Upload
mysa-vijay
View
170
Download
6
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Predicting Stock Market Returns and the Efficiency Market Hypothesis
By: Mohammad AbouzarKarthik GollapinniVijay Soppadandi
Professor: Lutz Maria Kolbe
Advisor: Patrick Urbanke
Department of Business AdministrationGeorg-August University of GoettingenCrucial Topics In Information ManagementJanuary 30th, 2015
Overview Introduction Algorithms 1st Effort: Lu et al. (2009) Analysis 2nd Effort: Ince and Trafalis (2006) Analysis 3rd Effort: Khansa and Liginlal (2011) Analysis Conclusion
2
3
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Introduction Motivation:
Issues in Investment Decision Making Efficiency Market Hypothesis
Why do we care? Our Goal:
Stock Market Returns Prediction Test EMH Theory
Methodology Evaluation
4
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Algorithms 1/5 - ARIMA AutoRegressive Integrated Moving Average Integrated Non-Stationary Process Identification:
Autocorrelation Function Partial Autocorrelation
Hypothesis Testing Estimation:
Maximum Likelihood Estimation Diagnostic Checking
Forecasting: Dynamic Forecast
5
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Algorithms 2/5 - VAR Vector Auto Regression Multi-Equation System An Equation for Each Variable as Dependent Variable
Yt = A + B1Yt-1 + B2Yt-2 + … + BpYt-p + εt
Why VAR? Time Series Data with Autoregressive Nature Analysis of Multivariate Time Series Describing Dynamic Behavior Financial Time Series Making Predictions
6
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Algorithms 3/5 - Neural Networks Machine Learning Algorithm Based on Human Brain How it works:
The Weights Adjustment Training Method
Goal: Hidden Layer Number Neurons Number
Learning and Momentum Parameter
(Sermpinis et al. 2012)
7
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Algorithms 4/5 - ICA Independent Component Analysis X = AS, where:
A is Unknown Matrix S is Latent Source Signals
Goal: Noise Removal and Signals Separation Two Pre-Processing Steps:
Centering Whitening
8
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Algorithms 5/5 - SVR Support Vector Regression Extension of SVM Follows Regression Problem
Linear Regression & Non-Linear Regression(Lu et al. 2009)
9
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Lu et al. (2009) Main Goal: Two Stage Model First Stage: ICA – Identify Noise and Filter out Noise Second Stage: Use Reconstructed Data as Inputs to SVR Data Set:
Nikkei 225 Opening Cash Index Prices TAIFEX Closing Cash Index Prices
Limitations: Data Availability
10
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Lu et al. (2009)Original Results of Nikkei 225 Reproduced Results of Nikkei 225
Original Results of TAIEX Reproduced Results of TAIEX(Lu et al. 2009)
(Lu et al. 2009)
11
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Lu et al. (2009)T-tests Results:
Experiments ICA + SVR SVR
Reproduced Results 0.375985 0.30949
n-components = 1 0.318908 0.30949
Standardized data 0.502299 0.446244
12
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Ince and Trafalis (2006) Main Goal: Hybrid Model First Stage: Input Selection Using ARIMA and VAR Second Stage: Prediction Using MLP and SVR Data Set:
GBP/USD, AUD/USD, JPY/USD and EUR/USD Rates Limitations: Parameters
13
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Ince and Trafalis (2006)
Exchange rates MLP network SVR methodARIMA VAR ARIMA VAR
EURO/USD 0.000445 0.000478 0.000193 0.000272GDP/USD 0.004173 0.004021 0.000618 0.000210JPY/USD 1.931316 1.666312 1.144361 1.412094
AUD/USD 0.000223 0.000242 0.000152 0.000177
Original MSE of ARIMA and VAR Input Selection
Reproduced MSE of ARIMA and VAR Input Selection
