Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
By Ehud Arye Laniadowww.ehudlaniado.com
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
Presentation by Ehud Arye Laniado
2
Looking back at 2015, I would like to go over what we achieved, what we are in
the process of correcting, and what still needs to be addressed.
A link to the full article can be found on the last slide of the presentation
December 2015
The views expressed here are solely those of the author in his private capacity. None of the information made available here shall constitute in any manner an offer or invitation or promotion to buy or to sell diamonds. No one should act upon any opinion or information in this website (including with respect to diamonds values) without consulting a professional qualified adviser.
DOC ID
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
3
Transparency
September 2015
DOC ID
4
• Transparency is of the outmost importance. It is needed to gain the full trust of consumers. Their confidence in our product is essential to getting us back on track and growing our businesses. Our aim is to make sure that the buyer’s appetite for diamonds never dwindles.
• We also need transparency in order to expand our offerings to new outlets. Investment firms, financial institutions, personal equity funds, private investors and even run-of-the mill jewelry buyers will consider diamonds as a wealth preservation vehicle if we disclose all characteristics of a diamond to them – and create a new reason for them to buy diamonds.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
5
• We need transparency to regain the trust of the banks and encourage them to finance the industry.
• We must implement transparency throughout the diamond pipeline. Banks operate under heavy regulations that require full transparency and compliance with Basel II and III.
• At the same time, there are some banks, operating where the majority of the pipeline comes from, which seem to operate with less strict enforcement of the regulations and easier access to credit lines based on projection. That is creating an uneven playing field. Added to that are the emotional and irrational behavior patterns of some players in the pipeline.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
6
Transparency is an issue we still need to address. There is a long road ahead of us and we should not waste time adopting necessary standards that will bring us to where we need to go.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
7
Financing
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
8
• Financing and cash flow are among the most important issues we will have to address in the coming year. We need to resist the uneven playing field where some companies get financed against projections rather than against real-life business acumen.
• This is a fundamental component of the industry, specifically in the midstream. We must correct this or else we will all pay a price. As long as financing is provided against projections, smartly-operated companies that need the financing will continue to have less access to it, rough diamond prices will continue to be pushed up, and polished diamond prices will keep being pushed down – making any chance of working in a sane and healthy environment near impossible.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
9
• Over-capacity of financing is certainly the biggest issue in the manufacturing sector of the diamond pipeline today. It creates an oversupply of polished diamonds from huge factories, leading to constant polished diamond price drops and forcing the midstream to continue to buy unprofitable rough diamonds to feed the vicious cycle.
• We asked if the midstream is working as a polisher for the whole pipeline or if it is working as a broker for its banks and the mining companies, shifting funds from one to the other, remaining in between with no profitability.
• Without correcting the unequal financing throughout the pipeline, business will shift to one side of the globe, putting their competitors out of business.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
10
Marketing
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
11
It used to be that De Beers ran and managed generic diamond marketing for the entire diamond industry, and then, after relinquishing its role as the custodian of the market, it rolled that responsibility onto Sightholders with the Supplier of Choice program.
Midstream players and retailers were not the right fit for the job and the result was that diamond jewelry marketing fell to the wayside. The natural outcome was a decline in interest in diamond jewelry and the drop in sales we have experienced since late 2014.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
12
Our marketing efforts might have a two-pronged approach: romance and value. The first, romance, continues the age-old approach of lasting love symbolized by a unique and lasting diamond.
The other approach emphasizes that there is no need to view purchasing a diamond as an expense. Here we discuss the full characteristics of a natural polished diamond, the tracked value history, and provide consumers with the knowledge and confidence that is needed before a large purchase. This will transform the purchase from an expense to an asset.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
13
Currently, generic diamond advertising by De Beers promotes Forevermark with a strong message that Forevermark diamonds are the most ethical. That is true, but the rest of De Beers’ polished diamonds are also ethical, as are the diamonds coming from other mining companies. Diamonds should therefore be promoted generically as ethical, because most of the diamonds in the world today are ethically sourced.
We must emphasize the exchange value of natural diamonds and that diamonds are not necessarily an expense. In doing so, we should highlight the fact that exchange value is more about the quality of natural diamonds, quality that laboratory-grown diamonds can never match.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
14
We should highlight in advertising the resell value of natural diamonds, that they are rare and hard to find, and that the economy of rarity applies to them.
