View
231
Download
1
Category
Tags:
Preview:
Citation preview
Slides for Sociology W3480: Part 2 of 3
Revolutions, Social Movements, and Contentious Politics
Columbia College
Spring 2007
Prepared by Charles Tilly and
Ernesto Castañeda
send questions to ec2183@columbia.edu
RevolutionsRevolutions
• Revolution = forcible transfer of power over a state in the course of which at least two distinct blocs of contenders make incompatible claims to control the state, and some significant portion of the population subject to the state’s jurisdiction acquiesces in the claims of each bloc.
• A full revolution combines a revolutionary situation with a revolutionary outcome.
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 3
Revolutionary SituationsRevolutionary Situations
1) contenders or coalitions of contenders advancing exclusive competing claims to control of the state or some segment of it: mobilization process.
2) commitment to those claims by a significant segment
of the citizenry: mobilization plus diffusion
3) incapacity or unwillingness of rulers to suppress the
alternative coalition and/or commitment to its claims: ruler-subject interaction
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 4
Revolutionary OutcomesRevolutionary Outcomes
1) defections of regime members2) acquisition of armed force by revolutionary
coalitions3) neutralization or defection of the regime’s armed
force4) control of the state apparatus by members of
revolutionary coalition5) transfer of state power to new ruling coalition.
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 5
CONFLICT, REVOLT, AND REVOLUTION CONFLICT, REVOLT, AND REVOLUTION complete great
revolution
civil war top-down seizure of power TRANSFER coup OF POWER revolt routine politics none none complete SPLIT IN REGIME 6(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
How to Analyze Contentious How to Analyze Contentious Event CataloguesEvent Catalogues
Adapted from Tilly’s “How to Detect and Describe
Performances and Repertoires”Chapter 2 of upcoming book “Contentious Performances”
April 11th, 2007
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 7
Aerial Graph of Contention in Russia (based on Bessinger 2001).Aerial Graph of Contention in Russia (based on Bessinger 2001).
Source: Data Supplied by Mark Beissinger
Figure 5.4: Demonstrations and Violent Events in the Soviet Union and Successor States, 1987-1992
0
50
100
150
200
250
30019
87
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
Year
Cu
mu
lati
ve N
um
ber
of
Eve
nts
Violent Events
Demonstrations
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 8
Event AnalysisEvent Analysis
• The fundamental unit of analysis in this study is the contentious event.
• Event analysis is widely recognized as a tool for studying waves of mobilization.
• It is essentially a way of tracking over time the rise and fall of particular types of events and the features associated with them (Beissinger 2002: 42).
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 9
Different Soviet nationalities staged protest demonstrations Different Soviet nationalities staged protest demonstrations month by month from 1987 through 1991 month by month from 1987 through 1991 (Beissinger 2002: 84). (Beissinger 2002: 84).
For the most active, these were the peak months:For the most active, these were the peak months:
• Armenians May 1988• Estonians November 1988• Moldavians February 1989• Russians January 1990• Crimean Tatars April 1990• Ukrainians November 1990• Latvians December 1990• Lithuanians December 1990• Azerbaijanis December 1990• Georgians September 1991
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 10
Results Results
• “In all, I have been able to identify thirty-two major waves of nationalist violence in the former USSR during the 1987-92 period, part of sixteen larger ethnonationalist conflicts involving violence during these years. Only in four of these conflicts (the Azerbaijani-Armenian conflict, the Georgian-Ossetian conflict, the Georgian-Abkhaz conflict, and the Moldovan-Transdniestr conflict) did violence become a self-sustaining strategy of contesting state boundaries, with relatively short waves of violence growing increasingly protracted over time. In all other cases, violent mobilization remained short-lived. What distinguished conflicts in which mass violence grew sustained from those in which violence ceased to proliferate was the relationship of state institutions to the production of violence” (Beissinger 2002: 309).
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 11
Graficas de violenciaGraficas de violencia
Source:
Samuel González RuizSamuel González Ruiz
Mexican specialist in comparative legal systems, in relation to the fight and prosecution of organized crime.
