View
2
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
THE 21ST CENTURY
CMO PLAYBOOK
Being a CMO will be one of the most interesting, but
also one of the toughest jobs in the 21st century.
Consider the context: consumer behaviour is changing
faster than the planning cycle of marketing campaigns,
marketing technology is becoming the most complex
part of the enterprise stack while the rise of agile,
ruthless competitors from new markets means that
brands have to achieve global scale to avoid imitation
and replication.
1THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
2THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
The average household watched television at dinner time,
read the newspaper at breakfast, listened to the radio on
the way to work, and enjoyed magazines in between.
Today, consumers have multiple devices, intelligent
objects and networked screens surrounding them.
They are exposed to as many as 10,000 ads per day.
More than 4.4 billion people, or about 60 percent of
the global population, have cell phones, according to
2014 figures from IC Insights. About 2.5 billion people
are on the Internet.
Technology is changing marketing, but that doesn’t
mean that the CMO of the future should act like a CIO.
High performance CMOs don’t need to manage and
provision IT systems, but rather what it takes to push
technology to its limits in the service of transforming
customer experience.
That should come as no surprise. Of all the roles in the
business, marketers have always been closest to the
customer and the market. What has changed in the
21st century is not the focus of the marketing team, but
the source of their insights. In the past, focus groups,
market research studies and advertising agencies were
reliable channels of consumer information. No longer.
Marketers must be data natives. Like high frequency
traders, they have to design platforms and deploy
resources so that they are always in the middle of real-
time data streams, constantly testing and adjusting
their market interventions.
Data is the lingua franca of the modern enterprise.
Finance, HR, IT, customer care, marketing and
operations are all moving into the Cloud, becoming
more integrated and automated. As that happens, data
will change from being something used to describe
past events - to a currency of real time value that can
be used to not only predict what might happen next, but
actually shape the design and delivery of your product.
Why measure brand awareness, when you target a
specific individual? In the data driven enterprise, it is
possible to track the lifecycle of a customer—as they
undertake their journey from an initial brand discovery,
through to trial, purchase, evangelism and upgrade.
With that information at your disposal, there is nothing
you cannot achieve.
You can literally design an entire company
to serve a single person.
Things were once far simpler.
The platform doesn’t matter. How people use it, does.
We are moving into the era of hyper-personal business.
Already, no one sees the same retail home page at
Netflix or Amazon, nor the same newsfeed on Twitter
or Facebook. These are companies built to scale for
millions of customers, but fashioned to serve just one
at a time.
Embracing data has real rewards. According to
McKinsey & Company, companies that are more data
driven are 5 percent more productive and 6 percent
more profitable than other companies. If anything, that
understates the case. Can you really say that Netflix is
simply 5 percent more productive than a TV network, or
Amazon slightly more effective than another retailer? In
truth, they are entirely new kinds of businesses.
Change is not easy. Marketers have been schooled to
think in channels, not customer behaviours, to measure
their success through abstractions not algorithms, to
create strategy not run experiments, and to applaud
advertising that wins awards not customers.
Embracing a new marketing playbook will be
confronting both for you as a leader, as well as for the
rest of your team. But doing nothing is no longer an
option. Your customers will force you to change long
before your shareholders do.
This book features 10 insights for CMOs to consider. It is by no means an exhaustive list, but hopefully it will provide you with
a rough sketch of a new kind of marketer. One who, aside from their data
fluency, combines a fervent customer obsession with a tactical ability to
orchestrate the complexity at the heart of tomorrow’s enterprise.
10
The next generation of companies will do just that.
3THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Redefine Your Metrics
Buy Programmatically
Communicate Effectively With Data
Structure Your Team For
Success
Automate,Then Elevate
Forget Funnels,Focus On Journeys
Think Like A Media
Company
7
8
9
Build A Strong Relationship
With IT
10
3
4
6
5
10 INSIGHTS FOR CMOs
4THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Solve Problems, Don’t Manage
Channels
2Design
Your Business With Data
1
Design Your Business With DataAfter leaving Harvard, Jennifer Hyman and Jennifer
Fleiss had the insight that women might rather rent high
fashion items than own them. Fashion is expensive and
has a limited shelf life. The two founders decided to start
a company based on a simple idea – a woman should
never have to wear the same outfit twice, and shouldn’t
have to buy it at all.
Rent the Runway was born. Many of their earliest
customers were Millennials, who intuitively understood
the value of access rather than ownership. After all, if
you can use Spotify to listen to music rather than buying
albums, and Uber to get to places rather than owning a
car - how hard might it be to ‘stream’ a designer dress?
As it turns out—more difficult than it might seem. In their
early years, Rent the Runway struggled to meet their
targets. It took a radical mindset change in marketing
to turn things around. The founders realized that to fix
engagement, they needed to focus their efforts on data
science, pricing models and their mobile platform.