Advertising should target the new generation of buyers, who have a different mindset. The traditional diamond industry must adapt to consumers more exposed to other luxury items.
This is another issue that has not yet been addressed by the industry at large. The diamond miners association that was formed in the past year was meant to address marketing, but has not yet done so. We are looking forward to change in this regard, and are already rolling up our sleeves to take an active role in making this change, as detailed below.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
15
Gatekeepers
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
The Awakening of Diamonds in China
16
As alluded to above, the rise of financing against business projections in the midstream has helped push up prices of rough diamonds. It is also in the hands of the midstream to restrain these runaway rough diamond prices.
We suggested that the consumer market for diamond jewelry is shrinking. Conventional wisdom puts the annual value of mining production at around $15-17 billion worth of rough diamonds. Manufacturing output is about $21 billion in polished diamonds, and consumer consumption in polished diamonds at wholesale prices sits at around $22-23 billion annually.
December 2015
DOC ID
17
According to these figures, the midstream has about $6 billion in revenue annually. With an estimated margin of 5% (if that), the entire diamond industry makes $300 million in total profits. Divided by about 5000 active midstream companies, that amounts to just $60,000 per company per annum. Is this still the case?
We would argue that it is not. In the past I stated that global consumption has declined from $22-23 billion to $17-18 billion annually. Today, as the year is about to end, we at Mercury Diamond™ believe market demand has declined even further, to about $14 billion.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
18
In the last six months of the year, rough diamond supply to the midstream by miners and other sources decreased to $300 million per month or $1.8 billion for the six month period in response to the drop in demand. Assuming margins remained unchanged at 5%, the midstream’s margin was $90 million, or $18,000 on average per midstream company. These figures express the structural problems of the diamond industry as a whole and the midstream in particular.
At the same time, midstream inventory has increased to $6-$7 billion at the onset of the current crisis.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
19
• Part of the issue is that rough diamond prices rose when the market was better and those prices have not declined with polished diamond prices. Prices didn’t decline because there was always someone willing to pay for the goods. That is why I called on the midstream to utilize a new logic – that of reverse engineering the wholesale price of polished diamonds.
• This approach dictates that if you take wholesale polished prices, and subtract the cost of manufacturing from the manufacturer’s margin, you reach the maximum cost manufacturers should pay for rough diamonds. They have to act asgatekeepers because of their technical knowledge and refuse pay more. This will serve as a way to balance miners’ tendency to raise prices in disconnection from polished prices.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
20
• We believe that the midstream should act as gatekeepers of the pipeline, and take only economically rational decisions and refuse high rough prices. We showed an example of an unprofitable box that we analyzed and how to avoid such high rough prices. The midstream should say no to the $16.5 billion annual cost of high-estimated rough. The entire polished wholesale yield is worth $22 billion.
• During the past year, it seems that manufacturers took more calculated decisions and refused high-priced rough. When the market improves (and the only way to know is by a better polished diamond inventory with the right ratio), they should remember that they have the ability to keep rough diamond prices in tow and stick to rational and economical decisions for the long-term. December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
The Awakening of Diamonds in China
21
• We believe that the midstream should act as gatekeepers of the pipeline, and take only economically rational decisions and refuse high rough prices. We showed an example of an unprofitable box that we analyzed and how to avoid such high rough prices. The midstream should say no to the $16.5 billion annual cost of high-estimated rough. The entire polished wholesale yield is worth $22 billion. This means revenue of only $5 billion that nets at best a profit of 5% divided by 5000 midstream companies.
December 2015
DOC ID
22
• During the past year, it seems that manufacturers took more calculated decisions and refused high-priced rough. When the market improves (and the only way to know is by a better polished diamond inventory with the right ratio), they should remember that they have the ability to keep rough diamond prices in tow and stick to rational and economical decisions for the long-term. That is why we argued that a deep change is required and we still believe that it is required.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
23
Laboratory-grown goods
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
24
• We witnessed in the past year the continued rise of laboratory-grown diamonds.This is inevitable and there is no point fighting it.
• My vision of diamond consumption, and the role of laboratory-grown goods, has three parts. The first is the traditional market of diamond jewelry. This market should maintain a popular price point, made possible by the falling costs of natural diamond production. It may face some competition from laboratory-grown goods, which are already priced at around 30% below natural diamonds. This is a niche market with its own economic behavior.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
25
• The second market is that of fine and high-end diamond jewelry. These niche market items are expertly designed and are fit for the bridal and the luxury sector. The cost of these jewelry items is comparable to other high-ticket luxury items and will compete with them in the store.
