Click here to load reader
Barberis -article_AFDI 1999 doc.1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
- 1. M. le Professeur Julio
Barberis!"#$%&"#$()*&+&,)"#$"-*"$%./-0-$"-$#1$-"**&-1&*"$2$3"*#3"4-&5"#-671*&,)"#$"-$751%)-&1$+)$+*1&-$&-"*0-&10%82$9)0&*"$:*0;0$+"$+*1&-$&-"*0-&10%I
2332[]G +I78E7I X=`89; :6 FA89 N>Q7I95 S 7>8EYI> FI
:I9:VEA89 5899I 5=9: F= N>=76VEI U FAIWN>I::689 J
7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K; 89 5867=9=FS:I> 78E: FI: L=:
VE6 :I N>Q:I97I97 N8E> I9 5Q5E6>I FIE>:
L=>=L7T>I:L8OOE9:G !X69 5I 5899I> E9I 65QI 5I F=Y=>6Q7Q
5I :67E=7689: 5897 89 58677I96> L8ON7I; 6F L89Y6I97 5I
OI976899I> VEIFVEI: L=: U 767>I 5AIWIONFI B F=P=:I
O6F67=6>I 5I fE=97n9=O8 U 4EP=; FI >QR6OI 5E F=L -676L=L=
:IF89 FI7>=67Q 5E 23 XQY>6I> 23gj I97>I FI 8E I7 F=
H8F6Y6I; FI %68 5I F= =67Q 5E 23 98YIOP>I 23j] I97>I
FA!>RI9769I I7 FA#>ERE=S; I7 FI:O69I: 5I LM=>P89 :67EQI: U
F=X>8976T>I I97>I FA!FFIO=R9I I7 FI: =67Q: 5E 2k
Z=9Y6I> 23g^ I7 5E k 98YIOP>I 23hp; 6F IW6:7IE9I F6O67I 5=9:
FI :8E:1:8F [HI7>6IP:R>I9eI VE6 I:7 56XXQ>I97I 5I LIFFI
5=9:F= :E>X=LIG #9I LI>7=69I 7MQ8>6I ZE>656VEI I7
VEIFVEI: 5QL6:689: 5I ZE>6:N>E5I9LI69LFEI97 5=9: F= 987689 5I
J 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K FI: 9=Y6>I: =>P8>=97
FIN=Y6FF89 5I LI7 &7=7 VE6 :I 7>8EYI97 I9 M=E7I OI> I7
N=>FI97 =F8>: 5AE97I>>6786>IXF877=97G +=9:
LI78>5>I 5A65QI:; 6F L89Y6I97 5I L67I>E9
N=::=RI5IF=:I97I9LI=>P67>=FI5ELQFTP>IZE>6:7I(>Q5Q>6L5Il=>7I9:
5E 2] [^gXQY>6I>2k3j5=9: FA=XX=6>I
5EP=FI696I>48:7=%6L=IF= f>=95I1H>I7=R9II7 FI: OIB J[GGG I9
M=E7I OI>; OqOI FI: 9=Y6>I: O=>LM=95: L89:767EI97 5I:
N=>76I: :QN=>QI: 5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 5897
6F: =>P8>I97FI N=Y6FF89K [iG +I OqOI; E9I =E7>I 7MQ8>6I
ZE>656VEI IWLFE7 5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7FAI:N=LI
8LLENQ N=> FI: =OP=::=5I: Q7>=9RT>I: I7 :8E76I97; 5=9: LI
:I9:;VEAIFFI: PQ9QX6L6I97 UAW7>=7I>>678>6=F67Q[gG I
4I77I >IO=>VE=PFI Y=>6Q7Q 5I :67E=7689: = =OI9Q VEIFVEI:
ZE>6:7I: UL89LFE>I VEA6F I:7 6ON8::6PFI 5I 5899I> E9I
5QX6967689 5E J7I>>6786>I 5IFA&7=7K :E> FI NF=9
697I>9=7689=FG 4AI:7 =69:6 VEI mI9RFI> =XX6>OI B J .I:
=NNF6L=7689: OEF76NFI: 5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 5I F=
N=>7 5E 5>867 697I>9=7689=F N8:676X >I95I97 QY65IOOI97
6ON8::6PFI 5I >IN>85E6>I 5=9: F= :6ONFIX8>OEFI
5AE9IA7MQ8>6I 5E7I>>6786>IA
AFAI::I9LIA697I>9=7689=FI5E7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K
[hG +=9:FI OqOI :I9:; *ES76I97 N8E>6ON8::6PFI
5AQF=P8>I>E9I 7MQ8>6I 5E7I>>6786>I :E:LIN76PFI 5I
>QN895>I U 78E7I: FI: VEI:7689: VEI N8:I F=Y=>6Q7Q5I
:67E=7689: 5=9: F=N>=76VEI 697I>9=7689=FI[jG l=FR>Q LI:
8N69689:; 6F I:7E76FI 5I X=6>I I9L8>I E9 98EYIF IXX8>7
N8E> I::=SI> 5I Y86> LI VEA897 I9L8OOE9; 5E N8697 5I YEI
ZE>656VEI; 78E: FI: L=: 5=9: FI:VEIF: 89 N=>FI 5IJ
7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K; I7 7>8EYI> =69:6 E9I
5QX6967689 5I LI L89LIN7G [] H8FI769 ,X6L6=F5I F=
%INrPF6L=!>RI9769=; ^gG$/G233^G [i .= (897=69I; 6:6I
697I>9=7689=FI; HI>9I; 23p^; NG g22G ,9 NIE7 7>8EYI> E9
>=6:899IOI97 :IOPF=PFI 5=9: FI L=: 5E .87E: [4G6I !; "s 2p; NG
^gG [g !69:6; 0=77IFQL>67 B J ,9 L89:65T>I; =E O869: 5=9:
78E: FI: L=: 8>569=6>I: 5I F= Y6I;FACb7IF 5AE9!OP=::=5IE>
L8OOI Q7=97 M8>:5E -I>>6786>I;=E::6 P6I9VEI :=
NI>:899IK [.I 5>8675I:RI9: 8E N>69L6NI: 5I F=
F869=7E>IFFI; .895>I:; 2jgk; .6Y>I$0; LM=NG $/; N=>G
22jG 086> =E::6fI9I7; ->=67Q 5I+6NF8O=76I I75I
+>867+6NF8O=76VEI; 6:; 23]2; 7G $; NNG i2j1i^^G [h J +6I
Y6IFXnF76RI 0I>aI95E9R5I: *7==7:RIP6I7: 5E>LM 5=: N8:676YI
0bFdI>>ILM7 O=LM7 I:8XXI9P=> 66PI>M=EN7 E9ObRF6LM; 5=:
YbFdI>>ILM7F6LMI AmI:I9A 5I: *7==7:RIP6I7: 69 5I>
I69X=LMI9(8>OIF I69I> AfIP6I7:7MI8>6IA; a6I5I>eERIPI9K
[mI9RFI>; 0bFdI>>ILM7; HI>F691fb7769RI91CI65IF1PI>R;
23hi; NG 3j2G [j *ES; J %QXFIW689: :E>F= 56:769L7689 I97>I F=
:8EYI>=69I7QI7 F= L8ONQ7I9LI
7I>>678>6=FIK;$97I>9=7689=FI(I:7:LM>6X7XE>!FX>I50I>5>8::eEOkpG
fIPE>7:7=R;lr9LMI91*=FePE>R; 23j2; NG gpkG
- 4. 2]i
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
$G 1.& -&%%$-,$%&&"-!"- @#& LM6I: =P:8FEI:;
I9RQ9Q>=F; FI *I6R9IE>8EFI 69LI 56:N8:=67 5I :89 58O=69IL8OOI
5AE9 8PZI7FE6 =NN=>7I9=97G .I7I>>6786>IX=6:=67N=>76I
5I :89 N=7>6O869IG 4IL6 I:7QY65I97 987=OOI97 5=9:FI: O85I: 5I
7>=9:O6::689 5E 7I>>6786>I[kG +=9: LI7 8>5>I
5A65QI:; 89 NIE7 OI976899I> 5A=P8>5 FI:
L89YI97689:O=7>6O896=FI:;F= :ELLI::689I7FIN=>7=RI
5I:58O=69I:5AE9:8EYI>=69I97>I:I: MQ>676I>:G +A=E7>I:
O85I: 5I 7>=9:O6::689 5E 7I>>6786>I :897
I9>=NN8>7=YIL FI 5>867 XQ85=F 8E FI: 69:767E7689:
N>8N>I: 5I FAQN8VEI 7IFFI: VEI; N=>IWIONFI; FA69XQ85=7689;
FI >QR6OI 5I >IYI>:689; FAJIWNIL7=76YI K
6ONQ>6=FI;FA=77>6PE7689 N=N=FI I7 FI: N=L7I: 5I X=O6FFIG
4I>7=69I: :I97I9LI: =>P67>=FI:5QL65=6I97 :E> FI:
O=>6=RI: I7FIE>: L89:QVEI9LI: N=7>6O896=FI:; VE6
ION8>7=6I97:8EYI97 5I: LI::689: 5I 7I>>6786>I[3G .I:
=LL8>5: 5IO=>6=RI
69LFE=6I97VEIFVEIX86:5I:7I>>6786>I: 5=9:F= 5875I
F=XE7E>I QN8E:I[2pG 4AI:7 =69:6 VEI FI: O=>6=RI: :ELLI::6X:
5A!99I 5IH>I7=R9I =YIL FI: >86: 5I (>=9LI 4M=>FI: 0$$$
[h 5QLIOP>I 2i32 I7 .8E6:/$$ [j Z=9Y6I>Fi33 897 =NN8>7Q FI
7I>>6786>I 5I H>I7=R9I =E >8S=EOI 5I(>=9LI[22G .I
^^ ZE6FFI7 2g2g XE7 LQFQP>Q E9 58EPFI L897>=7 5I
O=>6=RII97>ImF=56:F=Y;>865IC89R>6I; I7 l=W6O6F6I9$I>
5A!E7>6LMIG.A=LL8>5N8>7=675AE9I N=>7 :E> FI
O=>6=RI 5E X6F: 5I mF=56:F=Y =YIL l=>6I; NI767I1X6FFI
5Il=W6O6F6I9; 5A=E7>I N=>7 :E> FI: 98LI: 5ENI7671X6F: 5I
LI 5I>96I>=YIL !99I;X6FFI5ImF=56:F=Y[2^G 4I:=LL8>5:897
Q7QE9I5I:L=E:I:5IF=:EP8>569=76895I F= C89R>6I U
FA!E7>6LMIG +I F= OqOI X=`89; :IF89 FI L897>=7 5E
^]ZE692hh2;-=9RI> I7H8OP=S897 Q7Q 5899Q:L8OOI 5875I4=7MI>69I
5I7ER=F=E >86 4M=>FI: $$ 5A!9RFI7I>>I U FA8LL=:689 5I
FIE> O=>6=RI[2]G .I 7I>>6786>I N8EY=67 N=::I>5AE9
N>69LI U FA=E7>I U 767>I 5AMQ>67=RI 5=9:FI L=5>I
5AE9I :ELLI::689 =P 697I:7=7 8E 7I:7=OI97=6>IG .I: F676RI:
N8E>
LI:L=E:I:8LLENI97NFE:6IE>:LM=N67>I:5IFAM6:786>I5I::6TLFI:N=::Q:G.=fEI>>I5I
4I97!9: [2]]j12ig]I97>I F= (>=9LI I7FA!9RFI7I>>I N=>
IWIONFI; 7>8EYI:89 8>6R69I 5=9: FI: >6Y=F67Q: I97>I FI:
N>Q7I95=97: VE6 69Y8VE=6I97 5I:>QR6OI: 5I:ELLI::689
56XXQ>I97:GO6 FI:56:N8:67689:7I:7=OI97=6>I: =S=97IE5I:
L89:QVEI9LI: 7I>>678>6=FI:; 89 NIE7 OI976899I>F=
5QLF=>=7689 X=67I FI^i =Y>6F 2]2^ N=>-M6P=E7 $$; 5EL 5I
.8>>=69I[2iG 4I>7=69: >86: 897 N=>7=RQ FIE>:
58O=69I: I97>I FIE>: MQ>676I>: N=> E9=L7I I97>I
Y6X:G #9 IWIONFI 5I LI77I L=7QR8>6I I:7 F= 5QL6:689 5E ^]
ZE6FFI7 [k E9I =9=FS:I 5Q7=6FFQI 5I LI :EZI7; Y86> 0I>e6ZF;
$97I>9=7689=F .=a 69 C6:78>6L=F:NIL76YI; .IS5I; 23jp; 7G
$$$; NG ^3k ::G [3 .A=>7G ^5E7>=67Q 5E 2gG/$G2j2g I97>I
*GlG$ONQ>6=FI I74=7M8F6VEI; F= f>=95I1H>I7=R9II7 FI: I FI:
O85I: 5A=LVE6:67689 5E 7I>>6786>I U LI77I QN8VEI [4G-G*G;
Y8FG ^3; NG]]jG [2p VEIFVEI: L89:65Q>=7689: 697Q>I::=97I:
:E> LI77I VEI:7689; Y86> H=>7MQFQOS; J +EL=>=L7T>I