Like Amazon, Rent the Runway had to become a logistics
and data business, not merely a retail and fashion
one. Their new data driven approach paid off, and now
the company ships more than 90,000 items a day to 5
million members, and not surprisingly, also operates the
country’s largest dry-cleaning facility.
For CMOs, the story of Rent the Runway illustrates the
central role that data plays in business today. No longer
just a measure of past activity, it has become a pro-
active metric capable of changing your entire approach
to customer value creation. Data is not just for IT geeks,
it belongs at the heart of your growth strategy.
“Data’s a big part of our business, encompassing
everything from the whole fashion component to metrics
around utilization of a given dress,” Jennifer Fleiss said in
an interview with Forbes last year. “We have an analytics
team of six people internally, who look at rental statistics,
such as how many long dresses get rented, how many
short, how many red, black, orange and so on. What
trends worked last season, what fabrics last the longest,
which dresses are being turned and utilized the most?”
Ultimately, for smart marketers, data changes the way
you design your business. Rather than buying their
dresses from retail, Hyman and Fleiss now partner
with designers - providing them data on what styles
are the most popular in return for discounts and better
availability of sizes. In the same way that Netflix
uses data from its customers to commission original
programming, Rent the Runway has approached
emerging designers to create collections exclusively for
their platform.
1
5THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Solve Problems, Don’t Manage ChannelsThe problem with today’s advertising industry is not what they do, but the way they sell what they do. Rather than solving your problems, they pitch fragmented solutions based on their own internal structures.
You know the drill. Creative agencies want you to make expensive TV spots. Graphic design firms recommend that you
update your corporate identity and packaging. PR firms suggest a big launch party while digital agencies put together
a plan involving micro-sites and a flashy media buyout of high traffic websites. Basically, when faced with your brief,
agencies tend to solve for their own channels.
Unfortunately, while agencies might think in channels, customers do not. Today’s consumers are both sophisticated
and demanding. They interpret brand signals from a wide variety of sources, and expect consistent treatment regardless of
the platform they are using. Winning their attention is an exercise in problem solving, not ticking the boxes.
I met Johnny Vulkan a number of years ago, when we were both speaking at a conference in Oslo together. His agency,
Anomaly, has attracted some of the biggest clients in the world including P&G and Google based on their unique
approach. Although they don’t call themselves an ad agency, they conceived and produced the most popular Super
Bowl ad two years in a row. They are not a design company, and yet they designed the number one lip balm in the U.S.
They are also not a broadcast media company, but they have won awards for the cooking show they produce.
In Vulkan’s view, what makes Anomaly successful is not what they do, but how they approach their work. When they
start working with a client, their first goal is to clearly identify and articulate their problem. Carl Johnson, one of
Anomaly’s other founders cites Charles Kettering as inspiration, the famed inventor and head of research for GM, who
said, “A problem well stated is a problem half-solved.” Once the real marketing issue has been identified, the Anomaly
team is able to select the right set of tools, people and platforms most relevant to fixing it. If the right answer is better
packaging, then that is what the team does - even if making a TV commercial might have meant more fees.
2
6THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
As CMOs become more sophisticated in the way they buy marketing services, it is not just individual agencies that will need to adapt their approach, but also entire marketing networks.
I recently joined the board of The North Alliance (NOA), a collection of marketing companies that originated in
Scandinavia but has since established a global footprint. NOA was founded by Thomas Hogebol, a former head of
McCann Worldgroup in the Nordics. Backed by private equity, the management group acquired the best creative and
digital agencies from Stockholm to Copenhagen, Oslo to Warsaw - combined with an engagement model that allowed
clients to tailor-make a dream team of problem solvers from a diverse talent pool, whilst retaining regional scale.
One of NOA’s first regional clients was Scandinavian Airlines (SAS), the leading airline in the Nordics. SAS were
facing growing competition in its market from low cost carriers. Like many brands, much of its communication was
traditional - not just in choice of channel, but also in the style of messaging. When it spoke to customers, it picked
concepts it believed were important to travellers—price, reliability and the speed of its fast-track service. Interestingly,
once the NOA team started analyzing the issue, it became clear that people were willing to pay a premium for their
travel tickets –not because the service was efficient, but because they wanted to be part of a community, to feel the
joy of travelling and share those experiences with other people. Acting on this insight presented its own challenges.
Clever creative was not enough. To enhance SAS’s community platform would require fundamental changes to
commercial strategy, the loyalty program and the underlying technology infrastructure. Hence, a very different type of
agency engagement model.
CMOs face the paradox of actionability daily.
They have the clearest visibility of the customer’s unmet needs. However, acting on those insights requires big
changes, both in the design of their own teams, as well as the way they work with external agencies.
