View
224
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
1/108
Request for Decision
Application for rezoning in order to permit low and
medium density residential uses on the former
Jessie Hamilton school site, 16 Jessie Street,
Lively - Seeley Homes
Presented To: Plan
Presented: Mon
Report Date Tues
Type: Publ
File Number: 751-
Recommendation
THAT the City of Greater Sudbury approve the application by
Seeley Homes to amend Zoning By-law 2010-100Z by changing
the zoning classification from "I", Institutional to "R1-5", LowDensity Residential One and "R3(S)", Medium Density
Residential Special on those lands described as PINs
73375-0518 & 73375-0123, Parcels 16797 & 15784 S.W.S., Lot
51, Plan M-442 in Lot 4, Concession 4, Township of Waters,
subject to the following conditions:
1. That the owner provide the Development Approvals Section
with a registered survey plan outlining the lands to be rezoned toenable the preparation of an amending zoning by-law;
2. That the amending by-law indicate the following site specific
provisions pertaining to the R3", Medium Density Residential
portion of the property:
i) The only permitted uses shall be the following:
1. The conversion of the former school building to a multipledwelling with a maximum of 29 dwelling units;
2. A multiple dwelling with a maximum of 26 dwelling units and a
maximum building height of three (3) storeys;
3. Related accessory uses;
Signed By
Report Prepared ByMauro Manzon
Senior Planner
Digitally Signed Feb
Reviewed By
Eric Taylor
Manager of Developm
Digitally Signed Feb
Recommended by th
Paul BaskcombDirector of Planning S
Digitally Signed Feb
Recommended by th
Bill Lautenbach
General Manager of G
Development
Digitally Signed Feb
Recommended by t
Doug NadoroznyChief Administrative O
Digitally Signed Feb
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
2/108
the consent process.
STAFF REPORT
Applicant:
Seeley Homes (Agent: D.S. Dorland Ltd.)
Location:
PINs 73375-0518 & 73375-0123, Parcels 16797 & 15784 S.W.S., Lot 51, Plan M-442 in L
4, Township of Waters (16 Jessie Street, Lively)
Application:
To amend By-law 2010-100Z being the City of Greater Sudbury Zoning By-law from "I", In
"R1-5", Low Density Residential One and "R3", Medium Density Residential.
Proposal:
Application for rezoning in order to permit the following:
1. Create five (5) lots for single residential use on Patricia Street by way of the consent pr
illustrated on the attached plan;
2. Convert the surplus school building into 29 dwelling units; and,
3. Construct a new multiple dwelling with 26 units on the northeasterly portion of the prop
Official Plan Conformity:
Living Area policies
The subject land is designated as Living Area 1, which permits a range of residential uses
neighbourhood-based institutional uses such as the former elementary school. In reviewin
rezoning in Living Areas, the following criteria under Section 3.2.1 of the Official Plan are
suitability of the site to accommodate the proposed density and building form;
physical compatibility with the surrounding neighbourhood in terms of scale, massing, h
setbacks; adequate on-site parking; and,
traffic impact on local streets.
Surplus institutional properties
The former elementary school site also comprises surplus institutional lands and is there
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
3/108
Site Description & Surrounding Land Uses:
The subject property comprises a former school site located in the easterly section of the
subdivision in Lively. The area is fully serviced by municipal water and sanitary sewer.
Total site area is 2.78 ha (6.87 acres), with 129 m (423 ft.) of frontage on Jessie Street an
flankage on Patricia Street. The site is occupied by a vacant school building with an appro
area of 2 786 m2 (29,988 sq. ft.). The building height varies between one and two storeys
A small, northeasterly section of the property falls within a designated flood plain. This ar
to be developed. The school building is situated at a slightly higher elevation than the sch
east and south.
A wooded area with mature vegetation forms a large buffer along the northeasterly and eboundaries. A single detached dwelling directly abuts the school building to the north (8 J
Three single detached dwellings on Patricia Street abut the property to the southeast. The
benefit from a significant buffer formed by the wooded area. Single detached dwellings co
adjacent uses on Jessie Street and Patricia Street.