Niveles de Violencia en México
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
1990
1989
1988
1987
1986
1985
1984
9 Violencia mortal Terrorista
X1
X2
8 Violencia mortal intimidatoria Generalizada
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
X11
7 Utilización de armas de destrucción media.
X12
X13
X14
X15
X16
X17
X18
X19
X20
X21
X22
6 Violencia contra políticos y de primer nivel
X23
X24
X25
X26
X27
X28
X29
X1
X30
X31
X32
5 Violencia mortal contra funcionarios y periodistas
X33
X34
X35
X36
X37
X38
X39
X40
X41
X42
X43
X44
X2
X45
X46
X X47
X48
X49
4 Violencia mortal contra Terceros
X50
X X X X51
X 52
X53
X
54
X 55
X56
X X X X X X X X X X X X x57
3 Violencia mortal contra Rivales
X 58
X 59
X 60
X 61
X62
X 63
X X64
X 65
X
66
X 67
X 68
X 69
X 70
X 71
X 72
X X 73
X X X x x
2 Violencia física
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X74
X X X X X x x
1 Violencia Moral
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X x x Violencia Moral o intimidación (amenazas o daño en propiedad ajena para amedrentar a las 1 Inicio de la utilización de grupos armados tipo autodefensas. (la familia en Michoacán) 2 Caso de los Fernández. Hotel Camino Real Guadalajara. (Sólo ha habido un único intento en México de usar bombas en caso de narcotráfico. Los Arellano contactaron con libaneses y
1 Preparación de atentado contra el General Rebollo. Contrato contra Francisco Molina.
2 CIUDAD VICTORIA.- Francisco Morales Hernández, comandante de la Policía Judicial en Tampico, fue asesinado ayer por Hilario Gómez Herrera, comandante de la misma corporación en Ciudad Madero, quien además hirió a dos policías preventivos.
Eduardo Rodríguez Masso, director de la PJE, informó que los hechos ocurrieron la noche del sábado en Ciudad Madero.
Explicó que el enfrentamiento entre los dos comandantes se debió a que Gómez Herrera había detenido antes a dos hijos de Morales Hernández, al parecer de manera arbitraria
Increase of Violence in Mexico due to Organized Crime
13(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
Niveles de Violencia en Colombia
07
06
05
04
03
02
01
2000 99
98
97 96
95
94
93
92
91
90
89
88
87
86
85
84
83
82
9 Violencia Terrorista
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
x8
X9
X10
X11
X12
X13
X14
8 Violen. intimidatoria. Generalizada
X15
X16
X17
X18
X19
X20
X21
X22
X23
7 armas de destrucción media.
X24
X25
X26
X27
X28
X X X29
x
6 Violencia contra políticos y de primer nivel
X30
X31
X32
X33
X34
X35
X36
X37
X38
x39
x40
x41
X X42
5 Violencia mortal contra funcionarios y periodistas
X43
X44
X45
X46
x47
X X
48
X X X x49
X X50
x51
4 Violencia mortal contra Terceros
X X52
X53
X54
X55
X56
X57
X58
X59
X60
X61
X62
X63
X64
X65
X66
X67
X68
X69
X X X X
3 Violencia mortal contra Rivales
X70 X X X X X X X X X X X X
71 X72
X X X73
X X74
X75
x x
2 Violencia física
X X X X X X X X76
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
1 Violencia Moral
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X 77
07
06
05
04
03
02
01
2000 99
98
97 96
95
94
93
92
91
90
89
88
87
86
85 84
83
82
1 La Policía atribuyó a las Farc el ataque con carro bomba contra una planta de Nestlé en Doncello, Caquetá, en el que 4 personas sufrieron heridas leves. Médicos del hospital de Florencia, reportaron que las personas lesionadas ya fueron dadas de alta. Las autoridades investigan la hipótesis de que el atentado se produjera porque la multinacional no pagó una suma de dinero que les exigía la guerrilla. Enero 22 del 2007. Un atentado con 30 kilos de pentolita, distribuidas en dos cargas, fueron activadas al paso de una patrulla de la Policía, en el barrio La Independencia. Seis personas murieron y catorce resultaron heridas. Dos atentados de las FARC dejan 6 muertos en puerto colombiano.