697I>9=7689=F 5I: L897>=7: 5I O=>6=RI 5I: 69LI: 5I X=O6FFI
:8EYI>=69I K; %GfG+G$GN: E96YI>:IF 56NF8O=76VEI 5E 5>867
5I:RI9:; !O:7I>5=O1.= C=SI; 2j^h;7G $$$; N=>76I $$; NNG ^j2
::G; ipg I7 iphG [2^ +E l897; 8NG L67G; 7G $0; N=>76I $; NG ^22
::G [2] (I>>I6>=H8>RI:5I4=:7>8; 48FFIL`n858:
7>=7=58:; L89YI9`8I:; L897>=78:I =L78:NEPF6L8:LIFIP>=58:
I97>I = 48>8= 5I 7ER=F I7 =: O=6: Q:I97I; .6:P8=;2kgh; 7G $;
NG ^]i ::G [2i +E l897; 8NG L67G; 7G $; N=>76I $; NNG i^j I7
i^kG
- 5.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2]g2kii 5I *IS651*=t5; :8EYI>=69 5I l=:L=7I I75I u=9e6P=>; 5I
N=>7=RI>I97>I5IEW5I :I:I9X=97: :I:N8::I::689:I9!:6II7
I9!X>6VEI[2gG !N>T:F=O8>75I FIE>NT>I; E9I
L897>8YI>:I QLF=7= I97>I :I: 5I:LI95=97:; VE6 XE7
7>=9LMQIN=> F= :I97I9LI =>P67>=FI 5E ^ =Y>6F 2kh2 5E
f8EYI>9IE> RQ9Q>=F 5I FA$95I;F8>5 4=9969R[2hG #9I
=E7>I X8>OI 5A=LVE6:67689 5I 7I>>6786>I = Q7Q LIFFI
5I: N=L7I: 5S9=:76VEI: 8E 5I X=O6FFI VE6 N>QY8S=6I97 F=
:ELLI::689 >QL6N>8VEI I97>I FI:56YI>:I: P>=9LMI:
5S9=:76VEI: =E L=: 5AE9I QYI97EIFFI IW769L7689 5I FAE9I5AI97>I
IFFI:G O6 FI: 98OP>IE:I: L89YI97689: 5I LI RI9>I; 89 NIE7
OI976899I> F= L89YI97689 5I "=EOPE>R 5E ]p O=>: 2h2i
I97>I FI: QFIL7IE>: 5I*=WII7 5IH>=95IP8E>RI7
FI:F=95R>=YI:5I CI::I;>IF=76YIUFIE>
:ELLI::689>QL6N>8VEI[2j I7 FA=>76LFI 2h 5I FA!L7IX69=F 5E
489R>T: 5I 06I99I5E 3ZE692k2g VE6 L89X6>OI FA=9L6I9 5>867
5E >86 5I *=WI U F=:ELLI::689 QYI97EIFFI5I: N8::I::689: 5I F=
P>=9LMI I>9I:769I 5I F= l=6:89 >QR9=97I[2kG .I
767EF=6>I 5E*=697 &ON6>I>8O=981RI>O=96VEI N8EY=67
=77>6PEI>U E9N>69LI FI 5>867 5I :ELLI::689 5AE9I
=E7>I N>69L6N=E7Q 5=9: FI L=: 5AE9IQYI97EIFFI Y=L=9LIG 4I77I
:67E=7689 567I J IWNIL7=76YI K [IWNIL7=76YI; !971a=>7:LM=X7 =
Q7Q >Q:I>YQI U FA&ONI>IE>ZE:VEA=E 5QPE75E /0$$$I
:6TLFI; NFE:7=>5FI L89:I97IOI97 5I:N>69LI: QFIL7IE>: = Q7Q
>IVE6:G ,9NIE7OI976899I>L8OOI E9 L=: 5AIWNIL7=76YI =S=97 5I:
L89:QVEI9LI: 7I>>678>6=FI: F=
LM=>7I[&WNIL7=97e1H>6IXX =LL8>5QI FI i 98YIOP>I
2gjp N=> FA&ONI>IE> l=W6O6F6I9$$ =E >86 5E
+=9IO=>d (>Q5Q>6L $$ I7U :I: X>T>I: !58FNMII7 ?I=9;
5EL: 5I*LMFI:a6R1C8F:7I69; U FAIWNIL7=76YI XQ85=FI 5I: L8O7Q:
5A,F5I9P8E>R I7 5I+IFOI9M8>:7[23G ?E:VEA=E /$/I :6TLFI 5I:
LF=E:I: 5I >IYI>:689 XE>I97 X>QVEIOOI97
69L8>N8>QI: 5=9: FI: L89YI97689:G &FFI: 56:N8:=6I97 VEAI9
L=: 5AIW769L7689 5I F=F6R9I 5I :ELLI::689 =E 7>b9I 5AE9
>8S=EOI; :89 7I>>6786>I XI>=67 FA8PZI7
5AE9I>IYI>:689 I9 X=YIE> 5AE9 =E7>I N>69LIG +I:
56:N8:67689: 5I LI RI9>I 897 Q7Q=NNNF6VEQI: 987=OOI97I9$7=F6I
I7; I9RQ9Q>=F;IFFI: =Y=6I975I:L89:QVEI9LI:
7I>>678>6=FI:[^pG #9I =E7>I 69:767E7689 OQ56QY=FI =S=97
5I: L89:QVEI9LI: 7I>>678>6=FI:Q7=67LIFFI 5I:N=>I=7RI:G
$F :A=R6::=67; I9 RQ9Q>=F; 5AE9=LL8>5 N=> FIVEIF
E9:I6R9IE> 69XQ85=67:89 7I>>6786>I I9X=YIE> 5AE9
=E7>I :I6R9IE>NFE: NE6::=97I9QLM=9RI 5I :=N>87IL7689G
(>QVEIOOI97F=L89YI97689 =Y=67F6IE I97>I E9QYqVEI 8E =E7>I
:I6R9IE>ILLFQ:6=:76VEI I7E998PFI F=tVEIG .I:N=>I=7RI:
9IN>8LQ5=6I97N=: 78EZ8E>: 5AE9I L89YI97689; 6F: Q7=6I97
VEIFVEIX86: FI>Q:EF7=75AE9I 5QL6:689 =>P67>=FIG
.A8>6R69I 5A!958>>I I:7 5EI N>QL6:QOI97 U
5I:N=>I=7RI: 5I LI RI9>IG &9 22]]; FI L8O7I 5A#>RIFF
&>OI9R8F 0$; L89X6>O=97FI: =L7I: 5I :I: =9Lq7>I:; X67
589 U FAIYqVEI 5I 78E7 LI VEA6F N8::Q5=67 I9!958>>IG +INE6:
F8>: I7 ZE:VEAU F= O8676Q 5E /$$I :6TLFI !958>>I XE7
E958O=69I ILLFQ:6=:76VEI :8E: FAQR65I 5E 568LT:I 5I F= *IEG 4I:
QYqVEI: =Y=6I9769XQ85Q!958>>I I9X=YIE>5I :I6R9IE>:5I
F=>QR6895897 FI: 5>867: :897 N=::Q: N=> >=6:89
MQ>Q567=6>I =EW L8O7I: 5I (86WG 4I:5I>96I>: IE>I97
5I: F676RI: >Q67Q>Q: =YIL FAIYqVEI VE6 897 Q7Q X69=FIOI97 [2g
@E=97=EW=97QLQ5I97: 5I LI77I
=XX=6>I;Y86>.==5IFFI1P67>=RI:697I>9=7689=EW; ^I Q5G;
6:; 23gj; 7G $$; NG gg ::G [2h .==5IFFI176I $$; NG ^i^ ::G [2k
4G-G*G; Y8FG hi; NG ih2G [23 +E l897; 8NG L67G; 7G 0; N=>76I $;
NNG 2k] I7 2kiG [^p 086>; NG IWG; FA=>7G j 5E7>=67Q
5QX69676X5I N=6W 5A!6W1F=14M=NIFFI L89LI>9=97 FI 5>867
5I>IYI>:689>IF=76X=EW 5ELMQ: 5I O=; 6I 567I 5I FA8PZI7 =
>IL8E>: U E9I =9=F8R6I =YIL FI 5>867 N>6YQI7 :8E76I97
VEI FA&7=7 IWI>LI :E> FI 7I>>6786>I E9 5>867
>QIF :6O6F=6>I U LIFE65E N>8N>6Q7=6>I :E> E9I
LM8:IG $F 9I:A=R6>=67 N=: 5AE9IN>8N>6I7=:; O=6:
5AE96ONI>6EO 5I OqOI 9=7E>I VEI LIFFI1L6; =YIL FI:
L=>=L7Q>6:76VEI: 5AE9 5>867>QIFG O6 FI: ZE>6:7I: VE6
:8E76I99I97 LI77I 7MT:I; 89 NIE7 OI976899I>(=ELM6FFI[^h I7
+89=76; 5897 FA8EY>=RI *7=78 I 7I>>678>68 I9 I:7
FAIWN8:Q FI [^2 086> FI 7IW7I 69 HQF69RE6I>; .=
L89567689ZE>656VEI 5I: 0=FFQI: 5A!958>>I; 6:; 23jp;NG ^h3
::G .= 489:767E7689 =L7EIFFI 5I F= 69L6N=E7Q 5A!958>>I
[^kG$0G233] IWN>6OI 5=9: :89N>Q=OPEFIVEI
:I:69:767E7689:7>8EYI97FIE>
8>6R69I5=9:FI:N=>I=7RI:G086> =E::6FA=>7Gi]; =F69Q=^; 5I
F= 489:767E7689G [^^ 086> FI 7IW7I 69 HQF69RE6I>; 8NG L67G;
NG ^jk ::G [^] @E=97 =EW :I97I9LI: =>P67>=FI: 5E l8SI9 !RI;
Y86> "8Y=L8Y67LM; .I: L8ON>8O6:I7 FI:=>P67>=RI:
697I>9=7689=EW 5E /FFI =E/0I :6TLFI; 6:; 23pg; NG 33 ::G [^i
4G$G?G; %ILEI6F 23g]; NG ij ::G [^g E9 IWN8:Q 5Q7=6FFQ 5I:
7MQ8>6I: N>69L6N=FI: :E> F= L89LIN7689 5E
7I>>6786>I; Y86>CI9>6LM; J w>676d 5I>
fIP6I7:7MI8>6I9K; uI67:LM>6X7 XE> 0bFdI>>ILM7; 7G
/$$$; 23^h; NNG ^k ::G; 23i::G I7 ]^g ::G 086> =E::6
*LM967eI>; *7==7 E95 fIP6I7:M8MI67; uE>6LM1.I6Ne6R; 23]g; NG
]i ::G [^h (=ELM6FFI; ->=67Q5I5>867697I>9=7689=FNEPF6L; kI
Q5G;6:; 23^^; 7G $; F>IN=>76I;NG igpG
- 7.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2]jNFE: =LMIYQ[^jG 4I7 =E7IE> 96I VEI FI 7I>>6786>I
:867 E9 QFQOI97L89:767E76X5I FA&7=7[^k I7; =N>T: E9I =9=FS:I
5Q7=6FFQI; 6F =>>6YI U F= L89LFE:689 VEIFI 5>867 5I
FA&7=7:E> :89 7I>>6786>I I:7 J E9 56>6778 5I
58O6968 KG $F :A =R6>=675AE9 5>867 697I>9=7689=F;
N=>X=67IOI97 L8ON=76PFI =YIL FI 5>867 5I N>8N>6Q7Q5I:
NI>:899I: N>6YQI:[^3G 4I77I L89LIN7689 = IE E9I 69XFEI9LI
>IO=>VE=PFI :E> F=7I>O698F8R6I
I7:E>F=:S:7QO=76:=7689 5I 78E7 LIVE6 L89LI>9I FI
7I>>6786>I I9 5>867 5I RI9:G&9IXXI7; 89N=>FI5IJ
LI::689K;5AJ=P=9589K 8E5AJ=LVE6:67689K 5E7I>>6786>IL8OOI
89 FI X=67 F8>:VEA6F :A=R67 5I F= N>8N>6Q7Q N>6YQIG .=
:S:7QO=76:=76895I: O8SI9:5A=LVEQ>6>F= :8EYI>=69I7Q
7I>>678>6=FI; VE6 69LFE7N=>O65A=E7>I:;F=
N>I:L>6N7689 =LVE6:676YI; FA=LL>86::IOI97 N=> =FFEY689
I7 FA8LLEN=76895AE9I7I>>= 9EFF6E:; I:7 E9I N>IEYI QY65I97I
5I FA69XFEI9LI 5I LI77I L89LIN7689 :E>FI 5>867 5I RI9:G .=
987689 5I >I:7>6L7689 U F= N>8N>6Q7Q 697I>9=7689=FI
5IFA&7=7 I7 F= 7MQ8>6I 5I: :I>Y67E5I: :897 QR=FIOI97
5A=E7>I: IWIONFI: 5=9: FIOqOI :I9:[]pG .=L>676VEI
N>69L6N=FI VE6; 5INE6: := X8>OEF=7689; = Q7Q =5>I::QI U
LI77IL89LIN768976I97 ULIVEAIFFI X=67=NN=>=v7>IFI
7I>>6786>IL8OOI VEIFVEILM8:I5AQ7>=9RI> UF=
NI>:899=F67Q 5I FA&7=7G ! FA69:7=> 5AE9 6956Y65E VE6 NIE7
:I5Q7=LMI>5AE9ILM8:I:=9:VEI:=NI>:899=F67QI9:867=XXIL7QI;FA&7=7N8E>>=67;5AE9I
O=96T>I =9=F8REI; LQ5I> :89 7I>>6786>IG .=
L>676VEI I:76OI VEI F=>IF=7689 I97>I FA&7=7 I7 :89
7I>>6786>I 9I :=E>=67 q7>I L89:65Q>QI L8OOI
