View
222
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
1/19
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
Taxes arewhat we payfor civilized society
OLLIVER WENDELL HOLMES
Mr.Parth Singh
ID. No. 1903
Ist year BA LLB Hons.
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
2/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 1
INTRODUCTION
Indias service sector is renowned for its size and dynamism. The services sector has
witnessed massive and continuous growth, especially over the last 2 decades, and today
stands at a monumental 64.4% of the GDP (2011-12).1
The Economic survey of India (2011-
2012) reflects the role played by services in helping the economy navigate the turbulence
caused by the Eurozone crisis and the recession in economies world over.2
The Finance Act of 1994, envisaged the growing role of services in the Indian economy and
introduced a levy on services to create an additional source of revenue to fulfil therequirements of our fiscal policy. The indirect tax introduced was ideal to meet the dual
objective of fiscal management without hampering economic growth and productivity. Our
country adopted a selective approach wherein they taxed only specific services to allow for
the services sector to continue growing while simultaneously increasing the revenue
generation for the government. The list of taxable services continued to grow as the
robustness of our service sector grew but despite the frequent revision of the list of taxable
services, revenue from service tax was barely 0.3 per cent of the GDP and 3 per cent of the
tax revenue of the union,3
which considering the state of our Fiscal deficit, India can ill
afford.
Recent trends in service tax policy have dovetailed India fiscal policy. India expanded the
positive list continuously and finally bit the bullet and shifted to a comprehensive tax regime
for service tax in the Finance Act of 2012, to curtail the fiscal deficit which now stands at
5.6%.4
The paper provides a brief overview of the antecedents and the existing service tax
framework in India. The paper delves into the positive list system of the service tax regime
and continuous expansion of the same and the fluctuations in rate of taxation. The paper
1Concept Paper on Taxation of Services based on a Negative List, Central Board of Excise and Customs,
Ministry of Finance, Government of India (2011), available athttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-
negativelst.pdf, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).2
Chapter 10, Economic survey of India 2011-2012, available athttp://indiabudget.nic.in/survey.asp, (last
accessed on 4
th
April, 2012).3Supra note 1.
4Supra note 2.
http://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://indiabudget.nic.in/survey.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/survey.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/survey.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/survey.asphttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdf8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
3/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 2
establishes the economic rationale behind the aforementioned trends in service tax, and
service tax itself. The Introduction of the negative list system by the Finance Act, 2012 has
been analysed. The stated policy of the government to introduce GST5
which will incorporate
service tax in India has again been studied as one of the major trends in the policy fortaxation of services. The paper essentially describes the service tax trends and analyses the
rationale behind them.
5First Discussion Paper On Goods and Services Tax In India, The Empowered Committee Of State Finance
Ministers, available athttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdf,
(last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
http://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdf8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
4/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 3
Contents
Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1
Framework ................................................................................................................................. 4
Legal and Administrative Trends in service tax ........................................................................ 6
Trends dovetailing Fiscal Policy:............................................................................................... 8
Negative List ............................................................................................................................ 10
Future Trends In Service Tax Policy ....................................................................................... 13
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................... 15
Bibliography ............................................................................................................................ 16
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
5/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 4
FRAMEWORK
With the increasing importance of services in the domestic economy, Service tax was
introduced in 1994 as a levy on services and the provisions of the same are mentioned in
Chapter V of the Finance Act of 1994. It is an indirect form of taxation, which is levied on
goods and services and not on income and profits, thus, carrying the tax to the point of
consumption; hence the burden of the tax is on the consumer and not on the business.6
It has
helped raise the tax revenue for the government so as to fuel economic growth and
productivity without damaging the rate of savings in the economy, a key outcome of its
indirect nature. A planned growth of service tax will reduce the tax burden on international
trade (Customs duty) and domestic manufacturing sector (Excise duty),
commensurate with
the goals of economic liberalization and globalization.7
Moreover, it has an inbuilt ease of collection and safeguards against tax evasion.8
Since it is
levied at the point of consumption, it allows the government the flexibility to influence
patterns of production and reduce consumption of luxury goods through service tax rates. The
bit-by-bit nature, unlike the lump sum paid in direct taxes, cushions the impact on taxpayers
and does not prompt them to cut down savings, a vital requirement for a developing
economy.9
The point of taxation being point of consumption, it has brought under its ambit
people who do not pay direct taxes but avail of the services being taxed.