Departmental & Agency Comments:
Development Engineering
This site is currently serviced with municipal water and sanitary sewer. Municipal water an
are existing along Patricia Street at the location of the proposed single detached dwelling
A water capacity analysis was conducted for the site. The 150 mm diameter watermain a
provides sufficient pressures under Maximum Day Demand and under Maximum Hour De
provides a Fire Flow of 108.0 L/s at a residual pressure of 20.0 psi (elevation 262.0m). Th
diameter watermain along Patricia Street provides sufficient pressures under Maximum D
under Maximum Hour Demand and provides a Fire Flow of 104.6 L/s at a residual pressu(elevation 257.0 m). Should higher Fire Flows be required, the owner will be responsible f
water supply system. The developer will be responsible for the installation of hydrants req
minimum separation distance for hydrants in higher density areas of 90 m.
A 525 mm diameter sanitary sewer is existing along Jessie Street and a 200 mm diamete
existing along Patricia Street. Wastewater is conveyed southwesterly to the Jacob Lift Sta
to the Walden Wastewater Treatment Plant. Capacity issues are known to exist in the gra
downstream of the proposed development; as such, cost contributions for upgrades to thesystem may be required.
We have no objection to changing the zoning classification from "I", Institutional to "R1-5"
Residential One and "R3", Medium Density Residential in order to permit five (5) single re
fronting on Patricia Street, created by way of consent, conversion of the existing surplus s
29 dwelling units and construction of a new three storey 26
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
4/108
reviewing the report and will be providing comments to the applicant.
As a condition of approval, it is recommended that the owner complete the Traffic Impact
participate in the cost of any improvements or upgrading identified in the study to the satis
General Manager of Infrastructure Services.We also require that the east side of Jessie Street and the north side of Patricia Street, ad
property, be upgraded to an urban standard.
Drainage Section
No concerns.
Building Services
Upon review we can advise that Building Services has no objection to the proposed amen
Nickel District Conservation Authority
Please be advised that the Nickel District Conservation Authority has reviewed the above
and has no concerns or objection to same.
However, please be advised that a portion of the subject property is located in a designat
development in the flood plain area will require an application to the NDCA.
Neighbourhood Consultation:
The proponents have scheduled a neighbourhood meeting on February 20, 2013 at 7:00
gymnasium of the former Jessie Hamilton School. The applicant has also canvassed the
door-to-door during the period February 6 - 8, 2013.
As of the date of this report, a number of phone calls and letters of concern have been re
Services. A petition has also been submitted. The main concerns are summarized as follo
traffic impact on local roads;
local roads not urbanized;
proposed use not compatible with low density neighbourhood (predominantly single det
development will lower property values; and,
land should be developed for single detached dwellings only.
Planning Considerations:
Adaptive reuse can be a feasible form of redevelopment. It is based on the notion that a s
can be repurposed for a new use without the need for outright demolition, provided redev
complementary manner Adaptive reuse also represents good land use planning as it inv
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
5/108
use compatibility is maintained based on the following considerations:
The maximum height of the buildings will not exceed 11 metres (36 ft.), which is also the
permitted for single detached dwellings in the R1-5 zone.
The new apartment building will not be higher than the reconstructed school building baa lower elevation. The westerly (front) elevation of the new building facing Jessie Street w
storeys; the rear of the building will comprise three storeys with main floor walk-outs.
An existing wooded area provides significant screening and buffering for abutting single
dwellings to the southeast on Patricia Street. This large buffer area can be retained as a s
provision, and would be implemented as part of the Site Plan Control Agreement.
The large site allows the new building to be set back some distance from existing low deuses with no negative impact related to shadowing, sight lines and privacy.
A significant portion of the site (approximately 70%) is maintained as landscaped open s
space.
