures.
22
KYPHOPLASTY: ADVANCED INDICATIONS
AND RESULTS
P. Parchi, A. Poggetti, G. Calvosa, M. Lisanti
1st Orthopaedic Clinic University of Pisa, Italy. Chief: Prof.Michele Lisanti
Introduction: The use of mini-invasive percutaneous techniques for
the treatment of pain caused by vertebral collapse is increasingly
spreading in Italy. These techniques are designed to reduce pain, to
prevent the progression of vertebral collapse, and to restore quickly
the functional activity.
The was introduced by Mark Reiley in the late 90 s as an evolution
of vertebroplasty. This method, in fact, while still consists in a mini-
invasive augmentation the fractured vertebral body, allows a low
pressure cement injection due to the formation a balloon-created
cavity and the recovery of the height of the fracturated vertebral body.
The main indication of the kyphoplasty is the treatment of verte-
bral fractures from osteoporosis and from secondary osteolytic
lesions, but in recent years, the evolution of the technique resulted in a
widening scope of possible fields of application to include the treat-
ment of unstable thoraco-lumbar fractures are, in association with
spinal stabilization Methods
Also some contraindications to the use of this technique as the
painful vertebral pseudoarthrosis and the vertebral plane have become
advanced indications
Material and Methods: Aim of this study was to evaluate the
‘‘advanced indication’’ of kyphoplasty through the review of cases
treated at the Orthopedic Clinic of the University of Pisa in the period
between January 2004 and December 2008.
In this period were treated 90 patients of which 70% for osteoporotic
vertebral collapse and 30% for alternative indications (vertebra plana,
painful vertebral pseudoarthrosis, thoraco-lumbar fractures, meta-
static tumours and fractures in patients with an organ transplant).
Results: Patients were evaluated both clinically and radiographically.
From the review of our cases we obtained a high rate of positive
results (85-90% of cases) in terms of reduction of pain and in terms of
patient satisfaction without significant complications (leakage of
cement and cardio-pulmonary complications).
Discussion: Kyphoplasty is a mini-invasive treatment technique
that has proved both effective and safe in the treatment of recent
osteoporotic or osteolytic vertebral collapse, which represent its
main indication and in the treatment of certain pathological con-
ditions which were previously considered contraindications as the
vertebra plana, the vertebral pseudoarthrosis, metastatic tumours
and fractures in patients with an organ transplant and also in high-
energy fractures (in combination with Methods for transpeduncolar
stabilization). We consider essential to obtain good results and to
avoid unpleasant complications a careful and meticulous selection
of patients.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 737
123
23
ACUTE THORACOLUMBAR BURST FRACTURES
TREATED BY BALLON-ASSISTED
KYPHOPLASTY PERFORMED
WITH CALCIUM PHOSPHATE
G. Caruso, V. Lorusso, E. Bassi, L. Massari
Ferrara University Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Italy
Introduction: The progressive kyphosis and pain in patients with
acute thoracolumbar burst fractures treated conservatively so as the
recurrent kyphosis after posterior reduction and fixation were asso-
ciated to disc collapse rather than vertebral body compression. It
depends on redistribution of the disc tissue in the changed morphol-
ogy of the space after fractures of the endplate.
The aim of this study is to evaluate the safety and the efficacy of ballon
kyphoplasty with calcium phosphate, alone or associated to short posterior
instrumentation, in the treatment of acute thoracolumbar burst fractures.
Materials and Methods: eleven fractures in ten consecutive patients
with an average age of 48 years who sustained acute thoracolumbar
traumatic burst fractures without neurological deficits were included
in this study. The fractures were A1.2 (3), A3.1 (4) and A3.2 (4),
according to AO classification. In 7 fractures (A1.2 and A3.1) the
kyphopasty was performed alone in order to make the most of effi-
cacy in fracture reduction, anterior and medium column stabilization
and, as much as possible, segmental kyphosis correction. In the A3.2
fractures (4), that are unstable, the kyphoplasty was associated to a
short posterior instrumentation. To avoid the PMMA long run com-
plications in younger patients, we used a calcium phosphate cement.
VAS, SF-36, Roland-Morris questionnaire (RMQ) and Oswestry low
back pain disability questionnaire (ODQ) were used to evaluate pain,
state of health, functional outcomes and spine disability.
Results: To the average follow-up time of 15.5 months (range 8-31) we
did’nt observe statistically significant differences in 7 of 8 SF-36
domains in comparison to general healthy population of same sex and
age. At the same follow-up, the spine disability questionnaire showed a
functional restriction of 18% (ODQ) and 29,6% (RMQ) being 100% the
maximum of disability. No bone cement leakage, no implant failure and
no height correction loss was observed in any case.
Conclusion: Our data confirm the safety and the efficacy of ballon
kyphoplasty with calcium phosphate in the treatment of acute thoraco-
lumbar burst fractures. In this way we can reduce the possible
complications resulted from discal space collapse and obtain an early
functional restoration. When performed alone, this mini invasive surgical
technique offer the advantage of almost immediate return to daily
activities. When associated to a posterior instrumentation, it decreases the
long run complications and allows to reduce the number of stabilized
levels, maintaining, in part, the thoracolumbar junction movement.
24
EXPERIENCE OF VERTEBRAL FRACTURES
TREATED BY KYPHOPLASTY
B. A. Nannavecchia, F. Bigossi, P. F. Eugeni, F. Pineto, R. Sepe,V. Magliani, D. Lucantoni
Teramo - Unita Operativa di Neurochirurgia, Ospedale‘‘G. Mazzini’’, Italy
Authors analyze seventy patients with D/L vertebral fractures of
anterior wall treated by kyphoplasty since October 2005 to november
2008.
A review of an international litterature focalizes on the vertebral
stability concept and biomechanics features related to vertebral
fractures. These arguments are the introduction to definy the choise’s
reason of this technique.
After a short excursus about the etiopathogenesis of vertebral
fractures, authors describe the Methods used to select the fractures
divides in traumatic and onco-etiology.
An epidemiological study related to fracture’s level, fracture’s
tipology, sex and age is performed on this population of patients.
The paper describes the tecnique of the kyphoplasty and the
postoperatory managment.
The discussion is performed relating to the symptoms and to the
imaging of the follow-up.
EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES AND INFECTIONS
25
THE ROLE OF MELATONIN IN ADOLESCENT
IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS
M. Girardo*, E. Dema, N. Bettini, S. Cervellati
*Chirurgia Vertebrale, Ospedale C.T.O., Torino; Centro diChirurgia Vertebrale-Hesperia Hospital, Modena, Italy
The cause of adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS) in humans remains
obscure and probably multifactorial. At present there is no proven method
or test available to identify children or adolescent at risk of developing
AIS or identify which of the affected individuals are at risk of progres-
sion. Reported associations are linked in pathogenesis rather than
etiologic factors. A number of suggestions concerning its aetiology have
been proposed including neuromuscular, connective tissue structure,
vestibular dysfunction, melatonin secretion, platelet microstructure,
mechanical, growth related and developmental, asymmetry in the
brainstem, genetic factor, equilibrium dysfunction and impairment of
proprioception leading to the idea that a disturbance of postural control
but no single factor has been identified so far. Many authors think that a
relation exists between the origin of scoliosis and balance troubles.
Melatonin may play a role in the pathogenesis of scoliosis (neuro-
endocrine hypothesis) but at present, the data available cannot clearly
show the role of melatonin in producing scoliosis in humans. The data
regarding human melatonin levels is mixed at best and the melatonin
deficiency as a causative factor in the aetiology of scoliosis cannot be
supported. The biological relevance of melatonin in AIS is controver-
sial because: a) no significant decrease in circulating melatonin level
has been observed in a majority of studies, b) experimental pinealec-
tomy did not lead systematically to a scoliosis in all pinealectomised
chicken, c) melatonin injections in pinealectomised animals did not
always prevent the formation of scoliosis.
Melatonin the ‘‘light of night’’ is not a simple hormone. It has many
complex functions, which are only recently being defined. In compar-
ison with other signalling molecules the numerous actions that have
been attributed to melatonin are exceptional. Unfortunately there are
differences in the pharmacology of melatonin between the species and
different biological circadian rhythms. Chicken model cannot be simply
extrapolated to humans. No permanent deficiency of secretion of mel-
atonin occurs in patients with AIS. Evidence for a transient deficiency
before and/or during development of scoliosis is scant and requires
confirmation in a large number of subjects. The diurnal variations in
melatonin levels and the circadian rhythm of secretion play an impor-
tant role. There is now evidence that melatonin may have a role in
biologic regulation of circadian rhythms, sleep, mood, and perhaps
738 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
reproduction, tumour growth, cardiovascular system and aging. How-
ever, uncertainties and doubts still surround the role of melatonin. It will
be an important issue of future research to investigate the role of mel-
atonin in human biology, the clinical efficacy and safety of melatonin
under different pathological situations.
26
LATE-DEVELOPING INFECTION FOLLOWING
POSTERIOR INSTRUMENTED SURGERY FOR
ADOLESCENT IDIOPATHIC SCOLIOSIS
M. Di Silvestre, T. Greggi, A. Cioni G. Barbanti-Brodano,M. Spina, P. Parisini
Spine Surgery Department - Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli –Bologna, Italy
Introduction: A retrospective clinical and radiographic review of
patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis who were surgically re-
visioned due to a late-developing post-operative infection.
Methods: From a total of 540 patients who underwent posterior-only
fusion from 1993 through 2005, fifteen (2,77%) were surgically re-
visioned due to a late-developing post-operative infection. The
implant alloy used was a stainless-steel instrumentation in 11 patients
(4,56% of 241/540), and in 4 patients in titanium (1,33% of 299/540).
Comparing the two groups, there was a statistically significant dif-
ference on the incidence of late developing infection (p\0.0001).
There were 6 males and 9 females, average age at initial surgery
15,8 years (range,12-18), with infection occurred at a mean
70 months (15-195) after the index procedure.
Results: The clinical signs of infection included mild back pain,
spontaneous sinus drainage, and a fluctuance mass. Complete removal
of instrumentation was performed in 9 patients. In six patients an attempt
to save/replace the previous instrumentation was performed. A complete
removal of the instrumentation had to be performed 11,6 months later
(3-24) for the persistence or recurrence of infection. All healed
uneventfully at a minimum 2 years follow up (25-70). Intra-operative
cultures were obtained in all 15 patients, being positive in 13 (S. Epi-
dermidis in 5, S.Aureus in 3, Propionibacterium Acnes in 1, Serratia
Marcescens in 1, Propionibacterium Acnes+ S.Epidermidis in 1,
S.Aureus+S.Epidermidis in 1, coagulase-negative Staphylococci in 1).
Conclusions: According to our experience, late-developing postoper-
ative infection in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis surgery should be
treated only by means of a complete removal of the implant, continuous
drain and short-term adequate antibiotic therapy. To our findings, this
entity is sustained by a polimicrobic flora, always necessitating an
antibiogram-based post-operative antibiotic treatment. Our results
suggest that titanium alloy spinal instrumentations are less subject to
late post-operative infection, when compared to stainless-steel one.
27
THORACOSCOPIC APPROACH FOR THE
TREATMENT OF ADULT SPONDYLODISCITIS
A. Sinigaglia, R. Bassani
Ortopedia e Traumatologia - IRCCS Policlinico S. Matteo, Pavia,Italy
Pyogenic spinal infections encompass a large number of clinical
entities: spondylodiscitis, septic discitis, vertebral osteomyelitis and
epidural abscess. Pyogenic vertebral discitis and osteomyelitis are
uncommon entities with an incidence of 1 in 100,000 but this number
is rising up because of longer life expectancy for patients with
chronic debilitating diseases (immunocompromise, steroids thera-
pies, tumors, HIV, recent spinal surgery). The diagnosis of pyogenic
spinal infection is frequently delayed as symptoms are often non
specific. Spine is involved up to 7% of the cases of pyogenic infec-
tions: most of all the vertebral body (95%), then the posterior
elements (5%).
In this paper is presented a case report of a Thoracic discitis (T10-
T11) managed operatively by a minimal invasive thoracoscopic sur-
gery reducing morbility and morbidity compared to standard
thoracotomy.
A 42 years old male, complaining of chronic pain in thoracic spine
since six years was managed operatively.
Five years before this surgery diagnosis of discitis T10-T11 was
done. He was just treated by oral antibiotics (Cotrimoxazole and
Rifampicin) with partial relief of the symptoms. In the last year he
complained of worsening. MRI, CT scan and blood samples were
showing active inflammatory disease in T10-T11 disc.
In January 2008 he was operated by minimal invasive left tho-
racoscopic approach. Selective intubation and left lung complete
deflation were done. During the procedure the surgeon performed a
complete T10-T11 discectomy as well as removed the end plates
obtaining bloody healty bone. Blood and and disc samples were
collected for colture. To achieve a good fusion hydroxiapatite and
BMP was implanted in the empty space. The procedure was com-
pleted with a posterior approach for screws fixation and postero
lateral bone grafting. Patient was observed in subintensive care for 24
hours and discharged in 6 day post op. Intra Venous antibiotics were
delivered just in the following 15 days post op (Teicoplanin) followed
by oral cotrimoxazole and rifampicine for one month. No germs were
isolated from intraop colture.
Xrays and CT scan showed six months later complete fusion as
well as symptoms disappeared.
This clinical result is showing the feasibility and efficacy of this
minimal invasive technique for the treatment of discitis in thoracic
spine reducing morbidity and morbidity compared to standard
thoracotomy.
28
MORPHOLOGY AND TGF-BETA1
CONCENTRATION’S ANALYSIS OF FLAVUM
LIGAMENTUM OF PATIENT WITH LUMBAR
CANAL STENOSIS AND/OR LUMBAR DISC
HERNIATION
R. Rispoli, R. Mastrostefano
Neurosurgery, Avezzano (AQ), Italy
The study’s objective is to analyse the flavum ligamentum of patients
with lumbar canal stenosis and / or lumbar disc herniation to evaluate
the morphology and the concentration of the transforming growth
factor-beta 1 (TGF-beta 1).
The study is characterised by three phases:
• Measurement of the thickness of the flavum ligamentum of
patients with lumbar stenosis and/or herniated lumbar disc
through the sagittal, T1 weighted images of the lumbo-sacral
MRI;
• Removal of flavum ligamentum in patients undergoing interven-
tion for lumbar stenosis and / or lumbar disc herniation;
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 739
123
• Optical microscopy study of the morphology of degenerated
ligamentum and immunohistochemical analysis to assess the
concentration of TGF-beta 1 in the same.
The analysis of the morphology of the ligamentum (meant as the
increase of the fibers number or distension and relaxation of the same
as a result of degenerative processes) and the presence or absence of a
high concentration of TGF-beta1 (then more fibroblasts involved in
the degenerative process) can be important in the choice of surgical
treatment of stenosis and / or lumbar disc hernia, particularly:
• The removal or preservation of the ligament itself;
• The use of interspinous or interlaminar devices.
29
USE OF PLATELET GEL IN POSTEROLATERAL
FUSION: PRELIMINARY RESULTS IN 14
PATIENTS
A. Landi, R. Tarantino, N. Marotta, L. Giudice, S. Martini1,E. Rastelli1, G. Ferrazza2, N. De Luca2, F. Tomei2, R. Delfini
Department of Neurological Science, division of Neurosurgery,University of Rome Sapienza; 1Department of NeurologicalScience, division of Neuroradiology, University of RomeSapienza; 2Department of Hematology, University of RomeSapienza, Italy
Introduction: actually hematological research is based on already
known role of platelets in the mechanisms of tissue repair. The
combination of ultraconcentration of platelets with fibrin glue
(fibrinogen, XIII factor, fibronectin) in presence of activated trombin,
determines the formation of platelet gel, applied alone or in combi-
nation with scaffold for the repair of ‘‘hard’’ wounds. This
haematological component is assuming an important role in regen-
erative medicine. Authors took into account the possibility of using a
preparation of ultraconcentrate of autologous platelets to be applied in
addition to autologous or synthetic bone during the posterolateral
fusion in order to induce an higher degree of bone fusion.
Patients and Methods: have been assessed 14 patients (mean age
60.2 aa, 8 M and 5 F) underwent laminectomy, spinal fixation and
posterolateral fusion, from November 2007 to November 2008 there
were performed five 2-level stabilization, five 3-level, one 4-level and
one 5-level.
In our cases the platelet gel has been obtained taking 16 ml of peripheral
venous blood from patients, using for each surgical procedure two
tubes, each one with a capacity of 8 ml. Both of them are the REGEN-
THT� system (Thrombocyte, Harvesting Tube) that allows us to take in
40’-45’ from the sampling, 8 ml of autologous platelet gel. The process
requires the addiction of Ca-gluconate and ethanol at 95%, obtaining a
preparation of plasma rich in platelets and activated trombin, at a
concentration of platelets with an average of 5 times higher than blood.
The PRP is joined in the operating field with suitably fragmented
autologous and synthetic bone. To allow a comparative assessment
between the degree of fusion with platelet preparation and in his
absence, for each patient was arbitrarily decided to use the platelet gel in
a single surgical field, the right one. Patients underwent CT scans at 3
and 6 months after surgery, and RX scans at 6 months after surgery. CT
axial scans, allow a proper assessment of the degree of spinal fusion and
bone growth, by measuring the increase in bone density through the e
ROI (HU) evaluation in the newly-formed bone and comparing the
density between the bony callus formed only by autologous and syn-
thetic bone and the one with addition of platelet gel.
Results: in all cases we found a good bone fusion. In addition CT
evaluation at 3 and 6 months and RX evaluation at 6 months after surgery
showed an increase of bone density in the fusion stimulated by platelet gel
compared to the fusion stimulated only by autologous-heterologous
bone. These preliminary results confirm the objective of our study.
Discussion: the newly formed bone in areas where performed pos-
terolateral fusion, is well evident three months after surgery and
continued gradually in the subsequent 18-24 months. The autologous
platelet gel used by us seems to promote bone repair and regeneration
by increasing bone density at the same level of posteolateral fusion.
Moreover this preparation has a low production cost and is easy to
apply and use.
30
FOCUS ON RESEARCH ABOUT CELLS
MECHANISMS INVOLVED IN BONE
REGENERATION FOR ARTHRODESIS
C. Ruosi1, G. F. Tajana2, D. Maglione1, L. Pastore3
1Dipartimento di Scienze Chirurgiche, Ortopediche,Traumatologiche ed Emergenze, Universita degli Studi di Napoli,‘‘Federico II’’, Napoli, Italy; 2Cattedra di Anatomia e IstologiaUniversita degli Studi di Salerno; 3Dipartimento di Biochimica eBiotecnologie Avanzate, Universita degli Studi di Napoli,‘‘Federico II’’, Napoli, Italy
The aim of this study was the evaluation of molecular and micro-
molecular mechanisms on which the healing of bony callus of
arthrodesis is based.
In particular the aim was to investigate the way of recruitment,
proliferation and migration of undifferentiated cell populations
towards a differentiation in osteoblasts and ostocytes but in particular
towards a special organization precise enough to fill in bony gaps only
in defined points and not in others and only in proper quantity.
The study started from the identification of which stem cells were
involved in these processes and why. Subsequently, the cell mecha-
nisms determining the development of the phenomenon ‘‘bony
callus’’ were noticed and studied.
These fundamental mechanisms for the development of the bony
callus include four defined stadiums, either for the treatment of
fractures or of arthrodesis from bony micro-fragments:
The adhesion, the migration with its strategies, the cell movement
and the gene regulation.
Adhesion: It’s the fundamental condition for the bony healing and
only after this phase the processes of cell restyling, proliferation and
differentiation take place. In this phase the cells can receive precise
information about what to do, divided in positional and differentiative
information. This information derives from signal molecules that can
affect the formation of proteins that can activate the extracellular
matrix through genes called ‘‘architects’’.
Migration: It takes place thanks to chemo-attracted proteins like
BMP-2 and BMP-4 that recognize cell surface proteins; the interac-
tion between these two elements leads to the creation of ‘‘molecular
rails’’ to define the spatial orientation and the cell is also stimulated to
produce ‘‘sub-signals’’ that can mean both prosecution of the process
and stop of the process for the following cells.
These mechanisms have a direct influence of migration strategies.
Actually, according to their position and role, the proliferating cells
are divided in Analyzers, Marginators and Erasing.
Cellular Movement: This mechanism, that can be defined cell mi-
crobiomechanic, takes place thanks to a series of ultra-structures on
740 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
the cellular surface like the tractor pseudopods and the anchorage
plaque, together defined ‘‘lamellopods’’.
These structures allow a characteristic ‘‘jumping’’ or better rolling
movement of the cell in the environment.
The anchorage ties to the lamellopod and then the cellular cyto-
skeleton will stretch giving propulsion to the (long) part of the cell,
called uropod.
Gene Regulation: The differentiation of mesenchimal stem cells
(MSCs) in osteoblasts was widely studied and investigated in the last
years.
Recently a number of genes involved in this process has been
identified. In details the genes necessary to determine the differenti-
ation from stem cells to osteoblasts can be divided in extrinsic and
intrinsic.
The first group (extrinsic) includes the genes that codify for bony
morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) that lead to differentiation in osteo-
blasts with high efficiency; these proteins are very important both in
physiologic processes like the development of skeletal structure, and
in pathological ones, like the reparation of fractures. The BMP-2 in
particular demonstrated to be necessary for the recovery of fractures
in human being.
Nevertheless, many other factors take part in the building of post-
fracture callus like VEGF, FGFs and so on.
The necessary inner factors for the differentiation in osteoblasts,
instead, include essentially transcription factors and molecules
working as transduction signals.
In particular the transcription factor Runx2 (which causes, if
mutated, human cleido-cranial dysplasia) is absolutely necessary for
the differentiation in osteoblasts and for the deposition of the matrix.
More recently other factors involved in the pre-osteoblastic prolifer-
ation (e.g. Osterix) and in the mineralization of the matrix (e.g. Dkk2)
have been identified and isolated even in our laboratories.
Recently several studies have shown the importance of Periostina
in the induction of differentiation of osteoblasts. This researches
confirmed that there is a series of cellular mechanisms controlling the
bone building that are codified and ruled by special genes. Everyone
of them is responsible of a different aspect of those important pro-
cesses represented by induction, building, development and
consolidation of a repairing bony callus.
INTERSPINOUS DEVICES AND MOTIONPRESERVATION – Part 1
31
OUR EXPERIENCE OF EFFICACY AND SAFETY
OF DEVICE FOR INTERVERTEBRAL ASSISTED
MOTION (DIAM�) IN PATIENT UNDERWENT
SIMPLE LUMBAR SURGERY
(MICRODISCECTOMY): CORRELATION
BETWEEN CLINICAL AND RADIOGRAPHIC
IMAGING PATTERN: FOLLOW-UP EVALUATION
A. Villaminar, M. Comisso, M. Balsano
Ospedale ‘‘ C. De Lellis’’ Schio (Vicenza) - Centro di RiferimentoRegionale per le Patologie del Rachide, Italy
Object: To assess the safety and efficacy of device for intervertebral
assisted motion (DIAM�). For this we compared patients underwent to
microdiscectomy with DIAM placement against patients underwent
lumbar surgery only. We also correlated clinical with radiological
pattern (sagittal angulation and pain outcome). Four years follow – up.
Methods: Between 2004 to 2008, in our department, 60 patients
were operated of herniated disk. 35 patients underwent concomitant
surgical placement of DIAM interspinous spacer (group A), the
other 25 underwent only microdiscectomy (group B). Radiographic
imaging, pain score (VAS), clinical assessments (ODI), were
obtained pre and postoperatively to a mean 25 months (range 12 –
48 months).
In group A, no statistically significant differences were noted
compared with group B in visual analog scale (VAS) and ODI at a
mean of 12 mounths; differences, without a statistical relevance, were
noted in VAS and ODI at the end of the 24 months between the two
groups.
In group A, no statistically significant differences were noted
in anterior or posterior disc height when comparing patients pre
and postoperatively during all follow up. Differences were noted
in Group B in anterior and posterior disc height after 12 months,
no statistical relevance. In Group A was relevated a relative
Kyphosis (less than 4�) in postoperative images compared with
group B. Complications in group A included one infection treated
with antibiotic therapy, and two reoperation for hernia
recedivation.
Conclusions: After microdiscectomy, the placement of a interspinous
process spacer (DIAM�) did not alter the disc height or sagittal
alignment at the mean 24-36 months of follow up. No statistically
differences in VAS and ODI were noted between the groups treated
with or without the interspinous spacer at the mean 12 months follow
up, after 12 months were noted differences between the two groups
but not statistical relevance.
32
INTERSPINOUS DEVICES IN THE TREATMENT
OF LUMBAR SPINAL STENOSIS: OUR
EXPERIENCE WITH APERIUS
A. P. Fabrizi, R. Maina, M. Galarza, R. Parisotto
Neurosurgery, Villa Maria Pia Hospital (Torino), VillalbaHospital (Bologna), Italy
Introduction: Aperius represents a new treatment option for patients
with neurogenic intermittent claudication (NIC) for degenerative
lumbar spinal stenosis (DLSS). Traditionally, DLSS were treated with
unilateral or bilateral laminectomy with wellknown possible post-
operative complications.
Material and Methods: From April 2007 to September, 260 DLSS
patients underwent APERIUS PercLID (Percutaneous stand-alone
Lumbar Interspinous Decompression System) mono- or multi-level
surgical implantation.
Results: 240 patients reported satisfactory improvement with rapid
return to their working and domestic activities. Clinical improve-
ment was detectable in early post-operative period in 200 of these
patients.
Only 20 patients reported unchanged or unsatisfactory clinical status.
Conclusions: A longer follow-up period is needed but clinical results
are good and promising. We preset Aperius percLID system as a good
option for the treatment of DLSS.
Keywords: interspinous devices, APERIUS PercLID, neurogenic
intermittent claudication, degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 741
123
33
APERIUS COMPARED TO OPEN SURGERY
IN LUMBAR STENOSIS: A RETROSPECTIVE
MULTICENTRE STUDY
F. Postacchini*, P.P.M. Menchetti**, E. Ferrari*,S. Faraglia*, R. Postacchini***
*Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University Sapienza,Rome, Italy; **Rome American Hospital, Rome, Italy; ***Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University Tor Vergata,Rome, Italy
In the last few years numerous interspinous spacers have been
developed, some of which are specifically indicated for the treatment
of lumbar stenosis. The latter include X-Stop, which is inserted by
open surgery, and Aperius and Superion which can be introduced by a
percutaneous approach. The clinical efficacy, the indications and the
anatomical effects of these devices, particularly those that can be
inserted percutaneously, are still unclear.
This aim of this study was to evaluate the results of Aperius
compared with open surgery in the treatment of various forms of
central or lateral lumbar stenosis and to try to determine the clinical
indications for this spacer.
Materials and Methods: We analysed two groups of patients with
lumbar stenosis: Group I, consisting of 30 patients in whom Aperius
was used, and Group II, including 30 patients who underwent open
surgery with or without the use of the opearating microscope.
Group I included 14 males and 16 females, aged on average 72 years.
Mild degenerative spondylolisthesis was present in 2 cases. 20
patients were operated at L4-L5 level, 5 at L3-L4, 2 at L2-L3 and 3 at
L3-L4 and L4-L5. No patients had motor deficits. In most cases the
thickness of the spacer was 12 mm. Patients were followed for 6-
14 months (mean 8.2)
Group II included 13 males and 17 females with a mean age of
67 years, who underwent surgery in the period 2006-2008. Three had
degenerative spondylolisthesis, but none underwent fusion. The level
most frequently involved was L4-L5, follewed by L3-L4. Four
patients had motor deficits. One of the following types of decom-
pression was performed: unilateral laminotomy, bilateral laminotomy
at one or two levels, bilateral decompression by a unilateral approach,
bilateral laminectomy. Patients were followed for 8 to 30 months
(mean 1.4 years) after surgery.
In both groups clinical evaluation was carried out using VAS
and ODI by two orthopaedic surgeons not involved in the treat-
ment. Based on the preoperative MRI or CT, four degrees of
severity of stenosis were identified: mild, moderate, severe and
very severe.
Results: In Group I, 25 patients (83%) had an improvement of rad-
iucular symptoms, while five (17%) had a poor result; in two of the
latter, who had degenerative spondylolisthesis, the spacer was
removed and decompression and fusion was carried out. The mean
VAS score decreased from 73 to 20 and ODI from 63 to 11. Most
patients in this group had mild or moderate stenosis.
In Group II, 26 patients (87%) improved, while four (13%) had a poor
result. The mean VAS score decreased from 82 to16 and ODI from 69
to 12. Patients in this Group had moderate to very severe stenosis.
Conclusions: Open surgery gave better results than Aperius, but the
difference was not significant. However, in the Aperius group most
patients had mild to moderate stenosis, whereas in the surgery group
stenosis was consistently moderate to very severe. Aprius appears to
be indicated particularly in patients in whom stenosis is due to
hypertrophy of ligamenta flava. The poor results with Aperius were
mainly ascribed to poor selection of patients.
34
INTERSPINOUS IMPLANTS FOR DEGENERATIVE
LUMBAR SPINE DISEASE: EXPERIENCE WITH
DIAM AND APERIUS DEVICES
A. P. Fabrizi, M. Galarza, R. Maina
Torino, Italy
Introduction: The insertion of posterior lumbar dynamic devices is
common procedure for the treatment of degenerative spine disease
and lumbar stenosis. Clinical and radiographic results were assessed
to determine the clinical outcomes and fusion rate in 1575 consecu-
tive selected patients
Methods: From 2000 through 2008, 1315 consecutive patients
underwent ‘‘Device for Intervertebral Assisted Motion (DIAM)’’ and
260 had APERIUS PercLID ‘‘Percutaneous stand-alone Lumbar
Interspinous Decompression System’’. The main surgical indications
included: symptomatic degenerative disc disease with foraminal ste-
nosis (1060 patients), black disk and facet syndrome (240 patients),
foraminal stenosis with disc herniation (211 patients) and topping-off
syndrome (64 patients).
Results: 1100 patients underwent a single level implant and 475 had a
multiple level implant. Mean operating time was 35 minutes for
DIAM and 7 minutes for APERIUS. At the mean 12-month follow-up
assessment, all patients had solid bone fusions across the interspace.
There was no sign of heterotopic ossification in any patient. No
patient experienced migration of the intervertebral distracting implant
on follow- up imaging. Complications were detected in 20 patients
(10 cases of infections, 10 fractures of the posterior spinous process).
40 patients were subsequently treated with posterior arthrodesis
(n=30) or total disk replacement (n=10). Patient’s postoperative
clinical status was rated according to the modified Macnab criteria:
symptoms resolution or improvement was achieved in 1505 patients;
and unchanged or unsatisfactory results in 70 in a mean postoperative
time of 56 months.