E95>867 >QIF I7; N=> L89:QVEI97; LI77I L89LIN7689 9I
L89:767EI>=67 N=: E9I5I:L>6N7689 X65TFI 5I
F=>Q=F67QZE>656VEIG $$$G 1.&-&%%$-,$%& &"-!"-
@#A&*=FFTFIOI97UF=L89LIN7689N>QLQ5I97I;
89=5QYIF8NNQE9I=E7>I7MT:IVE6 N>Q:I97I FA&7=7 L8OOI E9
NMQ98OT9I L89:767EQ N=> 7>86: QFQOI97: X895=OI97=EW; U
:=Y86>B F= N8NEF=7689; FI 7I>>6786>I I7FI
R8EYI>9IOI97G *IF89LI77I 7MQ8>6I; FA&7=7 IWI>LI>=67
:89 ION6>I N=> >=NN8>7 U :I: >I::8>76::=97:5=9:
E9 I:N=LI 5899Q; FIVEIF :I>=67 N>QL6:QOI97 :89
7I>>6786>IG 4=>6
06L78>(>6LdI>I:7E95I:>IN>Q:I97=97:N>69L6N=EW5ILI77I
L89LIN7689G *=N>IO6T>IQ7E5I :E>FI :EZI7 5=7I 5I 2khj I7
:89 yEY>I N>69L6N=FI = Q7Q NEPF6QI
:8E:FI767>IfIP6I7E95fIP6I7:M8MI67I923p2[]2G
(>6LdI>=XX6>OI VEIFI7I>>6786>II:7 FAI:N=LI U
FA697Q>6IE> 5EVEIF FA&7=7 IWI>LI :89 ION6>I; VEI LI
9AI:7 N=:E9 8PZI7 O=6: E9 QFQOI97 L89:767E76X5I FA&7=7[]^G 4I7
=E7IE>IWN>6OI VEI [^j 086> 987=OOI97 +89=76; *7=78 I
7I>>678>68; %8O=; 23]i; NNG 2h12^]G [^k +89=76; 8NG L67G;
NG i]G [^3 J #9 56>6778 56 58O6968 5IFF8 *7=78 :EF
7I>>678>68; I L68T E9 56>6778 697I>9=e689=FI
5658O6968 [LMT 56 =F7>8 VE6 989 NEb 7>=77=>:6; T
NI>XI77=OI97I L89L6F6=P6FI L89 F= :6OEF7=9I=N>8N>6Q7Q 5I6
N>6Y=76 :E N=>76 5IF7I>>678>68GGG K[+89=76; 8NG
L67G; NG hpG 086> =E::6 F= L89LFE:689 UF= NG h2G []p z LI :EZI7;
(=ELM6FFI[8NG L67G; 7G $; F>I N=>76I; NG hhk =XX6>OIB J .I
5>867 5IN>8N>6Q7Q697I>9=7689=FI VEA897 FI: &7=7:
:E> FIE> 7I>>6786>I I7 :E> FI: LM8:I: :6:I: =E
7I>>6786>I NIE7 q7>I>I:7>I697 5I
56YI>:I:O=96T>I: B N=> F=L89:767E7689 5I>I97I: I7
=E7>I:5>867: >QIF:7IF:VEI 5>867:5I X6IX; 5I R=RI:;
5A=976LM>T:I:; 5AMSN87MTVEI:; I7 N=> FAQ7=PF6::IOI97 5I
:I>Y67E5I:KG []2 (>6LdI>; fIP6I7 E95 fIP6I7:M8MI67;
-66P69RI9; 23p2G !EW NNG 2pp122^ 5I LI7 8EY>=RI 6FI:7
>IN>85E67 FAQ7E5I 69:767EFQI 08O *7==7:RIP6I7; NEPF6QI I9
2khjG []^ J +=: fIP6I7 6:7 Y6IFOIM> 5I> %=EO 5I>
:7==7F6LMI9 CI>>:LM=X7K[8NG L67G; NG 2p; J GGG5=: fIP6I76:7
96LM7 ,PZIL7; :895I>9 HI:7=957MI6F 5I: *7==7I:K{8NG L67G; N;
22G
- 8. 2]k
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&FA89
9I 5867 N=: L89X895>I FI 7I>>6786>I [fIP6I7 =YIL FI :8F
[f>E95;
H85I9G.=:8EYI>=69I7Q7I>>678>6=FI9I:AIWI>LIN=::E>FI
:8F;O=6::E>FI:NI>:899I:VE6 :I 7>8EYI97 5=9: E9 I:N=LI
5Q7I>O69Q[]]G 4I77I 7MT:I :A8LLENI 5I N>QL6:I> FI
>bFIZ8EQN=> FI7I>>6786>I 5=9: FA&7=7=X69 5I :I
5QO=>VEI> 5A=E7>I: L89LIN7689:G +=9: LI :I9:;
(>6LdI> =XX6>OIVEI F= X89L7689 5E 7I>>6786>I I:7
56XXQ>I97I 5I LIFFI VEI >IONF67 E9I LM8:IN=> >=NN8>7
U :89 N>8N>6Q7=6>IG +=9: LI 5I>96I> L=:; F= LM8:I
I:7 :8EO6:I UF= Y8F897Q 5EN>8N>6Q7=6>I; LIFE61L6 56:N8:I
5I F= LM8:I; O=6: F= NI>:899I5EN>8N>6Q7=6>I 9AI:7 N=:
O856X6QI U L=E:I 5I LI77I >IF=7689 5I N>8N>6Q7Q;
:=NI>:899=F67Q >I:7I6OOE=PFIG &9>IY=9LMI; FI
7I>>6786>I= E9=E7>I :I9:N8E>FA&7=7B FI
7I>>6786>I I:7 FAI:N=LI 8o FA&7=7 IWI>LI :89
N8EY86>; FA&7=7 9I NIE7N=: IW6:7I> I9 5IM8>: 5AE9
8>5899=9LIOI97 E96VEI I7 LIFE61L6; U :89 78E>;9I NIE7N=:
IW6:7I> :=9:E9 I:N=LI :E>FIVEIF FI N8EY86>5IFA&7=7:867
IWI>LQU FAIWLFE:689 5I 78E7 =E7>I N8EY86>G ! N=>76>
5I LI77I =XX6>O=7689; FA=E7IE>L89LFE7 VEI FI
7I>>6786>II:7 E9 QFQOI97 I::I976IF5I FA&7=7; E9 O8OI97
5=9:FAI::I9LI 5I FA&7=7[]iG 4I77I 7MQ8>6I XE7 =58N7QI N=>
FI: L>Q=7IE>: 5I F= RQ8N8F676VEIG 4IEW1L6L89`86YI97
FA&7=7 L8OOI E9 q7>I Y6Y=97; L8OOI E9 8>R=96:OI =E :I9:
5I::L6I9LI: P68F8R6VEI:; 5897 FI L8>N: :I>=67 FI
7I>>6786>I[]gG .= RQ8N8F676VEIL89:65T>I FI
7I>>6786>I L8OOI =NN=>7I9=97 U FAq7>I 5I FA&7=7
I7 IFFI I:76OIVEAE9I 5I: R>=95I: 7>8EY=6FFI: 5I F= 7MQ8>6I
5I FA&7=7 L89:6:7I U Y86> F=>IF=7689 5I LIFE61L6 =YIL :89
7I>>6786>I L8OOI =S=97 E9 L=>=L7T>I NI>:899IFI7
989 >QIFG +=9:LI :I9:; E9 =77I97=7 8E E9I 697I>YI976895=9:
FI7I>>6786>I5I FA&7=7 :I>=67 E9I =77=VEI L897>I
FA&7=7 FE61OqOI I7 989 N=: E9I =77I697IU := N>8N>6Q7Q[]hG
,9 = L>676VEQ LI77I 7MT:I I956:=97 VEI; 5E N8697 5I
YEIZE>656VEI; IFFI9I L89:767EI N=: E9I 5I:L>6N7689 X65TFI 5I
F= >Q=F67QG $F =>>6YI VEAE9 &7=7;OqOI :6 :89
7I>>6786>I :EP67 5I: O856X6L=7689: 5AE9I 6ON8>7=9LI
>=56L=FI;R=>5I :8965I9767Q I97=97VEI7IFG *6FI
7I>>6786>IQ7=67E9 QFQOI97L89:767E76X5I FA&7=7; E9I
O856X6L=7689 X895=OI97=FI 5I LIFE61L6 6ONF6VEI>=67
QR=FIOI97E9LM=9RIOI97 5I FA&7=7 I9 7=97VEI 7IFG ,9 = =XX6>OQ
=E::6 VEI LI77I7MT:IN>Q:I97I FA&7=7 L8OOI E9I >Q=F67Q
:8L68F8R6VEI; O=6: 9I FA=9=FS:I N=: 5EN8697 5I YEIZE>656VEIG $0G
1.&-&%%$-,$%& &"-!"- @#& +,l!$"&+&
0!.$+$-D *6I: IWN8:QI:ZE:VEAUN>Q:I97I::=6I97 5I >QN895>I
UF= VEI:76895I :=Y86> LI VEAI:7 FI 7I>>6786>I 5I
FA&7=7 N=> >QXQ>I9LI =E O895I 9=7E>IFG []]
(>6LdI>; 8NG L67G; NG 22 ::G +=9: LI OqOI :I9:; ?IFF69Id
=XX6>OI VEI; :=9:
FAIW6:7I9LI5Aq7>I:MEO=69:;899INIE7N=>FI>5I7I>>6786>I;O=6:
:6ONFIOI975IN=>76I:5IF=:E>X=LI 7I>>I:7>I[J089
OI9:LMF6LMI9 *EPZId7I9 R=9e F8:RIFb:7 R6P7 I: dI69 fIP6I7;
:895I>9 9E> -I6FI 5I>&>58PI>XFULMIK; !FFRIOI69I
*7==7:FIM>I; ]I Q5G; HI>F69; 232i; NG 2jhG []i J +=: fIP6I7
d8OO7 =F:8 XE> 5I9 *7==7 =F: %=EO 69 HI7>=LM7 E95 6:7 =F:
:8FLMI> I69aI:I97F6LMI: &FIOI97 5I: *7==7I: :IFP:7 =PI>;
a6I 6LM O6LM =E:RI5>66Ld7 M=PI; I69 l8OI97 6OmI:I9 5I: *7==7I:K
[(>6LdI>; 8NG L67G; NG 2pG []g 086>; NG IWG; wZIFFQ9;
+I> *7==7 =F: .IPI9:X8>O; .I6Ne6R; 232j; NNG h] I7 kpG
%=7eIF;&>5I9O=LM7 E95 0bFdI>:LM6Ld:=F 1 &69I
!E:a=MF=E: :I69I9 mI>dI9; *7E77R=>7; NG 222 ::G [+I>*7==7
=F: ,>R=96:OE:G []h 489XGB wZIFFQ9; 8NG L67G; NG gkG
- 9.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2]3&9 23ph :AI:7 N>85E67 E9 LM=9RIOI97 5I L89LIN7689 U
FA8LL=:689 5I F=NEPF6L=7689 5I FA=>76LFI 5A&>9:7
%=5967edS :8E: FI 767>I J "=7E>IZE>656VEI
5E7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K; VE6 L89:767EI E9 =NN8>7
98EYI=E I7 X895=OI97=F =E:EZI7[]jG %=5967edS X=67 F= L>676VEI
5I: 7MQ8>6I: =97Q>6IE>I: I9 =XX6>O=97VEI F= :67E=7689
5I: 65QI: 5E 5>867 NEPF6L 697I>9I I7 5E 5>867 5I RI9:
:E>FI7I>>6786>I; U LI77I QN8VEI1FU; NIE7 q7>I
L8ON=>QI U LIFFI 5I FA=YIERFI I7 5EN=>=FS76VEI VE6 :I
:QN=>I>=6I97 VE86VEI 6956:NI9:=PFI: FAE9 U FA=E7>I []kG .=
L89LIN7689 5I %=5967edS :I 5QYIF8NNI :E> FI NF=9 98>O=76X U
N=>76>5I FA65QI 5I J L8ONQ7I9LIKG $F IWN>6OI VEI
FA&7=7 = := N>8N>I L8ONQ7I9LI;VE6 NIE7 q7>I 56Y6:QI I9
O=7Q>6IFFI; NI>:899IFFI I7 :N=76=FI[]3G .= L8ONQ7I9LI
=7Q>6IFFI I:7L89:767EQI N=> 78E: FI: =L7I: VEI FA&7=7NIE7
>Q=F6:I> I9 OYI>7E 5I :89 5>867; N=> IWIONFI; I9
O=76T>I 5I X69=9LI:; 5I 7>=9:N8>7:;5A8>R=96:=7689
O6F67=6>I; I7LG .= L8ONQ7I9LI NI>:899IFFI I:7 FI N8EY86>
5IFA&7=7 N=> >=NN8>7 =EW NI>:899I: B 6F NIE7;
N=> IWIONFI; Q56L7I> 5I: F86:N8>7=97 :E> F= 9=7689=F67Q
8E 5A=E7>I: O=76T>I: 5897 FI: 5I:769=7=6>I: :897FI:
NI>:899I: O=ZIE>I:; FI: Q7>=9RI>:; FI: NI>:899I:
O=>6QI: =S=97 NFE: 5I5IEW I9X=97:; I7LG .=L8ONQ7I9LI :N=76=FI
I:7 :S989SOI 5I F=:8EYI>=69I7Q7I>>678>6=FI
[fIP6I7:M8MI67[ip; VEI %=5967edS 5QX6967 L8OOI F=
L8ONQ7I9LI:N=76=FI 5I FA&7=7; FI 7I>>6786>I [fIP6I7
Q7=97 =F8>: FI 58O=69I :N=76=F 5EN8EY86> 5I FA&7=7[i2G !