As Hogebol puts it, “CMOs may have larger IT budgets than the CIOs in the future, but they will also need fewer
partners that understand more. The best place for CMOs to start is by clearly defining what their real problems are,
agnostic of media and channels. From that perspective, they can direct their energy and investments on exactly the
ideas most likely to transform their business.”
2
7THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Structure Your Team For SuccessOne of the most important decisions a CMO can make is how they organize their marketing team.
Team structure is the ultimate reflection of what a company’s leaders see as important. Do you organize around
functions, customers or markets? What capabilities do you keep in-house and what do you outsource? What activities
are better left to automation, and what should only be trusted to human creativity?
Traditional marketing organizations were largely structured around channels. Reporting to the CMO were divisional
heads of product, strategy, advertising, research, promotions and communications - all running their own individual
teams and in many cases, entirely separate agendas. Not surprisingly, that led to debates over dogma - whether
advertising was more effective than PR, whether online was better than TV, or above the line was better than below the line.
Once you shift your focus, even if you keep much of your existing marketing team in place, their performance should be
measured against contribution to business growth, rather than their own obscure metrics for success.
3
In the 21st century marketing organization, there should be only one debate:
What does it take to engage and sustain a profitable customer relationship?
8THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
In my view, here are the top five capabilities that modern marketing organizations will require:
3
9THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Agile Product Management is the team responsible for your portfolio
of products and services. If your company has a significant technology
component to your offering, you don’t have the luxury of long lead times
between product launches. Technology companies are expected to provide
a continuous delivery of innovation and services to their customers. That
means your product management teams need to be agile, able to identify
evolving customer needs and to translate those needs into new features, while
articulating where your business is going next.
Marketing Operations are your infrastructure and analytics people.
They are responsible for planning, analysis, performance management
and budgeting - as well as serving as a liaison with the IT department on
the management of technology and platforms. In a data driven business,
marketing operations are also an essential resource for the setting and
tracking of company wide engagement and conversion metrics that provide
evidence of the contribution made by your team.
Brand Strategy takes a long term view of your brand. They are the team
responsible for positioning, segmentation, buyer profiling, visual identity and
the definition of your brand values. Brand strategy is not an island, but rather
an airlock that facilitates access to external consultants and agency experts
to challenge your thinking. Like creative directors at luxury brands, your brand
strategists need to not only reflect the current market, but also be far enough
in front to push and drive it.
3
10THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Growth Management is the engine room of your business. They support
your revenue goals through lead generation, database nurturing and the
design of automated workflows that convert leads into customers. Think of
Growth Management as a mashup of marketing and sales. In the old days,
when those two functions were entirely separate it was easy for marketers to
complain that sales people didn’t convert their leads, and for salespeople to
argue that their leads were no good. In the modern enterprise, both roles must
be integrated. That way, the same metrics that measure customer acquisition,
conversion and retention apply to everyone.
Storytelling is an amalgamation of your communications, creative services
and content operations teams. Based on your brand strategy and product
roadmap, their role is to create and distribute stories that engage potential
customers, influential bloggers, consumer media or industry analysts. Great
examples of this function in action include Microsoft Stories or the team
at GoPro that curates customer footage on their YouTube channel. Since
storytelling is a real time phenomenon, you need to build a technically
creative team with the authority to distribute and publish in response to
events as they happen.
If there is a secret ingredient to the marketing department of the future, it is alignment. How many people you hire and
what titles you give them is not as important as having a common set of objectives, and a common language of data.
When the CMO talks to his direct reports and they talk to their teams, it has to be in the context of data driven evidence,
rather than opinion, gut instinct or ego. A blog article can be as valuable as million dollar TV commercial, if you take a
holistic and scientific view on the data behind contribution and conversion.
By building your team from the ground up with a focus on growth and performance, tomorrow’s CMO can not only redefine
their relationship with their CEO, but also the function of marketing inside the business.
A REAL-LIFE EXAMPLE:
How HubSpot Structures Its Marketing TeamYou would expect a marketing automation company like Hubspot to take an innovative approach to structuring their marketing team. And it does. HubSpot has structured its marketing department to align with each step of the inbound marketing sales cycle. Each team is measured by how well it achieves its primary function.
“I threw my old org chart in the trash when I joined HubSpot and started from the beginning. We built our entire company for the inbound era, from marketing to sales to service, because the buyer has all the power today and you need to realign your company for that. I think our org chart is the future of the marketing org because of that – we focus on an inbound
experience that the buyer drives, with us providing value along each stage.”
- Mike Volpe, HubSpot CMO
The Demand Generation Team is responsible for nurturing leads that can be passed along to sales. Its activities include lead nurturing, lead scoring, sales alignment and workflow optimization.
The Product Marketing Team oversees the HubSpot website, creates educational content about HubSpot’s products and teach the company’s sales teams to sell them.