The service tax regime was one of Positive Listing. Under this approach, each service is first
identified, the taxable event is then defined for each identified service and then tax is levied
on the occurrence of the event.10
S. 65(105) of the Finance Act, 1994 lists the services that
qualify for service tax.
11
The positive list system has a significant advantage for a nationexperiencing an initial boom in its services sector as it helps nascent services avoid the
burden of taxation and generates revenue through components of the service sector which are
6All India Federation of Tax Practitioners vs Union Of India, [2007] 10 STT 166 (SC) (Supreme Court of India).
7Challenges before the Service Tax Administration in India, available at
http://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htm,(last accessed on 5th
April, 2012).8
Sanjiv Aggarwal, TREATISE ON SERVICE TAX,Vol.1, 223, (Snowwhite Publications, 9th
edn., 2011).9
MichealTodero & Stephen Smith, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, 751, (Pearson Publications, 8th edition, 2003).10 S Mukhopadhyay,Is a negative list for service tax desirable?, BUSINESS STANDARD,AUG.7,2006,available
athttp://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/, ( lastaccessed on 4
thApril, 2012).
11 S. 65(105), Finance Act, 1994.
http://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htmhttp://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htm8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
6/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 5
firmly established. Initially when Service Tax was levied, most services were furnished by
small units which would not have yielded high revenue12
and would have lagged in growth
due to the tax burden; hence it was correct to eliminate these services. The definition of the
taxable event and the situation in which tax liability arises, both inherent in the positive listapproach are extremely important for a developing economy.
12 S Acharya,Back to the Past?, 38(11) ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY 1011 (Mar. 15-21, 2003).
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
7/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 6
LEGAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRENDS IN SERVICE TAX
The Union Government utilised the residuary powers vested in it through the Entry 97 of
Union List to impose service tax in India.13
Consequently, a slew of legislative interventions
by the central government, through constitutional amendments have been carried out to
enable the government to establish clear cut procedures and lay down rules for the imposition
of service tax in India.14
The constitutional validity of service tax has been challenged time
and again in the courts which have consistently held that the imposition of service tax is not
ultra-vires.15
Executive Response
Service tax is administered by the Central excise department which has been pro-active in its
attempts for ensuring high revenue collection through service tax coming out with a slew of
rules and notifications to provide clarity to the whole process. CBEC has set up multiple
commissionaires along with Large taxpayers units16
to accommodate the growing revenue
stream. The expanding positive list led to a trend of every service challenging their inclusion
and high rates of litigation which has been negotiated by the government through the
notification of Customs and Central Excise Appellate Tribunal (CESTATs) as the appellate
body.17
Anticipating further expansion, an office of director General of Service Tax (DGST)
has been set up, with an aim to centralise, streamline and fast-track processes with a view to
ensure effective implementation of Service Tax.18
A.C.E.S.
The biggest step forward in terms of the administrative aspect of service tax has been
Automation of Central Excise and Service Tax (ACES), an e-governance initiative by CBEC
which has a huge potential to enhance revenue collection by streamlining the whole process
13Entry 97, Union List, 7
thSchedule, Constitution of India.
1495
thConstitutional Amendment Bill, 2011 (India).
15Indian Institute of Architects Vs. Union of India, [2007] 6 STT 112 (MAD) (High Court of Madhya Pradesh).
16Supra note 8, at 204
17J.K. Mittal, LAW,PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE OF SERVICE TAX, Vol.II, (CCH Wolters Kluwers, 20
thedn., 2010).