F= 56XXQ>I9LI 5I: 7MQ8>6I: IW=O69QI: =97Q>6IE>IOI97;
N8E> %=5967edS;FI L89LIN75I 7I>>6786>I 9I 5867N=:
q7>I >ILMI>LMQ 5=9: FI O895I >QIF; O=6::E> FI NF=9
98>O=76XL=> 6F :A=R67 5E 58O=69I :N=76=F 5E N8EY86> 5I
FA&7=7GH6I9 VEI %=5967edS =67 QL>67 5A=E7>I: Q7E5I:
:E> LI :EZI7; 6F 9A= N=: I976T>IOI97 5QYIF8NNQ :=7MT:I O=6:
:89 OQ>67IN>69L6N=F L89:6:7I N>QL6:QOI97U=Y86> :67EQ FI
7I>>6786>I :E> LI NF=9G *= 7MQ8>6I = Z8E6 5AE9I
R>=95I :=YIE>=EN>T: 5I: ZE>6:7I:; N=>O6 FI:VEIF: 89
NIE7 OI976899I> CI9>6LM[i^ I7*LM8I9P8>9[i]G l=6:
FA6ON8>7=9LI VEAIFFI = =LVE6:I I:7 5EI; :=9: =ELE958E7I; U C=9:
wIF:I9; VE6 FA= N>QL6:QI I7 FA= NI>XIL76899QI U 7>=YI>:
:I:8EY>=RI:G &9 LI VE6 L89LI>9I F= 5QX6967689 5I
7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7; wIF:I9ION>E97I I9 IXXI7
FA65QI X895=OI97=FI 5I %=5967edS[ii; O=6: 6F O856X6ILI>7=69:
L89LIN7: =X69 5Aq7>I L89:QVEI97 =YIL := 7MQ8>6I NE>I 5E
5>867G%=5967edS 5QX696::=97 FI 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7
L8OOI J FI 58O=69I 5I F= L8ONQ7I9LI :N=76=FI 5E N8EY86>
5IFA&7=7K; 6FL89Y6I97 O=697I9=975A=9=FS:I>FI:O856X6L=7689:
697>85E67I: N=> wIF:I9G +=9: := 5QX6967689; %=5967edS X=67
=FFE:689 =E J N8EY86> 5I FA&7=7KG $FI:7 P6I9 L899E VEI;
N8E>F= 7MQ8>6I NE>I 5E 5>867; FA&7=7
=NN=>=v7L8OOIE98>5>IZE>656VEI>IF=76YIOI97LI97>=F6:QG
wIF:I9IWNF6VEIVEAE98>5>IZE>656VEII:7 E9 I9:IOPFI 5I
98>OI: 5897 F= Y=F6567Q 5Q>6YI 5AE9I OqOI 98>OI []j
%=5967edS; J +6I >ILM7F6LMI "=7E> 5I: *7==7:RIP6I7I:K;
!GbG%G; 7G //; 23ph; NG ]2] ::G []k %=5967edS; 8NG L67G;!GbG%G; 7G
//; 23ph; NG ]]3G []3 .=7I>O698F8R6IE76F6:QIN=>
FA=E7IE>I:7J :=LMF6LMI;NI>:89IFFIE95b>7F6LMIw8ONI7I9eK[8NG
L67G;!GbG%G; 7G //; 23ph; NG ]]3G [ip %=5967edS;8NG L67G;!GbG%G;7G
//; 23ph;NG ]ipG "8E:7>=5E6:89:6L6FI7I>OI
fIP6I7:M8MI67N=>:8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FIG-IF
VEI98E: FA6956VE89: NFE: F869; FI: =E7IE>:N8:7Q>6IE>:
5IF=9REI=FFIO=95I X897F= 56:769L7689 I97>I fIP6I7:M8MI67 I7
7I>>678>6=FI *8EYI>n96757; O=6: LI 9AI:7N=: FIL=: 5I
%=5967edSG [i2 %=5967edS; 8NG L67G;!GbG%G; 7G //; 23ph; NG ]i2G [i^
CI9>6LM; -MQ8>6I 5I: *7==7:RIP6I7I: I97a6LdIF7 =E: 5I>
.IM>I Y89 5I9 F8d=FI9 w8ONI17I9eI9 5I> *7==7:NI>:89;
m6I91.I6Ne6R; 23^^; NG ]2 ::G [i] *LM8I9P8>9; J .= 9=7E>I
ZE>656VEI 5E 7I>>6786>IK; %G5G4; 23^310; NG kg ::G [ii
wIF:I9 L67I IWN>I::QOI97LI77I Q7E5I 5I %=5967edS F8>:VEA6F
X=67>QXQ>I9LI =E 7I>>6786>I5I FA&7=7 [!FFRIOI69I
*7==7:FIM>I; HI>F69; 23^g; NNG ]3]1]3iG
- 10. 2ip
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&ZE>656VEI[igG
+=9:FI L=: 5I FA8>5>IZE>656VEI 5I FA&7=7; F= 98>OI
VE6 I:7 F=:8E>LI 5I F= Y=F6567Q 5I 78E7I: FI: =E7>I: I:7F=
489:767E7689 9=7689=FIG .I:98>OI: 897 E9I IW6:7I9LI :NQL6X6VEI;
567I JY=F6567QK [fIF7E9R[ih B 5I F=OqOI X=`89 VEAE9 8PZI7 5E O895I
>QIF [E9I 7=PFI; E9I Y=LMI IW6:7I; E9I98>OI [E9 =>76LFI 5E
485I L6Y6F 8E 5E 485I NQ9=F I:7 Y=F=PFIG .AIW6:7I9LII:7=E O895I 5I
FAq7>I [*I69 LI VEI F= Y=F6567Q I:7 =E O895I 5E5IY86>
q7>I[*8FFI9G .=Y=F6567Q5AE9I 98>OI 5867q7>I56:769REQI 5I
:89 IXX6L=L67Q [m6>d1:=OdI67; VE6 L89:6:7I U LI VEI F= 98>OI
:867 IXXIL76YIOI97 8PQ6I[ijG #9I98>OIZE>656VEI;
N8E>q7>IY=F=PFI;IW6RIE9O696OEO5AIXX6L=L67Q;LAI:71U156>I5867
L8ON7I> =YIL E9 LI>7=69 5IR>Q 5A8P:I>Y=9LI; 5867
q7>I 8PQ6I 5=9: E9ILI>7=69I OI:E>I; I7 :6 F= 98>OI
9AI:7 N=: =E O869: N=>76IFFIOI97 IXX6L=LI;IFFI NI>5
:=Y=F6567Q[ikG 4I VEA89 567 6L6 U N>8N8: 5AE9I 98>OI;
:A=NNF6VEIQR=FIOI97U E9 8>5>IZE>656VEII7; N=>
L89:QVEI97; :6E9 8>5>I 9AI:7N=: 8PQ65=9: E9I LI>7=69I
OI:E>I; 6F NI>5 := Y=F6567Q[i3G 4I: L89LIN7: IWN8:Q:; 6F X=E7
O=697I9=97 :I 5IO=95I> LI VEAI:7 FIJ N8EY86>5IFA&7=7K
N8E>F= 7MQ8>6INE>I 5E5>867G
4I77I7I>O698F8R6I;=XX6>OIwIF:I9; 98E: 5899IFA65QI
VEIFA&7=7 :I7>8EYI 5I>>6T>I FI
5>867N8E>R=>=976> :89 =NNF6L=7689 I7; 5=9: LI :I9:;
FA&7=7 I:7=NNIFQ QR=FIOI97 E9I 5I FA&7=7; L89X895E =YIL
FAIW6:7I9LI 5AE9 8>5>I ZE>656VEIIXX6L=LI; :I>=OT9I
UF=Y=F6567Q 5I FA8>5>IZE>656VEI; L=>F=
Y=F6567Q6ONF6VEIE9 O696OEO 5AIXX6L=L67Q[gpG LI: >=6:89:; FI
L89LIN7 5I J N8EY86> 5IFA&7=7K VEI %=5967edS 69LFE7 5=9: :=
5QX6967689 5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7; I:7>IONF=LQ
N=> wIF:I9 N=> F= 987689 5I Y=F6567Q 5I
FA8>5>IZE>656VEI 5I FA&7=7G "8E: =Y89: 5QZU YE VEI
%=5967edS 5QX6967 FI 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 L8OOI FI
58O=69I 5I F= L8ONQ7I9LI :N=76=FI 5E N8EY86> 5I FA&7=7[g2G
wIF:I9 ; U :89 78E>; >IONF=LI F= 987689 5I J N8EY86> 5I
FA&7=7K N=>LIFFI 5I Y=F6567Q 5I FA8>5>I ZE>656VEI
5I FA&7=7G $F =XX6>OI VEI FI: 98>OI: 5AE9 8>5>I
ZE>656VEI :897 Y=F=PFI:N=> >=NN8>7U E9I:N=LII7 U
E97ION: 5Q7I>O69Q: VEA6F=NNIFFI58O=69I 5I Y=F6567Q :N=76=F
[5I> >UEOF6LMI fIF7E9R:PI>I6LM I7 58O=69I 5IY=F6567Q
7ION8>IF [5I> eI67F6LMI fIF7E9R:PI>I6LM 5I: 98>OI:[g^G
&9 8E7>I;FI >=NN8>7 5I F= 98>OI =YIL :I:
5I:769=7=6>I: L89:767EI :89 58O=69I 5IY=F6567Q NI>:899IF I7
FI >=NN8>75I F= 98>OI =YIL F= O=76T>I VEAIFFI>QR67
I:7 =NNIFQ 58O=69I 5I Y=F6567Q O=7Q>6IF 5I F= 98>OIG .I:
58O=69I: 5I Y=F6567Q5I FA8>5>IZE>656VEI =EWVEIF: :I
>QXT>I wIF:I9 IWN>6OI97 F= OqOI 65QI VEIFI: 58O=69I: 5I F=
L8ONQ7I9LI5E N8EY86> 5I FA&7=7 5=9: F= 7I>O698F8R6I
5I%=5967edSG .= 56XXQ>I9LI >Q:65I 5=9: FI X=67 VEI LI
5I>96I> N=>FI 5I 7>86:7SNI: 5I L8ONQ7I9LI
[O=7Q>6IFFI; NI>:899IFFI I7 :N=76=FI; 7=956: VEI
N8E>FA=E7>I =E7IE>6F S =VE=7>I58O=69I:5I Y=F6567Q
[O=7Q>6IF;NI>:899IF;:N=76=FI7 7ION8>IF[g]G [ig J !6FI
"8>OI9; 5I>I9 fIF7E9R =EXI69I E95 56I:IFPI
f>E9598>OeE>oLdRIXEM>7 aI>5I9d=99; P6F5I9 I69
*S:7IOY89 "8>OI9; I69I 98>O=76YI
,>59E9RK[%I69I%ILM7:FIM>I; ^I Q5G; m6I9;23hp; NG 23jG [ih
wIF:I9; %I69I %ILM7:FIM>I; ^I Q5G; NG 3| !FFRIOI69I -MQ8>6I
5I> "8>OI9; m6I9; 23j3;NG ^G [ij wIF:I9; %I69I%ILM7:FIM>I;