Conclusions: We present our experience in DIAM implant over a
decade and with APERIUS in patients with degenerative lumbar
spine. Both techniques are safe, simple and less technically
demanding. These approaches appear to be an effective alternative in
selected cases, although conventional posterior lumbar decompres-
sion and fusion still may be required.
Learning Objectives: Keywords: Posterior lumbar dynamic devices
DIAM implant APERIUS PercLID
35
DYNAMIC INTERSPINOUS STABILIZATION
WITH COFLEX�: OUR EXPERIENCE IN 53 CASES
WITH 7 MONTHS TO 29 MONTHS FOLLOW-UP
G. Maida*, F. Garofano*, S. Sarubbo*, M. A. Cavallo*
*University-Hospital S. Anna - Division of Neurosurgery -Ferrara, Italy
We undergone 53 patients to dynamic stabilization with interspinous
device (Coflex�) for lumbar stenosis, joint facet syndrome, ‘‘black
disc’’ (with or without disc herniation and/or Modic degeneration),
recurrence of herniated disk, epidural scar, I grade lumbar listhesys
not reducible and without spondilolisys, all clinical manifest and after
failure of conservative treatment. The mean follow-up is twelve
742 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
months and fifty patients reported complete pain and neurological
recovery and motion preservation. Three patients did not experience a
pain improvement and resulted unsatisfied. We did not report infec-
tions, hematomas, neural lesions or spinous process ruptures. In three
cases with severe lumbar stenosis we produced a dural perforation
sutured and covered with fat patch and fibrine glue without
any CSF leakage. Just in one case, with very severe lumbar stenosis,
we observed a cauda equina’s syndrome and we undergone the patient
to the interspinous device removal and cages’ implantation stand
alone.
We consider dynamic interspinous stabilization with Coflex�device less invasive and really useful, safe and effective specially
considering the large surgical indications, low complications’ rate and
the good clinical outcomes reported. However, the ability in the
lumbar canal ‘‘reaclibrage’’ and the possible need to shift surgical
strategy ‘‘in itinere’’, we suggest this technique, in I� lumbar listhesys
and sever lumbar stenosis, for expert spinal surgeon alone.
INTERSPINOUS DEVICES AND MOTION PRESERVATION –Part 2
36
LUMBAR SPINE STENOSIS TREATMENT
BY PERCUTANEOUS VIA AND IN LOCAL
ANESTHESIA WITH INTERSPINAL DEVICES ‘‘IN
SPACE’’. PRELIMINARY RESULTS ON 60 CASES
L. Genovese, M. Muto, G. Anceschi
Napoli, Italy
The author reports the preliminary data on 60 patients treated with
interspinal spacers ‘‘IN SPACE (Synthes) type, applied by percuta-
neous local anestesia.
Indications: Patients treated were those presenting sympotms
chacaterized by low-back pain and/or radiculopathy and Neurologic
Intermittent Claudication.
The clinical evaluation of the symptoms occurred before and sfter
surgical operation via VAS and ZGQ.
The neuro-radiologic datum (Rx lumbo-sacral in AP,LL and
through dynamic tests, TC and RM lumbo-sacral) showed in all the
patients stenosis of the lumbar central canal and/or foraminal mono,
bi or tri-segmental, generated by the district conflict, secondare to the
osteo-artrhosis and disc degeneration and also to one or more ana-
tomical pathological conditions associated with it; such as disc
protusion, disc hernia not expelled, lower spondylolisthesis of grade
I�, events of arthrosis of the articular facets, hypertrophy or folding of
the yellow ligaments, reduction of the intersomatic space linked to
dessiccation phenomena of intervertebral discs and also results of
post-operative fibrous scarring recurrence of herniated disc
uncompressed.
The duration of symptoms, recent (continuing for at least 6 weeks)
and remote (for at least 6 years) and the failure of conservative
treatment were essential elemento for the indication of this kind of
treatment.
Materials and Methods: From January 2008 to end of December
2008, 60 patients, includine 36 male and 24 female were recruited and
treated.
The most treated levels in order of frequency were L4-L5, L5-S1 and
L3-L4, and properly:
• 3 cases at 3 levels (L3-L4, L4-L5, L5-S1)
• 10 cases at 2 levels (L3-L4, L4-L5)
• 16 cases at 2 levels (L4-L5, L5-S1)
• 31 cases at 1 level (L4-L5)
Surgical cutaneous access via a skin incision of 1 cm has been the
same procedure used for all the patients.
Device used: interspinal spacer ‘‘In Space’’ SYNTHES type of
8,10,12 14 mm.
Technique: Patient in prone position on an OR table with variable
aperture and head on antidecubito cushion, legs slightly bent.
Checking of the radiological level in the treated segments.
Side guide wire is applied to identify the line of the articular pro-
cesses. Then proceed with radiological checking for the identification
of the cavuum at the base of the interspinal ligament through which
the device (using the dedicated instruments annexed) must be added.
Local Anesthesia: Interspinal lumbar puncture is done using a 20 G
needle at the pre-chosen level and by proceeding gradually, until
reaching the base of the interspinal ligament when it crosses the
yellow ligament and release local anesthetic consisting of hydro-
chloride levobupivacaina 0,75 ml.
The duration of the operation is approximately 20 minutes.
Results: Clinical post-operative controls with VAC and ZCQ in all
the patients have showed positive results.
The VAS fell from 7.8 to 2.3 immediately after the operation and
remained unchanged in the controls at 1,3,6 and 9 months.
ZCQ showed an improvement of the severity of the symptoms, a
good functional recovery and a greater patient satisfaction for theb
treatment received.
37
INTERSPINOUS SPACER LIMITS AND FAILURE
M. Tenucci*, C. Giannetti**, M. Lisanti**, G. Calvosa**
*Ortopedia e Traumatologia USL2 LUCCA - Primario Prof. A.Fornaciai; **Ia Clinica Ortopedica Universitaria Cisanello –Direttore: Prof. M. Lisanti
Introduction: The objective of this study is to retrace the history of
the devices from their conception to their development and use in
relation to their design and different materials.
We do an analysis of the spacer from a mechanical point of view,
emphasizing the different technical characteristics. Observe their
effects on the biomechanics of the lumbar sacral spine. From these
observations we perform a critical review of our cases.
Materials and Methods: Review of 50 cases treated with interspi-
nous spacer in patients with central stenosis and lumbar sacral spine,
the disc hernia, some cases of recurrence of disc herniation syndrome
junctional in rigid stabilization and /or dynamic.
Thirty percent of patients were over 65 with associated diseases that
contraindicated major surgery. For these patients we decided to a
treatment in local anesthesia.
Results: All patients complained of progressive low back pain with
neurogenic claudication, radiculopathy and a diminished walking
distance. Anteroposterior, lateral and flexion/extension plain
radiographs, were performed in all cases. The patients were
investigated pre and post operative with Osvestry Disability Index,
VAS score; magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) pre and post
operative. A total of 80% were very satisfied with the outcome of
the operation.
Conclusions: Critical review of our case studies reveal considerations
on indications, contraindications and complications and limitations of
the treatment of degenerative disease of the lumbar sacral spine with
interspinous spacers.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 743
123
38
INTERSPINOUS PROCESS DECOMPRESSION
SYSTEMS: INDICATIONS AND CONTROVERSIES
M. Costaglioli, M. Piredda, D. Castangia, S. Casula, S. Caboni,P.P. Mura
Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: A growing number of interspinous process devices
have been introduced to the lumbar spine implant market. Implant
designs vary from static spacers to dynamized devices. Despite being
made of different materials, the common link between them is the
mechanical goal of distracting the spinous processes to affect the inter-
vertebral relationship. In contrast, the purported clinical goals are more
variable, ranging from treatment of degenerative spinal stenosis, disco-
genic low back pain, facet syndrome, disk herniations, and instability.
Posterior element distraction with an ISP device is intended to cause
restore of posterior tension band of the instrumented segment. By
doing so, infolding of the ligamentum flavum is somewhat reversed,
causing less intrusion into the spinal canal. Furthermore, longitudinal
distraction between 2 vertebrae can increase the neural foramina
dimensions and partially unload the facet joints and posterior portion
of the disk. Another advantage is the ease of revision. In case of
failure, these devices can easily be revised or removed.
Patients and Methods: Between 2002 and 2007 we treated 145
patients with various devices (Diam, Wallis, Back jak, X Stop, A-
perius). a mean age of 35,3, minimum follow up one years.
Patients were evaluated preoperatively, intraoperatively and postop-
eratively at 1, 3 and 12 months
Conclusion: Defining the indications for these minimally invasive
procedures will be crucial and should emerge from thoughtful con-
sideration of data from randomized controlled studies. Though few
published data exist, this paper will review the available clinical
results of the various devices and ours experience with some of these
(Diam, Wallis, Back jak, X Stop, Aperius).
39
BIOMECHANICAL CONSIDERATIONS ON
POSTERIOR MOTION PRESERVATION SYSTEMS :
INTERSPINOUS VERSUS INTERLAMINAR
P. Petrini�, G. Guizzardi*
�Orthopaedics, Hospital of Citta di Castello, Perugia, Italy*Neurosurgery. University and City Hospital Careggi, Florence,Italy
Introduction: In the last few year the market has been literally
invaded by interspinous/interlaminar systems for motion preservation.
The type of material, the surgical technique and moreover the
placement of these devices (interspinous or interlaminar) substantially
influence the ROM, but in different ways.
Material and Methods: The authors, that have been using these
devices for about 10 years, through static and dynamic radiographic
examinations and biomechanical tests, analyse both the segmental
mobility and the sagittal balance after these devices have been
implanted. We present a new device (INTRA Spine) for the treatment of
degenerative pathology of the lumbar spine. The device, in medical
silicone 65 shore coated by a pure poliester therephthalate sleeve, has
with respect to other posterior devices the advantange that it may be
implanted more anteriorily (interlaminar) and thus gets placed even
closer to the center of instantaneous rotation of the segment. The fun-
damental feature in the design of this new device is that of overturned
anvil with the anterior part to be placed between the laminae and whose
frontal extremity is covered by a silicone film that prevents adhesion to
the surrounding structures. The surgical instrumentation, designed ad
hoc, allows us to perform the procedure with a mininvasive monolateral
approach and with the maximum respect for the anatomical structures.
Finally, the difference in compression ratio between the anterior and
posterior parts of the device, do not limit the ROM.
Results: The results are undoubtedly in favour of interlaminar rather
than interspinous systems and this seems obvious if we consider
simply the different distances of the two types of implants from the
axis of instantaneous rotation.
Conclusions: The path we must take has yet to come to an end, but
the consciousness and understanding of this data by all those who use
these devices appears fundamental for their correct use, but most of
all so that the correct system be used for the various situations. We
nevertheless feel we should recommend the use of this device after
failure of conservative treatment, as a first choice over more invasive
surgical operations and especially in the first phases of degenerative
cascade in order to slow down its natural evolution.
40
SPINAL STABILIZATION USING AN ‘‘HYBRID’’
RIGID / DYNAMIC SYSTEM: PRELIMINARY
RESULTS
B. Misaggi1, P. Vigano’1, G. Fava1, D. Peroni1, M. Ferraro2,A. Trapletti3, M. Colombo3, W. Albisetti4
1U.O. Scoliosis and Vertebral Disease – Orthopaedic Institute G.Pini – Milan; 2S.C. II Division - Orthopaedic InstituteG. Pini – Milan; 31� Residency Program in Orthopaedics andTraumatology - Universita degli Studi – Milan; 4Universita degliStudi - Milan, Italy
Introduction: On the basis of the good results obtained with the
elastic stabilization, we decided to combine the elastic to the rigid
stabilization, especially in consideration of the fact that the disc
adjacent to the arthrodesis area undergoes excessive stresses which
can significantly accelerate its physiological aging process. If the disc
already has original degenerative problems, overstress will aggravate
its condition. Zimmer recently developed the DTO system, a new
hybrid stabilization system indicated for the treatment of degenerative
lumbar spine disc with or without instability.
The goal of the treatment is to obtain the fusion of the seriously
damaged segment, while preserving the adjacent segments with a
Dynesys dynamic stabilization.
Material and Method: We reviewed the early cases treated at our
Institute with the Zimmer DTO system, a peduncular hybrid system.
We selected the patients by age and by clinical situation, all the
patients were investigated with standard and dynamic x-ray exami-
nation and NMR study.
We performed a prospective study on 16 patients aged between 25
and 52 years, with an average follow-up of 10 months. In 80% of the
cases a 2-level stabilization was performed, in 20% of the cases a 3-
level stabilization was performed. The clinical rating scales used were
the Oswestry and the VAS
Results: In the 87.5% of the cases we obtained an important reduction
of the pain with a good / great satisfaction of the patients. Post-
surgery imaging investigations are also encouraging.
Discussion and Conclusions: Preliminary results indicate that a
hybrid stabilization using the Zimmer DTO system may offer real
advantages in patients affected by low back pain, reducing the
744 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
concentration of stress on the border disc, preserving it and reducing
the risk of its degeneration. This improves patients’ quality of life and
activity. However it is important to remember that the results
obtained, although encouraging, require further studies to confirm the
preliminary data and a statistically significant clinical evaluation.
LUMBAR SPINE – Part 1
41
MONOLATERAL IMPINGEMENT ROOT
SYNDROMES: TREATMENT OPTIONS
M. Cassini, G. Gioia
Orthopaedic and Traumatology Department; AULSS 21 MaterSalutis Hospital Legnago-Verona, Italy
Background: Monolateral impingement root syndromes may
manifest mainly with two aspects: monolateral pain to a leg with
or without motor sensitive deficit during rest or walking and pain
only during walking: this condition is named ‘‘claudicatio’’. Disc
hernia is often associated with the first situation while lateral ste-
nosis is more frequently responsible in the second condition.
Considering the frequency of these clinical syndromes and the
treatment options up today available (microdiscectomy, microde-
compression, interspinous devices) the right indication is
indispensable for a good outcome.
Methods: From November 2005 to July 2008, 112 patients (aver-
age age 54 yrs range 19-71) affected by root impingement
syndrome underwent to surgery. Disc hernia was responsible of
radicular pain in 101 cases with association of lateral stenosis in 21
cases (intraoperative evidence). We performed a microdiscectomy
(Caspar technique) in case of protruded or extruded disc hernia, a
microdecompression with high speed drill in the cases with lateral
stenosis associated, a microdecompression in the symptomatic side
plus DIAM interspinous device (11 cases) in those cases with
asymptomatic controlateral stenosis. All cases were revised at 2
mths and 6 mths after surgery.
Results: We observed an improvement of the radicular symptoms
in all the patients with complete recovery in over 90% of the
cases. The microdiscectomy and microdecompression group had the
best results in the short time after few days or weeks post surgery
with an earlier functional restore due to the MIS technique (Mini
Invasive Surgery). On the contrary the DIAM group presented in
the immediate postoperative period more pain and disability with a
longer hospital stay probably due to the more invasive approach
and the adaptation to the device.
Nevertheless the few cases treated with this kind of spacers don’t
allow conclusive considerations.
We had 1 case of durotomy during a microdiscectomy treated with
fibrin glue that lead to a prolonged bed rest of 3 days. 2 disc hernia
recurrence reoperated with micro technique. One case of disc hernia
1 year after surgery in a patient treated with DIAM device without
discectomy at the level involved. One case of persistent low back pain
in a patient treated with microdecompression plus interspinous spacer.
The MIS group patients was discharged from the hospital in the first
or second day after surgery while the DIAM group needed a pro-
longed hospital stay (4 or 5 days).
Discussion and Conclusion: The frequence of lumboradicular
syndroms is a common occurrence in the daily clinical practice.
Much of these improve with conservative treatment. Surgery in
case of disc hernia was usually considered after 4 or 6 weeks
following the guide lines (earlier in case of neurologic worsening
or intractable pain). Patients affected from ‘‘claudicatio’’ were
generally treated after months because of delay in the diagnosis
and prolonged conservative treatment. From the results of our
revision the majority of the procedures were effective because the
indication and the patient selection were accurate. In our opinion
the interspinous spacers, allowing an indirect opening of the
radicular canal, could be utilized in selective cases without mic-
rodecompression (stand alone). But the wide utilize of such
devices, too frequent from our point of view, will be revised
considering the rate of complications (spinous processes breakeage,
lower tolerance in the postoperative period) and higher costs in
confront of selective microdecompression.
42
SURGICAL TREATMENT OF INTRA-
EXTRAFORAMINAL LUMBAR DISC HERNIATION
WITH BI-RADICULAR INVOLVEMENT: OUR
EXPERIENCE AND REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A. Barbanera1, G. P. Longo1,2, E. Serchi1, A. Andreoli1,D. Rossi 1
1Unita Operativa di Neurochirurgia D’Urgenza e del TraumaOspedale Bellaria-Maggiore Bologna; 2Unita Operativa diNeurochirurgia AOU Policlinico ‘‘ G. Rodolico ‘‘ Catania, Italy
Intra-Extraforaminal lumbar disc herniations may cause a compres-
sion of both intracanalar ed extraforaminal roots.
The surgical treatment of this condition is still controversial.
Surgical procedures described in literature are intracanalar, extra-
canalar or combined.
At our institution we have decided to treat these patient through an
unilateral artrectomy, that allows a good decompression of both roots
even in the foraminal region, followed by a transforaminal interbody
fusion (TLIF).We performed this approach using both open and
minimally invasive technique.
Between May 2007 and April 2008 16 patients (16 women, 10
men), aged 39 to 73, with bi-radicular symptoms underwent surgery
through this approach.
The herniations were located at L4-L5 in 9 patients, at L3-L4 in 3
patients and L5-S1 in three.
Two patients were previously treated through an intracanalar
interlaminar approach with a partial resolution of radiculopathy.
Minimally invasive tecnique was used in 5 patients.
Operating time was beetween 2 and 2.30 hours, depending if
minimally invasive tecnique was used.
After a follow up period from 2 to 18 months, fifteen patients
showed an almost complete resolution of the symptoms, with a pre-
operative VAS in 8 and post-operative VAS in 2, without any evi-
dence of pseudoarthrosis or malpositioning of devices.
Taking into account the shortness of the follow up there isn’t any
evidence of adjacent segment pathology.
Even if others studies are needed we believe this tecnique is a
feasible method to obtain a complete decompression of both
roots with an almost circumferential arthrodesis (270�) in
single stage procedure. Frequently with a minimally invasive
approach.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 745
123
43
SURGICAL TREATMENT WITH
TRANSFORAMINAL LUMBAR INTERBODY
FUSION (TLIF) IN RECURRENT LUMBAR DISC
HERNIATION: INDICATION AND RESULTS
S. Astolfi, L. Scaramuzzo, V. Del Bravo, C. A. Logroscino
Departement of Orthopaedic Science and Traumatology SpineSurgery Division Catholic University Rome
Introduction: Recurrent disc herniation is a major cause of surgical
failure in spine surgery. The optimal technique choice in treating this
disease is, nowadays, controversial. A repeated discectomy and a
wide decompression increased the risk of segmental instability, dural
tear and nerve injuries due to the presence of scar tissue. Need to
prevent these complications and the growing facility in approaching
posteriorly the anterior lumbar vertebral column, make the trans-
foraminal lumbar interbody fusion a valid surgical treatment
possibility in recurrent disc herniation.
Methods: From January 2005 to January 2008 by Spine Surgery
Division of Department of Orthopaedic Science and Traumatology
of Catholic University 25 patients, 14 male and 9 female, with a
mean age of 47 years (range 34-67 years) affected by recurrent
disc herniation underwent transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion
combined with pedicle screw fixation. All patients were evaluated
post-operative with an antero-posterior and lateral X-ray 1 m, 3 m,
6 m, 12 m and then every year and with a CT scan of the treated
levels to evaluate the cages’ positioning and the fusion rate.
Clinical outcome was evaluated by SF-36 questionnaire, Oswestry
Disability Index and VAS Score.
Results: All the patients demonstrated a significant and progressive
improvement, in term of pain, especially radicular pain and inde-
pendence in daily life. CT scan control at 1 year minimum follow-
up exhibited a good fusion rate in 100% of cases. Cages’
positioning was very good in 85% of cases, good in 15% of cases.
There was no hardware failure at two years median follow-up.
Discussion: The gold standard in surgical treatment of recurrent
disc herniation is, nowadays, a subject of controversy. In our
opinion the transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion combined with
pedicle screw fixation has several advantages. It allows to perform
a wide decompression with complete release of neurological
structures, reduces or eliminates segmental motion and helps to
restore the physiological lordosis of the affected lumbar segment.
A transforaminal approach to the disc space allows to perform
decompression limiting the damages to neurological structures,
greatly increased in revision surgery due to the presence of a great
number of adhesions and fibrotic scar tissue.
44
STAND-ALONE CAGE FOR POSTERIOR LUMBAR
INTERBODY FUSION IN THE TREATMENT OF
HIGH DEGREE DEGENERATIVE DISC DISEASE
(DDD): DESIGN OF A NEW DEVICE FOR AN
‘‘OLD’’ TECHNIQUE. A PROSPECTIVE STUDY
ON A SERIES OF 119 CASES
M. Fornari, F. Costa, M. Sassi, A. Cardia, A. Ortolina, R. Assietti*
Istituto IRCCS Galeazzi, Milano; *Ospedale Fatebenefratelli,Milano, Italy
Introduction: Chronic lumbar pain due to Degenerative Disc Disease
(DDD) is a very common entity affecting a large amount of people
often in the full activity ages. Considering that the usual self-repair
system observed in nature is a spontaneous temptative of arthrodesis
leading in most of the cases to pseudoartrosis, many possible surgical
treatment of fusion have been proposed and introduced during the
recent years, such as PLIF.
Due to the growing interest toward minimally invasive surgery and the
unsatisfactory results present in Literature (mainly to the high incidence
of morbidity and complications) a new titanium made lumbar interbody
cage (I-Fly) has been developed in order to achieve a solid bone fusion
by a stand alone posterior device. This cage presents a modify head,
(blunted and thinned), in a way it can be used as a blunt spreader and a
small size core, leading an easier self-positioning of the cages.
Matherial and Methods: Between 2003 and 2007 119 patients were
treated for chronic lumbar discopathy (Modic III grade and V grade in
Pfirman classification) with I-Fly uses as stand-alone cage.
All the patients were clinically evaluated pre-operatively and at 1 and
2 years follow-up with a neurological evaluation, VAS and Prolo
Economic and Functional Scale. Radiological results were evaluated
with a polyaxial CT scan and flexion-exstension x-rays. Fusion is
defined as absence of segmental instability at dynamic x-ray and
Bridwel grade I or II at Ct scan. Patients were considered clinically
‘‘responders’’ with any improvement at VAS evaluation (comparing
to baseline values), and a PROLO value [ 7.
Results: At the last follow-up the rate of clinical success was assesed
in 93.9% patients while the rate of bony fusion was 99.1% evaluated
with flexion-extension x-ray and 92.2% evaluated with CT scan. The
rate of morbidity (no nerve root injury, no dural lesion) and com-
plications (subsidence and pseudoarthrosis) is minimal.
Conclusion: PLIF with stand-alone I-Fly cage can be considered as a
possible surgical treatment of chronic low-back pain due to high degree
DDD. This technique is not demanding and can be considered safe and
effective as showed by the excellent clinical and radiological success rates.
746 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
45
THE DIFFERENTIATED STABILIZATION IN THE
LUMBAR DEGENERATIVE DESEASE
M. Petruzzi, M. Laccisaglia, B. Cedron, C. Lamartina
I.R.C.C.S. Istituto Ortopedico Galeazzi – Chirurgia Vertebrale II,Italy
Introduction: The treatment of degenerative disk disease remains one
of the most controversial topics in the spine literature. The spine surgery
strategies depend on the clinical and radiological manifestation of the
degenerative lumbar disk disease. The fusion eliminates motion of the
functional spinal segment and may overload the adjacent segments,
thereby generating the transition syndrome and sometimes the need of
reinterventions. These disadvantages led to alternative procedures and
techniques for stabilization without fusion. Mobile stabilization systems
have to neutralize noxious forces and restore normal function of the
spinal segments and protect the adjacent segments. Very frequently in
the same patient different degrees of lumbar degenerative cascade are
observed. We often see one motion segment with an advanced degen-
eration (disk collapse) neighboring one or more segments with just a
mild discopathy (black disk/annular tear ‘‘HIZ’’). The symptoms can be
tied up to the different levels. Long fusion has a bad reputation and the
modern non-fusion techniques are not designed to address all multilevel
disease. In these cases, when the surgery is suitable, it is necessary to
differentiate and to adjust the stabilization to the degree of degeneration.
In this way an instrumentated fusion can be suitable to a level (laminar
screws or pedicular screws) and a stabilization without fusion to another
(pedicular dynamic neutralization). This study shows different surgical
strategies with or without fusion in relationship to the different level of
lumbar degenerative cascade.
Materials and Methods: We report our experience on 15 patients
suffereing from lumbar degenerative disease, registered in Spine Tango
Registry, treated surgically between January 2007 and December 2008.
We evaluated pre- and follow-up pain and fusion in a consecutive series
of 15 patients (6 male/9 female) with a mean age of 50.8 years (40-66) at
the time of the surgery. The mean follow-up time was 10.6 months (6-
19). Twelve patients received a three-level of instrumentation, 1 patient
had a four level of instrumentation, 1 patient had a five level of
instrumentation and 1 six-level of instrumentation. Three patients
received a TLIF, 2 a PLIF, 1 an interspinous spacer, 12 a fusion with
pedicular screws, 3 a fusion with laminar screws.
Results: Pre-op VAS was 8.4, f.up VAS was 2.06. We found a solid
fusion in all patients at the last follow-up.
Conclusion: Hybrid stabilization is a relatively new concept in spinal
stabilization procedures with the combination of a rigid stabilization
with fusion and non-fusion techniques in the same patient. Pre-
liminary clinical results suggest that these procedures benefit patients
with spinal disorders, varying stiffnes of the systems. The goals of this
procedure is to preserve the adjacent segment to the fusion.
46
TRANSFORAMINAL LUMBAR INTERBODY
FUSION: A RETROSPECTIVE STUDY OF 114
PATIENTS
P. P. Mura, M. Costaglioli, M. Piredda, D. Castangia, S. Casula,S. Caboni
Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: The goal of a fusion of the lumbar spine is to obtain a
primary solid arthrodesis so as to alleviate pain. Different circumferential
or ‘‘360’’ fusion techniques have been described such as combined
anterior–posterior fusion (APF), instrumented posterior lumbar
interbody fusion (PLIF) and transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion
(TLIF).
The TLIF procedure has rapidly gained popularity in these last few
years. Because of its posterolateral extracanalar discectomy and
fusion, it has been reported as a safe technique, without the potential
complications described when using combined APF and PLIF
techniques.
Patients and Methods: 114 patients operated from 2003 to 2008
• 60 patients operated between 2003 and 2006
• All patients operated in the same center
• All patients operated by the same surgeon
Patients were evaluated preoperatively, intraoperatively and postop-
eratively at 1 and 3 and 12 months.
Operation Technique: The spine was approached through a
classic posterior midline incision and subperiosteal muscular
detachment. The side of facetectomy was chosen according to the
subject’s symptoms of leg pain if present. A posterolateral annuloto-
my was made and subtotal discectomy was performed and the hyaline
cartilage of endplates was removed. Once the surgeon was satisfied
with endplate preparation, a banana shaped allograft spacer was
inserted through the annulotomy and placed anteriorly, along the
anterior apophyseal ring. Additional autograft locally harvested from
decompression was packed behind the allograft spacer in all cases.
Laminae and the remaining contralateral facet joint were decorticated,
and packed with bone graft (local autologous and allograft chips in all
cases). Finally, the posterior fusion was instrumented with pedicle
screws and rods.
No major surgical complication was observed.
Results: The TLIF procedure had led to shortened surgical times, less
neurologic injury, and improved overall outcomes. The introduction of
the transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion procedure has allowed
surgeons to achieve successful fusion without the risk of nerve root
tethering that is seen so frequently with standard PLIF techniques.
47
CLASSIFICATION OF LUMBAR STABILIZATION
DEVICES: A BIOMECHANICAL CRITERION
M. Brayda-Bruno1, A. Lovi1, M. Teli1, F. Anasetti2,C. M. Bellini2, F. Galbusera2
1Department of Spine Surgery III, IRCCS Istituto OrtopedicoGaleazzi, Milan, Italy; 2LaBS, IRCCS Istituto OrtopedicoGaleazzi, Milan, Italy
Introduction: The surgical devices currently used for the treatment of
lumbar disc degenerative disease can be divided into three categories:
fusion devices (rigid or semirigid rods), devices aimed to the reduc-
tion of the flexibility (flexible rods) and load-bearing devices which
preserve the physiological spine flexibility (very flexible rods, inter-
spinous devices, disc prostheses). However, devices belonging to the
latter two categories are difficult to be sorted. In this paper, the
authors propose a classification system based on the residual mobility
of the implanted segment.
Materials and Methods: The motion-limiting effect of several
devices was evaluated by means of a finite element model of the L2-
L5 segment. The following devices were considered: stainless steel
rods, titanium rods, PEEK rods, composite rods, and some dynamic
pedicular devices currently available on the market. Both single level
(L4-L5) and double level (L3-L5) stabilizations were considered. The
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 747
123
models were loaded with pure moments of 7.5 Nm in flexion,
extension, lateral bending and axial rotation.
Results: The spine flexibility after the implantation of the stabiliza-
tion devices resulted extremely sensitive to the mechanical properties
of the device materials. All the rods (steel, titanium, PEEK, com-
posite) induced a significant reduction of the flexibility (more than
70% in flexion and extension). The dynamic devices partially pre-
served the segment mobility. However, the stiffness of the implanted
spine models resulted strongly dependent on the device biomechanics
(flexibility reduction between 7% and 72% in flexion and extension).
Discussion and Conclusions: Based on the present results, the
authors suggest the use of a classification system for the stabilization
devices based on the residual flexibility of the implanted spine,
independently on the design of the device (e.g. pedicular or inter-
spinous). The devices able to preserve only partially (for example less
than 70%) the segment flexibility may be defined ‘‘flexible’’.
‘‘Dynamic’’ devices should be able to preserve a nearly physiological
flexibility (at least 70%).
48
ITALIAN MULTICENTRIC STUDY ABOUT THE
USE OF A NEW INTERBODY DEVICE WITH
PROGRAMMABLE LORDOSIS: FIRST RESULTS
ON 25 CASES
T. C. Russo1, M. Balsano2, P. Bruni3, R. Greco4, B. Misaggi5,P. P. Mura6, G. Rizzo7, C. Ruosi8
1Ragusa, 2Schio-Tiene, VI, 3Viterbo, 4Roma, 5Milano, 6Cagliari,7Bari, 8Napoli, Italy
The present study concerns the use of an expansion cage to the
lumbar level. Were evaluated 25 patients with degenerative lumbar
disease: 13 degenerative spondylolisthesis of L4 (Mayerding 1), 9
steno-instability and 3 litic spondylolisthesis of L5 (Mayerding 1).