18CAG Audit Report No. 25 of 2011-12 Union Government (Indirect Taxes) Central Excise & Service Tax,
available athttp://saiindia.gov.in/english/home/Public_Interface/In%20_Media/Report_25.pdf, (last accessedon 4
thApril, 2012).
http://www.taxmann.com/servicetaxlaw/Stonline_servicetax/Redirectpage.aspx?schc=y&Text=D%3a%2fTaxmannData%2fSTonlineData%2fRTF%2fST_H%2f%5b2007%5d006STT0112(MAD)_H.rtfhttp://saiindia.gov.in/english/home/Public_Interface/In%20_Media/Report_25.pdfhttp://saiindia.gov.in/english/home/Public_Interface/In%20_Media/Report_25.pdfhttp://saiindia.gov.in/english/home/Public_Interface/In%20_Media/Report_25.pdfhttp://saiindia.gov.in/english/home/Public_Interface/In%20_Media/Report_25.pdfhttp://www.taxmann.com/servicetaxlaw/Stonline_servicetax/Redirectpage.aspx?schc=y&Text=D%3a%2fTaxmannData%2fSTonlineData%2fRTF%2fST_H%2f%5b2007%5d006STT0112(MAD)_H.rtf8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
8/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 7
into a user-friendly format.19
It is a software application which aims at improving tax-payer
services, transparency, accountability and efficiency in the indirect tax administration in
India.20
19What is ACES, available athttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsp(last accessed on 4
thApril, 2012)..
20Id.
http://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsp8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
9/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 8
TRENDS DOVETAILING FISCAL POLICY:
The Indian government has manipulated the service tax regime to suit its fiscal policy as it
conceptualised the service tax as the bulwark against high rates of fiscal deficit. Along with
managing fiscal deficit, the Indian government did not want to stall the boom being
experienced by the services sector hence, it rolled out the service tax in a phased year-by-year
case by case manner through the expansion of services placed under the positive list.
Originally, only 3 services were taxed21
, but as the nations service sector grew, there was a
clear expansion in the number of services placed under the positive list by way of
amendments from time to time, to the Finance Act, 1994 and after the 2011 budget, services
taxed stood at 119.22
The constant addition year after year to the positive list reflects a clear
trend of expanding the tax base in a phased manner to meet the dual objective of controlling
fiscal deficit without stalling growth in nascent components of the services sector.
The fiscal policy of the nation is reflected in the rate of taxation levied by India as the
original levy of 5% in 1994 became 12% in 2006. Here again, the Indian policy of managing
fiscal deficit without stalling economic growth is apparent as the rates of taxation were
increased in a phased manner. There is a clear trend of manipulating the service tax rates to
meet the current fiscal objectives as the indirect nature of the service tax provides the
government with high levels of immediate flexibility.23 The tinkering with rates is clearly
reflected in the introduction of Education Cess and SAH education cess on service tax to
finance human resource development in the nation.24
The biggest example of the close links between the nations fiscal policy and service tax, and
in extensions the services sector itself, is reflected in the way the government used service tax
rates to tackle the effects of the economic recession in North America. As part of a financial
stimulus to the reeling economy, the Government of India rolled back the rate of service tax
to 10% in 2009,25
so that the services sector continues to grow optimally, fuelling the nations
21Supra note 8, at 206.
22Supra note 11.
23R. burgess and S. stern, Taxation and Development, XXXI, 2, JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC LITERATURE, 762-830
(1993).24
Supra note 17, at 2159-2161.25Sec.66B, Chapter V, Finance Bill, 2009, available athttp://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2009-10/ubmain.htm, (last
accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
http://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2009-10/ubmain.htmhttp://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2009-10/ubmain.htmhttp://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2009-10/ubmain.htmhttp://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2009-10/ubmain.htm8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
10/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 9
growth. In the Finance Bill, 2012, GoI shifted its focus to fiscal consolidation, increasing the
rate of taxation to 12%.26
Service Tax falls predominantly on business to business (B2B) services and is thus highly
cascading in nature.27 Cascading taxes directly effect competitiveness in the international
market and create a bias in favour of imports, through hidden burden of taxes on production
inputs.28
To maintain competitiveness of the service sector, GOI introduced CENVAT credit
which allows credit on the service tax paid on the input-service.29
The allowance of
CENVAT credit and exemptions granted for export of services30
reflects the forward looking
outlook of the service tax regime.
CENVAT credit and export exemptions coupled with the dual manipulation of the positive
list and service tax rates to generate revenue without stalling growth of the services sector has
been a pivotal trend of the services sector in India. The trends in revenue collection, positive
list and rate of taxation can be clearly can be clearly seen from the graph below.