The Content Team focuses on attracting visitors to the website with inbound blogs, articles and whitepapers, as well as creating educational resources and offers. It’s a dedicated function allowing it to serve multiple clients within the business from demand generation to PR and sales enablement.
HubSpot’s Brand & Buzz Team handles relationships with the media and other influencers, as well as events and advertising.
11
CMO
VPProduct
Marketing
VPDemand
Generation
VPBrand & Buzz
VPContent
Creative Director
Design & Multimedia
Influencer Relations
PR Events Blogging
Educational Resources & Offers
Inbound Marketing Manager Inbound Marketing Manager(Persona-Specific)
Web Development
Product Marketing Managers - Product
Launches
Product Marketing Managers - Sales
Enablement
Inbound Marketing Manager International Marketing
Customer Marketing
Marketing Ops
Growth Hacker
Automate, Then ElevateIn some ways, the future of marketing is not about departments, but rather platforms. The more you can automate the routine, transactional elements of customer engagement, the more time your team can spend elevating their activities to be more strategic.
Greater automation is a function of rising complexity. Data driven marketing operates on a scale beyond the capacity
of individual humans to manage. Williams-Sonoma, for example, leverages big data and a Hadoop platform to enable
marketing campaign budgets to be allocated to individual customers, not just segments of customers. Target’s data
mining algorithms were so infamously effective - they figured out a teenage girl was pregnant before even her parents did.
You can only achieve this level of precision with algorithms and workflows, rather than analysts and spreadsheets.
Most companies will benefit from evaluating a marketing automation platform that combines data analysis with the
ability to serve targeted content and customer offers. Software companies like Eloqua, Pardot, Hubspot and Marketo
started off as platforms for managing smart landing pages, product blogs and drip marketing campaigns. Now,
however, they are evolving into broader marketing management tools.
Traditional methods of customer segmentation and modeling are slow and don’t scale well with rapid growth. In the
near future, marketing automation platforms will integrate with mobile devices, customer support screens, point of
sale terminals, in-store digital displays, and even traditional advertising platforms - to act as a central intelligence hub
for the design and management of the entire customer experience.
“Marketing automation and CRM systems still have a little way to go to give a holistic view into program performance
and how it influences the sale in terms of start to finish,” said Courtney Wilson, a senior revenue marketing manager at
Parata, a company that sells automation tools to pharmacies. “There’s just dots that don’t necessarily get connected.
I can look at programs and silos in terms of individual performance, but Salesforce isn’t really going to show me how
Bob became a lead, engaged in several touch points, became an opportunity, what influenced the sale over the course
of the sales cycle and closed the deal.”
4
12THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
4
13THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
After implementing marketing automation nearly two years ago, Parata had a specific goal in mind—to shorten the
typical sales cycle, which could be as long as 120 days. Because the sales staff was working with busy pharmacists,
many of whom were also independent business owners, closing the deal often takes a great deal of time and money.
Wilson and his staff designed an accelerated program through which current customers could share information
with those who were considering a purchase. Using this accelerated pipeline has shortened the sales cycle for these
customers by about 30 percent, Wilson said. Since hitting potential customers with too much too soon can backfire,
a detailed qualification process has been crucial to making it work.
“It comes down to making sure you know exactly what your sales process is,” Wilson said. In her view, ensuring that
your investment in a new marketing automation platform is a success comes down to a few key factors. “Know the
buying journey from start to finish. Make sure you really understand your buyer personas. Then have a defined sales
process in place. From there, make sure your CRM reflects that process and is integrated into it. Then build your
marketing automation programs on top of that so you are mapping your marketing efforts to the buying journey.
Finally, take a hard look at what’s actually going to move the needle.”
Think Like A Media CompanyA few years back, branded content sat somewhere on a spectrum between cheesy corporate videos and high end, expensively bespoke magazines and books.
The digital revolution changed everything. Now, most buyers - either in their
personal lives as consumers or in a professional capacity as business decision
makers - conduct extensive research online before making a purchase. That
research may take the form of a keyword search on Google, a pinboard on
Pinterest, a shared link on Facebook, a review on a customer forum, a blog
article, an ebook or a YouTube video. Bottom line - your brand’s visibility in
the future can be directly correlated to your investment in content.
As a CMO, your content strategy should
be driven by both the kinds of customers
you want to attract and the things
that motivate them.
5
14THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Kraft Foods Group, for example, uses data to drive its editorial strategy.
When their team noticed a big increase in searches for green velvet cupcakes
on the St. Patrick’s Day holiday, they quickly developed a recipe with four
different Kraft ingredients, and shared it through their media channels. As
Deanie Elsner, executive VP and CMO at Kraft Foods, explained at the 2014 Ad
Age CMO Strategy Summit, “Data, going forward, becomes the new currency.”
