View
164
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Problem Statement
Group #1 : Lynda Kwiatkowski, Justin Fiocca, CorinSilvestrini, Kweshon Alexander , Bari Taub
STEP 1:
Background Information
First Hand Learning, Inc. is a New York nonprofit corporation founded in 1998 to promote inquiry-based teaching, learning from
direct experience, and closer links between cultural institutions and schools.
MISSION: Promote the process of scientific inquiry as a vehicle for learning. Most learners acquire and retain new knowledge
most effectively when it derives from firsthand experience.
Clientele: Middle School Students
Problem
There also may be an issue regarding the kids interest in what First Hand Learning’s program offers.
A major problem that First Hand Learning has been currently facing is engagement among the
students with the organization.
Objective
We have decided the best way to take control of the problem is to talk to the kids who attend the
program regularly and those who attend occasionally.
Solution
In a child-friendly way, we intend to talk to the kids involved in the program. To possibly create a
survey that evaluates weather or not what First Hand Learning is offering are the interests of those who
come to the program.
STEP 2 :
Similar Issue
In our research we found that nearby School 19 in Buffalo has partnered with UB in an after school program that uses
science to make things like slime and Styrofoam which is educational and fun for them.
.
Evaluation MethodsThe After-School Corporation (TASC) based in NYC, Elizabeth R.
Reisner lead a study on the effectiveness of after school programs for different age groups in school paired with community based and
non profit organizations.
Evaluation Methods Cont.
1. Gathering data on students exposure to the particular program
2. Focus data on events, activities, relationships that are important to the initiative's success
3. Bring people of the organization into the evaluation process
4. Make sure information is in understandable language
5. Set up a system for managing information
Sample Questions
1. My favorite subject is..2. Were you a student at this school last year ?
3. If you started coming to the after school program this year, what month did you start coming?
4. Before attending this after school program how often were you alone or with a friend without an adult or parent present after school?
5. What do you do after school now?6. How many days last month did you attend the after school
program?7. Rank the after school program
8. Yes or no questions about activities they have participated in at the after school
These are some sample questions we have come up with for our survey:
STEP 3 : Criteria
- Make simple questions that the kids can comprehend
-Use shorter questions and choices they can pick from
-Vocabulary will also be modified-Constellation prizes such as candy, pens, and
pencils to motivate the kids to fill out the survey, will be handed out
Positive Consequences
The organization will get an idea of why students can not return to the program on a regular basis, or if it is just a matter of disinterest
Resolving conflicts within the program can enhance kids attention to the subject
Positive Consequences Continued
Find out certain interests of the students so they get the maximum learning potential within the program
This may all result in an overall increase in attendance to programs, expanding young minds into science hands on
Negative Consequences
Students may not be able to understand questions if they are not at the correct reading level.
Students may not take surveys seriously and just want to get it over with leaving results to be inconclusive.
Negative Consequences Continued
Limited responses from just the students that attended the after school program that day
Students that young may be unfamiliar with surveys and feel they need to base their answers in accordance to the after school coordinators wishes.
Advantages and Disadvantages to a
Survey
Advantages
Surveys are relatively inexpensive (especially self-administered surveys)
Surveys are useful in describing the characteristics of a large population.(No other method of observation can provide this general capability)
They can be administered from remote locations using mail, email or telephone.
Very large samples are feasible, making the results statistically significant even when analyzing multiple variables.
Advantages Continued
Standardized questions make measurement more precise by enforcing uniform definitions upon the participants
Standardization ensures that similar data can be collected from groups then interpreted comparatively (between-group study)
High reliability is easy to obtain--by presenting all subjects with a standardized stimulus, observer subjectivity is greatly eliminated
Disadvantages
Relying on standardization forces the researcher to develop questions general enough to be minimally appropriate for all respondents, possibly missing what is most appropriate to many respondents.
Surveys are inflexible in that they require the initial study design (the tool and administration of the tool) to remain unchanged throughout the data collection.
Disadvantages Continued
It may be hard for young participants to recall information or to tell the truth about a controversial question.
As opposed to direct observation, survey research (excluding some interview approaches) can rarely deal with "context."
STEP 4: Recommendation
Create a list of questions in a survey to have the students take to find out why they are not
returning to the after school program.
Splitting the students into small groups will work more effectively & find out their
personal reasons for not wanting to return to the program.
Decision Process
It seemed like the best way possible to survey them would be in small groups, that way we
would be able to receive more honest answers and come up with the best possible solution to
why students are not coming back to the afterschool program.
Survey Questions
1. What is your age? ______________
2. About how many days a week do you attend this after school program? ____________
3. Are you a male or a female?
Male Female
4. How much do you like science at school?
1) A lot 2) Somewhat 3) A little 4) Not at all
5. Do you like First Hand Learning’s science activities?
1) Yes 2) No
6. Did you have fun with First Hand Learning?
1) Yes 2) No
7. Do you like doing science activities outdoors or indoors?
1) Outdoors 2) Indoors 3) Both
8. Do you like your First Hand Learning science teacher?
1) Yes 2) No
9. Do you think science is an important subject to learn?
1) Yes 2) No
10. Do you wish to do more science at school?
1) Yes 2) No
STEP 5 : Implementation
Traveled several sites to hand out the surveys
Only a limited amount of students that were present
Students were younger then expected
Many students didn’t understand the survey and it needed to be explained further to them
because of their young age
Variables to Implementation
The kids felt pressured by us being there, thinking that they have to like science
Not enough kids showed up and were the “correct age” to survey and make it equal
Some of the mentors decided that we should only survey the kids who take “science period”
Results
10
2
2
Do you like science?
A lot
A little
Not at all
Results
The variables when going to the sites show that the results are not completely accurate
The un-organization at the sites made it harder to find out clientele
We completed to the best of our ability with the available resources
Recommended