26Sec.66B, Chapter V, Finance bill 2012, available athttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp, (last accessed on 4
th
April, 2012).27
Gurcharan Das, The India Model, 85(4)FOREIGN AFFAIRS , 2, (2006).28
Auerbach, Alan J. & Hines, James Jr., "Taxation and economic efficiency, in: A. J. Auerbach & M. Feldstein
(ed.), Handbook of Public Economics, 1347-1421 , (edition 1, volume 3, 2002).29
Amaresh Bagchi, TAXING SERVICES:THE WAY FORWARD, 39(19), ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY , 1876, 200430
S Madhavan, Implications of service tax on export of services, BUSINESS STANDARD, (6th Nov. 2006), available at
http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
1994-
94
1997-
98
2000-
2001
2003-
2004
2006-
2007
2009-
2010
2011-
2012
2012-
2013
Revenue 410 1515 2612 7890 37482 58319 71174 124000
Service Tax rates 5 5 5 8 12.24 10.3 10.3 12.36
No. of services under tax net 3 18 26 62 99 117 119 0
0
20000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
Rs.
Crore
Revenue from Service Tax
http://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
11/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 10
NEGATIVE LIST
In June 2000, an Expert Group headed by M Govinda Rao observed that the selective
approach to taxation of services is undesirable for this violates neutrality in taxation, leads to
inadequate coverage in addition to raising several avoidable procedural and legal
complications. It recommended,a general and comprehensive extension of the tax to cover
all services with a small and clearly-defined exemption list.31
Subsequently, CBEC in its Concept Paper on Taxation of Services based on a Negative List,
advocated a model of taxation based on a negative list approach arguing that the resilience of
Indias service sector today is high enough to allow for casting the tax net far and wide.32
The
Finance Bill, 2012 marked a major shift in government policy as the government with an eye
on fiscal consolidation changed the service tax regime to a negative list system.33
The ever
growing positive list, which last stood at 119,34
clearly showed the governments intent to tax
service sector comprehensively; it was only a matter of time when the switch to a negative
list would have occurred.
According to data released by the Reserve Bank of India, the sector-wise contribution of
services (as % of the service sector) to the Indian GDP is as follows:35
Out of the mentioned sectors, it can be said that barring community and social services, (a),
(b), (c) and personal services have been already brought into the taxation net under the
31 T. Rustagi and Bijal Ajinkya, Time for a negative list of services for taxation?, THE ECONOMIC TIMES,Feb. 4,
2010, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012)..32
Supra note 1.33
Supra note 26.34
Analysis of Service Tax Revenue, Directorate of service tax, available athttp://www.servicetax.gov.in/, (last
accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
35 Data released by RBI for 2009-2010, available at
http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/3T_HBSE200910.pdf., (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
The sector-wise contribution of services to GDP
Construction-13.2%
Trade, hotels, transport and
communication-38.89%
Financing, insurance, real estate
and business services-25.78%
Community, social and personal
services-22.11%
http://www.servicetax.gov.in/http://www.servicetax.gov.in/http://www.servicetax.gov.in/http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/3T_HBSE200910.pdfhttp://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/3T_HBSE200910.pdfhttp://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/3T_HBSE200910.pdfhttp://www.servicetax.gov.in/8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
12/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 11
current policy. However, as per the specific classification of taxable services in the Finance
Act, 1994 as amended by subsequent Finance Acts, various sub-components of these services
are still not taxable, which leads to a significant revenue leakage for the government36
and
creation of unintended exemptions,
37
hampering revenue generation through the servicessector. A negative list would help to that extent by including within the scope of taxation all
the services which are able to escape the tax net currently. Ultimately, a negative list will help
in filling in the gaps in the selective system owing to which various service providers in these
sectors are able to escape tax liability, giving depth to the tax base. This is bound to boost
revenue for the exchequer as according to the Concept Paper, approximately 40% of the total
services will come into the tax net as a result of the proposed negative list, and after
excluding services provided by the informal sector, around 20-25% of the total service sector
contribution may be charged service tax.38
The existing system has been highly litigious as nearly every service which was added to the
positive list has challenged its inclusion and models of business have been created to avoid
service tax by exploiting the relative lack of clarity in defining the taxable services.39
.