^I Q5G; NNG 2p I7 22|!FFRIOI69I -MQ8>6I 5I>"8>OI9; NG ]G
[ik wIF:I9; %I69I %ILM7:FIM>I; ^I Q5G; NG 22| !FFRIOI69I
-MQ8>6I 5I> "8>OI9; NNG 22^ I722]G [i3 wIF:I9; !FFRIOI69I
-MQ8>6I 5I>"8>OI9; NNG 22^122]G [gp wIF:I9; !FFRIOI69I
*7==7:FIM>I; NG 3j| J -MQ8>6I 5E 5>867 697I>9=7689=F
NEPF6LK; %G5G4;23g]1$$$; NG jhG [g2 086> :EN>=; 987I i2G [g^
wIF:I9; %I69I%ILM7:FIM>I; ^I Q5G; NG 2^ ::G [g]
.=7I>O698F8R6I E76F6:QI N=> wIF:I9I:7 J :=LMF6LMI>85I>
O=7I>6=FI>; NI>:89=FI>;>nEOF61LMI> E95
eI67F6LMI> fIF7E9R:PI>I6LMKG
- 11.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2i2 .=987689 5I 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 I:7 I9
>=NN8>7 =YIL FI 58O=69I :N=76=F
5IY=F6567Q5IFA8>5>IZE>656VEI5IFA&7=7G wIF:I9
:6R9=FIVEI LI>7=69I:98>OI:
5ILI78>5>INIEYI97q7>IY=F=PFI:OqOI5=9:
FI7I>>6786>I5AE9N=S:Q7>=9RI>G IWIONFI; FI: F86:
:E> F= L=N=L67Q 5I N=::I> 5I: L897>=7: I7 5I:
=L7I:ZE>656VEI: I9 RQ9Q>=F :E6YI97 FI: NI>:899I: =E15IFU
FI: F6O67I: 5I FA&7=7 5I FIE> 9=7689=F67Q 8E 5I FIE>
58O6L6FIG !X69 5AQY67I> 5I: L89XE:689:; wIF:I9 E76F6:I
E9L89LIN7VEA6F =NNIFFI J >I:7>I697K 5I 7I>>6786>I
5IFA&7=7; I9>=NN8>7 =YIL FAI:N=LI 5=9: FIVEIF :I:
8>R=9I: NIEYI97 IWQLE7I> FI: =L7I:
L8I>L676X:N>QYE:N=>FA8>5>IZE>656VEI9=7689=FG
+=9:LI:I9:;wIF:I95QX6967FI7I>>6786>I5I FA&7=7 L8OOI J
FAI:N=LI UFA697Q>6IE>5EVEIFE9&7=7I:7 =E78>6:QN=> FI
5>867 697I>9=7689=F RQ9Q>=FU>Q=F6:I>78E:FI:
=L7I:N>QYE:N=> :89 5>867 9=7689=F 8E; LIVE6>IY6I97 =E
OqOI; FAI:N=LI U FA697Q>6IE> 5EVEIF; L89X8>OQOI97 =E
5>867 697I>9=7689=F; FI:
8>R=9I:5Q7I>O69Q:N=>E98>5>IZE>656VEI9=7689=F:897
=E78>6:Q:UIWQLE7I> LI7 8>5>IK [giG F= 7MQ8>6I
NE>I 5E 5>867; FI 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 I:7 E9
I:N=LI VE6IWLFE7 78E7 =E7>I L=> 6F 9I NIE7 N=: q7>I
:6OEF7=9QOI97 FI 7I>>6786>I 5I NFE:5AE9 &7=7G
&ON>E97=97 F= 7I>O698F8R6I 5I F= NMS:6VEI; wIF:I9
N=>FI 5IFA6ONQ9Q7>=P6F67Q [#95E>LM5>69RF6LMdI67 5I
FA&7=7[ggG 4I77I
L=>=L7Q>6:76VEI9AI:7N=:X89L76895E7I>>6786>I;
O=6:>Q:EF7I5IF= :8EYI>=69I7Q5IFA&7=7[ghG.I N>69L6NI 5I
FA6ONQ9Q7>=P6F67Q 5I FA&7=7 L899=v7; LINI95=97; VEIFVEI:
IWLIN7689:G IWIONFI; E9 &7=7 NIE7 L89LFE>I =YIL E9 =E7>I
E9 7>=67Q NI>OI77=97 U LI 5I>96I> FAIWQLE7689 5I
LI>7=69: =L7I: L8=L76X: 5=9: FI 7I>>6786>I5E
N>IO6I>| 5I OqOI :IF89 FI 5>867 5I F= REI>>I; F=
LI> 5I: =L7I: L8I>L676X: 5=9: FI 7I>>6786>I 8LLENQG
wIF:I9 L89:65T>I=E::6 VEI FI L8958O696EO I:7 E9I IWLIN7689 U
FA6ONQ9Q7>=P6F67Q 5I FA&7=7G .= L89LIN7689 5E
7I>>6786>I I9 7=97 VEI 58O=69I :N=76=F 5I Y=F6567Q
5IFA8>5>I ZE>656VEI I:7 IWN8:QI 5=9: LI>7=69I:
5QL6:689: 5I F= ZE>6:N>E5I9LI;I:7 =LLIN7QI U N>Q:I97
N=>E9I N=>76I6ON8>7=97I 5I F= 58L7>69IG !69:6;
:IF89F=:I97I9LI =>P67>=FI 5E ]2ZE6FFI7 23k3 VE6 5Q7I>O69I
F= X>8976T>I O=>676OII97>I FI *Q9QR=F I7 F=
fE69QI1H6::=EB J #9IX>8976T>I 697I>9=7689=FII:7
F=F6R9IX8>OQI N=>F=:ELLI::689 5IN8697: IW7>qOI: 5E 58O=69I
5I Y=F6567Q :N=76=F 5I: 98>OI: 5I FA8>5>IZE>656VEI 5AE9
&7=7K [gjG .=:I97I9LI =>P67>=FI5E 2] 8L78P>I 233g5=9:
FA=XX=6>I 5I F=.=RE9=5IF+I:6I>78; I97>I FI4M6F6 I7
FA!>RI9769I; 5QX6967 QR=FIOI97F=F6O67I 697I>9=7689=FI
7I>OI: :E6Y=97:B 5=9: FI: J #9I F6O67I 697I>9=7689=FI I:7 F=
F6R9I 5I L897=L7 5I: 58O=69I: :N=76=EW 5I Y=F6567Q 5I 5IEW
8>5>I: ZE>656VEI: Q7=76VEI:K [gkG &9 LIVE6 L89LI>9I
F= 58L7>69I; 89 NIE7 5A=P8>5 OI976899I> FI: 8N69689: 5I
+IFPIe I7 5I fERRI9MI6O X=Y8>=PFI: U F= 7MQ8>6I =9=FS:QI
6L6[g3G %8E: :I=E; N8E> := N=>7; I:76OI VEI F= 7MT:I IWN8:QI
N=> wIF:I9 I:7 PI=EL8EN [gi wIF:I9; 69L6NFI: 8X$97I>9=7689=F
.=a; "Ia c8>d; 23g^; NG ^p3G 086: =E::6 wIF:I9;fI9I>=F
-MI8>S 8X.=a =95 *7=7I; 4=OP>65RI [l=::G; 23ih; NNG ^pk I7
^p3G %EP; C=9: wIF:I9:0bFdI>>ILM7:FIM>I; uE>6LM; 233g;
NG ikjG [gg wIF:I9; !FFRIOI69I *7==7:FIM>I; NG 2i^G 086>
=E::6 69L6NFI: 8X$97I>9=7689=F .=a;NG ^2kG [gh wIF:I9;
!FFRIOI69I *7==7:FIM>I; NG 2i]G [gj %G*G!G; Y8FG //; NG 2iiG [gk
->6PE9=F =>P67>=F 697I>9=7689=F [!>RI9769=14M6FI;
*I97I9L6= =>P67>=F 5IF 2] 5I 8L7EP>I5I 233g; N=>G g3G
[g3 +IFPIe; J+E7I>>6786>I 5=9: :I: >=NN8>7: =YIL
FA&7=7K; %GfG+G$G=67Q 5I+>867 697I>9=7689=FNEPF6L;
fI9TYI; 23g]; 7G $; NG ]jiG
- 12. 2i^
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&NFE:
:=76:X=6:=97I VEI FI: N>QLQ5I97I: I7 VEAIFFI >IN>Q:I97I
=EZ8E>5AME6 FA8N69689 58O69=97I5=9:
F=F677Q>=7E>IZE>656VEI[hpG +=6FF6I>I7 7=RI97LI77I
8N69689[h2G .I: yEY>I: I:N=R98FI:>QLI97I: L8t9L65I97
=YILIFFIG +6Ie5I 0IF=:L8 I:76OI VEI F= L89LIN7689 =9=FS:QI J =
=77I697 E9I>IL899=6::=9LIRQ9Q>=F6:QI 5=9: F= 58L7>69IK I7
VEAIFFI I:7 J LIFFI VE6 NI>OI7 FI O6IEW 5IL8ON>I95>I F=
VEI:7689 5I F= 9=7E>I ZE>656VEI 5E 7I>>6786>IK [h^G
f89e=FIe4=ON8:; *=9LMIe %85>6REIe I7 !95>Q: *=I9e 5I *=97=
l=>6= :8E76I99I97E9I 8N69689 :IOPF=PFIB J [GGG .A8>6I97=7689
=L7EIFFI F= NFE: L89:8F65QI I:7 LIFFI =NNIFQI 7MQ8>6I 5I F=
L8ONQ7I9LI; Q989LQI N=> %=5967edS I7 L8ONFQ7QI 5=9:FI:
LI>LFI: ZE>656VEI: =E7>6LM6I9: I7 X>=9`=6:K [h]G
?6OQ9Ie 5I !>QLM=R= >IL899=v7 QR=FIOI97 VEAE9I R>=95I
N=>76I 5I F=58L7>69I O85I>9I 69LF69I N8E> F= L89LIN7689
5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 L8OOI58O=69I 5I Y=F6567Q
:N=76=F 5I FA8>5>I ZE>656VEI 5I FA&7=7; O=6: 6F
X8>OEFIE9I :QYT>I L>676VEI 5I LI77I 58L7>69I[hiG
4I>7=69: >=6:899IOI97: IWN8:Q:N=> wIF:I9 :897 VE=F6X6Q: 5I
J>IL899=6::=9LI QY65I97I 5I FAQLMILL89LIN7EIF5I LI77I
58L7>69I 5E7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7K I7 6F L89LFE7 I9
=XX6>O=97 VEI J FIL>67T>I8EN6I>>I 5I78ELMI
N>8N8:QN=>wIF:I99I98E:6956VEI N=: LIVEAI:7FI
7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7KG #9I =9=FS:I F8R6VEI 5E
>=6:899IOI97 5E ZE>6:7IE>ERE=SI9 98E: IONqLMI LINI95=97 5I
N=>7=RI> :I: L89LFE:689:G 0G 1.! +$*-$"4-$,"&"-%& .!