2 El comandante del Ejército, general Mario Montoya, reconoció que un capitán y un teniente de la institución estarían involucrados en el atentado con carro bomba ocurrido en Bogotá el 15 de julio, días antes de la posesión del presidente Alvaro Uribe para su segundo manda. 8 de abril de 2006
Reduction of Violence in Colombia
14(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
Niveles de Violencia en Irlanda
07
06
05
04
03
02
01
2000
99
98 97
96
95
94 93
92
91
90
89
88
87
86
85
84
83
82
Violencia mortal Terrorista
Violencia mortal intimidatoria. Generalizada
Utilización de armas de destrucción media.
Xi xii
Xiii
Violencia contra políticos y de primer nivel
Violencia mortal contra funcionarios y periodistas
Xivv
xvi
Xvii viii
Xix
Xx
xxi
xxii
Violencia mortal contra Terceros
Xxiii
Xxiv
xxv
xxvi
Xxvii Xxviii
xxix
Xxx
xxxi
Xxxii
Xxxiii
Xxxiv
Xxxv
Xxxvi
Violencia mortal contra Rivales
Xxxvii
Xxxviii
Xxxix
Xxxx
Xxxxi
Xxxxii
xxxxiii
xxxxiv
xxxxv
xxxxvi
xxxxvii
xxxxviii
Violencia física
Xxxxix
Violencia Moral
Xxl
xxli
i The government, which had prematurely declared last year that the fight against gangs was nearly won, is now cracking down, and police are seizing weapons - 500 this year - from sawn-off shotguns to M16 rifles and armour-piercing bullets ii Inicio de envíos de armas en los cargamentos de droga. Algunas fueron intercambiadas con el Ira iii
1982 bomba en un coche de un criminalista dr James Donovan puesta por el mafiosa Cahil iv 26 de junio de 96 asesinato de Verónica Guerin periodista que estaba investigando a la Delincuencia organizada. v 6 junio 96 dos policías muertos por tratar de impedir un asalto del IRA vi La periodista Verónica Guerin solicito una entrevista con Gillman para que explicara como había obtenido su dinero. Gillman la golpeo personalmente. Ella presento cargos contra el lo que implicaba una directa condena. vii El Criminal Gillman amenazo de muerte a los funcionarios de la Seguridad Social que investigaban a su hija. viii Verónica Guerin reporto que un criminal que había robado camiones bancarios había recibido una amnistía de impuestos por lo que había recibido del robo. Fue lesionada con un balazo en una pierna. ix Secuestro del Director del Banco de Irlanda. x 1989 El oficial Brian Purcell del departamento de Seguridad Social elimino los beneficios sociales de Cahill. Fue secuestrado y golpeado. Le dieron dos balazos en las piernas. xi El detective dominick hutchim disparo a dos personas de la banda del monk y el se llevo seis balazos. Murio su amigo thomas driscoll xii Los kelly amenazaron al juez . xiii Tearful parents today visited the scene where their son was shot dead in the first gun murder in Ireland of 2007. A 22-year-old man, named locally as Damien Dowdall, died after gunmen burst into his girlfriend’s house in west Dublin last night. Dowdall died in the living room after being shot twice, according to the Garda
xiv A man is being questioned about the murder of a couple who were set on fire at their home in Co Armagh. Thomas O'Hare and Lisa McClatchey died after an attack at their home near Armagh City five weeks ago. Both victims later died in hospital.
xv Gilligan amenazó a los dos testigos que se tenían para comprobar que es había ordenado la muerte de verónica guerin. Martus Baltus cuya hija amenazó de muerte no testificó. Tampoco una antigua amante Carol Rooney. xvi Tasa homicidio de 1.01 por cien mil xvii Tasa homicidio de 1.02 por cien mil xviii Tasa homicidio de 1.04 por cien mil
Trends of Organized Crime in Ireland(not linked to terrorist organizations)
15(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
Niveles de Violencia en Italia.