A negative list simplifies the taxation regime heavily as it automatically addresses the
problem of lack of definitions of terms in the current system as a clearly set out negative list
would be useful in crystallizing the boundaries of taxable and non-taxable services and thus
also curtailing unnecessary service tax litigation.40
The negative list would provide immense
clarity to the service tax regime which is one of the canons of taxation policy, as laid out by
Adam smith.41
In November 2011, a revised concept paper was released by CBEC which organized the
negative list into 9 sectors comprising of twenty-two items.42
While formulating the negative
36Supra note 1.37 A Bagchi, Towards GST: Choices and Trade-offs, 41(14) ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL WEEKLY, 1314 (Apr. 8-
14, 2006).38
Supra note 1.39
Supra note 31.40 D Sikarwar,India not ready for negative list to tax services, THE ECONOMIC TIMES,(Apr. 6, 2010), available
at http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-
exempt-service,(last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
41 Adam Smith, Main Canons of Taxation inAN INQUIRY INTO THENATURE AND CAUSES OF THEWEALTH OFNATIONS,
(1776).
42Revised Concept Paper on Taxation of Services based on Negative List, Central Board of Excise and
Customs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India (2011), available at http://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-
circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdf, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-service8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
13/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 12
list of services, the Government has taken into consideration notions such as administrative
considerations, contractual obligations under international bodies and diplomatic missions,
welfare considerations and explicit activities in the nature of services which are within the
taxing powers of states.
43
A lucid but concrete definition of service needs to be established with exhaustive
descriptions for the type of exemptions provided so as to avoid the high rates of litigation
plaguing the positive list system and to prevent tax evasion by service providers who exploit
the loopholes present in the definition. Service has been defined in clause (44) of the new
section 65B and meansAny activity (or omission) carried out by one person for another in
lieu of any consideration.44
An examination of this definition shows that the government intends to considerably expand
its service tax collections by defining service in an expansive, overarching way and
excluding a very limited range of services. The definition specifically excludes
Any activity that constitutes only a transfer in title of (i) goods or (ii) immovable
property by way of sale,
Gift or in any other manner a transaction only in (iii) money or (iv) actionable claim,
Any service provided by an employee to an employer in the course of the
employment,
Fees payable to a court or a tribunal set up under a law for the time being in force
Services listed under the negative list which is enumerated in Sec 66 D.45
There are multiple doubts that such an overwhelming change would lead to major transitionalissues as the existing system has been in place for over sixteen years would have its own
43Sec.66D, Chapter V, Finance bill 2012, available at http://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp, (last accessed on 4
th
April, 2012).
The negative list includes services such as notified services provided by the Government, Judiciary, RBI and
certain governmental bodies; services provided by individuals to Government; services by UN, international
bodies, diplomatic missions; social welfare and public utility services; agricultural and animal husbandry
services; certain financial sector services; public transport services; certain educational and health services,
certain construction services.44
Sec.65B(44), Chapter V, Finance bill 2012, available athttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).45
Sec.66D, Chapter V, Finance bill 2012,http://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
http://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asphttp://indiabudget.nic.in/bill.asp8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
14/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 13
inertia against change.46
FUTURE TRENDS IN SERVICE TAX POLICY
The Indian Tax system is undergoing a process of constant reform as it slowly moves away
from the Musgraves early stage framework47
to the modern taxation system.
Correspondingly, the future of service tax is the Goods and Services Tax. The
implementation of GST will lead to the abolition of other taxes such as octroi, Central Sales
Tax, State-level sales tax, entry tax, stamp duty, telecom licence fees, turnover tax, tax on
consumption or sale of electricity, taxes on transportation of goods and services, et cetera,thus avoiding multiple layers of taxation that currently exist in India.
48It is pretty apparent
that the introduction of the negative list has been carried out with an eye on introducing the
GST.49
Given the federal structure of India, India has proposed a dual GST system50
which
closely resembles the Canadian model51
which aims to demarcate separate services for
taxation by the centre and the state. Finance minister Pranab Mukherjee has proposed a multi-
slab structure for GST52
;
There is extreme controversy over GST with many states fearing for their fiscal
independence and inefficient tax administration due to lack of synergy between state and
46 P Ravindran, Carnival of the Tax Gods : Service Tax Concept Paper ahead of the Goods and Services Tax
Wide menu at the long table, available athttp://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-
cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).47
R.A. Musgrave, FISCAL SYSTEMS, (Yale University Press, 1969).48
Supra note 5.49
The CBEC Concept Paper statesthere are advantages in moving towards negative list at an earlier time in
order to gain useful experience in its implementation and minimize the impact of the mammoth changes that
GST may usher.Supra note 1.50
Supra note 5.51
RM Bird and Pierre-Pascal Gendron, Sales Tax in Canada: The GST-HST-QST-RST System, 63 Tax Law Review
517 (2010).52
Pranab Mukherjee moots three rates for rollout of GST, DNA, Jul 21, 2010, available athttp://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772, (last accessed on 4
th
April, 2012).