The cage has been always used in association with posterior sta-
bilization. In most cases (22 of 25) was preferred implant a
monocage with PLIF or TLIF access in the more symptomatic side.
We also discussed some known surgical technique and presented the
first results.
ISOLATED INTERBODY FUSION WITH A
POSTERIOR TRANSFORAMINAL MONOPORTAL
ACCESS IN LUMBAR DEGENERATIVE
PATHOLOGY
C. Formica, L. Cavaleri, M. Formica, G. Buzzi
SONG - Spinal Orthopaedical Neurosurgical Group; Alessandria– Clinica Salus - Gruppo Policlinico di Monza; Genova - ClinicaMontallegro – Universita di Genova, Italy
Purpose of the Study: To evaluate the results and the complications
of lumbar interbody fusion, even known as ‘‘stand-alone’’. Interbody
arthrodesis in primitive or secondary intervertebral disc degeneration
has still today a biomechanical and biological validity despite the
prosthesis coming. In the last years the posterior surgical procedures
have been changed looking for less invasive techniques than the
traditional PLIF (Posterior Lumbar Interbody Fusion) such as TLIF
(Transforaminal Lumbar Interbody Fusion). This open surgical
technique is less invasive on the dura madre and respects the bone as
well as the capsular-ligamentous structures of the opposite vertebral
lumbar side.
Material and Methods: From 2002 we began the isolated lumbar
interbody fusion (without pedicular screws) using a device with a
‘‘banana shape’’ in carbonium or titanium in a selection of patients.
The indications are very limited: monosegmental primitive or post-
surgical disc degeneration with no or less instability, close to a
physiological stabilization and with a good disc above and below. In
the case of a radicular pain the transforaminal approach was per-
formed on the same side of the nervous sufferance, apart when an
important scar tissue due to previous surgery was found. In the last
situation a traditional TLIF with pedicular screws and an interbody
fusion from the opposite side of the previous access would have been
done. Age and sex were discriminating; indeed in young or middle
age patients we like best disc prosthesis, also in males at level L4L5.
Results: From January 2002 to December 2007 we treated with the
isolated monoportal interbody fusion technique 148 patients: 93
males, 55 females. Minimum age 23 years old, maximum age
78 years old (average 42,7 y.o.). In 6 cases the levels treated were
L3L4, in 52 cases L4L5, in 90 cases L5S1. The complications
occurred were 2 lesions of the dura madre, sutured in first instance.
Pre-operatory VAS was 7.1 and post-operatory 2.7. Oswestry dis-
ability index improved from 84% to 22%.
Conclusions: These indications are not definitive. We are sure
enough that no absolute truth could be found in degenerative vertebral
diseases. The advantage of this procedure is the less invasion of the
nervous structures (dura madre and nerve roots) thanks to a mono-
lateral mobilization. The weight bearing is granted the day after
surgery and the average stay in hospital is 2/3 days. The microscope
or enlarger glasses are used as well as in herniated disc operations. As
a disadvantage a lesion of the dura madre might occur as well as the
formation of scar tissue around the foraminal root. If well seen and
checked, the root is never damaged nor stretched. Products against
adhesions or a fat patch could be used to protect the nerve root. The
venous plexus is probably the worse problem if responsible of a
compressive haematoma. For this reason we bring particular attention
to a precise haemostasis using bipolar forceps, collagenous layers and
drainage hoses after surgery.
LUMBAR SPINE – Part 2
49
SURGICAL TREATMENT OF ADULT LOW GRADE
LYTIC SPONDYLOLISTHESIS
G. Gargiulo, A. Solini
U.O. Ortopedia - A.S.O. S. Giovanni Battista Molinette, Italy
Introduction: Surgical treatment of 1th – 2th grade adult lytic
spondilolisthesis presents some controversies. Articolar rand disc
degeneration at the level of lysis, foraminal stenosis and istmic
traction spurs, degenerative changes at adjacent level and possible
concomitatant stenosis, osteoporosis in aged patient and different
surgical options available (Gill decompression, posterolateral, ante-
rior or circumferential fusion, with or without instrumentation, open
or mininvasive surgery) don’t give a general interpretation of the
surgical treatment when indicated. Authors report their experience in
these partiets discussing surgical strategies.
Material and Method: During the period of 1992-2004 63 patient 33
males, 30 females) of mean age of 39 y. (28-57) were treated at the
748 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
Orthopaedic Division of A.S.O. S. Giovanni Battista Molinette of
Turin for a simptomatic low grade spondylolistesis. Low back pain
affected 61 patients (VAS 8), in 2 cases radicolopathy pain was the
main symptom for surgical treatment. However radicular pain was
present in 59 cases with deficit in 21 and claudicazio in 9. All the
patients have been submitted to standard and functional rx, TC and
RNM. In 43 cases the lysis was in L5, in 13 in L4, in 4 in L3 and in 2
in L3 and L4. The surgical treatment was of simple decompression
according to Gill in 2 cases, of decompression and posterolateral
instrumented in situ fusion with transpedicular screws in 37 cases, of
alone instrumented posterolateral in situ fusion in 24 cases (Wiltse
access).
Results: Satisfactory results were achieved in most patients. At a mean
8 y. f.up (4 -12) they have been good in 51 cases (VAS 2), fair in 13
(VAS 5) for the irregular assumption of FANS for the treatment of a
residual light back pain but with significant improvement of day life
activities. In any case the worsening of the preoperative symptoms was
observed. A homogeneous callus of artrodesis has been clearly evident
in RX in 53 patients. Among the complications of the treatment we
observed pedicle violation of the lytic vertebra in 3 cases, of which in 2
has not been possible to insert screws, a transitory nerve root compro-
mise from excessive manipulation of the root in 5 cases. One case in
which the screw repositioning was been necessary in S1 after 7 days
from surgery was complicated by the appearance of a pulmonary
embolism without residual functional damages. In 3 cases the instru-
mentation has been removed for the appearance of a lombalgia after
4 years in average from surgery in a good fusion, with regression of the
symptoms. In a case of instrumented L5-S1 artrodesis has been nec-
essary to extend proximally the artrodesis after 6 years for the
reappearence of the lumbar and peripheral simptoms following a seri-
ous lumbar trauma with partial regression of the signs at last control. A
junctional syndrome treated with medical cares and physical therapy
has been observed in 3 cases after 7 years in average.
Conclusions: In our experience surgical treatment of low grade istmic
spondylolistehesis in adults was commensurate to the symptoms
complained by the patients. The nerve root decompression, also as the
only surgical action, has been performed always in presence of a
radicular compromise confirmed by an imaging that shows the central
or lateral stenosis at the level of lysis or at the adjoining levels. The
posterolateral instrumented fusion has allowed to adequately treat the
local instability and mechanical lombalgia with good clinical results
any degenerative characteristic of the articular tripode and any degree
of lysthesis.
50
SPONDYLOLYSIS OR FIRST-DEGREE
ISTHMICAL SPONDYLOLISTHESIS: ISTHMICAL
RECONSTRUCTION OR ARTHRODESIS?
B. Misaggi1, P. Vigano’1, G. Fava1, D. Peroni1,M. Ferraro2, A. Trapletti3, F. Spreafico3, W. Albisetti4
1U.O. Patologie Vertebrali e Scoliosi - Istituto Ortopedico G. Pini– Milano; 2S.C. II Divisione - Istituto Ortopedico G. Pini –Milano; 3I Scuola di Specializzazione in Ortopedia eTraumatologia – Universita degli Studi di Milano; 4Universitadegli Studi di Milano, Italy
Introduction: In young patients affected by lumbar pain due to
spondylolysis or first degree spondylolisthesis, if conservative treat-
ment failed, it’s better to choose a surgical solution consisting in
isthmical recontruiction.
The vertebral arthrodesis is obliged only in cases of severe instability
and discal degeneration.
The isthmical reconstruction is obtained by different techniques
Materials and Methods: In our experience, we used Buck and Gillet
techniques, indicated if there is not discal degeneration.
In our retrospective, uncontrolled study, we reviewed 88 patients;
patients aged from 11 to 36 year; the mean follow up was 8 years; the
operated level was L2 in 62 patients, L4 in 20 patients and L3 in 6
patients.
Oswestry and VAS scale were used for clinical evaluation. RX
evaluation was performed at 3,6,12, and 24 months after surgery; a
MR was performed in 65% of the cases at 18 months after surgery.
Results: The results of surgery were satisfactory; only in 11% of the
patients pain persisted after the intervention. At RX a complete
consolidation was observed in 93% of cases, with the complete
restored function in 90%.
At RM evaluation there were no signs of discal degeneration in 90%
of patients.
Discussion and Conclusion: Isthmical reconstruction is surely
advantageous respect to arthrodesis: it consents an anathomical rec-
ontruction, it saves the vertebral segment and the functional unit.
That’s why we consider it as functional surgery.
51
LONG TERM RESULTS OF THE DIRECT REPAIR
OF SPONDYLOLISTHESIS
F. Giudici1, L. Minoia, M. Archetti, A. S. Corriero, A. Zagra
1Istituto Ortopedico Galeazzi, Milano, Italy
Isthmic repair is an effective surgical procedure in lumbar spondy-
lolysis and spondylolisthesis with slipping less than 15% in patients
under 25 years old with painful symptoms resistant to conservative
treatment.
Isthmic repair of the lumbar spondylolisthesis was first proposed
by Buck in 1970. The Author performed the isthmic repair by iliac
bone graft and two trans-isthmic screws. Nicol and Scott (1986)
performed the fixation by two steel wirings that proceeded anterior
to the transverse process and were anchored to the spinous process.
Morscher et al. (1984) described a technique for the surgical
treatment of spondylolysis by bone grafting and direct stabilization
by means of a hook and a screw for each side. Salib and Pettine
(1993), Songer and Rovine (1998) proposed a fixation by pedicular
screws, segmental wire and bone grafting. Takuhashi and Matsu-
zaki (1996) proposed repairing the deficit in spondylolysis by
segmental pedicular screws and laminar hook fixation.
58 patients were operated for isthmic repair at Istituto Ort-
opedico Galeazzi of Milan, according to different techniques from
1994 to 2006. The males were 39 (67.2%), the females were 19
(32.8%). The mean age of the patients was 18 years (range 10-26
y.). The symptoms were: backache in 47 cases (81%), back and
radicular pain in 7 cases (12.1%), no pain in 4 cases (6.9%). The
defect was in L5 in 55 cases (94.8%) and in L4 in 3 cases (5.2%).
The slipping was from 0 to 15% (average 8%). An iliac bone
graft was applied in the lysis in all cases. The Buck technique
was performed in the first 7 cases (12.1%), the Scott technique
was performed in 12 cases (20.7%) and the modified Scott tech-
nique (pedicular screws and wiring) was performed in 39 cases
(67.2%).
The results of 52 cases were analysed from 2 to 14 years after
operation (average 7 years); 6 were lost to follow-up. The clinical
result of 7 patients operated by the Buck technique was good in 3
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 749
123
cases (42.8%), whereas backache was present in 4 cases (57.2%).
The x-rays showed in these patients: no change of the slipping in 6
cases (86%), increasing in 1 case (14%); bone graft absorption was
observed in 3 cases (42.8%); no loosening and no breakage of the
screws occurred. A second operation was performed in 5 patients
(71.4%). The removal of the screws in 1 case, the removal of the
screws and a posterior-lateral fusion without instrumentation in 4
cases. The clinical result of 11 patients operated by the Nicol and
Scott technique was good in 9 cases (81.8%), whereas backache
was present in 2 cases (18.2%). The x-rays showed in these
patients: no change of the slipping in 10 cases (91%), increasing in
1 case (9%), bone graft absorption only in the last case; breakage
and loosening of the wirings, but complete repair of defect, was
observed in 1 case (9%). A second operation was performed in 2
patients (18.2%): the removal of the wires in 1 case, the removal
of the wires and a posterior-lateral fusion without instrumentation
in 1 case. The clinical result of 34 patients operated by the
modified Scott technique was good in 30 cases (88.2%), whereas
backache was present in 4 cases (11.8%). The x-rays showed in
these patients: no change of the slipping in 33 cases (97%),
increasing in 1 case (3%) (bone graft absorption only in this case);
breakage and loosening of the fixation were observed in 2 cases
(5.9%). A second operation was performed in 2 patients (5.9%):
the removal of the implant in 1 case, the removal of the implant
and a posterior-lateral fusion in 1 case.
The data show a significant statistical difference among the
three groups of patients operated with different techniques
(p=0,025, Fisher’s exact test). The Scott and modified Scott tech-
niques, with respectively 81.8% e 88.2% of good clinical results,
seem to provide a better outcome than the Buck technique (42.8%).
In conclusion, these results demonstrate that the pars defect
repair is a helpful, easier and faster technique in lumbar spondy-
lolysis and spondylolisthesis treatment, especially the modified
Scott technique.
52
INSTRUMENTAL ARTHRODESIS WITH
TRANSPEDUNCOLAR SCREWS AND ONE
INTERBODY DEVICE IN THE TREATMENT OF
DEGENERATIVE LUMBAR SPONDYLOLISTHESIS
G. Incatasciato, C. Casamichele, M. Quartarone, A. Tumino,G. Giuca, T. C. Russo
Unit of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Major Hospital ofModica, Italy
Introduction: The increase in the average age involves an increasing
number of degenerative spinal diseases. These included degenerative
spondylolisthesis is one of the most frequent and disabling. In the
literature are numerous surgical procedures that are adopted by
decompression alone, decompression associated to the segmental ar-
trodesis, with or without instrumentation.
Materials and Methods: At Unit of Orthopedics and Traumatology
of the Major Hospital of Modica from 2007 to date 24 degenerative
spondylolisthesis have been treated by circumferential arthrodesis
with one interbody device by plif or tlif. The average age was 60 aa
(range 48-79), 17 women and 7 men, the most involved vertebra was
L4. The symptoms presented were backache, neurogenic claudication,
the mono / pluriradicolapatie paintings and mixed. All patients had
performed conservative treatment for a period of not less than
3 months. All interventions were performed by the same surgeon,
with an average time of 120 min, with contained blood loss (130 cc).
Patients with an average follow up of 12 months (range 3-24) and
were evaluated with controls at 1, 3, 6.12 months, bringing the
intensity of pain according to VAS scale and evaluating the results of
the SF 36 specially administered. Of all the patients we have obtained
x-rays in AP, LL and dynamic.
Results: The amount of pain, assessed with the VAS scale decreased
significantly to 23 (range 0-82) (P = 0.00001). SF-36 in 74% patients
have described their health good to excellent. Was not observed any
failure of the plant, while in 24% of patients show signs of degen-
eration of segments adjacent asymptomatic. The segmental lordosis
was maintained at fusion segment as well as lumbar lordosis.
Discussion and Conclusions: Treatment with one interbody device
reduces the surgery time and invasiveness of intervention itself. The
clinical and radiological results confirm the validity and effectiveness.
Keywords: degenerative spondylolisthesis, instrumental arthrodesis,
one interbody device, plif, tlif
53
DIRECT SCREW REPAIR OF SPONDYLOLYSIS:
AN ‘‘OLD’’ DYNAMIC SOLUTION
S. Casula, M. Costaglioli, M. Piredda, D. Castangia, S. Caboni,P. P. Mura
Cagliari, Italy
Introducion: Lumbar spondylolysis is not an infrequent finding and
has been reported in approximately 6% of the adult population.
Although most of patients affected by the disorder are asymptomatic, a
small number of patients experience chronic disabling low back pain,
sometimes radiating to the buttocks or thighs. Direct repair of the lesion
in the pars interarticularis is an appropriate and reasonable alternative to
fusion in those patients who have minimal spondylolisthesis and an
intact disc. The Buck technique proved to be the most stable method
among several techniques for the direct repair of a pars defect.
Patients and Methods: Between January 2005 and January 2007 we
treated 15 patients with a mean age of 22,3 years for bilateral bilateral
defect of the pars interarticularis (spondylolysis) at L5 level, opera-
tions were performed for persistent disabling low back pain. Direct
repair is indicated only in the absence of disc degeneration or radi-
culopaty. Each patient had an MRI which included T1- and T2-
weighted scans with axial views of the pedicles. Direct repair of a
defect in the pars interarticularis was performed with use of bone-
grafting and internal fixation with a pedicle screw, rod, and laminar
hook in order to achieve a higher prevalence of osseous union than
that achieved with commonly used procedures.
Conclusion: This technique offers the advantage of being a dynamic
motion preservation solution, it can be performed using a great
number of available spinal instrumentations using rods and pedicle
screws. There is no violation of the neural canal. No postoperative
brace was used, return to everyday life avoiding low back stress was
immediate, and return to work or sports was possible 3 to 6 months
after the procedure. This technique seems safe and effective but needs
careful selection of patients, as do all other techniques for direct
repair of pars interarticularis screw fixation is a safe and reliable
method of treatment for painful spondylolysis
750 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
54
LUMBAR SYNOVIAL CYST: OUR EXPERIENCE
AND METANALISYS OF LITERATURE
M. Ganau, F. Ennas*, G. Bellisano�, G. Faa�, A. Maleci
Chair of Neurosurgery, *Dept of Orthopaedics,�Institute of Anatomic Pathology - University of Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: Symptomatic lumbar synovial cysts (LSC) are rare
(incidence: 0,02-0,8%), their diameter may range between 5 mm and
2-3 cm, contributing significantly to the narrowing of the spinal canal,
and lateral thecal sac or nerve root compression. From a histological
perspective true synovial cysts have a thick wall lined by synovial
cells, containing granulation tissue, numerous histiocytes, and giant
cells; in contrast pseudo cysts lack a specialised epithelium, they have
a collagenous capsule filled with a mixoid material and may be
classified into ganglion cysts: originating from periarticular fibrous
tissues, and ligamentous cysts: arising from ligamentum flavum or
even from posterior longitudinal ligament.
Pathogenesis and biomechanics implications of LSC are not well
elucidated; moreover there is still a lack of consensus over the best
management since conservative treatment or surgical indication are
still controversial. Clinical results are reported in the form of small
series or case reports, while we see an ever growing number of facet
joint steroid injections, sometimes without a clear rationale, and
generally responsible for poor long lasting benefits (pain resolution in
only 1=3 of patient at 6 mos).
Herein we describe the surgical series of the Chair of Neurosur-
gery at the University of Cagliari, and match our results with those
from a metanalysis of the literature.
Materials and Methods: Between 2000 and 2006, we have surgically
treated fourteen LSC (7 women and 5 men; age: 58-76 years) pre-
senting with chronic low back pain (9), motor deficits (2) or cauda
equina syndrome (1). Diagnosis was obtained by MRI or CT scans,
showing LSC located at: L4-L5 (9), L3-L4 (3), L5-S1 (2); two
patients presented contiguous cysts on adjacent spine levels, no cases
of bilateral cysts were encountered. Facet sparing excision of LSC
was achieved by small hemilaminectomy in all patients.
Results: Our cohort experienced a complete resolution of symptoms
(MacNab: excellent), without perioperative complications, nor
regrowth of cysts or vertebral instability at follow up (*28 mos).
Diagnosis was confirmed by histological specimen examination
which detected the typical synovial epithelium, the intracystic pres-
ence of haemosiderin, histiocytes and calcifications. Immuno-
histochemical investigation revealed a positive stain for CK 5, 6,
AE1-AE3.
Metanalysis of literature was conducted from 1987 up to the
present: we were able to collect a total of 719 LSC surgically
treated and histologically confirmed. LSC appear to be correlated
to degenerative spondilolisthesis (Meyerding: I), rheumatoid
arthritis, and condrocalcinosis. Low back pain or radiculopathy are
often the only clinical findings (45%), less frequently patients
complain of motor deficits (35%) or cauda equina syndromes (5%);
lastly the onset with intra-cystic haemorrhage is rare: only 24 cases
described
Surgical excision seems to guarantee excellent results in 80-90%
of patients, with complication rate\3%. Arthrodesis rate account for
7% of all procedures, and is performed only in case of facetectomy or
evidence of preoperative instability. We did not find significant dif-
ferences in clinical outcomes between en bloc vs gross total cysts
excision, nor between endoscopic vs open surgery, or fusion vs
laminectomy/laminotomy alone.
Conclusions: Both clinical and histological findings described
in our study contribute to enrich the still limited amount of data
found in literature. Moreover our experience confirms the efficacy
of open surgical removal of symptomatic LSC, and particularly we
advocate the facet sparing technique as the one of choice.
55
MODIFIED WILTSE APPROACH FOR DTO
IMPLANTATION
P. Cervellini, L. Rossetto, L. Gazzola, G. Zambon
Department of Neurosurgery City Hospital, Vicenza, Italy
Introduction: Early degeneration of a adjacent disc to a fused area
may occur.
To avoid this problem many surgeons extend fusion to adjacent grade
2-3 Pfirmann disc degeneration.
We are using DTO for degenerative discopathy with a modified
Wiltse approach since 2007.
Materials: Surgical indicatin was:
1) Grade 1 spondylolisthesis
2) Severe discopathy
3) FBSS
All them associated with 1 or 2 discs degenerated.
Results: All the patients underwent VAS (visual analogue scale) test
before and after surgery with pain reduction, even after 6 months.
We also noticed a reduction in blood loss during this kind of surgery
and a minimal muscular trauma at MRI controls.
56
PLIF WITH TRABECULAR METAL: LONG-TERM
RESULTS
F. Postacchini*, G. Cinotti*, E. Ferrari*, S. Faraglia*, R.Postacchini**
*Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University ‘‘Sapienza’’,Rome, Italy; **Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University‘‘Tor Vergata’’, Rome, Italy
In the last 15 years, interbody fusions (PLIF or TLIF) have usually
been performed using intersomatic cages of various materials, filled
with autologous bone graft. In most cases, satisfactory clinical results
have been obtained. However, several experimental studies have
shown that interbody fusion may not occur with cages since the bone
graft may be replaced by dense fibrous tissue, probably due to the
stress-shilding to which it is submitted because of the rigidity of the
implant. An alternative to cages is represented by implants of tra-
becular metal (tantalum), which has a modulus of elasticity very
similar to that of bone, thus being able to undergo a good
osteointegration.
This study was aimed at evaluating the long-term clinical and
imaging (x-ray and MRI) results of PLIF carried out with trabecular
metal.
Materials and Methods: Between 1996 and 2002, an instru-
mented PLIF using blocks of tabecular metal was performed in 22
patients (14 males and 8 females, with a mean age of 52 years)
who had degenerative spondylolisthesis with or without lumbar
stenosis (14 cases), degenerative disc disease (5 cases) or isthmic
spondylolisthesis (3 cases). Interbody fusion was carried out at L4-
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 751
123
L5 in 15 cases, L3-L4 in 5 and L5-S1 in 3. One patient was fused
at 2 levels.
Patients were evaluated every 3 months in the first postoperative
year and most of them every 2 years successively. In 2008, 14
patients, who represent the clinical material of this study, were
evaluated at an average of 8,3 years after surgery. At the latter follow-
up, patients underwent clinical examination, imaging studies (x-rays
and MRI) and were asked to fill in the SF-36 and Oswestry
questionnaires.
Results: In all patients, x-rays and MR images showed a solid
fusion with no evidence of radiolucency at the bone-implant
interface or abnomalities of signal intensity of the vertebral
bones adjacent to the implant. The clinical results were rated as
excellent in 9 cases, good in 3, and fair and poor in 2, respec-
tively. In the postoperative period, out of the 14 patients, 3, who
had had a single level fusion, underwent degenerative diseases at
the vertebral level above or below the fusion after a mean interval
of 4.2 years after surgery. The 3 patients developed lumbar
stenosis, associated to degenerative spondylolisthesis in 1, at the
level above the fusion. All 3 patients underwent repeat surgery,
consisting in decomopression in 2 and decompression and fusion
in 1.
Conclusions: Intersomatic implants of trabecular metal appear to be
highly effective in obtaining fusion in the lumbar spine. The low
rigidity of the material appears to allow better osteointegration
compared to the cages. The incidence of degenerative diseases at the
levels adjacent to the arthrodesis is higher compared to that occurring,
in our experience, following posterolateral fusion; based on the
numbers available, we cannot determine whether it is also higher than
instrumented interbody fusion with cages.
57
140 CASES OF LUMBAR SPINAL FUSION
WITH SFS INSTRUMENTATION: PRELIMINARY
RESULTS OF A MULTICENTRIC STUDY
C. Ruosi1, D. Maglione1, M. Balsano2, M. Crostelli3,M. Costaglioli4, P. P. Mura4, B. Misaggi5, T. C. Russo6,S. Savino7
1Napoli; 2Schio-Thiene (VI); 3Roma; 4Cagliari; 5Milano; 6Ragusa;7Latina, Italy
SFS by Blackstone is one of the different spine instrumentations for
back surgery, performed both for short fusions (degenerative lumbar
pathologies, spondilolystesis, dorsolumbar fractures or metastasis)
and long fusions (scoliosis and kifosis).
It’s made of alloy titanium and is composed by self-tapping tulip
mono and multi- axial tulip screw and a large choice of hooks. The
longitudinal bars have a diameter of 5,5 mm with a length range from
40 to 200 mm., and, if necessary, there is the possibility to have a
measure of 450 mm and 600 mm for longer stabilizations.
Together with a group of orthopaedics and neurosuregeons from
several Italian centers we decided to define a study protocol to
demonstrate the reliability and the versatility of these new instru-
ments too.
The multicentric non-randomized controlled study started in 2007
and concerned the surgical treatment of lumbar degenerative pathol-
ogies with back fusion. The aim is to evaluate the results of the treated
patients in a short (3 months), medium (one year) and long term
(3-5 years).
Among 140 patients treated in the various centers between July
2007 and November 2008, 80 of them with at least 6 months of
follow-up have been chosen. We report the preliminary results related
to this group of patients that were evaluated after about 10 months
from the operation (range: 6 to 16 months)
We performed a clinical (Oswestry Scale, low back pain/disabil-
ity, l’SF-36 e il VAS score), radiological, and MR evaluation.
LUMBAR SPINE – Part 3
58
UP TO 2-YEAR FOLLOW-UP RESULTS OF NUBAC
DISC ARTHROPLASTY: A PROSPECTIVE
WORLDWIDE MULTICENTER CLINICAL STUDY
M. Balsano1, D. Coric2, M. Songer3, H. Yuan4, L. Pimenta5,A. Reyes-Sanchez6, D. Werner7, U. Agrillo8, A. Bucciero9
1MD, UO Ortopedia, Centro Regionale di Riferimento inch.Vertebrale, Schio, Vicenza, Italy; 2MD, Carolina MedicalCenter, Charlotte, NC, USA; 3MD, Ken Davenport, MD;Orthopaedic Surgery Associates of Marquette, Marquette, MI,USA; 4MD, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY,USA; 5MD, PhD, Santa Rita Hospital, Sao Paulo, Brazil; 6MD,Instituto de Ortopedia, Division de Cirugia Especial, Mexico City,Mexico; 7MD, Arkade Private Hospital, Breitungen, Germany;8MD, Sandro Petrini Hospital, Rome, Italy; 9MD, Clinica PinetaGrande, Casturno, Italy
Introduction: Disc arthroplasty is gaining popularity in treating low
back pain caused by degenerative disc disease. Disc arthroplasty can
be divided into total disc replacement and nucleus replacement or
intradiscal arthroplasty. Comparing to total disc replacement, nucleus
replacement could have the advantages of less invasive, less surgical
risk, faster post-operative recovery and non-bridge-burning. NU-
BACTM is the first PEEK-on-PEEK articulating intradiscal
arthroplasty device. After successful completion of pre-clinical design
verification and validation, this study has been initiated to assess the
clinical and economic outcomes of this PEEK-on-PEEK intradiscal
arthroplasty device.
Methods: An ongoing prospective, worldwide multi-center clinical
study which includes patients enrolled both outside of US and inside
of US as a part of an IDE study.
All inclusive 219 patients with main indication of discogenic back
pain caused by DDD.
Intra-operative and post-operative vascular and neurological
complications as well as ODI and VAS scores at pre-op, 6w, 3 m,
6 m, 12 m and 24 m were recorded. In addition, operation time and
the length of hospital stay were recorded to gain preliminary
knowledge on the economic benefits. A total of 225 NUBAC devices
have been implanted in 219 patients since December 2004. The
average age was approximately 41 years with a near even distribution
between males (49%) and females (51%). All three different surgical
approaches, posterior (52%), lateral (14%), and anterolateral (34%),
were used in this series. Six patients had two-level implantation and
the remaining had single level implantation. The majority of
implantations were on L4/5 (52%) and L5/S1 (42%) levels with the
remaining on L3/4 and L2/3 levels.
Results: The average operating time was 103 minutes and average
EBL 71 cc. No major intra-operative and post-operative vascular and
neurological complications occurred in this series. Most patients were
discharged from the hospital within1-2 days. Early clinical results
showed that good pain relief and improvement in function was
752 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
established and maintained from six weeks through 2 years (Fig-
ure 1). Disc height and the segment mobility and stability were also
maintained.
Conclusions: The early clinical experience demonstrated that
NUBAC performed as intended. The pain relief, improvement in
function, lack of intra-operative and postoperative neurological
complications and maintenance of the disc height suggests that NU-
BAC is a viable alternative to fusion and total disc replacement
surgery. The preliminary data on operative time and hospital dis-
charge time suggests this procedure also has economic benefits over
fusion and total disc replacement.
59
LUMBAR DISC REPLACEMENT. A 10-YEAR
EXPERIENCE
C. Formica, L. Cavaleri, M. Formica, G. Buzzi
SONG - Spinal Orthopaedical Neurosurgical Group;Alessandria – Clinica Salus - Gruppo Policlinico di Monza;Genova - Clinica Montallegro – Universita di Genova, Italy
Introduction: The treatment of low back pain due to a disc pathology
has been changed in the last years thanks to the improvement of the
biomechanical knowledge and therefore to the role of the intervertebral
disc in the segment of motion. However prosthesis and instrumentations
have had important improvements. Arthrodesis is still a diffused tech-
nique in vertebral surgery but the overloading of the discs above and
below is a common complication. The segment of motion preservation
is becoming imperative not only in young patients.
Material and Methods: From November 1998 to November 2008 we
implanted 84 lumbar disc prosthesis in 80 patients. 74 were females
and 10 males. The minimum age was 21 years old and the maximum
60 years old. The average was 40. We have never treated patients
over 60 years old neither patients with poor subcondral bone quality.