A strong investment in content will be equally relevant whether you are a
luxury brand that collaborates with contemporary artists on commissioned
works, a technology company using whitepapers to establish thought
leadership, or a retailer creating videos to help customers decide between
competing brands. Great content, however is more than just hiring a handful
of former journalists. You need a proper battle plan.
15THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
For marketing leaders, thinking like a media company means more than
just allocating a budget to content. It also reflects a shift in thinking from
using messaging as a promotional tool, to establishing a true dialogue
between a brand and its advocates.
5Kuno Creative, is one of the world’s leading inbound marketing and content
strategy agencies. Its approach is based on not just creating quality content,
but tailoring campaigns for specific buyer personas. One of its clients,
Invacare, was a company that provided portable oxygen concentrators for
those with respiratory ailments. The most common type of respiratory ailment
that leads to oxygen concentrator usage is Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease (COPD), a progressive lung disease that makes it difficult to breathe.
Rather than propose a standard product marketing campaign, Kuno worked
with Invacare’s marketing team to develop a web-based community for
those with COPD, their caregivers and their physicians. The result was
DoMoreWithOxygen.com, a site built with COPD sufferers in mind that
offered blog posts, tip sheets and eBooks with relevant information about
living with COPD.
The Do More With Oxygen website featured landing pages geared toward
several different buyer personas. Each landing page contained a form that led
to a relevant piece of content. Those with COPD filled out the form to receive
eBooks like “Travelling with Oxygen Made Easy,” while their caregivers received
eBooks like “Living with COPD: A Caregiver’s Guide.” Site visitors who filled
out forms were entered into a marketing automation platform, at which point
customized email campaigns were created to nurture them until they were
ready to convert into sales. In the first eight months of the campaign, the
website saw 54,000 visitors and captured more than 1,200 new leads.
Forget Funnels, Focus On JourneysOne of the most persistent metaphors from the era of traditional marketing is the sales funnel.
The idea is that marketers build awareness at the top of the funnel with
advertising and promotional activities. Next they convert this engaged
audience into leads, which are then qualified into prospects before they
finally become customers.
The sales funnel reflected a world in which data was scarce and sales
teams were in charge. Before digital engagement platforms, sales
representatives were the gatekeepers of information. If you wanted
to know something about a product or service, a company’s sales rep
was the only way to get specs, comparisons and even testimonials.
According to data from Google and the CEB Marketing Leadership Council, 57 percent of business purchase decisions are
made before engaging with a supplier’s sales representative. The same thing happens in the consumer world, where 81
percent of retail customers do research online before walking into a store (GE Capital Retail Bank Major Purchase Shopper
Study 2013).
What has really altered the idea of the sales funnel, however, is not just online research but the consumer data that is
now available in real time while buyers are doing their research. Marketing automation software allows that data to be
visualized and acted upon immediately, at the level of an individual customer. Sales funnels were simply not designed
to take into account the journey an individual buyer might take in their decision making process, and when implemented
poorly in a marketing organization, frequently led to leaks such as not following-up or responding to the buyer’s previous
action or inaction.
6
16THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
This all changed with the rise of online research.
Instead of a funnel, modern marketers and salespeople must adjust the way they look at buyers – exchanging the macro-level funnel for a micro-level journey.
As you can see in the diagram, a personalized
perspective can take into account the data
collected on a buyer and utilize that to provide
targeted offers that guide buyers to the
information they need as they take their own
path to making a decision. Both buyer #1 and
buyer #2 are moving through a funnel of sorts,
but it is one shaped by their own interests and
content requirements.
Over the next few years, it will be easier to map and
influence the customer experience across both
physical and digital platforms. Better customer
data combined with psychographic profiles will
allow marketers to map a variety of possible paths
to purchase and then design customized offers
that support the customer journey.
6
17THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Learning The New Language Of Data Driven MarketingMarketers still commonly use the concept of the sales funnel when selling strategies to internal stakeholders because it is
familiar, and they lack alternative metaphors. To change the way your organization thinks about marketing and sales, you
first have to change the language you use:
• Instead of the top of the funnel, say the start of the buyer’s journey
• Instead of the middle of the funnel, say personalized engagement
• Instead of the bottom of the funnel, say the end of the buyer’s journey
While we all know communication shouldn’t end when a buyer becomes a customer, the end of the journey signifies the
commencement of a new opportunity cycle in your CRM system with all of the contact points in the previous journey
collected as data that can support your predicative analytics.
LinkedInUpdate
How toGuide
CaseStudy
Contact Us
Customer Portal
InstructionalVideo
Buyer’s Guide
Request a Consultation
Promo Kit
Print Advertising
eBook
Product Demo Video
Free Trial
TrainingWebinar
AWARENESS
EDUCATION
CONSIDERATION
DECISION
RETENTION
Blog Post in Search
Results
Webinar
ROI Calculator
Get a Quote
KnowledgeCenter
BUYER 2BUYER 1
Redefine Your MetricsMarketing has never been short on measurements, although some of those metrics may have fallen short of actual meaning.