*,#0&%!$"&-D -&%%$-,%$!.& &-.! *#=F; 5=9: E9
I:N=LI 5Q7I>O69Q; FA8>5>I ZE>656VEI 5AE9 :IEF
&7=7I:7Y=F=PFIG-IFFI
I:7F=:67E=7689L89:65Q>QIN=>l=WCEPI>5=9: :=
:I97I9LI=>P67>=FI P6I9 L899EI :E> c}FI5I 6F 23^k
F8>:VEA6F =XX6>OI VEIF= :8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI
L8ON>I95 FI 5>867 IWLFE:6X5AIWI>LI>
FI:X89L7689:N>8N>I: 5AE9 &7=7[hgG .=
L=>=L7Q>6:76VEI 5I F= :8EYI>=69I7Q
7I>>678>6=FI;:IF89LI77I L89LIN7689; L89:6:7I
I9FAIWI>L6LI 5I F= NFQ967E5I 5I:L8ONQ7I9LI:5I F= N=>75I
FA&7=7 N=> >=NN8>7 U E9 7I>>6786>I;S
L8ON>6:LIFFI 5AI956:N8:I>:IF89 := Y8F897Q[hhG ,>; 98E:
FA=Y89: YE 5=9: FI N=>=R>=NMI N>QLQ5I97; 5A=N>T: FI
5>867697I>9=7689=FRQ9Q>=F;E9&7=7NIE7:IY86>=E78>6:QUX=6>I5I:=L7I:L8I>L676X:5=9:
E9 7I>>6786>I Q7>=9RI>G 4AI:7 =69:6; N=> IWIONFI;
VEI FA&7=7 5E N=Y6FF895AE99=Y6>I I97>=9:67
:E>F=OI>7I>>678>6=FI
5AE9&7=7Q7>=9RI>NIE7IWI>LI>;5=9: LI>7=69: L=:;
:= ZE>656L7689 NQ9=FI I7 L6Y6FI :E> FI: N=::=RI>: 5E567
[hp %8E::I=E; +>867 697I>9=7689=F NEPF6L; 6:; 23ji; 7G $$; NG
g2G [h2 +=6FF6I>1867 697I>9=7689=F NEPF6L; hI Q5G; 6:; 2333;
NG i22G [h^ +6Ie 5I0IF=:L8; $9:767EL689I: 5I
+I>ILM8$97I>9=L689=F 65; 233j;NG ]]gG [h] f89e=FIe
4=ON8:1*n9LMIe %85>6REIe1!95>Q: *=I9e 5I *=97= l=>6=;
4E>:8 5I +I>ILM8$97I>9=L689=F 65; 233k; NG g^^G [hi
?6OQ9Ie5I!>QLM=R=; 4E>:8 5I +I>ILM8 $97I>9=L689=F
>678>6=F :8YI>I6R97SGGG 69Y8FYI: 7MI IWLFE:6YI >6RM7 78
56:NF=S 7MI =L76Y676I: 8X=*7=7IK[%G*G!G; Y8FG $$; NG k]3G [hh
*NI>5E76; J*8Y>=967U 7I>>678>6=FI; =776 56
56:N8:6e689I56 7I>>678>6 I5 IXXI76Y67U69
56>6778697I>9=e689=FIK; %6Y6:7=; 23g3; NG ipgG w8MI9; =69I7Q
7I>>678>6=FI;6:; 233j; NG 2iG
- 13.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2i]9=Y6>I[hjG $F I9 Y= 5I OqOI 5=9: FI L=: 5AE9 =Q>89IXI9Y8F
5=9: FAI:N=LI=Q>6I9 5AE9 &7=7 Q7>=9RI>[hkG *IF89 FI
5>867 5I F= REI>>I; F= >6786>I 5AE9 &7=7 I99IO6
NIE7 IWI>LI> LI>7=69I: L8ONQ7I9LI:I7IWQLE7I>
LI>7=69: =L7I: R8EYI>9IOI97=EW 5=9: FI 7I>>6786>I
8LLENQ[h3G +A=E7>I N=>7; E9 &7=7 NIE7 L89LFE>I E9
7>=67Q =YIL E9 =E7>I =X69 5I FE6L89XQ>I> 5I:
L8ONQ7I9LI: 5=9: E9 :IL7IE> 5I :89 7I>>6786>I I7 FE6
NI>OI77>I5AIXXIL7EI> 5I: =L7I: 5I R8EYI>9IOI97 I9 LI
VE6 L89LI>9I FI: L8ONQ7I9LI:LQ5QI:G +=9: F= N>=76VEI
L89YI976899IFFI; 987=OOI97 =E /$/I :6TLFI I7 =E5QPE7 5E //I; 6F I:7
N8::6PFI5I 7>8EYI> 5I: IWIONFI: 5I F8L=7689:;
=5O696:7>=7689:5I 7I>>6786>I I7 =E7>I: X6RE>I:
=9=F8REI:G +=9:LI7 8>5>I 5A65QI:; 6FIW6:7I 5I:L=:
5=9:FI:VEIF:E9 &7=7=7>=9:XQ>Q
UE9=E7>IFAIWI>L6LI697QR>=F5I :I: L8ONQ7I9LI:
N=>>=NN8>7 U E9 LI>7=69 7I>>6786>I; :I
>Q:I>Y=97 E96VEIOI97 F=X=LEF7Q 5I FI LQ5I> U E9 &7=7
Q7>=9RI>G !X69 5I N8EY86> IW=O69I>LF=6>IOI97LI77I
:67E=7689; F=58L7>69I 56:769REI I97>I7I>>678>6=FI
*8EYI>U9617n7 I7 fIP6I7:M8MI67; L89LIN7: N8EY=97 q7>I
7>=5E67: N=> :8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI
:EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI[jpG "8E: =FF89: O=697I9=97
IW=O69I> I7VEIFVEI: L=: 5=9: FI:VEIF: LI77I :67E=7689 :I
N>Q:I97IG .A=>76LFI 2 5E 7>=67Q I97>I F= -E>VE6I I7
F=f>=95I1H>I7=R9I 5E i ZE692kjk 56:N8:IB J *= l=ZI:7Q
$ONQ>6=FI FI :EF7=9 [GGG L89:I97 U LI VEI FAvFI 5I 4MSN>I
:867 8LLENQI I7 =5O696:7>QI N=>FA!9RFI7I>>IK [j2G
.=-E>VE6I=L89769EQUq7>I767EF=6>I5IF=
:8EYI>=69I7Q:E>FAvFIZE:VEAI9232i; =F8>: VEI F=
f>=95I1H>I7=R9I S IWI>`=67 F= :EN>QO=76I
7I>>678>6=FIG .Ig 98YIOP>I 5I LI77I =99QI; F=
f>=95I1H>I7=R9I; Y68F=97 FI 5>867 5I RI9:; ==99IWQ FAvFI;
=99IW689 >IL899EI NFE: 7=>5 N=> F= -E>VE6I 5=9: FI
7>=67Q 5IN=6W 5I .=E:=99I [23^]G &9 2k3k; F= 4M69I = L89LFE
=YIL 5I: 8NQI99I: NFE:6IE>:=LL8>5: 5I LI::689 U P=6F
N8>7=97 :E> 56XXQ>I97: :IL7IE>: 5I :89
7I>>6786>IN8E> 5I: 5E>QI: 5Q7I>O69QI:G E9
7>=67Q :6R9Q U : 2k3k;F= 4M69I = F8EQ N8E> 33 =9: =E %I6LM
=FFIO=95 F= P=6I 5I
w6=81LM=E[j^G.A!FFIO=R9ILQ5=I9:E67I:I:5>867:=E?=N89I9YI>7E5E7>=67Q5I0I>:=6FFI:G.=4M69I
= =E::6 L89LFE FI ^j [2g O=>: 2k3k E9 =E7>I7>=67Q =YIL
F=%E::6IN=>FIVEIFIFFI FE6= LQ5QN8E> ^g
=9:71!>7ME>I7-=1F6I91a=9 I7 FI: I=EWI9Y6>899=97I:[j]G .I
7>=67Q =XX6>OI 5=9: :89 =>76LFI 2 VEI J LI7 =L7I
5IF8L=7689 [GGG 9I Y68FI I9 =ELE9I O=96T>I FI: 5>867:
:8EYI>=69: 5I *G lGFA&ONI>IE> 5I 4M69IKG .= %E::6I =
5r LQ5I> :I: 5>867: =E?=N89 I9 23pgN=>FI 7>=67Q 5I
N=6WVE6 O67X69 U F= REI>>I I97>I FI: 5IEW&7=7:G
.=(>=9LI= =E::6 8P7I9E FI ^j O=6 2k3k F= LI::689 U P=6F 5I
F=P=6I 5I wE=9R1LM8Ea=9 N8E> 33 =9:[ji; F= f>=95I1H>I7=R9I
LIFFI 5I mI61M=6mI6 I75I: I=EWI9Y6>899=97I: FI 2I> ZE6FFI7
2k3k[jgG +=9: LI77I L89YI97689 6F I:7 :76NEFQ [hj 086> FI:
=>7:G ^j; ^k I7 3^; =F69Q= 2; 5I F= L89YI97689 5I: "=7689: #96I:
:E> FI 5>8675I F= OI> [23k^G [hk 086>FI: =>7:G ] I7
i 5I F= L89YI97689 5I-8d685E 2iG$/G23j]G [h3 @E=97UFA8LLEN=7689
O6F67=6>I;Y86>%8PI>7:;J mM=76: =l6F67=>S,LLEN=7689~ K;
HGcGHG;23ki; NG ^i3 ::G w8MI9; 8NG L67G; NG 3g ::G [jp 489XG B
0I>5>8::1*6OO=1fI6RI>;-I>>678>6=FI
*8EYI>5967n7 E95fIP6I7:M8MI67; H899; 23kp;NG ]jG [j2 J C6:
$ONI>6=F l=ZI:7S 7MI *EF7=9GGG L89:I97: 78 =::6R9 7MI $:F=95 8X
4SN>E: 78 PI8LLEN6I5=95 =5O696:7I>I5 PS &9RF=95K [4G-G*G;
Y8FG 2g]; NG jpG [j^ 4G-G*G; Y8FG 2kh; NG 2kj ::G [j] 4G-G*G; Y8FG
2kh; NG ^p2 ::G [ji 4G-G*G; Y8FG 2kh; NG ^32 ::G [jg 4G-G*G; Y8FG;
2kh; NNG ]gi I7 ]ggG
- 14. 2ii
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&VEI
F= F8L=7689 5E>I>= =E::6 F89R7ION: VEI F=%E::6I 8LLENI>=
71!>7ME>L8OOI F8L=7=6>IG ,9 6956VEI QR=FIOI97 VEI; 5=9: FI
7I>>6786>I LQ5Q; F=f>=95I1H>I7=R9I 9IZ8E6>= VEI
5I F=ZE>656L7689[jhG .I: &7=7: 767EF=6>I: 5ILI: LI::689:
U P=6F 897 >I989LQ U FIE>: 5>867: U FA8LL=:689 5I
F=489XQ>I9LI5I m=:M69R789 5I 23^2^^G +=9:E9I QN8VEI >QLI97I;
5IEW :67E=7689: VE6 98E: 697Q>I::I97 5=9: FIL=5>I 5I LI77I
Q7E5I 897 7>8EYQ E9I 6::EI B I 23p]; 6VEI 897 L89LFE FI
7>=67Q567 C=S1HE9=E 0=>6FF= U N>8N8: 5AE9 L=9=F
697I>8LQ=96VEI VE6 7>=YI>:I>=67FI 7I>>6786>I
5I 7E 5I LI 7>=67Q; NQ7E67Q U :89 L81L897>=L7=97FAE:=RI;
FA8LLEN=7689 I7FI L897>bFI 5AE9Ie89I5I 7I>>6786>I
7I>>I:7>I I7 :8E:1=VE=76VEI N8E> F= L89:7>EL7689;
FAI97>I76I9;FA8NQ>=7689 I7 F= N>87IL7689 5E XE7E>
L=9=FG .I 7>=67Q N>QL6:I VEI 5I =EW &7=7:1#96: 78E: FI:
5>867:; FI N8EY86> I7 FA=E78>67Q U FA697Q>6IE> 5I F=
e89I OI976899QI I7 VEA6F: I9 Z8E6>897 I7 FI: IWI>LI>897
L8OOI :A6F:Q7=6I97 FI :8EYI>=69 7I>>678>6=F; U
FAIWLFE:689 5I FAIWI>L6LI 5I 78E7 5>867 :8EYI>=69;
N8EY86> 8E =E78>67Q 5I F= N=>7 5I F= %QNEPF6VEI 5I 6VEI :I
:897 8PF6RQ: U N=SI> U :18> I7 E9I :8OOI =99EIFFI5I ^gpGppp
58FF=>:G+=9:FI5QYIF8NNIOI97 5IF=>IF=7689 I97>I6VEI;