Most of the cases were primitive lumbar disc degeneration, only 14 of
the patients treated were suffering for low back pain and radicular
pain after previous surgery. In 6 cases the levels were L3L4, in 56
L4L5 and in 22 L5S1. In 4 patients we performed a 2 level disc
replacement. Charite was used in 4 cases, Prodisc in 10 and Maverick
in the remaining 70 cases (62 frontal and 8 oblique implants). The
follow up starts from a minimum of 7 months to a maximum of
10 years and 7 months.
Results: VAS and Oswestry disability index were used to evaluate the
clinical outcomes. In 95% of the cases we had excellent results with
the remission of the symptoms. We had 3 cases of abdominal muscles
paresis and 1 of these underwent an abdominal plastic reconstruction.
In 4 patients we had a paravertebral simpatic suffering with an
alteration of the thermical sensibility of the lower limb. No problems
linked to the irritation of the sacral plexus were found, neither in
males. In only 6 cases a radiological asymmetric positioning was
found, even if without symptoms. There was an important remission
of the radicular pain in the 14 cases of secondary surgery. The
complications might have been linked to the first operations since we
never have found them in the most recent cases. The weight bearing
was allowed the day after surgery with an abdominal bandage. In
most of the patients the feeling of an important and immediate clinical
changing was found. All of the patients returned back to work and
practicing sports.
Conclusions: We consider that the prosthesis with a fixed metal on
metal insert are easier to handle especially considering the surgical
implantation technique, furthermore the one with the oblique insertion
allows a less invasive mobilization of the iliac vessels above all
approaching L4L5. Despite this is an apparent invasive surgery, all of
the patients were able to walk the day after the operation and they
were discharged after 2 or 3 days. We are very satisfied of this
technique, even if a severe selection of the patients and a long
learning curve is requested.
60
DEGENERATIVE LUMBAR DISC DISEASE:
TOTAL DISC ARTHROPLASTY VS POSTERIOR
INSTRUMENTED FUSION
M. Di Silvestre, F. Lolli, A. Cioni, G. Barbanti-Brodano,S. Giacomini, P. Parisini
Spine Surgery Department; Istituti Ortopedici Rizzoli – Bologna,Italy
Background Context: Artificial disc replacement has been proposed
as a substitute for spinal fusion for the treatment of degenerative
lumbar disc disease.
Purpose: To compare the results of total disc arthroplasty and pos-
terior instrumented fusion in the treatment of monosegmental
degenerative disc disease.
Study Design: A retrospective study.
Patient Sample: A total of consecutive 46 patients (32 females and
14 males; mean age 40.9 years), all affected by monosegmental
degenerative disc disease, were included in the study.
Methods: Patients were divided into 2 groups according to surgical
treatment made. 22 patients (TDA Group) were surgically treated
with total disc arthroplasty (Maverick), 24 patients (PIF Group: 13
females and 11 male; average age 41.8 years) with a posterior
instrumented fusion (19 XIA, 5 Claris; always titanium instru-
mentation). The two groups were well matched according to age
(39.9 vs 41.8 years), gender (female: 86.4% vs 82.3%), level
treated (always L5-S1), type of degenerative disc disease (Pfirr-
mann 2 77.3% vs 75%, Pfirrmann 3 22.7% vs 25%) and follow-up
(36 vs 39 months).
Results: At an average follow-up of 38 months (range: 24 to 51),
the questionnaires showed no statistically significant differences (P
[ 0.05) between 2 groups. ODI score improved in TDA Group
from a preoperative score of 64.7% to 21.8% at last follow-up, in
PIF Group from 66.3% to 24.6%. VAS score improved in TDA
Group from 7.8 to 2.3, in PIF Group from 8.0 to 2.8. Major
complications occurred in 1 case (4.5%) in TDA Group (a per-
sistent low back pain, that required a posterior instrumented
fusion), in 2 cases (8.3%) in PIF Group (a junctional disc degen-
eration, that required an extension of fixation, and a persistent low
back pain, that required instrumentation removal).
Conclusions: These results showed that total disc arthroplasty is a
safe and effective procedure to treat the monosegmental lumbar
degenerative disc disease, ensuring clinical results superimposable to
those obtained with posterior instrumented fusion, but preserving
vertebral motion at the operated levels and with a lower complications
incidence (4.5 % vs 8.3%).
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 753
123
61
EARLY AND LATE COMPLICATION IN TDR
CHARITE’. ANTERIOR REVISION SURGERY
AFTER 7 YEARS
R. Bassani, A. Sinigaglia
Ortopedia e Traumatologia - IRCCS Policlinico S. Matteo,Pavia, Italy
The use of intervertebral disc prostheses as an alternative to spinal
fusion has been advocated to preserve segmental motion and to pre-
vent adjacent segment disease. The purpose of this paper is to
consider early (fracture of the vertebral body) and late complication
(migration) in Total disc replacement using Charite I.
A 42 years old female complained about serious low back pain
since 15 years. No benefit from medical treatment and physiotherapy
(ODI 68% - VAS 9). MRI: DDD L5-S1
She was operated in June 1999 for TDR (Charite I) L5-S1.
Immediately in the post op period complained of persistent sciatica
without any benefit from NSAID and Steroids. Plain films showed a
bad positioning of the prostheses (too much posterior) and a minimal
posterior body fracture with a small fragment displaced in the canal.
In 5� day post op she was operated from posterior: flavectomy, nerve
root decompression and minimal repositioning toward of the front
with partial resolution of the symptoms.
Because of severe low back pain and leg pain the patient was again
operated in 2004 from posterior with monolateral PL fusion without
relief of pain. Plain Xrays showed from 1999 to 2004 progressive
anterior migration of the prostheses. No evidence of fusion after the
last posterior surgery.
In 2006 the patient came to our Department. VAS was 8 and ODI
75%. Plain films showed no evidence of fusion and further migration
of the prostheses.
Our strategy was anterior revision: removal of the prostheses and
anterior interbody fusion with tantalum implant, BMP and Calcibone
(TCP).
Fusion was complete one year later, well shown by Xrays and
MRI as well as pain desappeared.
Follow up is now 2 years and half. VAS is 2 and ODI 20%.
Total disc replacement implant revisions occurs largely as a result
of technical errors in positioning and sizing of the implant. Anterior
revision surgery for TDR failure is a challenging and demanding
procedure. Anyway an interbody fusion, after removal of the pros-
theses, could lead to a good primary stability and healing. Tantalum
implants, according to literature, require less bone graft and less time-
in presence of a stable construct-to achieve bone healing.
References:
1. Regan JJ. Clinical results of Charithe lumbar TDR. Othop Clin
North Am 2005;36: 323-40
2. David T, Lemaire JP, Moreno P, Lumbar disc prostheses: an
analysis of long term complications for 272 SB Charite disc
prostheses with minimum 10 year follow up. Spine J 2004; 4
(suppl):50-1
3. Scott-Young M. Revision strategies for total lumbar disc
replacement. Spine J 2004; 4 (suppl) 115
4. McAfee PC, Geisler FH, Saiedy S, et al Revisability of the
Charithe artificial disc replacement: an analysis of 688 patients
enrolled in the US. IDE study of the Charithe artificial disc. Spine
2006; 31:1217-26
5. Steiber JR, Donald GD III, Early failure of lumbar disc
replacement: case report and review of the literature. J Spinal
Disord Tech 2006; 19: 55-60
62
NUCLEUS DISC ARTHROPLASTY WITH THE
NUBACTM DEVICE: PRELIMINARY CLINICAL
EXPERIENCE
F. Milia, C. Doria, M. Balsano1, L. Tidu, A. Zachos,A. Ruggiu, P. Tranquilli-Leali
Orthopaedic Department - University of Sassari – Italy;1Orthopaedic Department - Hospital of Schio - Italy
Introduction: Back pain due to degenerative disc disease is a com-
mon condition that can be treated along a continuum of care: from
conservative therapies to several surgical choices. Conservative care
focuses on pain relieving that can be achieved by drugs administration
(NSAIDS-steroidal drugs), physical therapy and orthesis. The basic
goal in decompression procedures is to reduce or stop the pain by
taking off pressure on pinched nerves and, eventually, providing
fusion of the affected segment. Nucleus replacement is an intriguing
technology that could potentially fill part of the gap in the spine
continuum of care. The introduction of recent technologies that allow
the replacement of the degenerated disc nucleus using prosthetic
systems, may be considered an additional therapeutic tool that can be
used by the surgeon in selected cases of back pain due to degenerative
disc disease. Nucleus replacement products are designed to treat early
stage degenerative disc disease, which is one of the most common
spine disorders in the population under 65 years of age. This, com-
bined with an increasing desire to move away from invasive, motion
limiting procedures such as fusion, and a growing patient base in an
aging population, may propel this technology to the forefront of spine.
Nucleus replacement could help redefine the continuum of care by
broadening the focus to include not only early diagnosis of degen-
erative disc disease, but also a reduction in the need for surgical
procedures performed further down the continuum of care.
Materials and Methods: NUBAC is the first articulating nucleus disc
prosthesis, designed to optimally respect the lumbar anatomy, kine-
matics and biomechanics, constructed in a unique two-piece design of
a polyetheretherketone (PEEK) with an inner ball/socket articulation.
The racetrack geometry provides a large contact area designed to
distribute the load, reduce the contact stress and, subsequently, mit-
igate the risk of subsidence. The optimal indications for NUBAC
implantation are: disc height[9 mm, degenerative disc changes at an
early stage (Pfirmann 1-2 - max 3), single level affection, integrity of
articular posterior elements, lack of local anatomical contraindication,
patient non responder to conservative treatment for at least 6 months.
Results: From December 2006 to January 2008, a total of 16 patients
underwent nucleus disc arthroplasty with the NUBAC device. There
have been no major intra-operative or post-operative vascular or
neurological complications in this series. The data showed that there
were significant decreases in both VAS and ODI after the procedure,
expression of a significant improvement of symptoms in all patients.
The average VAS score increased from a preoperative value of 7.1 to
a post-operative of 1.0 after 24 months. The average ODI score
increased from a preoperative value of 58 to a post-operative of 7.0
after 24 months.
Conclusions: Although preliminary, the initial results are very
encouraging. The absence of any major intra-operative and post-
operative vascular and neurological complications supports the design
rationale of the NUBAC being less invasive and of less surgical risk.
The initial effectiveness data as seen in the significant improvements
on both VAS and ODI have also suggested that the NUBAC could be
a viable treatment option for patients with low-back pain caused by
degenerative disc disease.
754 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
CERVICAL SPINE – Part 1
63
FIVE-YEAR OUTCOME OF STAND-ALONE
FUSION USING CARBON CAGES IN CERVICAL
DISK ARTHROSIS
N. Marotta, A. Landi, G. Rocchi, R. Tarantino, C. Mancarella,C. Delfinis, R. Delfini
Department of Neurological Science, Division of Neurosurgery,University of Rome ‘‘Sapienza’’, Italy
From 1 January 2001 to 31 December 2003, In the Neurosurgery
Department of Rome University o ‘‘Sapienza’’, 167 patients under-
went anterior surgery for cervical spondylodiscoarthrosis
Materials and Methods: The levels treated by the anterior stand-
alone technique were: C3-C4 (11%), C4-C5 (19%), C5-C6 (40%),
C6-C7 (30 %). All patients underwent left anterior presternocleido-
mastoid - precarotid approach, microdiskectomy and interbody fusion
using a carbon fiber cage filled with hydroxyapatite. All patients were
discharged within 48 hours after surgery with cervical orthosis. In one
case a hematoma of the surgical site occurred within 12 hours of
surgery; for this reason the patient underwent surgical revision and
was discharged 4 days later. All patients have worn cervical orthosis
for a mean period of 7 weeks and underwent radiological follow-up
with cervical RX at 1 month and 3 months after surgery. All patients
underwent follow-up from 54 to 90 months after surgery, and all of
them underwent cervical RX, cervical CT scans for the estimate of
fusion, and evaluation of neurological status using VAS and NDI.
Results: Of 167 patients, 119 were cooperative for this study, 18 were
non-cooperative, and 17 died. The estimation of fusion made by
cervical CT scans with sagittal reconstruction, showed complete os-
teointegration of the cage in 103 patients (83%), while it showed
pseudoarthrosis in 24 patients (17%). In 24 patients we observed
adjacent segment degeneration, and 13 of these underwent new sur-
gical procedures in our institute or in another hospital. Clinical
evaluation with VAS and NDI showed a good outcome, with poorest
benefit in patients over 60 years.
Conclusions: Our clinical analysis showed a good fusion rate in
according with literature, 13% of non fusion rate without clinical
evidence and 20% of ASDegeneration but only 10% had required new
surgery. We also observed that patients over 60’s had less satisfactory
outcome, probably related with the evolution of pathophysiological
degeneration of the cervical spine. In our opinion pseudoarthrosis is
caused by malpositioning of the carbon fiber cage.
64
SPINAL SURGERY OF THE CERVICO-THORACIC
JUNCTION: MULTICENTRIC EXPERIENCE
A. Ramieri, M. Domenicucci*, P. Ciappetta**, G. Costanzo***
Orthopaedics, The Don Gnocchi Foundation; * Neurosurgery,Rome University ‘‘La Sapienza’’; ** Neurosurgery, BariUniversity; *** Orthopaedics, Rome University ‘‘La Sapienza’’,Italy
Surgical treatment of the cervico-thoracic junction (CTj) in the
spine requires special evaluation due to the anatomical and
biomechanical characteristics of this spinal section. The transitional
zone between the mobile cervical spine and the relatively rigid
thoracic spine is the site of serious unstable traumas or neoplastic
lesions, frequently associated with neurological impairment due to
the smaller canal caliber and/or the spinal cord vascular insuffi-
ciency. We considered 32 lesions of the CTj (trauma=22,
tumour=8, infection=2) treated by means of different type of pos-
terior instrumentation (hooks, transarticular and traspedicular
screws, wires, dual diameter rods). All cases had significant neu-
rological deficits. The surgical procedure was posterior in 28 cases
and combined in 4. Follow-up evaluation showed an improvement
of neurological deficits in 19 patients (60%), with good stability of
all implants and without significant back pain.
In our experience, neurological results in the surgical treatment of
CTj lesions are often unsatisfactory, due to the initial serious impair-
ment. On the contrary, the recovery of the spinal stability seems to be
essential to avoid disability due to back pain. There is no type of
instrumentation more effective than other. In each single lesion, the
most suitable type of instrumentation should be employed, considering
the familiarity of the spinal surgeon with different types of implants and
the morphological and biomechanical features of the damage.
65
ANTERIOR CERVICAL FUSION WITH A BIO-
RESORBABLE COMPOSITE CAGE (BETA TCP –
PLLA): CLINICAL AND CT SCAN RESULTS FROM
A PROSPECTIVE STUDY ON 20 PATIENTS AT 3
YEARS FOLLOW-UP
S. Aunoble1, F. Debusscher1, D. Clement2, J. C. Le Huec1
Bordeaux 2 University, spine unit 2, CHU Pellegrin, Amelie-RabaLeon state 33000 Bordeaux, DETERCA surgical lab,BORDEAUX Cedex France; 2SBM, ZI du Monge, 65100Lourdes, France
Background: A resorbable composite material (40 % PLLA and 60%
beta TCP) with a high breaking strength and capacity to withstand
plastic and elastic strain has been developed for cervical interbody
fusion.
Objective: To evaluate clinical and radiological results of 20 patients
implanted with 27 cages (mean follow-up: 27 months).
Methods: Clinical (neck disability index, VAS, neurological evalu-
ation) and radiological (anteroposterior, lateral, bending X rays) data
were assessed before and after surgery. At the end of the study, CT
scan was performed to evaluate fusion, resorption of the cage and
density of new tissue substituting the cage.
Results: The mean patient age was 50.3 years (range 18 to79 y). The
average improvement was 55% for neck pain, 83% for arm pain and
65% for NDI, with 85% good or excellent results at final outcomes.
Radiologically, lordosis was significantly improved (mean gain of
5.4� and 3.7� for overall and segmental lordosis respectively). This
correction was conserved in 95% of cases. Fusion was obtained in
96% (CT evaluation). Resorption was started in all cases and com-
pleted in an average of 36 month after surgery.
The mean density of tissue substituting the cage was 659 UH with a
range of 455 to 911 UH (compatible with bone nature). Over time the
amount of bony tissue increased and the graft remodelled with an
increase in density value. This demonstrates a biological activity and
changing bone mineral content of this tissue.
Conclusion: The new composite cage under investigation provides
long term fusion without loss of correction or inflammatory reaction.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 755
123
The ceramic block guarantees the maintenance of the disc height and
its slow resorption allows long term fusion and stability with good
and reliable clinical and radiological outcomes.
CERVICAL SPINE – Part 2
66
TRANSPEDUNCULAR SCREW FIXATION
FOR CERVICAL STABILIZATION
M. Ganau, F. Ennas*, A. Medda, A. Maleci
Chair of Neurosurgery and *Dept of Orthopaedics -University of Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: For decades cervical instability related to degenerative,
neoplastic or traumatic diseases has been managed by anterior sur-
gical approaches, but the recent availability of specific
instrumentation has opened new frontiers also for posterior approa-
ches. When compared from a biomechanical perspective, posterior
approaches appear to be more appropriate, especially for the treat-
ment of two or more vertebral segments. Nevertheless, while
transarticular screw placement, as described by several authors, does
not provide an optimal stability, particularly in case of bone fragility,
transpeduncular screw fixation seems to be more effective, as estab-
lished by experimental studies that have confirmed their higher
biomechanical stability.
Even though, up to 1991, Roy Camille has stated that transpe-
duncular screw fixation harboured an unacceptable risk of
neurovascular complications, since the late nineties many authors
have described their experience with this technique reporting excel-
lent results with few drawbacks.
This retrospective study, conducted at the Chair of Neurosurgery
at the University of Cagliari, focuses on the surgical results obtained
with transpeduncular screw fixation for cervical instability.
Materials and Methods: Between 2001 and 2008, 42 patients
admitted at our institution have required posterior stabilization for
cervical instability related to: degenerative mielopathy (C 3 levels) in
31 cases, post-traumatic instability in 7 cases, and bone metastasis in
4 cases.
Every patient underwent axial CT scan preoperatively, in order to
evaluate orientation and width of peduncles, and postoperatively to
confirm the correct screw placement. Arthrodesis was always performed
with Neon system (Ulrich, Germany) without neuronavigation; during
surgery sagittal orientation of the screws was assessed by radiofluores-
cence control, while a specific protractor guided their lateral orientation.
Results: In every case peduncles were large enough to allow the
placement of 3,5 mm screws, for a total of 196 screws. Inclination
of peduncles ranged between 30� to 48� at C3-C6, and between
21� to 33� at C7. No intraoperative complications were encoun-
tered; but 7 patients complained of transitory radicular deficits.
Postoperative CT scans detected incorrect positioning of 17 screws,
without any need for replacement. Every patient showed an optimal
cervical stability at follow-up radiographic examination (range 6-78
mos).
Conclusions: Our experience confirms the feasibility and efficacy
of transpeduncular screw fixation for cervical instability. The risk
of iatrogenic neurovascular damage, even if not higher than other
posterior techniques, has always to be considered; since only a
tailored presurgical planning can reduce it.
67
ANALYSIS OF THE PERIOPERATIVE
COMPLICATIONS DURING THE CERVICAL DISC
PROSTHESIS SURGERY
A. A. Rocca, L. Attuati, M. Medone, P. Castellazzi – IRCCS SanRaffaele – Milan – Italy
Introduction: The increasing number of the operation for cervical
disc prosthesis is based on the need to preserve a range of motion after
discectomy. To day, mobile cervical prosthesis allow an easy posi-
tioning without increasing of surgical time. But as in the classic
discectomy and arthrodesis so this operation may cause complications
in the perioperative periods.
Methods: In our opinion and according to Goffin et al. a classification
of complications shoul consider five main ‘‘steps’’ :
1. the ‘‘step’’ of indications (=wrong indications)
2. the surgical ‘‘step’’ conditioning the intra-operative conplications
(1 to 30 days) represented by dysphagia, laryngeal nerve palsy,
soft-tissue hematoma, esophageal or dural perforation
3. the ‘‘step’’ of the early complications (1 to 6 months) represented
by wound infection, prosthesis migration, worsening of the
symptoms.
4. The ‘‘step’’ of the intermediate follow-up (6 to 60 months) with
complications represented by subsidence, osteolysis, heterotopic
ossification.
5. For the five ‘‘step’’ or ‘‘long time follow up’’, literature lack of a
consistent number of reports
Results: In a period lasting from 2003 to 2007 we have operated
on 23 patients with herniated cervical disc by a discectomy and
cervical disc prosthesis positioning with Bryan prosthesis in 16
cases and Mobi C prosthesis in 7 cases. Median age of the patients
was 45 years (range 29-56) and male:female ratio was 11:12.
Indications to operation were: age between 20 and 70 years, her-
niated cervical disc (at 1 level between C3 and T1) showed at MRI
or CT scan images, cervical radicular pain consistent with level
and side of the disc affected and not responsive to at least 6 weeks
of steroid or analgesic drugs.
In our experience there were no main complications. In 1 patient we
observed prosthesis migration after 4 months by implant.
Conclusions: We analyzed literature data and the results of our
experience
Intermediate follow-up after treatment of degenerative disc disease
with the Bryan Cervical Disc Prosthesis: single-level and bi-level.
Goffin J, Van Calenbergh F, van Loon J, Casey A, Kehr P, Liebig
K, Lind B, Logroscino C, Sgrambiglia R, Pointillart V. Spine. 2003
Dec 15; 28(24):2673-8.
68
HETEROTOPIC OSSIFICATION FOLLOWING
CERVICAL ARTHROPLASTY. ANALYSIS OF 30
PATIENTS WITH 2-3 YEARS FOLLOW-UP
V. Albanese, L. Corbino, G. Olindo, V. Russo, N. Platania,G. Barbagallo
Department of Neurosurgery, Azienda Ospedaliero-UniversitariaPoliclinico, Catania, Italy
Introduction: It remains uncertain whether or not heterotopic ossi-
fication (HO) after arthroplasty retains any clinical relevance.
756 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
Materials and Methods: 30 patients (18 males), with a mean age of
40.9 years, underwent cervical arthroplasty because of radiculopathy
(n. 13), myelopathy (n.4) or myeloradiculopathy (n.13) due to disc
hernia (n.17), spondylosis (n.8) or both of them (n.5). We treated 1
level in 19 cases, 2 levels in 7 patients and three levels in 4 patients,
with a total of 45 disc prostheses (7 Prestige LP e 38 Prodisc C). The
distribution of devices/level is as follows: C3-C4:5; C4-C5:4; C5-
C6:23; C6-C7:13. SF-36 and NDI questionnaires were used, before
and after surgery, for clinical and functional assessment. Preopera-
tively, all patients were assessed by x-rays, with flexion-extension
views, CT and MR. Patients were followed-up by x-rays and CT scan,
when clinically required.
Follow-up ranges from 24 months (16 patients) to 4 years (1 patient),
mean 36.1 months.
The McAfee classification was used to quantify the presence of
HO/level. The surgical technique used in both groups of patients is the
standard one described for each disc prosthesis.
Results: 19 levels (in 16 patients) presented different degrees of HO
(42.2%): grade 2 in 8 levels, grade 3 in 10 levels and grade 4 in one
level only.
In 10 patients we observed HO’s progression over the months; in 6
patients HO presented de novo several months after surgery (from 23
to 46 months, mean 33.3 months).
In patients without HO (n.14), preoperative SF-36 values were PH:
39.4 e MH:44.3; the NDI value was 43.1. At 36-month-follow-up the
same values were 83.9, 74.1 and 7.3.
In 16 patients with HO, preoperative values were PH: 42.5,
MH:7.1; NDI was 32.7. At 36-month-follow-up the same values were
PH:71.7, MH: 68.9; NDI:8.8.
No patients required further surgery, neither for revision nor for
adjacent segment disease.
Discussion and Conclusions: No specific protocols to prevent HO
was used in our series. In most of the cases, HO was shown anteriorly
to disc prostheses. No signficant differences were demonstrated
between disc hernia vs spondylosis in patients with or without HO.
HO’s causes remain uncertain. No significant clinical and functional
differences were demonstrated in patients with or without HO.
In 15/16 patients (93.75%) with HO disc prostheses remain mobile.
Therefore, HO does not seem to alter the clinical and functional
results and, hence, the indications to arthroplasty.
We analyse potential causes for HO with reference to the surgical
technique and discuss possible surgical strategies to prevent HO.
69
60 PATIENTS FOLLOW-UP, FROM 6 MONTHS
TO 2 YEARS, IN PATIENTS TREATED
WITH DISCOVER� ARTHROPLASTY
AFTER DISCECTOMY AND PRELIMINARY
COMPARISON WITH DISCECTOMY AND FUSION
AND DISCECTOMY ALONE
G. Maida*, F. Garofano*, S. Sarubbo*, M. A. Cavallo*
*University-Hospital S.Anna - Division of Neurosurgery -Ferrara – Italy
The fusion procedure, after anterior cervical decompression, seems to
allow the better neuroradiological and clinical results in the treatment
of cervical discoarthrosis, even if the debate is still opened. The
anterior cervical fusion, performed with bone, cages or locking plates,
avoids kyphosis but can produce immobilization of the interested
cervical tract and symptomatic junctional disease. So, many authors
suggest cervical arthroplasty may be the best solution to preserve
motion and lordosis of the cervical tract.
We present our case series of 60 patients undergone to cervical
discectomy and arthroplasty (Discover �) with follow-up ranging
between 6 to 29 months. We obtained a good and steady clinical
outcome in all the patients with arthroplasty after discectomy. In all
patients the two-years morphodynamic X-rays and MRIs showed
preservation of motion and physiological cervical lordosis, absence of
junctional disease without foraminal narrowing. After 24 months, we
didn’t find any significant clinical and neuroradiological difference in
the results obtained in patients treated with discectomy and arthro-
plasty vs discectomy and fusion. The kyphosis discovered in
discectomy and fusion was clinical manifest only in 1 of 60 patients,
with junctional disease too. Yet Patients treated with atrhroplasty
referred, instead, the best satisfaction. Moreover, we found significant
better outcome in respect to patients treated with discectomy alone, in
which we reported seven cases of kyphosis clinical manifest (about
11.6%). In the patients underwent atrhroplasty we didn’t report any
surgical complication or artificial cervical disc displacement.
Our follow-up is, of course, too short to be conclusive and the
debate remain opened but we consider cervical atrhroplasty a good,
safe and really effective option to fusion and the best treatment in
respect to cervical discectomy alone.
70
A NEW SOMATIC CERVICAL PROSTHESIS.
PRELIMINAR EXPERIENCE
A. Solini, G. Gargiulo
U.O. Ortopedia - A.S.O.S. Giovanni Battista Molinette, Turin,Italy
The Authors bring the results to short and middle term of a new
prosthesis of the cervical vertebral body replacement that finds indi-
cation in the somatectomies for the treatment of degenerative
pathologies (mielopaty or foraminal stenosis of two adjacent levels),
for primitive os secondary tumors, for cervical deformities results of
fractures or infections and in the treatment of somatic fractures. The
prosthesis represents the evolution with innovative characteristics of
the conceived one and described by the elderly author in 1994 already
applied in more than 200 cases. The prosthesis is constituted by a rigid
titanium body, full or cable, that allows the simple reconstruction of
the size of the vertebra and to perform an interbody fusion, available in
different dimensions in length and width. Of simple and rapid appli-
cation the prosthesis is inserted after preparing the lodging in the
vertebral body and determined the dimensions with a witness of test.
The prosthesis is definitely fixed to the adjoining vertebral segments
by 4 screws endowed through 2 holes in the anterior proximal and
distal fins with which the prosthesis takes contact with the anterior
surface of the neighboring vertebral bodies. In the cases of cable
prosthesis the fusion is performed through bone chips from iliac crest
or vertebral body resected pushed in the empty body, taking rela-
tionships with the neighboring vertebral dishes through the open
proximal and distal surfaces of the prosthetic body.The prosthesis has
been used in 23 patients of age middle 53 years (31 -71) affected from
metastasis (11), degenerative pathology (8), deformity from infection
(1), somatic fractures (3). The patients have been mobilized in 2� p-op.
day wearing a collar for 30 ggs in cases with fusion. At a 3 y, f.up (1 -5)
in all the cases the prosthesis appeared stable. In the patients fused the
osseous continuity has been underline in TC with the neighboring
levels. In conclusion the new cervical prosthesis has dimostrated at
short and medium term to give stability to cervical spine trough a
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 757
123
simple and fast surgical procedure like the previous one but it offers a
wider surgical application concurring to carry out fusion when indi-
cated assuring stability in the time.
TUMOURS
71
PERCUTANEOUS TREATMENT OF VERTEBRAL
OSTEOID OSTEOMA WITH RADIOFREQUENCY
THERMAL ABLATION
U. Albisinni, M. Chiatante, M. C. Malaguti
Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology,Bologna, Italy
Introduction: The percutaneous treatment of osteoid osteoma (OO)
with thermal ablation with radiofrequency (RFTA) is actually the first
choice in the treatment of non-vertebral OO.
In this work we present our experience in the treatment of vertebral
localization of this pathology.
Material and Methods: From November 2002 until June 2007 we
have treated at Rizzoli Orthopaedic Institute 34 patients (23 male and
11 female) with vertebral OO, never treated before.
The patients were between 8 and 48 years old (middle age: 23,4).
The diagnosis was made on clinical and radiological (RX, bone
scan, CT, MRI) examinations; it was confirmed histologically in 18
cases.
The percutaneous treatment of vertebral OO with RFTA needs to
pay attention to the narrowness of vasculo-nervous structures and
spinal cord. Therefore we performed this procedure only under deep
general sedation and local infiltration of anesthetics; the mean dura-
tion was around 90 minutes.
We used under CT guidance a bone bioptic set with 14G cannula
to place the monopolar needle electrode into the ‘‘nidus’’. We
delivered RF for 2 minutes at 60�C. The time of RF delivery was
between 8 and 30 minutes with a temperature not below 90�C.
Our tools include a non cooled monopolar electrode, 0.35 mm
calibre, 145 mm length with active tip of 5,10 or 15 mm with dis-
posable cannula of 20G.
Results: 31 patients have been treated successfully after the first time;
a second procedure was necessary in 3 cases and was successful
twice. In the remaining case, the recurrence occurred because a
suitable dose of RF could not be delivered due to the impossibility to
the patient to bear the pain.
Conclusions: The first treatment with percutaneous RFTA of OO was
made by Rosenthal and his experience has been exhaustively reported
in literature since 1992.
Since then a lot of similar experience have been reported in literature
about the treatment of non-vertebral OO with good results.