Goods:20% Services:16%Essential
Items:12%
http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=192931118/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
15/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 14
central tax authorities.53
There has been debate over what comprises essential items and what
do not comprise essential items as various sections of the economy try and grapple with each
other to avoid GST.
53Supra note 46.
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
16/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 15
CONCLUSION
The Service Tax policy of our nation has been of optimism checked by pragmatic principles.
India has been consistently optimistic about the growth in services sector and the subsequent
revenue it stands to gain but it has been pragmatic enough to apply a phased approach to]]in
expanding the service tax base and increasing the service tax, so as to not stall the explosive
growth enjoyed by Indias service sector. The dual objective has been the cornerstone of the
service tax policy defining the service tax trends in India.
Service tax trends have dovetailed Indias fiscal policy ambitions therefore the introduction
of the negative list system makes an attempt to widen the tax base and bring in more services
into the taxation net, to increase government revenue and rein in the fiscal deficit which has
taken a further hit due to the global economic slowdown and the recent weakening of the
rupee and stands at 5.6%. The negative list will not only widen the tax base but also provide
depth by plugging loopholes through its comprehensive nature. It is hoped that the definition
provided by the government clarifies and simplifies the framework and avoids the litigious
route the positive list had to undergo.
Now, that the Indian services sector has achieved critical mass and still continues to grow at
rapid rates, India has begun to shed its inhibitions regarding taxation of services. The
introduction of the negative list system in 2012 has been as much about fiscal consolidation
as it has been about facilitating an eventual shift towards the GST. GST is the future of the
service tax policy in India. India needs to ensure that the dual system to be followed under the
GST doesnt end up becoming as complex and laborious as the present archaic system. There
is also the burgeoning question of getting the states on board and establishing synergies
between the various taxation authorities in our country to effectively administer an uniform
taxation system.
The future trends in taxation of services and realisation of its true potential depends on how
well the government manages fiscal consolidation and the transition from the positive list to
negative list and subsequently the advent of GST.
8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
17/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 16
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Articles
1. RM Bird and Pierre-Pascal Gendron, Sales Tax in Canada: The GST-HST-QST-RSTSystem, 63 Tax Law Review 517 (2010).
2. P Ravindran, Carnival of the Tax Gods : Service Tax Concept Paper ahead of the
Goods and Services TaxWide menu at the long table, available athttp://discover-
decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
3. A Bagchi, Towards GST: Choices and Trade-offs, 41(14) Economic and Political
Weekly, 1314 (Apr. 8-14, 2006).
4. R. burgess and S. stern, Taxation and Development, XXXI, 2, Journal of Economic
Literature, 762-830 (1993).
5. Gurcharan Das, The India Model, 85(4)Foreign Affairs , 2, (2006).
6. Auerbach, Alan J. & Hines, James Jr., "Taxation and economic efficiency, in: A. J.
Auerbach & M. Feldstein (ed.), Handbook of Public Economics, 1347-1421 , (edition
1, volume 3, 2002).
7. Amaresh Bagchi, Taxing Services: The Way Forward, 39(19), Economic and
Political Weekly , 1876, 2004
8. MG Rao, Taxing Services: Issues and Strategy, 36(42) Economic and Political
Weekly 3999 (Oct. 20-26, 2001).
9. What is ACES, available athttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsp(last accessed on 4th
April, 2012)
10.S Acharya,Back to the Past?, 38(11) Economic and Political Weekly 1011 (Mar. 15-
21, 2003).