The rezoning sketch illustrates 87 parking spaces where a minimum 83 spaces are requ
requirements can be accommodated on-site. There is ample site area to provide addition
needed.
Existing parking along Jessie Street will be eliminated and replaced with landscaping.
Density
Official Plan policy requires that the proposed density be appropriate within the context of
location.
1. Single detached dwellings
The proposed lots on Patricia Street exceed the minimum requirements related to lot fron
under the applicable zoning (R1-5 for single residential use). The size and configuration o
consistent with the existing lot fabric in the area. As a condition of approval, it is recomme
applications be permitted to proceed by way of the consent process.
2. Medium density residential use
The total area of the R3 portion of the site is approximately 2.48 ha based on the applican
buildings containing a total of 55 dwelling units results in a residential density of 22 units pwell-below the maximum density of 36 units per hectare permitted under the Official Plan
neighbourhoods (singles, semis and duplexes). It is further noted that medium density sit
up to 90 units per hectare.
The low density results from the expansive site, a significant portion of which will remain u
applicant has proposed a residential density (i e number of units) that addresses land us
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
6/108
indicated that 90% of the traffic generated by the new use will utilize the signalized interse
Drive and Municipal Road 55. With the permission of the applicant, the Traffic Impact Stu
available to residents who requested a copy through Planning Services.
Supplemental to the TIS, the traffic consultant provided a comparative analysis which dem
traffic generated by the proposed residential use (55 apartment units and 5 single detach
be significantly less than the traffic generated by the former institutional use (elementary
peak periods.
Based on the scale of development and the resultant traffic impacts, the applicant is not r
the local road network to an urban standard. The redevelopment of the site itself, howeve
current engineering standards. As a condition of approval, Roads and Transportation staf
recommending that the east side of Jessie Street and the north side of Patricia Street abu
land be upgraded to an urban standard. These upgrades can be incorporated into the Sit
Agreement if this application is approved.
Other considerations
A review of building permit data indicates that there has been no new construction of ap
since 1999, when the Meadowbrook complex was constructed.
The redevelopment expands the range of housing options in the community, which is pa
with an aging demographic.
Alternative forms of housing allow seniors to downscale and remain in their community o
than relocating to more urbanized areas of Sudbury where the vast majority of medium an
residential developments are located.
A majority of units will be accessible and therefore ideal for seniors and persons with dis
renovated school and 100% in new building).
The applicant has confirmed that there are no restrictive covenants on title to the proper
The proposal is also consistent with the Provincial Policy Statement (2005), most notably
provisions:
Section 1.1.1.b: Healthy, liveable and safe communities are sustained by accommodatin
range and mix of residential, employment (including industrial, commercial and institution
recreational and open space uses to meet long-term needs;
Section 1.1.1.f: The municipality shall improve accessibility for persons with disabilities a
removing and/or preventing land use barriers which restrict their full participation in socie
Section 1.1.3.3: Planning authorities shall identify and promote opportunities for intensif
redevelopment where this can be accommodated taking into account existing building sto
including brownfield sites and the availability of suitable existing or planned infrastructure
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
7/108
meet projected requirements of current and future residents of the regional market area.
Summary
Planning Services staff are satisfied that the proposed residential use of the site is approp
location within an established residential area. It is also consistent with the underlying lan
(Living Area 1). No negative land use conflicts are envisioned, as there is ample site area
the proposed development, including the provision of adequate on-site parking and effect
buffering. The overall residential density would be lower than what is permitted in new low
subdivisions. Staff have reviewed and are generally satisfied with the recommendations oStudy.