The treatment with RFTA of vertebral OO is still uncommon
because of the narrowness of structure like vessels, nerves and spinal
cord and their high risk of damage.
The experience made on over 400 patients with OO allowed us to
create some particular technical devices to treat safely also vertebral
OO.
Our experience allows us to claim that also in vertebral OO
treatment with RFTA is a safe and effective procedure with a lot of
advantages: it is less invasive, there are fewer complications, the
patient can resume daily living activities in about 2-3 weeks, the rate
of recurrence is very low and hospital and procedure costs are lower.
72
MORBIDITY OF EN BLOC RESECTIONS IN THE
SPINE
S. Bandiera*, F. De Iure, A. Gasbarrini, M. Cappuccio,L. Amendola, R. Donthineni**, S. Boriani
*Presenting author; Ospedale Maggiore ‘‘C.A.Pizzardi’’, Bologna(Italy); **Spine & Orthopaedic Oncology, Alta Bates SummitMedical Center (USA)
Introduction: Spine tumour surgery has often a high risk of com-
plications, worse than other surgical procedures and this is
particularly true for en bloc resections.
A retrospective review of a large series of en bloc resections could be
helpful to identify risk factors and therefore to reduce the rate of
complications and to improve the outcome.
Methods: A retrospective study of 1035 patients affected by spine
tumours treated from 1990 to 2007 identified 134 patients (53.0%
male, age 44±18 years) who were submitted to en bloc resection for
primary tumours (90) and for bone metastases (44). All the clinical,
histological and radiological data were recorded since the beginning
in a specifically built database.
The prospective study was set up to correlate diagnosis, staging and
treatment with the oncologic and functional outcome recorded for all
the patients at periodical controls (follow-up from 0 to 211 months,
av. 47 months, 25th-75th percentile 22-85 months)
Results: Forty-seven on 134 patients (34.3%) encountered a total of 70
complications: 32 patients (68.1%) had one complication, while the rest
had 2 or more. There were 41 major and 29 minor complications. Three
patients (2.2%) died from complications. Sixteen (45.7%) of the 35
patients with a recurrent or contaminated tumor suffered at least one
complication; by contrast, complications appeared in 31 (31.3%) of the
99 patients who had had no previous treatment. A local recurrence was
recorded in 21 cases (15.7%). The rate of deep infection was higher in
patients who had previously undergone radiation therapy (RT), but the
global incidence of complications was lower. Re-operations were
mostly due to tumor recurrences, but also to hardware failures, wound
dehiscence, hematomas and aortic dissection.
Conclusions: En bloc resection can improve the prognosis of
aggressive benign and low-grade malignant tumors of the spine, even
if with high related morbidity, sometimes fatal.. Re-operations have
higher risks due to the dissection through scar from previous surgeries
and possibly from radiation.
The treatment of recurrent cases and planned transgression to reduce
surgical aggressiveness is associated with higher rate of local recur-
rence, the most severe complication
In terms of survival and quality of life complicated cases have
better outcomes than recurrent events. Careful planning for the
treatment and referral to a specialty center in case of uncertainty.
73
VESSEL-X IN THE TREATMENT OF VERTEBRAL
OSTEOLISI
M. Quartarone, C. Casamichele, A. Tumino, G. Incatasciato,G. Giuca, T. C. Russo
Unit of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Major Hospital ofModica, Italy
Introduction: Plastic somatic performed using a mini spinal access
(vertebrates and cifoplastica) has been widely used in the treatment of
758 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
vertebral compression fractures (VCFs) to neoplastic etiology, oste-
oporotic and / or traumatic. Starting in 2003 we used the technique of
cifoplastica and since 2004 we used the vertebroplastica in cases with
osteoporotic collapse with severe somatic deformities. The latter
technique, however, presents a significant risk of leakage. In recent
years in order to remedy this complication has developed a new
technique represented by Vessel-x that can be considered a valid
alternative to vertebroplastica. Since 2007 we have used the vessel-x
with selective indications such as spinal osteolisi.
Materials and Methods: From January 2007 until today, in our Unit
were performed 22 vessel-x for osteolisi kind of tumor. The average
age of patients was 64 years (55-80), 10 women and 4 men. The
primary locations were 9 and in 13 cases this was secondary locations.
In 14 cases the localization was to a single vertebra, were involved in
the remaining 2 or more vertebrae. Each patient was evaluated at 1, 3,
6, 12 months after surgery. Were assessed: location of pain, intensity
of pain according to VAS scale, neurological symptoms, spinal
motility, complications caused by surgery. For each control were
made rx-spellings control AP, LL. 5 of these patients have died of
complications related to the pathology of the primitive tumor
Results: The intensity of pain according to VAS scale was signifi-
cantly decreased (27 with range from 0 to 83). There were no cases of
posterior Leakage
Discussion and Conclusions: Based on the clinical and radiographic
results obtained it can be said that the vessel-x is effective and safe in
the treatment of osteolisi with and without vertebral collapse.
74
ANEURYSMAL BONE CYST OF THE MOBILE
SPINE
L. Amendola, S. Bandiera, F. De Iure, M. Cappuccio,A. Gasbarrini, S. Boriani
Ospedale Maggiore ‘‘C. A. Pizzardi’’, Bologna, Italy
Introduction: Fifty cases of aneurysmal bone cyst (ABC) of the
mobile spine were retrospectively reviewed. Our aim is to evaluate
the role of surgical and non-surgical treatment of ABC of the spine.
ABC is a pseudo-tumoral condition typical of the younger patients
and frequently involving the mobile spine. The progression of disease
and the type of treatment depends on the aggressiveness of the tumor.
Intralesional excision, radiotherapy, selective arterial embolization
(SAE), used alone or in combination, seem to be an effective
treatment.
Methods: From 1952 to 2008, fifty cases of ABC of the spine were
treated and 42 patients have follow-up greater than 24 months.
Treatment must be based on Diagnosis, Oncologic Staging (Enne-
king) and Surgical Staging (Weinstein-Boriani-Biagini). Diagnosis
can be achieved by X-ray, MRI and CT in most cases with high
reliability; biopsy is mandatory in the remaining cases. Fourteen
patients were submitted to SAE (3 of them followed by radiotherapy),
26 received radiotherapy alone (2 cases combined to palliative sur-
gery), 9 patients underwent curettage (3 of them followed by
radiotherapy) and one underwent Enbloc excision.
Results: All patients were found alive: 48 without evidence of des-
ease and two, treated by SAE, alive with desease. In this 2 cases the
residual cyst is maintained under control and not progressive any-
more. One local recurrence appeared 5 months after an incomplete
curettage and was successfully treated by radiotherapy. In our series,
curettage and radiotherapy, although effective, showed the greatest
incidence of late axial deformity.
Conclusion: Despite SAE was totally curative in 12 of 14 cases in our
series, it seems to be the first option for spine ABC. SAE is the
treatment with the best cost-to-benefit ratio and is indicated when
diagnosis is certain, when technically feasible and safe, and when no
pathologic fracture nor neurologic involvement are found. If SAE
fails, other options for treatment would still be available. In case of
pathologic fracture, neurologic involvement, high technical impossi-
bility of performing embolization, or local recurrence after at least
two embolization procedures, complete intralesional excision would
be the therapy of choice.
MINIMALLY INVASIVE TREATMENT ANDMISCELLANEOUS
75
MINIMALLY INVASIVE TREATMENT OF
THORACO-LUMBAR FRACTURES IN THE
YOUNG ADULT: OUR EXPERIENCE WITH
THE PERCUTANEOUS PROCEDURES
S. Caserta, G. A. La Maida
Hesperia Hospital. Modena, Italy; Orthopaedic Dpt. NiguardaHospital – Milan, Italy
The incidence of spinal injuries has been increasing over the last
decade and the vast majority of these are the consequence of high-
energy trauma due to a road traffic accidents, falls and sports
injuries.
Mechanical failure of the spinal column following a trauma fre-
quently occurs at the thoracolumbar junction as a result of its
transitional anatomy and biomechanical environment.
In order to well analyse and consequntly understand a spinal
fracture, it is very important to apply a comprehensive and prog-
nostic classification system. In our opinion the most useful
classification is the one proposed by Magerl et Al in 1994. The AO
classification associated with the McCormack classification points
system are, in our hand, the best way to better analyse and con-
sequently treat a spine fracture.
We report our experience in the treatment of thoracolumbar spine
fractures in the young adult by using a percutaneous approach.
We selected all the type A fractures of Patients up to 45 years of
age considering only the percutaneous approaches and we found
about twenty procedures. The surgical techniques we consider were
percutaneous vertebral augmentation by using a kyphoplasty or a
intravertebral mesh with morcelized bone graft (allograft or bone
substitutes) or bone substitute (calcium phosphate).
All Patients underwent a clinical and radiographic follow-up at 3,
6 and 12 months post-op with a minimum follow-up of six months.
The group treated with kiphoplasty had also a CT scan view of the
treated level at six months post-op.
All Patients had a good clinical and radiographic results with no
complication related to the material injected.
We concluded that very selected type A fractures of the thoraco-
lumbar spine in the young adult can be very well treated with a
percutaneous augmentation by using bone substitutes.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 759
123
76
XLIF: A NEW MINIMAL INVASIVE TECHNIQUE
TO ACHIEVE LUMBAR INTERBODY FUSION.
INDICATIONS AND PRELIMINARY RESULTS
M. Balsano, S. Caserta*, A. Villaminar, M. Comisso
U. O. Ortopedia e Traumatologia - Centro Regionale diRiferimento in Chirurgia Vertebrale - Ospedale Civile Thiene eSchio (VI); *Clinica Capitanio, Milan, Italy
Introduction: Lumbar interbody fusion represents nowadyas the
‘gold standard’ to treat different pathologies of the lumbar spine.
Scientific research has lead to find new surgical techniques that allows
to minimize the rate of complications and the length of recovery.
Xlif means Extreme Lateral Interbody Fusion. This is a new mini-
mally invasive approach to the anterior spine that avoids an incision
that traverses the abdomen and also avoids cutting the posterior
muscles of the lumbar spine.. In this fusion technique, named ALPA
approach, the disk space is accessed from a very small incision on the
flank of the patient, a couple of inches in length, occasionally with
another small incision (one inch long) just behind the first incision.
Special monitoring equipment is used to determine the proximity of
the working instruments to the nerves of the spine, because the
instruments are introduced through the psoas muscle.
With this technique the lumbar spine can be approached from L1
to L5, excluding L5-S1 for anatomic limits (iliac wings). The indi-
cations are degenerative spondylolisthesis, degenerative lumbar
scoliosis, and severe disc degeneration, or other conditions that needs
an interbody fusion of the lumbar spine.
Methods: A clinical series of 9 patients with 11 implants have been
included in this study. Patients ranged in age from 27-71 yrs. (ave
55.2). For achieving lumbar fusion and to provide primary stabil-
ization a Peek Cage (Coerent, Nuvasive, S.Diego, USA) filled with
allograft has been used.
Results: All of them showed lumbar segmental stabilization with
radiographic signs of fusion.
Surgical operative time ranged between 50-60 minutes per device
implanted. Length of stay I hospital ranged from 2 to 4 days. Median
preoperative ODI was 64 to baseline, improving to 13 at 6 months.
VAS improved from 8.5 preoperatively to 1.9 at 6 months.
No major complications have been noted. One case of femoral
neuroapraxia has occurred, with complete recovery after 10 days.
Conclusions: XLIF provides access to multiple lumbar levels through
small lateral incisions and retroperitoneal dissection, minimizing
approach-related morbidity while providing anterior column access
for large cage placement, good disc height and alignment restoration.
Initial results in the treatment of lumbar spine disease are very
favourable with the advantage of a low rate of complications and a
shorter hospital stay. This is a novel technique that may avoid more
invasive surgery in many patients but a formal prospective random-
ised control trial and further user experience are welcomed to
establish its benefits in this respect.
77
MINIMALLY INVASIVE POSTERIOR LUMBAR
INTERBODY FUSION AND PERCUTANEOUS
PEDICLE SCREWS FIXATION FOR
DEGENERATIVE LUMBAR SPINE DISEASE
C. A. Logroscino, L. Proietti, E. Pola, S. Astolfi, F. R. Frasso,L. Scaramuzzo
Departement of Orthopaedic Science and Traumatology SpineSurgery Division Catholic University Rome, Italy
Introduction: The aim of the study was to evaluate the feasibility and
safety of mini-open transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion for
instabilities and degenerative disc disease.
Methods: All patients who underwent mini-open lumbar interbody
fusion(TLIF) combined with percutaneous pedicle screw fixation of
the lumbar spine were studied retrospectively. Transforaminal lumbar
interbody fusion was performed at L3-L4 in 4 patients, L4-L5 in 9
patients, L5-S1 in 7 patients. Surgical time, intraoperatrative blood
loss, preoperative diagnosis, number of stabilized levels, mean hos-
pital stay, complications and fusion rate were recorded at routine
intervals. In all patients pedicle screw postion was studied with
postoperative CT scan. Clinical outcome was assessed using the
Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), and
SF-36.
Results: From May 2005 to October 2008 20 patients, 14 males
and 6 females (age range 28-59 yr; mean 46 yr) underwent mini-
open TLIF procedure for degenerative disc disease or degenerative
spondylolisthesis. The mean follow-up was 24 months. The mean
estimated blood loss was 230 ml, the mean length of stay was
5,3 days, the meantime needed before ambulation was 3,2 days.
The mean pre-operative VAS score was 7,1 (range 5,9-8,3),
decreasing to a mean of 2,1 (range 1-3,5) at 6 months minimum
follow-up, mean pre-operative Oswestry Disability Index was
52,8% (range 40,2%-72,7%) decreasing to a mean of 27,1% (range
11,2%- 34,8%) at 6 months minimum follow-up, mean pre-opera-
tive SF-36 questionnaire was 34,5% (50,4% - 25,7%) improving to
a mean of 75,4% (range 68,2%- 99,4%) at 6 months minimum
follow-up. 80 screws were implanted in 20 patients. Screws’
positioning was excellent in 85% (68 screws) of cases, acceptable
in 13,75 % (11 screws), and unacceptable 1,25% (1 screw)
according to the criteria published by Yokulis et al. [1]. We
observed 1 case of misplaced screw that required revision. At mid
term follow-up all patients exhibited a good intersegmental stability
and no hardware failure.
Discussion: In our opinion mini-open TLIF is a valid and safe
alternative in the treatment of low-grade lumbar instability and
degenerative disc disease. The use of mini-open technique for pedicle
screw instrumentation with spinal fusion procedure provides good
clinical results and may be a definite indication in selected patients.
Advantages of this surgical technique are reduced soft tissue damage,
reduced estimated blood loss and length of stay.
760 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
78
CLINICAL AND RADIOLOGICAL REVIEW
OF PATIENTS OPERATED WITH MINIMALLY
INVASIVE ARTHRODESIS WITH CANNULATED
SCREWS AND TLIF
P. Cervellini, L. Rossetto, L. Gazzola, G. Zambon
Department of Neurosurgery City Hospital of Vicenza, Italy
Introduction: We use since 2004 the minimally invasive systems
with cannulated screws and transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion
(TLIF).
The indication were: grade 1 isthmic spondylolisthesis, degenerative
spondylolisthesis, discopathy and FBSS.
We operated 80 cases, the follow-up was from 6 months to
4 years.
Materials and Methods: 50 patients operated at least 6 months
before were controlled with VAS, x-rays and CT Scan.
Results: All the patients had reduction of the pain.
Only in 10 radiological studies the fusion was evident.
In many cases we noted small subsidence.
In 3 cases there was a migration of the cage, 1 anteriorly with
loss of the correction of the listhesis; 2 posteriorly, without
radicular problems.
Conclusions: The minimally invasive systems with cannulated
screws and TLIF, in degenerative pathology, are valid in the cases in
which the indication is correct. The small surface of the cages for the
transforaminal approaches doesn’t allow the radiologic optimal result
however.
e-POSTERS
1
OUTCOMES ON THE FIRST CASES OF BALLOON
KYPHOPLASTY WITH KYPHOS IN YOUNG
PATIENTS WITH VERTEBRAL FRACTURES
R. Partescano
U.O. Ortopedia e traumatologia - P. O. S. M. Annunziata - ASL10 Firenze, Italy
Introduction: Since 2006 we have begun treating young selected
patients with the Balloon Kyphoplasty using KyphOs cement (Cal-
cium Triphosphate).
With this kind of procedure it is possible to also treat those patients
that cannot be treated with PMMA as for their young age.
The procedure using the KyphOs differs from the one using the
PMMA as for the following:
Limited time of introduction of the KyphOs in the Vertebral Body
Patient must remain in prone position for half an hour after the
conclusion of the procedure
Patient must have bed rest for 18-24 hours after surgery
Patient must avoid hard activities for almost 3 months after
surgery.
Materials and Methods: We treated 8 patients aged between 27 and
43 with wedge vertebral fractures, type A1.1 and A1.2 in the thoraco-
lumbar segment, levels between D10 and L2.
In all cases we made pre-operative X-Rays and CT.
Periodical clinical Follow Up has been made. 1 year Follow Up
controls have been made through X-Rays and MRI
Conclusions: We consider the Balloon Kyphoplasty with Calcium
Triphosphate a good alternative to the Conservative Medical Man-
agement of the wedge vertebral fracture[30� in a well informed and
motivated patient.
The outcomes show how the procedure presents remarkable benefits
in patient management. 24 hours after surgery the patient can stand up
right without using any brace or plaster devices.
The procedure can restores the vertebral body height.
2
MULTIDISCIPLINAR TREATMENT OF GIANT
CELL TUMOUR OF THE CERVICAL SPINE: CASE
REPORT
P. Rocco, E. D’Avella, R. Tarantino, R. Delfini
Neurological Sciences Department, U.O.C. of Neurosurgery ofPoliclinico Umberto I in ROME ‘‘Sapienza’’ University, Italy
Introduction: Giant cell tumours of the bone are rare and benign
neoplasms. Spinal localization is most common at the sacrum, while
cervical giant cell tumours are extremely rare. The treatment of
choice of cervical giant cell tumour is complete surgical excision.
However the high vascularization and the adherence to surrounding
structures make complete excision of the tumour often impossible.
The role of adjuvant radioterapy is still controversial because of the
associated risk of malignant transformation. We present the case of a
30 year old woman with giant cell tumour of C2 who was treated
successfully with endovascular embolization, surgery and
radiotherapy.
Case Report: A 30 year old woman presented to another institution
with a three month history of pain in the neck. A RM scan of the
cervical spine revealed a destructive slightly hyperdense mass lesion
completely occupying the body of C2 and the odontoid process. The
patient underwent a biopsy trough a transoral approach and the
histopatological examination showed a giant cell tumour with asso-
ciated aneurismal bone cyst. The patient was surgically treated with
vertebroplasty and occipito-cervical stabilization.
Four month later the patient presented to our attention because of
worsening of the sintomatology. The woman complained of neck pain
radiating to both arms, more severe at the right side, progressive
dispnea, swalling difficulty and voice disturbance. A RM scan
revealed a contrast enhancing mass with anterior extraosseous
extension from the body of C2, compressing farinx, larinx and tra-
chea, and lateral extension reaching the right vertebral artery. The
patient underwent surgery trough a lateral cervical approach. Com-
plete removal of the tumour was impossible because of massive
bleeding. One week later, the patient underwent an endovascular
procedure of embolization of the tumour to reduce intraoperative
bleeding. Second surgery trough a transoral approach was successful
and complete removal of the tumour was accomplished. The patient
underwent post operative radiotherapy. At 40 month follow-up, MR
scan showed no recurrence of the tumour and the patient is relieved
from symptoms.
Conclusion: Giant cell tumours of the spinal axis have an aggressive
and unpredictable behaviour and therefore their management is con-
troversial. Although frequently difficult, wherever possible radical
microsurgical resection in required for treatment. The use of adjuvant
therapy is not very well defined. The world literature about cervical
giant cell tumours is rather sparse, due to the rarity of these lesions.
We report our experience of a successful multimodal treatment of
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 761
123
cervical giant cell tumour to add more information to the present
literature.
3
TRANSITION DYNAMIC FIXATION SYSTEM
IN THE LUMBO-SACRAL SPINE: SELECTION
CRITERIA AND PRELIMINARY RESULTS
A. Ramieri, G. Costanzo
Orthopaedics, The Don Gnocchi Foundation and RomeUniversity ‘‘La Sapienza’’ Polo Pontino, Italy
Above or below lumbar fusion disorder is a worrying long-term
complication, often yelding to revision surgery. A particular lumbo-
sacral stabilization system has become available, coupling both rigid
and dynamic rods by a transition zone.
From 2007, we perspectively treated 12 consecutive adult patients
with severe L5-S1 DDD together with L4-L5 moderate degeneration
and disc herniation. Patients complained chronic LBP and unilateral
radicular symptoms. Surgery included discectomy, rigid L5-S1 fixa-
tion and fusion and dynamic neutralization of L4-L5 level.
Outcomes were evaluated by means of x-ray and Oswestry Dis-
ability score. After a maximum follow-up of 14 months, all implants
seemed stable with a good fusion of L5-S1 level and without L3-L4
degenerative changes. Sagittal alignment (pre-operative kyphosis)
improved as well. LBP improved too.
Dynamic transition fixation seems to show biomechanical and
clinical advantages in our group of selected patients. However, the
effect in protecting from adjacent level disease, as it appears from our
short and mid-term results, still remains theoretical and should be
validated with further studies.
4
BACJAC� AND TREATMENT OF LOW BACK
PAIN: STARTING EXPERIENCE
E. Amoroso, A. Guarracino, M. Genovese
U. O. C. di Neurochirurgia - Ospedale ‘‘Umberto I’’- NoceraInferiore (SA), Italy
Introduction: BacJac� is an interspinous spacer. Made of peek, this
device is biocompatible, and radiolucent, except for a fine metal
thread passing through its structure. Impiantable, by local anaesthesia,
with unilateral minimally invasive open approach, tissue sparing and
sopraspinous ligament preserving, the spacer would reduce subacute
or chronic low back pain (resistant both drug’s treatment and phys-
iotherapy), in selected cases. Available in 5 heights (from 8 to
16 mm) and 2 A/P widths (small and medium), it would adapt to both
individual needs for interspinous strain and different length of spinous
process, resulting easily to implant in case of short process too.
Purpose: To determine the safety and effectiveness of this new
spacer.
Materials and Methods: We have selected 8 patients, in the first six-
month period 2008, (5 male e 3 female; mean age 58 years) with sub-
acute or chronic low back pain (4 patients) or with intermittent
neurogenic claudication (4 patients), refractory to the best not surgical
treatments, but all presenting clear improvement of the painful symp-
tomatology when they bend (flexion) lumbar spine segment (score
decrement [ 5 of Visual Analogue Scale of pain). Pre-operative
imaging (standard and dynamic L/S spine x-ray, lumbar CT or MRI)
showed typical findings of spondylosis (bulging of intervertebral disk,
slight retro-listhesis, ‘‘kissing spine’’, facet subluxing, ‘‘soft- stenosis’’
of the spinal canal, black disc, Modic 1-2). In no case there was anterior
spondylolisthesis. The average operating time was 42 min., under local
anaesthesia with lidocaine and ropivacaine. All cases were followed for
6 months after surgery with clinical examination, L/S spine x-ray,
Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) and VAS scale.
Results: All patients achieved reduction of both intermittent neuro-
genic claudication and low back pain, in orthostasis (pre-operative
VAS average 8, post-operative 2; pre-operative ODI average 52%,
post- operative 28%). No adverse events occurred. In second post-
operative day, all patients were discharged from the hospital with
lumbar corset.
Conclusions: Although shortage of the surgical cases and brevity of
the ‘‘follow-up’’ don’t allow conclusions about long term effective-
ness of BacJac�, this device appears safe, fast and easy to implant,
and it finds both patient favour and approval, in selected cases, with
subacute or chronic low back pain and with or without intermittent
neurogenic claudication.
5
TWO-YEAR RESULTS OF FLEXIS INTERSPINOUS
IMPLANT FOR THE TREATMENT OF LUMBAR
SPINAL STENOSIS. THE VENIZELEIO-HOSPITAL
EXPERIENCE
N. Syrmos, V. Valadakis, Ch. Iliadis, K. Grigorio, D. Arvanitakis
Neurosurgical Department, Venizeleio General Hospital.Heraklion, Crete, Greece
Aim: Aim of our study was to investigate the clinical outcome of
patients with symptomatic lumbar spinal stenosis before and at
periodic intervals after FLEXIS implantation
Material and Methods: The FLEXIS Interspinous Device is a rela-
tively new interspinous implant designed for patients with
symptomatic spinal stenosis particularly neurogenic claudication. 63
consecutive patients were enrolled and surgically treated with
FLEXIS implantation. The FLEXIS device was implanted at the
stenotic segment, which was either at 1 or 2 levels in each patient.
They were clinically evaluated at the preoperative 1 month, 3-month,
6-month, 9 month and 1-year stage with clinical questionnaires (VAS,
Zurich Claudication Questionnaire, Oswestry Disability Index, SF-
36,JOA,AO SPINE)
Results: 13 patients failed to complete all the questionnaires at
all time intervals and hence were excluded, leaving 50 patients who
had completed all questionnaire at all time interval. By 12 months,
80% of these 50 patients reported clinically significant improvement
in their symptoms, 5% reported clinically significant improvement
in physical function, and 5% expressed satisfaction with the
procedure.
Conclusions: The advantages of the FLEXIS interspinous device are:
• Low Risk Operation
• Shorter Surgical Time
• Minimally Invasive Surgery
• Preserve Flexibility and Mobility
• Faster Rehabilitation
762 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
6
CERVICAL MYELOPATHY DUE TO OPLL AND
OLF ASSOCIATED WITH DISH, CRANIO-
VERTEBRAL JUNCTION MALFORMATION AND
C2-C3 SYNOSTOSIS. CASE REPORT
V. Russo, F. Graziano, D. Romano, M. Giarrusso, V. Albanese
Universita degli Studi di Catania, Dipartimento di Neuroscienze,Clinica Neurochirurgica, Italy;Direttore: Prof. V. Albanese
Diffuse Idiopathic Skeletal Hyperostosis (DISH) is characterized by
calcification and ossification of soft tissues. It has been found to
involve the axial skeleton and, in up to 76% of patients, the cervical
spine. The disease is characterized by ossification of the anterior
longitudinal ligament and production of flowing osteophytes with
preservation of the intervertebral disc space. The prevalence of DISH
varies in different populations: 25% and 15% in men and women over
50 years old respectively and 35% and 26% in men and women over
70 years old, respectively. The association with the ossification of the
posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL) has been described in up to
50% of cases. Whereas it has been rarely reported the association with
ossification of ligamentum flavum (OLF) or congenital malforma-
tions. The difference with ankylosing spondylitis is the absence of
inflammatory changes in facets or sacroiliac joints. Patients with
DISH are mainly asymptomatic. Dysphagia is the most common
clinical manifestation in symptomatic patients.
We report the case of a 72-years-old man with a severe cervical
myelopathy and neck pain due to OPLL and OLF with concomitant
DISH, cranio-vertebral junction malformation and C2-C3 synostosis.
X-Rays revealed a flowing ossification of the anterior aspect of the
cervical spine. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed cranio-vertebral
junction malformation, C2-C3 synostosis and, on T2-weithed images,
intramedullary high signal intensity at C3-C4 level. CT of the cervical
spine showed narrowing of spinal canal primarily at C3-C4 level due
to OPLL and OLF. The patient underwent a C3-C6 decompressive
laminectomy. Postoperative course was uneventful and carachterized
by progressive and rapid improvement of the pre-op symptomatology.
To the best of our knowledge this is the first report on a patient with
DISH associated with OPLL, OLF and congenital malformations. In the
present case a posterior approach has been choosen because of the
absence of dysphagia and preserved cervical spine lordosis. In conclu-
sion, only patients with dysphagia need resection of the anterior
ossification. A posterior approach has to be performed in case of absence
of dysphagia in patients with a physiological cervical spine lordosis.
7
EXTRAOSSEOUS EXTENSION OF T5 VERTEBRAL
HEMANGIOMA: A RARE CAUSE OF SPINAL
CORD COMPRESSION
F. Graziano, V. Russo, D. Romano, M. Giarrusso, N. Platania
Universita degli Studi di Catania, Dipartimento di Neuroscienze,Clinica Neurochirurgica;Direttore: Prof. V. Albanese, Italy
Vertebral hemangiomas are relatively common benign dysplasias or
vascular tumours affecting the vertebral column. They account for
approximately 2 to 3% of all spinal tumours and occur with an
estimated incidence of 10 to 12% in the population as based on large
autopsy series and review of plain spine radiographs. These lesions
are usually asymptomatic and often present as incidental findings on
plain radiographs and on magnetic resonance images. Rarely, they
may cause pain or neurological deficits because of spinal cord com-
pression, vertebral body or arch expansion, or pathological fracture.
Radiation therapy or decompressive surgery with or without postop-
erative irradiation have been the traditional means for treating these
lesions.
We report the case of a 75-year-old woman with a severe thoracic
myelopathy due to extraosseous extension of a thoracic vertebral
hemangioma. The MRI revealed mild anterior wedging of the T5
vertebral body with extensive signal abnormality throughout the body
extending into the pedicle, the transverse process and the spinous
process. An extraosseous extension of this lesion, that appeared as an
extradural soft tissue mass encroaching on the posterior aspect of the
spinal canal with a marked cord compression, was found. A bilateral
paravertebral soft tissue mass laying between the T4–T5 and T5–T6
intervertebral discs was also seen. Axial T1-weithed images showed
the characteristic ‘‘polka dot’’ pattern of trabecular thickening
involving most of the vertebral body, the pedicle and the spinous
process. The patient underwent a posterior decompression through a
Th2-Th6 laminectomy and osteosynthesis with rods and laminar
hooks, to prevent progressive neurologic deterioration and potential
instability with the risk of vertebral collapse. The extraosseous
extension of the tumor was removed. The histologic examination
revealed a benign capillary hemangioma. Postoperative course was
unenventful and carachterized by progressive and rapid improvement
of the pre-op symptomatology.
It is generally agreed that surgical decompression should be
undertaken if significant or progressive neurological deficit is present.
The choice of surgical procedure is determined by the location of the
hemangioma and by the severity of neurological condition. In this
case a decompressive laminectomy with posterior fixation was per-
formed in order to avoid a progressive neurological decline due to
neural canal stenosis caused by osseous tumor growth involving the
vertebral body and posterior elements.
8
SPINAL EPIDURAL ABSCESS
D. Romano, V. Russo, F. Graziano, M. Giarrusso, N. Platania
Department of Neurosurgery, Neuroscience Institute, Universityof Catania, Catania, Italy
Spinal epidural abscess (SEA) (described for the first time by Ber-
gamaschi in 1820) is an uncommon disease with a frequency of 0.2 to
2 cases per 10.000 hospital admissions and a mortality rate of 10-
30%.