Exchange Rates MLP network SVR methodARIMA VAR ARIMA VAR
EURO/USD 0.000029 0.000005 0.000004 0.000003GDP/USD 0.000012 0.000009 0.000002 0.000012JPY/USD 0.053500 0.032300 0.010600 0.015900
AUD/USD 0.000002 0.000006 0.000001 0.000004
14
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Ince and Trafalis (2006) T-tests Results:
Exchange rates MLP network SVR methodARIMA VAR ARIMA VAR
EURO/USD 0.774534 0.235134 0.121729 0.120220GDP/USD 0.482344 0.754345 0.134559 0.134967JPY/USD 0.471323 0.458653 0.139211 0.143889
AUD/USD 0.764532 0.466566 0.118899 0.116609
15
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Khansa and Liginlal (2011) Main Goal: Security Threat Influence on Stock Market Return First Stage: Aggregating Data Second Stage: ANN and VAR Analysis Data Set:
Market Return Value of Information Security Firms Market Weighted-Value Index Intensity of Daily Malicious Attacks
Limitations: Data Availability
16
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
Khansa and Liginlal (2011) Results:
T-tests Results: Experiments ANN VAR
Number 1 0.959528 0.95455
Number 2 0.434657 0.57677
Conclusion Accurate Forecasting is Important in Investment Decision Making Our aim was to Predict Stock Market Returns and EMH Reproduced:
Lu et al. (2009) Ince and Trafails (2006) Khansa and Linginal (2009)
Analysis : No Valid Prediction Stock Market Returns No Statistically Significant Outperformance No Evidence that the EMH is not True
17
IntroductionAlgorithms
Lu et al. Ince et al.
Khansa et al.Conclusion
References Cheung, Y.M., and Xu, L. 2001. "Independent component ordering in ICA time series analysis." Neurocomputing(41), no. 1, pp. 145-152. Hyvärinen, A. 1999. “Fast and robust fixed-point algorithms for independent component analysis.” IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks (10), pp. 626–634. Hyvärinen, A., Karhunen, A. J., and Oja, E. 2001. Independent Component Analysis, John Wiley & Sons, New York. Hyvärinen, A., and Oja, E. 2000. “Independent component analysis: algorithms and applications.” Neural Networks (13), pp. 411–430. Ince, Huseyin, and Theodore B. Trafalis. 2006. "A hybrid model for exchange rate prediction." Decision Support Systems (42), no. 2, pp. 1054-1062. Khansa, L., and Liginlal, D. 2011. “Predicting stock market returns from malicious attacks: A comparative analysis of vector autoregression and time-delayed
neural networks.” Decision Support Systems (51), pp. 745–759. Lam, Monica. 2004. “Neural network techniques for financial performance prediction: Integrating fundamental and technical analysis.” Decision Support
Systems (37), pp. 567–581. Lu, Chi-Jie, Tian-Shyug Lee, and Chih-Chou Chiu. 2009. "Financial time series forecasting using independent component analysis and support vector
regression." Decision Support Systems (47), no. 2, pp. 115-125. Sermpinis, G., Dunis, C., Laws, J., and Stasinakis, C. 2012. “Forecasting and trading the EUR/USD exchange rate with stochastic Neural Network combination
and time-varying leverage.” Decision Support Systems (54), pp. 316–329. Trafalis, T.B., and Ince, H. 2000. “Support vector machine for regression and applications to financial forecasting.” Neural Networks, IJCNN 2000,
Proceedings of the IEEEINNSENNS International joint Conference, vol. 6, IEEE, pp. 348–353. Vapnik, V.N. 2000. The Nature of Statistical Learning Theory, Springer, New York.
18
Thank you.Any questions?
19
Predicting Stock Market Returns and the Efficiency Market Hypothesis
By: Mohammad AbouzarKarthik GollapinniVijay Soppadandi
Professor: Lutz Maria Kolbe
Advisor: Patrick Urbanke
Department of Business AdministrationGeorg-August University of GoettingenCrucial Topics In Information ManagementJanuary 30th, 2015