06
05
04
03
02
01
2000
99 98
97 96
95
94
93
92
91
90
89
88 87
86
85
84
83
82
9 Violencia mortal Terrorista
Xi
Xii
Xiii
Xiv
8 Violencia mortal intimidatoria. Generalizada
7 Utilización de armas de destrucción media.
X X X X X v
X X X X X X
6 Violencia contra políticos y de primer nivel
Xvi
Xvii
X viii
5 Violencia mortal contra funcionarios y periodistas
Xix
Xx
Xxi
Xxii
Xxiii
Xxiv
Xxv
Xxvi
Xxvii X1
4 Violencia mortal contra Terceros
xxviii
xxix
Xxx
Xxxi
Xxxii
Xxxiii
Xxxiv
Xxxv Xxxvi
Xxxvii
Xxxviii
Xxxix
Xxxx
Xxxxi
Xxxxii
Xxxxiii
Xxxxiv
Xxxxv
Xxxxvi
Xxxxvii
Xxxxviii
xxxxix
xxl
3 Violencia mortal contra Rivales
X X X X X X X X X X X X X Xxli
X X Xxlii
X X X Xxliii
X X
2 Violencia física X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
1 Violencia Moral X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
i 27/ 7/ 1993: a Roma, un’autobomba esplode nel piazzale antistante il vicariato, dietro la basilica di San Giovanni in Laterano. Poco dopo un’altra autobomba esplode davanti alla chiesa del Velabro. Lo stesso giorno a Milano, un’autobomba parcheggiata in via Palestro provoca cinque morti: quattro vigili urbani accorsi sul posto e un extracomunitario che dormiva su una panchina. 27/ 5/ 1993: a Firenze, esplode un’autobomba in via dei Georgofili, cinque morti. 14/ 5/ 1993: a Roma, esplode un’autobomba in via Fauro al passaggio dell’auto con a bordo il conduttore televisivo Maurizio Costanzo. ii Utilización de 800 kilogramos de explosivo para volar la carretera del aeropuerto a Palermo y asesinar al juez Falcone. En el incidente muere su esposa Francesca y varios miembros de su escolata. Utilización de explosivos para volar a el Juez Paolo Borselino. En el incidente mueren varios miembros de su escolta iii Nostra decise di rispondere con un agguato, luogo prescelto la sala trattenimenti “Madison” dove i Grassonelli erano stati invitati ad una festa di matrimonio. Venne rubata una A 112. Ma i Grassonelli intuirono il pericolo e imbottirono di tritolo l’auto destinata a trasportare i loro killer. L’esplosione ridusse in brandelli Calogero Salemi (nella foto i resti dell’auto). iv
1 Asesinato del Periodista Nino Pecorelli
Violence in Italy
16(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
0,00
0,20
0,40
0,60
0,80
1,00
1,20
1,40
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
Year
Rat
es p
er 1
00.0
00 in
habi
tant
s
“Concussione” Passive corruption Active corruption Instigation to corruption
Reported “corruption” offences - rates per 100.000 inhabitants
(Italy 1989-2000)
17(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)
0,00
0,10
0,20
0,30
0,40
0,50
0,60
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
Year
“Concussione” Passive corruption Active corruption Instigation to corruption
Rat
es p
er 1
00.0
00 in
habi
tant
sConvicted people for “corruption” offences -
Rates per 100.000 inhabitants (Italy 1989-2000)
18
Organized Crime ↔ Corruption ↔ Obstruction of Justice Organized Crime ↔ Corruption ↔ Obstruction of Justice = Escalation of Violence and Loss of State Capacity= Escalation of Violence and Loss of State Capacity
• “La relación entre la violencia, la corrupción y la obstrucción a la justicia son de protección directa de la delincuencia organizada y se configuran como un círculo exterior que protege el silencio o la oferta de las organizaciones criminales” (Gonzalez y Flores 2007).