BOOKS
1. Adam Smith, AN INQUIRY INTO THE NATURE AND CAUSES OF THE WEALTH OF NATIONS,(1776).
2. J.K. Mittal, Law, Practice and Procedure of Service Tax, vol.II, (CCH Wolters
Kluwers, 20th edn., 2010).
http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://www.aces.gov.in/aboutaces.jsphttp://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=19293111http://discover-decouvrir.cisti-icist.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/eng/article/?id=192931118/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
18/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 17
3. Micheal Todero & Stephen Smith, Economic development, 751, (Pearson
Publications, 8th edition, 2003).
4. R.A. Musgrave, Fiscal Systems, (Yale University Press, 1969).
5. Sanjiv Aggarwal, Treatise on service Tax, Vol.1, 223, (Snowwhite Publications, 9thedn., 2011).
CASES
1. All India Federation of Tax Practitioners vs Union Of India, [2007] 10 STT 166 (SC)(Supreme Court of India).
2. Indian Institute of Architects Vs. Union of India, [2007] 6 STT 112 (MAD) (High
Court of Madhya Pradesh).
CONCEPT PAPERS
1. Challenges before the Service Tax Administration in India, available at
http://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htm, (last accessed on 5th
April,
2012).
2. Concept Paper on Taxation of Services based on a Negative List, Central Board of
Excise and Customs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India (2011), available at
http://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdf, (last accessed on 4thApril, 2012).
3. First Discussion Paper On Goods and Services Tax In India, The Empowered
Committee Of State Finance Ministers, available at
http://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%2
0Discussion%20paper.pdf, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
4. Revised Concept Paper on Taxation of Services based on Negative List, Central
Board of Excise and Customs, Ministry of Finance, Government of India (2011),
available at http://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdf, (last accessed on
4th April, 2012).
NEWSPAPER ARTICLES
1. D Sikarwar, India not ready for negative list to tax services, The Economic Times,
(Apr. 6, 2010), available at http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-
06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-service, (last accessed on
4th
April, 2012).
http://www.taxmann.com/servicetaxlaw/Stonline_servicetax/Redirectpage.aspx?schc=y&Text=D%3a%2fTaxmannData%2fSTonlineData%2fRTF%2fST_H%2f%5b2007%5d006STT0112(MAD)_H.rtfhttp://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htmhttp://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htmhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-04-06/news/27577607_1_taxable-service-service-tax-exempt-servicehttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/concpt-ppr-velst.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://finmin.nic.in/GST/Empowered%20Committee%20of%20SFM%20%20First%20Discussion%20paper.pdfhttp://www.cbec.gov.in/draft-circ/taxservices-negativelst.pdfhttp://www.servicetax.gov.in/ovw/ovw5_challenges.htmhttp://www.taxmann.com/servicetaxlaw/Stonline_servicetax/Redirectpage.aspx?schc=y&Text=D%3a%2fTaxmannData%2fSTonlineData%2fRTF%2fST_H%2f%5b2007%5d006STT0112(MAD)_H.rtf8/2/2019 Service Tax Trends in India
19/19
SERVICE TAX TRENDS IN INDIA
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY PAGE 18
2. Pranab Mukherjee moots three rates for rollout of GST, DNA, Jul 21, 2010, available
at http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-
rollout_1412772, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
3. S Madhavan, Implications of service tax on export of services, Business Standard, (6
th
Nov. 2006), available athttp://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-
taxexportservices/263827/, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
4. S Mukhopadhyay, Is a negative list for service tax desirable?, Business Standard,
Aug. 7, 2006, available at http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-
list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/, ( last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
5. T. Rustagi and Bijal Ajinkya, Time for a negative list of services for taxation?, The
Economic Times, Feb. 4, 2010, (last accessed on 4th
April, 2012).
STATUTES
1. 95th Constitutional Amendment Bill, 2011 (India).
2. Finance Acts of 1994, 1997, 2000, 2003, 2006, 2009, 2011 (India).
3. Finance Bill, 2012(India).
REPORTS
1. Economic Survey of India (2011-2012)
2. CAG Audit Report No. 25 of 2011-12 Union Government (Indirect Taxes)Central
Excise & Service Tax
http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/isnegative-list-for-service-tax-desirable/259045/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://business-standard.com/india/news/implicationsservice-taxexportservices/263827/http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_three-rates-mooted-for-gst-rollout_1412772Recommended