The adaptive reuse of the existing building, and the additional intensification that can be a
the large site, are consistent with Official Plan policies and the Provincial Policy Statemen
Site-specific zoning provisions can be utilized to limit the scale of development. The prop
good land use planning and is recommended for approval subject to the above noted con
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
8/108
ANN
JE
SS
IE
17
MIKKOLA
PATRICIA
KANTO
LA
LAURA
HILLCREST
DILLON'S
RU
I
M3
R1-5
R1-5
P
R1-5
R1-5
R1
-5
M3(10)
R1-5
R1-5
C1
R1
-5
R1-5
R1-5
Junction Creek
Junction Creek
2
6
6
87
5
7
1
2 6
73
62
70 76
55
39
22
2719
53
86
14
82
49 63
48
95
41
61
95
85
64
16
14
65
56
47
29
17
81
96
50
45
91
91
30
43
9692
18
47
50 78
10
6648
997765 73
74
10 1826303438424650
6351474331
15
9288
54
67
66
59
3511 23
58
200
170
105
100
136 140
128
123
159
149
134150
133172
145
132
160
119
163
100
159145
156
171
147
129125113 166
133
101
164
175
142
200
146
174
104
127123
155
176
167
103141
163
173
136
132
168
135
118114
166
111107
167141121
122108
102
149
164
Kelly Lake
Meatbird Creek
NG
LOYD
MAGILL
VAGNINI
Growth and DeveloDepartment
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
9/108
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
10/108
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
11/108
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
12/108
PHOTO 1 16 JESSIE STREET, LIVELY VIEW OF SCHOOL BUILDING FR
JESSIE STREET
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
13/108
PHOTO 3 16 JESSIE STREET, LIVELY SINGLE DETACHED DWELLINGS
JESSIE STREET OPPOSITE SCHOOL
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
14/108
PHOTO 5 16 JESSIE STREET, LIVELY SOUTHERLY VIEW TOWARDSPATRICIA STREET AND LOCATION OF PROPOSED R1 LOTS
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
15/108
PHOTO 7 16 JESSIE STREET, LIVELY VIEW OF WOODED AR
ALONG EASTERLY BOUNDARY OF PROPERTY
/
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
16/108
Subject Proper
HIGHWAY17
JE
S S
IE
S T
RE
ET
LAURAAVENUE
HILLCREST DRIVE
File: 751-8/12-416 Jessie Street,Lively
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
17/108
751-8-12-004 letter of support 1/1
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
18/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 1/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
19/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 2/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
20/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 3/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
21/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 4/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
22/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 5/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
23/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 6/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
24/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 7/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
25/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 8/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
26/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 9/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
27/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 10/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
28/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 11/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
29/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 12/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
30/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 13/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
31/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 14/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
32/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 15/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
33/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 16/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
34/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 17/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
35/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 18/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
36/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 19/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
37/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 20/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
38/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 21/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
39/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 22/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
40/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 23/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
41/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 24/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
42/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 25/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
43/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 26/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
44/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 27/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
45/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 28/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
46/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 29/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
47/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 30/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
48/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 31/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
49/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 32/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
50/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 33/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
51/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 34/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
52/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 35/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
53/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 36/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
54/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 37/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
55/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 38/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
56/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 39/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
57/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 40/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
58/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 41/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
59/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 42/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
60/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 43/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
61/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 44/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
62/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 45/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
63/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 46/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
64/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 47/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
65/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 48/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
66/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 49/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
67/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 50/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
68/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 51/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
69/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 52/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
70/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 53/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
71/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 54/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
72/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 55/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
73/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 56/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
74/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 57/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
75/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 58/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
76/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 59/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
77/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 60/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
78/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 61/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
79/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 62/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
80/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 63/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
81/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 64/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
82/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 65/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
83/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 66/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
84/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 67/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
85/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 68/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
86/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 69/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
87/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 70/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
88/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 71/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
89/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 72/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
90/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 73/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
91/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 74/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
92/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 75/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
93/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 76/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
94/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 77/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
95/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 78/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
96/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 79/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
97/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 80/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
98/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 81/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
99/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 82/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
100/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 83/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
101/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 84/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
102/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 85/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
103/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 86/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
104/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 87/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
105/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 88/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
106/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 89/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
107/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 90/91
7/29/2019 Seeley Homes Planning Committee Report
108/108
751-8-12-004 letters of concern 91/91
Recommended