Source forthcoming as:. “Violencia, corrupción y narcotráfico: el desafío del México democrático.
”González Ruiz, Samuel y Carlos Flores.” Foreign Affairs en Español ▪ Volumen 7 Número 2.
Special thanks to Samuel Ruiz for sharing his research and slides with the Mexican Graduate Student Groups at Conferences at Yale and Columbia.
19
Tarrow’s Italy StudyTarrow’s Italy Study• Tarrow examined Italy’s cycle of protest from 1965 to 1975, for which the national
newspaper Corriere della Sera yielded 4,980 “protest events”, non-routine actions in which the participants revealed a collective goal. Tarrow tells us,
• I collected information on ‘protest events’, a category which included strikes, demonstrations, petitions, delegations, and violence, but which excluded contentious behavior which revealed no collective claims on other actors.
• I defined the protest event as a disruptive direct action on behalf of collective interests, in which claims were made against some other group, elites, or authorities (Tarrow 1989: 359).
• Tarrow produced a record for each event. But he enriched the enterprise in two important ways:
• First, he incorporated textual descriptions at a number of critical points – summaries of events, grievances, policy responses, and more. That made it possible to refine his classified counts without returning to the original newspaper sources.
• Second, within the record he placed checklists where two or more features could coexist. As a result, he was able to analyze not only the overall distribution of events but also the frequency of such features as different forms of violence – clashes with police, violent conflict, property damage, violent attacks, rampages, and random violence (Tarrow 1989: 78). (Taken from Tilly Contentious Repertoires. Forthcoming [It has now appeared in Cambridge university Press. 2008]).
20
(Source: Tilly and Tarrow 2007)
Figure 5.2: Italian Contention, 1966-1973
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
550
600
Semester
Conventional Events
Confrontational Events
Violent Events
Source: Tarrow 1989: p. 70
21
Tilly’s Great Britain StudyTilly’s Great Britain Study• Over about ten years, research groups at the University of Michigan and the New School for
Social Research worked with me to create a systematic body of evidence on actions, interactions, performances, repertoires, and their settings in Great Britain between 1758 and 1834.
• The central data set we produced includes machine-readable descriptions for 8,088 contentious gatherings (CGs) that occurred in southeastern England (Kent, Middlesex, Surrey, or Sussex) during thirteen selected years from 1758 to 1820, or anywhere in Great Britain (England, Scotland, and Wales, but not Ireland) from 1828 to 1834.
• In this study, a CG is an occasion on which ten or more people gathered in a publicly-accessible place and visibly made claims which, if realized, would affect the interests of at least one person outside their number. In principle, CGs include almost all events that authorities, observers, or historians of the time would have called "riots" or "disturbances" as well as even more that would fall under such headings as "public meeting", "procession" and "demonstration".
• Our standardized descriptions of CGs come from periodicals: the Annual Register, Gentleman's Magazine, London Chronicle, Morning Chronicle, Times, Hansard's Parliamentary Debates, Mirror of Parliament, and Votes and Proceedings of Parliament; we read these periodicals exhaustively for the years in question plus January-June 1835. Although we frequently consulted both published historical work and archival sources such as the papers of the Home Office in interpreting our evidence, the machine-readable descriptions transcribed material from the periodicals alone.
• We did not try to find every event about which information was available or even a representative sample of such events. Instead, we assembled a complete enumeration of those described in standard periodicals whose principles of selection we could examine, and sometimes even test.