Predisposing factors of SEA include infections, diabetes, chronic
liver disease, intravenous drug abuse, AIDS, immunocompromised
condition, alcohol abuse, spinal surgery or trauma, cancer and steroid
use, however 20% of patients will have no clear predisposing factor.
The classic triad is composed by three typical symptoms: spine
pain, fever, and neurological abnormalities, but this triad is present in
only 10-15% of SEA patients.
In a patient with SEA the value of surgical intervention versus
antimicrobial therapy alone is controversial.
We report a patient with SEA treated successfully with a medical
regimen.
Case Report: A 74 years old female was admitted because sudden
neck pain, left superior arm hypostenia, dizziness, dysphagia.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 763
123
On admission the physical examination showed weakness in the
abduction movements of the left superior arm, hypoesthesia in C5
nerve root distribution, weakness of left deltoid muscle, patellar and
achilles hyperreflexia, bilateral Hoffmann sign, spontaneous and
evocated neck pain.
Laboratory examination revealed: leukocytosis with white cell
count of 10.67 x 10^3/mmc, elevated C-reactive protein of 7.23 g/dl
and elevated VES of 49 mm/h. Blood cultures were negative.
Cervical Spine Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demonstrated
spinal compression along the anterior aspect of the thecal sac at the
C5-C6 level, with an epidural mass.
The patient was started on intravenous vancomycin and Glazidim
(ceftazidima) for 45 days.
This prompt antimicrobial therapy resulted in excellent, relativily,
early neurologic outcome, in fact the neurological disorders and RCP
(Reactive C Proteine) and VES values in this patient normalized, and
a post therapy MRI exam showed a unmistakable improvement.
In conclusion SEA is a rare disease usually associated with spe-
cific predisposing factors; however, patients may present atypically.
Diagnostic delays lead to adverse neurological outcomes. Magnetic
resonance imaging is now the diagnostic procedure of choice.
The decision to treat the patients with SEA medically was
based on the short duration of the cord dysfunction, the gradual
improvement of neurological signs within the first 24 hours of the
initiation of therapy and the absence of immunodeficiency. The
medical (antimicrobial) therapy should be reserved to those cases
in which there is a high surgical risk related to unfavorable clinical
circumstances.
This case suggest that surgery may not be required in all cases
with cervical spinal epidural abscess causing epidural compression
and neurological involvement, conservative treatment with antibiotic
therapy (Glazidim and Vancomicyn) may be sufficient.
9
TARLOV’S CYST-RETROSPECTIVE REVIEW
OF 5 CASES
N. Syrmos, C. Iliadis, V. Valadakis, K. Grigoriou, D. Arvanitakis
Neurosurgical Department, Venizeleio General Hospital.Heraklion, Crete, Greece
Introduction: Tarlov’s cyst or perineurial cyst is disease on portion of
the posterior nerve root in lumbo-sacral region. The lack of knowledge
of physicians around the world about Tarlov’s cyst as to their nature,
significance and treatment also with differential diagnostics to radic-
ulopathy in legs. The pathogenesis Tarlov’s cyst remains unclear;
several cases have history of the trauma, old hemorrhage, congenital
and iatrogenic. Cysts provoke low back pain, sacral radiculopathy,
dyspareunia, urinary incontence. The magnetic resonance imaging is
now the gold standard to diagnose cysts. The treatment is clinic or
surgery depending neurologics finding and neuroimage.
Aim: 5 perineurial cysts cases (Tarlov’s cysts) are reported
Material and Method: The evaluation was performed among 198
adult patients with symptoms of radiculopathy, sacral pain, low back
pain
Results: The diagnosis was made by magnetic resonance imag-
ing.Following surgery, the claudication pain resolved with no motor
or sensory deficits. Tarlov’s cysts should be considered as a differ-
ential diagnosis of sacral radiculopathy, sacral or lumbar pain
syndromes and mainly to the lumbar disc prolapse. The goal of the
surgical treatment is to relieve the neural compression and stop bone
erosion.
10
SPINE INJURIES AND ROAD TRAFFIC
ACCIDENTS RETROSPECTIVE REVIEW
N. Syrmos, C. Iliadis, V. Valadakis, K. Grigoriou, D. Arvanitakis
Neurosurgical Department, Venizeleio General Hospital.Heraklion, Crete, Greece
Aim: Aim of our study was to investigate the causes and the conse-
quence of the spine injuries, with and without neurological injuries,
who were treated in our hospital
Material and Method: We retrospectively reviewed data for 210
patients who were admitted to our hospital after road traffic accidents,
between 2001 and 2007. Spine injuries nd other factors were stud-
ied(Age, helmet status, alcohol and drug use, head injuries, length of
stay, disposition, hospital costs).
Results: 81,4%(171) of victims were male, with an average age of
33.5 years. 18,5(39) of all patients were wearing helmets.99 patients
(47,1%) sustained spinal injuries. There were a total of 17 deaths
(8%)
Conclusions: It is estimated that the annual incidence of spinal cord
injury, not including those who die at the scene of the accident, is
approximately 40 cases per million population in the U. S. or
approximately 12,000 new cases each year. In Europe some 330 000
people suffer from spinal cord injuries, with more than 10 000 new
cases occurring each year. Young people between the age of 25 and
35 are most affected by these injuries. Spine and brain injuries
occurred in 80% of fatal crashes. Crete has a fatality high rate. We
conclude that safety legislation would save lives.
11
MYELOPATHY HAND. CLINICAL SIGN OF CORD
DAMAGE
G. A. La Maida
Orthopaedic Dpt. Niguarda Hospital – Milan, Italy
The myelopathy hand is a characteristic dysfunction that has been
observed in various cervical spinal disorders when there is
involvement of the spinal cord. The most frequent causes of
myelopathy hand are cervical disk herniation, spinal stenosis,
tumours or syringomyelia. The most important clinical signs are
the loss of power of adduction and extension of the ulnar two or
three fingers and an inability to grip and release rapidly with these
fingers. Very characteristic is the escape finger test that is a loss of
adduction of the fifth finger of the hand. The muscular strength
reduction begins in most cases in the intrinsic muscles of the hand.
The sensitive impairment is often absent or very light. These
changes have been termed ‘‘myelopathy hand’’ and appear to be
due to pyramidal tract involvement. The Author would like to
underline a very characteristic clinical sign that can be easily
checked in the Patient and that could be expression of a very
important cord damage.
764 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
12
RISKS OF THE CEMENT IN SPINE SURGERY
G. A. La Maida
Orthopaedic Dpt. Niguarda Hospital – Milan, Italy
During the last years we observed an increased in the use of the
cement in spine surgery. The cement can be very useful especially in
some pathological conditions characterized by bone mass loosening,
like osteoporosis or some osteolytic lesions and so up to now a lot of
vertebral augmentations were done all over the world. Some surgeons
try now also to use cement in order to treat the traumatic fractures of
the young adult, with excellent results reported also in type A3
fractures.
I personally regularly use both the vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty
procedures to treat some type A fractures of the elderly patients but
I’m as many convinced that the use of the cement must be limited to
treat only very selected cases of the elderly age.
I report the case of a Patient of 69 years old affected by osteolytic
pathological fractures of T5 and L3, with a limited involvement of the
posterior wall in both levels
I planned a double spine short segment stabilization by using
pedicular instrumentation, combined with a vertebroplasty procedure
of the fracturated vertebral body in order to have an anterior support.
During the procedure of vertebroplasty in T5 there was a massive
cement extravasion into the canal with high grade stenosis and
compression of the spinal cord. The cord compression was immedi-
ately demonstrated by the suddently reduction of the evoked potential
and an emergency procedure of cord decompression was done in
addition to an immediate methilprednisolone infusion according to
the NASCIS III protocol. The decompression of the canal was
achieved by bilateral lamino-artrectomy and by direct removal of the
cement from the canal. At the end of the procedure the Patient was
neurologically intact without any peripheral pain and without any
sensitive or motor damage.
Cement leakage during vertebral augmentation procedures is
reported to be very useful, with rate ranging from 8 to 60% in the
litterature.
Additionally the cement, when used to treat spine fractures, is not
able to lead to a biologic healing of the bone and so it should be
contraindicated in young Patients.
I’m finally convinced that the use of the cement must be very
useful in spine surgery but it must be indicated in very selected
pathologies and Patients. I also think that any kind of vertebral aug-
mentation procedure should be performed in general anesthesia and in
operating room in order to immediate decompress the Patient if a
leakage complication is seen. I’m sure if my Patient had had to wait
the necessary time to organize an urgent decompression from the
angiographic room to the operating room, she would have had a
neurologic consequence.
The indiscriminate use of the cement, like in fractures with pos-
terior wall involvement or in young Patients, could easily lead to a
dangerous consequences for the Patient.
13
THE DISC PROSTHESIS IN TREATMENT OF
CERVICAL DEGENERATION DISC PATHOLOGY
A. Tumino, T. C. Russo, C. Casamichele, M. Quartarone,G. Incatasciato, G. Giuca, D. Pitino
Unit of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Major Hospitalof Modica, Italy
Introduction: Anterior Cervical Discectomy and interbody fusion
(ACDF) has for years been the gold-standard in the treatment of
symptomatic degenerative disease of the cervical disc. Despite the
good results obtained, after the merger intersomatic cervical discec-
tomy addition to causing a limitation of the range of motion leads to a
acceleration of the degenerative discs adjacent to fusion. In this work
we evaluate the radiographic and clinical results obtained following
cervical arthroplasty that assess the efficacy of this treatment.
Materials and Methods: Were evaluated 8 patients with implanted
prosthetic 9, 5 males and 3 females. In one case it is the level C4-C5,
in 3 cases of C5-C6 level, in 2 cases of C6-C7 and in one case of a
double level C5-C6 and C6-C7. Patients were evaluated both clini-
cally (Vas scale and ASIA) and radiographically with x ray in
standard projections and those dynamics.
Results: The results obtained showed that the emergence of the
prosthetic disc, while maintaining the benefits of ACDF (decom-
pression, restoration of stability and the height of intervertebral
space), keeping the movement, protects the disc levels adjacent to
fusion overload which will accelerate the degeneration.
14
A CASE OF ATYPICAL SPONDYLODISCITIS:
CASE REPORT
G. Giuca, T. C. Russo, A. Davı, C. Casamichele, M. Quartarone,A. Tumino, G. Incatasciato, M. Stamilla
Unit of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Major Hospital ofModica, Italy
Introduction: We present the case of a patient of 60 years suffer
from pain ingravescent symptoms a dorsal location, hyperthermia and
a history to recent right basal pleurisy with pleural payment agree-
ment. For this reason the same was subjected to repeated admissions
to other healthcare centers with final diagnosis of septicemia from S.
Aureus suspected spondylodiscitis D8 and D9-and antibiotic therapy
was carried out without resolution of pain symptoms will febrile
episodes.
Materials and Methods: The patient then came to our observation,
and during hospitalization at our UOC chose a multidisciplinary
approach with involvement of the infectious disease specialist and the
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 765
123
microbiologist and after excluding a spondylodiscitis of tubercular or
brucella nature, the patient was treated with antibiotic therapy with
broad spectrum and surgical stabilization of D7-D10 with biopsy with
negative results.
Results: In post-operating there was a marked improvement in pain
symptoms, the hyperthermia does not reappear and control to one
month the patient had resumed normal ambulation. The state of
welfare remained unchanged over time even with the new controls at
three, six months and a year with permanent normalization of bio-
chemical parameters.
Discussion and Conclusions: This is an atypical case because the
basal pleurisy may have been the cause for contiguity of vertebral
localization. From this case shows how the multidisciplinary
approach is the ‘‘gold standard’’ in the treatment of bone diseases of
infectious nature even more atypical.
15
PRELIMINARY REPORT ON PERCUTANEOUS
TRANSPEDICULAR SCREW INSTRUMENTATION
COMBINED WITH MINIMAL ALIF APPROACH
J. Buric, D. Bombardieri, M. Pulidori
Functional unit for Spinal Surgery - cdc Valdisieve – Pelago (FI)- Italy
Objective: This study was performed to compare the minimally
invasive circumferential fusion to standard open circumferential
fusion for low back pain in lumbar degenerative disc disease.
Background: Standard open circumferential fusion is associated with
better clinical and radiological results than PLIF or TLIF fusion
procedures but has a higher degree of intraoperative and post-oper-
ative complications. Minimally invasive ALIF and XLIF combined
with percutaneous trenaspedicular screw instrumentation has the
potential of reducing the disadvantages of the procedure.
Methods: Twenty-five affected by low back and leg pain due to
degenerative disc disease from L3 to S1 levels were submitted to
surgery during 2007 and 2008 using this minimally invasive
approach. Posterior part of the procedure was performed using the
percutaneous transpedicular screws (Pathfinder, Abbott Spine) and
(Silverbolt, Vertiflex) while the ALIF was performed in by minimally
invasive retroperitoneal approach implanting anterior full-body cage
(Perimeter, Medtronic) or by lateral percutaneous approach using
XLIF cage (Nuvasive).
Results: All of 25 patients improved upon surgery. The mean
improvement was of 5,7 points on VAS scale and 7 points on the
Roland Morris Disability Quetionnaire. The mean operating time
for the posterior part of the procedure (skin to skin) was as fol-
lows: 55 minutes for one level and 80 minutes for two levels. The
mean operating time for the anterior approach was 90 minutes for
one level and 110 minutes for two levels. The total amount of time
for both approaches, including the turn-up time for patient repo-
sitioning ranged from 160 minutes for one level till 300 minutes
for double level. Just one case of common iliac vein rupture was
encountered and successfully resolved. No other minor or major
intra-operative complications were encountered. The mean blood
loss per surgery was approximately 250 milliliters and in no
patient, except the one with vein rupture, blood transfusion was
indicated. Surgical wound drainage was never used. All the patients
were raised from the bed between 12 to 18 hours after the surgery.
The longest hospital stay was 6 days. As compared to standard
circumferential fusion, the reported post-operative pain was 3-fold
less and the use of post-operative opioids and painkillers was 60%
less. No wound or systemic infection was ever encountered. There
were no complications observed due to pulmonary embolism.
Conclusion: Minimally invasive ALIF or XLIF combined with pos-
terior percutaneous transpedicular screw instrumentation seems an
equally usefull system as compared to standard open circumferential
fusion with the advantage of less blood loss, fewer complication rate,
shorter operation time and shorter hospital stay. It is not indicated in
cases of 2� or more of lysthesis as well as when laminectomy is
planned, too.
16
FIVE YEAR FOLLOW-UP ON INTRADISCAL
OZONE INJECTION FOR DISC HERNIATION
J. Buric*, L. Rigobello#, B. Frankel’’, D. Hooper^
*CDC Villanova – Florence, Italy; #Dpt for Neurosurgery – Univ.of Padua, Italy; ‘‘Dpt. of Neurosurgery, Med Univ of SouthCarolina, USA; ^Minimus Spine-Austin, USA
Objective: This study was performed to collect five-year follow-up
on patients with lumbar disc herniation treated with intradiscal
injection of ozone gas.
Background: Disc herniation is the most common cause for spinal
surgery, and many clinicians emply epidural steroid injections with
limited success. In numerous countries, intradiscal injection of
ozone gas has been used as an alternative to epidural steroid and
surgical discectomy. Early results are positive, but long-term data
are limited.
Buric JosipNinety-five patients with confirmed contiguous disc
herniation were treated with intradiscal injection of ozone in 2002.
Eighty-seven patients were available for telephone follow-up at five
years and a chart review was performed. Patients were asked to
describe their clinical outcome since the injection. Surgical inter-
ventions were documented. Available MRI films were
collectively reviewed to assess the reduction in disc herniation at
six months.
Results: of the 87 responders at five years, 63 (72%) reported being
‘‘much better’’, three (3%) were ‘‘better’’, eight (9%) had no
improvement and 13 (15%) went on to surgery. There were 12
discectomies and one fusion, with ten of the 13 surgeries occuring
during the first year. Two patients had a second intradiscal ozone
injection for an average of 1.02 injections per patient. MRI films
demonstrated a consistent reduction in the size of the disc herniation.
Seventy-nine percent of patients had a reduction in herniation volume
and the average reduction was 56%. Other than subsequent surgeries
typically associated with these patients, no complications were
experienced.
Conclusion: Ozone is a conservative alternative to surgical discec-
tomy for many patients. The gas reduced the size of the disc
herniation. Randomized trials are required to gain wider acceptance
of this treatment option.
This work was published as a Clinical review article in Orthopedic
Product News, May/June 2008 pp 66-9
766 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
17
NEW COMPRESSION VERTEBRAL FRACTURES
AFTER VERTEBROPLASTY OR KYPHOPLASTY:
MYTH OR REALITY?
G. Caruso, V. Lorusso, E. Zamagni, S. Poggiali, L. Massari
Ferrara University Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Italy
Introduction: Percutaneous vertebroplasty and baloon asissted
kyphoplasty are efficient and safe procedures to improve quality of
life and to treat pain due to osteoporotic vertebral compression
fractures (OVCFs). To date, literature data did’nt clarify an etio-
logical potential correlation among these mini invasive surgery
techniques and new osteoporotic vertebral fractures incidence.
Materials and Methods: In this retrospective study we have evalu-
ated incidence and spine distribution of new OVCFs in 124 patients
previously treated for 193 OVCFs with percutaneous vertebroplasty
(105 vertebra) or balloon assisted kyphoplasty (88 vertebra), from
2003 to 2007 in our Orthopaedic Clinic.
Results: We observed that 16,5% of patients have developed new
OVCFs at an average time of 8,6 months (1-35) from surgery. The
28,1% of these fractures incurred in an immediately adiacent level to
the previously treated vertebra whereas the 71,9% in the distance.
Also in this case the number of new compression fracture decreases
drifting away from the previously treated vertebra. Vertebroplasty
was most often associated to this complication (68,75%).
Conclusion: The biomechanical alterations resulting from poly-
methylmethacrylate injection in vertebral body involve the risk to
develop new OVCFs in adiacent level to the previously treated ver-
tebra. This event does not seem to be higher than that resulting from
the presence of the fracture itself. As a matter of fact, literature data
show a new OVCFs incidence in 12 months, following the first
OVCFs of 19,2%; this percentage is correlated to the osteoporosis
progression and to biomechanical modification depending from the
fracture itself.
18
SCOLIOSIS SURGERY: TREATMENT
OF SURGICALS FAILURES
C. A. Logroscino, S. Astolfi, F. C. Tamburrelli, L. Scaramuzzo,L. Oggiano
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, UniversitaCattolica del Sacro Cuore School of Medicine, Rome, Italy
Scoliosis operative planning and surgical technique can be considered
very challenging. Technical and clinical success of treatment are
defined by the occurrence of a three-dimensional correction of
deformity, an accurate postural balance and an improvement of pain.
Revision surgery can be considered even more demanding; it would
be necessary to correct a failure or mobilization of instrumentation or
a wrong assessment of the fusion area leading to structural imbalances
and to treat involvement of adjacent segments not instrumented.
Between January 2006 and September 2008 fourteen patients previ-
ously treated for scoliosis were submitted to revision surgery. In 2
cases they had been treated for an adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, in
10 cases for adult scoliosis and 2 were scoliosis in children with spina
bifida. Surgical treatment consisted of 9 osteosynthesis revisions with
pedicle screw instrumentation and proximal or caudal extension of
fusion area, 1 anterior approach revision and 4 osteotomies (PSO) to
restore a correct sagittal balance. Patients were evaluated by clinical
and radiographic examination, ODI-2 and SF-36 questionnaires
administration to assess functional disability degree. No death
occurred in the present case series. Complications included blood loss
more than 1500 ml in 4 cases, wound infection in 1 case and deep
venous thrombosis in 1 case.
19
LUMBAR STENOSIS TREATED BY X-STOP
DEVICE: PRELIMINARY RESULTS OF AN
EXPERIENCE OF 30 MONTHS
B. A. Nannavecchia, F. Bigossi, P. F. Eugeni, F. Pineto, R. Sepe,V. Magliani, D. Lucantoni
Unita Operativa di Neurochirurgia, Ospedale ‘‘G. Mazzini’’ -Teramo, Italy
Authors describe a clinical retrospective of 65 patients with lumbar
stenosis treated by X-Stop device since october of 2006 to november
2008.
After a review of an international litterature of lumbar stenosis
pathology, it focalizes on the epidemiology and the traditional sur-
gical treatments; then, the study analyzes the age, the life outcome,
the preoperatory clinical aspects and the levels of stenosis.
The paper describes the Methods used to select the patients, all the
steps to implante the device and the postoperatory managment.
The follow-up based to the results related to the symptoms and to
the imaging is discussed.
The conclusions of this preliminary experience highights a man-
agment standard to treat this type pathology of cervical disc able to
resolve by a surgical procedure minimally invasivity the disfunction
and no the microinstability.
20
CERVICAL MICRODISCECTOMY WITH DISCO-
CERV DEVICE: OUR PRELIMINARY
EXPERIENCE
B. A. Nannavecchia, F. Bigossi, P. F. Eugeni, F. Pineto, R. Sepe,V. Magliani, D. Lucantoni
Unita Operativa di Neurochirurgia, Ospedale ‘‘G. Mazzini’’ -Teramo, Italy
Authors describe six clinical cases of patients with soft slipped disc
surgically treated by cervical microdiscectomy and implante of disco-
cerv device since June 2007 to June 2008.
After a review of an international litterature of cervical disc
pathology, it focalizes on the epidemiology and the traditional sur-
gical treatments; then, the study analyzes the age, the life outcome,
the preoperatory clinical aspects and the slipped disc levels of
selected patients.
Topics related to the device’s system are the biomechanics fea-
tures and its relationship to a biologically young cervical disc.
The paper describes the Methods used to select the patients, all the
steps to implante the device and the postoperatory managment.
The follow-up based to the results related to the symptoms and to
the imaging is discussed.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 767
123
The conclusions of this preliminary experience highight a man-
agment standard to treat a soft slipped disc disease in patients with a
biologically young age.
21
SHORT INSTRUMENTATION IN THE FRACTURES
OF THE THORACIC-LUMBAR JUNCTION: OUR
EXPERIENCE
B. Cappelletto, F. Giorgiutti, C. Veltri, P. Facchin, P. Del Fabro
The thoracic-lumbar junction is the part of the column most fre-
quently involved in traumatic lesions: it is, in biomechanics, the most
susceptible zone because there is a passage without transition from
the rigid and kyphotic portion of the dorsal column to the mobile and
lordotic portion of the lumbar column.
The objective of surgical treatment is to obtain a stable column,
pain-free and flexible, and to gain the best possible neurological
result.
There is controversy regarding which is the preferred method for
achieving these goals. It has been demonstrated that short posterior
fixation causes a high incidence of failure of the hardware and of the
correction. We argue that the choice of the treatment should be based
on the classification of the fracture and, from this, one should carry
out as short a fusion as possible.
The purpose of this study is to analyze our case records in com-
parison to those reported in the literature. From January 1994 until
December 2007, we performed stabilization with short instrumenta-
tion on 175 patients with fracture of L1 (117 cases) or T12 (58 cases).
In 36 cases the patients presented a neurological deficit due to spinal
cord or root lesion while in 139 cases there was no deficit. We carried
out laminectomy in 68 cases and put two screws in the fractured
vertebra in 156 cases.
All patients were examined 3 and 12 months after the operation
with X-rays. We observed a neurological improvement in 67% of
the cases. In no case was it necessary to remove the hardware, and
in no case did hardware breakage occur. Patients tolerated the short
instrumentation well and never requested removal.
In conclusion, our view is that the insertion of two pedicle screws
in the fractured vertebra adds a crucial element of stability. In selected
patients, short instrumentation brings about good stability, permits
good mobility, and is well tolerated.
22
VASCULAR INJURIES IN CERVICAL SPINE
TRAUMAS
M. Campello, M. Broger, P.C. Cecchi, M. Baldassa, N.Vezzali1,A. Schwarz
Neurosurgical Unit and Radiology1, General Hospital – Bolzano -Italy
Injuries of the main cervical and cephalic arteries, following cer-
vical spine traumas, can result in significant, possibly devastating,
neurological sequelae. Extra-cranial dissections can cause ischemic
accidents, sometimes in more than one vascular territory. Recent
advances in multiplanar reformatting of the axial images at CT-
scan and the availability of MR scans, even in emergency settings,
facilitate early diagnosis of these vascular injuries, more often than
previously done. Aim of the present study is to review our policy
in detecting and treating suspected – then confirmed – carotid and
vertebral arteries post-traumatic injuries in order to avoid ischemic
complications. Since fall 2004, in our hospital, a comprehensive
multiple trauma management protocol is routinely performed;
according to this protocol a total-body CT with angio-CT scans are
done; MR and angio-MR are done in selected cases. Our experi-
ence stems from 531 consecutive traumatized patients (time span:
November 2004 - November 2008) in which that protocol was
applied. We used the 5-points Denver grading scale as a tool to
classify the diagnosed vascular injuries, from mild wall damages
till a complete vascular transection. We found 11 patients (2,07%
of the total population) with 13 vascular lesions. It is of note that
all eight patients with vertebral arteries damages had a concomitant
osseous spinal lesion, but only one third of carotid arteries lesions
were associated to a bone fracture. We analyze pathogenesis,
pathological and radiological spectrum, clinical features and ther-
apy – when delivered – of these positive cases.
23
SPONDYLOLISTHESIS REDUCTION WITH UNI-
THREAD� SPL SYSTEM
M. Piredda, M. Costaglioli, D. Castangia, S. Casula, S. Caboni, P.P. Mura
Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: Spondylolisthesis occurs when one vertebra slips for-
ward in relation to an adjacent vertebra, usually in the lumbar spine.
The symptoms that accompany a spondylolisthesis include pain in the
low back, thighs, and/or legs, muscle spasms, weakness, and/or tight
hamstring muscles. Some people are symptom free and find the dis-
order exists when revealed on an x-ray.
The latest developments in spondylo-implantology have increased
interest in operative treatment of slip. The reduction of slip, however,
remains controversial and is broadly discussed.
Spondylolisthesis reduction effectively relieves clinical com-
plaints, and reconstitutes physiological spinal load bearing and
spino-pelvic balance. Stabilization eliminates segmental instability
and improves conditions for spondylodesis. Currently, one-seg-
mental interbody stabilization with transpedicular fixation is a
recommended method. Broad and complete decompression of
neural elements and its control during the reduction procedure is
recommended in order to avoid neurological complications.
Patients and Methods: Eight patients with lumbar spondylolisthesis
were collected from January to December 2008, they were treated by
posterior restoration and fixation with UNI-Thread� SPL system.
This device permits unconstrained anteroposterior reduction of the
listhesis and gradual, fully controlled correction of the profile.
Conclusion: The UNI-Thread� SPL device provides a true mono-
segmental micrometric reduction and a 360� fusion with interbody
cages (TLIF o PLIF procedures).
768 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
24
SELECTIVE SEGMENTAL STABILIZATION WITH
A NEW DYNAMIC/HYBRID CONSTRUCT
P. P. Mura, C. Formica*, M. Balsanoo, M. Costaglioli,L. Cavaleri*, A. Villaminar
Cagliari; *Alessandria; oSchio-Thiene (VI), Italy
Introduction: In the last few years, there was a shift from rigid to
dynamic fixation of spinal segments.
Dynamic stabilization system decrease the load of intervertebral disc
of corresponding movement segments and provide a good environ-
ment for the recovery of intervertebral disc and soft tissues. It also
delays the degeneration of small facet and reconstructs the biome-
chanical function of spine at instrumented level.
Patients experiencing pain and biomechanical instability at one
level may also present with radiographic or other indicators of
early degeneration at an adjacent level. Clearly, fusion would be
warranted at the symptomatic level, but the treatment plan for the
adjacent level remains controversial. Additionally, the effects on
adjacent motion segments above a fusion level are currently not
well understood.
The varying degrees of functional spinal unit (FSU) degeneration
have led to recent discussion of tailored treatments at multiple levels
in a single-stage operation. Bertagnoli et al have defined the use of
motion-preserving technologies combined with fusion as a multilevel
hybrid construct category.
Patients and Methods: In this article we analyze the first 100
patients operated with a new dynamic/hybrid construct: FlexPLUS
(Spinevision). The FlexPlus system is unique because it offers various
degrees of stabilization, rigid, hybrid and dynamic, 3 types of rods
compatible with the same bone anchorage screw mechanism and
instruments.
FlexPLUS allow to apply Selective Segmental Stabilization during
the procedure and therefore adapt to multiple disc-degeneration
stages: dynamic one-level posterior stabilization constructs to one-
level rigid rod fixation constructs.
Conclusion: This original construct requires no more surgical steps
than a normal fusion, and allows easy conversion to fusion in case of
revision surgery or construct extension
25
ORTHELIUS: A NON INVASIVE DIAGNOSTIC
SYSTEM IN EVALUATION OF SPINAL
DEFORMITIES
P. P. Mura, M. Costaglioli, M. Piredda, D. Castangia, S. Casula,S. Caboni
Cagliari, Italy
Introduction: Accurate and non-invasive measurements are essential
for deformity diagnosis and assessment of curve progression.
Although the standard procedure for diagnosis and follow-up of the
progression of scoliosis is the Cobb method of radiographic mea-
surement, there is much concern related to the multiple exposures to
ionizing radiation.
Modern technologies for assessing spinal deformities are based on
assessment of the surface topography of the back in various ways.
Ortelius 800TM is a unique device that allows radiation-free, simple
and accurate assessment of spinal deformities.
Ortelius 800TM is based on direct measurement of the patient’s
back with a fingertip scanner. The fingertip scanner is equipped
with sensors, a fusion of varied technological elements. The
scanner is worn over the examiner’s index finger while leaving the
tip of the finger exposed. This maintains the palpation at the bare
fingertip to enable accurate recognition and recording of the ver-
tebral spinous processes. The examination is extremely concise and
the system provides very accurate recording of the spine coordi-
nate. The recorded positions are used to reconstruct the 3D contour
of the spine and to calculate the location of each verterbra as well
as deformity angle, graphically presented by the system on the
LCD monitor in real time.
The data is then digitized and stored and Ortelius 800TM provides
a novel method for plotting and analyzing the spine. Details regarding
the patient history and examination results are stored in the patient log
for comparisons with follow-up visits required for monitoring.Patients and Methods: 1500 Ortelius examens were collected and
retrospectively reviewed and analyzed.
Conclusion: Follow-up of the scoliotic patients with the Orte-
lius800�, provides the managing orthopaedic surgeon with a
radiation-free accurate Cobb angle measurement.