Like the Ptolemaic model of the universe that required complex explanations to prove the sun moved around the earth,
traditional marketing metrics also required their own suspension of disbelief. In the pre-digital world, proving the actual
impact of advertising was tough. So the success of campaigns was benchmarked with metrics like reach, frequency,
gross rating points, impressions, cost per thousand or cost per point. PR campaigns had an even tougher task of
establishing impact—resorting to measures like clip counts and advertising value equivalency scores.
Abstract measurement numbers made sense in a world with only a handful of media outlets, allowing brands to
effectively buy consumer attention. With a limited number of platforms competing for audiences, marketers could
quantify the entire universe of potential exposures, and then work out whether or not a brand’s messages reached their
targets in a cost-effective manner.
With the arrival of the Web, we attempted to translate these measures into a digital form—measuring media interaction
rates, cost per click, cost per interaction or cost per view. In reality, these were just the same old exposure metrics in a
new guise, and they did little to really justify the strategic contribution of new marketing to business growth.
Return On Investment (ROI) is not a hypothetical concept anymore. You don’t need a proxy based on channel spend
or media exposure. You can actually measure whether or not an individual, after marketing, has changed his or her
behaviour, become a customer, or even better, become an evangelist for your brand.
7
18THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
21st century CMOs need to take a new approach.
ROI is an aggregate concept suitable for talking to your board or CEO, but if are looking to fine tune your marketing
actions, you need to be focused on what it really costs you to acquire a new customer.
You can work out your CAC by adding up all of your sales and marketing costs (both the cost of your advertising
spend as well as the cost of your team) divided by the number of new customers gain over a defined time period.
Calculating your CAC will give you a deeper perspective into related performance metrics such as:
Once you can quantify the relative performance of your marketing efforts, the next step is to start assigning values
to potential customers as they start to engage with you. This is known as lead scoring.
With a lead scoring system in place, you can automate a large number of activities, all of which can contribute significantly to your growth objectives.
Lead scoring has many potential applications but the primary goal is simple: how do you help your sales team close
a deal? Whether you go strictly with a lead score or add an at-a-glance layer (like a lead grade) on top of the score,
your analysis will help sales focus their efforts on leads who are further along in the buying cycle, and in the best
position to be converted into customers.
• What is the ratio of marketing costs to your cost of sales?
• What is your customer lifetime value, and how does this compare to your acquisition costs?
• How many of your customers were actually gained or influenced by marketing?
• Alerting salespeople when a lead in their queue reaches a certain score.
• Sending an automatic email to a lead when she reaches a certain score.
• Changing a lead’s lifecycle stage to “marketing qualified” when he crosses a score threshold.
• Providing more specific content to a lead based on a combination of lifecycle stage and lead score.
• Updating a lead’s rating in CRM software from warm to hot.
7
19THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
In a time of greater visibility around marketing performance, the more useful number to track is not ROI but rather Customer Acquisition Costs (CAC).
The final measurement methodology worth paying attention to is closed-loop marketing.
A form of attribution modeling, closed-loop marketing involves collecting data about the customer journey, from
initial engagement to final transaction. It requires setting up a means of tracking your campaigns and then either
looping in your enterprise systems or maintaining open communication with your sales team about what leads they
received and what happens next.
Closed-loop marketing is essential in e-commerce. Companies like Amazon.com were early adopters of the Google
AdWords platform, selecting keywords and targeting them to appear next to Google search results when potential
customers looked for a specific item. As customers started clicking, Amazon captured information about what
motivated them to take action and compiled it all into massive databases. This information gave them a powerful
tool of customer insight. If someone looked at a particular book and didn’t buy it, Amazon could use retargeting to
remind them of it later. The company was among the first to offer an intensely personal online shopping experience
by showing items related to the ones you’ve looked at before and even make recommendations for you.
Amazon’s culture of experimentation and testing is one of the hallmarks of their success. As CEO Jeff Bezos has
said, “If you double the number of experiments you do per year you’re going to double your inventiveness.”
7
20THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
21THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
How To Score Your LeadsBefore a lead enters your pipeline, your marketing and sales team need to agree on how to classify it. Your aim to is define the threshold of when an ordinary lead becomes a marketing qualified lead (MQL) - an individual more likely to become a customer based on your data intelligence. These factors will help you develop a scoring system:
EngagementEngagement scores are metrics easily obtained from your marketing
platform, such as page views, website visits, email open or click-through
rates. Social media interactions also indicate engagement, but be warned
- they don’t always translate into sales-readiness. In fact, engagement can
sometimes provide more false positives than any other type of criteria.