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 22
Tilly’s Great Britain StudyTilly’s Great Britain StudyTilly laced computer-stored records for Contentious Events into separate sections and provided:• a general description of each event (8,088 machine-readable records)• a description of each formation -- each person or set of persons who acted distinguishably
during the event (27,184 records)• supplementary information on the geographical or numerical size of any formation, when
available (18,413 records)• a summary of each distinguishable action by any formation, including the actor(s), the crucial
verb, (where applicable) the object of the action, and an excerpt of the text(s) from which we drew actor, verb, and object (50,875 records)
• excerpts from detailed texts from which we drew summary descriptions of actions (76,189 records)
• identification of each source of the account (21,030 records)• identification of each location in which the action occurred (11,054 records)• a set of verbal comments on the event, or on difficulties in its transcription (5,450 records)• special files listing all alternative names for formations and all individuals mentioned in any
account (28,995 formation names, 26,318 individual names)• Except for straightforward items such as date, day of the week, and county names, the records
do not contain codes in the usual sense of the term. On the whole, we transcribed words from the texts or (when that was not feasible) paraphrases of those words. Think of formation names: Instead of coding names given to formations in broad categories, we transcribed the actual words used in our sources.
• For example, the transcription of each action includes the actor’s name, a verb characterizing the action, and (in the roughly 52 percent of cases in which there was an object) the object’s name.
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 23
Subject – Verb - ObjectSubject – Verb - Object
Transcription subject verb object the same night the mob (gathered) mob #gather none the mob committed great violences in Surry-Street, in the Strand, particularly at the Coach Office, not a window was left with a whole pane of glass mob #break owner of Coach Office
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 24
My research team found multiple accounts of these attacks in 1829’s Times of London. Here is how we transcribed and classified the major actions within a cutting incident on May 4th: Transcription Verb Broad Verb Category certain evil-disposed persons riotously assembled assemble move entered the dwellings of the journeymen silk weavers enter move and maliciously cut and destroyed the silk in the looms destroy attack #end #end end a reward of 200L is hereby offered offer negotiate The left hand verb presents our simplified transcription of the phrase’s central action. The right hand column shows our placement in one of eight extremely broad categories of verbs: attack, control, end, meet, move, negotiate, support, and other. (More on verb categories in a moment.)
Source: Tilly. Contentious Performances Chapter 2. Unpublished draft 2007.(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 25
Figure 2-3: Major Categories of Verbs in British Contentious Gatherings, 1758-1834
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
1758 1759 1768 1769 1780 1781 1789 1795 1801 1807 1811 1819 1820 1828 1829 1830 1831 1832 1833 1834
Year
Per
cen
t o
f A
ll C
Gs
Fea
turi
ng
Ver
bs
in C
ateg
ory
ATTACK
CONTROL
MEET
OTHER
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007)26
Figure 2-2: Locations of Action Verbs in Two Factor Space F1 = Indoor (low) vs. Outdoor (high) F2 = Disagreement (low) vs. Agreement (high)
0.900.600.300.00-0.30-0.60-0.90
F2
0.90
0.60
0.30
0.00
-0.30
-0.60
-0.90
F1
VOTE
THANK
SUPPORT
RESOLVE
RESIST
REQUEST RECEIVE
PROCEED
PETITION
OPPOSE
NEGOTIATE
MOVE
MEET
MARCH
HEARPET
GATHER
FIGHT
ENTER
DISPERSE
DELIBERATE
DECRY
CONTROL
COMMUNICATE
CHEER
CHAIR
BLOCK
ATTEMPTATTACK
ASSEMBLE
ADJOURN
ADDRESS
27
Over-represented Verb Categories* by Broad Type of Over-represented Verb Categories* by Broad Type of Gathering, Great Britain, 1758-1834Gathering, Great Britain, 1758-1834
• authorized celebrations (78 CGs): bracket, celebrate, cheer, dine, enter, gather, observe, proceed, receive• delegations (79): address, bracket, deliberate, gather, negotiate, proceed, receive, support• parades, demonstrations, rallies (142): attempt, block, bracket, celebrate, cheer, decry, dine, enter, gather,