We propose the Ortelius 800 as a clinical tool for the routine follow-
up measurements of patients affected by spinal deformities such as
scoliosis and kyphosis, thus enabling a significant reduction of radi-
ation exposure.
26
THE ANTERIOR CERVICAL ARTHRODESIS
BY PLATE – CAGE
M. Quartarone, T. C. Russo, C. Casamichele, A. Tumino,G. Incatasciato, G. Giuca
Unit of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Major Hospital ofModica, Italy
Introduction: The anterior cervical arthrodesis is a procedure used
for the treatment of degenerative and post-traumatic diseases.
The present work aims to evaluate the cervical arthrodesis obtained
through the use of the plate-cage (PCB) that is a titanium- made
implant introduced recently in spinal surgery. It has a plate attached to
the anterior surface of the cage.
Materials and Methods: Were assessed 9 plates cage in 8 patients (6
males and 2 females), mean age 67 years. The follow-up has averaged
24 months. Patients were evaluated clinically, by VAS scale, ASIA
and SF36, which radiologically. It was valued in the local cervical
lordosis and general.
Results: This work has showed good stabilizations, which led to an
increase in cervical lordosis of levels treated in 100% of cases.
Conclusions: This technique allows to obtain stable arthrodesia,
while maintaining the advantages of cage or plate (restoring the
height of the interbody space and physiologic lordosis), has reduced
the complications related primarily to the mobilization of the implant.
Given that the final aim is segmental arthrodesis, the long-term status
of the adjacent mobile segments must be assessed.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 769
123
27
OUTCOME ASSESSMENT IN SCOLIOTIC
PATIENTS OPERATED ON VERTEBRAL
ARTHRODESIS
A. Accardo*, C. Latte*, G. Parente*, C. Gioia*, A. Toro**,S. Gatto***
*Medico in formazione specialistica Clinica Ortopedica S. U. N.Napoli; ** Direttore U. O. C. Ortopedia e Traumatologia ‘‘G.Fucito’’ Mercato San Severino (Sa); ***Professore e Direttore U.O. C. di Chirurgia riabilitativa del traumatizzato S. U. N. Napoli,Italy
Introduction: The follow-up of scoliotic patients operated on ver-
tebral arthrodesis shows excellent clinical and imaging results.
Nowadays there are few publications about life quality out come after
surgery. The aim of this work is to estimate trought a specific eval-
uation scale named SRS-22 the surgical correction on the life quality
in patients suffered by idiopathic scoliosis.
Materials and Methods: We checked 23 patients with idiopathic
scoliosis (7 males, 16 females) operated on vertebral arthrodesis.
Patients have been subdivided: 21 with idiopathic scoliosis; 1 case
with secondary scoliosis based on neurological disorders; 1 of
congenital kyphoscoliosis based on hemivertebra. The mean age is
16,9 years (range 14 - 25). The mean follow-up time after surgery
is 3,4 years (range 1 - 8). Every patients had SRS-22 which
includes five subjects (function/physical activties,pain, aspect,self-
esteem, mental health, treatment satisfaction),inside of these
subjects there are 5 items;the answers for each item goes from 1 to
5, the scale foresees points for every subjects,a satisfying result
will be more than 3
Results: In these three subjects function/physical activity, pain and
mental health, most of patients had a score more [ 3 while about
aspect/selfsteem and therapy satisfaction the 25% of them had a mean
score \ 3.
Discussion and Conclusions: We consider necessary to carry out an
outcome assessment about the life quality before and after surgical
treatment in order to estimate a right evaluation of scoliotic patients
operated on vertebral arthrodesis.
28
LUMBAR INTERSOMATIC ARTHRODESIS
WITH ‘‘B-TWIN’’ EXPANDIBLE CAGES
N. Ronchini, T. Godowicz, F. Kalfas, T. Capuzzo, P. Severi
Department of Neurosurgery, Galliera Hospitals, Genova, Italy
Lumbar intersomatic arthrodesis with ‘‘B-Twin’’ expandible cages is
an effective and simple surgical technique for symptomatic vertebral
instability.
This technique is particularly suggested in cases of degenerative
dynamic unstable I grade vertebral spondylolisthesis (with or without
the presence of spinal stenosis), and in cases of degenerative inter-
somatic vertebral instability (radiologic evidence of dynamic
disalignment of vertebral somatic plates, also without the presence of
spondylolisthesis), with the presence of symptomatic discal pathology
and/ or spinal stenosis.
In the last five years (2003-2007) we surgically treated with in-
tersomatic ‘‘B-Twin’’ expandible cages 40 patients (mean age:
63 years old, with a range of 39-82 years old).
Of these patients, 36 presented a I grade dynamic unstable
spondylolisthesis (associated to spinal stenosis in 27 cases, without
spinal stenosis in 9 cases), 4 presented degenerative intersomatic
vertebral instability without spondylolisthesis, but associated to
symptomatic herniated disk (3 cases) and to symptomatic spinal
stenosis (1 case).
‘‘B-Twin’’ cages were positioned in L4-L5 discal space in 32
cases, in L3-L4 in 11 cases, in L5-S1 in 1 case; in 4 patients we
positioned B-Twin in two different discal levels (L3-L4 and L4-L5).
We observed (mean follow-up = 18 months) a symptomatic
improvement in 90% of these patients.
In one case we found the mobilization of one cage.
In our opinion lumbar intersomatic arthrodesis with ‘‘ B-Twin’’
expandible cages is the surgical technique of choice in symptomatic I
grade spondylolisthesis, particularly when is also necessary to per-
form a discectomy for the presence of an herniated disk or when is
simultaneously necessary to perform a mono/bilateral laminectomy
for the presence of a spinal stenosis.
To achieve a correct positioning of ‘‘B-Twin’’ expandible cages is
mandatory the intraoperative Rx-scopy.
29
KYPHOPLASTY: DISTANT EFFECTS
A. Nicoletti, N. Giuffrida
U.O.C. Ortopedia e traumatologia P.O. Bronte - Azienda USL 3Catania, Italy
Percutaneous kyphoplasty is a procedure used for the treatment of
osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures. It is an injection of a
radiopaque bone cement into a cavity created in the vertebral body by
a balloon introduced through percutaneous way.
Compared with the vertebroplasty, kyphoplasty allows a restora-
tion of the vertebral body height and a reduction of kyphosis.
Moreover, applying this procedure, the risk of a venous embolization
caused by cements is lower, since cement is injected into a preformed
cavity.
The percutaneous kyphoplasty has reached a broad consensus,
particularly in USA where about 18.000 surgeries been performed in
2002.
Objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of the kyphoplasty on the
improvement of the quality of life in patients affected by osteoporotic
vertebral compression fractures.
Materials and Methods: Since November 2003, 46 patients (30
women and 16 men) have been treated. In 8 cases the surgery has
been implemented contemporaneously on 2 vertebral body. The other
cases have been operated at a single level.
About half of the treated fractures were at the lumbosacral level (D12
and L1). We have assessed the pain (VAS), the degree of kyphosis
(%), the quality of life (Owestry Disability Index), the vertebral
height restoration and the return to daily life.
All patients have been treated with the medical therapy for oste-
oporosis with bisphosphonates, PTH, or strontium ranelatic associated
with calcium and vitamin D.
Results: After the surgery, all patients have shown a remission of
pain and a rapid return to the everyday activities with a good quality
of life.
The three-year follow-up shows the maintenance of the vertebral
body height in the 70% of cases with low segmental kyphosis. In the
other cases, we have noticed a deformity of the operated vertebral
body (further crushing) or more osteoporotic fractures at the adjacent
levels.
770 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
Conclusions: The kyphoplasty perfomed in patients with vertebral
compression fractures reduces the pain, improves the static spine,
through a restoration of the vertebral body height, and improves the
quality of life.
It is a quick method of easy implementation. We currently perform it
in local anesthesia with mild sedation.
It offers the possibility to restore, at least in part, the alignment of
the spine if it is performed by the end of the first 2-3 months after the
fractures.
30
THE TREATMENT OF OSTEOPOROTIC VCFs
WITH BALLOON KYPHOPLASTY (BK): OUR
EXPERIENCE
A. Piazzolla, S. De Giorgi, M. W. C. Damato, G. De Giorgi
Azienda Ospedaliero Universitaria ‘‘Policlinico’’ - Bari –Dipartimento di metodologia Clinica e Tecnologie Medico-Chirurgiche, I Clinica Ortopedica, Italy.Direttore: Prof. G. De Giorgi
Background: The International Osteoporosis Foundation declares
one woman each three and one man each eight aged 50 and above are
affected with osteoporosis with an high risk of vertebral compression
fractures of spine (VCFs) after minimal or no trauma. Traditionally,
VCFs caused by osteoporosis have been treated with bed rest, narcotic
analgesics, brace, and physical therapy. In the time new possibilities
of treatment are enveloped: Vertebroplasty and Kyphoplasty. Ver-
tebroplasty is a medical procedure where bone cement is
percutaneously injected into the body vertebra in order to stabilize it
and fill the defect: polimethylmethacrylate (PMMA) cement is used.
Kyphoplasty involves the use of a device called a ballon tamp to
restore the height and shape of the vertebral body; this is followed by
application of bone cement (PMMA) to strengthen the vertebra. The
technique kyphoplasty can be performed within 60 days from the
fracture. A known complication of these minimally invasive proce-
dures is cement extravasation with lower risk in the kyphoplasty than
in vertebroplasty. Worldwide, over 95,000 VCFs in 75,000 patients
have been treated with balloon kyphoplasty. Results with the tech-
nique have been reported in prospective and retrospective studies in
patient with osteoporotic VCFs and in patients with fractures sec-
ondary to multiple myeloma.
Object: Aim of this study is to confirm the safety effectiveness of
balloon kyphoplasty (BK) in the treatment of VCF.
Patients and Methods: Between September 2001 and September
2008, 63 transpedicular BK in 61 patients with VCFs are performed
by our institute. The site of fractures was T12 (10), L1 (31), L2 (15)
and L3 (7). The mean time from the trauma was 6 days (min 2 max
15). The bilateral approach was done in 61 cases. The unilateral was
instead indicated in two cases with monolateral vertebral body
compression fracture. In 2 patients we treated double (2 levels) VCF.
The men age was 67,7 y.o. (min 62-max 89). Preoperative AP and
lateral X- Rays, MRI (T1-T2-STIR sequences) and CT scans of the
fractured vertebral body were always performed in all patients and
read always by the first author. In all patients, on lateral X-Rays scan,
we have measured the central and anterior vertebral body height,
valued as the ratio compared to posterior vertebral body height (Index
AH/PH=anterior vertebral body height/posterior vertebral body
height; index MH/PH=middle vertebral body height/posterior verte-
bral body height). We have also valued the Vertebral kyphosis (VK)
and the Regional kyphosis (RK). Vertebral kyphosis was measured
from the superior endplate to the inferior endplate of the fractured
vertebra. Regional kyphosis was measured from the inferior endplate
of the intact adjacent-distal vertebra to the superior endplate of intact
adjacent-proximal vertebra. Post-operative and 2-4-6-12 months-after
surgery Cobb angle, central and anterior height of the fractured ver-
tebral body, vertebral kyphosis (VK) and regional kyphosis (RK)
were assessed with radiographs and CT study, read always by the first
author. Also pain intensity was evaluated with a visual analogical
scale (VAS) preoperative, postoperative and 2-4-6-12 months-after
surgery.
Results: In our study, mean Vertebral kyphosis was 18,8 degrees
preoperatively (min 0-max 24), 7,34 degrees postoperatively (min 1-
max 22) and the same postoperatory degrees at the 2-4-6-12 months
follow-up. At the same time the mean Regional kyphosis angles were
respectively 12,84 (min 0-max 44), 10,65 (min 1-max 45) and the
same postoperatory degrees. The mean middle height ratio (MH/PH)
was 0,58 (min 0,24-max 0,82) preoperatively, 0,69 (min 0,52-max 1)
postoperatively and 0,67 (min 0,53-max 1) at the 12 months follow-
up. The mean anterior height ratio (AH/PH) was 0,77 (min 0,25-max
1) preoperatively, 0,85 (min 0,43-max 1) postoperatively and 0,84
(min 0,56-max 1) at 12 months follow-up. The average VAS (visual
analogical scale) score decreased from 8 (+/- 2) preoperatively, to 2
(+/- 1) one day after surgical procedure, to 0 (+/- 1) at 12 months
follow up.
Conclusions: In conclusion our results confirm the balloon kyp-
hoplasty improved multiple measurements of quality of life, back pain
and disability that last at least one year after the procedure.
31
IMPLANTS REMOVAL IN SPINE SURGERY:
FROM CAUSES TO CONSEQUENCES
S. De Giorgi, A. Piazzolla, A. Luca, G. De Giorgi
Dipartimento Di Metodologia Clinica E Tecnologie Medico-Chirurgiche - U.O. Ortopedia E Traumatologia I, Policlinico Bari.Chief: Prof. Giuseppe De Giorgi
Introduction: Metal implants removal in spine surgery is not usual, it
is performed in failures and complications and in fractures according
to the surgical programme.
Instrumentation removal can be definitive or temporary as the first
step of following surgeries.
This kind of removal can be intraoperative (neurological compli-
cation, revision surgery, etc.) or postoperative. The last one is early if
it is performed before the ripening of fusion or late.
Aim of the Study: Aim of our study was to evaluate the most
common causes of implants removal in our experience, the conse-
quences of the removal and the strategies we used to solve the most
complex cases.
Materials and Methods: The implants we removed were four Har-
rington, one Dove instrumentation, fifteen CD and similars
instrumentations.
There were three males and seventeen females, age at surgery
between 14 and 72 years old.
The most common diseases were adolescent idiopathic scoliosis
(4), and adult idiopathic scoliosis (5), congenital deformities (1),
postinfectious ones (2), secondary scoliosis (1), segmental instabili-
ties (1), tumours (1), spondylolysthesis (2), fractures (3).
Etiological causes were infections, implants breakage, cranial or
caudal hooks dislodgement, pseudoarthrosis, screws pull-out, wrong
choice of the fusion area, wrong strategy of instrumentation, pain
persistence without an apparent cause, early or late neurological
complications. In many subjects more causes were found.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 771
123
In many cases implants were removed only to be implanted again
in the same surgery or in a second time, after a good radiological
study (CAT, MRI). This occurred to better correct the deformity, to
extend fusion, to repair the pseudoarthrosis, to solve neurological
complications, while it was not effective in solving pain without
infections and pseudoarthrosis.
We observed in two subjects operated by adding collagenous
matrix as bone substitutes, an increasing of curve values in the fol-
lowing months after surgery, in spite of the implant removal after
more then two years from fusion, even in the absence of
pseudoarthrosis.
Conclusions: Our analysis shows that:
1. Normally, current implants are not removed, because they
perfectly integrate in the fusion and guarantee a good arthrodesis
evolution when it is performed without bone substitutes.
2. Implant removal and its reapplication to ameliorate the fusion
area and/ or to recover the compromised stability is the base for a
good result.
3. Pain disappearance is not always guaranteed by the implant
removal.
4. Definitive removal has to be realized in case of infection, but only
when fusion is recognized as mature, that is at nearly two years
after surgery.
5. In multisegmentary fusion realized in major surgery (scoliosis)
and performed by adding bone substitutes (collagenous matrix),
late metal implant removal equally exposes to the curve
worsening. In our opinion it occurs for a slow and late mass
fusion ripening.
32
ALGODISTROPHY OF THE SPINE: DIAGNOSIS,
PATHOGENESIS AND TREATMENT
A. Ramieri*, G. Costanzo*, V. Barci*, V. Petrozza*,C. della Rocca*
*Orthopaedics, The Don Gnocchi Foundation and RomeUniversity ‘‘La Sapienza’’ Polo Pontino; **Experimental Medicineand Pathology, Rome University ‘‘La Sapienza’’ Polo Pontino,Italy
Even without fractures, an osteoporotic vertebral body may develop
some structural modifications with dystrophic aspects, defined by the
literature as ‘‘intravertebral clefts’’ and ‘‘intravertebral vacuum’’.
Such phenomena can be painful and the MRI is the imaging technique
of choice for their evaluation. This is one of the forms of ‘‘Kummel-
Verneuil syndrome’’, a clinical entity which has been unjustly
neglected for 30 years, characterized by ischemic necrosis of the
vertebral body. The positive diagnosis is based on specific criteria but
one must always rule out spinal affections of inflammatory, infectious
and neoplastic nature. Recently, histological features of these lesions
are represented by blood accumulation with progressive trabecular
resorption. We observed and perspectively treated by biopsy and
vertebral percutaneous augmentation 16 algodistrophyc lesions of the
thoraco-lumbar spine (MRI hyperintensity = 7; vacuum = 9). Histo-
logic aspects during hyperintesity without vertebral body deformity
were neoangiogenesis, inflammation and blood gaps. During vacuum,
trabecular resorption prevailed. Vertebral augmentation achieved
good results on VAS and Oswestry score.
We assume that have identified three stages of the same disease.
During the first stage, the vertebral body is not deformed and it
appears with signal hyperintensity on MRI. The second stage is
characterized by intravertebral vacuum with initial vertebral body
deformity and ‘‘impending collapse’’ condition. Kummel’s disease
with complete vertebral body collapse due to osteonecrosis represents
the third stage. In our hand, vertebral percutaneous augmentation
seems to avoid the final vertebral collapse blocking these histological
and biomechanical cascades.
33
PHYSICAL-MATHEMATICAL MODELS
OF LUMBAR SPINE SEGMENTS SUBJECTED
TO TORSION
G. De Nunzio1, L. Tarricone2
1Materials Science Dept. – University of Salento – Lecce, Italy;2DOCstudio srl – Lecce, Italy
Introduction: Qualitative and quantitative understanding of stress
distribution in an intervertebral disc (IVD) is fundamental in order to
estimate the solicitations to which the disc is subjected. This infor-
mation is useful, in case of disc degeneration pathology, both in the
diagnostic phase and at therapeutic level.
This work deals with physical-mathematical models of a lumber spine
segment composed of two vertebrae (L5 and S1) and a IVD, and then
extends the model to a larger spine segment (from L4 to S1).
The purpose of our research is the analysis of tangential stress in
discs subjected to torsion because of the rotation of one or more adjacent
vertebrae.
Materials and Methods: In the first case study (L5/IVD/S1 system)
the inferior vertebra is fixed, while the superior one can axially rotate
around its equilibrium position. An intervertebral disc is situated
between the vertebrae, with its faces rigidly connected to L5 and S1.
In this model, L5 acts by transmitting the axial rotation movement to
the disc, while S1 exercises a constraint reaction on the disc, pre-
venting it from spinning, and subjecting it to torsion. This causes in
the disc a distribution of cross-sectional stress, whose strength varies
point by point and depends on L5 rotation angle and on the elasticity
parameters of the IVD fibers.
Our work delves into various simulation models, starting from an
elementary disc scheme like a hollow cylindrical structure with cir-
cular or elliptic section, of solid, elastic, approximately homogenous
material (the fibrous ring or annulus fibrosus) containing the nucleus
pulposus. This model has the advantage of being intuitive and
didactically effective, and shows how a rotation movement of L5
vertebra necessarily transmits torsional motion to the disc below,
which is thus subjected to tangential forces.
For a deeper description of the disc mechanics, it is however nec-
essary to resort to numerical simulations with finite element techniques.
These experiments are currently in progress at our Research Group,
both on the L5-IVD-S1 segment, and on a larger lumbar-spine segment
starting from L4, with the aim of putting in evidence the phenomena
happening in the system, and the distribution of disc stresses.
Preliminary Results and Conclusions: Being elementary models
approximated, surface stress values deduced from them are overes-
timated, if compared to experimental measurements in the literature.
The intervertebral-disc shape and its inner structure (an aggregate of
inhomogeneously distributed collagen fibrils) allow the absorption of
torque, and therefore of cross-sectional tensions on the annulus fibers,
more effectively than circular sections, though tangential stress is
however high and causes usury. More elaborated models show better
correspondence with experimental measures.
In particular, we are studying the distribution of stress in a lumbar
spine segment containing a degenerative disc, in order to understand
772 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
how the stress, than the degenerative disc cannot absorb any more, is
transferred to the nearby (superior) spine segments.
34
PERCUDYN: A NEW DEVICE FOR
PERCUTANEOUS TREATMENT OF LUMBAR
DEGENERATIVE DISC DISEASE (DDD)
M. Balsano, C. Doria*, A. Villaminar, M. Comisso
UO Ortopedia e Traumatologia – Centro Regionale diRiferimento per la Chirurgia Vertebrale - Schio, Vicenza, Italy;* Clinica Ortopedica Universita di Sassari, Italy
Objectives: To report the benefits of outpatient treatment for lumbar
DDD at 1-2 levels with a novel percutaneous facet augmentation device.
Methods: This is a prospective, non-randomized study to investi-
gate safety and efficacy of a new percutaneous device, PercuDyn, for
patients presenting mild/moderate DDD and concordant X-ray/MRI
who have failed conservative treatment for at least 6 months. The
mechanism of pain relief is by preserving disc height. Using percuta-
neous over-the-wire techniques and a 15 mm incision, the Teleport
dilator establishes a posterior working port at the base of the inferior
facet. Each device has a titanium Anchor and a PCU/titanium Stabilizer
that are serially introduced and mechanically connected in vivo via a
secure locking mechanism. Once the Anchor is driven through the pars
into the pedicle, the Stabilizer is ratcheted over the serrated shaft and
wedged between the inferior facet and the pars/lamina. One size
accommodates all patients with working lengths of 28-35 mm. Devices
are placed bilaterally at each treatment level. No additional rods or
connecting hardware are required. The procedure is reversible with
minimal anatomic impact on the spine.
Results: A clinical series of 34 patients with 96 implants have been
included in the study. We reported short operative times, discharge
from hospital within 4 to 24 hours, no significant complications and
marked improvement in ODI and VAS scores that were sustained at
6-18 month follow-up. Our initial series of outpatients were had
conscious sedation and did not require an airway intubation. 5-10 cc
of local anesthetic with epinephrine was administered.All patients
received intra-procedural antibiotics. Marked improvement in ODI
and VAS scores were noted on early follow-up.
Conclusions: Lumbar back pain and functional disability, measured by
VAS and ODI, can be successfully treated in ambulatory patients using
percutaneous techniques. Patients benefit from short procedure and
recovery times, and require fewer medications. Complication rates are
low.
35
THE ROLE OF SURGERY IN THE TREATMENT
OF VERTEBRAL METASTASIS
F. Tancioni, P. Navarria1, M. Lorenzetti, P. Pisano, P. Gaetani,A. Di Ieva, D. Levi, E. Aimar, S. Serra, A. Santoro2,M. Scorsetti1, R. Rodriguez y Baena
Department of Neurosurgery, 1Department of Radiotherapy,2Department of Oncology and Haematology, IRCCS IstitutoClinico Humanitas, Rozzano (Milano), Italy
Introduction: Increasingly effective oncology protocols have, on one
hand, raised average survival rate in patients with solid tumors, on the
other hand raised cases with secondary vertebral localizations. The
misconception by which a patient with secondary lesions of the
vertebral column is to be considered terminal rather than a candidate
for surgery, leads to grant and often dramatic developments which
could be avoided or at least better managed if planned ahead rather
than treated in emergency. Whereas we agree on the diagnostic-
therapeutic approach for primitive vertebral tumors, we can’t rely on
a common guidance universally accepted for the treatment of sec-
ondary lesions of the spine. 2.5% to 5% of patients affected by
malignant tumor, develop a compression of the spinal cord within the
last two years of life. Surgical techniques have evolved from simple
laminectomy, already practiced at the beginning of the century, to
modern decompression techniques such as stabilization, somatectomy
and vertebrectomy which are carried out through anterior, posterior
and combined anterolateral approaches. At present we do not have a
reference scale or classification applicable in clinical practice, only
clinical and instrumental references for the choice of the more
appropriate therapy.
Materials and Methods: In our study carried out at Istituto Clinico
Humanitas from 2004 to 2007 we reviewed 89 patients treated for
spinal cord compression affected by vertebral metastasis, for a total
number of 98 vertebral surgical procedures performed. 76 of them
have also undergone radiotherapy in the periooperative period. All 89
patients followed a multidisciplinary therapeutic course with onco-
logical, radiotherapeutic and neurosurgical approaches. The
considered characteristics were: ASA, KPS, spread of systemic dis-
ease (osseous and visceral), age, radiological and clinical evidence of
vertebra-compressive metastasis. Great importance was given to
clinical aspects (VAS and Frankel scale) and to the disease localized
evolution, obtaining further results from cross survival evaluations
between istotype and type of surgery.
Results: Global survival has resulted in 43.5% in a 12 months peri-
od; pain remission in almost every patient for an average remission
period of 12 months; neurologic recovery in 30/36 patients with
deficit before treatment. Local relapse disease was inferior to 11%,
with an average time to progression period of 7 months. We had
complications on 5 cases. Among 61 deaths on the follow up, 85%
were caused by primitive tumor disease.
Conclusions: Surgery has a substantially palliative significance in the
global process of treatment in patients affected by vertebral metas-
tasis. A multidisciplinary evaluation is vital to a correct patient
selection and to concretely carry out a therapeutic timing which takes
into account course and modalities of the natural evolution of the
compressive vertebral metastatic pathology. According to the study,
we conclude that a particular attention to the indications and thus to
the choice of the more appropriate surgical procedure/technique
results in a significant improvement in local control. If this element
may have an indirect effect on survival remains to be demonstrated. It
is still necessary to apply more comprehensive and universally
approved guidelines in order to obtain an advantageous homogeneity
in the treatment of vertebral metastasis.
36
TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION AND
PERCUTANEOUS VERTEBROPLASTY
F. Tancioni, P. Pisano, P. Gaetani, D. Levi, E. Aimar, A. Di Ieva,M. Lorenzetti, R. Rodriguez Y Baena
Department of Neurosurgery. Istituto Clinico Humanitas,Rozzano (MI), Italy
The vertebral fracture is the most common complication of the
ostheoporotic disease; in a significant percentage pain is
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 773
123
invalidating in spite of the forced rest, the use of orthesis devices
or bed setting which are, moreover cause of cardiorespiratory
complications. The evidence of a vertebral fracture is common in
tumoral pathology both in benign and malignant tumours) such as
a conseguence of direct or indirect traumas or in degenerative
diseases (i.e. Metabolic disorders) From years the different repair
techniques (vertebroplasty and cifoplasty) had permitted a quick
regression of pain and a fast functional recovery, becoming com-
monly used procedures in those centers equipped for vertebral-
fractured patients management.
However these procedures aren’t risk free: cement lickage from
the vertebral body, asymptomatic in most cases, may beco me a real
problem for the related clinical consequences. Since one year we have
been using a new device (Viscosafe Viscometer – Synthes) actually
available, that measures the real resin viscosity avoiding the viscosity
evaluation to be dependant upon the operator’s experience. This
because the the correct viscosity of the resin, that may be altered by
different variables such as temperature in particular, is very important
in the final result (distribution within the vertebral body, leackage
etc.) In our 40 patient-treated experience the percentage of resin
leackage, even if asymptomatic, fell from 40% to less than 20 %. This
percentage is even lower than those reported in the international lit-
erature. It’s to note that the high viscosity resin does not only reduce
the leackage from the vertebral body but also improves the distribu-
tion inside of it creating a radial distribution from the tip of the
injecting needle, thus avoiding further failures of the vertebral body
treatment. Last, but not least, the dedicated needles are fenestrated on
their side to permit a better control and the guidance of the distri-
bution of the cement limiting the necessity of a bipedicular approach
to the vertebral body.
37
TREATMENT OF THORACIC AND LUMBAR
FRACTURE WITH VERTEBRAL AUGMENTATION
BY BONE GRAFT
M. Girardo, A. Bruno, L. Caruso, M. Muratore, P. Viglierchio,S. Aleotti
Department of Spine Surgery; C.T.O., Torino, Italy
Introduction: Percutaneous vertebral augmentation (BVA) is an
emerging technology for the management of osteoporotic, traumatic
and neoplastic vertebral compression fractures (VCF). The reco-
struction with intravertebral polyethylene mesh sac (Optimesh) and
morcelized bone graft provided a minimally invasive efficacious and
controlled delivery mechanism to stabilize the fractures and treat the
pain.
Aim of the study was evaluate the evolution of single level frac-
ture after augmentation in non osteoporotic patients.
Material and Methods: 18 patients consecutive (11 men, 7 women),
with average of 38 +/- 14 years, underwent one level percutaneous
kyphoplasty for treatment of vertebral fracture at the thoraco-lumbar
spine. We managed fractures type A and B (Magherl’s classification).
All patients were radiologically examinated with X-Ray (2 P),
Computer Tomography (CT), and MR imaging. Follow –up was
carried out at the 1 month, 3 months, 6 months and at one year fol-
lowing treatment. We recorded and analysed the sagittal balance, the
vertebral body height, the kyphotic angle and the evidence of osseous
union of the bone graft. Pain assessment was carried out using a
patient-administered questionnaire as well as VAS scores determined
during the patient visits.
Results: Kyphoplasty was performed between T12 and L5. A total of
18 vertebral bodies were augmented. All patients was treated in one
time. All patients received immediate improvement in their pain. The
mean VAS reduction was 6. There were no cases of adjacent seg-
mental fracture seen on CT. At the last follow-up (one year), there
was demonstration, by CT, of bone remodelling and persistence of the
construct with the mesh and its contents still discernible and no
resorption of graft surrounding bone. There was no radiologic evi-
dence of hardware failure or subsequent re-kyphosis by CT and X-
Ray imaging. There was no new development of kyphosis deformity,
or loss of 5 degree. There were no complications.
Conclusion: The kyphoplasty with biological vertebral augmentation
in the treatment of compression fracture is a safe and efficacious
method to provide pain and increase function. There has been no
evidence of promotion of adjacent segment fracturing
38
SECOND GENERATION CERVICAL BI-
ARTICULAR DISC PROSTHESIS IN THE
TREATMENT OF CERVICAL DISC HERNIATION
R. Mastrostefano, R. Rispoli, M. Fontana
Neurosurgical Department, Avezzano, Italy
Discectomy, decompression, and interbody fusion are the traditional
surgical treatment of disc disease with neural element compression.
However2, it has been proved that fusion may cause or increase
adjacent level degeneration.
Cervical disc replacement has been considered as alternative
surgical solution to the fusion, for the symptomatic relief of pain by
neural decompression, without the resulting loss of motion associated
with a fusion procedure.
The present study analyses the results of 25 consecutive cases of
single level symptomatic cervical disc herniation, without important
osteophytosis, treated by a second generation cervical bi-articular disc
prosthesis.