BehaviorBehavioral metrics go beyond the number of interactions your customers
have with your website and focus more on the type of interaction. Think
about where you would look if you were considering a purchase of your own
product or service. For example, if someone clicks on an ROI calculator, fills
out a needs assessment or lands on a pricing sheet, you should assign an
appropriate score to that action.
PersonaScoring based on persona is the most valuable type of scoring you can
do. For example, if you’re selling solar panels to homeowners, you might
discover that one of your most likely candidates has a certain income-level,
can utilize a local tax credit, or is more likely to be married than single. By
scoring based on these specific qualifiers, you can quickly determine if the
lead is the right match for further sales development. Disqualification is
just as important. While you might score a person with director or president
in his or her title, you may negatively score or even disqualify an associate
level employee.
Buy ProgrammaticallyWhile brands have made considerable progress in digital marketing, the actual process of buying media has until recently remained stubbornly analogue. Big advertising deals were typically arranged with a confusing mix of phone calls, emails, insertion orders and four martini lunches.
Real time bidding changed everything, allowing brands to buy online impressions from publishers via auction
systems, with computers making split-second decisions about what ad unit to serve. The classic application of
this technology was “retargeting”, whereby a consumer who viewed a product on a retailer site would then see an
advertisement for that same product a few minutes later when they jumped to another site. Marketers spent $3.1
billion on real-time bidding in 2013. Real-time bidding is expected to account for more than $18.2 billion in digital
advertising revenues in 2018.
That said, programmatic marketing is a much bigger idea than real time bidding,
Programmatic involves the use of data driven software to automate the entire process of advertising placement
and may in the future define the way that all media is bought and sold—even on traditional platforms. Publishers
and platforms are starting to realize that automation is not just relevant to low value inventory, but is also the most
appropriate method for pricing premium offerings as well.
The real power of programmatic is that it allows marketers to buy people rather than placements.
For CMOs, that doesn’t mean firing everyone in your strategic planning team, but simply that once you can automate
the transactional elements of buying and selling, your people need to be focused on more higher-value activities.
Programmatic platforms learn through feedback cycles what kinds of advertising really work for a particular
customer segment. Next generation planners can use those insights to constantly adjust their brand strategy, and
the design of the workflows that activate potential customers.
8
22THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
With greater use of algorithms in the media buying process, we may see the end of “prime time”.
For example, if you can combine set top box data with online profiles, you might discover that one of your
customer segments watches a relatively unpopular TV show. This will then allow you to cost effectively target
those customers using broadcast marketing at a fraction of the cost of a prime time slot. This is a reversal of the
traditional TV formula - rather than using data about shows to find the right audience, marketers can use data about
audiences to find the right show.
“The magic of programmatic is that it’s about de-averaging and it’s about data,” said Jay Sears, senior vice
president of market development for the Rubicon Project, in an interview with Ad Week. “De-averaging means
you’re decomposing everything down to an impression level, and you’re using machines to look at it. You’re making
decisions in milliseconds—and it’s very easy to make those decisions at the impression level and then re-aggregate
them so you can continue to buy at scale.”
More data does not mean less creativity. Programmatic marketing instead encourages brands to constantly develop
compelling content while aligning messaging with an individual customer’s journey. If anything, programmatic
technology is an invitation to finally fulfill the promise of personalized engagement.
8
23THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Communicate Effectively With DataThe Crimea, 1855. Britain faced two enemies - Russia and disease. The legendary Florence Nightingale had done extensive statistical analysis of data that showed unsanitary living conditions led to high mortality rates, not the lack of food or supplies.
To fix the problem, Nightingale wanted the government to invest in hospitals and healthcare instead of guns and
ammunition, but she was afraid Queen Victoria and the members of Parliament would not read or understand her
statistical reports. So, in one of the world’s first examples of sophisticated data visualization, Nightingale created a
data rich infographic called a polar area diagram. Her “Diagram of the Causes of Mortality in the Army in the East”
was so evocative in its simplicity, it persuaded decisions makers of the need for reform by improving the sanitary
conditions of military hospitals.
9
24THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Like Florence Nightingale, tomorrow’s CMO has to play a critical role in not only finding the right kinds of data to make an argument for change, but bringing that data to life in ways that the rest of the business can understand.
Take predictive analytics as an example. You might invest in a platform that provides up-to-the-minute
recommendations about your marketing strategy, but unless you can present this data in a way that engages the
CFO and the finance team, it will be tough to reallocate your investments in real time.
Visualization works best when it provides the viewer with an awareness of contexts that otherwise wouldn’t exist.
That perspective is essential whether you’re considering launching a new product or service or trying to work out
the best way to cut costs. A good infographic is more than just a pretty picture. It can mean the difference between
making the right decision and making a multi-million dollar mistake.