6F=Q7QLF=6>IOI97 Q7=PF6 VEI FI N>IO6I> L89:I>Y=67 F=
:8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI :E> F= e89I 5E L=9=FG +=9:
LI :I9:; 89 NIE7 OI976899I> F= 5QLF=>=7689 L89Z8697I :6R9QI
FI j XQY>6I> 23ji N=> FI l696:7>I 5I: =XX=6>I:
Q7>=9RT>I: 5I Q7=6>I 5A&7=7 5I: &7=7:1#96: VE6
X6WI FI: N8697: VE6 :I>Y6>897 5I P=:I U E9 98EYI=E 7>=67Q
:E> FI L=9=F; 5IY=97 >IONF=LI> LIFE6 :6R9Q I9 23p][jkG
+=9:LI77I 5QLF=>=7689 L89Z8697I 89 IWN>6OI VEI F= %QNEPF6VEI
5I =697I>>678>6=F; =LL8>5I>= =EW&7=7:1#96:
5A!OQ>6VEI; NI95=97 F= 5E>QI 5E 98EYI=E 7>=67Q :E> FI
L=9=F 697I>8LQ=96VEI; FI 5>867 5AE76F6:I> FI:
7I>>I:; FI: I=EW I7 FAI:N=LI =Q>6I9 VE6 :I>897
9QLI::=6>I: U FA8NQ>=7689; FAI97>I76I9; F= N>87IL7689
I7 F=5QXI9:I 5EL=9=F I75E7>=9:67 5I: 9=Y6>I:G 4I N>69L6NI
XE7 69LFE: 5=9: FI 98EYI=E 7>=67Q :E> FI L=9=F 5E j
:IN7IOP>I 23jj;VE6>IONF=`=FI7>=67Q
C=S1HE9=E0=>6FF=I7>I:7=I9Y6REIE>ZE:VEA=E ]2 5QLIOP>I
2333[j3G *E> F= P=:I 5E 7>=67Q 5I 23jj; QLENQ>QE9I
N=>76I 6ON8>7=97I 5I :=L8ONQ7I9LI 5=9: F= e89I 5E L=9=F
L=>
FI:&7=7:1#96:5A!OQ>6VEI9I:AQ7=6I97>Q:I>YQZE:VEAUF=X69
2333VEAE95>867 5AE:=RI N8E> 78E7 LI VE6 L89LI>9I FIL=9=F
I7 FI 7>=9:67 5I: 9=Y6>I:G .A8>6R69I 5I FA=9L6I99I L8F896I
5I C89Rw89R I:7F6QI U FA697>85EL7689 5I FA8N6EOI9
4M69I;IXXIL7EQI N=>FI:P>67=996VEI:U 7>=YI>: FIN8>7
5I 4=9789G.A&ONI>IE> 5I 4M69I = I::=SQ 5AIONqLMI> LI
L8OOI>LI; LI U VE86 FI:H>67=996VEI: :I :897 8NN8:Q:;
7>=9:XQ>=97 FIE>: =L76Y67Q: U C89R w89RG&9:E67I; F=
f>=95I1H>I7=R9I = I9Y8SQ E9I X8>LI O6F67=6>I VE6 =
Y=69LE F=4M69I 5=9: F= J REI>>I 5I FA8N6EOKG .= L8F896I
P>67=996VEI 5I C89R w89RQ7=67 X8>OQI 5I
7I>>6786>I:VE6 =Y=6I97 5I:8>6R69I: 56XXQ>I97I:G
.AvFI5I C89Rw89R =Y=67 Q7Q LQ5QI U NI>NQ7E67Q N=> F= 4M69I U
F= f>=95I1H>I7=R9I N=>FI 7>=67Q 5I "=9d69 [^3 =8r7
2ki^; U F= :E67I 5I F= REI>>IG E9 =E7>I7>=67Q 5I 2khp;
F=4M69I =Y=67 LQ5Q QR=FIOI97 U NI>NQ7E67Q U F=
f>=95I1H>I7=R9I E9I N=>76I 5I F= N>I:VEAvFI 5I w8aF889
I7 FI: vFI: =5Z=LI97I:G l=6: LI [jh J m67M69 7MI =P8YI1OI97689I5
7I>>678>S FI=:I5; f>I=7 H>67=69 :M=FF M=YI
:8FIZE>6:56L7689K [4G-G*G; Y8FG 2kh; NG ]giG [jj 4G-G*G; Y8FG
23i; NG ^h] ::G [jk !G?G$G.G; 23ji; NNG g2h I7 g2jG [j3 !G?G$G.G;
23jk; NG ^^g ::G
- 15.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2ig VE6 98E: 697Q>I::I 6L6I:7 F=L89YI97689 5I F=VEIFFI F= 4M69I
= LQ5Q U P=6F N8E> E9I NQ>685I 5I 33 =9: U N=>76> 5E
2I> ZE6FFI7 2k3k E9I N=>76I 5E 7I>>6786>I =77I9=97 U
F= N>I:VEAvFI 5I w8aF889 I7 E9 =>LM6NIFL8ON8>7=97
5I98OP>IE:I:vFI:[kpG .=L89YI97689N>QL6:I VEI;5=9: FI
7I>>6786>I F8EQ; F= L8ONQ7I9LI 7I>>678>6=FI
:I>= IWI>LQI N=> F= f>=95I1H>I 7=R9I [k2G
!N=>76> 5I 23k^; NFE:6IE>: 9QR8L6=7689: :I :897 :ELLQ5Q
I97>I F= 4M69I I7 F= f>=95I1H>I7=R9I N8E>
7>8EYI>E9I :8FE7689 5QX69676YI =E >QR6OI L8F896=F5I
C89Rw89RG .I 235QLIOP>I 23ki;FI: 5IEW76I: 897:6R9Q E9I
+QLF=>=7689 L89Z8697I; I97>QI I9 Y6REIE> FI ^j O=6 23kg;
=EW 7I>OI: 5I F=VEIFFI F= f>=95I1H>I7=R9I 5IY=67
>I:767EI> C89R w89R U F= 4M69I FI 2I> ZE6FFI7 233j;
LAI:71U156>I U FAQLMQ=9LI 5E 5QF=6 5I 33 =9: L89YI9E 5=9: FI
7>=67Q 5I QLENQ>Q I9 233j 78E7I: FI: L8ONQ7I9LI:
7I>>678>6=FI: LQ5QI: =E /$/I :6TLFIG &9 LI VE6
L89LI>9I F= ZE>6:N>E5I9LI; F= 56XXQ>I9LI I97>I
:8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI I7 :EN>QO=76I
7I>>678>6=FI =NN=>=v7 5=9: FA=>>q7 5I F= 48E>
NI >O=9I97I 5I ?E:76LI 697I>9=7689=FI 5E k 8L78P>I 23]j
VE6 O67 X69 =E F676RI I97>IF= (>=9LII7F= f>TLI :E>F=
L89LI::6895I NM=>I:I9 4>T7II7U *=O8:G .=48E> 5IY=67
=F8>: 5QL65I> :6; =E O8OI97 5E L897>=7 Y6:=97 U
N>8>8RI>F= L89LI::689 5I: NM=>I: [=Y>6F 232]; FI:
vFI: :E:OI976899QI: Q7=6I97 8E 989 5I:J 7I>>6786>I:
5Q7=LMQ: 5I FA&ON6>I 8778O=9KG &9 L89:65Q>=97F=
:67E=7689 5IF=4>T7I;FA=>>q7=XX6>OIVEI;
ULI77IQN8VEI1FU;FAIWI>L6LI5IF= :8EYI>=69I7Q N=> FI *EF7=9
=Y=67 :EP6 5I: >I:7>6L7689: 6ON8>7=97I:; O=6: VEI F=
:8EYI>=6 9I7Q 7E>VEI I9 IFFI1OqOI IW6:7=67 I9L8>I I7 VEI
LI77I :67E=7689 = :EP:6:7QZE:VEAU F= :6R9=7E>I 5E 7>=67Q VE6
O67 X69 U F= REI>>I 5I: H=Fd=9: I7 VE6 =77>6PE= LI77I vFI
U F= f>TLI[k^G @E=97 U F= 58L7>69I; !FX>I5 0I>5>8::
:AI:7 NI9LMQ 5AE9I X=`89 5Q7=6FFQI :E> F= 56:769L7689 I97>I
:8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI I7 :EN>QO=76I
7I>>678>6=FIG &9 23^j; 6F L89:65Q>= LI77I VEI:7689
U FA8LL=:689 5I: L>676VEI: 5I +89=76 L897>I F= 7MQ8>6I 5I
F= L8ONQ7I9LIG 0I>5>8:: IW=O69= FA8PZIL7689 5E ZE>6:7I
67=F6I9 :IF89 F=VEIFFI; :6 FI 7>=9:XI>7 5I F= L8ONQ7I9LI
7I>>678>6=FI 5AE9 &7=7 U E9 =E7>I 6ONF6VE=67 F=
LI::689 5I FA6ONI>6EO; F= :8EYI>=69I7Q 7I>>678>6=FI
5IOIE>=67I97>IFI:O=69:5IFA&7=7LQ5=97G+89=76I95Q5E6:=67VEIF=LI::689
9I :I P8>9I N=: =E 7>=9:XI>7 5IF=L8ONQ7I9LI
7I>>678>6=FI; I7 VEI; 5T: F8>:; F= 7MQ8>6I 5I F=
L8ONQ7I9LI 9I :I>=67 N=: =NN>8N>6QI N8E> IWNF6VEI>
LI VE6 =>>6YI 5=9: F= >Q=F67Q[k]G 0I>5>8:: :8E7697
=E L897>=6>I VEI F= :67E=7689 IWN8:QI N=> +89=76 N8EY=67
q7>I LF=6>IOI97 IWNF6VEQI U 7>=YI>: F= 7MQ8>6I 5I F=
L8ONQ7I9LI[kiG ! :89 =Y6:; E9 &7=7 NIE7 LQ5I> VEIFVEI:1E9I:
5I :I: L8ONQ7I9LI: N=> >=NN8>7 U E9 7I>>6786>I
78E7 I9 :I >Q:I>Y=97 FI 5>867 5AI9 56:N8:I>G
0I>5>8:: Q7=PF67 589L E9I 56:769L7689 I97>I 6ONI>6EO I7
9E5EOZE:G [kp 4G-G*G; Y8FG 2kh; NNG ]2p I7 ]22G [k2 J m67M69GGG 7MI
9IaFS1FI=:I57I>>678>Sf>I=7H>67=69:M=FFM=YI
:8FIZE>6:56L7689K [4G-G*G;Y8F; 2kh; NG ]2pG [k^ JGGG F= 4>T7I
9A=Y=67 N=: LI::Q 5IX=6>I N=>76I 5I FA&ON6>I 8778O=9G
*A6F I:7 Y>=6 VEI FI*EF7=9 =Y=67 5r S =5OI77>I
5A6ON8>7=97I: >I:7>6L7689: U FAIWI>L6LI 5I :I:
5>867: 5I :8EYI>=69I7Q;LI77I :8EYI>=69I7Q OqOI; VEIFFI
VEAI9 =67 Q7Q F= VE=F6X6L=7689 58L7>69=FI; 9A=Y=67 N=: LI::Q 5I
FE6=NN=>7I96>G 4I7 Q7=75I LM8:I: =:EP:6:7QZE:VEA=EO8OI97
8o;N=> 5I:7>=67Q: VE6 :897 5I:7>=67Q:5I LI::689; F=
4>T7I = Q7Q :QN=>QI 5I FA&ON6>I 8778O=9 I7 I:7
5IYI9EGGG E9 A7I>>6786>I 5Q7=LMQAK[4G6I !H; "s j2; NG 2p]G
[k] +89=76; *7=78 I 7I>>678>68; NG gpG [ki 0I>5>8::;
J *7==7:RIP6I7; *7==7I9RIOI69:LM=X7:RIP6I7 E95 *7==7I9RIP6I7K;
"6IOISI>:uI67:LM>6X7XE> $97I>9=7689=FI: %ILM7; 7G ]j;
23^j; NG ^3k ::G
- 16. 2ih
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
.I N>8XI::IE> =E7>6LM6I9= N>Q:I97Q5I
X=`89NFE:L8ONFT7IF=56:769L7689I97>I :8EYI>=69I7Q
7I>>678>6=FI {7I>>678>6=FI *8EYI>n967n7 I7
:EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI [fIP6I7:M8MI67 I9 23i3; 5=9:
E9I Q7E5I NEPF6QI 5=9: E9I >IYEI*L=9569=YI[kgG *IF89 :89
8N69689; E9 &7=7 NIE7 LQ5I> U P=6F E9 :IL7IE> 5I:89
7I>>6786>I 8E I9 7>=9:XQ>I> FA=5O696:7>=7689 U