All selected patients (15 $, 10 #, age 26-39, average 31), were
submitted to discectomy by anterior cervical approach, with simul-
taneous implant of bi-articular semi-constrained prosthesis Mobi-C�.
All the patients were pre-operatively submitted to cervical MRI and to
standard and dynamic plain x-rays films, to exclude instability. Effi-
cacy was assessed by evaluating pre and post-operative Neck
Disability Index, VAS score, Radiologic Range of Motion, and, at
follow-up, Odom’s criteria.
After the operation, all the patients improved, as confirmed by
VAS and NDI scores. Average follow-up was 20 months (range: 3-
36): primary stability of the implant was excellent at latest follow-up,
and no spontaneous ossification was noticed at operated levels. Ex-
cellents clinical results was observed in 24 cases. Only one case had
post-operative minor complication (transient dysphonia), but had
relief of radicular pain. ROM also improved in 80% of cases. All the
patients came back to their work.
The second generation prosthesis permits the self positioning of
the superior plate versus the inferior plate, through the controlled
mobility of the mobile insert, limits the constraints on the bone/
implant interface (origin of dislocation), and favors the decrease of
the constraints on the posterior facet joints. The self centering of the
mobile insert favors the respect of the instantaneous rotation centers,
and also gives back to the treated intervertebral segment its natural
physiological movement within the respect of the cervical lordosis.
This prosthesis present a surprendent simplicity of insertion (one
774 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
step), which is similar to a cage, in opposite to the first generation
prosthesis.
39
RIGID VS. HYBRID THORACIC AND/OR LUMBAR
STABILIZATION
N. Koumpouros, R. Rispoli
Department of Neurosurgery, ‘‘SS. Filippo e Nicola’’ Hospital,Avezzano, Italy
The indications for thoracic and lumbar dorsal instrumentation are
evolving. The most common current use for thoracolumbar instru-
mentation systems is in the setting of degenerative lumbosacral
instability. The stabilizing effect of dorsal instrumentation allows for
earlier mobilization of patients with traumatic or neoplastic spinal
instability. The role of fusion and instrumentation for the treatment of
dysfunctional motion segments remains somewhat controversial.
However the improvement of materials and implant systems has
permitted the extension of the indications. The introduction of hybrid
systems has ameliorated the biomechanical properties of the instru-
mented spine. The combination of rigid instrumentation with dynamic
or elastic systems may offer response to complex biomechanical
problems. Hybrid stabilizing systems reduce the incidence of adjacent
segment syndrome. Hybrid solutions permit customizing and patient-
tailored solutions. However still remain several controversial aspects
concerning the appropriate use of rigid or hybrid systems for thora-
columbar stabilization.
In the current presentation we present our experience in the use of
either rigid or hybrid stabilizing systems. The latter ones include
different dynamic or elastic solutions. We discuss biomechanical
advantages of different systems and present our results.
Although no benefit regarding neurologic outcome has been
demonstrated, the use of hybrid stabilizing systems has improved the
biomechanical behaviour of the instrumented spine and reduced
adjacent segment incidence in selected cases.
40
HIATROGENIC STENOSIS OF THE FORAMEN
MAGNUM DUE TO FIBROSIS AND ADHESIONS,
WITH CONGENITAL STENOSIS OF C2 IN THE
ACHONDROPLASIA: MULTIDISCIPLINARY
APPROACH AND SURGICAL TREATMENT
F. Guarnera, A. Florio, M. Furnari, M. Giuffrida, G. Ponzo,G. F. Nicoletti
Catania, Italy
Introduction: in the paediatric population with achondroplasia, ste-
nosis and compression at the level of the foramen magnum commonly
occurs and can give rise to lethal neurological complications also due
to a cervico-medullary compression. Stenosis is osteo-fibrous’ type:
reduction of diameter of the foramen magnum coexists and there is
almost always a thickened reactive fibrous tissue band overlooking
the dura mater. The appearance of specific neurological deficits due to
the chronic compression of the cervico-medullary region, the evi-
dence of stenosis to the imaging (compression of the cervico-
medullary region, lack of CSF space at the level of foramen magnum
etc.), represents an indication to the surgical treatment.
Materials and Methods: the AA. report a case of three and half years
old child operated on already at the age of fourth months, at another
neurosurgical center, with C1 laminectomy only, because of frequent
and serious fits of dyspnea and cyanosis. He came to our observation
subsequently to progressive clinical impairment from about
15 months. The indication to a surgical procedure of wide occipito-
cervical decompression has been valued with multidisciplinary
approach (pediatricians, neuroradiologists, paediatric anesthetists,
neurosurgeons). The surgical procedure was performed on with a
bony decompression at the level of occiput and the midline posterior
arch of C1 and C2. The bone removed was limited to approximately
3 cm. in width to avoid the complications of cerebellar sagging or
craniocervical instability. Also the thickened reactive fibrous tissue
band was carefully separated from the underlying dura mater at the
level of the previous laminectomy of C1. The patient in the immediate
post-operative course, was transferred in the department of intensive
care where he was observed carefully for improvement of his pre-
operative neurological symptoms.
Results: the following post-operative course was very good. The follow
up has shown an important improvement of the neurological findings.
Conclusions: the surgical treatment of the cervico-medullary com-
pression according to the data of the literature stays controversial
because of different opinions: the one believes that it deal with a
surgery that doesn’t give up of hazards in terms of mortality and
morbidity and that the stenosis would go toward to a progressive
resolution following the growth of the child owed to a physiological
widened of the foramen magnum, the other favorable to an early
surgical operation with the purpose to prevent irreversible or cata-
strophic neurological damages (‘‘sudden death’’).
The AA. they share such thought as many other Authors. We think
to propose a clinical multidisciplinary assessment with a complete
neuroradiological study at the first year of lifetime. In cases of
important stenosis we propose bony and fibrous decompression
(suboccipital craniectomy with opening of the foramen magnum,
C1 laminectomy and if necessary also C2, removal of the thickened
reactive tissue band), as in the symptomatic patients as in the
patients without symptoms that have alterations of the evoked
potential or cervico-medullary signs of compression on RM. The
C1 laminectomy only in such patients is not ufficient in to deter-
mine a meaningful clinical improvement, also in the time, of thel
patients.
41
PEDUNCOLAR SCREWS INSERTED BY FREE
HAND TECNIQUE IN THE TREATMENT OF 120
SCOLIOSIS CASES
M. Crostelli, O. Mazza, M. Mariani
Children Jesus Pediatric Hospital Palidoro-Roma, Italy
The authors present 120 dorso-lumbar scoliosis cases treated by
posterior instrumented arthrodesis with the use of peduncolar screws
inserted by free hand tecnique, without using navigator or exploring
laminectomy and with limited x-ray aid.
In the cases there are idiopatic scoliosis, neurological scoli-
osis, and scoliosis associated with dismorphic and congenital
diseases.
In 60% of cases the authors used ibrid instrumentation with
lumbar and dorso-lumbar screws, dorsal hooks and laminar wires,
while in 40% of patients they used only dorsal or lumbar screws.
In patients treated by hybrid instrumentation (pedicle
screws + laminar hooks) mean age has been 14 years and 6 months
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 775
123
(12 years 3 months–20 years 8 months), mean follow up 46 months
(24 months–134 months). Mean Cobb angle value of scoliosis curve
treated by laminar hooks has been 73� before surgery (63�–96�).
Mean curve correction has been 43% (27�–66�). Mean curve value
after surgery in scoliosis treated by laminar hooks has been 37,5�(16�–46�), with 49% bettering.
Mean Cobb angle value of scoliosis curve treated by peduncolar
screws has been 50,2� (30�–65�) before surgery. Mean value after
surgery in scoliosis treated by screws has been 19,2� (15�–30�), with
60% bettering.
In patients treated by all screws instrumentation mean age has
been 14 years and 9 months (12 years 5 months–21 years), with
mean follow up of 30 months (24 months–48 months).
Mean Cobb angle value of scoliosis in these patients has been 79�before surgery (48�–97�); curve correction has been 40%. After sur-
gery mean curve value has been 27� (9�–46�).
There was no case of major complication (infection, neurological
lesion of any type, vascular lesion, or other kind of iatrogen lesion). In
10 patients in standard X-ray examination there was defective posi-
tion of screws, without any complication and without consequence on
arthrodesis and on correction obtained or on patient clinical condition.
There was no necessity of more accurate examination like CAT.In
authors opinion use of peduncolar screws leads to best correction and
balancing of vertebral bodies, with better results after time on man-
taining the correction.
Free hand technique with screws at every level has longer surgical
timing than ibrid constructs, and if x-ray are use during surgery
exposition by patients and phisicians is enhanced. In the personal
experiences of authors this risk is reduced by the terminal check when
the screws are all placed. Blood loss, tissues exposition is slightly
wider, in the personal experiences the mean is about 45.The radiations
absorbed by operators, patient and operatory room personnel are
reduced using the terminal check. Free hand tecnique, even at thoracic
level, is an affordable procedure but, having potential severe com-
plications, should be used only by experienced operators, with
peculiar expertise in vertebral surgery and moreover in vertebral
deformity surgery. Learning curve is very long and execution must be
accurate.
42
TRANSFORAMINAL ENDOSCOPIC DISCECTOMY
S. Scopetta, N. Calabrese, R. De Vizia, U. De Crescenzo,M. Vollaro
Casa di Cura ‘‘GE.P.O.S.’’ Telese Terme (Benevento), Italy
Since 1960, there has been a development in minimally invasive
percutaneous techniques for treating lumbar discal hernias, bearing in
mind, the different ways of operating. In the 70 Kambin e Hijikata
performed the first percutaneous nucleotomy without direct vision
check. The approach of transforaminal description was a great step
forward in disc lumbar surgery. In 1994 Matthews and Kambin in
1996 started treating lumbar hernias with the transforaminal
approach. We have been using Thomas Hoogland technique since
June 2006 but is still not common in Italy.
Materials and Methods: Since June 2006 to October 2008, we have
treated 30 patients, of which 16 male and 14 female, aged 25 to 65
with back pain, and or radiculopathy for the most part the latter. Were
all tested with VAS (back and leg), ODI and MacNab questionnaire.
The radiological diagnosis has been of 20 intraforaminal and 10
postero-lateral. Treated levels: 17 L4-L5; 8 L5-S1; 5 L3-L4.
The uniportal system (Thessis e Max-More) has allowed discal her-
nias to be removed using the transforaminal approach under
simultaneous visual check in surgical manoeuvres.
It is made of a foraminoscope (6,5 mm Ø) light, camera, cannula,
drills, bipolar, forceps and monitor. The patient lies on his side, local
anaesthesia about 10 cc and Remifentanil (Ultiva). Operating time is
60-80 minutes, all patients were discarged a few hours later.
There have been no immediate or tardy complications. Follow-up
1 year: excellente and good in 81,4 % (MacNab).
Conclusions: The transforaminal approach with direct and concurrent
vision, allows the treatment of non contained LDH intraforaminal and
postero-lateral.
Cranially or caudally herniated fragments and those that take up more
than 50 % of spinal canal cannot be reached by this approach.
The limits of this technique,is mainly due to the localization and
dimension of the hernia and sometimes to anatomic problems.
The transforaminal approach has some advantages with other per-
cutaneous techniques, and has also some important characteristics such
as the removal of non contained LDH and the possibility to operate
under direct vision check. This procedure should be taken into con-
sideration whenever possible to standard surgery.
43
ASSOCIATION BETWEEN ABLATION WITH
RADIO-FREQUENCY AND VERTEBROPLASTY
IN VERTEBRAL METASTASES TREATMENT
A. Toro, G. Calabro, G. Iervolino, G. F. Trinchese
Divisione Ortopedia e Traumatologia – Ospedale ‘‘G.Fucito’’ – Mercato S. Severino (SA), Italy
Summary: The contemporary use of these two techniques is reported
only by few studies with similar encouraging results. 14 patients
affected by lumbago or dorsalgy from vertebral metastases, have been
selected from those referring to our center from March 2004 to
October 2006. Patients have also been given a pain evaluation scale
(verbal numerical scale) and an evaluation scale of their quality of life
(SF-36). While the patient was lying on the operating table, face
down, the trocar was placed in the relative vertebral body in a trans-
peduncular way. Once the tip was taken off, some small bone samples
were taken for the bioptic exam and then for the ablation in radio-
frequency; once this phase was over, the bone cement was prepared
and then injected in the vertebral body.
Of the 14 patients treated, all have reported a decrease of the pain
within one week. The average score in the Verbal Numeric Scale
decreased from 9.1±0.6/10 in the pre-operation period to 4.3±0.8/10
in the after operation period, with a statistically significant decrease
(p\0.0001) of the pain perception.
In the same way, it was possible to record a statistically significant
average improvement (p\0.0001) of the SF-36 scores, which went
from an average value of 22.5±0.2 to 59.4±0.6.
Similarly to the results of other works, 100% of the patients
we treated had a drastic decrease of the pain perception in one week.
In literature there are few works on the association of radio
frequencies and vertebroplasty in the treatment of vertebral metasta-
ses, but, as in our study, the results are very encouraging.
776 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
44
TREATMENT OF DEGENERATIVE DISC DISEASE
AND INSTABILITY OF THE LUMBAR SPINE BY
MEANS OF LUMBAR INTERBODY FUSION
VIA LATERAL PERCUTANEOUS APPROACH
ASSOCIATED WITH MINIMALLY INVASIVE
PEDICLE-SCREW FIXATION. TECHNICAL NOTE
U. Agrillo, K. Panagiotopoulos, L. Corbino, G. Schettini,F. Puzzilli, M. Giarrusso*
Neurosurgical Division, Sandro Pertini Hospital, Rome, Italy;*Neurosurgical Department, University of Catania, Italy
In recent years minimally invasive techniques for lumbar interbody
fusion and lumbar fixation gained popularity worldwide. Herein, we
present a personal technique for lumbar interbody fusion via a lateral,
true percutaneous unilateral approach, associated with minimally
invasive pedicle-screw fixation for the treatment of degenerative disc
disease and instability of the lumbar spine. We provide a step-by-step
description of the procedure along with preliminary clinical and
radiological outcome, and we discuss indications and limitations of
the procedure. We believe that the present technique may offer a
valuable alternative to other anterior and posterior interbody fusion
procedures in terms of minimal invasiveness, operative duration and
surgical risks.
45
PATHOMORFOLOGY OF THE LIGAMENTA
FLAVA IN LUMBAR SPINAL STENOSIS
E. Ferrari*, S. Faraglia*, R. Postacchini**
*Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University ‘‘Sapienza’’,Rome, Italy; ** Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University‘‘Tor Vergata’’, Rome, Italy
Numerous studies have shown that the ligamenta flava play a sig-
nificant role in the compression of the neural structures in patients
with lumbar stenosis. However, it is still unclear whether structural
modifications of these ligaments are present in stenotic patients.
The aim of this study was to analyse the microscopic and ultra-
structural changes of the ligamenta flava in patients undergoing
surgery for lumbar stenosis and to compare them with those in
patients operated for vertebral fractures. The clinical relevance of this
study is related to the use of interspinous spacers in the treatment of
lumbar stenosis.
Materials and Methods: Ligamenta flava obtained from 10 patients
with stenosis of the lumbar spinal canal, aged 46 to 82 years (mean,
64), were studied at histological, histochemical and ultrastructural
level. The control group was represented by ligamenta flava excised
from 6 patients (mean age, 46 years) who underwent surgery for
thoracolumbar fractures.
Results: The ligamenta flava of the control group consisted of
numerous, extremely thick elastic fibres, thin bundles of collagen
fibres and few fibrocytes containing with a scarce amount of cyto-
plasm. Near the attachment of the ligaments to the laminae, the tissue
showed fibrocartilaginous features with cells which had intermediate
features between fibrocytes and condrocytes. In subjects in the control
group aged more than 50 years, the cells were less numerous and
showed poorly developed cytoplasmic organelles.
The ligamenta flava of stenotic patients showed large areas in which
the elastic fibres were few in number and thin, and were separated by
abundant collagen tissue. In some cases, elastic fibres consisting only
of microfibrils were observed. In these areas, the fibrocytes were more
numerous and had the features of actively synthesizing cells.
Degenerated elastic fibres and aggregates of amourphous electron
dense material were occasionally seen in the intercellular matrix
Conclusion: With advancing age, the ligamenta flava undergo grad-
ual fibrotic and chondrometaplasic changes. In stenotic patients, the
decrease in elastic fibres, the increase in size of the fibrotic areas and
those of chondroid metaplasia lead to a considerable decrease in
elasticity of the ligaments. As a result, they become less thinner in
flexion of the spine and protrude more in the spinal canal in the
standing position, and particularly in extension of the spine, due to the
inability to shorten with no thichening as occurs in the presence of a
normal elasticity of the tissue. This holds when the ligament is either
thickened and of normal thickness.
These findings may be of relevant importance to understand the role of
distraction of the spine, and thus of the ligaments, obtained by inter-
spinous spacers, which extend and put in flexion the vertebrae of the
motion segment by increasing the intervertebral distance posteriorly.
46
PROSPECTIVE CLINICAL RESULTS OF 1 LEVEL
CERVICAL ARTHROPLASTY WITH THE
PRESTIGE DEVICE: PRELIMINARY RESULTS
A. P. Fabrizi, M. Galarza, R. Maina
Torino, Italy
Introduction: The rate of symptomatic adjacent cervical level that
may occur after Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion (ACDF) is
up to 30% is concerning. The cervical disc replacement provides an
option for the treatment of radiculopathy and myelopathy degenera-
tive anterior cervical spine, while it may prove to provide an impact
on the development of adjacent segment disease.
Methods: To check the preliminary results about efficacy and safety
of the Prestige cervical replacement.
This is a prospective study of 35 patients with cervical arthroplasty at
a single institution with the Prestige device for 1 disc level. There
were 20 sole implants and 15 associated with other ACDF. Follow-up
is up to 2 years now, and the results are reported in terms of Visual
Analog Scale (VAS) for pain, VAS for patient satisfaction, and
flexion-extension range of motion.
Results: Improvements in neuropathy, pain, and patient satisfaction is
noted in 90% of patients. There is a trend to increased benefit in cases
with multi-level fusion, which correlates to increased preoperative
disability. At the mean 12-month follow-up imaging all patients had
solid bone fusions with device. There was no sign of heterotopic
ossification in any patient and no patient experienced migration of the
cervical replacement. There have been no re-operations for continued
pain. No adjacent segment problems have been detected at final
follow up imaging.
Conclusions: Cervical disc replacement had good clinical results as
measured by preoperative and postoperative VAS. Radiographic study
suggested normal motion at implanted site and restrictive postoperative
management is not required. In our opinion, Prestige cervical disc
replacement is a stable implant in reconstructing cervical spine after
anterior discectomy. This study represents the largest number and longest
follow-up of single level cervical disc replacement in Italy. Final effec-
tiveness will be determined after long-term follow-up studies.
Learning Objectives: Keywords: Anterior Cervical Discectomy and
Fusion (ACDF) cervical disc replacement Prestige
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 777
123
47
INTERSPINOUS PROCESS DECOMPRESSION
WITH THE BACJAC DEVICE FOR LUMBAR
SPINAL STENOSIS: PRELIMINARY CLINICAL
EXPERIENCE
A. Zachos, C. Doria, A. Ruggiu, F. Milia, L Tidu P. Lisai,P. Tranquilli-Leali
Orthopaedic Department – University of Sassari, Italy
Background: The BacJac is a new interspinous process decompres-
sion device designed to distract the posterior elements of a stenotic
lumbar segment and place it in flexion in those patients with neuro-
genic intermittent claudication. Materials and
Methods: We present 8 months follow-up data on the BacJac
patients. The inclusion criteria for the trial were leg, buttock, with
back pain relieved during flexion and claudication (being able to walk
at least 100 meters). The exclusion criteria were fixed motor deficit,
cauda equina syndrome, previous lumbar surgery or spondylolisthesis
greater than grade I at the affected level. From April 2008 to
November 2008 nineteen patients have been included in this study (8
women and 11 men). The average follow-up was 4 months and the
average age was 57 years. Thirteen patients had the BacJac implanted
at either L3-L4, L4-L5 or L5-S1 levels. Five patients had the BacJac
implanted at both L3-4 and L4-5 levels and one at three levels L2-L3,
L3-L4 and L4-L5. Two patients had a grade 1� spondylolisthesis, the
other seventeen single or multi level spinal degenerative stenosis.
Results: The mean preoperative Oswestry score was 47. The mean
postoperative Oswestry score was 16. The mean preoperative VAS
score was 8.7 and the mean postoperative one was 3.8. Our results
have demonstrated a very good success rate in the BacJac interspi-
nous process decompression group at an average of 5 months
postoperatively.
Conclusion: The initial effectiveness data as seen in the significant
improvements on both VAS and ODI have also suggested that the
BacJac could be a viable treatment option for patients with low-back
pain caused by degenerative disc disease and low grade spondylo-
listhesis. Furthermore, the characteristic feature of this device is the
low invasiveness and the possibility of use it in L5-S1 thanks to the
variety of sizes and its simple surgical approach.
48
PERCUTANEOUS AXIAL LUMBOSACRAL
INTERBODY FUSION: PRELIMINARY CLINICAL
AND RADIOLOGICAL RESULTS
A. Zachos, C. Doria, L. Tidu, F. Milia, A. Ruggiu, P. Lisai,P. Tranquilli-Leali
Istituto di Clinica Ortopedica – Universita degli Studi di Sassari,Italy
Background: Anterior access to the L5-S1 disc space for interbody
fusion can be technically challenging, frequently requiring the use of
an approach surgeon for adequate exposure. We reviewed our expe-
rience with a novel minimally invasive technique for L5-S1 interbody
fusion (Trans1) that exploits the pre-sacral space and its relative
dearth of critical structures.
Materials and Methods: 4 patients were included in this analysis.
Average follow-up was 6 months. Back pain was secondary to
lumbar degenerative disc disease (DDD) in 2 cases, failed-back
surgery syndrome in 1 case and lytic spondylolistesis in another 1
case. All patients had radiographic evidence of L5-S1 degenera-
tion and underwent percutaneous fusion with Trans1 cage and
local bone autograft. Trans1 was followed by percutaneous ped-
icle screw-rod fixation in 2 patients; in the remaining 2 patients
facet joint screw fixation devices were implanted. Clinical eval-
uation was performed using a visual analogue scale (VAS) and
Oswestry form.
Results: Mean operative time for the Trans1 procedure was 55
minutes. All patients had radiographic evidence of stable L5-S1
interbody cage placement and fusion at last follow-up. The VAS
scores assessing back pain improved significantly from 7.20 to 2.65.
The mean Oswestry score improved significantly from 58.3% to
31.5%. No device related complications were identified.
Conclusion: The percutaneous paracoccygeal approach to the L5-S1
interspace provides a minimally invasive corridor through which
discectomy and interbody fusion can safely be performed. It can be
used alone or in combination with minimally invasive or traditional
open fusion procedures. It may provide an alternative route of access
to the L5-S1 interspace in those patients who may have unfavourable
anatomy for or contraindication to traditional open anterior approach
to this level.
49
CLINICAL AND RADIOLOGICAL OUTCOME
AFTER TREATMENT OF CERVICAL
DEGENERATIVE DISEASE WITH STAND-ALONE
CAGE: LONG-TERM FOLLOW-UP STUDY OF 116
PATIENTS
P. Quaglietta, S. Aiello, G. Corriero
Azienda Ospedaliera di Cosenza; Dipartimento di Emergenza -U.O. di Neurochirurgia, Italy
Aim Of The Study: anterior cervical discectomy and fusion
(ACDF) with cage is currently the gold standard for surgical
treatment of patients with symptomatic single- or two-level cervical
degenerative disc disease. The purpose of this study was to eval-
uate the long-term results in these patients taking into account of
clinical signs changes and symptomatic disc disease appearances on
adjacent segments.
Methods: From December 2001 to December 2007 one hundred and
sixteen consecutive patients underwent to anterior cervical discec-
tomy and fusion with CBK cage (ACDF) (82 males and 34 females,
average age 49.8 years) for a total of 130 implants. The clinical and
radiological data are based on standard and dynamics X-ray and on
MRI images. The follow-up was conducted with a telephone
questionnaire, ambulatory clinical examination, with the VAS scale
for pain and Oswestry scale for disability. Have also been per-
formed cervical spine static and dynamic X-ray at 1, 3, 6 and
12 months after surgery to assess the spine stability, sagittal
alignment, mobility of the treated segment and any presence of
antero or retrolisthesis. In 20 patients MRI was performed 2 years
after surgery to assess the change of disc space height at operated
level and at adjacent levels, the spondylosis progression, the
improvement of the area of the anterior spinal canal and appearance
of disease in adjacent segments.
778 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123
Results: The average follow-up was 3 years. There were no intra-
operative complications and no cage subsidence. All patients were
discharged within 72 hours with a cervical orthosis to be weared for
30 days. Radiographic follow-up showed the cervical spine good
stability without evidence of collapse or cage subsidence. Two
patients showed a slight anterolisthesis on operated level following a
mothorvehicle accident. In any case, the cervical spine showed a
mobility in adjacent segments in the functional tests. The follow-up
MRI showed, in all cases, good decompression in the treated levels. In
sixteen patients (13.8%) MRI showed new diseases in adjacent seg-
ments (osteophithosis, disc disease, spinal stenosis). In four of these
cases (3.4%) new surgery was necessary. In 15% of the patients there
was a clinical worsening. In only one case was observed ossification
of posterior longitudinal ligament. At follow-up we had eighty-five
percent of patients with an excellent or good results according to
Odom’s criteria, while in 15% of cases the results have been poor.
Eighty-two percent of patients have resumed their work. At the final
follow-up the VAS rating was 2.1 and Oswestry average score was
23.1.
Conclusions: The outcome of ACDF has good clinical results during
long-term follow-up. The cervical spine stabilization, which for us
was the most important parameter, has been ensured in all patients.
The incidence of the adjacent-segment disease in our experience is in
line with those published in the literature even if the percentage of
patients who had to undergo to further surgery is lower than the
literature. Indeed we believe that surgery does not cause a variation in
the natural history of degenerative disease of the cervical spine, but at
most result in a stop of symptoms progression.
Of course, our results, also compared with those in the literature,
can not be considered conclusive taking into account that this is a
retrospective study with a small number of patients remotely
controlled with MRI and also relation to the follow-up period still
short.
50
THE PALLIATIVE TREATMENT OF VERTEBRAL
METASTATIC LESIONS: VESSELPLASTY
G. Guizzardi*, D. Fabris Monterumici�
*Neurosurgery, University and City Hospital Careggi, Firenze;�Spine Surgery Department, University Hospital, Padova, Italy
Introduction: The Vesselplasty is relatively new method of the
percutaneous transpedicolar Kyphoplasty, which allows to fill the
cement directly in to a container cutting down the risk of leakage.
Materials and Methods: The Authors present their experiences of
using such a method in metastatic Vertebral Compression Fractures
and general form, myeloma multiple, etc., in cases where the sur-
gical intervention is not indicated and the patients were negative for
the neurological point of view. This method is preferred in many of
these cases where it was very important solution of continuity the
cortical of the vertebrae. 30 patients have been treated with 35
levels.
Results: The result has been really excellent, relatively to pain relieve
and even for the percent of vertebral leakage (4.5%).The truthful of
such a percent is absolutely verified by all the patients, because they
were examined after the surgery by CT. In none of cases the leakage
was clinically significant, and nobody had complications.
Conclusions: In our opinion this method is particularly indicated in
cases where the risk of leakage is high.
51
THE USE OF THE NEOADJUVANT MALIGNANT
TUMOURS OF THE SACRUM
M. A. Rosa, G. Maccauro*, G. Giuca
Section of Orthopaedics - Surgical Specialties Department -Policlinico Universitario ‘‘G. Martino ‘‘- Messina; *Department ofOrthopaedic Science - Orthopaedics and Traumatology -Universita Cattolica Sacro Cuore – Roma, Italy
Introduction: The authors report their experience on 28 cases of
malignant tumors in sacred location which includes 21 primary
tumors (5 Cordomi, 3 Giant Cell Tumors, 2 Ewing’s sarcoma, 1
Condrosarcoma) and 7 secondary locations (3 from Breast k,2 from
Prostate k,1 from Renal k, 1 from Pulmonary k).
Materials and Methods: Malignant lesions observed showed a dif-
ferent clinical disease under the seat (sacrum proximal: region S1-S2,
sacrum distal: region S3, S4, S5), the size and the histological
aggressiveness. Outside of Myelomas in which the act diagnostic
biopsy was followed always and exclusively by chemotherapy anti-
blastic, all other histological type, after closure biopsy, have
undergone surgery that included the use of ‘‘ curettage ‘‘ associated
with the use of liquid nitrogen and in three cases, the use of
methylmethacrylate.
The selective arterial embolization was performed in pre-operative
in order to reduce the vascularization in the three cases of giant cell
tumours and in two cases of Ewing’s sarcoma, since the Cordoma and
Condrosarcoma, poorly vascularised tumours.
Conclusions: With regard to the metastatic embolization was per-
formed in secondary injury of Renal K, in the one Lung k and in two
out of three cases the lesions secondary to Breast K.
The surgical ‘‘en block’’ was not in ‘experience of the authors never
performed for high risk traders and serious neurological deficits as
possible especially in proximal locations. In the authors’ use of liquid
nitrogen has a greater impact of surgical treatment with a subsequent
extension in the range free from disease. This ‘‘disease free intervall’’
is different when tumors are distinguished for local aggressiveness,
although with different biological nature, such as Giant Cell
Tumors, the Cordoma and Condrosarcoma I and II grade, highly
malignant tumors such as secondary locations and the Ewing’s Sar-
coma in which the surgical action is always associated with a
multidisciplinary treatment involving the use of chemotherapy and /
or radiotherapy.
52
OUR EXPERIENCE USING EBPM (PARNAPERIN)
ON VERTEBRAL SURGERY
C. Casamichele, T. C. Russo
Modica (RG), Italy
Since one year, on our orthopaedic department (Ospedale Maggiore
Modica and Ospedale Busacca Scicli), we have done antitrombotic
Prophilaxisis on 20 patients underwent major vertebral surgery with
EBPM (parnaparin) for 30 days.
Aim of our study is to check, using ematochimic Exams and
doppler of lower legs, efficacy of this drugs in order to avoid TVP and
lung embolya.
Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780 779
123
We had a control group of 20 patients with the same kind of
surgery and deseases without EBPM.
Material and Methods: 20 patients were treated with parnaparin in
order toh ve tromboembolyc prophilaxisys (10 man – 10 woman)
mean age 40 years using a personal evaluation score involving ematic
coagulation elements, risk factors, associated desease, other terapy
and collaterals effect. We didn’t advise, since today any embolic
complication or lung embolysm.
780 Eur Spine J (2009) 18:727–780
123