march, negotiate, observe, oppose, other, proceed, receive, support, vote• pre-planned meetings of named associations (985): dine, hear petition, meet, petition• pre-planned meetings of public assemblies (3197): none• other pre-planned meetings (1672): dine, meet• strikes, turnouts (76): attack, attempt, block, control, deliberate, donkey, gather, hear petition, march, move,
negotiate, observe, other, proceed, resist, turnout• attacks on blacklegs (27): attack, block, control, decry, die, enter, fight, gather, move, observe, turnout• brawls in drinking places (24): attack, attempt, block, bracket, celebrate, control, deliberate, dine, enter, fight,
gather, give, move, negotiate, request, resist, turnout• market conflicts (12): address, block, gather, negotiate, oppose, other, proceed, request, support• poachers vs. gamekeepers (71): attack, attempt, block, bracket, control, deliberate, die, disperse, enter, fight,
gather, hunt, move, negotiate, observe, other, proceed• smugglers vs. customs (49): attack, attempt, block, bracket, celebrate, control, die, fight, gather, give, move,
observe, other, proceed, resist, smuggle• other violent gatherings (1156): attack, attempt, block, bracket, control, decry, enter, fight, gather, give, march,
move, negotiate, observe, petition, proceed, resist• other unplanned gatherings (520): block, celebrate, cheer, control, decry, demonstrate, enter, gather, march,
move, negotiate, observe, other, proceed •
* over-represented = 2+ times the proportion in all gatherings or (in the case of end and meet, which appear in 73 and 54 percent of all gatherings respectively) 20%+ more than their general proportions
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 28
Takeshi WadaTakeshi Wada
• Wada (Wada 2003, 2004) drew accounts of protest events from the daily newspapers Excélsior, Unomásuno, and La Jornada for 29-day periods spanning national elections over the 37 years, a total of 13 electoral periods.
• From the newspapers he identified 2832 events, some linked together in campaigns, for a total of 1797 campaigns.
• Wada’s subject-verb-object-claim transcriptions made it possible for him to employ sophisticated network models of who made claims on whom. Overall, they reveal a sharp politicization of Mexico’s collective claim making as the country’s partial democratization proceeded. From claims on business, landowners, and universities, protesters moved to making increasingly strong claims on the government itself.
• According to Wada’s analysis, the weakening of network ties among the elite (especially as concentrated within the longtime ruling party PRI) provided an opportunity for claimants to divide their rulers. It thus advanced the partial democratization of the 1990s. Technically, Wada broke free of many restrictions imposed by classified event counts. That technical freedom opened the way to a sophisticated treatment of interaction in Mexican politics.
Source: Wada, Takeshi (2003): “A Historical and Network Analysis of Popular Contention in the Age of
Globalization in Mexico,” unpublished doctoral dissertation in sociology, Columbia University. (2004): “Event Analysis of Claim Making in Mexico: How Are Social Protests Transformed into Political Protests,” Mobilization 9: 241-258.
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 30
LessonsLessonsThe innovations of Tilly, McPhail, Tarrow, Franzosi, Beissinger,
Wada and others offer three lessons for analysts of contentious politics:
• First, it is practically feasible to record and analyze the internal dynamics of episodes instead of settling for classified event counts.
• Second, the recording of particular verbs rather than general characterization of the action is crucial for that practical purpose.
• Third, verbs with objects make it possible to move from individualistic analyses to treatments of connections among contentious actors (relational).
(Tilly & Castañeda 2007) 31
Extra lecture:What Happened in Oaxaca?
Triangulating Outside Witness Accountsto Analyze the Contentious Politics
in Oaxaca, Mexico
Nayeli Chavez-Geller, UNIVISIONRene Ramos, MPA Student SIPA Columbia
Ivania de la Cruz Orozco, MPA Student SIPA ColumbiaManuela Garza, The New School and Fundación Comunitaria Oaxaca
Ernesto Castañeda-Tinoco, PhD Student Department of Sociology, Columbia Leslie A. Martino, PhD Student, Department of Sociology, CUNY, The Graduate Center
Thursday April 12th, 2007.
Organized by Mexican Initiative Co-sponsored by the
Institute of Latin American Studies, LASA-SIPA, and ALAS-TC.
For this see extra Lecture file 4.
Recommended