E9 =E7>I; 5I X=`89 7IFFIVEILIFE61L6NE6::I IWI>LI>78E7I:
FI:L8ONQ7I9LI:;LIVE6:I>=67F=:EN>QO=76I7I>>678>6=FI;
78E7 I9 :I >Q:I>Y=97 F= X=LEF7Q 5I 56:N8:I> 5I LI
7I>>6786>I; LIVE6 L89:767EI>=67 F=:8EYI>=69I7Q
7I>>678>6=FIG +A=E7>I N=>7; E9 &7=7
N8E>>=67=E::6 LQ5I> L89Z8697IOI97 F= :8EYI>=69I7Q I7 F=
:EN>QO=76I I7 LAI:7 LI VE6=>>6YI I9 RQ9Q>=FG
0I>5>8:: = 5QYIF8NNQ LI77I L89LIN7689 5=9: :I:
yEY>I:EF7Q>6IE>I:; :867 L8OOI =E7IE>; :867 L8OOI
L81=E7IE>[khG 0$G 1.& -&%%$-,$%& &" -!"-
@#&+,l!$"& +&0!.$+$-D *I9LI VE6 IW6:7I I97>I
:8EYI>=69I7Q I7 :EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI; 6F X=E7
O=697I9=97 :I 5IO=95I> L8OOI97 :A=NNF6VEI FIL89LIN75I J
7I>>6786>I 5IFA&7=7K IWN8:Q N=> %=5967edSI7
N>QL6:Q N=>wIF:I9=EW L=: 5=9: FI:VEIF: E9 &7=7 IWI>LI
F= :EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI :E> E9I>QR689 =F8>:
VEAE9 =E7>I I9 I:7 FI :8EYI>=69G !E 7I>>6786>I 5I
VEIF &7=7=NN=>76I97F= >QR689 I9VEI:7689~ *6 89=NNF6VEI F=
5QX6967689 5I J 7I>>6786>I5I FA&7=7K X8E>96I N=>
wIF:I9; 6F I9 >Q:EF7I VEI F=>QR689 I9 VEI:7689
XI>=N=>76I 5E 7I>>6786>I 5I FA&7=7 VE6 IWI>LI
F= :EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI[kjG .=7MQ8>6I9A6956VEI
N=:989NFE:VEIF5IR>Q5A697I9:67Q
5867=Y86>F=L8ONQ7I9LI7I>>678>6=FI 5AE9 &7=7 N8E>
VEA6F NE6::I q7>I =NNIFQ :8EYI>=69[kkG .I: L>676VEI:
=5>I::QI: U F= -MQ8>6I NE>I 5=9: LI :I9: :897
ZE:76X6QI:G*= 5QX6967689 5I 7I>>6786>I 9I 76I97 N=: L8ON7I
5I F= N8::6P6F67Q VEI FI:767EF=6>I: 5I F= :8EYI>=69I7Q I7 5I
F= :EN>QO=76I :E> E9 7I>>6786>I :86I975IEW &7=7:
56XXQ>I97:G LI77I >=6:89; 6F X=E7 QF=P8>I> E9I
7MQ8>6I 5=9:5I: 7I>OI: 7IF: VEAIFFI 69LFEI FAMSN87MT:I
6956VEQI 5=9: FI N=>=R>=NMI N>QLQ5I97 =69:6 VEI
5A=E7>I: :6O6F=6>I: N8EY=97 :I N>Q:I97I> 5=9: F=
N>=76VEIG $F I:77ILM96VEIOI97N8::6PFI 5AIXXIL7EI>E9I
I9EOI>=76895I: L8ONQ7I9LI: NIE7 IWI>LI>
N=>>=NN8>7 U E9 7I>>6786>IG 4I77I I9EOI>=7689
VEAE9 &7=7L8ON8>7I>= N=> IWIONFI; FI 5>867 5I
FQR6XQ>I> I9 O=76T>I NQ9=FI I7 L6Y6FI;LIFE6 5AIWNF867I>
FI: >I::8E>LI: 9=7E>IFFI:; 5A=LL8>5I> 5I:
L89LI::689: 5I:I>Y6LI: NEPF6L:; 5I X6WI> FI: L89567689:
5AQ7=PF6::IOI97 N8E> FI: Q7>=9RI>:;I7LG 4M=LE9I5ILI:
=L76Y67Q:L8>>I:N895 UE9IL8ONQ7I9LI I7
FA&7=7:8EYI>=69NIE7 F=7>=9:XQ>I> U E9=E7>I
&7=7; VE6Y6I95>= 589L U IWI>LI>F=
:EN>QO=76I7I>>678>6=FIG [kg 0I>5>8::; J
-I>>678>6=FI *8EYI>n967n7 E95 fIP6I7:M8MI67 K; ?E:
RI976EO 1 "8>56:d-65::d>6X7 X8>(8FdI>I78R
697I>9=7689==F 6Y=7>I7; Y8FG $; 23i3; NG ^ij ::G [kh
0I>5>8::; 0bFdI>>ILM7; gI Q5G;m6I9; 23hi; NG
^hh::G0I>5>8::1*6OO=1fI6RI>;-I>>678>6=FI]I Q5G;
HI>F69; 23ki; NG hgg ::G*8EYI>n967n7 E95 fIP6I7:M8MI67; H899;
23kp; NG 2g ::G 0I>5>8::1*6OO=; #96YI>:IFFI:
0bFdI>>ILM7; 5I: L8OOI97=6>I: :E> LI77I L89LIN7689;
Y86> *ES; J %QXFIW689: :E> F= 56:769L7689 I97>IF=
:8EYI>=69I7Q I7 F= L8ONQ7I9LI 7I>>678>6=FIK;
$97I>9=7689=FI(I:7:LM>6X7 XE>!FX>I5 0I>5>8::
eEOkpG fIPE>7:7=R; NG i3] ::G| 489X8>76; J
-MI-MI8>S8X48ONI7I9LI 69 0I>5>8::K; &E>8NI=9
?8E>9=F8X$97I>9=7689=F .=a; Y8FG h; 233g; NG jp ::G [kj 489XG
B *ES; 8NG L67G; :EN>=; 9G j; NG gp2G [kk 489XG B *ES; 8NG L67G;
:EN>=; 9G j; NG gp^G
- 17.
.&*.$&"*?#%$+$@#&*&"-%&.AD-!-&-*,"-&%%$-,$%&
2ij ,9 567 N=>X86: VEAE9 &7=7 N8E>>=67
7>=9:XQ>I> U E9 =E7>I 78E7I: FI:L8ONQ7I9LI: :E> E9
7I>>6786>I 78E7 I9 :I >Q:I>Y=97 E96VEIOI97F= X=LEF7Q
5ILQ5I> LI 7I>>6786>I U E9 76I>:; LAI:71U156>I;
5I 56:N8:I> 5I LI 7I>>6786>IG +=9:LI L=:; FA&7=7
VE6 :I >Q:I>YI LI77I X=LEF7Q L89769EIUZ8E6> 5I
F=:8EYI>=69I7Q7I>>678>6=FI; 6F :I>=67 78EZ8E>:
FA&7=7 :8EYI>=69G 4INI95=97 6F X=E7 :6R9=FI>VEI F=
X=LEF7Q 5I 56:N8:I> 5AE9 7I>>6786>I; 5I FI LQ5I> U
E9 &7=7 76I>:; I:7=E::6 E9I L8ONQ7I9LI[k3G L89:QVEI97; 89
NIE7 =XX6>OI> VEI FA&7=7:8EYI>=69 I:7 LIFE6 VE6 = F=
L8ONQ7I9LI N8E> LQ5I> FI 7I>>6786>I U E9
&7=776I>:G $F I9 >Q:EF7I =F8>: VEAE9 &7=7 I:7
:8EYI>=69 :E> E9 7I>>6786>I 5=9: F=OI:E>I 8o 6F =
F= L8ONQ7I9LI 5I FI 7>=9:XQ>I>G .I 7I>>6786>I 5I
FA&7=7 :I>=589L 5Q7I>O69Q N=> FI 58O=69I :N=76=F 5I
Y=F6567Q 5I F=98>OI VE6 =LL8>5IF= L8ONQ7I9LI N8E> FI
7>=9:XQ>I>G .= O856X6L=7689 VEA6F X=E5>=67 589L
697>85E6>I U F= L89LIN7689 5I %=5967edS I7 5I wIF:I9
L89:6:7I>=67 U >IONF=LI>FI58O=69I :N=76=F 5I Y=F6567Q 5I
FA8>5>I ZE>656VEI 5I FA&7=7 N=> FI 58O=69I:N=76=F
5IY=F6567Q5AE9I98>OIZE>656VEI:NQL6X6VEI; U:=Y86>LIFFI
VE6=LL8>5IU FA&7=7 F= L8ONQ7I9LI N8E> 7>=9:XQ>I>
FI 7I>>6786>I I9 VEI:7689G z LI77I 7MQ8>6I 89
N8E>>=67 8NN8:I> FA8PZIL7689 VEI F= L8ONQ7I9LI
N8E>7>=9:XQ>I>FI7I>>6786>IU E9&7=7
76I>:NIE7q7>I FA8PZI75AE9I 56Y6:689 I7; N=>L89:QVEI97;
5AE9I LI::689 N=>76IFFIG !69:6; E9 &7=7 :8EYI>=69
N8E>>=67 =LL8>5I> E9 =E7>I F= L8ONQ7I9LI 5=9: E9
58O=69I 5Q7I>O69Q :E> LI>7=69 U7I>>6786>I I7 FE6
L89XQ>I> =E::6 F= X=LEF7I> 5I F= LQ5I> U :89 78E> U
E9 =E7>I&7=7G ,9 N8E>>=67 589L :I 5IO=95I> 5=9:
VEIFFI OI:E>I E9 &7=7 :8EYI>=69NIE7=LL8>5I> U E9
=E7>I E9I L8ONQ7I9LI 5Q7I>O69QI :E>E9 7I>>6786>I
I7 F=X=LEF7Q 5I F= 7>=9:XQ>I> U E9 76I>: :=9:
NI>5>I F= VE=F67Q 5I :8EYI>=69 5ILI7I>>6786>IG .=
>QN89:I I:7 :6ONFIB E9 &7=7 I:7 :8EYI>=69 U FAQR=>5
5AE97I>>6786>I N8E> =E7=97 VEA6F L89:I>YI
697QR>=FIOI97 F=L8ONQ7I9LI 5I 7>=9:XQ>I>LI
7I>>6786>I U E9 &7=7 76I>:G ! N=>76> 5E
O8OI97 8o 6F LT5I LI77IL8ONQ7I9LI; OqOI N=>76IFFIOI97 I75=9:E9I
O8695>IOI:E>I; 6F LI::I5Aq7>IFI :8EYI>=69
7I>>678>6=F; I7 89 :I>=67 =F8>: I9 N>Q:I9LI 5AE9
L=: 5I L8958O696EO 697I>9=7689=FG ,9 = 5QZU 6956VEQ VEI F=
X=LEF7Q 5I 56:N8:I> 5AE9 7I>>6786>I; LAI:71U156>I5I
FI LQ5I> U E9 &7=7 76I>:; I:7 QR=FIOI97 E9I L8ONQ7I9LIG
,>; 5=9: F=N>=76VEI; 6F S = LI>7=69: L=: 5=9: FI:VEIF:
5IEW &7=7: L89LFEI97 E9 =LL8>5U N>8N8: 5AE9
7I>>6786>I 5=9: 5I: 7I>OI: 7IF: VEI FAE9 5AI97>I IEW
8P76I9778E7I: FI: L8ONQ7I9LI:; S L8ON>6: LIFFI 5I FI
7>=9:XQ>I> U E9 76I>:; 7=956:VEIFA=E7>I
L89:I>YIF=J :8EYI>=69I7QKG *6FA89
=9=FS:IFI7IW7IL89YI976899IFI9 F=6::=97 5I Lb7Q FI Y8L=PEF=6>I U
697I97689: N8F676VEI: :8E:1Z=LI97I: VEA89E76F6:I :8EYI97 5=9: LI:
L=:; 89 N8E>>= L89:7=7I> VEI LI77I J
:8EYI>=69I7QKO=9VEI 5I L897I9E I7 9AI:7 VEAE9 O87 Y65I 5I :I9:G
.I 5>867 9I 76I97 N=:L8ON7I 5I: 7I>OI: E76F6:Q:; O=6: 5I F=
>Q=F67Q 5I F= :67E=7689G LI77I>=6:89; 5=9: LI L=:; 6F 9AS =
N=: E9 &7=7 :8EYI>=69 I7 E9 =E7>I IWI>`=97
F=:EN>QO=76I 7I>>678>6=FI; O=6: E9 :IEF &7=7
:8EYI>=69 VE6 56:N8:I 5I 78E7I:FI: L8ONQ7I9LI: 7=956: VEI
FA=E7>I 9A= =ELE9 767>I ZE>656VEI; I9 5QN67 5EF6PIFFQ 5I
FA=LL8>5G [k3 489XGB 0I>5>8::; J%TRFI: RQ9Q>=FI: 5E
5>867 5I F= N=6WK; %G5G4; 23^310; NG ]kpG