• The third venue, and the one with growing importance, is diamonds that have the potential for wealth perseveration: a tool to store value. These diamonds will be bought and treated specifically for that purpose, with a new methodology that is based on the economy of rarity. In this category, lab-grown diamonds do not pose any competition. This will be a separate market, with its own economic behavior
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
26
• This last venue is yet to be established as a widely-used category. It is the venue that will pull the diamond industry out of the current rut and climate of uncertainty it is in.
• After creating a clear differentiation between natural diamonds and laboratory-grown goods, highlighting the exchange of value would be possible. According to a recent survey by the Diamond Federation of Hong Kong 77% of female respondents said they would “feel disappointed” if a diamond gifted to them turned out to be synthetic and 47.5% of total respondents would not wear it. About 87% said that it is important that diamond jewelry purchased for them be natural. However, 95% of all the men and women polled said an engagement ring ought to have a natural diamond in it.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
27
• Clearly, the women answering this survey feel that laboratory-grown do not carry the long-lasting value that natural diamonds do.
• Another issue encountered in the past was that of undisclosed laboratory-grown goods mixed with natural diamonds. This apparently fraudulent behavior prompted the diamond industry to act. Today, parcels and individual diamonds are carefully screened and as a result we hear a lot less about this issue.
• The appearance of laboratory-grown diamonds requires differentiation from natural diamonds on two levels: its beauty and its value of exchange. Without transparency, we will not be able to apply the above suggestions.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
28
Pricing
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
29
• This is the issue I discussed the most over the past year, as it encompasses all the topics above, and is at the core of elevating rational decision-making for the diamond industry at every part of the diamond pipeline.
• This applies whether times are good or bad, whether there is a crisis or not, or if asking prices are dropped every Friday.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
30
• As stated above, there should be three diamond outlet categories: diamonds for fashion jewelry, diamonds as a high-luxury product, and the crystal clear value of diamonds as a tool for wealth preservation. The Crystal Clear value proposition has the potential of becoming a game changer, transforming the face of the diamond industry. Backed by full transparency, it has the power to change banks' attitude towards the industry as well as add to our profitability while keeping the end users interested in consuming diamonds.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
31
• To achieve these goals, we need a new concept of price list. I’m not talking about a benchmark, but rather of a price list based on transactions. This has the power to transform the language we speak in the market, moving away from “discounts” and “rough and polished price disconnect” to an empowered position of transparency, knowledge and accurate pricing all along the diamond value chain.
• This will allow a consumer to decide on a budget and then walk into a store with an understanding not only of what can be bought for that budget, but also what is the value proposition of each option.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
32
• It will allow buyers focused primarily on long-term value to identify diamonds fit to store that value. These diamonds will need to be purchased in the right part of the diamond pipeline, be purchased correctly, and have an accurate grading report. This report should go beyond the 4Cs, into the irregularities and the differences that exist between stones of the same grade, to serve as a tool to store value and to further the idea of capital preservation.
• For the midstream, this concept provides the tools they need to act as gatekeepers, and for miners it serves as an essential tool for pricing rough, and communicating accurately to financing institutions the potential of advanced exploration projects.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
33
• I’m happy to say that in this regard there is already change. A few weeks agoMercury Diamond™ announced that it is launching a price list, putting it up for the consideration of the diamond community.
• My feeling is that it is not enough to talk - you also need to do. This is my contribution to the diamond industry.
• I hope that we soon find a way out of the current crisis, addressing and improving the structural issues that are pulling us down, and recreating a sound new structure on which we can go far beyond what we have achieved already.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
34
My best wishes to you all. May we begin 2016 with renewed energies and an enhanced inspiration to ignite the
coming year with great profitability and success.
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
DOC ID
35
The views expressed here are solely those of the author in his private capacity. None of the information made available here shall constitute in any manner an offer or invitation or promotion to buy or to sell diamonds. No one should act upon any opinion or information in this website (including with respect to diamonds values) without consulting a professional qualified adviser.
A full version of the article can be found here:http://
www.ehudlaniado.com/home/index.php/news/entry/new-year-new-challenges-for-the-diamond-industry
December 2015
New Year, New Challenges for the Diamond Industry