Procter & Gamble’s immersive Business Sphere collects real-time business information so company leaders can
respond to data in a visual way. Working with Tibco Spotfire, over 50,000 P&G employees also have access to a
“Decision Cockpit” that contains a variety of real time business graphs. In one example, P&G’s system used supply
chain sufficiency models to illustrate multiple data points, resulting in an inventory reduction of 25 percent and
a savings of tens of millions of dollars. By bringing their data to life, P&G is changing the way its leaders make
decisions. In an interview with the Harvard Business Review, P&G’s CIO Filippo Passerini called it “getting beyond
the what to the why and the how.”
Visual data is not only relevant as an internal tool; it also serves as a way of sharing impactful stories with the wider world.
General Electric, for example, does a great job of capturing the imagination with its data. GE generates a quarter
of the world’s electricity. To communicate that idea, the company measured data from 713 of its turbines every
15 minutes for 15 days. The team then put together a striking visual representation to illustrate how GE’s turbines
generate power for homes and industries all over the world. Similarly, when the company sponsored the 2012
London Olympics, it leveraged that relationship to create a visualization of the last 100 years of world records for
the summer games. GE now uses visualizations in places as diverse as annual reports, customer whitepapers or
press announcements aimed at business media.
9
25THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
26THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Five Data Visualization Questions To Consider
4:1
What is a complex decision you need to bring to your CEO that could be better explained visually?
Which of your business stories would make an ideal candidate for a data visualization video for YouTube?
What is the ratio of words to images in your presentation decks for both internal and external audiences?
If you had a world class data visualization team at your disposal, what project would you give them first?
If you had to make all of your decisions using just five real-time graphs, what would they show?
Build A Strong Relationship With ITOne of the defining executive relationships in the 21st century will be between the CMO and the CIO.
The marketing technology stack is getting more complex - both at the front end where your customers engage
with your products and services, as well as at the back end where all the orchestration of your business processes
takes place. Integration is key. Your new tool box of analytics, conversion optimization, lead nurturing, personalized
content, re-marketing, mobile engagement, marketing automation, loyalty management, and programmatic
marketing require deep integration into enterprise systems to be truly effective.
The rise of marketing technology has led some to argue that we will see the merger of the CMO and CIO position in
the enterprise. In truth, that is unlikely. CMOs have a lot more to worry about than just technology, and CIOs equally
have more on their hands than just building better marketing engagement platforms.
The source of departmental conflict has more to do with relative speeds of change.
For a number of years, traditional IT has lagged on the adoption of Cloud based marketing technologies, mainly
due to a lack of specific knowledge of the new marketing platforms necessary to provide useful feedback. That
is changing. The new generation of IT leadership is not only Cloud savvy; they are undergoing the same cultural
transformation toward agility, speed and adaptability as marketing teams are. Rather than blocking line of business
managers from making technology decisions, they want them to be more engaged and empowered – leaving IT
leadership to focus on the larger design of the enterprise technology stack.
10
27THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
10
28THE 21ST CENTURY CMO PLAYBOOK
Shadow IT, where managers sidestep IT to buy their own managed services, is a strategic dead-end. Getting value out of marketing technology investments requires more integration with core enterprise platforms, not less.
In the future, marketing technology will be merely a utility and of little competitive advantage in and of itself.
Marketers will differentiate themselves not by the technology they own, but how they design unique customer
workflows and engagement programs. Another source of future advantage will be the richness of a brand’s data
management platform (DMPs). DMPs will allow brands to combine their own proprietary data with other sources for
more accurate targeting and personalized customer experiences.
Building a strong relationship with IT is essential if you want to reimagine the marketing organization
The CIO’s experience in managing complex systems, combined with the CMO’s expertise in consumer behaviour will
be a power relationship that will define your success.
Selecting the right marketing technology solution is the least difficult part of the road ahead for CMOs and their
teams. The real challenge is change management. How do you break down the existing mindsets, management
practices and departmental silos that have until now held you back?
The coming era of data driven marketing is not about just technology.
For the 21st century CMO, the future of marketing is about finding
new ways to make better decisions and design more compelling
experiences that delight the customer.
Mike Walsh brings the future to life for business
leaders and their audiences. He is the best-selling
author of Futuretainment and The Dictionary of
Dangerous Ideas. As CEO of Tomorrow, he advises
leaders on how to design their businesses for the 21st century
and thrive in this era of disruptive technological change.
Mike constantly travels the world as part of his extensive
innovation research program. He distills the most relevant
insights into high impact keynotes that allow any audience
to understand and influence their future. We look forward to
discussing your next event and how Mike can work with your
team to identify the key levers of change in your business.
Visit www.mike-walsh.com to learn more.
CONNECT WITH MIKE
IN COLLABORATION WITH
Recommended